#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 286 of 1
why would she kill milton then?
why would she work with the people who would later kill her husband
why wouldn't she leave john
this thoery is dumb lmao
Because if she didn’t Arthur would
She did it to save John but didn’t realise that outlaws can’t survive
even though she hated john at the start of the game
only started feelling for him around chapter 6
Exactly
She thought by the first game she would be happy and fine with John
But the pinkertons won’t let outlaws live
Like what
So Arthur doesn’t think she’s a rat that’s pretty obvious
Because she loves him
They knew where they were after they got back from Guarma because Bill couldn't shut up
I never said when she became a rat
when did she then
ok? why did she kill milton lmao
Well I wasn’t exactly sure but after the bank would be my guess
To prove her loyalty
That’s pretty obvious
to who? a gang that doesn't exist? a man who won't live another week?
But why? Milton was about to kill Arthur
If she was the rat, then she would wait until Milton kills Arthur and then she kills Sadie
she saved his life
Exactly bruh? If she’s a rat Arthur gonna kill them both
Maybe she killed Milton because she thought she’d have better chances with Arthur in that moment
There could be many reasons
She’s still a rat
She's a pretty dumb one then
not really...if she's working with the feds milton can offer her and john a good deal and he gets the glory of killing Arthur, basically the story of gta 5 lmao
makes no sense for her to kill milton if she is a rat
She’s not a genius
It doesn't take a genius to figure out that Milton was about to kill Arthur
so her decision was still dumb (if she was a rat)
this evidence is also very weak, the women are often hidden during tense moments like this, especially someone who is only in the gang because she has a child, light explained the guarma one, and he doesn't kill her because he doesn't think she's a threat
that's the point! r* meant her to be the dumbest person in the game for this one scene and no other!
that's just good writing!
To be fair maybe she thought “oh it’s going to look suspicious to the other gang members if Arthur and Sadie die and I somehow survived… also maybe she thought “oh if I killed Arthur then John is gonna leave me (because by then she was in love with John)
the gang is dead lmao
she knows this
Arthur told her and John to escape
she would just escape
and no one would question it lmao
John would question it
Would have uncle successfully shot micah if he was with John and Arthur during the standoff
the rest of the gang? which gang? all of them were about to escape anyways
You think johns gonna not question where the fuck Arthur and Sadie are?
Probably not while the Pinkertons are on his ass
ngl this theory is stupid lmao
Even if Abigail was the rat, I felt like she had the most reasonable motivation
she wasn't! I refuse to even suggest this possibility!
Exactly
Exactly that’s why she’s the rat 😭😭 she wanted to save her son
Even if she did rat out the gang , she did save arthur
the pinkertons aren't after her, if they know about her at all she is just some whore they kept around as far as they knew
might have some useful info but not a wanted person they have to bring to justice
they just wanted Dutch dead
True
They know her because she’s the rat
also the other key members like john and Arthur, but yeah Dutch was the main one they wanted
I think John's actually the rat
Hell no
No, Arthur is actually the rat
Uncle is the true rat guys
remember how they "didn't recognise" John? playing dumb for the gang so they don't question him escaping without a price on his head!
genius!
that one I would be willing to believe lmao
but like an accidently rat, like he admitted to milton while sleep talking everything the gang had done
100% could happen
and he thought he might as well sell out all the way since he was screwed anyway
Arthur Morgan was the rat all along and the 5000 dollar bounty on him is fake
I feel like uncle didn't care alot for some people in the gang
don't you think it's weird no one is trying to collect this supposed 5000 bounty?
no posters or anything?
strange 🤔
exactly, he's the true rat
I missed trying to tame the red arabian, will it spawn back again?
Pearson can't possibly be the rat because he's a tiger
probably
oh he actually does care a lot
I love uncle
it is actually sweet seeing him try and cheer people up around camp
and Dutch doesn't need tigers...well I guess the tiger doesn't need him or his gang!
ha!
Is the arabain the best horse in the game?
I think so
All Arabian horses I have seen have really good stats
me and my black Arabian against the east 🖤
the best horse is whichever one is with you at the end 😔
facts
When can I forgive debts
chepter 6
that's the neat part, you don't, don't collect the debts you sick fuck
True
you give them back at the ledger, where you can give camp funds
IMO Speed is really the only stat that "matters" even though the difference between the fastest horse and the slowest horse is quite small because with max bonding stamina is infinite and any horse will be way more of a bullet sponge than you need it to be
By that metric the silver dapple pinto missouri fox trotter has the best overall stats between the five 7/10 speed horses in the game
behind or in front of Dutch's tent depends on the camp
Do we gotta buy it or tame it in the wild
Also now i have stopped doing main missions in chapter 3 and been doing the. Side quests an exploration
Well you can buy it after epilogue part 1 but there is rather famously an "exploit"/abuse of intended game mechanics to get it in Arcadia for Amateurs III as early as chapter 2
ohhh, exploring in this game is a real treat
actually the amber champagne has identical stats and is available after chapter 4
Maybe Hosea and Lenny are the rat that’s why they killed him to get rid of loose ends
i just got hit by a goat in butcher creek and charles shot it
I spared him, Tilly said to let him go and it's her battle to fight
I didn’t
I fed him to the pigs instead so technically they killed him
I think Fenton's the rat, never trust a quiet one...
Maybe cain is the rat
that's why Micha ate him, he was protecting the gang
like he always has
Rip Wan Winkle is the rat
Why are exotics so annoying
i finally caught mini micah in a cage and now medium mini joe try to broke him free (joke aside that rat been terrorising my room for past 6 days)
mini micha is the rat
now i have to take care joe
i saw him try to brake micha out
for their size they r fast as fk
fr what are you talking about lmao
a rat a real life rat
i finally caught with a cage that little bster been terrorising my room since 6 days ago i thought i see thing cuz lack of sleep no om sec day he was on my bed frame straying at me
i have photo
it technically a house mouse
i call micha cuz before he came everything was okay
Why are egrets so hard to find
Yes after eventually getting the spoilers out the game ending, exploration is the best way to enjoy the genre
Umm guys Arthur got fiddled
yeah if I were you I would mostly stay off this server
it spoilt a major mid game event for me
How do I get egrets
is it normal to get killed with one shot if your bounty is $700+
not that i know of but i have a video of my horse instantly dying from full health with one bullet
not "dying" but put in the revive state
had no idea that was a mechanic
Has anyone experienced sudden audio crackling/popping in RDR2? I’ve played over 300 hours without any issues, and it started out of nowhere. It only happens in RDR2 — other games and music are fine. Any ideas?
Where were you, and who shot you?
I once accidentally rode my horse off of what looked like a 5 foot ledge and it got put in the revive state
Hey
Did Dutch just freaking walk out on me
That’s it he’s cooked
Imma get ready for the last couple missions and then do them
Shaving my level 10 beard gonna be hard 🥀
Is it true killing rat will raise our honor ?
ye
Arthur’s ready for his final rodeo
Now I gotta release my horses
Get Buell
And one last ride
Tumbleweed
Normal officers and deputies
Playing as John
My current Arthur’s story is so dumb
Well I guess it’s not too dumb but
He got his haircut
Got someone horse
Sold his horse
Which is normal so far
Then he gets robbed of all his money
Bros day was going good until-
Every day to me is another day running straight to scalp hunters and running to towns and KILLING EVERYONE and bringing law to landmarks i wanna holdout so i can kill as many scumbags as i can before i die
Where i do buy bait for fishing?
Go to lagras, murder everyone and loot the fish store for special lures
Be sure to dump their corpses in the swamp to feed the gators!
Can I get the tiger striped mustang in the epilogue 2
Es
Yes
Rio bravo rock area
Alright thank you
Be wary it spawns near the cliff so you may fall off the cliff when breaking it
@spice jetty I
I fell off the cliff twice when breaking it
So be careful
Alright
Where is lagras?
I love the fact that rockstar added a Swedish family living in West Elizabeth, showing the Swedish immigration to the US during the 1800s
I noticed this when I was exploring near Blackwater and almost rode past their houses If I hadn't heard them saying a Swedish word
Dutch is a terrible person
Arthur: you take this money too
How did Arthur get the money? The pig farmers stole all his money
Can some one look at media I can’t find the mustang
I looked
What’s the best horse in the game? I keep seeing people say different things or it’s between an Arabian or Foxtrotter
Is it the right place
I like to play poker, in game for fun.
highest stats overall is the rose grey arabian
I had to close the game during the final mission I hope I don’t gotta do all that again
My screen froze during a cutscene at the end of a mission and i cooked
why lol
Do you guys think jack ever visited pearson ?
I mean maybe? But if John, Abigail, Sadie and Charles never talked to Jack about gang life then Jack probably doesnt really remember pearson
Where is the tiger striped mustang I’m near that rock but it isn’t there
on top of it
or wdym
Basically on top
Like at first I was looking at it from afar
Then I went closer and it ain’t there
im pretty sure its usually near the edge. if its not there reload or sleep
Fuck this game bro, I found almost every single rock carving before meeting Francis (the game won't let you find the last one) he gathered my locations when meeting them, and afterwards got mailes rewards for said locations
I thought, like any logical person, the same would happen with Deborah, I got every 22 dinosaur bone you can get as Arthur, finally met her, and she took my location notes right there and then
I waited, and waited, yet no mail whatsoever
I understand the game takes time with mailing, the mayor ones take like three days between them, however, it's already been like five days, I check the wiki, no bug mentions about any of this, then start searching on reddit, and yeah, Deborah won't sent you any reward unless you mail at least one dinosaur bone
I've already found every Arthur bone, and I can't load a previous safe file, which means, I either wait until fucking end-game or do that shitty new austin as Arthur glitch
Fuck me, why, why is this game like this
I hate it
Can you dm me the exact place of the horse
Like on top of it
Not close
Is it bc I killed the legendary pronghorn
Like on my way there
Dutch 100% went crazy after he banged his head
Can anyone help me so I have red dead on disc for PS4 I’ve had it for a year now I think I rarely played it and haven’t played it for a year atleast when I went to download the data disc it say cannot download application or something or error has occurred has anyone else had this happen what did you do to fix it if not I’ll have to buy a new one at CEX tomorrow
He was always coo coo
Can you help me please
I dont have a PS4 so I dont know
Do you have the game on a disc or online
Mines a digital download. I dont have any discs or anything
wut
if you find rock carvings before meeting francis, the game will still count them as sent when meeting him, thus having his rewards, this does not happen with a test of faith
were you able to actually study the bones?
yes
weird
but i dont get why that makes you want to glitch into new austin or load an old save
dont you just have to go find all the bones again
Yeah if you find any bones before talking to the prof you just hand them over to her when you meet her
can't
why?
I found the bones before meeting her, met her, she took my notes locations, can't send mail, and she won't send anything
I go back to said bone locations
there's nothing
because they're already marked as sent
the map too, has the bone icon
Yeah that happens
wdym she took your notes locations
You dont get money if you do that
when meeting her, in the cutscene, she'll take your location notes
thus unable to send her any notes at mail
I don't care about the money, I just wanted the quartz
so whats the problem? you didnt get paid?
the reward, of the quartz, that you use for a talisman, ergo the 100%
not actually needed for 100% tho
also why didnt you just talk to her before lol
shes right in new hanover
like I've said previously, I'm tryna do a real 100%, do everything as soon as possible without the need of exploits or glitches, you've read my text about that before too
I had avoided anything cutscene related until doing most side content
before I had even realize it I had found all 22 bones arthur can find
had the bear claw, said, why not, I had to do the talisman anyways
and thus
tragedy happened
you dont have ocd by any chance do you
what's ocd
all I know is I have ADD
I kept playing, overriding previous save files thinking "oh I'll get sent the mail in a few in-game days, always been like that" it's been way over a few days
Did uncle babysat jack
❤️🩹
Also oh my gawd I just realized the mission im in...
💔
obsessive compulsive disorder
look it up
yeah I did, I don't know if it applies tho, I just wanted to do a proper rdr2 100%, this kind of shit doesn't happen at mario oddysey and breath of the wild
TAHITI
you're not doing a proper rdr2 100% lol you're going way beyond that
either by exploits or waiting till' endgame
I don't know man, I just find it bullshitty this doesn't work but Francis' works just fine
well you were obviously meant to pick up the mission a long time ago
you went out of your way to avoid starting the mission
the game has additional dialogue for if you have previously found the bones before meeting her
it's not as if the developers didn't think it would happen
matter of fact they programmed Deborah taking off your notes so she could have them
and yet they forgot to actually mark them as sent, like they did with Francis'
Just woke up on guarma...
well yeah one or two maybe lol not every single one you can find as arthur
they programmed her to take off your notes, yet forgot to have her actually sent any reply whatsoever, with Francis, if you met him, the rock carving locations are immediately treated as mail, as he next-day sents you the rewards, regardless of whether you've mailed anything or not
I'm just saying, that's quite bullshit
pretty small oversight tbh
the game isnt perfect
but even though youve screwed yourself as hard as possible on that it IS still possible to get the quartz, just not before the epilogue
Well maybe its because there arent any rock carvings in new austin
"screwed yourself" my brother in christ they had in mind the player would find the bones beforehand
And you're not meant to be able to get there as Arthur
I don't think it's too far-fetched to assume a regular player would think "hey, if it works with francis, it should work on Deborah"
this means that even if you just find five bones, you won't get the five bones reward until you send a sixth bone
through mail
Well yeah but theres more then 5 bones
that isn't my point
my point is, the game doesn't register them as sent, despit the fact they do mark as sent with Francis
You actively made the decision to go into New Austin as arthur to get the bones, you fucked it up yourself
???
brother I only got the bones in the arthur area
ergo, nowhere near new austin
Oh
or blackwater for that matter
it's aight
as you all know, sean's rescue mission, if you don't start it yet, gives you a slight margin to explore blackwater/west of west elizabeth
so I checked the map, oh well, maybe there's one bone near that area
there isn't
the rest of bones are at new austin
bro yes they probably expected some people to find a couple of bones before starting the quest. they did not expect someone to find every single bone across new hanover, lemoyne, ambarino and big valley before meeting her
and yet they still programmed her taking your notes, only to not count them as sent
I've found said posts and mentioned on my original message
there were in fact other folks who've had this issue
and they probably went "oh well, i can still get the talisman later"
till' endgame yeah
I never denied that was a thing
you're only as peeved as you are because of the absurd restrictions youve placed on your current playthrough
my brother in christ, I can handle bugs here and there, but shit that actually affects gameplay progress is what irks me, in any other game too
for as much as I love Cyberpunk 2077, holy shit, is it filled with those
and I hate every single one of them
so? my point isn't on progress
it's about the fact I just wanted to get all the talismans I could as soon as possible
but shit that actually affects gameplay progress is what irks me
if I had ever knew the game would have this bug, I wouldn't have done it
I mean as in the quantity of said progress
any form of progress affected by a bug frustates me
I don't think it's too much to ask for a eight year old game to work something as simple as a mechanic they had already nailed in another mission
right which is kinda crazy to do so if you're gonna do something crazy that the devs didnt really foresee then you gotta expect you might run into a bug or something that prevents you from doing exactly what you wanted without getting pissed off at the game
"the devs didn't foresee" they made addiotional dialogue
a cutscene
and programmed deborah taking away the notes
only for them not to actually set them as sent
what they didnt foresee was that someone would want to collect every single possible talisman as arthur and then not progress any further
im not saying they didnt foresee someone collecting one dinosaur bone before meeting deborah
my point isn't on what they foresee, is the fact they fucked up something they had already nailed
they literally took the time to add all this shit
just to have it no work???
you also just said "i can handle bugs here and there", its a small bug, get over it
I can in fact handle bugs, but my message mentioned, when they don't affect gameplaywise
and no, I can't really get over it as much as I could, I don't know if it's ocd or anything else
the effect on your gameplay is only so significant because of the strange way that you're playing the game
but I'm the kind of feller that can't get their head away when noticing even the most tiny mistake
exactly lol this is a you problem
"strange way" and it's something they knew a player would do, found some bones beforehand
the bug isn't
"i can handle bugs here or there"
in my message said "as long as they don't affect gameplay progress"
"im also extremely bent out of shape about this minor bug that no one would normally notice"
I love me the flying horses and glitched npcs on the ground
I'm not the first person to try do a rdr2 100% and neither the last
you're not doing rdr2 100% you're doing "get every single thing possible in a perfect world as arthur"
I'm just doing them as soon as I could without using exploits, this is literally a 100%, since the in-game meter doesn't even count things as gold medal
for example, in breath of the wild, the only in-game 100% meter is for the map
are you getting every single hat too?
when someone talks about 100% botw they mean everything
and every single collectible?
yup
you sure you didnt miss any?
pretty much
well, you said "getting"
as in, they don't get missed
like the bucket hat which you might not get if you progress the appleseed company too much
anyways I gotta go bye
lol
Guarma is soo beautiful
How do u get back to Guarma
Rip
not much to do there anyway
that’s how I felt lol
I just finished the epilogue
Two missions and done
now I’m trying to discover the whole map
Wow
I have most of it almost
But atleast the last mission was FIRE
Jesus arthur looks like crap after the guarma part
I sure wonder if I just shave his massive beard off
Random npcs getting angry with me after I greet them? They're always in a pair of 2 on horseback, and after I greet them, they'll tell me to leave them be, and when I walk away, they'll follow me at full throttle to then threaten me again, then shoot at me for not walking halfway across the map, and when I fight back, I lose honor. Is this normal??
Some people just don't want company.
If they don't want company, why are they following me 💀💀
if you stop and kinda lurk around npcs on horseback, even if just for a minute, theyll take it as a threat and become aggro
Oh, ok
I don't even stick around that long tho
Like I just spend maybe 5 seconds processing the words, then turn my horse around and walk away
What if uncle's real name was tacitus kilgore
no
yeah theyre reallt sensitive
Do shire horses not allow you to store more animal corpses on them? Compared to other breeds?
You can buy an upgraded saddle pouch at the stables tho, can’t remember where it is exactly but I know you can buy one there. Applies to all your horses too
How am I supposed to get the tennis boat ending
low honor
@real compass My cooldown in the other channel is to long still so I’ll ask here lol, where exactly in valentine did you find them?
lol it’s okay! In the general store! You can shop for clothes using the ledger! I really love all the colors the shot gun chaos come in
I didn’t know chaps wan an option in there omg I must’ve never noticed
under accessories right?
I think so!!
I hope I’m being helpful lol 
Honor isn't honorable
You are! Thank you kindly

Ye it's under accessories
I’m glad I was able to help then! 
I have two missions left before guarma so im lollygagging with random stuff before I get to the next chapter
Like getting a huge bounty
im trying to get the panther cloak before guarma
I think you have to do master hunter 9 for it to be available
I meet a strange grandma in random house in the wood, can I take her donkey as my main donkey?
no, the donkeys cannot be made your primary nor secondary horse
indeed
What’s y’all’s favorite song from the story?
The one that plays during that scene where you are doing the thing
*insert gif of them building the house because this channel doesn’t allow gifs
What do I do after I completed the epilogue
and i am
There’s no more main missions
I cant go anywhere with these bounty hunter mane
Ohhh nice
But I can ride it
It's so rare to Ride a donkey I never encountered any donkey outside that place
there are a few donkeys, like one at rhodes
Where's Rhodes
in lemoyne
The animal stuff (finding them, taking a picture, killing/skinning,etc.)
Have any of you guys been attacked by a whitetail buck?
yup
Alright good i was recently vicimtimized by one, while picking some thyme
I found a perfect coyote pelt can I just put it on the ground
I just put it on my horse
The way it is
hmmmm
how can i know if im doing a side quest or a main story
if it's yellow, it's main
on the map right?
yuppers!
Very nice
may iiii have some bacon
And please, and please some gravy too
How can I store perfect animal pelts
what is this red line in the map
thats the border to an area youre wanted in
leave them in camp
skin and store on your horse
When I die it goes away
i see
So there’s no way to store my pelts
where do i take the animals i just hunted
sell to a trapper, you cant get it back, but hell hold it for crafting
So I just sell it to him
depends on what you want to do w them! i usually donate the carcass to pearson
yup!
Like I hold the the r button to sell
im on xbox, so idk, but however you usually sell
i dont think i can go to him i think i still didnt unlock him yet, im carrying an animal right now and it said it will decompose if i dont do anything
you should be able to donate to him anytime between ch2 - ch5...
you can sell it to a butcher though!
where is he located?
in the camp
ok ok thank you
ofc!
Is there a way to upgrade my satchel
After the story
And epilogue
buy the satchel upgrades at the fence
ok thank you
Yes. If you just go to customize your outfits satchel should be an option. The highest upgraded satchel legend of the east should be there
That’s how I got mine at least when finishing the main story
Didn’t have to buy it
if you didnt unlock it prior to the epilogue you gotta buy it
Not in my case. Never bought/unlocked it but I had it🤔
I saw this creep talking about Charlotte (the woman north of annesbug who Arthur teaches to survive) and when I heard "I watched her from the bushes" I shot him in the neck. I was just so mad
good! he fucking deserved that!
The Litchfield revolver right to the neck. Just. BAM and then he died
I gotta know. How many hours you got in story?
I love shooting everyone except those high honor folks
like that charlotte
i turn almost every shit into a shootout 🙂
It’s so windy where I live rn that it’s 25 degrees but feels like 3 degrees just from the wind 😭🙏
Bruh…I only got 408; 17 days sounds a lot better 😭
ive been playing for a while haha. its my whole thing
how can i know if i have a bounty and if i have how do i pay to remove it
if you look at your map, itll say if you have a bounty. if you do, you can pay to remove it at a post office
in a town
either look at your map to tell or press the button that shows you your honor level, money, region, temperature, time etc (idk the button on pc)
how can i swap between dead eye and eagle eye? i just tried to rob the doctor but i used eagle eye and died
if you have a gun out and aim, youre going to be using dead eye. if you dont have any weapon out, youll use eagle eye
i have 6 gold bars, what do i do with the money after i sell it
anything
buying new guns, customizing them afterwards etc
horse
btw im at dutch's tent where you contribute and it shows 2 different balance in the top right, what is this?
one is the camp's funds, one is your money
the icon that looks like a wallet is your personal fund
ohhh i see
Oh that's who he was talking about, should have sniped him when I scared him away
is this where i convert gold into money?
the fence is where you convert gold to money
oh ok so where do i convert my gold into money
a fence
wait but i can donate my gold to buy things in the ledger right
bc thats what im trying to do
the fast travel thingy
yeah
im pretty sure you can
ok ok thanks
anyone got any suggestions to fix freezing on pc? randomly started today it’ll freeze for about 5 seconds then go back to normal and keep repeating
I’m in the epilogue
I got the gambler hat
I need my guns back already so I can get Arthur’s money from the pig farmers
I’m so confused about why John wears Arthur’s hat to deal with the Laramie’s 😭
guess he's taking arthur with him for (presumably) his first step into returning to his old gunslinging life
Coffee feels so better after getting no rest 🥹
He wears it for significant events I guess
It’s funny you don’t get a choice to not wear it while playing American venom
But it’s annoying when it gets shot off his head for the “Just you left is it?” Lines
How do I get 48 weapons in this game Jesus that’s a lot
They are all unlockable by late chapter 5
I’m pretty sure I have every weapon
You’d be surprised
Bruh
There’s a guide on YouTube that shows the location of every one
Why is skinner bros hideout so hard to make it count for 100%
I was doing so well in fort mercer until a fucking machine gun decimated me
just ride until you encounter some Lamerie's trying to rob someome and beat them up with hand
that's how I got guns after 20 minutes of the epilogue starting
I got all the fish let’s goooooo
Why did rdr2 reset my progress with the chain gang missions 😭
Making me take down the posters again
don't bother
It'll just let u take down the posters and then go back to having all the Chain gang missions completed
its ok to kill the people that turns red in the map right
Honorwise, not necessarily.
depends
If you made them mad at you then no
theres some o driscolls
shoot them
do NOT listen to this guy
Question
How did John not get cholera
I’ve been spending the whole time in the town and haven’t gotten anything
he's just built like that
Why did kieran's fate hit me harder than hosea and lenny
I almost shed a tear for kieran
😢
Now how am I gonna make John look badass in the epilogue
Kieran is mid
bro HOW
He didn't deserve his fate
fr
I think the horse wanted to do it it just jumped right off a cliff
True but he was an odriscoll
He was NOT
how do i unlock fences
😭
he was
fences are someone who sells things right
If he didn’t die Sadie would’ve finished him off
wdym?
He was kieran Duffy!
both my black Arabian horses immediately stop whenever I am anywhere near a cliff, how did you get it to jump off
How do I get to tumbleweed without riding there because I can’t see it on the map
Do trains go there
follow train tracks or follow the signs
no but they go very close to tumbleweed
Take the southwest road out of Armadillo. After you pass the railroad bridge on the left, you'll see a road that goes up a hill to your right. That's Tumbleweed.
This gonna be so annoying
I just want the dinosaur bones why can’t I get a train to tumbleweed 🥀
10
Laura stop, this isn't you
I’ll give you the count to 10
or he gonna turn on deadeye
Do I get gold platet uncle miniature
No but I will give you
shut up
I decline your request for friendship!
wdym ?
I said no!
please
No!
Hey guys, im about 50% through the campaign, on pc. I keep crashing, no error messages, crashes to desktop, typically an hour or two into gameplay. Any fixes?! Driving me insane
Using steam
Gpu is 7900xt, cpu 7800x3d, 32gb ddr5
No mods
I recommend restarting your pc every 2 hours it should fix the error
Ahaha, really? I was hoping there was a well known setting of some description to fix this 😅🥺
waterborne disease, blud can’t swim
Logik 
Buy another one hah
Saint Denis stables
That’s where I got it
fuck you
But you know, I don’t think I will be so scared to die. I think it’s like today: the end of a vacation when you are ready to go home.
But you know, I don’t think I will be so scared to die. I think it’s like today: the end of a vacation when you are ready to go home.
update gpu drivers, verify game files, run the game with no overlays (steam discord and amd radeon software all have these). run the game in windowed and see if it's still crashing. beyond that no clue. hope it is not your ram.
But you know, I don’t think I will be so scared to die. I think it’s like today: the end of a vacation when you are ready to go home.
Ok, and?
Thank you! Drivers are up to date, verified files. I will try disabling any overlays and windowed! It best not be RAM, its gone up in value a tad since I got mine 😅
overlays are theoretically useful but they cause problems in so many games i like ive just learned to automatically not use them
I dont think i use them at all, not even sure what they are! But maybe something running in the background
windows event viewer may also give you some information but someone smarter/ with more time than me would have to help you with that
Okay thanks, i'll look into that
Theres a setting I accidentally disabled that kept me crashing let me find it
It was Nvida reflex low latency. I accidentally disabled it at some point and it made me keep crashing
Okay i'll check that too thanks!
Never completed this game before, this is furthest i have got, the crashing is really testing my patience!
You could probably make like $1200 from the ram alone rn
Go get yourself a good pc
Ram prices are fucking mental
Cost me £75 when i got it! 6000mhz, best investment ive ever made
I do regret not going for 64gb at the time though 🙁
Hi, how does the gang hideout at total completion tab work? i have 5/6, but i cant figure out what im suppose to do to get 6/6
do i just find thier base?
you have to find at least one gang hideout from each of the six gangs
for example one of the lemoyne raiders hideouts would be shady belle
oh tysm, but i cant find skinner ones
i searched online but no skinners anywhere
i think you have to be in specific area during a certain time
i think around tall trees
o i see, tysm
No
Totally not
I just saw this video of Keiran and I Feel like I lost a friend
which character would be best to get the secret weapons on
Doesn’t matter
They transfer over
You can, just play rdr1
yeah but i wish i can be a big bad bastard in rdr2
You can
thanks I never knew that
the thing is after i build beecher's hopeif i bring law here i insta die 😭
so i can't do holdout challenge here
unless a mod lets me
how do you mod rdr2?
idk, i cannot discuss it here
as much as they do close an eye in here
so in other words when I get a computer that let me mod games I will just have to figure it out myself?
no it's actually real simple, it's just that.... this server dont really allow me to tell you how to download mods and stuff and i pretty much would adhere to it
i mean, singleplayer QOL is fine is all
why would I mod the online game I only want to mod single player
yeah i know
see, the issue is that rule 15 exist
so i can't go tellin you how to install and stuff here
is it alright if you dm me how?
hmmmmm no. but well, just follow the instructions, mostly it's on the rdr2 root folder
okay
ye, sorry i couldnt chat like i could in this topic
it was worth a shot asking
ye, no hard feelings
it's fine it would probably be better if I learned myself anyway
Search for a tutorial on your device or your version
Why can’t I buy newspapers bruh
How do I get Tilly to be in Saint Denis in epilogue
I think you gotta get to part 2 first
That's when I saw her. Well that's when I saw all the camp people aside from Pearson
I wonder if Charles meets rains fall again in Canada
Oh? I saw all the others in part 1
What do you think happened to Jack Marston after RDR1?
Fought in WW1 and became a writer?
Chapter 6 is breaking my heart oh my gawd
I dont see him joining the army...
Even if forced
Due to it being just an easter egg, I think there's a decent likelihood that Jack took his own life after killing Edgar Ross, to end the cycle
Both parents and uncle dead, essentially had to raise himself. I heard Abigail committed suicide? No idea if that's true or not
Abigail would never kill herself considering jack is the only person she REALLY cared about
Fair, it doesn't even fit her character at all, but grief can really fuck a person up, she did see John's swiss cheese of a body
Unrelated, but I thought the 2nd mission with Mary was quite cute
Every mission with Mary is cute
Keyboard players missed out; the controller vibrates in the rhythm of a heartbeat when he's pinned up against her
thump thump
thump thump
No way dude
Im srs
I have my vibrations turned off
LOLOL
😢
its such a cool detail i had no idea it existed
i play on steam but use a ps5 controller. i hate that it only displays xbox ui
turn ur vibrations on and replay the mission
if side missions are replayable
Idk
I do kinda hate Mary tho
Oh god i can't get past Banking, The Old American Art, because i get an infinite black loading screen after the gang gets on the ship, what can i do to complete the mission??
I'm pretty sure if you die 3 times you can skip the mission/checkpoint(?)
To kill myself I throw dynamite at my feet
If i die and retry i still get this infinite black loading screen
Have you died more than 3 times?
Can't try it
Because if i die once i get this infinite loading screen
With the spinning thing in the bottom right corner
I love how uncle just clings onto anyone he can to survive
But he is loyal deep down
What if uncle was a rat too
And that’s why they found beechers hope so fast
I don’t think Elizabethan megasaur is a thing…..
the epilogue is so fun
When Arthur dies and you're aggressively sobbing and you're immediately thrown into John and Abigail bickering and leaving you no time to grieve
I didn’t cry sadly
However
heartless mfer
This time I played
I felt really sad
But I think that’s because I used buell for the final mission
Dressed Arthur up all nice
Gave his money to the pig farmers
It felt like I worked for his death
Anthony foreman should be a dead or alive bounty so I can finish the job Arthur said he’d do
Dude i thought you would get the option to kick strauss
I just confronted him
I might reload the game just to not kick him
You always kick him
I dont dislike the guy
It’s not a option you always kick him out of camp
Oh...
To be fair it’s better than keeping him in the camp
With all the craziness that’s going on there
It’s just a shame what happens at the end with everyone but I won’t spoil
Why did Sadie just admit to murder 😭
Sadie is sadie
I noticed this but arthur is so lively when doing missions with non gang members
What is the best revolver
people argue between lemat and schofield
but generally there is no best revolver
it comes down to preference
I think Sadie would be a good character for rdr3
Imagine she gets shot out of South America
Tries to find John
And in her final scene she finds the ranch with what happened after rdr1
And then the Pinkerton surround her too
Maybe she meets Charles somehow
i think if rdr3 happens it will either be a perspective from the side of the law/pinkertons or the beginnings of the gang with a younger hosea and dutch.
And the van der Lind gang finally ends
I don’t think it’ll be the first thing lol
Red dead redemption is about redemption
I wouldn’t be surprised if it’s about Charles or Sadie
i dont think theres a lot of their story that can be bridged off about
since we already know most of it
We don’t know what happens after they leave beechers hope
Although I think the fact there’s a letter in rdr1 saying Sadie Adler died could be interesting
Ok and? Arthur didn’t exist in rdr1 and they made a whole story about it him, surely they can make a story out of 1 newspaper with Sadie in it
i mean yeah
i would like to know
however thinking logically i think its unlikely that rockstar would see that as an opportunity, considering sadies story doesnt have that much and anything they try to expand on might be confusing
then again
idk what south america was like back then
nor canada
i mean, the only reason they were able to do that is because the entire chapter of the gang was unknown during rdr1 except for the obvious things we learned (w bill and javier and the pinkertons).
i dont even know if theyre gonna make an rdr3... theres been "little teasers" or wtv but im not gonna follow a false theory unless i get real evidence
would be cool tho
I've had a glitch involving Sadie having a gun out in plain sight during camp, and when I got back to lemoyne after Guarma Sadie had a Double barrel shotgun and it was glitched into the chest or throat of Tilly 😭
So many people have said Landon ricketts. It'd most likely be impossible because Ross Hagen who played Ricketts in RDR1 died shortly after RDR1 released
ah. yeah, a va dying is usually a no-go, however it wouldve been cool!
Yeah, only one I've seen being recast after the actor passed or disappeared in this case is uncle, his original actor spider madison has just disappeared, then they recast him to John O'Creagh who passed away but it was too far into development to just cut uncle
i wanna play rdr2 to scratch a certain inch but all i have with it is crashes of 000000ff
so try again if it is the same you will have to reinstall the game
i used mods before. i guess the mods are broken. what mods not to use?
just dont use any mods
too late for cowboy stuff by that point
rdr1 and 2 are about the end of the wild west
1 is already seriously pushing it in terms of time period
It’s still western though
The main theme is redemption
so is gta V
I wanna play rdr1 again
If there is an RDR3 sometime in the future it's definitely not related to the van der Linde gang
yup'
123 hours of peak
but now I wonder what'll happen in rdr1
because now they live on a ranch
all will be made clear to you
The lamet revolver has worse stats than the Schofield what makes it good
it holds 9 rounds, shoots faster, has a shotgun shell round, and does more damage.
what the lemat lacks, the schofield has, and vice versa
thats why its preference
I personally like the look of the lamet
What you mean by preference to you mean looks or stats
looks, stats, how you play, etc. it all comes down to what you like
Are revolvers better then pistols
again its preference.
neither one is "better"
its dependent on how you play and what feels better to you
Ok sorry
And thank you
yw
My deer arthur
My 🦌 Arthur
my 🦌 🖼️🙋♀️

is chapter 3 long?
first playthrough?
if so, its best you just go along with the flow, dont rush, and dont worry about length
take your time and engage with the story and side characters
gotchuu
also, another word of advice
care for your horse, feed it, nurture it, get it up to max bonding level, etc.
i always try to
good good
ill be on my way 🫡
Broooooooo I’m on chapter 3
Get an rtx5090 64gb ddr5 ram to play faster
Fuck u
SHIT
Be quiet piece of shit
Syfm
Oh look it’s the Children in need charity donator
I bet 90% +~ people here are black asf
?
Sadie?
Yes
Tf did I do
what the hell is happening 😭
You’re my bitch
that’s what am tryna figure out
That reminds me of vas
so tuff
fr
Shut the hell up
no one cares, you racist fuck
Hello folks, the bug to get the Missouri Fox Trotter near the Cornwall kerosene & tar works in ps4?
Ts a unc game
Yea it still works
Hi folks, Half an hour ago I finished red dead redemption 2 And the game is fucking masterpiece And im new here bye
arthur does not look right clean shaven
fr
x2
Lul I know the feeling
Noice
is there any tool/manager to disable mods in order to play online?
i really wanna play online every once in a while but really don't want to remove every single mod all the time
This is happening to me as well, it's driving me crazy!
It was working fine before, and suddenly it starts crackling. The shotgun sound at the start seems to be fine, but as soon as you get to the main menu, it starts crackling
Happens with my speakers and headphones. Already tried reinstalling the game.
Does anyone know where to find seagulls in rdr2
Does anyone have the location of skinner brothers? and the time they show up, the camps
Usually can be found in Tall Trees but also some parts of West Elizabeth manly near Blackwater tho
ty
the rocks alongside the shore south of van horn
Why Dutch kill Arthur and why Micah want to kill saddie
Technically, Dutch didnt kill Arthur
Bcuz she rode up to the mountains to kill Micah with John.
what is this white part of the map with a dollar sign
thats a debtor
i had a plann!!
i just finished the epilogue W game
howdy partners, i'm new here.
whats ur favorite horse in rdr2/online?
Mustang
gypsy cobs!!!!
whats the best way to find skinner bro's camp?
use an online map that tells you all the possible locations. then put a pin on each of the spots and cycle through them until one spawns. remember to reload and sleep often
i just started playing the game, finished quite a few missions in chapter 2 but i really dont know any good ways to make money and i really just wanna know the best way thats also fun so no stupid exploits or bugs
treasures!
are there any areas where i can start the mission to search for treasures? or do i just find treasures randomly
if you go near flatneck station (near where you rescued reverend, assuming you already did that) there should be a white question mark/stranger mission near there
its an explorer and he'll offer you a map for a price
ah okay
theres other treasure maps you can get throughout the map, but that usually comes from more explorers or other things... most treasures reward you with gold bars. each gold bar is worth 500 bucks
and its pretty fun
theres a few non-treasure ways to get money, that give you gold bars, and theyre pretty fun. like a puzzle
yes
thanks
yw yw
i'm thinking to buy mustang horse.. I like big horses, but mustang also look strong and cool
It’s the best tbh in my opinion
i have dutch warmblood, shire and turkoman rn. i'll buy mustang soon
Alr then
why does it say trains are unavailable, Its been like this for quitw a bit now
im in chapter 6
i use tenesee walker
good foe long rides
yeah i love tenesee walker and morgan horse. they are common but also lore accurate
Where is saint Denis I've been trying to find it in mobile
in rdr or rdr2?
if youre talking about rdr on mobile
