#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 263 of 1
I used to go for all gold, but that usually ends up looking tacky, I mostly use silver now
I like using the broken pirate sword for the giggles sometimes
I usually use blackened steel with gold or silver details
Coolio
Which look do y’all prefer, unbuttoned shirts of buttoned up?
My Arthur is wearing buttoned up ATM but I need to change his fit soon
Imma make a compilation of my current outfits and send it into the media channel if you wanna see it
I just posted my main outfits for Arthur in the fashion channel if you wanna give me some feedback, which I would really appreciate
Does your horse reslly get faster the higher the bond
It says it does but idk for sure if it does
I believe so
If you don’t mind, I would like to see your outfit of Arthur at the moment
Oh
Yeah i prefer john less crazy
Can I see ur outfit for John then?
Its just his normal cowboy outfit i dont make outfits
You should, it’s fun
To u its fun rn i bonding with my fox trotter
Fair
Its a brave horse atleast internet says it is
I got an American Thoroughbred named Lois
If you're behind cover and pick them off one by one it's a fine rifle as it kills in one shot, but I mainly use my springfield for hunting.
@delicate spindle is ent ya a friend reuquest and a dm
There are some youtube videos which shows the day to day life of some NPCs in town. There is also one showing what the rancher at Larned Sod does. Also Pearson, Susan and Uncle in camp
does anyone know what happens if you go back to the farm that john starts working in, after all the missions
If thou goest back unto the ranch thou shalt find it the same as epilogue 1
Nothing happeneth
will the characters still be the exact same
I have no idea, but the ranch shall be the same
oh alright thanks
Thou art welcome
For thine information, thou canst enter the geddes big house
But using a glitch of course


Those that hate arthur i do not know how they think, but verily they are evil
Verily they are low honor players
Where can i set up camp!?!?!?!?!?!
Thou canst set up a camp in the wilderness
Thou canst not set up a camp in the gang camp or in a city/town
Huh?
You can set up a camp in the wilderness
You can not set up a camp whilein the gang camp or in a city/town
How do i take and keep out all my weapons from my horse cuz i take them out then they dissappear...?
I was
Take your weapons fron your horse when you get off of your horse
Then what is exactly the problem then?
It wasnt letting me but i got it thank you
...every time?
You are welcome
That is what i do, because each time i get off of my horse i do not get my rifles with me
How can i speed up splitting ammo?
How can i replenish my health stam and dead eye completely?
All at once
Use an opened miracle tonic for replenishing them, use a miracle tonic to replenish and fortify them
But like in a way that i dont use any tonics, im talking about like sleeping or some thing..
If any
How do i get my horse and saddle from the ultimate edition?
Yo, what's up people's?
How do you get your horse and saddle from the Ultimate Edition? Didn't know there was one. 😅
You can't split your ammo any quicker than when you're doing it manually.
Just got to hold down the button and wait

Doth the valuables satchel increase the number of jewelry bags i can carry?
does whyem's dlc still mess with the npc spawning rates?
Idk but I cant install it, I thought it was my 8gb 4060Ti and I upgraded it to a 16gb 4080 super and still cant jnstall whyems so it must be me, whyem mustn’t like me
damn
I think so
I scared micah
Just a fire did the job
Was hoping to make his horse fall off
The cliff
In his coach mission
I hate strauß
How do i get my horse and saddle from the ultimate edition?
stable
the horse is stabled and the saddle can be equipped
no actions needed
my game just closed on me. no warning just boom black screen application closed
now i gotta replay this stupid quest
It is all because of strauß
He is the reason behind everything bad that happens
Thou shalt not damn a nation because a single man is damned
Austrians are 
i shall leave this conversation for good
i see where thou wast going
But eh


No he isn't, people asked him for a loan, he just had Arthur doing the dirty work and getting the money... it's not on Strauss that Downes was sick and spit on Arthur.
If rdr1 was never made arthur would of probably lived
How?
Idk just a theroy
Yes, I realise that, but.. how? A theory has at least some form of substance to it, so.. go on, I'm curious.
Look up on youtube arthur would of lived he would of helped john in rdr1
Ill asd u ill send u the video i watched on it if he lived
That's okay, I don't add people on here, just DM's.
I sent it
Not for long
Just watched it... I mean, it's possible, I guess... but what about the TB? Arthur is meant to get sick so he can redeem himself by the end of his life.
Mean idk the video and I don't wanna watch it. But if Arthur didn't die from his TB, or from the missions of from when the Pinkertons were hunting them down
Like idk if he'd have lasted long in ww1. Like it's not far away
So this is the rdr2 chat?
Indeed it is! 😊
Yea
Okie
Thou convincest me
why are you talking like this lol
Why not?
Thou doest not like that type of speech?
you mean wherefore not


Sorry? What do you mean?
Thou convincest me
You convince me
Why.. didn't you just say that? xD
I like old english
Thus, i speak old English
Fair enough.. but for some, it could be confusing. 😅
Verily
I rate it 7/10 old english
I found Reverend Swanson in chapter 1, where he readeth a passage from the bible, and i liked it
Its not fantastic, but its okay
Thank thee for thine opinion
Wild...
What is?
What's up with it
Nothing. I just thought it was wild lol
I mean I can understand the rp aspect of it. I just didnt expect to see it soo early in the morning ( for me) lol
Yeah, they responded to me and I didn't understand they as a reply 😅
So i have my mustache at lenght 7
i have the spartan
im drinking hair tonics but its not growing anymore
Grow everything then.
oh ok thanks
I don't know EXACTLY how the mechanic works, but I also have a lvl 7 spartan stache. I had downed some hair tonics and it didn't grow either. I bet there's something in there about not being able to grow if the lowest point is too low.
Keep in mind, those last few levels can take a while even with a hair tonic. The more hair tonics, the better
Does anyone else have the bug where later on in the game, the "Save Outfit" option bugs out and then you can't save 4 or 5 outfits, only 2 and they eventually save in the wrong order too?
Like, say you deleted all saved outfits, then you start again, save one thinking it'll save as Outfit 1, but it saves as Outfit 2 or 3.
No but I’ve had the game straight up delete saved outfits
Have you tried restarting your game?
It's happened through multiple playthroughs.
It's actually a fairly common bug.
I just thought to ask here.
Restarting the game has solved it in my experience.
As in, you have experienced that exact bug?
Yeah? But I'm also on PC, so I'm unclear the differences between systems.
Saved the game, restarted, every outfit was where it should be.
Upgraded saddle bags
You didn't say yes when I first asked, hence why I did to clarify.
I'm on PS5.. restarting didn't help, pretty sure when I first discovered the bug, I went through a lot research, nothing ever worked.
I've only noticed it happens later on in the game, but I forget exactly as it's when if feel like a chance in outfits.
Like I said, it's a common bug, Reddit has several threads about it.
And it's not just about outfits being where they should be, it's also about it bugging out when you want to create a whole new wardrobe of outfits, the "Save Outfit" bugs out.
"Save Outfit" greys out* I meant.
I mean I only figured out yesterday how to have Arthur's shirt unbuttoned
I guess i just never figured it out properly
Nice! How long you been playing the game?
This is my second playthrough
Im mid chapter 4 and really wanna restart cause I miss my irish man
Ahh, okay, fair enough.. I actually can't remember how I figured it out - may have Google'd it, I can't remember. 😅
What do you mean?
Next playthrough
Oh right, makes more sense.
It's almost 8:15pm in the UK here, having a joint and drink.. anyone else (hopefully of a legal age in your country xD) having a smoke/drink?
Well one of those things aren't legal here but you do you boo /lh
Oh, I know, known that since I started xD
It's not legal, I mean.. it is if you get it through a doctor.. but I don't.
But yeah.. kind've smell it almost anytime you walk anywhere.
germanys gotten funny with it since the legalisation
that is so real
he has so little time
Help a blind man
im gonna kick a blind man
Thou shalt show mercy unto the blind
fr. he deserved more time.
cackled
shouldve been literally anyone else instead
Like I've put over like 72+ hours into this save
But I'm still like
restart restart restart Sean Sean Sean
Weird how?
well damn germany liked it before that but its BAD
I don't know who else id rather it to be 😭.
His death was so tragic 💔
it was unexpected, just shock value nothing else really
I mean so was Lennys
122 for me
im also mid chapter 4
I just wish we had more time with him
yes
More quests
more missions
getting to know him and all
he had more potential thats all im saying
Not sure why you said "well damn", but fair enough, wasn't aware of that
Lenny was such an abrupt death, like Hosea.. no time to mourn.
?
jeezzzz
Let us go drinking with Sean
poor sean
I wasn't sure what "well damn" meant in your response, but fair enough, I wasn't aware of the Germany thing
hes definitely a runner
no idea whats confusing about that but sure
shouldve chased after him
Arthur and Sean would so get in fights
lets pretend hes still alive
because his death didnt have any big story value anyways
Apologies, got a bit of an overthinking thing, and don't always understand stuff - but never mind. xD
yes. brothers energy
*cmon u feckin Englishmen show me whatcha made of"
Things went to shit after his death
He pops his clogs out his brain, and then everybody's dying
it was a turning point, but said turning point is flexible
Things went to shit long before, they just didn't appreciate how badly until Sean.
But we deserved more Sean 😭😭 We should've gone drinking with that lad
but theres nothing really pointing to sean you get me?
could have been someone else. unlike in other death cases
Honestly only reason Im wanting to play rdo and stray from storymode is for his missions 😅
its just rude that hes so likeable and funny 
The person you spent a dangerous mission rescuing, rescued from torture and certain death, loved like a rascally brother and everything feels like on the up and up? No one else fit better.
He'd have loved ragebaiting people
still does not set him as the target. no reason to discuss it further cause i unfortunately aint gonna change my opinion. have a good one
100%
What are you talking about?
I just wish Arthur had been more affected by people's deaths
I'm talking like this is a TV show not a game 😭
LMAOO
well the storymode is massive in this game so thats fair
i almost wrote fat

Bros little brother figure got shot in the head, his dad figure got shot in the heart, then his bestie Lenny gets shot to, gets diagnosed with TB and he's like yeah let's continue on
What do you mean "still does not set him as the target"?
We ball
what i said before
Dude.
yeah but you do gotta see how hes already went through so much crap
probably shaped him, i still get what you mean though
I'm literally telling you that you aren't making sense. "What I said before" does not help. I'm looking for you to expand or rephrase it.
Explain what you mean.
it does! if you actually read back, i already rephrased what i said before.
I'm asking for more explanation, why are you being weird about it?
i am not, i am pointing to the message
Are you trolling? Your explanation isn't relaying what you're thinking adequately. It doesn't make sense. Would you try and rephrasing it?
Expanding on it, might help.
It does not set Sean as the target. = There is nothing pointing to Sean having to be the target.
this is the relation between the messages
Right, that's the meaningless of it. The pointless loss of life all in service of "the plan"
i was rephrasing what i already said before
Sean is someone you cared for, took great risk to save, and soon after pointlessly extinguished over the unnecessarily risky plan to make more money. If it feels unsatisfying, that's the point of what they're trying to get across with Dutch's plan.
i am going to have to remind you of what i said here. your opinion is ok and so is mine and im afraid we are done discussing now, ive decided to keep my opinion
Are we talkin about Sean’s impact on the story? Given what I’m understanding from context
His death specifically and why it was him
Even tho I wish it wasn't an we got more time with my boy
yep 🙂↕️
Honestly how I see it, the greys just shot anyone that was related to van der linde gang. I don’t think Sean was exactly targeted, he was just the one they decided to take a shot, in turn starting the gun fight and all that
You shouldn't disparage yourself like that, insisting on your narrative and symbolic illiteracy and total unwillingness to consider you're empty interpretation is worth challenging. You're better than that. If that was the case, why bother? A chatbot can tell you you're right unquestioningly if that's what you actually wanted.
and abraham reyes
Probably recognised his beautiful accent from when he burnt down the fields
yeah no thats not what we meant - more like somebody else could have died and it wouldnt have still made sense
abraham reyes impregnated a girl
but youre all good
and rip van winkle caught them in the middle of the act
bad job to be an irish red head
not gonna lie
LMAO
Ya greys probably recognized his accent, who wouldn’t honestly?
hes not exactly subtle
His accent is recognizable anywhere lmao
i love it
right, i'll go argue a bit with chat gpt, seems like the better option definitely
With it being as dark as it was when they burnt the fields could they have seen his ginger hair tho?
And his stupid fucking hat which I love way to much
100%
It was daytime when they took the wagon in
i gotta buy one
I adore his stupid hat 😭
same
Why am I not recalling it being daylight? I must’ve done the mission purely at night if that’s possible🤔
its not
The fields was nighttime
theres a point where you wait for it to get dark

Before the guy gets absolutely murked
Fire was probably bright enough to see his hair
still havent gotten rid of the damn squirrel and raccoon curse
but who saw it and survived
I’m still working on my 100 completion😭
im just happy to get those fucking animals
Exotics is my worst nightmare right now
Some people were left alive to my knowledge. You just kept shooting till you could get away. But I doubt everyone got murked
What's your guys' go to for the cougar challenge? I go for the area near the Trapper just North of Owanjila lake
I've not done the challenge yet, but that's where I've been going to get the camp cougars
Ahh, nice! I know there's other places, but that's the one I tend to go with...
Hopefully kill find it - kill it - skin it - pick up the corpse and either put it else where or sell to the Trapper - camp a while away to "reset" things - then go back a day'ish later
is there a role here for getting the ''it's art'' achievement?
oh yeah you got it alr
Roles are in the role channel
Oh yeah i didnt have that shown
I just remembered, I created an Arthur Morgan inspired piece a few years ago.. but there's no where on this Discord to post art, that I can see anyway.
Ahhh man, I'd love to show you guys it.
I just spent so many hours hunting muskrats just for my laptop to shut down moments before I get to camp
Thank you.
For what reason though?
Also, I posted my art.
Garments
As part of outfits, okay, I didn't know if they were mentioning part of a mission/quest or something.
does every gang hideout/enemy encounter get backup?
Camp. Needed legendary pelt for camp
Well
Perfect pelt
No, not every one, that I've experienced.
right, thank you. every one i remember definitely did and every time it jumpscared me because they spawned in VERY close
Roughly around Annesburg, you get those weirdos at someone elses camp, then you kill them, then back up comes up
I don't think I've actually experienced many "back ups" with camps outside.. UNLESS it's a big camp in a mission or a quest...
From my vague memory anyway.
Ahhh, that explains it!
I mean, I've played the game 4 - 5 times (only completed 2 - 3 times as I found Chapter 6 too depressing), but have never put in any effort with the camp.. as I learnt that you don't get any rewards for it... so that's why I asked because Muskrats don't tend to come up.
(unless they come up with the Trapper, but I can't remember, so I could be very wrong)
I like making the camp look pretty
That is absolutely fair enough!
It's just when I first saw how much you had to get and then learnt that you don't actually earn anything from all the hunting... it put me off. 😅
But maybe.. I'll just give it a go in this playthrough.
If anyone wants to see my art of Arthur Morgan, I posted it in #community-content 🙂
why do you lose honour for killing lemoyne raiders that jump you after that one bridge?
im so confused
definitely wasnt the horses or npcs
random npcs*
Sir, it is honor
as i am taught british english in school i prefer the british spelling 
now dont drown my question
Thine art looketh great
In school i learn british English also
But Blessed are the Americans
If youre speaking old English you gotta use the British English spellings
the only correct opinion
Wherefore
I do antagonize strauß, but i do not antagonise him
The reason is i just do not like British spelling
You gotta do it for the bit
If you're speaking old English you gotta do it for the bit. Go all out
Verily i pronounce it with an s, but wherefore should i spell it with an s
I am not used to it
Nay
true that
not impossible to change
Ye know...
They did it to cut down printing costs in newspapers
Maybe the game did not realize they started it first
yeah nothing good comes out of being poor /j
So they got rid of the u's changed e's and A's and what not
i started the interaction, they started their dialogue and started shooting
they didnt get to finish.
What is it with /j and /hj


It's to help people understand the tone of the messages
i appreciate them and i dont wish to offend anyone
I don't think that's true.
Like /srs is serious /sarc is sarcasm /nm is not mad /gen is genuine
Just makes tones easier to distingish
i merely joked about american english spelling:)
Like if I called one my friends a fucking idiot and put /j or /lh they'd know I wouldn't be insulting them yknow
Swear this is a new thing cause just recently I’ve seen people adding these to their messages and all that
No it's not new
its been around since the 2000's
One time, a stranger likeneth me to the type of my speech, i look like Trelawny, is that what he saith is correct?
It's been a thing since atleast 2020
when online chats started
Well me personally I hadn’t seen people start using /j and /gen and all that until fairly recently
its popular nowadays. its especially good for neurodivergent people and anyone who struggles to read between the lines
That might be due to the social circles you run in.
yep
Everybody I knew was using them back in 2020 if not before
most people only use the very basic ones but there is a lot
oh yea definitely
I mean I guess, idk🤷🏻♀️
It most likely would be. I've not seen them stop getting used since they gained popularity again
sonny respawns after you kill him before the first encounter???
ive never heard of that happening
i have returned to the house once after killing him to loot
wasnt there
okay for some reason its the first encounter mixed with the second....? i am so confused

dialogue got chopped up
why redoing American Venom is so satisfying?
Being English of Irish descent, I smiled at this haha.
Yes he does.
heard people say he doesnt, weird
but again my encounter was glitched too

killed him again afterwards
let him beg, though
I set him on fire
Well I had his first encounter as John in my first playthrough, killed him when John realised what happened and rode past a few days later and he was there
I wenr back to sonny as john the second time i set him on fire
He ran inside because he knew death was coming haha
Yeah
He even called John a creep lol
yep
The irony in that
LMAO?
Bill will tease you in camp if it happens to Arthur
Arthur singing while on his horse gives me joy
When he is drunk too haha
Anyone on?
no.
Ok well anyone see my fashion posts?
no.
How do you get this to happen btw? I’ve had it occur 1 time in my whole play through and it’s never happened again since
Oh and you gotta like almost do walking speed on hirse
I thought I was being followed by a random npc when my Arthur started singing
Wasn’t expecting it at all lol
I set a routine for roleplay purposes in my playthroughs. Arthur usually sleeps at midnight unless he is night hunting
Speaking of singing, any one else like the camp fire songs? One eyed Riley is hilarious
Poor lonesome cowboy and as we go marching on are my personal favorites
Those are good ones too along with the Jack Hall song
I did all the requirements in their correct order for Robbie Laidlaw's bounty hunting mission but it still won't trigger, shame
So weird question but I wonder why you can't buy RDO gear as add-ons for the story? Id pay five bucks for 3 online horses to use in the story. Probably buy several packs like that
Shoot, id buy the weapons too, would love to see that elephant gun knock Arthur on his ass and make him cuss it out or something
100 men’s vs “Oh dear Arthur, You never showed up”
1000 men’s vs “ there’s a good men in you but he’s wrestling with a gient”
10,000 men’s vs “ I give you all I had, I did”
100,000 men’s vs “ uh you have tuberculosis”
guys for the hunter master challenges, where can i find rabbits, and what gun is good for killing them
Thou canst use the varmint rifle to hunt them, and they are everywhere but the snowy parts, try forests
And do not forget to get the legendary buck trinket, it will help thee
And also they will be running across the roads near horseshoe overlook
rabbits can be found everywhere, mostly in forests, can be killed using varmint rifle or a bow with small game arrows, remember, SMALL GAME ARROWS, not normal arrows
buck trinket if you want to get better pelts
if just for hunting rabbits, then you don't need to go get the buck trinket
but, buck trinket is useful
so you'll get some more money as a side bonus
He wanteth rabbits for the master hunter challenge
wait, the master hunter challenge requires pelts?
Thus i suggested he shall use this trinket
Yea
ohhh
Master hunter 2 or 3 i guess
It requireth 3 perfect rabbit pelts
but yeah, if for pelts, buck trinket is the way to go
also, definitely use eagle eye, and dead shot for more accuracy when aiming for the animal
aim at the head
small game arrows are generally preferred for their silence, varmint rifle will be a bit louder (I think, rarely ever bothered to hunt rabbits)
bows are just...generally good for hunting
that and poison knives
do a fetch quest for javier and you can get poison knives and arrows....or is it just knives
but yeah, those stuff allow you to kill a bison with just one knife
Who doesn't kill a bison with a shotgun
dude, that ruins the pelt
you don't kill bison with a shotgun
you kill them with a bolt action or springfield
that or a bow with big game arrows
shotguns are risky
unless you're using slugs, don't use shotgun for bison
headshot? no
just....don't use shotgun for hunting
definitely no
one hundred percent
rifles are best
no, bows are best
bows have all types of arrows
small game arrows, normal arrows, improved arrows, poison arrows
and they don't alert nearby animals as much
but yeah, rifles are good too
just remember, always hit a headshot
buck trinket decreases your chances of ruining the pelt
also scout the animal beforehand with a binocular, I think those can scout out what type of pelt they'll have
pristine being perfect
yeah, cover scent lotions are probably for the best
baits are good too
Nay, varmint rifle is the best
(For small animals like rabbits of course)
bows have small game arrows for that
bow may look primitive, sure, but it works better than anything
Yea, but... Varmint rifle is cool
and you can collect those arrows back
Convincing
the look of a tool is not what makes it cool, rather its usefulness
that's why double action revolvers aren't as cool as compared to the m1899s
LeMat revolver is the best
Thou shalt try them
It combineth both revolver and shotgun
Maybe
Yea
But verily, since i bought the LeMat revolver, i have never used a revolver or a pistol other than it
I shall go waste my time hunting animals for the legend of the east satchel
gl
I hate hunting small animals
I found a squirrel that was
, i shot it in the head with a varmint rifle, and it became 
Wherefore?

What is going ooon - afternoon from the UK
whats yall main revolvers (don't say otis miller's)
Afternoon from the... Somewhere on the earth
LeMat
Verily
a worn out cattleman revolver
Wherefore is my buck trinket not working?
still dont have dual holster 😭
Thou shalt buy one
poor fella
fella atleast I have lvl 9 dead eye
ill give you $15
ayy
15 dollars and a quarter
tf am I supposed to get
1 can of peeches?
2 cans of sweetcorn?
you keep killing folk dutch
I found a buck, a gift from the lord of the earths and the heavens
I have finally found a buck
Blessed are the bucks
a buck
Yea
you keep killing bucks @modern bobcat
atleast the buck had faith
bro you can find like 20 bucks in the dakota river
I shall hunt animals for the Legend of the East satchel
how many gold bars can you carry with that
?
Thou shalt ask r*
oh yeah arthur has 34kg of goldbars and 24kg of gold nuggets
bros satchel is like
I have found a deer, a gift from the lord of the earth and the heavens
i didnt know that you'd lose all your gold when you give the satchel to john
rip $500
how is john lifiting a satchel that has like 50kg of gold bars and every item known to mankind
I saw a cougar in my dream, verily it hath scared me
cos he has faith
they were talking about hanging him
you didnt bro
you just needed more moneh 😔
micah could have killed john if john wasnt fast enough
you just shot him 1 time
I swear bro I could have shot dutch in the ass when he walks away
prevents rdr1 anyway
so everybody lives happily ever after
we can never leave the past behind dutch
you think we can run away from the things we done
Dutch... When Swanson readeth "Have ye not known? have ye not heard? hath it not been told you from the beginning? have ye not understood from the foundations of the earth?", i remember hosea trying to stop ye from doing the blackwater job
micah is a rat dutch I gave you all I had
We needed the money
Sometimes a few has to die to save a whole lot
they will not crush us you said that dutch
When karen, bill, lenny and arthur robbed the valentine bank there was more than enough money to help ye going to tahiti
it couldve
you keep killing folk dutch
i just needed you to stay loyal
I dont eat folk...
you destroy everything in your path
killing angelo bronte why the hell would you do that
but that got all the heat on us
plus who steals a goddam boy to harm him
he even gave him some worm food
and then he put the law on us...
well killing him put more law on us
Doth camp upgrades that can be crafted stay to the next chapter?
Are you still speaking in old English?
Yea, wherefore not?
Thank thee
Just a little confusing to understand what you're saying sometimes, that's all.
Lo, that is the reason wherefore i speak early modern english
I don't understand, sorry. 😅

Okay, xD
Where are people's go to for cougar hunting for the challenge? I usually go just North of Owanjila
I usually go North*
The only time i hunted a cougar i went to the north of owanjila
So.. same as what I've said.
Weird, so, you.. tend to go in and out of Old English? xD
Nay it is just that i do not know any words in this sentence that are different between early modern English and modern English
Right, gotcha. xD
Yea
It feeleth impossible to hunt a perfect squirrel
It's almost always the case with this game, perfect pelts appear when you're not looking for it and then don't when you are xD
I alway find perfect squirrels, but when i hunt them even if i shoot them in the head it is not perfect
Sorry, you just contradicted yourself a little bit there... but uhm.. have you got the trinket to help? And are you using the right weapon?
Yea
I have the buck trinket, and i use the varmint rifle
Well, if you're using the right things, then maybe you're just not hitting them correctly.
I just found one and shot it in the head and it was 
But thanks to the lord my trinket worked
But that's 2, not 3. xD
Yea
It was
, i shot it in the head using a varmint rifle, and it became 
So.. the trinket didn't work... so I'm not sure why you're thanking the lord xD
When i picked it up it worked
Sorry, I don't quite get what you're saying. 😅
does anyone know why i can only have 5 tonics when i try to craft ? Im trying to do herbalist 7 ive read the pamphlet already but it only lets me craft 5 tonics and idk how to add the special miracle tonic to the 5.
When i picked up the squirrel that was
it became
because of the trinket
You need to upgrade your satchel
to which one
The limit of tonics thou canst carry is 3, with the tonics satchel it is 5, with the legend of the east satchel it is 99
oh ok ill try that ty
You need to hunt animals for it
no wait i have legend of east satchel already
im saying is that when i try to craft
Just drink some and you'll be able to make more
But you said just earlier that it was 3 star... shot in the head and it became 2...
Now you're saying you picked it up as a 2 and it became 3....
I'm sorry, I tend to struggle understanding when things aren't properly articulated. 😅
i can only have 5 recipes
and theres no special miracle in the 5 tonics i have in the crafting menu
You need the Legend satchel to carry more than 5.
Yea, because i have the buck trinket which highereth the chance of receiving perfect quality animal parts
Or the tonic one
I am sure that there is a big misunderstanding between us
I think there is, as I'm not understanding you on my end, my apologies.
Yeah.. I always skipped all the satchels and just got pelts for every satchel to then upgrade to the Legend one xD
Thou dost not have to apologize, it is me who shall apologize for not clearing things
Does somebody know when i get guns with john? I want to go get arthur's money from the pig farm but i can't because i don't have any guns
That is what i am doing right now
Which epilogue art thou on?
Epilogue 1 and the last mission i did was cleaning up horse poop
Thou shalt wait, thou wilt get thy weapons someday
Ok but it's kinda boring i want the guns back
What's boring, sorry?
Thou canst not even use weapons, wherefore thou needest them?
Not having guns with john
I need them to get arthur's money from the pig farm
We need MONEY
Thou canst get arthur's money without weapons
Fair enough! It's been a while since I've fully completed the game, so I can't really remember, so.. but I think it's after you work at the ranch
You can punch people
Verily
And you get your guns back eventually
Verily? 😆
Or thou bumpest into them until they eventually die
Yeah but i don't think i'd win against that fat guy in the pig farm
You'd be suprised
Another way of saying indeed, i hope
Youll never know unless you try
Oooh, I read it as "Very" xD
I tried and got absolutly destroyed before getting to the farm
Thou shalt try
In dede
Huh?
That is not what my Bible saith
You're getting this from the bible???
The irony that you don't understand Fake Sean 😆
I heard swanson reading a passage from kjv bible, and i liked that language used in it
Oh well I wouldn't say it's old English
Early modern, from what i have been told
Yeah thats diff to old English 😭
The history nerd In me has been quaking the whole time
Did you just keep hanging around Swanson to sort've learn what he says or something?
You're speaking Shakespeare, old english is like beowulf
I just saw him reading from his bible in colter, and i was surprised with that wonderful language
Yes, but you've "learned" quite a few words.. so I'm just wondering how long you hung around as it's obviously stuck with you xD
Or do you use that translator online
I learned everything i know right now in under 30 minutes
or just know it of the top of the head
No idea how
Eh nay
👃🏿
Woah
Yes... but my question is how long did you hang around Swanson to learn?
Just 5 minutes in colter
5 minutes listening to the beauty swanson reads, and 25 minutes doing some research on how to speak like that, and i have learned it in that 25 minutes
What is going on with thee brother?
👶🏿
Ooooh, okay, gotcha - see, I think you need to work on how you articulate what you're saying xD
Idk bored messing with ppl
Yea, i guess
You'll probably get booted if you don't contribute to the actual chat
Not trying to be rude, but that's why I've had to ask questions to clarify.
Yeah.. so, it's kind've pointless you sending those faces.
O
Which books thou suggestest?
Kl
I personally really like Macbeth
great play
Thank thee, i shall read it
"OKl"? xD
@ember ridge u support lgbt?
Also, did Shakespeare shake a spear?
yes
Midsummers night dream is also a good play
He writes plays not book, but its really good
🙁
Oh i also liked the tempest
That was goofy as hell
#calibanbabies
Thats a refrence people whove read the tempest will understand
Oh, we have a homophobic here, do we?
Bruh
"Bruh" 😆
Bruvvah
Why...?
In my life
Alot of people in here are lgbtq+
What's your point here?
Oo
And mostly everyone supports them
Okay meevrik
Supports in my country
If you don't support LGTQ+, you're welcome to leave... you already said you're bored and want to mess around with people... so, that isn't wanted here.
Hmm
idk why but not the legend or the tonic one increases the recipes. they do increase the carrying number but i still only have 5 recipes and theres no special miracle tonic even though i have the pamphlet and read it. Is it possible to remove a pamphlet maybe that i dont need someway so i can add the special miracle tonic one?
Meevrik lets not
Yeah... we don't want anything negative like that here.
You can have those opinons but dont show them
Ok
Keep them in a box and stow them away. They're not wanted here
Oh i thought you were talking about the amount of ones you can make. Idk why you're having problems. I have more then 5 tonic recipes im pretty sure
I have some opinions that Will get me banned, verily, but i prefer keeping them in a box and stowing them away
Did Shakespeare shake a spear?
Anyone know how to fix this glitch where after the epilogue everyone at beechers hope just disappears
No idea why you felt the need to come on this chat and ask about lgbtq+...
Opinions about what?
Don't ask
One day i have asked 3 english teachers in my school about this, two said no and one said i don't know
Exactly
That's not a glitch, that's meant to happen. xD
I wasn't sure the context, but fair enough!
Let him keep his opinions secret espically if they can be contrevisal.
Were you the one that asked yesterday
Is it about LGTBQ+?
Yeah
I told you yesterday 😭
How about we talk about hunting rabbits?
Oops
Do a mission if theres one available
Bobo's asking a question that they already got the answer for? xD
its meant to happen
Hmmm... I hope you're not phobic in any way... but okay. 😅
I am heightophobic
Scared of heights
Why is Bobo asking a question that you already answered? xD
Riiiiight... xD
Mightve missed it
Fair enough
Yea
Oh wait... Beecher's Hope... I just realised.. I thought you meant an older camp from the main Story... but yeah, it's before the events of RDR1, so the Beacher's Hope hadn't been built yet.
If theyre all gone still do a mission
I’m trying to 100% and this is the first time ive spent a lot of time post-epilogue so yeah never noticed it until now
Can someone help me
What's up?
I gotta do herbalist 9 next man 
So I’m playing online and I’m doing the hired body guard easy prey it says search the area for clues and I cannot find anything it’s been like one hour
Oooh, you might want to go on the Online chat, this is Single Player chat
I haven't played Online, so can't help you there
Ohh okay tysm
You're welcome. 🙂
Just want to know beforehand after I complete herbalist are the sharpshooter challenges easy or hard
Herbalist is long
Ive done the first 2
Sharpshooter is okay if you know how to use weapons
Can john helpeth Saint denis' mayor?
Not really hard, just yeah, takes a while - walkthroughs help though.
I got the gambler ones over with thank god
Gambler 8
I did that within like 30 minutes
Probably because they take so long and you win by luck... waiting.. and waiting.. and waiting.... and more waiting.. xD
You got some good Rng then
I just sat there and hit no matter what cards i had
till i reached three and then i stood
Gambler 9 is overhated
Im on gambler 9 right now. Its fustrating depending on the type of domineos game you're playing
Takes time but if you’re losing you can just quit and your progress won’t restart
Emerald Ranch was the easiest imo
Yeah, I've done the YouTube hacks where you sit in a particular chair and sit up to skip stuff and all that with Gambler 8 I think it was
The worst thing of 100% is by far those damn exotics
It is recommended to do Emerald Ranch so it's more likely that not as many people will be there
Ahhh... the exotics mission... that was... fun.... xD
Yeah im doing that one atm
I was told i should wait to hunt the ochids till herbalist 9
so im doing that first
I am dreading the hunting requests
Oh ive done one
Same
But where the hell are you meant to find a woodpecker
or rats 😭 or any of the ones in the 2nd one
You know the cabin with the bear in it that scares you? There
Rats... the cave behind a waterfall, forgot which one
There is a 3 star perfect rat up on Mount Hagen
Can i find a perfect elk in tempest rim or outside of the game map?
Already dead too
Good to know.. I didn't think abotu the 3 star thing xD
It even gives you a unique gun!
I just use YouTube for those requests
And almost every collectible
I shall search for perfect elks outside of the game map
Why? And isn't Tempest Rim not an accessable area?
Because i can not find elks inside the game map when i am looking for them, and if i find it is only 
And yea, tempest rim is not accessible
Also how bad are the master hunter challenges?
Thank youuu
My brain is just not undestanding "outside of the game map" xD
Thank youu
I find perfect elks only when I look for perfect moose
I've not even seen a moose
It's usually on the actual horizontal beams
I thought you were being fr i was like awh thanks
Is there anywhere else I can ask for help no one is answering and I’m just stuck here on my desk waiting idk what to do 😭
But... how can you find an animal... when you're "outside" the game map.. it's just non exisitent... that's my confusion xD
No cause lots of people dont play rdo
Have you googled it?
To be fr there is a mini mission in Saint Denis where a bar owner asks you to kill rats
I’m shocked tbh
I did that!
Ah dang
I only got good pelts
I have and I can’t find anything on it
Gotta be patient, people aren't always going to be online in that section to answer.
I was well miffed
Caves are a good option ig
I guess but I can’t wait for hours while my pc is on :(
Unless these guys have played Online, then not sure what we can do to help really
I used a a small game arrow or my varmint rifle but still only good pelts. I was super mad 😭
Algeron Wasp how much I hate you
I guess it’s just so frustrating because I tried everything in the game I can’t find a damn clue like dude 😵💫
Wherefore doth not r* make rdo cross-platform
Still confused by what you mean by "outside of the game map"
There would be nothing, because it's not the game, it's non existent... so what did you mean by that? xD
Cause its different controls so itd be unfair
Gambler 8 is why I don’t play blackjack in rdr2 ever again 
Somewhere to the north of tempest rim
Outside of the playable map
Yeah, but why do you want to go there...? If there's going to be no animals there...?

Dude, this is what I meant by articulating xD
theyre easy to find
There are few animals near the map borders but they do not move
Nay
Go north of strawberry or van horn near the waterfall thing where the posionus map leads you to
i see them all the time and theyre one of the animals that are slow and dont flee easily
Theres so many of them
Thank thee
Yeah... map borders, but not literally outside of the game, because it's non existent xD
I thank thee
there is terrain outside of the map borders that is "playable" in some way.
Outside of the playable map, but not far from the playable map borders
Oooooh... okay, see now that I understood.
I thank thee for thy correction unto my speech
But when you said "outside of the game map".. i'm picturing Arthur in the non existent part. xD

just unreleased content and place holders to avoid having the borders look "cut off"
I'm potentially Neurodivergent, so I don't always understand and think things in a literal sense.
I have tried going there... for fun and all that, but when fgh4 said "outside the map", that didn't make sense to me xD
Anyway, I'm getting a snack xD
Imagine arthur walking above land that doth not exist, it maketh no sense but it is hilarious in a way
I may need to YouTube the hack/glitch, as I want to go to Tempest Rim... and I'm pretty OCD when it comes to revealing all of the black lines in the map, and that's the only place where it's not totally black, only a little
dont say im pretty ocd ever again like that 💀
Goest somewhere near wapiti, gettest drunk, and thou art in tempest rim
I mean, I haven't been officially diagnosed with Neurodivency, but I am on a waiting list and OCD is something I look into as well.. so that's why I said that.
using ocd as a term to talk about wanting to have something very neat or perfect without it actually relating to ocd is disrespectful whether you have it or not
i am not attacking you but it is uneccesary. its a term thats widely misused
No, but respectfully, if you're going to tell someone to do something, kindly ask them, don't tell them "Don't say that ever again".
Okay, so I'll rephrase it... I like things being very neat, so I like revealing the entire map...
I mean, fair enough, if it's disrespectful, I genuinely didn't intend for it to be that way.
But it's also a little disrespectful to tell someone you don't know to not do something "ever again".
i totally mean it that way





