red-dead-singleplayer

[wet ridge]

Where you can get infinite cash

[pseudo patrol]

holy pmo

I miss Mr. Pearso

[tulip solstice]

how exactly?

you mean pick up cash then save and reload?

[wet ridge]

Like yes

Idk if it available in chapter 4 without giving you spoilers

[tulip solstice]

do i even need to saddle? i mean i could access all my weapons and shit from the horse soon as i bought it so i assumed my saddle was already on it??

[tulip solstice]

nevermind then i dont want any spoilers

[wet ridge]

Idk what he means too

Even tho I got full game like 8 times

[tulip solstice]

but why the fuck is that little shit not even in my stable tho??

[wet ridge]

Still dont know all camp interactions,details,npc interactions and just realistic details

[tulip solstice]

like why does it not immediately gt saved soon as i buy a horse?

[fallen hare]

When I buy a horse from a stable it automatically gets saved

And then I can choose to saddle it

Dunno how you got out of the stable without it storing or saddling

[tidal slate]

There was a Bug or something, but as far I know it's only in RDO. If you enter the Stable, on your horse... Make him flee or call to leave. Otherwise it crashes all Time

[tall obsidian]

OMG

GAMBLER 10 is clear

[fallen hare]

Do you get an achievement?

[tall obsidian]

Uhh... No

For some reason

[fallen hare]

No ps trophy :(

[tidal slate]

I just need the Ring Billed Gull for the Zoologist Archivment and 1 Thing I can't find... The Moose 🫎 which I need to skin.

[tall obsidian]

Ok that master hunter,horseman,gambler the most RnG challenge

Is there any rng challenge after the latter 3

[tidal slate]

The Canadian Elk Moose what ever it's called

[fallen hare]

Zoologist cus of animal spawns probably

[tidal slate]

Ye especially two Different Panthers XD

Took me a While to get the California Panther beside the normal one

[tall obsidian]

Require for 100%?

[fallen hare]

Idk

Are the challenges needed for 100? It's over for me

[tall obsidian]

The 90/90 ues

For the animal o e i evelie you dont have to find all of it

[tidal slate]

It shows what's needed for 100 completion

In your Menu (should do at least)

Rock Carving, Dinosaur Bones, Dreamcatchers ...

[tall obsidian]

I mean how bad is it

The animal part

[tidal slate]

All Challenges

[tall obsidian]

Collectible arent rng atleast

[tidal slate]

The Mission, where U need the Rare Flowers+ Bird Feathers

[tall obsidian]

My favourite moment of animal is cougar die from arrow wound still doesnt count kill 5 cougar with arriw

[tall obsidian]

Wich one

[tidal slate]

Duchesses and other Animals

The Mission in Saint Denis from Algernon Wasp

That needs to be completed for 100 also

I remember the Cougar Thing on PC as well, that something doesn't count... At the end it worked, heck knows why

Lucky me I got the Hunter Missions done.

[errant sundial]

im still in chapter 2 and can you get any actual jobs

[ashen edge]

What can you do with fish besides eating it?

[tidal slate]

Use the Meat to craft something

cartilaginous meat for predator bait

@ashen edge

You can even sens of small Fishes via mail and get meat for it as return

[tidal slate]

@midnight ocean now I just need to find the Ring Billed Gull, then I have it 🙂 and + one Canadian Elk 🫎 Moose or what ever. But I haven't seen him yet beside the Legendary

[jovial epoch]

Guy why doesn't the game include stuf Lore from the war in Phillipinse since Americans were fighting in 1899

It only includes old civil war NPC's like Mickey

[haughty geyser]

Bruh idk

[jovial epoch]

Like there's too much civil war fragments and stories

Like the gang

And other

[haughty geyser]

just enjoy the game idk

[jovial epoch]

Ok?

[haughty geyser]

I just finished it i'm just sad don't mind me

Poor Arthur

[jovial epoch]

Dutch just dissapears

And you play as john

[haughty geyser]

Yah i know

Now i wanna know what will happen with john

In rdr1

[jovial epoch]

Nothing Reely

Oh wait

He dies

In rdr1

[haughty geyser]

wow

[jovial epoch]

A sh@t spoiler

Ahahdudjdjdjdjkddjdj

[haughty geyser]

[jovial epoch]

Yeah ig

[haughty geyser]

He found dutch?

[jovial epoch]

In rdr1?

[haughty geyser]

Yep

[jovial epoch]

Idk I haven't played it I just finished rdr2 like 3 months ago

[haughty geyser]

oh ok

[jovial epoch]

For spoilers you have to go on #general

And like ask someone if

Ig

[haughty geyser]

Ok thnx

[obtuse trellis]

i hear kieren screaming i hate this game man 💔

[midnight ocean]

moose are hard to find

i just saw one in tall trees last night tho

after finishing the authors second quest

also try owanjila and isabella

or even cattail pond

[tidal slate]

I'm just looking. That's the last animal which I need to skin for the achievement

(beside picking up the Gull)

[midnight ocean]

i had to skin four for the trapper lol

took the whole playthrough to find em all

[tidal slate]

The Carolina Panther was a Pain in the Butt... But I just saw a funny Hint. And it works well...

That Panther can't climb, so I went to a Crossroad where permanently Panthers spawn. And jumped on the 🪨 and that kitty standing right in front of me meow meow grrr... But don't get me XD

[midnight ocean]

i just waited until i knew a panther would spawn there and ride towards the spawn with rifle in hand

my approach for killing any predator

except grizzlies of course

[tidal slate]

The Gull should be easy

The Bridge or some Harbour Areas should do it

[midnight ocean]

gulls are everywhere yeah

well near water

the fishing shack at gills landing has them spawn on top

i still cant find a fer de lance

[tidal slate]

Not even with the Loading/Save Thing?

I saved the Game at the small Pond, loaded it 2 times again and it turned up in front of me

[midnight ocean]

most of the times i load theres no snake at all, when there is its usually a copperhead

sometimes a black tailed rattlesnake or a timber rattlesnake

after dozens of loads

no fucking way

no way

i just got it lmao

fuck you sheriff we're celebrating

im gonna go to strawberry and get absolutely hammered

[tidal slate]

How you got it? XD

Finally loaded enough

[cyan pendant]

@midnight ocean do you remember if gold health core circle prevents panthers from one shotting you

I’m hunting the legendary one and I hate fighting panthers

[midnight ocean]

i have no idea i just stay on my horse and shoot em with the bolt action

legendary is easy because you know it spawns right in front of you on the third clue

just deadeye and spam it

use explosive ammo if you're really nervous

[tidal slate]

@cyan pendant you know what I hate 😄 I saved at the spawn... And almost everytime the Panther attacks me and bite my Neck... The Game asked me for an "Auto save" man I was just starting to rage

[midnight ocean]

but it couldnt hurt to eat a minty big game ofc

[tidal slate]

How do you get that 🐍 finally

[midnight ocean]

it spawned in literally right after i sent this lol

[tidal slate]

😂 good call

[midnight ocean]

right next to the pond ofc

thats probably the only place it can spawn

every single post ive seen had it spawn in that exact same place

[tidal slate]

Same happend for me, it even bite me

[midnight ocean]

i almost ran it over

thank god i didnt

[cyan pendant]

Wait I have an Ardennes what am I worried about

[midnight ocean]

i took the 3 star skin off it as a trophy

[tidal slate]

😄

[midnight ocean]

even a skittish horse wont buck you if you maintain distance

but if you do get thrown you should still be able to kill it before it gets you

[cyan pendant]

God damn my horse killed it

[midnight ocean]

the panther? damn

[cyan pendant]

This thing is my favorite now

[midnight ocean]

see thats the downside with those war horses lol

oh wait its the legendary you're fine

[cyan pendant]

Since its legendary

I don’t care

[midnight ocean]

gg

[tidal slate]

But it does only on stage 4 right?

Mine is at Level 3 and it bucks me off all the Time I get to close to Alligator 🐊 s

[midnight ocean]

going through certain parts of the swamp on my thoroughbred was pretty much untenable even with level 4 bond

that was the only time having a low bravery horse hurt me

but you can shoot near a gator to make them turn around and move away a bit

it was mostly just trying to cross those little bridges like near catfish jacksons

sorry crawdad willies not catfish jacksons

[cyan pendant]

It also depends on the kind like I have the strawberry one

The thing ran up on me and my Ardennes was like nah

[midnight ocean]

there seems to be a lot of debate on how bravery works or even if it exists at all

[cyan pendant]

Idk all I know this thing is awesome

[tidal slate]

Btw does Honor affect anything later on in the Free game ?

[cyan pendant]

Nah

Not really

Maybe some dialogue

[tidal slate]

I was just wondering, that a random Bounty for me pops up, near Rhodes... I thought Ive catched them all

Seems the Game tried to keep me busy

🙁 and I haven't won the Domino aka gambling challenge yet

I can do blackjack or Poker but this... 🙄

[cyan pendant]

I don’t understand poker and dominos all I know is get rid of yours first poker I kinda just throw out shit and it works

[tidal slate]

I use to play Black Jack and Poker in another Game called Test Drive Unlimited 2 or some Casino Simulations. Kinda funny

[midnight ocean]

i played one of those back in the day but it definitely didnt have a casino lol

might have been the first one

test drive off road unlimited

[cyan pendant]

I learned blackjack from my father

[midnight ocean]

i learned poker from my mom

well sort of

she taught me gin rummy which is very similar to poker

[cyan pendant]

I think I was like 18 at the time my dad made me take a shot every time I busted

[midnight ocean]

damn lol

[cyan pendant]

I was drunk by 10:00

It was so fun though all my cousins and family

[midnight ocean]

i bet

[midnight ocean]

turns out you dont need rufus for zoologist

[misty prism]

Me trying to understand it on RDR1 for trophy without any guides

Actually i am pretty much closer to RDR2 platinum than RDR1

[midnight ocean]

poker?

[misty prism]

Yep or something similar i guess

I am doing it all after missions

[midnight ocean]

all you gotta know is the different hands you can make and the hierarchy

pair, two pair, three of a kind, etc

[misty prism]

Meh, i am too dumb for those games so i just try to guess or see any guides on internet

[midnight ocean]

its really simple tho i promise you

[misty prism]

That's how i cleared those card games in RDR2 for challenges

[midnight ocean]

just google "list of poker hands"

dont worry about how the betting works exactly

[cyan pendant]

Rdr1 was so much easier to plat for me at least

[cyan pendant]

Shit if I get a face card I play it and see what happens

[midnight ocean]

bruh lmao

i worry for the next generation

[cyan pendant]

We are littarly the same generation

I think

I agree the next gen is screwed

[midnight ocean]

you just said your dad taught you poker but then that you just play face cards and hope for the best lol

[cyan pendant]

I said black jack

[cyan pendant]

^

[midnight ocean]

ohhh rip

well poker is super easy too

[cyan pendant]

I just could never pick it up

[midnight ocean]

but like if the first three cards go down and its a king a two and a jack

and you're holding a jack and a six

you have a pair of jacks, but you have to imagine someone else might have a king which would be a pair of kings and would beat your jacks because king is higher

ace, king, queen, jack

[cyan pendant]

I understand the face cards mostly its when I get like a pair of 7s and I win randomly

[midnight ocean]

well if you won with a pair of sevens that just means no one else had anything better than a pair of sevens

so someone might have had a pair of sixes

from lowest to highest it goes high card, pair, two pair, three of a kind, straight, flush, full house, four of a kind, straight flush

a straight is five cards of any suit in order, a flush is any five cards of the same suit

a straight flush is both, its five cards in order of the same suit so like 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6 of all spades or whatever

a full house is just a two pair and a three of a kind together, so like two 3's and three 5's

and three or four of a kind is obviously just 3 or 4 of the same number respectively

not possible to have 5 of a kind because a deck of cards only has 4 of the same number one of each suit

if you fold then your hand no longer counts so it doesnt matter what you have

whats important to remember is a complete hand consists of five total cards so even if you only have a pair your hand still technically consists of the five best cards you have

so if you have a pair of 5s and the other guy also has a pair of 5s but you have an ace in your hand and the other guy has a king, you win that hand

[tulip solstice]

yo guys

I wanted to ask

in rdr 2 , does having low/high honor give you like 2-4 of the final missions as different and then a different ending, or do almost all th missions in the game change up completely ?

[midnight ocean]

i dont think any missions really change with honor just cutscenes

[tulip solstice]

because I remember watching a yt short where Arthur was kicking out Strauss off the camp, and now I'm in chapter 4 and somehow that ain't happened yet, so did I miss it or what

[tulip solstice]

oh fr?

[midnight ocean]

thats like chapter 5 or 6

[cyan pendant]

So that’s if you do all the missions

The debts

[tulip solstice]

Ohh so that's later got it

[hidden moss]

Is anyone else having a crashing issue rn

[tulip solstice]

so I still do experience all the game missions no matter what honor I have

[hidden moss]

My game keeps bluescreening and it’s pissing me off

[cyan pendant]

You can do it low or high Arthur in low honor is just so angry with Strauss and high honor Arthur is just disappointed

[tulip solstice]

I assume this is true then

[hidden moss]

Help :(

[midnight ocean]

there are some side missions that are only available with high honor

i think it might just be one stranger mission chain

[cyan pendant]

It’s the ED one

I’m not gonna say the name

[midnight ocean]

those are my irl initials lol

[cyan pendant]

Damn

[fading trout]

hey, anybody knows how to modding in rdr2 , create a script , i began but its so complicated, underestimated it

[errant nacelle]

Got a question on singleplayer story. I have a bounty in Valentine from robbing the back room at the doctor's. But in a cutscene, Dutch just told me to take Lenny to Valentine and get him drunk.

[midnight ocean]

you're fine

[mortal tusk]

@tulip solstice the story itself doesn't change but rhe dialouge does

[mortal tusk]

And yes

There's some stuff that might be missing but nothing that's genuinely important

[tidal slate]

So i made it? Zoologist and Skin Deep

Gambling Challenge 8 now -.-

[mortal tusk]

I've seen people do it on the boat mission

[tulip solstice]

oh alright ty everyone

also another thing

after the mission where arthur got kidnapped and tortured a beaten to an inch of his life by a rival gang due to a false call by micah, why and how did arthur and micah not have any kind of dialogue or discussion or nothing?

i mean i thought arthur would beat the piss out of micah

and then micah got a member killed and arthur still didnt say nothing?

like im genuinely confused asl how he just skipped past it so easily

[cyan pendant]

Uh you can’t? Gambler 8 is blackjack the boat misson is poker

[mortal tusk]

Oh sorry! I confused the challenges

[regal matrix]

hey so this mission "no good deed" is missing for me
for some reason
the one where you return the wagon to the black doctor
which was stolen by lemoyne raiders

[calm oasis]

Why do I lose honor for killing Roseate Spoonbills?

[tidal slate]

How many did you kill 😏

[cyan pendant]

Well I’ve killed all of Saint Denis just cause

[errant turtle]

Will the mission in which we rescue the boy from the house will come in chapter 3 and uh it has a famous dialogue which is who steals a goddamn boy

(Sorry I forgot the name of the house and that family )

[regal matrix]

thats one of the main missions also its the braithwaite manor (and family)

[errant turtle]

Oh yea
Is it in chapter 3

[regal matrix]

yes

[errant turtle]

Thanks for telling

[foggy tundra]

I cant tell if the treasure maps are a slog or really fun

Somewhere in between

[foggy tundra]

Its not as hard as people make it out to be, it only takes time

Spend a few hours doing it while watching youtube or something and it goes by fast

[tidal slate]

That sounds at least not that bad. I haven't done it so far, with the others except a few runs in domino I got them without issues

[foggy tundra]

Make sure to save after you get each one lol

I crashed and lost progress for it

Id say it takes 3-4 hours?

9 and 10 arent nearly as long

[obtuse trellis]

not rn but there are a few missions that always make my game crash

[tidal slate]

Well a new Role

Zoologist your welcome

[flat flax]

I can't get a panther to spawn anywhere on the map for the perfect pelt, does anyone have any suggestions?
(I've tried every place i can find online)

[tidal slate]

Well yes

You can even jump on the rock, do yourself a favour save the Game and then. Maybe reload a couple of Times. He spawns very often in there forest where is no Road/Path towards that House

Because the Panther doesn't climb,he just surrounds you sitting on top

If he's not there you may walk inside the forest but as soon you see a red dot on the map, try run backwards to the rock

I found the California and the Regular one there

[cyan pendant]

Near catfish Jackson’s is a great place

[flat flax]

so I should start spamming reloads on the big rock

i've just started walking into the forest in hopes of a spawn lol

[midnight ocean]

florida

[tidal slate]

I just did that a couple of Times, went there during the Night and it worked

Yes Mr woolie

[midnight ocean]

idk the panther always spawns in the same place for me

[tidal slate]

I found the Elk finally 🫎 and it was the last animal for skin deep

[midnight ocean]

the moose? lol

[tidal slate]

Moose 🫎 Elk 🫎 it puts up the same Symbol XD

[marble wagon]

personally the spot that worked for me was the area beyond bolder glade but before catfish jacksons, thats the legendary panther location, but after youve hunted that regular panthers spawn in regularly. Once youve killed the legendary, wait a few days in game by sleeping to the max, then set some bait by the road and eventually after a few tries it should pop up

its just a regular panther now, but i found thats the most trustworthy spot where a panther will spawn, other places wouldnt work for me

[flat flax]

okay thank you, i could try that

[midnight ocean]

I gotta say in all my time hunting bait really never did much for me

[marble wagon]

i also would leave a deer carcass by the road where i placed the bait, which draws it to eat from it

[marble wagon]

you gotta get the potent one from the recipe:P works better and attracts more animals with perfect pelts

[midnight ocean]

i think i tried that one

but it seems if i can't find something like a panther it's just because it hasn't spawned

there usually right near the icon

[tidal slate]

Ask woolie about the Fer de Lance 🐍 adventure that tells all the Story

Hehe

[midnight ocean]

fuck that snake lol

[supple trout]

right for the low blows lol

[midnight ocean]

but i finally fully completed every entry in the animal and fish compendium

and got every single item from the trapper

i never have to look at another animal again

[supple trout]

When woolie + Turion are online this is always a happy channel

[tidal slate]

Late Night Comedy

As always

But I'll bet, I can't get a Poker Win Vs woolie on the table because he bluffs all Day

[midnight ocean]

i hide cards in my sleeve

[tidal slate]

I wonder how you play 5 finger filet with a Xbox controller... I would throw it out of the window. Or peek my Fingers all Day long

But to be fair, you helped me that much... That I finally get some Things done. Now I just have the Challenges...

Still some Things to do, but I'm on Gambling 8 right now...

I'll get there... After now 430 hrs on Steam 🙈

Well it counts together with Online

[marble wagon]

i play it on ps5, its very silly

[midnight ocean]

it's super easy

i might post a clip

[midnight ocean]

good shit

[tidal slate]

I can't imagine how that feels but I've never been a Console Player... The last one I've ever touched was that Nintendo Thing looks a bit like a Cube?!

[midnight ocean]

gamecube lol

[tidal slate]

Yes. And then a friend of mine let me try a PS3 and I should do some sharpshooting. I just rage quit

On Pc it's just hammering wsad keys in the right order...

[midnight ocean]

its the same on controller

just with A, B, X and Y

[tidal slate]

Now I see where I struggle... I remember some asked the same question

For the Sharpshooter 8 you need to disarm 3 ppl without reloading

What's the best Way of doing this?

Shoot on their Guns

[midnight ocean]

shoot the hand thats holding it i think

go to hanging dog ranch and there are two guards out front and you can get two pretty easy off of them iirc

its much easier when they have a handgun and not a rifle type weapon

[tidal slate]

And what weapon you prefer?

There are not much Revolvers with more bullet's

I'm blocked here 😄

[midnight ocean]

i just used the lancaster repeater

[tidal slate]

I keep writing and writing but it won't get through

[midnight ocean]

thats weird

maybe bad connection

[tidal slate]

Cats Magic I assume 🪄✨

[obtuse trellis]

i just lost 700 dollars bc someone robbed me in an ally and when i went to load my pervious save i accidentally saved again

wheres my money

it happend in saint denis

[hidden moss]

I need help finding a mission

It’s the one where Arthur talks to the lonely yeti

People are saying it never existed

Does it exist?

[midnight ocean]

are you thinking of undead nightmare where john talks to a bigfoot?

[obtuse trellis]

?

[hidden moss]

No this one was in the snow in rdr2

The yeti won’t come out of hiding

[gloomy hill]

.

[hidden moss]

It’s one of those rare occurrence

Nevermind I guess I wanted it to be a yeti it’s Bigfoot

I found it

[midnight ocean]

in that guys pocket

[midnight ocean]

isnt it just a giant guy

[obtuse trellis]

no he wasnt at the tailor

it was in a ranom ally by the docks

and i woke up in the cemetery

he stole close to 1k

[midnight ocean]

did you go back to the alley

[obtuse trellis]

yeah

nothing

[midnight ocean]

well you can try again later and hope you run into them again

might just have to take the L though

its not like you really need that money

[obtuse trellis]

i only had 3k

[midnight ocean]

so?

you still have $2.3k

[obtuse trellis]

but i lost it to some random hil billy

[midnight ocean]

think street rat is a more applicable term here

but unfortunately i think your only hope is to run into the same guy again

maybe go sleep to the next day and go back to the alley again

[hybrid moth]

am i the only one having trouble playing first RDR after doing RDR2?

[midnight ocean]

nah i think a lot of people arent prepared for how dated the game is

[hybrid moth]

yeah im doing it but not like i'll continue playing after im done

[midnight ocean]

well yeah you're not really meant to

older games pretty much expected you to stop playing once you finished the story

though rdr1 was kind novel in the way it did its post game

[hybrid moth]

rdr2 still has stuff to do tho at least after finishing story

[midnight ocean]

yeah its more common now to have games that get you to keep playing after the story

[hybrid moth]

what i hate the most so far is the horse mechanic

[midnight ocean]

wdym

i havent played rdr1 in forever

[hybrid moth]

they have no stamina lmao

but hey they run fast asf

[regal gust]

Anybody have tips on hunting predators in rdr2?

[midnight ocean]

know where the spawns are, stay on your horse, keep your springfield/bolt action equipped and deadeye full

know when your horse is getting agitated and keep your eyes peeled for red dots on your radar

[regal gust]

Thank you

[midnight ocean]

np and if its a grizzly bear you will need to use high velocity or express ammo but other than that every predator's ideal ammo is just the regular rifle round

oh and aim for the head obviously

very easy when they're charging at you tho

and even if your horse throws you you should be fine if your rifle is equipped

[regal gust]

I have question though

I shot a panther in the eye and it was a 2 star pelt can you tell me why?

[midnight ocean]

the animal has a quality to begin with. you may have just come across a 2 star panther

btw if you plan on doing a lot of hunting you may want to kill the legendary buck asap and craft the trinket

[regal gust]

So the Antler trinket doesn't play a role in that?

I already have it

[midnight ocean]

ah lol

[regal gust]

Lol

[midnight ocean]

no i think all the trinket does is prevent you from losing a star on a botched kill

sometimes

you cant actually upgrade the quality of the pelt

[regal gust]

Okay

[midnight ocean]

but if you had a 3 star panther and shot it with the wrong weapon or in the wrong spot on its body and caused it to become a 2 star, you can try to skin it anyway and the trinket may revert it to a 3 star pelt

if that makes sense

[regal gust]

I really need to study the panther though I keep accidentally almost missing the fact that its there because of how long I was waiting for it

[midnight ocean]

yeah its tricky to study and track the ones that just come right at you

after you've killed a few youll be more familiar with where it spawns and youll be able to sneak up on it

i felt so lucky the other day i actually got to watch a cougar drink from a stream

[regal gust]

That's awesome

Speaking of spawns where is the best spot for hunting Panthers

[midnight ocean]

ill tag you with an image of where the spawn is one sec

bottom right

and remember theres actually two panther types, panther and florida panther. its random which type will spawn but they count as separate animals in your compendium. pelts are the same

[regal gust]

Oh okay

I'm just trying to get the panther saddle

[midnight ocean]

ah yes

luckily you only need a single pelt for that

[regal gust]

Yup

Originally I was trying to get the snake saddle but that needed 10 perfect skins and I only have 2 after a day of hunting snakes

[midnight ocean]

yeah it can take a bit to build up the snake collection

i never really went hunting for them i just watched my radar whenever riding down a road and if i saw a red dot right on me i knew it would be a snake

after a while of doing this youll have too many snake pelts

but panther is considered by most to be the best saddle anyway

with gator being a close second

[regal gust]

Okay thank you

[midnight ocean]

anytime

[midnight ocean]

got 100% and all gold medals now i just need its art, bountiful and grin & bear it

[chilly heron]

@midnight ocean You guys know you can just go to the islands off of Clemens Point and farm perfect snake pelts all day long, right?

You can also get iguanas, crabs, various birds, and sometimes an owl and eagles. Plus a pirate hat, pirate rum, and a trinket.

[midnight ocean]

yeah thats the only place to get iguana pelts afaik

[chilly heron]

This method made the snake saddle + improved throwing knives way easier for me

[midnight ocean]

as arthur

[chilly heron]

Other than Guarma, yeah

[midnight ocean]

well you cant take pelts back from guarma

so if you want to craft the satchel with pearson you need to go to those islands

[chilly heron]

You can do the carcass glitch and slingshot yourself with the glitchy bridge in New Austin to get to Guarma as Arthur outside of Chapter 5, it's really hard though. Best carcass to use is the legendary buck or stacking pronghorns and your timing has to be perfect.

[midnight ocean]

yeah i dont really do glitches

[chilly heron]

You're missing out, they're really fun when you hit them correctly.

I'm still in Chapter 2 and I have all West Elizabeth and New Austin outfits, the Bolero hat, Otis Millers revolver, and I plan to go back for the Ram Skull mask and Turtle Shell trinket.

[pallid summit]

i bumped into someone and lawmen killed me

[regal matrix]

Yeah the law system sucks

[midnight ocean]

i mean if you do something minor a lot of the time theyll just tell you to gtfo

[regal matrix]

yeah but they have like psychic abilities too what about that

[real pond]

hey question about rdr1, I took a bounty posters from armadillo but went to do a mission and the bounty marker disappeared. will the bounty poster come back, or is it gone forever?

[ocean steppe]

hello

Does anyone know the exact graphics settings in RDR2 for clouds lights and shadows? I don’t care about making them high quality, I just want the settings that show all the effects like sunlight passing through the clouds

[barren imp]

not sure how to directly answer ur question, but bounty posters are everywhere and always respawn so don't worry lol

[real pond]

oh okay cool ty

[serene harbor]

Good morning.

[ocean steppe]

guys is there anyone who knows how rdr2 graphics works

i want to max out only the clouds

[fresh root]

Ay

Uh

Idk im tripping or the game bugging

But i think i saw something following me

When in the jumgle part near annserburg

No its not murfree

[chilly heron]

use mods or something

[chilly heron]

what they look like?

[royal kettle]

Depending on time of day might be night folk

[ocean steppe]

u dont need mods to max out the settings bruh i dont want to make everything ultra cause that will kill my fps

[fresh root]

I think a dark figure or something

Thing always there whenever i stop in the forest

Might be crazy glitch tho

I think ill restart rdr2 since im currently trying to grind it

[amber island]

i just saw dutch crash with an npc

[cyan pendant]

Yeah they do that then act like nothing happened

[amber island]

bro dutch just continued to yap and the npc he crashed into was limping

[hidden moss]

I just got banned from my second favorite game's server for mentioning A. H. so I suppose this will be my main server now. Won't make the same mistake here.

[regal matrix]

mentioning what?

[hidden moss]

A. H. The mustache man the mustache man who lives on Auchswitz lane.

[chilly heron]

the meth addict who likes to paint?

[amber island]

ahhhh

[olive token]

Hello could anyone PLEASE help with with managing Lenny's mod loader. I don't understand in which order i need to put my mods in for all of them to work properly, thanks.

[calm oasis]

Where on earth do I find a rainbow boa? Cant find it

I swear to god, the rng.. just stepped on it

[neon anchor]

Can someone please explain me why myMasterhunter 3 progress won’t go up? I’m riding around the map and watch every single animal I see with my binoculars but it doesn’t increase. I can’t get more than 3/10

[calm oasis]

you must hold E to track it with binoculars

oh wait

uhh

just hold down the track button

[leaden gull]

yeah you gotta study it and then you can hold down E to track it like W.W said, sorry if you were it might just be a glitch if so. I also believe that you gotta kill the animal for the master hinter 3 challenge i may be wrong tho

[calm oasis]

And now I cant find the red boa, these snakes are driving me crazy

[calm oasis]

Thank god

[tidal slate]

I tried the gambling Challenge today for 3 hours and I don't get a single one... This Blackjack Game on its own "Ok" but get a win with 3 or more Cards... Seriously

Even 5 Finger filet with harder opponents is easier...

Only good Moment kill 4 enemy's with 🧨 used them on a Camp of the skinners a high explosive one. Blew the whole Camp apart and got 7 at once... Good 👍😊

[calm oasis]

@regal matrix 1920x1080

[regal matrix]

hmm what settings

[neon anchor]

Okay thanks I will try it out

[calm oasis]

uhhh, ultra/high, anisotropic on X16, FXAA MSAA both off and advanced are locked so default

[regal matrix]

yeah makes sense the pic looks really good

[leaden gull]

np bro, have a magnificient day

[calm oasis]

I cant do MSAA even on 2X because my pc will start shitting itself

[regal matrix]

even i dont have msaa on

[calm oasis]

But it looks good and I get 50-70 fps so cant complain

[regal matrix]

it doesnt even make any difference tho

[calm oasis]

A little

[regal matrix]

it doesnt make any difference to me i think

[regal matrix]

however i played with max upscaled resolution at max settings

it made me feel like i got a new pair of eyes

it dropped the fps significantly from 90 to 30 fps

i play at like 1440p

i did it to counter the taa blur

but then i settled on forced dlaa via nvidia control panel

[regal matrix]

it sucks that the taa only looks good at 4k

its so bad at resolutions lower than that

[leaden gull]

@regal matrix what did i do?

[regal matrix]

i promise i dont hate arthur this is the mod's doing

[leaden gull]

😭

oh of course of course. couldnt have a fellow homo sapien dislike arthur morgan!

I AM a homo sapien by the way...

[midnight ocean]

needs to be 10 different species so not just 10 animals

and you don't need to kill them

[vale sinew]

should my Arthur use double schofield, double sawed-off, or double M1899?

[midnight ocean]

double sawed off sounds kinda interesting lol

a bit impractical maybe

[pseudo patrol]

just trying to get to tumbleweed and suddenly every single del lobo in the state is dead

geez

[midnight ocean]

weird how that happens

[fresh root]

Is there faster way for honor up other than greeting the entire saint denis population

[obtuse trellis]

yall get more than 40 fps 😭

[midnight ocean]

not really

if you're trying to gain honor for the ending though you'll get opportunities to gain quite a bit during chapter 6 side missions

so don waste your time on trying to max out before that

[cyan pendant]

Have you done all the honor missions like the downes one or Strauss missions

[midnight ocean]

all single player achievements are now done

holy moly

[hybrid moth]

im sad there is no achivements on epic

[midnight ocean]

rip

well at least im sure the mods here would still give the roles if you could prove you earned them

[oblique quiver]

Double Schofield or double cattleman

My fav revolvers

[royal kettle]

4 hunting challenges away from being able to hunt the legendary Panther. I also need to hunt the legendary boar and I think the fox and I'll have hunted every legendary creature in the game

[midnight ocean]

good stuff

remember to craft those trinkets

[royal kettle]

I have been. Still need a few bits and bobs like handcuffs and silver earrings

[midnight ocean]

do you know how to get the handcuffs

[royal kettle]

Nope. Probably in an abandoned fort or something

[jovial marlin]

you can get the civil war knife in an abandoned fort

but I haven't found the handcuffs there

[midnight ocean]

the handcuffs cant be found

you get them through a side quest

[jovial marlin]

ah, time to finish all Stranger missions

[midnight ocean]

its one of the collectible ones

you need to turn in a set of cigarette cards

[jovial marlin]

oof

[tidal slate]

@hidden moss so your here too? Nice to see someone flipping around 😉

[cyan pendant]

Yeah it’s just 1 set tho

[frank cedar]

If I create a save without cheats, and then I make a save with cheats, can I revert back to my old save

I don’t even get cheats

[frank cedar]

Best rifle to kill gators to perfectly kill?

[regal matrix]

Springfield rifle or even an improved arrow will do

[frank cedar]

Either comes out bad or good

Never mind, I got a perfect belt

Prlt

[cyan pendant]

Bolt action works okay

You put a scope on that and you got a decent hunting rifle

[midnight ocean]

and by the time you've completed one set you've probably nearly completed the others anyway

and wdym ok lol bolt action is the best thing for gators and you definitely don't need a scope

[cyan pendant]

That’s fair

[oblique quiver]

You can’t make a save with cheats on

Rockstar don’t want u using cheats so that’s the consequence

[midnight ocean]

does anyone know like how it works when you're wanted and the cops are actively looking for you in a town

isnt that supposed to go away after a while even if you keep the bounty?

like ive been away from new austin for probably a week in game but when i went to tumbleweed the sheriffs were looking out for me while i have a much higher bounty in west eliz but theyre not looking for me in blackwater

[oblique quiver]

Yeah they should stop actively looking for you after like a few days but if you interact with 1 of them, then they’ll go after you

maybe ur game bugged

[midnight ocean]

maybe

i just wanted to do the bounty thats there but i think im gonna have to pay mine off

and its only like $290

maybe when you have the west eliz bounty they just only look for you in strawberry and not blackwater for some reason

[tidal slate]

Dum te dum

I'm not sure what's harder to achieve. Getting Gambling Challenge done or doing a driving License on German Highways 🛣️

[midnight ocean]

lol

not hard so much as tedious

just takes time

tbh anyone who gets to the epilogue and THEN decides they wanna go for 100% should just start a new save because the while main missions take up a lions share of % completion they actually go by pretty quickly and easily compared to the rest of the shit you have to do and a lot of challenge sets are way easier to complete if you start them in chapter 2 or 3

and instead of going out hunting for hours to do the hunting requests, you can just keep your eyes up when traveling around the map and pick up some of the animals you need as you go

[tidal slate]

I try some Gold medals on Missions but I can't achieve them all... Most of them fail because I get hurt, while I'm not allowed to take Medics

[midnight ocean]

yeah and gold medals arent actually required for 100% so you can just skip them if you dont want gold rush

[midnight ocean]

a big tip for those ones would be to eat a minty big game before you start the mission to give yourself a gold health core for the entire thing

and of course you can stack that with an oregano and thyme big game as well for more gold cores

[tidal slate]

Does that work?

[midnight ocean]

not on replays but otherwise yeah

[tidal slate]

Oh, nice to know

[midnight ocean]

the gold health core from seasoned big game lasts an entire day iirc

[tidal slate]

I am only confused that I have the MTD on Level 4 while replay some missions. Strange you keep the Horse I even had Buell on the Start

[midnight ocean]

yeah in replays you just get whatever horse and guns you have thankfully because otherwise youd probably be stuck with cattlemans and a tennessee walker lol

[tidal slate]

I only stuck on the Mission with the damn Blackjack... And I have the feeling I miss understand something

[midnight ocean]

but honestly replays are usually harder just because of the lack of consumables compared to what you have in your main playthrough

[midnight ocean]

you mean poker? dont think theres a mission with blackjack

[tidal slate]

Gambling Challenge for me says win 3 Games with 3 Cards or more in Blackjack

Don't tell me it's Poker...

It's gambling 8

[midnight ocean]

ohh thought you meant a mission lol

[midnight ocean]

its not three cards or more its three hits or more, so five cards in your hand total

since you start with two cards and have to hit three times

[tidal slate]

Rats!

That's the Problem I have, I always get to high Number's that I even get close to 4 or 5

[midnight ocean]

yeah it sucks you just have to get lucky

remember to split when you can, that usually helps

pretty sure 2/3 of my wins were on a split

[tidal slate]

Almost every ppl Claim that's the worse Challenge of all

[midnight ocean]

yeah i think on average it takes 2-2.5 hours to complete

i got lucky and got it in 90 mins

the good thing is you dont really have to pay much attention and you can kinda just space out to youtube or something while you do it

[tidal slate]

I'm looking forward to it

[midnight ocean]

and the second worst is probably gambler 9 lol

both the dominoes ones are pretty rough in fact

[tidal slate]

Well, I have a bunch of others to achieve. So it's not getting Boring

[midnight ocean]

outside of gambler i think the hardest one might be the hunter one where you need to kill and skin five cougars with the bow

just because it can be hard to find a cougar when you want one

[tidal slate]

I got that already

[midnight ocean]

the ones where you have to pick every single plant and catch every single fish kinda suck too

[tidal slate]

I have Hunter 10 completed

At the Moment I got the Disarm 3 ppl which I already said and the one killing 4 enemy's using the same tomahawk

I haven't done it yet, disarming... Maybe I need to be more careful 😄 instead killing them

[midnight ocean]

yeah you really just have to look for a guy holding a revolver or pistol and shoot him right in the hand

i think i said already but hanging dog ranch in big valley is a great place for it

and six points cabin in cumberland forest is where i got the tomahawk ones

try crafting a homing tomahawk if you're struggling with those

[tidal slate]

I wonder what ChatGpt says...

I should lure 4 enemy's into one small archway and just aim for the 1. Guys head

So I kill one in a Row

[midnight ocean]

well the problem is then you have to run over and grab the tomahawk while the other 3 shoot at you lol

[tidal slate]

It says the Tomahawk will went through all 4 XD

[midnight ocean]

yeah dont ask chatgpt lmao

itll be like "you need to go to new austin in chapter 3 to get the ak47"

[tidal slate]

I'll just Copy and paste what's written

2. Force a Line-Up

Lure enemies into choke points (doorways, alleys, or narrow paths).

Running into a barn, train car, or building works well — they’ll chase and cluster.

3. Aiming Technique

Enter Dead Eye (this helps with precision).

Line up the throw so the Tomahawk pierces through multiple enemies.

😄

[midnight ocean]

yeah no lol terrible advice

[tidal slate]

Hahahah

I guess

[midnight ocean]

just watch an actual guide if you need

[tidal slate]

I guess if that ever works, some ppl won't struggle

[midnight ocean]

i mean if you can line up four enemies in a row like that thats almost more impressive than doing the actual challenge

for the tomahawk one tho seriously go to six points cabin. there is an enemy standing on the west side of the camp who you can just sneak up on, throw the tomahawk, pick it up, and run away until all the red dots disappear. you then walk back to the camp and the guy you killed will have respawned

he's also a good candidate for the 60ft tomahawk throw or the 5 bow kills in stealth

[cyan pendant]

I mean you can by doing a glitch

[tidal slate]

Oh dear now woolie turns blue

So you got 100% complete. Well done I have a long long way to ride

[midnight ocean]

youll get there cowpoke

[oblique quiver]

May the wind be at your back🫡

[hidden moss]

Who pinged me

That’s not nice I was enjoying a good nap

[naive barn]

That is so weird no trains showed up at valentine and i following the tracks their no train at all

[midnight ocean]

try just staying in one spot for a while and one will probably pass by eventually

or if you really want you can buy a train ticket

[naive barn]

Usually a train arivves at 9 pm at valentine and 6 am but they havent

Im at valentine always so ik the train times

[midnight ocean]

i didnt even know there was a schedule lol

wiki says theres no schedule and its random due to a programming error

[obtuse trellis]

i actually did it

i went from average to perfect weight

only took 1 month

[tall obsidian]

can you discuss ingame glitch here

[trim hamlet]

nope!

[tall obsidian]

Oh 🙁

[midnight ocean]

i thought average was perfect

[vale sinew]

does red dead offline just not work anymore?

been trying to get it to work for the Remington mod but havent gotten any luck

[broken ice]

Baby dont yell at me

[tidal slate]

You play Ghost Recon while taking a Nap 😴

[hidden moss]

Yes I leave me console on

So what lol

[royal kettle]

I bought myself an Arabian horse and I don't see what the big deal is. I mean it's fast but I've never know a more cowardly horse

[tidal slate]

All good 😊😁

Just saw you on Frozen District

Familiar Nickname

[regal matrix]

Yeah that's true

[daring mountain]

Anyone know how to fix files on RD2, kinda messed with some stuff and now story wont load (Black screen)

[trim hamlet]

yeah, max speed vs. 2 speed doesn't actually save more than 30 seconds over long distances lmao

as for (the hidden/random stat) courage, ardennes tend to have a better chance at higher rolls (no I'm not biased, wdym)

[royal kettle]

I use a war horse myself. I don't remember it's breed but it's white with gray spots

[trim hamlet]

Hungarian halfbred?

oh wait you said white with gray spots nvm

[vapid sphinx]

Howdy. Not sure if this is where I should ask but - I installed the Weapon Improvements mod. How can I be sure that it's actually working? Some of the weapon improvements arent visible at the Gun Smith, but Ive only just started a new save file. When I launch the game I do get a prompt about outside files being loaded however?

[royal kettle]

That's the one. Best horse I ever rode.

Think I bought my first one in chapter 3 and used it all the way until the end. Then I bought another one first chance I got

[trim hamlet]

yeah

I got one for free cause it spawned as my temp horse lmao

[royal kettle]

That's neat

[trim hamlet]

so I literally just brought it back to the stable and then saddled it up

I even had the option to sell it. Infinite money.

[desert edge]

Guys should I keep my piebald tobiano hungarian halfbred or get a bay roan ardennes?

[main plinth]

Dude, am i stupid or rdr2 is broken?

im doing the train mission pouring fourth oil 4, which has a requirement not to consume health items, i DID not, and it still counts as if i did

[thorny peak]

did you use checkpoints?

[main plinth]

No.. nevermind man, it was Rocktar's ass fucking shit bait system, they put a Brandy on the shelf to bait you into taking it

which wouldn't count for it

[desert edge]

I think my stable is finally complete, buell, silver mft, white splashed American paint, few spotter appaloosa and piebald tobiano hungarian halfbred

[desert edge]

Last change I'd do maybe the appaloosa for an ardennes perhaps the bay roan

[trim hamlet]

what chapter you on

[regal matrix]

epilogue prolly

cause of the silver dapple pinto

[trim hamlet]

the strawberry roan has better stats than the bay roan

[regal matrix]

strawberry roan looks so beautiful too

[desert edge]

Yeah ik, don't rlly care about the stats

But yeah I'm at 93.9%

I like them both tbh but can only get one, also idk if I wanna swap the few dappled for it but lately I've been liking big horses

Sold my red arabian

Got the piebald tobiano hungarian halfbred

The only small horse I have and it's my fav is the splashed white American paint

[celest tinsel]

I was guiding the andulusian towards a place after breaking it with a rope
then I got jumped by murfree
after the encounter was over the horse was nowhere to be seen
went to original place and slept twice but still not there
where the hell can I find the horse

[desert edge]

If you save and then reload I think it will spawn

[celest tinsel]

its there

thanks

@desert edge

[desert edge]

Yep

Np

[tall obsidian]

Guys

Other than the herbalist 9

Every other challenge is beatable with arthur right?

[regal matrix]

yes

but i would recommend you leave horseman 9 for john

[cyan pendant]

That’s why you throw your saddle on it

[humble ether]

does someone know how to delete the graphic cache?

i have the steam version

btw

[rocky edge]

hey guys

why am i getting only one ammo option in my both of schofields revolver?

i have the ammo as it shows in other weapons

this happened after i attented the saint denis show and took a shot at the bullet catcher guy

[trim hamlet]

i would recommend the shire, but the Heavy handling that it has is definitely sluggish. Ardennes actually have Standard handling, despite actually being a draft breed in real life and looking like it should definitely have Heavy handling based on its build.

[desert edge]

Yeah I liked Arabians for a time but that's over and now I've settled on buell, an American paint, a mft, a hungariam halfbred and an appaloosa I'm willing to swap for an ardeenes or possibly a shire not sure yet

I also like Belgian drafts too

And I Saw a bay morgan today it was gorgeous too

On onother acc I have the beautiful dark bay andalusian

I mean playthrough

[trim hamlet]

i mean if you don't mind the Heavy handling (and therefore needing to avoid any forests at all costs) then go for a shire or maybe a suffolk punch

[regal matrix]

What does heavy handling even feel like

All of it feels the same to me

[desert edge]

Oo never thought about suffolks

[trim hamlet]

slower reaction time, less sharp turns, basically more inertia (resistance to change, it's a physics thing).

[regal matrix]

Hmm

[desert edge]

Tbh I would just love a big horse I can chill and explore with

[regal matrix]

I use Thoroughbreds

[regal matrix]

Thoroughbreds are the best for this they fast and big too

[desert edge]

My favorite horse is the splashed white American paint, bit I love very big horses

[trim hamlet]

those are the exact opposite lmao.

heavy handling is gonna feel like driving a semitruck vs light is like an f1 car

[regal matrix]

That horse is good too

[desert edge]

By big I mean huge

[regal matrix]

Hmm

[desert edge]

Isn't the Belgian draft the biggest?

[trim hamlet]

by light i meant Race handling.

[regal matrix]

Yeah

[trim hamlet]

i think Shire is the biggest by scale (1.15x or something idk). It's the only Extra Large horse in the game (even tho Ardennes irl are close to Shires in terms of size)

[desert edge]

I'd say maybe shire biggest and Belgian tallest

Idk they look bigger to me

[regal matrix]

I wish I could keep more horsies in the stables

4 just ain't enough

[trim hamlet]

and suffolk punch is w i d e s t lmao

[desert edge]

I really like the dark bay morgan I saw today too that horse was small but beautiful

For they're like chubby lil horses

Fr*

[regal matrix]

Wanna see a picture of my arthur and his horse?

[desert edge]

Sure

[regal matrix]

Okay general media

[trim hamlet]

should be called Suffolk Paunch.

See what I did there

[regal matrix]

Okay guys check general media I posted

[desert edge]

Nice isn't that the tb from the special edition?

[desert edge]

yeahhh

Btw guys guess what show in watching rn

[regal matrix]

Yes

[regal matrix]

Hint?

[trim hamlet]

...uh idfk lmao

[desert edge]

Well it's got horses, swords, dragons..

[regal matrix]

Game of thrones?

[trim hamlet]

HOTD.

[desert edge]

Yep

[regal matrix]

Oh cool

[desert edge]

Might watch it next

I finished twd a lil ago so I thought to watch this

[cyan pendant]

I’m just rewatching AOT for like the 17th time for no reason

[ocean steppe]

yo guys anyone mod rdr2 here ? cause i have like 6 mods installed but everytime i enter towns the game crashes

[tidal slate]

Vanilla FTW, no crashes, 😏

[midnight ocean]

i kinda wish horse stats werent tied to coat

makes a lot of people wind up using the same horses

[tidal slate]

Since you can only use 4 in the Story but Online it's at least 5, I wonder why you need that much...

The only Story Horse you get so far is Buell. If I'm not mistaken

Or better keep

[chilly heron]

I'm on console and the only mods I'd like to experience is the AK47 mod and the UFO mod

[chilly heron]

what do you mean tied to coat?

[midnight ocean]

thats what i mean

horses of the same breed and coat will always be identical

like a blood bay throughbred has a particular stat set which is different from the dapple black

i know speed doesnt really matter that much but i like to know im using a horse with a good stat set so i avoid using coats like blood bay even though they look cool

[chilly heron]

Oh, ok, got ya. Yeah it's weird that they did that, its not like a blue car is faster than the red version of the same make and model car. I don't know why they did essentially that but with horses.

All that aside tho I wish we had ownership of all breeds, like the black Missouri Fox Trotter and the albino Arabian

[midnight ocean]

to keep things simple probably

yeah is it even possible to get a mft other than the silver one?

[chilly heron]

those are like the coolest horses in the game

[naive barn]

I thought mustang horses were brave this one very skitish

[chilly heron]

theres a brown one that will linger near saint denis if I remember correctly but it's been so long and I'm more into Arabians so I don't remember

I could be mistaken.

[midnight ocean]

tbh theres some debate in the community as to whether horse bravery even exists. it might just be a complex set of factors that falsely gives the impression of certain horses being less likely to scare than others

like how calm your horse already is when it spots the predator, the angle you approach it at, that stuff definitely factors in

[naive barn]

Im tmepted to sell the darn thing its more skitish then my rose grey araiban

[chilly heron]

Bravery stats dont exist for horses, thats a symptom of mass hysteria that players gave themselves back in 2018 because they were too impatient to max bond their White Arabians.

[naive barn]

Thats not what fanous youtubers said

Buell is so darn slow

[chilly heron]

it doesn't exists, if anything its cut content that maybe had trace amounts of the feature lingering around release day but it hasn't existed since then. Thats IF, but really my money is on the idea that it was never really in the game

[chilly heron]

They're wrong.

[midnight ocean]

buell aint even that slow doesnt he have like 9 speed

[naive barn]

It seems slow to ne

Me

[chilly heron]

its a big horse, probably has poor acceleration

[naive barn]

Yeah im used to araibans

[midnight ocean]

7

[chilly heron]

I dont blame you. They're objectively the overall best horses in the game

[midnight ocean]

smaller horses might also just give the illusion of going faster

[naive barn]

Idk

Buell cant out run lawmen as fast as my rose grey araiban can

[midnight ocean]

only 1 point difference in acceleration lol

then theres that other guy in here who says speed stats are basically meaningless

[chilly heron]

thats certainly not true, I'm riding an Andalusian and that fucker is definitely slower than my Turkoman

[naive barn]

Their people that tested horse speed on youtube the rose grey araiban is a tiny but faster then the fox trotter

[chilly heron]

which guy is that? because I agree with him to an extent

[naive barn]

If only i can find that youtube video ill prove speed matters

[midnight ocean]

i dont mean enough to make it seem like a slower horse is faster than a faster horse but enough to make the difference in speed seem slightly greater than it is when the smaller one is faster

[chilly heron]

yes, because of acceleration. Its objectively the best horse in the game but everyone is convinced that Arabians are pussies and that RDR is just GTA with horses so "top speed = best horse" and thats just not the case on either accounts

[midnight ocean]

jase

he hasnt been around for a bit

[naive barn]

Rdr2 is way better then gta 5

[midnight ocean]

i mean for me when i started my 100% run i picked the rdb thoroughbred because it has 10 speed and i knew i would be doing a lot of traveling on my horse so i figured the time save would add up eventually

[chilly heron]

in terms of quality and story yeah, gta has a better online experience tho

[naive barn]

But gta 6 is proablly gonna pass rdr2 sells day 1

[midnight ocean]

also idk if they were just bad but ive seen people complain about the mission where you have to race dutch saying it was too hard

[naive barn]

I beat him in my white araiban left him in the dust

Proably once gta 6 comes out soon their annouce rdr3

Who knows it may be in the works rn

[chilly heron]

that was the easiest race in the game, people dont understand that the game purposely gives you the most complicated route. If you go on the map and mark your destination the radar will give you the quickest route so you just have to follow the red line instead of the yellow one

[trim hamlet]

if you turn on motion blur and move your camera to the farthest distance than even a slow horse can look fast lmao

[chilly heron]

pretty sure I either beat him with an Andalusian or a Turkoman

[midnight ocean]

i dont think any of them are difficult in any way lol you just spam the button and cut corners

i let dutch win on my first play of that mission because i knew i missed the gold already anyway

[chilly heron]

yeah, just stay ahead and dont crash

[naive barn]

I like buell he just seems slow is all so i never use him he just sits in my stable

[midnight ocean]

can i like stable my main horse and then use the temp horse without saddling it

[trim hamlet]

i mean i think since you usually are doing longer trips, acceleration is a little less meaningful because usually you reach top speed relatively quickly into the journey

[trim hamlet]

yeah
or you could bring it back to a stable and sell it for free money

[naive barn]

I usally stay in valentine

[midnight ocean]

well the problem is i wanna ride buell but with hamishes saddle and not mine

[trim hamlet]

ohhhhhhhhh. then i have no idea lmao

[midnight ocean]

id like to be able to continue taming horses without stabling buell

[trim hamlet]

what breed is buell anyway?

[midnight ocean]

dutch warmblood

[naive barn]

Yes u can stable your main horse and use your temp ive done it just leave the temp outside the stable

[trim hamlet]

why is that?

[midnight ocean]

but it stays as the temp right so if i tame a new horse buell will be replaced

[midnight ocean]

because it looks cool and once you stable him i think its gone forever

[naive barn]

Yeah if u tame a new horse u lose buell

Thats how i lost him in my first play through

[trim hamlet]

also is horse bravery/"courage" just a giant case of the mandela effect?

[midnight ocean]

i would just call it a rumor lol but yeah seems so

[trim hamlet]

if only we had a rockstar dev confirm or deny this...

[chilly heron]

I'm not sure, I think at one point I was rocking two temp horses but I could be imagining things

[midnight ocean]

maybe ill just try it and see what happens

[chilly heron]

its a giant case of dumb children experiencing mass hysteria on reddit in 2018 and spreading the word like religious gospel ever since

[naive barn]

Dont i tried it u will lose him

[chilly heron]

they only invented the "horse bravery" stat in their heads because everyone was too lazy and impatient to max bond their white Arabians

"Many people believe that Red Dead Redemption 2 has a hidden bravery stat for horses but this is not how the game actually works. All of the evidence from player testing and from the game files shows that once a horse reaches maximum bonding level every breed behaves the same when near a threat. The Arabian only appears to be more skittish because it has faster and lighter animations and because players often ride it before bonding is complete which makes it harder to control at first. When bonding is equal an Arabian will not spook any more than a Shire or a Turkoman.

There is a field in the game’s data called horse unruliness and there are also references to horse courage inside the pedattributes file. For example the Arabian’s unruliness value is listed as fifty while most other breeds are zero. However the effect of this number is limited to idle and fidget animations and does not control how the horse reacts to predators gunfire or scripted ambushes. Multiple independent testers have placed different breeds at the same bond level a few feet from predators and have found no consistent difference in bucking or fleeing behaviour.

This means that Rockstar probably planned to include a courage or unruliness system during development but either removed it or left it inactive in the final release. The values still exist in the files but they do not feed into the live AI behaviour. The only factors that actually reduce spooking are bonding level player calming input and specific scenario scripts. If the scenario forces a buck or rear it will happen no matter what breed or value you have.

The conclusion is that there is no active bravery stat in the current version of the game. Unruliness is cosmetic and courage appears to be cut content. Once horses are fully bonded all breeds will behave the same near danger and the widespread belief that Arabians are coded as cowards is based on perception and leftover data rather than real mechanics."

Dropping this here.

[midnight ocean]

i think what i can try is stable my main, get on buell and go find a new horse, tame it and then drag it to the stable with a lasso

without bonding with it

[naive barn]

U tame it u lose buell period

[midnight ocean]

yeah im not gonna tame it until i get it in the stable first

[trim hamlet]

damn

someone should mod that feature back in lmao

it would be really funny

[midnight ocean]

wait can i make an unbonded horse my main? lol

or can you just not put a saddle on it

[naive barn]

If u equip your saddle to it

Dont tame another horse or u lose buell its happened to me

[midnight ocean]

taming is ok just not bonding

hitting level 1 bond is when that horse becomes your new temp

[naive barn]

U cant bond yes taming is ok

[midnight ocean]

but you can tame a horse and lasso it and pull it along with you without bonding

[naive barn]

Yes

[midnight ocean]

thats what im gonna do

[naive barn]

Just cant bond with it

[loud ingot]

Does anyone know how to increase horse bonding fast? I just over feed my horse

[naive barn]

I thought u dragged a horse with a lasso it drains your stamina

Lead it like u would irl

[loud ingot]

Ty

[naive barn]

Yw

I thought u dragged a horse with a lasso it drains your stamina

[midnight ocean]

pet it, feed it, hitching it also seems to give some

[celest tinsel]

I need a mod that gives me more stable slots

cmon I need them horses

[loud ingot]

Thanks

[midnight ocean]

np

[naive barn]

Leading i found is the quickest way

[midnight ocean]

yeah seriously

[celest tinsel]

there are so many cool horses in this game

like cmon rockstar

[midnight ocean]

the least they could do is give you more space in the epilogue when you literally own your own ranch lol

[celest tinsel]

dude atleast give us an option to pay for extra stables or something

[naive barn]

I was start over but i like the piece playing as john

[celest tinsel]

or make the camp stable store extra ones

why we paid 250 for it anyways

[naive barn]

Arthur u get ambushed everywhere

[celest tinsel]

that's the fun part , if you're playing low honor each ambush they drop like 40$

[midnight ocean]

you still do get ambushed as john

[celest tinsel]

6$ ammo and u get a free 34

[naive barn]

I havent yet

[midnight ocean]

just maybe happens less often around blackwater where you spend most of your time because theres no good ambush spots

[naive barn]

Im always in the heartlands

[midnight ocean]

i just always have bounty hunters on me now because i got that one achievement where you need to get a bounty in every state and never got rid of em

[naive barn]

I been in new austin lots only been ambushed just once

[celest tinsel]

so there is no mod like that?

I'm so sick of this bullshit

[midnight ocean]

no clue i think most of us play vanilla

but i would assume there is one

[naive barn]

@midnight ocean i rarely get ambushed as john

[midnight ocean]

well new austin is mostly open too right

[naive barn]

Yeah

[midnight ocean]

try riding around roanoke and some murfrees will probably jump out at ya

or tall trees has skinners

[naive barn]

The skinners i have had them get me once

[midnight ocean]

lemoyne raiders are still around in the epilogue too for some reason

feels like they should be gone

[naive barn]

Arthur i get ambushed more

[midnight ocean]

you also probably spent more time as arthur than as john

[naive barn]

No john

Ive been with john 6 7 straight months now maybe more

[midnight ocean]

wow lol

[naive barn]

I know muliple glitches if i go broke or i go hunting and fishing

[hoary dome]

Which glitches?

[naive barn]

Money glitches why

[hoary dome]

Wanted to know

I don’t know what to do after the main story

[naive barn]

I just chill have fun beat people up shoot gang camps

[midnight ocean]

bounties

or go for completion/achievements

[naive barn]

Or get in shootouts with the lawmen

[midnight ocean]

mission replays for gold medals

[hoary dome]

Mission replays?

[midnight ocean]

yeah go to progress and story

you can replay missions and try to get the gold medal by completing the optional objectives

they can be difficult tho

[hoary dome]

I’ll probably do American venom to kill Micha in different ways

[celest tinsel]

man whatever

it seems modders don't care

I'll just sell the wapiti

[midnight ocean]

wapiti?

[midnight ocean]

googled and it seems theres something in the games code that prevents stable space from being moddable

[celest tinsel]

that's bullshit

Ai says whatever

its just not easy to change it so they gave up

[midnight ocean]

then you do it

[celest tinsel]

its cuz there isn't a clear value to change

[midnight ocean]

ask ai to tell you how

[celest tinsel]

all they have to do is create a new one

I'm a consumer

not a creator

[midnight ocean]

then dont claim its possible when people who know more than you tell you it isnt

[celest tinsel]

I'm telling you that because I found the comment the Ai based its typings on

its a random reddit user

not even a modder

[midnight ocean]

and stop asking chatgpt for information that you cant verify yourself

[celest tinsel]

everything is possible

have you seen skyrim

[celest tinsel]

you're the one who asked chat gpt for info lmfao

[midnight ocean]

? when

[celest tinsel]

this is literally the ai response bro

u got exposed

bro tellin me on to not use chat gpt bullcrap when he's taking the gemini response

[chilly heron]

I did the math and you can max bond a horse from 0 to 4 in under 1½ hours by just leading it around the map.

[celest tinsel]

I don't even use gpt lmao

[midnight ocean]

i didnt get that from the google ai bro i got it from other human beings

[celest tinsel]

I just open a buncha websites and read

[celest tinsel]

totally bro

[midnight ocean]

dude i work with ai every day at my job i know not to trust it for shit lmao

[celest tinsel]

ok then lemme guess u just took the first reddit response that popped up without even openning the convo?

[midnight ocean]

man i was trying to help you by explaining why the mod doesnt exist

[chilly heron]

6 7...

[midnight ocean]

so you got so salty about not having more stable space that you take it out on me lol

grow up

[celest tinsel]

nah u got argumentive over nothing , u grow up

ur throwing a tantrum

[midnight ocean]

totally

[celest tinsel]

"make the mod yourself" isn't really helping bro , stop playing yourself