#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 235 of 1
shes more just taking care of the camp making sure everything is clean and no one is sitting on their ass
the camp budget is separate from the rest of the money
Yea, Hosea is the exception then
yeah theres an argument between dutch and hosea about how much money they need in chapter 4 i think
I only saw an argument about where they were going and the plans
But I don't remember Hosea talking about the stash, maybe I missed it
maybe not idk
i wonder if anyones done the math to try and come up with the actual dollar amount they would need to move everyone to tahiti and start a mango farm
this guy on reddit says $51k
I don't think dutch was gonna establish a mango farm with the money, he probably thought they were just gonna grab em from the trees XD
Inflation is crazy
Dutch literally knows nothing about Tahiti, he probably read about a tropical island in one of his books and just decided Tahiti
well he had to know enough to convince hosea
"Do people live on Tahiti?" Dutch-"IDK Tahitians?"
Arthur asked him something like that
Btw do some trinkets appear on your character?
Don't think so
yes
I have trinkets and they don't show up
I saw somewhere that like a bracelet with teeth on it showed on their character wrist
Just the talismans
theres an eagle one that goes on your boots
Ah
There's one that always has a passive equipped and another that you have to manually choose
Can’t believe I’ve played this game for so god damn long and didn’t know that
Trinkets are always equipped
I forgot trinkets and talismans are different
wdym
Oh, I read somewhere that you have to equip it for it to apply the bonus
Even better if it's how you say then
theres a ton of misinfo about this game out there
That's cool then
You can have 2 or 3 on your character at a time I think
Tahiti
I forgot to include Faith, does that change your answer or nah
Nah
who lives in tahiti
my man
Lol
I mean he’s not wrong
dude what the fuck is this mission lol
sadie dies SO fast
i cant ride ahead of her and enemies spawn in three at a time
the nice thing about gta is even if the mission starts with a dialogue section you can just drive super fast to the mission marker and skip the rest of the dialogue
but in rdr you are not allowed to go fast most of the time
💔this shit make me so fucking sad man it hurts so bad I can’t even focus in school man. Just can’t believe it’s come to this. Fuck it hurts.
wrong chat homie
ty
How did you get emoji next to your name 😭
got 70 gold medals and dmd proof to modmail
Proof means picture right?
generally
my gamertag is linked to my discord profile so i just took a screenshot of the xbox app with the achievement and my gamertag
👍🏻
they have similar ones for the achievements for getting 100%, all animals studied and level 50 in online
if you're interested
I got all im trying to figure how to prove it😭
damn nice lol
well looks like your psn is linked so just find a way to capture your psn and the trophy in one pic
Do i need to say somthing or just send picture in mod mail
id include a message
also they might not see it for a bit so you may or may not want to try tagging them in general or something to let them know
it took like 3 or 4 days for them to give me the role
Roger 🫡
Well the Roles...
For Its Art you don't get one 🙂
I mean an icon, since I have the Role even as Notorious for Level 50 Online
I just have the feeling the normal Roles aka Cattle Rustler won't raise ... Or maybe I don't write as much as others
I hate fishing missions
Oml
Hate this veteran
The fish has gotten awayy 7 times let it go old man
I just found the meteor house without having any prior knowledge of it
As soon as I saw the mangled body on the table I fuckin ran
HOW do you hate hamish he’s so cool
Fucking hate fishing
just got skin deep
@nimble goblet want another reason to use the mft
npcs compliment you on your horse
Fishing is so easy lol
I love that at the end all that others are really cared about was that John made it
Kind of
Really wish rdr1 didn't end the way it did
Shh no spoilers
The channel literally says be cautious of spoilers, so don't look in here if you don't want to read them
this channel literally is meant to be about the Story and such stuff
I'm down to my last 13k w john after the 20k + all treasure maps 😭
I actually forgot all about the treasure maps being in the game. I need to find some
How do you find treasure maps? Like location wise
what did you spend it all on?
I have no idea
It vanished 
for most of them you obtain the next treasure map when you find the previous treasure
Horses, guns, customization on guns, more guns, more horses, bountys, clothes, yeah that's about all I recall
Legit hated the game because of domino challenges 😭
are we talkin bout 100%?
Whoever made it to 100% that's for hats off, full respect cause to play those fking Poker games and other stuff and keeping nerves all together...good job
Hey guys so I saw a person here who send a picture of two American paints and one of them had a mixed black and white mane and I was wondering is that possible without mods? Can I just find it in the wild with that mane?
Are you talking about the splashed American paint
?
I think the tobiano one, I'm not sure
Does it have like a white body?
Can I dm you a picture of it, it doesnt let me send here
It was like brown with white and half it's mane was white and the other half black
I’m 90% that’s a mod
Ah okay, thanks!
It’s basically one of the only reasons I’m still in this sever is to help newer players
Hey y'all
I wanted to know if the men and angels mission was available after chapter 5
i think were on the same mission lol i just got done with it yesterday
i got plans
Any tips on 100% the game? Like literally anything. I've completed the main story.
You will need a guide for the swamps
You will come to understand the swamps
You will be one with the swamps
Stranger mission bounty haunts
The Swamps are my Home, sadly you can't build your Home there... Protected by all them Alligators
I made it to 98,1 % I still need to finish a bunch of Challenges. Bandit 10,Horseman 10,Master hunter 10 and those who are remaining... Gambler 2, Herbalist 7, Sharpshooter 7, Survivalist 7, WeaponExpt. 3
Yawn 🤓 🥱
Gambler
Youre cooked
Usually I don't have an Issue playing Cards e.g. Poker or Blackjack... But...
I think I need to win a few Double downs to get to LV 3
I have more issues with getting 10 one Health, Endurance and Dead Eye
I have the Feeling, that if you playing as John it won't raise
And I have all Perks beside 1 (Missing Silver Ear plugs) to craft it
Why cant I find micahs body, i went back to collect his pistol
so real
i could not fuckin wait to get out of there
but i need big game meat now that im in the epilogue
i stopped my 100% after that
then i returned
and stopped again after gambler
then i returned
and stopped again after hunting requests
mine is so close at hand now all i need is herbalist 10 and finish the last few missions and the last hunting request
but i also wanna get gold on every mission and finish the compendium as much as i can
See above woolie thats my current Stats
But as I said, even if I have a bunch of Talismans, my HP is still at 8/8
I wonder why...
you need to complete all the challenges and then buy the equipment at the trapper
talismans have nothing to do with it
I thought the talismans give you an additional Bonus for something
Even to health or similar
they do but not to your actual level
they do stuff like make your core drain more slowly
At least the easiest Mission was Bandit 10
i enjoyed all the bandit ones except stealing the coaches
Train Robbery was kinda easy, I don't expect that ..
5 Tickets payed, not even alarmed once and no loss of Honor
But I got eaten 3 times by that legendary Panther....
Damn thing lol
Giagouro
i just jumped on grabbed one thing and jumped off again lol no ticket needed
didnt know that we can sleep in the bed on the dowens farm 😂
achievement unlocked add insult to injury
Since my profile is now based on a different character, can I get the Mark of Morgan Hatred taken?
Sadie is so peak
Thats fair. She actively looks for a fight
and she sucks at fighting
she cant fight worth a shit
she picks fights and then you have to bail her out every time by killing 99% of them
and then she acts like shes the hottest shit west of the lannahachee
I don't think she lasted long in South America XD
i mean hopefully she gets better by then but holy shit no other npcs ruin a mission by getting killed like sadie does
does anyone else feel like the mission in the epilogue have a slightly different design philosophy
like theres a lot of boring shit you have to do in the main story and a lot of boring shit you have to do in the epilogue but in the epilogue a lot of it gets skipped for you
like you're shoveling shit and after a couple it just turns into a cutscene showing you shoveling the rest of it
whereas in the main story it feels like that mission would actually have you shovelling every pile yourself
and also im thinking maybe they tweaked something about allies in combat for the epilogue and thats why sadie keeps dying on me
Micha
He got killed in my last playthrough more times then any npc
i hardly had anyone die during missions in chapters 1-6
Fucking I leave Micah alone for 5 minutes and he dies
shes better later on and during epilogue
isn’t it because of what the o driscolls did to her husband
im in the epilogue
Daily Rdr2 report I didn't play red dead any further I wasn't motivated but my teeth r getting fixed today and after I either play Rd high on life or Detroit become human
i think its because it was meant to convey a timeskip
and you also do do chores throughout without montages no?
like before that mission
I payed 3 dollars each, turned round run to the Chest 🧰 inside the last Coach open it (you don't even need to take some) jumped off the Train and traveled back. The Guard doesn't pay attention.
yeah it would just be nice if they did those more in the main story
feels like a lot more stuff they make you sit through
well tbf rdr2 is def not meant to be replayed like 10 times
i do like the epilogue for how we can finally attempt to be a rancher
but ultimately, like john with us. We are just itching to be a hero
this is only my second playthrough lol
Any tips for gambler 9
Holy fuck
Maybe just me however the probelm is my opponent somehow jave the best draw and hav 0 tile on his hand
Once he ad 8 tile that made up only 4-10 freakin score
if you stand up from the table during your turn it will end the game without counting as a loss
use your biggest number tiles first
try to play against a single opponent
Fr?
You say i can keep streak tehnically
yes
Ok thank u
np
No idea how I’m gonna get past it when I get there, still got 0 clue how to play Dominoes
you take turns placing dominoes end to end so that the ends match
so if the first domino has 1 on one side and 2 on the other you can play a domino that has either a side with 1 or 2
you take turns doing this until someone has gotten rid of all of their dominoes
at that point the dots on the losing players remaining dominoes are tallied up and given to the winner in the form of points
then you keep playing rounds until one person hits the target score
if you cant play any dominoes on your turn you have to draw from the draw pile until you can make a move
if no tiles left in the draw pile your turn is skipped
all threes or all fives is a bit more complex because points are also awarded whenever a player makes a move that results in the total number of dots on each end of the domino chain being a multiple of three or five respectively
i got the challenge done playing all fives with hosea in chapter 3
hogtying a guy should not be enough to spook horses into sprinting off
makes robbing coaches so unfun when the coach takes off no matter what
Yeah ikr
So I'm about to rob the Saint Denis bank. And I find myself agreeing with Hosea about the plans not being executed properly. Also for being a man with a plan Dutch never seems to plan for what might happen if things go wrong
reminder to shoot the armadillo general store owner everytime
he made deals with The Strange Man so armadillo will get cholera except him
Well when I unlock that part of the map I will. What he do?
Oh
Unfortunately he didn't make a deal about not getting a shotgun shell to the face
satan can't stop a 12 gauge
That reminds me doesn't the strange man have a cabin in the swamps
Dutch is full of shit
Like hosea said he's gonna get everyone killed
So I've noticed. Hosea could come up with better plans
Hosea WAS making plans with arthur for a scam
In blackwater
Before the ferry job
Then they had to pack shit up and run away
Because of what Dutch and Micah pulled off
funny detail
Let's face it Dutch was never going to give up this life. Maybe he'd settle down for a bit but he'd be causing problems soon enough
@royal kettle btw after this bank heist, EVERYTHING changes
if you let a bandit steal your horse and then kill them and get it back john will have dialogue for the horse
dutch doesn't realize when to stop. "if we don't stop soon, we'll all be dying" hosea said that back in colter
What dialogue
Oh yeah. I watched videos on this game when it first came out so I kinda know what's going to happen
Yup
Hmm okay
he was like "why didnt you kick him in the head" lol
his biggest mistake was wanting to go to tahiti
he should've gone to the Carribbean
it's a lot closer and cheaper
His biggest mistake was being the way he is
he never really wanted to go to tahiti
I feel like Dutch almost has that cult leader personality. Where he expects loyalty and for people to not question his poor choices
after that braithwaite business in chapter 3, he definitely wants to betray the gang
and suck micah's dih in mount hagen
he recruited a lot of the gang by saving them from bad situations which basically makes them feel like they owe him their lives
which might be why he targets them to begin with
Yeah this is obvious in rdr1
Same reason here
Uhhh spoilers for rdr1...
But when dutch is near the cliff, he legit says that he can't fight nature. And his nature is to fight so it's a paradox
He legit can't stop fighting
Dutch CANT give up that life style
wait, that means that he can't fight his nature?
Yah
I thought he meant he can't change what will happen
He also says he can't fight change but that's for the topic of wild west ending
He says both
He says he can't fight nature and change. And that his whole life he always fought. Jhon proceeds to tell him to give up but dutch says he cant give up. He can't fight his own nature. It's the paradox.
cause he splat all over the ground
well he said it right before jumping off a cliff so
Miach wearing an all white suit when hes nothing but a dirty rat
fun fact about his white suit, it was inspired by dr harlan fontaine's shirt, an antagonist in l.a. noire that Peter Blomquist also played
Also for this he means that he can't fight the wild west getting tamed. He also basically tells jhon that he can't either
As he says "if I'm gone they'll just find another monster...they have to justify their wages somehow"
Obviously telling jhon that he's next
Its easy on paper
Bassically connecting same number of nodes
The probelm is the npc fucking cheated 99% of time seems
They have always perfect draw and have the blank tile on finishing round
Dude I haven't played that game in YEARS
I genuinely can't understand dominoes
Connecting number that is
I can only play the fives
It's easy to understand
But I honestly don't remember how to play
I've never played dominoes in my entire life
Let say there tile with 6/6 you can only connect it with tile with 6/6,5/,6/4 until 6/0
we don't have no dominoes here in asia
I've yet to play dominoes in this game but I've played them with my family before
But still im only learning it for this dumb challenge
Evn then that stupid emerald rancher keep getting 0/1 and 0/0 tiles
You're on point
This is what he craves
Being treated as a Messiah
Being someone people can follow
He's afraid of becoming irrelevant
Afraid of being unheard
e
Hey cat
halo
Hi there kitty
Just had a dream about a deer
May you stand unshaken

uncle had a random interaction with dutch and he became an absolute poet
"he wants to be an american king"
"better? your kinda better"
Oh yeah I've seen this too
"oh, put me out of my majesty your misery"
You beat me by a second
"Away with you! "
lol that's my favourite quote
to the bar senor
I think John's daughter's death made uncle all miserable in rdr1
"Vamos!" as arthur said to a german family
Senor por favor
ive never played rdr2 😎
Go shit in the bush(this what John says to a cat when drunk)
i just finished my last challenge and turned in the last hunting request
john being mean to uncle was his revenge when uncle absolutely ANNIHILATED john that one time
Oh yeah lmfao
"not even a retired 2 dollar whore will stay with you"
"Oh darling abigail, I've changed, please come live with me in a outhouse I wouldn't ask my worst enemy to take a shit in"
"it needs levelin"
its like they were trying to one up the infamous lemar and franklin scene
"No woman is touching this place"
Yeah lmfao
also different scene but
lol
you dont build a barn DUMBASS
What is this the 1785?
what you think this is? 1785!?
I love when John is dumb
he should've let the wolves eat all his brain
Like even rdr1 he's dumb enough not to pick up on what bonnie feels about him he's just so dumb and loyal and so in love with his wife I love him
Or maybe he did know
Nah I don't think she likes him
That way
i dont think she meant it like that lol
Yeah exactly
Nah Sadie doesn't like anyone but me😼
No she likes me SHE DOES
She's moved on from jake she told me
Unironically she's moved on from jake in the epilogue cause she did say she would like to ride with a handsome revolutionary
jk mods don't ban me
That's just rude man
srry
It's fine no worries ig
I'll delete it
It ain't that serious bro😹
nah ion want the mods to ban me
Yeah they can be pretty unforgiving lmao
They will ban you for one harmless word
Btw can I dm you? If you don't mind?
sure
accidentally pressed smtn
Oh what did you press?
js the ignore button dw
I feel like my Arthur is always underweight. Like I try and eat at morning and night and occasionally he'll get to average then the next day he's underweight again. At this point I might just have to visit an saloon and do nothing but eat all day
Yeah ikrrr
Eat big game meat
I've have been
10 atleast it will take you from underweight to average in one sleep
Alright. It's good to finally have a number to use.
Once I get off this island I'm hunting all the big game. Which hopefully shouldn't be too long now
Oh yeah. Guarma.
Oh shit
Bro
Forget about gaining weight 😭
🙏🥀
Yeah i know. But i'm a try my best to keep him fed
.. I don’t even feed Arthur
You're a monster!
I mean assuming I manage to eat 10 meals a day every day until the end. Surely I'll manage to keep him average weight
No.
Yes😼
Nope
It's literally not possible
He is a grown man, he can feed himself 
Hmm fair
Well I tried my best then
He's gonna always stay underweight cause theres only one model being in used
It's very sad
Don’t be sad … he gonna die anyway..
At least there's John. Maybe I can keep him average weight once I get there
Yes you can even get him to become fat
Which is why I'm sad bruh
Once I get off Guarma is there anything I should do as Arthur that involves needing to swim since John can't
You don't have to swim yourself get a boat or ride your horse
Good to know
But i really suggest you spend a little time with him now that his life is coming to an end
Help people
Don't rob any people after the tb news
I've been trying to do as much as possible with Arthur. I've been helping the photographer, saving people from snake bites, drawing points of interest
Nope
Maybe on a next playthrough
Yeah that's what I'd recommend
At what point should I visit the pig farm so they can relive me of my money so John isn't dirt poor later? I know its towards the end if chapter 6
Don't do that
It undermines American Venom
It also taints the story Epligoue is trying to tell
hi guys im in chapter 6 i just finished the mission where arthur and sadie saves john now im wanted dead in east coast including saint denis and this is really bad since i wanted to max my honor in saint denis what can i do
any help is appreciated thank you
You should try maxing it somewhere else, just doing stranger encounters that are honorable help
You don't need to max your honor it just needs to be right leaning that's it
i see thank you
should i try on rhodes?
If you haven't helped the veteran there you can try that
If that ending is what you wanted you just need to have a guy looking icon that is white
And whenever you find random people that need help or a ride help them
Btw don't like do any criminal activities when free roaming only in story missions because it doesn't make sense logically
Have you done the compson quest?
Wdym sense logically?
not really i only did main quests mostly
but i try to do some side missions when i have the time
Do the brandywyne drop widow missions
ill try
Don't TRY. Do it
I haven't found that mission
Go to an old guy in Rhodes he will ask you to get a few things from his home that he’s not aloud to go in then kill him to gain honor cause you find out things about him
Go to brandywyne drop
I don't even recognize the name
Is she still alive?
Brandywyne
near the post office?
Yeah
Guys I think if you choose to kill Jimmy Brooks high honor playthrough is out of question
alr thank you ill do it
I let him fall
Nah you can still save it
Suffice to say my playthrough ended with low honor
At that point you should prolly do low honor
Nah cause it gets noted down by the strange man
It’s mostly chap 6 where that gets decided
also there is no difference by greeting people in saint denis and rhodes right?
Their is a lot less people
It was an accident, I tried but as soon as I was gonna lift him up he slipped XD
Nah you can't just murder your way across half the country and then suddenly decide to become high honor
Yeah I understand
Yeah honestly
i see is the wanted dead alive in east coast permanent till the end?
No pay bounty
I think
Idk
They can’t
Hmm okay
It’s after the whole Cornwall incident I think
Hmm
Your just gonna have some bounty hunters on you for awhile
I have two games slots, the one I completed I was just doing missions and having fun, ended low honor. My other save is currently just chapter 2 trying to get as many trapper outfits as possible with high honor for the reduced store prices
should i just greet people in saint denis while trying to not get seen by bounty hunters?
See I get a 100% off by robbing the store
Once I get cool outfits I want from the trapper i will split that game slot into two, a high honor playthrough and a even worse Micah playthrough
The second save sounds the best to me ngl do side missions in that second save
Yea fr
Yeah the thing about taht law is everywhere
I just want the drip then I'm gonna do super high honor and super low honor playthrough with my drip
Especially in Saint Denis
damn
it will take a lot of time getting high honor
You should really get most things as arthur and leave some loose ends for John imo
Try fishing
is it fast?
You gain honor is you throw back fish
What is your honor atm?
No
low 💀
… alright then
Do strauss debt missions
I'm gonna try to go out of the map to get a collared peckary pig for the snake boots as arthur
You get good honor that way
Don't please
@hidden moon do these
Leave some loose ends for john
ill surely do
Y, I want that drip for Arthur not john
thank you guys
It's just for those boots nothing else
ty for the help
Make sure to give back money or cancel the debt
🙏
No but that is John honoring his memories you gotta understand
ill cancel the debt
ty again imma gtg now
And give the debtors extra money
I will leave john other stuff to do but those snake boots are just, I was so disappointed when I found it they were from epilogue
I totally forgot about the hunting veteran my first playthrough
Definitely doing that with my 2nd
Arthur cant go in blackwater that's the whole point
Also if you haven’t done so do taht penolopi braithwrath misson if you let her keep teh braclet you gain honor
It is so much rewarding when you can go to blackwater with john
I'm not gonna go in blackwater
Yeah but that other place
I'll be outside the map for the new austin spawn
Don't head west
Arthur gave his little brother a second chance at life that he didn't choose
I go solely to go get tiger mustang and Ottis millers revolver
Isn't there an invisible sniper?
Or is that only new austin
The glitch I want to do is get drunk and teleport outside the map
Yeah there are a ton of videos on it it’s that one misson you do when you have to go get jack back
Unfortunately last time I went there were only 2 star pigs
I'll have to go try my luck again
Please don't go there ip using glitches
Why
Yeah I don’t
Because it rujns the story
I just go as John it’s complicated
Bro a boot is not a story element
I just want to combine the snake boots and snake gloves
You don't understand my point
I do not
It's satisfying to head west as John cause Arthur couldnt go there
He didn't have that chance
I agree
The only reason I go there is for the pelt, I won't go for story items
Please explore east
Bro...
I just want to know how a pelt would ruin the story
Arthur could never explore the fauna and flora there and John does it for him to honor his legacy
That's the point
Arthur sacrficed his life so his little brother can have what he couldn't
Except he did canonically they were just run off it
Yeah but it's not in the journal the other one got burnt
And this is why I think rdr3 is gonna be a younger Arthur
Dude, the only reason you can't go there is because of an invisible sniper. I know that if they actually allowed me into new austin my Arthur could evade the law.
It's a gameplay thing so that you have more to do as john, but it's not really story breaking to think Arthur decided to sneak in for a valuable pelt one day
Also what do you mean snake boots ..
Cus hunting an animal wouldn't break immersion, and doesn't Arthur have journal entries for the animals there?
The trapper has a boot that's is a snake
..,ok
And it looks awesome
greetings
I know what I’m hunting for next
I think a story about the callander brothers would be interesting
And it looks really good with the snake gloves the trapper sells, aswell as the hat
Except it does break immersion, the West for Arthur represents the free land they can't go to cause of the shit they got themselves in
Agreed, let us play as Mac
I thought that was the death roll
Arthur at multiple points say if we go anywhere near there we're dead
snake buldogger hat?
Can’t believe they made a model just to kill him in the first minute
If we try to grab the money anytime soon it'll come with a noose
Yea, all snake items look awesome to me
Same I actually do have snake skin boots on right now irl
They literally went in and broke sean out and your saying Arthur would attract more attention by killing a pig in the wilderness?
You’d be surprised
Going for the money and killing a pig are very different things
hosea said that they were ruthless, but they still had a heart. that's another redemption story for ya rockstar
Still want a younger Arthur and John dynamic
And Bill says nice stuff about them too, the story could have Bill be more of a star than the last 2 installments
bill in the army would be interesting
It really make a big brother and little brother dynamic
I would want this but, sometimes when a certain characters story gets stretched it can get worse
I mean would you really complain
Would just have to hope rockstar does it beautifully
It's really just a problem I see with other franchises
Or hear me out we can play as lyile Morgan
That I wouldn't like to see happens to Arthur and John, but if they do it well by all means
Arthur’s father
I think there's a better chance for me to get ran over by a toyota corolla than to find a 3 star moose
Is it the infamous Red Bull moose
The thing about characters like that is that rockstar would be limited in what they can write so as to keep the story connected, Mac would be a better choice since we know little about him and he was confirmed an outlaw, it would also show us the glory days of the gang
Eh
I think that wouldn't be too interesting as he was just a petty criminal
Yea but what story would there be to write about Arthur's fam
They have more material they could do with Mac
A petted criminal just trying to help his family
Just cause of the fact he is a member of the gang
or maybe hear me out...
Not really
young sean in donegal
We know like two things about him
Ireland
He literally died in the blackwater heist, how. Imagine seeing the heist firsthand
And Davey died afterwards
That’s were Arthur in the prologue comes to play
You don't get to see the heist go down
maybe they could do wars between families, like the grays and braithwaites
You only see the outcome
Still wish we got a black water heist dlc
there's so much possibility for rdr3 imo
Put us as John
callander brothers
young sean
bill in the army
Lyle Morgan
Imagine callander brothers and you can switch between them
posh trelawny
yeah that's what rockstar is bickering about right now
I just want a younger version of the gang
Also they have to be characters that you can do low honor and high honor with
Bassically
maybe young hosea?
So can't be trelawny, the guy doesn't do gunfights
It would need a redemption arc
Like a prequel that’s not terrible
make it a spinoff
Or a Dutch one
Unless it shows us something Hosea only saw then it can't, cus all the games have been redemption then death
So characters that are alive by rdr2 can't be protagonists
Again they can make up shit we don’t know a lot about hosea
Yes but Red Dead Redemption
….
he was a scam artist at a young age
Unless they change the name it won't make sense
I’m just gonna stick with my idea about a younger Arthur cause I want a young Arthur and John dynamic
Like what if it picks off when they first get John into the gang
I really want the Macallender brothers, and being able to switch between them or not I think it would be cool either way
how about, john eventually finds out what the gang does, gets depressed or something, then he finally accepts it
…what would he be depressed about …
Jack being born
Ok that’s fair
We don't need more prequels I'm gonna be honest
The callander boys are supposed to act as parallels to micah and Arthur they're not supposed to be explored
They don't get to have their redemption unlike Arthur cause their lives were cut short
They were ruthless and davey threatened to murder the whole town but he wouldn't actually do it but micah WOULD make that sentence a reality
It was said that Mac had a heart, their redemption could be something so simple as sacrificing themselves for the gang before dying, just like arthur
I would also just welcome new missions
Yeah but we don't really need to see that they're supposed to just serve this story of the end times of the gang
The map could be different
I understand being in love with the characters and this setting wanting to know more but this kinda goes against the point of the game
I just think that out of all the ideas, those two would fit the name: Red Dead Redemption most since they died and could have had an act of redemption
Like a young dutch or Hosea would not fit since they died in other games
And don't get redemption, maybe Hosea in a way but not dutch
I'm just saying they are the most likely fit if rockstar wanted to make a 3rd, I would also enjoy a completely new gang or group of characters and get away from the van der line gang story
I personally would like a jack centered sequel some people may not like that cause they interpret it that even jack was eventually put down as it reinforces the theme of the cycle of violence but I personally would love if he got the happy ending
I don't agree cus by that time the wild west had ended.
But I do want a remaster of rdr1
And then maybe they could do what they did in rdr2 epilogue and add jack missions
Yeah and that's interesting to see somewhat
Damn i just need 4 Animals for the Zoo Achivment and 8 for the Skinned one
Really hate how rdr2 introduces these unique side characters like fenton, melvin and hoagy macintosh and doesn't even bother to resolve their stories, bumstar really doesn't care about their games😒
Him killing his mother wasn't his fault he just did it ironically
Sometimes I feel like Gavin
In what way?
Lost of course
💯
could somebody private message me to help me with my mods
i could help
Watching Dexter and..
Joe Driscoll
Colm O'Driscoll
i got skin deep but i need like 4 or 5 more for zoo
one is a poodle lol
oh i don't need the fer de lance snake but i wanna find one anyway
But you know where the Poodle 🐩 is?
rhodes
also need a standard donkey from the farm north of there
Ah the Snake I'm missing too I guess, Fer de Lance
find it south of thieves landing
it doesn't count for achievements tho since the game considers it a guarma animal i guess
There are only 8 Animals who count as Guarma
I saw a Guide how to glitch there after the Mission, but I dont make it. To complicated
yeah i just made sure to get them all when i was there
Asking Chat GPT which are the 8 from Guarma
Blue & Yellow Macaw
Scarlet Macaw
Great Green Macaw
Red-Footed Booby
Sunglow Boa
Rainbow Boa
Red-tailed Boa
Fer-de-Lance Snake
Not sure if that's right XD
I found a few Things which are missing for me. The Californian Horned Owl or how it's called. 3 Different Dogs, Husky Poodle and Labrador + a Pigeon
i think that is right
Well that's very helpful what you said there. I'm checking where to find em
yeah im still missing these except the husky i got last thing before i logged off last night lol
florida panther is in the same place as normal panther
just random which spawns
He mostly bite me, so I can't check which one it is XD
the parakeet will probably be a huge pain in the ass
they're like specially rare
only one flock of them exists at a time and it rotates around
The Pigeon is easy to find. There is one 🪨 Rock below the big Bridge where constantly 2 Sitting
i just happened to stumble upon them while I was doing duchesses and other animals
only time ive seen them
i dont know how to post clips but arthr just did a double front flip
The Sherrif is in Town

fer de lance doesnt wanna show up 😔
I'm not 100 save but my old Friend ChatGPT says this.
- Stillwater Creek, southwest of Thieves’ Landing, on the main map.
A known spawn point is directly east of the pool of water where you later find the Legendary Redfin Pickerel.
yeah im looking there i just keep finding southern copperheads and black tailed rattlesnakes
Maybe I should rename Gpt into Micah but then I should be aware it's trying to fool me 🤣
lol
Just read hahahaha
Can I call you Micah? Or you trying to fool me then?
You can definitely call me Micah if you’d like—it’s just a nickname!
I’m not trying to fool you though; I’m still GPT-5 under the hood.
Want me to answer in full Micah Bell style from RDR2 too, partner?
But Micah isn't a nice Person, I can't call you like that
Fair enough—that’s a good call. Micah’s reputation isn’t exactly glowing!
😄
Brave AI
What do yall think should I keep my nokota taht i just got and decided to use or should i use my mft that i use for 90% of my playthroughs
im just not a fan of the small horses
It’s medium sized
It’s still bigger then a Arabian
Its speed accel are the same as my mft its just like do i want it to be faster or do i want a tanky horse
Is there any better Horse btw then the White Arabian?
I’m also just worried that my nokota ain’t gonna survive in the later game
There are a few
The black one is slightly better
Dang it
The mft can be better sometimes and even a nokota can out speed it
I mean, the first Thing what im doing if I start a new Game and can ride along... Is to get the White Arabian as early as I can
thats because arabians are very small
theres very small small medium large and very large
So right when chap 2 starts
And you go hunting with Hosea
Ah yes big horse supremacy
The only big horse I like is my Ardennes
I mean you have no money and it's. Basically free to have
Do you like war horses?
The Perlino Andalusian is quite a good early horse and it’s not even spooked by a cougar
I might just bring back black lung
I'm still trying to figure out what's good or not... Because depending on my Compendium I'm missing some Horses
Your probably missing the ones you can’t find in the wild or anything easy
Like turkoman and stuff like that
There are 2 which I haven't found yet
Ardennes and Missouri Fox Trotter
I just compared the companion
Ah is that what you mean with MFT?
the nokota is a small horse not medium 🤓
yeah and you have to buy it
Ahhh now I see, and the Ardennes?
did someone say it was medium
same thing though you can sometimes get them from bounty hunters too
🥶
but much easier to buy one
Do they have a specific Stable?
oh yeah i think nightwolf thought there was only small medium and large
blackwater for the mft
arabian very small, nokota small, american standardbred medium, thoroughbred large, shire very large 🤓
van horn or scarlett meadows for an ardennes
real ones use the iron grey roan ardennes from pre ordering the game
if i ever want to complete the horse compendium i guess ill use that one
why wouldnt it
cause its a pre order horse
not everyone has it
would mean not everyone can finish compendium
never even seen an andalusian
might look for it when i go back up there next
do you know where it is
brandywine drop? yeah
way northeast
i think i wanna look for a couple robins up there
yeah but
its a ridge below it
where the boy calloway duel takes place i think
soy boy calloway
Missouri Fox trot
My all time favorite horse
Right next to Ardennes
i wonder if mft is the only one npcs compliment you on
maybe turkoman or arabian too
How do i get a bounty in ambarino
Aribans do too
Ambarino can be a bit tricky as there is not a major town so kill someone on your way there, mount them to your horse and then when you see another civilian, they will alert the authorities.
alternatively you can get on top of a train at annesburg and ride it into ambarino then rob it
thats what im gonna do
I REALLY wish npcs had prestige horses that you could steal
I just got wanted after asking that what I did was shoot fort mercer from across the river on the cliff inside ambarino and the cops eventually showed up
doesnt make sense for residents of saint denis to not have thoroughbreds and arabians
like arthur stealing a mans horse and selling it to the horse fence just for half a dollar doesnt make any sense
well theyre not all rich
and the ones that are probably prefer to ride in carriages
im aware but almost NO ONE has elite horses
thats for gameplay
im saying it would be a lot more rewarding selling horses to the fence if the horses yielded more money
doesnt make sense for arthur to take the effort of stealing a horse just for half a dollar
It’s any horse that is rare or costs a lot
you can get a lot more than half a dollar for some i think
well the list of those isnt super long
wait wtf
people have said you cant get a bounty in new austin as john?
I have a ~$200 bounty there for robbing one
Does sleeping make the 3 days for the bountiful achievement go down or do i have to play the game for that long
It progresses the achievement
I can finally finish this😭
Also for sharpshooter number 9 if I shoot them in the head and their hat falls off does that count for it or do I have to shoot their hat without killing them
without killing them
Alright thanks
Best place to do it is at the Valentine barns
i did it at six points but it took a couple tries
luckily if you fuck up you can just run away and come back to respawn the enemies
I was planning on going to valentines hotel to skip some of the days for the bountiful achievement so ill get it and then do sharpshooter 9
my horse picked the WORST time to randomly go in circles
in the blessed are the peacemakers mission
this game
wdym randomly go in circles
Can I just stay inside the hotel room and wait for the bountiful trophy?
Yeah
I mean their ain’t much law out there
it only happens on pc
your horse will randomly spin
and its impossible to stop
Anyways I gotta go do irl John Marston things I’ll be back
I have a 1500 bounty in new austin
you should get a controller
i have my xbox controller is it better
How long is the cooldown for sleeping
I'm out where the white Arabian horse spawns but can't seem to find it?
Can it just not spawn sometimes?
It spawned everytime for me
Where exactly are you?
Like send a pic or something
Do you need to complete all the challenges to obtain 100%
I can't upload pictures.
Yes
Rdr2 media or general media channel
For uploading pictures
Is it possible to get 100% with john or is there stuff I could only do as arthur?
Probably gonna go 90/90 for challenges as Arthur
Wtf 10 minute slowmode I hate servers like this lmfao
Can I just DM you
Post in general media it doesn't have that also real
Yeah sure
Do you have to do all of them as arthur?
I'm right near the burned down cabin.
No, but I’m probably gonna anyway since I don’t wanna do Dominos again once I’m done with gambler challenges
Weren't you going to dm me?plus I don't think there was a burned cabin near the arabian spawn point
I did, did you get it?
Ok last question I swear is there animals in quarma that I have to study for 100% and the trophy that cant be found as john?
Nah
its just on the west side of lake isabella
I honestly dunno this is my first ever time 100%ing the game
there are guarma exclusive animals but none are required for 100% or zoologist
Guess Ill just do a new play through anyways since I need the gold medals on every mission aswell
Same thing with skinning the animals?
these grays i swear
yes
How long does it take to reach rank 50 in rdo
couldnt tell ya
idk if i can actually force myself to go for the rdo achievements or not
Awhile
Like 200 + hours or something like that
I really want that plat but going for the online trophies is gonna suck
why is there slow mode for 10 mins bruh
The worst one is skinning and studying
Even the rdo ones are easier
so people dont spam the media channels with text
Ikr
10 way too much
well you can still conversate here
I completed the tomahawk challenge btw haha
nice
I used the kkk for it
Fucking rotten bastards
Wish I could kill them irl
Go back in time and figure out how to do it
thats what frankie sinks was doing
but he fucked up and turned himself into a babby
That is a nice way to interpret that lmao
And so I've reached chapter 6
red dead depression
I wish we could get a dlc with Arthur, Francis Sinclair and Deborah Macguiness trying to undo a dino apocalypse
Basically undead nightmare but with DINOSAURS
Red Dead Dinosaurs
I was going to say that
Now that would be absolute cinema🙌
Should've been more quick then, skill issue😹
Well time to collect on some debts
Yeah gives you lots of honor
Do the downes missions too
I will
trying to find a fer de lance for my compendium
im in the correct area i just keep encountering other snake types instead
Hmm sounds very tedious
far from the most tedious thing ive had to do on this run
What's the most tedious thing?
I had really good damn luck with blackjack today
Gambling is easy money more people should do it(please don't ban me)
getting all the guarma animals was a huge pain too because of how small the area is
Guarma got fucked over by the deadline ngl
gambler 8 wasnt so bad because i didnt really have to pay attention and just kinda zoned out to youtube
and some of these gold medals where ive had to play the mission over and over and experience the same scripted sections multiple times was pretty bad
Btw can I save in the hotel?cause I don't want the game to spawn me back outside the hotel
Hmm
i doubt it
why
Sucks
Cause like It would take me less time to get back to the blackjack players
Like imagine if you could save right there
Next to the players
you mean poker?
That too
Any gambling area
Like I wish we could spawn anywhere we want
Wish there weren't fix spawn areas
i mean its not like its a far walk lol
i assumed you meant you were resetting your game over and over for the poker wins
It is a bit tedious
Yes
And I don't want to like spawn near the valentine stable then have to go all the way to the bar
A hundred times
could try a different smaller town
this game does not want me to have this snake man
ive encountered a northern copperhead two or three black tails and like five southern copperheads
He’s just like me fr
I met the Widow that you teach to hunt
i just had to shoot a guy nine times before he died lol
Is there a way to replay missions?
yes go to progression > story
Thank you 
