red-dead-singleplayer

[warped ridge]

You’re a bit too egotistical about this calm down lol

[soft root]

arabians have the best stat on the table

[covert rock]

No, he isnt.

[soft root]

but, I don't think they are necessarily the option that you must choose

[covert rock]

bro your basically jsut saying worse is better

[soft root]

horses just depend on personal preferance

[warped ridge]

You literally don’t read at all

Bro reads one message and sees red

It’s all personal preference

[covert rock]

i read all of them

[soft root]

all horses are nice

if you like arabian bc of the stats, sure, go ahead

but, other horses are also very nice

arabian has good stats on the table

[warped ridge]

^^^

Some horses are better off terrain

[soft root]

but you ain't gonna appreciate the arabian all that much when it dumps you the moment you get into a gun fight

[warped ridge]

Facts

[soft root]

unless you have max bonding, still, it's gonna be skittish

arabians are...extremely skittish

[covert rock]

no, ive been in many fights

[warped ridge]

ok then why are you peeing yourself

[soft root]

unless you have max bonding

[warped ridge]

If you like your horse GOOD

lol

Bro acting like we spit on his mom

[soft root]

arabians are also pretty small tbh

I really like the big horses

[warped ridge]

Yeah they look funky

[soft root]

they are dainty

[warped ridge]

little rocket pony

[covert rock]

?

[warped ridge]

It’s as big as morgan

[soft root]

the raven black shire is so cool

big, black, surly stature

the stats aren't the best

[warped ridge]

I’m a huge fan a buell since I got him

[soft root]

but, it works

[covert rock]

i just drive my car around the map, you brokies

[warped ridge]

Big, decent speed, good stamina

[soft root]

I've been glazing the black shire since I started the game

[warped ridge]

Brave too

[soft root]

nice

[warped ridge]

Since I finished the game I don’t gallop anywhere I usually just trot

[covert rock]

uh sorry to ask but i watch the tutorial and i got some mods but i cant get to install this vehicle mod in this formant, can i get help 😭 ?

[wary jacinth]

What a POS

[wintry venture]

Pls someone tell me i don't have to cry when i play online right?

[covert rock]

No

[sturdy cloak]

I did several times and there's no horse

Only some wild animals

[queen leaf]

what horse?

white arabian?

[royal stirrup]

the respawn point is very flexible, have u roamed around for a bit? mine spawned on top of a hill, kinda far from where it was meant to spawn

[sturdy cloak]

Yes

The one near snow lake

[frank cedar]

I’ve only ever had an issue with an Arabian horse. They always throw themselves off a mountain. How do I get a war horse? Something that doesn’t spook from wolves and stuff and get me killed.

[midnight cloud]

I find the Arabian too skittish

[covert rock]

just mod him as i did

or just drive a car brokie lol

[covert rock]

JK

[real shore]

Is it harder to get all trapper outfits or do all the 90 challenges

[prime pilot]

As a person who has done both, the trapper outfits are hard, and the gambler 8 challenge is hell

[raven vessel]

any tips for completing all 90 challenges

[viscid dagger]

don't die

[raven vessel]

I just want the white hat bro

why is the only white hat locked behind 90 challenges

[royal stirrup]

can be done in 1 day if u just sit and follow a guide for each

[raven vessel]

hopefully

[chrome seal]

What you get from collecting Dinosaur bones

[raven vessel]

Can I do it in chapter 2

[chrome seal]

Or dreamcatchers🤔

[raven vessel]

Or are some challenges only completeable in like chapter 3 or something

[chrome seal]

Ah challenges i think you need to finish chapter 6 to Access new austin

To do herbalist nine

[raven vessel]

There’s glitches so u don’t have to do herbalist

That way arthur can get it as well

[trim hamlet]

Arabians take longer to bond. that's why they seem more skittish.

[trim hamlet]

What look are you going for?
cause there's multiple war horses that have different sizes/builds

[midnight ocean]

all challenges probably

though four perfect moose pelts can be kinda tough

[midnight ocean]

start early

if you're planning on doing the exotics sidequest, try waiting until you're on herbalist 8 before you go around getting all the orchids

[midnight ocean]

horse bravery is a myth

[midnight ocean]

well you still have to do it, its more that the glitch allows you to collect the plants with arthur

[bleak iron]

Id suggest a MFT or buell, MFTs are the fastest and aren't as skittish. Buell has the perks of every breed with none of the downsides

This being if you want something thats comparative to the Arabian in stats

[midnight ocean]

turkoman

[bleak iron]

Fully forgot about turk, tiny bit lower stats but has a lot of health as a war/race breed

[raven vessel]

They say “you can do herbalist if you want but it’s not needed for this”

[midnight ocean]

not needed for what

getting LOTE? it definitely is

[raven vessel]

Well it’s a glitch

[midnight ocean]

is it the glitch to get into new austin as arthur or something else

oh i think i found it actually

thats interesting

[raven vessel]

Hope it still works

[midnight ocean]

idk if the thing you're looking at says this but

you dont actually even need to ride to blackwater to get horseman 9

you can ride to the tip of the beach east of blackwater and it will count

[raven vessel]

Oh wow

Is it a video?

that you’re looking at

[midnight ocean]

no

[raven vessel]

or is it just knowledge u have

[midnight ocean]

yes

[raven vessel]

oh lol

[midnight ocean]

i think besides herbalist thats the only thing that requires you to go to the restricted part of the map as arthur

[raven vessel]

So I don’t need to enter

[midnight ocean]

no just ride to the tip of that peninsula northeast of blackwater

[raven vessel]

aight thanks

I might hop on later tonight to get some challenges done

[midnight ocean]

if it doesnt work that means you messed up and touched water at some point

np

[raven vessel]

wow

[midnight ocean]

ping me if you need help with any challenges i can probably recommend something

[raven vessel]

aight tysm

[tropic anvil]

Do u guys know any mod or load order that mess with The sound?

[tardy island]

guys the ultimate question who would win in a fight? John or Arthur

[midnight ocean]

depends on timeline

but if theyre both in their prime probably arthur because hes bigger

[tardy island]

what about in a shootout

[supple trout]

what about in water

[tardy island]

arthur

[midnight ocean]

thats not fair

[queen leaf]

i have a clip on my playstation of my tenessee walker doing that, i whistled for him and he launched his dumbass of of mount hagen

[tropic anvil]

Apparently, after I exit and enter the game about 10 times, Rockstar can no longer send emails. They display a message saying, “Sorry, we’ve sent too many emails to this account and can’t verify your details at the moment."
Have you ever had this problem? If so, how did you fix it?

[sacred siren]

is there any diffrence in content from pc and console?

[midnight ocean]

no

unless you count mods

[sacred siren]

ok ty

[prime hound]

Any news on the new secret of the question mark?

[near badger]

anyone else hate the mission with arthur and lenny in the bar

[midnight ocean]

yes lol

[queen leaf]

can anyone give me a hint on where the serial killers map leads to? (the one where map peices are in victims mouths)

[queen leaf]

i love a quiet time :c

[queen leaf]

ik its prolly somewhere near stawberry or somewhere around the connection from rdr2's map to rdr1's

[boreal garden]

funny to see it, but playing it you notice it's literally nothing

[prime hound]

Why?
It's one of the funniest missions in the game.

[near badger]

Feels like a unskippable cutscene

[prime hound]

Well, the mission doesn't have much action overall.

[ashen steeple]

should be good enough, if you're seeing deers and not wolves in your visions then you should be fine

[atomic cedar]

is it worth starting a new playthrough? i have nothing to do anymore and im getting bored so im thinking about resetting everything

[ashen steeple]

yeah its worth it to see new things and do stuff you havent done before

when i beat the game the fun was sucked out of it until i started over

theres also fun in just doing the story again

[atomic cedar]

ok thanks

[thorn kelp]

Yea

I’m on my 2nd play through

I’m on chapter 3

[ashen steeple]

im technically on my third but i never finished my second

im on chapter 2 rn and got to chapter 4 i think in my last one

[atomic cedar]

chapter 3 is peak red dead

[thorn kelp]

Yea man

I’m liking it very much

[terse flame]

Facts

[atomic cedar]

i like how the whole gang comes together to rescue jack

[thorn kelp]

Real peak

Then the party

[atomic cedar]

when i first did that mission i took like 100 screenshots because it was just so cool

[terse flame]

Is there any hidden or not too well known side missions or interactions worth checking out ? In chapter 3

[ashen steeple]

and the overall beef between the two manors is just peak

[atomic cedar]

eh the party was kinda lame.... prob because i skipped the dialouge because i had to go like 5 mins later lmao

[atomic cedar]

fr

[ashen steeple]

party annoys me cause you cant save or do any missions during it

[thorn kelp]

For me it really showed the beauty of rdr2

[ashen steeple]

just gotta sit and wait

[atomic cedar]

yeah next playthrough im gonna try to not skip any cutscenes because i skipped like 1/3 of them

[thorn kelp]

Definitely

[glacial geyser]

How to get the legendary fish with John in the epilogue?

[atomic cedar]

wait are you on that fishing mission?

with the old guy

[glacial geyser]

I finished that

[atomic cedar]

damn

i never did

[glacial geyser]

I'm now with John

[ashen steeple]

why would you skip a cutscene 😭

[atomic cedar]

i wasted like 30 mins on that mission

[glacial geyser]

Fax

[atomic cedar]

then i just left

[atomic cedar]

idk i was in a rush that day

[glacial geyser]

It happens

[atomic cedar]

but next playthrough im not gonna skip any

[ashen steeple]

if you were in a rush you couldve just not spent that much time on the game

didnt have to skip through it

[glacial geyser]

Please somebody tell me how to get the legendary 🐠 in 🆕 Austin with John 😃👍🏼

[atomic cedar]

mistakes happen okay

lol

[terse flame]

Are you gonna go for a low or high honour play through?

[atomic cedar]

low

[ashen steeple]

did you do high honor last time?

[atomic cedar]

nope

[ashen steeple]

alright WHY

[terse flame]

No one online knows I don’t think

[atomic cedar]

i just like being a bad boy

[terse flame]

Hope you get the fish

[ashen steeple]

gng

[thorn kelp]

High honor is peak

I was disappointed in Low honor death

[thorny cargo]

[terse flame]

Being hunted can get so annoying especially with the high bounties

[ashen steeple]

my first run was low honor even though i tried to be high honor

[atomic cedar]

its not too bad

[ashen steeple]

now im gonna succeed at being high honor

i just know it

[atomic cedar]

i like the bouty hunters

it makes it entertaining at times

and the bountys i can get rid off through glitches

[thorn kelp]

I kill the bounty hunters so I can loot them

XD

[atomic cedar]

that too

[glacial geyser]

200 iq

[ashen steeple]

dude once in saint denis someone lured me into an alley, knocked me out, and robbed me of like 700 bucks

i will never forget that

[thorn kelp]

700 bucks????!!?

[ashen steeple]

i was so pissed i reverted back to an older save

[atomic cedar]

now that you mentioned it i might try to do i high honour playthrough

[thorn kelp]

Honor doesnt even matter at that point

[ashen steeple]

yeah, didnt know it was possible

[thorn kelp]

I’d shoot instantly

[ashen steeple]

couldnt

they knocked me out

i woke up later

[thorn kelp]

It happen to me in Saint Denis

[atomic cedar]

lmao

[ashen steeple]

tbh i dont see what the point of having that much even is

[atomic cedar]

yeah

[ashen steeple]

like in gta you can spend your money easily but in rdr2 there isnt much to buy

[atomic cedar]

i just decided to give myself something rediculous so i could buy everything out of stock at the rhodes general store

[ashen steeple]

did you get that satchel too

the one that increases your carrying capacity

[atomic cedar]

yeah i think i bought that really early on

[ashen steeple]

seriously? dont you have to hunt like a whole bunch to get it

im not talking about the horse satchel

[atomic cedar]

ik

i really dont know

[glacial geyser]

You have to donate to Pearson for example 2 perfect deer skins

[ashen steeple]

more than that

im talking about the everything satchel

[glacial geyser]

The legendary satchel you can only get at the camp

[ashen steeple]

that requires all other satchels

[glacial geyser]

Yes

[ashen steeple]

i NEED that

we all do

[glacial geyser]

I have that

Its worth it

😃👍🏼

[ashen steeple]

dude how many hours you put into this game 😭

[atomic cedar]

i have only put in 70 hours

but i got this game 2 weeks ago

[ashen steeple]

got the game a year or two ago

[atomic cedar]

yeah

i wanted to get it

but at the time

[ashen steeple]

i just got it on ps5 yesterday tho

[atomic cedar]

i didnt have a pc with a graphics card

[ashen steeple]

thats when i started my next playthrough

[atomic cedar]

or i didnt have a console

and 2 weeks ago it was on sale

[ashen steeple]

cause it ran like dookie on my pc

[atomic cedar]

so i decided that i should buy it

[glacial geyser]

This is my third time playing it hahaha

[atomic cedar]

i wanted this game for 2 years+

[ashen steeple]

same

[atomic cedar]

100% worth it

[ashen steeple]

but i didnt finish the second run

[ashen steeple]

fr

[glacial geyser]

Yeee🤜🏼🤛🏼

[ashen steeple]

only game that can compete with it is the witcher 3 imo

but they both have strengths and weaknesses

[glacial geyser]

I have never played that game

[ashen steeple]

w3 is more combat and adventure focused while rdr2 is more story focused

i still sunk way more hours into w3 tho

[glacial geyser]

My type is more like story games

[ashen steeple]

its like god of war vs tlou

[glacial geyser]

But yes i have heard that Witcher is a good game

[ashen steeple]

tlou is more story while god of war is more combat/adventure

[glacial geyser]

Yes tlou is a good game i have played both tlous

Joel 🥲

[ashen steeple]

i played them both for the first time recently

great games

[glacial geyser]

Samee😃

[ashen steeple]

i bought them with my ps5

[glacial geyser]

How much 💰

[ashen steeple]

i feel more bad for abby tbh

[glacial geyser]

Noo😭

[ashen steeple]

like 450 for the ps5 and 50 for both games

[ashen steeple]

im not joking

have you seen what she went through

[glacial geyser]

I saw that but i dont like her

[ashen steeple]

she didnt bring this upon herself any more than ellie did

[glacial geyser]

But she was the villain

[ashen steeple]

dude even the game tries to show you that she isnt the villain 😭

[glacial geyser]

But she wasss

I can't send you proof of that

[ashen steeple]

she's only the villain in ellie's story

[glacial geyser]

Maybe fair enough

Maybe i interpreted it wrong

[midnight ocean]

revenge bad

[ashen steeple]

bruh why cant i use spoilers in this server 😭

its either a bad attempt at preventing spoilers or trying to display them out in the open for everyone to see

[midnight ocean]

i think its just a moderation thing

like the automod cant read it or something

[ashen steeple]

whatever

what im trying to say is even ellie spared abby

[midnight ocean]

tlou is pretty old i think spoilers are ok lol

[ashen steeple]

not even her worst enemy had the heart to kill her

[vernal osprey]

Helloo

[hallow cosmos]

Use special lake lure

[prime pilot]

The normal one or the huge one which sucked in a man

If it's the normal one, use a special river lure, if it's the huge one, you can't catch it

[wicked estuary]

[snow otter]

may I

stand unshaked

amidst

amidst a crashing world

[snow otter]

on my first run I got maximum high honor

[ashen steeple]

sheesh

sweating at rdr2 is crazy

[snow otter]

when I got that

I started to hogtie people

and throw them in the sea to drown

[ashen steeple]

i only did that with kkk members

still do

[snow otter]

I burned them alive

[ashen steeple]

i leave them at the shallow end

so they just sit there straining their back to try to breathe

[snow otter]

I threw fire bottles on them

and stabbed them

but I don't know where to find them

I only found them once near saint Denis

I kept stabbing their leader

and burnt him alive

[ashen steeple]

idk they just appear in random places at random times

ive found them around 4 to 5 times

[snow otter]

I found them at night near saint Denis, there was a guy trying to get in, when they lit the cross they all burned alive

only the leader was left

I stabbed him and threw fire bottles

[ashen steeple]

dang i shoulda watched it happen instead of ending it early

[snow otter]

I did and when they finished that happened

[ashen steeple]

i do know theres another one where they raise a cross and it falls on the two people raising it

and of course the leader survives

[snow otter]

I just saw the one where they burn alive

[ashen steeple]

i think that may be a common theme

[snow otter]

I have like 50 hours on rdr2

it's not alot

[ashen steeple]

bro just started playing

[snow otter]

like a month or 2 months ago

[ashen steeple]

i have around 150 on pc but ive been on and off for around a year or two

on ps5 i js got it and started a new playthrough so i dont have that many

[snow otter]

I play it on my ps4

[eternal estuary]

Is the modding scene on rdr2 good

I don’t mean mods like superhero’s or modern cars I mean actual good mods

I’m getting a pc soon and I want to mod rdr2

[marsh flint]

Decent

I mean , you should install some mods on pc such as the poncho

[ashen steeple]

chat

yk something funny

so i was riding to seamus to sell some stuff and i ran over a dog

and he disappeared

so i left and came back

when i came back, the dog respawned somehow and seamus stood there with a bandage on his head and said "i've still got bruises y'know"

like what 😭

[grand valley]

hi

[ashen steeple]

didnt realize bro was connected to the dog

[grand valley]

so I'm playing rdr2 for the first time

how do I fully enjoy the game

[ashen steeple]

by playing it

[grand valley]

like don't miss a lot of cool stuff or like speed past idk

I plan to do all the missions

[ashen steeple]

try maybe

playing it

[grand valley]

but I'm worried I might miss stuff or like hold back my experience

[ashen steeple]

dont skip anything ig

[grand valley]

I won't like miss stuff just casually?

[ashen steeple]

you'll hold back by overthinking it

[grand valley]

fair enough

[ashen steeple]

if you see a mission, do it

its not that deep

you can also do other things outside of missions

like hunting and playing poker and dominoes

and fishing

so its not all about the story

theres the adventure and the world to explore

[grand valley]

so just play slowly

[ashen steeple]

not exactly that, just take your time

[soft root]

oh, look through everything

it is extremely easy to miss stuff

[ashen steeple]

hey its okay to miss stuff

the important part is enjoying what you dont miss

its just best to not skip over things that are right in front of you

[royal birch]

can anyone tell me the best legendary animal to get

i need to complete all of the animal compedium. well honestly its just for fun but yeah

[midnight cloud]

Personally I think the best gear to get is the legendary aligator

[lapis sable]

Personally, i think the best things to do in the game is to get so hated to every lawman that they will chase you forever as you hunt, gather, rob, steal or murder folk or exploring areas

Not paying off bounty and let it rise up and up aw ye

[stuck star]

hey does anyone know a good discord (or if this discord has a channel) about mysteries i.e spiderdream

[royal stirrup]

I had bounty on all states and I just paid it yesterday because it really gets annoying when they spawn while you're crafting, checking shops...

[lapis sable]

I'll shoot up the town if they do it!!!!

[hidden moss]

they always shoot down my horse when they come for me

[lapis sable]

If they run to me when i was looking for landmarks, i camp and ambush em all here AW YE

They are free loot!

[hidden moss]

a few bucks and rings

[lapis sable]

With cigarettes, bottle of whiskey, and they give me free ammo, i love them all

Loada of snake oil too

[hidden moss]

how does one even get a bounty in Ambarino?

there are no towns there

[lapis sable]

Get witnessed, let him go.

Easiest way is to kill a guy, dismember him, stash him on your horse

[sacred yarrow]

Which are the best legendary bountys?

Hellloooo

[royal stirrup]

kill someone and force a witness to escape

then kill waves of policemen

[sacred yarrow]

?????

[amber island]

is red dead redemption good

im thinking of palying it too

[sacred yarrow]

Great

[amber island]

ogey

[brave sphinx]

yay did herbalist 9

[raven vessel]

How do I unlock bandit challenge

[queen leaf]

low honor players are always cool ❤️

[lapis sable]

HELL YE

[queen leaf]

rob ppl in towns

[lapis sable]

The town is my playground!!! Die!!!

[queen leaf]

i think idk i do high honor so imma do em as john

[raven vessel]

Bro I robbed someone with a mask on

I’m wanted

But there’s no bounty to pay

Only red lines around the city

And the lawmen are after me

What can I do to fix this

[queen leaf]

uhhhh

i have no idea

[raven vessel]

When does Micah get imprisoned

After what mission

[sour inlet]

waitwhat

[glacial geyser]

After Colter

[sour inlet]

im so sad about chapter 4

just finished it 😭

[cursive mulch]

How do I get the Missouri fox trotter if I already beat Albert mason’s quest

[keen perch]

Anyone now why stagecoach is always unavailable? Even if the icon is not greyed out on the map its never there in any city

I have no bounties

Neverfind suddendly fixed literally this moment after days of not working

[raven vessel]

Huh

But I’m in chapter 2

[cursive mulch]

Is this your first playthrough

[raven vessel]

No

[azure sluice]

Chapter 2

you can skip Micah’s mission as far as chapter 3

[raven vessel]

I wanna do it now tho bc I can hold up 5 townsfolk without getting the law on me

[real shore]

Do the woman sniping glitch I haven't tried it but there should be tutorials on YouTube

[viscid dagger]

can i still get achievements when i used a cheat code?

[violet obsidian]

Why does this story have to hurt so much

I just had the I'm afrsid scene

This game didn't have to be this emotional

[prime pilot]

No

[lone crown]

U can't

Nvm

[lapis sable]

get wanted in all 5 states, kill everyone and loot em as you see

[indigo helm]

why the hell would you be able to

[royal stirrup]

i forgot cheat codes were a thing

[viscid dagger]

idk

[raven vessel]

Oh my god bro I’m trying to do kill 6 animals without reloading

the game is reloading for me

they’re ragebaiting me

BRO WHY

[ashen steeple]

go to the bison in heartland overflow

they travel like 20 at a time

[lapis sable]

go to carmody dell, kill the idiot rancher, kill all the cows 🙂

[indigo helm]

if you run out of ammo it reloads for yoy

just use a repeater

[thorny cargo]

also if you use dead eye it reloads.

[raven vessel]

I’ll try this

They don’t get one shotted

I need to one shot them

Only 6 bullets

[ashen steeple]

they do if you shoot em right

with the right gun

in the right spot

[raven vessel]

I waited for a flock of birds to fly over me and shot them all down

[ashen steeple]

aye gg

[raven vessel]

Anyone know what I need to do in order to start the sheep mission with John

Think it’s called sheeps and goats

[mortal cedar]

🇧🇷 - Alguém consegue me ajudar? Minha eu ganho honra mais a barra de honra não sobe.

🇺🇸 - Can someone help me? I gain honor, but the honor bar isn't going up.

[ashen steeple]

press down on the dpad if you're on controller or alt on keyboard and it will show up

[mortal cedar]

Yes, I've already done that, but it doesn't seem to be increasing.

[raven vessel]

You need to gain a lot of honor points for the bar to go up

Not just 1

[mortal cedar]

Do you know approximately how much?

I've already earned more than fifty, and I'm not getting anywhere.

[raven vessel]

You need more and more each time

[mortal cedar]

Okay, I understand. I'm Brazilian, so don't worry if I'm spelling it wrong.

[raven vessel]

Keep getting more honor and it should go up

[mortal cedar]

Do you think it's easier to fill the honor bar or to decrease the honor bar?

[raven vessel]

Hmm

As long as you don’t do bad stuff it won’t decrease

[mortal cedar]

okay

[raven vessel]

It depends on how you play

[mortal cedar]

I'm focused on getting the platinum trophy in the game, and there's a trophy that asks you to "Reach the maximum or minimum Honor level".

I don't know if it's the same in your country.

[ashen steeple]

probably decrease

but if its high already then increasing is better

[mortal cedar]

I'll send a photo #red-dead-media okay?

[raven vessel]

If you want to get the achievement go around antagonizing people or kill farm animals

That’s easier than getting it up

To get it lower

[mortal cedar]

I sent an image there.

[ashen steeple]

@mortal cedar yeah definitely get it up, atp getting it down will probably take longer

[mortal cedar]

Okay then partner, thank you very much.

[midnight ocean]

do other missions

[raven vessel]

Why didn’t they keep the dark jacket and green shirt for arthur

[sharp forum]

guys what do i name my horse

[raven vessel]

is it bc they wanted that for the o’driscolls

[raven vessel]

which horse is it

[sharp forum]

a shire

i kinda like shires

[midnight ocean]

is it the black one

[sharp forum]

yeah

[fast warren]

a stranger asked me to watch his wagon while he finds someone to deal with it do i wait for him or not

[midnight ocean]

nah

[fast warren]

should i take the gold watch on the ground

[midnight ocean]

yeah take everything

[thorny cargo]

youll lose honor

if u dont care about that then go ahead

[fast warren]

ill js take the gold watch and leave

[midnight ocean]

a little hit to honor never hurt nobody

[raven vessel]

Found the guy with high stakes map

I hog tied him and took the map

Is it important to cut him free

Or can I leave him

[midnight ocean]

you can leave him

[raven vessel]

Aight

[slim wharf]

I never put this much thought into my honor lmao I just picked the low honor option always my first playthrough

[midnight ocean]

name checks out

jk

[hollow dagger]

it was actually hard to tell on my first playthrough to realize that the choices mattered

my honor was just a little below to receive the better ending

well plus without thinking i chose to go for the money lol

alongside the low honor ride back to camp at the start

i thought thats what everyone heard

if i did the kicking strauss out side mission i would've actually gotten a better ending lol

i js stopped doing his missions since idk chapter 3

[midnight ocean]

yeah they give you a bunch of stuff in chapter 6 to help get your honor up

but its all side stuff so

[raven vessel]

He will go and fall asleep by a tree like 100ft away

[earnest dawn]

Hey guys, what is the most cool pistol or revolver idk? (on chapter 4)

Just interesting

[midnight ocean]

schofield or lemat for revolver, 1899 for pistol

check the saint denis gun store

[earnest dawn]

Thanks

[snow otter]

I got the semi automatic

[azure kestrel]

Is there a glitch to become immortal or have no wanted level?

[raven vessel]

Hopefully not

And there shouldn’t be one

[midnight ocean]

theres cheats

[zinc ocean]

has anyone got a clue why john turns invisible in armadillo saloon using project new austin?

and how to fix it

im about to crashout

[raven vessel]

hehehehe would his last name happen to be cena hehehehe get it

hehehehehe am I right or am I right

hehehe

When I do run from van horn to blackwater

Does the timer still go when I pause the game to open the map?

Oh it doesn’t

Nice

[indigo helm]

why did my master hunter 7 reset

[rich lily]

Am I allowed to talk about single-player mods here

[midnight ocean]

you need to do them kinda close together time wise

[indigo helm]

how close

[midnight ocean]

actually i think you just need to do one after the other without killing anything else in between

[indigo helm]

well

i didnt

so it must be a time thing

[midnight ocean]

did you do anything else in between

[indigo helm]

nope

[midnight ocean]

weird

idk if its bugged or poorly worded or what

[indigo helm]

filthy o’drisscolls shot at me but i didnt shoot back and just ran

[midnight ocean]

maybe that reset it somehow

[indigo helm]

???

i guess so

[midnight ocean]

lol

[indigo helm]

maybe an Odriscoll shot an animal and cus they were aggroed on me it counted as my kill somehow?

[midnight ocean]

it might just be the fact that you were in combat

[indigo helm]

yeah maybe

[midnight ocean]

id just try again

[indigo helm]

thats what im doing

i hate this challenge so much

easily the worst of all master hunter challenges

not only is it just annoying its just a whole lot of waiting

[midnight ocean]

i think 6 is worse

trying to get five cougars to spawn can be a pain

and when i was doing it i think i forgot to use the bow for like two of em

[indigo helm]

i found a spot where one cougar spawns every single time you go there

so that one wasnt too difficult for me

well

you need to sleep 24-48 hours

then come back

but its always there

also, i just neckshotted a coyote with express bullets and it survived

so thats cool

[indigo helm]

express bolt action

oh my god its coming back to the same spot i just shot it

it might be dumb

[raven vessel]

@midnight ocean

I’m gonna do the blackwater and van horn thing

I can just stop at the beach right?

Wait not beach

wait yes

the beach

[indigo helm]

why is getting a herbivore to fall for the bait so much more difficult than predator

[raven vessel]

When does the timer start

[indigo helm]

will having a corpse near the bait stop a herbivore from going for it?

[main yarrow]

Is there really not a gunsmith in Blackwater?

[cerulean moat]

I’m afraid..

[midnight ocean]

when you leave the town i guess

and yeah you wanna ride to the tip of that tiny peninsula thats north of blackwater

its still in the legal area for arthur

but i guess its close enough to blackwater itself that it tricks the challenge

[indigo helm]

omg im actually gonna lose it

i lured and killed a hog, then on my way to a herbivore I DIDNT EVEN HIT IT

a bird had a heart attack NEXT to my horse

WTF

im gonna jump, rope attached atp

[raven vessel]

BRO

i spent all that time between van horn and blackwater

[indigo helm]

ok i wont celebrate

[raven vessel]

and it doesn’t count

WHY

[indigo helm]

what happened

what happened??

[raven vessel]

I’m doing the horseman challenge bro

I have 17 minutes on me to travel from van horn to black water

And I can’t touch water

And I just got to blackwater

But I took too long

[indigo helm]

oof

sorry man

[raven vessel]

what happened to u

[indigo helm]

after two days i finally completed master hunter 7

just now

[raven vessel]

Fire

[indigo helm]

turns out all i had to do was slather myself in clover oil and place two baits next to a a herd of herbivores

[raven vessel]

lol fair

[indigo helm]

and they go right for it

the predator part was easy tho

it was just the herbivore part

[raven vessel]

What’s the predator part

Haven’t done it yet

[indigo helm]

lure a predator and herbivore and kill it consecutively

[raven vessel]

oh wow

[indigo helm]

and theres a time limit i believe

a hidden time limit

[raven vessel]

all this for an outfit bro

[indigo helm]

lol

its worth it

[raven vessel]

yea

[indigo helm]

master hunter 8 is so easy tho lol

[raven vessel]

only rewarding and doable challenge is the explorer one

[indigo helm]

catch 3 small fish without a rod

[raven vessel]

How do you do that

[indigo helm]

like all i need to do is shoot some fish in water

[raven vessel]

Do you just shoot

[indigo helm]

yep

[raven vessel]

damn

how many challenges have u completed

out of the 90

[indigo helm]

not many

ive just been focusing on master hunter

[raven vessel]

ahh fair enough

[indigo helm]

i only recently started doing challenges

[raven vessel]

same bro

some people finish it in like a day

how

[indigo helm]

I’ll be doing horseman next

damn

a day?

[raven vessel]

horseman is such a pain

[raven vessel]

yea idk how they manage

they say following guides help but it barely does

[indigo helm]

either herbalist or horseman

[raven vessel]

are you arthur or john

[indigo helm]

arthur

currently

[raven vessel]

u can skip herbalist

[indigo helm]

i dont wanna progress in the story for a bit

[raven vessel]

bc u can’t finish herbalist as arthur

[indigo helm]

oh

[raven vessel]

there’s ways on yt to skip it

that’s what I’m gonna do

[raven vessel]

yea u gotta go to like armadillo i think

[indigo helm]

ah

well

i can still do some of them as arthur

[raven vessel]

yeah

[indigo helm]

and finish off the rest as john

[raven vessel]

alr alr

[indigo helm]

alright well im off to go shoot fish in a barrel, quite literally

lol

[raven vessel]

lol aight

yo hold on

I found a way

if this helps me complete horseman 9 ill be happy idk what else to say

[bleak iron]

Theres ways that allow you to DO them as arthur, but you cant skip them. It us very possible to get all of them done as arthur if you have the time

[indigo helm]

already beaten master hunter 8

so easy compared to the 3 previous master hunter missions

[quick python]

man, just found out about the cutscene at the end that only triggers when you have a level 4 bond with your horse, had to just sit and compose myself for a couple of minutes after that

[midnight ocean]

yeah theres even a note on the wiki about how weird it is that master hunter 8 and 9 are so easy lol

[quick python]

shit tugged at my heart strings heavy

[raven vessel]

There actually is

You can skip herbalist

Search it on YouTube

My friend did it last month and it worked

[raven vessel]

who doesn’t have a level 4 bond with their horse at the end tho 🤔

[indigo helm]

aaaand thats master hunter 9 done

lmao

im gonna save killing the panther for john

[raven vessel]

is master hunter här

hard**

if not I’ll do it next

[indigo helm]

ive killed most of the legendary animals as arthur

[indigo helm]

its pretty hard

[quick python]

on my other playthroughs i switched horses around a lot

[indigo helm]

the cougar one especially

[indigo helm]

i feel bad for john so ill let john get a couple aswell

[quick python]

i also tend to go for horses i like the look of or ones that look similar to ones i know irl which made me usually have like a level 3 bond at most

[indigo helm]

what challenge should i do next

since im at valentine i’ll quickly do horseman 3

[midnight ocean]

do some bandit ones if you havent

you can stick people up behind the saloon in valentine

[indigo helm]

lmao what is horseman 4

not even a challenge just funny

well since im in rhodes

ill go kidnap a braithewaite

nvm found a klan meeting

even better

LOL

i threw in a dynamite and everyone died except for one guy

[raven vessel]

kill him or else he’ll become leader

[quick python]

thinking about it it's probably for the better that i never got that cutscene with a horse that looks similar to ones i love irl, i wouldbe bawling my eyes out highkey

[indigo helm]

bro…

arthur keeps letting go of him

i keep getting to around 2000/3300 feet and arthur just… lets go

resetting it

why is arthur being such a bitch

[raven vessel]

u dragging the body?

[raven vessel]

If u jump he will let go

[indigo helm]

didnt jump

arthur just let go

[raven vessel]

Wow

[halcyon sparrow]

i guess he got tired

[boreal tapir]

Is there any possible way to play red dead on Xbox with keyboard and mouse?

Recently Ive felt like controller is sluggish compared to mouse

Since I know pc players can use controller so I assume you can use kbm somehow

It would only make sense

[muted orchid]

So im in the epilogue part 1 and im trying to get the White Arabian again but its not there? Do i have to wait longer or am i just missing it?

[hallow cosmos]

It usually respawns after a few days, try camping there for 24 hours and it might spawn.

Or save and reload at lake isabella

[muted orchid]

So i got it the first time like months ago in game time haha. Did it during Chapter 2

[hallow cosmos]

That's nice

I'm not getting it bcz I don't have space in stables

🥀💔

[muted orchid]

Oh but i guess it would base the respawn off its death not capture wouldnt it

[hallow cosmos]

And I mostly want the male version from horse flesh for dinner glitch. With the B Stamped

[hallow cosmos]

I think so and check for any wolves or lost man events out there that is a high cause of not respawning the white arabian.

BTW you can get horses similar to the White Arabian in the epilogue like the Rose Grey Bay Arabian, MFT Silver Dapple Pinto but you need money. I'm buying the Silver Dollar Turkoman at Tumbleweed.

[blissful crane]

the unique B brand disappears after you save and reload

the game just turns it into a normal dark bay turkoman

you still get to keep it ofc but the unique braithwaite symbol is temporary

[narrow silo]

Hey guys, yesterday I was riding my horse through the Lemoyne area and both I and my horse were killed. Now I don't have my horse. Do you think I should reload my last save (which would take 2 hours) to get my horse back? Or would the most realistic thing to do be to admit it's dead and use the Hosea's Shire that you get at the beginning?

[slim wharf]

If the horse is really important to you then sure go back to your save otherwise you’re never getting it back got to find a new one

[narrow silo]

Yes, it was the perlino Andalusian horse. If, for example, my horse dies and I don't, then I accept its death and continue. But in this case, we both died, so the fairest thing would be to reload a save, right? I like to play as realistically as possible.

[boreal garden]

I like how rdr2 gives hints of jack also becoming a outlaw in the future, like when he successfully robs saint denis, or when he kills javier with just one bullet left, bravo rockstar

[bleak iron]

that i did not know, still finding stuff out about this game after all this time

[soft root]

sure

reloading the save is fine

[narrow silo]

Nice

[soft root]

since when you respawn, it's not actually coming back to life after the event

[narrow silo]

Of course if My horse die but I’m still alive I have to continue but when we die both…

[soft root]

it's just turning the event in which you and your horse dies into a possibility

rather than actually reality

since the story doesn't end when you die in-game

so...yeah

just...reload a save

it's realistic enough

[narrow silo]

The last save is 2 hours before but np

[raven vessel]

yea it’s crazy

the level of detail this game has is crazy

last night I found 2 deers fighting with their horns

[royal stirrup]

is there any explanation to why o'driscolls have remarkably better loot when you kill them?

[raven vessel]

do you mean than other people

@midnight ocean the beach isn’t working

but I see comments from like 6 days ago saying it works for them on yt

idk what’s going wrong bro

[real shore]

You do realise you can just load your autosave and your horse and you will be back just minutes before that accident when your horse died

[royal stirrup]

yep

[raven vessel]

hmm

probably bc they’re richer and more successful

they’re rivals with dutchs gang and they used to be rich before blackwater

normal enemies are just bandits or something

[soft root]

compared to who

civilians? random criminals

law?

I think that's bc o'driscolls get great pay bc their gang is really huge

there's a reason they kept existing no matter how much dutch's gang killed till colm died

[narrow silo]

In that accident we died both, me and my horse, that’s why I’m going to reload, if my horse die but me no, I have to be realistic and continue without my horse

[raven vessel]

Finally bro

I’m never doing horseman 9 as arthur again

[royal stirrup]

If you ride from Van Horn to the tip of the peninsula below Lone Mule Stead, the challenge will trigger complete

you get to ride back before they snipe you if ur quick

[snow otter]

I think he's gonna be the main character in rdr3 ngl if there is a rdr3

[fast warren]

My horse always gets so dirty what am I doing wrong bro

[slow flicker]

use the brush or run your horse through water

[wooden agate]

My game keeps crashing on the loading screen

[hollow relic]

anyone know a fix for this gamebreaking bug?

im on the first train robbery mission, where bill tries to blow up the tracks

after helping him connect the detonator, and going back up to the others, upon equipping my bandana, the screen goes black for a few seconds, and the cutscene that's supposed to play is just bugged, and the actor's voices don't work

after the cutscene finishes (that i couldnt see), and i jump on the train, the game remains bugged and gives me no further instructions - the train has no interiors, the guards aren't visible, only their guns, etc.

if i try to restart the mission the game just completely freezes and i have to close it in task manager

[fast warren]

Uhh I was doing the mission with uncle and like some girls idk who but it's the mission where a guy comes up to me and asks if I was in Blackwater and I finished the mission but how the hell do I get back to camp because the horse I used it told me to return it to the owner but idk where he is and it says it's "my horse now" but idk if I should take it or nktt

[raven vessel]

I managed to do it

Next time as John bruh it’s not worth it

How long does it usually take to complete all challenges

Cause I’ve been grinding for like a day and I only completed 23 out of 90

[versed ember]

Recommendations for survival mods that work well together. Wanted to use dynamic seasons, with basic needs and humidity and temp overhaul. Wasn't sure if dynamic seasonss/seasons manager will account for temp values properly.

Also wanted to use injuries overhaul, but it's old and I've read to stay away from things that fool with the version. dll

[violet obsidian]

Is there a mod where i can shoot dutch and micah

[royal stirrup]

its meant to be slow even endgame so dw

[raven vessel]

aight fire

Should I try and complete them all in chapter 2 or should I mix with main quests so it doesn’t get overwhelming

[royal stirrup]

It's just my opinion but, to me they become a burden if you go for them back to back

[raven vessel]

ah

[royal stirrup]

It all comes down to how many things u want done and how quick

If you are aiming for the 100% completion, treasure challenges, dino bones, dreamcatchers (collectibles in general) take way less time with a guide

It's meant to stick around for when you got literally nothing else to do

I'm just chilling and taking it as a second run, but also aiming for the 100%

[lapis sable]

Or you can be a real low honor bastard

[raven vessel]

nah I just want the outfit

[violet obsidian]

Just finished chapter 6

I don't even know what to say man

[raven vessel]

High honor or low honor?

Why are ppl saying low honor ending is canon when the game does a lot to get your honor up in chapter 6

I have no problem with low honor

But it’s obvious the devs were hinting at high honor more

it’s a redemption story

[boreal garden]

I have read people saying that it is because you can blind one of micah's eyes in that ending
But i mean, you can also do that with high honor

[raven vessel]

Yeah

[warped geode]

i like high honor

[raven vessel]

Same

[warped geode]

but i will 100% shoot some people if they're annoying me

[raven vessel]

rs they can’t be talking shit and expect to get away with it

[warped geode]

but other than that help everyone that i can to get more honor

[raven vessel]

yeah

[warped geode]

in the last debt mission

i gave money money to that second woman and to the first guy i didn't make him pay his debt

[raven vessel]

I’m also pretty sure u get exclusive stuff in the shop and cheaper prices with high honor

[warped geode]

oh fr i didn't know that

[raven vessel]

bro I was so mad when Arthur was just giving away all my money

[warped geode]

money money lol

[raven vessel]

then he dies

[boreal garden]

I love high honor so much omg
The "I'm scared" cutscend is so peak
I love how Arthur opens himself not with someone really that important to him, but with a random person he helped

[raven vessel]

Agreed

[warped geode]

i like when there's choices

[raven vessel]

yeah

[warped geode]

like either give money or something else

idk why but i almost always picked the option that was for honor

[raven vessel]

same

I wish the stuff Arthur does with low honor was worse than it is

like some really bad things

[boreal garden]

Does Arthur also stays with his dying horse in the ending if you have low honor? I won't see why would he do that in that version

[raven vessel]

Don’t think he does

Only high honor

[boreal garden]

Make sense to me
If he doesn't care about human life, why would he care for a horse

[raven vessel]

I like doing some low honor things at the start and then after chapter 3 u do good stuff

[molten walrus]

i massacred towns and animals and had very low honour but as chapter 6 approached i started greeting people for high honour ending

and i did get it

i also caught a fish and threw it back into the water it gave me honour too

[raven vessel]

🙏

van horn is fun bc there’s no laws there

[molten walrus]

whats that

[raven vessel]

van horn trading post

[molten walrus]

OH that place

[raven vessel]

In like chapter 6

Yes

[molten walrus]

yeah

i got free gun from there

for my good deeds

[raven vessel]

What gun

Oh was it that

U helped someone

[molten walrus]

if u save a guy

yes

[raven vessel]

And he bought whatever u wanted for u

fire

[molten walrus]

from a bear trap

yeah

[raven vessel]

i did that in valentine

and Rhodes I’m pretty sure

didn’t know u could do it for van horn

[molten walrus]

when i was in chapter 2 i was fucked in the head so i saw the valentine guy and threw an axe on his head

i didnt knew he would give free gun

but i greeted some guys later so i got honour back

[raven vessel]

lol

bro I was doing a horseman challenge thing

I had to run from somewhere to Saint Denis I think

And it was timed

And in the middle of the challenge I see a man getting executed by bandits and he screamed for help

I got minus honor bc I didn’t help him

bruh I had no time

Think it was strawberry to Saint Denis

In like 9 minutes

[molten walrus]

😭😭😭

[molten walrus]

one time i was trying to help a guy being executed by bandits but i mistook him for one and ended up killing every single guy

[raven vessel]

Hahaha

It’s so hard to tell

It’s the same thing with bounties sometimes

when I wanna bring them in alive

But they’re all in a crowd

Idk which I should shoot and who I should spare

[midnight ocean]

check your minimap

[versed ember]

Recommendations for survival mods that work well together. Wanted to use dynamic seasons, with basic needs and humidity and temp overhaul. Wasn't sure if dynamic seasonss/seasons manager will account for temp values properly.

Also wanted to use injuries overhaul, but it's old and I've read to stay away from things that fool with the version. dll

[violet obsidian]

High honour

[violet obsidian]

They mostly see him as evil

[trim hamlet]

me personally

i feel like you should do low honor, and then get your honor up towards the end

[violet obsidian]

But after all that he did in chap. 6, i Can't force myself to see hin as that

[trim hamlet]

cause it shows how he's changed

and redeemed himself

[violet obsidian]

I had max honour since like chapter 2 lol

[trim hamlet]

same

[violet obsidian]

I mean the max you could get

[trim hamlet]

but it's too much work to go all the way down atp lmao

[violet obsidian]

I just don't like hurting folk

[violet obsidian]

I might, i got no problem shooting everyone i see

But I'm not touching the animals

Also, i never used the rob option that the game gives to random people

I always just greeted them

[trim hamlet]

if someone so much as sneezes near my horse they are dying

[violet obsidian]

Except that one racist guy in saint denis

[trim hamlet]

yeah nah i just quickdrew him and put a new hole in his skull

[violet obsidian]

That's the first guy I'm giving a double barell shotgun headshot when going for low honour

[violet obsidian]

Not enough

I'll stab that bastard

And vomit on his body

"I'm not evil, just racist" 😭

[trim hamlet]

bro truly believed that racism was not evil

[violet obsidian]

I held myself back because i didn't want to lower my honour

But dang i wanted to beat the guy

Man, since i started playing rdr2, my English vocabulary changed 😭

Did you finish the game?

[trim hamlet]

nah

i'm on chapter 4

[violet obsidian]

Don't get spoilers

Be very careful

I got some end spoilers sadly

But the less you know, the much more better it will be

It's a masterpiece

Enjoy it brother

[trim hamlet]

i mean i saw thomas downes cough into arthur's face and i'm like

"...wait is that why this game is called red dead redemption 2"

(tb was called "the red death" during that time period)

[violet obsidian]

I had no idea

I didn't even know who downes was until i googled it because i genuinely forgot about that part 😭

[trim hamlet]

@violet obsidian am i the only one like this or nah

[fast warren]

Guys help I'm doing the mission where John and idk who else rob a train and I have to steal a wagon but it's inside this place and there's loads of guard what do I dooo

[molten walrus]

i just shoot the suspicious ones which results in multiple deaths of innocents lol

[slim wharf]

I keep getting killed in the last mission where you’re going up the mountain for Micah

[violet obsidian]

I went through 4 horses

[obtuse zodiac]

What are chance encounters again

[slim wharf]

Micah is unreasonably op

[midnight ocean]

i dont like doing low honor stuff even at the start because while he is a mean bastard arthur really isn't the type of guy to just kill without reason

i guess i can see the jimmy brooks thing going either way tho

[empty patio]

Unless there's money involved

[thorny cargo]

same here

[marsh flint]

Do ya'll think arthur would have changed if he never got tb

I feel like he would atleast after coming back from guarma

[obtuse zodiac]

Why can't u rob banks in rdr2 bruh

[marsh flint]

Because game is missing some stuff that would make it the greatest game of all time

But then , cant have it all

[mortal cedar]

I achieved

Thank you very much, my friend.

[obtuse zodiac]

Man that's disappointing

[marsh flint]

It happens

[obtuse zodiac]

I mean if u banks all over the map, why not make it another option to get money

I don't see why they didn't add this, even if it was later on when the game released

[marsh flint]

That goes for ponchos , bandanas , different pant options ,being able to use masks with hats , etc.

[obtuse zodiac]

Yep definitely

[raven vessel]

They’re saving it for the missions

Master hunter challenges are very easy

[snow otter]

I got in there by taking them out in stealth

[sacred yarrow]

anybody played rd on pc?

is it worth it?

it kinda got boring playing alone on ps5 n the mechanics ns tuff

[fast warren]

It's pretty good ngl I've played it on ps5 and PC, theres not a lot of different stuff

[sacred yarrow]

game wise or just graphics n stuff

[fast warren]

Both I suppose

But in my opinion I think on pc it's easier to use guns and stuff like that but I haven't played a lot on ps5 so it might just be me

[glacial geyser]

Does cyberpunk 2077 worth playing?

[wary jacinth]

Your such a POS

[wary jacinth]

Not sure what you think but I will bet you it’s wrong

[thorny cargo]

what are you on about lmao

[midnight ocean]

😳

[thorny cargo]

😭

[obtuse zodiac]

Yeah but why u asking here

[violet obsidian]

I played it on there , it's decent

A bit hard to shoot with the controller but not bad