red-dead-singleplayer

[worn solar]

If they make a rdr3 they should make the money so useful

[ember ridge]

But no what I was gonna say. Is I'll take my leave now before I spoil things people clearly haven't seen yet 😭

[worn solar]

I just say random things I think is right I watch the cutscene again and realize I am insanely wrong

[ember ridge]

Nah I'm not worried about you, tis the other two

[worn solar]

Ahh

[worn solar]

I ruined the game for myself because I searched up rdr2 and immediately got told if you shoot Micah in this mission

[ember ridge]

My friends ruined it for me

[jaunty lagoon]

Samee

My friend that got me into rdr2 spoiled so much of the damn ending while i was on like chapter 2

[tight turret]

I knew that SOMEONE died at the start, but all the other content was all new to me

[jaunty lagoon]

Just as long as it’s not fully spoiled

Cuz stuff getting spoiled sucks

[worn solar]

My friends would immediately scream the main sentence in the end mission the second i would join a call

[jaunty lagoon]

Broo😭

[tight turret]

I gotta admit i wasn't interested in the game at the start

but in valentine and rhodes i changed my mind

[worn solar]

In my second playthrough I was like when is this over and I finished the train mission I loaded the game up again and I forgot to save

Chapter 1 is really boring imo its just about finding John,food and stuff

[tight turret]

"Hey scarface"

[worn solar]

"Never thought I would say this im happy to see you arthur Morgan"

[tight turret]

"You don't look so good"

[brisk fern]

The snow in chapter 1 was what got me uninterested in the game tbh

Only rescuing John and the mission when Lenny makes a joke about Micah were fun

[brisk fern]

You might be the only idiot to get half his brain eaten by a pack of wolves and come back smarter than before

"lose the other half of your brain and you'll become a genius"

[lapis panther]

Chapter one isn't that bad

Finding John and hunting with Charles are snooze fest missions where as the the shootout with the O'Driscolls at their mining camp and the train robbery are quite good. First mission isn't that bad

[vital crypt]

i really enjoyed it actually

of course its "boring" its supposed to guide you into the game

[storm berry]

GUYs who plays on pc

[peak veldt]

?

[storm berry]

Does rdr2 freezes and crashes with no error

For you

[peak veldt]

No

[storm berry]

Bruh

Mine crashes so many times

[peak veldt]

Update your drivers, verify file integrity, don’t use mods, have minimum specs.

[storm berry]

I dont have mods

I have the best specs

And i have drivers updated

Idk what to do

[steep hinge]

Shoot a guy in the eye Dutch style, I love my horsey and my horsey love me,John look out agent Ross is coming,Dutch Van der linde gang is the gang Im in, Robbing banks, Robbing trains for cash, I got a boy named Jack yes he's mine

[storm berry]

I need a fix

[steep hinge]

Who thinks Charles chatenay is a freak

[peak veldt]

Love me that freak.

[vital crypt]

i love him

[lapis panther]

He's funny

[gusty meadow]

why do i keep getting stuck on loading screens when intro to replay missions?

[twilit cypress]

So can I change my main mask

[vital crypt]

yes

[peak veldt]

The bandana? No. Masks, sure?

[vital crypt]

yep

[twilit cypress]

Ok I meant bandanna

[peak veldt]

I figured.

[twilit cypress]

That sucks

That would be so cool

[peak veldt]

Big manly marlboro man and I want to dress him up in a variety of styles like a Barbie.

[vagrant plover]

Hey does anyone know why sometime arthur jst don't want to hit

like i can't click to hit the enemies

with fists

anyone please ?

[pure brook]

I had this i think it might be to do with surroundings blocking you. I was fighting someone between a building and a horse lashing post and he just stood there refusing to swing

[pure brook]

I already told you sone suggestions your ignoring them or have you tried them

[storm berry]

BRO

u never even told me anything

u said look in steam discussions

i literaly put a dif gpu in my pc

js to test and it still crashed

[fluid musk]

he's such a qtie icl

[pure brook]

This is a discussion channel for rdr2 singleplayer. I offered advice, you don't wanna take it and try and sort it yourself so be it. But this channel isn't here to fix your system issues.

[subtle karma]

A few weeks ago I installed RDR2 and I don't play online, but I did install some mods like Gun Tricks, the Remap Menu, and Red Dead Offline. The problem is, the Red Dead Offline mod isn't working for me. When I followed a YouTube tutorial, I installed other mods, some of the most popular ones like Lenny Simple Trainer, and others. Everything seemed to work fine, but all the NPCs wanted to kill me as soon as they saw me, and when I moved away, bears started falling from the sky. I don't know what to do. I just want Red Dead Offline in story mode, please.

[vital crypt]

youre not allowed to talk about mods

[pale yew]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[dark ferry]

main island

that banner’s interesting

[brisk fern]

I lost honor for shooting a guy who hit his horse

[brisk fern]

You don't say 😂

[vital crypt]

but i am a wanted criminal for running over a dog that was ASKING for it

somewhat unrelated

[brisk fern]

Interesting

What did the dog do

[vital crypt]

but cats and dogs and whatevrr else is loose in the streets always run in front of my horse

[brisk fern]

Same with civilians

[vital crypt]

freaking jumped in front of me at a full galopp???

[brisk fern]

They dont run into me but theres always like 3 of them standing on the god damn street in saint denis

[vital crypt]

yeah but they jump back like you were going 100 straight at em

[vital crypt]

and they absolutely flip when you ride past

its a mf street

use your EYES

[brisk fern]

Rdr2 npcs are blind

[vital crypt]

im the same irl tho i also yell at people who try to run me over

at least i look before i walk

[vital crypt]

and sour af

[brisk fern]

I'm not trying to run them over I'm just not looking at the street in saint denis

Everywhere else you go you dont need to really

[vital crypt]

real tho

my horse still runs folks over without me

[brisk fern]

Molly saying she broke the rules just for attention gotta be some top level attention seeking

Not to mention how stupid it was since she knew the rules and probably would've expected that stunt would get her killed

[azure sluice]

she was drunk

[brisk fern]

Good point

She must've drank more than Karen does

[azure sluice]

the gang was cooked in chapter 6

well the game is mainly about the gang's downfall but chapter 6 was awful

[vital crypt]

id just love a game about the gangs prime

[pure brook]

Yeah, I think I'm approaching the end of chapter 6. Everyone's either left, been thrown out or dead

[pale yew]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[pale yew]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[ember ridge]

She was really drunk and desperate. Dutch stopped paying her much attention after the gang moved from Horseshoe. She never thought she'd actually get killed. And if Susan didn't shoot her nobody would've

[dark ferry]

i dunno how people even possibly think doing that is a good idea

just makes you seem like a degenerate

[brisk fern]

I'd shoot her

[brisk fern]

They probably are

[ember ridge]

Well you're not In the gang are you 😭😭

[vital crypt]

who knows

[ember ridge]

You're just seeing it from an outside perspective

[brisk fern]

Nah I join the gang when they go to Australia

[winter moat]

Guys so like I beat rdr2 this summer and it’s been like 3 months and I already want to do another playthrough lol

But just stay in chapter 2 for as long as possible

[worn solar]

I never really liked it but imo opinion epilogue one takes the cake as the most boring chapter

[worn solar]

Some guy can shoot me 4 times but the second i shoot back and kill him the law is on me and I lose honor

[vital crypt]

real

[worn solar]

I'm 5 feet away from them and they be telling me to get on the road im on the road just get some glasses

[vital crypt]

but when i kill someone in a bar fight i definitely provoked all good

[worn solar]

She saw those 5 cent beers or something 😭

[hidden moss]

When a random person shoots me and i shoot them back the law is on me cuz of a witness that doesnt know whats happening🥀

[worn solar]

I liked chapter 6 for the gameplay but that chapter was emotional

[nocturne shale]

I completed Margaret's quests but I don't have the lion's paw

I remember collecting it from the lion

[worn solar]

Same

[worn solar]

[worn solar]

Wow they both are shooting this one looks more like a outlaw lets tell on him

[blissful crane]

sometimes it doesn't happen

i guess you gotta let them take 1-2 shots at you first before shooting back so the law doesn't immediately get on your ass

but if the situation started out as a normal fist fight that you turned into shootout because you pulled a gun first
you'll most likely get wanted if you kill the guy

[worn solar]

Even if they shoot me 4 times they still tell on me

[blissful crane]

i find that horseback riders pull their guns on you most of the time when you antagonise em

[worn solar]

Antagonizing people is fun when they fight you but more then likely they just scared and tell on you

[blissful crane]

so when i shoot back after they shoot first im usually fine

[blissful crane]

you gotta antagonise the ones with holsters

[worn solar]

Ahh

[blissful crane]

because those are "tough" npcs and will almost always fight instead of running

most of the time they just want to brawl but rarely they aim their gun at you

when they aim their gun at you, antagonise them further
this makes them start shooting so you can kill them without repercussion because it was technically self defense

[worn solar]

I hate when I get into a fist fight with someone but 3 of their buddies come up and start quadruple teaming me

[blissful crane]

if you don't want to get wanted but still want to end the fight quickly, let each of them punch you atleast once

then run away

use the crouch punch that one shots them

[worn solar]

Ok

[blissful crane]

do it once for each person, done

[worn solar]

I think I got like 300 hours of playtime because I did 2 playthroughs and some online but spent so much time going from lowest honor to get to high honor

It was like 3000 into the camps box and Dutch was still yapping about needing money for Tahiti

[brisk fern]

[brisk fern]

Never go to Downes

[rugged lantern]

Send Micah to Downes

[brisk fern]

But rdr1 plot hole

Who can we even send that isn't in rdr1 and is a bad person who deserves to die

[lone wing]

Wtf I just woke up from camping and my horse is laying on its side dead. I’m near the legendary moose

[brisk fern]

Legendary moose is a savage

[lone wing]

I killed it already lol

I’m so confused

[brisk fern]

Exactly. Its so savage it kills your horse even when its dead

[lone wing]

I got my first perfect wolf pelt so I’m pretty salty about having to reload my save

[brisk fern]

No horse reviver?

[lone wing]

It’s too late I reloaded already. Didn’t think it would work since I slept two days before realizing he was dead in the camp

[brisk fern]

I swear to god everytime I loot bodies mid shootout for heals someone dies and I mission fail

Dutch: I have a plan
Arthur: could you explain it to me?
Dutch: are you doubting me?
Arthur: no I'm just trying to understand
Dutch: oh the doubting, it hurts that you doubt me son

Gaslighting 101

[lone wing]

wtf just happened. I just did the rest of the stranger mission with charlotte and it removed my perfect wolf pelt

[brisk hornet]

“Arthur have some goddamn faith”

[brisk fern]

Total take: 6000$
Gang take: 6000$
Your take: 0¢

Interesting

[rugged lantern]

Its for the plan

[brisk fern]

What plan

[lapis pebble]

Its for tahiti

[rugged lantern]

and mangooes 🤤

[fluid panther]

I wanna go for the money but I wanna help john but I'm on my low honor playthrough

[lapis pebble]

If you want money, collect maps and get gold ignots with arthur

For john, just use the gold ingot glitch in new austin

Ooh u mean the end

[fluid panther]

Yea

[lapis pebble]

For low honor, go for money

It fits

[fluid panther]

Ok (I'm currently in chapter 4)

[lapis pebble]

I went for high honor- and helping john

Ooh

[fluid panther]

I'm not gonna help the wapitis bcs I always helped them I wonder what'll happen

[lapis pebble]

Wspitis?

The indians?

[fluid panther]

Yea

[lapis pebble]

If you dont kill anyone when collecting the items from an army campf for the tribe elder- he'll give a talisman that lowers how quickly weapons wear down

Its the misson when you go on a walk with him

[fluid panther]

Yea

[lapis pebble]

Its pretty good since it lowers it by 20%

I do it purely for that

And for a better story in the end cuz u know what ur getting into when you fight with the indians to help the elders son

Idfk the names

Also i think poison arrow blueprints are in the camp

[modern bobcat]

Why didn't arthur respawn after micah killed him?

[lapis pebble]

Because he gave it to john

The hats the source of his respawn power

[junior axle]

now why..

marybeth is just standing in the rain in her undergarments

and they be like " mr morgan you'll catch a chielll"

[lapis pebble]

Cuz they dumb asf

[brisk fern]

I search ONE red dead redemption video and my YouTube feed keeps fucking spoiling me now

[lapis pebble]

Fun

[brisk fern]

I didn't get that talisman I got one that lowered all cores reduction rate by 15%

[lapis pebble]

Oh, mb i mixed them up

The one im thinking of is the crow talisman that can be crafted with a pocket watch lol

[junior axle]

my game started tweaking after playing for 2 hours

[azure sluice]

You should keep from searching up stuff about the game lol

especially this server

[brisk fern]

I was watching my favourite youtubers playthrough of the game to see his thoughts of the story while I played

[junior axle]

ok yall ihav

28 hours in this game

should i start with chapter 3 now

[lapis pebble]

Word of advice, don't go to the pig farm till chpt 5 or 6 so u can store ur money for the epilogue

Unless u got like 7k or smtz then deposit that shi

[lapis pebble]

I got abt 300 on pc

[junior axle]

wwhat do yall think i should do before starting ch 3

i did the jamie quest

i did uhh

the gunslinger quest for the guy at the pub

[lapis pebble]

Just go around exploring the map, doing side quests and legendary animals

U could also do legendary fish if u wanna no life the game

[ember ridge]

You gotta do the fish if you want to 100% the game

[vital crypt]

i started chapter three at about eighty hours

i unlocked the entire available map and stuff tho

before saving micah

[lapis pebble]

Yeah, but its such a pain in the ass- i wouldnt suggest for first time players, do it when ur done with everything else fr, like the corset dude

[vital crypt]

i hate fishing in every game but i gotta do it some time

[lapis pebble]

I only fish to raise honor

[vital crypt]

fishing is fucking nonsense

[lapis pebble]

If u go to the legendary fish spot in the poisoned pool, its real easy to catch with special lake lure

Takes like 20 seconds per catch

[vital crypt]

i didnt fish outside of missions until chapter four

for the challenges

[junior axle]

question about uh the online mode

[vital crypt]

[lapis pebble]

The only challenge i did with fish was collecting small ones

[vital crypt]

#rdr2-online-support

[junior axle]

did they stop updating it and are reusing events or smth

oh

well idk if this counts as a support question just general

[vital crypt]

yes

[junior axle]

awh

[vital crypt]

if its a question about online mode its probably not right in the singeplayer channel

[junior axle]

i just died by a horse kick

[peak veldt]

It's for the best.

[lapis pebble]

Dirty thief

[junior axle]

it was for mason 💔

[lapis pebble]

I'm gonna pretend ik what that is

[stark sparrow]

anyone know a guaranteed spot for moose

[brisk fern]

Somehow the closer I am to completing the game the more I'm being spoilt

[lapis pebble]

Tbh no rlly, but i usually see one at lake issabella

[peak veldt]

There are no guaranteed spots. Have you been checking an interactive map for locations?

[lapis pebble]

Focus on snowey areas, thats where i usually see them

Probably around elk areas too

[short iron]

Anyone know how to solve the bug where the journal completely dissapears from the satchel? I’m in chapter 6 and last time I saw it was in a manual save from chapter 2.

[peak veldt]

J ?

[junior axle]

yall

WHAT is going on in GOD's name in that area near emerald ranch

the one with ranch

firtly everyone in tha tshack is gone

secondly i was leaving the area and some dude just flopped from his horse and is just dead

[lapis pebble]

Emerald ranch

[pure brook]

What pig farm? Can you store money for epilogue ? I'm in chapter 6 now

[lapis pebble]

Yeah

If you dont go back to collect it

It'll store till you do

But tbh, u can just do the gold glitch in new austin instead

Idk

I dont think it has a name

[peak veldt]

Aberdeen pig Farm in northern Lemoyne. Whenever you're ready to do the point of no return mission "Our Best Selves", go sell off your valuables to a fence, animal products to the trapper, herbs to a doctor, provisions to a general store, then visit the Aberdeen Pig Farm. Don't collect your money from behind the painting inside when you're done (but feel free to dispatch with the residents if you want)

Only works if you did not already do the encounter.

[pure brook]

Ah ok, i may have encountered them and legged it when they invited me in? Is that the same one. It's in a marshy area and a guy asks if you wanna cone in for food or something

He seemed creepy so I ran away! Lol

[peak veldt]

It's okay if you can't do it. There's no shortage of money at the end of the epilogue.

[lapis pebble]

With legend of the easy satchel too, so your not limited on how much u can get

Cuz, 99 is a lot

[peak veldt]

uhhh okay. Nothing to do with this.

[lapis pebble]

I mean more stuff to carry = more stuff to sell

[peak veldt]

Not that relevant. Vast majority of your money is from missions and treasure maps.

But obviously get your satchels as early as chapters 2 or 3. That's just generally good advice. But not specifically to sell a few hundred dollars of junk at the end.

[deep glacier]

May not be relevant to you zesty but they’re still allowed to give their input too

[peak veldt]

Sorry, did I bar them from speaking?

[brisk fern]

Arthur Morgan, the bay harbour gunslinger

Or should I say outlaw

He's more of an outlaw than gunslinger

[lapis pebble]

John, the barn pin cushion

[brisk fern]

I don't think I've found a single satchel and I'm in chapter 6

[brisk fern]

John, the rip van winkle

[lapis pebble]

U dont find satchels..

[brisk fern]

Exactly

[lapis pebble]

U craft them after buying the leather working stuff at camp

Or buy them in epilogue

If ur lazy

[brisk fern]

I didn't know about that at all 😭

[lapis pebble]

..

Ur lying...

[brisk fern]

Nope

[lapis pebble]

I refuse to believe u didnt know that

[brisk fern]

Then your name checks out

[deep glacier]

Actually reminds me that for my next play through I need to buy more upgrades for camp

[brisk fern]

Most upgrades I got I've rarely used lol

[lapis pebble]

I maxed my upgrades first thing

Makes life easier

[brisk fern]

Only the fast travel but I've only really started using it alot in chapter 6

And chapter 4/5 with saint denis

[lapis pebble]

U can refill on ammo,food and tonics at camp, granted you'll have to restock them after

[peak veldt]

The benefit is the camp funds can restock them.

[lapis pebble]

Yeah

[brisk fern]

Food and tonics would be pretty helpful if I weren't lazy to grab them

[lapis pebble]

Tho, ur also the one giving camp funds

[peak veldt]

Fast Travel is a good buy.

[brisk fern]

Other camp members donate

[lapis pebble]

Tbh i just make a camp and fast travel

[brisk fern]

You need to buy it tho to use that

[lapis pebble]

I rarely use the map one

[lapis pebble]

?

[peak veldt]

By the time you can afford to upgrade everything up, there's no reason to save the pennies on what the camp followers can restock. You aren't limited by money after a point

[peak veldt]

It unlocks fast travel in your mini camp

[brisk fern]

Don't you need to buy the fast travel in camp to use fast travel when setting up a camp

[lapis pebble]

Tbh i didnt realise that cuz i always buy fast travel first thing

And when i do need to fast travel its alr there

Laughing at me when u didnt even know u could craft satchels...

[brisk fern]

Fair enough, you don't really need fast travel until you buy it and even then you rarely need it

[lapis pebble]

Ye

[brisk fern]

Well the game doesn't mention crafting satchels anywhere

I don't remember seeing it in the camp upgrades

[lapis pebble]

When u donate or craft with pearson it says i'm pretty sure

Its says u can craft satchel upgrades, or smt similar

[dire carbon]

I'm with John and I didnt craft any satchels

Can I still do it sonewhere

[ember ridge]

No

[dire carbon]

F

[lapis pebble]

Go to a fence

[dire carbon]

Oh

[lapis pebble]

They'll sell the satchels

[dire carbon]

For moneyz?

[lapis pebble]

Ye

[dire carbon]

W

[lapis pebble]

Its basically the game calling u lazy. Or inexperienced

[dire carbon]

I am

Lazy

[lapis pebble]

I couldn't make the legend of the east satchel till chpt 4 or 6 cuz badgers are actually so annoying to hunt

[peak veldt]

Vast majority of my gameplay is before the epilogue. Makes sense the game basically gives it away at that point like "better skill next playthrough I guess"

I got a little checklist of pelts/carcasses I need for all the satchels/upgrades in a playthrough

amongst all the other little things

[lapis pebble]

Same here

[ember ridge]

Yeah I do to

[peak veldt]

Sent you mine

[lapis pebble]

U did?

[peak veldt]

And i only ever craft the panther saddle for my horse

Hate the color. I go with one of the darker brown trapper saddles.

[lapis pebble]

Like the rattlesnake?

[peak veldt]

It was the last one I grabbed but I never ended up looking at it

[lapis pebble]

The panther pairs well with cream horses or the rose grey arabian

Like the uh, rare horse that spawns near a big ah waterfall

Real good since its brave and the stats are aight

[dire carbon]

Arabian best horse yes?

[lapis pebble]

For stats

Its not brave at all though

And only the rosegrey arabian has good hp

[peak veldt]

Bravery doesn't matter. Hit the "that's my boy!" button when running through alligator infested rivers. No big.

[lapis pebble]

I try, they always buck me cuz arabians timid asf

[peak veldt]

Free White Arabian in Chapter 2. Black Arabian in Chapter 4. You're set for the game.

[lapis pebble]

Rose grey for epilogue

Tho i use the strawberry war horse up near annesburg, fav horse right there

[peak veldt]

Rose Grey has more HP/Stam by 1 bar, so I just keep using a Black Arabian in the epilogue. I like the look better.

[lapis pebble]

Rose grey has max hp with max bonding i think

[peak veldt]

I would LOVE for more horses to be top-tier. But the benefits of elite handling and acceleration over the other horses are just too good.

[lapis pebble]

Ig, i just like war horses better

Since they will rarely buck you and are tanky

Plus you can increase its speed with races

Tho not a lot

[peak veldt]

My horse never dies, nor do I get bucked off because I hit the "that's my boy!" button

[peak veldt]

That's all horses.

[loud kernel]

I LOVE the indian warped horse

[lapis pebble]

War horses are slower, so u gotta

I just prefer them in terms of design too

Just a 7ft giant of a horse

[loud kernel]

but they clutch in a lot moments

[lapis pebble]

Fr, tho i never get a horse killed

Only in chpt 6

[loud kernel]

lets not talk about that...

[peak veldt]

I don't know how you would get any horse killed in a gunfight. You'd have to be using it as a shield.

[lapis pebble]

Fr

[peak veldt]

My point being I don't benefit from a tanky horse.

[lapis pebble]

I just use one that isnt max bonding normally for chpt 6

[loud kernel]

I know how to rev a horse without horse rev

[lapis pebble]

Only times mine have been close to dying is when they trip over smt and fall off a bridge

[peak veldt]

If you're using a tanky horse to stop your horse dying when you crash/trip over things, you are making an unnecessary trade-off.

You can change out a tanky horse for some skill and carrying a horse reviver. There's no consumable I can hold onto that will make my horse zippy.

[lapis pebble]

Its not so much lack of skill as it is lack of sleep

[peak veldt]

I'd say that's under the skill umbrella.

There's stats innate to the horse and then there's what you're bringing to the table. If you can compensate for HP, then the horse can be more zippy, which you can't bring to the table.

[loud kernel]

also bond with the horse because you can crash into tree like nothing

and make the trinkets

[peak veldt]

As opposed to not bonding with your horse? It just happens.

[loud kernel]

nah lowkey

[peak veldt]

Hit the "that's my boy!" button for free horse stamina, bravery, and bonding.

The gold objective for "Fatherhood, for Beginners" should be to lose the race back to Pronghorn Ranch.

[loud kernel]

and spend 40-50$ on food it got me from level 1 to 3 in no time

[peak veldt]

Totally unnecessary to go out of your way to grind bonding.

But I'm not raising dozens of horses I guess!

[loud kernel]

idk it worked for me ig

[timber ingot]

bro

i spent like 9 hours making the camp perfect

every single tent upgrade with the animal skins n shit

there’s ONE thing left

and it’s a moose antler

i have literally every camp upgrade except that

and i can’t find a moose

[peak veldt]

okay?

[timber ingot]

okay?

[peak veldt]

Do you have a map of their spawn locations?

[timber ingot]

ive went to 4

[loud kernel]

wait i have something

[peak veldt]

Go to a moose spawn. Save game. Load game. No moose? Save game, load game. Repeat. Don't skip the saving step.

[timber ingot]

i have BITW on my ps4

is there a way I can get the role without giving them all of my information

[peak veldt]

This acronym has no meaning to me

[timber ingot]

best in the west

im pretty sure that’s the achievement for 100% completion

i have “its art” also

[peak veldt]

Because social club was down, they wanted me to make my steam profile not private to see my steam achievements, though I was providing a screenshot of my social club achievements. I don't think you can get away with showing them nothing.

[timber ingot]

i mean i can screen record my rdr2 achievements list

[peak veldt]

Like I said, I don't think that's enough. They wanted a method they could check the profile themselves.

Whoever does that.

[loud kernel]

Go to the top of Ann Berg. I’m sure you’ll find something there or in the west of Black water.

I can’t spell for shit

[timber ingot]

im in chapter 2

trying to get as much as I can before going to chapter 3

every playthrough i learn that i miss something so i make a new one

[peak veldt]

Want some checklists of missables?

[timber ingot]

i watched a Strange Man video of missable chapter 2 content

[loud kernel]

So you know when you went hunting for the bear

Just go into that little divot

I’m sure you’re gonna find something there

[timber ingot]

o’creaghs run for a moose?

i tried a spot near the loft

[loud kernel]

Yes

[peak veldt]

There's no guaranteed moose spawns. Just go to a spawn, and do the reset method

[timber ingot]

and near that hill house

im at the road west of strawberry looking for cougars

[loud kernel]

I have a book and it says it there

[timber ingot]

i got mauled by a white cougar when i got here but it was poor condition

[peak veldt]

lol?

[timber ingot]

i swear they hide the animals you need on purpose

bru

Alligator skin
Ram Carcass
2 cougar pelts
2 ox hide
5 boar pelts
2 pronghorn hides
Pronghorn carcass
Moose antler ❌
Wolf carcass
2 snake skins
Beaver pelt
Muskrat pelt
Fox pelt
2 wolf pelts
Cow hide
2 goat hides
Elk antler
1 Buck antlers

All perfect quality

everything except the moose antler

[loud kernel]

lol I have a book in my closet and it has the guide

[timber ingot]

ive gotten all perfect quality

its just too big of a coincidence

why are moose so hard to find ONLY when im looking for them

[peak veldt]

And the guide says "100% of the time when you go to this spot, a moose will be standing there"?

[loud kernel]

No but just save n load

[timber ingot]

wait

so if i go exactly where someone said a moose would spawn

like right where it would be standing

[peak veldt]

So do exactly what I said to do? I don't understand why you're telling me I'm wrong when I said "go to a spawn and save n load"

[timber ingot]

i save and load in that exact spot and load it

it’ll spawn there? or has a chance to

because

[peak veldt]

It might. It'll try to respawn the animals in the area, assuming you aren't occupying the spawn slots with corpses. So do it where there's a lot of spawn points for a moose clustered

[timber ingot]

i always had to ride like halfway across the map then save and load

should i try 100% again?

i got it on my ps4 a while ago but my xbox runs it way better

[peak veldt]

I mean this very nicely. I don't care. Do what brings you joy.

[timber ingot]

and i don’t have a disc for rdr2 for the ps4 rn

you remind me of jezebel

i get that you “don’t care” but you can stop being an ass

[peak veldt]

I'm very specifically saying I mean it nicely. It doesn't matter to me whether you 100% it, I want you to do what brings you joy.

No one is attacking you.

[midnight ocean]

most of these are hella common

[midnight ocean]

not likely to happen

[timber ingot]

ik

but the things like cougars, boars and wolves

they’re easy to kill but its a pain in the ass to find one, especially 3 stars

atleast for me

[midnight ocean]

for wolves if you ride up north from the owanjila trapper into the snow area youll likely run into a pack

but otherwise keep trying around ambarino

[timber ingot]

that’s where i had the least luck finding them

[loud kernel]

If you want better chance in getting the moose pelt, I recommend getting the herbivore bait

[timber ingot]

and where i was told to go

but

[peak veldt]

woolie, no one is being hostile here except you with this message. No need to be smarmy. Everything is okay. 🙂

[timber ingot]

panthers are kinda easy because there’s like 1 spot on the map where they’re at

[midnight ocean]

boars are super easy just go to the owanjila trapper

[timber ingot]

maps show they’re near bayou nwa but ive never seen one there

[midnight ocean]

and you can find a cougar there often

[timber ingot]

the boars were easy but still took a while

its where i got 4 out of the 5 perfect ones

im in that spot rn trying to find a cougar

[midnight ocean]

there's a pattern here lol

[peak veldt]

Yes, I noticed you take every jab you can.

Even when it's not warranted.

[loud kernel]

the ‘hot spot for moose’ is sometimes in the top of annesberg

[junior axle]

Hi chat

I just realized this game is the first single player fane to make me roleplay

[loud kernel]

Hi

[timber ingot]

bro

[loud kernel]

the ‘hot spot for moose’ is sometimes in the top of annesberg so just go over and save and load

That’s all I can say

[timber ingot]

i got irritated bc i accidentally fast traveled to colter instead of annesburg 💔

[loud kernel]

💔 it happens

[junior axle]

Do yall think there will be a rdr3 one day

[loud kernel]

Prob in 2099

[timber ingot]

probably in like 20 years

[timber ingot]

probably, and it’d be something like “200 years ago from today, there’s was a man called Arthur Morgan..”

[loud kernel]

Yeah sumthing like that

[junior axle]

Its 2050 and gta6 online is still being milked

[loud kernel]

Fr

[timber ingot]

im lowkey not excited for gta 6 anymore

[timber ingot]

they don’t even have anything to continue off of for rdr3

[loud kernel]

It kinda lost the hype

[junior axle]

This rockstar launcher makes ne maddd

Boy if you don't launch my game

[loud kernel]

Young Arthur just watch 😒

[timber ingot]

i just found a guy hanging

in Roanoke ridge

outside the hermits house

is it an ambush

[junior axle]

Yes

[timber ingot]

let’s find out

[loud kernel]

Watch out you might get ambushed

[timber ingot]

yeah it was an ambush they came from the trees

[junior axle]

Saw that one tr

[loud kernel]

Damn

[junior axle]

Tt

[timber ingot]

lightwork they’re already dead

[junior axle]

Were they the nitewalkers

Nite..

[midnight ocean]

first one i saw was also at owanjila

[junior axle]

Fortnite

[midnight ocean]

owanjila is the place to be

[timber ingot]

murfree brood

[loud kernel]

That is also hotspot

[junior axle]

If you really think about

Rockstar devs arent the best in tech issues

[midnight ocean]

lake isabella is good too

[pure brook]

I went free Arabian and Mustang, the Perlino Andulusian. Arabian for posing or speed, other two for all else

[midnight ocean]

also saw one at cattail pond once

[junior axle]

Cause it has been a few days and my game still dosent let the steam overlay popup

[midnight ocean]

and one in tall trees

[timber ingot]

just grabbed the rare shotgun

[junior axle]

You guys whats the lore with the family and their father

[loud kernel]

Did you get the pump shotgun?

[junior axle]

That had the shotgun

Ljke the one thag says the recknoning will come to ya

[timber ingot]

The ones at Chez Porter?

[loud kernel]

Yea

[junior axle]

I think?

[tight turret]

People, may I ask how to do the weapon expert challenge 9?

[timber ingot]

they isolated theirselves for years and developed their own language basically

[pure brook]

Try using potent predator bait to attract 3 star (predators obv)

[loud kernel]

Wait, hold up

[junior axle]

Yall im going to get dutch's pipe

[timber ingot]

@junior axle dms

[timber ingot]

make sure your health is full first

lol

[midnight ocean]

you can get them during missions like the one where you rescue eagle flies, or you can go somewhere like six points cabin and keep killing the same enemy from behind, then run away until the red dots disappear and go back to let him respawn

[junior axle]

oh dw

dynamite

[timber ingot]

there’s also a potent health cure on the nightstand

[tight turret]

Going to do eagle flies rescue mission, I think I can do it there

[loud kernel]

And if you complete the mission without doing it, just go to hanging dog ranch

[tight turret]

I already kill all the O'Driscolls with Sadie-

[timber ingot]

is it the one where you do sneak kills on enemies or smth?

[midnight ocean]

i like six points better for that tbh at hanging dog its kinda hard to get behind someone since its so open

[midnight ocean]

with the bow

[loud kernel]

Oh yeah, sorry

[timber ingot]

it was easy for me at hanging dog

[loud kernel]

Go back to that one fort thing

[timber ingot]

there was always a dude that spawned with his back towards the creek

[loud kernel]

That mission you did with Eagle flies and just go to the camp army thing whatever you wanna call it and just do it from there but you will get a bounty

If it doesn’t get completed

[timber ingot]

make sure you grab the cavalry hat during that mission

[peak veldt]

I wouldn't bother with bait. It doesn't spawn anything, just attract things that are already very close.

Just cruise around on your horse to their spawn points.

[midnight ocean]

i wish hats saved when grabbing them in a replay

[timber ingot]

explains why i got coyotes 90% of the time i placed bait

[junior axle]

bumped into someones horse and they didnt start immdeatly shooting me america is so back

[timber ingot]

yesterday i completely crashed my horse into some dude, flung both of us and our horses and he somehow wasn’t hostile

[junior axle]

same

[pure brook]

Ah it worked for me to get a cougar for the saddle.

[timber ingot]

i hate when i lose an entire honor point for self defense

[junior axle]

rockstar is sabotaging its devs by making its most popular games on sale i just can't prove it

[timber ingot]

i was skinning a badger near some guys camp and he randomly opened fire

[peak veldt]

I'm not saying it won't attract nearby things. I'm saying it's a LOT of time spent for little benefit.

[timber ingot]

so i shot him in the forehead and the bar went down

it’s stupid

[loud kernel]

Yesterday, I also bumped into one guy’s horse. I didn’t know if he was going to be hostile or not because he died.

[timber ingot]

a good cougar spot is where Dutch’s rdr1 camp is supposed to be at

[loud kernel]

I think the bait is the best thing to use to get the cougar saddle

[timber ingot]

I couldn’t find cougars in the area but when I started placing bait they came almost immediately

[pure brook]

Fair enough, I must've got lucky I guess. It seemed to like the later in the game you progress the higher grade animals are about. More of them anyway

[timber ingot]

I thought the panther saddle was the best in the game

and everyone else says it is

but the rattlesnake one is better

it has more balanced stats

[pure brook]

Sry I meant panther

[loud kernel]

They kinda go bar to bar

[timber ingot]

the stats are like

36 and 32

i think for stamina and health

[peak veldt]

I know where all the cougar spawn points are. Save/Load on them to force the spawns, just keep in mind that once you got a cougar corpse sitting there, it's taking up the spawn point, so you should move to another if you need, say, 5 cougars for a challenge.

[timber ingot]

but on the snake saddle it’s 34 and 34 (I think)

[timber ingot]

im just trying to make all of the saddles

[loud kernel]

I’ll see

Idk

[peak veldt]

Easy peasy? Here's a spreadsheet of them.

[timber ingot]

i know you can just buy them in the epilogue but im trying to get every possible thing in chapter 2

i haven’t done many missions

[peak veldt]

Sent Saddle sheet to tabber, jake, and chris

[timber ingot]

i want to read marys letter but i know it’ll force me into getting downe’s debt

[timber ingot]

so

the only differences are

panther is -20% health drain and -26% stamina drain

snake saddle is 22 and 24

so it’s more balanced

basically better

[peak veldt]

The difference in stats between all the trapper saddles is low enough that you should just pick any one you like the look of. But trapper saddle for sure, because they have speed/acceleration bonuses that the stable saddles do not.

[timber ingot]

i have the panther saddle on the raven black shire

[timber ingot]

the best horse to go with the panther saddle is the MFT you can buy at the stable north of rhodes

they match

[loud kernel]

The two of the saddles are basically the same

They just swap the heart drain rate for the stamina

[timber ingot]

am i the only one who barely wears custom outfits for arthur and only wears his base gunslinger outfits with his base hair and beard

i mean out of any of you

wearing custom outfits just looks odd to me

[loud kernel]

I basically do, but I just swap it out with the cow puncher shirt

[peak veldt]

I have a clothing layout I like.

[timber ingot]

anyone know any good outfits that don’t require the special gun equipment or trapper items that are hard to obtain

[peak veldt]

It's all subjective.

[timber ingot]

google ain’t helping me rn 😔

[peak veldt]

The youngins were in here the other night saying how they go ALL BLACK. Like yeah, I was once 15 too. I get it.

[timber ingot]

COUGAR

pls be perfect

[loud kernel]

Plz

[timber ingot]

it’s “good”

bru

im currently unhappy and dissapointed

great now a wolf is charging at me

[loud kernel]

[peak veldt]

Free meat

[timber ingot]

and it’s also “good”

[peak veldt]

Delivery straight to your horse

[loud kernel]

Fr

[timber ingot]

bruh

[loud kernel]

OK now it’s just rubbing it in your face

[peak veldt]

Wolf is big game right? Great for spicing.

[timber ingot]

nope I didn’t get anything because I already have 5 big game meat

😔

[peak veldt]

Upgrade those satchels

[timber ingot]

that’s why im looking for the cougar

[peak veldt]

Did you see the random encounter cougar? That one is perfect

[timber ingot]

where

[peak veldt]

There's one encounter of it near Horseshoe and another style of it west of Hanging Dog Ranch

uhhh

let me check a map

[timber ingot]

Oh yay I need a buck for one of the satchels and I just found 2!

They’re also both “good”

[peak veldt]

But I'd just go to a normal cougar spawn and save/load. Just saying to take advantage of the random encounter if you happen to see it

[timber ingot]

im at the legendary moose location and its 4am and foggy

[peak veldt]

Sent the map screenshot.

[timber ingot]

isn’t that actually in horseshoe? 😭

Uhh

I just found a dude

There’s a coach missing its horses

The driver is dead

And there’s a body on the side

and some dude is just sitting next to it

[tight turret]

now i did the eagle flies mission, where else I can found enemies to kill from behind without being detected?

[timber ingot]

and told me to leave

[timber ingot]

try to find lemoyne raider camps

[peak veldt]

No? That's SE

[timber ingot]

they show on the map as enemies before you attack them

oh i saw the flat area and thought it was horseshoe

[tight turret]

ima see near rhodes

[timber ingot]

im in the forest and my horse is going apeshit

so hopefully it’s a cougar

[peak veldt]

Hell yeah

[timber ingot]

I purposely don’t wear cover scent lotion

[peak veldt]

Yeah, all that and bait just waste of time and effort. Hunt down your quarry, shoot them in the head. No big.

[timber ingot]

there’s like 10 coyote tracks

[tight turret]

aren't you at the side of the owanjila lake?

[timber ingot]

@granite peak don’t whine because im too fast for you bub

[timber ingot]

i moved to north of annesburg

I’m at the very top right of the map

[tight turret]

that's not a very good place tbh

it takes like 5 days in spawn a single cougar

[timber ingot]

I ran into a cougar before i even arrived

but it was “good”

[tight turret]

are you searching the cougar perfect pelt?

[timber ingot]

yes

i placed some predator bait

who wants to bet a coyote will come

[tight turret]

it will

[timber ingot]

yep it was a coyote

[tight turret]

that place is full of coyotes

[timber ingot]

also 2 stars

[tight turret]

and black bears

[timber ingot]

like everything else

i shot it in the neck

[tight turret]

let it suffer

[peak veldt]

Bait not going to attract something that isn't there

[timber ingot]

saw a bull elk and thought it was a moose

guess ill try that cougar attack encounter now

ew

i got that camp encounter with that crazy woman

[brisk fern]

Which one

[timber ingot]

the one in Roanoke who asks to sit by the fire

[junior axle]

what if rockstar had a lil sis called matchastar and they talked about arthur morgan's hot girl walk

[timber ingot]

and has a crazy stutter

[junior axle]

i need to go to sleep

[pure brook]

You definitely using correct weapon right? Cause wrong type of weapon will lower 3 star to 2 or 1 in kil

[timber ingot]

“shivering like a shittin’ dog!!!!!”

[timber ingot]

Was 2 stars before i shot it

[pure brook]

Just checking

I did that before I realised so thought I'd ask 👍

[timber ingot]

I hate when i finally find a perfect quality animal im looking for and the deadeye marks it twice and destroys the pelt

[peak veldt]

Go to the next deadeye upgrade when you can mark manually

[timber ingot]

tryna do it all before i get tb

[tight turret]

lemoyne raiders r so chill even when I killed 3 of their members

[timber ingot]

i hate when i get wanted for murder when i kill them in rhodes

[peak veldt]

If that's the kind of struggle you want.

[timber ingot]

i know literally nothing happens after that mission until chapter 5-6 but it still feels wrong

[peak veldt]

?

[timber ingot]

Arthur’s TB doesn’t actually show until around chapter 5-6

he gets diagnosed in chapter 5

[peak veldt]

I don't understand what that has to do with doing extracurriculars early. Other than a personal challenge.

[timber ingot]

don’t feel like doing all the work when i have a terminal illness

😔

[peak veldt]

Some people treat illnesses or disabilities like they're already dead. Not people who actually have illnesses/disabilities, mind you. And they can still do things they enjoy.

I like to think Arthur got really into being a naturalist during this time period. Drawing animals, cataloguing their information. Something that brought him joy.

[timber ingot]

ive been out of camp for weeks except for the occasional stop to donate the pelts and get the camp upgrades

[midnight ocean]

are you using potent bait at least?

[timber ingot]

no lol

can’t make it yet

[midnight ocean]

yeah you need potent for a cougar

but as has already been said, bait is kinda useless

[timber ingot]

didn’t need it before

ive gotten like

6

perfect cougars with normal bait

[midnight ocean]

oh

[timber ingot]

across different playthroughs

[midnight ocean]

alright then lol

i rarely use bait but all i got was boars when i used predator bait

[timber ingot]

it doesn’t matter where i put my bait 90% of the time i get coyotes

[midnight ocean]

yeah i wouldnt bother with it

just ride around the general spawn area and the cougar will usually find you

if you cant find one, sleep and try again or try another spot

[timber ingot]

i mainly need help finding a moose

im not concerned with it being a perfect pelt yet i just need the antlers

i wish you could just buy animal skins

[peak veldt]

Why are you not save/loading on the spawn point?

[timber ingot]

not all at once but at trappers you had the option to buy a variety of animal skins and rarely some perfect ones

[timber ingot]

i did twice

but im not playing rn

[peak veldt]

Do it more than twice. Moose don't have a high spawn chance

[timber ingot]

i was looking for cougars

lel

when do the bandit challenges unlock?

im gonna try to get LOTE again

gambler 8 had me sobbing

and the one where you need to pick every single herb

and multiple others

why is this game so hard

sometimes

i didn’t expect to open a western game and spend hours playing blackjack

i dont even know how to play poker but somehow i usually win

[peak veldt]

You can't do Herbalist 9/10 and Horseman 9/10 before the epilogue without exploits.

[midnight ocean]

same time as every other challenge

[timber ingot]

yeah im trying to do whatever i can in chapter 2

[midnight ocean]

unless im crazy

[timber ingot]

but i remember getting LOTE before I even finished the gambler challenges

[peak veldt]

yes, you've said.

[timber ingot]

i unlocked it at like gambler 9

[peak veldt]

Just go start it

[midnight ocean]

that shouldnt be possible

[timber ingot]

i was confused too

[midnight ocean]

LOTE is the reward for completing all 90 challenges

[timber ingot]

i got it before i finished the last few challenges

like I loaded up the game and it showed the notification saying i got it

[midnight ocean]

i feel like you're just misremembering

[timber ingot]

i assure you im not lmao

[midnight ocean]

unless you mean the satchel and not the outfit

[timber ingot]

if i look hard enough I can maybe find the screenshot

[peak veldt]

Game can be jank.

[timber ingot]

nope the outfit

there’s a Reddit post of someone who unlocked the outfit at 82/90

“As you can see I've completed 82/90 challenges but I've got the outfit already. I got it after finishing explorer 10 and as i picked up the final tresure in the elemental trail, the outfit came with it. Is this a bug I wasn't aware of lol or am I just lucky?”

[midnight ocean]

wiki does list a way of getting it without completing all of the gambler challenges using a mission replay

[timber ingot]

WAIT

i think I remember how I triggered it

[midnight ocean]

Complete all the challenges except Bandit 6 and tame every horse for Horseman 10 except Hungarian Half-bred (RDR 2).
Replay "Who is Not Without Sin" (you can skip the poker game this time). When you have Swanson on your horse, go to Blackwater and tame Hungarian Half-bred.
Complete the replay.
Horseman 10 is completed and the Legend of the East is acquired.

[timber ingot]

i think I replayed “Who is Not without sin” or whatever it was called

to finish gambler 10

and when the mission was done I had the outfit

[midnight ocean]

oh wait thats bandit

[timber ingot]

before I finished the other challenges

[midnight ocean]

i did the same but i didnt get shit lol

in fact i had to go redo the last poker win in valentine because it didnt save the challenge completion

[timber ingot]

replaying the riverboat mission is like 3 guaranteed poker wins for challenges

[midnight ocean]

2

[timber ingot]

if you listen to Strauss’ signals you can’t lose

[midnight ocean]

you dont even have to

[timber ingot]

ik you can just remember it

[midnight ocean]

you play three rounds of poker in that mission, you lose the first one and win the second two

[timber ingot]

it’s one of the mission challenges

oh

[midnight ocean]

unless you fold i guess lol

[timber ingot]

if you lose the rounds you fail the mission

i think

like if you lose all of them

[brisk fern]

Bounty hunters are probably the least most threatening thing in this game tbh

[timber ingot]

a giant group of them got me while i was fishing once

[brisk fern]

I actually only just ran into them for the first time finally all the way into chapter 6

[timber ingot]

someone must’ve fished them up after i was done with them

lel

[brisk fern]

Dutch is terrifying me in chapter 6 ngl

[brisk fern]

"John died"
Suspiciously sized John on the front cover of red dead redemption 1

[timber ingot]

i remember watching playthroughs and people shitting on the game bc they thought “The game got it wrong john wasn’t supposed to die idiots!!!!”

[midnight ocean]

during the army train?

[zealous fern]

So true

[timber ingot]

Yes

Like i watched playthroughs from people who had already beat rdr1

[midnight ocean]

thats so ironic lol

[timber ingot]

And when john “died” they got pissed because they thought it was a major plot hole

[midnight ocean]

if they paid attention to rdr1 theyd remember the part where john describes exactly what happened

[timber ingot]

lmao

he literally says “i got shot during a train robbery”

“they left me behind so i left them”

i think

The

[midnight ocean]

LENNAY

[zealous fern]

Your on the John prison break mission right

[zealous fern]

Hello

[midnight ocean]

he tells ricketts "i left the gang after the gang left me. left me to die after id been shot"

[timber ingot]

i swear i remember hearing this line tho

or somethign like that

[midnight ocean]

he continues "i got shot in a robbery, they left me and i left them"

[timber ingot]

i tried to say that I just realized

but this bot is making me go apeshit

[midnight ocean]

"but first i went back to them, and then a bunch of pinkertons showed up and me and this other guy had to shoot our way out, it was crazy"

[timber ingot]

now ur just bullshitting lol

[midnight ocean]

lol

[zealous fern]

Is there a way to rob the Saint Denis gunsmith without the law being alerted

[timber ingot]

maybe

try it at night

[midnight ocean]

you can take out the guy upstairs before he shoots if you're quick

i think

that should give you more time

[timber ingot]

i robbed the strawberry general store midday with no law

[zealous fern]

Ok

[midnight ocean]

but generally no there is no real stealth in this game so you always gotta be ready to get outta there fast

[timber ingot]

i even got trapped for like 30 seconds because of a coach

[midnight ocean]

i did the saint denis gunsmith as part of the four robberies in one day challenge

[timber ingot]

Bro

[midnight ocean]

started with that one, then i think i did the doctor, then i went to rhodes and then valentine

yeah the bot hates caps lol

[timber ingot]

“Look! That guy has a full face mask and a large coat that hides his body proportions!”

“It’s definitely Arthur Morgan!”

[midnight ocean]

gotta wear green so they think you're an odriscoll instead

[timber ingot]

I can wear the most absurd clothes

Not showing any skin or hair whatsoever

And they know it’s arthur

[midnight ocean]

tbf though if the mask completely hid your identity it would be kinda op

[timber ingot]

the mask in rdr1 was op

kill whoever you want with no honor loss

[zealous fern]

Theirs a person behind a black door in the gunsmith(Saint Denis) what is it

[timber ingot]

pair it with the agent outfit and you can kill civilians with zero consequences

[timber ingot]

It’s a side business

I think it’s some high stakes poker game

There’s a homeless man that tells you about it if you give him what he asks for

[zealous fern]

Ohh I’ll rob that to

[timber ingot]

You can’t rob it without getting the tip first

it’ll say like “side business discovered” or something

[zealous fern]

Ohk

[midnight ocean]

i think you can

unless i got the tip and forgot

[timber ingot]

you cant

you have to see what it is or get a tip

then it unlocks the option to rob the side business

for example

the valentine doctor

if you look through the window in the back there’s odriscolls

it unlocks the option to rob that back room

it’s also the earliest way to get a Schofield

for free

but you get ambushed by the cops when you walk out

they wait for you outside and if you take long enough one of them walks in

[midnight ocean]

they should really let you go out the back door when you do that one

[timber ingot]

ikr

[midnight ocean]

like it locks from the inside obviously

[timber ingot]

i feel like i remember being able to once

but im probably misremembering

“mister”

[midnight ocean]

i remember that being a big disappointment for me when i first played

after also trying to rob a train in free roam and being swarmed by lawmen before i could get that much money

like yeah robbing a train is fun but its more fun if you actually make some money in the process

[timber ingot]

robbing trains by yourself is basically asking for a disaster

[midnight ocean]

there is a way to do it but its exploitative

[timber ingot]

you don’t get shit, a dozen lawmen

[timber ingot]

yeah you have to hide the train in the tunnel or on a bridge

[peak veldt]

Take a train to riggs station. Park in on the bridge. Rob someone. Leave.

Repeat 5 times for a challenge

[timber ingot]

wish you could just rob it in a remote area by yourself and it actually be successful

[timber ingot]

No

[peak veldt]

Yes.

[midnight ocean]

the challenge is super easy, you can just hop on when its stopped in town and grab a single can of vegetables then hop back off without even triggering a witness

[timber ingot]

i was gonna say this but my mom came in lel

but yes stealing 1 canned food counts for the quest

it’s 10x easier

[midnight ocean]

hope you werent getting a deluxe bath

[timber ingot]

alright bru 💔

deluxe baths are overrated

[midnight ocean]

real

[timber ingot]

the easiest way to do this quest

[midnight ocean]

if you're gonna do the riggs station thing you might as well rob the whole train lol

[timber ingot]

Go to Riggs station on a train
Grab a canned food from one of the cars
Go on a train to Wallace station and do the exact thing
Ride back to riggs

repeat

[timber ingot]

it’s 5 separate trains

plus

i have a thing about losing honor

i dont like it

i like that extra body loot and discounts

do you guys kill or spare Jean-Marc?

[midnight ocean]

i dont even know who that is but spare

[timber ingot]

it’s during the quest with the Saint Denis mayor

at the end of his side quest chain he tells you to kill one of his workers

[midnight ocean]

you know i think i missed that whole quest on this last playthrough

[timber ingot]

if you kill him you get a 10% discount on everything in Saint Denis

[timber ingot]

ive only done it once

a long time ago

[midnight ocean]

is a discount really that helpful tho

[timber ingot]

he claims he’ll “destroy” the mayor if you spare him but i have no idea what happens if you do spare him

if you kill him you have to dump his body in the water after

if you fish in the same spot later on you can actually fish up his rotted arm

[timber ingot]

I didn’t even know I would get it when i first did the quest

[midnight ocean]

well also the high honor discount

[timber ingot]

i only killed him because i thought it would he satisfying to get a clean headshot on a forehead

[midnight ocean]

you have so much money anyway

[timber ingot]

i was kinda evil on my first playthrough

[timber ingot]

you can easily get rich with that gold ingot glitch in new Austin

[midnight ocean]

you dont even need to do that lol

literally just playing the story missions gets you more money than you really need

[timber ingot]

on my first playthrough i spent the full 20k that you get after beating the game lmao

so i had to do the ingot glitch

[midnight ocean]

on what? gun customization?

[timber ingot]

maybe

[midnight ocean]

thats basically the only way to spend a lot

you can buy horses but you can only have four of those

[timber ingot]

tbh i keep all of my guns stock

i try to be as canon as possible

fuck you

that was for the bot

[zealous fern]

Why does the Bot Keep showing up

[timber ingot]

it’s being an ass

[peak veldt]

He spams messages rather than writing out full sentences.

[timber ingot]

I don’t have to act professional to live up to your expectations you formal fuck 🤯😶‍🌫️🫥🫣

brace

[peak veldt]

You do if you don't want the bot to auto-mod you. I don't know why you've been so aggro, trashy, and immature at the drop of a hat multiple times over nothing. 🤷‍♀️

[zealous fern]

Damn

[midnight ocean]

f

[zealous fern]

F

[midnight ocean]

you know what else is immature? this message

[zealous fern]

Wait for the storm

Still going

I guess not

[modern bobcat]

The blind man is great

Ye shall alway give him a dollar

[zealous fern]

He is

[midnight ocean]

in the epilogue he spawns on the road between blackwater and beechers hope and it sucks if you have a west elizabeth bounty because the bounty hunters will always spawn as you leave blackwater and youll lose honor when the blind guy gets scared

and you wont be able to talk to him obviously

[modern bobcat]

I wonder how he knoweth if arthur is honorable or dishonorable

[brisk fern]

Nah way past

[zealous fern]

What mission then

[brisk fern]

The only time I've seen all caps not get banned

[modern bobcat]

LENNAY

How did that work?

[midnight ocean]

the trick is not to overdo it

just keep it short

[brisk fern]

Lennay is the exact cap amount lmao

Ironic

LENNY

The rdr1 remaster was a misopportunity for them to rewrite the game a little to add some lines about Arthur

Considering how important Arthur was to John it just makes sense for them to do that

[modern bobcat]

Heh

Why didn't the end just be arthur killing micah then dying because of TB in a year or two? Or going to tahiti and listening to the doctor's advice?

[modern bobcat]

Considering John's good at remembering faces

[grizzled haven]

because rockstar writers are heartless /hj

[peak veldt]

rockstar writers are heartless handjob?

[humble yew]

😭

[modern bobcat]

Approved, agreed upon, verily, yea indeed, yes