red-dead-singleplayer

[calm seal]

Story Mode way better

[pseudo patrol]

[midnight ocean]

horseman 7?

[crude linden]

Can someone send me link

[crude linden]

I finished it

[tall obsidian]

Horseman do have one but im referring into WE spsifically

Its spesifically mountrd enemry

So if your horse isnt lv4 bond or high hp andalusian youre dead lol

[pseudo patrol]

guys I

I have a confession

I threw a Molotov at Arthur's grave 😔

but dw though I had cheats on at the time so

it didn't save :)

[oblique quiver]

mods give this guy a shame role

ragebait used to be believable😔

[sturdy radish]

Micah is a fucking rat

[oblique quiver]

he is

he's a rat

you know it

and i know it

[sturdy radish]

My arthur is dead

[brazen wren]

The law started going after me for "disturbing the peace" after I shot a wolf that was mauling me

[cyan pendant]

Mf be like we must protect nature meanwhile nature

[vapid orbit]

…

[minor kelp]

hey can someone help me fix stuttering presumably caused by lml?

[reef rose]

Gavin

Where are you

It’s 1907 where are you

He might be dead : (

[torpid light]

rest in peace gav

right funny fellow he was

[royal kettle]

Well found the white Arabian on accident and as I stable it the guy goes on about not having any papers for it and it might be stolen. Because as we all know White Arabians are a very common horse

[potent estuary]

well I kinda found it on accident aswell

I was hunting for the legendary bison

[steel sage]

Does anyone know how to hunt a panther? I've been wandering around the woods of Old Harry Fen for 3 hours and haven't found a single panther.

[midnight ocean]

save and restart your game or try potent predator bait

[steel sage]

I did save and restart but nothing about pantera appeared.

The only time a panther appeared to me I didn't have time to kill it and it attacked me.

[midnight ocean]

try setting up camp and sleeping a day

for me theres a panther there basically every time ive gone there

[steel sage]

Is there another location where the panther appears or is it just Old Harry Fen?

[midnight ocean]

thats the only one i know of though ive heard they can spawn where the legendary was if you killed the legendary

that is kinda in the same area though

[steel sage]

Well, I'll keep trying to search in Old Harry Fen. If I have any questions, I'll post them here. Thanks for the help, by the way. :)

[midnight ocean]

np good luck

[royal kettle]

I was there for the legendary fish and circled around the lake looking for the elk. Didn't find it but did get several pelts out of it along with the white Arabian

[royal kettle]

Looking at my map there's apparently one in the circle of roads between emerald Station and Kamassa river. Assuming I'm reading the animal symbol right

[wintry stream]

Be sure all of ur mod files r installed correctly and ensure that wherever mod u HAVE installed does not conflict with another mod

[steel sage]

It's too stressful...

[wintry stream]

U could also change ur graphics API between Vulcan and DX12 and try out different graphic settings to see what works

If ur game works normally vanilla and only with mods there are issues, then do the first. If it always has a stuttering problem, adjust ur graphics settings

[minor kelp]

It's a bit more complicated than that. it was working perfectly and then it wasn't. i've tried everything. it works perfectly vanilla. i'm currently doing a clean install and will try something i haven't tried yet

i'll keep you posted if you want @wintry stream

[wintry stream]

Ok so the mods r definitely the problem is seems as it worked fine vanilla

Clean install sounds good, or u could also just remove the lml and script hook files so that the mods don’t have anything to connect to and launch within the game

[minor kelp]

yes it's either lml itself or scripthook because i disabled all lml mods in lml itself and it did nothing

[wintry stream]

100% some mods r either installed incorrectly, conflict with each other and/or are too demanding on ur game

[potent estuary]

how the tf do you get sheep hide again

i tried taking its pelt

but the trapper refused

[royal kettle]

Using Google apparently there's one to the Right of Laura's above the church

[minor kelp]

i think it might be scripthook. it was a pain getting it working initially because as we all know it's abandoned and dinput8.dll wasn't working so i have to use version.dll. i have a guess what it might be, wish i had the idea sooner. it'll be done installing clean around 4am my time (it's 2:15am now) so i'll either ping or dm you in the morning

[midnight ocean]

wdym he refused

[toxic pier]

get out of the area, sleep 3 days, go back into lemoyne, use cover lotion scent, and put down a predator bait (can be crafted or bought from the store)

there's another panther spawn in the bayous but it only spawns at night which is scary (nightfolk and whatnot)

[azure sluice]

just skin a sheep and sell it to the trapper

how does the trapper refuse

[midnight ocean]

im wondering if he killed a rocky mountain or sierra nevada sheep instead

[azure sluice]

you can find some sheep a bit north of Valentine

next to the house that Mary rented a room in

does the legendary panther only spawn on Master Hunter 10?

[midnight ocean]

yes

[azure sluice]

[royal kettle]

Finally got my revenge on the Panther that killed me

[royal kettle]

I was down there earlier thinking about hunting the panther there then thought better

[tidal slate]

Well im now I'm at survivalist 10 and need to catch 10 fishes

And then only Gambling remains...

I got those 8 Animals with small Arrows at Emeralds Farm, poor Chicken 🐔 just went there at Night

[cerulean pond]

JOHN MArstonnn

[midnight ocean]

loool nice

[lime crest]

apart from that one island off clemens point, is there anything else worth setting sail into flatiron for>

[tidal slate]

I feel very Sorry for the sleeping Rooster 🐓 and the Chickens 🐔 but if you went there at Night... It's the best spot to get them easily

Now I found a Checklist for the Fishing. I guess it might be some Traveling, but I'll get there

[tall obsidian]

Does golden cores actually matter

Seems like that thing only work with BGM seasoned

[desert edge]

Guys gold or silver turkoman?

[lime crest]

not really i don't think, afaik they just work like Fortified stats, means they can't deplete for some time

[toxic pier]

gold, cause it looks like bob (sadie's horse)

btw I need a name for my blue roan nokota, what y'all got?

[lime crest]

boy or gal?

[toxic pier]

gurl

stole her from a treasure hunter

[lime crest]

Rosie

[toxic pier]

hmm okok

[lime crest]

my first gut was Lily but then i realised that's just my name hahah

or Lavender, that matches the colour more

[toxic pier]

I'll keep that in mind

[lime crest]

the horse i used my entire Arthur time was called Daphne

[toxic pier]

thx for the suggestion tho!

[lime crest]

np

[toxic pier]

I also had a horse that stayed with arthur all the time

astrid, she's a brindle thoroughbred

[lime crest]

i was gonna have a secondary i called Gregory for hunting, but i found out as soon as you stable them you can't take the fucker out

along with your main

[desert edge]

Lol that's the point gold looks like Bob and silver like silver dollar (hoseas horse) I already have the dark bay one too

[tall obsidian]

The dead eye golden corr add like 5-10 sec i guess

I chase meta but holy hell

[lime crest]

wait what i go to armadillo, shoot a couple guys and suddenly i'm the sherrif?

[tall obsidian]

Cooking in this game is hillariously slow

I get the realistic part but holy shit

Even rdo has Multiple cooks

[royal kettle]

I know honestly that's the worst part. Because I'll sometimes have like 20 big game and then it takes forever to cook

[tidal slate]

If I would be worried about cooking in a Game where I spend 400 hrs + on Steam, I would ask myself what to do with the Rest of my Western Cowboy 🤠 Life..

[proven thicket]

hi guys

[toxic pier]

why is benedict allbright still in jail after 8 years?

[proven thicket]

who is benedict

i forget

[oblique cloud]

the doctor that sold deadly medicine to people

[proven thicket]

oh

got it

[potent estuary]

what really happned what I took the pelt rode like 15 minutes and then when I got there he got afraid and ran away

2nd time after sleeping for 16 hours or something same thing happend

after reloading save same thing

then I just went to the saint denise trapper

I think the trapper remembers the last time I killed him so he says something like "oh I remember you" "back here to cause more trouble" and then he closes and leaves

[potent estuary]

his horse is pretty good

[proven thicket]

you mean in the mission?

[potent estuary]

yeah

i stole it

[hoary nacelle]

hey i just found the white arabian, do yall think i should keep it or sell it? I dont know if it's important for something later in the game or its just a horse.

[dark ferry]

it’s just a horse you can get an unlimited amount of them tho

[oblique cloud]

It is the rarest breed in the game so keep it

Also doesnt sell for much

Just like 150

[hoary nacelle]

I’ll have to abandon one of my horses😭

[oblique cloud]

Stable them

[quick glen]

For me after some time disappears so idk

The one that stays in prison for 8 years is the serial killer lady

[minor lion]

Random question but does anyone know of some good locations to find perfect robins in? I've looked through most yt tutorials and none are helpful

[azure flame]

Hlo guys can any one help me my rdr2 crashes when anabling fsr2

[tidal slate]

#pc-technical-stuff 🙂

[coarse pike]

Do I need to find the Sister quest before the Rains Fall quest at the meeting with the Colonel?

I'm worried, I started this mission now but I still haven't found the sister in Saint Denis

[near parrot]

Can someone tell me rq, I'm doing a quest where I have to steal a canoe and it doesn't tell me HOW to do so..

Nevermind chat

[earnest sky]

I wish there was more to professor dragic’s story

It’s really cool

[quiet rain]

wsp everyone

anyone who has some good mods? i kinda installed every possible mod and need some new good ones

[midnight ocean]

do you ride a stolen horse

this can cause that i think

[midnight ocean]

upper montana river

[midnight ocean]

yes

[midnight ocean]

it's not really rare lol you can go find it at the lake anytime

[coarse pike]

I got it, thanks Woolie!

[turbid gate]

i got a question, why i cant see a bone? i was literally on the place where it should be, reloaded game 3 times, slept 1 time and nothing. what shall i do?

[midnight ocean]

use eagle eye

[turbid gate]

i did

theres literally nothing

[midnight ocean]

maybe you got it already

[turbid gate]

nah i dont

i need 1 bone

and i didnt unmark it so 100% i didnt take it

[midnight ocean]

or you just forgot to unmark it

[turbid gate]

i may look in new austin again

[midnight ocean]

im confused lol

[turbid gate]

also, whats fastest horse and how to get it?

[turbid gate]

if i get the bone it dissapears??

[midnight ocean]

so theres no bone in the exact spot it should be? or you just cant find the exact spot?

[turbid gate]

i was lit looking 10 times with a youtube tutorial and in a map

[midnight ocean]

even if you already recorded the location you should still be able to see the bone on the ground

[turbid gate]

i saw an response cuz someone had the same bug and he said to play a mission

[pseudo patrol]

ok guys I managed to make my friend load his save before he lost that horse in the hosea bear hunting mission phew

[turbid gate]

so i might go to the side mission

also- how to get the side mission from dream catchers?

[midnight ocean]

you started the side quest right?

[turbid gate]

nah i didnt i wil do tmrw

[midnight ocean]

dream catchers doesnt have one i think you just start collecting them

[turbid gate]

i got 20/20 and i got a map

[midnight ocean]

wdym

[midnight ocean]

the map should show a final location to go get the treasure

think its the cave at elysian pool

[turbid gate]

welp i got only the dream catchers map connected

maybe its that one?

[midnight ocean]

yes lol

[turbid gate]

oooh

[midnight ocean]

why

oh i asked already

[turbid gate]

also if im john will the hunter (from side mission) idk his name, will he die? the one near the lake in grizzlies

[midnight ocean]

hamish? yeah

mission outcomes are the same whether you're john or arthur

[midnight ocean]

if you have special edition theres a free thoroughbred at the valentine stable

otherwise you can buy a missouri fox trotter at blackwater or scarlett meadows

[turbid gate]

thanks

[midnight ocean]

np

[rough mural]

i've sadly skipped one of the npc encounters near the central union railroad, anyone know the outcome?

it was a bit up between the O and V in Hanover, where the railroad ends just a smidge north from there

a npc set a camp there and you could either respond friendly or aggressively

[turbid gate]

also last question i got, what do i need for 100% the game?

[midnight ocean]

go to progress > total completion

[true parrot]

hello brother

[rough mural]

i would've sent a screenshot of the location but i dont have picture perms

[turbid gate]

brother 😮

[true parrot]

I saved your life

[turbid gate]

and i didnt

[true parrot]

TB took me,but I still beat the hell out of Micah

[midnight ocean]

so not part of the railroad quest just a nearby campsite?

[turbid gate]

i took revenge for you with Sadie

[rough mural]

exactly

[true parrot]

thank you

[midnight ocean]

could have been a few things probably

[true parrot]

ok stop the roleplay

[rough mural]

i could send you the location in dm's if that helps

[midnight ocean]

probably not, think those are just random

[midnight ocean]

was it a mexican guy?

[true parrot]

Javier?

[midnight ocean]

no lol

[rough mural]

yea

[midnight ocean]

probably the guy who warns you about aberdeen pig farm

[true parrot]

pfff

Armadillo is so cool

[rough mural]

is there a yt video about the encounter maybe

i havent found one sadly

[trim hamlet]

so theoretically if i typed

+rule15

okay apparently that's not the right prefix lmao

[true parrot]

MY NAME

[trim hamlet]

oh right mods can do that

[true parrot]

what the hell!!!!!!!

[trim hamlet]

i mean

is it inaccurate?

[true parrot]

how do I get it back?

[trim hamlet]

ask mods (DM Alden.)

[true parrot]

bet

wait

what now?

[pseudo patrol]

isn't that horse rare or smth

or did I just misinfo my friend

[rough mural]

if i go in an old save, will the autosave still be available?

[true parrot]

my username

raaaaaaaaaaah

[midnight ocean]

the black shire is unique but stable space is so limited that theres no reason to keep it if you dont really want it

[midnight ocean]

they dont let people name themselves after characters lol

[true parrot]

oh

[midnight ocean]

otherwise thered be like 50 arthur morgans

[turbid gate]

what abt john?

[cyan pendant]

You’ll probably get it removed

[midnight ocean]

only slightly less common

but yeah they must not have seen you yet

[turbid gate]

hmmm maybe cuz i joined tday?

[true parrot]

I joined 10 minutes ago

[turbid gate]

well

unlucky

[true parrot]

and my name is already gone

[midnight ocean]

i wonder if theyd let me rp as van horn harmonica player

[true parrot]

doesn't the server have custom stickers?

[true parrot]

go to #roleplay

[midnight ocean]

i dont have permission for the channel lol

[true parrot]

where are they?

[midnight ocean]

in stickers

[true parrot]

can't find them what the hell

[midnight ocean]

maybe you arent allowed yet

[true parrot]

not yet

shit

got them

[cyan pendant]

Because Arthur is more popular cause like everyone played rdr2 first except a few people

[turbid gate]

congrats

why fake why not temu

[midnight ocean]

[earnest sky]

I played the first game first but I still prefer Arthur

[minor lion]

I'll try that out tommorow , tysm!

[midnight ocean]

np! theyre easiest to see when they perch on the rocks in the river but also sometimes in the shade on the south bank. try the spot with a large sandbar just south of fort riggs

[midnight ocean]

arthur kinda has more depth to him so i get that

rdr1 is serious and philisophical but slightly less so than rdr2 i think

[minor lion]

Ouhh righty I see!! I really hope it works LOL I've spent hours already and still nothing so tysm again!!

[midnight ocean]

anytime, robins were the last thing i had to look for because the trapper needs a bunch of their feathers. i tried for hours at kamassa river and couldnt find any but that spot i just described worked well

[minor lion]

Those damn hunting requests will be the end of me I swearr

[midnight ocean]

oh wait are you in the epilogue or

[minor lion]

Yeahh I've done kamassa river too and got absolutely nothing

[minor lion]

Yup

[midnight ocean]

ok good

not sure if you can use that spot otherwise

[minor lion]

still good to try it out ig LOL

[dapper birch]

Saint Denis best part of the map

[midnight ocean]

no

[dapper birch]

ye

s

[midnight ocean]

fuck everything east of emerald station

imo

rhodes is chill

wait i just noticed something

[dapper birch]

Nuh

Saint denis so pretty

[midnight ocean]

the east part of new hanover where van horn and annesburg are kinda feels like its own state rather than part of new hanover

but i just noticed theres actually an unused border line separating the two halves

wait those are all over the place wtf

[tidal slate]

Well, I have to admit. The first Time I played RDR2 and saw Saint Denis the first Time ever I thought... oof that's actually amazing

[midnight ocean]

different counties maybe?

[dapper birch]

yea I love video game cities

[midnight ocean]

it is very cool to see but then you spend time here and you start to understand why the gang prefers open country so much

[tidal slate]

Well, the Game on its own... Is just stunning and I thought during the Gameplay how you are even able to find everything without the Map

[midnight ocean]

wow til every state is separated into named counties

the area of new hanover that contains van horn and annesburg is roanoke ridge and the area with valentine is the heartlands with cumberland forest being the third county?

some of these sound kinda weird as county names but oh well

also makes sense remembering marshal johnson talking about bill being in a different county. armadillo is in cholla springs and fort mercer is in rio bravo

[dapper birch]

idk I like it more in the city

although Annesburg is probably my fav looking town

[midnight ocean]

bro likes industry

i like rhodes because it feels like nothing is going on just permanent lazy sunday

great place to day drink

[dapper birch]

yea it looks great

Annesburg buns tho

they don't even have a saloon

[midnight ocean]

yeah and neither annesburg or van horn even has a butcher

[wraith raven]

Rhodes is the best

Strawberry chill also

[dark ferry]

i did it. Took me like 8 hours across 3ish days

[sand ledge]

bravo twin

[midnight ocean]

3 days to get an ardennes? how is that worth it lol

[dark ferry]

it likely isn’t

[midnight ocean]

maybe if you're on pc and really feel like you need the max health for your horse

[dark ferry]

i mainly did it for the looks of the horse

besides that was nothing compared to herbalist 9 as arthur which i’m gonna do sooner or later

[south tapir]

Where do I find cougars?

[dark ferry]

there’s a little path past owanjila towards the B in big valley

just ride up that path

[midnight ocean]

also near the legendary moose spawn

[dark ferry]

yea

[midnight ocean]

in the northeast corner of the map

[dark ferry]

but i tried both for awhile

that one seems a little inconsistent

[south tapir]

Thank you guys!

[midnight ocean]

sometimes they appear further south closer to annesburg

[dark ferry]

the path in owanjila usually spawns a cougar every 4-5 days in game

[midnight ocean]

i had to use both to get the cougar bow challenge done

[south tapir]

That's what im trying do

Its not to bad yet

But its definitely painful

[midnight ocean]

thats probably the most annoying hunting challenge

[dark ferry]

i usually just sleep for 3 days and then save, reload sleep for another day and the cougar spawns

[south tapir]

How many days did you say it takes for them to respawn

[dark ferry]

4-5

but after you sleep 3 times the game won’t allow you to do it so save and reload

[south tapir]

Would it work if you just save then load?

If not ill just do what you said

[dark ferry]

you have to sleep 3 times, save and then reload

sleep again once or twice

[south tapir]

Ok ty

[dark ferry]

ride up that path again kill the cougar repeat

you also have to skin it

also you can just give the corpse of the cougar to the trapper for some extra money

[celest tinsel]

this game so goofy man , I got a glitch where arthur started dead eye drawing when I hold right click , every npc got scared shitless and I ended up purging strawberry

[dark ferry]

that’s not a glitch

quick draw!

[celest tinsel]

quick draw is hold left click while holding right click

right click by itself is focus

lmao

[wild plume]

POV Me when i played RDR2 for the first time and saw arthur die:

[wild plume]

Its called deadeye

[celest tinsel]

he was confused , its clear u just baiting tho

[wild plume]

No im just saying

[celest tinsel]

u baitin

[wild plume]

Im literally not

[celest tinsel]

then u straight stupid , sorry to inform u

[wild plume]

Im not gonna argue with you

[celest tinsel]

good lol

[dark ferry]

ah alr

[celest tinsel]

see , he misunderstood , u just a fool bro

[dark ferry]

?

[celest tinsel]

I'm talking with YTghost

[cyan pendant]

Still a dick huh

[cyan pendant]

That’s the one by the trapper right?

I should know this but I forgor

[toxic pier]

just take a ride through roanoke, you'll get back with 5 wolf pelts 2 cougar pelts and a black bear pelt

that's what happened to me tho

[dark ferry]

correct

i don’t know why i didn’t use the trapper as a reference to the location

welp

this is also a great spot for snakes!!

and sometimes wolves

[cyan pendant]

I use that path by hanging dog ranch

For wolves

[trim hamlet]

so I know that horse "bravery" being tied to coat is a giant hoax and is random, but maybe it has weighting towards certain breeds to be higher? cause in the compendium for certain horse breeds, it says stuff like "reliable under pressure" and "is not easily scared by predators or gunfire"

[midnight ocean]

it also says stuff like "their intelligence makes them easy to care for, perfect for ranch work" so idk if i would rely on those descriptions for gameplay lol

[dark ferry]

Am not entirely sure but i really do believe arabian horses are more skittish

i was just afk near train trucks and my level 1 bonded arabian started freaking out just by the train, don’t think my other horses have done this

and they also freak out when you ride em at the top speed

[royal kettle]

I mean I could believe it. I bought another Arabian just to see what the fuss was about and while I wasn't fully bonded with it. It did seem to get the jitters a lot

[midnight ocean]

horses gain courage as you bond with them so it makes sense that a level 1 bond scared easily

[dark ferry]

i haven’t seen other horses get spooked by trains

level bond 1 or not

i can probably test this tomorrow

with an ardennes and an arabian

[pseudo patrol]

The most unrealistic part of this game is the fact that micah even lived to see chapter six with the way he antagonized a gang of ready to shoot outlaws CONSTANTLY

Arthur gets punched by a gang member if he antagonizes the gang too much so I can only imagine what they'd do to micah if he didn't have plot armor??

[royal kettle]

I always think about how many times Arthur could have just killed Miach himself. There were several occasions where he could have done it and nobody would have known

[midnight ocean]

depends on other things like the angle of the horse to the offending object and its prior level of agitation

[royal kettle]

How often does the Panther of Old Henry spawn?

[elfin mesa]

How do I keep Buell after Arthur dies?

[midnight ocean]

by not finishing the questline until the epilogue

[midnight ocean]

i thought it was once per day but maybe im wrong

[royal kettle]

You're probably right. I hunted it before and wanted to hunt it again but didn't know how long it respawned

[elfin mesa]

Thank you

[tall obsidian]

Find it fuhny you can find and collect all azuna orchid cuz its not despawned by the game yet

[crystal night]

About to start my first ever playthrough

Is there anything I should be aware of without spoiling the story?

[wheat ginkgo]

All i see there is a honor system try keeping it as high as possible

[elfin mesa]

How do I find the do not seek absolution mission?

[wheat ginkgo]

To find the "Do Not Seek Absolution" mission, you must play in Chapter 6 with a high honor rank and visit Edith Downes in Annesburg after some chapter 6 missions

[midnight ocean]

yeah stay out of this server lol

you will get spoiled massively

but apart from that i would just say take your time and explore and really take in the game dont rush the story

[royal kettle]

Just explore, hunt, spend time in camp getting to know people, and try to keep Arthur fed regularly. Theres a weight system for both him and his horse.

I was constantly underweight when I played

[reef rose]

Hello

[elfin mesa]

Okok

[desert edge]

Does anyone know a good location where I can find the blood bay thoroughbred? Not having luck lately

[tulip solstice]

got the high honor ending

man what a game

[desert edge]

Nvm I just found a herd of 2

[turbid gate]

what to do if i still dont have dinosaur bone? i played a mission and nothing still

[river island]

do legendary animals respawn cus i stored a legendary coyotes pelt on my horse but it got glitched and i cant take it off my horse and the trapper doesnt have it but i cant sell it to him either

[dark ferry]

the pelt goes to the trapper automatically

and you can’t take pelts off your horse from what i know

Oh. I see okay you don’t need to take the pelt off your horse you can just sell the pelt while your horse is nearby to the trapper

[river island]

i know but its literally glitched , it doesnt show up in the horse cargo, if i make my horse fall the pelt drops but it just shows up as "pelt" and when i try to put it back in my horse it js glitches again

[dark ferry]

what i’d try is just leaving the pelt, the trapper eventually gets it on his own if you lose a legendary pelt

[tall obsidian]

Guys does small animal carcass like those small bird and squirrel carried over into post game?

Or you also lose them just like $

[hybrid moth]

Im playing rdr1 and there is one spot in new austin i didn't explore and idk why i can't find it lmao i've gone everywhere

[dark ferry]

animal carcasses don’t carry over

[hybrid moth]

Agreed

[cerulean pond]

hey why is my original message deleted

[tall obsidian]

God fucking damint so i have to suffer shooting those damn bird for that stupid collectible

[boreal temple]

my name is john marston!!

[tropic depot]

MICAH🗣️🔥🔥🔥

[small storm]

[trim hamlet]

true

but it also says stuff like "their weight makes them difficult to handle" if the horse has Heavy handling

[rough mural]

arabian or missouri fox trotter?

or the thoroughbred from the deluxe edition?

[trim hamlet]

whichever one looks best to you imo

[rough mural]

arabian and missouri are so small in comparison to thoroughbred

[trim hamlet]

arabians are smallest in the game iirc

they look like ponies when arthur is riding lmao

[rough mural]

but the stats on arabian are far more better than thoroughbred

[trim hamlet]

man, f stats honestly

[rough mural]

i mean the stamina and health lmao

[dark ferry]

honestly stamina doesn’t matter heavily on a lot of horses after you’ve gotten them to max bond

just keep pressing L3 every 30ish seconds

[trim hamlet]

is that the calm button?

[dark ferry]

yes

it recharges the horse’s stamina by a considerable amount

[cyan pendant]

I’m surprised a lot of people don’t know that

[trim hamlet]

the core or the bar (okay it's a circle but you know what I mean)?

[rough mural]

the bar

[dark ferry]

it’s the bar

[trim hamlet]

do you have to be at a trot for that to work or no

[dark ferry]

no you just have to be on the horse

just press the calm button

it’ll recharge

the recharge depends on the bond

[trim hamlet]

so at level 4?

[cyan pendant]

Nope

Also yes it’s either level 4. Or 3

[river island]

apparently according to a reddit post this glitchs been around for over 7 years and ppl had the same issue , the pelt js glitches and it counts as if you didnt skin it and the trapper wont have it and you cant get another one, not even the fang for the trinket

[cyan pendant]

Stats don’t matter bro

Only really health does

[hollow mulch]

oh

this is not a mod server right

[south tapir]

Is there side missions only arthur could do? Cause im trying to 100% the game and im on 86.3% I fully completed the story already.

Like maybe side missions i missed when I played as arthur

[royal kettle]

I just found a random 3 star fish lying next to the water. And I am so confused

[brazen wren]

If rdr2 had 60fps on consoles and gameplay as good and smooth as the last of us part 2, I think it would be one of the best

[south tapir]

Does anyone know if there is a map online of every single side mission location on a map? I dont know which ones I've done and not done and where they are located

[midnight ocean]

bounty hunters have them, I've found a wild one by riggs or flatneck station can't remember which

oh oops

[midnight ocean]

not that important imo

[trim hamlet]

see my earlier message lmao

[midnight ocean]

I know the part of arcadia for amateurs with the horses is arthur only

[midnight ocean]

that happens lol

[midnight ocean]

health too tho

[trim hamlet]

fair

but speed/acceleration is not really that impactful I'm p sure

[midnight ocean]

the time saved adds up after a while imo

[trim hamlet]

maybe

but I feel like it's gradual enough where you don't notice it

[trim hamlet]

like, if you're speedrunning, then sure, it'll matter

but for the average player it's not too noticeable unless you're looking for it

[royal kettle]

Does it now?

[midnight ocean]

its not noticeable but with all the traveling around i did on my horse during my whole playthrough im sure i saved a bit of time overall

[trim hamlet]

prolly yeah

[midnight ocean]

thats good enough for me lol

[trim hamlet]

bro just wanted the validation 😭

[midnight ocean]

not really

just explaining my pov

[hidden moss]

im still in chapter two and i was rooming around and i found a cabin just off of saint denis, and i went up to it and there was a guy acting really wierd and he invited me into the house, i havent gone in yet, should i? he says hes got food

[midnight ocean]

save your game first and then decide lol

[hidden moss]

ok

[trim hamlet]

that's generally good advice for anything you're unsure of in the game lmao

[hidden moss]

saved, ima go in now

i got knocked out and i lost a few bucks, thats all

he was talking about me struggling and stuff, what did he mean?

brb

should i go back and get my $1?

my money was at $2021 but now its $2020 and i dont want my money balance the covid year

[trim hamlet]

yes. get the 1

[hidden moss]

ok

but what did he do to me?

[hybrid moth]

Just finished rdr1 too

Should i do gta v? XD idk

[tidal slate]

Haven't said a Thing, but I'm still alive

No progress yet

[sinful mason]

quick question to everyone. what would happen if i kill Micah?

[hybrid moth]

as Arthur or John?

[sinful mason]

i'm currently at Strawberry

Arthur

[hybrid moth]

Sadly mission failed Micah has died

[sinful mason]

ah, ok

[hybrid moth]

wish we could just kill him<

[sinful mason]

gawd, i don't like this mission

hate the guy

[hybrid moth]

the rat

[sinful mason]

gawd, he sucks so much. so scummy

[hybrid moth]

the legendary rat sorry

[pseudo patrol]

the

the 1899 pistol lowk shreds??

and the reload speed is fire???

[rigid kiln]

if you put blackwater on lockdown, then start the mission "A New Future Imagined", you actually cant get your portrait taken because it bugs out

i just tried skipping the checkpoint and i have a black loading screen, so i guess ill have to wait until blackwater isnt on lockdown.

[hybrid moth]

blackwater on lockdown?

[dark ferry]

meaning shooting up the entire place

[dark ferry]

peak

[potent birch]

rdr2 taking so long to download on my pc😭

1 percent got me tweakin

[fathom notch]

It took me almost the whole day yesterday for it to download :/

[dark ferry]

having slow wifi sucks

[brazen wren]

The only legendary fish I have to get now is the largemouth bass, redfin pickerel, and rock bass

[midnight ocean]

dont even have to do that

all i did was rob the tailors cash register and i got it put on lockdown

maybe because i had a bounty already

[royal kettle]

2 more cougars and then I'm finally done with this awful challenge

[azure sluice]

could someone check #red-dead-media rq

[lunar sky]

seach saddle bags

haha just filled you with dread

[small quiver]

Angel Batista

[earnest sky]

What are you talking about

[lunar sky]

have you never tried that

prepare to be filled

with dread

[frank cedar]

Did jack have kids

[copper cave]

Not even gon fake

Im lowkey the lebron of this shit 💯 🤕 🤧

[dark ferry]

maybe if i didn’t exist

[unkempt bronze]

Hey guys, I’m in RDR2 for the god knows how many-th time. But for some reason I never thought of this. But in the mission where you go hunting with Hosea, you HAVE to buy a new horse, can’t even use that shire. But if I sold that and bought the second best one there, can I sell it for a profit if I bond with it later? I wanna get that Hungarian Halfbred from the Polish guy cause I prefer that

And I also don’t wanna ever let Arthur use a Morgan cause I have more respect for my man’s than that

[dark ferry]

you’ll probably get like a 80 dollar profit and that’s being generous

[unkempt bronze]

That’s sound then lol, worth it

I use a few mods to make getting money tougher so £80 profit is pretty good

[dark ferry]

i usually sell the shrine buy the cheapest horse and get another horse

[unkempt bronze]

I would use the Morgan just for that mission

But man it’s tiny

It’s so smol

Shire is cool and I would’ve rather just use that

For until I get the Hungarian anyway

[copper cave]

Who is you yng 😭 ✌️

Gng

[dark ferry]

the goat?

[copper cave]

Ah myf

[dark ferry]

i’m simply the best rdr2 player. Anyone who says otherwise is worse and a hater

[maiden robin]

How do you play as different characters in rdr2?

[warm torrent]

in story mode, you can only play as john and arthur

to play as marston, you would have to finish the story mode to end in the epilouge

however, you cannot play as other characters besides those two, unless with mods

[unkempt bronze]

Should’ve had a Sadie and Charles DLC

Or a Sadie and Javier DLC

Like TBoGT and TLAD

[unkempt bronze]

I had to leave the bird who had her leg trapped under her horse after saving her cause I had the legendary bear pelt

Will I see this Event again or is it one and done

Can’t recall

[elder sequoia]

Hi guys. Do you know the best Spot for finding owls? I tried so much guides but had no luck...

[unkempt bronze]

Try barns at night maybe?

[paper star]

@unkempt bronze i want red dead redemption 3 as sadie adler

[cyan pendant]

No there will littarly be nothing to do

[unkempt bronze]

Nah I’m more for either prequel as Dutch or Sequel as Jack in a more mafia inspired time

More a fan of Dutch, just to fill up that

But wouldn’t mind either way

[elder sequoia]

Yeah got 2 there but Californian Horned Owl won't appear :/

[trim hamlet]

pretty sure you can elect to keep the shire

[midnight ocean]

wouldn't it be better to keep the shire and sell it later

what's the point of buying the second horse

[unkempt bronze]

You HAVE to buy a horse anyway

Anyway I just want the Hungarian Halfbred

[trim hamlet]

no
you can keep the shire

[azure sluice]

Trapper clothes are 10x better than tailor clothes bro they’re awesome

I’m trying to get every set

[dark ferry]

i’m glad to see somebody is just as unemployed and dedicated as i am ☺️

[midnight ocean]

the principal vest solos all other vests

[azure sluice]

real

cleanest one in the game

[midnight ocean]

it also perfectly matches the black stalker hat because they both have the brown trim

[azure sluice]

I’m still in school bro I got nothing better to do 😭

[azure sluice]

don’t have it yet though

I don’t have the bear set yet

[midnight ocean]

i made a point of unlocking every single thing from him this playthrough

[azure sluice]

tailor clothes are just

boring

there isn’t much you can do with them aside from a few cool outfits

otherwise it’s meh

trapper clothes are unique

[midnight ocean]

also decking yourself out in all fur and going to ambarino

fur hat fur jacket fur vest fur chaps

[azure sluice]

🔥

[midnight ocean]

warm and toasty af

[azure sluice]

then you burn to death in Rhodes

[midnight ocean]

lol

heat stroke

[azure sluice]

awesome

[unkempt bronze]

Yes you can. But even if you do, you HAVE to buy a new horse anywa

I just sold him for money, got the Morgan, sold the Morgan and I’m just gonna get the Hungarian Halfbred

[trim hamlet]

no, you can press Esc i'm pretty sure

[unkempt bronze]

Nah I don’t think so, maybe I just missed it though, doesn’t matter all that much to me anyway cause I never use Shires

[azure sluice]

shires are beautiful but painfully slow

[trim hamlet]

fair
do u like the bigger look tho?

[trim hamlet]

exactly
I mean, some warhorses do have a bigger build but have Standard handling which is nice

[midnight ocean]

i think reality is correct

even if you keep the shire you have to buy another horse anyway

which is really stupid lol

[unkempt bronze]

It’s cool! It’s just not how I picture Arthur personally. Warhorses are what I think he would ride

[trim hamlet]

yeah i have him riding an Ardennes (shocker, I know)

[unkempt bronze]

John I can picture with a race or Like a Fox Trotter

[river island]

is it normal for the wagon in "the fine joys of tobacco" to be THIS slow? like sean even comments on how slow im going but i cant speed it up

[midnight ocean]

the acceleration controls on pc are weird from what ive heard

maybe you're just not pressing the button right

[lime crest]

for bandit 7, i assume the people of saint denis will on average have the most money on them to give me?

[midnight ocean]

rob a train

[lime crest]

THATS an idea

these challenges are RUINING Johns reputation tho

[midnight ocean]

lol

yeah my johns honor aint great

[lime crest]

i was like, high neutral. now it's solidly dishonourable

[dark ferry]

if you take a train to annesburg, wait a little until the train is near the mountain where the legendary moose area is the law won’t be alerted if you’re fast enough

[verbal ingot]

Howdy, I’m new on this server, I need help finding the roles, please

[dark ferry]

also there’s a cart with people in fancier clothes and they give ya more money

[dark ferry]

you got most the roles already 🤔

#roles

[verbal ingot]

Oh, but the one for having the best in the west, in game

It says I need to DM someone there, but I can’t

[dark ferry]

i believe it’s modmail am not sure tho

[verbal ingot]

Yeah, someone send it to me on general chat

[lime crest]

oh I know how to rob a rain lol

[verbal ingot]

Are you doing those challenges?

[brave marsh]

I'm new to rdr2 can someone help me how can I get rid of the bounty?

[cyan pendant]

Head to the post office

[brave marsh]

Yea ik 🤔 but is there any other way?

If I don't have money then?

[verbal ingot]

You need to do some stuff to get money then, that bounty is gonna follow you until you get rid of it

[brave marsh]

Ohh 😮 so I have to pay in post office anyway it means

Thanks you both 😊

[verbal ingot]

No problem

[cyan pendant]

Uh no

Just fight the bounty hunters if you can’t pay the law

[brave marsh]

I was doing this the whole time 😂 but I think I need some honour in game too

[trim hamlet]

greetings

[plucky hawk]

How do you undo eating rat poison

[trim hamlet]

See, that's the neat part. You don't.

[latent glade]

just made it to banking, the old american art i am not emotionally prepared for this

[cyan pendant]

Nah let the intrusive thoughts win

[brave marsh]

Just died with $780 bounty i was stuck in a room with too many ppl I didn't notice someone had seen me robbing 😂

Well but I got the weapon in Rhodes

[snow veldt]

rdr2 is so fun that I spent 4-5 hours playing it thinking i only played for like 2-3 hours

[lethal sleet]

i killed a legendary animal, ram i think, and only picked up the skin when i skinned it - no meat or other parts of the animal, and now i am unable to craft the trinket because of that. internet said legendary animals don’t respawn so i didn’t know if y’all had a work around.

[snow veldt]

once a legendary animal is killed and you loose the hide or the animal completely the game should automatically put it in for you to craft the gear and stuff.

[cyan pendant]

Yeah you can get lost in it

There is so much content

[deep glacier]

I was on it for 6 hours the other night. Couldn’t stop playing

[snow veldt]

I’m on my second game, already beat it once, but I couldn’t fully get 100% because I never discovered the snake on the jungle island, I think I’m taking things slow now

I never really payed that much attention to the little details but now I am

[deep glacier]

I beat it for the first time couple nights ago. I learned pretty fast you need multiple saves lmao

[snow veldt]

you don’t need multiple but it’s nice to have a few, like I’m keeping a save for the beginning of each chapter

[lethal sleet]

i’ll have to go back to the fence and see if i’m able to craft. thanks!

[snow veldt]

should be automatic that’s how the game does it, at least when I died from bounty hunters once with a legendary pelt it was automatically put into the trappers shop

[lethal sleet]

i wonder if it had anything to do with my satchel being full

[snow veldt]

wouldn’t be from that, you’re satchel can hold legendary horns, claws and other things but the meat, that’s different it shouldn’t be the reason

try fast traveling somewhere

[royal kettle]

Well the LeMat revolver just saved me. I'm doing the hunt 5 cougars with a bow challenge and as I ride along the rails north of Annesburg one comes out of nowhere. Fortunately I had the LeMat equipped with a shotgun shell and scared the thing off and then was able to kill it with a bow

[dark ferry]

i did not know you could scare off cougars

[royal kettle]

You can if you give them a face full of shotgun shells

Damages the pelt but I survived

[dark ferry]

ah i see i see

[snow veldt]

I hated that one, worst then killing a bear with throwing knives

trick is with the throwing knives though is to use poisson throwing knives

[royal kettle]

Well luckily I have some. But yeah that cougar challenge was awful. Luckily I'm done with it now which means I now need to hunt a herbivore and predator. Which as I understand it is easy as long as I don't fire my weapon

[snow veldt]

I gotta redo all of them, I restarted so I could 100% the game this time instead of 98% of it

but I’m making progress taking it slow

good luck

[austere narwhal]

yo

im new here

any tips to give while playing as john?

ive completed red dead 3 times now

[royal kettle]

I've been thinking of restarting too because there's a lot of things I missed out on. Like fully upgrading camp and certain camp interactions

[brave marsh]

Same for me this game is very fun

[silent plover]

guys i found a glitch in the epilogue

where you can play as Arthur

[brave marsh]

I didn't even know if we can change characters 😭

[silent plover]

want me to explain it?

[brave marsh]

Yes please

Well only If you got time

[silent plover]

so you have to go to the del lobo hideout near tumbleweed

Kill the del lobos then go under the third to last light atfer this you can't play as John anymore so make a save. load any mission from chapters 2-3-4 i used the misson a fine night for debachury if you do it use should die and respawn as Arthur but the money and outfit wont transfer

and when you make a camp and try to fast travel it wont work

[brave marsh]

🤔 thanks it will help me in future
that was a lot to type

[royal kettle]

Once again I go off on the quest to find a 3 star moose. Hopefully it doesn't take as long as last time. And worst case apparently one always spawns a little past the loft if you wait long enough

[royal kettle]

Well I found one up at the loft but despite being shot directly in the head it still managed to run off. And after shooting it in the head again it gave me a good pelt. Thanks a lot game

[tulip solstice]

yo guys what's the sogn that plays before Arthur confronts Micah and Dutch he's like on a horse all happy and shit

[royal kettle]

May I stand unshaken?

Or that's the way it is

[placid wadi]

im sure its that's the way it is

if its the scene where he hears em voices from the past too

amazing song tho

[placid wadi]

no way imma have to see if this works

[oblique quiver]

That’s the way it is

[lime crest]

OOF these bandit challenges have dragged john from high neutral honour to SOLIDLY min honour

[tulip solstice]

thanks fellas

[lime crest]

chat idk if this reinforced bandit gear was worth it

[visual skiff]

sup yall

[tall obsidian]

Im pretty sure every challenge get you extra stat boost so yeah i guess

Could be useful if you planning medal objective dont use tonic (hillariously overpowered mgl)

[lime crest]

true but I'm end game as John I already have Max on most

[dark ferry]

there’s a spot where moose’s spawn more commonly

i’ll try uhhhh describing the spot

[royal kettle]

Up in Roanoke?

Apparently there's also one that spawns by Colter

[dark ferry]

actually i think an image would be better

wait

well it’s in red dead media

the moose does spawn out of bounds and is unreachable by the player but if you shoot your rifle around the moose and spook it, it’ll eventually run and be within bounds

make sure not to shoot the moose while it’s out of bounds

i am pretty sure it only spawns in during the mornings to noon

[royal kettle]

Oh that moose

Yeah I uh made that mistake once. Thought it wasn't that steep

[dark ferry]

😭

[royal kettle]

I'm still getting used to not being able Skyrim my way up mountains and hills

Its an outrage I tell you

Fortunately I managed to get a moose by the widows house. Decent enough place to hunt with good views. Plus its far enough away from the cougar

[dark ferry]

I’ve somehow just stumbled across moose’s each play through

i was hunting for that bear encounter near the cabin and i see a moose just chilling

[snow veldt]

getting a moose is annoying but I believe there’s 3 places that you can find a moose almost instantly for going there first time

[royal kettle]

I would have gotten my moose at the loft if it wasn't bullet proof

Makes me realize why people use poison arrows

[snow veldt]

improved arrow to the head works

might need 2 to the head

[dark ferry]

i just use a Springfield

[royal kettle]

That's what I used

[snow veldt]

that’s how I got my moose

[dark ferry]

mooses are also quite fast, hard to catch up

[cerulean pond]

am john MARSTOOON dU DU duD ud DUudUD DU du DuUUh bu Bu dU DU du DU dudu DU duDu DUuUuh EH uH

[potent estuary]

idk I was riding a white shire

[quick glen]

@frosty quail Sorry for the ping but about that photo in red dead fashion, where did you get the hat

Is that a mod?

[frosty quail]

I stole it

from an annesburg guard

[quick glen]

Can you save it?

[frosty quail]

no sadly it was supposed to be a savable but the textures were different leading you cannot save it

you can get it from whyem dlc I think

[quick glen]

There’s a savable version?

With another texture?

[frosty quail]

yes beaver drifter hat or the one uncle gives

[quick glen]

Okay thanks

[south tapir]

Does anyone know how to max your horses stats fast?

[frosty quail]

just ride with the horse while feeding it for 1 hour and 45 minutes

[frosty quail]

@quick glen you can get it at online at any general store I think

[quick glen]

I don’t play online

[frosty quail]

ok

[south tapir]

Ill try that ty!

[trim hamlet]

@dark ferry

[dark ferry]

you can just lead the horse while stopping every few minutes to feed and brush the horse.

[deep inlet]

guys

hello

[dark ferry]

Get some peppermints or sugar cubes as they increase the bonding faster

helo

[trim hamlet]

henlo

[unkempt bronze]

what do we think

the regular vanilla green

or yellow of the heartplains mod

i'll share in the media channel

[brave marsh]

So it doesn't matter if I buy or tame a good horse? 🤔 Becuz I can always increase the stats of my current horse? 🤔

[south tapir]

Ok ty!

[dark ferry]

some horse breeds have more health or stamina than others

tho stamina matters little if you’re max bond

[dapper birch]

Worst mechanic is the goddamn saving

[dark ferry]

it might be arthur automatically putting his weapons away on the horse

[frank cedar]

Why if you shoot Micah immediately judge instantly shoots you but if you wait a minute, he shoots Micah for you

Dutch

[gritty zinc]

Do I actually need to be washing my horse

[twin trail]

judge?

[frank cedar]

Dutch

[twin trail]

ohh

[lethal sleet]

increases bonding, which will level up your horse’s stamina and health. i’d say so.

[twin trail]

dutch is crazy

chat i accidentally killed buell so badly no horse reviver could save him

[gritty zinc]

Also I’m confused about the premium cigarettes. Do they have the cards in them? How can I get the card without smoking them cuz I don’t care for the effects

[twin trail]

yes, if you buy premium ciggaretes u get a card (duplicates sometimes of cards u alr have)

you can also find cards around the map

[gritty zinc]

How do I get the card out of the packets though. My inventory is full of premium cigarettes

[twin trail]

they alr are out

when you buy you get

• premium ciggaretes
• card

two different items

[gritty zinc]

Ohhh only if u buy? Not if u find the cigarettes

[twin trail]

if u find i don’t think so

i buy loads and discard them, care for the cards only

i accidentally overwrited my best save

[foggy river]

Hello, can i still buy the bear hunter items from the trappers once i've sold the legendary bear pelt to them?

[midnight ocean]

yes you get a card if you find a pack

you can also just find loose cards

if your inventory is full of cigarettes tho you have to smoke one or discard them so you can pick up another pack

[midnight ocean]

yes

[foggy river]

Do i need to go back to the same trapper?

[midnight ocean]

no, its all the same guy he just "moves around" lol

its also worth noting that its ok if you dont get the actual pelt to him, once you kill the corresponding animal the pelt is "unlocked" at the trapper. but actually bringing it to him and selling will get you a good amount of cash

because it is possible to lose the pelt by dying while its on your horse

[cyan pendant]

Except you get no money out of it

[foggy river]

I see

[midnight ocean]

i think i covered that lol

[lethal sleet]

is there a reason why there aren’t as many shops/gunsmiths as you move west on the map? kinda figured that shops weren’t around since RDR2 is a prequel to RDR1.

[midnight ocean]

armadillo is abandoned in 1907 due to cholera

thieves landing is run by a gang

that pretty much just leaves tumbleweed

[lethal sleet]

yeah they’re always complaining about it when you pass thru. thought it was cool that developers took timeline into consideration when they developed the map

[midnight ocean]

i think it was just an excuse because they didnt have time to finish it tbh

they had to cut nuevo pariso entirely

[coarse pike]

@midnight ocean The Bacchus Station Demolition mission with John, right? I already did it

[midnight ocean]

yes

how much money are you putting away? im curious

[coarse pike]

$3,755 was more, approximately $4,400, but Arthur gave John's inheritance to several people in Chapter 6 and I helped that man build his house south of Valentine with $100

so, there is 3700 left

[midnight ocean]

nice

you wont need it anyway

pretty sure i've only gained money since starting the epilogue, even without the final payout

[vital flicker]

I replayed a mission The King's son and got a death message, and then I appeared as arthur. I quit the game and opened it again and now I'm john but in 1899 how do I go back

[coarse pike]

Yes, anyway I can loot some places and secure 200 dollars just in case, but I will do the pig farm mission so I don't forget

Thanks woolie!

[midnight ocean]

how do you know you're in 1899

[vital flicker]

Arthur's face is on pause menu, when I open save file editor it says I'm arthur

Hanging dog ranch is empty etc

[vital flicker]

The character is john but the game treats it as if it was arthur

[midnight ocean]

wdym

[vital flicker]

I mean that the world is literally in 1899

Not 1907

[midnight ocean]

okay but can you give like one example lol

like you're wanted dead or alive in the southern part of west eliz?

[vital flicker]

Like blackwater isn't as built, hanging dog ranch is empty, there are odriscoll camps

[vital flicker]

Nah

[midnight ocean]

blackwater is still under construction in 1907 also

and hanging dog ranch is still a gang hideout right

[vital flicker]

No

It's how it was in 1899

[midnight ocean]

theres no odriscolls or laramie gang?

[vital flicker]

No

And when I open the save file editor it says I'm arthur

It's weird I've never seen this happen

[midnight ocean]

did you glitch back into arthur on purpose?

[vital flicker]

No

I was completing challenges and wanted to replay a mission for it

And I got a death screen

And reloaded as arthur

[midnight ocean]

where were you when you started the mission replay

[vital flicker]

At east point cabin

[midnight ocean]

six point cabin?

[vital flicker]

Yeah that

[midnight ocean]

sucks

reload a save from before you did that otherwise idk

what challenge were you trying to get

[vital flicker]

I saved unfortunately I didnt know the game glitched out

Don't really have any other save

And I was at 93%

Can I edit my save some way

[midnight ocean]

gotta save often and use all those slots the game gives you

you have 15 save slots lol just saving over the same one again and again is crazy

[vital flicker]

I have multiple but I thought it was safe so I saved on all of them

[midnight ocean]

is beechers hope there?

[vital flicker]

Yeah

[vital flicker]

It's pretty weird

Beechers is there but some things around the map are different

[midnight ocean]

so its more like a bugged version of 1907

i mean maybe you can still finish the challenges

which ones do you need

[vital flicker]

Last 2 for herbalist and last weapon expert

[midnight ocean]

well you can still get those right

[midnight ocean]

can i ask which mission you replayed btw?

[vital flicker]

The king's son

[midnight ocean]

hmmm

[vital flicker]

Blackwater is in it's 1907 state so it's some weird mesh

[midnight ocean]

thats a funny coincidence

you just so happened to do the exact thing explained by this five month old reddit post as a way to play as arthur in the epilogue

[vital flicker]

It was actually on complete accident

[midnight ocean]

sure thing lol

[vital flicker]

I wanted to do the weapons expert 9

And that mission is the best for it

If i was doing on purpose I would have saved

[midnight ocean]

and you made sure to do it immediately after clearing six points cabin right

[vital flicker]

Nah six point cabin didnt have nobody

In the first place

[midnight ocean]

so what were you doing there

[vital flicker]

Wanted to complete it there but realised its empty in the epilogue

Why does it matter

[midnight ocean]

because this guy gives instructions on how to do this glitch which is to clear a hideout and then immediately replay the kings son

but i guess those are both good ways to get stealth kills with the bow

[vital flicker]

Sucks

[midnight ocean]

maybe you can do another mission replay and fix it

[hybrid moth]

where can i get the legendary rat?

[snow veldt]

have you completed the main story?

If so it should be at the top of one of the mountains not sure which one

[tidal slate]

I found legendary Rats if I open the Door 🚪 and watch inside the Staircase

There are always legendary Rats outside called Neighbours

[midnight ocean]

hagen

[hybrid moth]

murican venom? yeah no worry was just curious to see the answers 😂

[tidal slate]

I haven't touched the Game yet, I can't be asked to spend frustrating Time within Blackjack

[snow veldt]

well you asked where the legendary rat is, and if I’m correct you can’t get it till you complete the main story

[midnight ocean]

me chilling at the blackjack table in rhodes:

[tidal slate]

If you would be on the other Side,I would bribe you to give me bad Cards

I should try to contact Rockstar and say please give me a decent Card Dealer

[midnight ocean]

lol

just keep grinding bro itll be over before you know it

[tidal slate]

Well, if I catch the 10 fishes I need to

Because there is nothing else

Beside the Missions changing to Gold

[midnight ocean]

well remember you dont need gold medals for 100% thats just for that achievement

[tidal slate]

I know 🙂 but... Well...

I guess with the 100 % you get two achievements at once

[midnight ocean]

which ones

oh the graves?

[tidal slate]

No the get Health, Stamina and Deadeye+ full completion

[midnight ocean]

dont think that is an achievement

[tidal slate]

On Steam it is

[stone thicket]

should i replay rdr2?

[midnight ocean]

whats it called?

[midnight ocean]

yes

[tidal slate]

What do I mix now?! I thought it says reach max health Stamina and Deadeye

Is that in-game but not an achievement

[midnight ocean]

its a requirement for 100%

but you should get that well before completing the epilogue

[tidal slate]

Ah... Well that explains it

I haven't got it inside the epilogue

[midnight ocean]

but if you save visiting the graves for last you will get that achievement at the same time as best in the west

[tidal slate]

At least John is now at Level 8

I guess you reach Level 9 with the Herbalist and 10 with the Gambling one

At least... I thought so

[midnight ocean]

think all the challenge sets apply evenly to the last two levels

the first eight can be gained without doing challenges

[foggy valve]

just finished the Epilogue story for the first time!! I did not expect to be as emotional as I was upon seeing the scenes in the credits

which is silly of me, of course I'd be emotional as all hell

[midnight ocean]

good stuff

[fluid scarab]

Peak moment was the last mission right?

[foggy valve]

it was SO GOOD. I had gotten a few spoilers but it was still exciting as hell

and even the stuff that was spoiled still made me jump from my seat

also that little flute... at the end of the American Venom theme..... so perfect

[fluid scarab]

I still remember when I first got there

It was so epic 😎

[foggy valve]

I had a moment of total ridiculousness as the game decided to equip the varmint rifle, of all things as I went up that trail

thankfully I also had the Lichfield but for a sec I just didn't understand why my headshots weren't downing the enemies

[fluid scarab]

Should I continue using the bolt action rifle of switch to the Lancaster?

[foggy valve]

honestly I went through the entire game with the bolt action rifle, its damage potential is insane

but I think it's a matter of how used you are to either one of 'em

[desert root]

i hate micah

[midnight ocean]

i prefer the repeaters for regular combat

unless its like super long ranges

but you can equip two primaries anyway

i prefer the repeater because it fires faster and you only need one shot to kill anyway so its not like the bolt actions extra damage is doing much

plus you can use special ammo to increase your damage anyway

[snow veldt]

I watched my uncle complete it and when I got there on my own, I still felt heartbroken even though I knew what exactly was gonna happen

[deep glacier]

Which scene was your favorite?

[midnight ocean]

sigh

well i know the downfall of having a bounty now

any minor offense in a town will put it on lockdown

[foggy valve]

from the final mission it's probably the part right after Micah gets shot. the way he's not even angry... it's perfectly in line with Micah's belief about there being no good or evil, just living and dying. what a brilliant piece of writing and acting

[midnight ocean]

i found a baby buffalo all alone 🥺

[deep glacier]

That’s a good scene for sure but I was referring to the ending credits, which one was your favorite?

[foggy valve]

oh my bad. hmmm lemme think.
I was delighted by Mary Beth and by Pearson. but I think my favourite thing was the reoccurring scenes of Pinkertons on the hunt.... gave me chills

[midnight ocean]

ok this is silly now

i killed a few bounty hunters in the heartlands and now valentine is on lockdown

[deep glacier]

You’re good LOL. The Pearson one was my favorite cause it was sad watching him look at the picture of the gang and just smile. Tugged at my heart strings for real🥹

[foggy valve]

YEAH!! Pearson tugged at my heartstrings whenever I visited his shop

[deep glacier]

I still visit his shop just to see what voice line he’ll say🥹

[foggy valve]

that's my good friend Pearson and I'm sure nothing bad will happen to him off screen

even with Pinkerton agents on the prowl

[grizzled cedar]

Micah gives Arthur the 2nd holster. However, he has 2 after this. This implies that this man was tri-wielding

[tulip solstice]

guys I forgot the name of the sogn id asked I got a fat head man can someon remind em again

the sogn that's playing before confronting Dutch and micah

can't even find it on google

[deep glacier]

That’s the way it is

[tulip solstice]

thanks bro

also

do you get different endings if u make the final Arthur choice at different honor levels

[deep glacier]

Yes. It’s dependent on what you choose to do and your honor level

[hidden moss]

You’re a chump, partner

[opal lava]

I kinda think it's funny that I always have some sort of ring in my inventory