red-dead-singleplayer

[midnight ocean]

dont shoot the gun shoot the hand

[earnest sky]

They will drop a rifle but it takes more shots

Not worth it tho

[midnight ocean]

saving and quitting doesnt lose your pelts

dying does

[earnest sky]

Well I’m still alive and my pelts are gone

[midnight ocean]

you respawn when you die lol

its not like it reverts to an old save like other games

there is also sometimes a visual bug where pelts on your horse appear to disappear but if you check the horses inventory they will be there

[earnest sky]

I meant I didn’t die

And they’re nowhere

[tidal slate]

I did that Mission where you need to kill a Grizzly with a Throwing Knife on suprise

I had one Poisoned Knife left and a damn Bear turned up. Mission complete

At least I did that... X.x

[regal matrix]

weapons expert challenge 10

[tidal slate]

Yes...

I'm slowly and more Slow then Motion doing progress in heading to 💯 %

Sometimes it sounds so easy while ppl saying do this and that, went there and go... But I can't do it

[cyan pendant]

Well their is a spawn next to Wallace station

[tidal slate]

I still got issues to disarm 3 Enemy's, heck knows. I think I must be more patient...

Some Reddit Posts claim, I should use Poison Arrows and shoot them in the 🦵 legs...

Because they should drop their Weapons before they die and this counts as disarming

I might try this?!

[tall obsidian]

How long until you get RBR again?

I just got one super early lol... I think its lenny's RBR 💀

[cyan pendant]

Just grab 1899 pistols duel wield them and then you got 18 shots

[meager basalt]

Anyone here use the Basic Needs mod? I can't ask on the website because of course the creator disabled posts and bug reports.

It's ruining my experience so far. I was hoping to enjoy some survival mechanisms that make the game a bit more difficult but this is ridiculous. My cores all drained to absolute zero during the prologue and my stamina core being drained to zero made it impossible to jump on the train.

Anyone else have cores draining way too quickly and/or during cutscenes or how to fix it? I'll binge eat food and then a couple minutes later there's a red vignette flashing on the screen to indicate my cores are fully drained.

[restive siren]

You can do it with scofield revolver to

[restive siren]

Did you do it after arthur got tb or as john

[tidal slate]

Did anyone tried it with the Poisoned arrows? It might work to be fair

[raven skiff]

Hellloo. im turning to you guys after trying fucking everything but my rdr2 keeps crashing my gpu and throwing me out of the game completely randomly and giving me black screens. yes i have tried every single advice on whatever website i could find but it just does not work. is anybody having similar problems?
i have an RTX 3080 and Ryzen 9 5900x

[trim hamlet]

#pc-technical-stuff

[midnight ocean]

what's going wrong when you try to do it normally? are you not able to hit their hands?

[lime crest]

is thirsting allowed here

bc 1907 john lemme teLL YA

[midnight ocean]

he's married chill

[lime crest]

what happens in saint denis stays in saint denis

[desert edge]

Hey guys about Jeremy gill, um so is the mission completed when he gets sucked into to ocean or do I have to do smt else

[north pendant]

Any of you guys have a favourite revolver/pistol you used for the majority of the game

[grand sluice]

Schofield

[north pendant]

Bullshit

For nearly the entire game I used a kitted out schofield

[desert edge]

Schofield too

[north pendant]

Im unoriginal

Did you guys pair it with anything?

[desert edge]

I've just full on copied the twd cast

[lime crest]

yeah, a second schofield

i jest, i used volcanics

[north pendant]

Jesus christ 😭

[lime crest]

then replaced them with 1899s

[desert edge]

I have a shotgun, broken pirate sword, 2 schofields to represent colt pythons

[north pendant]

You can get a broken pirate sword?

[desert edge]

Maybe even a bow for daryl when i feel nice

[desert edge]

Yeah

Broken pirate sword to represent Lucille

[midnight ocean]

[north pendant]

That's cool

I liked the pump action a lot toward the end

[midnight ocean]

also two schofields because theyre just too good

great for the gold medals where you need to only use revolvers for the whole mission

[north pendant]

I just used it because I thought it looked cool

Aurafarming I guess

[desert edge]

I also used lemats for a while

They're reliable

[midnight ocean]

theres also a challenge for getting a certain number of kills with long barreled sidearms i think and the schofield has a long barrel by default

[lime crest]

Man, rachel's coat is gorgous isn't it. that black with the undertones of browny red

[midnight ocean]

as john i tried to mostly use cattlemans

[desert edge]

I like algernon and Micah gun as well since I busted my ah to get the algernon one and it has "TaHIITIAN peaRls"

[midnight ocean]

i used mine a couple times and that was it

i think i currently have otis millers and boy calloways equipped for the drip

[grand sluice]

Sliver and gold a good pair

[north pendant]

I really liked the blue scout jacket, I even used it as john

[lime crest]

i'm talking about Johns horse LOL

[north pendant]

Oh damn

Mb

[desert edge]

Yeah for drip I use my schofield "colt python copy" and algernons revolver

Damn I sold Rachel

[midnight ocean]

i like the blood bay thoroughbred

nice pretty red and a cool name

[desert edge]

I like the splashed white am3rican paint

[midnight ocean]

but i did keep rachel in my stable because i couldnt bear to sell her

[raven skiff]

Its a no access channel..

[north pendant]

Who the hell is Rachel

[midnight ocean]

johns horse

[north pendant]

Is it?

[trim hamlet]

go to id:customize and get the PC role

[midnight ocean]

yes?

[desert edge]

Well the witcher 4 is coming out in like 2027 do yall think it can come close to rdr2 horse graphics?

[north pendant]

Sadies horse in the epilogue is really pretty

[desert edge]

I kinda doubt it but I find amusing the idea of riding a what it looked to be like a friesian

[midnight ocean]

graphics? maybe. but will it control as smoothly

[lime crest]

i love how we all know you're asking about the horses balls

[raven skiff]

I have?…

[midnight ocean]

that thing is a monster lol

[north pendant]

Yeah but its got a cool name

[trim hamlet]

uh, it doesn't say you did in your profile

[desert edge]

No, but nice to point out lol, I doubt that it will work like rdr2

[raven skiff]

I swear its ticked in but i dont get the updated role..

[grand sluice]

What did y'all name your horse

[desert edge]

I feel like the graphics will be insane

[north pendant]

What one

[lime crest]

daphne. she was a white arabian

[midnight ocean]

rdb throughbred was henry, silver mft is mercury

[desert edge]

Is it worth even buying the witcher 3 since the witcher 4 is coming out

[lime crest]

yes

[north pendant]

First one was Kharne, Second was Phillipe.

[trim hamlet]

la refinida (the refined)

[raven skiff]

I guess it worked now.. Sorry for the confusion.

[desert edge]

My splashed American paint is named Lois

[north pendant]

Its a bit basic but the white Arabian is really solid

[desert edge]

Yeah I just find it too small for arthur or John personally and I don't care about stats so I tend to go for a lil larger horses

I had a red arabian for some time tho

[lime crest]

thats like asking is it even worth watching A New Hope since The Empire Strikes Back is coming out

[midnight ocean]

i too prefer the medium or large sizied horsies

[north pendant]

I was gonna find the black Arabian but I was in the area and I knew it was around there for my first time

[midnight ocean]

i bought witcher 3 on sale months ago and never touched it lol

[north pendant]

Witcher three is really good I recommend it

[midnight ocean]

isnt that one purchasable

[north pendant]

I think its lurking around saint Denis and you can steal it

[lime crest]

i personally didn't enjoy it, but thats 1000% a me issue. its a phenomenal game, just not for me

[desert edge]

Yeah but I feel like witcher 4 is going to be peak

[midnight ocean]

its also not coming out for a long time so why not play 3 in the meantime

[trim hamlet]

define "a lil larger"

like we talking hungarian, or like shire?

[north pendant]

Thats how i feel about bioshock, idk why but I just dont really enjoy it

Dishonoured is really good, reminds me of it

[midnight ocean]

bioshock is pretty dated now

[desert edge]

Maybe like a turkoman

[lime crest]

i liked one and 2, didn't get on with infinite though

[desert edge]

I do enjoy riding my paint tho

[north pendant]

Wonder what space marines three will be like

[trim hamlet]

It will be even more pro-Emperor.

[north pendant]

The magic corpse?

Khorne on top

[desert edge]

Rn I'm either contemplating buying rdr1 + undead nightmare expansion since it has dope horses or waiting to get the witcher 4

[lime crest]

this isn't about any of y'all but i've never understood the trend of dismissing an older property in a franchise as soon as the new one comes out. reminds me of Andy throwing away woody in toy story cos buzz is there

[north pendant]

Yeah is rdr1 good? I might play it next

[desert edge]

I haven't played it but it obviously is way smaller in terms of hours than rdr2 and the graphics aren't as good but if u can get a good deal on it why not

Personally I feel like imma wait for the witcher 4

[midnight ocean]

i mean if it was coming out soon i kinda get it, you dont wanna be in the middle of your first witcher 3 playthrough when 4 comes out

but it doesnt even have a release date afaik lol

[midnight ocean]

most games are smaller than rdr2 that doesnt mean you shouldnt play em dawg

[lime crest]

meh, why does it matter? if you're halfway through TW3, just finish that before you start TW4

[desert edge]

Didn't say you shouldn't play

[midnight ocean]

because when 4 releases you're probably not gonna wanna wait

you're gonna wanna dive right in

[desert edge]

Roach is peak but I think that I'll like kelpie

[midnight ocean]

sounded like you were citing that as a reason for just waiting for 4

[desert edge]

I was talking about me lol that if it was me I would get the witcher 4 but if someone wants rdr1 who am I to stop them lol? I'd get it too

[tidal slate]

I am, but as I said. It seems to do something wrong... I can count 1 or 2 Hits of them and then the Counter resets to 0 and I haven't reloaded or switch the Weapon

And I'm using Deadeye ofc

[desert edge]

Also are there any like plain palomino horses in rdr2 a palomino has been stuck on my head for weeks

[midnight ocean]

clip it if you can

[midnight ocean]

i know but it sounded like you were saying you would pass up on w3 because of graphics and content volume being inferior to rdr2

[tidal slate]

I'll do that... It's kinda piss me off, because I tried it serval Times. Shoot the Hands,Arms,Shoulders (as different Parts and trying) or even only the hand doesn't matter if handguns or rifles for the enemy. Heck I'm even using pistols or Lancaster on my own ...

[midnight ocean]

yeah only go for the hand and only enemies with pistols

[tidal slate]

And I rly wanna try the Poisoned arrow Thing if that works

[midnight ocean]

dont go for the shoulder or arm

and try to avoid enemies with a rifle or repeater

where are you trying to do it at

[tidal slate]

? What do you mean

[midnight ocean]

at what location are you trying to get the challenge

[tidal slate]

Ah, at the Moment on that Farm near Strawberry

[midnight ocean]

hanging dog?

[tidal slate]

Aye

I just read some Forum Posts where some said it should work with p. Arrows because they drop the weapon before they die and it counts as disarmed.

Strange that its also said the Bow even if you load new arrows still counts as "not" reloaded

I don't know if that's true, because if it is... It sounds very easy?

[midnight ocean]

give it a try

just need some oleander sage if you dont have any

i almost never used anything poisoned

one time i killed a cougar with one and i was like ok but i could have just used an improved arrow

[tidal slate]

I got a few floating around

I'm doing the Herbalist 7 at the Moment (where U need to use and Craft 5 Times that special medicine)

Collecting all the Things I found beside the ingredients

[midnight ocean]

that one is annoying

so much golden currant

[tidal slate]

I use one p. Throwing Knife for the Grizzly Bear. Works well

To get that Mission 10 done

[midnight ocean]

i cant remember if i did that or if i just spammed normal ones lol

[tidal slate]

I just used one. Works well enough

[midnight ocean]

sadly the next challenge after the disarms kinda sucks too

but the last one is easy peasy

[tidal slate]

What is it?

After the Disarm ones

Oh dear, shoot 3 Hats off

[regal matrix]

It's easy

Just use a shotgun

The base ammo

And shoot from afar

Use deadeye

[kind blade]

Or just do what I do and get headshots, sometimes I miss and bye bye hat

[tidal slate]

I just read some 😄 they claim to go Vs Del Lobo because they wearing Sombreros

[midnight ocean]

yeah but its all gotta be in one deadeye lol

[tidal slate]

Semi automatic shotgun

Aka Pump Gun

[kind blade]

Oh damn, so just pick a fight with the law, three hat shots

[midnight ocean]

or just do it at a gang camp

[kind blade]

True true, I just go around hunting for those or occasionally when I’m bored fight the law, I have a 1,000 dollar bounty on Saint Denis rn as John

[midnight ocean]

nice

[tidal slate]

Don't forget to listen to Joe Cocker "I will leave my Hat 🤠 on" 🤣

[midnight ocean]

im still wanted in every state from the bountiful achievement lol

not much of an achievement turns out

idk why people think they need to go hide out in colter lol

[tidal slate]

Some say you need to have 250 💰 in all Countries, other say just need one and hide

And weird it says hide in colter for 3 days and just sit there and take a rest...

I bet it doesn't work at all

[midnight ocean]

its definitely all states

[midnight ocean]

it does but its unnecessary

you can just continue playing the game as normal

i mean it is as IF you're only wanted in one state right because bounty hunters dont cross state lines to come after you

and you can only be in one state at any given time

[tidal slate]

So you get it In every state and just keep going?

Or is it as soon you reach the 5th state with 250, the Achivment pops up

[midnight ocean]

yeah after you have it in all states you then have to not die for three days

[tidal slate]

Is there any preferred Place to go?

Don't say Colter now XD

I bet you may craft enough food and just keep moving

[midnight ocean]

why not lol

you dont need to go anywhere just kill the bounty hunters when they show up

easy

[tidal slate]

And on the end just chop 🪓 tons of wood to get your Honor back

[midnight ocean]

unless you're in the epilogue

im not actually sure if you can get it as arthur but i think people have claimed to

[tidal slate]

Well I'm inside the epilogue as you maybe know

[midnight ocean]

then you dont need to worry about honor

[tidal slate]

If says only the higher the Honor, the more bonus you get inside stores

I don't rly care about

I thought with low Honor you cant do anything good

And technical epilogue is over now

I'm inside the free game after the last mission of Epilogue P2

[midnight ocean]

wdym

[tidal slate]

If you are an enemy to everyone because your Honor is low, I thought you could not do anything else or still

[midnight ocean]

dont know what you mean by not doing anything

you can do whatever you want regardless of honor except for the honor locked side mission in chapter 6

npcs will tell you to gtfo sometimes but i think thats related to committing crimes rather than your actual honor level

[tidal slate]

I hear that even if I enter Strawberry or Rhodes...

Even if I haven't done anything

I should not cause trouble again

And stay calm ect...

[midnight ocean]

also valentine after you beat up tommy

strawberry is from the micah jailbreak

rhodes after short walk pretty town

[earnest sky]

They got Kieran too

NOOO

[midnight ocean]

f

[hexed portal]

now it dont feel right arth-

[cyan pendant]

Nah that was taht little Irish bastard

[hexed portal]

Oh right

They do look similar

[hybrid moth]

"Its John Marston Micah!"

[hybrid moth]

meh he can rot there

[midnight ocean]

no

you must progress

[upper lodge]

We need a like a brawl only mod

The brawls in this game are so fun

For some reason

[vocal thistle]

hey chat

so it took me about 70 or so hours to 100% rdr1

(with the dlc)

so at my rate how long would it take me to 100% the second game?

[cyan pendant]

Nah it’s the good ending

[midnight ocean]

arthur remains a bad man
john never becomes a husband and father
reverend stays drunk forever

[vale sinew]

would love a mod that adds the Strange Man at certain areas in key missions

[midnight ocean]

so much longer

[vale sinew]

would give you the feeling that Death is actually watching you

[midnight ocean]

i dont think hes death

[vale sinew]

whatever he is then

[exotic onyx]

RDR2 takes most people 150-200 hours
So, if you needed 70 hours for RDR1, you can expect roughly double that like about 150 hours if you play efficiently, maybe longer if you explore casually

[vocal thistle]

okay

[potent birch]

are you just now playing?

[midnight ocean]

mine was probably like 250-280

i played pretty casually

[earnest sky]

I was when I sent that

[potent birch]

when Kieran died i was sad

[midnight ocean]

wow bills rdr1 fit is so much better than 2

hes actually wearing a suit

[exotic onyx]

I haven't done a 100% run yet, wanted to do it for a while now but I just know from other ppls experiences that it's hard and stressful

[midnight ocean]

the only things thats stressful imo is trying to get gold rush which isnt even a part of 100%

its also much easier to work on everything you need from the start instead of like doing all the challenges and hunting requests and exotics in the epilogue

[royal kettle]

Gotta love explosive bullets

[tulip solstice]

guys someone help me pleeeeease

i cant

save the game manually

i dont know why

its not a point specific thing

one day i clicked "no" when the game asked to override my current save and then

my manual save got permanently turned off

bro i lost like 7 hours of progress please help me

[tulip solstice]

yo so

in my previous save, after coming from guarma and going to the new hideout i talked to dutch instead of going to saint denis and talking to sadie

ive now found out that i wouldnt have known arthur has TB if i never talked to sadie

cause now i went to sadie and fell down and thats how i knew

what the hell is this design??

how much more damn content have i missed??

[barren dagger]

He dies?

[cyan pendant]

Uh nah

It’s a mod

[barren dagger]

I can't send honor gif

[cyan pendant]

There you go

[barren dagger]

[cyan pendant]

That ain’t doing shit to my honor

[barren dagger]

fair enough💔

[quick glen]

Uh actually yes it’s been 150 years it’s already dead

[barren dagger]

..

spoiler

[quick glen]

It’s not spoiler

[barren dagger]

kidding

[quick glen]

I know but I don’t know how many meals I have to give him

@next orchid

[next orchid]

I buy meat from the butcher then cook it all so i always have some

they're not too expensive

[quick glen]

I just make him eat when his cores are red

[next orchid]

ooof
I feed him every 15 minutes when i play lmao

give him candy or chocolate!

that makes him chubby faster

[quick glen]

I rarely eat the camp stew and drink coffee but that’s it

Anyway I won’t disturb you no more since I see you’re playing rdr2

[next orchid]

nah im good
im avoiding camp, trailin doin side quests

I treat Arthur like my son
I feel so bad seeing him underweight or sick lmao

[quick glen]

Why are you avoiding camp

[quick glen]

Oh so I guess you rush chapter 6 a bit

[next orchid]

chapter 4 is boring, and i wanted to give him some alone time
also cus I wanted to see if Charles or Javier would come for me

[next orchid]

i def did

I rushed my first playthrough

what I'd do to do it all over again

[quick glen]

Only Javier came for rescuing Bill

[next orchid]

oh i meant for me
Charles or Javier show up when you avoid camp for long

to take you back

[quick glen]

I know but never managed to get that

[next orchid]

yea it either takes a week ingame or a month

its rare

[quick glen]

I just can’t keep my Arthur out of camp for so long

[quick glen]

Maybe I leave for hunting trips but then I go back to camp

[next orchid]

yea i love camp too, I actually spend time there, talk to people, and do chores too
Did low honour once it genuienly felt horrible lol

[quick glen]

Probably chapter 4 camp is where I spent more time

[next orchid]

I love chap 2 and 3 the most

[quick glen]

Chapter 2 camp is a bit cold, Sadie will be forever crying about Jake Adler’s death, John will be always useless Reverend Swanson is always high, and almost nothing is unlocked yet, in chapter 3 it’s a bit better, you have more things unlocked but every time you go to bed Dutch and Molly repeat the same 3 arguments (I had enough to hear them always argue)

[quick glen]

Then of course it’s okay if you don’t mind about Dutch and Molly arguing

[next orchid]

I mostly shut them out💔 i feel bad for Molly
Chap 2 I enjoy a lot
Yea lots of things not unlucked but camp is new and "happy"

[quick glen]

I know, most of the characters are happy, but as one video said, ‘’if you linger in chapter 2 you’re okay with these characters suffering’’ then of course it’s up to you deciding your favorite chapter to stay

[copper cave]

What should I do in chapter 2

[north pendant]

I do NOT feel bad for molly

[next orchid]

treasure maps for sure! gather some money
side quests, hunt legendary animals

[north pendant]

Aurafarm

Chapter 2 is when I set myself up for basically the entire playthrough with my fit, weapons and kinda my horse

[fervent mauve]

inished the game main story
what a game

[tidal slate]

I´m just freak out... i dont get the disarming done.... grrr

But by Surprise i found the Carolina Parakeet in Lemoyne with a "Hidden" Mission

[hexed portal]

what gives me health XP apart from the elexir and shooting my bow?

[brazen wren]

Is there any way to skip the story in red dead redemption 2 so I can fish and have all other activities unlocked

[midnight ocean]

my arthur was underweight the whole playthrough despite me being stocked on food lol

i just kept forgetting to eat

[hexed portal]

What filled your cores?

[next orchid]

why does no one feed him💔

[midnight ocean]

no i mean i did feed him fairly often but i think you need two full meals per day to maintain healthy

[next orchid]

i give him like 5 venison meats every game day :,)

[midnight ocean]

i only ate if my cores started to get low or if i was about to do a mission and needed gold cores

[next orchid]

so he's chubby

but thats better then underweight

[midnight ocean]

same with my horse, always underweight because i only fed when cores started to drain. even just a little bit

[next orchid]

and some snacks

[next orchid]

not the HORSE TOO💔

[midnight ocean]

i like how we're talking about arthur like hes a tomagotchi lmao "i feed him every day"

[midnight ocean]

[next orchid]

he's my male barbie

[midnight ocean]

good stuff

did the poison arrows not work for the disarms

[tidal slate]

They dropped the Weapon and died afterwards, it counts till 2 of 3 disarms... But it doesn't progress any further

I'm not sure why the fecking counter resets...

It seems it work , I'm just not sure what I'm doing wrong...

But hit them into the legs with a poison arrow let them drop the weapon

[hexed portal]

is that a challenge?

[tidal slate]

Aye Sharpshooter 7

[hexed portal]

havent gotten that far tbh

But cant you deadeye mark the weapon?

[tidal slate]

I've tried that but it doesn't seem to work either

It's kinda annoying

Even trying to find a group or something who are only armed with Pistols...

So I might shoot their hands

[hexed portal]

theres also the melee disarm

But idk how to do it consistently

[midnight ocean]

nah you have to shoot the hand

if you shoot the gun they wont drop it iirc

but also yeah you cant mark the gun anyway

same as you cant mark their hats for sharpshooter 8 you just have to get the free fire deadeye

wait no disarms is 8 hats is 9

[midnight ocean]

there should be enough guys at hanging dog that you dont need them all to have pistols

also try the varmint rifle instead of the repeater

apparently arm shots also work not just hand

[cyan pendant]

It’s littarlly just you go up to them bare handed and you punch them and it disarms them

[trim hamlet]

bro if you just feed it to full cores and then like 3 hay bales more, it will stay at Fit for a while

[midnight ocean]

then i gotta buy food

almost never loot hay

besides underweight horses go faster

[trim hamlet]

pretty sure that's a myth

[trim hamlet]

the wiki says obese has lower top speed but i don't see anything saying the reverse is true

[trim hamlet]

hay is like really efficient tho

6 haybales (with no work in between) sends your horse up a class

[midnight ocean]

its not a bale of hay btw

[trim hamlet]

i know

i just call it that cause it's square shaped in the menu lmao

and it just feels kinda weird saying "6 hay"

[hexed portal]

They do?

time to starve my mango

[trim hamlet]

as if it's individual pieces lmao

[trim hamlet]

wait no one has actually confirmed it yet--

[midnight ocean]

uh maybe not

the official guide says over or underweight both go slower

the amount of misinfo on this game is maddening lol

[south tapir]

Question. Do you need to do any missions to unlock being able to kill any legendary animal (im 100% story)

[midnight ocean]

yes

legendary gator isnt available until chapter 5 or 6

[south tapir]

What about panther?

[midnight ocean]

the legendary pronghorn, cougar and tatanka busin arent available til the epilogue

panther just requires you do master hunter challenges 1-9 i believe

[south tapir]

Dang

Ok, I'll try thst

That

[hexed portal]

Challenges are fun and games until it says to pick herbs

[coarse pike]

you just need to do Hamish's last mission with John to get Buell permanently, right?

He would be beatiful with Arthur, but getting him in chapter 6 is a waste....

[midnight ocean]

fr lol

[midnight ocean]

yes

[cyan pendant]

Gambler 8 exists

[midnight ocean]

it really depends on the person i think

i really didnt mind gambler 8 at all

[coarse pike]

Thanksss

[midnight ocean]

id rather sit and play blackjack than cross the entire game world looking for herbs

[midnight ocean]

np

[coarse pike]

I just arrived at the mission, and wow. The Buell is incredibly beautiful.

[coarse pike]

[midnight ocean]

yeah hes shiny and gold

[coarse pike]

Yeahhh, The shiny horse

Hahaha

[midnight ocean]

he has a special saddle too but it disappears after you stable him

so i kept him as a temp horse eternally

[coarse pike]

That's a brilliant idea, I didn't know your saddle was unique!

I thought about getting an Andaluz for John, because I was going to make mine totally All Black, I completely forgot about the Buell

[midnight ocean]

yeah its got like a gold trim

[south tapir]

Is the panther the only legendary animal that you need to do challenges for?

[midnight ocean]

yes

[south tapir]

Ok good

[calm seal]

Hey guys im in Chapter 6 almost to the end i know what happens im not ready for it again 😢

[hexed portal]

We all need to have a little chat

[midnight ocean]

black lung

you're back

hooray

[daring moat]

Where i can sell vehicle with 2 Horses?

[daring moat]

Can someone help?

[rigid kiln]

im almost onto "Arthur Saved My Life, More Than Once Part 1" for the 8th time

[rigid kiln]

seamus at emerald ranch

[daring moat]

Thnx , is that nourth or west etc.. can u take a look?

[rigid kiln]

yea ill get on right now

ik its in west elizabeth

[daring moat]

Thnx

[rigid kiln]

gotchu

i lied its in new hanover

i cant send pictures

can i send u the location in dms?

[calm seal]

Dutch Think!

[blazing turret]

where do i get perfect boar pelts or just boars

[calm seal]

no idea where

[blazing turret]

ok wasnt asking you specifically

[calm seal]

I wish i could help but i forgot where are the boars either way good luck to you

[midnight ocean]

by the trapper in big valley

or lagras maybe

[midnight ocean]

a little way east of valentine

by emerald station

[gloomy ember]

guys how do i trade my golden wedding rings

[tall obsidian]

Every valuable item sold at fence

[midnight ocean]

or donate to camp

[tall obsidian]

If you on chapter 2 best bet is rhodes and saint denis fence since probably u wont use emerald ranch fence cuz of exploit for early rolling block riffle

[hybrid moth]

first game is so much quicker to do compared to RDR2 tho

[calm seal]

how many hours

[hybrid moth]

idk im at 18H and i got like 60% total completion but 40 missions done so far idk how many there are

[sick geode]

I found a Merino sheep wearing a pink bow and a wedding ring

What is it for

[midnight ocean]

i went to go 100% it last night and after a few missions i checked my achievements and realized i already 100%ed it years ago lol

[midnight ocean]

its just there

i think somewhere you can find a guy who talks about or wrote a note about marrying a sheep

something along those lines

[sick geode]

Icky

[midnight ocean]

yeah lol

hopefully he stopped at the bow

[hexed portal]

Idk if its a bug but theres body on the lemoyne fields thats has the yellow eagle eye particals

cant loot it either

[midnight ocean]

screenshot?

[hexed portal]

erm sure but it takes time

Xbox has some time issues with uploading screens

[supple trout]

it takes forever for them to load to the Xbox app and half the time the app doesn’t even work

[hexed portal]

Nevermind the pre placed body is gone but its called robands farm directly at southfield flats in scarlett meadows

Just another spooky cowboy tale

[midnight ocean]

where exactly was the body

[neat elk]

Guys anyone knows how to fix this: i downloaded the automatic ak47 mod for rdr2 but the gun isnt automatic how to fix this

[hexed portal]

Behind the house leaned against the wagon next to wood pieces

[midnight ocean]

found it

its a woman

looted her and got a letter

holy shit this is dark lol

did you go inside the house

[hexed portal]

Yea

Stole their buns of the plate

[midnight ocean]

yeah i dont think theyre gonna miss them

[hexed portal]

Did she have the particals?

[main plinth]

any tips for gambler diarrhea 8 and gambler diarrhea 9?

[midnight ocean]

yes

[midnight ocean]

yeah for 8 watch tv or youtube while you do it

for 9 you can quit while its your turn and wont count as a loss

[hexed portal]

Idk what else there wad apart from the letter

[midnight ocean]

just stand up from the table if you start to lose

[midnight ocean]

nothing, the game just wanted to draw your attention to it

[main plinth]

Ah man

I finished herbalist 10 as athur, i feel proud

but gambler shit... man

[midnight ocean]

are you still arthur?

[main plinth]

yes

[midnight ocean]

chapter?

[main plinth]

CH3

[midnight ocean]

paly dominoes in camp if you can

[earnest sky]

Takes about $300 in $21 increments of donations per level

[midnight ocean]

i got gambler 9 by playing with hosea and im pretty sure it gave me a free win

[main plinth]

I played once with Tilly, but it was when I was at challenge 2 gambler

[midnight ocean]

also its always just one opponent

[main plinth]

does she come back?

[earnest sky]

Currently stuck on the blackjack one where I need to hit 3 times

[midnight ocean]

i also did that one with tilly

no you can play with hosea

itll be all fives tho not just draw

[main plinth]

what about blackjack?

[midnight ocean]

like tips?

[earnest sky]

There’s a challenge where you need to win 3 games of black jack each with a hit of 3 times

[midnight ocean]

im starting to get suspicious of this strategy guide btw

[main plinth]

Yeah, im looking for more ways to do it

[main plinth]

where? which strategy guide?

[earnest sky]

It’s old honestly

[midnight ocean]

theres really no shortcuts there you just gotta keep playing

[main plinth]

it turns out you can do sharpshooter 10 with 3 bird kills in CH3

[midnight ocean]

make sure you split when you can

[earnest sky]

But it still helps a little for more hidden things

[midnight ocean]

and obviously it goes faster if you dont care about losing money

but i did try to win hands i knew i couldnt get three hits on and still got it done in less than 2 hours

[earnest sky]

I got 4000 and the only thing I really want to buy are the grips

[midnight ocean]

for some reason it says the white arabian is marked on the map lol

[earnest sky]

Most of that is gonna go to the tithing box

[midnight ocean]

i wonder if they were making the guide mid development and a lot of stuff changed along the way

[earnest sky]

Where?

[main plinth]

Yes, a lot of stuff changed

[midnight ocean]

in the section on wild horses

[main plinth]

you don't need to do the shots in sharpshooter consecutively, no need for Dead Eye, just make sure you land your shots without being shot back at

[midnight ocean]

sucks because this is probably the best way to confirm hidden mechanics and other less obvious stuff but it doesnt appear to be completely trustworthy

[main plinth]

Yeah... fucked up

[earnest sky]

Came out with the release of the game via a collectors box

I believe it can with the box

[main plinth]

what fucked my run as well is also the fact that there are many challenges you can do easier than meant to be in the old runs.

[earnest sky]

Kinda sad the collectors box wasn’t like the camp tithing box

[midnight ocean]

like what

[main plinth]

sharpshooter

10 and 7

you don't need CH4s's dead eye to do it

[earnest sky]

Which ones are those

[midnight ocean]

well 10 is just easy af isnt it

[earnest sky]

Idk

I haven’t done it

[main plinth]

yes lol

10 is easy but you need rolling block

[midnight ocean]

7 is 7 headshots in a row?

[main plinth]

yeah no interruption

which also means not being shot back at

[midnight ocean]

i thought it was just without missing

[main plinth]

i did it in six point cabin, didn't work

Nah, you need to shoot at peaceful ppl

[midnight ocean]

uh i dont think so lol

[main plinth]

thats what worked for me

[earnest sky]

It shows where those type of horses are

[main plinth]

i think it also works in train seaters

[midnight ocean]

yeah but you can also just do it on enemies

you dont need to avoid being shot

just cant miss

[main plinth]

I didn't miss a single time in six point cabin

the challenge to golden it requires 15 headshots anyway

[midnight ocean]

not in a row necessarily

[main plinth]

ppl also do it by killing hogtied npcs

[midnight ocean]

i mean i literally just completed a 100% run and i dont even remember having to think about that one i just did it

[main plinth]

fair enough

did you finish all challengs as arthur?

[midnight ocean]

only the ones that you can do without glitching

[main plinth]

ah

my herbalist was a torture

[midnight ocean]

yeah ive seen videos on that and i just preferred to have a normal experience lol

[main plinth]

I just want to buff arthur as much as i can, i dont play as john anyway

[midnight ocean]

i also didnt realize i could do the horseman where you ride to blackwater as arthur until saw a reddit post after i reached the epilogue

[main plinth]

arthur has access to all the content

Oh yes you can

i just think gambler is annoying

[midnight ocean]

wdym

[main plinth]

You get to play with a much stronger arthur throughout all missions in the game, 100% outer cores

[midnight ocean]

wat

[main plinth]

arthur has access to pretty much 80% of the game's missions

[midnight ocean]

well until he completes them lol

[main plinth]

well you can't complete them with john lmao, you can only replay them, most as arthur still

the legend of the east outfit also looks badass on arthur

way more badass

[midnight ocean]

idk if getting slightly more of each stat is really worth it

[main plinth]

Oh yeah, i always make a shootout in vanhorn

i dont get sun obliterated by someone too close to me lmao

[midnight ocean]

getting the lote satchel already gives you essentially infinite stats by letting you hold so much of every tonic

[main plinth]

it also helps with getting golden medals easier, more dead eye time

[midnight ocean]

chewing tobacco

and thyme big game

[main plinth]

golden medals require not consuming these

[midnight ocean]

wrong

[main plinth]

correct

look it up

if you consume any items from your wheel, you won't get a golden medal

[midnight ocean]

you eat the big game before the mission, chewing tobacco doesnt affect any gold medals because its not a health item

only items that restore health are not allowed on some missions

stamina and deadeye are fine

[main plinth]

ah

[midnight ocean]

and the golden core from big game lasts like a full day so its easy to just eat it before the mission and have a gold core for the whole thing

[brisk heron]

Sean just died im so sad rn😟

[midnight ocean]

f

[main plinth]

my favorite shootout in the entire game

[midnight ocean]

yeah that mission rules

[main plinth]

Lmao

[brisk heron]

..

[main plinth]

one of the best heck yeah

[midnight ocean]

that one is a real treat on a replay because theres no long walking or riding sections

just that short one at the start

[main plinth]

Yeah, very much natural, not heavily scripted like the final shootout with Micah as John

that sniper script is gay

[midnight ocean]

oh yeah i had to restart because of that shit

[main plinth]

Lmaooo same hahaahaha

[midnight ocean]

i ran forward too fast and couldnt deal damage to the sniper and was like wtf

[main plinth]

scripting ruins the vibe of the mission

Rockstar should've never scripted the final shootout with Micah, until the very end

[midnight ocean]

especially annoying because so many gold medals require you to rush forward unnaturally

[main plinth]

true

thanks for the tip abt the chewing tobacco tho, i thought consuming any item counts

[midnight ocean]

no problem it was probably my most used item in the whole game

[brisk heron]

Whats that mean?

[midnight ocean]

arthurs jaw should have been rotting off by the time the game ends

[main plinth]

the golden medal, plus the revenge and the whole vibe of the mission would've made this mission the most favored by game players

but the scripting ruined it, woolie explained it

the scripting ruins the fact that most golden challenges require you to rush unnaturally

[midnight ocean]

and comboing it with the thyme big game is a good idea because chewing tobacco drains the dead eye core a teeny bit

or just use snake oils

[main plinth]

So btw woolie

[midnight ocean]

drinking liquor is also ok

[main plinth]

Right now, I almost am done with gambler like I said, 8, 9 and 10

I have the rest at 3-4-5

which should I begin with next? I only did Sharpshooter fully and Herbalist

I'm not sure I want to dip into something I hate doing, gambler ruined the grindy vibe

[midnight ocean]

id get going on hunting

on my playthrough i did things very spread out

survivalist too

for survivalist you eventually gotta catch one of every fish which is kind of annoying but im pretty sure the legendaries count

[main plinth]

any off map-arthur fish?

[midnight ocean]

no

[main plinth]

Ok great

[midnight ocean]

i mean one of the legendaries is but its not needed for te challenges

or is it two

[main plinth]

I see

[midnight ocean]

i would just go over all the challenges that are available and just do them as the opportunity arises

like for the one where you need to rob trains you dont need to spam trains you can just go about other business and if you happen to see a train, hop on and steal something

[real urchin]

Anyone else lasso innocent wagons drivers and dangle them from bridges before letting them fall?

[midnight ocean]

no bro

but when i find someone who kills the innocent for fun i like to lasso them and drag them behind my horse for as long as they can survive

[real urchin]

I guess bro doesnt know how peak murdering innocents is🥀

[midnight ocean]

ok skinner

see you in tall trees

[toxic pier]

playing rdr2 after 2 months is nauseating lol

too realistic for my eyes

[midnight ocean]

you can always play 1 lol

[reef rose]

Gavin where are you?

[oblique quiver]

He’s dead bro

[tidal slate]

Leave Gavin alone, he is my only soulmate in the whole Game

[tall obsidian]

I know this is late but

Sharpshooter is one of easiest if you dont count the early RBR for 660 m

[tidal slate]

I just did it on the hanging Dog Ranch thanks to Woolie (as always) I went on the opposite Side on the Hill, used the Scope and walked forward until the Enemy was rendered and it was done

And now I understand what he means with the Herbalist Thing... Where you need to collect 43 Plants and you can't see which one you already got
...

Even as it says "you can use the compendium" good joke

For me it says 21/43 ...

[midnight ocean]

happy to help lol

[midnight ocean]

have you done the exotics sidequest yet? all those plants count

[tidal slate]

I've finished it already. You mean all them Orchid's?

[midnight ocean]

yeah

did you have that challenge active the whole time?

[tidal slate]

No sadly not... I wasn't doing the Herbalist and the side Quests at the same Time... I guess that's not a time consuming Problem

Which means I need to think, which one I haven't collected yet

Or try to gather the Orchids all together, I guess they are a few

[midnight ocean]

those may be a good amount of the ones you need

maybe the new austin ones

[tidal slate]

I will get there... 🙂 I hope

This annoying shooting Quests are p... me off

Disarming, then shoot 8 Animals using small arrows

The Gambling Challenge still no progress

I think I'm at 98,4 %

[midnight ocean]

the 8 animals i did by emerald ranch

think there were some tiny animals running around in the riverbed as well as a bunch of birds

[tidal slate]

@midnight oceani found the Issue now, its Time based... the Disarming...

Because i shoot 2 and i wasnt reloading, wasnt changing weap... but then then Counter resets

i guess i have to disarm 3 PPL fast

i did it...

FINALLY at this Fort in the Desert...

Lucky there are 3 Del Lobos next to each other

Now the Hats but first another annoying Driving Lesson

[midnight ocean]

you werent putting the weapon away were you

[tidal slate]

No I dont

But as I said above I finally got it

But it seems to be time Based same as the 8 animals

I'm not really sure how much time you have that we in the shots of disarming

And I did it with the 1899 pistols

I just went into the desert because I was collecting some random plants and stuff

And on this fort, there are standing two del Lobos next to each other plus one on the guard tower

Fort Mercer

[midnight ocean]

good stuff

now you gotta do the hats

[main plinth]

will you ever share your 100% save file?

[midnight ocean]

im on xbox lol

[main plinth]

ah

console boyo

[midnight ocean]

i didnt finish it as much as id like

didnt do the whole compendium

[main plinth]

im pushing for the whole compendium

[midnight ocean]

i think i literally need one more pelt for the trapper to have everything

i did gold medal every mission tho

[main plinth]

man i dont know about you but the legend of the east outfit looks better on arthur

john looks like micah but slimmer

[midnight ocean]

idk about looks but it definitely fits better

john is the legend of the west, arthur is the legend of the east

[hollow quiver]

hello, has anyone tried hunting panthers recently? specifically in chapter 4. i tried to many methods for it and no luck, i was wondering if it's because i am in chapter 4 and main camp is near panther spawn

[regal matrix]

Near braithwaite manor or lagras

Place bait

[hollow quiver]

i know the spawn point, it just doesn't spawn, that's why i'm asking if maybe it's because i'm in chapter 4?

[dapper birch]

Ive just arrived in Chapter 4 and it says Ive completed about 40% of the story

is this accurate?

[hollow quiver]

yes

[tidal slate]

Woolie, the Hat sounds easy right? Use a semi automatic shotgun and shells. Use all in one Deadeye and aim above their heads

And the birds, will I did that with the NPC or random guy who is asking me for a challenge. Why you need to blast birds from the sky so

[dapper birch]

alright thank you

[royal kettle]

Well I finally got around to robbing the side business of the Valentine doctor. For fifty whole dollars

[normal holly]

Cool

[dapper birch]

truly lucrative

[royal kettle]

Oh yeah especially when compared to the 21k I already have.

[normal holly]

I tried doing 2 train robberies

No money

[royal kettle]

I keep wanting to rob a train but I don't want to loose honor

But maybe next time I'm in New Austin I'll see if I can rob one there that way if I get a bounty it won't matter because it's New Austin

[regal matrix]

It's okay to lose some honor

Arthur isn't a saint man

[regal matrix]

Don't rob trains as john

Breaks the story

[royal kettle]

Well a little late for that I robed a cargo train a few days ago. Not as exciting as I thought it would be

Currently I'm missing like an inch of honor from max. Which might have something to do with the fact I shoot the Armadillo store owner in the face and loot his register every time I visit. That and a few other alleged murders

[river island]

is the rare rolling block rifle the only thing u can only get in a mission? or are there other things u can only get in some circumstances , i js wanna know so i dont miss anything

[eternal zinc]

Hey does anyone know if there is a journal entry for The Course of True Love V or something after it?

[tidal slate]

For real??

[dreamy cobalt]

This game is so peak

[azure sluice]

I’m on chapter 3 rn (replaying the game), can you get max honor? I can’t get past the last level on the meter

[hybrid moth]

rdr1?

[regal matrix]

No, honor is capped

[midnight ocean]

idk i didn't use the shotgun for that

[midnight ocean]

it's gotta be a certain kind of train

the cars should be blue rather than green or red

you can spawn one by buying a train ticket, the train you get off of will be a blue one

[midnight ocean]

yeah

[midnight ocean]

as far as weapons go yeah i believe that's the only mission locked one

there's also the rare double barrel that isn't connected to a mission but might me missable if you don't get it before epilogue

other than that there's a ton of little stuff like hats and letters and a couple things for trinkets that are missable during missions

[midnight ocean]

can you elaborate?

[midnight ocean]

why lol

[regal matrix]

Doesn't make much sense story wise

[midnight ocean]

guess you cant do any of those epilogue bounties either since abigail said no

[regal matrix]

Bounty hunting is legal work tho

Train robbery is like wayyyyy worse

[midnight ocean]

yeah but it also doesnt actually have an effect on anything

if you want to do it then you should do it

plus honor no longer matters and you lose a lot for robbing a train

[midnight ocean]

no they should still be there

the panther spawn isnt even that close to shady belle

[hexed portal]

I think i've seen about every animal but the animal compendium is just filled to 35%

I also struggle with owls how do i spot them

[midnight ocean]

like any other bird

either sneak up before they take off or try to get under them as they fly

if theyre too far try zooming in with the binoculars

[hexed portal]

Do they fly?

Because tiny birds chill on wood or rocks near water

[midnight ocean]

yes owls fly lol

theyre not like chickens

[hexed portal]

Yeah but i mean like i hear their screams

[midnight ocean]

but yeah you can probably find them perched in places too

like other large birds

[hexed portal]

Should i look foe them sitting or flying

[midnight ocean]

might depend on the particular owl

for the california one its best to try and spot them flying in a certain part of new austin

[hexed portal]

I randomly shot one off the trees with a cattleman but after that they became more extinct than the parakeet

[midnight ocean]

make sure you're looking at night

and google some locations

[hybrid moth]

yeah i met Dutch yesterday tho

[blazing turret]

is there any way to get the satchel or bandolier going the other way

[midnight ocean]

not in vanilla

maybe with mods

if the satchel were on the right it would interfere with the holster though so idk

[blazing turret]

man that sucks

[eternal zinc]

Does Penelope and Beau send you some mail after their last mission giving a journal entry..
Because I never got journal entry from finishing the last mission or is it one of those mission
with no journal entry?

[midnight ocean]

dont think it has one

no letter either

[hybrid moth]

Rip Dutch

[eternal zinc]

@midnight ocean thx

[azure sluice]

Until which chapter?

[midnight ocean]

6

[cedar obsidian]

Can someone tell me: If i move on to chapter 3 from chapter 2 will all the "tasks" in my log that i havent compelted yet from chapter 2 go away and then i will not be able to finish them? Or do they stay in my log as i go through the whole game so i can complete them at my leisure?

[azure sluice]

Ah that’s unfortunate

[azure sluice]

No tasks will stay

You can complete Arthur’s tasks as John lol

They stay until you complete them

Including side quests

[cedar obsidian]

Im confused by your answer. why would i complete them as john? no spoilers please

[azure sluice]

Oh yea mb I should’ve made it a bit clearer

The gang moves on from crime eventually

Arthur leaves

So you play as John

Hope I didn’t spoil much

[cedar obsidian]

that was.... a spoiler

[azure sluice]

It’s deeper than that tho that’s just surface level sorry 😭

[midnight ocean]

how come?

[midnight ocean]

not all

[midnight ocean]

i would avoid this server altogether until you beat the entire game

[cedar obsidian]

Ok thanks.

[azure sluice]

I saw that there was some special grip engraving on the cattleman once you get max honor

[raw tiger]

How long is the rdr1 story until you get to missions where you capture javier or something, i got nigel west dickens first encounter

[midnight ocean]

dont think you need max

should be able to get it at the chapter 3 cap

[azure sluice]

no I tried

well I’m not sure what the special one is but prob an eagle

[midnight ocean]

it is an eagle yeah

you might be able to get the low honor one

for double actions

[dry schooner]

is double action rev good

[rapid burrow]

How badly can a bank robbery go?

Very badly, went to a different country badly. I hate Ch5.

[midnight ocean]

not really

unless you like having a faster fire rate

[reef rose]

Gav where are you

[rapid burrow]

Oh my god 😭

[frank cedar]

Are female avatars targeted in rdo

[reef rose]

GAVIN

where are you

[midnight ocean]

funny you ask because we just had a convo about that in general earlier

but yes

[frank cedar]

I ended up going with the guy

[midnight ocean]

i made a female character forever ago when the game came out and now i wanna get into online but im scared lol

[frank cedar]

How do I spin my gun?

[next orchid]

Press tab twice on pc

[frank cedar]

Ro

Bro

I shot a npc in the ehad and he killed me

[frank cedar]

I mean, like tricks

[frank cedar]

Is the cattlemen not a one shot head shot?

[random glade]

every weapon kills in one shot in the head

[next orchid]

You can't, thats only online i tuink

[frank cedar]

I eas online

[royal kettle]

The Poisonous Trail treasure hunt might just be the worst one

But 2k in gold almost makes up for it

[regal matrix]

arthur gets himself poisoned just for some gold lol

[royal kettle]

Arthur gets poisoned and John gets the reward.

[regal matrix]

nice way of looking at it lol

[royal kettle]

Don't know what I'm gonna do with like 22k except buy every possible weapon upgrade and clothing

[toxic pier]

y'all got any good riding horses to buy? I'm tryna chill and explore the map without rushing

(i got 100% already)

[cyan pendant]

Like there’s two and that’s ain’t good

[toxic pier]

I wanna buy kieran's horse

[amber island]

are the saddle bags worth it to get?

[azure sluice]

its a black one no? I checked it out at high honor it worked normal

[azure sluice]

Arabian, very fun

[opal lava]

Kieran died in my game but istg he barely did ANYTHING while he was alive 😭 all he did was walk around, and I'm seeing clips of him interacting with characters I didn't even know he ever talked to 💔 feeling like I missed out

[azure sluice]

u can find one in the St. Denis stable or you can go for the white one near lake Isabella

[toxic pier]

too fancy

I might just buy Branwen or Ennis

[azure sluice]

Morgan are pretty fun too but they’re small

Andalusian

idk where u get that tho

[tall obsidian]

Is there any cigarette set that doesnt force you into new austin

Any 12 of it? (144)

[tall obsidian]

The waterfall at northwest of annesburg, its sadly near one of cougar spawn location that can screw you off if you arent lucky

[lime crest]

is seamus still open 7 years later? i'm already pissed off enough i gotta go all the wya over there so he better be open

[frail shuttle]

my name in real life is Gavin

i killed the guy looking for me

[trim hamlet]

alr so you probably know what I'm gonna say but just hear me out—

[toxic pier]

oh let me guess, the ardennes?

[trim hamlet]

what?! how the heck did you figure that out? /lh

[toxic pier]

divine intervention, the universe spoke to me

[lime crest]

fuck the ardennes, get the white arabian

[azure sluice]

bro how on earth am I supposed to do Horseman 9

Van Horn to blackwater

help pls

do masks help

[desert edge]

Honestly I really like boaz or branwen to just explore I also use my splashed paint or dark bay turkoman

Also hear me out

Gwydion is super underrated

Like rn my stable is full but I'm torn between keeping silver dollar or gwydion for my final selectiom

[dark estuary]

Hello

[radiant bobcat]

Is anyone on rdr2 rn

[tiny sandal]

Yes

[azure sluice]

alr bruh horseman 10 is 5x worse

[light mauve]

yoo

[midnight ocean]

is it

[azure sluice]

yeah you have to get hold of 8 different wild horse breeds

[midnight ocean]

there's not that many horses and it tells you which ones you've gotten

[azure sluice]

around 8 idk I didn’t count them

[azure sluice]

yeah I know but like

it’s hard to find them when I actually need them

[midnight ocean]

you can get most of them around blackwater

[azure sluice]

but last I looked was near blackwater I didn’t find any

[midnight ocean]

it went by fast for me

[azure sluice]

I came across some while doing horseman 9 but didn’t manage to catch back up

I’ll look tmrw

I’m also still at Master Hunter 1 I can’t find any perfect rabbits

I remember seeing some near lake Isabella

[midnight ocean]

thats wild

rabbits are also around blackwater

and like everywhere else

[azure sluice]

I don’t go near blackwater much

I stay in Lemoyne and New Hanover mostly

[midnight ocean]

they're everywhere there as well

look near horseshoe overlook

rabbits and deer are the first animals you encounter in this game

[azure sluice]

I am aware but they’re either good or poor

I’ll look into it tmrw

[midnight ocean]

well it's not like another area is gonna have more perfect ones lol

[tidal slate]

Well, here i am on the RDR Road again. Moving up to 99,1 %

Now Survivalist at 7 and Gambler 8 ... but not today 🙂

At least those are the last Remaining Challenges

This Stupid Herbalist with 43 Items... i found a List Online, an PDF File where u can check the Plants you already found...

But the last dumbass Berry -.^ Wintergreen Berry was the last one i was missing. But i found it 😄

[midnight ocean]

nice

for me it was bay bolette

[tidal slate]

Im now on 420 Hrs on Steam 😫 no comment

Was kinda easy as you said, as soon i shoot the Hats of (at Valentines Station) i ran away... and while running away i saw the Birds starting, stopped and finished Sharpshooter 10 straight away

[trim hamlet]

imagine using a horse because it's "technically optimal" and not because "hehe i like tank" /lh

[tidal slate]

and lucky me, after i had all 43 Plants, i could cook the Things straight away because i had all the Meat,Fish and Crabs + Birds

[azure sluice]

I’ve been trying to get Gambler 1 done for a while but I don’t have the slightest idea how poker works

ngl these challenges are fun

[trim hamlet]

First question

Did you read the guide

[azure sluice]

yes

[tidal slate]

You dont even need to understand how Poker Works its kinda easy

[azure sluice]

the higher the number the weaker the card?

idk

unless it’s a king / queen / joker

[trim hamlet]

opposite.

So... I'm gonna be typing for a while bear with me

[tidal slate]

Ardennes works in a Casino in RDR2 😏

[midnight ocean]

higher numbers are better and higher ranking hands are better than lower, so two pairs is better than one pair

google a list of poker hands

[trim hamlet]

In poker (the style RDR2 uses is Texas Hold 'Em), there are two cards in your hand, and eventually will be 5 community cards (the first 3 community cards are revealed all at once, then #4, then #5). You can use any combination of those 7 cards, to create the best hand of 5 cards you can.

Like the other guy said, Google a ranking of poker hands.

[azure sluice]

Yea I should look into it sometime

[trim hamlet]

So an Ardennes walks into a bar—

[azure sluice]

Would be cool if blackjack was in RDR2 lol

[midnight ocean]

it is bro

[azure sluice]

what

[trim hamlet]

it is

[azure sluice]

where

[tidal slate]

Blackjack is in RDR2

[midnight ocean]

rhodes

[azure sluice]

bruh

I never knew

[midnight ocean]

and annesburg i think?

[azure sluice]

OHHH I REMMEBER

[tidal slate]

Rhodes, Saint Denis and Annesburg

[azure sluice]

second floor in the Rhodes bar

iirc

or st denis

[midnight ocean]

blackjack will lose you money tho

[azure sluice]

yea I entirely forgot lol

[midnight ocean]

poker is better odds

[azure sluice]

yea fair enough

[midnight ocean]

because youre not betting against the house

[trim hamlet]

it's funny, irl, it's the opposite—blackjack is the game where the casino has the least edge against you.

[midnight ocean]

oh this guy doesnt know about gambler 8 oh god

[tidal slate]

Good Luck with Blackjack youll enjoy doing Gambling Challenge 8 later on 🤣 😡

[azure sluice]

what is it

[midnight ocean]

still worse odds than poker right?

[trim hamlet]

nope

blackjack is the statistically closest to 50/50 in a casino

house still has an edge tho, but it's slight

[tidal slate]

Lets say it like that, its the worse Challenge in RDR2 beside "Domino" and Domino compared to Challenge 8 is easy...

[midnight ocean]

in poker there is no house edge

its also more skill based

[trim hamlet]

I highly doubt that. I'm not a gambling junkie tho so I can't tell you first hand lmao

[midnight ocean]

do you know what the house is

[tidal slate]

Should i use a Copy and Paste from Reddit @azure sluice ? 😄

[azure sluice]

what

[tidal slate]

@azure sluice Challenge 8: Win three hands of blackjack, with three hits or more.

This is by far the stupidest challenge ever made. Their is no easy way this sucks. The goal is to hit 3 times in a round and win. So in the end you should have a total of at least 5 cards. Just keep betting 2 cents every time. Though for some odd reason I had some luck betting 12 cents sometimes. If you tie, it does not count. So best of luck.

[azure sluice]

oh my days

yea I’m out I’m not doing gambler

[tidal slate]

I bet hes uninstalling now 🤔

[azure sluice]

💔

[tidal slate]

I want to have 100% Complete... so i need to force me (i dont know how , but i will 😄 )