red-dead-singleplayer

[hidden moss]

C4

[vale osprey]

Steal papers from a office

[hidden moss]

What for? I was a bit confused

[lapis panther]

Incriminating documents. Cornwall wants the reservation so was to use said documents to drive the Natives off

[hidden moss]

Ohhh right okay.

[vale osprey]

Yeah what they said

[hidden moss]

Stuff got a bit confusing after the party at the Italian dudes place

[vale osprey]

Thats fair a lot happens really quickly

[hidden moss]

A lot of side missions as well

[hidden moss]

The trelawny boat robbing thing was fun ngl

[lapis panther]

Good mission

God knows how Strauss managed to swin all the way to the shore haha

[vale osprey]

real tho

[hidden moss]

Probably held Arthur’s hand 🤫

[lapis panther]

I am going to start playing the game again tomorrow after a few months from not playing it

[hidden moss]

High or low

[lapis panther]

Honour? Depends on my mood whilst playing haha

[hidden moss]

fair lol

[lapis panther]

I have a permanent chapter 2 saved filed at the start, so I never have to play chapter 1

I know I killed the O'Driscoll in the barn last time I played chapter 1 haha

[lapis panther]

Yes that party opens up a few avenues

[midnight ocean]

i think the documents were about oil wells on the reservation so it would be a pretense to get rid of the natives to get to the oil

if you guys have HBO you should check out the show deadwood

lot of parallels i feel like

[vocal copper]

how do i make cinematic camera actually follow my companions

[vestal shard]

Does anyone know a reliable spot for the wild hungarian halfbred that isn't in New Austin? I'm at horseman challenge 10 as Arthur and got every single other horse except this one

I've tried a few spots like north of emerald ranch and flatneck station, but no such luck

The latter even appears at the wiki, I've read from users that it is possible to find one as Arthur

Do any of yall have a reliable spot? Good spot?

[lapis panther]

Yes

[midnight ocean]

great plains?

[lapis panther]

I'll check it out. I wonder if it's available elsewhere as I don't have HBO here in the UK

[lapis panther]

Big Valley is a good spot to get a HH

[vestal shard]

My message mentioned not New Austin

[midnight ocean]

thats not new austin but ok

[lapis panther]

Also they can spawn anywhere in The Heartlands, but it's rare

[vestal shard]

Isn't great plains in black water?

OH that's west elizabeth

[midnight ocean]

yeah thats west elizabeth

[vestal shard]

Yeah I'm as Arthur

[vestal shard]

That's quite a large area, got any uh specifics?

Like do you mean near mountain shann?

[lapis panther]

Other side

East of Big Valley

[vestal shard]

Hawka eye creek?

[vestal shard]

You mean near the path that leads creek river?

[lapis panther]

Not far from Wallace Station, if you head into Big Valley, sometimes a group of horses spawn next to Little Creek River

[vestal shard]

You've found a HH there?

[lapis panther]

I have found there before

I have also found one in The Heartlands and near Flatneck Station

They can spawn where horses are, but it's rare

[vestal shard]

So I've heard

[vestal shard]

By next, do you mean to the south or north? If you mean east then isn't that next to wallace station?

[lapis panther]

Go from Wallace Station and head into Big Valley and usually there are horses that spawn near the river

[vestal shard]

I'll try it there then

[lapis panther]

If that fails. Go west across Big Valley and you're bound to come across another group of horses at some point

In the Heartlands, the best place to find one is The Heartlands Overflow

[maiden chasm]

Cannot connect to rockstar services?? Guys?

[astral compass]

Anyone got a good tactic for getting perfect rabbit carcass? Skittish lil guys, and I crept around crouched for 40 mins and couldn't pin one down at all.. I'm looking around the Valentine area

[shrewd kayak]

Keep your distance and use cover scent lotion if you have any

Varmint rifles are probably the best weapon, too, I usually ride around on my horse and shoot them, but that's just me

[midnight ocean]

just ride back and forth in that big open area from where wallace station is to hanging dog

should be easy to spot horses

[vestal shard]

I've found a shitload of horses here true, seems like a great amount of varied horse spawns, but unfortunately, no HH yet

[midnight ocean]

keep looking youll find one

[dark ferry]

i usually get on my horse ride around the grassy plains using eagle eye

[calm dragon]

i've been playing story mode for 14 CONSECUTIVE HOURS and obtained all weapons and collectibles

[midnight ocean]

just ride down the roads around that area and youll spot one, then use the varmint rifle

[midnight ocean]

damn only 14?

[calm dragon]

the pirate sword is my favourite item

[dark ferry]

that’s kinda quick

[calm dragon]

youtube helped me

but i was at a good point already

i just had to find the rarest ones

then used some time to hunt and expand the compendium

almost there guys

[vestal shard]

I FUCKING DID IT, four consecutives hours and I made it! All horseman challenges as Arthur completed

[midnight ocean]

excellent

[lapis panther]

Wish I got 14 hours straight when it first came out. I couldn't even play it every single day

[lapis panther]

Nice one. Where did you find the HH?

[calm dragon]

well i've been playing it almost everyday for a year and a half

[vestal shard]

Wallace Station, immediately after realosding, it spawned me on the other side, I made my way to the path that leads to the creek, accidently ending up near the rails-bridge, and there I saw, a bunch of horses hidden between the trees, and one of them... the HH

Worth it

[lapis panther]

That is why I love Big Valley. You can find most horses there for horseman 10 and most pelts there for LOTE satchel.

[wraith raven]

[hidden moss]

Does anyone know how to do that favourite game thing on discord?

[pastel linden]

doing compendium stuff and side missions really makes you feel the ginormity of this game, not gonna ever get to finishing rdr1 at this rate

rdr2 is just massive

[hidden moss]

Uhh does anyone know about a guide or something to get rdr2’s 100%?

[deep glacier]

Not sure if there’s a full on guide of everything within the 100% but there’s guides for stuff associated to the 100%. Such as locations for the collectibles and animal locations for hunting and all that

[hidden moss]

But in general what do I have to do to achieve it?

I just know a few like the bones, legendary animals, uhh cigarette cards

[deep glacier]

If you pause and click “progress” it’ll show everything that you needa do. It’s a lot of stuff

[dark ferry]

IGN has a checklist of all the things you need to do

[hidden moss]

oh god

[dark ferry]

but i dunno if there’s a video about it

[hidden moss]

how long does it take?

if any of you have already get that 100% ofc..

[deep glacier]

Takes a while if you play on and off. If you play consistently tho it shouldn’t take that long. What takes long are the hunting requests, challenges, and exotics

[noble valve]

Can anyone tell me how to fully remove music in rdr2

[vale stream]

Hey dude! You have to go to the audio or sound tab, adjust the master volume and turn Music down!

[upbeat dragon]

Funny enough I just found one, I’m in chapter two but I glitched out of the map into the outskirts of the western parts just so I could get a Condor feather for the hat I want. The first horse I found out there was the HH, I didn’t realise it’s tied to a challenge, think I’m only on Horseman 4

[tulip solstice]

hh ??

[sinful barn]

Arthur should’ve killed Micah in Strawberry and told Dutch he died in a shootout. What a mistake.

[tulip solstice]

bro now that im playing gta4 i see how good i had it with the horses in rdr. my god the driving is so dog water

[noble valve]

Thanks!

[noble valve]

Then the game wouldn't be called red dead "redemption" lol

Also cuts half the story

[scarlet zodiac]

Am I a rdr2 addict

I have 518 hours

[noble valve]

Yes

[scarlet zodiac]

Yayyyyyy

[noble valve]

I had the game for like 2 years on playstation and I only played like 24 hours maybe?

That was also 2 playthrough tho

[scarlet zodiac]

Damn so I'm a super addict

[noble valve]

Yeah but I didn't take my time on ps I used to only do main missions and skip the cutsfenes

And I mean all the cutscnes

Including Arthur death

[scarlet zodiac]

Same

Sometimes I would just go straight to the mission but sometimes I would explore

After beating the game's main story that's where I racked up all those hours

[noble valve]

I installed like 200 mods lol

[scarlet zodiac]

Damn lucky you I'm on PS5 so I can't do none of that

[noble valve]

It sucks that you need to pay for online

[scarlet zodiac]

Yeah

[night bluff]

I really wish they would’ve given players the option to rescue Micah or let him die

[tropic oyster]

lowkey wish we can use glasses for arthur or john ngl

[night bluff]

An eyeglass with a top hat would fire for Arthur

[tropic oyster]

i saw a few shorts with those golden rim glasses they look op

[tropic oyster]

fr bro

[wispy spoke]

Do i play with the shire untill arthur dies

[wispy spoke]

The horse

[vital crypt]

no

[night bluff]

No

[lyric pike]

Where do I find bison?

[strong cave]

what do i name my horse hes black

[flat quartz]

Y'all I just finished RDR2 for the first time 🐧

[vital crypt]

Nox

[lapis panther]

Heartland Overflow just north west of Guthrie's Farm where there is a whole field of them. There is also a lone bison that spawns not far from the Trading Post. If you're in the epilogue, they can be found on the Great Plains not far from Beecher's Hope.

[lapis panther]

Not leave in jail. Had he not been rescued and the day comes when he's about to be hanged, he'd have ended up talking just to save his own skin

[night bluff]

Fair point lol

[west linden]

i lost my save file after reinstalling windows i tought it was in the documents folder like with any other game

i was 30 hours into the main story

[lyric pike]

alright next question, what is a fast, not skittish horse with good stamina I can get (dont really care about health as my horse rarely takes damages) also something thats accesible before the epilouge

[night bluff]

Missouri Fox Trotter

[lyric pike]

also is it possible to save custom outfits like In GTAO/GTA5?

[night bluff]

The Turkoman is also good

[night bluff]

Yes

You can save em to your horse and rotate between em

[lyric pike]

great, thank you

[hidden moss]

What are the Pinkertons? Are they like the law type people or

[vital crypt]

private detective agency

hired by cornwall

[hidden moss]

Do they try and take outlaws to jail or something

oh

[vital crypt]

just turning them in as instructed

[hidden moss]

ohh ok

[midnight ocean]

just turning them in with a gatling gun

[tiny hazel]

y this server dead

[modern bobcat]

Heh

[turbid gate]

any tips how to make gambler 8? im dying rn

[deep glacier]

That the poker one?

[turbid gate]

im here like 30min 😭

[deep glacier]

I’m pretty sure you can cheese that one through the one boat mission

[turbid gate]

im end game bro 😭

im not on chapter 6

[deep glacier]

Right but you can cheese that challenge through the boat mission in chapter 4 I think it is where you get Strauss’s help if you replay the mission

Think it was woolie who told me that

[turbid gate]

what about epilogue pt.2?

i did it

1/3 bruh 😭

[midnight ocean]

think hes doing the blackjack one tho not poker

[deep glacier]

I asked if it was the poker one and he confirmed with the green check mark reaction

[midnight ocean]

but he also said gambler 8 lol

hmmm

[turbid gate]

i forgot which one is poker 😭

im here a goddamn hour and won once

[midnight ocean]

poker is where you try to make a good hand and beat the other players

blackjack is where you try to get close to 21 and beat the dealer

[turbid gate]

oh ok

[modern bobcat]

Can john get max stats if i do the challenges as authur?

[midnight ocean]

yes

[turbid gate]

so umm... any tips how do i not become insane?

[midnight ocean]

watch youtube

while you play

[turbid gate]

i am watching tiktok for the whole time

[modern bobcat]

Can i do all the challenges right after eastward bounds?

[midnight ocean]

watch something longer

[turbid gate]

looking for tips for that challenge

[midnight ocean]

you cant do every challenge until the epilogue unless you use glitches

but otherwise yeah

[modern bobcat]

Huh
Why

[turbid gate]

u can make horseman 9 i think from van horn i think to blackwater withouth glitches

[midnight ocean]

because some of them require stuff from new austin, like herbalist

[modern bobcat]

Ah i forgot about that

How many challenges can i do right after eastward bounds?

[midnight ocean]

yeah you can do the blackwater horse ride as arthur easily

[midnight ocean]

most of them probably

another one you will have to wait for without employing weird strategy is the one that requires shooting enemy hats off

[modern bobcat]

Hmm

[turbid gate]

my luck is so good i always get +10 😭

[midnight ocean]

because its meant to be done with chapter 4 deadeye

[midnight ocean]

well theres mostly 10s in the deck in blackjack if you count face cards

[modern bobcat]

Can i use the Angelo Bronte, A Man of Honor glitch to do that challenge?

[midnight ocean]

i have no idea

i know next to nothing about glitches

[modern bobcat]

Good job

Is it possible to know every single minute detail in rdr2?

[tawny rivet]

this game is so incredibly massive I doubt anyone knows every minute detail in it

[modern bobcat]

I think not even the developers know everything in that game

Did Roger clark really grew his beard to level 10?

[vital crypt]

as we all know that is the only way to render hair

[hidden moss]

Do crocs and alligators look much different or? Ik crocs arent in game just curious lol

like IRL

[vital crypt]

crocodiles have a more narrow build i believe

teeth are often more visible

[tidal basalt]

is there anywhere or anyway to explore parts of guarma without being wanted or the sniper

without mods

[lapis panther]

Really? They had Hosea and shot him in the street instead of turning him in. Before that they tortured Mac and killed him.

[vital crypt]

yeah or killing them.

meant to add that

or doing whatever theyre supposed to

[lapis panther]

I think early they just wanted Dutch

[vital crypt]

if the client wanted info only they might as well just torture someone then discard of them

[vital crypt]

yes. theyre instructed to find and control the gang

[lapis panther]

They were paid to

[vital crypt]

sorry, yes? i am aware?

[lapis panther]

I think it became personal for Milton when he was told to get lost during Chapter 3 when he visited their camp

[dark ferry]

no you cannot

herbs nor dinosaurs bones spawn during that mission

[oblique quiver]

probably

but you’ll keep getting jumped

[hidden moss]

Bro that huge alligator in c4 with dutch and those two black dudes is like immortal xDD

[solid trench]

What to do in chapter 3?

I havent done the micah mission he pisses me off i dont want him back

[hidden moss]

Im not happy one bit 😭

@deep glacier Ive come so far! Im on some like island now wtf 😭

[deep glacier]

My favorite mission is in that chapter, just wait

[hidden moss]

Favourite mission of all RDR2?

ur saying?

[deep glacier]

Yes, it’s not a common favorite one. It’s my personal favorite because of the music and stuff

[hidden moss]

Ahh, I see! Is this chapter 5 now then or not yet?

[deep glacier]

You just get to the island?

[hidden moss]

yeah im doing some long ass walking holding W 😭

[deep glacier]

Ah yes, very beginning of chapter 5 then

It should say soon

[hidden moss]

just hasnt said chapter 5 yet

okay 😄

Ive heard that C5 is very bad idk why

we will see!

[deep glacier]

You’ll see why people don’t like all that much

[hidden moss]

Ahh alright

do u personally like the chapter itself?

[deep glacier]

I found it ok

Not the best but not the worst either

[hidden moss]

Whats ur fav chap!

Mine so far is prollyyy idk actually 😭

[deep glacier]

6, not so common favorite one either

[hidden moss]

All chapters are good in their own way 😄

[deep glacier]

Facts partner

[hidden moss]

Has this game won GOTY? Surely right

[deep glacier]

You’d be surprised

[hidden moss]

NO!?

[deep glacier]

God of war beat it in 2018 I think the year was

[hidden moss]

WHAT

nuuh not having that

Oh there we go it says C5 now

[deep glacier]

Yaaaa, god of war is great so I’ve heard. But not rdr level I’m pretty sure

[hidden moss]

Guarma

is that a real place IRL

[hidden moss]

I kinda got bored idk why.

[deep glacier]

What a lot of people I know have said

And no Guarma aint a real place

[hidden moss]

It looks beautiful ngl

[deep glacier]

But they took inspiration from Cuba to make it and stuff

[hidden moss]

Oooh

[deep glacier]

It is off the coast of Cuba in game if I’m remembering it correctly

[hidden moss]

Yeahh dutch was talking abt something to do with cuba anyway

on the ship

[deep glacier]

Sounds about right then

[hidden moss]

Second island east of cuba

[deep glacier]

Explains why it’s similar to Cuba obviously lol

[hidden moss]

yeah lol

How the hell did bill make it 😭

Feels so weird not using MY guns

[flat quartz]

I love god of war but like come on RDR2 is better

[deep glacier]

I’ve never played god of war and I don’t think I will. The concept and detail rdr has is why I love it so much personally

I’m not into the concept of what god of war is, not for me

[hidden moss]

Idk if this is a spoiler or not, but on guarma would i not have my normal weapons id have?

[flat quartz]

That was how I felt during epilogue I

[flat quartz]

No you wouldn't. But you'll have them once you return back to America

[hidden moss]

Thats a bit annoying 😭

As least i have my pistol

😄

[flat quartz]

Is this your first playthrough? I don't want to spoil anything for you 🦜

I finished my first playthrough yesterday

[hidden moss]

Yes it is

[hidden moss]

Everything i collect btw in the island, does it come back with me

[midnight ocean]

like consumables?

[hidden moss]

Yeah anything like that.

[flat quartz]

No it doesn't

[hidden moss]

Theres so many guns scattered around o nthe island its crazy

[deep glacier]

You’ll need them, trust

[hidden moss]

Guarma was so quick wtff?

[deep glacier]

What part you at?

[hidden moss]

Arthur is back in america and some music starting playing, which was relaxing asf

it took like

not even like a while lol

and i took my time haaha

[deep glacier]

Funny you said that guarma was quick because I’ve seen people say that it was dragged out lol

[hidden moss]

Like there was only a couple missions lol, no sides or anything

[deep glacier]

Right

The guarma part is why people don’t like chapter 5 tho I’m pretty sure

[hidden moss]

That is fair lol

Why tf does arthur keep coughing 😭

[deep glacier]

You’ll see soon partner

[hidden moss]

MY HORSE better not be dead. Why tf does it say its lost.

Maybe i gotta finish this first mission in america frist

first

[buoyant maple]

I have the perfect image but I js cant send it bc I don't wanna spoil(idk if that's the right word) it😭

[hidden moss]

No spoilers not even the tiniest 😉

[buoyant maple]

nods

[deep glacier]

First play through type thing

Wish I could experience this game for the first time again maneeee

Sadge

[hidden moss]

Get brain damage or something!

😭

Why does sadie sound so different 😭

[opal lava]

I forgot I can't censor stuff in this server

But I cant get myself to play the game after SOMETHING happend 💀😭

[midnight ocean]

people just really hate losing their gear and getting limited to a certain area

makes it feel longer than it is

[deep glacier]

I figured that’s the case

Not having your load out does suck

[deep glacier]

Intrigued to know what part you’re talking about exactly

[opal lava]

I can js dm it to you cuz I dont wanna ruin it for people who don't want spoilers

If that's alright with you

[hidden moss]

The losing gear part is so awful tho

ngl 😭

[deep glacier]

Of course, was gonna say to just do that lmao

[hidden moss]

I hate arthur with a long beard idk why

[opal lava]

Same it just makes him look like a hobo

He looks better with a stubble or completely shaved

[hidden moss]

I like him with a bit of beard but not too much weight yk

[deep glacier]

My Arthur always has the scruff scruff. Hate the long beard on him

[hidden moss]

What is a shotgun that has a decent enough of ammo before reloading?

that is a big shotgun not like a sawed off

Do you guys realy care about weapon stats or do u choose whatever is more fun

[deep glacier]

I choose whatever feels good to use honestly

[hidden moss]

That’s fair lol. My fav rifle is the bolt action whatever it’s called

[deep glacier]

I like using the repeaters

[hidden moss]

Oh yeah repeaters 100%

[tulip solstice]

man rifles are poo compared to repeaters ngl

[hidden moss]

Lancaster my fav

[tulip solstice]

almost the same amt of dmg on both

but one is just slow and cumbersome

[hidden moss]

Does Dutch always have a plan or some shit 😔

[pastel linden]

"The Guarma part" you mean the entire chapter? 💀

[pastel linden]

I use varmint rifle on enemies for the challenge

[deep glacier]

It was majority of the chapter but sure. I guess the whole chapter, go off

[lapis panther]

Only good thing about Guarma were Hercule and the last two missions there

[deep glacier]

The fort shootout was insanely cool

[lapis panther]

It was

Worst thing was sharing the island with four gang members I care the least about

[lapis panther]

Same here

[lapis panther]

Am I the only one who isn't bothered if Micah is in camp? I hardly acknowledge he is there and if he talks to me, I just press not now like I do with most in camp if I don't want to here their crap haha

[lapis panther]

Have some goddamn faith 🤣

[lapis panther]

Travelling by foot that annoys me haha

[tulip solstice]

counts as a repeater I think

[pastel linden]

nope, uses rifle ammo

really is its own thing though since its its special .22 varmint ammo

[midnight ocean]

for what challenge

[modern bobcat]

Dead server

[dark ferry]

i know people use it for the disarm challenge

[hidden moss]

[flat tusk]

Guys I'm new on this game (currently on chapter 3) do I have to download mods like rampage trainer?

[brave tulip]

I accidentally switched what shoulder I shot from in rdr from the right side to the left. How do I switch back? It’s kinda awkward shooting my rifle from the left side

[hidden moss]

Play game vanilla first

[terse grove]

on xbox its on of the buttons on the dpad

left i think

[brave tulip]

Ok.

Thank you

[flat tusk]

Guys what's the best weapon?

[brave tulip]

In what class of weapons?

[flat tusk]

like revolvers or shotguns

for missons

[brave tulip]

For shotguns, really anything but the double barrel. I like the semi auto shotgun

Revolvers, I like the LeMat

I like the evens repeater cuz ammo capacity and fire rate. Rifle I like the Springfield with long scope

[stable shard]

Revolver Schofield and Shotgun Pump action

imo

[wraith saffron]

What can I use money on? got 4 grand on me after the bank robbery

[vital crypt]

save it for a good horse, clothes, weapons, ledger

[wraith saffron]

save it, roger!

[vital crypt]

look up the price of your "dream" horse

but definitely use it on the ledger

[wraith saffron]

Already got a arabian, is there anyrthing better than that?

[vital crypt]

unlocks fast travel and no need to run to a stable to get another horse

[vital crypt]

mft, turkoman

rose arabian

[lyric pike]

does setting up a tent at a temporary camp actually do anything for you or is just cosmetic?

[vital crypt]

no difference

[hidden moss]

I think it just is for cosmetic.

No this game is making me upset oh god 🙁

[sinful barn]

An Honest Mistake is a dope mission.

[eternal zinc]

Is the legendary channel catfish catchable after finishing a fisher of fish or am I just wasting my time ?

[midnight ocean]

wasting your time

[hidden moss]

Woolie i just learnt whats wrong with arthur.. 😭

NOT Happy

[eternal zinc]

Thx

[modern bobcat]

I'm going to do horseman 9 for the billionth time, I'm going for the bridge route, any tips so it doesn't reset for an idiotic reason?

[hidden moss]

If i snuck into a house in the open world, took money that was sitting there would that lower my honour

[deep glacier]

Probably

[hidden moss]

Nah, surprisingly it didnt!

[lapis panther]

Depends on the homestead

[hidden moss]

And alyssa, i found out abt arthur.. 🙁

[deep glacier]

The reason for the coughing?

[hidden moss]

Yeah.. i went to the doctors.

[deep glacier]

I bawled my eyes out at the part

[hidden moss]

Tuberculosis?

I think thats how u spell it

[deep glacier]

Yes

[hidden moss]

Is that kinda like lung cancer

or

[deep glacier]

Sorta, it’s more or less and really bad infection of the lungs caused by bacteria

[hidden moss]

ah, crap..

Wait was it by that farmer guy in C2?

[deep glacier]

Correct

[hidden moss]

Thats how easy you can just give it to someone wow

[lapis panther]

Easily cured now with antibiotics about

[vital crypt]

can dangerous animals spawn directly next to your camp?

slash come to your camp

[lapis panther]

Yes

[vital crypt]

ok dear cougar let me sleep dont eat my horse

[lapis panther]

I've seen a video on youtube where the player woke up from his tent and a cougar attacked him

[vital crypt]

WHAT

[deep glacier]

[lapis panther]

I'll try and get it

[vital crypt]

dont???

ok sorry

i am calmly leaving

[hidden moss]

Omg i got max honour and a achievement!

[lapis panther]

It only can happen if you're not in the tent or resting by the fire

[vital crypt]

good

"dont sleep too deeply for the man with no nose is coming for you" voldemort?

[dark ferry]

could be referencing death

[lapis panther]

I remember when he warned me about taking another person's horse as it would not go to plan. The thing bucked me off and ran haha

[vital crypt]

ill go with voldemort

[pastel linden]

personal challenge lol

[lyric pike]

Can I store more than 1 pelt at a time on a horse I really dont feel like taking 21 trips to and from camp in order to get the legend of the East satchel?

[vital crypt]

yes

except big ones

bison, alligator and such

i did not spoiler myself and i have to say unexpected deaths are the worst

like some deaths you can really call. but sean? no way

[lapis panther]

I think Kieran had the worst death

Most died quickly and by getting shot.

[vital crypt]

that is unfortunately true

but it was not exactly unexpected

kieran definitely felt that well. super unclean cut.

[lapis panther]

It wasn't but god knows what they done with him

[midnight ocean]

yes for the ones that you just kinda drape over the horses butt like deer wolf cougar etc

but no for the big ones that you roll up and put on the back like a body

[vital crypt]

theres an ugly history on people screaming and talking when their head was half off

[midnight ocean]

what you can do is get a temp horse to carry a second one

[vital crypt]

caused by unsharpened tools

not nice at all

[lyric pike]

okay thank you

[vital crypt]

and kieran is really one of the characters that did not deserve what happened to them at all

only ever tried to be good to the gang

[lapis panther]

Yes and the gang were starting to like and trust him

[vital crypt]

its just a gruesome death

one of the worst in my opinion

i accidentally spoilered myself but im afraid ill still get emotional over it

[lapis panther]

Unexpected death I'd have to say a certain one in that bank mission

Especially because you're still mourning the first

[vital crypt]

which one

also how micah treated seans death solidified my opinion on him

that was NASTY

[lapis panther]

You done the Saint Denis bank robbery ?

[vital crypt]

no

[lapis panther]

Okay I'll keep quiet

[vital crypt]

i dont particularly like anyone else who dies so uh

i mean yes arthur

oh wait yeah no i do know who dies in the mission

my memory

[modern bobcat]

What's the highest point in the game?

[lapis panther]

Mount Hagen I think

[modern bobcat]

I think there's a higher mountain out of bounds

[lapis panther]

There is but you cannot go there

I thought you meant traversable

[modern bobcat]

Why can't i?

[midnight ocean]

because its out of bounds

[vital crypt]

rip van winkle my favourite characters just made his appearance

[modern bobcat]

What if I'm already out of bounds

Can i get there?

[deep glacier]

Probably not

[modern bobcat]

Why so

[deep glacier]

Cause it’s outta bounds for a reason

[modern bobcat]

Heh

What if i set a camp in mexico?

What will happen?

[lapis panther]

You'll be returned to New Austin I think

[modern bobcat]

Goddammit

[lapis panther]

I know you can access Mexico by glitches, but you're not suppose to be there lol

[modern bobcat]

Thanks for telling me before trying that

Being out of bounds where there is nothing to see and to do is more interesting than being inside the game map which you can see and do lots of things

[lapis panther]

I guess it might be a good cure for insomnia

[modern bobcat]

What's that

Ah

True

Why did the developers spend some time on making lots of things in areas that the player cannot see?

Like what's the point of making mountains outside of the game map where the player can't see

[lapis panther]

Background scenery

[vital crypt]

yes

and you see some things from places further out

plus a map that just cuts off looks lazy

they were smart with their boundaries

all naturally keeping the player from going further

[lapis panther]

Plus in the beta map, Ambarino was much bigger and was scaled down for the final version of the game

[vital crypt]

sad about that

[lapis panther]

I think they could've done more with that state. You hardly go into Grizzlies West post chapter 1

[vital crypt]

true

i wish some places weren just dead

like

used for the story and bam gone

[lapis panther]

Plus there is no one up there which is weird

[vital crypt]

nothing happening

[vital crypt]

exactly

a dead frozen couple

how romantic

[lapis panther]

I have seen an npc race through on his horse near Ewing Basin

[vital crypt]

LMAO

your company are the wolves and bears

[lapis panther]

Haha

[vital crypt]

trying to tear you apart every two minutes

[lapis panther]

They don't bother me

[vital crypt]

making it unenjoyable to enjoy the scenery

[lapis panther]

My springfield sorts them out haha

[vital crypt]

im a massive mountain guy but i will not ride in fear

okay shut up bot

[lapis panther]

Going south from Ewing Basin to Hanging Dog Ranch and you'll run into wolves haha

[hidden moss]

Molly?! No way

[midnight ocean]

getting out of bounds on halo 2 maps back in the day was kinda fun

but that could also be done with friends

[hidden moss]

I got a question. If i ever wanted to do another playthrough on LOW honour, would doing side missions GAIN honour?

[vital crypt]

yes, i assume

[hidden moss]

I guess the best thing is to NOT do that then

[vital crypt]

well

losing honour is super easy

[hidden moss]

True, but mostly the side missions is helping people and being low isnt like

[vital crypt]

yes but i would get the rewards

[hidden moss]

Trueee

[vital crypt]

just kick a dog afterwards

[past berry]

NO

KICK A HUMAN

[hidden moss]

Idk why but my dead eye core doesnt FULLY restore

[vital crypt]

yes but running over a dog wont give you immediate trouble

dont kick anyone

just run an animal over

[midnight ocean]

what are you restoring it with

everything gives different amounts

[hidden moss]

Just like foods that restore enough dead eye to fully restore

[midnight ocean]

try a big game meat

[hidden moss]

Ohh wait its okay now!! idk why it didnt work earlier

[midnight ocean]

although its better to cook it with thyme for a gold core

also if you eat a chewing tobacco itll remove a little of your core so be wary of that

[hidden moss]

Oh yeah

omg i have 99 chewing tobbacos how tf

[dark ferry]

looting bodies

perhaps

[hidden moss]

Im not a killer yall i promise 😄

[midnight ocean]

yeah you often get like 4 off of a single body

and you only need one chewing tobacco to kill quite a few enemies

so if you loot its pretty hard to run out

[hidden moss]

Ohh yeahh

So what does fortifying actually do? Does it just last a little longer?

[midnight ocean]

essentially it just overfills the core

itll let you use deadeye for a bit longer after draining the meter without starting to drain the core

but it will go back to white if you keep doing that

[hidden moss]

ahh ok

[midnight ocean]

but otherwise it lasts like 24 hours

so its a great idea to eat gold core food right before missions because you can have the gold core throughout the whole thing if you dont abuse it

[vital crypt]

cool didnt know that

i just stop for some liquor mid shooting ngl

im never prepared

[midnight ocean]

pick some thyme and skin some gators

[calm dragon]

is it weird that i play the game mostly with a knife?

i don't like using guns but knives are so fun

[midnight ocean]

i imagine that makes some fights a bit difficult

[misty mango]

genuinely how do you do that lmao

[deep glacier]

I imagine they play stealthy or somethin

[misty mango]

rdr2 isn't really a game that allows for stealth a lot of the time

[calm dragon]

no i just run towards my enemy avoiding bullets and cut their throats

it's really easy

easier than shooting for me

[misty mango]

yeah sounds it

you should upload that to yt

[calm dragon]

why

[deep glacier]

You’ve got plot armor for real

[calm dragon]

the only time it doesn't work is when enemies are on a horse

[misty mango]

because people would watch that and you will make moneyz

[midnight ocean]

thats nuts lol

especially on console

[lapis panther]

Throwing knives?

Poisoned ones haha

[calm dragon]

nop

standard knife

cmon it isn't difficult i find shooting much more annoying

[calm dragon]

or pirate sword, aka my favourite weapon in the game

[lapis panther]

I am a blast them and move on player so I'll stick to my guns haha

[calm dragon]

pirate sword is so versatile it's crazy

one good hit and the enemy's down

[lapis panther]

Machete is good too

[calm dragon]

yeah but tomahawk and hatchets are meh

i don't like tomahawks

[lapis panther]

I hardly use them

[calm dragon]

my ranking would be
knives
pistols
revolvers

[midnight ocean]

how

you're on playstation the game aims for you

[calm dragon]

yeah but cutting down enemies is more fun

running around trying to avoid bullets

[midnight ocean]

and then chugging moonshine when you inevitably fail lol

[lapis panther]

Not the way I'd play but it sounds like fun running around like a mad man stabbing people in missions

[calm dragon]

it's easy if you can dodge bullets by seeing that small white line in the air

[calm dragon]

it is lol

i should make a video to show you

[brave tulip]

Hey, how do I find a legendary game trail I lost? I was attacked by a bunch of bounty hunters and I can’t find the trail again. Was hunting the legendary buck/deer. do I sleep outside of it’s territory and enter again?

[dark ferry]

yes

[brave tulip]

Thank you!

[brave tulip]

Please do!

Mad man ax murderer would be cool too

[hidden moss]

A little lost, but why are we stealing the explosives from army covoy in C6 again?

[cedar pollen]

tryna run a new game and i wanna get 100% if any1 got any treasure or animal maps it would much appreciated if some1 sent those

[cedar pollen]

wasnt it to blow up that bridge and blame it on the natives or sum

[hidden moss]

Why would they wanna do that again

[cedar pollen]

cuz dutch wanted to get atention away from the gang but he prob just wanted dudes to die

[ruby cypress]

I went to tame a red Arabian horse and lost sight of it and its trail. How can I find it again? I'm a beginner.

[ruby cypress]

Bro

[lapis panther]

Divert attention away from the gang.

[hidden moss]

What does that exactly mean?

sorry im slow 😭

[lapis panther]

They have so much heat on them

[hidden moss]

oh yeah they have ive seen in the camp

theyre trying to do something to distract em from all that or?

[lapis panther]

They are wanted but still cause chaos. So a blown up bridge diverts attention away from them

[hidden moss]

Ohhhh

Right okay

ty lol. sometimes i get lost

[lapis panther]

They also blew it up so the government would send money and supplies by train and the gang would rob it.

[dreamy canyon]

So how far into the story is the train robbery with john

Asking for a smallfry

[lapis panther]

Chapter 2

[dreamy canyon]

Is it close to chapter 3

Cause ive been a bad boy in rdr2

If i show what I’ve done to the law they will not let me go be free

[lapis panther]

Yes

[dreamy canyon]

Thx

[hidden moss]

I’m like a tiny bit away from reaching max max honour. Can just spamming greet in a place get me to max?

Accidentally killed a horse so lost some honour

[dreamy canyon]

I think

Donate some money to the camp

[cedar pollen]

just go to saint denis and greet bunch of people

[deep glacier]

Throwing fish back in the water or greeting people in Saint Denis should get it max again if you’re a little bit off

[hidden moss]

Donate $20.01, spam that and you'll get high honor the quickest.

I did this after a few of the hiests, that were successful.

Anything over $20 will get you good honor. So do 20.01.

I often did $21 for an easier time to spam

Spamming greet takes too long in my opinion

[oblique quiver]

yuh

and don’t donate any more than $21

In my first playthrough I made the mistake of donating literally all my money thinking it would 100% my honor

it did not

[midnight ocean]

he's in chapter 6 lol

[hidden moss]

Same here,

[hidden moss]

Dang rip, I go to YouTube before I do anything

[lapis panther]

Who do you reckon smashed the box?

[midnight ocean]

gotta be micah or bill right

[lapis panther]

I always thought it was Dutch

[midnight ocean]

how come

[lapis panther]

Fits with his personality cracking.

[midnight ocean]

true

[dreamy canyon]

I like hosea

[lapis panther]

Same

[dreamy canyon]

John seems important

Killed that bear for hosea and forgot to save

[deep glacier]

Finished one exotics request just to get another one

[modern bobcat]

[meager herald]

guys, I need help! I have completed the “Double-Action Revolver Headshot Challenge” on GTA Online but it never appeared in RDR2. I even checked my weapon wheel, horse holster, and weapon locker. But there are no Double-Action Revolver Headshot.

[modern bobcat]

I guess it has something to do with social club, but what exactly? No idea

[dark ferry]

connect your social club account to your rdr2

[meager herald]

Never mind, I thought this was needed for compendium

[modern bobcat]

Is the out of bounds map to the north of blackwater in rdr1 the same as it is in rdr2?

[hidden moss]

Good morning

[lost halo]

How we doing sir

[hidden moss]

Good, hbu?

[lost halo]

Not bad

[hidden moss]

That's great 🙂

[hidden moss]

my rdr2 crashed mid side mission. once i relog, will it just make me do it again?

[wraith saffron]

is it important to help mary?

[dark ferry]

it’s your choice if you wanna or not. It isn’t that important plot wise

[modern bobcat]

[lyric pike]

Does the chocalate turkoman have the same stats as the turkoman in the saint denis stable, im in chapter 2 and dont feel like riding all the way to saint denis

[azure sluice]

Are there coats other than the bay roan for the Ardennes horse?

I recall seeing a grey coated one but that’s through cheats

[hidden moss]

use the train

[lyric pike]

I tought you couldn't fast travel to cities unless you been to them

[hidden moss]

that just applies to fast travel (the one u get from the camp) and diligences

you can use train to go to sd or Rhodes even if you just started chapter 2

[lyric pike]

oh okay thanks

[hidden moss]

Oh my god how many times does john need saving 😭

[vale osprey]

Morning

[lyric pike]

stables are universal right If i drop a horse off at the strawberry stable ill be able to retrieve it in the valentine stable?

[wild jackal]

my goat

[vestal shard]

I'm doing the 100% and GOD DAMMIT I MISSED THE RAILROAD MISSIONS

But I've already done so much I can't just lose every progress I made

And it's not like I can go back to a previous save, the railroad was probably finished in-game weeks ago

Fffffffuck

[vale osprey]

I am like 99% sure you dont need to do that for 100%

[lyric pike]

Is there anyway to get a missouri fox trotter or turkoman in chapter 2?

[vestal shard]

Yeah it doesn't count for the in-game's 100% meter (which to be fair, isn't an accurate way to determine 100%, it doesn't even need you to complete the entire compendium) but still

Such a shame I missed on side content missions

[hushed delta]

Howdy fellers

[vestal shard]

I love micah's voice actor, check out the clip where a kid approaches the actora on a con asking about their fav moment in the game, they asked the kid back the same question, and he said "was it the one with micah? was that your favorite moment?"

[hushed delta]

Heh

Never seen him

Just seen john’s and Aurther’s actors

Holdup

I think i got a photo

[vestal shard]

The cast are so nice

[dark ledge]

Yall how do I get to the gun wheel?

Ik this is a dumb question but I haven’t played in months lmao

Just got back on (I’m in guarma for extra information)

And I forgot all the controls

[serene trail]

What wheel?

[dark ledge]

Nvm i think i got it lmao

[hidden moss]

I just talked to sister for the very last time I think? 😭

That was sad

[lyric pike]

Micah reminds me so much of trevor

[vale osprey]

Fair it is a very fun side mission.

[vestal shard]

For the cyberpunk run I was fine resetting for a mission I missed

But here!?!? After completing horseman, weapon expert, master hunter, gambler, every cigarette catd every rock carving every treasure map!?!?!? Hell naw

Not gonna lie, it's gonna bum me down knowing I missed the side quest, but oh well, that's the way it is, it's not worth resetting all my progress

[hidden moss]

Arthur had a son? With who?

[dark ferry]

you can get an MFT during the third mission of “Arcadia for Amateurs” as for a turkoman i don’t believe you can get any in chapter 2, closest is chapter 3

[dark ledge]

Bro how do I gain honour fast

I’m tryna greet people in Saint Denis but this is taking forever

I wanna have high honour before doing the doctor mission

[lyric pike]

Okay, Thank you

[vital crypt]

eliza

[hidden moss]

Have i missed something i never knew who that was

[vital crypt]

she died before the game started

long ago

his son isaac was four

[hidden moss]

ohh

howd he die

[vital crypt]

killed in an ambush i believe

[hidden moss]

ahh i see

[vital crypt]

some kind of gang matter

[lyric pike]

Is there a way of getting a poncho for Arthur? I've seen videos of him with one, but I'm unsure whether they're modded or not

[midnight ocean]

modded

[midnight ocean]

some bandits robbed and killed them for a few bucks

[vital crypt]

excuse me how do i get my horse out of the water

i already relogged and camped and its still swimming

[hidden moss]

Have u told it to flee

[vital crypt]

yes it literally just swims further out

i dont know how it even got in the water

[dark ferry]

that’s pretty much the fastest way

[lyric pike]

donating to camp and releasing fish is also pretty good

atleast from what ive hear

[hidden moss]

Anyone else like the Schofield revolver?

[midnight ocean]

maybe just go to a stable or the horse thing at camp and retrieve it?

[midnight ocean]

yeah probably my favorite

[hidden moss]

I also like calloways yk that one?

[midnight ocean]

that is a schofield i think right

[vital crypt]

didnt work but i relogged a few more times and it worked

[hidden moss]

They have the same stats pretty much. schofield tiny bit faster thats all

[midnight ocean]

yeah calloways is just a unique schofield

i was dual wielding it with otis millers which is also a schofield

[hidden moss]

Oh i see! I dont like the volcanic pistol. too slow yk

[midnight ocean]

yeah i never use the pistols

i thought they had higher firerates in general tho

[hidden moss]

Some are very fast just shit dmg

volcanic has high dmg just slow

[midnight ocean]

ah

i started using double actions since im low honor lol

[hidden moss]

ooh i see. Ngl, my whole playthrough ive barely used a shotgun..

[midnight ocean]

i only used one for two things

one was getting the grin and bear it achievement

other was getting that challenge for killing enemies with crafted ammo or something

[hidden moss]

I just prefer repeaters and like revolvers lol. I only rlly use rifles for hunting or like sniping someone yk

[midnight ocean]

yeah same

combat for me was always repeater or revolver

[hidden moss]

Yeahh im always hitting headshots anyway lol

[midnight ocean]

precisely

[hidden moss]

im on chapter 6 and wtf has happened to the camp.. its depressing

[midnight ocean]

yeahhh dw things will take a more optimistic turn at some point

[hidden moss]

Seems only charles, john and sadie actually like me 😭

[hidden moss]

Was strauss kicked out bc he kept handing out money to the people who couldnt pay him back

[midnight ocean]

yeah arthur finally got sick of it

strauss' way of making money for the gang is like the polar opposite of the original ideals

its like stealing from the poor

[hidden moss]

I mean he was loyal and stuff but just his work was not good

[midnight ocean]

was his loyalty even tested

and does it matter anyway

[hidden moss]

Tbh he was just sitting there ngl

[hidden moss]

What did you say your favourite repeater was

[midnight ocean]

hm

lancaster i guess

not too sure

when the game gives me a new one i just use that

but i didnt get the evans until i had already finished the entire game lol

[hidden moss]

Is Evans a better one would you say?

Than Lancaster

[midnight ocean]

tbh its hard to tell because like you pointed out earlier every gun is a one shot to the head

and fire rate/reload speed isnt that important either when you spam deadeye

the best thing to do might just be to go with whatever one sounds the coolest to you lol

since each weapon has a unique firing sound

[hidden moss]

Ohh yeah true. It ain’t like an mmorpg or anything like that lol. I can just use whatever I like yk

[midnight ocean]

yeah and ultimately its not a hard game at all

so no meta

[hidden moss]

Is it the same for online or a bit more like looking into the stats

Since I’ll prolly play that after story maybe

[midnight ocean]

yeah for online i think it matters more

i dont know jack about online though

ive heard the navy revolver is good

[hidden moss]

do you not play online?

[hidden moss]

Also i rlly like the carcano rifle in story

[dark ferry]

the carcano is so powerful

[hidden moss]

Yeah fr

[dark ferry]

but sadly there isn’t many cases of having to use a long ranged weapon

[hidden moss]

Only in hunting

[dark ferry]

barely in hunting

i never really track animals on foot

it’s a lot easier to just run up on them on a horse

[midnight ocean]

i think i hit level 5 back in 2018 and never touched it again

i kinda want to get into it so i can platinum the game tho

[dark ferry]

online is so annoying

i played for like 2 hours before getting frustrated and ragequitting

[midnight ocean]

moose and buffalo i guess

but an improved arrow or high velocity rifle round might also work

[dark ferry]

improved arrows are really cool

they shoot through a lot of stuff

like i remember getting a double kill with a single improved arrow

[midnight ocean]

damn lol

[hidden moss]

You HAVE to play online for plati?!

[midnight ocean]

yeah theres a bunch of online achievements

[vital crypt]

god i hate online

[hidden moss]

Godd

[blazing turret]

idk if i actually get a pistol or stick with the revolver

alright i made my pair of m1899 into ebony and ivory

[lapis panther]

Yes it's my favourite revolver

[lapis panther]

I personally think seeing the widow and her son brought back bad memories for Arthur too.

[vital crypt]

cut arthurs hair for the first time

but i could not bring myself to get too much off

im attached

[deep glacier]

What level you cut it to?

[vital crypt]

had it at longest, cut down twice. forgot how many levels there are

[deep glacier]

10? If I’m remembering it correctly

I kept mine between 2-3 personally. Longest I’d go was 4

The long hair doesn’t suit him lol

[vital crypt]

i totally think it does

short hair makes him look old

i like long hair on men anyways

and i mean, hes an outlaw. when does he ever cut his hair

[deep glacier]

True, I personally didn’t like it tho

[vital crypt]

right now i have mine longer than arthurs. the curls cut the length though.

short hair feels weird for me not gonna lie

[hidden moss]

Its so sad hearing arthur struggling to breathe at times 😭

[deep glacier]

What mission are you at now?

[hidden moss]

I just finished the one where we get the indian chiefs son out of that camp

[deep glacier]

The ending to that mission is so sad

Just sits on the rock wheezing

[hidden moss]

He just coughs, unable to breathe 😭

[deep glacier]

Literally

[hidden moss]

Some C6 missions are boring, some are good

[deep glacier]

I mostly liked ch.6 cause of the side missions

If I’m being for real

[hidden moss]

I found those 2 like twins side missions funny 🤣

Yk where they fight over the girl

[deep glacier]

You fully finish that one?

[hidden moss]

Uhhh im not sure?

Would telling u the last one i did help?

[burnt fulcrum]

what should i do after lowk completing the epilogue

[deep glacier]

Ya, where’d ya leave off

[deep glacier]

100% completion

[hidden moss]

The two twins get into a barrel, fall off a waterfall and then they forget about the girl and just yeah 😭

[deep glacier]

Ok ya you did finish it. The barrel was crazy

[hidden moss]

Yeahhh 😭

[deep glacier]

I was like “aint no way”

[hidden moss]

Looked fun thoo

[vital crypt]

im feeding my arthur my entire inventory every fucking day

and hes STILL underweight

fast metabolism king

fifty cans of something later.

[deep glacier]

Fast metabolism for sure

[dark ferry]

i got him to max weight by spamming drinking fine brandy

pass out

drink and pass out again

[hidden moss]

Does he actually get fat or

[deep glacier]

I’ve seen on YouTube he does but that’s probably mods

[hidden moss]

Yeah more than likely

[dark ferry]

he gets a little bulkier

and takes less damage

but his stamina drains faster

tho honestly him getting bulkier isn’t very noticeable

[midnight ocean]

big meals

[vital crypt]

I DO

i swear i do

i give him meat and all

stew

[dark ferry]

big game meat has the most calories

[vital crypt]

everything

i know

[dark ferry]

just buy a lot of brandy

[vital crypt]

he drinks like fifteen bottles a day

[dark ferry]

and drink that repeatedly til he passes out wakes up and repeat

maybe he’s doomed to stay a thin king

[vital crypt]

eat arthur

[dark ferry]

i just encountered really weird dialogue i’ve never heard before

i don’t like it..

[midnight ocean]

?

[vital crypt]

im free.

a badger finally spawned.

[dark ferry]

check rdr media

[hidden moss]

Wth dutch left me to die in that factory!?

[night bluff]

Ta heee teee

[hidden moss]

Apparently im on the last mission, i cant tell

[lyric pike]

is the Double action or scorchfield revolver better?

[deep glacier]

The ultimate betrayal

[lapis panther]

Sounds like a gay O'Driscoll

[hidden moss]

I'm not crying right now.

That hit hard what the hell

[hidden moss]

im not happy 😭

[deep glacier]

What part you at now?

[hidden moss]

Epilogue 1 🙁

I cried my eyes out.

[deep glacier]

Play through it. I promise it’s bitter sweet

[hidden moss]

Does it get more fun? Im scooping shit at the moment.

[deep glacier]

Yes

[hidden moss]

Yayay

[hidden moss]

What the hell is john wearing 😭

[deep glacier]

Not diggin his rancher outfit?

[hidden moss]

Ill get used to ittt

[hidden moss]

For the little horse race between me and jack, i let him win!

[deep glacier]

I did too I think? I don’t quite remember

[hidden moss]

No point in winning! ruins jacks fun!

[deep glacier]

Valid for that

[hidden moss]

Why is John so nice 😭 rn

[deep glacier]

He trynna be a better man so to speak

[hidden moss]

You reckon arthurs 💀 changed him alot?

[deep glacier]

I’d say so ya. Towards the end of Arthur’s life he kept telling John to make it and do what’s right

[vestal shard]

hey fellers I'm at chapter 2 hoping to do the item requests I've got left

how did y'all trigger pearson's rabbit request? I've checked and done multiple videos but from what I seem to read because I have the Kieran mission icon (I haven't done said mission yet) it doesn't trigger, maybe? how did y'all trigger that one?

I'm also trying to get dutch to smoke so I can give him a pipe and for abigail to ask for five bucks for jack's new clothes, but again, haven't been able to get either of all these

[dark ferry]

you don’t need to do any mission for the pearson item request.

[hidden moss]

Yeah. God I miss him already 🙁

[vestal shard]

the Kieran icon doesn't affect anything?

[dark ferry]

Just wait around until he goes behind his table with a bottle in his hand

and start whistling

annnnd there you go

[vestal shard]

he has done this multiple times (whistling too) but every time I chat him up he never asks for a rabbit

[dark ferry]

no. i’ve gotten the outfit way before that

[dark ferry]

did he have a bottle in his hand?

[dark ferry]

jacket*

[vestal shard]

that's the thing, is not a matter of before or after doing the mission, from what I read, just having the icon on the map itself makes it unable to trigger according to some users

[vestal shard]

yup

[latent knot]

this is ur first time u finish 6 chapters or?

[hidden moss]

Yep

[latent knot]

i feel ya

[hidden moss]

I dont feel happy 🙁

[latent knot]

i play 7th story mod

[dark ferry]

i don’t know why that’d affect any random item request but maybe

[vestal shard]

you will, don't worry (trust the process)

[deep glacier]

I felt the same way too playing through the epilogue but it’s really bittersweet once you finish it

[latent knot]

i was crying when i saw arthurs deadth

[vestal shard]

I don't know either, I've just been trying so many methods to get pearson's request but it just won't trigger

[latent knot]

every single time

[hidden moss]

And at the end i can freeroam and do whatever!!?

[deep glacier]

Correct

[hidden moss]

Its the music aswell! That song at the end

[dark ferry]

you could always try doing the mission. I believe i’ve gotten it around like 12 pm

[hidden moss]

Crash of worlds

[latent knot]

micah its me john marston

[deep glacier]

No spoilers

[vestal shard]

yeah I'll try doing the mission, and afterwards do the item request (I've also heard some folks get pearson's request immediately after waking up from Lenny's drinking mission, approach pearson and he'll ask for the rabbit)

[deep glacier]

That’s the way it is gets me every time

[hidden moss]

do i get to choose high and low honour endings as john on epilogue as well orrr a bit different?

No spoilers)

[dark ferry]

there’s no difference

[vestal shard]

@dark ferry how did you get the item request btw? nothing out of the ordinary? just approaching pearson while he's at the wagoon table drinking and preparing food while whistling?

[dark ferry]

i believe so

[vestal shard]

aight got it thx

[deep glacier]

His request should just show up on the map at a certain time and when it shows up you go talk to him

[dark ferry]

it’s begins around 12ish pm

[deep glacier]

Unless you’re talking about something else

[hidden moss]

Now idk what to be, naughty or good bahaha

[deep glacier]

Be good for Arthur’s sake

[hidden moss]

YEAH

okay

[dark ferry]

i definitely do this..