red-dead-singleplayer

[thin flower]

red dead revolver on my ps2

[midnight ocean]

but ive heard at least like five completely different explanations/theories for how bravery works if at all lol

[thin flower]

it was released even before rdr1 lol

[deep glacier]

Heard that’s a good one

[eternal estuary]

Is it even a real stat

[midnight ocean]

i almost platinumed that a while ago

[thin flower]

Thats wot i need to change i think i will try having multiple horses and switching between otherwise i onyl rock with one horse the entire game all the time

[eternal estuary]

Feels like something people made up to defend this game in debates lol

[midnight ocean]

so good

[deep glacier]

I’ve tried probably 2-3 horses and noticed a difference in them personally. None were the Arabians either

[midnight ocean]

i just got burnt out halfway through revelations

[thin flower]

meh even older than rdr1 but yes for the time i enjoyed it but it was a way smaller project

[midnight ocean]

some say yes some say no. the game itself doesnt show one but does state in descriptions that some horses are braver

[eternal estuary]

I think it’s fake

[midnight ocean]

ive heard some say that theyre all the same except arabians, others say it has to do with the size of the horse due to how the coding is

[eternal estuary]

Someone on PC would’ve revealed it by now

[thin flower]

I tink i can fact check this rq

[midnight ocean]

go ahead and try lol

[peak veldt]

You'd be mistaken.

[midnight ocean]

ive also heard that a developer confirmed bravery is real but also there is no code for it in the files

[eternal estuary]

So it’s not real then lol

[deep glacier]

I mean given the fact that descriptions say some horses are braver than others I’d say it’s a stat but that’s just me

[peak veldt]

The game lies all the time.

[midnight ocean]

well my point is its not shown alongside the health, stamina speed or acceleration

if its a stat why does it not simply show you there

[deep glacier]

Good point there I must say

[eternal estuary]

Cuz it’s most likely not real

[midnight ocean]

i mean i guess it is a stat kinda its just that its not inherent to breed which is usually the claim

because i think a level 4 bond horse is braver than a level 1 bond

the question is whether breed makes a difference

[deep glacier]

I feel it’s dependent on the coat if anything

[midnight ocean]

the most convincing explanation i heard was that whether a horse gets agitated is dependent on the distance from the horse to the predator, but instead of that distance being measured from the actual body of the horse its measured to a single point in the center of the horses body

and for that reason, a larger horse will appear to be able to get closer to a predator than a smaller one

which is why everyone says arabians are the most scared, because theyre the smallest

and larger breeds like ardennes or shire are commonly seen as braver

also ive seen videos of a guy riding an arabian quite close to a grizzly bear without getting thrown

[vital crypt]

that would make the absolute least sense

[vital crypt]

yes thats how its usually done in games

[midnight ocean]

and also most people are basing their opinion of the arabian on the white arabian. most people will capture the white arabian and then immediately ride it back through predator territory which commonly leads to them getting thrown because theyre riding a level 1 horse past grizzlies and wolves

lots of factors at play here lol

[vital crypt]

its been tested so many times its like out of the question atp

[thin flower]

For example

[vital crypt]

but that definitely is a factr

[deep glacier]

I mean I’ve seen debates that it matters so I don’t know. Again, going based on what I’ve seen.

[midnight ocean]

yeah people will be like "i tested this extensively and found the arabian is the most scared even with level 4 bonding, while the ardennes is much braver"

[vital crypt]

no no i mean the other way round!

[midnight ocean]

i know lol but you see people saying both

[vital crypt]

people pull what you mentioned by the hair

mostly clickbait

[peak veldt]

Stat bars on weapons. They aren't tied to actual stats. They're manually set. And wrong in many cases.

[vital crypt]

or people who know better and just want hype in the comments.

[thin flower]

"Some horses will become agitated if they feel threatened or hear loud
noises (such as gunshots). Use silent weapons such as the bow to avoid
spooking a new mount; its courage will increase as you unlock horse
bonding levels."

Tis is from the official rdr2 guide

[midnight ocean]

ok but what does "some horses" mean

[deep glacier]

So basically saying bonding plays a part which makes sense

[peak veldt]

Piggyback? That guide is FILLED with innaccuracies.

[midnight ocean]

also i think the official guide is even wrong about some stuff

[thin flower]

what's the guide wrong about

[peak veldt]

Filled.

[midnight ocean]

cant remember what it was specifically

something to do with honor i think

also like when was the guide written? during development? when they were still cutting and changing stuff?

trust no one

a man who never reads game guides leaves no hostage to fortune

or something

[vital crypt]

wise words or sum

[peak veldt]

Here's some. @thin flower

[lapis panther]

Looks like Micah's Baylock if I remember

[midnight ocean]

missing information is different than incorrect or misleading information

also it clearly does mention bravery since thats where nono pulled his quote from

[peak veldt]

Try reading the whole message

[midnight ocean]

well the first few things sound more like nitpicks

[peak veldt]

So you stopped reading, sure you got the jist, and made a fool of yourself?

I mentioned incorrect information in there too.

[midnight ocean]

everything in there is just missing info except "Challenge categories have the wrong stats associated with them."

[peak veldt]

Missing info is incorrect info

[midnight ocean]

no it is not lol

[peak veldt]

Yes, it is.

[midnight ocean]

unless it states "here is every single weapon" and then fails to list them all

[peak veldt]

If you are listing the rewards for something, and don't list everything, that's incorrect info

[thin flower]

Try being normal

No need to be aggressive for no reason we are discussing a game

[midnight ocean]

not likely

he does this every day

[thin flower]

I wasn't familiar with his game

Every server has one

[midnight ocean]

but we're all the problem clearly lol

[peak veldt]

It's the official strategy guide and it's missing weapons. lol?

[midnight ocean]

official does not mean "100% comprehensive"

notice how i can disagree without insulting you

[thin flower]

That's fine missing information and incorrect information are 2 different things

Which just makes the point about bravery being a stat real lol

Give me examples from the guide where the guide says this thing exists and is very real and the game doesn't have it

[peak veldt]

Your arguments are in bad faith.

[midnight ocean]

no i am being completely genuine with you right now

[thin flower]

I will not tolerate any woolie slander here

[deep glacier]

Deadass tho

[thin flower]

I will tolerare scoopy slander tho

Game is game

[deep glacier]

Oh cmoooooon >:(

[thin flower]

I am sorry it must be done to keep the balance in the universe

[near lily]

Yo

[deep glacier]

Negative honor for you

[thin flower]

I will just hey partner my way to high honor don't worry

[thin flower]

Hey partner

[lapis panther]

Throw fish back too haha

[thin flower]

Quick way to remember the difference:
Missing = “I don’t know” (absence of information)
Incorrect = “I know the wrong thing” (presence of falsehood)
In most practical situations, incorrect information is riskier than missing information because missing data at least signals that caution is needed, whereas wrong data can confidently send you in the wrong direction.
So: different concepts, different implications, and definitely not the same thing.

@peak veldt grok has spoken

[thin flower]

Fishing boring bruh

[peak veldt]

lol grok. CRINGE.

[thin flower]

Imagine getting owned by an AI tho

Couldn't be me

[peak veldt]

a couple days ago, grok was saying Elon Musk could beat Lebron James at basketball

[thin flower]

Here is a version you will understand

Okay, imagine you and your friend are drawing a picture of a dog.

• Missing information is like forgetting to draw the tail.
  There’s just a blank spot where the tail should be. You can see “something is missing.”

• Incorrect information is like drawing a cat tail on the dog by mistake.
  Now the picture looks wrong, but if you don’t know dogs very well, you might think “Oh, dogs have cat tails!” and believe something silly.

So:

• Missing = “Oops, I forgot that part.” (nothing is there)
• Incorrect = “I put the wrong part!” (something is there, but it’s not right)

Missing is like an empty space.
Wrong is like the wrong toy in your toy box.

They’re different! 😊

[thin flower]

Elon is just that guy wot can I say

[lapis panther]

I find it relaxing and passes the time when I want to relax in game

[thin flower]

I can see the appeal ngl

Even gta 6 will have fishing lol

[lapis panther]

Camp can never have too much food

[thin flower]

I don't even refill any supplies bruh

There is nothing to be gained

Give away the things you would have used to some npcs and you don't get anything out of it

[lapis panther]

Once I done camp upgrades I hardly donate money anymore. Which means the dreamer with the plan and the old hag annoy me, but I ignore them

[thin flower]

Same here

I only donate when I want my wallet to look like a good number

Like ending with a 5 or a 0

A superior number

Number racism

Btw I think if you kill the racist guy in saint Denis you get honour lolll

[deep glacier]

Testing this out the second I can

[thin flower]

Confirm for me and you also don't get the police on you

[lapis panther]

Yes the law do nothing

This game rewards you with honour for killing despicable racists

Like the slave catcher, the KKK, and the spastic in Saint Denis

[peak veldt]

Don't call people "spastic".

[lapis panther]

No

[peak veldt]

It's ableist and trashy as hell, Friend.

[lapis panther]

I don't care

Telling me what to say is very counter productive, so quit while you're ahead

[peak veldt]

Because you're fucking trash. Just as a human being.

[midnight ocean]

wow lol

[lapis panther]

Who you calling trash you little cunt?

[midnight ocean]

LOL

[peak veldt]

I'm calling you trash for using slurs. It's trashy and pathetic, and your little anger snap over it really shows the kind of person you are.

[lapis panther]

Okay spastic

[midnight ocean]

btw even if they were, thats not cause to go even lower and start insulting me. if someone is arguing in bad faith, calling them names isnt gonna change that. you can either walk away or, if you wish to continue, be the bigger person. but none of that is an excuse for you anyway, because i have seen you on multiple occasions berate and belittle people who were just ignorant of something or simply looking for help

i think you're just a bully

[deep glacier]

My live reaction:

That escalated so fast because of one word said

[peak veldt]

Not using slurs is actually super easy. Look how you manage it.

woolie is a jackass, but even they don't use slurs. It is an incredibly low bar to clear, and yet!

[deep glacier]

I’ve not once seen woolie be a jackass. Pretty sure that’s a you thing, not to mention you started it by calling Dan trashy as hell like????

[midnight ocean]

funny how im the jackass yet you're the one always name calling and getting into it with people

im so tired of seeing you treat people who just need help on the game like shit

and im just gonna start reporting you from now on

[peak veldt]

If you were to call someone a racist term, and someone called you trashy over it, would the other person have started it? You're defending using slurs right now?

[midnight ocean]

if someone uses a slur, report and move on

[peak veldt]

The first time we interacted, you were putting down a newbie because they didn't know a thing. I called you out on it. You're on a revenge crusade, I got it.

[midnight ocean]

that so did not happen lol

[peak veldt]

I have three examples that I've found in a 5 minute scan of the guide that is incorrect information, even by your definition you defined after the fact. You handwaved those away. Amongst those criticisms, there are many more examples of missing information. For example, you're saying the official strategy guide missing weapons entirely is fine because they don't write the words "Here is literally every weapon in the game". It's the official strategy guide, there's clearly an expectation it is complete in at least listing the available weapons. You are clearly arguing in bad faith.

[midnight ocean]

"anyone who disagrees with me is bad faith and deserves to be ridiculed"

[peak veldt]

Weird quote. When did I type that?

[deep glacier]

Not defending anything. Simply just pointing out facts. If you thought it was a slur being used then you should’ve just reported it and moved on

[autumn lynx]

from what i've seen, woolie is a LOT friendlier than you and it's kinda crazy how you seem to miss the point of his earlier message about you being a bully

[midnight ocean]

its essentially what you're saying when you misconstrue ignorance or disagreement for "arguing in bad faith"

bad faith would be if i knew i was wrong but arguing that im right anyway, which you must just be assuming so that you can be a dick without feeling bad about it

but again that doesnt explain the way you act the rest of the time

[peak veldt]

I don't think you're stupid at all, which only leaves bad faith.

[midnight ocean]

remember when we disagreed about the particular effect of the buck antler trinket a week or so ago? and you later admitted to being wrong? are you stupid or were you arguing in bad faith? which is it?

[peak veldt]

"The official strategy guide doesn't say it's listing every weapon in the game, so it doesn't actually have inaccurate information" is patently bad faith that is further emphasized by also ignoring the numerous other examples of inaccurate or missing information. I don't think you're stupid. I think you choose to say ridiculous things like that just to be contrary.

[peak veldt]

Are you saying that admitting fault and correcting myself is arguing in bad faith?

Bananas.

[deep glacier]

Woolie and ridiculous just doesn’t belong in the same sentence I’m sorry

[midnight ocean]

i mean prior to correcting yourself

when you confidently stated something false as being true

[peak veldt]

Oh? I was wrong. I corrected it after your argument gave me pause and an interest in testing it.

You don't do that. You stick to your guns.

[midnight ocean]

assuming i was wrong, did you give me a chance to correct myself before belittling me?

because as i recall you didnt retract your claim about the trinket until hours later

should i have just started calling you stupid on the spot?

[midnight ocean]

i also went back to refresh myself on this. what happened was i called you rude for the way you responded to me and you replied by claiming i was mocking someone who had just beaten the story by saying they probably didnt have every achievement yet. lol.

[glacial mica]

yeah

indeed

[midnight ocean]

red dead redemption 2

[lapis panther]

What's worse? Chapter 1 or Chapter 5 in Guarma?

[thin flower]

Bahahaahaha

Grok did a number on our boi

[thin flower]

Heard of it ngl

Dang I missed all the drama what a shame

[thin flower]

Next time drama happenin plz tag me

@midnight ocean you 2

[latent glade]

was just drinking in rhodes, and i greeted someone and arthur said "LENNY! oh... not again"

[thin flower]

I have yet to replay chapter 5 so will tell you afterwards but I didn't realize people didn't like chapter 1 lol

I remember it passing quickly and it was ok with the train heist and the o Driscoll shootout

[thin flower]

Man's traumatized

@peak veldt you can talk here no need to be shy and dm me

mans trying to insult me in dms

[deep glacier]

Harassment at this point

[deep glacier]

There’s also a random encounter at camp with Lenny about it if you greet him

[lapis panther]

Chapter 4 Jack's party haha

[lapis panther]

A lot of people find chapter 1 boring

[thin flower]

dw No one harasses me

I like watching people like him seethe

[eternal estuary]

Which is so stupid

The very first mission you’re thrown right into a shootout

And 2 other missions your in a shootout as well

[thin flower]

Man that party is one of the most memorable things in the game. Cuz of all the tension before it and shi and now you celebrate

[lapis panther]

That and Sean's party were good. Was good to see the gang have fun

[thin flower]

Fr

Very interactive and immersive

I think you can even dance with one of the ladies of the group

Mary Beth?

[lapis panther]

Mary-Beth

[thin flower]

I wish

[lapis panther]

Karen asks you to dance in chapter three

[thin flower]

Oh noice

[lapis panther]

When Dutch and Grimshaw dance in camp, Karen will appear and ask Arthur to dance too

[thin flower]

Molly gets curved bruh

Molly was done bad ngl

[lapis panther]

Haha sad but Dutch is looking for fresh meat haha

[thin flower]

How old was molly?

I liked the redhead

[thin flower]

He had his eyes on mary beth if I am not wrong

[lapis panther]

Early 20's? I don't think her age was mentioned

[lapis panther]

Can you blame him? LOL

[thin flower]

You know Arthur and Abigail had sort of a love interest

[thin flower]

Nah nah i understand

[thin flower]

Dang how much fresher he wanted bruh I thot she was in her 30s or something

[lapis panther]

Trade in for a younger model. Until he gets bored and does the same. I don't think Dutch loved any one after Annabelle

[thin flower]

Gon delete that rq

[thin flower]

What a womanizer

👀

[pulsar ruin]

Which one-handed guns are your favorites?

I love the Mausers because they're good overall, and I like the M1899s because I feel they have good stopping power and just look cool.

[lapis panther]

Schofield revolver

[thin flower]

Mausers feel weak

I need to try each and every gun extensively to decide my favorites ngl

My bad habit is finding one good weapon and sticking with it lol

[green whale]

+honour. Just put a bird out of its misery after my cat brought it in and broke both its legs and wing

[empty sequoia]

Yeah cats just do that and they dont even eat it

I mean they do if its a streetcat

A house cat just do that for stimuli

[green whale]

We put him in a room until we got the bird out and when he came down, bro started running around the house looking for it

[solar summit]

ظ

يا شباب

[glacial mica]

English only
it's the server's rules

[solar summit]

I'm from Saudi Arabia and I don't know how to write in English.

[glacial mica]

Are you using a translator right now?

[solar summit]

yes

[thin flower]

You will have to get comfortable with a translator then sorry

[wary radish]

What's the best spot for bison hunting?

[thin flower]

Did you try the spot where the bisons spawn

[solar summit]

[glacial mica]

[wary radish]

Yes

[thin flower]

thats crazy

[wary radish]

The police just shot 2 o Driscoll's that were trying to shoot me

He saved me

[thin flower]

Wot were you doing bruh

Y you didn't kill em

[lapis panther]

I usually batter them and leave them laying in the mud

[gilded quest]

Hello

[wary radish]

They started the fight, and they shot me so the guard absolutely wrecked them

[cunning dove]

is the white arabian the best horse or no

[pure brook]

It's one of the fastest and quickest to accelerate. If that's what your after it's a great horse. But as others will likely say horses are very player specific, people tend to have favourites for different reasons.

[cunning dove]

oh ok thanks

[steep hinge]

Uncle is red Harlow

1911 is when uncle died

1850 was Harlow's youth years

Subtract that and you get 61

Which was how old uncle was in the epilogue

And he says he used to be called the one shot kid

[cunning dove]

and now all he says is "i have lumbago"

[cunning gorge]

when does trapper get unlocked or sum cos i cannot find ir

[pure brook]

Start of chapter 2 you have to find them like most locations to have them added to your map

[lapis panther]

Impossible. Red Harlow was half native American.

[lapis panther]

Bring a carcass to Pearson for the first time and he'll tell you about the trapper

[cunning gorge]

alr thx

also theres only 1 mission on my map in blackwater, but in blackwater im wanted dead or alive

what i do

[soft root]

you uh...go to the edge

there's an edge

by the shoreline

where there ain't any guards

the shoreline close to the mission

yeah, don't stroll in through the road

there's pinkertons at the roads

[placid mango]

is playing as low honour worth it?

im replaying the game and idk

[lapis panther]

Javier mission? Cross the river south east of Lone Mule Stead and you'll be fine. Do not follow the GPS

[cunning gorge]

ok thanks

should i keel my hinour highlr low and what soes it do

[weak acorn]

whats a good horse that has a lot of stamina? preferably black, and not too big or too small

[soft root]

ig if you're looking for a nice black horse that ain't too big, the black american standardbred works

[torn jay]

hi..

[soft root]

me personally I prefer the raven black shire, but you asked for something that's not too big

there's also this reverse dapple black thoroughbred

[vital crypt]

thats ultimate edition only

[soft root]

yeah, so if you have special or ultimate, dapple black thoroughbred

[vital crypt]

i dont think they would be asking if they had it

[soft root]

if you don't, black american standardbred

[soft root]

might've passed over their heads

[vital crypt]

its stats are not good

[soft root]

hi

[vital crypt]

its literally in your stable lmao

[soft root]

well you try finding a nice horse with good stamina that is preferably black

and, you can't find something too big

[vital crypt]

cant have both

/ all

[soft root]

well, they also asked for it not to be too small

so the black arabian is out

not too big? raven black shire is out

[vital crypt]

i know, thats why i said it

[soft root]

yeah, so black american standardbred...is the best option left

[vital crypt]

"preferably black" means its the option you can throw out if you cant include it

lol

[soft root]

ik....

fine, there's also the ardennes and mustang

I am definitely planning to use a mustang next playthrough

they just look so wild

it's perfect

[vital crypt]

the mfts have a good size, stamina is fine
nokota as well. black roan in saint denis i believe

[vital crypt]

they look fine but stats suck so a no for me

[soft root]

they just ain't fast

they have good stats in stamina and health

they are also courageous and have standard handling

so not too sensitive

[vital crypt]

on bonding 4 all horses have the exact same temper

[soft root]

really?

[vital crypt]

yes.

[soft root]

the arabian certainly never not abandoned me

though I never got max bonding with the arabian

[vital crypt]

eh

fine i suppose

[soft root]

what are your opinions on the mustang

[wary radish]

should I shoot compson?

[soft root]

btw, the seal brown dutch warmblood seems to have good stamina when maxed out

[hybrid yarrow]

do it

[wary radish]

no, I'm better than him.

[blissful sky]

.

[weak acorn]

How much?

[vital crypt]

just for character? i love them. my dream horse irl. gorgeous. but theyre not too good in game

[pure brook]

The Mustang to me is like the horse of the wild west, the embodiment of wild and untamed. It was also one of the first horses I got in chapter 2 as there's a wild one close to horseshoe overlook. I loved my Mustang, everyone else disses them, I don't know why.

[vital crypt]

cause the stats aint great. no matter how pretty the horse, theyre simply not really good.

[pure brook]

Yeah but you don't need a 10 speed Arabian to get through the story. I did almost the whole 6 chapters with my Mustang, never felt the need for anything faster/tougher etc etc. I only used the Arabian for posing around St Denis or Valentine 😆. Some of the comments I got from npc had me laughing out at my pc. "Damn that horse is hotter than my wife" or something was funniest

[vital crypt]

you can do the game with a morgan if you wanna. but it saves lots of time and work especially in challenges, open world and the list goes on. my point is that its easy to understand why the majority of players dont enjoy mustangs.

[weak acorn]

Is the Dutch warmblood a good horse in chapter 3?

[pure brook]

Go grab the free wild Perlino Andulusian up north east prob better

[remote raptor]

What's the fastest wild horse

[pure brook]

White Arabian

[vital crypt]

wild or just free to catch?

[cunning gorge]

theres no missions on the map and im only chapter 2. just fjnished the javier mission to save sean i blackwater

[ember ridge]

Yeah there's a party at camp

[cunning gorge]

what i gotta so

do

[ember ridge]

...go to camp?

Have the party or sleep to skip it

[dense gate]

is the trolley mission in chapter 4 the end of chapter 4?

[azure sluice]

no

"Banking, the Old American Art" is the last mission in Chapter 4

[manic cipher]

Anyone got convenient panther spawn locations?

I'm looking in the forest very south of rhodes

[pure brook]

That or East of Lagras lake

[hybrid yarrow]

halfway

[cunning dove]

is low honor john better than high honor john

[gaunt sky]

low honor

no need for high hnor in epilouge

f*ck them saint dennis street urchins

[manic cipher]

for the trophy of getting a bounty of 250$ in each state, should I just go on a world war level killing spree?

[cursive mulch]

Is there a noticeable difference playing rdr 2 on dlss quality compared to native ?

On a high end gpu

[pure brook]

Damn straight! 😆

[weak acorn]

Does your bounty matter that much? I have like a 300 dollar bounty on most areas and I don’t wanna pay the bounty

[cursive mulch]

You’ll get constantly chased by bounty hunters

It’s up to you if you wanna deal with that

[trim hamlet]

me, who doesn't care and just plays the game casually:

(wait why the hell am I 7 hours up the chat )

[glacial juniper]

is micah's revolver better than the classic double action revolver?

[trim hamlet]

like, let's be realistic here

i don't give a singular fuck about horse stats as long as it doesn't feel sluggish

[lapis panther]

High honour. It fits the narrative of him trying to go straight.

[cunning lodge]

Ive played both games but does jack ever learn to read

I cant remember

[knotty remnant]

I thought it was kinda well known?

In undead nightmare intro you can see him reading

Pretty big chunk of the intro too

[deep glacier]

Swear this game just knows when you need 3 star animals

[cunning lodge]

was just tryna make sure hosea's efforts wasnt in vain

[ember ridge]

He's always reading in the Epilogue of rdr2 aswell

[lapis panther]

So true

[lapis panther]

Hosea taught him and he can be seen reading in the epilogue

[lapis panther]

The mission where the gang attack the O'Driscoll's at their mining camp is one of my favourites. Same with the train robbery.

[grizzled haven]

Every train robbery with the gang is so fucking fun

[thin flower]

too bad they heavily punish you doing those in free mode

one of my bigger complaints with rdr2

You, as an outlaw shouldnt lose honor doing outlaw things

Not only honour but then you are hunted by bounty laws and they wont leave you alone until you pay a hefty fine for your crimes

[lapis panther]

Just like real life haha

Commit a crime and get caught. Pay a heavy price, unless you get a warning and slap on the wrist haha

[lapis panther]

I agree

[proud spire]

It is

[dense gate]

can someone answer me in #red-dead-media please :)

[thorny cargo]

done

[dense gate]

thank yew

[thorny cargo]

yw yw

[manic cipher]

it doesn't matter as much, you can play like that if you enjoy killing bounty hunters every now and then,
but my concern was regarding the achievement where we need to survive 3 days in each state with a bounty of over 250 dollars

[weak acorn]

Oh I don’t mind the bounty hunters they die so easily

[manic cipher]

it gets intense after like 600 dollars when there are like 20 people running after you

[vital crypt]

so special aint'cha

i was just explaining why people dont enjoy the mustang lol

[lapis panther]

Mustangs ain't bad, but not the best of horses. I like the Tiger Striped Bay Mustang you can get in the epilogue though.

[lapis panther]

Makes the game more fun having a price on your head in numerous states

[drifting lichen]

Guys how i get a perderci gila monster pelt?

[grizzled haven]

exactly

[vital crypt]

just lost honour killing enemies dogs that were tryna kill me

im sorry, what?

also can someone tell me why tf the losing honour sound keeps playing during autotravel although im literally looking at the screen and everythings fine?? havent run anyone over or sum

[lapis panther]

Bounty hunter dogs?

[vital crypt]

nah

[solid trench]

Is it just me who decides to go the other way when bounty hunters appear

[vital crypt]

the one of that woman up the stream by hanging dog ranch

like mate theyre marked enemies

[lapis panther]

Hermit woman? Yes you lose honour for that

[vital crypt]

i said that..?

i know

[lapis panther]

Also you lose honour for killing wolf man's wolves too

[vital crypt]

idk who that is

[lapis panther]

He's in Roanoke north of Beaver Hollow near the river

I know you lose honour for being out of camp for more than three days

As well as other silly things

[steel palm]

i got rdr2 today

[lapis panther]

Enjoy

[spring light]

Real

[manic cipher]

bros in for a ride

[manic cipher]

Nah I just kill them and loot them

[steel palm]

im on chapter 2 rn no missions done just freeroam

[vital crypt]

huh

ive 100% done that

[vital crypt]

dont waste your time, youre missing out on important features that you obtain in missions in chapter 2

[manic cipher]

Oh I just spedran missions, and I'm doing the freeroam now

[vital crypt]

not enjoying the main objective of the game is a strong one

[steel palm]

my honor is really low rn

[manic cipher]

yeah I was too hooked on the story 😭🙏🏻

[steel palm]

i mean theres a little bit too much horse riding

[fresh ibex]

Same I’m doing the bandit challenge and it’s knocked my honour bro

[steel palm]

so far

[manic cipher]

i checked my animal compendium after all the missions,
I was at 7/178

[vital crypt]

saying that about rdr2 isnt the brightest

[steel palm]

im probably gonna download the gun tricks mod it looks cool

[vital crypt]

rule 15 i think

[steel palm]

yeah but like 90% of each mission is just actually horse riding to the mission

[steel palm]

but i only do singleplayer

[vital crypt]

what do you want? for it to spawn you to the mission? theres a lot of immersive dialogue

[vital crypt]

no mod or glitch discussions at all

[steel palm]

still its just a bit too much

[steel palm]

mb

[fresh ibex]

I’m not surprised tbh, do u want to be spawned straight there?

[vital crypt]

has never seemed too much for me. the chats they have are always interesting

[steel palm]

i think i was already told that

[vital crypt]

good thing theyre joining in.

[steel palm]

it says talking about how to download or distributing them is prohibited

[manic cipher]

Some missions have important lore implications, and also some are missable depending on your interactions, so that's a little important

[fresh ibex]

Agreed

And it also makes the game more realistic

[vital crypt]

and its not like you ride ten minutes. its usually not more than two

[steel palm]

i mean idk ive only done the chapter 1 missions so far

[vital crypt]

then do the c2 ones

[steel palm]

tomorrow

[manic cipher]

yeah I love the horse riding in this, I only fast travel for extremely far distances, like, Saint Denis to tumbleweed type stuff

[vital crypt]

onwards from chapter three is your time for free roam

[vital crypt]

i do fast travel because i have explored the game VERY thoroughly

but before that? never

[fresh ibex]

Yeah or when I gotta get somewhere rlly quick

In my first play through i didnt even know you could fastravel

[vital crypt]

i didnt find out till chapter four

[manic cipher]

I have explored a huge chunk of the game during the animal hunt I was doing for compendium, it's actually magnificent

[vital crypt]

because i didnt need it either

[manic cipher]

I also figured it out post epilogue

[vital crypt]

yeah i mean i am used to open world and i explore very thoroughly in every game. now im focusing on hunting and treasure maps.

but now i barely have stuff left to discover

all houses been looked into, all gang hideouts raided, all landmarks done

[steel palm]

is it possible to kill a bear close range before it gets to jump on u

[vital crypt]

yes

[manic cipher]

shotgun🙏🏻

[steel palm]

i used one but i was like really close

[vital crypt]

you can also scare a bear away for a moment by shooting anywhere else. it buys time

[fresh ibex]

IVE only found the del lobo hideout through my 5 playthroughssss idk where the others are

[steel palm]

i didnt even see the bear i just heard it and saw it way too late

[vital crypt]

google..?

[vital crypt]

pause and logout to not lose anything

[fresh ibex]

Shush I feel dumb now

[manic cipher]

I've completed a gang hideout as I found them randomly,
I am just focusing more on the animals rn

[steel palm]

i didnt die tho i killed it

just started spamming f

[vital crypt]

defo should ❤️

[vital crypt]

thrn where is the problem

[steel palm]

i wanted to know if u could kill it before it attacks u

[vital crypt]

course?

[steel palm]

didnt say it was happening rn

[fresh ibex]

Bro I didn’t know that no matter how you killed a legendary animal the pelt would be perfect so I would keep restarting my game if I killed one wrong

[manic cipher]

man these farmstead people are always so angry, like,
bro, I just want to binocular your pig,
let me do it, I'll leave

[fresh ibex]

At emerald ranch THEYRE so rudeee

[vital crypt]

i figured that out on my first legendary

i massacred that coyote

[fresh ibex]

No I’m just a dumbass

[vital crypt]

i always kill their animals for all trapper items so thats fair

[fresh ibex]

Me too

[manic cipher]

guess what,
I found a legendary cougar or coyote it was one of those, I think in new austin,
the animal was lying down in pain, I just had to shoot one bullet,
a rattlesnake bit me

[solid trench]

Eh i dont wanna have to sleep it off again

[fresh ibex]

I hate all snakes in rdr2

[vital crypt]

theyre so annoying.

[steel palm]

how do people on those short tiktok clips kill and not immediately get chased by bounty hunters? are they modding or am i missing something

[vital crypt]

you CANT hit em proper

[solid trench]

Or waste some of my snake oil/miracle cures

[vital crypt]

they always spook your horse

[vital crypt]

people still need to report lol or wdym

[solid trench]

I think the coyote is in lemoyneish

[manic cipher]

I think I have studied and skinned all snakes except guarma,
and I am so happy I got all those randomly, I have little patience, and I will not be looking around 1 hour for something moving in the water

[vital crypt]

just above rhodes

[solid trench]

Yeah so lemoyneish almost in new hanover by valentine

[vital crypt]

thats pretty damn far from valentine

[fresh ibex]

Reall

[steel palm]

is online worth playing?

[manic cipher]

some of the problems I will be experiencing in this hunt will now be,
red tailed hawk, rio grande turkey, coastal horned owl, ring necked pheasant(forgot to skin this one and magically just cant find it anywhere now)

[manic cipher]

never played it but it looks fun(unless your goal is achievement hunting)

[fresh ibex]

All the birds will be the death of me

[manic cipher]

nah you go to a riverside,
there will be plenty and plenty just chilling on rocks

the tiny ones are annoying when they start flying tho

[fresh ibex]

Thank you gnggg

[manic cipher]

birds are considerably easy(tiny but they actually spawn commonly),
Moose, arguably the biggest normal animal in the game,
I think it took me about 4 hours to find both mooses

[vital crypt]

absolutely not

[manic cipher]

I looked at the online trophies, and I just made up my mind that I wont do the online stuff

95% of it is just bullying etta doyle

[vital crypt]

its super glitchey and full of shit people and hackers

[lapis panther]

I always go at a steady pace unless I am in a race, chasing or being chased.

[lapis panther]

Dewberry Creek

[placid pilot]

Its not that hard as you think

The online has a pretty decent story, considering they didn't update it in years

The only hard trophy I struggled with is "The real deal", that one took a few days to complete

Anything else is pretty easy

[thin flower]

Yeh but just cuz it's realistic doesn't mean its a good choice to put it in a game

[placid pilot]

The bounty hunters are hella unrealistic, u can go all the way to the grizzlies and they will still find u, be there few days, they will spawn every single one of em

[thin flower]

They just don't want you committing crimes

.....in a game where you are supposed to be an outlaw committing crimes

[surreal creek]

What fit should I get from the trapper this playthrougu

[thin flower]

This is why they punish you so heavily you just can't enjoy the game when constantly being hunted by bounty hunters even the random events despawn if they are near and the fines are too high for you to be able to pay them constantly

Not to mention how much you lose honour

[surreal creek]

I barely hunted last time

2nd playthrough

[thin flower]

The segsy one

[surreal creek]

Which would that be

Also should I go low honour

[thin flower]

You can kill, rob and loot anyone you want without worrying

[placid pilot]

They're just annoying

[manic cipher]

okay so you are telling me that "notorious" is an easy trophy?

its more like a me problem but I dont really have he patience to bully etta doyle like 20 million times

[placid pilot]

I'm lvl 130, you don't have to grind Etta Doyle 24/7, just play the missions, do bounty hunting, have fun with ur friends

That's what I did

[thorny cargo]

notorious is hard if youre actively trying to get it. just play the game and youll naturally get it without even realizing

[manic cipher]

yeah friends are out of the question, they can't see a world outside of cod mobile

I mean, if it's not that bad I'll consider when I buy ps+

[placid pilot]

Yeah, been there, codm took over my life one time I was grinding that shi 6 hours daily 🤣🤣

[manic cipher]

mine too, I am legendary in both br and multiplayer rn😭🙏🏻

but I haven't played in like 2 weeks

[placid pilot]

I was just grinding mp

Had a lot of shi ngl

[manic cipher]

I mostly grind mp alone, and br when friends call

[placid pilot]

Oh nice

Got any mythics?

[thin flower]

You can't camp properly and you miss a ton of events they are more than annoying

You don't deal with em and your honor will go to 0

[manic cipher]

nah

I did get most of the legendary skins of this update tho, the f2p ones

[placid pilot]

Yeah sadly

[manic cipher]

ak117 is taking some time

[placid pilot]

That's the reality

I had like 6

Mythics

2 maxed

[manic cipher]

f2p or money?

[placid pilot]

Dlq lotus

Money

[manic cipher]

oh man I love that skin

the fact that im my teams sniper

for BR i mostly use DL or tundra, for MP i'll use outlaw for the unreal quickscope

[placid pilot]

Yeah it's insane

Krig 6 maxed out

Ofen

Oden also

Templar maxed out too

[vital crypt]

outlaw scores under both lol

[placid pilot]

never got used to playing

Outlaw

Ngl

[vital crypt]

outlaw is fine, but its got a marshmallow feeling to it

i have it gold and both dlq and tundra diamond, you do feel the quality difference

[placid pilot]

I was just rocking krig 6 and for sniper the locus

[vital crypt]

tundra took me a long time to get used to though. very stiff for the first few weeks

[vital crypt]

krig is long long gone

[placid pilot]

Yeah, the movement was different

[placid pilot]

I was at lb

With it

32 I think

[vital crypt]

wasted potential then:D

[vital crypt]

i never quite enjoyed it but its meta so uh do what you gotta do

[placid pilot]

Fr

[vital crypt]

ak117 is long gone as well, i just love it sadly

[placid pilot]

Stopped playing the game maybe month ago

Not planning on returning tbh

[placid pilot]

Yeah sadly

[vital crypt]

stopped playing long ago

my mentor ghosted me and my clan as well

i lost the fun afterwards

i play br sometimes but thats more for relaxation

[placid pilot]

I don't play anything rn lol

PUBG maybe

And ps games

Wbu

[vital crypt]

pubg is complete and utter trash i will not lie

on mobile i dont "game" anymore

freaking hayday alright

grinding that

subway surfers and piano tiles cause im autistic and gotta live up to the standards of being unruly good at rhythm games and similar

[placid pilot]

Fair enough

[placid pilot]

I meant pubgm

But pubg on ps is good too

I enjoy it a lot

[vital crypt]

yeah exactly

its trash

[manic cipher]

im grinding clash royale

i really feel like bending my phone sometimes

but then I realise it cost money

[vital crypt]

[spice jetty]

I just finished chapter 2 do I stick with my Arabian white horse or do I get a mustang or smth different

[thorny cargo]

personally im not a fan of arabians... i say get something that appeals to you visually and personality wise since you dont really have a need for speed

[spice jetty]

What if I get a horse that’s good for fighting

[thorny cargo]

like a draft/big horse?

those are the ones i usually like to get

shire, suffolk, belgian, etc

mustang

[spice jetty]

Idk much

I heard smth about a mustang

[thorny cargo]

uuuhhhhhhhh yes i mean

there are wild mustangs

in the heartlands

and others places but you cant go there as arthur

[spice jetty]

Is the tiger striped mustang decent?

[thorny cargo]

yes, but you cant get that as arthur

thats in new austin

[spice jetty]

Oh you play as different characters?

Later on

[thorny cargo]

this is your first playthrough?

basically arthur cant access the area with the tiger-striped mustang, yes

however if you go to the heartlands, which is east of horseshoe overlook, there should be wild mustangs around there

[spice jetty]

Yes this is my first

[spice jetty]

Is it better than my white Arabian?

[thorny cargo]

well

stats? no. visually imo? yes

[pulsar ruin]

Has anyone heard an NPC voice when there was no visible NPC around?

[manic cipher]

man I really wish we could ride an american bison or a moose

it would be really funny

[deep glacier]

How many trophies you at

[manic cipher]

15300

[thorny cargo]

arabian is one of the fastest horses in the game, but personally i think that its too small and too skittish, so i prefer to get bigger horses

[manic cipher]

*arabian has the fastest acceleration

[spice jetty]

Is bigger horses braver?

[manic cipher]

as far as I recall, arabian does not have the highest speed

(my bad, I didnt read "one of the" before the arabian)

[thorny cargo]

yes

this is true

[deep glacier]

Arabian overrated in my opinion respectfully

[thorny cargo]

i think the missouri is the fastest in terms of actual speed? but only 5 accelerationb

[thorny cargo]

exactly

[thorny cargo]

yes, against predators

[vital crypt]

there is no such thing as bravery in rdr2.

[vital crypt]

you can max out the arabians speed as well

[spice jetty]

What about the turkoman

[thorny cargo]

bigger horses spook less to predators than smaller horses do

[vital crypt]

there is no such thing as bravery in rdr2.. to you too

[thorny cargo]

i think thats a good horse, sure

honestly just pick something based on YOUR preference

[manic cipher]

I think I have the thoroughbred horse,
I dont really know the stats

[vital crypt]

there is no such recorded thing. but somebody here said its likely because the center of mass

bigger horses are not braver and smaller horses are not less brave

bonding related only

[spice jetty]

I prefer the tiger striped mustang but I can’t get that ig I’ll just think with my Arabian

Thanks for the help

[vital crypt]

which would make sense, but then its purely distance related and fools the eye.

[thorny cargo]

no, im pretty sure its based off breed? ive read somewhere that larger horses like draft and mustang dont spook as easily to predators compared to horses like arabians, even on full bonding

[vital crypt]

it is not

this has been proven wrong so many times this game is so old people need to let it go

[thorny cargo]

ohh ok i just looked at a forum and apparently youre right there is no such thing as bravery

the internet fooled me

i still prefer bigger horses for other reasons anywho though

[vital crypt]

forums are not the best place

[thorny cargo]

well i mean like

not forum sorry

a verified source

tested

[deep glacier]

I mean new players don’t know that

[manic cipher]

when I buy a PC,
I will mod so that I can put saddle on any animal,
and ride the Bull gator and Golden Eagle

[vital crypt]

most people who claim bravery is a real thing are not new players

[thorny cargo]

i learned it WHEN i was new and nobody ever told me it was untrue and i never found out

[thorny cargo]

like me but now i know

[vital crypt]

doubt it, cause its wrong? lmao

[manic cipher]

the only thing brave was me to attempt the platinum of this game

[vital crypt]

youre good

[vital crypt]

LMAO

good on ya

[thorny cargo]

no like, that there is no bravery

not that there is

i meant that i was reading on how its proven to not be a real thing

[manic cipher]

i started off the animal compendium with like 7,
now I'm at 147,
I'm so close, so so close

[deep glacier]

How many animals are there total in the compendium again?

[vital crypt]

ahh

[manic cipher]

I think 156 excluding guarma and legendary

[vital crypt]

yeah it aint. the human mind is incredible. if you believe something enough it starts actually feeling like it in experience

even small things such as bravery

[thorny cargo]

178 in total

[vital crypt]

humans expect a lot. so much they start to truly believe it

[manic cipher]

162

[deep glacier]

Tis a lot of animals

[thorny cargo]

you dont need all of them tho

[manic cipher]

yeah I was looking for lizards in the bushes of new austin

really fun

[vital crypt]

quick reminder that night folk can and will kill your horse if you leave it

[manic cipher]

I missed a bird by a fraction of a second left to study, because it flew too far, yes

[vital crypt]

i hate that

[manic cipher]

What's night folk

[vital crypt]

the people in the swamp

enemies

[manic cipher]

Oh

[trim hamlet]

yep

i know I'm really unique /s

[thorny cargo]

i hate the night folk so much

[vital crypt]

one of the only moments i have ever been scared in rdr2

[thorny cargo]

truth nuke

[vital crypt]

not even related to a phobia which makes it more special

[manic cipher]

Ohhhh these homeless individuals

[thorny cargo]

lmao

[manic cipher]

Yes, i kill them

[vital crypt]

when they sneak up on you they make these whispers and clicking noises before jumping you

DONE

[deep glacier]

Lagras area in general is just freaky

[thorny cargo]

yeah NO..

[trim hamlet]

wait, that WHAT can and will kill your horse if you leave it?!

[vital crypt]

they can, yes

unrevivable

[trim hamlet]

where can this happen

[vital crypt]

where night folk roams

general swamp area

[trim hamlet]

but like
where do they roam

oh

[manic cipher]

Swampy areas around Saint Denis I believe

[deep glacier]

Wonder if they’ll take your horse if you set up a camp and then sleep

[manic cipher]

There can be more, Saint Denis is the only place I've encountered them

Yes we get it dyno

[vital crypt]

only if you walk away and leave your horse

[vital crypt]

dumbass

[manic cipher]

Ahhhh

Also, is there any possible way to get to the island on the right of the map?

[vital crypt]

only other thing i am afraid of is caves, including the cougar mission in strawberry. im really claustrophobic and caves are like NO

[vital crypt]

no

you will, in a mission

[manic cipher]

oh trust me I'm entering a cave, both the guns I use will be the double barrel, or the pump shotgun

Yeah the mission I have done, so, can't go back there, 😔

[vital crypt]

i shot it at the mouth of the cave but it was really uncomfortable overall

[manic cipher]

also I can't really find a place to spend money, I've bought a lot of guns, I need to spend around 2.5k more

[vital crypt]

phobias are acceptable until they appear in games tbh

thats just awkward

[manic cipher]

how do elevators feel

[deep glacier]

Horses are a good way to blow through it

[vital crypt]

im more afraid of escalators lol

i dont use elevators a lot

very very rarely

[manic cipher]

escalators are scary yes

[vital crypt]

god i hate them

the really steep ones in train stations??? get me away

[manic cipher]

i don't hate them, but god do they feel weird

[vital crypt]

i do

[manic cipher]

I once saw a guy going down on an upwards escalator, i was getting triggered... A lot

bro was not moving from that spot

[vital crypt]

i didnt use to be scared but my dog was and for some reason i adapted to it

[manic cipher]

I want a dog 😔

[vital crypt]

i dont have a dog anymore

my mother wants one

i dont

cause all the work is going to ME

[deep glacier]

I have 5 of them take one of mine please

[manic cipher]

Give it to me 🙏🏻😭

[vital crypt]

im so stressed dawg

i feel like im gonna blow up

getting a mcflurry

[manic cipher]

i have an exam in like 12 hours, but I need to sleep 8 of those

[vital crypt]

omg real

i have an exam wednesday

havent studied

tomorrow is me mothers birthday

tuesday i have to ride my horse

[manic cipher]

I have today, I have studied, but I have forgotten

[manic cipher]

u know how to ride a horse?

I've only been on a horse like, once

[dreamy canyon]

Odriscolls made my horse suffer and i killed every last one of them

[real flint]

how goes it my Odriscolls and Pinkertons, I have a question. I'd really like to play this game from the beginning with my dad this Christmas season. He's a big Clint Eastwood guy so I think he'd like it, I might even download some mods for the second playthrough.

My question is, I just finished John's epilogue. I have done very little side missions post arthur, so Im curious now that Im finished (i think) is it okay to restart the game or should I still do some side missions before? December's right around the corner so i gotta know soon

[midnight ocean]

you might as well just restart i think

[thorny cargo]

you can restart the game and come back to the side missions later in that save if you want

[real flint]

gotcha, so after john "reproposes" to Abigail then its like the "end" until red dead 1?

[thorny cargo]

well... no

there is still another mission after that that is the END. as in no more story missions

i recommend doing that

[real flint]

gotcha

[thorny cargo]

youll know when the game is over, itll roll credits

[real bone]

aw man why arthur kicked strauss

oh nevermind

i got a lot of honour

holy shit

[pure brook]

Cause he's trying to do the right thing, Straus just caused misery to everyone

[placid pilot]

@vital crypt why did bro get muted 😭

[real bone]

fr

[pure brook]

You mustve done what I did and dissolved the last two debts!

[real bone]

i dissolved both of the debts

yo

what is the mission that arthur says ' i am afraid'??

[pure brook]

Oof I can't remember now. Last 2 chapters of Arthur were kind of a blur to me

[placid pilot]

It's not a mission

[pure brook]

I didn't enjoy them at all

[placid pilot]

At emerald ranch, u can meet nun, idk her name, and start a dialogue w her

[real bone]

ohh

thanks friend

[placid pilot]

But it depends

U might need to do some side missions forst

First*

[real bone]

alrr

how do i get rid of my temp horse

i dont even know why i have an temp horse

[midnight ocean]

sell it

[midnight ocean]

stranger mission in chapter 5/6

in saint denis not emerald ranch

its called "of men and angels"

[real bone]

ty partner

[placid pilot]

Really?

[midnight ocean]

wait no

i guess it is emerald ranch

[deep glacier]

To add to what everyone else has mentioned it’s also part of the Penelope/beau side quest. It’ll trigger once you finish the last part of their quest

[placid pilot]

It is

The I'm afraid cutscene is Chapter 6 at rmerald ranch station, after Favored Sons mission. The earlier nun missions are in Saint Denis, but the emotional final meeting is not

I think your honor plays a role too

For that part

[midnight ocean]

i think the way it works is swanson shows up instead of calderon if either you didnt do the other nun missions or your honor is too low

and swanson has something different to say if its high or low

[placid pilot]

Yeah I think that too, you need low honor for that

And neutral/high for the nun

[deep glacier]

I thought you get Swanson if you didn’t do the nun quests? Not that it’s dependent on your honor level?

[placid pilot]

Hmm

[deep glacier]

What he and Arthur says in their dialogue is honor dependent tho

But I’m certain you get Swanson if you don’t do the nun quests. Honor is a factor with the dialogue

[placid pilot]

Mb gng

[spice jetty]

what should i buy with my 600 cash

[placid pilot]

The nun appears at ranch only if you did her Saint Denis interactions
If you skipped those, you get Swanson instead.
Honor just changes the dialogue, not the character.

[placid pilot]

What chapter u in?

[spice jetty]

early 3

like one mission in

also what ammmuntion does the varmit rifle take

[placid pilot]

.22

[placid pilot]

Just spend it on whatever makes the game more fun for you

If I was you, I would do few treasure maps, save up more

And get a better horse

Or upgrade the camp

[spice jetty]

i have the white arabian i was planning to get the tiger striped mustang

bc i like the look on it

[placid pilot]

If u like it, go for it

[spice jetty]

if im taming a horse can i have the horse without a saddle follow me when im on the new horse

[placid pilot]

Yeah it will follow ya

[spice jetty]

do i go for the male white arbian or the turkoman on the horse flesh mission

is the male the same as the female

just with a mark

[placid pilot]

Yeahh

[placid pilot]

Depends on u

Do u like Arabian or turkoman

In my opinion, turkomans are better

[spice jetty]

I heard the Arabian is fast but a coward

[placid pilot]

It's really fast

But small too

[spice jetty]

What’s with the turkoman

[placid pilot]

Turkomans are like the perfect mix

Fast also tough as hell

They're not cowards lol

But it's up to you, whatever you like the most

[spice jetty]

I’m going with that then

In missions where I’m forced to kill people does my honor go down

[placid pilot]

Nope, mission-required kills don’t lower your honor. If the game forces you to kill someone, you don’t get punished for it. Honor only drops from optional stuff

[spice jetty]

When I free Micah the town started to shoot at us and my honor went down

[placid pilot]

Maybe u shot random npcs

[midnight ocean]

how did you free him

[azure sluice]

Yeah happens to me all the time

So far I’ve either used the pulley or freed him from the inside

[midnight ocean]

well if you free from inside then i wouldnt be surprised if you lose honor since you're intentionally choosing the most violent method

[thorny cargo]

your honor goes down no matter which escape method you use, it goes down because of when you kill the lawmen

[thin flower]

Huh i had no idea it went down in missions too

[thorny cargo]

yes, usually just in missions where youre killing a lot of lawmen. it is frustrating in that mission because you dont really have a choice but its jjst a feature they have

[spice jetty]

Th steam donkey or wtv

[grizzled haven]

you blow up micah the wall with dynamite

[thin flower]

I guess they do it to make it a bit accurate

they make arthur do bad stuff and lose honor forcefully so the story makes sense

[solid trench]

Arabians have better handling

Also you can get a free one that has very good stats

In chapter 2 no less

[midnight ocean]

habibi is the cbvids of arabians

those who know

[solid trench]

Im arabian, inshallah i will ride the horses that killed the roman and persian empires to battle against the pinkertons

[placid pilot]

Pony ahh horse

[solid trench]

The word is the word that tyrants like cornwall meet an end by express Schofield revolver shot

[thin flower]

dont tell zesty you are an arabian

we aint responsbile for wotever he does to u then

[midnight ocean]

in fact just dont even talk to zesty

[solid trench]

He seems alright he sent me a animal guide

What does he do to arabian horses

[thin flower]

arabians in general man

[thin flower]

u are saying he alr made it to the dms?

bois we might have been too late this time

[winged charm]

Hi, for some reason I keep getting out of Memory errors most of the time when I try to start the game.

It started happening a lot once I reached the Saint Denis chapter

[winged charm]

this is just simply booting up the game, it hadn't even loaded in Story mode yet

This never happened before, and it's inflating my Pagefile.sys file to absurd numbers. It is at 40 GB rn because of the Out of Memory errors caused when I try to start rdr2.

[deep glacier]

Rockstar support is the way to go my friend

[winged charm]

Oh ok, thanks for ur advice!

Do you have any similar problems?

[deep glacier]

Can’t say I do since I’m console but I’ve heard pc has all sorts of issues

[thin flower]

no skill issues here i am afraid

[thin flower]

how u doin

[deep glacier]

Doin well, how about yourself?

[thin flower]

better than u noobie

[deep glacier]

Not the real life antagonize

[thin flower]

U think i am only low honour in game???

[deep glacier]

Crazy work

On a real note tho why tf are possums just as rare as moose

3 star ones I mean

[thin flower]

i dont remember possums i remember beavers tho bruh

falling into the water and shi all the time

[thin flower]

i get crazier dw

roasting others is how i bond with them

[deep glacier]

Wait till you do the hunting requests

[midnight ocean]

no way lol

i think they appear more at night

[deep glacier]

They do but mine are always 1-2 star

Never a 3 star, feelsbadman

[placid mango]

i swear they are litreally torture i gave up

[deep glacier]

I’ve surprisingly been doing well with them. Breezed through the birds for the 3rd request, I just can’t seem to get a possum

[placid mango]

well goodluck😭

[thin flower]

Oh yeh need to finish those

[midnight ocean]

i wanna say emerald ranch

[thorny cargo]

the way that i got them was via the forest just south west of big valley. make a save in the morning and then sleep till night, do some rounds looking for opossums

[midnight ocean]

i find a lot of little critters around the dried up riverbed to the west

[thorny cargo]

sometimes i also kill the cougar and opossums will show up to the corpse

[midnight ocean]

and yeah definitely in big valley

[thorny cargo]

rinse and repeat until you get a three star. just be patient because its not guaranteed and theyre pretty rare, let alone a 3 star

mhm

[deep glacier]

Definitely noticed 3 stars are rare, been getting 1-2 stars consistently

[midnight ocean]

i remember one time i was reading chat while riding from owanjila to strawberry and someone was complaining about 3 star possums, and i looked back at my screen and there was one playing dead right in front of me lol

i felt bad

[deep glacier]

Feelsbadman

It be like that tho

Forget who it was but someone here was having a hard time finding woodpeckers. Meanwhile I found mine in 5 seconds

[midnight ocean]

woodpecker drove me crazy when i first started my 100% run because i started the hunting requests super early and didnt know what i was doing

robin also took me a while later on

[thin flower]

Ok I will have to start the hurting requests soon cuz it seems like they take time

[placid pilot]

Hunting ones?

Oof those are annoying

Damn robin took me ages

[midnight ocean]

for sure, also just look up what you need ahead of time since all small carcasses and be stored indefinitely until the epilogue

[thin flower]

Oho that's good to know

[midnight ocean]

but yeah you will need basically every single one of the tiny bird species

[thorny cargo]

also make sure you have the right weapons. varmint rifle and bow with small game arrows

those kill birds

[midnight ocean]

robin, songbird, waxwing, cardinal, blue jay, woodpecker

so if you happen to see three star ones try to get them

all require small game arrows

[thin flower]

Ah yes yes got those down

Ever since legend of east

[thorny cargo]

i have the spots of where they spawn most frequent memorizekd but cant remember the names... i do know waxwings fly consistently over fort riggs

crows are there too, cuz if i remember correctly u need a perfect crow

robins are on one of the islands off of braithwaite manor/clemens point

[midnight ocean]

i got my robin in the river south of strawberry

[thorny cargo]

a blue jay spawns on the fallen down tree near horshoe overlook going towards valentine... if that makes sense.

ah

yes all the birds have multiple spots and some work better than others its really a hit or miss...

woodpecker i got along the river northeast of valentine? in that spot with the little piece of land in the middle of the river

northwest*

essentially the internet will give you reliable spots

if you need exact spots on the map anytime just ask and i can provide! i cant explain well

ok im done

[thin flower]

Utube and rdr2 map for the win lol

[thorny cargo]

yupyup

[thin flower]

Yipyip appa

[thin flower]

Can you repeat it

[thin flower]

Tell me you got that

[thorny cargo]

so

i can probably send you the exact spots for some of them

hold on

[thin flower]

Plz do thank you

[deep glacier]

Fort Bennard is a good place for the Robin and woodpecker. Got both of em from there

Wait no actually, this prairie area between hanging dog ranch and pronghorn ranch is a good spot for the birds

[midnight ocean]

i favor rivers

since its easy to spot them perched on the tops of the boulders

and gives you a clear path to follow when searching

[thorny cargo]

yup

[deep glacier]

Thank you so much for suggesting big valley for the possum btw

If I could type in all caps in here I would

[lapis panther]

I always find a possum at night in the Heartlands near Oil Derrick

[thorny cargo]

ofccc! glad i could help