red-dead-singleplayer

[marsh flint]

And enjoy farmer life

[mossy gyro]

as soon as the epilogue started, I rode towards blackwater and saw a wagon about to get robbed so I beat the robbers up and took their guns

you can do what??

[steady bear]

I’m really struggling with the Lindsey Wofford bounty, currently got my housemate trying because it’s doing my head in! If I decide to skip mission will I still get the opportunity to loot the fort?

Because I’m ready to give up 😡

[tight plaza]

I finnaly saw the Ghost Train!

Wasn't trying I was just in the rght place at the right time

[marsh flint]

Once in a lifetime experience

[pliant bolt]

hai

[marsh flint]

Hi

Mustard

[steady bear]

Am I supposed to do anything with the prisoner in shackles that’s near Southfield flats? He called me over asking for help so I approached him, but now he’s just waddling about in his chains, aside from greeting him it won’t let me do anything else?

According to Google you are meant to shoot his shackles off… but he just told me to get the hell out so…

[slow echo]

Yo im at chapter 6 dont know which mission im at any tips?

[mortal oriole]

Why does jack keep saying I’m dressed like a lawman

[astral ferry]

guys i got rdr1.....

[marsh flint]

Why did john talk to the scientist in annensburg like they met before

[mortal oriole]

Oh no….

[solid current]

i have a pet o’driscoll on my horse where should i take it🥹❤️

[astral ferry]

dont trust pet odriscoll

[marsh flint]

Shoot all o'driscoll

[solid current]

took it down to the lake but apparently o’driscolls are not very strong swimmers😢😢 i saved it and now we are going to the train tracks to see if we can find a train❤️

[steady bear]

Savage

[reef island]

Do any of you guys use script hook from dev-c.com?

Just asking because I’m wondering if any of you are having issues with mods, because in some missions I play I have to disable all my mods in order to do the mission and it gets annoying but I don’t know which mod (if a mod issue causing the issue) is causing the game to break.

It usually happens right before a cutscene.

[bleak iron]

Does the Missouri fox trotter glitch with the Albert mason mission only work on console or both PC and console?

[unreal flax]

first time playing!! any tips or helpful things i should know?

[bleak iron]

Avoid spoilers like the plague, moderate your honor somewhat, do every single random encounter. That's really the best things to note

And I'd also suggest keeping the black shire that Hosea gives you

[unreal flax]

okayy!! tysm

[chrome terrace]

Macinater9000 dies

[steady bear]

Wish I had known this before I played, still sore about that 🤦‍♀️

[chrome terrace]

I always stable that horse

[ember ridge]

I always sell it

[warped ridge]

🚨FUN FACT🚨: The flower Arthur kept by his bed, his mother’s favorite, ended up leading to the cure for tuberculosis in the early 1900s. (Plants: Mullein, Butterfly Pea, Artemisia)

[steady bear]

If I end up doing another play through I will definitely keep him. But didn’t want to start over for the sake of a horse, specially cos horses die

[dense pasture]

That is interesting

[warped ridge]

MY BOY ಥ_ಥ

[reef island]

If only he ate it.

[turbid rampart]

Why doesn't the trapper saddles have a preview of it? They do that for the stables

I had to google what they looked like because there weren't any previews

That's so odd

You'd think they'd put previews for that

[obtuse berry]

hi

[nova quartz]

.

[marsh flint]

Holy epilog missions

[tardy void]

I just did the stagecoach robbery with Micah for the first time in 100s of hours

I never liked him so I always skipped it

But the way he talks about the women in camp firmly supports my belief that Micah lovers are weirdos

[reef island]

I personally like Micah a lot but not for that reason.

[rugged furnace]

guys is there a way to recover arthurs belongings as john?

[sterile wagon]

Hey yall

[reef island]

Like guns or money?

[rugged furnace]

either

even the saddle if thats possible

[tardy void]

Depends why u like him

[midnight ocean]

what is the reason

[tardy void]

Personally I think he’s fun to ride with

But he’s a terrible guy

[midnight ocean]

you get them automatically at some point

[reef island]

The guns you get on one of the epilogue missions, the money you have to go to the Aberdeen pig farm as Arthur and not do anything until you beat the epilogue as John then go back for the money.

The saddle I recall you can’t get back unless you buy it again.

[rugged furnace]

well money aint too important, its rather easy to get

[tardy void]

Saddles aren’t too expensive tho so it don’t matter

[reef island]

Probably because he’s such a beast.

[tardy void]

Especially with the 20k post AV

[reef island]

Arthur and Micah duo is insane.

[rugged furnace]

as long as i can get my beautifull volcanic pistol back

[tardy void]

Volcanic pistol users exist?

[reef island]

Indeed you will.

[rugged furnace]

i had no better choice when i got a free coupon in valentine

[reef island]

I used to use them a lot but recently switched to Schofields.

[tardy void]

I’ve always used double actions, schofields, or 1899s

[reef island]

Never was a fun of the double action besides the honor design.

[rugged furnace]

i wanna switch for a faster firerate, makes dead eye better

[reef island]

Most guns I buy I buy them to design them.

[tardy void]

I like quick drawing with them

[reef island]

Fair.

[tardy void]

It’s satisfying

Same with m1899s

Schofields are overall the best sidearms in the game

What loadouts do you guys use as go-tos?

[rugged furnace]

are any of the wild guns better? i mean like you gotta kill to get them

[tardy void]

You mean special guns like from killing the legendary gunslingers or just the basic ones off bodies?

[rugged furnace]

both i guess, but npcs dont really drop good stuff so mostly the gunslingers

[tardy void]

Well you can get a nice pistol from midnight, his Mauser is great

And then jimboy calloways Schofield is something I use if I go out of my way to do his mission

[rugged furnace]

yeah i had that as arthur but i dont think i had it equiped at the end so i wont get it back

[tardy void]

But I skip a lot of stranger missions except brother dorkins

And the twin brothers

[tardy void]

That’s a shame

I always use my personalized Lancaster, pump shotgun, and duel schofields, double actions, or m1899s

[rugged furnace]

i really like the pump shotgun

[tardy void]

Same

I carry it as my main weapon

If I’m not using my schofields 9/10 I’m using the pump

[rugged furnace]

rdr1 starts 1911 right?

[tardy void]

It has solid range and massive dmg

[tardy void]

Yes

[rugged furnace]

okay random question abt that, does it feature the colt 1911?

[tardy void]

Yes

[rugged furnace]

damn cool

[tardy void]

It’s not called the 1911 though

It’s called the high power pistol iirc

It’s been a couple years since my last rdr1 playthrough

[rugged furnace]

i prob wont even try it tbh

dont like the gun play

[tardy void]

It’s better tbh

That might just be me though

It feels way punchier

Also better ragdolls

And some more realistic npc interactions

[rugged furnace]

are duels more frequent?

im probably doing it wrong but im struggling to find duels in rdr2

[tardy void]

Well it’s a big part of rdr1

RDR2 does not have optional dues

*duels

It has random encounters that lead to duels

[rugged furnace]

the gunslingers were fun

[tardy void]

And if you do the legendary gunslinger missions you duel them

[tardy void]

Yea I like them but they’re a hassle imo

[rugged furnace]

i just go into auto pilot to get to them

[tardy void]

I mainly play how I think Arthur would and I don’t think he’d care to hunt random gunslingers and kill them

[rugged furnace]

i play every day with the mindset of "how can i make the world a little bit worse?"

[marsh flint]

It was the first mission i did and i can tell you walking around the map without having any idea where's what is very annoying

[tardy void]

I agree

I try to play Arthur fairly canonically

I occasionally act a little brutish but unless I’m specifically doing a low honor playthrough I act kindly and get mid-high Arthur

[rugged furnace]

holy shit dude my pc is having a hangover

[tardy void]

How many playthroughs have you done?

[rugged furnace]

lol on my first ish

[tardy void]

Oh nice

What chapter?

[rugged furnace]

ive played before on 2 seperate ones

im on start of the epilogue

[tardy void]

Sweet

Have you been spoiled for rdr1?

[rugged furnace]

like it more than the main part actually

[marsh flint]

Epilogue starts horrid

[rugged furnace]

everything was spoiled before i played lol

[tardy void]

I enjoyed it actually

[tardy void]

Shame

I played both games spoiler free

[marsh flint]

But once you get to the raid mission , it becomes the best one

[rugged furnace]

i knew arthur was gonna die the entire time and i knew when ish

[tardy void]

Felt amazing

I feel bad for spoiled people

[marsh flint]

I knew EVERY spoiler and i hate it

[tardy void]

It ruins the emotional impact

[rugged furnace]

the end with the fight on the mountian with micah was supposed to be exciting, i knew the outcome so ...

[marsh flint]

My most emotional moment was kieran's death actually

[rugged furnace]

same actually

[marsh flint]

Still beat the living crap out of him

[rugged furnace]

im surprised he could even stand, he got punched in the face by a grown ass man, and not a weak one either, many times

[tardy void]

I JUST got there bro

It kills me every time

[marsh flint]

Not hosea, not lenny

[tardy void]

Even on my 7th playthrough seeing kieren die hurts

[marsh flint]

None of them actually made me almost shed a tear

[rugged furnace]

i was kinda sad about lenny

[marsh flint]

Not even arthur.

[tardy void]

Hosea and lenny hurt more personally

[rugged furnace]

i just liked him, nice boy

[tardy void]

The only deaths that made me personally sadder than normal were Hosea Arthur and Kieran

[rugged furnace]

i was shaken a bit by mrs grimshaw

[tardy void]

Sean made me sad but it was too quick

[tardy void]

I never cared for grimshaw

She was cool that was it personally

[rugged furnace]

i liked her cuz she killed that traitor woman

[tardy void]

Molly wasn’t a traitor though

[marsh flint]

Molly was innocent

[rugged furnace]

i was smiling ear to ear when she shot her

wait what...

[tardy void]

Son 💔

[rugged furnace]

it was fucking micah wasnt it

[tardy void]

Do you not remember?

[tardy void]

Yes??

[rugged furnace]

uh so

[tardy void]

This was a big reveal

[rugged furnace]

she said she did it

so i thought she was a seperate issue

[marsh flint]

She was sad.

She had her motives

[rugged furnace]

drunk...

[tardy void]

She was trying to get Dutch’s attention

[rugged furnace]

i mean good job ig

[tardy void]

It’s a big thing throughout the game if you do a second or third playthrough

You can see her sulking all the time and getting brushed off by ditch

*dutch

So she tries to get his attention

Hence why she says “the high and mighty finally sees Molly” or whatever she says

[rugged furnace]

i really like that woman that wanted to do the same job as the men

i forgot her name

[tardy void]

Milton also says she never talked and Milton had no reason to lie since he believed he was gonna kill Arthur anyways

[tardy void]

Sadie Adler

[rugged furnace]

yeahh

[marsh flint]

I also didn't like grimshaw considering she attacked mary beth for no reason in camp

[rugged furnace]

she was really fun to ride with

[tardy void]

I didn’t like grimshaw much either

I will always utterly despise Micah

For everything he did

[marsh flint]

I couldn't bring myself to kick strauss

[tardy void]

Including killing grimshaw

[rugged furnace]

i think i would've enjoyed the game way more if i didnt know micah would so the stuff he does

[tardy void]

He’s a scumbag idc that he was a part of the gang

[marsh flint]

Say all you want but he never wronged the gang or arthur

[rugged furnace]

i really liked the "veteran" npc in valentine

[marsh flint]

I know..

[tardy void]

He indirectly gave him the disease that killed him and he preyed on people that had the life Arthur wanted for both himself and John

[marsh flint]

I know but i pity him

[tardy void]

We see this parrelel directly when he has to collect debt from someone named Arthur living the life HE wanted

Having kids and a wife and a home

That man dies because of Strauss debts

[marsh flint]

Mickey is such a nice person

[tardy void]

Mickey is my goat

Some people kill him it’s insane to me

[rugged furnace]

can i have like a special interaction with him as john because i was nice to him as arthur?

[marsh flint]

I could never

[tardy void]

YES

[marsh flint]

Yes

[rugged furnace]

new mission unlocked

[tardy void]

I always walk around valentines as John to get that interaction

You can do it with the southern one to

[tardy void]

Did you let Anthony foreman live?

[rugged furnace]

nope

i knew i should have

[tardy void]

Shame

[rugged furnace]

i saw it on a video

[tardy void]

That interaction is so cool

[rugged furnace]

but i hate the racist people so i killed him

[tardy void]

Anthony wasn’t a racist wdym?

He was just a part of a gang

[rugged furnace]

the slave guy?

[tardy void]

Anthony foreman was the guy who kidnaps Tilly

[rugged furnace]

that kidnapped the lady from us?

yeah

wasnt he racist as can be?

[tardy void]

No?

He was a black guy a part of a gang

With his cousins?

[rugged furnace]

OHHH

[tardy void]

There is a slaver you can kill

You get honor for it

[rugged furnace]

i think thats who im remembering

no its not i remember it being the tilly guy

[tardy void]

Nope

He’s a Strauss mission

[rugged furnace]

i killed some guy in relation to tilly

[tardy void]

Prolly Anthony

[rugged furnace]

whether he was black racist or whatever he was i dont know

but hes dead

[marsh flint]

It kills me hearing jack slowly losing the happiness in his voice each chapter

[midnight ocean]

yeah i get those two things mixed up all the time

[rugged furnace]

usually if i get a choice to kill a bad person

i do it instantly

wait what

i have arthurs stuff

everything from his saddle even

i didnt even do anything

[marsh flint]

U john rn?

[rugged furnace]

yeah

[marsh flint]

I noticed i have some stuff left

[rugged furnace]

i just got out of the bank money borrowing

god damn it my game crashed again

[midnight ocean]

remember when i said "you get them back automatically" lol

[rugged furnace]

i thought you meant like a mini mission

even got the midnight pistol

[midnight ocean]

well you do get them back during a mission

jim milton rides again i think

[rugged furnace]

the bank one is when i realised

[midnight ocean]

pretty sure its when you see him put on arthurs hat

[rugged furnace]

also

does your game ever crash and give the error message "ffffffff"

just a bunch of fs

[marsh flint]

How do I get my cousin to continue rdr2

He bought it yet he has like 8 hours in it

💔

[rugged furnace]

yk when arthur gets kidnapped?

try those techniques

[marsh flint]

Apparently he was far into the game but a cousin of ours played and "deleted" his game..

Hard to believe but Ok...

[rugged furnace]

dude the amount of people who dont get past the winter start

it pisses me off

[marsh flint]

He got to the first camp

Atleast

And he had the game LONGERA than i do

And i got 90 hours and im not even done with main story

[turbid rampart]

Do legendary animal carcasses rot?

[tardy void]

I have a friend like that

I convinced him to get red dead

[thorny cargo]

nope

[turbid rampart]

Oml, thank god

[marsh flint]

Feeling when Grizzlies are genuinely a bigger threat than enemies

[turbid rampart]

That one cabin almost sent me into an early grave because of the grizzly yeah

Grizzlies and cougars are a nightmare for me 😭

[tardy void]

You can scare them off

Literally just stand your ground and shoot your weapon up and they get scared

[marsh flint]

Good luck with that

[tardy void]

Or blast them

[turbid rampart]

I throw dynamite at them if I have the chance

[marsh flint]

When i see them they're ussualy 5 meters infront

Horse ran faster than a tesla

And now im alone with just a pistol facing a grizzly

[turbid rampart]

Type shit

My horse leaves me with the cougars, and luckily, I've only been near 2 grizzlies so far

Cougars are a death sentence tho

[marsh flint]

Wow

I once shot a camp of enemies

And a grizzly decided to give me a visit

[turbid rampart]

Yeah, you mentioned 😭😭

Don't text and ride, guys, I just slammed into a tree and shot Arthur 20 feet forward

[dense gate]

stupid fawking handcar won’t push

[marsh flint]

I noticed the running animation has a uncanny resemblance to the san andreas animation

[dense gate]

bro i’m going to tweak it won’t goooo

[marsh flint]

I know

Stupid handcar

[dense gate]

fr

[turbid rampart]

Just witnessed a rabbit spawn in- 10 feet off the ground

That's not normal

It died upon impact

[dense gate]

i was like “why i am so short in first person fov”

i was crouched

[dense gate]

😀

[turbid rampart]

Sane reaction quite frankly

[solid current]

how can i get the thoroughbred that you get for free with ultimate edition?? it says to just check the stables but i looked and its not on there

[midnight ocean]

get to the hunting mission with hosea

[tight plaza]

I have a similar question - I lost the TB I got at Pronghorn Ranch

err I should say JM got it

[solid current]

i have, im on my second playthrough rn and i played through the whole game the first time without even knowing it existed lol

[midnight ocean]

its at valentine then in the stable, theres two horses

[marsh flint]

I got a outfit idea...

Make John's outfit take ideas from the gang

As in clothing pieces

[solid current]

already checked valentine and its just the american standardbred, hungarian halfbred and dutch warmblood😭

i think theres just something up with my story mode, i have the free horse on online mode so idk why its not showing up on story mode

[rugged furnace]

do you guys play with settings on ultra?

[midnight ocean]

yeah thats weird, maybe not properly installed?

[rugged furnace]

guys i think im using dead eye wrong

how do i get the little x to show up, the preplanned shot thingy

[tight plaza]

If I am understanding your question correctly, that comes with more gameplay

in other words, dead-eye ability is enhanced as you proceed through the story

[midnight ocean]

where in the story are you

[rugged furnace]

im in 2nd part of the prologue

not prologue

uhh epilogue

[midnight ocean]

check your keybinds to see what it is to mark targets

[brittle ruin]

Js found out i needed to do a quest in chapter 4 to get the nun dialogue 😔

[rugged furnace]

thx, q is really bad ima change it to like a side button or sum

[tight plaza]

The main problem with controller play is I don't see an option to zoom in on things. Is that a KB only feature in your experience?

[unborn meadow]

guys is chapter 3 good

i just completed chapter 2 a couple of hours ago

[tight plaza]

during my 3rd time through I tried to stay in Chapter 3 as long as possible. You can fill out all the satchels in Chapter 3 and it makes things soooo much easier later on

I am at the tail end of my 3rd time through and I am just living the thug life as JM after completing all the chapters

[unborn meadow]

Alright

Is chapter 3 long?

[tight plaza]

yes many stories but don't rush

that's my advice

[unborn meadow]

Thanks man

I started playing 2 days ago

The game is awesome

[tight plaza]

totally you can slow down and enjoy chapter 3. It's hard the first time through but try and hunt more

[unborn meadow]

Okay

Thanks for the advice bro

[tight plaza]

happy to help

hunting and treasures

you can get rich and be a pro collector - great prep for the rest of the game

at this very moment I am all about JM post game living the life. It's fun

[unborn meadow]

Who's jm?

[unborn meadow]

John Marston?

[thorny cargo]

yes

[unborn meadow]

Oh

Why not arthur

Do we get to pick?

After

[thorny cargo]

cant tell you, thatd be spoilers :-)

just play the game.

[unborn meadow]

Okay

[thorny cargo]

additionally try to stay out of this channel, its riddled with spoilers

[unborn meadow]

Oh

I didn't know

[lapis sable]

This game goes like this, you take a gun, go to a store, rob them, loot everything, go on a killing spree, BABY!

[thorny cargo]

not really

[unborn meadow]

If that's how u see it

[lapis sable]

Ain't that what Dutch want, loads of smoke?

[thorny cargo]

yes but unless youre doing low honor theres no reason to go on a killing spree lol. i wouldnt

[unborn meadow]

Being low honor is so peak

[lapis sable]

Everything you do will always make you lose honor unless you are a fish

[thorny cargo]

yeah you wont be thinking that when you get further into the game.

lmao

[tight plaza]

... or throw fish back

[unborn meadow]

Well see

I like being low honor for now

[thorny cargo]

mhm, most people do early on

[lapis sable]

I love being absolute lowest honor

[unborn meadow]

Fr

I kill everyone

My aim insane

[lapis sable]

Nah nah nah, i love being shot in the head by micah

[tight plaza]

I have two saves: one with low honor, one with high honor. Both are lethargic

[unborn meadow]

Cool 💔

[thorny cargo]

a lot of low honor players (who arent new) have no respect for the story so i dont really respect them.

SOME low honor players

not saying all

[thorny cargo]

i suggest gettin out of here before you get spoilered.

[unborn meadow]

Okay

[lapis sable]

I have no respect for any peds in the game at all

I see, i take out my gun and shoot em

[tight plaza]

I play low honor when I don't GAF and want to rampage. Currently I am stuck on my 3rd play through hovering around 87%

[lapis sable]

Shoot em, loot em, go gunfighting with more folk

[tight plaza]

I am just above the median and it's a smooth game

[thorny cargo]

im a high honor player every time even after 11 playthroughs however i do play low honor sometimes. but i never finish like that

it isnt appealing to me

[tight plaza]

yeah I didn't finish with low honor, I just have one save with JM as a total a-hole

[lapis sable]

Everyone has their own unique way of playing rdr2

They are all right

[thorny cargo]

and the uniqueness of that is whats great about it

lets people choose

[lapis sable]

I wanna be a lowdown rambo

Nothing wrong with that

[tight plaza]

it plays different every time I love it for that

[unborn meadow]

Fr

Best game of all time

[lapis sable]

Pc ver can have mods like nuevo paraiso

[tight plaza]

maybe I should start a fourth on 1/1/2026 to see how it goes

[lapis sable]

Once its finally out i'll have a 6th state to murder folk at

[tight plaza]

i finished my 3rd with the highest honor I could muster.

[unborn meadow]

Is there a story for blackwater

I probably missed it

They describe it like hell

[tight plaza]

Arthur's journal has clues

[unborn meadow]

I never actually read it

[tight plaza]

I am torn between rdr3 being a prequel or a sequel

[unborn meadow]

Rdr3 will come out?

That's peak

Can't wait

[thorny cargo]

not confirmed

[unborn meadow]

I hope they confirm it

[tight plaza]

I mean a sequel would be cool with Jack coming home from WW1 and having to battle the mob for control of Beacher's or the story leading up to Blackwater

it's no confirmed I'm just a dreamer

[unborn meadow]

It would be nice

[thorny cargo]

i do not think that rdr3 will still follow the vdl gang (or its past members i mean)

[unborn meadow]

Yea maybe new guys

[thorny cargo]

if it is, itd probably be going to even before with dutch and hosea and the beginnings. and even that is unlikely, considering the fact that theres no more redemption really

or maybe there is

[tight plaza]

there's some rich unexplored history in the eary 1900's leading up the Great Depression

[unborn meadow]

Rdr2 is 1899 right?

[thorny cargo]

while this is cool, the whole thing about rdr2 is the "ending of the outlaw times" and putting an end to gangs, as well as redemption ofc

[thorny cargo]

indeed

[tight plaza]

up until 1911?

[thorny cargo]

yes

and rdr1 is 1917

up until i mean

[unborn meadow]

What

[thorny cargo]

i believe

wait let me check

1914

rdr1 starts in 1911, ends in 1914

[unborn meadow]

That's weird

[thorny cargo]

rdr2 starts in 1899 and ends in 1907

[thorny cargo]

rdr2 is a prequel to rdr1

[unborn meadow]

Oh

[thorny cargo]

chronological order is rdr2 -> rdr1

[unborn meadow]

Cool

[thorny cargo]

mhm

[unborn meadow]

Yea that's good

[tight plaza]

so 3 would have to include WW1 and prohibition among other things if it was a sequel

[unborn meadow]

I'm glad I didn't do rdr 1 first

[prisma karma]

How do I get low honour grip? Side note - I have another account and high honour play through so this account is low honour anyways but pls help

[tight plaza]

i do the same thing

[thorny cargo]

rockstar did not make rdr1 with the intention of a second one. arthur and the rest of the gang (besides bill, javier, and dutch) did not exist

when it was made

[unborn meadow]

That's cool

[prisma karma]

So can someone help

[unborn meadow]

Arthur almost made it in rdr1

[thorny cargo]

do you have the double-action revolver unlocked i assume?

you should get your honor to at least rank -4

and any lower works too

[unborn meadow]

Do u know how to get the thing around my neck

Like it almost looks like a carpet

[prisma karma]

I’m max low honour 😭

[tight plaza]

do some chores, throw some fish back

[unborn meadow]

I love the sound of low honor

[thorny cargo]

poncho?

[prisma karma]

High honour play through is better tho

[thorny cargo]

youre probably talking about the panther coat

[prisma karma]

But low honour is also fun

[tight plaza]

sisco?

[prisma karma]

I finished bandit challenges today tho

[thorny cargo]

you do have the double-action revolvers unlocked right?

[prisma karma]

Yes correct

Do I need to be high honour to unlock it?

[unborn meadow]

I think so

It's black coloured

[tight plaza]

don't forget the Tall Man

he knows

[unborn meadow]

The gang is so peak

I hope they never separate

[midnight ocean]

go to the trapper and see what you need to craft it

[tight plaza]

visit your local trapper, he'll tell you the ingredients you need

[warm drum]

do mountain rocky cow elk works for the legend of the east satchel?

[unborn meadow]

Thanks guys

[midnight ocean]

if its an elk pelt yeah

[thorny cargo]

to unlock the low honor grip? no

maybe just reload and see.

ah, i lied!

you do need to be honor level +4 to unlock both

[prisma karma]

Ahhh!!

[thorny cargo]

which is really weird. i dont know why rockstar would program it like that

[prisma karma]

Yeah cause I thought it was the other way around

Did they change it?

[thorny cargo]

no idea

[indigo helm]

i wish there was even more freedom with the gang members

like you can bring them along to do tasks with you

[thorny cargo]

i mean you can but

[indigo helm]

well not really

[thorny cargo]

yeah

they cant do tasks

[indigo helm]

we can only do what they want to do

[thorny cargo]

no i mean

nvm

[indigo helm]

well i mean like, bounty hunting and stuff like that, robbing banks

trains

[eternal estuary]

If I ever get the urge to I just turn off auto save so I don’t ruin my perfect honor lol

Or I just rampage whenever I’m messing with cheats

[midnight ocean]

by mistake

[thorny cargo]

interesting

[tight plaza]

I just rode all the way back from Emerald Ranch to Evelyn Miller's place to deliver food.

[thorny cargo]

why didnt you just... fast travel...

[tight plaza]

I wanted to do the trip with Cinematic View to see what happens.

I had to stop twice - once for wolves and once to kill some Skinner Bros. It was an experiment.

I'm not complaining just stating facts. I wanted to see if I could just travel in CM without interruption (i.e. while watching the news). So yes, agreed, if you want to travel without impedance, use fast travel.

[lapis sable]

stop forcing people to play high honor

[solid lion]

Yo i just joined this server

[thorny cargo]

hi

[deep glacier]

Cause immersion

I personally don’t think I’ve used much fast travel

[warm drum]

is there a good sequence to do the missions or i can just do one first whenever i want

[snow smelt]

starting the epilogue, Jack and John seems distant

[thorny cargo]

there isnt a set chronological order really

its whatever you see fit

[eternal estuary]

Is it just me or do a lot of the del lobo gang members in gaptooth breach carry gold nuggets

I looted all the bodies and I got 6 gold nuggets total

Pretty solid way to earn money by just selling them, i got $150

[indigo helm]

rabbitd

[solid lion]

yo who wins John in rdr1 or Arthur mrogan before tb

morgan*

[solid trench]

How do you unlock fast traveling with the camp

I accudentally went to rhodes instead of strawberry and for some reason my camp doesnt allow me to fast travel what upgrade unlocks that

[umbral bolt]

I think the tent upgrades

[solid trench]

Yeah i already got the second tent upgrades i thought that was supposed to be the one

[visual skiff]

hey uh can anyone give me some good roleplay ideas

[viral path]

How do I Take Off my legandary wolf pelt?

[mortal oriole]

I’m replaying rdr1 if makes zero sense

Bill: “you left me”

Like the fuck?

[drowsy moth]

Ah

Hello.....

[mortal oriole]

Then again

They hadn’t seen each other for 11 years or more so

I guess it makes sense

He forgot what happened

[heady jewel]

anyone here play disco elysium?

[mortal oriole]

This isn’t the right chat

Although I do own that game and I have tried it

[heady jewel]

whats the chat

for it

[heady jewel]

how would u compare its story to rdr2

better , worse or on the same level

just story btw nothing else

im thinking of trying it

[mortal oriole]

I dunno I tried to find a clue went crazy and left the case

So it’s umm

Interesting to say the least

I can tell it has a lot of endings I just haven’t played it enough yet

[heady jewel]

so what do i play to get a story as good as rdr2 or better

[heady jewel]

damn

[heady jewel]

oh i see

[mortal oriole]

It didn’t immediately grasp me as my type of game but maybe when I try it more I’ll like it

[heady jewel]

yakuza 0 ?

[mortal oriole]

Never played

[heady jewel]

would u put any game

on rdr2s level

in terms of story alone

[mortal oriole]

Good question

Hmmmmm

Let me think

Assassins creed games I would say

But they are completely different from rdr series

LA Noire was fun but I kinda had to google all the answers to the cases because I’m not a genius

Mafia games are good too

[mortal oriole]

Mafia 1 definitive edition probably I would say

[hollow barn]

rdr3 when

[mortal oriole]

Sleeping dogs too

[mortal oriole]

I want rdr3 to be about Sadie and how she dies when the gang gets hunted down

You know what else could be interesting

[hollow barn]

gavin

[mortal oriole]

Playing as Bill or Javier

We find out how they left Dutch

How they started their own shit

And it ends with John hunting them down

[hollow barn]

or uh

im not creative

we play as arthurs horse

[marsh flint]

I dont want rdr3

I want rdr1 remake.

[solid trench]

Nvm for some reason it only works part of the time?

[hollow barn]

rdr1 remake+and it starts right after epilogues final mission

[mortal oriole]

Same

It might be happening

Hopefully

[marsh flint]

More jack missions

[solid trench]

Honestly i want a red dead game that isnt redemption i would love to see what they can do with a clean slate

[mortal oriole]

Red Dead Revolver 2

[hollow barn]

upgraded mexico (idk i didnt play rdr1 yet)

[marsh flint]

Uncle simulator

[blissful crane]

what would the epilogue be though

[mortal oriole]

No

Well yes

[blissful crane]

every red dead game gotta have an epilogue with a new mc

[warm drum]

just started blood feuds, ancient and modern, wish me luck lol

[mortal oriole]

Well

[blissful crane]

unless the game just ends there

[mortal oriole]

Epilgoue could be playing as John again 💀

[blissful crane]

which is okay for a spin off title

[blissful crane]

aw hell nah it just crashes the game and starts rdr1

lmao

[mortal oriole]

Or maybe one of javier or bills closest gang members

[hollow barn]

no epilogue is played as gavin who runs away from that gavins friend all the time

[blissful crane]

one of their gang members that ran away

[mortal oriole]

He murdered Gavin and the trauma made him forget

[blissful crane]

if they get good character development then i could see it happening

[hollow barn]

or we play as jack

[marsh flint]

Rdr1 remake but we get more missions as jack

[mortal oriole]

They could just end the game

We don’t need an epilogue

Unless we have a 3 character wheel with Dutch Javier and Bill and when they all die we play as agent Ross 💀

[marsh flint]

I dont want a game as dutch Javier or bill

Its all gonna be crimes and crimes

No redemption in their life

[hollow barn]

arthur again,but it starts when he is 14

[marsh flint]

I dont think Rockstar is gonna let you

Play as a 14 year old

Considering arthur was shooting people most likely at that age

[mortal oriole]

Bonnie sucks at racing 💀

Imagine thinking she can beat John Marston

[hollow barn]

rockstar games let me rob trains,burn hogtied people,kidnap people,and be robbed by armed children in saint denis

[mortal oriole]

Can we play as Mac and when he dies the epilogue is Arthur in the mountains

[hollow barn]

and with all those i can't name my horse "bullet"

[solid trench]

YES

[mortal oriole]

Name it Bu11et

[marsh flint]

Why are rats so hard to find

Omg

[hollow barn]

i tried finding rats too but gave up and decided to shoot down saint denis

[mortal oriole]

I want this too but I think they’d low-key have to change some of the voice lines or add some or something to make it make more sense

Rdr1 has some weird dialogue

Like bill blaming John for ditching him

[rugged furnace]

i just finished the epilogue

killing micah is so fun

[hollow barn]

i just entered the epilogue

[full sequoia]

nice

[hollow barn]

when do i get to buy clothes

[rugged furnace]

i hope i didnt spoil it for you

[hollow barn]

i already know all the lore

[full sequoia]

after a couple missions

like parrt 2

[rugged furnace]

good lol

[hollow barn]

i stole arthurs money and bought myself an arabian horse

[rugged furnace]

the campaign took me a total of 57.1 hours

[hollow barn]

and going to obtain the white one once again

[rugged furnace]

haha at the end of the end text screen thing my game decided to crash

thanks amd drivers...

[opaque bone]

[snow otter]

is there actually a way to not make Arthur look like dead guy in chapter 6

[mortal oriole]

Rdr1 is fire

I’m tryna get deadly assassin

[snow otter]

who changed my name lmao

[unborn meadow]

if he dies then there is a way 💔

[snow otter]

dude

no I mean before he dies

in chapter 6

he looks so bad

his whole face is literally purple

from the sickness

[unborn meadow]

.

it could be my fault cause i sent a message in here

[mortal oriole]

Wear a mask

[snow otter]

wow

[unborn meadow]

holy spoil

[mortal oriole]

So he doesn’t spread the turburculosis

[snow otter]

if I'm getting turburculosis

everyone is getting it

[snow otter]

you said if he dies I thought you already knew

😭

[mortal oriole]

How do I get someone to duel me in armadillo

[hollow barn]

my brother was playing the game and someone duelled him,and since my brothers a dumbass,he shot the guy on the head and got arrested

[snow smelt]

pull your gun out and shoot them regardless

[unborn meadow]

im on chapter 3

[snow otter]

mb

[unborn meadow]

youre good 🥀

[mossy gyro]

abandoned buildings have quite alot of them

[unborn meadow]

low honor arthur last meme of 2025

[marsh flint]

When hunting a rat is harder than a legendary animal❤️‍🩹

[hollow barn]

you got a rat in the camp,whyd you need to find more

you can even greet or antagonize it

[mossy gyro]

best chapter in the game imo

[unborn meadow]

i just startted it

[mossy gyro]

its so peak, trust me

[unborn meadow]

i trust

im on the molly oshea mission rn

[snow smelt]

what molly o'shea mission

[mortal oriole]

It’s for a challenge in rdr1

[dense gate]

💔

[snow smelt]

the jim calloway thing or?

[mortal oriole]

The one where she kissed Dutch?

[mortal oriole]

Rdr1

[snow smelt]

oh woops you said rdr1

woopsies doosies

I'm like an hour into the epilogue and I already miss Arthur

[mortal oriole]

It’s ok you will get used to John and then play rdr1 and get more used

[dense gate]

no

😭

[hollow barn]

i can get another white arabian when in epilogue,right

i got one in the start

[mortal oriole]

You can get a better one… rose grey Arabian

[hollow barn]

whats that wait lemme search

[snow smelt]

I already came into an NPC from the earlier chapters, the guy who keeps slinging rocks into the rivers and venting his frustration

he must be really ass at relationships for him to be back slinging rocks after 8 years

[hollow barn]

oh ok its 1250 dollars

[dense gate]

my wrapped brindle arabian just ceased to exist

[hollow barn]

i have arthurs money so i can buy it

[dense gate]

fr

[outer prairie]

he can’t even sling

[snow smelt]

😭

[outer prairie]

that was what i thought but he threw them mostly

[mortal oriole]

Bill williamson sucks balls

Literally

[outer prairie]

full room of pc players

[outer prairie]

bill’s DEAD

[mortal oriole]

RIP Bill Williamson, you would’ve loved Grindr

Imma cheat at poker chat

Lmao someone tried to duel me so I shot him in the umm

And he didn’t die

Wild

[rugged furnace]

guys is there a good way to get one of them machine gun carriages

[mortal oriole]

No

[rugged furnace]

they duel you if you cheat?

[mortal oriole]

Yes

Well if you fail the cheating mini game

[lapis sable]

Today's rampage is in valentine 1899 where I racked up a 1500 bounty AW YE

[mortal oriole]

You need to play rdr1 because there’s a whole country you haven’t rampaged in yet

[lapis sable]

dont worry, im hoping the Nuevo Paraiso mod will deliver soon

[mortal oriole]

What’s that?

[lapis sable]

im hoping it will be a 6th state where I can murder and rack up 1500 bounty ❤️

[mortal oriole]

I want rdr1 remaster except make it a $40 dlc for rdr2 that has the exact same graphics and you can start right after epilogue

[lapis sable]

I wish the modders also release new unofficial areas in pc after this mod ngl

I want more places to be a real big bastard to

I kinda wanna see what's on the other end of the Lannahechee River

[true dune]

do we know if RDR3 is going to be a thing

[lapis sable]

I hope RDR3 will be a sequel to RDR1, where Jack Marston finally have a happy ending and writes the book in GTA V

but who are we kidding, there never will be a happy ending in Red Dead

[mortal oriole]

It’s clear in rdr2 that herr Strauss faked his death and became a author and used Jack Marston as his pen name

[arctic nymph]

does anyone know how to get that clothing, like a scarf with a bandana pattern, it covers your upper body in story mode, im currently in chapter 4.

[mortal oriole]

Neckerchief?

In the wardrobe look in neckwear

[arctic nymph]

No, its way bigger covers your whole upper body just tummy is visible

[mortal oriole]

Oh?

I’m not aware of that

Not sure what that is

[arctic nymph]

I can send you a picture in dms

[marsh flint]

Odd

[arctic nymph]

It has the texture of a neckerchief but its way bigger

Covers whole upper body

[marsh flint]

Can u send a photo

[arctic nymph]

yes in ur dms

[marsh flint]

Sur

[earnest flume]

I'm playing RDR2 on PC at 1440p with around 70 mods, I'm maxing my rtx4090's vram at 24Gb, is that going to give me a problem?

[trim hamlet]

dear god why do you have so many modssss

[earnest flume]

I'm a Mod-a-holic

I even have GTA5 with mods maxing vram around 22gb

I just can't stop modding, I think I have a problem

[midnight ocean]

i think what happens is the first time you meet him hes pining over a girl but doesnt have the courage to ask her out, but then after you give him advice he actually gets with her and then 8 years later she leaves him or cheats on him or something

and thus you find him once again

[lapis sable]

I just help him by shooting a dynamite arrow at his feet.

The same way I treat Thomas Downes in town when I first saw him 🙂

[midnight ocean]

thats not berry 🍓 nice

[lapis sable]

I hope hell is hot and unbearable! Otherwise I'd feel I've been sold a false bag of goods

[lone crown]

Guys my white arabian died and I need a replacement who should I get? (Got turkoman adulasian and mft) and i'm in chapter 4 and story got spoiled

[deft knot]

Reverse Dapple Roan Nokota?

[lone crown]

Not that fast tho

[trim hamlet]

not fast? how about an all-white Shire

[marsh flint]

Rip van winkle strikes again

[lone crown]

😭

[trim hamlet]

I mean it's all white, and you said "not that fast" so like...

[lone crown]

Yea i'm good off the shire

Prob may get a black arabian warped brindle or a nokota or brindle thoroughbred

[trim hamlet]

oh you didn't care abt the coat color?

[lone crown]

Nah just speed bc i got turkoman and andulasian for bravery

[trim hamlet]

so uhhh

bravery isn't breed specific

it's bonding specific

all level 4 bonded horses have same bravery

some horses bond quicker, yes

[trim hamlet]

but all level 4 bonded horses are the same bravery

[lone crown]

Ah I see

[lone crown]

Oh ok

[trim hamlet]

So

it really just depends on the stats you can see

speed, acceleration, handling, stamina, health

although

speed + accel can be increased w good saddles

as can health + stamina I think

[thorny cargo]

cores only

hooded stirrup + panther trail saddle is the absolute best combo possible for horse stats

[naive birch]

67

[trim hamlet]

what does it do

[thorny cargo]

hooded stirrup increases speed and accel by two gold levels*

panther trail saddle lowers core drain rate

the most out of all saddles

[trim hamlet]

wdym "by two gold cores"

like by 2 levels?

[thorny cargo]

yeah levels

not cores mb

and if you win two races against npcs, both of those go up to 3 gold levels.

[trim hamlet]

so it can practically turn a shire into a thoroughbred?

[thorny cargo]

yes

and a thoroughbred into an arabian

lol

[marsh flint]

Buell

[trim hamlet]

except for the handling

[valid bay]

I finished the story mode and did all the missions now I'm redoing the story mode

[true dune]

get 70 gold medals for the achievement

[outer vortex]

do i have to study the animals on guarma for the zoologist achievement?

[true dune]

no, thank god

[outer vortex]

thank god

[lone crown]

I got the panther and crocodile saddle

[snow otter]

what if someone says

they dislike Arthur and john

And LIKE dutch and micah

what do you do.to them

[chrome terrace]

I forgot how far in chapter 3 do i have to get in order to free the dude under the gunsmith

[azure sluice]

pretty sure you can do that as soon as chapter 2

could be wrong

[thorny cargo]

yeah as soon as chapter 2 you can

[old rose]

idk

oh.

why am i fake arthur morgan

[thorny cargo]

cuz ur not real arthur morgan

[solid current]

i love looking at the ledger and seeing all the gang members donating the most useless shit

[old rose]

im aware.

[old rose]

spit it out what u typin

[solid current]

yeah i just spent all day stealing and selling 400 dollars worth of wagons to donate to camp but i really think that the 5 cent bat wing that strauss donated is gonna save the gang❤️‍🩹

[old rose]

i rlly wish donating to camp impacts the storyline like tahiti or smth

[thorny cargo]

then why did u ask 😭

[old rose]

because im not arthur?

[thorny cargo]

????????

[marsh flint]

Oh my god uncle is slowly dying

😭

[turbid rampart]

What gun is best for getting perfect fox/coyote pelts? I know the bow with improved arrows does a good job, but I can't find the arrows in half the spots where I know foxes and coyotes spawn

[marsh flint]

Lanchester

Aim for head

I believe so

[turbid rampart]

I thought that would massacre the poor things but I'll give it a try, thank you

[hidden moss]

Can anyone tell me how to craft arrows if you can is there a pamphlet if so where

[midnight ocean]

you need a repeater, improved arrow is too powerful

regular arrow might work

[turbid rampart]

I'm skeptical of regular arrows but I'll try that too

[turbid rampart]

You can't craft arrows, I don't think

Only upgraded ones

Poison, fire, improved, and small game I think

You have to buy arrows from the gunsmith or at a general store at the end of the ammunition section of the catalog

[midnight ocean]

you can study the animal or check the comendium if you've studied it before and it will tell you what you can use

for coyote its repeater or regular arrow

[turbid rampart]

Oh true

I keep forgetting that's a thing 😭😭

[marsh flint]

Uncle's horse is so DIRTY

Jesus

[turbid rampart]

I wish you could tend to the camp's horses, ONG

Let me brush down brown jack and old nelle, they need BATHS

[marsh flint]

Horse

[trim hamlet]

FACTS

[turbid rampart]

I like doing the camp chores way too much, but I feel like there should be more things you could do for the camp to add some variation rather than just have 3 chores that are just "bring this thing to the x" and 1 chore that's just spamming the r2 button

I like doing anything but progressing the game, I realize

[gray raft]

Hey quick question, is Margaret transgender? Or is she just saying she's a woman for the circus act thing?

She's quite an interesting character

Ah nevermind, I figured she's (or he) is just dressed in drag for the show

Or just to put it simply

Cross-dressing

[snow smelt]

I just came across the feral man

and I feel so bad

[indigo helm]

wolf man?

[snow smelt]

Yup

I knocked him out, hopefully he can find new pups cause I killed his wolf companions

[indigo helm]

btw even if you dont do the mission for thomas downes properly you still get TB

that makes me think he wasnt the reason

maybe someone in camp

[snow smelt]

Arthur said he gets TB by downes

so

[indigo helm]

yeah but

how

[snow smelt]

it's a fixed storyline, the cause will always be thomas downes's fault

[thorny cargo]

canonically, thomas coughs into arthurs mouth, like a little spit. thats what you see in the cutscene, and thats what transmits TB. even if you dont do it the way intended, its a fixed storyline. thats what canonically happens

thomas downes IS the way arthur gets TB

it isnt anyone else

[midnight ocean]

wdym dont do the mission properly

[turbid rampart]

I've made the mistake of walking into a stable with 2 horses and had to stable the temporary one to buy a saddle for my other horse. How do I get them both out at the same time, I need my second one with me for moral support 😭😭

[indigo helm]

whistle

[midnight ocean]

you can't

[turbid rampart]

NOOO

[midnight ocean]

once you stable the temp you need to go get a new one

[turbid rampart]

I'm gonna just restart from my last save and speed run all the shit I did and never stable my temp horse

[midnight ocean]

why lol

[turbid rampart]

I'm emotionally attached to the one I stabled

That's my baby

And now she's in baby jail and I'm stuck with her stupid brother

[midnight ocean]

yeah try hitching it next time

[turbid rampart]

I will 😭👍

[midnight ocean]

i had the same issue a few times because i have buell as my perma-temp

since he has a unique saddle that goes away once he's stabled

[turbid rampart]

That's literally the prettiest horse I've ever seen oml

Great taste in horses

[midnight ocean]

yeah hes shiny

just gotta keep that coat clean

[turbid rampart]

Con of having a white horse 😔

The one I stabled is a light grey (she's just white, idc) shire, so I unfortunately have a permanently dirty looking horse

[marsh flint]

White horses are the best because you can see the dirt

And dont spend 20 years brushing

[turbid rampart]

I don't mind brushing my other horse, purely cause he's the raven black and I can see all the dirt on him still

[midnight ocean]

yeah on the dark ones you get those weird sweat stains tho

[turbid rampart]

If he was a bay, I'd be fucked

Oh, yeah that's how horse sweat is

It's glue-y and white

[midnight ocean]

yeah lol

i never even noticed until i had a dark bay turkoman and i was riding it around the bayou

constant sweat

[turbid rampart]

I noticed in the middle of the mountains near colter somehow

Idk why my boy was sweating that much

[midnight ocean]

probably from climbing the mountain lol

[turbid rampart]

Yeah probably

I did some googling about the horse breeds while I was waiting for my save to load and I apparently like the subpar breeds more than the "best" breed in the game

Why is there so much shire hate and arabian glazing

[snow smelt]

damn epilogue 1 is short

[snow smelt]

racism

/j

[turbid rampart]

💀💀

[midnight ocean]

shire slow arabian fast

and i think arabians also have comparable health and stamina to the shire

[digital blade]

I think I've seen the opposite in my case

[turbid rampart]

The dutch pfp scared me oml

[digital blade]

because people keep saying how cowardly the arabians are

[digital blade]

[turbid rampart]

😭😭

[midnight ocean]

i like medium-large horses so arabians are way too small and shires are a bit too big

[digital blade]

my favourite breeds are either andalusians or missouri fox trotters

[digital blade]

right

[midnight ocean]

i like the turkoman and thoroughbred

[digital blade]

I've tried using shires before on arthur

they make him look like he's riding a trex or something

[midnight ocean]

lol

[turbid rampart]

I really love the shires because I just love how big they are, and I'm not very interested in speed or acceleration

[trim hamlet]

based

ok I go back to lurking now

[turbid rampart]

Also because the raven black shire is my son

[turbid rampart]

Real asf

[trim hamlet]

why do you think my name is what it is? lmao

in my mind big horse = cool 😆

[turbid rampart]

I didn't even know this was a breed in the game, oml

I thought it was just shires

I'm in love

Thank you so much, ardennes enjoyer

[trim hamlet]

did you just look at the ardennes

[turbid rampart]

Yes

They're beautiful

[trim hamlet]

check out the breton in RDO

it's very similar

[trim hamlet]

and they've got standard handling instead of Heavy too lmao

[turbid rampart]

If I had access to rdo, I'd be SPEEDRUNNING to get it

Ong

[trim hamlet]

don't you, if you have the main game?

[turbid rampart]

I technically do, but it's stuck behind the ps+ thing and I am not willing to spend money on it yet

It's stupid, really, putting a paywall to stop you from playing the online portion of the game you already bought

[marsh flint]

Ps+ is horrid

I hate it

Burn it

[turbid rampart]

If I could pirate the online version just to bypass the paywall, I would

I hate it

The worst part is that I have another game that's entirely online and I didn't have to pay for ps+

It's picking and choosing, and of course my new favorite game is one of the ones you have to lay for

[marsh flint]

Uncle is the best side character in all of rdr

[turbid rampart]

The most tragic, I'd say

Lumbago is very serious 😔

[tight plaza]

Possibly a pinched nerve which is very painful

I had a pinched scatica while waiting tables in my youth. Totally lays you out.

[trim hamlet]

bro I hate consoles for that exact reason

you can't do that kinda thing as easily

you also can't customize them

[lost finch]

I can’t find a Florida panther to save my life. Every location I go to. I only find a normal panther and not a Florida one

Not once

[bleak summit]

These are some long ass credits 😂

[tight plaza]

it takes a village 🙂

[bleak summit]

I gotta look up how long this game was in production because holy

[thorny cargo]

over 1,200 actors and around 700 core vas