red-dead-singleplayer

[midnight ocean]

i said that because you claimed its possible to create the mod while knowing nothing about modding and knowing that people who actually DO know about modding have tried and failed and believe it to be impossible based on what they can glean from the code

[celest tinsel]

me claiming its possible does not mean or refer to it being possible for me in any shape or form , all I was stating is an educated guess , but guess who had to make it personal , stop being delusional and move on

besides check dms , the dude who u read the comment of knows jackcrap about modding anyways

[chilly heron]

You quite literally can make the mod yourself if you vibe code with Claude and ChatGPT. Let Chat deep search the information you need about RDR2 game file data and feed it to Claude to do the coding.

[midnight ocean]

then on what basis are you claiming it is possible?

[celest tinsel]

he isn't even a modder , he doesn;t even know what he's talking about , he just says "there has to be a reason"

[midnight ocean]

neither do you, so why do you know more than he does?

[celest tinsel]

its modding , almost everything is possible with enough time

[midnight ocean]

then why doesnt the mod exist for something so highly requested?

[celest tinsel]

its possible until proved otherwise , not the other way around

[midnight ocean]

hence why i told you to make it yourself, because thats the only option you have

[chilly heron]

whats your job btw?

[midnight ocean]

if its possible then its up to you to prove it instead of whining about how other modders wont do it

[celest tinsel]

no modder answered that question , so you're just making assumptions if ur saying its not possible , cuz like most current rdr2 mods rn only change values and u can actually do the same thing they do without even modding u just need to edit files

the rdr2 modding community is just not as strong as other ones

doesnt mean its not possible

[midnight ocean]

lets say you're right and its totally possible. what do you have to gain from bitching about how modders havent accomplished it yet?

i didnt have a problem with what you were saying until you started insulting modders for not having created the mod you want

[celest tinsel]

you know you didn't say that to be helpful bro , you said that with the meaning of "if its possible go make it" fully knowing that if I had that power I would never be searching the web for a mod like that anyways

[midnight ocean]

you can learn

its either learn and do it yourself or keep complaining, those are your two options

[celest tinsel]

what do you have to gain by glazing people who don't exist just to win an argument?

[naive barn]

Stop being mean i think thats a rule no drama no fighting

[midnight ocean]

i just read ai responses all day and determine how accurate they are for the most part

[celest tinsel]

if u checked dms u will know how wrong you are

anyways moving on

this is getting frustrating

[midnight ocean]

i can see that

[chilly heron]

Whats the title of that specific occupation? How much are you paid and are you on salary or commission? What certifications do you need to qualify?

[cyan pendant]

Tf is going on

[naive barn]

@cyan pendant just a disagreement

[celest tinsel]

disagreeable men

[naive barn]

Go get a life

[celest tinsel]

tf did I do to you

idk why people on the internet take crap too personal , this is an app for entertainment

I make a pun refrencing trelawny and bro says go get a life

smh

[chilly heron]

@midnight ocean May u answer?

[cyan pendant]

Ah so this is a whiskey time

[celest tinsel]

lmao arthur passed out after 2 aged pirate rums

and a moonshine

[trim hamlet]

i mean that works too i think lmao

[celest tinsel]

wtf

this is the second time my horse gets kiled by the train

this time I had to watch it in slow mo cuz arthur was drunk

[naive barn]

Next time dont ride a horse why drunk lol

[celest tinsel]

but drunk driving is fun : (

[naive barn]

True

Next time stay away from the tracks

[supple ridge]

Howdy partner

FAKE???

[naive barn]

@celest tinsel next time stay away from the tracks

[celest tinsel]

got it

[naive barn]

@celest tinsel unless u want another dead horse

[celest tinsel]

I just reload when that happens

the train spawned out of nowhere I thought arthur was hallucinating lmao

it felt like a ghost train

[naive barn]

Ima send ya something ib dms that happened ti my yesterday in new austin if thats ok

[celest tinsel]

sure

[chilly heron]

Yeah, mods did the same to me 😔

[supple ridge]

I didn't do anything

[royal kettle]

How did you guys deal with Compson during his quest? Trying to think of things to do to him on my next playthrough

[pseudo patrol]

this rat extermination side quest up in the mountains in really dramatic

[midnight ocean]

lol

[royal kettle]

So I noticed. But boy is it satisfying

[cyan pendant]

What…

[midnight ocean]

think about it

[royal kettle]

You know the quest where you have to exterminate the Rat at the top of the mountain while all the rats friends attack you

Missed out on using a dynamite arrow unfortunately but maybe next time

[tidal slate]

Reading the Yawning about Mods and the Game Crash and some I got to much moonshine but I complain about anything... Doesn't make the Day even better

[midnight ocean]

dont think ive had a crash a single time in like a 150 hour playthrough

[serene cedar]

Why the hell does the game detract honor and alert the law when you so much as knock out that asshole in the bar in Valentine who constantly talks about how much he enjoys murdering indigenous people? How is it any different than the eugenicist/racist in Saint Denis, whom you can straight up murder without consequence?

[midnight ocean]

the raccoon hat guy?

[serene cedar]

Yeah

[serene cedar]

And hell, atleast the eugenicist never actually claimed to murder anyone, unlike the Valentine racist. I feel like killing people for their race makes someone more worthy of death than just being a non-murderous racist.

[midnight ocean]

i mean is he talking about murdering them or just fighting them

[serene cedar]

No, he constantly brags about how many "red****" and "savages" he's killed

[midnight ocean]

that could be self defense honestly

dunno if you can assume he was just going around murdering them

[serene cedar]

From reddead.fandom.com

"Jon (racoon hat guy) claims to have hunted Indians at some point in his past. He allegedly massacred those he encountered, and even ate the heart of one. He can be heard loudly expressing his hatred towards Native Americans, and claims to have massacred bison as well"

[tidal slate]

Oh he claims more... If you leave him alone

I did it RDR2 Style... 😆 The 3rd Time I went to Valentine again sat at the Bar drank a Whiskey, punched him into the Face so he was gone... Go back to the Bar drank another Whiskey and all was peaceful and quiet 🤐

He keeps talking all the Time, im Not even sure if he became some sort of aggressive

[midnight ocean]

yeah idk i whooped his ass and took his hat but i dont remember if i lost honor

[tidal slate]

I dont lost Honor either just the guys surrounding me was looking confused... But even as he layed down on the floor they don't get mad

Maybe because u don't shoot him?! Taking out a Gun inside the Bar causes mostly trouble

[midnight ocean]

i know i gained honor for leaving jeremiah compson alone too

think you gain honor either way with him tho

[tidal slate]

Only place where you feel welcome is the General Store in Rhodes because of Mr Pearson

Last Time I was in there, his Wife was jelling something in the backyard

[desert edge]

Guys do I keep my few spotted appaloosa or get the bay roan ardennes idk if I like the strawberry that much

[limpid wharf]

Need help

[midnight ocean]

whats up

[tidal slate]

He's roasted 🍠 😄

[proud bolt]

what help?

[limpid wharf]

nvm

Fixed it

It was just a bug

[desert edge]

Atp idk if I'm crazy but I'm starting to like the red roan Tennessee walker

[regal matrix]

He said he killed indians cause they weren't Christian and he sent them to hell

[midnight ocean]

damn

weird that you lose honor then

[royal kettle]

Loosing honor is a small price to pay. Which reminds me if memory serves me right I need to shoot the owner of the Armadillo general store

[regal matrix]

Really

[regal matrix]

Real

[royal kettle]

Who else needs a shooting

[oblique quiver]

sonny

at bayou

hogtie him if u can

and burn him

[midnight ocean]

me

i'm worth $700 in new hanover

[desert edge]

Guys tell me like underrated horses lowk

I think bay morgan and red roan tenessee walker are pretty underrated

[tulip solstice]

oh my god bro read this in caps

what the fc did they do to keiran

god damn it

im glad i wasnt spoiled on this but

im sad that hes dead and how he died

idek when he got kidnapped

[royal kettle]

Next time you do a playthrough you should see at what point he stops being at camp or if its one of those things where he's at camp until you start the mission and all of a sudden he's dead

[trim hamlet]

you don't like the strawberry roan ardennes or?

[tulip solstice]

yo guys what just happened?

there was like a woman crying by like a swamp, i waddled over and pressed E to help and i got shanked??

then she ran and i shot her outta pity, and then some crazed folk came and killed me with a hatchet

is this a "lucky" event or part of story or what?

[tulip solstice]

i'll pay mind to it

[tulip solstice]

please help man im feeling very at unease right now

[lament delta]

stuff

[tulip solstice]

that does NOT help

[lament delta]

😢

[true bobcat]

Yo

You said you wanna chat here

[tulip solstice]

god damn it yall aint a help

[lament delta]

nah we helping you just not listening

[tulip solstice]

sure kid

[regal matrix]

its a random event

youll find a variety of random events throughtout the world

this one in particular was a nightfolk ambush

they just kill for the hell of it

[regal matrix]

where do i catch the lake sturgeon/

im in lagras and i cant catch any

[cyan pendant]

Or hear me out it’s a skill issue

[tall obsidian]

Guys

Anyone here had New austin w arthur strat

[cyan pendant]

Yeah Brontë mission

[tall obsidian]

Damn just one

[cyan pendant]

That’s the only one I know that works

[tall obsidian]

Does Teleporting cops, with aimbot accuraccy doesnt spawn on that mission

My favourite realism of Rdr2 is the fact that telepods,Satelite are used by pinkertons 👍

[tulip solstice]

now this is called help, thanks brother

[obtuse trellis]

stay away from people in the swamp

[tulip solstice]

how about i shoot all them folk dead

[regal matrix]

With your guns

Use dead eye if you don't wanna lose your health

[tulip solstice]

i think you read my statement as "how do i shoot them dead" i wasnt asking but making a declaration

[regal matrix]

Ohhh

[azure sluice]

hey y'all is there any way to get Arthur's outfit from Chapter 1 without mods?

[midnight ocean]

go to your outfits

it is there

you'll overheat if you're not in the cold areas tho

[regal matrix]

its not

the closed winter gunslinger isnt in the game

the one in the vanilla game is the opened version

[midnight ocean]

then no you need mods

oh you're a different person

[ancient forge]

why arthur couching on chapter 6 ?

he is sick :(

[hybrid star]

pepole does my horse dies in some mission and is there any way to counter it

[ancient forge]

buy horse revive tonic

[scenic dirge]

for some reason when im using dead eye, it marks the enemy as soon as my crosshair goes over it

that never happened in my last run
is there a way to disable it or something

[midnight ocean]

too much smoking

[midnight ocean]

no theres levels to dead eye

the first level auto tags

second level you manually tag but it exits when you fire

third level you can keep firing without exiting if you dont tag

it upgrades during particular story moments

you need to finish one of the last missions in chapter 2 to get the next one

[regal matrix]

Once you get to that train robbery mission you'll unlock custom deadeye marking

[green plinth]

Do the stats of guns improve the more you use them?

[obtuse trellis]

no

you just get better

[green plinth]

Are you sure because the Carbine has way better stats than the Lancaster in my game despite the Wiki disagreeing

[green plinth]

Like Arthur gets better at using them?

[cyan pendant]

Your Lancaster is probably dirty

[regal matrix]

No but you can get upgrades like the scope and rifling at the gunsmith

[green plinth]

It's not, I cleaned them both first.

[midnight ocean]

in what way does the wiki disagree

[green plinth]

I can't post images

They should be pretty comparable

[midnight ocean]

so the numbers dont match up to what you see in game?

[green plinth]

Wow I can't post links either

Yes

[regal matrix]

Post in general media

No links tho

[midnight ocean]

does one have attachments maybe?

mine are both stock afaik and the only thing that doesnt match with the wiki is that they have the exact same range

carbine has better damage and reload speed but worse fire rate and accuracy

[green plinth]

should both be stock

[midnight ocean]

what stats dont match the wiki for you? can you post a screenshot of each gun?

[cyan pendant]

They probably have rifling on one of them

[midnight ocean]

well im wondering why mine both have the same range now lol

only guns i ever customized were my schofields

[cyan pendant]

It also depends on the bullets your using like high velocity have more range

[midnight ocean]

ohhh shit i didnt even realize the stats change when you equip different ammo

someone on reddit complaining that the challenges cant possibly get harder than master hunter 2 lmfao

[cyan pendant]

…. Master hunter 6 is a thing

[midnight ocean]

why are cougars so much harder to find than panthers

feel like i can get a panther anytime but cougar is hit or miss

[cyan pendant]

Exactly there’s this one spot I go to all the way left of strawberry by that lake

The hard part is they show up when I don’t want them to

[midnight ocean]

yeah by the trapper right

i had to alternate between there and roanoke

[cyan pendant]

I always just slept you can get lucky and get two sometimes

But I love when I’m hunting for a bear cougar shows up but when I’m hunting for a cougar bear

[midnight ocean]

grizzly bear i always just go to that spot by wallace station

ive gotten a double spawn there a few times

only once did i see a grizzly over by the cougar spawn

[earnest sky]

I’ve been doing a bunch of chores,donating money to the box,greeting everyone and doing as many random encounters as I can get and my honor will not go past 50%

Idk why but it’s really annoying

[midnight ocean]

there are honor caps in early chapters

cant go past a certain level

or do you mean the bar is right in the middle and wont move at all

[earnest sky]

I’m in chapter three, which I believe the max is 75%

Kinda dumb there is a max tho

[midnight ocean]

try restarting the game

but also dont worry about honor so much unless you really want to buy the outfits and stuff right this minute

[earnest sky]

Already did that a few times and I’ve done about 5 rounds of all chores

[earnest sky]

I really want the gun grips

Kinda weird both are locked behind high honor

[tiny dawn]

This helps so much. I was walking around saying hi to everyone at St Denis and my honor wasnt moving. I understand now

[earnest sky]

And one of the clothing items will complete my outfit

[wise nebula]

Peak name btw

[earnest sky]

It really is

[midnight ocean]

one is high and one is low isnt it?

[earnest sky]

Apparently not

[midnight ocean]

pretty sure the double action grip is low honor only although i have heard of a bug that allowed you to purchase it with the same amount of high honor

[earnest sky]

You’d think it would but both are locked behind high honor

The wiki says otherwise tho

[midnight ocean]

If the player has an Honor rank of -4 or lower (25% or less on the Honor bar), a unique Gunslinger Ebony grip becomes available for this weapon, obtainable from any Gunsmith.
The player may also be able to purchase this grip with the corresponding amount of high Honor, likely as a result of an oversight.

[earnest sky]

Exactly

The wiki says one is locked behind low

[midnight ocean]

you just said both are locked behind high?

[earnest sky]

But both are locked in high

[midnight ocean]

according to what

[earnest sky]

Everyone who has tried to get the grips

And me

That got max low honor and still wasn’t able to get it

[midnight ocean]

if you havent unlocked them yet how would you know tho

[earnest sky]

The hundreds of Reddit posts

About this exact thing

[midnight ocean]

well like i said there is a known bug where you can purchase the low honor one at high honor

but it should still be obtainable at low honor as well

[earnest sky]

I’m pretty sure the bug is you can’t buy it at low honor

Possibly a forgotten negative somewhere

[midnight ocean]

yeah i think people are just confused

i see lots of people saying they were able to get the double action grip at high honor but i dont really see anyone saying they were UNABLE to get it at low honor

[earnest sky]

It’s not like wikis are right all the time

It is a fan-edited website

[earnest sky]

Just look up “can’t get ebony grip reddit”

I’ve heard nothing but good things about this game until I get it and then suddenly it’s “this game sucks” and “it’s trash” fun game but some infuriating things

[midnight ocean]

yeah but ive also seen people confirming they got it at low honor

weird

[earnest sky]

I’ve tried looking to make sure I wasn’t crazy but I honestly can’t find it

Possibly something weird going on In-between the chapter transitions

[midnight ocean]

well all games have their bugs

[earnest sky]

I really wish this game got worked on some more

[earnest sky]

True

[midnight ocean]

theres so many great things about the game i feel like we can forgive a small glitch related to weapon cosmetics

[earnest sky]

Just to fix the smaller things like this

[ionic pike]

howdy... just got to Valentine 1st time... looking to clean my horse... can anyone tell me how to get a brush?

[midnight ocean]

think you get it in a couple of missions

[ionic pike]

oh ok thanks

[trim hamlet]

you can also cross rivers/ride your horse through water to clean it

[earnest sky]

I’ve also got soft locked a dozen times,no clipped out of nowhere and had an “enemy” wander in for no reason

[midnight ocean]

soft locked doing what?

[ionic pike]

wish I thought of that ... thx!

[earnest sky]

It’s a really fun game but it’s the small things that get me to put it down for days or weeks at a time

[midnight ocean]

i just did an entire 100% playthrough with hardly any bugs lol

[earnest sky]

Idk if soft locked is the right term but story enemy’s glitching into inaccessible areas, story just not progressing, getting stuck between two npcs in camp

[royal kettle]

The only bug I experienced was back end of the carriage weirdly parked and I couldn't cook for some reason while in the cooking animation

[earnest sky]

All fixable with a save reset but annoying at times when the autosave is before important or long quest

[midnight ocean]

and you play on playstation? thats bizarre

oh yeah the one bug i got a few times was my horse transforming into a tennesee walker

[earnest sky]

Only reason im on discord is because im next to Pearson getting constantly knocked back by nothing

[midnight ocean]

post a clip lol

[earnest sky]

I would but my recent clip is just out of the time limit

I closed the game not to long ago

I know it’s very suspicious but I promise you it happens

[midnight ocean]

are you like triggering this stuff on purpose?

[earnest sky]

No

I went to grab the bucket,Pearson walked up then I was stuck

[cyan pendant]

Not anymore

[midnight ocean]

i spent a lot of time in camp and walking around near pearson trying to get his request to trigger and never got stuck or anything like that

[cyan pendant]

Oh his scout jacket

[earnest sky]

Request?

Which one

[cyan pendant]

That’s I like my favorite jacket

[midnight ocean]

did it get changed in a patch?

[cyan pendant]

I believe so

[midnight ocean]

he wants a rabbit carcass

gives you a unique scout jacket color

chapter 2 only

[cyan pendant]

He gives you a Jean color scout jacket

[earnest sky]

Goddam chapter locked things

[cyan pendant]

That’s why you take your time with the chapters and especially the camps

[midnight ocean]

its ok i thought i wanted it then when i got it i never wore it lol

[cyan pendant]

Shit I wore that thing throughout chap 3

[midnight ocean]

yeah but holy shit some of them take forever to trigger even if you sit there and try over and over between missions

[earnest sky]

Most of my time was in the camp

Mainly for fishing and upgrading

Got everything max before chapter 3

[midnight ocean]

most of your time was in the camp? how lol

[earnest sky]

Chores too

[midnight ocean]

idk why anyone would do the chores

[earnest sky]

Honor

But NooOOoo

[midnight ocean]

its so slow though

[earnest sky]

They HaVe to Be cHapTer locked

[midnight ocean]

i mean you can get enough honor in chapter 2 or 3 to get the outfits and grips

75% is enough

thats the cap

[earnest sky]

It’s locked at 50% in chapter 2

I believe

[trim hamlet]

ohhhh so that's why i kept on greeting people in saint denis and never got more than slightly whiteish gray

[earnest sky]

I already got my main outfit anyways so I don’t need those but it would be nice

[midnight ocean]

maybe until a certain mission

[earnest sky]

Does the honer “puck” move in large increments for each level or slowly?

[midnight ocean]

increments i think

it will appear to almost not move at all then suddenly it will move a noticeable amount

if you want to gain more i would recommend just donating what you have in valuables in $21 increments and greeting people in saint denis

i did a lot of low honor stuff in chapter 3 but then was able to raise it enough to get the outfits unlocked without too much effort

[earnest sky]

I find the chores to be better then greeting

3 people for 1 honor

[wise nebula]

Are you guys talking about honor?

[earnest sky]

15 seconds for ten is a better deal in my eyes

[midnight ocean]

where do you find the values

[midnight ocean]

yes

[wise nebula]

For me I just do the camp chores and donate money to the box, the saint Denis thing takes a while

[earnest sky]

A post on Reddit but it seems to be a verified chart

[wise nebula]

Aslong as your good on money

[obtuse trellis]

no you do

sorry im 10 hours late

[cyan pendant]

You guys do know that your suit in the Saint Denis robbery changes depending on your honor right?

[obtuse trellis]

yeah the low honor version looks 10x better

[cyan pendant]

It’s red if your low and blue if your high honor

[wise nebula]

I never noticed 😭

[earnest sky]

I would post it here but I can’t

[cyan pendant]

Yeah it’s cool

[green plinth]

700 hours of tf2 taught me to be good at shooters already

[obtuse trellis]

what is tf2

[earnest sky]

I think it was in the pamphlet that came with the disc version

Wish they still did that

[midnight ocean]

titanfall 2

[green plinth]

team fortress 2 not titanfall 2

have you really heard of neither

[earnest sky]

Either or

[green plinth]

im getting old

[midnight ocean]

[obtuse trellis]

liar fraud coward

micah

lying micah

[midnight ocean]

ok blacklung

[obtuse trellis]

coughs

[earnest sky]

Titanfall is the better game anyways

[obtuse trellis]

no i dont play many story games

[foggy glade]

Both are multiplayer

BOTH are shooterd

[obtuse trellis]

i dont play those either

[foggy glade]

We got Mr chess over here or what

[green plinth]

rdr2 only game

lol

[obtuse trellis]

nah

i play a few gamepass games

[earnest sky]

Account made last year,no pfp,plays on pc

[midnight ocean]

so what do you play lol

[foggy glade]

[earnest sky]

So Probably

[obtuse trellis]

red dead 2 read dead 2 and read dead 2

[foggy glade]

So that guy fits you

[earnest sky]

Top three games right there

[obtuse trellis]

sometimes i play cod but it lowk fell off

[green plinth]

at any given time i will generally be playing a pc game and a console game

[midnight ocean]

not lowkey lol it fell off like 10 years ago

[green plinth]

not at the same time but like i switch between the two

[foggy glade]

I'm tryna convert my dad into bf6 and not black and ops 7

[foggy glade]

Black and ops💔

[obtuse trellis]

yeah but the new mw2 was alright

[green plinth]

rn thats rdr2 on pc and gran turismo 7 on ps4

[foggy glade]

New?

[midnight ocean]

yeah exactly it was aight

[obtuse trellis]

theres 2

[foggy glade]

That thing is like 2 years old

[earnest sky]

Grand tiramisu is ok

[cyan pendant]

…

No

[midnight ocean]

the original cod4 and mw2 were goated

[green plinth]

lol

[foggy glade]

Ion like tiramisu

[obtuse trellis]

2 years is nothing

[green plinth]

its excellent but ruined by microtransactions and live service unfortunately

[foggy glade]

Sorry unc

[midnight ocean]

waw and black ops 1 were also goated

[cyan pendant]

I don’t care I’m still gonna play og mw2

[obtuse trellis]

i was thinking of buying either rdr1 or ghost of tsusima

[foggy glade]

Best campaign in cod games is for me ww2

[green plinth]

did goat sushi come out on pc yet?

[wise nebula]

Same

[cyan pendant]

Ghost os Tsushima is peak but so is rdr1

[earnest sky]

Both are good

[obtuse trellis]

i have no idea

i still gotta play gta 5 💔

[foggy glade]

Either sick cowboy or random guy fighting for Honor with cool sword and shin shin shang

Those are sword sounds bte

[earnest sky]

Get rdr if you love story and lore but ghost of Tsushima would be an entirely new experience which is good for everyone

[cyan pendant]

Bro is just a uchiha from Naruto

[obtuse trellis]

i wanna play rdr1 because it feels like an actual cowboy game

rdr2 feels more like i dont even know

[earnest sky]

Sick cowboy fighting for honor or sick samurai fighting for honor

[foggy glade]

Trust got also cowboy

[cyan pendant]

A lot is changed from rdr2 fair warning

[foggy glade]

But you use machete more often

[obtuse trellis]

yeah i know

[foggy glade]

And it's long and thin

[cyan pendant]

Like wounds are a thing

[obtuse trellis]

hopefully dead eye wont be as op in 1

because i hate dead eye

[earnest sky]

The accuracy in GOT is better then RDR2

[cyan pendant]

It’s is

[earnest sky]

In my opinion

[cyan pendant]

Dead eye was always op

Dueling is so much harder tho in rdr1

[obtuse trellis]

it makes the gameplay so unfunny

[earnest sky]

Just don’t use it

[obtuse trellis]

like 90% of fights are slowed down

[green plinth]

you die too easy when youre fighting 8 bounty hunters at once

[foggy glade]

Same in ghost of Hiroshima

[green plinth]

if you dont use it

[cyan pendant]

Those are way easier

[green plinth]

game has too much latency for me to aim in sweaty mode

[foggy glade]

The last fight

[cyan pendant]

Ok

[obtuse trellis]

if theres a tempting special ability i can easily activate thats placed right in the middle of my fingers im gonna use it

[cyan pendant]

Bro was not that hard

[oblique quiver]

You mean Tsushima?😭

[earnest sky]

Unbind it then

[foggy glade]

And the first against khan I sweated till I realized the story was made to loose

[green plinth]

no i mean in rdr2

[obtuse trellis]

but that doesnt mean its good

[obtuse trellis]

good idea

[foggy glade]

Jedi survivor dark force

[oblique quiver]

Ghost of Tsushima not Hiroshima lol

[green plinth]

you replied to the wrong person i think

[earnest sky]

You can’t complain about a ability and then continue to use that ability because it’s good

[foggy glade]

Bro it's 3:30 idek what I'm saying

[oblique quiver]

O yeah I did

Mb

[cyan pendant]

Bro here it’s 8:30

[earnest sky]

I guess you can but it seems counterintuitive

8:35 here

[foggy glade]

Am or pm?

[cyan pendant]

Yo let’s go America

On

[green plinth]

suit yourself but its too easy to die to bounty hunters without it in my opinion

[cyan pendant]

Pm*

[obtuse trellis]

65:15 here

[green plinth]

also helps you get perfect pelts (generally requires a one-shot kill)

[foggy glade]

ᠣᠣ ᠸᠧᠮ ᠪᠢᠷ᠎ᠠ ᠪᠢᠳᠡ

[obtuse trellis]

i just run away from bounty hunters

[green plinth]

why

[blissful pier]

Lol same

[obtuse trellis]

im not getting mauled by a dog like john did

[earnest sky]

I usually just use the lasso for perfect pelts

[green plinth]

they drop comfy loot

[cyan pendant]

Bro walk slowly towards them for like no reason

[earnest sky]

Less of a chance to mess up

[green plinth]

i had genuinely forgot the lasso exists

[foggy glade]

Gn guys

I have to wake up at 8

[cyan pendant]

Gn Yeezy

[earnest sky]

I use it a lot for no reason

Sometimes I’ll lasso someone to the tracks just because

[green plinth]

oof

[cyan pendant]

I like only use it for bounty’s

[earnest sky]

But now I gotta watch my honor

[foggy glade]

night

[cyan pendant]

Nah embrace the low honor

[foggy glade]

Iiiiii shoot the lights out

[earnest sky]

But I won’t get the cool villain handle

[cyan pendant]

Fair

That is my favorite grip

[foggy glade]

Oh one thing before I fall asleep

[earnest sky]

Arthur’s gotta be sweating like hell

I have a pirate outfit on with the level 8 beard

The pirate outfit is insanely hot

[obtuse trellis]

i hate dutch more than micah

ngl

[foggy glade]

Who's with me

[earnest sky]

Nevermind misread it

[foggy glade]

And who's against me

[foggy glade]

Yooo pause

Bro got crush on pirate Arthur

[earnest sky]

For all you know I’m a raccoon

[cyan pendant]

Be practical

[earnest sky]

The outfit is hot the person wearing it is not

[foggy glade]

Raccoon city

[earnest sky]

Unless if the person wearing it was Tilly

[foggy glade]

Aight gn guys

[obtuse trellis]

i never liked dutch

even first playthrough

[foggy glade]

Love yl

[earnest sky]

Or Karen

[obtuse trellis]

but the first time i played micah was mad cool

[foggy glade]

Micah turned bad when he did his thing in strawberry

[obtuse trellis]

i was eating during that mission i didnt even realize what he was doing

[foggy glade]

I can just imagine "Yo wtf happened, I just took a spoon of my soup and the towns dead"

[earnest sky]

There is a random dead bird 7 feet above the stew pot

[cyan pendant]

Bro I left micha alone for like 5 seconds and he died I have to supervise him everytime

[obtuse trellis]

hes the strongest npc how 😭

[cyan pendant]

I literally don’t know

[midnight ocean]

you could also just not have a bounty

[cyan pendant]

I left him alone to go loot then I come back and he gets headshot

[green plinth]

im not paying it off when i get it paid off for free later anyway

also you get a bounty from story missions

also bounty hunters drop loot so its more profitable to have a bounty

[midnight ocean]

but if you couldnt use deadeye you would be incentivized to pay it off

profit is meaningless anyway unless you just want to have money for the sake of it

paying off bounties is one of the only useful ways to spend all that money lol

[green plinth]

id be more incentivized to git gud and spam tonics tbh

[midnight ocean]

then there you go

its not a lack of deadeye that would be the problem

[green plinth]

theres so much you can buy in this game

[midnight ocean]

minty big game would help too

[midnight ocean]

clothes?

[green plinth]

clothes guns horses

[midnight ocean]

you can only have four horses

[green plinth]

gun customization

[midnight ocean]

get most guns for free

[green plinth]

not engraved/upgraded

[midnight ocean]

thats just for fun

[green plinth]

only way to get the improved gear for skills and legendary pelts is by paying the trapper to make thme

[midnight ocean]

yeah but thats all fairly cheap in the grand scheme of things

[obtuse trellis]

money is so useless i cant lie

like clothes

thats it

[midnight ocean]

i customized the shit out of two guns and bought nearly everything possible from the trapper as arthur and still had $15k at the end of chapter 6

[green plinth]

you also only get one free handgun of the types you do get free

gotta buy a second to dual wield

[earnest sky]

Fr got 5k before chapter 3

[midnight ocean]

yeah i bought two schofields and customized them both a good deal

[green plinth]

ive got close to $4000 in chapter 3

[obtuse trellis]

ive been playing on the same save for a few months now and literally have only spend money on clothes

[midnight ocean]

so why do you care about profit lol thats so much

[green plinth]

sadge you get a free schofield from the valentine doctor's office robbery

[cyan pendant]

I think I had 7k?

[midnight ocean]

oh maybe i did do that then

[earnest sky]

I wish you could rob banks

[midnight ocean]

i forgot

robbing trains is fun

but banks would be nice too

[earnest sky]

But not very profitable

[midnight ocean]

i mean

[green plinth]

is it any different in rdo?

[earnest sky]

I rarely get anything

[midnight ocean]

you can make at least a hundred off a train robbery

net

[cyan pendant]

Not really

[green plinth]

more trouble than its worth tbh

[earnest sky]

Most I get is baked beans and pocket change

[midnight ocean]

$100-$200 in a few minutes is pretty good

imo

[midnight ocean]

you gotta rob the right trains, the blue ones are where the cash is at

[green plinth]

i have no idea why you would specifically grind for money in this game rather than just playing it

[midnight ocean]

i dont think they spawn in the open world until chapter 4 or so

but you can manually spawn one by buying a train ticket, the train you get off of will be a valuable train

[cyan pendant]

I think I got 400 in like 10 minutes off of trains

[midnight ocean]

well you were the one talking about purposefully having bounty hunters pursue you so you could make a profit lol

[green plinth]

that's ezpz though

[midnight ocean]

so is the train

[green plinth]

it's not grinding, that's extra free money i make by playing the game

[midnight ocean]

robbing trains is not grinding lol its fun

[green plinth]

they are annoying when you want to track legendary animals though

[earnest sky]

Money is really easy to come by in just the story missions

[obtuse trellis]

has anyone else noticed arthurs visibly scared in lemoyne

[green plinth]

you also dont lose honor for killing and looting bounty hunters

[midnight ocean]

like honor matters

[earnest sky]

Treasure maps are pretty easy too

Wish it told you which ones were completed

[midnight ocean]

i robbed tons of trains and still maxxed honor by the end

and in the epilogue honor matters even less

[earnest sky]

Honor gives you discounts

So if you really need a lot for something then might as well get that 40% discount

[midnight ocean]

honor doesnt matter because discounts dont matter discounts dont matter because money doesnt matter

imo

[earnest sky]

50%*

[obtuse trellis]

low honor gives 100% discounts

[green plinth]

on what?

[midnight ocean]

what ive heard is high honor gives discounts but low honor gives better loot from bodies

[obtuse trellis]

everything

[earnest sky]

Nope

[green plinth]

you can steal custom engraved firearms?

[midnight ocean]

think hes making a joke about stealing

[earnest sky]

Low honor gives nothing

[green plinth]

yeah but it doesnt make sense in context

[obtuse trellis]

engravings give no tactical advantage

[earnest sky]

You get better loot from higher honor

[midnight ocean]

Much like in Red Dead Redemption, the player can receive discounts from various stores if they have high honor. At rank 2, stores offer a 10% discount; at rank 4, stores offer a 25% discount; and at ranks 7 and 8, stores offer a 50% discount. Meanwhile, having low honor allows the player to loot better-quality items from dead bodies.

from wiki

[earnest sky]

The wiki really needs to be fixed

[midnight ocean]

how do you know its wrong tho

[cyan pendant]

Robbery

[earnest sky]

Some guy posted the pamphlet that comes with the disc version

I trust the pamphlet more then the wiki

But we were both wrong

They both give different chances for different things

Not the pamphlet, mb

The strategy guide

[midnight ocean]

official or unofficial strategy guide

[earnest sky]

Official

I actually use the internet archive instead of reddit for most things

[midnight ocean]

how are you viewing the strategy guide

[earnest sky]

Internet archive

[cyan pendant]

The only time I ever use a guide for this game is the 90 challenges

[earnest sky]

I just said it

ttps://archive.org/details/guide_RDR2/page/n92/mode/1up

[earnest sky]

Only problem I’m having is with the gambling ones but that’s more rng then anything

[cyan pendant]

Yeah

But thankfully those are done

It’s just herbalist and survivalist now

[midnight ocean]

okay so im reading where it says that at -1 honor you get more stuff from bodies

[earnest sky]

I corrected myself

Different chances for different things

[midnight ocean]

you said we were both wrong lol how was i wrong

it matches what is said on the wiki

[earnest sky]

You said it was only for low

[cyan pendant]

I have no idea what going on …

[earnest sky]

Tbh

Neither do I

[midnight ocean]

oh

[cyan pendant]

So this is pointless ..

[earnest sky]

I’m on my bed eating takis and shooting at a floating bird in camp

[midnight ocean]

we're talking about the differences between low honor and high honor

[earnest sky]

It’s a cowboy game

It’s definitely pointless

[cyan pendant]

Low= bad high = good

Somehow Arthur is still considered a good man

[midnight ocean]

so apparently potent tonics, restorative items, food and jewelry drops are increased with high honor but deadeye tonics, thrown weapons, alcohol and tobacco as well as money and jewelry from lawmen increase with low honor

[earnest sky]

Makes sense

[cyan pendant]

Yeah I knew money was

[earnest sky]

The more combative items for low

[midnight ocean]

lawmen definitely give better loot regardless

[cyan pendant]

Yeh cause there lawman

[midnight ocean]

but i also dont see anywhere where it says you get +1 for greeting npcs

[cyan pendant]

God I love poison throwing knifes

They just fuck up bears

[midnight ocean]

and it says camp chores only give +5

also i dont think the donation one is accurate because afaik you get one amount for donating $20 or less and a slightly higher amount for donating more than $20

[cyan pendant]

The only problem is if your in chap 6 Dutch smashes the box and you can’t donate

[midnight ocean]

yeah but chapter 6 is still the best time to gain honor despite that

[cyan pendant]

Yeah the Strauss missons basically give you max honor

[midnight ocean]

theres a few side missions that give you a lot

like the widow of willards rest

also all honor gains are increased by 50% in chapter 6

[earnest sky]

I was thinking about getting the book but it’s $300

[cyan pendant]

What book?

[midnight ocean]

holy shit lol

[earnest sky]

The strategy guide

[midnight ocean]

i do miss paper strategy guides

especially versusbooks, they had the best

[cyan pendant]

Ah that’s why we have internet

[midnight ocean]

yeah but man it can be so much easier to hold it in your hands

[earnest sky]

I think the book was part of the collectors box

[midnight ocean]

i hate reading books online

[cyan pendant]

That’s fair

[earnest sky]

You would need an entire case just for the paperback pamphlet

[cyan pendant]

Does anyone else kinda just go through Arthur’s journal as John or is that just me

[earnest sky]

That used to come with games

I go through Arthur’s journal as Arthur

It says there’s a new entry but it’s a lie

[midnight ocean]

i did because i wanted to see what the last thing arthur wrote was

[earnest sky]

The aliens are beaming false info into my brain

[midnight ocean]

it was a drawing of the bridge explosion

pretty fucked up

[earnest sky]

That’s why I wear this here cap I found on a strange man in a hole

[cyan pendant]

I like seeing the black water plan in the front

[midnight ocean]

i get that all the time

and i just think "ive seen like 50 of this animal, how can he possibly have something new to draw" lol

[earnest sky]

I really want armor added to this game

Not to actually do something but just for looks

[cyan pendant]

In rdo there is

[earnest sky]

At least actually finish the Viking set

[midnight ocean]

like plate metal armor?

[cyan pendant]

Yeah

[midnight ocean]

that would be odd

[cyan pendant]

There is this one misson in rdo where you raid a fort

[earnest sky]

There’s a Viking helmet

[cyan pendant]

It’s the one where John gets shot by bill in rdr1

I forgot the name

[earnest sky]

Whats so different about finding someone with armor

[midnight ocean]

i just saw a scene on youtube from that movie the ballad of buster scruggs though and a guy who was getting robbed threw on a set of armor made of pots and pans and rushed the guy lol

[earnest sky]

That would be amazing

[midnight ocean]

yeah thats more meant to be like an antique that you find though not something someone actually made recently

[earnest sky]

Antique armor

[midnight ocean]

viking armor?

[earnest sky]

Believe it or not armor wasn’t invented in the last 200 years

[cyan pendant]

What I would give for a leather black jacket in the game

I know on pc mods there is

Just make it a dlc

[earnest sky]

Viking armor is leather but yea

[midnight ocean]

but what kind of armor would you find in america

[earnest sky]

Probably Viking

[midnight ocean]

conquistador? probably too far north for that right

[earnest sky]

With the dead Viking

[cyan pendant]

Eh

That’s all like uk

[midnight ocean]

but vikings didnt wear heavy plate

also it wouldnt really be found too far from the east coast would it

[cyan pendant]

Vikings were never really in America

[midnight ocean]

i think they were briefly

[earnest sky]

Leather

Not plate

[midnight ocean]

okay i said plate before and i thought you said yeah but that was nightwolf lol

i wish the found weapons had more variety but most of them seem to be hatchets of some kind

which i guess makes sense

[earnest sky]

There’s a sword

And a civil war knife

[midnight ocean]

yeah but theres like 10 different hatchets

[earnest sky]

But yea mainly hatchets

Can you lose those?

[midnight ocean]

a cavalry sword would have fit the setting

[earnest sky]

You can throw them but idk if you can lose them

[midnight ocean]

no i dont believe so

wait you can throw the unique found ones? i thought they were just melee

[earnest sky]

Yea

Just the hatchets tho

[midnight ocean]

they might just stay where you toss em

[earnest sky]

That’d be annoying

It might go back to the weapons locker

[midnight ocean]

tbh i could care less i never use throwables anyway

as long as i got em in the compendium

[earnest sky]

I threw a hatchet to test it and the valentine police are on me

[midnight ocean]

holy shit the lote outfit gives bonuses??? i didnt know that

[earnest sky]

I’m in strawberry

[midnight ocean]

i thought it just looked cool

[earnest sky]

Where’s that

[midnight ocean]

in the guide

[earnest sky]

I meant page

[midnight ocean]

171

or 86 according to the viewer thingy

[earnest sky]

Oh that

It tells you that in the description of the item

[midnight ocean]

okay so i just tossed every hatchet i had at beechers hope, fast traveled to annesburg, saved, quit the game, booted back up and it seems theyre all back in my inventory

[earnest sky]

Not exact percentages but it does tell you

[earnest sky]

Nice

[earnest sky]

They’re always active

[midnight ocean]

i think i forget item descriptions exist

i just found out the horse compendium actually tells you which coats are wild and which can be bought at the stables for each horse

[earnest sky]

Makes sense

Its flavor text most of the time

[earnest sky]

I don’t customize my horse all that much

I really should look at those

[midnight ocean]

yeah i dont do that it feels kinda weird

like i cant really picture john or arthur getting their horses hair colored and braided lol

[earnest sky]

Same

[midnight ocean]

i do try to make the saddle look good tho

[earnest sky]

Maybe tied up a little but nothing fancy

[earnest sky]

I think I’m using the premium saddle or the legendary boar one

[cyan pendant]

I really hope if they go in the direction for the 3rd game to do a young Arthur we get his old horse bodacea

[earnest sky]

Whatever it is its definitely a boar pelt

[earnest sky]

I’m kinda hoping for a Dutch game

[cyan pendant]

I just want a young Arthur and John dynamic

[midnight ocean]

hell naw

to both

new protag

[cyan pendant]

…no

[midnight ocean]

where does it end

[cyan pendant]

Idk

[midnight ocean]

rdr4 play as baby hosea

[cyan pendant]

There is so much they can still do with a younger version of the gang

[midnight ocean]

in terms of like action setpieces sure

narrative less so

[cyan pendant]

Like who was the guy that Dutch shot in camp Arthur’s old dog and horse John’s upbringing

[midnight ocean]

in rdr1 there was a lot of intrigue about what the van der linde gang was like so in rdr2 we explored that. now you wanna know what the van der linde gang was like again but just earlier?

[cyan pendant]

Ye

[midnight ocean]

bruh lol

that just aint interesting enough for a whole game

[cyan pendant]

Idk I’ll just be happy if we get a rdr game soon

[midnight ocean]

that kind of thinking is how you wind up with the han solo movie

how did han get the falcon? how did han get the dice? how did han get the name?

[cyan pendant]

That movie was ok

[midnight ocean]

you always gotta have some lore for your game that doesnt mean you need to actually experience that lore in a prequel every time

some stuff is better left unsaid

[trim hamlet]

i'd take a remaster of rdr1 honestly

[cyan pendant]

Yeah and you just wanna leave John out of everything

[trim hamlet]

mid-2010s game design with modern graphics

[midnight ocean]

yes we dont need to do john again

[earnest sky]

Terrible idea but possibly a future where the vander Lin gang is famous and you learn about your ancestors “either Arthur or John” through a fallout type environment

Possibly tech kinda like horizon

[midnight ocean]

well at least that one is original lol

[earnest sky]

Would definitely feel like a horizon knock off tho

[cyan pendant]

This so not assassins creed

[midnight ocean]

id be happy with another game set earlier during the height of the west but the characters story is not connected to the van der linde gang except that maybe hosea appears as a mission giver or something like that

[earnest sky]

That’s more looking for an object of power rather then past

[midnight ocean]

or give me my bootlegger jack sequel

[cyan pendant]

Honestly I kinda just want a rdr1 remake

[midnight ocean]

jack with a car and a tommy gun

[midnight ocean]

thatd be cool but new games are better than remakes imo

[cyan pendant]

I need it okay then I’ll die happy

[midnight ocean]

maybe i should 100% rdr1

i know itll be way easier

we kinda got robbed of undead nightmare 2

that could have been insane

[earnest sky]

I really want to play the other games but they are expensive

[cyan pendant]

I need too to man

[earnest sky]

Looked at rdr1 earlier and it was $70 just for the base game

[cyan pendant]

It’s not 70

I know that for a fact

It’s 50

Since it’s a remaster

[earnest sky]

You right

[cyan pendant]

It’s such a good game tho

And it did win goty

[earnest sky]

It’s such a I can’t afford it tho

[cyan pendant]

2010

Plus you do get undead nightmare which is fun

[earnest sky]

What’s that about

Hellur

[cyan pendant]

Basically John vs the zombie virus

You go around the towns trying to find a cure cause jack and Abigail got bit

And you have to kill zombies in that town

[earnest sky]

Third game about the beginning of the virus?

[cyan pendant]

?

[earnest sky]

Just saying that could be the plot of a third game

[cyan pendant]

I thought you were talking about undead nightmare

[earnest sky]

I am

[cyan pendant]

Ok I’m so lost

[earnest sky]

You said undead was about a zombie virus

I said that a plot for a third game could be about the beginning of that virus

Since we were talking about that earlier

I get off track easily

[cyan pendant]

I see adhd

[midnight ocean]

i think the beginning of the virus is that the racist store owner from armadillo makes a bargain with the devil

iirc

[earnest sky]

Kratos’s type situation

Make a deal and hunt down the deal maker

[earnest sky]

I was thinking that but I don’t really know

[earnest sky]

NOOOO

SEAN my boy

[midnight ocean]

f

[ionic pike]

So I have the game before I am asked to help find a hunter by Cairn Lake... Things go side ways... I reload my say, and NO encoutner... WTH?

[midnight ocean]

sounds like a random encounter

they wont always trigger at the exact same time

[raw tiger]

I caught the white arabian as john, it was dificult because for sone reason theres wolves that spawned near it, I went ahead and finished the 8th chapter is what i call epilogue 2,

Got johns portrait taken with abigail in arthurs old clothes

[ionic pike]

Thank you @midnight ocean

[ionic pike]

ya, I found it... Hunter Needs Help Looking for his Friend. a random one.

[midnight ocean]

[vale sinew]

4 playthroughs and I've only just now notice Agent Ross was at the SD bank mission

I thought it was just some random Pinkerton there

[tulip solstice]

guys i think some time i accidentally clicked something and now i am unable to manually save, can someone help please

how do i turn it back on i cant find it in the settings

[tulip solstice]

it was alberto stealing some underground artifact that started the virus

bro it keeps saying my horse is lost

my 1000 dollar horse

i cant take this bullshit this is the second time hes gone

and it isnt even my fault

the story killed him or what

nvm he teleported back

[royal kettle]

90.2% done with everything feeling good

[azure sluice]

Settings > general i think

not too sure

[tulip solstice]

incorrect

that is the option to turn on or off the autosave

theres no way to turn on manual save again then i guess

fml

[radiant solar]

hai

[potent birch]

I just came here and I already love the emoji and the emoji

[tulip solstice]

yo chat

whats the name of the song that plays after ur back from guarma

?

[obtuse trellis]

unshaken

[tulip solstice]

ty bro

also chat

i think i fucked up my first every playthrouhg of this game

it was supposed to go from low honor to high honor gradually but

now im in chapter 6 and im still hella low honor

its so hard to get your honor up in this game

and it doesnt help that i cant resist shooting random people on the street

mostly i accidentally run people over with my horse though

i dont know what to do

i think i should take a break from doing the story and just go and raise my honor as much as i can

[cyan pendant]

It’s not really especially in chapter 6 you get an honor boost I think

[tulip solstice]

what for??

also i have absolutely no idea whats supposed to be the progression of arthurs actual canon honor/morality

[cyan pendant]

He doesn’t really

He can be both

[tulip solstice]

like in ch 3 he seems like a mid honor guy but then i think he like takes money from a widow whose husband just died??

[tulip solstice]

thats what the devs say so they dont have to declare a canon officially but

i mean the games called red dead REDEMPTION theres clearly a theme here

[tulip solstice]

and im prety sure he also threatens the kid that hes gonna sell his mother or something so 💀 im confused

[cyan pendant]

Arthur’s honor was most likely mid to low then high honor in the later chapters

[cyan pendant]

Nah he says I’ll keep her in black on your behalf

[tulip solstice]

these are not mid honor activities bro

[tulip solstice]

whats the difference?

[cyan pendant]

You know what keep her in black means?

[tulip solstice]

idk what it means in 1899

[cyan pendant]

So basically women back then wore black at the funerals

So he was threatening to kill the kid

[tulip solstice]

ohh

wow thats such a roundabout threat

[cyan pendant]

Still he’s considered a good man somehow

To be fair he is the gangs enforcer so he has to be cold and brutal

[tulip solstice]

wasnt considered a good man back then, will be soon in my perspective

[cyan pendant]

Bro i still get called good man and I’m the lowest honor possible

[obtuse trellis]

why is there music in mexico

[tidal slate]

Because of RDR 1 I assume

[oblique cloud]

"Youre a good man arthur morgan" Proceeds to kill half of valentine

[cyan pendant]

Exactly

[desert edge]

So I mightve done smt kinda cute and impulsive but I was gonna sell my piebald tobiano hungarian halfbred for a turkoman either silver or dark bay but I liked them both so I sold my few spotted appa and got them both and it's like so fun to have them both out and riding in blackwater

[desert edge]

Might keep the dark bay, sell the silver one and get the brindle tb

[obtuse trellis]

finally playing gta5

[timid pewter]

12 years

[obtuse trellis]

its so boring bro

[timid pewter]

na

just keep going

it gets better

[oblique cloud]

anyone know how i can make one of those "quickdraw" videos from yt cause the enemies just feel like dumbasses in those they dont even shoot back

[earnest sky]

You just click the shoot button with the gun equipped

[oblique cloud]

Yeah but i also need a way to improove my accuracy

these guys are getting 3 headshots in 1 second

which definitely isnt possible without some kind of mod

[quick glen]

I thought you were playing as Arthur but then I read about silver bay turkoman and riding in Blackwater💔

[desert edge]

Yeahh its js my main playthrough tho I have arthur in onother playthrough right before the killing bronte mission bc that's when I feel it all went to shit

[quick glen]

If you don’t do American Fathers 2 you can kill Brontë and the gang is still most of the times happy

In that case you have Hosea and Dutch stuck waiting for forever for the mission

[desert edge]

I just use that playthrough when I miss playing ad arthur

Then I have 2 more playing as John but I don't use them

And then my main one

[quick glen]

Okay

Why my message got eliminated

[tidal slate]

Does anyone have a good advice for hitting 8 Animals in a Row using small arrows

[earnest sky]

Go to the old church and wait at the top

It doesn’t have to be in quick succession so just pay attention to when they come down

Works best if you leave a carcass on the ground

[tepid jungle]

Can some explain how the legendary bear comes back to life after skinned and how to do it?

[hexed portal]

how many animals can i lasso kill?

For now it was the hog and some deer

[earnest sky]

It doesn’t

[earnest sky]

deer, pronghorn, sheep, pigs, and cows.

[thick mango]

5

[hexed portal]

Very well

[hybrid basin]

how to play dead red

[cyan pendant]

?

[tiny dawn]

I bought el senor in RDR1

my goat el senor

[obtuse trellis]

break the wheel

[tiny dawn]

you sir are a fish

[hybrid basin]

you thank

[tiny dawn]

then you get drunk and scream LENNEY at the top of your lungs

[earnest sky]

Don’t forget about the quarter

[tiny dawn]

shut up arthur

[pastel plinth]

Would anyone know a way to get cutscenes to play in Ultrawide as well as normal gameplay on pc?

[cyan pendant]

Let’s hope it bites you first Dutch

[obtuse trellis]

?

[pastel plinth]

the cutscenes have borders that goes back to "normal" on an Ultrawide screen after the cutscene, and gets "smaller" when cutscenes start

sorry, I am not exactly tech smart enough to explain it, but it is very annoying XD

[opal marsh]

Does someone know if I can do the gunslinger quest with John marston ?

[pastel plinth]

The 4 old gunslingers? yes you can I believe

[opal marsh]

Does it appear on the map or do I go looking for them

[cyan pendant]

Did you study the pictures and turn them around they should appear on the map

[opal marsh]

Are they in John marston s inventory?

[midnight ocean]

why don't you open your inventory and see lol

[cyan pendant]

Also did you guys know that you can get John’s old gambler hat the one he wore during the main game

[tidal slate]

With the old Church for the 8 Animals I guess they mean the Building near Saint Denis right?

[earnest sky]

200 hours in and I still don’t understand how the dueling works

Isn’t deadeye supposed to activate?

Anyone else absolutely hate the save system

[midnight ocean]

i did it near emerald ranch

mostly birds

[midnight ocean]

you can disable auto save

and stop getting those annoying pop up screens

[earnest sky]

It’s not the actual saving it’s more of the loading

I expect to load in the area I save but I always forget that you don’t

And those popups only happen if you save the game manually in the autosave slot

[midnight ocean]

it should be the general area just not the exact spot

and no i got the pop up like any time the auto save triggered

[earnest sky]

It’s the items I have that make it annoying

2 hour hunting trip and a horse full of pelts suddenly gone

[earnest sky]

Weird

[earnest sky]

You sure it’s not after you manually save or the first time loading in

[tidal slate]

@midnight ocean i haven't made much progress. I don't know I still struggle with the disarming... It seems like I got one or two and then I do something wrong and counter resets...

And it's not the reload

Since I'm trying to do it with the Lancaster

[midnight ocean]

yes its whenever the game tried to autosave, i turned it off and it stopped

[midnight ocean]

just shoot them in the hand and make sure they have a pistol or revolver

if its a rifle they wont drop it