#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages Ā· Page 243 of 1

gaunt sky
#

who john?

short ocean
#

He was kinda brutal

blissful crane
#

kinda bummed that they cancelled the combat voicelines for rdr2

gaunt sky
#

oh i didnt know abt that but ok

blissful crane
#

it added alot of atmosphere to shootouts in rdr1

short ocean
#

Like he killed more than in rdr2 if you get to play as him

blissful crane
#

i mean, arthur's were fully voiced and ready to use but were never added

short ocean
#

Oh Arthur my fav line

#

Makes me want to punch her

gaunt sky
#

lol

blissful crane
#

also arthur casually sinking a warship

#

that's gotta be a few hundred to a thousand people dead, right?

short ocean
#

Atleast Arthur can swim

gaunt sky
#

he is built diff

blissful crane
#

arthurs kill count is fucking insane

gaunt sky
#

but his body count is not

short ocean
#

Better than John atleast

#

I hate that Dutch was a fool

blissful crane
#

arthur was without a doubt, the deadliest gunslinger in that old west era of the red dead universe even though technically it was already ending at that point

gaunt sky
#

what is yalls fav chance encounter like the ppl you come across the road asking for help or smt like that

short ocean
#

My fav encounter is when you see odriscolls

blissful crane
# short ocean I hate that Dutch was a fool

his increasing desperation to escape the law and his actions throughout the game slowly drove him insane, with the trolley incident and hosea's death practically boosting him there

#

also micah keeps stroking his ego

short ocean
#

So I can shoot them with a pump shotgun

gaunt sky
#

i do that in van horn with every civilian

#

low honour epilouge šŸ’€

blissful crane
short ocean
blissful crane
#

that's what you get for trying to steal my horsie

gaunt sky
#

could you whistle for ur horse after it gets stolen

gaunt sky
#

oh good to know

blissful crane
#

it bucks them off then runs to you

gaunt sky
#

lol

azure sluice
#

Likely got married and started a family in Canada

short ocean
#

Nah shoot them WITH A PUMP SHOTGUN

azure sluice
blissful crane
gaunt sky
#

i like hogtying ppl and doing unimaginable things to them first of all pump shotgun to their limbs and head so its only the torso left and then i keep stabbing w a knife or axe

short ocean
#

Pump=the best gun in rdr2 no argument

blissful crane
#

so he was probably fine

gaunt sky
#

and throw them in the river afterwards

azure sluice
#

It is weird how you can shoot Micah like 12 times in the head but doesn’t die until the dead eye ends or you need to reload 😭

short ocean
azure sluice
#

like he still holds his guns up until dead eye runs out

gaunt sky
blissful crane
#

the only correct way to kill micah

gaunt sky
short ocean
azure sluice
short ocean
#

With the pump

azure sluice
#

then they run

#

and I steal their celery

gaunt sky
short ocean
#

Fuck double barrel

gaunt sky
#

f sawn off

short ocean
#

Pump is the best

short ocean
azure sluice
#

Sawed off>>

gaunt sky
#

as soon as they stand you pin them to the ground again

azure sluice
gaunt sky
#

probably

short ocean
azure sluice
#

I just make them run away

gaunt sky
#

npc torture

short ocean
gaunt sky
#

doesn't that make them witnesses

azure sluice
#

it’s weird how you can kill Mickey in valentine

azure sluice
#

wait no

gaunt sky
#

drowning is pretty fun but a bit hard to pull of without wanted lvl or bounty

azure sluice
#

only if you attack them while they’re running away iirc

gaunt sky
#

ohh ok

gaunt sky
#

wdym

short ocean
#

Where the legendary wolf is

azure sluice
#

no bounty

#

If you get away quick enough

gaunt sky
#

i still get bounty even with a mask

short ocean
#

Same

azure sluice
#

yea u gotta be quick

#

can’t linger around law too long without them finding out who you are

gaunt sky
#

oh ok ig

#

didnt work for me yet

azure sluice
#

Masks are meant to cover your identity for a short period of time

gaunt sky
#

now it makes some sense

#

btw am i the only one who loves emerald ranch

#

its top 3 towns for me

azure sluice
#

It’s kinda boring there

gaunt sky
#

you can do so many quests there

#

it helps you out a lot

azure sluice
#

Challenges u mean?

gaunt sky
#

i did like 50 quests in or around emerald ranch

#

oh yea

#

challanges

azure sluice
#

Ah

#

Yea I’ll check that out sometime

gaunt sky
#

its got everything you need

azure sluice
#

Valentine is fun I just bump into ppl until they start a fight 😭

gaunt sky
#

my top towns are:

azure sluice
#

Yk west of annesburg is rly cool as well

#

cougars are annoying but overall it’s fun

gaunt sky
#

1.valentine 2.emerald ranch 3.Saint denis 4.Van horn 5.strawberry

#

what do yall think

fast talon
#

About time I said Hi. Believe it or not I've only just bought the game! Eeeekk ... I know, why oh why didn't I get it sooner.. Asking myself this since installing it šŸ˜…

gaunt sky
#

i have a few tips for you

#

avoid spoilers and dont skip cutscenes

#

EVER!

#

i did that and i feel very bad now

fast talon
#

I get that... Was wondering how I get a horse brush.. AH! Do the hunting story bit 1st dimwit šŸ˜…

gaunt sky
#

skipped almost every cutscene in the game and i barely understood the story

#

the story is the whole point of the game bcs its beautiful

#

also make 1-3 saves in every chapter and dont delete them

fast talon
#

It's quite stunning. Even today's UE5 games aren't the same visually

gaunt sky
#

ik right

#

dont worry about horses or money yet just live the story to the fullest before everything goes to shit

#

and try not to look for tutorials yet

fast talon
#

Will do, thanks šŸ˜€

gaunt sky
#

a good horse but im not sure you can get it yet is under lake isabella

#

my main horse even in the epilouge

#

beautiful and fast but very scaredey and skittish

#

do u need any tips

#

ill try to help u

azure sluice
#

However I suggest avoiding this server a bit lol since spoilers are common

#

and yes never ever skip cutscenes

#

RDR1 needs a remaster bro

midnight ocean
cyan pendant
#

1 Rhodes
2 valintine
3 blackwater
4 strawberry
5 annesburg
6 van horn
7 Saint Denis

#

I still hold a grudge

fast talon
# gaunt sky do u need any tips

Thanks for asking, I know where to come to ask now. I'm only on chapter 2, working thro that and wandering off all over the place sight seeing šŸ˜€

azure sluice
#

also why did you exclude tumbleweed and armadillo

#

šŸ’”

cyan pendant
cyan pendant
feral grotto
#

unmuted at last

stark sparrow
#

wow hunting birds is hell on earth

#

I’m doing hunting requests and i need a cardinal, rat, and woodpecker

#

i got a good cardinal but you need perfect šŸ’”

short ocean
#

I can feel yar pain mate

stark sparrow
#

I got the hunting request at 6 am and now it’s 10 LMAO

#

Ima do something else

#

oh my god man

#

was riding around saw a 3 star cardinal but it got away

#

i will never forgive myself

#

ok i got one

#

it’s gonna be straight up impossible to find a woodpecker

#

for rats I’ll do that thing where you get rid of the rats at the Saint Denis bar

desert edge
#

Hey guys I'm picking my final stable member, it's either the few spotted appaloosa or the dark bay andalusian but idk which to pick lol

charred flax
#

guys i have a question, I went to catch the legendary smallmouth bass but when I caught it and stored it on my horse, a cougar killed me at the same time and now it’s not on my horse anymore and I can’t post it what can i do?

warm torrent
#

i think you might have to catch it again šŸ’”

storm bramble
umbral island
#

Im feeling good

#

Just killed the entirety of strawberry + valentine

warm torrent
#

what's the bounty 😭

charred flax
warm torrent
#

that's so weird

next orchid
#

howdy
I'm actually enjoying the epilogue a lot rn
finished everything

azure sluice
#

do legendary animals respawn if you lose their pelts

midnight ocean
#

saint denis is a death trap

#

rhodes is peak chillness

#

outside of chapter 3 at least lol

dark ferry
#

i just went down to 6- honor for the gunslinger grip only to find that you have to be 6+ honor to unlock it

dark ferry
deep shard
#

guys i need help
i wanna buy the drover outfit
i have honor rank 6
enough money and cleared all my bounties
im chapter 2 on my second play through
but it still says its locked any help?

stark sparrow
#

yeah i think i give up on trynna find a woodpecker

dark ferry
#

i’ll send a image of the spot on red dead media

stark sparrow
#

I’ll look there

#

I was looking near strawberry at the lake

#

I heard them but couldn’t see any

dark ferry
stark sparrow
#

i was

#

idk why I couldn’t find any

dark ferry
stark sparrow
#

looked near the lake in 2 spots and in strawberry in 2 spots

dark ferry
#

am not sure if i’ve even seen a woodpecker aside from the location i’ve sent

deep shard
umbral island
cyan pendant
grizzled finch
umbral island
torn mantle
#

Hey guys, quick question, how do I get a new horse😭?
I've found a raven black shire in camp and need that fella

grizzled finch
umbral island
#

Dont even know how to report on discord

grizzled finch
midnight ocean
midnight ocean
#

or maybe you still need to do the mission

torn mantle
midnight ocean
#

with hosea

#

he gives you that horse, its the only one in the game

torn mantle
#

yeah I'm dirt new to rdr2 and have no clue where to do that

midnight ocean
umbral island
midnight ocean
#

itll be an H marker in the camp

torn mantle
umbral island
midnight ocean
#

so be careful if you dont wanna know what happens

torn mantle
#

Nah its cool

torn mantle
torn mantle
umbral island
#

But im not sure about this

torn mantle
umbral island
#

Think so

deep glacier
#

Didn’t know you could get the raven shire prior to the mission

deep glacier
#

Don’t think so. You get it during a mission with Hosea

torn mantle
#

bet bet bet

#

is that in chapter 2 or later?

deep glacier
#

Chapter 2

#

Just make sure NOT to sell it

torn mantle
#

I wont😭

deep glacier
#

You’d be surprised how often people make that mistake 😭

torn mantle
#

idek how to if I wanted too

#

man idek how to get a saddle for it when the time comes šŸ¤·šŸ½ā€ā™‚ļø

deep glacier
#

It’s all within the mission. You’ll see

deep shard
#

i have 25% discount on all stores

#

just greet people in saint denis

bright fjord
#

yo why does my game crash everytime at the Angelo Bronte mission

chilly spade
#

so if i do 4 hunting requests as arthur, how do i get the fifth one as john?

midnight ocean
cyan pendant
stark sparrow
#

@dark ferry alr im at the location you sent, i definitely hear some woodpeckers and im looking through the trees high and low but I dont see any

#

This is actually hell

dark ferry
#

with trees

midnight ocean
dark ferry
#

they aren’t high up on the trees tho

midnight ocean
chilly spade
#

also the map doesnt show all the legendary fish

#

are there 2 you catch with jeremy fraudgills?

#

the one that sends you useless lure

stark sparrow
#

I’ve probably seen every bird in this game except the damn wood pecker

midnight ocean
#

theres another in a different stranger mission

deep glacier
chilly spade
#

But you can't have it

chilly spade
#

Which can be catched outside the mission

deep glacier
#

I must be remembering it wrong then cause I swear I caught a legendary when fishing with Kieran

midnight ocean
chilly spade
#

Hamish takes him

midnight ocean
chilly spade
midnight ocean
chilly spade
#

Ok so there are only 13 on the map, how do you catch the the rest

#

The 15th is with Jeremy right?

midnight ocean
chilly spade
#

So do you only give him 13 of them?

midnight ocean
#

yes

#

the northern pike is not part of the quest because its part of the veteran instead

midnight ocean
#

when you have to troll to cover up how stupid you are lol

chilly spade
#

Oh no i admit im stupid

#

I'm just tired of fucking up playtroughs

#

So i wanna be careful

torn mantle
cyan pendant
#

We might need to come up with nicknames for Arthur and other characters

chilly spade
#

Mr tahiti

#

Rat

#

Lumbago

#

Scar face

pure dragon
#

Taco

deep glacier
pure dragon
#

tuberculosis

chilly spade
cyan pendant
pulsar ruin
#

How do I get groups of bounty hunters to leave me alone?

cyan pendant
deep glacier
chilly spade
pure dragon
deep glacier
pulsar ruin
#

but they keep coming back

pure dragon
deep glacier
#

You’re not riding away far enough then

pure dragon
#

close the game

#

alt f4

chilly spade
#

Nah.

#

Kill them.

#

If they keep coming?

#

Kill em again

pure dragon
#

dead eye with pistols

deep glacier
#

Or repeater without dead eye, easy 2 shot

chilly spade
#

Coldly walk slowly with a pump action shotgun and make sure the funeral ain't gonna be pretty

midnight ocean
pure dragon
#

like a real MAN

deep glacier
#

Real outlaws keep their bountiesSipArthur

chilly spade
pure dragon
pure dragon
midnight ocean
#

if you have no money do some story missions or google gold bar locations

midnight ocean
chilly spade
#

Bounty hunters do prevent sleep and it is annoying

midnight ocean
pure dragon
#

go to blackwater and see.....Uhm

midnight ocean
#

whats more annoying about having a bounty is that if you commit any crime whatsoever even a minor one it will put the town on lockdown

#

in fact even killing the bounty hunters near the town can put it on lockdown

pure dragon
#

just

#

someone speak french

deep glacier
midnight ocean
#

lmao yeah i was like why

#

i wasnt even that close

deep glacier
#

You was in heartlands right?

azure sluice
#

Je m’appelle

midnight ocean
#

i was probably just past twin stack pass

pure dragon
midnight ocean
#

also tumbleweed is on like perma lockdown for me so i cant get to the bounty poster without paying it off first i think

pure dragon
#

MONEY dutchsmart

deep glacier
#

What’d you do to have tumbleweed perma locked😭

midnight ocean
#

just got a bounty in new austin

azure sluice
midnight ocean
#

i waited a pretty long time after and went back but it was locked down still

#

i dont wanna kill the sheriff or id try just shooting them and then grabbing the poster

#

finally i was like fuck it ill just go hang out in van horn

#

got pickpocketed walking into the saloon

#

shot the guy and of course yeah the whole town started lighting me up

#

the good thing is that theres no lockdowns in van horn so you can kill everyone then just walk back into the saloon and play blackjack

deep glacier
#

Pickpocketers go to the gators

pure dragon
#

GO in the water

deep glacier
midnight ocean
#

they were too scared to not let me play pepesit

midnight ocean
#

wut

azure sluice
cyan pendant
#

Sorry

midnight ocean
chilly spade
midnight ocean
#

he took 600 but i got back 1200

#

after i walked back onto the main street like hmmm ok which body is the pickpocket

azure sluice
#

LOL

#

The amount of cash they rob depends on how much money you have in total right?

#

I think at some point at the Saint Denis tailor someone pickpocketed like 3k 😭

#

My hard earned Blackwater money grrr

azure sluice
#

yea I got it back it’s easy

midnight ocean
#

do you know how much you had when you got the 3k taken?

deep glacier
azure sluice
#

I was fresh out of American Venom

deep glacier
#

Makes sense that way anyways

midnight ocean
#

well probably not then because i had like 37k when they took my 600

#

maybe theres a range

deep glacier
#

Or you just got lucky

azure sluice
azure sluice
#

the grind never stops

midnight ocean
#

aberdeen exploit

#

you can store arthurs money for john to get later

azure sluice
#

At my old 100% story completion save I went down to 13k 3DInnocent_

midnight ocean
#

yep

azure sluice
midnight ocean
#

yes

azure sluice
#

šŸ‘€

midnight ocean
#

if you dont retrieve the money as arthur you can get it later as john

azure sluice
#

I don’t think we’re allowed to discuss that anyway

deep glacier
#

Vieltz about to go try it out now lmaoSipArthur

midnight ocean
#

nah we talk about it all the time. its not a glitch

azure sluice
deep glacier
#

I’ve yet to come across them in my play through

azure sluice
#

I also instantly killed that swamp guy and I lost honor for some reason smh

midnight ocean
#

i mean its pointless to do i just wanted to because i hoard money and wanted to have as much as possible in the epilogue just for the sake of it

#

should i go for 50 lmao

deep glacier
#

Might as well lol

midnight ocean
#

think these van horners are probably hoping for me to move on anyway

deep glacier
midnight ocean
#

my honor as john is not good lol

#

i am evil john

deep glacier
#

Mines a good John

#

Following Arthur’s footsteps🄹

midnight ocean
#

i had to get that achievement for having a massive bounty in every state so

#

okay blackwater valentine rhodes and saint denis are all on lockdown but tumbleweed looks ok

deep glacier
#

Oh ya, for that achievement does every state need to be locked down and stuff? Or you just gotta have a bounty on you?

azure sluice
#

I hardly lose honor as Arthur

#

My John is

#

well

#

I’d rather not talk about it

midnight ocean
#

you need to have $250 bounty in every state at the same time for 3 days

deep glacier
#

I’m guessing to get that high of a bounty I really need to cause chaos then

midnight ocean
#

i just robbed trains and then killed the lawmen that came until i had 250

azure sluice
#

You lose honor for knocking out guards though

deep glacier
#

They don’t lessen your honor for real?

midnight ocean
#

im gonna do a train rn do i do it at bards crossing, saint denis, or ambarino?

deep glacier
#

Saint Denis

midnight ocean
#

excellent choice

azure sluice
deep glacier
#

I would’ve thought the opposite but I’ll keep that in mind for sure

azure sluice
#

I got a $60 bounty for shooting 5 birds from a moving train šŸ’”

cyan pendant
azure sluice
midnight ocean
#

oh shit bounty hunters can enter van horn

cyan pendant
#

Especially in Saint Denis

cyan pendant
#

Only law can’t

midnight ocean
#

those boys just came upon a grizzly scene

azure sluice
#

can bounty hunters get into smaller towns?

#

Emerald ranch / valentine for instance

midnight ocean
#

emerald ranch isnt really a town i dont think

#

definitely not valentine

azure sluice
#

also raiding that Del Lobo gang in New Austin is so fun

cyan pendant
#

No idea about valintine

azure sluice
#

but the last one got ahold of a turret and disintegrated me

cyan pendant
#

I swear whenever I see a turret I give my horse drugs so it doesn’t die

midnight ocean
#

yeah i remember getting smoked in that one lemoyne raider ambush

#

honestly props to them because it was clean af

azure sluice
#

Is Edith Downes Thomas Downes’ wife or what

midnight ocean
#

yes

azure sluice
#

oh yea

#

that mission where u go get her son

midnight ocean
#

you see her a few times

cyan pendant
midnight ocean
#

she doesnt recognize arthur and tries to proposition him for sex in saint denis in chapter 4 i believe

azure sluice
cyan pendant
#

Yeah

midnight ocean
#

regardless of honor

azure sluice
cyan pendant
#

Works for me

azure sluice
#

Then calls a lawman

cyan pendant
#

But I only really play low honor so like

azure sluice
#

and you get arrested if you have a bounty already

#

šŸ’”

cyan pendant
#

Kill the witness

cyan pendant
#

Yeah

azure sluice
#

I only got low honor as John idk man

#

My Arthur is so pure

#

he wouldn’t hurt a fly

cyan pendant
#

Ha your natures bitch

midnight ocean
#

btw i just confirmed the bounty hunters can follow into emerald ranch

azure sluice
#

(he did in fact commit genocide at both Rhodes and Valentine)

cyan pendant
#

He had to do taht tho

#

Because Dutch is a Moran

midnight ocean
#

i think the part where you rescue bill was micahs bad actually

cyan pendant
#

I mean I blame bill more … he accepted the job

midnight ocean
cyan pendant
#

Am I defending Micah no

midnight ocean
#

yeah i might be misremembering

misty prism
#

Man...doing this one quest for trophy in RDR1 feels like Nicholas Cage from that one western movie w bison hunt lol

midnight ocean
#

ive heard of that movie but i havent seen it

misty prism
#

Butcher's Crossing i think

midnight ocean
#

crazy i just came upon a herd of buffalo in game after you said that lol

misty prism
#

From novel adaption Cripps

cyan pendant
#

Rdr1 if you kill every Buffy they actually go extinct I had to do it for a trophy and felt bad after

azure sluice
azure sluice
#

Didn’t play 1

cyan pendant
#

Yeah but you get no trophy for it so

#

I’m not a total monster in this game

cyan pendant
misty prism
#

Ik there is some similar stuff w birds in RDR2 but nothing you get from it i think

midnight ocean
#

i thought it was micah who took the job

azure sluice
#

how much is it on Xbox

misty prism
#

Atleast i didn't saw nothing

azure sluice
midnight ocean
cyan pendant
azure sluice
#

not another month till I get my allowance

cyan pendant
#

Yeah just saying you should if you get the chance

deep glacier
azure sluice
#

I knew the ending for RDR2 years before playing the game and still cried when I finished it

cyan pendant
#

Everyone did

#

Only game that has actually made me cry

deep glacier
#

Same, I accidentally spoiled it myself when looking for guides yet I still cried

cyan pendant
#

Okay scratch that cyberpunk exists

#

2 games

azure sluice
#

I didn’t rly care cause I didn’t see myself buying such games in the future

#

but yeah here I am

#

miserable

deep glacier
#

Little did you know lol

azure sluice
#

šŸ’”

cyan pendant
#

Yeha now you have depression with us

azure sluice
#

I almost spoiled the game for someone a while ago here

cyan pendant
#

Wait till you play rdr1 if you haven’t seen taht ending

azure sluice
#

I was talking about playing as John and they got confused I had to make up something 😭

azure sluice
deep glacier
#

Accidentally spoiled the rdr ending for myself also😭

#

It was all over my damn feed

cyan pendant
#

When I bought rdr2 I was like there is no way I’ll get attached to Arthur cause i liked John and here we are

deep glacier
#

A lot of people thought that I feel

#

Little did people know lol

cyan pendant
#

He really is no matter how you play him

azure sluice
#

Well the entire game is

#

bruh

cyan pendant
#

Well he’s important

#

Micah is

azure sluice
deep glacier
#

Micah was a well written antagonist for sure

azure sluice
cyan pendant
#

Look okay I don’t th ink we would have rdr2 if they didn’t bring him

azure sluice
cyan pendant
#

Again I’m not defending him still hate em

azure sluice
#

He’s just pure evil

azure sluice
cyan pendant
#

Funny thing is I didn’t mind Micah until chapter 3

azure sluice
#

šŸ’”

deep glacier
cyan pendant
azure sluice
midnight ocean
#

tf lol i just saved and quit the game then booted it back up and my jacket is off?

cyan pendant
azure sluice
#

I think he was genuinely attracted to Mary Beth though

cyan pendant
deep glacier
#

I don’t think he was genuinely attracted to any of the girls tbh

#

Maybe Abigail actually

cyan pendant
#

My favorite one is when Charles throws Micah halfway across the camp

midnight ocean
#

i think theres a couple times he hits on abigail

deep glacier
#

My favorite will always be the one he has with Javier ā€œplaying with my knifeā€

#

Or is that with bill he says that?

midnight ocean
#

and like implies he wants to be jacks stepdad lol

deep glacier
#

I dont remember

torn mantle
cyan pendant
midnight ocean
#

its bill tho

#

bill is drunk af and calls javier a greaser

deep glacier
cyan pendant
torn mantle
cyan pendant
#

It’s not a bad horse early game

#

Keep it

midnight ocean
#

the annoying thing is even if you stable the shire you still have to get a different horse it doesnt just let you swap to that one

cyan pendant
#

Unless you really need the 65 bucks

midnight ocean
#

but you can just saddle it up after the mission

#

youll have to go back to the stable

deep glacier
#

Ya I wish it didn’t force you to buy a horse

cyan pendant
azure sluice
deep glacier
cyan pendant
#

Kieran didn’t really like anyone

#

He was still the outcast of the gang

midnight ocean
#

micah tries to smash grimshaw

midnight ocean
deep glacier
#

I feel he liked Mary Beth, their camp interactions were always cute

midnight ocean
#

they liked each other for sure

#

when kieran disappears mary beth is obviously worried about him asking if anyones seen him

cyan pendant
#

Maybe he did idk I knew Mary Beth had a thing for Arthur and Sean had a thing for Karen

misty prism
#

With who was Irish?

cyan pendant
midnight ocean
#

sean and molly

misty prism
deep glacier
#

I forgot molly is Irish too

misty prism
#

We had two Irish XD in series, one bearded fugitive that went to Mexico and other who lost half of head šŸ’€

cyan pendant
#

She is literally not any use around the camp for once I agree with Micah to let people go taht do nothing

deep glacier
#

Wasn’t she just there as Dutch’s side piece?

#

Basically

cyan pendant
#

Yeah

#

That’s it

misty prism
#

Sean to everyone: Englishman cowboykekw

cyan pendant
#

He calles Arthur that I don’t know about the others I think he calls Micah German

#

And then John Scott

midnight ocean
misty prism
#

Ik Morgan has some Welsh origin i guess, somewhere i read it

deep glacier
#

Speaking of dutch I forgot him and grimshaw used to be a thing

midnight ocean
#

i saw someone point out that she should have replaced bill at the saint denis gala and i thought that was a good point

cyan pendant
#

He’s welsh

#

I’m not welsh though I’m Irish

deep glacier
cyan pendant
#

That’s better

misty prism
#

I think Dutch still couldn't forgot that girl he and O'Driscoll fight for, that died

#

Ik there is some mentions about her through game

gloomy igloo
#

Annebell?

gloomy igloo
#

or however u spell her name

#

yeah

#

Colm killed her bc Dutch killed Colm's brother

deep glacier
#

And ya, it’s obvious she meant a lot to him

gloomy igloo
#

I think that was the only woman he truly loved

cyan pendant
#

He obviously liked her more then Molly

gloomy igloo
#

My poor gal Molly šŸ’”

#

bro Molly was such a baddie and sweetheart sigh

#

I really wish she ran away like tilly and them instead of getting killed off

cyan pendant
#

Well taht was before they didn’t that

deep glacier
#

It’s valid the way she was killed off tho. They all thought she ratted

cyan pendant
#

She walked in drunk and got shot

cyan pendant
#

No

gloomy igloo
#

Like for the saint denis robbery

#

she said she wanted them to kill dutch

#

Thats why Dutch was furious

cyan pendant
#

Nope Milton said they sweated her a few times didn’t say a word

deep glacier
#

Pinkertons said she wouldn’t talk but idk

gloomy igloo
#

right oops

deep glacier
#

It’s the pinkertons we’re talking about

gloomy igloo
#

I dunno, Milton has a habit of lying, no?

cyan pendant
#

Micah was picked up after returning from guarma

gloomy igloo
#

Fuckass micah

deep glacier
gloomy igloo
#

hes such a good charachter I hate him

cyan pendant
#

Me with every single antagonist ever

midnight ocean
gloomy igloo
#

Peter Blomquist did such a good job with Micah

deep glacier
#

True, that was a rule to not murder yet grimshaw shot her with no hesitation lol

midnight ocean
gloomy igloo
#

It also jumpscares me when he talks because thats his actual voice for both him and Micah

#

hello i cant speak

cyan pendant
#

I don’t believe so

#

He told the truth about Mac

deep glacier
gloomy igloo
#

I really hope they do rdr3 more deeper into the past

#

even playing as a younger arthur would be cool

cyan pendant
gloomy igloo
#

or having a new character all together

deep glacier
#

I just wanna know the black water massacre mane

gloomy igloo
#

Me to

cyan pendant
#

It would have been a good dlc

gloomy igloo
#

Too*

gloomy igloo
cyan pendant
#

I mean not really…

gloomy igloo
#

It was avoided all together or not answered

cyan pendant
#

There’s a couple

gloomy igloo
#

It was so vague tbh

deep glacier
#

I feel what happened at Saint Denis is what happened at black water except it was a ferry robbery

gloomy igloo
#

One of the fun missions were the riverboat robberies tbh

cyan pendant
#

The one we’re Arthur gambles ?

gloomy igloo
#

but a tear jerker was the alst one and "My Last Son"

gloomy igloo
azure sluice
cyan pendant
gloomy igloo
#

Fuckass Dutch flirting with marybeth when Molly was around 😭

cyan pendant
deep glacier
azure sluice
azure sluice
cyan pendant
#

I love that it’s the only misson that feels like and all out war

azure sluice
#

she deserved way better

gloomy igloo
#

wha

azure sluice
#

1984

#

this bot is so annoying bro

gloomy igloo
#

What does it mean too many caps

#

what

azure sluice
#

Capital letters

#

Caps

gloomy igloo
#

IK that

#

freakass game šŸ’”

#

Molly was so complex and she had a good reason to flip her shit

#

I HATE when people tell me that rdr2 needs more complex characters and they skim over Molly and Mary

azure sluice
#

I don’t understand why she lied about ratting to Milton tho

gloomy igloo
#

She wanted to die ig

azure sluice
#

Wait she was drunk too then no?

gloomy igloo
#

It wasn't like she had anything to lose too

azure sluice
#

Yea

gloomy igloo
#

Which was so sad bro

cyan pendant
#

And wanted ditchs attention

azure sluice
gloomy igloo
#

My god I cant think abt it im gonna ccry

azure sluice
gloomy igloo
#

her situation was so bad and throughout the whole game i yearned for her to run bro

cyan pendant
#

Least saddest t death in the game for me

gloomy igloo
#

Water you talking about šŸ’”

cyan pendant
#

Saddest death besides Arthur is hoseas

gloomy igloo
#

HOSEA.

#

Dear lord I miss that old grandpappy

cyan pendant
#

Lenny is a lot sadder because it came out of knowhere

azure sluice
#

That air balloon guy’s death was sad too

cyan pendant
#

And same with Sean’s

azure sluice
#

Sean, Kieran and Lenny all had shocking fates

gloomy igloo
#

god sean is so sad

#

KIERAN

#

Dont even get me started

cyan pendant
#

He has holding his damn head

azure sluice
#

yea I don’t even wanna talk about Kieran it’s so tragic

cyan pendant
#

It was right after jacks party too

gloomy igloo
#

"Go... and get.. a JOB."

azure sluice
#

Like bro it took me 20 seconds to comprehend what happened to him 😭

gloomy igloo
azure sluice
gloomy igloo
#

he was off to the side

cyan pendant
#

Multiple charters mention kirean is missing

gloomy igloo
#

especially grimshaw btw

#

people making headcanons that she was like a mother figure and im slightly on the fence

azure sluice
#

Also you can hear O’Driscolls shouting around camp

gloomy igloo
#

and his screams

azure sluice
cyan pendant
#

I forgot about those

gloomy igloo
#

Genuinely one of the saddest deaths was Eagle flies

cyan pendant
#

Oh yeah taht one was hard

gloomy igloo
#

Dude that was Rain Falls LAST son

azure sluice
gloomy igloo
#

All other lost to the same fate bro 😭

gloomy igloo
azure sluice
#

I never rly paid attention to the natives part 😭

cyan pendant
#

The name is my last boy so

cyan pendant
azure sluice
#

yeah

gloomy igloo
#

fuckass game

azure sluice
#

.

gloomy igloo
#

I hate this damn game bro šŸ’”

#

they made it so sad too

#

cuz wdym I grieve character's deaths for MONTHS.

azure sluice
#

honestly yeah I regret the purchase

#

I am mentally exhausted because of the game

#

please

#

why does everyone die

gloomy igloo
#

Like theyre not even real

#

why am I feeling guilty

#

LOL

azure sluice
#

literally every single character

#

aside from Charles and Sadie

cyan pendant
#

And uncle

gloomy igloo
#

Im so glad charles and sadie lived

cyan pendant
#

And John

azure sluice
gloomy igloo
azure sluice
#

he doesn’t know does he

cyan pendant
#

Rdr1 hit different

gloomy igloo
cyan pendant
#

I know

azure sluice
#

šŸ’”

gloomy igloo
#

Let's take a walk....

cyan pendant
#

I know uncle dies

gloomy igloo
#

Lumbago gets uncle

cyan pendant
#

Buddy you don’t get to give me the talk

gloomy igloo
#

lumbago is tragic and very real šŸ’”

azure sluice
#

Jack is adorably funny bro

#

there are these videos where they like

gloomy igloo
#

Definitely johns kid bro

azure sluice
#

swap Arthur and Jack’s mocaps and voice lines

gloomy igloo
#

do u see the SASS on that boy

azure sluice
#

it’s so funny

gloomy igloo
#

"You think you're funny?!" If you anagonize jack too much

azure sluice
#

go catch us some FISH

gloomy igloo
#

same with john ;sob:

gloomy igloo
azure sluice
#

yea lol

#

Like father like son

gloomy igloo
#

I hate it when ppl be trying to tell me John isnt Jack's father

#

what

#

Lies

#

its all blasphemy

azure sluice
#

Abigail is weird

#

from what I’ve heard

#

idk freaky stuff I am gonna avoid that topic

gloomy igloo
#

Abigail was a prostitue

midnight ocean
#

lol

gloomy igloo
#

prostitute

#

**

#

She slept with a lot of the male members

#

but settled on john after he got her pregnant

#

Then he ditched her and jack a year after he was born

azure sluice
midnight ocean
#

i mean at least he knew they were well taken care of with the rest of the gang around not like he left them destitute

#

but still unfair to abigail

azure sluice
#

It’s crazy how you watch the main character die then go milk a cow 20 minutes later

gloomy igloo
#

yeah

azure sluice
#

😭😭

gloomy igloo
#

emotional roller coaster into divorce simulator 😭

midnight ocean
#

i saw a funny reddit post where this guy was like "i got tears and snot runnin down my face and theyre making me milk this stupid cow"

azure sluice
#

ngl it’s kind of embarrassing

#

I play Xbox on the TV in the living room and sometimes my dad watches

#

I’d rather go commit massacres in Saint Denis than milk cows infront of my family bro 😭

gloomy igloo
#

thats genuinely so real

#

I cried for 2 days straight

#

I was inconsoable

azure sluice
#

u guys are fun icl

gloomy igloo
#

for a good while

#

You're funny im gonna find your IP hehe

azure sluice
midnight ocean
#

i remember watching my sister beat rdr1 back in the day and she started like scream crying as soon as the song started playing lol

azure sluice
#

šŸ˜”

#

alright goodnight y’all

#

was fun talking hi

gloomy igloo
#

sleep well

#

ty for talking with us

misty prism
#

I think Molly was smthing like muse to him or idk, he was very manipulative towards her

deep glacier
deep glacier
midnight ocean
#

im also replaying 1 rn

misty prism
#

Could it be similar relationship between that one Rebel leader from RDR1 and young girl who adored him, i am writing this as someone who can't remember names even tho i played the game today cowboykekw

misty prism
#

Or i'll just replay missions

midnight ocean
#

but theres a couple other ones i dont have

misty prism
#

Mostly i am proud on that trophy from RDR2 Best in the West...that shit was horrible long

deep glacier
#

Do the graves show up in rdr1 at all? I’d guess not considering the rest of gang technically didn’t exist yet

misty prism
#

Took me whole summer vacation after college under exams to do...which was stressfull

midnight ocean
misty prism
#

Definitely XD

#

That's Medal of Honor here

midnight ocean
deep glacier
#

That’s what I thought

#

If they ever do a remaster of 1 I wonder if they’ll add them

misty prism
#

I like graphics of RDR1 on PS5 looks clean

#

For game that is from 2010s

deep glacier
#

It’s not to bad on the Xbox either as far as I can tell

misty prism
#

Proud on playing that game, first ever that i finished to the end on PS3

#

Even tho story is somehow more emotional in RDR2 personally

#

Morgan arc was deeper for me than Marston had idk

midnight ocean
#

well 2 has a lot more scenes and dialogue

#

so they had time for much more character stuff

deep glacier
#

Yaaaaa, the character development and story went crazy in the second game

misty prism
#

I mean i was intrigued w RDR1 story when i was younger but after RDR2 had absolute cinema experoence

deep glacier
#

If/when they do a third game I wonder what it’ll be based around

#

Cause as long as I can see what happened in black water I’m good

misty prism
#

I just wanz conpletely new era and characters tbh

#

Something like 1870/1880

#

Like Call of Juarez stuff

deep glacier
#

Ah so you want a fresh story

misty prism
#

After Civil War

#

But not too long after war

deep glacier
#

Not gonna lie I saw a short on YouTube of a potential rdr3 plot that’s actually fire

misty prism
#

Rockstar knows to do some shitty stuff like grinding GTA Online and leaving RDRO in dust but when they write story it is peak cinema

#

I believe that RDR3 stuff would be just upgraded version of prequel and sequel

deep glacier
#

Potentially or like you want it, have it be a completely new story

misty prism
#

quick off topic: Since you have Snoopy profile i assume you re gonna watch Great Pumpkin movie from Peanuts rcthumbsup

deep glacier
#

Duh

#

It’s only fair I do

misty prism
#

Since i already mentioned spooky season, Undead Nightmare was fun to play lol

deep glacier
#

I reckon that’s a dlc right?

misty prism
#

Yep

#

Mexican Nuns w shotguns rcthumbsup poshonor

deep glacier
#

I’ll have to see if I have it cause I do wanna try it out for real

misty prism
#

I just bought it w original game at PS Store

#

I think it is bundle idk

opaque lodge
#

does anyone know any mafia mod??

#

I saw a video and it doesn't include the mod link or the name, but I don't think I can send it here.

lethal sleet
#

can you accidentally run into legendary animals or do you always have to track them?

hybrid moth
#

oi fellas i got a big problem... i finished RDR1 too

#

and even undead nightmare

#

idk what to play lmao

half yacht
#

i finished every game i own it's lowk sadšŸ˜”

hybrid moth
half yacht
#

play gta4 again

#

gta 4 is peak

hybrid moth
#

maybe i'll go on diablo 4 idk

green plinth
#

Gambler challenge 8 is excruciating

green plinth
royal kettle
#

Robbing a train isn't as exciting as I thought it would be

deep glacier
#

Actually was excruciating

rare harness
#

they arent that bad, then i again i just do fast travel for it so

deep glacier
#

The climbing was actual pain

green plinth
#

i am alternating between pressing enter and H

#

worse, it costs me money. a pittance but still.

#

what i'll do just for the drip

#

stg

deep glacier
#

Anything for the drip for real

#

Not looking forward to doing the challenges one do tho

green plinth
#

they alternate between being piss easy and total bullshit

#

this one's total bullshit because the odds of getting 3 hits in blackjack without going bust are ridiculous

#

i don't know if the game skews the odds or not though

deep glacier
#

I’d imagine so? Could just be unlucky today so far unfortunately

green plinth
#

the poker AI is broken and doesn't deal with bluffing very well at all

#

you can go all-in every time and win more often than not i think

deep glacier
#

Hmm good to know since I needa do that challenge still lol

green plinth
#

i'm not necessarily faulting the devs because i imagine programming a computer to handle that without straight up cheating is hard as fuck

deep glacier
#

Yaaaa could just be having bad luck today with it

#

As gambling usually goes

green plinth
#

as far as i can tell the computer assumes you are never bluffing, so if you go all-in first chance you get, it assumes that you have a 161 of clubs from balatro and just folds

green plinth
deep glacier
#

Five finger fillet my favorite mini game out of all of them I can’t even lie

#

Easy money right there rcthumbsup

green plinth
#

poker is cool but i just like playing poker tbh

#

my least favorite is dominoes because it's slow as balls

deep glacier
#

Poker would be my favorite if I understood it

#

But I don’t so five finger fillet it is lol

green plinth
#

the goal in poker is to have the best set of cards between the two you're dealt and the community cards

#

there's a help section if you're ok with reading lol

deep glacier
#

Oh ya, I don’t mind the reading I just never bothered with it lol

#

I was hard focused on the story and side quests my first play through

green plinth
#

fair enough but i would say you're better off understanding poker if you want to do the gambling challenges

#

even though it's cheesable

#

it helps with the monotony if you know what you're actually doing lmao

#

if that makes sense

deep glacier
#

It does ya

#

I plan to do the challenges once I do the 100% completion

green plinth
#

i just want the gambler equipment because it's drippy as hell

deep glacier
#

What’s it look like?

green plinth
#

hold on

#

im surprised theres not an image of it on the wiki

#

but just go to the trapper and it should be under reinforced equipment i think

deep glacier
#

Nahhhh that’s all CLEAN

#

The bandolier especially

#

Holsters aren’t to shabby either

#

I see why you’re grinding for that set

green plinth
#

fr

#

FINALLY got it

#

But now I think I have to play dominoes cowboy_sob

#

Yep

#

Looooooots of dominoes fml

#

Worse I have to win 3 whole rounds in a row

#

But then it's comfy poker again so all is well

#

And then I'm done

deep glacier
#

You got it, just have to have that patience lol

green plinth
#

Yep

vale osprey
#

You need patience for all the chambler challenges

green plinth
#

Some of them like I said are piss easy

#

Like winning a round of filet in every location

deep glacier
#

That’ll be cake walk for mercthumbsup

vale osprey
#

yeah the later ones are terrible almost stoped me for 100% the game persoanlly

green plinth
#

it's cake walk for anybody really because you only have to do the super easy round with two keys lol

#

if you can spam two buttons you can do it

deep glacier
#

You know what I meant

green plinth
#

yeah

deep glacier
#

Considering that’s my favorite mini gameSipArthur

green plinth
#

hehe

#

im glad you dont have to do the third round

#

thats when its actually hard

#

third opponent, rathetr

vale osprey
#

I got really good at five finger fillet for no reason

#

I was just bored but wanted to play the game so

coarse pike
#

So...what do you like to do when you finish the epilogue?

deep glacier
deep glacier
coarse pike
#

😭

deep glacier
#

Yes! All the camps but lakay

#

I personally haven’t heard any at lakay yet

coarse pike
#

This game is full of details right after all, I love it

deep glacier
#

Cool detail too is that the voices are different each time you visit the camps

#

It’s not the same voices every time

#

Visit them on different days and you’ll see, it’s pretty neat

coarse pike
#

I heard that the church in the civil war also has sounds, there is also the ghost train

deep glacier
#

Ooooh I haven’t tested the church one but I believe it. Ghost train also happens once per play through

#

So I’ve heard tho

coarse pike
#

I believe these are things we should keep as memories 🄺

#

Thanks for telling me about the camps! I had forgotten

deep glacier
#

No problem! If you wanna see the ghost train too it happens when entering lemoyne between 3-6

#

Actually gonna test if it’s once per play through cause now I’m curious

coarse pike
#

Thank you!! It will help a lot, I think it's always worth going to see it, it's a really cool detail haha

#

I heard about a ghost too, it was in Lakay I think? I don't remember

deep glacier
#

Oh yes! Ghost lady, not to sure on where she is since I haven’t seen her yet

#

But she’s somewhere around lakay/outskirts of Saint Denis if I’m remembering it correctly

hybrid ruin
#

Hey guys

coarse pike
deep glacier
coarse pike
hybrid ruin
#

But for you good night

coarse pike
coarse pike
#

Have you fed your Buell today?

deep glacier
#

Me personally…I’d leave her be😭

coarse pike
#

Haha

deep glacier
#

Killing her feels wrong

coarse pike
#

for someone who has 4 thousand dollars, killing a ghost for a few bucks is very greedy

deep glacier
#

She had 4k on her???

#

Dayum she died with bank on her lmao