red-dead-singleplayer

[lime forge]

run away from the horse and try again

[midnight ocean]

i accidentally punched my horse the other day i felt so bad

[lime forge]

works for me

[copper copper]

yea still doesnt work

ever since i got to saint denis

it just messed up

when i press F it mounts every other horse that an NPC is riding

but not mine

i dont think E is my hotkey since it doesnt let me mount any horses

[midnight ocean]

check your keybinds

and restart the game

the other day my horse just straight up transformed into a different horse and i had to restart the game

[copper copper]

when i press F he does some little fist clench thing which hes never done before

since then i just cant get on the horse

yea i can literally get on any other horse but mine

[midnight ocean]

did you restart the game and check the keybinds

[copper copper]

yes

i reset my keybinds and restarted

still cant

lol but in an older save it works

saint denis must've just completely fucked my game

i'd take the saddle off and put it back on and try it but i dont have the option to take it off

[midnight ocean]

mods?

[copper copper]

i have mods but havent changed them since i started the playthrough, horse was perfect until saint denis

no reason it shouldn't work

none of them should intertwine with the horse

since it was working good like 3 hours ago and i havent added any new ones since then

ok somehow fixed it

no idea how

but it works now

[midnight ocean]

mods do wacky shit though

they tend to mess with the game in unpredictable ways

[lime forge]

what is the point in having my horse rear up?

it seems completely useless

[midnight ocean]

yeah its just for fun i think

oh wait

apparently it agitates the horse which gives it a speed boost when it starts to sprint

[twin loom]

Cold outfit idea:
Arthur’s hat (any accessory, preferably the huntsman)
Legendary bear coat
Classic vest (black)
Jeans (black)
Bison and bear fowlers (I think they are called)
Muskrat gloves (I think it’s called)

Oh yeah

Stand collar overshirt (black)

[midnight ocean]

i like a fur hat for cold outfits

[hybrid moth]

i finished the game recently and im like changed a lot tho

[lime forge]

how do i actually catch legendary fish?

i cannot catch this pike in lagras with the special lure

[midnight ocean]

need to get the "special" lures from the fishing shop

[lime forge]

yea i got it

[hybrid moth]

legendary lures you get them from the lagras shop

there is more than one

[midnight ocean]

just cast where it shows the fish on the map

[lime forge]

ive been doing that for 40 minutes...

[hybrid moth]

there is Lake lure, swamp lure and river lure

[lime forge]

using the swamp lure

[hybrid moth]

try lake

or river

[midnight ocean]

sure you didnt catch it already?

[lime forge]

fishing here

nvm

cant post screenshot

[lime forge]

havent got one before

[hybrid moth]

put it in #red-dead-media

[lime forge]

and no X over it

[hybrid moth]

try the river one

sometimes it seems that it works

but try to go to that small island on west

[lime forge]

alright

thanks

[hybrid moth]

look i sent back the ss

[midnight ocean]

wait isnt that the longnose gar

[lime forge]

think so

[hybrid moth]

it is

[midnight ocean]

that definitely should be swamp lure

[hybrid moth]

yeah told him to move to where i caught it

it might get easier

[lime forge]

bro where is this fish 😭

[hybrid moth]

but honestly its the fish that took me more time than the others

get on the island i circled then try east

like throw your line on east side

[lime forge]

i got one bite and it was 20 minutes ago

[hybrid moth]

look at your compendium to be sure because map ain't 100% trustworthy

[lime forge]

nope

havent got it yet

im starting to question if this fish is real and im just schizophrenic

[junior quartz]

Chapter 5 lowkey sucks

For the story i mean

So out of place

[midnight ocean]

wtf lol

make sure you see fish in the water

youll see the ripples on the surface

[lime forge]

i do

im constantly casting to different groups of fish

[midnight ocean]

it shouldnt take more than like 30 seconds to get a bite

[lime forge]

its been like 3 ingame days

[lime forge]

aparently not

[midnight ocean]

what are you doing after you cast the lure

[lime forge]

letting it sit there and reeling it closer if there are more fish infront of me

and also jigging sometimes

[midnight ocean]

just start slowly reeling in as soon as you cast

usually dont need to pull on it

but also when you do get a bite and you're reeling it in make sure you are pulling the rod back too

[hybrid moth]

if not working reload the game

[lime forge]

i just left the area

i got the legendary musky tho

so what do i do with it

[hybrid moth]

ship it to the dude

[lime forge]

how

[hybrid moth]

post office

[lime forge]

k

thanks

and

i lost the fish

someone ran their OWN WAGON into the train and their horse died

aparently i was to blame and got jumped by 20 people

[hybrid moth]

rip

[midnight ocean]

jesus lol

did you go to van horn or something

[lime forge]

no clue where that is

but i got jumped by literally 20

thats prob cuz i killed at least 8 waves of bounty hunters

[cyan pendant]

How tf

[midnight ocean]

its a town on the east coast

theres no law there but all the people will attack you if you commit a crime instead

[fading nebula]

i think my end goal for red dead is to either platinum or to just play long enough that my beard grows to 10 without the van horn fence glitch

[lavish pilot]

The second one may be harder than the first one

[fading nebula]

exactly!

[lime forge]

this gar

is so annoying

and for some reason i just cant jank my rod up like the game wants me to

my rods goes to the right

every

single

time

and of corse while reeling in the fish when it wasnt struggling my line broke

for no reason

[lavish pilot]

I kinda liked fishing🙂

[lime forge]

right now

i hate it more then anything

because when i was about to reel in the legendary gar

my damn line broke on nothing

again

[lavish pilot]

I don’t know if I’m just too good

But my line never broke

Not even once

[lime forge]

this is literally the only thing that seems to be a glitch in this game ive found

[midnight ocean]

your line only breaks if you reel while its fighting

[lime forge]

i think ur build different

[lavish pilot]

That may be why

[lime forge]

no bubbles and my line just broke

that took

way too long

[toxic pier]

so uhh I killed evelyn miller

I firebombed his cabin

[obsidian flame]

am i the only one that likes micah?

very well written character

Of course i hated what he did to cain and arthur

[lime forge]

if i get the dark bay turkoman from the horse flesh for dinner quest can i get the turkoman again as john in the epilogue from one of the stables

[hybrid moth]

i hates him as a character but i praise the voice actor and the people who made the character what he is since he was well made

[hybrid moth]

Hello There

[hybrid moth]

idk i hated him from the start

to Arthur maybe but he still almost r*ped Sadie

at the begining if Dutch and Arthur didn't hear her scream pretty sure he would have

its at least implied

maybe but still would not trust him

[mortal tusk]

Idk how Micah fans exist...maybe just finding him attractive ?

[soft root]

it's like with the fans for the villains, micah is a great villain and that's why he gets fans

and he's not just evil, there's a few more layers to him

[mortal tusk]

Ah ywah idk why I didn't see it that way

[mortal tusk]

Like what? I'm not disagreeing just genuinely curious :0

[soft root]

his respect/jealousy with arthur

[mortal tusk]

He respects him?

[soft root]

somewhat, arthur is a capable fighter and pulls his own weight around

it's the fact that arthur has more compassion that they stood on opposite sides

[mortal tusk]

There's this camp interaction where Bill tells Micah his real name and Arthur and Micah both team up to make fun of him XD I honestly really like the moment. The only time the 2 where calm with each other

[mortal tusk]

Ahh yeah I see

Arthur at the time was the "strongest" in the gang imo

He's the one that always went out and got stuff

At least if you listen to some people in camp

[soft root]

yeah

[mortal tusk]

What's your opinion on javier

[soft root]

honestly? not the most memorable

but he's also is just wanting to survive, but a bit more down to earth

[mortal tusk]

He's my favorite apart from jhon XD

He was too loyal guhhh

[soft root]

yeah, too loyal

[mortal tusk]

Reminder he didn't aim his gun at jhon or arthur

[soft root]

he was much more hesitant

[mortal tusk]

Yeah...this was on purpose according to the actor for javier

[soft root]

which makes sense, since javier was never that ruthless and was an ok guy

[mortal tusk]

Yeah true

Like we said, he just was too blind

[soft root]

no, he wasn't too blind, he had no choice

[mortal tusk]

Also he's attractive but we don't talk about it

[soft root]

think of it, just arthur, john and mrs grimshaw against dutch's side which is more than 3 people

[mortal tusk]

Dutch side had 4? I think

Wait

5

[soft root]

he wants to survive, and he knew taking arthur's side would lessen his chances for survival

[mortal tusk]

Bill Dutch 2 brothers and Micah

(Not counting javier)

[soft root]

also, is it just me or does micah's fit have the exact opposite colors to arthur's gunslinger fit

micah has a red shirt for low honor, arthur has a blue one for high honor

arthur has a black hat, micah has a white one

hm.....

[mortal tusk]

Micah had a white onr?

[soft root]

somewhat white

[mortal tusk]

Oh yeah ur right

I never noticed rhat

[mortal tusk]

I wonder why tho..black is usually low honor and white is high

[soft root]

well, arthur ain't completely high honor, how many policemen has he killed

how many pinkertons has he killed

[mortal tusk]

Well mostly to defend himself but yeah

True

Also I'm sure he was like

Mid honor before the story began

[soft root]

but, I personally think that this is a symbolism made by the devs to signifying micah is just the other side of the coin that arthur was on

two gunsligers in dutch's gang, both pulling their own weight

one ends up high honor, the other ends up low honor

[mortal tusk]

I hate that some people think the high honor ending isn't canon

Roger Clark legit says so

[mortal tusk]

Yeah I think youre right

I still wonder why Dutch trusted micah more than arthur

Maybe because he saw that there's no getting everybody out?

[soft root]

now, dutch always had hosea by his side. when hosea died, he basically lost his right hand man, his strategist. and with the dire situation on hand and seeing that arthur's loyalty is slowly but surely starting to wavering, he started to trust micah

since dutch starting to unveil his true colors in chapter 4, dutch is slowly realizing that arthur's no longer on his side

[mortal tusk]

But didn't Arthur's loyalty start to waver because of his actions

[soft root]

and micah, the snake he is, has his words going along with dutch's thoughts

[soft root]

yes, and dutch thinks that his actions are right

like with him thinking that drowning angelo bronte before feeding him to a gator instead of just shooting him in the head is ok

like with him thinking that shanking that woman with a knife instead of just knocking her out was ok

like with him thinking that using the american indians for his own gain without even caring about the american indians' lives was ok

you get what I mean?

[mortal tusk]

Yeah he basically showed how he doesn't care for people

Do you think he was always like this?

Or do you think chapter 5 turned him like this

[soft root]

absolutely

[mortal tusk]

Really? Why so

I always thought losing hosea is what made him go downhill

[soft root]

look at what he did to angelo bronte BEFORE hosea's death and BEFORE chapter 5

[mortal tusk]

Guh true

And Heidi mcourt

Idk if I spelled it right

[soft root]

he's just as bad as colm o'driscoll, the only difference is that he has more charisma, and that he cares a bit more for his men

but if it was life or death, dutch would happily abandon most of them if it meant that he got away scot free

[mortal tusk]

That's basically what he did to jhon and arthur

[soft root]

exactly

[mortal tusk]

Do you think this could've gone any other way?

[soft root]

what could've gone any other way

[mortal tusk]

Like dutch betraying arthur and jhon

Do you think there was any way not to do that

[soft root]

yes, dutch could've not betrayed them, but the one thing about dutch, is that he values loyalty, and arthur and john were in his eyes at that point, not loyal, if dutch just opened his eyes and had his moral alignment be a bit better, he wouldn't have done so

[mortal tusk]

Do you think Dutch regretted everything? I personally do

[soft root]

......perhaps with arthur

but definitely not with john

[mortal tusk]

Well yeah XD

[soft root]

the only reason he shot micah that day on the mountain and not john, is bc of arthur

[mortal tusk]

Yeah I was gonna say that

[mortal tusk]

If you look at rdr1 that becomes obvious

[soft root]

ik

[mortal tusk]

Also idk...his face when he leaves arthur in the high honor jhon ending makes me feel like he realized arthur was right the whole time

[soft root]

he regretted leaving arthur, despite knowing arthur wasn't loyal

he didn't think that arthur was right the whole time, else he would've shot micah down the instant he realized it

arthur was a son to him, he practically watched him grow up and arthur was with dutch's gang the longest after hosea

[mortal tusk]

Wasn't it jhon/hosea?

[mortal tusk]

Ah yeah you're right actually

[soft root]

sry, forgot about hosea for a sec

[mortal tusk]

Yah ur good

What abt jhon? I thought he was the longest one too

[soft root]

john was probably a son to dutch at one point, but since john left the gang for like 1 whole year, dutch disliked john much more

[mortal tusk]

Oh yeah true. Also dutch believed jhon to be a traitor

Guh everyone who would've sided with arthur was either dead or just not there

[glass glen]

Des français ?

[empty ingot]

how can i see the mission objectives while doing the mission?

[soft root]

press alt iirc

[cyan pendant]

I mean he did care about John earlier but towards the end like 4 and 6 he was getting mad due to John being rebellious

[toxic pier]

chat do y'all have any suggestions after 100%?

I'm bored doing chores in the ranch

[late onyx]

Hunt down your old gang

[soft root]

restart

get as much money as possible

earn the highest bounty

get a maxim gun

get a second one

get a third one

[toxic pier]

nah I've made john a family man

but I guess I could massacre van horn

[soft root]

get more MONEY for tahiti

[toxic pier]

20k is more than enough to go to wherever john wants

20k in 1907 is 600k today

[mortal tusk]

Yeah ik but I feel like he already had a bias against him yk?

[hybrid moth]

maybe its why he killed himself?

[mortal tusk]

That was more of going out on his own terms

I mean he was gonna die anyway

[cyan pendant]

Yeah he literally said he was gonna

[mortal tusk]

Might aswell go out on his own

Dude that speech before he did it is so good

[hybrid moth]

by killing himself he condemned John tho

[mortal tusk]

How so?

[hybrid moth]

instead of focusing on Dutch they focused on John

[cyan pendant]

It’s the same one when he was with Arthur trapped by the military

[mortal tusk]

Well yeah ik but he was gonna die anyway

[mortal tusk]

Rlly??

Why didn't I notice

[hybrid moth]

might have gained some time tho

and if Dutch would have killed one or two of them might have changed the game

[obtuse trellis]

he was abouta die anyway

[mortal tusk]

Wdym? In rdr1 it was only jhon and jhon had his gun ready

[hybrid moth]

they were a gang and they were after Dutch before going after John if they would have fought Dutch he might have got few of them before he died

[mortal tusk]

But dutch and jhon where alone

[lime forge]

Is grangers revolver any good?

[mortal tusk]

I don't get what ur saying

[mortal tusk]

Pretty much any weapon is good

It depends on you

[hybrid moth]

The guys who killed John they wanted Dutch at first if im not wrong if Dutch had fought them first instead of going down cliff like a coward he could have got few of them and it might have removed few guys for John to kill

[cyan pendant]

Yeah when they are on the cliff

[empty ingot]

no like the objectives that u need for gold medals

[vapid spear]

Where do moose spawn

[mortal tusk]

If dutch killed a few, that would've done absolutely nothing

• Dutch didn't like jhon

[mortal tusk]

I should replay rdr2 guh

[cyan pendant]

Probably

[cyan pendant]

Dutch didn’t like late game John

[mortal tusk]

In rdr1 I'm pretty sure he didn't like him at all

As he hunted jhon "for sport"

[cyan pendant]

Yeah no he didn’t

[celest eagle]

Recently started playing for the first time - and I can see why this game is so popular. Up to chapter 3 and I'm obsessed.

[hybrid moth]

take your time do all secondary quests/missions etc. don't rush it

finished the game recently for the first time and now all other games looks meh to me

[celest eagle]

I'm going slowly.I love riding around and exploring.

[hybrid moth]

good continue like that. Im doing AC black flag rn and im not having as much fun tho

[lean flint]

I lowk don’t even know why ppl hate guarma so much

It’s honestly a fun part of the game

I feel like it was rushed tho they could’ve done more with it

And also if I got back to guarma after chapter 5 am I still wanted dead or alive there

[mortal tusk]

??? Have you played the game

[winter sequoia]

U cant go back to guarma after chapter 5

Unless u use mods

[lean flint]

There’s 2 glitches

They both involve getting drunk passing out and respawning outside of the map

Does anyone know if your still wanted tho

Bc I wanna be able to actually explore it

[hybrid moth]

im wondering if im buying back RDr1 on pc tho

[upbeat notch]

Does donating items contribute to the 250 dollar trophy

The one where you gotta donate 250 to camp

[cyan pendant]

I ment he didn’t like John

Yes I’ve played rdr

[mortal tusk]

OHHH sorry I got confused I thought you were calling me a liar I'm so sorry

[cyan pendant]

Why would I start beef without even knowing tf

[marsh pewter]

Guys

I beat the game!

now what?

(I beat the epilogue btw)

[delicate solstice]

Explore. Side missions treasures challenges collectibles encounters hunting and ...

[hybrid moth]

do like me sit like Thanos at the end of Infinity war and just look depressed lmao

[strong pasture]

Guys can anyone Tell me whats that sheep in Red dead media?

[mortal tusk]

That's why I was confused...

Especially since that scene is infamous

[obtuse trellis]

restart or just explore

[lean flint]

Platinum it

Also I’m still wondering…

If I glitch and go back to guarma either before or after chapter 5 am I wanted dead or alive there like I am in the chapter or what

And is the sniper still there

[marsh pewter]

Yeah I did that, now I just go hunting, hang out at Beecher hope, gamble, or massacre cities

[mortal tusk]

That's perfect! Exploring in this game is so peak

[shell blade]

I agree I agree I agree

[marsh pewter]

Ikr, can you do the quests where you fight the gunslingers as John though?

[mortal tusk]

Honestly I would rather explore this game than ANY other

[mortal tusk]

Any side quests can be done as jhon. Some even have special fialouge

[shell blade]

Open world riding horses interactions one of the most detailed games

[mortal tusk]

Yeah it's so fun

[shell blade]

It’s peak both this and gta 5

[mortal tusk]

I haven't finished gya story so

[shell blade]

Finish it it’s actually a great game

[mortal tusk]

Guh I can't

[shell blade]

Do you love playing as Arthur or John ?

[mortal tusk]

Hmm jhon

Although the game feels weird without arthur

[shell blade]

I just love as Arthur especially in chapter 3 when all the gang is in one place

[mortal tusk]

I wanna replay the game ngl

[shell blade]

Do you save some game files?

[mortal tusk]

I have 1 save as jhon

[shell blade]

I have about 8 saves maybe more

[mortal tusk]

For what XD

[shell blade]

Idk

[shell blade]

Bruh why does John in RDR2 look like Arthur ?

[mortal tusk]

It's jhons head on Arthur's body

[shell blade]

I figured second it’d John not jhon

I putted Arthur cowboy clothes on John and it looks like they have the same body

[mortal tusk]

Oh XD

[mortal tusk]

Yeahh irs just Arthur's body

[unborn shadow]

I finally did it

[mortal tusk]

Is it hard or just takes a while

[unborn shadow]

Honestly, its not that hard

But some missions are a pain in the ass for sure

But most of them I got first try

[mortal tusk]

Like which

[unborn shadow]

Like "Who the hell is leviticus cornwall"

I think thats the name

Took me six tries

Final section is tough because of time limit + no hit

Chapter 1

@mortal tusk "Just a Social Call" too

Time limit is crazy

You have to be john wick

But the mission is fire

[mortal tusk]

Guh

I forgot the exact names can you remind me

[unborn shadow]

Of which ones

[mortal tusk]

The last thing I remember from chapters 1-3 is Kieran being released

That's how bad I don't remember them

[mortal tusk]

Like the earliest thing I mean

[unborn shadow]

🤣

[mortal tusk]

I REALLY need to replay it

[unborn shadow]

The "who the hell is leviticus cornwall" is the mission where you rob the train

In chapter 1

You jump above the train, save lenny and stop it

Remember?

[mortal tusk]

Yah isn't it the 1st or 2nd mission

[unborn shadow]

Its the fifth mission

[mortal tusk]

Something like that

[unborn shadow]

Yes

My save is almost complete now

Only a couple of hats and Im done

[mortal tusk]

How do you get them

[mortal tusk]

Which one was this one

The name sounds familiar

[cyan pendant]

It’s the one where Dutch micha and Arthur go to kill Cornwall i think

[mortal tusk]

2nd to last?

[mortal tusk]

Oh

Hehe Micha

[cyan pendant]

Ima be honest my phone auto corrects Micah to micha and I don’t care anymore

Cause he’s a rat

[hybrid moth]

yeah and im just wondering if i buy rdr1 or not last time i played it was like 12 years ago on ps3

[marsh pewter]

Yeah, I think you should, my birthday is in about a month, and I’m gonna get it, I’ve heard it’s AMAZING

[cyan pendant]

Yeah you definitely should some mechanics are cut from it but a few were cut from rdr2 like wounds are a thing

They don’t just walk off a gun shot to the leg

[midnight ocean]

gz

[cyan pendant]

Another note the horses kinda run out a stamina fast you have to wait a few seconds before you tap

[mortal tusk]

Idk why people have such an issue with rdr1 horses

Legit you have to wait like 2 seconds and the bar is full

And you only go down 1 stage of speed

[unborn shadow]

Depends, some you have to craft, other you have to steal lol

And you have to collect a couple of them in the open world as well

Some are missable, mission related

Same as documents

[unborn shadow]

But I got them all already

Finally 😭

Im doing the perfect 100% bro

Its crazy

So many things are missable

[cyan pendant]

I don’t have a problem it’s just a big difference if you played rdr2 first

[mortal tusk]

Meh not reslly....

[mortal tusk]

How much is it at rn

[cyan pendant]

Compared to how fast they run out of stamina yeah there is

[mortal tusk]

That's such a non issue thoo

[mortal tusk]

^

[mortal tusk]

^

[cyan pendant]

Yeah like I adore the war horse in rdr1 I don’t have a problem with the horses

[merry rain]

ive had this in both rdr games
if i die to to a cougar
they refuse to spawn for like 3 hours
is this a mechanic or some shit
cuz its really slowing down my master hunter progress

[cyan pendant]

Oh yeah that’s definitely a thing the trick is finding them first then deadeye em

[merry rain]

i cant deadeye them with a knife

master hunter 5 rdr1

im gonna try doing the first agent ross mission and see if that makes them spawn after

[cyan pendant]

Try sleeping

It might force them to spawn

[merry rain]

also uh
what happened to uncle and uh
i forgot the native american gang members name
after rdr2 ended
cuz they arent here

[midnight ocean]

charles

[merry rain]

eh atleast maybe this free pistol will weaken the cougars and let me stab em

[merry rain]

yeah

[cyan pendant]

Uncle is still there and Charles is up in Canada

Remember uncles taking care of the farm in rdr1 when John is away killing his old friends

[merry rain]

so uncles the reason the barn lights are on but the rest of the place is dark?

[cyan pendant]

Ye

[merry rain]

hope he can survive the cougars cuz i was reading that the ranch can have them spawn chasing foxes and stuff

[cyan pendant]

I’m also 90% sure that pistol will one shot the cougar

[merry rain]

yknow seeing how ross just insulted natas ican see why charles left for canada

[merry rain]

fandom guide says if i hit in the back above the legs it weakens it

[cyan pendant]

Just throw your knife in its face I don’t know what else to tell ya

[merry rain]

it counts throwing knives?

it says with melee knife

a
saw video guys stabbing them from a honse

idk if i can get them to spawn ill try throwing knive ig

was told rattlesnake hollow and by silent stead

[wanton shoal]

whatre some unique horses that bounty hunters or most npcs dont ride

[unborn shadow]

The perfect 100% that I mean is different

[unborn shadow]

Because for the normal 100% you dont need full compendium, all gold medals, hats, documents, points of interests, valuables, journal entries, icons on the map, all types of horses with level 4 bonding and so on

And that is what Im going for

Like, the REAL 100%

[unborn shadow]

But for the "normal" 100%, im at 98%

[bright wolf]

Deer Carcass Vs. Skinned Deer Carcass for camp food...?

.... Different Values...? by how much....?

[merry rain]

dutch seems a bit mental

more than i remember at the end of 2

[unborn shadow]

He is

Totally insane

You can see the real dutch during chapter 5

And after that?

[merry rain]

i mean in red dead 1

hes acting like a actual mental patient

[unborn shadow]

Oooh!

Even worse!

🤣

[merry rain]

id be having a lot more fun if the cougars would spawn so i can do master hunter but they wont so im just doing the story missions

got 4 left for west elizabeth chapter

at this point id have better luck stabbing bear with my knife than a cougar

[unborn shadow]

Just sleep a lot and dont interact with anything

Then go to the trapper close to strawberry

[merry rain]

not 2.

[unborn shadow]

Fuuuuck

[merry rain]

i died to one trying it

and now they refuse to spawn

its been 3 hours

[unborn shadow]

My bad bro

I didn't played rdr1 yet

I didn't know west elizabeth was in the game

[late onyx]

theres a really good cougar spawn area close to strawberry, specially at night

[merry rain]

now im being fucking attacked by one while skinning a animal

[unborn shadow]

Thats why I guessed rdr2

[merry rain]

well the wiki calls the blackwater chapter west elizabth

[unborn shadow]

Exactly

[late onyx]

pain in the ass ik

but you can get em easily

[unborn shadow]

The real pain in the ass is the fucking moose

[late onyx]

what moose

[merry rain]

well ofc the first cougar to spawn bites me in the ass and kills me when i cant move

[unborn shadow]

From rdr2

[merry rain]

now i gotta kill the bear again

[unborn shadow]

Rdr1 idk

[late onyx]

ik im just

i just arrived to the conv

so idk what the subject is

[merry rain]

i just wanna fight brumas

[unborn shadow]

I was just mentioning him

[merry rain]

but for some reason legendary animals are locked behind master hunter 10

[late onyx]

only 1

[unborn shadow]

So rdr1 has challenges too?

[late onyx]

the legendary panther

unless its

rdr 1

then i have no clue

[merry rain]

3 on 10 1 on 9

[unborn shadow]

What

[merry rain]

brumas gordo and lobo are 10 kahn is 9

[late onyx]

yeah its rdr 1

[merry rain]

Rank 9
Search Ojo Del Diablo for "Khan", the legendary jaguar and collect his pelt

[late onyx]

sorry friend, cant help ya there

[unborn shadow]

[unborn shadow]

Me neither

[merry rain]

Rank 10
Search Aurora Basin for "Lobo" the legendary wolf, Stillwater Creek for "Gordo" the legendary boar, and Nekoti Rock for "Brumas" the legendary bear and collect their pelts

[late onyx]

i still gotta play rdr 1

[unborn shadow]

Yeah me too

[merry rain]

ISSUE

[late onyx]

undead nightmares looks so goated

idk why john act like an idiot

[unborn shadow]

For real 😭

But its canon?

[late onyx]

worlds ending and hes just strolling along the story

[unborn shadow]

Or just fire asf

[late onyx]

i take it like a spinoff

or a really funny what if

[unborn shadow]

Huumm

Got it

[late onyx]

since i dont even know where it would takes place in the story

[unborn shadow]

Exactly

[late onyx]

deeply wish they did smth like that for rdr 2

but with arthur

[unborn shadow]

Yes

I would play FOR SURE

And they would gain a lot of money bro

Win win situation

[late onyx]

yeah but gta 6

also very hopefully rdr 3 somewhere

[unborn shadow]

It will break the internet

[unborn shadow]

I wish

[late onyx]

dont wanna even mention gta here since its the

rdr 2 channel so uuuh

how far are ya in the story man?

[unborn shadow]

Everything done already

Im after the perfect 100% now

[late onyx]

dope

did all the challenges as arthur in chapter 4 recently

most patience and skill based thing i done in my life

[unborn shadow]

I said about it here

[unborn shadow]

For real! It takes a lot of time bro 😭

[late onyx]

mostly just gambler and herbalist

[unborn shadow]

Bro, I got insanely lucky with gambler 8

[late onyx]

new austin with arthur is just getting good at evading the sniper and getting the flowers ig

[unborn shadow]

I got it in 30 minutes

I saw people playing that shit for 3 hours

[late onyx]

gambler 8 is straight up luck, for 9 and 10 there are cheeses tho

[unborn shadow]

For real

[cyan pendant]

Uh that’s cause he is

[late onyx]

living proof infront of you

[unborn shadow]

You can quit the game during gambler 9

And gambler 10 just do the missions that you always wins

[late onyx]

also

you can go all in 3 times in a row

[unborn shadow]

[unborn shadow]

Yes

[late onyx]

because npcs back out or lose to your hand

most of the times

all worth it for legend of the east arthur tho, outfit rocks during cinematics

and gives sweet bonuses

[unborn shadow]

Exactly

Its dope asf

[late onyx]

yeaah

[unborn shadow]

Can you rate the outfit I did with john

[late onyx]

sure

[unborn shadow]

I think its fire but idk

[late onyx]

just upload it somewhere

rdr media probs

[unborn shadow]

Its in media rn

[cyan pendant]

I keep forgetting you can put feathers on Arthur’s hat

[unborn shadow]

Should I change something?

Huummmm

[cyan pendant]

Nah it’s kinda good

[late onyx]

maybe the pants but idk

its fire

[unborn shadow]

You see the feathers in the pants?

I think its bugged

Idk

[late onyx]

you can put a lot in that hat its just really forgetable

[unborn shadow]

But is nice

2 pink feathers there

Idk how it got there lol

[cyan pendant]

What vest is that im guessing it’s legend of the east

[late onyx]

mhm

[unborn shadow]

Yes

[cyan pendant]

Yeah I’ve never gotten that outfit so idk

[late onyx]

such a shame the legend of the east outfit is the only one with a chain for arthur

i think

[unborn shadow]

Yes it is

[cyan pendant]

Yeah it is

[late onyx]

also

never did all the challenges with john 💀

[cyan pendant]

I wish you could get John’s vest or that style for Arthur

[unborn shadow]

You can!

[late onyx]

so i got no idea how much easier it could be, aside from herb 9

[unborn shadow]

Its difficult asf tho

[cyan pendant]

WhT

[unborn shadow]

It has a couple of ways

You can glitch to new austin during some missions

[cyan pendant]

Is it a glitch..

[late onyx]

which outfit?

[cyan pendant]

His normal blue vest

[late onyx]

oh

[unborn shadow]

You can glitch an animal in arthurs head

So you dont die to the invisible sniper

Crazy

You can use the coach strategy

A lot of ways

[late onyx]

i got trauma from the sniper, dodging him with a wagon for 28 mins

readjusting the cam

[unborn shadow]

This mf

[late onyx]

getting the position well to grab the plant and the camera not to fully go into the character

[unborn shadow]

I hate him fr

[late onyx]

so glad i never have to return to new austin

[unborn shadow]

Normal blue vest?

What you talking about

[cyan pendant]

Like his cowboy one his rdr1 style

[late onyx]

looks so weird tho to have almost everything from new austin as arthur tho

[unborn shadow]

But you can get it, no?

[late onyx]

think they mean john´s farmer outfit

[cyan pendant]

As Arthur idk

[cyan pendant]

No I mean his actual one he wears in the beginning of rdr1

[late onyx]

oh

[unborn shadow]

I have the union suit, whittemore suit, tuxedo suit and guarma outfit as arthur

[late onyx]

i got no idea tbh

[unborn shadow]

As john, the belt one and the union

[late onyx]

guarma outfit?

[unborn shadow]

Ooooooh

[cyan pendant]

Like the one you use when you leave the farm

[unborn shadow]

Yeah you can keep the outfit you use during chapter 5

Even the satchel is different

[unborn shadow]

I really dont know about rdr1

[late onyx]

yeah ik, guarma is so fun

[unborn shadow]

Fr!

[late onyx]

shame i got lazy with the catalogue

[cyan pendant]

Oh I’m not the only one who likes guarma

[late onyx]

and didnt find everything

[cyan pendant]

I like the primal feel to it

[late onyx]

its really fun to survive just about smth like that

wish they could have fully finished it, but then it might be bloated with too much to do

[cyan pendant]

Plus you have like no horse and you have to run around everywhere

[late onyx]

yeah but the map isnt that big

[cyan pendant]

That’s fair I guess

[late onyx]

pretty sure you could blow throgh guarma in like

1 hour and a half

if you dont stop at anything

pretty sure most people do it in 1 sitting

[soft root]

no one really likes guarma

[mortal tusk]

OHH I see. Are u doing arthur or jhon

[mortal tusk]

What's left

[mortal tusk]

People don't like it?

[mortal tusk]

Yah

[unborn shadow]

I did everything I could with arthur, now im playing as john to finish it

[unborn shadow]

4 bounties, the graves and finishing the ms hobbs quest

I waited to do the bounties so I can get all bounty posters as john with the glitch

[mortal tusk]

Oooo I see I see

[mortal tusk]

I wanna go to the graves

[unborn shadow]

Me too!

I will do them for last

[mortal tusk]

You should play rdr1 btw!! I saw that yoy didn't play it

[unborn shadow]

Arthurs grave will be my final 0.1% to get the 100%

Absolute cinema

[mortal tusk]

Yeah that's peak!

[unborn shadow]

I want to play it so much!

But i dont have the game rn

Fuuuuck

[mortal tusk]

Guh I would gameshare

But idk how to

[unborn shadow]

How much is it?

[mortal tusk]

50...I got it at 30 when it got discounted

[unborn shadow]

50 dollars?

[mortal tusk]

Yah

[unborn shadow]

[mortal tusk]

IKR

[unborn shadow]

Thats insanely expensive

[mortal tusk]

[unborn shadow]

Im not from usa

[mortal tusk]

Indeed.

[unborn shadow]

This shit is crazy

[mortal tusk]

Like I said

[unborn shadow]

Its 300 here

[mortal tusk]

I could gameshare it but ifk how to

[mortal tusk]

300 what

[unborn shadow]

Reais

1 dollar = 6 reais

[mortal tusk]

Oof idk the currency

[unborn shadow]

From Brazil

[mortal tusk]

Ah I see

[unborn shadow]

So 50 dollars is 300 reais

[mortal tusk]

I can understand a bit of Portuguese bc I know Spanish

[mortal tusk]

Guh

[unborn shadow]

300 reais is TOO MUCH

Like, 1400 is the minimal wage

So 300 is a huge amount

For 1 game

Crazy

[mortal tusk]

Do you know how to gameshare

[unborn shadow]

Thats awesome!

[mortal tusk]

I have the game on my ps4

[unborn shadow]

I know but I would need your account unfortunaly

[mortal tusk]

Aww man

I genuinely would give it to you but yk :(

[unborn shadow]

I do the same with the account of my friend

Thats how I play rdr2 lol

[mortal tusk]

Yall should combine ur money to buy rdr1

[unborn shadow]

I know bro dont worry

[unborn shadow]

I will talk to him

Maybe some day

😭

[mortal tusk]

It's genuinely such a good game. And you will enjoy rdr2 even more cause you will see all the references to rdr1

[mortal tusk]

Hopefully!

[unborn shadow]

Exactly!

The good part is I never watched anything about it

So no spoilers

[mortal tusk]

Yah ofc

[mortal tusk]

Be careful

Sometimes they talk about it in this channel

Like randomly

[unborn shadow]

I didn't meant you would say something 🤣

It was to say I didn't get any spoilers

Until now, at least

[unborn shadow]

Yeah I know

[unborn shadow]

I will be 🙂‍↕️

[toxic pier]

didn't let the vampire get his cutscene, just shot him dead

still got the dagger tho

[merry rain]

How do I hunt the liars and cheats dlc legendary animals in rdr1

[next kindle]

whats up everyone

im going for 100% completion and im currently through the story at 88.9%

[obtuse trellis]

are you at the epilogue

[next kindle]

i have little to no challenges done at the moment and was wondering if any of them are locked to earlier points in the game

[next kindle]

done

i’ve finished the story

[obtuse trellis]

ive never done 100% competition do you have to get every random encounter too or something

[next kindle]

no

theres a checklist in the pause menu

[obtuse trellis]

which ending did you get

[next kindle]

low sadly

[obtuse trellis]

which low

[calm oasis]

Is gold on american pastoral scene even possible? 6 minutes is too short of a timespan to complete the whole mission, it takes 5 minutes 30 seconds just to get to the ambush, how do I kill all of the Odriscolls in 30 seconds???

Okay nevermind its broken

[vale osprey]

Which low?

[cyan pendant]

There is one where you go with John or you go back for the money

[lime forge]

there is a weird red symbol that randomly appears on the horse health core

[fresh lake]

brush like?

if it is a brush sign go to a trot and brush the horse

[lime forge]

oh

thanks

[errant vapor]

hi! so I just killed the legendary bear but got killed and lost the bear skin. I read that the bear wont spawn once killed, so I just lost the things? 😭 Tried to load the last save but it wasnt possible

[weary yoke]

Yeah I think you lost it

[midnight ocean]

all you lost is money

the parts from legendary animals become available at the trapper and fence whether you deliver them or not, you just lose out on the money youd get from selling

[errant vapor]

Oh ok bc I read something about outfits but that's answers my questions! Thank you everyone 😚

Tho money would come in hand rn ahahahha

[late onyx]

yeah sorry sis

you lost it

but plenty of other things to do to get money

[weary yoke]

That person said you can still have them no matter you sell them or not, you just don't have money from the selling since you don't sell

If thats your question

[tidal slate]

Reading that someone still plays makes me calm. I'm stuck at 90,3% of completing the Game. 100% Story done but... Damn so many things

[midnight ocean]

youll get plenty lol dw

i can tell you where to get a quick 500 bucks though if you want

[midnight ocean]

im on a 100% run rn

at the end of chapter 4

[trim hamlet]

Quick question, does feeding the horse while riding (as in through the quick action wheel thing) have the same effect as feeding through pressing R when standing near your horse?

cause I saw it was malnourished, and turned my horse into a walking piece of hay but it did nothing, but then did the other one (pressing R while near) and it actually did take the weight up to Fit

[cyan pendant]

Yes it does have the same effect don’t worry about the whole fit thing

[unreal patrol]

Im stuck in the hamish mission, when the boar comes straight to me it activates deadeye but i dont have any weapon to fire 🤔

First it gave me a db shotgun but the two shots didnt kill it and after respawning i dont draw anything

[errant vapor]

fair enough ahah

[errant vapor]

its an awesome game ngl

[errant vapor]

oh that would be great!

[midnight ocean]

you're in chapter 2 right

just west of your camp should be a little burnt out settlement called "limpany"

if you go there, find the sheriffs office, theres a gold bar hidden inside worth $500

[junior quartz]

What are the most brutal ways to deal with a Murfrees brood body

And how do I torture one

[midnight ocean]

fire, drag them across the ground from your horse, leave them on train tracks

poison maybe

[opaque dew]

Use minigun mod

[soft root]

burn them, shoot of their limbs, pull them onto a train track, run them over with horses, pump them with enough poison to kill a bison

drown it, feed it to a gator

lasso it while on a train or horse and drag it all the way from strawberry to saint denis

dump it from a high place

use a maxim gun on it

blow it up

hack the body with as many axe hits you can hit it before getting bored

[junior quartz]

What does poison do?

[midnight ocean]

make them die slowly i think

[junior quartz]

What if they’re already dead …?

[midnight ocean]

idk i never use it tbh

uh then nothing lol

[junior quartz]

Oh ok lol

[midnight ocean]

one time a murfree was attacking me and i lassod him but he was standing near the river

so he falls down and kinda slides down headfirst into the water and i just stood there while he drowned

it was from that encounter where theres two of them looting a camp and then two more show up

[junior quartz]

Oh yeah I’ve had that happen

[unreal patrol]

If you kill Anthony Foreman and skin him that means you got a Fore skin?

[lime forge]

what is a good way to get high honor quick? i want to get some of the items and cosmetics from high honor before going back to playing low honor

[topaz tundra]

It's pretty stupid how you lose all your pelts when you die

[mortal tusk]

Fishing and greeting

[tidal slate]

😄 I just found that Guy looking for Gavin, I felt rly sorry for him... But it seems there is no Way to help. I saw him in Saint Louis and later on in the deepest Desert... Gavin where are you??? And I thought Dude, the hell you get here???

He was on the Way far West side of the Map somewhere in nowhere... Poor fella

Some Forums claim that I should lasso him and you get a Letter? Not sure at all what to do, or if I ever find him again

[toxic pier]

greet everyone and do camp chores

[tidal slate]

Just a quick Question, is high Honor necessary in rdr2 Singleplayer? Or do you have anything good outcome from it?

(I mean later) as I said, I'm proceeding and stuck at 90.3 smth percent

[swift moth]

Hello

[fluid ravine]

Hi

[weary yoke]

Wait what does it says I've been answering to you, I thought I saw the kinda same question from another person am I lagging

[whole quail]

Any idea which is the best horse after the Arabian?

[weary yoke]

Just in stats ? I think the Missouri fox trotter is a good one

[loud ocean]

missouri fox trotter is the fastest

so, i guess it's best after arabian

the handling isn't the same tho

[tough plank]

Hi!

[loud ocean]

hellou

[weary harness]

are we deadiss 💔

[calm oasis]

Why is it so hard to get gold on missions

[ruby isle]

What do you mean?

Willy Wonka

[calm oasis]

Like gold medal

[ruby isle]

I believe you can replay the mission

[calm oasis]

Yeah but still, pain in the ass

[ruby isle]

Real, crazy shit like doing whatever in 15 seconds

[calm oasis]

Mainly the accuracy, because my allies shoot them, they fall over and I miss. And this is happening quite a lot

[ruby isle]

I believe you, I never played the game

[calm oasis]

I'll tear my hair out in a minute for christ sakes

[ruby isle]

I don't know what to say

[blissful crane]

missouri fox trotters

[blissful crane]

just deadeye em

[ruby isle]

Dead eye is the best weapon in the game

[warm salmon]

Fake news

[warm salmon]

Thoroughbreds

[blissful crane]

they're better because they aren't tiny

but use any horse you want

[warm salmon]

Why didn't you say shire then?

Or belgian draft

[blissful crane]

i dont like the handling

fox trotters are the perfect size and still have high speed and stamina

[warm salmon]

Thoroughbreds >>>> fox crapper

[midnight ocean]

accuracy is the easiest objective to get just use deadeye

[calm oasis]

Poor Arthur is going to be addicted to snake oil

[ruby isle]

I've been through the desert on a horse with no name

[frozen yarrow]

can someone help me with smth

im the mission where

the bull gator

and

julius keeps getting attacked

idk why

[calm oasis]

You are meant to go for him

Take him to the boat

And shoot the living hell out of the gator

[ruby isle]

ye u can shoot it, stab it, blow it do whatever

[frozen yarrow]

he getting bugged

like

he flew

everytime he in the boat

when patching his leg up

[compact robin]

bruh every 10 -30 minutes in game i somehow keep getting random interactions wtf

can any game be anymore detailed than rdr 2

[calm oasis]

How is it even possible to get gold in Preaching Forgiveness as he went, Lenny takes 2 business days to reach Shady Belle

[ruby isle]

are you that impressed

[ruby isle]

are you trying to 100% the game or what?

[calm oasis]

Done, Im trying to get gold rush achievement

[compact robin]

yup been playing the game for 2 weeks

and i never felt more immersed in the game than rdr2

witcher 3 and gtav felt soulless

[ruby isle]

fr

[ruby isle]

I understand, I really wish I could play it

It's my favorite game

[compact robin]

sometimes i just wanna quit my job just to play rdr 2 all day

ngl

[ruby isle]

brah I feel you

If I had rdr2 i would play all day

[compact robin]

dw you'll get it soon

im also a new player

luckily i timed it during the last steam sale

i saved like 40%

[ruby isle]

I've been trying, I need like $19 more

[compact robin]

wait for a sale

[ruby isle]

I wish

[compact robin]

next sale is probably hallowween

or christmas

[ruby isle]

Damn...

Every rockstar game is on sale rn

except for rdr

😓

[compact robin]

ye rdr 2 rarely even gets on sale

its mostly on sale on major holidays tho

[calm oasis]

I hate preaching forgiveness as he went

Lenny was abondoned, HE WAS 2 FEET AWAY

[weary yoke]

FR

[calm oasis]

Im gonna glue his ass to the damn wagon with tar and super glue

[weary yoke]

That would be great yeah

[ruby isle]

sucks bro

[junior quartz]

I got it for 15 bucks on Xbox sake

It’s also on Amazon for 15 bucks

[drowsy vessel]

yo chat if in the epilogue I robbed a guy and got his gun early on will i still get arthurs gun later on or nah?

[smoky solar]

hi yall

[sonic temple]

All 🖥️ players...

[compact robin]

you will still get arthurs

its one of the trophies you get for completing the storyline

[drowsy vessel]

Ok thank you because I heard there’s a glitch where if u get weapons early in the epilogue u won’t get the weapons

[merry rain]

You get a unique pistol from Arthur?
I don’t remember that

Am I meant to 100% the game?

Cuz that’s not happening lol too many collectibles

[compact robin]

not really a special gun as in a different gun

he means the design on the revolver

[merry rain]

Ah

I’m somehow at 80% completion unintentionally I believe

Do the master hunter type challenges count towards completion %?

[compact robin]

better keep that high honor up

[merry rain]

I can’t remember the other types of challenges

[compact robin]

was that the one with hamish?

[merry rain]

I’ve been doing a lot of rdr1

[merry rain]

I’m not sure anymore

Ik there was a few other challenges with 10 levels like master hunter

Idk if they count as % or not

[compact robin]

wait which chapter are you right now

[merry rain]

I’ve finished both games

Rdr2 and rdr1

[compact robin]

oh oh ok

y'know i wanna play rdr 1

but darn thing is too expensive on steam

pc

[merry rain]

It’s good but the ending is

[compact robin]

im waiting for a sale

[merry rain]

Eh

Not gonna say what it is though

[compact robin]

i know the ending cuz of youtube lol

[merry rain]

Also hunting is annoying cuz legendary animals are only available in the multiplayer mode or at master hunter 9 and 10

[merry rain]

Which ending

There’s technically 2

But one is just a stranger side mission for revenge and it rolls credits

[compact robin]

i think jack isnt that type of guy\

[merry rain]

Well it’s a side mission

[compact robin]

i still wanna play it tho

[merry rain]

It felt like a cheap addition added on I won’t lie

[compact robin]

only thing that spoined rdr 1 for me is landon rickets and the ending

and maybe abt edgar ross

[merry rain]

Hm

I wonder if rdr2 completionist is like gta
Where you just have to do some not all

But most of it

Maybe I’ll look into it after undead nightmare

[compact robin]

i read that you dont have to do all

just complete the challenges

other than that if you complete all challenges theres still the random encounters but they wont add to the 100% completion

they say allegedly that there are 300+ random encounters in game bruh

[merry rain]

Hm
I guess I could use a map with all collectibles and make a custom map getting them all in one journey

New Austin to Saint Denis