red-dead-singleplayer

[violet obsidian]

First got shot, second ran over by train, third ran too hard in a tree and died, fourth train, again

[trim hamlet]

goddamn

[trim hamlet]

third is low-key your fault

if you stop holding a and d then your horse will auto-evade trees

try it

run straight at a tree without holding anything but forward

it will dodge it

[violet obsidian]

Not on pc

[violet obsidian]

Yea i know, i was in a hurry to end the mission because i didn't want to lose the progress and i wasn't paying attention

Rest in peace ma horsey 3

[grizzled haven]

im doing an Indigenous mix with cowboy with Arthur. any horses recommended to match?

(yes im the person who matches outfits with horses)

[thorny cargo]

american paint!

[grizzled haven]

thank you!

[violet obsidian]

Did you finish the game yet?

[grizzled haven]

I'm beginning chapter 2 of my 5th run

[violet obsidian]

Oh alright haha

Well there's a really nice and pretty horse a tad west of the wapiti reservation

Tame him

It's got great stats aswell

[grizzled haven]

Ooh! I know the one you're talking about

[violet obsidian]

With the white mark on it's side

I feel like it'd sit

Considering it's also near their camp

[obtuse zodiac]

Someone tell me there's a way to get the raven black shire again

[thorny cargo]

npe

nope

[obtuse zodiac]

Wow

It died when I had no horse revives

[obtuse zodiac]

Can I get a horse that has similar stats?

[thorny cargo]

a regular shire i suppose?

[obtuse zodiac]

Is it a big difference

[trim hamlet]

oh

just connect a keyboard to your Playstation /j

[violet obsidian]

Haven't tried it, but I'm too used to the controller now

I'm going to finish the game soon anyway

Then I'll play a string of games, replay rdr2 and buy rdr

[trim hamlet]

I mean if you somehow managed to go straight forward (which is near impossible on a controller unless it's a N64 controller or smth) then maybe the same mechanic would work

[violet obsidian]

Oh well

It is what it is

[trim hamlet]

cause the N64 controller joysticks weren't circular around the edges

it was like an octagon that was tilted so that the points were directly up, down, left, right, and in between each cardinal direction

[obtuse zodiac]

Can u feed ur horse when ur on it?

[trim hamlet]

yep!

press and hold whatever button you use for weapon wheel. while you have that button held, press RB till you get to the Horse tab, then select the food on the left. Your weapon wheel button should stay held through all of this.

[obtuse zodiac]

Alr thanks

[violet obsidian]

What I'd do to play this game for the first time again

[bold yacht]

who else thinks the blackjack odds are bs

[bold yacht]

3 hits didnt bust and dealer got 20 twice n beat me

shit ass game

[lapis sable]

Stand up from the table, shoot them all to get your money back

[bold yacht]

i just need the challenge completion 😭

[lapis sable]

After you are done with the challenge, stand up and shoot them

[bold yacht]

bro i got blackjack then dealer got it then i got it

this game aint real

[obtuse zodiac]

Actually?

Like it won't just give u 40 cents when u loot dead pepe

[lapis sable]

Yeah but the corpses in the saloon will reward you plenty

[obtuse zodiac]

I will def try

[bold yacht]

u dont get money back

only body loot

[obtuse zodiac]

Oh ig I misunderstood

What he said made it seem like u get the money back

[bold yacht]

this fucking dealer

push me twice again

on 17 and 18

istg the game programs his deck to match mine so the odds of me completeing this challenge are impossible

[frank hamlet]

yeah i hate in game blackjack for that reason oml

[bold yacht]

i finished gambler 8

fuck this dealer

[lapis sable]

Go on. Stand up, shoot em all!

Reason for getting $1,500 bounty in a state: gambling rage

[supple sky]

How do I make Arthur fat?

A question I wanna ask even more is where I can sell valuables

Pls help ;-;

[brave sphinx]

the fence, there's one in emerald ranch

and another north of rhodes

[vagrant kindle]

Fence in emerald ranch

You unlock it after spines of America

[supple sky]

Thanks!

[humble sonnet]

hello

i am john marston

[royal stirrup]

Nice

[violet obsidian]

John

What do we think of micah

[raven vessel]

I always thought the missiouri fox trotter was like super expensive in story mode

only 950

[violet obsidian]

Pocket change

[raven vessel]

lmao

[violet obsidian]

Money is easy to get

[elder saddle]

Its the most expensive horse and the best horse with 10 speed bars in online

[gritty trail]

yea i got that one

[elder saddle]

Ye I have it too maxed

Play and learn

[gritty trail]

💀

fr

[gritty trail]

ever since my arabian died i keep 3 horse revivers on me now

[elder saddle]

Did you not have it insured?

[gritty trail]

wha?

how do u that?

[elder saddle]

Bruh

You didn't know this?

[gritty trail]

nah

is it in story mode?

[elder saddle]

Ah

You talking about story

[gritty trail]

yeah

but i found out abt that after the horsey died

[elder saddle]

Unfortunate then

[sacred yarrow]

It just feels like i have an limit on ps5

and the thought of playing on pc it just seems like i have much more to do and many more possibilities

[ember ridge]

Eat lots of big game meat, chocolate, alochol. intereact with a few people, sleep alot etc etc

[bleak iron]

I don't why but rockstar made the console version way too reliant on auto aim, it's so goddamn sticky with a joystick when you turn it off

[supple sky]

Thanks

I should probably stop sprinting a bunch

I bet it’s burning off the calories

[bleak iron]

I think it's more time based, almost no foods in this game have calories so just snack on the ones that do from time to time

I think crackers a good one

They made the weight system in online so bs I'm snacking all the time, prolly gave my guy diabetes so he can tank more hits

[manic cipher]

it's pretty difficult to do micro adjustments on a controller

when compared to a mouse

[dusty hill]

Noooo arthur died

[livid wind]

Finished American venom

Peak

[livid wind]

A character dies then 30 mins later ur milking cows

Crazy game

[ember ridge]

Food has food points

[hollow dagger]

a character dies then 30 mins im finally playing as my favorite character

[ember ridge]

Each item of food has a diff amount of food points which can helpy ou gain weight, Big game meat has like 10?? i think??

[sly field]

bar meals also help, i feed my arthur meals from the nearest bar 4 - 5 times and eat the essentials in my satchel when i need to and he's average weight ^^

[bleak iron]

90% of foods have low calories is what i mean

[ember ridge]

Well that's just not correct

[bleak iron]

Meant low calories

Typo*

[ember ridge]

Oh

Yeah

Low calories yeah, but still better then none

There's alot ofmgood stuff. I can link a Reddit thread rhabjas the list of consumables and their calorie count

[bleak iron]

They are physically called calories in game, i just wish they showed how many calories a food had in the catalogue. I believe the only list is the official guide book that comes with the game?

[ember ridge]

Yeah I think so

[bleak iron]

Its so dumb they hide info about the items, same thing for seeing how many heat points clothes have

[raven vessel]

My horse is such a pussy

Threw me off his back and fed me to the cougars

[bleak iron]

Max bond makes the skittish horses a bit more bearable

But for most horses max bond is enough, if you want them to never buck you off ever. Get a war horse

[raven vessel]

Which is the best war horse

Turkoman?

[bleak iron]

Andalusian and Mustang are the bravest i think

If you want good stats the turkomann is a hybrid and is the 3rd best horse in the game

[wary jacinth]

You really get off on that what a creep it’s too bad your so spineless

🖕

[raven vessel]

Damn

[trim hamlet]

this also exists for horse foods btw

[hollow dagger]

just keep the raven black shire 🙂

the horse you didn't ask for nor deserve but you get it

[bleak iron]

a shame most people sell that beauty

[trim hamlet]

hate to be that guy but bravery is NOT breed-dependent

it's ONLY bonding dependent

some breeds just take longer to bond so they feel skittish for longer

Arabian is 500 pts per bonding level, Ardennes is 250.

[bleak iron]

I dunno, its a big unknown thing what effects the hidden stat.

Might be a myth, was it ever confirmed?

[trim hamlet]

the guide says it's just bonding.

the reason why the "won't spook as easily" text is in the description of war horse breeds such as the Ardennes is because war horses bond really quick so they stop being skittish

so I guess it does technically depend on breed, but not in the way you're thinking

[bleak iron]

Was it confirmed breeds have absolutely 0 effect on bravery?

[trim hamlet]

it's not possible to test that, but the only thing that we know from official game guides and info is that bonding affects it. Nothing mentions breed.

If it affected it, why wouldn't that be communicated to players?

[bleak iron]

Crazy how much mis info vids there are on RDR2

[bleak iron]

Rockstar have done that before, example being the buck antler trinket. They really do suck at explaining their mechanics sometimes

Things like these are noteworthy because of how popular them as debates still are, so unless rockstar confirms most of it we honestly never know

[woeful basin]

Hi I really wanna play story mode on RDR2 but I don’t have the money can anyone share the game with me?

[bleak iron]

But the horse thing does make a lot of sense its just crazy how popular that is if its completely false

[untold hazel]

Hello

[raven vessel]

that’s the horse I’m using

how is he gonna be one of the bigger horses and still be this scared

[trim hamlet]

How much bonding level do you have

[trim hamlet]

yeah

Like, i mean it makes sense irl right? If a horse takes longer to trust you, then it would seem more skittish at first. But once you've bonded with it, and it trusts you, it would be a loyal companion

[raven vessel]

4

[trim hamlet]

is it still getting scared?

cause you know you can hold the calm button and not just press it, right?

That'll calm it down faster.

[raven vessel]

Hold??

[snow otter]

I let my sister do the LENNNNYYY mission

she walked on the 2 lennys in the room doing uhuh

some stuff

[raven vessel]

what if that was actually lenny with his brother and he just quickly got dressed so arthur wouldn’t suspect nothing

🤔

[snow otter]

prolly

[trim hamlet]

yeah

like you can keep the "Calm" button held, and it will calm it faster than if you pressed it repeatedly.

[hidden moss]

does anyone here have whyems dlc

[trim hamlet]

uh

that's modding stuff

[hidden moss]

yea

[trim hamlet]

i don't do that
(despite being on PC lmao)

[hidden moss]

why not

i only want it for more outfits

[trim hamlet]

uh

so i don't actually know how to install that

i know someone who does

[hidden moss]

would you please ask him to talk to me

[trim hamlet]

sure
i'll create a group in dms if you're alr with that?

[hidden moss]

yes im fine with that

@trim hamlet

[raven vessel]

damn bro I never found the drunk fort riggs veteran before

[obtuse zodiac]

Do the crafting options at camp provide any usage?

Or is it just for decoration

[midnight ocean]

holy shit

[midnight ocean]

aside from the satchels yeah its just deco

[quaint lintel]

where is wild mint typically found

[obtuse zodiac]

They give extra storage?

[midnight ocean]

yes, and if you get all of them you can craft the OP one that holds 99 of almost every item

except watches idk why

[elder saddle]

Ye bruh

Everything has some sort of usage in camp

Except uncle

[midnight ocean]

well i think he was talking about like the moose antlers and the cougar rug and stuff

[violet obsidian]

Does getting the low honour ending give an achievement? If i already did the high honour

[thorny cargo]

no

the only thing might be extreme personality, reach max or minimum honor, but if you did high honor already im assuming you already got that one

[violet obsidian]

Ok i can do that ez

Spoiler messages are not allowed ? Sad

[violet obsidian]

That's a relief, I didn't want that to happen, i wouldn't be able to live with myself

[thorny cargo]

just cuz automod cant detect it

[violet obsidian]

Oh alright

[violet obsidian]

I didn't want to phrase it like this but eh

You get the point

[thorny cargo]

mhm

[violet obsidian]

How am i ever gonna play another story game after this

If humans could forget things permanently on command, I'd be forgetting the plot of rdr2 every month

[smoky wadi]

2 more missions before bed…. Sees the mission is “our best selves”

[violet obsidian]

Those words strike fear in my soul

[fair hearth]

can someone tell me who or what the nite folk are??? are they like the Lemoyne raiders??

[thorny cargo]

the night folk are kinda like the lemoyne raiders i suppose... but a lot creepier

[fair hearth]

how?

[thorny cargo]

they lurk in the swamps. they will stalk you and attack you. if you see a hanging/dead body and approach it, theyll spook you off your horse and then ambush you

[fair hearth]

oh-

[thorny cargo]

and theyre also connected to the wailing woman you hear in the swamps... if u approach her youll get attacked.

i heard they can also kill your horse if its left alone far from you but i think thats a myth.

[fair hearth]

i did see a woman crying though i just left.

[thorny cargo]

yeah

its a trap

[fair hearth]

oh good to know

are they like good in combat or are like decent like how the lemoyne raiders are

[thorny cargo]

uuhhh

i dont know? a lot of them use machetes and close-range weapons and sneak up on you unlike the raiders.

[fair hearth]

oh

good to know

so..do they only hangout at the swamps?

[thorny cargo]

yeah

[fair hearth]

ok

do you whats a good weapon do use to fight them?

[thorny cargo]

a repeater or rifle to get them from far away

[fair hearth]

ok also thx your the only person i actually got a good answer from.

ive been playing rdr2 since like june or july of last year but i somehow never heard of the nite folk

[next kayak]

Anyone know how i open the Log menu on PC?

[hollow dagger]

m

[quick python]

who's y'all's favorite side character that isn't a part of the van der linde gang?

[bright yacht]

does anyone have a reliable cougar location map?

[dusky citrus]

charles chatenay

he’s hot

[bright yacht]

charlotte balfour

[dusky citrus]

no but isnt the internet a reliable source?

[hollow dagger]

ur flagged as a spammer btw

[dusky citrus]

well maybe not

[bright yacht]

bruh

[dusky citrus]

what me?

[hollow dagger]

u

'1 message hidden from likely spammer'

[dusky citrus]

ouh

[bright yacht]

yea i know idek why

[hollow dagger]

per message of yours

[bright yacht]

ive done nothingg

[bright yacht]

lmao

[hollow dagger]

spammer!!

[dusky citrus]

about that map

do u trust the red dead wiki

[bright yacht]

what can i do to fix this tho

[dusky citrus]

it has a map

[bright yacht]

cuz im not a spammer

[hollow dagger]

i have to click show on every message of urs

[bright yacht]

alr ty

[bleak iron]

Kind of annoying having to show each time lol

[hollow dagger]

lets just ban this spammer

[bright yacht]

ok…

[dusky citrus]

no worries

[bright yacht]

k i aint a spammer tho.

[bleak iron]

Have you spammed in another server?

[bright yacht]

nope

maybe its cuz i joined like 3 diff servers at once

i wanted emotes

[dusky citrus]

am i the only one that doesn’t see the spammer thing

[hollow dagger]

save some bother and ban this person so we dont have to click show on their messages

[bright yacht]

bruh chill i js wanted to ask for the map

[bleak iron]

So discord does this if you spam in dms or have suspicious dm activity

And i think you can contact support or wait it out

[bright yacht]

is it going to wear off or something?

[bleak iron]

Its kind of like a shadow ban

[bright yacht]

oh alr ty

[dusky citrus]

guyz do i play rdr or study for my upcoming exams

[bleak iron]

RDR all day

[dusky citrus]

the only correct answer

[hollow barn]

study for the upcoming rdr

[bleak iron]

My teachers keep talking to my parents but they aint know i got to help the gang get to tahiti 🗣️ 🔥

[dusky citrus]

exactly

my parents be sending me to therapy but i got bussines to do on rdr

[dusky citrus]

loud correct buzzer

[quick python]

i love you

this is my first playthrough going through his questline

his chemistry with arthur is just amazing, he's my fav too

[quaint lintel]

"you cannot set camp there activity nearby"

i hate that so much

[elder saddle]

If no one is helping she probably gonna spam

[dusky citrus]

she

[elder saddle]

Ye ok

[dusky citrus]

❤️‍🩹

[night bluff]

They iguanas Arthur they iguanas… and they’re going to havvveee usss🦎

[obtuse zodiac]

After Arthur dies all his horse goes to john or?

Is there a way to get ur horses from Arthur?

And also same for the weapons

[prime estuary]

No you'll get your weapons back after a point but the horses are gone

[obtuse zodiac]

In the epilogue?

[prime estuary]

Yes

[obtuse zodiac]

So I'm guessing u can't do this after Arthur dies

[obtuse zodiac]

Like how? Do u just take all of Arthur's stuff?

[prime estuary]

It'll automatically go into your inventory once you progress

[obtuse zodiac]

Alr thank you

[main yarrow]

Abt to do American Venom

It’ll be my first story completion

[dusky citrus]

dude

[dusky citrus]

enjoy!!

it’s peak❤️‍🩹🤞

[night bluff]

What I would give to play RDR2 for the first time again

[obtuse zodiac]

Idk how people the the story is too long and boring

[night bluff]

They’re the kinda people who never got past the snow

[obtuse zodiac]

Honestly when I played first I didn't like the snow, but ngl I kinda miss it

It was too short

[night bluff]

Agreed it’s definitely better than Guarma in my opinion

[royal stirrup]

it's such a shame that the guarma part got cut off

[main yarrow]

Holy peak… I js finished it

I accidentally wore Arthur’s hat while I was doing it too

[short wave]

Some nice symbolism though, even if it was purely by accident

[main yarrow]

Exactly

[dusky citrus]

no it puts it on automatically

🫶

[main yarrow]

Ah, Still incredible.

[dusky citrus]

frfr

[short wave]

Okay then, not as accidental as I thought 😅

[dusky citrus]

lol

arthur doesnt like revenge but john did him justice

[main yarrow]

I only died like 3 times. Once was because I shot dutch in the standoff

Misinput

[trim hamlet]

should have shot dutch, micah, and then hosea and then taken charge of the gang

[dusky citrus]

was lowk surprised when dutch shot micah

[dusky citrus]

what gang bru

😭😭

[mystic pecan]

Hi everybody, does anybody knows if daveys grave has a journal entry in chapter one???

[short wave]

If the game was a fully blown RPG with robust amount of branching off choices, I could see you getting away with this

[dusky citrus]

well wouldnt make sense since rdr1 exists

[main yarrow]

It would be cool if there was a branch though

[dusky citrus]

true

[short wave]

Fair point, but one can hope, right?

[dusky citrus]

surely

but rdr1 without dutch wouldnt be the same

bro reached the peak of insanity

[trim hamlet]

Red dead revolution be like

[main yarrow]

Lol

[opaque hamlet]

me in chapter 4: oh wow! a quest with Sadie :D this will be a fun one!
me 30 seconds later: wtf happened to Kieran

[dusky citrus]

no fr

bring back kieran

[opaque hamlet]

I'm crashing out currently 😭🙏

[dusky citrus]

kieran is so sweet he didn’t deserve this

[opaque hamlet]

FR 😭

[dusky citrus]

goddamn o’driscoll’s

[opaque hamlet]

how to blow colm up

[dusky citrus]

wait u haven’t finished the story yet?

[opaque hamlet]

no

[dusky citrus]

ohh

[opaque hamlet]

first play through

[dusky citrus]

something exciting awaits you then

[opaque hamlet]

:0

[dusky citrus]

enjoy

[opaque hamlet]

[dusky citrus]

🫶

[karmic grove]

Kieran did NOT deserve to die I swear

I need to finish the game dude im like 60% finished

[woven zodiac]

Sean didn't deserve to die

Mac Davey Jenny too

[karmic grove]

I loved sean he was so funny

[woven zodiac]

Funny Irish man

[woven zodiac]

Romantic man

[karmic grove]

he was definitely a romantic for sure

[tropic oyster]

i liked charles

[midnight ocean]

you can buy the satchels in the epilogue at the fence

[woven zodiac]

With Karen

Yes

[obtuse zodiac]

For money?

Or would u still have to get the materials and then craft it?

[midnight ocean]

money

[lapis sable]

I play my latest playthrough slow and steady.

Every time i complete a main mission, or a side mission, or visit a landmark, I go about looking for rampages

Bring law in here, shoot em till they are dead!

And i dont pay my bounties. Let the bounty hunters come, they all shall die

And i love torturing dogs and horses with my poison arrows

As they lay dying, I walk up to them with a sawed-off shotgun with inciendary shells and blast their face

I only wish I can skin humans just so I can make my horse feel warm on account of my body count

And when i beat gambling challenges, i make sure to scorch every table i find

It's so fun to shoot dynamite arrows in the saloon and be a real terrorist.

And when i wanna escape a town, I make sure to lasso one lawman and ride at full speed outta here

Before stopping and putting a shot at his head with a shotgun

Every canoe rider gets sniped by my carcano rifle with explosive bullets ofc

[thorny cargo]

animal abuse isnt tuff 🥹✌️

[crisp oxide]

I am taking npcs and putting them back into the wild, safely and legally, of course totally.

[hallow cosmos]

You Goddamn maniac, I shoulda left you to hang!

[lapis sable]

I think I am worse than a Skinner brother!

[hallow cosmos]

Most sane RDR2 player:

[quiet abyss]

You sir are a very bad man

[lapis sable]

Uncle told me that I'm a good man. A good man.

[lapis sable]

Blame the bounty hunters that bring their dogs then. they should have kept nice ol waggy tail Cooper back at home

Now that you mention it, I'm going to valentine, kill all the sheep, and then kill law while filling my horse with SHEEP SKINS

and ride on over to the pig farm at the sheriff to kill ALL THE PIGS too

For their Pig skin

and I will kill all their horses, and all the shopkeepers, and EVERYONE!!!!

[vagrant carbon]

Question.
Started a new playthrough, traveling around and found the WHITE COUGAR CAVE. Exploring, safely since cougar has not spawned, and I see ledges and platforms above. Has anyone been able to access these?

[crisp oxide]

I think you can only get it with that one debt mission near strawberry

[vagrant carbon]

Sorry, no. Not the quest. I mean to get up on the pathways.

[crisp oxide]

Ohhh

[vagrant carbon]

I found em earlier for the first time. Lol I was able to look around without a cougar trying to eat me.

[lapis sable]

I wanna bring law to the caves to play hide and seek

I wanna feed the cougar when they respawn with their corpses

[crisp oxide]

Lol

[frank atlas]

What are the spawning requirements for that white Arabian I’ve been looking for a good 2 hours now and I cannot find it

I’ve left and came back multiple times thinking it wasn’t spawning because I was nearby I just can’t seem to find it

[lapis sable]

I tame horses using poison arrow and horse reviver rather than the good ol lasso

[thorny cargo]

are you reloading?

you should try that

and have you unlocked the stables already?

[elder saddle]

I don't care about the dogs that much but horses? Fr? Its your best companion in the game your most true friend bruh its generally the best designed thing in the game bruh (even if it's not yours it could possibly be)

[lapis sable]

sorry my aim is bad it landed on the heads of horses

Also, their saddles have loot too

for eg, the prospector's horse have a gold nugget too. Bastard got a lot of them. Might as well kill that horse 🙂

the only good horse is the horses that belong to me!

[lapis sable]

I wish i have Baylocke

[hard zephyr]

I kept on redoing this ONE SPECIFIC mission,where this Sean came with us on the train robbery

And he kept on dying bro

It's not even the player bro

It's the npc

I was just like "I can't do this anymore bro"

It was a Saturday,I just came home not remembering how to open the deadeye so I was struggling hard

[thorny cargo]

isnt it the scroll/middle button on ur mouse on pc?

maybe im wrong

[hard zephyr]

You are unfortunately wrong

It's the keys at the left of the keyboard

Tho I don't remember what it was name

[thorny cargo]

oof

[lapis sable]

I wish I can shoot the people in the train or outlast the law here

in pouring forth oil

[karmic grove]

Pretty sure with money

[vast sky]

Best spot for reddish egrets? They seem non-existent.

[trim hamlet]

Bro same!

[royal stirrup]

i cant mail a legendary fish can someone help?

[ember ridge]

He just has a hangover

[ember ridge]

Are you sure it's legendary

[royal stirrup]

uru right it isn't, but it's one of the fish mailing requirements for jeremy gill

[ember ridge]

You can only send legendary fish

[royal stirrup]

so how do i bring it to him

[ember ridge]

You don't

He only wants legendary fish

[royal stirrup]

but it's literally in the list of the samples that he wants

ahh nvm

i got u now

mb

[hallow cosmos]

Capslock

[hallow cosmos]

I honestly thought I would go to a random odriscoll camp to fight them and steal a robbery plan from them like old friends.

[gritty zinc]

Do the bounty posters In Rhodes keep spawning or can you actually complete them all?

I keep seeing them but don’t need money so I’m wondering if there’s a point to do them or if it’s just for money

[quaint furnace]

any particular reason why alden has a giant bandage on his head

[trim lichen]

what horses do yall use?

[ember ridge]

If you shoot him he will get bandages on him

He doesn't usually.

[quaint furnace]

im in chapter 3 though

[robust birch]

Depends on the chapter

[trim lichen]

I use the white Arabian and the Shire

[robust birch]

On my 100% playthrough as Arthur I used the black Arabian obtained for free from the Saint Denis holdup event

and used Buell in the epilogue

[elder saddle]

Because you shoot him

[obtuse zodiac]

U get the black Arabian for free?

I thought u had to either purchase or find it in the wild

[robust birch]

There is a random event in Saint Denis (its a hold up and if you save the couple you can just take their horse that spawns near them)

[nocturne charm]

guys, i didnt know i could take jim calloway's revolver at the gunslinger mission start and now i want to have it so bad. im still in chapter 2, but the mission is already gone since i accepted it. are there any way i could have the revolver?

[obtuse zodiac]

This in online or story?

[robust birch]

Story

[obtuse zodiac]

What chapter?

[robust birch]

Random event as soon as the open world is unlocked

It is only available at night

[elder saddle]

Bruh this is only story the channel called single player for a reason

[obtuse zodiac]

Near the stables?

[elder saddle]

No rdr2 has not the same bounty system with rdr1 in rdr1 there are pretty much unlimited bounties rdr2 ones are limited when you finish them there is no more

[obtuse zodiac]

Yeah I'm but he said event, so just needed to make sure it wasn't online

[nocturne charm]

can anyone help me with this 😓

[gritty zinc]

Okay so if I see them I will do them then

[robust birch]

Its a random event just ride around Saint Denis at night and save a couple being robbed if you see them shoot the robber fast cause the event is really fast

[obtuse zodiac]

Alr thanks

[elder saddle]

Yeah if you see them do them it's probably 2-3 bounties per town after you done all no bounties

[gritty zinc]

Is that the same with the wagons you can steal by asking the guy at the post office

[elder saddle]

Ye they are limited also 3 in Rhodes 3 in strawberry

If i remember correctly

[fluid sky]

if you go into mr worberls stable you can steal the second best hoirse in the valentine stables forgor the name

[mortal cedar]

Good afternoon, I need to earn the "America's Sweetheart" achievement, but in some cities I'm wanted dead or alive. Will I still be able to get the achievement?

I am wanted in Blackwater and Saint-Denis.

[edgy glacier]

hii

[mortal cedar]

hey

[tropic oyster]

hey what are the other war horses aside from the arden

[vague robin]

Mustang, Andalusian, and Hungarian Half-Bred

[tropic oyster]

thnx

[tropic oyster]

any horses that sound different from each other?

for an example the strawberry arden has a deeper tone

[tropic oyster]

it caught me offguard yesterday xd

[shadow verge]

do you need to study animals in guarma to get 100% completion

[raven vessel]

Master Hunter is so easy

Just takes some time doing like 1 of them

[real shore]

I'm hunting moose and I need 4 perfect moose pelts so I can get all trapper things. This is harder than gambler 8.

[raven vessel]

That’s not a challenge right

[raven vessel]

Is it really

Just call them

And then head shot

Or is it hard finding a 3 star one?

[real shore]

It's hard finding a single one

It's as if they are an endangered species

I've tried every single location

I only found 2

All of them 2 stars

[raven vessel]

lmao wow

“Go to brandywine drop. By the waterfall on the right there is a moose usually 2 or 3 star.”

[real shore]

Trust me this took longer than me getting the animals in new austin as arthur

[raven vessel]

Found this on reddit

[real shore]

Already tried it 💀

It was a 2 star

[raven vessel]

Someone else said

“Cattail pond. West of valentine. Then, brandywine drop. Hammer on those two. You’ll get it”

[raven vessel]

Wait for it to respawn

[real shore]

Already tried it too

[raven vessel]

You gotta wait 3 in game days

[real shore]

I saw a video saying just place 6 herbivore baits spread across on the usual locations where they are likely to spawn, go a bit far away and a moose or two of em should spawn

[raven vessel]

It takes a lot of patience I had to do the same on master Hunter 6 with the cougars

[real shore]

Master hunter 6 ain't nothing compared to this

I also did all the challenged and this.

[raven vessel]

not what I’m trying to say

I’m talking about waiting 72 in game hours

and grinding that

[real shore]

Alr

[raven vessel]

Set up a camp and sleep through the hours

[wary jacinth]

Why don’t you FO you POS

[midnight ocean]

gotta do the bear hunting mission with hosea first

[empty ingot]

is it on me or does the law system make no sense? Like am wearing a mask, commit a crime, then it says theres an unknown suspect. Then all of a sudden, they know exactly its arthur, know exactly where i am, and shoot me

[midnight ocean]

you gotta get out of the red area

and also lawmen can see through the mask

[real shore]

Finally got the 4 perfect moose pelts

[lapis sable]

I dont wear my bandana

[midnight ocean]

no one cares

[midnight ocean]

gz lol probably the rarest animal in the game

[hollow barn]

"greet-greet-antagonize" ahh

[lapis sable]

The feeling is mutual

[midnight ocean]

lol yeah that guy is annoying as hell

[thorny cargo]

i blocked him

[midnight ocean]

fair

[lapis sable]

Me too

[hollow barn]

what did he do to be that annoying

[midnight ocean]

just constantly looking for attention by being edgy

ragebaiting

[thorny cargo]

indeed

[lapis sable]

I was just enjoying the game as it is

You don't like how i play, that's your business I suppose.

[bleak cargo]

Did anyone manage to dig deeper into the spider-web secret ?

[lapis sable]

I think its more of an easter egg than a reward.

[royal stirrup]

gaaviinn?! 🗣️ 🗣️

[bleak cargo]

is it only me or the game is really buggy on ps5 ?

[lusty kernel]

uhm so

i cant go on my horse when i click e

💔

[lusty kernel]

console version is capped at 30 fps

[bleak cargo]

not about fps, but on ps4 i had no objects clipping or things dissapearing in rdr2, but on ps5 these things happen
no other game does this

[lusty kernel]

idk

then

[midnight ocean]

you could try reinstalling

[trim hamlet]

wdym

you're near it right

[tidal slate]

Where is Cat if you need some sharp Claws? Meow

[supple sky]

Anyone else use only the 15$ horse you get at the start?

I named mine Nutmeg

Haven’t traded her out for a different horse yet and I’m at 20% completion according to the save file

[trim hamlet]

the brown-and-white one?

[supple sky]

Yeah

[trim hamlet]

isn't it a he?

could be wrong, but check the player menu

Nutmeg still works tho, which is cool

[supple sky]

Nah the 15$ horse I got for the stable tutorial was a mare

It has no balls

The game also says it’s a female horse

So it’s not a gelding

[trim hamlet]

oh really?

huh.

[supple sky]

Whether the tutorial horse is male or female is prob random

[trim hamlet]

oh come on

[trim hamlet]

like

in the snow?

[supple sky]

O

No

I mean when you get to the stable in valentine

[trim hamlet]

oh, I was talking about the one you first get

like the very first one

[supple sky]

And you get the tutorial for the stable and are forced to buy a horse but you can only afford the 15$ one

[lapis prism]

guys this game was so boring

[subtle finch]

Try to beat the whole game without breaking the laws of islam

that would be fun

[quaint lintel]

What would that be like as example

[subtle finch]

you must follow the 5 pillars

except the pilgrimage to mecca which isnt possible in rdr2

[thorny cargo]

the morgan

i hate that horse

[supple sky]

Ye been using the morgan

[tropic oyster]

recently got the ardennes very satisfied with it

[supple sky]

For as immersive as the game is idk why tf shotguns have no range unless you use slugs

Like I shot a guy who was about twenty or so feet away without a slug and he lived and wasn’t all that hindered at all

He just shrugged off getting hit with buckshot from 20ft away

[tropic oyster]

common video game logic be like xd

i hate when that happens and thats when i switch up to inciendary and just make sure they actually go down

[supple sky]

Then I switch back to slugs and nail a dude center of mass immediately putting him down from the same range

I was sitting in my tent during a rainstorm and heard horses trotting nearby then got up from the tent to see there were a few bounty hunters nearby

Headphones rule

[trim hamlet]

say that again for the people in the back 🗣️

Easily my favorite breed

[supple sky]

Hiring an artist to draw the horses from red dead as umamusume characters

[trim hamlet]

Because the--wait buckshot?

He should be dead!

[supple sky]

We need the four horses of the apocalypse from the first game as umamusumes

[supple sky]

I know 😭

[tropic oyster]

lil chunky mars bars such a great breed

[trim hamlet]

shire is just 7 feet tall 😆

[trim hamlet]

OOH
Mars Bars

I'm stealing that name. Right now I named my bay roan "Dr. Pepper".

[tropic oyster]

i was gonna have the white shire but chose the strawberry roan over it

[supple sky]

I hate that my horse has to stand outside in the pouring rain while I’m cozy in my tent

I wish I could give it a raincoat or something

[trim hamlet]

same 😔

[tropic oyster]

i like the pepper one too xd

[trim hamlet]

i try to put my camps under trees/forested areas so my horse has at least some cover

[tropic oyster]

i wish those horses would just sit down when idling for a long time that would be nice too see

i only see horses in stables sit down

[trim hamlet]

I think they do if you take the saddle off at camp

[supple sky]

I killed some o’ Driscoll and took over their camp

Was hoping more o’ Driscolls would come by so I could kill more

[trim hamlet]

like, as your semi-permanent camp?

Can you just keep your camp up forever?

Like, the one you set up using the weapon wheel

[supple sky]

I just took their camp and am staying there rn

[tropic oyster]

what about away from camp?

like with john

[trim hamlet]

you should drop a bunch of ammo and canned goods and stuff to make it a resupply spot too

like, hit Discard from your satchel

I think that drops them

I'm not sure

[supple sky]

I think they’ll despawn lmao

[trim hamlet]

dang...

[supple sky]

The dead bodies despawned when I left the camp to go fishing

I wish Arthur would throw knives faster

[trim hamlet]

Did you check though? Like, does it just drop the items on the ground if you Discard them?

[supple sky]

No idea

[trim hamlet]

@supple sky am i the only one that does this lmao

[rocky latch]

So I played Red Dead Redemption 1 until I got John's family back from the federal government is there a point to continue playing the game??

[subtle finch]

No

Thats it

now go complete all the side quests and such

[thorny cargo]

well clearly you arent done with the game... so i suggest finishing the story.....

[rocky latch]

Oh okay

[rocky latch]

Okay

[subtle finch]

No

[thorny cargo]

no point trying to prevent it

[obtuse zodiac]

Does antagonizing people at camp actually impact mission interactions, and saving u when ur in jail?

[thorny cargo]

missions interactions no, saving you when youre in jail i have no idea but id assume not

[tropic oyster]

hey which coat of arden u got?

[supple sky]

I bought a pump action shotgun and I absolutely love it

This thing absolutely destroys everything I shoot with it

And it reloads super quick

It’s crazy with slugs

I just used all my slugs on the mission that’s right before chapter 3 and now I only have 10 left and idk where to buy more now

Frick

[supple sky]

I feel like Micah might be a really bad dude

Imagine if red dead 2 had gotten an apocalypse themed dlc like the first game

The survival mechanics would compliment it really well

[midnight ocean]

real

[lapis sable]

You can use mods to make an unofficial undead nightmare 2

[midnight ocean]

totally

[supple sky]

So in the scene between Kieran and Karen when she says he looks like a baby and he says he is one were those two flirting with each other?

It feels like they were both flirting

[thorny cargo]

no

[thorny cargo]

what chapter are you in?

kieran is romantically interested in mary-beth and karen is romantically interested in sean.

so no, they werent flirting

[supple sky]

Oh

I saw the scene animated on tik tok and someone in the comments said her name was Karen. That person could have got the name wrong. I forgot who she was.

Rn I just started chapter 3

[midnight ocean]

it is karen in that scene

[thorny cargo]

it was karen yeah

but uh

i feel like kieran was just doing whatever he could to make himself seem non-intimidating, considering they had him tied up and he kept getting called an o'driscoll. and karen just doesnt like him, so she was mocking him

[supple sky]

I thought the same thing at first

But with the dialogue removed from the body language it does kinda feel like flirting due to the tone of their voices

[thorny cargo]

id argue karen is a naturally flirty woman

lmao

[supple sky]

That does make sense

The game makes me feel bad about killing people

Like it’s so immersive that it’s a little disturbing

I was about to lose a shooting contest and realized I could just turn around and shoot him in the head so I wouldn’t lose money and it was super disturbing and uncomfortable after I did it

I also was traveling to do the quest for Micah(the one after you bust him out) and along the way I killed a guy and stayed in his house sleeping in his bed and eating his food

Woke up in the morning hearing flies buzzing around his body

I do feel uncomfortable about this ngl

He has pigs and chickens for me to kill and cook

Oh boy

Some bounty hunters surrounded me while I was cooking and I got into a rlly tense shootout

Then after I was done shooting them one of them was still alive bleeding on the ground

This game is amazing

[lapis sable]

Oh yes it is.

To this day, I'm still hoping I get a real hunting wagon mod to harvest pelts and meat from farms i raid

But I suppose the current mod works fine by allowing me to carry 3 animals without much worry

[midnight ocean]

serial killer origins

[lapis sable]

Only thing i didn't quite like is animals on the wagon rot quickly if not sent to the butcher or camp fast

[supple sky]

Low honor Arthur reminds me of Blood Meridian

[lapis sable]

Oh i love playing low honor

[thorny cargo]

dont get him started

[supple sky]

It’s crazy how I was so disturbed and uncomfortable killing people in this game at first and how quickly I’m getting comfortable with it

[lapis sable]

Imagine fools here telling me how i must play their games. Well, way I see it, I didn't do anything wrong.

Aside from not play the games to their rules.

[midnight ocean]

i'm not telling you how to play the game its just that when you constantly brag about doing the most evil possible things in the game after a while it starts to get annoying and feels like attention seeking behavior

fyi

[lapis sable]

You could have told me nicely. And yes, I'm aware somewhat. It's just me sharing my game session a bit in good fun

But you chose to act like some moral police here.

Over a rockstar game OML

So... banging prostitutes, killing people, robbing stores, causing mayhem is fun for you but killing dogs and horses by bounty hunters makes you draw the line?

[thorny cargo]

you seem to be doing all of those things

[lapis sable]

Yes i do. Proud of playing it this way though.

Sorry I ain't being high honor like you

[thorny cargo]

when i made the comment about the dogs and horses, it was without the knowledge you were saying bounty hunters btw <3 you didnt mention that at all <3 i assumed you were just killing random dogs and horses.

[lapis sable]

I think the only time i killed dogs and horses in this way randomly is to see if I can harvest dog meat and horse meat like in RDR1

And i think that's like months ago...?

[thorny cargo]

well theres something i guess. i dont care if you do all your evil doings, its fine, im not telling you to not play low honor i really dont care--the issue lies in when, like woolie said, you constantly brag about it and make a chat wall explaining your crimes. i feel like the distaste for it in the chat was obvious, and it gets to a point of annoying.

[lapis sable]

That's your opinion

It's not the server's gospel

[thorny cargo]

ok, hide behind saying "thats your opinion" when you hear something you dont like sure... im just letting you know. its annoying, and again like woolie said, gives off attention seeking

[lapis sable]

You're annoying and I should block you for trying to tell me how to play the game and express my enjoyment of the game.

I'll play high honor when I feel like it, and play low honor when I feel like it, and when I wanna express some of it, I ain't caring about your opinion

Good day, sir.

[thorny cargo]

1. not telling you how to play the game, again
2. not telling you you shouldnt express your enjoyment. telling you that when you consistently do so, in ways that are obviously distasteful, it IS bothersome
3. youre going to block me because you know that im right.

anyways

[lapis sable]

And just to home in on the point, I'm going into graphic detail of how I'm raiding Annesburg and wontonly killing everyone and trying to survive like 1 hour before I finally die

probably.

and totally depends if I even make it past 30 mins

[viscid charm]

Is this server also for rdr 1

[lapis sable]

I think so!

[viscid charm]

I only played

[thorny cargo]

yup

[viscid charm]

Rdr1

[lapis sable]

I love both RDR games

[viscid charm]

Yeahhh I played 1st on switch and wanna play 2nd

[lapis sable]

RDR1 rampages are real fun as well

[viscid charm]

Bro i completed 1

It's so peak

[lapis sable]

but not as actual graphic when it's hunting

[supple sky]

Hopped on a train to catch a ride and decided to rob it

Super fun

It’s a shame you can’t buy beanbags for shotguns to avoid killing

[lapis sable]

That it is! Especially the shooting of passengers to loot them a second time!

Like, they certainly are hiding some more of their wealth, and I like Rockstar for doing it like that

[supple sky]

That’s just edgy for the sake of it

[viscid charm]

Rdr comunity is good for indians 😁😁😁

[lapis sable]

You could say it that way but I think it's worth it if you holdout in the train

heck, it's such a free server I can't tell you how to think

rob em, ride with them, shoot and loot em, cause mass mayham, idrc

so long as you have fun playing it your way, unlike some idiots here that claim they are the better moral ground on how to make people play this game

what clowns, if I do say so myself

[thorny cargo]

once again saying that we're telling you how to play the game

actually this is ragebait. ill pass

[lapis sable]

any other way of summarizing the shit you told on me? because I don't see it any other way.

[viscid charm]

What you talking about

[thorny cargo]

lmao CLEARLY you didnt read my messages. the issue doesnt lie in your playstyle, bud. it lies in the fact you continuously share these edgy things for attention. its fine a few times, but every single time you come in here youre sharing that info... its just annoying, and youre clearly doing it to get a reaction out of people

[lapis sable]

Whatever you say. I'm not ever talking to a clown like you who can't appreciate other people expressing their fun times.

[thorny cargo]

lmao, you know im right

[lapis sable]

Being immature and claiming you're right LOL

Sure tells a lot about you.

[thorny cargo]

if im expressing an opinion, its expressing how i feel, which means im right, and factual in what im saying.

being immature and calling me an idiot and a clown really tells me a lot about YOU.

[lapis sable]

So your opinion is always right, and people's opinion is always wrong? I see how it is.

[thorny cargo]

i know people who have already expressed their distaste for your comments. and im sure there are others.

[lapis sable]

I also know people who don't care about your opinions

Now agree to disagree, don't talk to me, and move on.

[thorny cargo]

i moved on, my guy... youre the one who made a comment about it after it was already settled i can agree to move on if you agree on being respectful. but what youve shown me so far has been the opposite.

not only a comment, but calling me an idiot, as well!

[lapis sable]

which... you are.

[thorny cargo]

uh huh. sure

im going to assume youre going to say goodbye and quit with the comments? ive shared my opinion, respectfully, albeit how you responded. that ends this conversation

bye bye

[lapis sable]

You didn't notice I was ignoring you?

[thorny cargo]

you didnt notice i said goodbye? are you picking fights or what, my dude?

im good but thanks for the offer.

[lapis sable]

Now, where to start my shootout, I think I wanna visit the coal factory first

the Annesburg coal factory.

[supple sky]

I hogtied the eugenics supporter and stole his money

Pretty funny that nobody calls the police on you for it because they must think he’s super insufferable

I hate that you can’t punch people outside of fist fights in like gta cuz I kept trying to punch him and Arthur was pulling out guns

[lapis sable]

hahaha!

[supple sky]

[lapis sable]

tbh I was actually conflicted on whether this was a developer oversight or if it was intentional that they made that eugenics support like that

[supple sky]

No

[lapis sable]

Like, normally, hogtying a random person would get you wanted

[supple sky]

I’m sure all the people in his town are tired of his racism and of him being annoying

[lapis sable]

haha!

[supple sky]

They probably think he’s deserves it

[lapis sable]

Well, i hope it is.

[supple sky]

I followed him for a while after he ran away and he ran onto a boat with nobody on it so maybe that’s why? People still reacted to it with voice lines so I don’t think so.

[lapis sable]

I really like the Aberdeen pig farm folks when it comes to scripting people

[rain current]

Those people creep me out ngl

[lapis sable]

like oml, I've never met such a disgusting couple all my life, and I love rockstar for making such quirks

[supple sky]

Yknow what would be badass?

If you could open and operate a donut shop

Chef Arthur Morgan introducing the cops of the old west to deep fried icing covered donuts

If they can make cream cheese or basic icing and also fry dough idk why we don’t see donuts for sale anywhere

I guess because sugar isn’t that common?

Still though. It wouldn’t be too expensive to crush up some berries and nuts and top a fried pastry with them. Maybe brush or drizzle on some honey too.

Then dust very lightly with cinnamon, nutmeg, etc. Maybe use ground pepper flakes or cloves if you wanna be really bold and daring.

[lapis sable]

Are there any donuts in 1899?

[supple sky]

I made some cookies with cloves for Christmas and really liked them. It was a little bitter but I enjoyed it.

Eating a cookie that tastes bitter is an experience

Like it was still good just really strange

There was still a bit of sweetness the bitterness just came through a lot more

[lapis sable]

Wait, it does exist in the 18th century, but not in the wild west. the more you know 😮

[supple sky]

If they can bake bread they can fry dough

[lapis sable]

18th century in new york tho 😭

[supple sky]

Ancient people were frying dough in oil

[lapis sable]

Meaning if the gang rode further east and stopped robbing folk, they could have enjoyed the treat

[supple sky]

Arthur and the gang need pizza

[lapis sable]

All they need is no pinkertons, no "plans"

[supple sky]

No group on earth can collectively agree on what a pizza even is so the gang could 100% make and eat a pizza

[lapis sable]

Van der Linde Pizzaria

Not approved by Angelo Bronte

[trim hamlet]

Bay Roan!

[lapis sable]

I lasted 38 mins fighting law in annesburg before i died due to out of supplies

Did a small mistake of jumping off a mine shaft

Ouch

[digital moat]

gonna br starting my second playthrough soon

[modern bobcat]

[empty ingot]

but then whats the point of the mask if they can instantly recognize it was me? Like the mask serves so the witness cant describe me. So realistically they should have no idea who it is, it could be a random NPC in the area aswell

[lapis sable]

there is a mod where you'll get 0 bounty while wearing a mask for PC but.... I feel it sorta breaks the point of lawmen recognising Arthur/John so.....

I prefer the challenge of bounty hunters as well so that's why i didn't quite use that

[empty ingot]

yeah but then the mask makes absolutely nothing, as far as i understand

[tropic oyster]

what about strawberry roan? :D

[rocky latch]

Is the character we control after John's death jack Marston??

[waxen zinc]

Yea

[half bluff]

Good evening, does anyone have any advice on where to find the female specimen so I can study it, please? I've been looking for it for several days but can't find it anywhere. I've only found the male specimen.

[trim hamlet]

haven't got to epilogue yet

[lapis sable]

Masks only prevent civilians from identifying you to the law

Meaning, you could technically still get away of lawmen do not suspect you are the criminal

[empty ingot]

they always do know i am the criminal tho, thats the thing. It says unknown suspect as i wore the mask, then the policemen just know it was me when they see me.

[lapis sable]

So long as you aren't seen by the lawmen

[raven vessel]

Bruh saw someone hating on rdr2

I asked how many hours he had on it

He said like 12-20

ofc u won’t like it if u rush through main story

[thorny cargo]

considering the speed run record is 12 hrs, i wouldnt be surprised that he didnt like it. he completely rushed through it

thats sad

[raven vessel]

yeah

[thorny cargo]

probably skipped all the cutscenes too

[raven vessel]

don’t understand how u can just do main story only

I find it boring rushing through the main quests

most of the games content is outside the main story as well

[fast warren]

Yall I came into the general store but the guy aint here is is it safe to take the money in the cash register

🤔 🤔

[half breach]

ye

[midnight ocean]

only lawmen instantly recognize you. the mask protects you from civilian witnesses as long as you vacate the area quickly

i mean it's a piece of cloth lol it's not magic

[thorny cargo]

ive been named a nerd again. i will not stand for this slander

[trim hamlet]

So ik that there's a visible effect on the player model if you're Thin or Overweight, but is there a similar effect for the horse model or am I not seeing it?

[raven vessel]

I have a black shire and a white Arabian, should I get the dark bay turkoman??

The brown one not gold

Cause I used the black shire on my last playthrough and the Arabian would be fine if it wasn’t so small

[fast warren]

How Do I view item requests

[raven vessel]

Left dpad

[midnight ocean]

[exotic crystal]

I am very picky, sorry

[midnight ocean]

think the dark bay turk is in blackwater

[raven vessel]

I can get it early apparently

Wow nvm it’s patched

Sometimes I don’t like rockstar

Hold on there’s another way

I can steal it in chapter 3

During a mission

What is the overall best horse

including looks

[midnight ocean]

that would be totally subjective

best stats are on the rose grey arabian but thats also only obtainable in the epilogue

but arabians turkomans and missouri fox trotters are the best three breeds for stats

[raven vessel]

Hmmm

aight ty

arabians would be so much better if they were bigger

arthur looks ridiculous on the white arabian

[midnight ocean]

i agree lol thats why i like turkomans better

you can buy one in saint denis

[faint vapor]

if i paddle my camp canoe from camp to somewhere else, then take a train back to camp, will my boat be there?

[trim hamlet]

...Realistically, no. But from a game design perspective, they'd probably just have it teleport back.

[faint vapor]

well im asking game wise lol

[trim hamlet]

I don't know. If I were designing the game I'd have it teleport back as soon as the player got near. But IDK what Rockstar did.

[wary jacinth]

You really get off on that shit don’t you goof

[midnight ocean]

i think so yes

[midnight ocean]

hi are you schizophrenic

[thorny cargo]

im at the dentist mid operatio. a d km trying noyt o laugh i cant

[midnight ocean]

lol

[full pivot]

👋

[obtuse zodiac]

can u loot people, who started a fight with you or something without getting wanted

[grizzled haven]

if there's no witnesses then yeah

I tryna eat some stew and ms grimshaw slapped me:(
I was going to clean myself off soon

[reef rose]

Elllo

[silk garden]

ms grimshaw is bad asf

[reef rose]

May I… stand on chicken

[reef rose]

Nahhhhhh

[silk garden]

she a gilf

[reef rose]

Bro why you glazing miss Grimshaw

[silk garden]

stfu goofy

she got popped anyways

[reef rose]

Ik

I have completed the game like 2 times haven’t cried to any gang’s death except LENNY

[silk garden]

micah is lowk tuff

he funny

[reef rose]

Until he gets popped

[silk garden]

like my second fav character fr

[silk garden]

thats what they do to the good ones smh

[reef rose]

Nah he’s a rat

🐀🐀

[silk garden]

still a fire character

[reef rose]

I mean until chapter 6

[silk garden]

even then

[reef rose]

Nah for me I don’t greet him no more

[silk garden]

greet greet antagonize

[midnight ocean]

still waiting for you to tell us why

[marsh flint]

Micah is a good character up until guarma

Then he just becomes bad

[midnight ocean]

no

he's bad from the first mission onwards

[trim hamlet]

good as in morally good or as in well-written?

[marsh flint]

Well written

I didn't find a motive to hate him up until chapter 5ish

[midnight ocean]

so you just didnt mind all the times he acted like a racist sex pest

[marsh flint]

Fair point

But then i barely was at the camp

[midnight ocean]

i guess you also skipped every cutscene and held your ears closed during missions

[spring halo]

If there was a third game what would you think would be the main theme around it for me if there was I would think of the rest of the gang in the after math of being split

[silk garden]

Already told you

[midnight ocean]

"i just do" isnt an answer lol

[silk garden]

I didn't say that lmao

Open ur eyes fool

[midnight ocean]

Cuz he funny as hell I js like him as a character

[silk garden]

Yea is that not an answer

[midnight ocean]

its a pretty weak one

so its just because hes kinda funny? lol

[silk garden]

Bros mad over an opinion lol

[midnight ocean]

im asking a question

[silk garden]

Js because I didn't say authers the best character in the universe doesn't mean u need to get mad

[ionic totem]

John or Arthur?

[silk garden]

micah tops both ngl

in terms of character not so much morals

[thorny cargo]

i think its valid to be genuinely curious as to why somebody likes micah. hes not even just a bad character personality wise... he is genuinely a BAD PERSON. you can say that they were all outlaws and they did bad things, but micah did things and said things that even dutch was against

[silk garden]

i just like him i dunno like i said he aint a good person but hes a cool character

[thorny cargo]

why do you think hes cool?

[silk garden]

i just like his humor

getting interrogated rn

[thorny cargo]

what about his humor do you like...???...? i am kinda interrogating you because im curious as to the innerworkings of a micah fan's mind.

[silk garden]

hes dark im not trying to be edgy or nun i just think hes a really good written antagonist

i mean peep the pfp

[midnight ocean]

no one is mad lol

[silk garden]

u still on ts dawg

[midnight ocean]

i left and came back the convo is literally still going wdym

[silk garden]

cuz ts guy asked

[thorny cargo]

you responded to a new question still expressing your opinion of micah, i think its pretty warranted that we keep that convo going

[silk garden]

but that question was connected to the previous one

[silk garden]

ts guy js upset bout sum

[thorny cargo]

?

[midnight ocean]

i thought ts meant this shit

does it just mean this now

[wild orchid]

It does

[silk garden]

idk bruh ts confusing

[thorny cargo]

it does

[wild orchid]

Some people use it as both tho idk

[thorny cargo]

LAMO

[silk garden]

wow

[midnight ocean]

saved by sheriff dyno

[silk garden]

what

[midnight ocean]

nothin buddy

[sterile wagon]

So I found a new way to have fun in rdr2 I walk out the prison after killing a few people then I blow sherif malloy or whatever his name is head smoov off

Then go on another rampage the streets of valentines crime rate went up 62 %

[supple sky]

It’s funny that Arthur basically has a Pokédex for animals and flowers

Also I’ve discovered how satisfying melee can be in this game

Like I hid behind a tree till a bounty hunter got close then jumped out and chopped him up with a machete before chasing down and doing the same to a second bounty hunter

[silk garden]

keep an eye on ts one

[supple sky]

Genuinely rlly helpful to save a bit of ammo mid fight if you see you can just get a melee kill without being at super big risk of dying

Like if it’s not too dangerous to get a melee kill that means you can go longer in the fight without reloading

I kinda just wish there was a quick throw key for stuff like dynamite and throwing knives when you’re in first person the way you can toss grenades in first person in GTA 5

[ember ridge]

There is isn't there? I can throw dynamite with like left click or something on PC. Idk what what it is on PS

[midnight ocean]

eh

reloading is fast especially with deadeye

and you can carry plenty of ammo

only takes one bullet to kill someone

[ruby falcon]

depends where you hit em

[lapis sable]

Micah Bell is a really great antagonist and I really like Peter Blomquist giving that character so much life that I see him as the perfect outlaw