red-dead-singleplayer

[hardy meadow]

💀

[empty patio]

💀

Whatever bro

[hardy meadow]

They werent killing for sport btw

They were killing for money

Read the dialogue

💀

[empty patio]

Wow, it's almost like, killing for sport is literally for the money 😭

Do your research 😭

[hardy meadow]

Wow thats almost like charles literally killed one for money 5 mins earlier

💀

If you kill the hunter, you should kill charles too

[empty patio]

You're trying so hard to be right but just digging your own grave

[hardy meadow]

Otherwise its race based discrimination/preferential treatment aka racism

[hardy meadow]

"I ran out of arguments so i say generic useless comment"

[hardy meadow]

Not killing charles in that scene was racist of arthur

[empty patio]

Charles didn't kill based on race, dumbass, he killed because of people who were destroying the land and the Wapiti tribes

[thin elbow]

I found a train that was being robbed, killed the robbers. If I bring that train to a train station, will I get a reward?

[ebon patrol]

Yo

[rapid tinsel]

Yo

[hardy meadow]

english classes arent that expensive

[hardy meadow]

No you will get shot

[rapid tinsel]

0/10 ragebait

[hardy meadow]

🤡

Aint no way there are people who support the white sup guy, charles, or the kkk or micah 💀

[rapid tinsel]

Why are we putting charles and the KKK in the same category

[empty patio]

You couldn't come up with a reasonable excuse to keep arguing so you say this shit that makes zero sense 💀 whatever bro

[empty patio]

Because they hate Charles

[ebon patrol]

I actually haven’t finished rdr2 yet I’m on chapter six

[rapid tinsel]

Lisr

[hardy meadow]

How about scroll up, read again, and realise what bs did you say

[hardy meadow]

Both kill innocents

[rapid tinsel]

Your entire discord is dedicated to arthur morgan and his quotes, you definitely have played through the story

[empty patio]

How about realize you supporting racism is actually mind blowing and you do realize this server is against racism

[zinc oxide]

What do yall think of my first playthrough, 32% completion 38 hours 10% story

[ebon patrol]

I haven’t seen spoilers of the game just like those quotes I have to finish tho

[rapid tinsel]

Was this a 38 hour sitting dog?

[zinc oxide]

No js doing random bs

[rapid tinsel]

Thats a lot of non story related completion

[zinc oxide]

Yea

[rapid tinsel]

I got that 100% completion personally

[soft root]

Good for you, there's a lot of side content, and most of them make you appreciate the game more

[obtuse zodiac]

Charles the goat

[hardy meadow]

Charles the villian

[hardy meadow]

#red-dead-media

[obtuse zodiac]

Press the button that makes ur in game map bigger for a few seconds, that shows time

[hardy meadow]

Js use a clock

[gritty island]

#idontlikemicah

[high sphinx]

Fr

[gritty island]

he full manipulated dutch

[high sphinx]

Ikr

How did he not he was being manipulated

[sleek cradle]

Does anyone have an epilogue save game file?

I'm on the epilogue mission where John follows Sadie down to Ambarino to get back a bounty that was stolen from her. Unfortunately, even after a reboot and verifying the game files, the script gets stuck after Sadie stops to watch from behind the second rock while they bad guys are in the canyon. No one moves or says anything. I can go down and kill everyone, but no one fights back and Sadie stays up behind her rock.

I'd like a new save game file if anyone has it. I predict the next mission will be the house building mission. Does anyone have an epilogue savegame that starts just before the Housebuilding mission? I don't mind to skip this mission with Sadie and jump right into that.

[gritty island]

Micah manipulated the dutch

[timid dove]

is dutch from the netherlands?

is that why

hes called dutch

[gritty island]

idk i am new in rdr community

I haven't finished 1 epilogue yet

[high sphinx]

Interesting

[gritty island]

What to go first rdr2 or 1

[devout fractal]

rdr2 is prequel to rdrq

Rdr1

[gritty island]

why i have "cattle rustler"

[devout fractal]

Wha

[gritty island]

Idk now I pass rdr2 then 1 I will pass because I try to pass games from the earliest events to later

i have role cattle rustler

[tight plaza]

sounds like you are playing multiplayer?

[gritty island]

rarely

[heady vector]

Im saving Micah rn from prison but he talks like he’s gonna betray me one day

[dense pasture]

He won't dw

[heady vector]

Okay thx

[obtuse zodiac]

Nothing beats Micah's missions

[gritty island]

Yeah but micah is just a traitor

[hollow barn]

you are confusing micah with evil micah

micah goes on a trip after chapter 5 and evil micah takes advantage/steals his position

[thorny cargo]

yup

[marsh flint]

Micah was a character I considered a friend up until post guarma

[thorny cargo]

thats crazy

[hollow barn]

if mobile phones existed in 1899,sean would force little jack to prank-call micah

and micah would rage

[marsh flint]

Rdr2 is such a experience

You can play it for 100 hours and barely feel it

[halcyon zinc]

Hi im trying to platinum the game and do 100% and im wondering can i still do arthurs unfinished side missions with john

[marsh flint]

Yeah

Pretty sure you can

[halcyon zinc]

Even the one with the exotics and that weapon?

@marsh flint

[marsh flint]

Uhh

Im not sure

[halcyon zinc]

Ok thanks for the help

[marsh flint]

Try the wiki

It should tell you

[halcyon zinc]

I did😭

Every site says different

Some says i should do all of it now

Others say its ok to do it as john

[hardy meadow]

close game and open again 💀

[open shell]

i finished rdr2 last night

[obtuse zodiac]

Which are u talking about give me an example

[pliant imp]

hi im new at the game im at the chapter 3 can someone give me some advice? 🙂

[obtuse zodiac]

Advice on?

[pliant imp]

I dont know

[urban gorge]

His family is

[urban gorge]

His father to be exact

[zinc oxide]

I rlly dont want to finish the game tbh, I hate knowing spoilers

[obtuse zodiac]

That's why do all side missions first

Hunt legendaries and proceed with the story

It's way more better

[low osprey]

Hey just to check, I have WhyEm's DLC installed, can I install catalogue improvements without any conflict?

[shell latch]

idk

[wary jacinth]

Your tactics are weak buddy

[wary jacinth]

No not you

[zinc oxide]

is it a good idea to leave some treasure hunts free for when I play as John?

[thin elbow]

(I don't know if my question is considered a spoiler). I came at the point where I have to choose an assignment between the moonshine family (with Hosea)or the other. Is this choice decisive, or will I need to do both families anyways?

[hollow barn]

its not a choice you do both of them

[thin elbow]

Ok, thanks

[prime hound]

Guys, I saw some videos saying that certain areas of RDR 2 are scary, like Lagras.
So I set myself a challenge: to go into one of those areas with only a gun and no horse.
Which areas do you recommend for me?

(Area where I can go with Arthur)

[hollow barn]

goddamnit i was gonna say mexico

[wary jacinth]

You going to just keep calling my phone must be a real tough guy bahaha

[rare topaz]

why did reviveing my horse just give me low honor

[zinc oxide]

who sells the tuffest clothes

[hollow barn]

you don't need clothes my friend

[zinc oxide]

what am I supposed to do with 3,6k

[shell latch]

give it to me?

[hollow barn]

"mr morgan i noticed you stop donating to the camp"

[zinc oxide]

balls saying give it to me

lowk

I should feed my horse more

[hollow barn]

or idk golden all your weapons

[zinc oxide]

L

[zinc oxide]

lowk how do I get a better bag

I cant be having js 3 of every item

[crimson crane]

you got to go to Pearson

in the camp

[zinc oxide]

cant I buy or craft any?

[crimson crane]

And you have to get petls to get a better bag

Pelts

[prime hound]

In the field improvements section, there's a purchase option called "Ledge work," so you go to Pearson and see the bags.
All bags require leather from specific animals.

The best bag lets you carry 99 of your items.
It is called a "legend of the west."

[zinc oxide]

what shop owner is this?

[hollow barn]

is dead eye enough for hunting perfect animal skins

or do I have to use godly powers to aim

[prime hound]

Right there at camp, with Pearson.

[prime hound]

You need to use a specific weapon and ammunition for each animal, but Dead Eye can be useful as it increases accuracy.

[crimson crane]

Pearson

[hollow barn]

Appleson

[thin elbow]

I am in camp, where do I drop off the herbs?

[hollow barn]

Williamson

[prime hound]

Oh.

[midnight ocean]

buy leather tools for the camp

[thin elbow]

Or does the icon only appear when I have sufficient/all herbs?

[midnight ocean]

then pearson can craft them

[midnight ocean]

did someone ask for herbs

[hollow barn]

jack lowk asked arthur to bring his coloring book from blackwater

like hell I am going there

[thin elbow]

In the beginning, a lady at camp...

It's Susan, herbs for seasoning

[zinc oxide]

my horse looks like travis

[zinc oxide]

wdym

[midnight ocean]

do you know where to buy camp upgrades

[midnight ocean]

you give them directly to her

[midnight ocean]

you can find him a replacement

[rare topaz]

do you know how i can make the winter shotgun coat how it was in colter

[midnight ocean]

not possible without mods afaik

you can change it to be closed i think but its still not the same

[hollow barn]

i deadass thought the game wanted me to go to blackwater back then

🥀

[storm venture]

So what brand is your microwave

[midnight ocean]

hamilton beach

[storm venture]

Mine is nokia

W brand

[midnight ocean]

so its bulletproof

[storm venture]

Ye

What about your fridge

[midnight ocean]

[rare topaz]

dude

[hollow barn]

@granite peak Too many caps.

[rare topaz]

Theres NO WAY that its not cannon that strauss actually CHEATS IN POKER

A

[midnight ocean]

you can play him in camp?

[rare topaz]

YES

[midnight ocean]

didint even know that lol

[rare topaz]

HE WINS

[hollow barn]

sheriff let him speak bro

[rare topaz]

HE ate MY 25 DOLLARS

[midnight ocean]

jesus

bros betting it all at the casual friendly poker game lol

[hollow barn]

well you should've known it after the robbery with trelawney

or idk

if you didnt go that far in story

[rare topaz]

thats so bs bro

[rare topaz]

ive finished the story but i dont remember it

[midnight ocean]

the river boat mission

[rare topaz]

oh yeah

[midnight ocean]

strauss helps you cheat at the high stakes poker game

[rare topaz]

i remember it

lowk

i still dont know how to play poker

but ive won lots of money at the valentine saloon

just assumeing that if i had a card that isnt a number is good

[hollow barn]

when strauss nudged me to keep betting in that mission i didnt know what that meant

so i stopped the game and watched a tutorial

[rare topaz]

im only good at black jack but you cant play any black jack in velntine

valentine*

[midnight ocean]

well that may have contributed to strauss' W

[rare topaz]

i just finished buying all the lodgeing upgrade for camp

dude

it did nothing

[midnight ocean]

not really lol its about getting groups of cards. two 2's is better than one ace

because its a pair

[rare topaz]

did it give me reinforced tents or something?

are my sheets premium now?

[midnight ocean]

think you get some extra free items behind your tent

maybe

[opal lava]

Guys I finished the game, like I sat through the credits and it brought me back to the game, but there aren't any tasks to do

Is it js letting me do wtv I want now that I finished the game

[midnight ocean]

yes

[opal lava]

Ohhh alr then

[midnight ocean]

if you want more stuff to do there are probably a few bounties you havent done, or you can hunt stuff for the trapper or work towards 100%

[opal lava]

Aye you're right

[prime hound]

I was walking around Lagras and ended up finding a guy hanged with his hands tied, and as if that wasn't bizarre enough, Four guys appeared out of nowhere and started walking towards me.

[midnight ocean]

keep an eye out for a new side mission in lagras after that

[prime hound]

A short time later I heard a woman's voice lamenting.
"Come back to me" or something like that.

[thorny cargo]

its rigged for you to win no matter what

[zinc oxide]

why are some guns locked for me

[oak phoenix]

progress in the story to unlock them

[obtuse zodiac]

did u do all the dinosaur bones, geology side quest, treasure maps, legendary animals?

[zinc oxide]

alr and what about the stats, theyre still a little empty even tho Ive fully upgraded

[midnight ocean]

the gray parts show the guns potential depending on what ammo type and attachments you use

[zinc oxide]

ive got maxed out attachments

what do we fw more, dual wield revolver with sniper and repeater or dual revolver/dual pistol, repeater and shotgun

[thin elbow]

Why does the camp share after earning money not appear in the ledger? Like cuts of $500 or the likes

[midnight ocean]

the camp funds you can donate to is separate from the camp cut that comes out of robberies

the larger fund is the money dutch is keeping for mango tree seed money

the one you donate to is basically camp maintenance

[thin elbow]

Even though it is only a game, I don't see why I need to hand over my money to those lazy low lives!!!

Is there a way to invest my money, like buying a farm or something? (I am now at the moment where I am robbing the bank in valentine

[midnight ocean]

no

but the camp upgrades do benefit you quite a bit

[opal lava]

No but I probably should

[ebon patrol]

I’m about to play red dead revolver for the first time

[obtuse zodiac]

hmm been playing a lot of GTA

[thin elbow]

Maybe

[thin elbow]

How exactly?

[midnight ocean]

have you looked at them?

[thin elbow]

Yeah... I recall like a chicken pen?

[midnight ocean]

theres also leather tools to create better satchels and the ability to fast travel

[thin elbow]

I mean, bullets and cans I get plenty (or so it seems) ransacking houses

[thin elbow]

Better satchel means what? More room?

[empty patio]

Yes

More room for certain things, the best satchel is Legend of the East. Extra room for everything

[thin elbow]

And fast travel means like going from one point directly to another? But then I will miss out on the white dotted people, no?

[empty patio]

You can fast travel to your camp or towns/cities, but if you don't want to miss out on stranger missions then I'd prefer not fast travel at the moment if you don't wanna miss out on them

[thin elbow]

At the moment I actually have a sort of technical problem: the esc key is not working, I can't turn off my game

It happened after I donated to the ledger

The values of the ledger and my money are fixed in the right top corner

[empty patio]

Are you still in camp or out of camp? If you're still in camp, you can always see your money and the camp funds when you're in or close to camp

[empty patio]

Oh this message never loaded until now

Uhh I'm not sure then

[thin elbow]

In camp, but I had to pause (using the windows button) I will try to kill myself in the river to see if it turns back to normal

[empty patio]

Alright

[thin elbow]

Is it possible that there's something I should do? However, even in-missions it was always possible to press ESC

[midnight ocean]

try leaving camp

[thin elbow]

Will do as soon as my kids go to bed 🛏️

So I "paused" using the windows key, but it seems the game doesn't pause, so I died in the river, and now the ESC key is working

[sleek cradle]

I said I did, dude.

[halcyon lion]

Where's the spoiler free channel?

Im only 5 mission in chapter 5

[midnight ocean]

there aint one

[sour inlet]

i am a weirdo for dressing my arthur black in low honor and white in high honor or someone else does it too

[stray void]

I’ve never done low honor but if I did i probably would dress him in darker clothes unlike the lighter clothes he has right now with high honor

[sour inlet]

after 2 high honor playtrought i wanted to do a low honor one, did not reached after chapter 3 i feel like a bad person

but my arthur is well dressed

[stray void]

I mean it’s for the game so don’t feel like a bad person because half the time people are just experimenting about how far you can go and all

[viral yoke]

I just finished the main story but I didn’t do all the side missions with Arthur. Can I seriously not 100% the game without restarting?

[low raven]

whats the last mission you can free roam before saving john and red dead redemption

[mystic blaze]

If i buy the premium version of red dead on steam do I unlock online with it

[low raven]

u get it with just buyting the game

[mystic blaze]

oh okay I didnt know because you can buy the online version by itself so I didnt know if u had to buy both

im switching over to pc

[subtle finch]

Im getting absolutely wasted at the valentine saloon

[lethal sleet]

gambler challenge 8 has me wishing arthur left me for dead.

[midnight ocean]

no, you dont need every single side mission for 100%

[prisma gust]

i cant believe it

ive been grinding pelts for like 3 hours

[prisma gust]

jumped by bounty hunters, and i cant even get an autosave for before that

[woeful scarab]

Me Seeing: ”Money Lending and Other Sins-III” pop up on my map

[tropic oyster]

anyone got the grey arden?

[solid current]

im trying to fish with dutch and hosea and theres a fish swimming around IN the boat with us and no one else seems to care😭😭 i thought it was just swimming through the boat but its trapped inside

[lapis panther]

Yes

[tropic oyster]

did u like it more compared to the other ardens?

[lapis panther]

For some funny hidden dialogue, during that mission while fishing, jump out of the boat and swim haha

[lapis panther]

It was okay. Better than the one you can get in Scarlett Meadows stable

[tropic oyster]

too its not in the basic version of the game and cant save after spawing

[timid fox]

hey, i have some elk skin in perfect condition and talking to Trapper i can sell him the skin but when i start with Buy option and try to craft clothes says i have none

[empty patio]

Because you have the sell the skins first before you can buy anything that calls for elk skins

[hazy sorrel]

D

Hol

[timid fox]

can i keep money somewhere or just run with all the cash?

i think i have a bug with weapons loadout - i always go to chest and set firearms to have on my back but when i'm out of the camp, i don't have any weapons on me but revolvers

[zinc oxide]

Youll never get me alive

[zinc oxide]

Jz don't die

[light cypress]

Is red dead multi-player still alive

[timid fox]

in rdr2? hell yea

[light cypress]

Nah bro I meant red dead 1

Yea red dead 2

😭✌️

[timid fox]

rdr1 has players on xbox

not sure about ps3 version

friend broke my console and i miss my ps3 :D

[timid dove]

i know

[fair isle]

i ended it gentlemens.

i saw the death.

[high sphinx]

Yes

[fast warren]

I just finished epilogue part 2 and theres no missions left

What am I supposed to do now? Start a new game?

[thorny cargo]

you did american venom already?

[fast warren]

Yea

[thorny cargo]

well, you can do 100%, explore more etc.... complete the compendium.

or start a new game

[fast warren]

Ohh okay

[left forge]

Good morning all

[prime gull]

Just realised mary beths therapy sessions are there to help you achieve high honor, It changes between what arthur does

[obtuse zodiac]

So I got a letter from the mayor at St Denis

And I'm not sure where to go

But the letter asked me to come to his house

[vale osprey]

you got to go to his house a night, it should show up on your map.

[sleek cradle]

Does anyone have an epilogue save game file?

I'm on the epilogue mission where John follows Sadie down to Ambarino to get back a bounty that was stolen from her. Unfortunately, even after a reboots of the game, restarting my PC and verifying the game files, the script gets stuck after Sadie stops to watch from behind the second rock while they bad guys are in the canyon. No one moves or says anything. I can go down and kill everyone, but no one fights back and Sadie stays up behind her rock.

I'd like a new save game file if anyone has it. I predict the next mission will be the house building mission. Does anyone have an epilogue savegame that starts just before the Housebuilding mission? I don't mind to skip this mission with Sadie and jump right into that.

[midnight ocean]

your long guns and any other sidearms you have on you are stored on the horse

[lone crown]

guys should I keep tiger bay mustang or get a horse like rose grey arabian

i tamed it a while ago

[midnight ocean]

why not both

[lone crown]

Got grey turkoman mft and gonna get buell

[midnight ocean]

fair

up to you tbh

if you sell off the mustang you can always get it back again anyway

[lone crown]

True

arabian does have way better stats and I already got 3 brave horses

[midnight ocean]

also true

rose grey arabian is the best in the game in terms of stats

[brave sphinx]

i love john

[midnight ocean]

i love my johnny and my johnny loves me

[thorny cargo]

johnny is such a bad name

[midnight ocean]

play it again

johnny guitar

[brave sphinx]

he forgot his swimming lessons

[obtuse zodiac]

Would there be a marker?

And I got a mail from the artist way

And it said something about money not sure where I can collect this

[vale osprey]

There should be a marker. It should be at the mayor's house

[brave sphinx]

i remember the first time i tried riding my horse into blackwater as arthur i got to the city and someone hollered "that's one of the van der lindes" nice detail haha

[midnight ocean]

thats pretty cool tbh

[tropic jasper]

Julio is still alive:D

[timid fox]

yeah, just that 90% of the time i have to select the right gun with LT/RT, otherwise it's blank :D

[midnight ocean]

yeah you cant really keep em on you all the time for some reason

[ebon scroll]

should i skin animal first then donate carcass to pearson or donate entire carcass? i already got the east satchel btw

[zinc oxide]

Have you played rdr1

[brave sphinx]

no, need to

i know what happens sadly but yeah

[zinc oxide]

Im still at chapter 2 in rdr2 but I lowk hate it

[brave sphinx]

how can you hate this amazing game😭

[nocturne bone]

Roughly how long does it take to get out the beginners snow area

[harsh linden]

guys

[atomic tiger]

Just completed the epilogue, and this game EASILY makes it to my top 3 game OAT

[atomic tiger]

It gets better, much much better

[atomic tiger]

Maybe like 30m to an hour

Maybe longer

I kinda forgot

[nocturne bone]

Never played this game or the first before looking on YouTube there’s so much stuff it’s making me dread it haha like what if I miss this or that or do something wrong lol

[obtuse zodiac]

At night u say?

[vale osprey]

Yeah should be a night

[midnight ocean]

one of the only side quests i didnt do on my last playthrough lol

[ebon scroll]

?

[wary jacinth]

Goof

[midnight ocean]

dont think it really matters

you get a slightly larger amount of money when you break an animal down before selling but its not really worth the time

[ebon scroll]

thanks

[obtuse zodiac]

Does anyone know if letters mean anything like a quest or something

Because I have lots, like I stole letters too bruh

And I'm not sure if I should just sell em to the fence or keep them

[night crown]

I just got the black Arabian horse

is it good

[obtuse zodiac]

Fast horse but very small

Doesn't suit Arthur

[zinc oxide]

Nono I mean Johns fate

[atomic tiger]

What do you mean?

Sorry, I’m a little slow

[chrome seal]

What happens if you fast travel to thieves landing

[left forge]

Good morning all

[chrome seal]

Good morning

[chrome seal]

But do you know what happens if you fast travel to thieves landing

[midnight ocean]

then you watch a little cinematic and arrive at thieves landing

[left forge]

What Woolie said

[lapis sable]

You could technically disable the guardzones and new austin sniper for Arthur to enjoy new austin but if you get wanted in new austin, tons of pinkertons will swarm you either way

Its something to consider if you wanna do rampages in 1899 new austin

[nocturne bone]

And it’s downloaded! Let’s goooo

[left forge]

Anyone know what you do with the gold shield that you take from the Braithwaite manor?

Never mind, the answer is nothing lol.

[hardy meadow]

You can disable wanted too lol

[lapis sable]

yeah i could but I wanna play rampages anywhere in both 1899, 1907, 1911 and 1914

I treat it as Survival till I die

[stiff storm]

guys mine is getting download

[stiff storm]

i want ask u something

should i add rampage trainer

[lapis sable]

yes

its awesome

[stiff storm]

i can save game while using it?

trainer is for story mode only right

[solid current]

im working on a map of animal and wild horse spawns and its taking so long💔

[late pivot]

I finally did it before.

I did the trapper outfit glitch.

[solid current]

which one??

[late pivot]

Something named Death Roll or something.

[spark mica]

what year could rdr3 be

[soft root]

I feel like there should be a red dead prequel game of arthur

like....before the events of rdr2

arthur has an interesting past

I kinda wanna see that interesting past

[nocturne bone]

Ok so I killed a farmer hearding some sheep .. then it took me back to camp like I had fallen asleep why ?

[hardy meadow]

personally im more of rdr4 fan

[real shore]

Chapter 5 is the most underrated chapter. It's amazing

[uneven arch]

Just bought the game like yesterday, how do i make some money? I know i can go hunting and sell the animals and their skin, but there has to be another way right??

[spark mica]

i hope they feature suspension bridges in this game.

alongside a city with midrises and highrises similar to chicago or new york

and obv some middle-of-nowhere's

i'd like well idk but traditional architecture

[dense kayak]

i found some guy passed out on a beach and i wanted to be nice and drop him off in town but when i put him down i got wanted for unarmed assault☹️ so much for being nice

[soft root]

that would be nice

new york would be interesting

[zinc oxide]

42 hours, 14% story 32% discovered am I doing well

[obtuse zodiac]

Yes

[tawdry lichen]

Hello fellow PC's

[night crown]

I also have the all black American standardbred

[obtuse zodiac]

Yeah that's a good one, all black horse

[night crown]

yea

[open sinew]

more likely it would be the early days of the gang, dutch and hosea and it would probably end with the blackwater boat heist that they talk about at the start of rdr2 and somewhere in that game arthur would probably be introduced with john

[open sinew]

my guess is they announce it late 2020s and release it mid 2030s

[open sinew]

about 1.5 - 2 hours on your first time

[nocturne bone]

So you skin then sell to camp or just sell to camp

[exotic drift]

Hi everyone
So got a question about the revolvers, im at Chapter 3 or 4 not sure but its in the Rhodes town. I kept my original revolvers just upgraded them. Are they good or i can buy better at the gunsmith?

[tropic anvil]

GUYS

how i go bactk to normal?

I pressed something and now I have a + sign and some options, like de select move rotate

[fast warren]

I just started a new game and I'm in chapter 2 and I can't find the ledger thing where u can upgrade the camp how do I get it

Or where Is it

[ember ridge]

You don't get it till a few missions in

[fast warren]

Ohh okau

[midnight ocean]

you should be able to buy a schofield

if you like it you can get a second one for free by robbing the valentine doctor's back room

[midnight ocean]

playing missions gets you money, theres also treasure maps you can do

you should also be introduced to the wagon fence soon

[hardy meadow]

How tf do i get a perfect rabbit pelt

I hit him in an EAR and it became from perfect to 1 star

[midnight ocean]

hit him with what

[hardy meadow]

Vermin, and low game arrow (two rabbits so far)

[midnight ocean]

small game arrow does not work

you need the varmint rifle

[hardy meadow]

Vermin does not either

[midnight ocean]

you need to hit a crit spot

[hardy meadow]

How is ear not critical 😭

[midnight ocean]

?

because its an ear lol what

if your ear got shot off would you instantly die

[hardy meadow]

I hit him in an ear and let him bleed out, how did that even damage the pelt

[hardy meadow]

Ear shot doesnt dmg pelt bruh

Pelt is lower torso

💀

[midnight ocean]

bled all over the pelt

anyway

hit in the head neck or heart

[hardy meadow]

😐

[midnight ocean]

you have to kill them in one shot

[ancient pagoda]

I don’t even know anymore if you guys are talking about rabbits in game or irl 😂

[honest jolt]

Any1 wanna play

[strange lily]

is it worth it to get a mod that boosts performace and keeps texture to max?

[eternal saffron]

can someone do the gambling challanges for me? idk how poker and domino's work

[midnight ocean]

wdym do them for you lol

[eternal saffron]

playing for me using share play

[midnight ocean]

i would if i had ps5 tbh

but poker is easy, its just about knowing the types of hands

[pastel galleon]

Can someone help me? Every time I go to take a screenshot on my console it takes a clip instead, Ive already gone into my settings and changed the bindings for the button to screenshot, the last time I took a screenshot it worked but now its only taking clips

[midnight ocean]

are you using the designated controller button

[pastel galleon]

Yes

[midnight ocean]

weird

mine screenshots

you can always do it the old fashioned way by hitting guide and then Y

[pastel galleon]

Everytime ive used it before this its taken a screenshot but even after changing the bindings it records a clip

[pastel galleon]

Yeah, but im trying to get ss of my horse moving and I feel like it won't turn out the way I want it

I think its broken now, I changed the bindings for the button to record and it didn't record anything, then I changed it back and still nothing, then I reset it to default and still nothing

[nocturne bone]

Guys do you need to skin then sell or just sell

[pastel galleon]

Depends on the animal because say you have a 3 star buck its 10 dollars for the carcass with the skin on but it will be less for the skin and the carcass, elk, bear, bison and gators are different because you cant pick up the animal

[nocturne bone]

Oo I see ok, am brand new to game so still working it all out

So much is goin on at once lmao

[pastel galleon]

Its okay!

[nocturne bone]

Can I get my own carriage and hunt for longer ? Or is it only just the horse I can use to carry animals

[pastel galleon]

You can always go on Google and search up animal carcass and pelt price and it'll pull up a reddit page that has all the info

[pastel galleon]

Your horse has unlimited pelt storage but I think you can only get the carriage in online for the trader role

[nocturne bone]

Oo okay nice , how many deer can you carry on a horse ? Just 1?

[pastel galleon]

Yes, other than the pelts you can store say two rabbits on the saddle

[midnight ocean]

its actually more for the parts not less

[pastel galleon]

How? The full carcass is 10, the pelt is 3.25 and the antlers are 1.35?

[midnight ocean]

what about the meat

[pastel galleon]

I dont pay attention to the meet prices because I cook it

[midnight ocean]

okay

what i said is still true tho

[pastel galleon]

Okay, I'm not going against you, I'm just saying what I know

[midnight ocean]

not that its worth it to break the animal down just for a little extra cash

[nocturne bone]

Omg just realised I didn’t have to walk back and forth with each animal to sell just leave it on my horse ffs

🤣😂

[pastel galleon]

😭

[strange lily]

does test of faith get reset if arthur eventually yk comes to that point and john can meet her?

[rare topaz]

is it possible to make the rolling block rifle or carcano scopeless or have the abillity to de-scope?

[regal shoal]

has anyone had a bug when they buy a weapon you just cant do anything in the gunsmith

like its just stuck swaying in the catalogue

[midnight ocean]

there is a glitch to remove the scope but i dont remember the details

[sullen lantern]

anything suggested for hunting the Ghost Bison?

[midnight ocean]

it doesnt reset

[strange lily]

least transfer to john?

[midnight ocean]

anything really

[midnight ocean]

yes, in fact some bones can only be found in the epilogue

[strange lily]

what if i find some of the bones as arthur and then john is given the rest to find in the epilogue?

[sullen lantern]

no like best way to kill or anything?

[midnight ocean]

for the legendaries you cant ruin the pelt so it doesnt matter

people sometimes recommend explosive ammo

[sullen lantern]

lake Isabella ain’t that in the cold area or sum? I just started playing the game like 2 days ago and still learning the map

[midnight ocean]

yes, you can find a good horse there too

[sullen lantern]

goodlucks ty

[obtuse zodiac]

Does anyone know if letters mean anything like a quest or something
Because I have lots, like I stole letters too bruh
And I'm not sure if I should just sell em to the fence or keep them

[midnight ocean]

no

they're just flavor

[rain plume]

Is modding allowed in single player

I gotta fix roles

[lapis sable]

Yes but in this server we cannot share mods

[rain plume]

okay so im using my family’s computer and i need help modding

[lapis sable]

We can't discuss troubleshooting mods too

[rain plume]

its not that i just cant get to lennys mod loader

microsoft family thing

Nvm found work around

[rare topaz]

how can i make it to where guns stay on my back and shoulder instead of going inside my saddle when i hop on my horse

im tired of needing to manuelly select them every time i ride my horse

[potent stirrup]

select them at the gunsmith

or any weapon locker

it usually stays for a while but sometimes its buggy

[midnight ocean]

dont think you can

[rare topaz]

aparently if you shoot near micah at his strawberry camp he just gets scared and runs away

what a loser

[tropic oyster]

on PC in the keybind settings explain to me how the "quick use item" button works

ive been trying to figure out how this keybind works for months now

been able to equip tonics might be handy at times

[tall radish]

I wonder is there a way to manually set the key for fishing? (I have 4 buttons on my mouse, just wanted to sit back and only use my mouse for fishing)

[azure hull]

You can key map in settings

[tall radish]

cant find options for the fishing keybinds there

[heady vector]

Micah talks like he will betray me at the end of the game

Im chapter 3 rn what weapons can I get?

[midnight ocean]

check rhodes gun store

[heady vector]

I robbed it and saved the boi

[heady vector]

When do I get the bolt action rifle?

[midnight ocean]

you can probably get it now

or itll be given to you on a mission

[tall radish]

wait isnt chapter 3 where u become the deputy in rhodes? iirc u cant pull out a gun during that chapter

[heady vector]

U can’t pull out a gun in Rhodes but u can out of Rhodes

[tall radish]

the gun store is in rhodes

I robbed the store on chapter 4, after that I just went on rampage.. triggered a wanted after I robbed the register lol

[night crown]

what’s the best gun in the game

[rare topaz]

dude i keep on hopping off rdr2 and thinking it will be for the day then hopping back on like 30 minutes later

its a cycle that will never end

[thorny cargo]

there is no "best gun" since it depends on what youre using it for.

[rare topaz]

u cant pull out your gun untill your no longer deputized

[night crown]

like all round stats

[rare topaz]

same thing

dosnt matter

[thorny cargo]

yeah theres no gun with all round stats

[night crown]

alr

[rare topaz]

why do you even want "the best gun in the game:

actually

stupid question

[night crown]

for a friend

duh

[thorny cargo]

i guess i use my alncaster for everything

lancaster

but its not an all-rounder

[rare topaz]

btw do you know where the roots thing for keiran is

[midnight ocean]

check near water for burdock root

[thorny cargo]

yes, the shore of water

waters

[rare topaz]

i usually run pump shotgun, then lancaster, or bolt action

[thorny cargo]

theres a lot near the water going up the river like. near clemens point

youll find it fast

[rare topaz]

i usually imeedietly go to rohdes to pick up the lancaster and then end up with an extra cuz micah gives you one

i hate haveing duplicate weapons that aernt pistols

or revolvers

then again i dont even use pistol

it feels wrong

[obtuse zodiac]

So sell them?

Including those pics of Albert Mason and stuff

[midnight ocean]

if you want to lol

i didnt even think they were worth anything

[soft root]

Double action revolver users, what makes you use double action revolver?

[soft root]

Yeah, the m1889 pistols are awesome though, fast and accurate

[tropic oyster]

i think its how they look which me use them

i would use them in a serious situation tho

since dead is a thing id use them

[soft root]

I have been...thinking about using them in my next playthrough

[tropic oyster]

but if i was to pull a fight and restrict myself from deadeye id never use the double action

[tropic oyster]

for the longest time i had been using the guns without the extended barrel after adding them i realized they are more decently accuracte

[soft root]

Their firing speed is very fast after all, but I'm not sure if their lack of accuracy will hinder me too much

[soft root]

Yeah, extended barrel is a must

They're fast guns.....

[tropic oyster]

to make a big impact u gotta dual wield plus it does less damage so u gotta focus on headshots more

[soft root]

....quick fire with the double action is quicker than quick fire with the schofield, right?

[tropic oyster]

should be faster than schofield

some people actually throw shade into the the double action but i still love them

they would be the pistols of rdr2 if actual pistol didnt exist

[soft root]

Man, I am definitely gonna replay rdr2 soon

Gonna be low honor arthur

[tropic oyster]

i still use them in red dead online too

in storymode atm iam using double action

made them silver yesterday they look awsome

[soft root]

Last time I was low honor arthur, that save was in ch4 and I had a good fit

[wary jacinth]

When I’ve just started playing as the character John Marston, it’s not possible to change the horse’s saddle. Is it the same for you as well?
Do the missions need to be completed first?

Also, are the legendary satchel and the legendary horse saddle that were for Arthur no longer available?

[gaunt sky]

guys after hundreds of painstaking hours i can finally say

i finished rdr2

[eternal saffron]

could someone help me complete the gambling challanges? i suck at poker and dominos. ps5

[nocturne bone]

I keep donating meat to camp and other stuff but still all in the red

[grizzled cedar]

"Oh, you dont build a barn" he says before outlining how they are going to build a barn

[sullen lantern]

did you do side missions?

just curious

[glad flame]

Well the game is based on luck so you cant say you suck.

[eternal saffron]

welp if i dont understand the rules i think i can state that i suck

[glad flame]

the only thing i do is just press "call" or whatever it says i forgor.

[warped geode]

i love drunk walking in rdr1

[naive shoal]

does anybody know where i can find woodpeckers?

[thick cloak]

So in the middle of Dutch's speech, there was lightning.

[glad flame]

Me too.

[thick cloak]

Between Clemens Point and Horseshoe Overlook, what's your favorite camp?

[glad flame]

Probably Horseshoe overlook.

[thick cloak]

Does anyone else...not get the hate for Mary?

I get it. I totally get her. The conflicting feelings with her and Arthur, what they want vs the lives they're living, how she eventually had to end things because the way they're going, nothing's going to change...and Arthur understands.

[glad flame]

Dang i cant read all that

[thick cloak]

A grand total of 3 sentences.

3 goddang sentences.

[glad flame]

💩

Well.

Imma try.

[thick cloak]

I wish I could refurbish Shady Belle.

Micah had a brother?

[warped geode]

sad that it isn't in rdr2

[solid current]

i’m gonna crash out i’m trying to hunt squirrels and i keep losing my small game arrows

they’re so annoying to craft😭

[round heath]

Is there a way to go back to playing as Arthur after finishing the epilogue?

[molten crest]

No

[round heath]

Like, there's no chapter select or nothing?

[molten crest]

You can replay missions which have Arthur in them

[round heath]

but no way to just free roam?

[molten crest]

Nope unless you got another save file as arthur

[round heath]

noted

[solid current]

this is why i try to keep a save file for each chapter in every playthrough so i can go back to whatever chapter i want

[hidden moss]

She gets hate??

[lapis panther]

TAHITI

[lapis panther]

My two favourite camps. I say Horsehsoe just edges it for me as the view from the cliff is nice and it feels more homely

[solid current]

a lot💔 but mostly just misogynistic people who hate half the women in the game

[lapis panther]

Fort Brennand is a good place

[naive shoal]

alright im heading there right now, i looked it up on google and it said a good spot was ranoake valley so i been searching there and have just kept goind down the river, ive been searching for over an hour now 🫠

[lapis panther]

Good luck in finding one. Check the rocks at any riverside as birds tend to spawn on top of boulders

[hidden moss]

Why do they hate her?? She's just there as Arthur love interest.

[naive shoal]

thank you! I have been keeping an eye on every rock ive seen 😭

[solid current]

i’ve seen them along the dakota river a couple times, plenty of birds on the boulders there

[naive shoal]

i know i saw multiple blue jays song birds sparrows orioles but not a single woodpecker

[rare topaz]

Dude

i wanted a screenshot of charles throwing micah

but reverend fuckin

distracted me

came up asking some schizo shit

[solid current]

i hate when he does that bro😭😭 EVERY time theres an encounter that u wanna see hes suddenly there yapping in ur ear

[rare topaz]

also i think tilly haunts you in the woods if you dont play dominos with her

i was out in like murfree country

and i just hear

"hi arthur"

[gaunt sky]

EVERYTHING. also side missions are i think even required for 100%. i even got the best weapons, customized them all, got pretty much every tailor outfit, almost all talismans and trinkets

if i wanna go full completionist i can hunt the rest of 100 cigarette cards

have all the top tier horses in my stable with the best saddles and so on

rn i have about 240 hours and at 260-300 max i should for sure have acomplished everything there is and will probably start a new playthrough

i will also try some glitches to get in guarma if i can as john

[sullen lantern]

good shi bro

[midnight ocean]

did you get 100%?

you can get a special role for it in here

oh you still need the cards

[glad flame]

Yea rdr2 drunk physics arent as fun as rdr1's

[warped geode]

only good thing is that there's custom voicelines in rdr2 and i think there aren't in rdr1 i'm not sure tho

[glad flame]

Yea and the effects are better

But rdr1 physics are better in my opinion

[warped geode]

true

also sad that in rdr1 if you shoot both legs he can't move

[glad flame]

Wait why did my color change

[midnight ocean]

real

[glad flame]

Yea in rdr2 they just run for some reason.

[spring swift]

Rdr

[glad flame]

Well now there is a 2nd

[midnight ocean]

get out

[spring swift]

Why

[midnight ocean]

we dont do that here

[spring swift]

Do what?

I cant say rdr in a rdr server?

Bruh

[midnight ocean]

no

[mossy basalt]

guys what should i do before our best selves

[rare topaz]

strauss takes 1 bullet to the leg and hes forced to sit on a wagon while a defenseless npc takes 3 bullets to legs and runs faster then my horse

[wary jacinth]

At the lawyers tonight

[midnight ocean]

have you done aberdeen pig farm

[stoic furnace]

I'm trying to platinum the game and I realized I haven't done 3 missions from chapter 4. I just found out they're honor missions. Do I need them for the 100% completion trophy? From what I've seen, I need to do 104 missions in the game for the trophy; 104 are all the missions. Do I really need this, or can I finish my 100%, then go back to my save and do the honor missions, thus getting both achievements and moving on?

[midnight ocean]

anything missable is not needed for 100%

idk what you mean by both achievements

[stoic furnace]

the best in the West: 100%
lending a hand: honor missions

because I had seen in some guide that it was necessary to do 104 missions for 100%

[candid stratus]

I wasn't exactly sure where to post this so ill post it here. I have been playing and loving RDR2 for the last couple of days and wanted to add some mods. I saw a thread where someone says to play with Sgt. Joe's bank robberies mod. Now in Rhodes, everyone is invisible upon entering a building. I unfortunately do not have a prior save and don't know what to do. From what I read, this has ruined my save. Does ANYONE have a fix for this? Can I edit my save maybe to fix this somehow? The mod is already uninstalled, and I have no clue what to do. I honestly really don't want to restart, as I'm 13 hours in, and frankly, if I have to, I probably will just stop playing.

[midnight ocean]

yeah those are the 104 non-optional story missions

so you should be able to go back and get lending a hand on another save

the devs did us a solid and made it so you cant miss 100%, although it is easier to attain if you start it from the beginning

[subtle finch]

Man

sailing down the river in the bayou with a steamboat is a vibe

[mossy basalt]

too late and forgot to do research

[midnight ocean]

rip

no biggie tho its not like you need it

[mossy basalt]

yeah i only had like

1.5k

[midnight ocean]

what???

[mossy basalt]

?

[midnight ocean]

in chapter 6?

[mossy basalt]

not a big crime doer

[midnight ocean]

you get thousands just for story missions tho

[mossy basalt]

spent it ig

[midnight ocean]

thats wild lol

must have some sick guns

[mossy basalt]

plus i gave money to like

every person i got for honor

[midnight ocean]

same

[mossy basalt]

meh

[midnight ocean]

i just hoarded mine ig

[mossy basalt]

im on the ranch as john rn

[midnight ocean]

i had 15k at the end

[mossy basalt]

i lowk ruined the story for me by going on the wiki a lot

[midnight ocean]

now john has like 37

[mossy basalt]

but wtv still peak

[midnight ocean]

yeah i did that with the og

i went to john marstons wiki page before i played the last mission

[mossy basalt]

i got lending a hand on my first playthrough tho

highest honor is so peak

[midnight ocean]

yeah i do everything high honor i can

which balances out all the trains i be robbin

[mossy basalt]

another reason i was poor

didnt rob anything

[midnight ocean]

yeah that was probably a very small chunk of my overall cash tho

most of it was just from the main missions

i just didnt see anything to spend it all on

[eternal estuary]

How much time would have to pass for yall to consider rdr2 a retro game

I say when the ps4 is 3 generations behind is when rdr2 can be called a retro game

So when we’re on the ps7 basically

[thorny cargo]

im not sure ps will make it that far

[glad flame]

probably at 2032-2035

[soft root]

it will take a long, long time

and, will require graphics technology to advance to a whole other level

bc well, rdr2 is 8 years old now

and still going strong with the graphics

[flint flint]

finally killed the damn legendary bear ! 🐻 shame why we can't post pic here 🙁
i notice I was hunting for a bull and cow hide, I can just lasso them and gut them and still get perfect pelt...? or i was just lucky.

[soft root]

no, that is actually a tactic to get perfect pelt

well, you won't ruin the pelt at least

if they had a bad pelt from the start, nothing can really improve on that

[flint flint]

this is what i want to know

also i don't understand the having 2 horse trick of getting pelt faster, can someone elaborate or pretend i'm 4 and dumb it down for me?

[soft root]

ok, the more horses you have, the more pelts you can carry

and, if you can carry more pelts, ergo, you don't have to make as many trips to a place to sell the pelts

so you can focus more time on gathering pelts

and less time travelling back and forth to sell pelts so you have space to carry new pelts

2 horse trick matters when you're gathering pelts that or deer, elk, bison, bear, big stuff

if you're just gathering small pelts like rabbit or squirrel, you don't need horses for that

[brave sphinx]

i love rdr2

[soft root]

me too, even if I don't play it, everytime rdr2 vids start popping back into my feed, it makes me wanna replay rdr2 again

[brave sphinx]

yeah i took my time to fully enjoy the game and immerse myself

[flint flint]

some reason im reading this like a very condescending tone in my mind 🤣

ok so how i like have two horses ?? the 2nd one will just follow me ?? I can only ride 1 horse..

[lapis sable]

Yes, the second horse will just follow you based on your whistle

And if you bond with it to max level as a temp horse, you can call it at it's longest range without having to backtrack

[fair lark]

Helloo! Im having trouble with missions bugging out in the prologue, I have a bunch of mods installed. In "Old friends", as soon as I get to the camp they just start shooting and I get killed. Is it ok to ask here? Or should I ask in a different chat

[flint flint]

WTF

but you can't do this with your main horse ? ?

[lapis sable]

I mean to say you can have 2 max bonded horse, 1 main 1 temp

[flint flint]

i mean the whistle at no limit range

[lapis sable]

But its harder to get max bonding for temp horse

[flint flint]

you mean longest as ing just further or no limit lol

i may have misunderstood

[lapis sable]

It does have a limit range, but its significantly bigger for max bonded horses

[flint flint]

it's still shit though 😅

there are few mission for some weird reason, I mean I had to ride another horse or whatever, so my main horse was left exactly the spot there and I finished the misison being super far away from my horse....

not a good time... 🤦

[soft root]

Remember, you have temporary horses, they can follow you, you can at most have 2 horses

[soft root]

I once got a temporary horse stuck somewhere in the mountains, it remained there for as long as I could remember

[obtuse zodiac]

Just get bonding level 1 with temp horse and make it follow u that's it

[zinc oxide]

ngl I think Ima neglect fasttravel because it feels like Im killing a part of the game

[soft root]

yeah, fast travel makes you miss many sights

[formal wolf]

I had completed 82% of Story Mode on my main save. Recently, I wanted to restart the story while keeping that old save. However, whenever I play the new Story Mode run, the game asks me to overwrite the existing save file.
If I choose "No," it says automatic saves will be disabled.
I’m worried I’ll eventually misclick and overwrite my original save if I don’t find a proper solution. Am I misunderstanding how this works? Do I need to manually back up or copy my save file somewhere?

[flint flint]

if the map isn't this insanely large...and the horse moving at 1 MPH I wouldn't mind lol...

[heady vector]

What is the best rifle ?And where do I get it?

[bleak iron]

It's just your autosave file, turn it off if you want, save the game manually, and then turn autosave back on

As long as your 82% wasn't only in your autosave slot it won't be overwritten

[midnight ocean]

yeah just open the menu and save lol

[obtuse zodiac]

Can u lose the horse u get from ultimate edition?

[midnight ocean]

wdym lose

its not invulnerable so yeah

[thorny cargo]

the ultimate edition horse is the only one you can get back if it dies iirc, you can retrieve it again at the valentine stable but you lose your bonding level and stuff.

you just get a new version of the same horse

[obtuse zodiac]

Oh that's makes it so much better

Thanks

[midnight ocean]

just use deadeye and your horse will never die

[deep glacier]

What’s the best way of doing master hunter 7?

Like what’s the best spot for it

[thorny cargo]

i did mine near the trapper north of owanjila.

usually do mine there

cuz theres boars and foxes etc. sometimes wolves

remember that the baits only work if the animal is already spawned. so just look for wherever a herbivore and predator are conventiently near each other, then place the baits, then kill them

[deep glacier]

Preciate you

I just didn’t know of any decent locations

[thorny cargo]

another good place is east of valentine, the heartlands, with deer and coyotes

mhm

[midnight ocean]

same

boars are very plentiful for a predator

[hidden moss]

Trying to learn the map of red dead 2 and all the locations without using the map is really fun and immersive. Because the environments are so distinct from each other

[soft root]

The most popular rifle is the bolt action, considered by many to be the 'best', you can obtain it from a gunsmith

[hollow yew]

ive got a quest (the winton holmes loan) that I can't complete because of my wanted level since its right next to strawberry. how do I get that down?

[flint flint]

i don't think there's ever like ' best ' weaps in most Rockstar games lol...they all just different by the firing rate maybe bit of accuracy but it's never really a big deal to me because first shot is always a headshot and that's all it takes

I guess Range maybe noticeable in RDR2 with different weapons, revolvers/pistols are quite bad at long range 😫

[hollow yew]

I mean, I'm new to the game but I say bow superiority in all gun games regardless

<----biased from TLOU

[midnight ocean]

pay it off at a post office

but also it shouldnt be too difficult to do it with the bounty active

[hollow yew]

nono its literally locked

like, the game says that I can't do it due to a wanted level, and ive got a $300 bounty for the mission where you slaughter the whole town

[midnight ocean]

wdym it says you cant do it

like a notif thats popping up or the marker is locked or what

[hollow yew]

both

theres a little padlock icon on the map marker and when I go to the location it says its locked due to a wanted level

presumably from my $300 bounty from the afformentioned mission

[midnight ocean]

well i guess you gotta pay it then

[hollow yew]

and I can just stroll into strawberry to the sheriff's office to do that? I wont get killed?

[midnight ocean]

no you have to pay it off elsewhere

like valentine

[hollow yew]

also wanted there of course, but I can do it in rhodes

[midnight ocean]

lol

[hollow yew]

like I said, new to this game and have zero clue what I'm doing lul

[midnight ocean]

its weird that the bounty stopped you from doing that one, usually you can do main missions with a bounty with no problem

[hollow yew]

its fun dispite my 5 hours eorth of in game time all dumped into troubleshooting (I learned that the game does not like computers with second moniters)

[hollow yew]

weird

[midnight ocean]

yeah pc presents some unique challenges

[hollow yew]

this game does feel duct taped together in some ways

kinda charming if you can get past the issues

[midnight ocean]

well it was initially released for console only and then ported to pc

i think

[hollow yew]

its annoying, I posted a bad review after my progress got wiped and I had to replay the entire first chapter and a little of the second while trying to debug the game because I didnt figure out what the issue was (I was fed up) and got a clown award on steam for posting a bad review of a game that id had a bad experience with qwq

I have since updated my review

but yeah that happened

[midnight ocean]

was it an autosave issue?

[hollow yew]

I have no clue. I made the progress over multiple sessions so it had saved at one point

[midnight ocean]

unfortunate

[hollow yew]

yeah

ive also had some other here and there issues

[wooden island]

Did you manually save though?

[hollow yew]

like arthur deciding to hang up his pistol and find the way of the pacifist right as he pissed off a gunman

[hollow yew]

is that even an option? I have no clue where the save button is lol

[wooden island]

In the menu when you pause the game

Suppose it could be different maybe for PC?

[hollow yew]

I see map, help, progress, player, story, online, social club, settings, and quit game

[wooden island]

Story

That's how you save

Click it and should give you save, load, start new game

[hollow yew]

ohhhhhhh

[wooden island]

You silly goose

[hollow yew]

I figured it was like

a recap of the story thus far qwq

[wooden island]

That's okay, common mistake

[hollow yew]

anyways, yeah after I was killed arthur decided he'd had enough, challenged a guy to a gun contest and decided to kill him right there for no reason

also the horses seem to love spinning

[wooden island]

The game is so buggy

Wait check #general-media

[hollow yew]

yeah, but when its not annoying, its charming

its not the buggiest game ive ever played (that might go to skyrim but not sure), but its definitely up there

[midnight ocean]

horse controls kinda wonky on m&k

from what ive been told

[wooden island]

The buggiest game I ever played was fallout 4

[midnight ocean]

they dont call em bugthesda for nothing

[hollow yew]

I actually kinda like them. the weird thing is that s isnt stop, it just turns your horse, and you use control to break

I just learned that tonight

would have been useful before I accidentally destroyed like 5 stolen carriages but whatever lul

[hollow yew]

omg wait I also just realized that I could have been save scumming if I wanted to. I literally thought it just wasnt an option

not that I'm gonna start

I just

thought it was impossible lul

[wooden island]

Save scumming?

[hollow yew]

loading an old save to reverse a bad decision

[wooden island]

Ohhh

I mean you could have auto save on if you don't wanna manually save

[hollow yew]

no I do

I didnt know there was a manual save button until 10:02 EST today

[wooden island]

LMAO😝

[hollow yew]

truthfully, I am enjoying the game though in spite of all of the jank. I love arthur's voice

[wooden island]

Roger Clark is the goat

[hollow yew]

its gonna be fun when my neurodivergrnt ass starts adopting some of the speech patterns and articulation, to make me vaugely a british westerner from italy

[midnight ocean]

oh i be saving constantly and re loading if my horse dies

[hollow yew]

(because yes, thats already kinda happened a little bit)

[hollow yew]

yeah

[midnight ocean]

or in case something happens like i miss out on an item i need

[hollow yew]

personally I like doing without save scumming, but I will if I make a catastrophic decision

[midnight ocean]

i had to go back several missions to make sure i got some dumb watch that you only have one opportunity to get

[wooden island]

That's why I did most of the exploring of the map and locations in chap 2

[hollow yew]

I actually lost the legendary bear pelt both times I played through the intro qwq

I would have save scummed that if I knew about it

kinda loving chapter 3's irony lul

[wooden island]

That sucks 😟

[hollow yew]

oh, another issue I keep having btw, arthur forgets how to move occasionally for a few seconds

not a huge issue tho, typically happens more in areas where I'm not allowed to run

[wooden island]

That'll happen

[hollow yew]

yeah, real funky game

[midnight ocean]

all you really lost is money

you can still craft everything craftable from the pelt

[wooden island]

Oh yeah you could

[hollow yew]

alright well thats good to know

ty

[wooden island]

I remember one time my horse died when carrying the beaver pelt and I still got the pelt at the trapper

[hollow yew]

is there any reason to bring them to the trapper rather than just donating the whole animal at camp?

[wooden island]

You can't donate the legendary animals at camp I believe

But correct me if I'm wrong

Also a easy money method is buying a ticket from Saint Denis to Annenberg and then stopping the train in the tunnel and robbing it

[hollow yew]

ive not even gotten to those places yet lul

still in rhodes and haven't explored most of the map yet

[wooden island]

You can explore when you're in chapter 2

That's what I did

In chapter 2 I did everything I could

[hollow yew]

I like to let the story take me

[wooden island]

That's fair honestly

[hollow yew]

I mean, I'm only 25% if the way through the story. I figure I'll get curious before I get all the way

[midnight ocean]

the trapper can sell you clothing and saddles made from legendary and regular animal pelts

[hollow yew]

ohhhh

[midnight ocean]

pearson can use pelts to craft better satchels

[hollow yew]

gotcha

[midnight ocean]

if you buy the leather working tools

in the ledger

also after you've killed a legendary you can usually go to the fence and craft a trinket

which will provide a permanent passive ability

[hollow yew]

gotcha

tyyy

[midnight ocean]

np

[hollow yew]

yeah, I feel like a number of systems are either poorly explained or not really explained

or if they were, I missed it

[midnight ocean]

yeah i think they just assume when they tell you about the fence that you're gonna check him out and see what he has

[hollow yew]

I did not lul

I got distracted

I don't have adhd, you have adhd /j

[midnight ocean]

lol

you're right tho there are some things that are very mysterious

people argue about whether horses have a courage stat to this very day

also the way other stuff works like masks/witnesses is kinda weird

[hollow yew]

and nobody has dug through the code?

[midnight ocean]

people have

but somehow theres still disagreement

[hollow yew]

fair

I guess kinda like the disproving of L IS REAL 2015

or whatever the number was

[wooden island]

It only works for citizens

The law sees through it immediately

[midnight ocean]

yeah

which is strange but also if the mask worked on lawmen then it would be kinda OP

[wooden island]

Yuppers

[soft root]

I think the law recognizes us bc we never change our clothes

[subtle finch]

My horse just died while i was trying to rob a train

[midnight ocean]

sadly common

[hallow folio]

Lennyyyyy

[lapis sable]

Recently i'm revisiting the use of fire arrows and fire bottles and incendiary shots from shotguns to kill more folk

It feels so fun to burn folks alive in the train as i rob em

[midnight ocean]

🥱

[molten tusk]

Yo what’s the best side quest

I’m tryna do something outside of a mission

I beat the game 4 times and rn I’m in chapter 3

[wary jacinth]

Just can’t give it up hey goof

[midnight ocean]

do em all

also consider hunting or bounty hunting

[oblique quiver]

imo the noblest of men and a woman

most enjoyable for me

[open shell]

I just finished the epilogue!!

[deep glacier]

An easy restart of the game will bring it back to life

[calm lagoon]

Had that happen with my white arabian last playthrough 😭