red-dead-singleplayer

[brave tulip]

I think I was robed before I was stranded on that island

[midnight ocean]

nope

[silent peak]

Bruhhh

[midnight ocean]

theyll be gone whether you kill them or not

but the money will remain

you can encounter sonny as john tho

[silent peak]

It gives you % in the progress?

[cobalt fiber]

The encounter?

[midnight ocean]

probably counts as a chance encounter but thats it

[silent peak]

Yes

[midnight ocean]

go to progress and total completion to see everything needed for 100%

[cobalt fiber]

It's an ambush encounter isn't it ?

You need to get ambushed by a gang

[brave tulip]

How hard is it to get money as John tho?

I can’t imagine ranching is particularly lucrative

[silent peak]

Missions and strangers completed

Random encounter too

[midnight ocean]

nah i dont think aberdeens count as that

they might not count as anything tbh

[cobalt fiber]

Cruel cruel world I'm moving on 🎵🎵

[midnight ocean]

oh uh spoiler maybe

oops

[forest nexus]

who are your guys fav character

[midnight ocean]

sean

[cobalt fiber]

I did all the chores cuz there was nothing to do at 3am 💀 literally all the hay bales and sacks and water buckets that was fun

[cobalt fiber]

" Hey guys I guess that's it " ahh fate

[silent peak]

Dutch

[forest nexus]

i love hosea

[cobalt fiber]

Fr man

[brave tulip]

For my second play trough, should I just go all in on dishonorable ? First time I tried being a goodie two shoes.
What is the benefit of dishonorable? For my high honor I got big discounts on things I buy

[silent peak]

U could do this

Be dishonorable at chapter 1 to 5

[cobalt fiber]

Better loot from the dead bodies and a cool grip for double action revolver if you're low honor

[silent peak]

Then, when Arthur discover he has TB, start being honorable again

[cobalt fiber]

But what about the optional honor missions

Like the one with mary in chapter 2

Your honor must be high

[brave tulip]

Does going for the money do anything post chapter 6?

[midnight ocean]

he forgot to activate his shield generator

[silent peak]

Well then, i dont know

Its just an idea

[midnight ocean]

unfortunately i think that grip is bugged and is actually available with high honor instead

[brave tulip]

Sounds like a fun way to play I think

[midnight ocean]

also according to the offical guide you get more of certain kinds of loot if you're high honor but more of others if you're low

low honor gives better loot from lawmen i think

and i wanna say more jewelry in general

and high honor gives more tonics

something like that

[silent peak]

I its like “ive been a bad guy all the way here. Lets, at least in the end be a good one”

Redemption

[cobalt fiber]

Makes sense

[brave tulip]

Is rdr1 worth playing?

[forest nexus]

yes

[midnight ocean]

i dont think you need high honor for that one

[cobalt fiber]

Yes I completed it and the undead nightmare as well

That shit is so peak

[silent peak]

Does anyone knows where are the Black and White wanted posters?

[cobalt fiber]

You do I didn't see the " ML " mission logo until I was high honor where you have to meet her in valentine

[midnight ocean]

coincidence maybe

some missions only pop up at certain times of day

[brave tulip]

Ok. And the rdr online? How is that? Are players fun to play with or is it filled with trolls/griefers?

[cobalt fiber]

Oh hell nah

I hate online

No offence to anyone who plays it

[silent peak]

I want to play online just for the missions

[cobalt fiber]

What's your favourite horse guys ?

[silent peak]

I dont know too much about them

[cobalt fiber]

Mine is Rachel and Missouri fox trotter

And probably andalusian and turkoman as well

[forest nexus]

i like arabian

but

[silent peak]

Do i guys know where are de Mr Black and Mr White wanted poster?

[forest nexus]

rhodes

[brave tulip]

I like the Arabian but Arthur is a big guy and the horse looks like a pony with him on it

[forest nexus]

i agree

[silent peak]

Its only there?

[cobalt fiber]

It's in Rhodes

You can see it on your map as well

[forest nexus]

there scattered in rhodes

in the town itself only

[silent peak]

Ohh

[cobalt fiber]

One is in the post office

[midnight ocean]

turkoman

[cobalt fiber]

The saloon

I guess

[forest nexus]

My fav horse is Strawberry Roan Ardennes

[silent peak]

I dont lnow its name in english but its Mestiço Hungaro

[tepid ledge]

Mine is the Tiger Stripped Mustang.

[cobalt fiber]

They don't look like an outlaw horses and also they are skittish but they have good stats

[cobalt fiber]

Hungarian halfbred?

That's a good war horse

[silent peak]

I think so

[forest nexus]

Really nice

[brave tulip]

What are the benefits of a war horse tho?

[cobalt fiber]

They are less skittish than the other breeds

But they still buck you off

[tepid ledge]

Fearless I think, isn't so afraid of predators.

[brave tulip]

Ok so they won’t freak out when wolves are nearby

[cobalt fiber]

Nope not immediately

[silent peak]

And shots too

[forest nexus]

i rarely get bucked off the Strawberry Roan Ardennes

[cobalt fiber]

You still gotta press the calm button tho

" easy there girl "

[forest nexus]

il find a pic of my roan

[lyric pike]

is there any other way to get small game arrows other than crafting them getting flight feathers isnt hard but it takes some time and you only get 1 per bird

[midnight ocean]

pretty sure horse bravery isnt real btw

its mostly just the bond level

[silent peak]

Nope

[cobalt fiber]

You can use morgan to kill the legendary panther 💀

I did

If you have max bonding

[silent peak]

I got a horse level 4 of bond and i tried to rob a place and he ran away cus of the bullets

[midnight ocean]

i think they all do that

[cobalt fiber]

Use the calm button during fights and near the predators

[midnight ocean]

ive heard smaller horses appear to scare more easily from predators because the center of the horse appears to be farther away when the horse is small

[forest nexus]

il send in #red-dead-media

[cobalt fiber]

Alr imma share mine

[silent peak]

Yeah but, i robbed a store and, when i find it, my horse wheremiles from me, i had to run to my horse whole town

[cobalt fiber]

I named my trotter " McQueen"

Since she's the fastest

[brave tulip]

Can y’all help me figure out what trinkets, talismans I am missing? I will send pics in the media channel

[silent peak]

What horse do you guys recommend me?

[silent peak]

And where can i find it

[cobalt fiber]

You can use andalusian if you want a brave one

[silent peak]

You know its name in portuguese?

[cobalt fiber]

Cavalo Andaluz

[silent peak]

Thx

[cobalt fiber]

I used google translate so

[silent peak]

Oh

Where can i buy it?

[cobalt fiber]

You have to tame it

Lemme send you the location

Hold up

[silent peak]

Bruh

[cobalt fiber]

If you need a fast horse then tame the white Arabian near Lake isabella

[silent peak]

Nah, i need to learn how to tame and a brave one, so…

Can u give me the location of andalusian?

[cobalt fiber]

I texted you

In DMs

[forest nexus]

Minor spoiler incoming?

i think its cool you can rob the rhodes bank in rdr2

[silent peak]

Its a mission?

[forest nexus]

well kind of

its a robbery activity you can do in chapter 4

Which chapter are you in?

[silent peak]

Seen the credits already

[forest nexus]

oh

[silent peak]

Ended all the chapters and the epilogues

[silent peak]

Why?

[forest nexus]

Just wondering

[silent peak]

Oh

And you?

[midnight ocean]

think you need special or ultimate edition for that

[forest nexus]

oh

[midnight ocean]

kinda sucks anyway lol you dont get shit for it

[tepid ledge]

You need the ultimate edition for that

[tepid ledge]

Yeah

[cobalt fiber]

And an extra treasure map

Near horseshoe overlook

[forest nexus]

well i got nearly 600 dollars for robbing the bank just now

not that much but

its decent ig

[silent peak]

Can i rob banks for myself?

[cobalt fiber]

Nope but you can hold up stores

Just like you said

[silent peak]

@cobalt fiber i got in the place and didnt find any horses

[brave tulip]

Can I still do treasure hunts/maps as John?

[candid kindle]

Can any1 help me i have the book to give to hosea but i cant find him

[cobalt fiber]

I sent you a picture of the location

[tepid ledge]

Yeah

[cobalt fiber]

Its near a waterfall

[tepid ledge]

What chapter are you in?

[candid kindle]

2

[cobalt fiber]

@silent peak you got it ?

[tepid ledge]

Did you do the hunting mission with him?

[silent peak]

Tryna find it

[cobalt fiber]

And also if you do drag the left stick down wards and move it to left and right otherwise the horse will buck you off

[silent peak]

Ok

[candid kindle]

check dms

[silent peak]

@cobalt fiber im at the place and find nothing. Theres other good horse you know?

[cobalt fiber]

Did you do the mission with Hosea ? Where you go hunting

[silent peak]

Yes

[cobalt fiber]

If you have then sleep for a day or two and head to the same place

Happened to me as well

It spawned eventually

[silent peak]

Where? I did the mission a long time ago

[cobalt fiber]

I meant go to sleep by going to your camp or by setting it up

Then go to the horse's location

[silent peak]

Ohhh

Got ir

It*

[cobalt fiber]

Sleep for maximum hours

Like 18-20

[silent peak]

Ok

[midnight ocean]

is he part of a current mission marker

[silent peak]

i got the horse!!!

@cobalt fiber

Thx too much broo

[cobalt fiber]

Yeah

W

[silent peak]

Ill name it after you bro

[cobalt fiber]

Nahhhh

That's very kind of you though

But name whatever you like

[silent peak]

Nah bro

I need to do it

[cobalt fiber]

Nah you did the job I just told you where it was

[silent peak]

I know but, if tou didnt helped me, i wasnt going to get this horse

[cobalt fiber]

If I hadn't showed up someone else would've helped you

[silent peak]

Either way dude

You helped me

Not other person

You

Its the least i can do bro

[brazen wren]

Is it possible to beat up and kill Jack on PS5 or do I need to get a PC?

[cobalt fiber]

Bro 💀

[tepid ledge]

[midnight ocean]

i recommend therapy

[brazen wren]

Can I mod red dead redemption 2 with it

[deep glacier]

Probably ya

[silent peak]

What do you guys think is a good protagonist for a rdr3?

[tepid ledge]

Pff, I really don't know, maybe Hosea or Dutch.

Or maybe Landon Ricketts.

[deep glacier]

Hosea or even one of the callander boys

[silent peak]

I think is Davey and Mac Callinder

[tepid ledge]

Mac Callander

[deep glacier]

Or a whole new person not related to the van der linde gang at all

[silent peak]

I think is both brothers, cus it can have the swap character mechanic from gta 5

[tepid ledge]

Yeah

[wheat crypt]

Ive been playing this damn game for a little over 2 years now and im still finding stuff ive never seen before

[silent peak]

Good idea too

[tepid ledge]

I was thinking Landon Ricketts to be a good character in Rdr3.

[silent peak]

Only thing we can do either way is wait

[tepid ledge]

Exactly.

[deep glacier]

Who’s Landon ricketts again

[tepid ledge]

A legendary gunslinger in both Rdr2 and Rdr1.

[deep glacier]

Hmmm

I wouldn’t mind playing as one of the legendary gunslingers

[wheat crypt]

I lowkey want rdr3 to be about sadie

I love not being awake

[cobalt fiber]

He's a legendary gunslinger in rdr universe and he helped john marston in rdr1 and taught him advanced jujutsu ( dead eye )

Even in rdr2 when arthur and sadie were being chased by del lobos he says " A new pair of pants and they think they are Landon ricketts "

[midnight ocean]

someone new

[azure sluice]

It'd be nice if RDR3 is a prequel of RDR2

or honestly just an entirely new storyline

[wheat crypt]

We dont need ANOTHER prequel

[azure sluice]

yea I genuinely don't think Rockstar can expand on this storyline any more 😭

[cobalt fiber]

Imagine if it's both prequel and sequel like in first few chapters we play as Hosea , dutch and arthur and then in epilogue it cuts to " after the events of rdr1 " where jack kills edgar ross

[azure sluice]

that's a bit messy

[wheat crypt]

The only way I see them expanding the story is either with Sadie in South America or with Jack

[cobalt fiber]

Charles ?

[azure sluice]

Sadie just did bounty hunting no?

[azure sluice]

He left his old life behind and likely got married up north there's not much to do

[cobalt fiber]

She's annoying man I don't wanna play as her

[azure sluice]

Canada probably

[wheat crypt]

Sadie's amazing man

[cobalt fiber]

Maybe jack could team up with both sadie and Charles

[azure sluice]

I find her voice a bit annoying

[cobalt fiber]

Like he's lost and has nothing to loose

[azure sluice]

sorta

[azure sluice]

idk about Charles

he left that stuff behind

[wheat crypt]

Her voice is the american southern accent, I have a gf with that accent, so im used to it lol

[cobalt fiber]

Imagine rockstar gives us Pearson as a main protagonist

💀💀

Gotta stir up the stew

[azure sluice]

its not the accent its like

[tepid ledge]

Nah and his time in the navy

[azure sluice]

raspy? 😭

[cobalt fiber]

Ahh those 50 days

[wheat crypt]

I like Sadie's character, she can be a tad annoying

But literally any character can be annoying

[tepid ledge]

"And you unfortunately survived!" - Arthur

[midnight ocean]

[ember ridge]

I saw that

[night oasis]

Woops wrong board 😂

[ember ridge]

I was about to say

[night oasis]

Meant for battlefield

[ember ridge]

Lmao

[night oasis]

Gonna go mess with them fools

[ember ridge]

I was like you don't buy skins on Rdr2???

[night oasis]

TIL they ban me that is

😭

Ok just reposted it there, see how long I last

[onyx kindle]

Yall really be gassy round here?

[midnight ocean]

wrong chat homie

this isnt the fetish server you joined

[high isle]

is it normal that i lost my progress in rdr2

(singleplayer only)

[turbid gate]

how long do i need to sleep to make enemies respawn in their hideout?

[midnight ocean]

if you didnt save then yeah lol

[midnight ocean]

three days i think

[turbid gate]

i slept more and they didnt spawn

[midnight ocean]

what are you trying to do

[turbid gate]

weapons expert 9, kill ppl with bow

[midnight ocean]

what hideout did you use

[turbid gate]

1 sec

hanging dog ranch

[midnight ocean]

btw if you run away far enough before you kill them all everyone will respawn immediately

you can go try to get some at six points in cumberland forest

[turbid gate]

but they dont spawn cuz im after epilogue

[midnight ocean]

oh

idk try sleeping three days and then fast travel far away and back maybe

or go to another place like gaptooth breach or something

[turbid gate]

where is that

[midnight ocean]

west part of new austin

[turbid gate]

gaptooth ridge*

yeah i could've

[midnight ocean]

sigh

i love when people who dont know jack shit try to correct me

[turbid gate]

nah dw

im so stealthy i killed a guy and they all got alarmed

[midnight ocean]

gaptooth ridge is a county

gaptooth breach is a gang hideout in gaptooth ridge

[turbid gate]

oh ok

i didnt 100% game so idk bro 😭

[midnight ocean]

dont need to 100% lol just look at the map

[turbid gate]

it says gaptooth ridge 😭

[midnight ocean]

look closer

[modern bobcat]

[lyric pike]

one hundred percenting the game is easier than I thought

[midnight ocean]

which part

[lyric pike]

all of it

100% the entire game

cause theres like 170 animals but you only need 70, its not even really 100%

[peak veldt]

Then do a true 100%

[midnight ocean]

i would have if i could find those stupid parakeets

[peak veldt]

Find, study at a distance, dynamite arrow them all at once.

[midnight ocean]

yeah im stuck on "find" lol

well i got the entry already but i wanted to finish the quest

[silent peak]

What are u guys talkin bout?

[peak veldt]

Carolina Parakeet.

[silent peak]

Who?

[midnight ocean]

its a bird in game lol

its hard to find

[silent peak]

Ohh

[midnight ocean]

appears around lemoyne in various places and has a side quest associated with killing all of them

[silent peak]

Ohhhh

[lyric pike]

does anyone elses game get slowly choppier and choppier as they play it?

[unreal sun]

How do i load the last checkpoint, i wanna get better medal goals?

i cant find it any where....

[peak veldt]

I don't get that problem, but the game definitely gets unstable if you play long stretches. Game doesn't update the map as you uncover it, forgets how many outfits you're allowed to store, that kind of thing. Just restart the game every so often, especially if you're noticing weird issues.

[peak veldt]

During mission, D-Left. Click on mission. "Abandon", then it gives an option to retry checkpoint, restart, cancel.

I assume D-Left anyway. I use an XBOX controller on PC.

[unreal sun]

Doooooope, thank you thank you

[peak veldt]

Sorry, meant D-Left.

[unreal sun]

And how do i retry a mission to get better medals?

[peak veldt]

Do you mean when you're free roaming?

Pause -> Progress -> Story

[unreal sun]

No like little objectives that are in missions, i dont really know wyat they are called

[peak veldt]

I don't understand.

I believe I'm describing what you're looking for.

@unreal sun I see your PM. I am describing that to you. Pause -> Progress -> Story. Look at the missions, they'll show the optional objectives for medals and you can replay them from that menu.

[unreal sun]

Hmmmm ooh

[peak veldt]

Before you waste a couple runs, when it says "Complete the mission without taking any health items", it means any consumable. Even tonics that give back deadeye.

If you're early in the playthrough, it might be worth saving a replay until later when you have better stats/equipment, since you can replay missions with your current equipment, not the equipment available to you at the time.

[unreal sun]

Is there NG+

[peak veldt]

Nah

[unreal sun]

And i cant loot bodies for some reason

@peak veldt

[peak veldt]

?

[unreal sun]

Oh is there no body looting? Lol

[peak veldt]

There is. I just don't know what the problem is. Sounds like you're very new to the game.

[unreal sun]

Just started to day

[unreal sun]

Im at a dead body/ x on the mini map but its not prompting to loot.......

[ember ridge]

You might not be close enough to the body

[peak veldt]

Black X or Faded X.

I wouldn't stress it. You'll figure it out.

[unreal sun]

Looks black

[unreal sun]

Well id like to know.... ://////

[peak veldt]

You're not going to play a 200 hour game without figuring out how to loot bodies.

[lyric pike]

it was mostly just frame drops for me especcially first person, first person was running at a way lower fps than everything else, I just close the game and wait like an hour let me PC cool off

[unreal sun]

Lol i know!! I just dont wanna miss any loooooooot

[peak veldt]

It's fine.

[unreal sun]

Hhaa ok!! :))

Thanks

[peak veldt]

You can't even carry that much right now. Game is silly with how limited you can stack items initially.

[unreal sun]

Im sure i read some where that you can retry missions to get those better goals...i think!!!

[peak veldt]

Don't bother until you're in Chapter 3 or 4. Increase your stats, get better weapons, better horse, etc.

[unreal sun]

Oh! So you can?

[chrome thicket]

I wish the game had more limited items

Rushing to use all my assorted tobacco to pick up them cards

With mods making the enemies damage you 2x as hard and making you half as powerful makes it so much more fun and realistic

PDO reloaded also lets you beef up your companions so they don’t die immediately

I feel like Sean dies so damn much lol

[peak veldt]

👀

[unreal sun]

... that's pretty dope

[chrome thicket]

He’s the only NPC that can’t take a gunfight well

Even Hosea does better

[peak veldt]

Yeah, like the cutscene that says he's bad in a fight.

Almost as if it's intended behavior. 🤔

[chrome thicket]

Yeah I appreciate they put that in bc it makes sense

God I love this game

I’m currently just past torchin the tobacco fields part but I’ve done like all the side stuff you can

With the house mod you can get the leg venom guy buy you a whole fuckin house lol I love that

[unreal sun]

Can i post a link?

[peak veldt]

nope.

[unreal sun]

Ok soo, is any one familiar with the official piggyback strategy guide?

[peak veldt]

Who is buying strategy guides this century?

[unreal sun]

Lololol

[deep glacier]

You’d be surprised

[unreal sun]

i like them in fact i actually collect them

[peak veldt]

Scanning through it. Actively wrong and missing information.

Take the Camp Item Requests section. No pamphlets mentioned, the unique clothing rewards aren't mentioned, except the Vaquero Rider Spurs, which are just called "spurs" and no mention that they're unique.

Doesn't mention relative bravery of horses, which would have been nice to have outside of random anecdotes you see people making up on reddit. What are the horses even sorted by? Looking for the Arabians and they're all over the place. Wouldn't a table have made way more sense than individual infoboxes per coat?

Weapon stats section doesn't mention how you get better at weapons over time, increasing their stats (you can tell in-game by how much the 'reload' is filled, which isn't affected by ammunition, but is affected by how often you have used the weapon)

Challenge categories have the wrong stats associated with them.

The LeMat is missing from the list of weapons. So is the M1899. Likely more, but I wasn't too meticulous here.

Weapon stat bars don't reflect actual stats of weapons.

Hunting weapon tables is missing information. Animals must not be categorized correctly because the beaver returns a 3-star carcass with a varmint rifle, for example. But several other weird choices. Why are some perfects colored red and some black? What's the difference? Table doesn't make sense.

This book is somehow information overload and missing information at the same time.

I've never heard that weapon wraps reduce weapon degradation by 10%. It doesn't say anywhere in game. So either, to it's credit it has this piece of info, or it's not actually a mechanic. Who knows. Would be an annoying thing to test and it's not that big of a deal.

[ember ridge]

Hey how are people doing this #red-dead-media

[peak veldt]

Doing what?

[ember ridge]

Ive been trying to do it for hours but the repeaters seem to auto-reload, the rifles dont seem to work

[ember ridge]

Sharpshooter 5, I put it in #red-dead-media

[ember ridge]

Idk if bows work, and throwing knifes are a bit of a faff

[peak veldt]

Just use a repeater.

[ember ridge]

Thats what i've been trying

[peak veldt]

Lancaster has 14 bullets

[ember ridge]

But they seem to auto-reload? Like I shoot with it like twice and then it goes back up to 14

[peak veldt]

Are you dead-eye-ing them?

Don't do that.

[ember ridge]

Oh

Okay i wont

[peak veldt]

Deadeye slow-mo reloads your weapon, thus failing the challenge.

[ember ridge]

OOh okay thatll be why i keep failing

[latent knot]

auto reload exist in rdr??

[silent peak]

Yeah

[ember ridge]

In deadeye yes

Which I didn't know till today

I was just confused on how my repeater kept getting reloaded

[silent peak]

If youre low on ammo, just use dead eye that you reload your ammo

[ember ridge]

I did the challenge tho

[latent knot]

in settings i can put auto reload or

[latent knot]

oh

[silent peak]

Guys

I need help

To find at least a clue about any legendary animal

[latent knot]

which legy animal

[peak veldt]

What's the issue?

[silent peak]

I mean, i hunt for 30 minutes and dont find ant goddamn single clue

[silent peak]

Any

[peak veldt]

30 minutes? They're in specific locations

Use your eagle eye when it announces you are in their territory

[latent knot]

u can watch on yt

where is in the map

and use eagle eye

[silent peak]

I tryed

But dont apear that yellow thing

[peak veldt]

YouTube

[latent knot]

bruh

its glitched

try restart rdr and try again

[peak veldt]

Sounds like user error to me more than a bug. Watch someone else do it, find your mistake.

[silent peak]

I mean, i did find once that bull alligator, but only once

[peak veldt]

watch for the notification in the corner. "You have entered a legendary animal's territory" but make sure it doesn't say something about not being available because of activity nearby

[silent peak]

It apears

But not the clue

The hint

[latent knot]

that is bug i guess

[silent peak]

That yellow thing on eagle eye

[latent knot]

some issue

u can just restart rdr

or something

[peak veldt]

It's much more likely user error by someone who doesn't know the mechanic,.

[latent knot]

its rdrs problem

not for user

[silent peak]

I dont think so

Like i d sayed, i found the bull alligator once, but only that time

It feels like that im just dumb

[latent knot]

when i was in one mission bill willimson killed himself

without anything

just died

and i killed enemy

and he killed himself like tf

[latent knot]

bug

[naive barn]

I cant tame the white araiban it keeps bucking me off

[peak veldt]

Leaning forward or backward properly?

[naive barn]

I did it easily before now i cant

[peak veldt]

You calming it to the point you can pat it?

You pulling back on the stick when it's lifting it's back legs?

[pliant basin]

Yall know where the strange man hut thing is

I want to go there seen vids but don’t know where it is

Pls tell

[naive barn]

Got it finally

[pliant basin]

Bro what

@peak veldt

Bro thank u

I’m riding there right now

[dark ledge]

Yall what is your opinion on uncle

[deep glacier]

One of my favorites cause of his roasts

[dark ledge]

Lowkey he’s a real homie

[deep glacier]

Low-key want a game of him in his prime

[dark ledge]

He’s not a rat like Micah, he may be a drunk and not helpful much lmao, but he went out protecting John and his family

That’s a ride or die homie right there

[dark ledge]

It’d be Arthur’s story except instead of tuberculosis itd be lumbago

[deep glacier]

You think?

[dark ledge]

Nah bro he had it worse then Arthur

Lumbago is no joke

Guys should I do the bandit challenges?

I’m in the epilogue right now

[deep glacier]

Yes

[dark ledge]

Are they like super fun?

I’m not in in for 100 percent completion

I’ve kinda just stayed away from the criminal activities due to honor

[peak veldt]

None of the challenges are "fun"

[dark ledge]

Oh

I know you can rob a bunch of stuff tho. Stagecoaches, trains

[peak veldt]

You can do that anyway.

[dark ledge]

What are the funnest ways to kill npcs

[viscid spade]

Hogtie then dangle them off a cliff or bridge

[peak veldt]

Hogtie the eugenicist, throw him into an alligator.

[hallow cosmos]

Hogtie then throw them into flames ☠️🔥

[dark ledge]

lol

I tried it where you lasso them and then drag them until they die

[hallow cosmos]

Most sane RDR2 Player

[hallow cosmos]

That's very fun

[dark ledge]

It’s so sadistic tho lmfao

[hallow cosmos]

Or you shoot in the legs or hands until they die

[hallow cosmos]

Fr

[dark ledge]

Eeesh

How do you rob trains/stagecoaches btw?

[hallow cosmos]

Nah we are normal people 😉

Hmm

Kinda

[dark ledge]

Apparently you can even rob a steam boat? Or is that like mods

[hallow cosmos]

I don't really care about money

I already have 5k

[peak veldt]

Not mods. Just do it.

[hallow cosmos]

There isn't much to buy

[dark ledge]

Me neither

I’m in the epilogue, doing all the fun low honour shit I didn’t do with Arthur

[hallow cosmos]

I'm at chap 2 and I already have 5k dollars

[dark ledge]

And I wanted to try doing that bandit challenge

[dark ledge]

You can actually rob it? Lol

I was really just asking like how

[hallow cosmos]

I'm not progressing story it's just depressing to see Arthur progress through tb

Smallmeatjohnson ☠️ what a name

[dark ledge]

Trains I guess you just board them, stagecoaches it seems at random or you can steal one, but the steam train?

[dark ledge]

When I first joined the server awhile back, it was big meat Johnson. That’s my actual user lol

But I think a mod changed it for fun or something

[hallow cosmos]

I don't usually rob trains but I rob stagecoaches

Yea

My name was Van Der Linde

But then the mfs did this

😭

[dark ledge]

Lmfao

Yeah I think the mods in this server 100 percent are doing it for funsies

[hallow cosmos]

Why aren't you using any tags?

[dark ledge]

Either that, or it’s been hacked lmao

[dark ledge]

What

[hallow cosmos]

Then a mod changed another feller's name to old man that can't cross a road

That's hilarious

LOL

[dark ledge]

lol.

[hallow cosmos]

The server tags

[dark ledge]

Honestly surprised mods would be doing that in a decently sized server

[hallow cosmos]

See I have rdr2 server tag

[hallow cosmos]

That's correct

[dark ledge]

Compared to the gta online server it’s crazy lmfao

[hallow cosmos]

This server has around 115k members or so

[dark ledge]

Is it just random? Can you come across heavily guarded stagecoaches

[dark ledge]

Yeah

[hallow cosmos]

I don't think so

[dark ledge]

The gta online server is super strict it’s fucking crazy

[hallow cosmos]

I hate strict servers

Why so serious

While you can be happy swearing and cussing

[muted summit]

I'm a bounty hunter / hitman

[dark ledge]

I’ve been banned for 3 months, not even joking for saying “PC users are gooners”

[hallow cosmos]

Nice

[muted summit]

I just enjoy tracking people down and taking them out xD

[hallow cosmos]

I'm PC user

[muted summit]

Hard part was when they are in jail and i have to shoot through the window XD

[hallow cosmos]

Lol I got warned

For saying the G word

[muted summit]

i had to run from valentine for twenty minutes to get away

[dark ledge]

Bro what

[dark ledge]

It was a joke

Omg there’s no way bro got muted

[muted summit]

XD

[dark ledge]

lol.

I guess both servers have weird shit

This one seems a bit better, but I mean wtf how did that guy get muted

[muted summit]

im new to this server so 🤷

[dark ledge]

I’ve been here since like June but I’ve only interacted with the chat like twice

First time was about the gunslingers mission, and then I kinda quit rdr2. Got back on again and decided to finish it so I’ve been more active

Ahh

[dark ledge]

I’ve been doing all these sadistic murders around blackwater lol

It’s insanely easy to get away

[serene vortex]

I was just playing RDR2 and looting someone's house I grabbed a money clip heard someone bash through the door and grab me. Arthur span at the speed of light and got thrown to the bed and my pc froze and crashed and I was at -2147483648 Celsius. I would send a screenshot but can’t

[potent estuary]

nah you should have had some faith in your pc

some goddam faith

[potent estuary]

yeah but when you have a perfect pelt on your horse which took hours to get and 50 bounty hunters kill you

[unreal sun]

@peak veldt wheres the most accurate source for information?

[tall obsidian]

id it true there like over 48+ weapon in the game

i actually only nevermanaged to fully it

3nd playthrough btw

[wintry socket]

i met mary clinton in a mission in chapter 2,when will i meet here again?

[warm salmon]

The Clintons seem to be very popular I see

[modern bobcat]

If i greet people in real life, will i get ?

[sinful barn]

Hot take: Guarma is the best chapter in the game.

[unreal sun]

Is the "MapGenie" interactive map a accurate source for every item in the game?

[unreal sun]

100% complete

Where can i find all the information i need to 100% this game??

[vale osprey]

In the progress tab and then overall competition, that will be the “100%”. Which isn’t true 100% but that’s what needs to be 100% for the achievement.

[clever nimbus]

guys how do i get honor before chapter 6 ending any tips cause i wnaa go greet people i saint denis but the whole area is marked red

[lapis panther]

Funny character and smart as hell, but full of crap too

[vital crypt]

lost a shooting but we both died. didnt we both win?

[potent estuary]

Chp 6 has tons of missions that you can get honour from

I suppose you are still on chp 4

[clever nimbus]

im on chp 6

🙂

[potent estuary]

Oh

[clever nimbus]

my honor is rock bottom i was on a killing spree cause a law man shot my horse

and it died

[potent estuary]

Do chp6 money collecting missions

Do edith downes missions

[clever nimbus]

the one robbing train thing with dutch?

[potent estuary]

No

Where you go collect money for strauss

[clever nimbus]

i saw someone on tiktok shooting rats and it got so much honor

[clever nimbus]

oh.

i never liked strauss always igored his mission

[potent estuary]

Well you cant go to saint denis

[clever nimbus]

ye f

[potent estuary]

Since you said its red

[clever nimbus]

should i spam fishing?

[potent estuary]

Rats I think only spawn there

[potent estuary]

Fishing would take time

[clever nimbus]

real

[potent estuary]

Do some sidequests and choose the good option

[clever nimbus]

ill see whats up then

[potent estuary]

Do the money collecting missions and try to be a good person

[clever nimbus]

u reckon how long will it take to get high honor for the deer scene

do i need to get my honor bar max or like 75 percent?

[potent estuary]

Hmm you might get tons of honour after missions

Probably about 1 to 2 hours?

For max honour

You dont need max honour for ending just a white cowboy

[potent estuary]

Kicking strauss out of camp gets you like 20% of honour

[clever nimbus]

how do i kick him

[potent estuary]

Do his money lending missions

For chp6

[clever nimbus]

all of it?

[potent estuary]

Then arthur will see what a snake he is and kick him out

[clever nimbus]

alright alright ty man

appreciate it

[potent estuary]

Yes chp 6 only

[potent estuary]

No problem just helping a fella out

[clever nimbus]

yooo i just gained so much honor from kicking strauss out

[potent estuary]

told you

he was a parasite but charles tells later when he was caught he didnt snitch on the gang

[ember ridge]

Also greeting people increases honour

[scenic musk]

time to go and say hi to everyone on the street

[vital crypt]

saw two seperate panthers in less than five mins without moving or putting down bait. lost the first one in the trees, got the second one. why did i even bother to play at risk

[blazing zodiac]

What’s the overall best horse in rdr2 (stat vise )

[clever nimbus]

missouri fox trotter

[clever nimbus]

,

[vital crypt]

name twin

[clever nimbus]

theres 2 mft
silver daple and champainge

u can buy them in the stable for like 9501.2k i think

[vital crypt]

took me a second to get you

i mean we have the same name

[clever nimbus]

oh oh... im so slow

haha

xd

[silent peak]

Morning

Can someone pls help me?

[cosmic parrot]

yoo

[soft root]

I wonder why some people like the double action

I mean, as fast and chaotic as it is

it trades off too much accuracy for speed in my opinion

I don't mind the dmg being less bc it shoots real fast

but the accuracy....why the hell can't the accuracy be a bit better

[silent peak]

Bri

Bro*

Can u help me pls?

[soft root]

with what?

not sure how much I can help, haven't played rdr2 in a while

[silent peak]

Have you already hunted a legendary animal?

[soft root]

uh...yea

what, you killed a legendary animal but lost the corpse?

[silent peak]

You’ve used the eagle eye, right?

You know that yellow thing that appears?

[soft root]

yea

the clues

[silent peak]

Yes

[soft root]

the trail went cold?

[silent peak]

It aint apearing to me

No

[soft root]

oh

[silent peak]

Isnt apearing the clues

[soft root]

wdym it ain't appearing to you

are you sure you're at the right spot?

[silent peak]

Yes

[soft root]

I remember one legendary deer being at some location the map didn't even mark it at

[silent peak]

It says that im in an legendary animal area

[soft root]

or...some legendary animal

are you trying to hunt a legendary deer

[silent peak]

Im hunting for that bull alligator

[soft root]

ohhhh

are you past ch4?

[silent peak]

Ive hunted him once, but i died and him and the clues disappeared

[soft root]

the big f**king white gator?

[silent peak]

Ended the game

[silent peak]

Yea

[soft root]

huh....

weird

[silent peak]

Passed all the chapters and epilogues

[soft root]

well, never hunted that gator

so can't help you with that

at most I can give you some advice when ready to kill the gator

bring a shotgun

explosive ammo

definitely explosive ammo

that or poison arrows or knives

I recommend shotguns

[silent peak]

Alr

[soft root]

with slugs

those are good

[silent peak]

Thx

[soft root]

just...throw everything you have at it

bc, legendary animal pelts don't get damaged even if you blow them up with dynamite

[silent peak]

Got it

[vital crypt]

youre good

i just stumbled over a panther while doing a bounty

it wasn't marked red so idk

maybe glitched, it wasnt aggressive although it was right next to the road and with that me for a good five secs

[soft root]

still wondering tbh

any double action fans can tell me why they like the double action?

and how they can actually use the thing well?

[silent peak]

Bruh

I found the problem

Theres too much activity

[silent peak]

Because they’re fast, proly

[soft root]

yeah, but they have low dmg

and are inaccurate

[silent peak]

Some people prefer to just clean the area than to do more damage

[lyric pike]

damage doesnt matter if its a headshot

[quick quiver]

does anyone here have the rdr2 guide book pdf?

[silent peak]

Need too

[remote latch]

Does anyone have a spreadsheet with all ledgendary animals

[silent peak]

Will send to you in dm

[silent peak]

Map you mean?

[remote latch]

Yes

[silent peak]

Ok

[vestal shard]

Who tf at rockstar thought it was a good idea to make one of the medal objectives in The New South a "no-hit" for a fist fight

[silent peak]

What do you mean?

[lyric pike]

how do you complete the gunslinger mission I got all of the photos but I dont know how to actually complete the mission

chapter 2

[silent peak]

You’ll need to wait till chapter 4

[lyric pike]

oh okay

[chrome thicket]

There’s a cool exploit to get the reward for the mission at the beginning of the game

PED Reloaded mod glitch made the final mission at the Braithwaite mansion unbeatable

[vital crypt]

if i were to shoot a beaver on the other side of the river where i am wanted dead or alive, how many problems would picking it up and going back cause? is it that fast or do i need to be on that land for longer than a few secs

just curious btw

not like i can just search another beaver

[vestal shard]

After the fishing trip with Dutch and Hosea, I stuck around camp to see if Dutch would smoke a cigar so I could trigger the pipe request, and he did, but Arthur just said the same generic lines "You'll work it out Dutch, you always do" and it's probably because wasn't standing by the right side of his tent

I reloaded the save file to try again but... he isn't at camp? he isn't anywhere, no Dutch icon no nothing

Is that supposed to happen? Is he supposed to be gone after The New South?

[dark ferry]

they sound cool, look cool, feel cool

and it’s story mode

[dark ferry]

yes, i believe so

[vestal shard]

Ah ok

[midnight ocean]

think i just used the bolt action lol

[midnight ocean]

i dont think its supposed to trigger by his tent

but idk

[vestal shard]

From the videos I've seen, it has to be specifically him standing on the front ot his tent, to the right, smoking a cigar with one hand in his hip

Thus far I've found him smoking behind his tent, on the front but to the left, everything but the correct one

[midnight ocean]

huh maybe thats why i couldnt get it

[vestal shard]

For the life of me I couldn't trigger, I'm at chapter 3 now tho, I've heard it's easier to find it here, here's hoping

[midnight ocean]

yeah i waited til 4 and couldnt get it

[vital crypt]

arthur acting like a teenager on his first date with those moves in the theater

[modern bobcat]

What will happen if i go to the strange man shack before doing the mission where you get the choice to kill jimmy brooks or save his life?

[deep glacier]

Mary had him nervous

[vital crypt]

absolutely

i felt a bit sorry

[candid kindle]

Abigails mission doesnt appear to me any one knows why

[fossil thorn]

Hey guys I am new here. I am playing on PS5 and I am playing story mode. I am playing dishonorable and it looks like my honor meter is frose in place. It goes up but not lower. Why is that?

[midnight ocean]

honor is capped early on

[midnight ocean]

might need to do other missions first

[fossil thorn]

Aight thanks mate

[lapis panther]

You can try moves on her? Wow. Been so long since I helped her out the second time in a playthrough.

[vital crypt]

one, yes

[lapis panther]

I always help her with her brother

[vital crypt]

its awkward

[lapis panther]

Never her drunk ass father

[peak veldt]

Yeah it’s a good bit. After a little bit of time in the performance, try locking onto her and then use the “make a move” prompt. It’s good.

[lapis panther]

I think the best time to trigger Dutch's pipe request is the first day in chapter 2.

[vestal shard]

I'm aware, by the time I realized it was already far too late

[lapis panther]

It's ridiculous. The guy you fight has a knife and they expect you to take no damage as a gold requirement.

[warm coral]

Guys, I killed a bird just by pressing the up arrow and shooting it, unintentionally. Is that very difficult? i have the video

[turbid gate]

whats that thingy we get from the fisherman when he dies

[peak veldt]

Hat

Looks terrible though. Should have used the bucket hat model and then covered it with more detailed and colorful lures. I’d wear that all game.

[tidal spindle]

I finished the main story

[peak veldt]

Ok.

[clever nimbus]

I just finished the game first time

all i can see is that its

PEAK

had me tearing up at 4am

[turbid gate]

W pfp-

guys whats the best heron plumes location?

[peak veldt]

Lemoyne.

[turbid gate]

what abt the other thing

[turbid gate]

but closer location

[peak veldt]

google "jeanropke rdr2 map"

jeanropke.github.io/RDOMap/

[clever nimbus]

i just realize this ending hit me harder because i used buel for my last ride and ive stuck with him for so long on my journey his pretty eyes NOOOOOO

[granite peak]

Interactive Maps for Red Dead Online -
RDO Map: (https://jeanropke.github.io/RDOMap/)
RDO Collector's Map: (https://jeanropke.github.io/RDR2CollectorsMap/)

[clever nimbus]

well it felt better after rethinking that buel gotta go to after hamish pass and authur passing whos gon take care of him

[turbid gate]

rdr2 story mode

[peak veldt]

It's the same thing for all the animals and herbs on that map

[unreal sun]

Do masks completely disguise who i am? 100%??

[turbid gate]

Not if police sees u if u hold weapon or smth i think

Its only when u commited a crime

[midnight ocean]

no it just allows civilians to witness you commit a crime without giving you a bounty if they get away

lawmen see through the mask

[lyric pike]

so the mask omly works on civi's

[midnight ocean]

yeah

[lyric pike]

oh, I feel like that makes it kinda useless but IDK

[midnight ocean]

well like i said it can prevent a bounty in certain cases

[peak veldt]

I think the mask system is one of the weaker parts of the game.

[midnight ocean]

its easy enough to escape the law that it would be kinda OP if simply escaping meant no bounty every time

if you dont escape that means you died or got arrested which should mean no bounty anyway

so what would the point of the bounty system be then?

[exotic crystal]

Stir it up good!

[dark ferry]

Jimmmmmm

[midnight ocean]

holy shit the real pearson?????????

[tepid ledge]

"Mr. Pearson "-Arthur

[deep glacier]

The fact I read this in Pearson’s voice is comical

[vestal shard]

Even at Chapter 3, I still can't get Dutch to ask for a god damn pipe

Oh my fucking lord

[solid trench]

Should i do the doctors office robbery now that im in chapter 3

Also how should i do it

[vestal shard]

I'd recommend doing them as soon as possible, also for that one you'd have to look through the back window or knock up the door, afterwards you can aim at the doc and press the correct button so they open the back door

[solid trench]

What guide do you recommend, i dont know what any of what you said means

[vestal shard]

I can't link so, just type in youtube about valentine doctor robbery

[solid trench]

First video is from a guy called tfm gaming

Is his guide good

[snow osprey]

I will lost everything in epilogue that I have as Arthur?

[vestal shard]

I used a yt short tbh

[solid trench]

Can i still rob the office while valentine is under lockdown?

[vestal shard]

Nope, at least, I don't think so

[solid trench]

Should i load a chapter 2 save to do it? I just started chapter 3

[vestal shard]

I mean, you can do it on chapter 3 too, as long as valentine isn't on lockdown

If it is, just go to a mail office and pay your bounty

[solid trench]

I think im just gonna load a save right before the sheep and the goats, idk if i have the money for that

[vestal shard]

There's plenty of ways to make easy money, specially gold bars, there's like four of them just outside free for the taken, and a bunch more as treasure hunting

[midnight ocean]

not really a lot of leeway for how you do it sadly

[vestal shard]

Nvm more than four, 7

[midnight ocean]

point gun, make the guy open the door, walk in and kill everyone

take the revolver on the table and i think theres a safe you can blow open

the annoying thing is you can only go out the way you came in and the lawmen get alerted super quickly

[solid trench]

Can you do it at night?

[midnight ocean]

the store has to be open

[vestal shard]

I fucking hate this pipe trigger, the worst part is I've got no guide whatsoever, the best lead I've got right now is some youtube comment saying "after honest mistske stick around, unc will talk to you and then dutch will be smoking the cigar" with tweleve likes and one comment saying it didn't work for them

That is literally the best I've got, nobody has ever taken the time to write what steps or order or literally anything to get the pipe request any time after the chapter 2 first few minutes

I hate it here

[peak veldt]

@solid trench Rob the doctor in Valentine as soon as you can for one of the best revolvers, free! The Schofield. It's in a weapon case back there.

Also, Rhodes for the best repeater, for free. Just peek in the window in the side of the gunsmith.

[solid trench]

How the helll do you use dynamite i tried 3 times

I remember why i have been putting off this game forever

[peak veldt]

On a controller? Left trigger aim, right trigger throw?

[solid trench]

PC also throwing it doesnt make it stick

[peak veldt]

Stick?

[solid trench]

I cant blow up the safe

[peak veldt]

If you blew up dynamite right on top of it and it didn't open, it's not interactable, I assume

[solid trench]

No its interactable ive seen it in the video and the wiki says you can blow up the safe

[peak veldt]

stream it

[solid trench]

Look up valentines doctor robbery on youtube first video by tfm gaming

[peak veldt]

Buddy. I know the game. You don't know the game. Show me what you're seeing so I can troubleshoot your issue.

[stark sparrow]

Did you guys see that Dan houser said rdr3 would probably happen without him

[peak veldt]

The guy who resigned from Rockstar in 2020? Shocker.

lol, started a "blockchain" game studio in 2022 and invested $13.2 million into the company.

[stark sparrow]

Someone’s got a stick up their ass

Ngl

They shouldn’t make a rdr3

If they make a new red dead it shouldn’t be redemption cuz there’s nowhere they can go with the characters and story we already have

[peak veldt]

👏 New 👏 Characters 👏

[stark sparrow]

Yea true but idk if it would be good or not

I guess we will see

in 10 years or whatever

[peak veldt]

Kind of an inane thing to say, isn't it? Things are good or not good. Everything might be good or not.

[stark sparrow]

yea true

i just don’t rlly think there should be a new game but it’s rockstar so im sure they can pull it off

[midnight ocean]

dont aim, just walk up to the thing you want to plant dynamite on and press the fire button

aiming first will make you toss it

[solid trench]

Okay good to know ill let you know how it goes when i play the game again

[ember ridge]

I might be being a silly goose but I can't find night Orchids. I'm going to the places that ive seen them being found. But can't find them

Do they only spawn randomly once you've got the quest?

[peak veldt]

I can check for you. I haven't gotten the quest on this playthrough.

[solid trench]

I like the plot and story of the game but idk why rdrs gameplay feels more like a chore than an actual game

[peak veldt]

Sounds like you've played all of 2 hours so maybe give it some time.

[ember ridge]

Please do. I'm looking around braithwaite manor at the moment

[solid trench]

I have no problem with open world story games i loved cyberpunk and the various fallouts

[solid trench]

Nah im about 15 hours in im in chapter 3

It just doesnt have the same feel i dont truly binge this game

[peak veldt]

Maybe it's just too much for you. 🤷‍♀️

[ember ridge]

I did

[solid trench]

Yeah there is something i dont understand that takes me out of it

[peak veldt]

I'm finding them just fine.

[ember ridge]

Oh

How weird 😭

[peak veldt]

PM'd you the screenshots

@ember ridge Don't forget eagle eye can highlight them

[midnight ocean]

they dont spawn there

[peak veldt]

Yeah they do. They're just south of it

[midnight ocean]

theres no orchids anywhere near braithwaite manor iirc

[unreal sun]

Whats more reliable, ign or neoseeker for quest walkthroughs...?

[peak veldt]

and you'd be mistaken. 🙂

[midnight ocean]

well id look around the bayou instead

just north of caliga hall too

[peak veldt]

What do you need quest walkthroughs for?

[midnight ocean]

there are a few but wayyy less dense than other areas

actually they're more in between the manor and shady belle it looks like

[peak veldt]

He has a map. I have a map. We know where they are. He just couldn't find them, probably because they were up the tree.

[midnight ocean]

wait a minute

night scented orchid or lady of the night orchid

i was thinking of the latter

[ember ridge]

Yeah they were in trees

Didn't realise how high up haha

[peak veldt]

Not all exotics are like that, but many are.

[deep glacier]

Lady of the night orchids is the bayou/legras area. You was getting them mixed up

[midnight ocean]

well tbf sean just said night orchids lol

coulda been either one

[peak veldt]

@ember ridge I'm seeing a thing about not being able to collect all the orchids ahead of time, so I'd let them sit until you have the quest.

For me, it only spawned the Night Scented at 4 locations so I can't get them all

I'd also wait until Herbalist 9 to do it

[ember ridge]

Oh right okay yeah I'll wait then

I started the duchess quest

[lapis panther]

Yes no VDL gang or Jack

[copper moat]

i agree

its good the way it is

it would be cool to see how the gang fold up

yes

but where is it its good

[hidden moss]

Does anyone know if the random mission where Javier looks after Arthur for help bill is really necessary for 100%?

I’ve been out for (in game) days, even weeks and I need to go back to the camp for some activities

[peak veldt]

It's not for the 100% achievement.

[hidden moss]

thank you

I even did all master hunter challenges…

[unreal sun]

Im trying to 100% the game

[peak veldt]

You don't need guides. Get to chapter 4 or so, and then think about getting gold on old missions.

Yesterday you didn't know how to loot NPCs. You need the fundamentals, the stats, and the gear. So just play through story mode. You aren't going to miss out on 100%.

You're not supposed to get gold on your first attempt at a mission. Enjoy the ride for a bit. Don't smack your head against the gold medals over and over. You aren't there yet.

[ember ridge]

I wouldn't suggest 100% the game on first playthrough either really

youll stress about 100%ing it rather then just enjoy the game

[peak veldt]

You don't get locked out of 100% either. You can work on it later. Definitely enjoy the story and learning process.

[midnight ocean]

you also don't need any gold medals for 100% anyway that's its own thing

[thick stream]

Gimme that

[lapis panther]

Doing the gold medals took away the fun for me. Anyways, I am on chapter one in a new playthrough, I forgot how fun the mission was when you attack the O'Driscoll's at their mining camp and steal their plans

[sinful barn]

The way Dutch killed Bronte and that old lady. Shows how ruthless he truly was.

Definition of a dope villain.

[lapis panther]

It was ruthless, but Bronte deserved to die for setting them up. The old lady on the other hand could've been knocked out.

[cobalt fiber]

Seriously?!!;

[hidden moss]

howdy fellers

[cobalt fiber]

" ohhhh my darling "

[hidden moss]

i completed rdr 2 8th time and.. is there newbies here?

make sure im not spoiling

[cobalt fiber]

Don't worry I got 324 hours and got 3 playthroughs

[hidden moss]

i cried like the first time

[cobalt fiber]

Mee too

[hidden moss]

i completed my 8th walkthrough today even after knowing everything i cried like the first time when i completed the game

[hidden moss]

it hurts feller

[cobalt fiber]

I cried a lot harder the second time cuz I did everything as arthur like most of the challenges , side missions and when he you know I said " those 80 hours I spent finding dinosaur bones , rock carvings , stranger missions

[cobalt fiber]

😭🤝

[hidden moss]

arthur did everything for the gang but dutch and micah

[cobalt fiber]

Yeah

" Bad buisness "

[hidden moss]

yes sir

[peak veldt]

Arthur was obviously doing it for Dutch until it neared the very end.

[hidden moss]

micah is a surviour so ofc he can betray anyone he want

[cobalt fiber]

Yeah and in the end he turned Hosea like he was in the start

Hosea doubted dutch and he was coughing 💀

[hidden moss]

he released that in the end all gonna die after seeing changes in dutch greed for money

[hidden moss]

yeah

and the worst he got tuberculosis

[cobalt fiber]

Yeah

[cobalt fiber]

" Bro didn't give him the money but something else " that downes guy

[hidden moss]

theres a good man in you but hes fighting with a giant

[hidden moss]

downes is the main villan

[cobalt fiber]

Good actions make you a good person

Then I'm doomed - John

[hidden moss]

vengences is a fool games but john felt different

[cobalt fiber]

Rdr2's ending makes you cry but rdr1's doesn't make you sad it's traumatizing you don't cry you just get PTSD

[hidden moss]

i was trying to find people who plays rdr but its rare tbh idk why people skipping this legendary game

[hidden moss]

1911

[cobalt fiber]

This is a fine spot

See ya around cowboy

[hidden moss]

true it was all good until arthur started to coughing in saint denis

[cobalt fiber]

He started coughing in chapter 2 while robbing that homestead with javier

Or maybe it's cuz of cold

That robbing request

[hidden moss]

probably not sure because sometimes tb gives you hints

[cobalt fiber]

The earliest symptom maybe

Have you completed undead nightmare?

That sh*t is so peak

[hidden moss]

yes it was so good

[hidden moss]

yes sir its absolutely is

no doubt

i want to continue playing rdr 2 now but i dont feel like to continue prologue again but want to see arthur revenge again but his dead still trumatizes me

i dont really know how long it will take me to move on

[cobalt fiber]

If you look at it closely arthur getting TB was the most fortunate thing he came across if he hadn't gotten TB then he wouldn't have came to his senses and could've blindly followed dutch forever

Some things you learn the hard way

[hidden moss]

true sometimes bad things makes good decision

[hidden moss]

always

[cobalt fiber]

" It pains me to say it " but TB was the only good thing happened to him

Despite being painful

He got his redemption

[hidden moss]

hurts to say but yeah

[hidden moss]

yes sir

i tried in the end i gave all i had, i did