#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 278 of 1
Yeah you can mail them all at once I’m pretty sure
After shooting down half of Valentine, I only get a bounty of $60?
Is there any way to get plants to respawn ? I’m trying to farm the oleander plant
try killing when law is after you
killing law people gives a lot of extra bounty
for the herbalist thing?
idk about plant respawn, just check multiple plant locations
Nope,I just wanna murder a whole town and need them for poison arrows and poison throwing knifes
Alright
the plants will respawn after a few days i believe. you can skip time by sleeping and that might work but idk if you can sleep enough for that
That’s lowkey quite smart
and you can get around not being able to sleep by skipping to night time and going to a closed store/shop and clicking wait till morning 
Ive been sitting for the last half hour fishing with javier and the same line over and over hearing Arthur say well done is starting to get annoying. How do I fix this?
Never mind I figured it out
sleeping creates an auto save, so 18 hours + 18 hours, reload, 18 hours + 18 hours, boom that's 3 days
If my math is mathing
also what's the deal with this creepy treehouse woman in new austin
sounds goofy as hell
Hey fellers does the master hunter challenge of killing tree bears count when killing the legendary bear?
tree bears lol
yes i do believe it does
im not sure but it's possible
its the same with the catch all fish types, legendary fish count for their type too
better use poison tho
Ah ok ok
This was clearly an intentional reference to paddington the bear and totally not a typo when trying to say three
i... believe you
Good choices in story missions, being helpful in random encounters, greeting people, throwing fish back when fishing
the fish thing is so random
Yes it is
Especially when it can be done to feed the camp
I don't see the point in fishing if you're just going to throw it back
Amen
me neither
ive got an incredible skill issue at fishing all for it to give me like 0.3 honor
Honor
But it takes too long
Just ride and greet everybody

Exotics are so absolutely trash
lol
is micah's revolver better than the classic double action revolver?
How many times are you going to ask this question?
Is there a reliable Arthur in New Austin glitch
I’m tracking the one with the glitched pronghorn carcass but that is so precise
i grow suspicious
kill them back
.
Man why tf is the andulasian such a wuss
if bucked me off like twice
and always runs away
never happened with my arabian tho
are you fully bonded
Nah
that will make it braver
But with arabian not bonded i never got bucked off
Alright how do I farm bonding fast
I do that a lot
Trynna hunt a perfect panther for the saddle
died twice and got a panther but it was 1 star
I already got the crocodile onr
one*
So I killed a legendary animal but a cougar killed me before I could skin it
itll automatically transfer to your trader inventory
The map has marked the legends animal off as dead but I have no pelt
Well it ain’t doing that for mine
I should preface that I went into new Austin as Arthur with the pronghorn carcass glitch, killed the legendary tatanka bison, now x’ed out on the map, and was killed by a cougar.
I was hoping it would transfer but it does not seem like it will.
Is it because you technically shouldn’t be able to get it as Arthur?
Any advice
Nvm
I fast traveled and got it
I’m trying to 100% the game as Arthur
Or get as close to it as I can aside from the story
The game forced me to beat Thomas Downes but Micah is still in prison, Sean is alive, Lenny is Alive, Hosea is alive
what is bill using hair pomade for..
me
what
🙂
The alternate ending we all want
I made it to chapter 6 today
Sup
Can anyone tell me a safe area where I can kill a mountain of cops?
what i like doing is going into a house with a window and making them go in the room and then shoot them down and then escape using the window, it gets me alot of money
Nice
i know the answer!!!!
hold on
the house where you can find the pig boar bear mutant, if you know where that is
the cops cannot come into that room
what’s the island near st denis?
What chapter are you at?
4
You'll find out then
I just reached chapter 2 what should I do
Sean
@thorny cargo can you recommend me a horse and a weapon that I can get ?
My current horse and weapon sucks
well
save up 150 dollars before you do hoseas bear hunting mission
and stop whenever you see a guy cleaning out his horse's hoof
(american standarbred. its an early very good horse)
and weapon
Should I get the white arabian ?
I heard it's really good
How about weapons
thats preference
the schofield is available in the valentines doctors office
or in the secret business
which some people think is good
@thorny cargo no way
?
🏠
homophobes when they see a home
im not homophobic LMAO a mod changed my name
i could change it but i think its funny
is micah's revolver better than the classic double action revolver?
can u stop asking this question
lmao
@thorny cargo I'm confused on how to use the dead eye
Well
After I went into dead eye mode I automatically aim at the enemy right
After the crosshair appeared on the enemy do I let go of the dead eye ?
i saw wot u deleted
it was incorrect
shame shame
😔
just test it all out one time for yourself and you will understand. I have forgotten what the low level dead eye is like cuz it changes a bit the more u upgrade
also there are a limited amount of drinks around the map idk if its aged pirate rum or something which boosts ur dead eye xp making u level up faster. If u want to go around collecting em do it cuz after max level they useless
its valerian root
ayo wadafak u are the girl that helped me with the hunting requests
dont womansplain it to me
im just SAYINGG>
After the crosshair appeared on the enemy do I need to press shoot. Or does it automatically shoot ?
u change ur name quite often bruh
no but a mod made my name I'm homophobic and people kept asking me if i was homophobic so i had to change it
press shoot
u dont chose homophobia, homophobia choses u
wot kinda mods u downloading bruh
lil shi bot
noice noice
yes
After I pressed shoot. I deactivate the dead eye ?
itll deactivate on its own
just try it out bro im very confident you can figure it out
tis guy
@unique shoal so how was it?
I thought I can save the dead eye bar by deactivating it quicker
So what I do is I activate dead eye. Once the crosshair appeared on the enemy I press shoot after that I turn off the dead eye ?
yeah
Testing every ounce of her patience
Respect tbh
Let's see her limits today she always happy and shi
Should I do bandit 8 challenge in Rhodes or Saint Denis? 🤔
emerald ranch. thats where you sell them and wagons come through there pretty commonly
yup rhodes
scorpi
I hate everyone in that town lol
Troll lol
Can the french couple mugging encounter respawn if I already encountered it once? Some places say yes and some say it's only once per game
it can respawn, but good luck trying to get it to
Can it be manually reset using a save editor?
nooo idea
OK. Guess it will keep trying to get it to respawn
good luck!
ayo i need ur help
?
do you have your phone
u look like a pro discord user
i do yes
fastest hands in the west
look in the top right section on your computer
near the expand, minimize, and exit buttons
it should be a flag
ok
Does it mostly spawn north of the domino's or is it a few different places? I can't remember
does wha
the french mugging encounter. See my convo a little further up
wheress lucky cabins near valentine?
Just west of Castor's Ridge
im finding valentines kiler
I just had the weirdest grizzly bear experience, that guy, was not attacking me at all, instead it was walking towards my horse the entire time
I kept shooting it with my bow to distract it, but, it just wouldnt attack me
Eventually it died
Sounds like a bear bug, similar to a bed bug, but way less annoying
Finally got the damn panther trail saddle
What trinkets/talismans are worth getting?
i only got shark tooth
Is having a high bounty bad?
Kinda
course
its ugly ngl
How do I lower my bounty
pay it off at a post office or surrender to the police
Where do I find the post office
theres multiple post offices around the map, usually at train stations
mourn him. cry about a pixelated horse. eventually (months later), decide it's time to pull yourself together and find yourself a new steed.
Create a genocide across the map
yes, if you got angry instead of very intensely sad, this is the only other route. you only have two options, choose wisely.
true...
flyboy, my black shire horsey who got jumped by a group of enemies with a gauntlet gun at the end of the bridge of Saint Denis 
Personal opinion there, if you care more about stats than looks it's the (arguably) best saddle, that or the snake skin saddle.
lwk, anytime smth happens to my horse, i let the enemy kill me, and js pray my baby respawns w me 😭
ill only go so far for stats
SO REAL 😭 🙏
I turned off autosave and got in habit of saving the game every 30 minutes or so (unless in missions where you can't save regardless). That way if something like that happens you can just reload last save
you can also logout the second it happens lmao
ive never lost something important doing that
Yes but you said its ugly, I like the look of it. Just cause you said its ugly doesn't mean it is, just means you think it is
when did i ever say its more than a personal opinion you delusional fuck 
Guys if u have the cheats enabled are u able to finish the game still Ik u can’t get achievements or trophies but just wondering if u are able to still finish the game
Look, if you can't discuss things on here I suggest you stay off of it. Go read the rules again and maybe stop insulting and swearing at people just cause they don't agree with everything you say
Maybe rule 1 and rule 2 I'd start there
uh huh alright 💀
Nuhuh
guys, can we js be friends and hold hands and sing songs? :(
wtf is your name
Idk they did this to me
i want you to spell shit right
i wish to be ekat aline too. 😔
hes always like this
Can I have my name back
its more deciphering than reading
respectfully, just be quiet. you legit have nothing to add that isn't unnecessarily rude.
calm down
were friends
Arthur morgan has a good maxilla, his cheekbones are high set, and he has a strong mandible, positive canthal tilt, and a tall ramus. Arthur morgan mogs me and you
im alive
im alive (slowed + reverb)
Guys if u have the cheats enabled are u able to finish the game still Ik u can’t get achievements or trophies but just wondering if u are able to still finish the game
Calm down fancy pants paranoxon is my friend
yeses, i'm sorry!
It's ok :)
Okay 💙
.
send a pic tho
I shall gobble my KFC up
dont choke
Hi
morning
.
Fixed my name aueh
Good
yaur
nevermind
best horse
the male ones so i can get arthur to say 'good boy'. on that note, it's rather difficult to play with one hand!
.
i'm not going to lie about who i am! 😞
im on pc. imagine how hard it is for me
i hate cinematic, icel.. anyway, lwk didn’t even know there was such thing as auto drive
There is
So you have to make a marker on the map, and then got your horse up to speed and then go into cinematic
Itll do it for you
sometimes it doesnt pick it up, just try again
can you guys recommend me a good horse in chapter 2
U want big or small
does it matter ?
If it doesnt just get the white Arabian. Common and easy after that u may find better horses
It is fast too
what's the best horse in the game ?
Some say arabian some say Buell and some say nokota and..
Its a debate u can decide which one u like
Oh and Missouri foxtrotter
just tame it normally right ?
after I tamed it can I immeadiately right it
or do I need a saddle
U can hop on it and ride
It will be a temporary horse
And if u tame other horses this one will get lost
So just put a saddle on it to be sure of your horse
In my opinion, the MFT
Hungarian halfbred isn't to bad either. Can buy it or get it from one of the chapter 2 debt collectors missions pretty early
how do I get a saddle
From your old horse
I had that and the white Arabian early on
how do I unequip the saddle
Oh
Ig u didn't do a certain mission
With hosea
Bear hunting
After that u can do this
Take your old horse to stable and stable it/remove saddle the ride your new tamed one into stable and saddle up
Or just walk up to your primary horse and use remove saddle option, then put it on your new horse
But that way makes your old primary horse now a temporary one
Unpopular opinion but I like the TW from Sadie's barn. Very underrated horse
It performs better than Liverpool this season
imma play onc its downloaded
It does haha
What's TW again?
Tennessee Walker
Oh yeah, Im just about to restart might give that one a go
Objectively is the arabian. Every horse has something that another doesn't have, if u like speed, then get the arabian. The Missouri Fox trotter is also a good choice
remember that the saddle and the gear can affect the horse, so if you have a good equip every horse will be fine
Sure its alot of money to spend at the start of the game but I always but them
i honestly prefer the arabian, i like an easy and fast horse
i got mine in the wild
I get the hooded stirrups
oh! also, some horses are braver then another
Too small for me. Looks like Arthur is riding a hobby horse haha
actually true
it look silly
i like the Micah’s horse, i don’t remember the breed
MFT
Taima is my favourite gang horse
right?? so pretty
Yes and we use her in the first mission
I want the count so much it's a shame its not possible
i honestly think that it doesn’t really matters which horses we choose, either way i look at the most fast one. But if i have to choose on the appearance, so it’s a horse like Taima
Appaloosa are cool looking horses. I like Trelawny's Appaloosa also
indeed
when i first started to play i thought that the most expansive horse it was the best one in the game, i was wrong
It's personal preference on what we all like with horses
Same with guns we use and how we dress Arthur and how we play him
the best horses can all be obtained for free
right?? i try to be on high honor but then i get the ick and i shot at everyone, for example
baylock, my pfp
not true
bravery aint a real thing
some horses are just easier to bond with
which is why theres elite, race etc.
i dunno.. i read it online before, i guess they lied idk. My arabian is scared even of her own shadow
its mostly clickbait. lol
all horses act the same on bonding 4

to them, yeah
I read it online before too like I heard mustangs are brave was it just nonsense ?
especially in videos theyre like "top ten bravest horses in rdr 🤓 "
anyway i love ur pfp, what a beauty
complete nonsense 
he is
naww
Damn
yuh 😞

@dapper jay no. potential means you can upgrade the gun until the grey areas are filled in.
But the gun is already fully upgraded...
Like leveling?
Alright thx
What's the best beginner gear for horses
Yes they are around gunfire as it's war/work horse
i used kneller dakota and hooded stirrups at first
Doesn't whine or cry like the highly strung snakedetector arabian lol
the arabian hates snakes omg😭 mine start to panic everytime
it’s just… a snake..
They're snake detectors
but i love my snow white, she’s dumb. Also 1 time the train almost killer her
she didn’t even try to move
My Choclate Roan Dutch Warmblood hardly flinches around gunfire or predators. I have to calm him with the latter and he rarely bucks me off
lmao mine could never
Oh Arthur
the description war horse only tells you how many points they need to bond
Guys if u have the cheats enabled are u able to finish the game still Ik u can’t get achievements or trophies but just wondering if u are able to still finish the game
save up to buy the best gear
why do people still not get that bravery is ONLY bonding-specific NOT breed-specific
IDK
join me in the trenches 
bond your damn arabian!!!
the descriptions horses have (elite, race etc.) ONLY tell you how long it takes to get higher bonding
I mean
that's the reason why you think they're skittish
because you haven't bonded
I've had them at level four bonding
Going through the swamps was a chore
then its you being a little delusional
Guys if u have the cheats enabled are u able to finish the game still Ik u can’t get achievements or trophies but just wondering if u are able to still finish the game
I don't want a snake detecting whining horse that bucks me off
can you please stop spamming the question everywhere
was the same for me at level 4
it doesn't solve everything
nobody knows
it is after all still an animal
and its not coded to absolute precision when they freak out and bolt. situations might be different every time.
you might?
it turns off autosave AND manual save, so you would have to do it in a single sitting so... good luck with that
@lapis panther
I told you I'd rather walk. Simple as that. I cannot stand the arabian horse
level 4 doesn't mean that your horse just loses the ability to be afraid
and wed rather have you stop sharing misinformation about the game. personal experiences? ok. if you dont like the arabian that's fine. but your experiences dont make anything factual
then it's probably just that you don't like them, and you use the "bravery" argument to justify it
you don't need to
if you don't like a horse, just say the reason
we (or at least I) don't judge
I am giving you my personal experience
Can’t u just then turn them off after to save
no, you have been claiming that arabians are less brave than other horses
certain ones, yes
but others are permanent
That is my personal experience lol
And yes
They are
this is claiming its true and a fact
Mustangs are brave
Through personal experience when I have used a mustang
It's too small is the main reason I do not like them and nothing to do with how it reacts in game
How is saint denis meant to be pronounced
San Da-knee
after burning the braithwaith's place, are there any other survivors
what a funny way to pronounce it
San duh-NEE
lots of knee jokes you can make with this
is honor capped? why is my honor not raising but it can be lowered after a certain point
What chapter are you in?
4
It's capped
damn, guess I can't get the gambler outfit
not really the way the americans do, lol. french version sounds nice and elegant
although its a bit of a shithole
i didnt even know
was already wondering why it wasnt raising
then i have quite literally been at max honour the entire game
figured I've been pronouncing it like americans do
i hope so atleast
Yes it's capped at 75% until chapter 6
wild
why hope
seems like mary and arthur still love eachother, atleast tha's what it looks like
i caught my first arabian and then died to a wolf
and now i cant find the horse anywhere

it respawns
there we go
see that take I wholeheartedly agree with
(are you really surprised? look at my name
)
I have pre order Ardennes in my game. Not a bad horse
I didn't pre order the game 😭
and I was gonna try for the glitch but I got the strawberry wagon encounter too early😭
I didn't pre order and found the code for horse in my game case
I got it off steam
the game I mean
I'm stuck with the bay roan
do I know why Rockstar, in their infinite wisdom, gave the Ardennes (a literal draft horse the size of a Shire in real life) Standard handling? No.
Do I enjoy the fact that they did it? Hell yes.
Does anyone here have a ps5
i got the red arabian and named it charizard
man this lake isabella, half the lake is frozen and in the legendary fish area, I've pulled a muskie like 5 times 😭🙏🏻
ardennes are a fairly small draft breed. theyre just very broad
Heyy anyone knows how to fix this bug where the hair of many characters get blonde and start glowing like they turned into a saiyan?
using any mods?
Nop
I don't know man, never heard about random people becoming super Saiyans in rdr2
that's fair
but suffolks take the prize in that category imo
as in?
suffolk punches look the heaviest
not tallest, obv shires are tallest
but just proportion wise
suffolk punches arent heavy at all
theyre very light drafts
i mean the game models aren't perfect to real life i suppose
ofc by "aren't heavy" we're talking like "only" 2000 lbs lmao

theres multiple directions theyre bred into
there are heavier sections
yeah that makes sense
im looking at it now , seems like they vary a lot.
yeah i've seen sites that say 2200 and sites that say 1800
like
irl or in rdr?
if its irl then you gotta do the greet-greet-antagonize
greet-greet-L2 R2
in real life is CRAZY work 😭
antagonize antagonize B B B B B B B
idfk the controls
L2 is aim, R2 is shoot
BBBBBBB is punchx7
lol
nah i antagonised him
but he didnt react
he watched me beat an odriscoll to death though!
and massacre valentine
I haven't massacred any place yet
I'll prolly do it after the collectibles
everytime I feel like doing exotics, I try for 10 minutes, realize it's ass, and then I do another collectible
I once had a 290 bounty , it was not fun, I paid it off
whys that
two perfect wolf pelts
lets pray a train doesnt come and run me over here
that would be inconvenient
i looked at main campfire upgrades the SECOND micah kicks swanson 
was just checking how many pelts i need... damn
I can TELL arthur and dutch hates bronte
😭😭😭
dutch also has the greatest drip in this game
He does have a plan
i cant remove the pelt from my horse why is that
i massacred armadillo and it was great there was no law
I killed all of black water for rdr 1 old time sake
i am low honor.
Guys how the hell do I talk to Henri Lemieux
Because anytime I arrive at his place it won't let me in the building
Thank you 
Hey guys
wym?
F*ck everyone from the gang except bill and arthur
Buy i kinda sometimes hates Arthur for being bully to bill.
But yeah, overall. The rest can go to hell.
you sound like bill lmao
Bill is cool, and actually had a succesful planned robbery
Not like the rest of garbage gang
John?
bill is also racist but youre entitled to your own opinion
my personal favs are Arthur, John & Charles
Dutch too, and micah...
No one likes Dutch nor Micah
exactly
lmao
also idk if id say dutch is really racist, he was the one who argued with bill when bill WAS being racist
but he probably is
I dont remember this. Was the boat scene when bill just said that, he saw indians doing bad things?
Dutch scolded him. The same Dutch who used indians for his own plans.
yes, thats true, doesnt make bill any less racist
but the entire gang isn't exactly nice ppl
Hyperbole 🙂
i dont like bill
I like Dutch
So, how saying that he saw indians doing bad things makes him racist?
also because he joked about arthur getting sa'd
actually I like all characters
I mean I like his style just not his personality
i can find good in all of them, and theyre all well written. but i do rank them
the fact you think thats all he was saying lwk shows what kinda person you are, im not gonna get into that
So give me more arguments. The boat scene is invalid.
"invalid"
while maybe the indians when he was in the war were "savage" or whatever he wants to say, not only is that racist (they clearly had a reason. that "savagery" could be applied to the whites, too) but it leads him to have a clear disdain for any indians or non-whites he meets in present day
which is RACIST
no way youre trying to say that bill isnt racist
course he is
he was nasty to javier too
mhm
Still, dutch is more garbage
which is a fat minus in my book
I hate Dutch more than Micah
bill isnt bright enough to be as bad as dutch
At least bill had a succesful robbery.
maybe because he’s two sided
in regards to the story? yes, yes he was, since dutch practically ends up becoming an antagonist. im just saying that bill as a standalone character was definitely not that great
but i know people who like him, and in some ways i can understand
yeah Dutch is two faced
bills actions in rdr1 are also inexcusable
maybe he didnt do it himself but he was responsible for his gang.
idk hes just annoying in rdr2 ngl
I never liked him ever since he held that thing up to Kieran’s …
perfectly cleae racism and joking about sa is not excusable at all
im like so convinced he was into kieran 💀 poor boy was terrified of him
no literally
"dishonourably discharged from the army" alright...
I was like wtf 💀
i kinda found that funny but also opne of my favorite lines (non-emotional ones) is "youll die, boy, but youll lose your balls first" soo LMAO
i mean its not funny in a general sense
but in regards to what we knew of kieran then
hed have kept em as souvenirs
Oh yeah that’s when they were going to the o driscoll camp
yes
"my children of the man of my dreams"
HAHHA
yeah idk why he was so obsessed with his balls
think a bit harder
Might aswell suck them
he wants it the other way round
My nans a lesbian
kieran has a fully modelled dickk for that scene btw
How do you know?
a friend showed me the video
"all kieran outfits on youtube"
skip a bit...
its nothing to swing around sadly
Yikes
dont let mary beth see
The times where gang was the gang, not some teletubbies Cartoon
Where they were all in it together
And when they acted like proper gang
two faced...?
ah yes?
You can’t tell me he wasn’t two faced
He says one thing and does another
They should add the "sandbox mode" to the game, when you chose the camp place, and all people are in, all get along and you doing stuff like hunting etc.
but he had a goddamn plan
can you only choose one and make it an awkward date
you guys can’t tell me blackwater isn’t the best city
Peaceful and calm
Has everything
Near a lake
Good hunting near great plains
oh i meant like
the linkin park song, Two Faced
(i listen to too much LP
)
erm okay I don’t get the reference 😂
I feel like that would get boring real fast
You can decide not do do missions in chapter 2 or 3 and just hang around lol
Besides, a good ending doesn’t mean it’s a good story
yeah it's a pretty new song from them
They don’t even push updates to the game anymore
they add like random missions
And 2x xp and whatever
No DLCs
cause they're working on a little game called GTA VI
(i pressed enter when i meant ' lmao)
Spending all that damn budget on gta 6
Didn’t they add Michael to GTA online or something
yeah they did
Idk I didn’t play GTA V lol but I heard that they released an update
yeah they did
Yipeee!!! :D
He's good in a way
But also bad in a way
You get what i mean
i suppose
He has a plan
But are you sure ?
I mean I like the characters story it's almost like a tragic Greek myth he's really well written, but as a dude I don't like him
In my dream John and I agreed Pearson should be kicked out and I also kicked out Charles and Sadie.

Sean gotta be my fav member of the gang
Tf did Charles do
Gambler 8 
what did all 3 even do 😭✌
don't disrespect the hand that feeds you
Funny irish men are my favourite kind of characters
Same here
dan, lets say I complete a master hunter challenge before its available for me,
I'm at 6 right now,
if I end up finding and killing a grizzly bear with only throwing knives,
will it count for the last one,
or can I only do those once its available for me
can only do those when its available for you
It won't count I don't think
ohhh okay thanks
He jokes and laughs about the Aberdeen Pig farm too if you get robbed and not return for your money. Bill is a vile peice of crap. Nothing redeeming about his personality
Who?
the veteran
which veteran, tons of veteran
he invites u to fish and hunt
Hamish
Oh, haven't met him yet
its a random encounter
btw he gives u the buel horse after he died
Brilliant character. Him and Charlotte make chapter 6 a little less depressing
fr
I've only met like 2 veterans
Mickey and the guy with the chopped off leg in rhodes
me too
man i feel bad for mickey
I leave the last encounter for John so Buell lives
i did the same thing
he was
prob
man i dont think anyone has killed mickey
but there are some myths that mickey pickpockets arthur
it aint true tho
also man buell is the goat
Mickey mentions Tommy beat him up once which is sad and makes me think Tommy deserves what happened to him. You go around bullying people and one day you'll get what is coming to you
fr i feel bad for mickey cuz he got beatin by tommy whos hulk in 1899
man i wish rockstar allowed us to kill tommy fully
I'm glad we didn't. We see him later on and Arthur practically beat him stupid
but out of no where when i was trying to finish tommy out of no where a random guy came and stopped
yea
i wouldnt call thomas random lol
wait that was thomas???
yeah
i didnt even noticed that
where did he even come from
he was litterally in his ranch
he was probably at his booth
oh
otis miller revolver, calloways revolver and the high roller revolver r my fav
He deserved it too. Might sound harsh but I feel no sympathy for anyone who steps into fight that isn't theirs and gets their ass beaten
yep he actually deserved it
dutch used to be my fav until chapter 6
it took you up until chapter 6?
it was my first playthrough i liked dutch because of his lead and then after he betrayed my fav was arthur and in epiclogue 2 it was john and arthur as well
also his dialogues
man i wish micah was executed in the prison
wheres the most common spot to find ducks.
literally like any place with water
probably emerald ranch at that place with water
the little pool
Rivers and lakes, so like a quarter of the map
You could probably just run along river banks for spawns
We all do, but can see why Dutch wanted him out. Micah is the kind of guy who would talk to save his own skin.
fr
It's why Dutch has a no man left behind policy
Not because he cares but because they can talk
yea
btw panther saddle and rattlesnake saddle r the easiest to get
Hosea told me to kick them out
Has anyone else had a bug where gold just disappears from their inventory? I had a bar of gold and then finished a treasure map and got 3 more but now like over 12 hours later I looked at my inventory and I'm back down to 1
Even though I haven't sold them or given them to camp
I would've kicked Strauss out personally
Strauss and Micah would've been my 2 choices
decided my final shall be reverend
No nevermind, reverend's a doctor
uncle's going
damn, no wonder he knows about em
Fitting that he meets all the weirdos being one himself
Never. But then again as soon as I get any gold in game, I am usually on my way to camp to donate or to a fence to sell it.
Yeah so do I normally, but I got distracted by some fishing and other camp side missions and now I've done way too much so I can't even reload a save to try and get it back 
Do you autosave?
Yeah but I mean it's too late now
I've been playing for hours since I got the gold and I don't want to have to go do everything all over again
Never autosave, because if you mess up, there is no way back. Use manual save
If you manual save and mess up, you can always load an earlier save
We become attached to the horses we use in game
your alter ego donated to the camp 😂✌
He scolded Bill for calling Lenny "boy"
You're not missing much by not playing that game.
Because they don't care about RDR. GTA is their golden child
RDR is the red headed step child that gets ignored.
this is the first time i see a game group have a dead ass chat\

Is it better to play RDRII using mouse and keyboard or a controller
just play how u want oh my god
play with ur feet
i’m sure u already asked this before
No there's an idea haha
I'm still unsure which one is the best one
Try both and decide for yourself
there is no best way to play, just do what makes you confortable
oh christ
we already answered this yesterday
You mean health, stamina and dead eye?
i discovered all of this things actually playing the game
I just searched google. It says that there are trinkets and talisman
Are they very important to acquire ?
oh god
They are useful
Which one should I get first
Depends on what you want to boost first?
I think I should get a horse
Since mine died
Is the sky blue and the grass green?
i’m not sure.. i should check outside
Get one unless you want to walk through the game
sorry Dan the sky is actually white
Same here
i’m waiting for “what is the best horse in the game”
How do I unequip my saddle off my horse ?
Have you done Hosea's mission or paid attention to any instructions on screen?
Which one is the hosea mission ?
u already asked this yesterday and someone answered you
Either you're a spastic or trolling
spastic HAHA
bro oh my god
we understand that but
u can’t really ask the same question everytime
How do I check my current quest
OH GOD
Pls help
Use google and stop asking the same questions in here
should i use cheats for money
so is a pc player problem being like this
i want MONAH
don’t play with cheats 🙁
Tahiti an expensive dream haha
because it ruin the experience, but do what u want idk
Because the game is easy enough without cheats
whats the fastest way to get money then?
Not spending your money on something you will not benefit from
Missions, looting, robbing, gold bars
moneææ
without losing my honor?
Go kill o'driscolls in their hideous
Loot their bodies
Wait for a few in game days
Repeat
alr thanks
You're welcome
Absolutely
GTA just makes them more money
Yes
I got my first ever satchel guys
maybe with the button that says something like "take off saddle" just an idea though
sticky side up get a free wax
Hi, i have modded rdr2 and i have a small problem with it, I don't have any hitmarkers
I now have my second ever
Valuables and materials satchel are both in my posession
It took two and a half dedicated sessions plus all my hunting from chapter 2-4
i beat the game without knowing i could upgrade satchels 💔
stagecoach robberies very good, no bounty no loss big reward, alternatively just do crimes and then run around saint denis greeting EVERYONE, easy honor.
train passenger robbery good, but hurry or the law will get you
Lol i almost decided to never upgrade the satchels
I did that during my first playthrough
Now I upgrade them in every playthrough. I like the grind and the reward of all that satchel space is worth it
thats plain stupid

🥀
how did you never check the damn camp upgrades
me too and i cannot go by any game without clicking everything available
could say im similar but i also do not notice A LOT of things
untypical though, sorry to defeat your excuse but autistic folks tend to get lost in details /lighthearted
wide spectrum it is what it is, anyways i got a lovely aligator saddle and the great one satchel now with john :D
im a massive hater of all trapper saddles without modded clothes 
🥀
yeah coats are so boring no texture at all
mine were rolled up in the first place
im a big customizer i change them all the time and theyre rolled down by default
i haven't changed my outfit much for the entire playthrough
got a good one in chapter 2
only changed chaps, boots and spurs afterwards
neat
my friend said RDR2 sucks because the first chapter is too long
💔
missed out on peak
It's 5 or 6 missions long and only takes over an hour or so to complete
yeah ofc but stagecoaches better, both are often easy
I just found a basement with civil war hat and knife
share
Fort Brennand?
bad taste and whining around
Colter is such a perfect opening to the game
it was so cool
kinda boring on replays
but cool on the first one
it really is
who wouldve thought that missions youve already played once are somewhat boring on the second run 😭
....some aren't
blood feuds is good no matter how many replays
blood feuds, ancient and modern.....
its natural for tutorials to be boring
I like it and the missions are good especially the mining camp and train robbery.
Yes and I always look forward to burning the tobacco crops with Sean. Chapter three has some great missions once you past the boring Beau and Penelope missions
yeah
guys?
idk if the mobile version holds up ok
Apparently Negan's actor from The Walking Dead, Jeffrey Dean Morgan wants to play a live action Arthur Morgan if RDR2 ever got a movie or a series
I feel like Daryl fits Arthur more.
i dont like how restraining the first hours of the game are after completing it
Trapper saw how i kill the wolf and run to notice authority, you little shit.. i came to bring you pelts :DDD
I remember going to him and getting wanted for trespassing haha.
i bumped into him and he ran away screaming
i hogtied him thinking he will be fine.. but no.. he ran away

walking somewhere without some gang jumping you and getting you a 65$ bounty mission impossible
how are you getting a bounty from killing enemy gangs
Try and kill the annoying O'Driscoll in Valentine standing back to the telegram pole, right before the sheep pens.
He can kill you for all anyone cares, but hogtie or beat him and Sheriff Malloy will be up at arms.
i beat him to death and no one cared
i beat two odriscolls to death right in front of the office
no one cared...
Lucky. I lasso'd him and dragged him through the pens.
but when i kill people who pulled a gun on me and shot me? lord forbid.
Blew off his limbs and head with shotgun.
Torched him.
Then cut into him with a machette and after that, kicked him.
like the logic just doesnt make sense
Why did I get the bounty?
im on the floor and not from laughing
I think I left his corpse in a pig pen or on tracks, cannot remember.
Anyways...is there a place on this server to ask for help with mods?
rule 15
?
Alright, whatever, then.
can someone explain step for step how to rob the gunsmit in saint denis correctly? people say hogtie first guard, hogtie or melee second guard before shots are fired and it should work. but i always end up getting reported before i get the safe. im not wearing a mask either.
i havent even tried shit with the others cause i never got further than the money on the table 
go in guns blazing, or try throwin blades or smthn
i think i tied the first one and then sprinted at the upstairs one and tackled him and tied him too before he could fire
but the rest went smoothly for me
lol
my condolences para 😞
I think gunsmith is bugged.
I pistol-whip the salesman, interrogate the guard and beat him, hogtie second guard and by the time safe is open, police is already untying the second guard and I am going all guns-blazing on them.
It is actually a very nice real-time faux-cutscene.
I slapped that salesman at same time he started pointing finger at me and screaming: "He is here to rob you-!"
And man, that guard of his needs replacement. One upstairs at least means business and has no qualms about shooting you.
But I have found that using even a throwing knife against one upstairs triggers the bounty.
My advice? Forget the damned safe. Loot the cashier and take cigar, gold nugget and money on table and leave through way for balcony.
That is easy +100 bucks in loot.
the only side buisness i stealthed is the moonshine one 😞
Unless you are interested in killing crooked cops in a cinematic shootout over the rooftops.
yo no way
i just used varmint rifle on battle of shady belle
smokes them in 1 hit bru
...Varmint rifle and bow are most useful weapons in the whole game.
Miau