red-dead-singleplayer

[rancid juniper]

What is castle rustler?

[fluid panther]

Cowboys that steal cows

[deep glacier]

The first prestige role when talking here

[nova breach]

can i hunt all legendary animals in chapter 4 or are some them locked behind something like chapters/mission/challenge?

[stable cove]

I think at least one is in chapter 6 only

Or you have to get to it first

[nova breach]

also should i do all the hunting things before the story ends? cause i already know what will happen i just dont know what happens after that happens

[nova breach]

sounds confusing but i dont want to spoil someone

[frank cedar]

I need an answer quick

Can i use explosive slugs on rh white bison and still get its perfect pelt

[nova breach]

the legendary?

[frank cedar]

Ueah

[nova breach]

i think legendary animals are always top condition

[frank cedar]

OK, I’m shooting it now

[nova breach]

i remember killing the legendary bear in the start of ch2 by peppering it with revolver bullets

[frank cedar]

It’s dead. It only took one slow or two not sure how many because I just usef dead eye.

Now to figure out how to safely without enemies following me, and without dying to a animal, get it to a trapper

The nearest trapper is all the way up there near annesburg

[nova breach]

also i dont think legendary animals have perfect good and poor pelts

i just know theyre always top condition in anyway you kill it

[frank cedar]

Yeah, I looked it up If you do have mods, you could use basically the cannon to kill any of them and you’d still get perfect .

My biggest fear with it on my horse right now is a wolf pack attacking me cause I don’t have any cool horses. I have an Arabian. He’s gonna freak out and knock me off.

[nova breach]

what chapter you in

[frank cedar]

I want to find an a war horse, but I don’t know where to buy one so I just won’t get one

FOUR

[nova breach]

you can buy fox trotter

pretty fast and not skittish like arabian

[nova breach]

in san denis

though i remember you can also get the other fox trotter much earlier in one of the side missions

[hearty seal]

Hi

Anyone Arab here?

I need something

Does anyone know how to get the Izbila map in online mode?

[frank cedar]

I plan on that. I’m probably gonna sell this one and get it.

I need a horse with a lot of HP doesn’t run from wolves and buck me off. That’s all I really care about and doesn’t run from a bunch of shots.

All right, where do I take my stuff manw tailsnen and trinkets

What’s the best rifle to use against foxes? I thought it would be 22 since that’s what I used in real life, but it didn’t go down after like 10 shots.

[honest latch]

ooh uum

the thingy

anrelano horse

or smth

i think it spawns where you kill Jim Boy Calloway

[frank cedar]

Am I supposed to keep all the cards I get in game?

[honest latch]

wdym

the cigerte one?

[frank cedar]

Prominent American card two

[honest latch]

u can do a sidemission thin

with a guy

[nova breach]

its a sidemission

thing

[honest latch]

if u get a full set

u can mail it to him

[frank cedar]

Oh, so don’t sell it

[honest latch]

and he gives u some chain, thingy

[honest latch]

yea

[nova breach]

if you dont have the quest go to flatneck station

he there

iirc

[honest latch]

@modern bobcat

so

adreas perlinos

[nova breach]

you also can easily get all the cards

[honest latch]

i think the war horse called that

[nova breach]

if you have alotta money

[honest latch]

guys

picture this

rdr2 but the main villian

is

bear with me now

jack marston and Cain

wut about uncle

[hot gyro]

Gamer girl here, hit me up

[honest latch]

T-T

wutchu meaan

[frank cedar]

Is there a way for me to put a bunch of skins on a carriage and use it to take a bunch of bison skins to a trapper?

I know Charles said to respect and kill only one bison in that one mission but I love selling their skins or fun to hunt

Like is there a hunting wagon in story mode?

[honest latch]

dont think so

[frank cedar]

I have two bison belts, but I can only carry one

[honest latch]

u could try getting a second temporary horse

to stow stuff on

u could maybe get one of em delivery ones

and drop on it

[chilly spade]

ok

[lapis panther]

You can kill legendary animals in any way you want and their pelt stays the same. I kill the Bull Gator with dynamite.

[nova breach]

do i only lose money if i failed to sell the legendary carcass

it rotted

and i cant pick it up

[lapis panther]

Did you skin it and sell it's pelt?

[empty ingot]

has anyone else noticed the breaking bad reference in the game? When arthur talks to the herbs guy?

[nova breach]

ye

[lapis panther]

Forget the carcass then. It's no use to you. It becomes vulture or other scavengers lunch haha

[nova breach]

it was right next to trapper too :{

i would have probably be able to sell it if i didnt do the rat problem of that one saloon

[lapis panther]

The only use I see in a skinned carcass is using it as predator bait. I have used a skinned deer to get the panther before.

[nova breach]

also

how come in other people's vid they can shoot during deadeye {no paint} and still be in deadeye state

and if i did it, it always turns off after every shot

[lost quarry]

So we just can't save horses with the rampage trainer?

[lapis panther]

Use a war or work breed then. They're not as highly strung as the snake detector white speed pony

[half belfry]

Do animal carcasses eventually despawn? I dont want to clutter the world with them

[lapis panther]

Yes they do.

[half belfry]

Thanks!

[honest latch]

oh um

u need to lvl ur dead eye up

im guessing you have it at a low level?

[nova breach]

its at 8/8

i thought its because of weapon familiarity but i tried in on a max familiarity and it still turns off after every shot

[turbid gate]

if you do challenges then you will have 8/10

10 will be max

where can i cut my beard after epilogue pt. 2?

[fluid panther]

In Beecher's hope you can do it in the bathroom and if u don't know where that is go to the front door then the door on the left

[turbid gate]

thanks

also if i die to a legendary animal do i need to track it again?

[fluid panther]

Yea

Bcs I had a similar thing with a legendary animal forget which but it's near Rhodes and I left game without selling the pelt but if you die to animal you can track it again

[turbid gate]

i slept 20 hours and it didnt reappear

stupid cougar 😭

[fluid panther]

I might be wrong but it'll probably reappear does it say like in the left top corner there's to much activity here

[turbid gate]

i didnt get any notiffication

i hate when it says theres too much things going on and cant track it

[fluid panther]

Yea

I tried to help all I could but I don't know alot about hunting in the game

[turbid gate]

nvm i need to go back later

imma go to it other time then

anyways thanks

[fluid panther]

I try the best I could

[nova breach]

what challenges? i already maxed the sharpshooter

[turbid gate]

master hunter i think

i dont know which one make 10 if any does

[nova breach]

does the legendary panther eye trinket resets after exiting dead eye and entering once again?

[nova breach]

guys can i dynamite fish a legendary fish

i havent tried cause it may sink if the carcass is on water

[midnight ocean]

you need to complete a certain mission first

chapter 4 i think

there are just points in the story where your deadeye upgrades to a better version like when you unlocked the ability to mark targets manually at the end of chapter 2

[gaunt sky]

oh hey woolie

what u up to

[midnight ocean]

working

but i like to check here to see if people have questions i can answer

[nova breach]

can i attach wagons on my horse?

[lapis panther]

No

[nova breach]

damn

that would help alot when hunting

[lapis panther]

Too many pelts or none that cannot go on horse - get back to camp lol

[bitter rampart]

im at the chapter 1 rob the train mission i put the wire like he told me to and im waiting on the cliff and its not coming

[lapis panther]

Weird

Cutscene should play

[midnight ocean]

you can get a temp horse

and carry two large pelts

[lapis panther]

Yes I usually kill two pelts near camp and put one on horse and carry the other

[midnight ocean]

i mean having a second horse lol

if you gotta go to the trapper

[lapis panther]

No I have Arthur carry it lol

[midnight ocean]

that must take a really long time

[lapis panther]

Not really

It's near camp

[midnight ocean]

most pelts go to the trapper tho

[lapis panther]

if I am on long hunting trip, I usually get a temp horse

[midnight ocean]

in fact does pearson even need any large pelts?

[lapis panther]

Not legendary ones

But for satchel

He needs a bison and two elk

[midnight ocean]

well i was more thinking for like when you need to bring all the cow, bull and ox pelts to the trapper

cut your trips in half

or maybe you're carrying something good like a legendary already but then you spot a moose

[nova breach]

whats the best seasoning for big game

[lapis panther]

For me it's thyme for dead eye core

You can also use wild mint for health and oregano for stamina

[nova breach]

i think ill go for thyme

dead eye drains too fast

[midnight ocean]

its nice to have all three

[lapis panther]

Yes

[midnight ocean]

theres a trinket that lets you harvest double the amount when picking mint thyme or oregano as well

[lapis panther]

Cook three big game meats with each seasoning on one

[lapis panther]

Ram?

[midnight ocean]

maybe

i know its an early one

[nova breach]

ohh i thought only 1 seasoning is allowed per meat

[midnight ocean]

it is but you can carry all three types

[nova breach]

nvm read that wrong

[lapis panther]

Yes, cook three peices with each season on one

[midnight ocean]

i mean i would make more than that if you can

[lapis panther]

Yes

Best place for big game meat is the swamp

[midnight ocean]

i hunted so much i never even had to go farming for it lol i just had a massive stack

[lapis panther]

Haha

[nova breach]

wait how many yields does oregano mint and thyme have when gathering without ramhorn

[lapis panther]

Three I think

[nova breach]

its 1 per harvest then its still gon be a chore even with trinket

ahh nice

[lapis panther]

No wait

Ram trinket doubles the amount you pick

[nova breach]

yeah

[lapis panther]

So you pick one, you'll get two

[nova breach]

so is it like 6 per harvest or 2 per havest

oh damn

[lapis panther]

So pick three of them and you get 6

Haven't touched this game properly in over a month so going by memory here haha

[nova breach]

so ineed atleast 50 herbs to get 99 seasonings

[lapis panther]

Just keep picking haha

Doesn't the health core go gold if you buy the chicken coop for camp and then eat stew?

[midnight ocean]

you dont need that many lol

[midnight ocean]

think so. also the five dollar meals at saloons give gold health i think

[lapis panther]

Yes they do

[midnight ocean]

used that a grand total of one time in the epilogue for a mission

[lapis panther]

Saloon meal?

[midnight ocean]

yeah

[lapis panther]

If I am in town. I usually eat a saloon meal

[midnight ocean]

because eating before missions is where the gold core foods really shine

[lapis panther]

Beats Pearson's stew haha

[midnight ocean]

since it will last you for the whole thing

[lapis panther]

I know in Valentine you can get free stew from that camp

[nova breach]

i need it cause imma min-max kinda guy

[midnight ocean]

you're not going to use it all

[lapis panther]

Yes you won't eat 99 big meats lol

[naive verge]

Does anyone have Red Dead Crack?

[lapis panther]

The hot air balloon guy

[naive whale]

what about the residents in strawberry?

[lapis panther]

Those that shoot at you while Arthur and Micah tried to escape?

[naive whale]

forgot about the shooting you back part...

[lapis panther]

Hot air balloon guy was just doing his job

[naive whale]

thats true

[lapis panther]

Until Sadie couldn't keep her blood lust for O'Driscolls under control for an hour or so

[naive whale]

it is the O'Dricrolls to be fair...

[lapis panther]

Then that poor sod gets killed for nothing

[naive whale]

justice for hot air balloon man

[lapis panther]

Yes I went to Hanging Dog Ranch haha

[naive whale]

lol

[midnight ocean]

heidi mccourt

[naive whale]

i want to replay the story but i deleted the RDR2 application and idk if i can sit through a 100 gig download again on my slow ass wifi....

[lapis panther]

Good one

Innocent mother who Dutch killed for no reason

Also do you remember when he shot that woman in the first one?

[fluid panther]

I like your jokes

[midnight ocean]

tf does that mean

[midnight ocean]

yeah

brutal

[fluid panther]

Heheh

[slate sentinel]

Guys, my Arthur is coughing

what will happen

[midnight ocean]

hes just got a cold dw

a tall glass of mango juice and he'll be right as rain

[turbid gate]

yeah he will

i tried it and he got cured from the cold

[pearl shale]

Who's gonna tell bro

[dark ferry]

i can’t believe i never knew this method of going into new austin

[midnight ocean]

i need to find a belgian draft horse lol

maybe im being an idiot but like every carriage i find is pulled by either suffolk punches or shires

[chilly cypress]

Guys i have a theory

[chilly cypress]

Hell be fine dw

[midnight ocean]

what is it

[trim hamlet]

just keep looking I guess ¯_(ツ)_/¯

[trim hamlet]

I mean maybe try personal wagons?
like one-horse ones? idk

[trim hamlet]

shh he doesn't need to know

just go with the bit

[midnight ocean]

those actually often dont even have a wagon horse

found one being pulled by a kentucky saddler

another by a nokota

[trim hamlet]

that is uh

why 😭

[midnight ocean]

i just wish you could see the horse type without stealing the wagon first

[trim hamlet]

are the people that stupid

or do they just want to also be able to unhitch the horse and have decent acceleration

cause the 2nd one is lowkey smart

[midnight ocean]

wut

oh

i mean horse stats is a gameplay thing lol

but yeah imagine its fairly common to use the horse without the wagon too

[trim hamlet]

True

but my headcanon is that the NPCs know the stats and such too

[midnight ocean]

or maybe they couldnt afford a bigger one

thats a weird headcanon

[trim hamlet]

like

maybe not the numerical stuff

but just generally how they behave

[lapis panther]

Yes I've seen a Morgan pull one of them before

[midnight ocean]

they definitely recognize rare coats i know that

[modern bobcat]

Heh

I want to continue playing rdr2

But after i got to the epilogue... I have absolutely no idea what shall i do

Of course I'll commit some massacres but... But what after that?

Great

[azure sluice]

🥀

[modern bobcat]

Thanks for keeping us safe, officer

[azure sluice]

Try doing challenges, side quests, hunting etc
I find hunting to be fun

[modern bobcat]

So, what were you saying?

[modern bobcat]

Heh, I'll start with bandit, since i want minimum honor

[azure sluice]

Also try unlocking every garment set at the trapper it’s very satisfying and rewarding

You can make some unique outfits with them

[modern bobcat]

I already have them all

[azure sluice]

Oop nice

[modern bobcat]

I did the save while cheats enabled glitch:)

I wonder why John's beard does not grow

[modern bobcat]

Oop... I liked that

[azure sluice]

Fr it feels like it grows way slower than Arthur’s 😭

[modern bobcat]

Yeah yeah

[azure sluice]

I miss playing as John

I accidentally overwrote my autosave with another one

I thought it like

[modern bobcat]

I'm doing the van horn fence glitch and still won't grow

[modern bobcat]

Heh

[azure sluice]

Only transfers the autosave function byt apparently it overwrites the entire thing

[modern bobcat]

Huh

[azure sluice]

I had 2 saves
One with 100% story completion (autosave)
Another on chapter 3 with manual saving
I wanted the chapter 3 one to be my autosave

and I overwrote the autosave one with the chapter 3 one

So the old autosave is gone

[modern bobcat]

John's beard won't grow, goddammit

[midnight ocean]

why would you not just save manually

the game gives you like 20 slots to save in

[modern bobcat]

Only 15

[midnight ocean]

only 15

[azure sluice]

Electricity was somewhy cutting off constantly at the time I kept losing progress

Sometimes I straight up forget

[midnight ocean]

thats why you make a habit out of it

[azure sluice]

Yea I probably should lol

I’ve seen some people make a new save on each chapter, should I do that?

[modern bobcat]

What? I thought electricity goes off only in iraq

[azure sluice]

😭

It was a temporary problem there was some work on electrical lines near my place

[modern bobcat]

As an iraqi i can confirm that info

[modern bobcat]

Heh

[midnight ocean]

man i love helping people out but some of you guys make me wanna smash my head against the wall lmao

[lapis panther]

I prefer manual save. I have save file at the start of every chapter

That way I can just load and play any chapter I want

[midnight ocean]

outside of forgetting or literally not knowing how to save your game i dont understand why you wouldnt just save after doing anything significant

beat a mission? save. did a challenge? save. killed a legendary? save.

its free

[lapis panther]

I always save after nearly everything I do in game

I only use auto save in Guarma

[midnight ocean]

people act like their credit card gets charged a fee every time they save the game

and you dont have to worry like "oh what if i accidentally saved before realizing my horse was dead" thats why you have fifteen slots

[lapis panther]

If my horse dies which is rare, I just load up my last save

[midnight ocean]

yeah same

[lapis panther]

I have only had a horse die on my a few times

Once where the Lemoyne Raider maxim gun ambush

[midnight ocean]

usually its because im impatiently navigating cliffy terrain

[lapis panther]

And once where I was riding fast and somehow fell off Cumberland Falls haha

[midnight ocean]

grabbing the perlino andy the other day was kinda scary because its standing right next to a cliff

[lapis panther]

Yes it can buck you both off from the cliff

I see a moose there too when getting that horse

[midnight ocean]

wish i could teleport the mooses i see to other peoples games

[lapis panther]

Didn't want to shoot it as it would scare the horse

[midnight ocean]

couldve used an improved arrow maybe

[trim hamlet]

meese*

wait no hang on that's actually-- oh god 🤣

[lapis panther]

Didn't think of that lol

I wanted the horse lol

[trim hamlet]

ignore my brief moment of forgetting how to speak my native langauge 😭

[brazen wren]

How many button presses per second is the maximum for the "pet dog" prompt?

[midnight ocean]

it should be meese tbf

[deep glacier]

Think it’s infinite, I personally haven’t seen a limit when I do it

[brazen wren]

Is it faster if I bind square to R1 and alternate my left and right pointer fingers to spam R1

[deep glacier]

Not sure as I’m Xbox and just spam X

[trim hamlet]

wait wait wait

for pc players if you bind an action to a singular scrollwheel movement, like one "tick" then it can uh... get pretty fast 😅

is there something similar for controller

[brazen wren]

I don't think so

[midnight ocean]

turbo button

[fathom mulch]

I've had the same horse since chapter 2 and only had 1 encounter where I had to use horse reviver and another time when a pelt fell off of it while I was miles away leading me to believe it had died but upon return it was alive and well

Noglette shall never die He's a good boy

[midnight ocean]

noglette huh

[fathom mulch]

yeah thats the name I've always given my horses

this is the first subject to have survived the longest

it happens to have a very small brain

[midnight ocean]

interesting

[tidal basalt]

anyone able to help on finding a 3 star black bear in story

cant find one for the life of me

[midnight ocean]

big valley

try the area just north of the trapper

also by watching the mini map you can tell when you encounter a black bear because your horse will get spooked but youll see a red dot moving away from you

[fathom mulch]

North west of annesburg is also a great place

[lapis panther]

Roanoke along side the Kamassa River is another good spot for black bears

[fathom mulch]

also north of strawberry

[tidal basalt]

just found one cheers lads

found it north of hanging dog

[fathom mulch]

nice

they always spawn north grizzlies spawn in the snow area

[lapis panther]

Black bears?

Never seen one in the snow

I see Grizzly bears up there though

[brazen wren]

Arthur can store 20 cooked big game meats and none of them rot even after years

[lapis panther]

I always wondered why coyotes in this game run from you, where as in RDR1 they can attack John

[midnight ocean]

with the lote satchel its 99

[midnight ocean]

rdr1 predators were brutal

[lapis panther]

Yes they could kill your horse

[midnight ocean]

they toned it down a lot

in one shot too

and then one of the first hunting challenges is to kill five wolves with a combat knife lmao

[lapis panther]

I read that bobcats were meant to be in this game but were cut

[lapis panther]

Ahh the memories

[midnight ocean]

whats weird is in rdr2 you have cougars and panthers which are two different animals providing two different pelts but are actually the same species irl

whereas grizzly bears and black bears are actually different species but provide the same pelt in game

[lapis panther]

Yes

I lost track of the amount of times a boar used to gore me or my horse in RDR1 haha

Where as in this game, I've been gored once

[midnight ocean]

boars attack you in 2?

[lapis panther]

Yes

It is rare though. Usually they run

[midnight ocean]

crazy

maybe it did happen once and i forgot

ive definitely been nailed by a buck and a ram

[lapis panther]

Me too. Buck knocked me off a cliff once haha

Also that goat in Butcher's Creek hates me

[midnight ocean]

stuff like that is why i stay on my horse when hunting lol

but also the cougars

mainly the cougars

[dark ferry]

it’s always elks for me

[lapis panther]

Me too. It's safe in this game

In RDR1, forget it haha

[lapis panther]

Can bison do the same?

[dark ferry]

i haven’t been around bison long enough

they always book it immediately

[lapis panther]

I know small animals like Muskrats, Raccoons, Badgers can bite you

[dark ferry]

oh yeah i’ve had that happen with a muskrat

[midnight ocean]

thats wild

[dark ferry]

the animation (at least for arthur) is the same as him getting bit by a snake

[lapis panther]

Never been bit by a snake

[dark ferry]

idk about the muskrat it’s a bit too small to tell

[dark ferry]

i always get bit trying to hunt them

[midnight ocean]

usually snakes run slither away

[lapis panther]

Too bad they didn't bite the legendary camp rat lol

[midnight ocean]

have you guys ever seen that funny ass video where the guy spawned a panther during the build a little house cutscene

we need that but with american venom and a grizzly bear

[lapis panther]

No but I seen videos where people spawn a cougar in camp

[night oasis]

Guys want to protest red dead 2 remaster and demand red dead 1 first with me?

[midnight ocean]

you gotta look it up its so funny

[midnight ocean]

not really

[lapis panther]

No. I want an RDR2 upgrade more than a RDR remaster

[night oasis]

Awe 😭

[night oasis]

Upgrade?!?!? I got bad news for you mochocho

[dark ferry]

they won’t be remastering rdr1 for a long time

[night oasis]

They’re gonna resell it to us, it’s rockstar after all. And make us start a new gamesave

[midnight ocean]

it just makes way more sense for them to remaster rdr2

[dark ferry]

and i don’t really want them to do seeing as what they did with the gta games

[lapis panther]

Of course they are. Hardly giving to us for free are they?

[night oasis]

Business wise yes, they have low honor

[midnight ocean]

which is to say about the same amount as everyone else lol

[night oasis]

Ok well I’m going to go to the next protest with either a red dead 1 remaster sign or a give us red dead 2 60fps upgrade for free sign

[lapis panther]

77 million copies this game has sold. Imagine how many more they'd sell with an upgraded version

[dark ferry]

i don’t think it’d be that much would it?

how many people really care about the fps in a story game

and a few upgrades in terms of the graphics

[lapis panther]

I don't know. I am sure people have brought all versions of GTAV

[midnight ocean]

in my dreams we get a 60fps rdr2 with cut content restored and a trailer for undead nightmare 2

[lapis panther]

Or RDO horses

[dark ferry]

see

that would maybe make me wanna buy it

[lapis panther]

Same

[dark ferry]

if they added all the customization options from rdo into story mode

[lapis panther]

I'd buy it anyway, but that would make me buy it on release haha

[dark ferry]

including clothes guns etc

[midnight ocean]

i just wanna spin my revolver

[dark ferry]

imagine that’s the only feature they add

[night oasis]

Oh and we need a gta4 remake with the same car physics

[dark ferry]

ok i think i’m gonna just stop torturing myself trying to get all the dinosaur bones as Arthur

[lapis panther]

Now that is a game I miss.

[midnight ocean]

lol

[midnight ocean]

now you're speaking my language

[lapis panther]

My 360 conked out a few years back. So I have no platform to play GTAIV

I am stuck with GTAV trash lol

[lapis panther]

Yes you cannot get all of them until the epilogue

[dark ferry]

you technically can

but it’s torturous

and not worth it

[lapis panther]

How?

[dark ferry]

there’s a video on red dead media

it’s pretty recent uploaded by me

[lapis panther]

I'll check it out

[midnight ocean]

i play it on my series x lol

despite the frame rate issues

[night oasis]

Yeah same, I need to buy a new one, it’s only like $100. Can just pop on the hd from the old one. Only problem I think is finding a controller, mines messed up I think

[midnight ocean]

aight time to finish this compendium

[tawdry spear]

[midnight ocean]

yuh huh

[midnight ocean]

genuinely found myself in need of the "request ride" feature for the first time

actually i should have just stolen and looted the wagon

but this was nice

[amber island]

guys after i finished red dead i started coughing

am i cooked?

[nova breach]

do you lose honor when you keep killing in blackwater when it still hve the bounty

been wanting to shoot up people now

[tawdry spear]

nah, eventually you gain honour

[trim hamlet]

uh

so technically

panthers aren't actually their own species

they can either be jaguars or leopards

but with a like genetic thing that makes their fur black i think

[midnight ocean]

i imagine you would yeah

[midnight ocean]

isnt that what i said

but also you're wrong i think

ok i guess a panther can be a cougar or a jaguar

[trim hamlet]

From wikipedia:

A black panther is the melanistic colour variant of the leopard (Panthera pardus) and the jaguar (Panthera onca). Black panthers of both species have excess black pigments, but their typical rosettes are also present. They have been documented mostly in tropical forests, with black leopards in Africa and Asia, and black jaguars in Central and South America. Melanism is caused by a recessive allele in the leopard, and by a dominant allele in the jaguar.

(this server doesn't like links apparently)

[midnight ocean]

and cougars

its also weird that theres a panther and a florida panther

[trim hamlet]

same article:

There is no authenticated case of a truly melanistic cougar. No specimen has been photographed or killed in the wild, nor has it ever been bred in captivity. Unconfirmed sightings known as the "North American black panther" are currently attributed to errors in species identification by non-experts, and by the mimetic exaggeration of size.

[midnight ocean]

alright but the panthers in rdr2 are just cougars

[trim hamlet]

true cause they have the cougar rosettes if the light hits them right

[trim hamlet]

yes. this. just...

add the RDO horses.

If they do that, then shut up and take my money!

[midnight ocean]

ok fuck having a bounty man

its just so annoying

im so tired of this lmao

its just completely random if the cops in town will be looking out for you or not

[lapis panther]

How much is the bounty?

[midnight ocean]

290

[lapis panther]

How much money do you have?

[midnight ocean]

37k

[lapis panther]

Pay it off lol

[midnight ocean]

i thought it would be fun to have a bounty everywhere

[lapis panther]

Okay

[midnight ocean]

but now i got so many i dont want to pay them

im gonna finish the compendium and then make a new save where theyre paid off

i did that achievement to get a big bounty in all states and i was like

it would be cool to just keep playing with all these bounties on me

its just the way the towns work is so weird

[lapis panther]

Haha it is more fun

[midnight ocean]

like before i was able to get the bounty poster in tumbleweed just fine but now the sheriff is on the lookout for me all of a sudden

[lapis panther]

I was in Colter once waking up and heard horses outside haha, Bounty hunters tracked me there, Was creepy as hell

[midnight ocean]

yeah everyone says to hide up there for the three days to get the achievement but idk why really

i dont think it lowers the spawn rate or anything

[lapis panther]

It doesn't

They track you

[midnight ocean]

also if you have a bounty that you dont plan on paying it frees you to rob a train and keep all the profits

[lapis panther]

Yes that's one reason I do not like the Rhodes bank robbery

I usually end up with a bounty more than I made in that mission haha

Fun mission

[midnight ocean]

yeah i remember the take being pretty bad from that one

[lapis panther]

Take is bad and bounty is huge, so what is the point?

[midnight ocean]

kickin it with charles

and uncle

[lapis panther]

That's all good but I like profit haha

[midnight ocean]

doesnt count as a gold towards gold rush either

[lapis panther]

Doing the gold in missions frustrated me a lot

[midnight ocean]

yeah same

the secret if you actually just want the achievement i think is to just skip the hard ones and only go back once youve finished the entire epilogue

because the epilogue has so many easy golds

[lapis panther]

Yes it does

[midnight ocean]

i was stupid and ocd about it and forced myself to do every gold i could in order

[lapis panther]

I remember that mission with Hosea where you rob the house

Loot everything in the home

[midnight ocean]

yeah that was annoying

i missed one cabinet in the bottom floor bedroom

and the timing to get back is so tight

[lapis panther]

Because there is time limit to how long Hosea keeps them distracted

[midnight ocean]

oh i just do the night time way

it lets you do a cool animation on the guy upstairs too

theyre asleep so you can take all the time you want

[lapis panther]

Even the second mission you got to be dead accurate and fast with the wolves charging you

[midnight ocean]

chapter 1 is surprisingly annoying

partially because your dead eye sucks

[lapis panther]

Yes

[midnight ocean]

and the train mission requires not getting hit a single time

[lapis panther]

Who the Hell is Leviticus Cornwall

Pain in the butt

The New South in Chapter 3, that fight in the train carriage is tough as you cannot damage and he has a knife

[midnight ocean]

yeah

not only that but you have the super long fishing section at the end

[lapis panther]

I didn't mind that

I'd say the toughest mission was getting John out of jail

Not for gold but because how super accurate those guards are

[midnight ocean]

itd be nice if it actually told you if you made the objective or not so you didnt have to spend the whole time worrying you messed up lol

[lapis panther]

Yes

[midnight ocean]

idk i just abuse gold cores and spam deadeye

makes all combat a breeze

[lapis panther]

It does

[nova breach]

i didn't know you lose honour when killing a braithwaite

[nova breach]

fuck

i lost my jimboy gun

also its weird

[nova breach]

i remember i killed the two murpher broods who warn you when you set up canp but now they showed up again saying "we warned you not to comeback'

[midnight ocean]

just because you dont like em doesnt mean its ok to kill em

[lapis panther]

You lose honour in that random encounter when you see the Braithwaite running from the Gray house and the Gray guards are shooting at him. If you kill him yourself, you lose honour.

[nova breach]

finna reload a 10hr save

[stark sparrow]

bro my game crashed on the final ride back to beaver hollow

I have to do that mission again

[midnight ocean]

f

[shy hull]

F

[stark sparrow]

it put me at the second half of it thankfully

[gaunt relic]

[midnight ocean]

wait what? how?

[stark sparrow]

idk it put me at the red dead redemption mission right after you rob the train

I crashed right when I got to camp

[frank cedar]

Kieran deserved a happy ending

[midnight ocean]

ohhh

yeah so thats the start of the mission

the penultimate mission leads directly into red dead redemption

[nova breach]

whats the fastest way to regain Honor

im grinding the bandit challenge

[dark ferry]

saint denis greeting people

you could do fishing but that gets very boring

[dusty helm]

If i use money cheat code and buy a revolver, will the gun stay or be gone after rejoining the game?

[distant nova]

If you use the Game cheat codes when you rejoin it will disappear, unless you use mods.

[dusty helm]

So the gun also disappears?, mod mean rampage ?

[azure sluice]

Pretty sure the game doesn’t save when you use cheats

[dusty helm]

Okay

[distant nova]

what part of the game are you in

or what chapter

There is a bug in Angelo Bronte's mission in Chapter 4 where you can use cheats and save

[dusty helm]

2nd chapter

[dusty helm]

Oh alr

[nova breach]

guys the ending of this game is honor based right? and not narrative decision? meaning like i can kill allotta people but just grind honor and the ending is in tandem to what honor you have?

cause right now ive been killing folks left and right for bandit challenge

[deep glacier]

It’s based on both. You make a decision at the end and then the outcome of that decision is based on honor. So it’s overall based on both

[torn mantle]

same bro, I'm doing the bandit just for a fit

[deep glacier]

Grinding honor at the end isn’t to hard tho, just spam greet people in Saint Denis

[torn mantle]

Arthur's greetings are burned into my skull

[austere narwhal]

lennyyyyyyy

[deep glacier]

Hey mister, ma’am, good morning partner🗣️🗣️

[torn mantle]

lenny where are ya😭

[austere narwhal]

Ahhhh found you lennyy

[torn mantle]

MISTER👹

[torn mantle]

I laughed so hard when the chick had Lenny's face

[austere narwhal]

i just had fun the whole mission

[torn mantle]

piano going crazy in the background too

[austere narwhal]

but a absolute cinema mission was the chapter 3 mission where they go to the caliga hall

or was it

[torn mantle]

dunno, just got to chp3 a min ago

[austere narwhal]

You a new player?

[torn mantle]

pretty much

I only played chp1 around a year or 2 ago and never continued for some reason, wanna finish it now

was hooked on cod ig

[austere narwhal]

same happened to me lol

wanna be friends?

[torn mantle]

[deep glacier]

That part had me crying laughing

[fossil trench]

Guys

when i get my PC the first game i would get is rdr2

[oblique quiver]

Lnney
ynneL

[nova breach]

will the train robbies still apply if i obly robbed one cart?

then dipped?

[stark sparrow]

there’s some really funny ones when you antagonize them

not the things he says but the line delivery is very funny

[oblique quiver]

Do greet greet antagonize

it’s so funny

“Hello mister. Your face looks familiar. Reminds me of the last time I lifted my horse’s tail.”

[torn mantle]

"you remind me of someone who got out an asylum"

peak

[stark sparrow]

John says some funny stuff too

[oblique quiver]

“Hey mister. Good to see manners ain’t dead yet. But you will be if you look at me like that again.”

“Hey mister. I like you mister, you have a kind face. The kind I like to punch!”

so peak

[deep glacier]

Nothing will be as iconic as Arthur’s “alright catch ya later then” after a serious convo

[oblique quiver]

“What’re we gonna do Arthur?”
“Just.. hang in there.”
“Alright Arthur.”
“Okay, catch you later then! ;D”

[deep glacier]

Cracks me up every time

[brazen wren]

I lost 4 perfect pelts because Pearson wasn't available for some reason so I slept to see if he'll come back and then it forced me into a mission I walked near

[oblique quiver]

tragic

[oblique quiver]

Greet greet antagonize is the best

“You seen any bounty hunters ‘round here?”
“No, sir.”
“Thanks for nothin’ idiot.”

[deep glacier]

I’ve seen the one where he goes “the kind I like to punch” before, that one’s comical

[oblique quiver]

One of my favorites is
“Hey mister! That is a fine horse you got there. How long you been married?”

[deep glacier]

HA

Next play through I’m doin greet greet antagonize more

[torn mantle]

doing that to the whole of saint denis

[oblique quiver]

“Hey mister! You remind me of a feller I used to know. Same annoying face of lazy eye.”

“Hey folks! Nice folk ‘round here. ‘Part from you two idiots, that is.”

[nova breach]

do i really need to learn poker and other gambler games to play it?

like learn the actual game

[midnight ocean]

yes but theyre easy

poker is just about knowing how different hands rank

you can look up a list

a pair beats a high card, two pair beats a pair, three of a kind beats two pair, etc

dominoes is kinda annoying but all you're doing is laying down a domino that has the same pips on one side as one of the ends on the table does

[nova breach]

only game i know how to play is BJ

[midnight ocean]

poker is about betting larger amounts of money when you think your hand is good and folding when its bad so sometimes you can trick the npcs buy betting all your money at the start. theyll think you have a really good hand and fold giving you a free win

[meager valve]

In general cards with extremely polarizing magnitudes and different suits in every way are bad hands

Like 9 of spades with 4 of diamond

[midnight ocean]

but there could be a 5 6 7 and 8 😳

well the 4 wouldnt even matter actually lol

i think the worst hand you can get is a 2 and a 7

followed by a 3 and a 7

[meager valve]

That's true

2 and a 7 are the worsy

[midnight ocean]

i like blackjack better

[meager valve]

I like both

Black jack is pretty fun ngl

I don't like dominos

[midnight ocean]

yeah fuck dominoes lol

[nova breach]

poker was fun

even though i barely know hands

[brazen wren]

Nevermind, I went to an island and back and my horsey and pelts are all fine #red-dead-media

[hidden moss]

Do you guys prefer midnights or grangers gun?

I prefer granger

[nova breach]

is the other npc in vanhorn blackjack scripted to keep winnign

he keeps winning every round

dafuq

[modern bobcat]

I hate chapter 1

Also epilogue 1

And half of epilogue 2

[nova breach]

omg

i just massacred butcher town

lmao

no wonder i keep losing honor

they suddenly attaqcked me aftrer i killed the murfree brood in my camp

[modern bobcat]

Shall i massacre every town in the game ?

[strange lily]

me hating on gambler challange 8

but got 1 out of 3

[hidden moss]

People would despise you 😭

[deep glacier]

I mean that’s one way to get a high bounty for the bounty achievement

[nova breach]

wtf is rank 9 and 10 of gambler

[honest latch]

just do micah missions

i swear

i got like a $500 bounty every time

@modern bobcat

anyone know how to get cool horse

[wraith saffron]

What's the best food for health, stamina and dead eye, Which we can buy at general store?

[wraith saffron]

You can find one at Lake isabella

Near mount hagen

[fathom mulch]

bro did u not read the part where i said grizzlies spawn up there

but in fact there are some near the lake where u find high stakes map 3

[wraith saffron]

@fathom mulch can you help me with this?

[fathom mulch]

none u must hunt animals and it will replenish all stats

[honest latch]

miracle tonic?

[wraith saffron]

So any animal can replenish all stats?

Aight bet ty

[fathom mulch]

also certain ingredients have a golden affect like oregano, thyme and mint

oregano does dead eye, thyme does stamina and mint does health

[wraith saffron]

Where can I get all three of those?

[fathom mulch]

i literally only eat what i hunt the other food it just for when i run out

[fathom mulch]

from plants around the world

[honest latch]

make sure u eat bullrush reed.

it best food source

right?

[wraith saffron]

I'm just eating canned food atm from the store

[fathom mulch]

make sure u eat Oleander Sage

[honest latch]

:0

[fathom mulch]

thats horse feed

[honest latch]

no

[fathom mulch]

canned goods are ass the best food is big game meat and venison

[honest latch]

it arthur feed

[fathom mulch]

oleander sage cures the black lung

[honest latch]

that the pink one right?

[fathom mulch]

yeah

[honest latch]

mmmm

the npc's love it

inserts knife see

how do u find out the seasoned game meat?

cuz i swear

i ate a big game meat

and then arthur was like "hmm wut if i put thyme on it."

[fathom mulch]

u scroll left and right on the meat to see the different ones

[honest latch]

then i got it

[honest latch]

wudda bout for playstation?

[fathom mulch]

same thing#

it might be D-PAD

[honest latch]

aah

wut if i put orelander sage on it

[fathom mulch]

Can only cook on camp fires in the wild tho

u camt

the game specifically only lets u eat it straight off the bush

[hidden moss]

Is it normal that im spending a bit while going through story? horse stuff, guns etc

[honest latch]

YAY

[fathom mulch]

yes ive spent like 20k on customization of guns, legendary outfits, horse apparel

and i still have 9k

[hidden moss]

Holy

[honest latch]

:0

[fathom mulch]

go on the treasure hunts and sell the gold bars to a fence u can get like 14k from it

some are worth 500 others 750

its not much of a hard grind since u can look up map spawns

[honest latch]

who is nazar

[fathom mulch]

but i tend to not use guides i like exploring and believe it or not many random cabins in the middle of nowhere hold treasure, maps, notes and much more

just try to enter every building

but be careful and save ur game a bunch while in treasure locations they can be quite deadly on an indiana jones level

[honest latch]

wut happens to hosea?

[fathom mulch]

also there are caves hidden on the map that have puzzles in them just keep ur eyes open

[fathom mulch]

nothing happens to him

[honest latch]

oh oki

[fathom mulch]

he dies of old age in 1907

[honest latch]

he no die?

oh

lenny?

[fathom mulch]

marston holds a funeral for him#

[meager valve]

Hunted the rare white bison and legendary buck today

[honest latch]

:0 noice

[fathom mulch]

nice i got the legendary elk 2 days ago but it doesnt spawn until chapter 5

[meager valve]

The coat is real nice

[fathom mulch]

the white bison outfit is goated

i usually pair the hood with the legendary ram cloak

[honest latch]

T-T i only got wolf, moose

[fathom mulch]

the white fox is the hardest to get good luck

make sure to use a repeater on them for clean kill

[honest latch]

is it any good?

[fathom mulch]

they alll have cool stuff im going for all of them

[meager valve]

#red-dead-fashion for my current winter look

[fathom mulch]

so i can mix and match

[wraith saffron]

i want to tame the white horse at lake isabella, and I went there with just canned food, i ran out of all food in like 10mins so i had to rush out of the snowy area. Now im going back while ill hunt some animals in the way and camp near the snow area

[honest latch]

nice

[meager valve]

Does the guy in valentine with the raccoon hat respawnn if I kill him

[fathom mulch]

hunt a bear and cook that bihh

[meager valve]

I knocked the bastard and killed him and threw his body off a cliff

He was getting annoying

[fathom mulch]

use ur fists he always comes back use a gun hes lost forever

[honest latch]

. what

oh ye

[meager valve]

Good

I have his raccoon hat

So idc

[honest latch]

wut happens to jimmy brooks

[meager valve]

He was a racist scumbag anyways

[fathom mulch]

atleast u got his hat

i quite like him

[meager valve]

I have this theory he is a manifestation of the strange man testing arthur

Cuz he never returns

[fathom mulch]

only coz i get to beat him up everytime i go to valentine

[honest latch]

w-well

u-h

[meager valve]

And something cool happens when you visit THAT shack

If you leave him alive

[fathom mulch]

i lose at poker? i walk up to him and give him a beat down then buy a shot of whiskey

[honest latch]

u know wut. that aint a bad theory

but, get this. wut if strange man is gavin

[meager valve]

I think my gf had the best theory- he is Karma

[fathom mulch]

gavin is clearly a split personality that dude lost

[meager valve]

The strange man is karma

[meager valve]

Yes I think so as well

[honest latch]

im sorry

but um

can u explain that

but like

in the dumbest way possible

so i understand

[fathom mulch]

the strange man is death warning the player the inevitable hence why he only shows up to john after many events trying to change his fate and only showing up when arthur is coughing his guts up

[meager valve]

His connection to Jimmy Brooks makes me think he is karma

[fathom mulch]

he sits waiting and sometimes conversating with the character to change there ways when they never will

[honest latch]

u know what

[fathom mulch]

hence john trying to shoot him and missing

[honest latch]

that actually makes sence

[meager valve]

Well if he's an ethereal being

[honest latch]

so does he have a connection to gavin?

[fathom mulch]

hes like the death in the movie meet joe black

if u ever watched it

[oblique robin]

i feel hes cain from the bible or the grim reaper

[fathom mulch]

he takes human form and pleads with the rich ceo to change his ways

[fathom mulch]

how is the grim reaper?

[meager valve]

That's a good one, cain at least

[honest latch]

who cain?

[fathom mulch]

and if u cant answer its fine it was retorical he is death

[meager valve]

Grim reaper is a very specific being I feel

[oblique robin]

he's not malicious but wherever he went death followed like tumbleweed

[fathom mulch]

the grim reaper and death are the same being

[meager valve]

Cain he could be tbh
Especially what dutch says about the dog cain

[honest latch]

someone who did smth real bad

[meager valve]

Never stopped wandering and did something awful

[fathom mulch]

death isnt malicious hes carrying out his duty to guide the lost

[oblique robin]

yeah thats what i felt too i like that r* keeps a bit of mystery around it

[honest latch]

what happens to Cain?

[meager valve]

Yeah

[honest latch]

i like the dog

[meager valve]

Unrelated but I saw this video called RDR2 characters deadeye

And Micah had the scariest ones

[honest latch]

how so

[meager valve]

It's like innocents screaming and wailing

And the screen goes red

[oblique robin]

"Cain is a biblical figure in Genesis who, as a farmer, killed his brother Abel, a shepherd, out of jealousy when God favored Abel's sacrifice over his own. As punishment, God cursed Cain, banishing him to be a restless wanderer and giving him a mark for protection, after which he went to the land of Nod and had descendants. "

[fathom mulch]

if rdr3 ever comes out i wanna play as micah or even see how he joins the gang

[oblique robin]

micah has no honor so it makes sense

[honest latch]

ooooooh.

[oblique robin]

unpopular opinion as much as i want to be with the gang the story of van der lindes is pretty well told

[fathom mulch]

i dont like micah due to his role in rdr2 but i feel he might have some reasons behind it and it would be cool to find out where he starting going wrong

[meager valve]

Yeah

I'd honestly never want to touch the rdr story tbh

[oblique robin]

also it kinda reminds me of that one family guy meme

[honest latch]

nah. he just a rat

[nova breach]

just wiped out van horn

[fathom mulch]

but we dont know why

[honest latch]

ye we do

it called

[meager valve]

Some people are just evil

[honest latch]

ahem ahem

[meager valve]

No reason behind it

[honest latch]

asshole

[oblique robin]

why cant i share links

[nova breach]

them peeps insulted me then when they got insulted back they draw guns

[fathom mulch]

yh but was he threatened was he offered a reward

i honestly think trelawny was the rat

[meager valve]

Maybe he was just an asshole as @honest latch said
Maybe it was greed

Who knows, me personally, I don't wanna know

[honest latch]

no. just his dad and granddad did smth

pretty sure robbery gone wrong

[oblique robin]

main reason why micah doesnt deserve a game

[meager valve]

I don't wanna even play as Micah or Dutch tbh

[oblique robin]

yeah i cant share videos

[oblique robin]

micah is just a bad person

[fathom mulch]

yh id rather play as hosea

[honest latch]

anyone else wanna play as Hosea?

[meager valve]

I actually think rdr3 with hosea and like 20 years ago would be cool

Much more light hearted, classic spaghetti western, you get to lie, cheat, steal

[fathom mulch]

hosea would be cool and dutch being a kid would be funny

[honest latch]

wut about sadie

or uncle

[meager valve]

And the game ends with hosea and bessie parting ways and Isaac dying

[oblique robin]

we kinda know how it ends

1. we can play as isaac: we dont really see him die sooo
2. we can play as the callander brothers: most accurate we dont know if they actually die

[fathom mulch]

uncle has a game already its called red dead revolver

[meager valve]

The game would take place further in the west

[fathom mulch]

yes it would be a good game

[honest latch]

REALLY? revolver about uncle?!

[oblique robin]

another one where he gets diagnosed with lumbago in the end
may i standard chicken (rip d'angelo)

[meager valve]

Yeah

You could charm people and rob them

Take young arthur hunting

I'd name it something like Red Dead tales: Outlaw Hosea Mathews

Not redemption

A smaller game

[fathom mulch]

bro wasnt diagnosed he was lumbago

[oblique robin]

as much as i love hosea i dont see him being an effective main character theres too much explored about him

[austere narwhal]

hello

[fathom mulch]

sounds more like an expansion to rdr2

[meager valve]

Again, in my opinion if that happens it won't be as deep or as dark as the other 2

[meager valve]

Exactly

[fathom mulch]

that wouldnt wash well with r*

[meager valve]

Fair

[oblique robin]

not a redemption game but a spin off of jack wouldnt be too bad going through ww and the rise of mafia

[meager valve]

Honestly r* should move away from rdr games and the 3 cities of gta

[fathom mulch]

they havent done expansions since GTA 4 and RDR1

[austere narwhal]

what u guys talkin bout?

[meager valve]

I think a great gta game would be a reboot of London

[fathom mulch]

I think it wouldnt be that good since it wouldnt be a cowboy game anymore

[meager valve]

You get london, berlin, dublin, edinburgh, and bruges as cities to explore and it's a gta game
Would be hella cool

[oblique robin]

but the whole appeal is the wild west thing

[meager valve]

It'd still be a western though

[meager valve]

I said gta already

It's not an rdr game I'm saying

[oblique robin]

oh mb i mean i guess it can work tbf i am not too keen on british centric media

[meager valve]

Like no country for old men and One battle after another

[fathom mulch]

it wouldnt WW1 didnt even have americans fighting it until 1917

[oblique robin]

one battle after another was fantastic

[fathom mulch]

the last 2 years of the war

[meager valve]

British crime drama gta would be goated. You should watch Guy Ritchie movies

[meager valve]

Sorta

It was contradictory

[oblique robin]

i would definitely like something about callander brothers; think of sinners where you can switch between stack and smoke

and one of them sorta survives the game

[meager valve]

Oh yeah sinners is also a western with horror

[meager valve]

I think expansions on hosea and callander brothers would be cool

[oblique robin]

and both of them have distinct personalities and varying level of loyalty to dutch

[fathom mulch]

GTA in essex would be good but id rather it be set in the 90s so we can play as the essex boys a notorious crime organisation that controlled the nightclub scene sold drugs and killed people then they all die mysteriously at the end exactly like the real life essex boys

[meager valve]

I'd love like the cities I said- London, Berlin, Bruges, Edinburgh, and Dublin. You also deal with the Ndrangheta

[oblique robin]

kinda sells on charles line "vicious pair of bastards

[meager valve]

Arthur would've been a skilled draftsman or a botanist

Or something in biology

Had he not been an outlaw

[fathom mulch]

if u want a reference watch rise of the footsoldier its a goated british movie about the essex boys obviously some things dramatised and other things based on real events

[oblique robin]

if we're going global

id want something that deals with settlement of australia and aboriginal people
thugs (yes the word thug actually comes from this) in india during british colonial era

[oblique robin]

i can see him as a sketch artist

[fathom mulch]

gta tokyo

[meager valve]

Well we have that lol

[fathom mulch]

it was a cancelled gta game btw

[meager valve]

Yakuza games are pretty fun as is

[fathom mulch]

it was meant to release after SA

[oblique robin]

also both of these as red dead spin offs i dont feel any non american city can carry the GTA vibe

[meager valve]

SA was the last gta game I liked

[fathom mulch]

true crime was the best gta clone

[meager valve]

It should be with a new name

Under a new banner

[oblique robin]

no reed do not abbreviate San andreas

[meager valve]

😭

[oblique robin]

i mean not in the redemption series

[meager valve]

Yeah

I didn't like 4 and 5 of gta tbh

[fathom mulch]

4 is my favourite gta

most realistic physics

[meager valve]

Mine is vice city and san andreas

[fathom mulch]

cars not so much but the lerning curve proved if u was skilled or not

i can drive really good in it

[meager valve]

I loved the story of 4 but the world was bland and grey to me

I really didn't wanna be in that world at all

The ludonarrative dissonance was insane

[fathom mulch]

it was supposed to be its gritty and depressing not colourful and glamorous

[meager valve]

You could get a really meaningful story mission and then kil 200 cops with no consequence

[meager valve]

Sure, rdr is also gritty, plenty of games are gritty

I didn't find it fun

[fathom mulch]

i personally loved the lost and damned DLC for gta 4

[oblique robin]

i started gaming literally this year and rdr2 was like one of the first games i played because its my best friends fav game and he hyped it up and it exceeded the hype

[meager valve]

And then they leaned so far away from 4

In 5

4 has the 3nd best story rockstar ever told

Gta 5 was ass man

It was hype moments and aura the game

Everything is satire and nonsensical

[fathom mulch]

i just wish 5 had the cool ragdoll physics and getting in a street fight which was life or death

[meager valve]

Remember in san andreas

You could learn martial arts

[fathom mulch]

san andreas had the best fighting stances

[meager valve]

I think the only time I felt like a crime boss was vice city

[fathom mulch]

once u learn kung foo the other gym isnt worth it when u get to vegas

[meager valve]

You could buy fronts and get payments from them

[oblique robin]

its literally the first game i ever played so take it with a liberal amount of salt but i felt its the kfc of games it does everything great but not outstanding and its a great intro to gaming

[meager valve]

Modern rockstar mechanics come from Bully bye

[fathom mulch]

what i loved about SA was playing virtual poker for 30mins and walking out with 600mil

[oblique robin]

also really funny

[meager valve]

Yeah I agree
But once you play other titles it sucks so bad

The theme of that game is so meaningless

In rdr every choice and consequence matters

In gta 5 the best ending is killing high profile people and an entire federal bureau and living happily ever after

[oblique robin]

yeah tbf gta5 is a pretty nihilist game whereas rdr2 does have a moral sense of right vs wrong

[meager valve]

Not all of them though

[oblique robin]

sorry i meant 5

[meager valve]

Morality aside, other than Niko and CJ none of the characters are interesting in Hta

*gta

They feel like caricatures

Gta5 is way to satirical for anything to mean anything

[fathom mulch]

gta 4 was good coz it gave u a choice to kill people

vlad must always die

[meager valve]

Niko is the best gta character period

[meager valve]

Yes

[oblique robin]

trevor and lamar are pretty funny bro i love them

[meager valve]

I hate what the game does with trevor

[fathom mulch]

trevor is legendary

hes almost as cool as niko

[oblique robin]

he's just an angry canadian

[nova breach]

what do i do to reset fff on vanhorn