red-dead-singleplayer

[woven kernel]

i was hoping Arthur would grab Micah and they both fall off the cliff and die

[maiden geyser]

I think it's a bug because I closed almost the whole game 100% and I only need 10 levels of the dead eye, thanks anyway

[drowsy sinew]

its alright :( the thing that got me to 100% was leveling my health up to level 10 with fishing so it might be the case for you !!

[kindred flax]

I have question.. I raced that dude in strawberry and that lady in the rhodes once, they are not showing in their locations now for second race

I stole her horse by the way

What to do

Was riding on their spawn locations for days and still nothing

[tepid raft]

hi guys i cant unlock achivements i am on chapter 3 rn i didnt get an achivement for it

[cyan pendant]

Are you using cheats

If you ever did you can’t get trophies

[tepid raft]

no

there was an power outage while i was playing i completed chapter 3 in that time when i became online again still no achivements

[next orchid]

Edith downes goes to camp?? this is so weird ive never seen this interaction before

[calm oasis]

Do all the challenges, I think gambler and sharpshooter give deadeye points

[maiden geyser]

i've already done it

[calm oasis]

OHHH

My bad

I was wondering the same

You have to go to the trapper

Holsters

Bandoliers

Etc.

The more you get, the more points towards deadeye, health and stamina you get

[tribal dock]

🍞

[final iron]

I'm getting rdr2 tomorrow anybody got some tipssss

[calm oasis]

Take it slow and enjoy the game, dont rush through it

[final iron]

Ok

[calm oasis]

Is there another spawn for stars of the stage cigarette card 11? I cant get it to spawn at Larned Sod, no matter what I do

[acoustic junco]

Guys everyone say javier didn't show his gun to us in the ens. But is wrong knowledge. If you check clearly, you can understand me.

[unkempt dock]

Im like 67% done with it but lowk wish i took more time exploring and learning the games areas while i had the chance theres a lot of aspects of the game id wish i took more time to explore and digest like saint denis

[final iron]

Ok

[unkempt dock]

Yeah i was obsessed with just doing story missions but missed out on a some of the little side quests and robberies i couldve done to get my money up earlier in the game

[final iron]

I am planning to do what you didn't and kill a lot

[midnight ocean]

you can view them all in the compendium

[maiden geyser]

does anyone know how to fix this bug with extra stock for Dead Eye, i can't get the achievement, i have 99.9% completed the only thing missing is that damn Dead Eye

[midnight ocean]

you sure you dont just need more xp?

[maiden geyser]

yes

I checked the character's condition but the extra stock of the dead eye is still 1/2 but the experience 1104/1100

[midnight ocean]

and you're absolutely sure you bought every piece of equipment at the trapper?

[maiden geyser]

yeah i checked 3 times

[midnight ocean]

think you're just fucked then

i think theres a mod that fixes it actually

[maiden geyser]

i’m just blind idiot i didn’t buy last set, sorry guys for wasting ur time

[midnight ocean]

lol

im a bit concerned about this herbalist 9 challenge

im at 28/43 but ive sorta lost track of which herbs ive picked and which i havent

hoping i dont get to 42/43 and cant figure out which it is

[true heath]

Hi all, any new beginners here

[toxic pier]

just buy it

I got 3 sets completed and it only cost me 2000$

[cyan pendant]

Don’t use a Morgan

[unkempt dock]

😭😭😭😭yooo waht dont do that

[unkempt dock]

Dont kill regular civilians or passerbys bro i did that alot at the start and it took me two whole days to regain my honor back 😭

Where did bro get kill a buncha civilians from that

[charred lance]

but the fun

[cyan pendant]

Come on it’s funny and plus low honor is way better gameplay wise

You get way more money off corpses and valuables

[winter moat]

When do I get to free roam in epilogue?

[calm oasis]

Technically you can freeroam right away

The gun will be stored in Johns ass isntead of a gunbelt though

[midnight ocean]

i wish it were easier to rob people without killing them

they always pull a gun even if you're already pointing yours at them

[stark ledge]

the prison pocket useful for everything

[calm oasis]

Indeed

[cyan pendant]

That’s why you target the people that don’t have guns

[midnight ocean]

carriage drivers almost always have guns

interestingly train passengers never do

or they just dont pull them

like i always see those fancy carriages with some passengers in them and i want to rob them but the whole situation immediately turns to chaos no matter what

[stark ledge]

wallace station in fresh rdr2 save here i come

[midnight ocean]

whats the significance of that

[stark ledge]

shirtless arthur

[midnight ocean]

oh lol

[stark ledge]

micah should've died with colm

[midnight ocean]

micah shouldve died at adler ranch

[stark ledge]

f*ck you micah

bad news about micah is good news

[midnight ocean]

the micah paradox

[stark ledge]

micah missions always ALWAYS GO BAD

[midnight ocean]

yeah its weird because he doesnt actually become a rat until like chapter 5 or something right?

but they make it seem like hes ratting from the very beginning

[stark ledge]

i wanna stab him

[midnight ocean]

i wonder if thats a plot detail that was changed mid development

[stark ledge]

he is the rat

[midnight ocean]

i know

i mean the time at which he becomes the rat

[stark ledge]

isn't uncle red harlow

[midnight ocean]

no lol

[soft root]

that's just a meme, like the dropbear in australia

[stark ledge]

he says he is the one shot kid

[soft root]

no one knows, there's even a theory that milton was just playing tricks at arthur through saying that micah is the rat to make the gang split apart from within even more

[stark ledge]

and has the bandage red harlow had

[soft root]

he also doesn't have the scars on his face like red harlow

[stark ledge]

yet has the same face

[soft root]

and if that's what red would've turned to in not really too many years, I'd be disappointed

the one moment red gets lumbago, he ain't going to be some lazy bum

look at landon ricketts, look at jim boy calloway, you seriously think uncle is red without realizing he does not seem to be any good in gun fights compared to arthur or john?

it's just a meme, red harlow is probably a legend that just got mixed up with many other tales to create the legend

[stark ledge]

thanwhy did he say in his chapter 2 valentine mission he was called the one shot kid

[soft root]

was red harlow ever called the one shot kid?

[stark ledge]

yes

[soft root]

when

[stark ledge]

when he shot a guys arm off

[soft root]

well, uncle isn't the most trustworthy dudes btw

so I don't think we should really believe his words

[stark ledge]

i trust him with my life over micah

[soft root]

he nearly got us killed with that cornwall stagecoach robbery

though, yeah, him over micah

although if micah was just a bit better of a man, he and arthur would actually be a pretty good duo (controversial opinion)

[stark ledge]

a revolver to the head point blank will solve all problems

getting me brawlin practice

[soft root]

seriously, micah is great with a gun

you see how fast he reacted the moment sean got killed

not to mention, he and arthur basically killed a whole town (although arthur probably did all the work)

and he actually is on the same coin as arthur, just on the other side

[midnight ocean]

theres way more evidence that he really did rat iirc

[soft root]

ik

that's why it's a theory

and not considered actual truth and facts

[midnight ocean]

well there are fan theories that are likely and have supporting evidence

that just isnt one of them

[soft root]

yeah

[tepid raft]

that still doesnt answer why i cant get any achivements

[obtuse trellis]

micah literally looked straight at the pinkertons when they were watching the showdown at camp

clearly he felt safe around them

[thick stream]

Hello

[midnight ocean]

one i like is him having an old wanted poster of dutch at his strawberry camp

[cyan pendant]

That’s kinda the point

[cyan pendant]

I don’t know man stop bothering me about it or ask somebody else

[obtuse trellis]

missions with micah gotta be some of the best in the game

gameplay wise

because unlike bounty hunting missions with sadie missions with micah dont through everyone at you at once just for the sake of it

also micahs actually skilled

[midnight ocean]

im gonna go berserk

probably gonna miss a gold medal on one of the easiest missions because arthur just refused to aim at this npc because of weird third person camera bullshit

yeah and i just missed a second shot in dead eye because the guy went behind a tree leaf lol fuck this shit

[obtuse trellis]

what 😭

[midnight ocean]

i marked his head but he passed behind a tree branch and the bullet just didnt hit him

[obtuse trellis]

i wish i could help but ive never done whatever a gold metal is

[midnight ocean]

its the most annoying thing in the game

makes missions completely unfun

[obtuse trellis]

then why are you doing them

[midnight ocean]

completion

[obtuse trellis]

do they give an achievement or something

[obtuse trellis]

oh

[midnight ocean]

yeah

[obtuse trellis]

i usually just do whatever side missions or whatever that i like

[midnight ocean]

its not needed for 100% but there is an achievement

[obtuse trellis]

like i aint hunting dinosaur bones

[midnight ocean]

those aint even that bad its all those freakin orchids and bird plumes

[obtuse trellis]

the only missions like that that i do are in online

this is literally the only game i play so

[midnight ocean]

bro

i just missed because i shot through his hair

dudes got a fucking afro

[obtuse trellis]

😭

[neat roost]

Yo wsg

[obtuse trellis]

i dont understand tho does it not let you use dead eye or something

[midnight ocean]

i just fell off my horse because i glanced over at the chat

[midnight ocean]

it does i just didnt think i needed to lock on that time

[obtuse trellis]

what gun you using

[midnight ocean]

schofield

[obtuse trellis]

duel wield?

[midnight ocean]

yeah

[neat roost]

Not bad

Ngl Schofield are overrated

[midnight ocean]

i just started using them to get the long barrel guns challenge and never switched back

[neat roost]

Yeah they are so good

But i always used cattleman for the cowboy style yk, I never realized it until at the end of the game

[midnight ocean]

wow thats insane

[neat roost]

I know

[midnight ocean]

no

i just locked on to this guys head in deadeye and it only shot his hat off

[neat roost]

Oh wow that's insane

[obtuse trellis]

i use the double action revolver

duel weild

like the rat

[midnight ocean]

especially since its not possible to lock on to just the hat

[neat roost]

Btw does anyone have tips to get the rdr2 platinum?

[fluid scarab]

Is it plausible in story mode or more of a run-and-gun thing?

[obtuse trellis]

wdym

??

[fluid scarab]

The accuracy and dmg isnt that great compared for other revovlers/pistols

I'm asking if its more of a weapon that you just fire and hope that you land a few hits

[midnight ocean]

i just deadeye literally everything so it doesnt matter what gun i use lol

[fluid scarab]

Dang that does make sense

[midnight ocean]

id love to not use deadeye all the time but i really hate the way arthur waves the barrels of his guns around after every shot

[fluid scarab]

I've been dual wielding lemat revolvers

[midnight ocean]

like how am i supposed to land a second shot if bro is tracing figure 8s in the air

[obtuse trellis]

no i main the double actions

the second they become available in the gunsmith i buy it and main it for the rest of the game

[midnight ocean]

i was dual weilding grangers and flacos revolvers at first

[obtuse trellis]

double action is really good if you can actually aim

[soft root]

or if you just spam dead eye

[warm salmon]

So I just ate 99 big game meat and some more gamey bird meat and slept but I'm still underweight?

How to get fat?

Or even average

[soft root]

.....sleep again

[warm salmon]

I cooked the meat with mint oregano and thyme

[soft root]

and are you sure that says underweight and not overweight

[warm salmon]

I slept max time

[warm salmon]

Yes

[soft root]

have you tried plain meat

[warm salmon]

Okay I tore down camp and checked again now it says average

[warm salmon]

I thought big game better

And 99 big game must be enough to make me fat no?

[soft root]

like, plain big game meat

[warm salmon]

No i had only seasoned

I've been doing 100% quests so had a bunch of herbs

[soft root]

oh

[sharp vapor]

I almost made arthur die cause i wanted to kill the legendary bear lmfao

Almost got beaten by a bear

[soft root]

oof

also, btw, legendary animal pelt qualities don't get ruined no matter what, so next time when you hunt some big legendary predator, bring a shotgun with slugs or the maxim gun cart

[blissful crane]

isn't the double action about going full auto at the cost of damage per shot

the double action sucks at it because the accuracy is so garbage

it's fun to use but you can use any of the semi auto pistols to achieve a way better result for the same playstyle

personally i didn't really like using em but i did customise em though

the only gun i have never customized is the repeating shotgun

because i always stay in chapter 4 + i never use it as john

[obtuse trellis]

if you buy all the upgrades for it which isnt that expenseive and you have good aim its a really fun weapon to use

[warm salmon]

I'm playing as john if that matters? Idk if fat john is in the game

Why can't I mail the wildlife exhibition carcasses?
#red-dead-media

[vocal oasis]

Hey guys so I just entered chapter 6 and all the stores are closed is something wrong with my game??

[warm salmon]

Yes uninstall and reinstall

[vocal oasis]

Aw:(

[calm oasis]

Is there an achievement or something for 100% the compendium?

[white seal]

Hey is there a chat for talking about mods?

[white seal]

i think its just the game completion percentage

[calm oasis]

Not to my knowledge, you could try asking in #pc-technical-stuff

[white seal]

i needed more like suggestions than help but thanks tho

[calm oasis]

Suggestions as in what mods to get?

[white seal]

yep

[calm oasis]

Well for starters definitely get rampage menu

Really good thing to have

[white seal]

meh i dont see the use

[calm oasis]

Then, it's really about what you would prefer

[white seal]

what i wanted to do is to ask about survival mods

in every videos there always the same

i wanted smth that made resources more scarce

[calm oasis]

You mean the thirst meter, illness meter etc.?

Ohh

[white seal]

not only that

like smth that doesnt let me save my guns on my horse, that makes ammo and food and stuff more rare

[midnight ocean]

no but there are two achievements for skinning every animal and studying every animal respectively

[white seal]

couldnt really find nothing with a quick search

[calm oasis]

Alright, thanks. Got those two 2 days ago

So nothing more

[calm oasis]

Uhhh, gun locker

[white seal]

like, i know the basic mods, rampage, stash that lantern, seasons, basic needs, but still aint what i search

[calm oasis]

Just go to a wardrobe but press r and you can stow those weapons in the locker, they won't appear on your horse

[white seal]

yea but i Remember that there was a mod that did it

[white seal]

i know that, but i wanted smth more immersive

[calm oasis]

Ohh, alright i get you

[midnight ocean]

food being scarce doesnt really make sense for the setting tbh

[calm oasis]

True, only in chapter 1

And that one is very linear

[midnight ocean]

i would love a more survival oriented version of this game tho

shooting animals for food doesnt feel necessary enough

[calm oasis]

Wouldn't be bad

But we will all die of old age 20 times over before rockstar makes a red dead dlc

[midnight ocean]

they would never make a dlc like that anyway

[calm oasis]

To be honest if they dropped a red dead dlc, like a major one, for example the Blackwater massacre or something along those lines, I'd buy it immediately. Red dead is an awesome game, they would just hype it up even more if they added a dlc of sorts

Just my opinion though

[midnight ocean]

oh yeah i would too lol

think we just gotta wait for rdr3 tho

[calm oasis]

Let it be 20 bucks, I'm buying it

[white seal]

i wanted to combine it with undead nightmare 2 origins, thats why

[calm oasis]

I tried getting the undead nightmare 2 mod, didn't work for me

[midnight ocean]

no chance lol

[white seal]

i dont need this mods for a playtrough just to have fun

[white seal]

yea after 7 years the dlc should be free

[calm oasis]

I mean the game is fun by itself, you dont need mods

[white seal]

point of view

[calm oasis]

It has shitton of stuff, even now almost 3 700 hours I keep finding new stuff

[white seal]

Good for you?

[midnight ocean]

so they can make no money off it?

[white seal]

Yea you right

10 dollar dlc and im buying it

but before i would like a remaster

[midnight ocean]

i imagine it would be like $40

[calm oasis]

Good enough

[midnight ocean]

do you think the remaster should be free too? lol

[white seal]

better off buying a new game

[midnight ocean]

depends on how much content there is and how crazy you are about rdr

[calm oasis]

Seeing how every remaster so far went? Yes

[white seal]

no, but after 7 years it would make more sense for a remaster than a dlc

[midnight ocean]

and why would they do that? good will?

[white seal]

did the same reasoning with elden ring, the dlc Is huge and the 30$ were worth it, so yea unless is undead nightmare aint paying more than 10$

[white seal]

its more like "caring for the community"

[calm oasis]

I mean, if they are to call it a remaster let it atleast be a remaster, not the definitive trilogy mess

[white seal]

like a texture update or smth like that

[white seal]

or the pc port for rdr1

[midnight ocean]

in exchange for billions of dollars

[calm oasis]

Exactly

[midnight ocean]

ok not billions but a lot

[white seal]

Bro do you know how much rockstar makes a year with Just rdo and gtao?

[calm oasis]

Billions

[white seal]

yea

[calm oasis]

With a b

[midnight ocean]

yeah and its not because they release games for free lol

that would be losing money

[calm oasis]

They got enough.. lmao

[lofty furnace]

Does anyone even buy gold bars in rdo?

[midnight ocean]

name one time in history where a company said "well, we finally got enough money. time to stop making more"

[calm oasis]

Not sure, highly doubt it

[errant turtle]

Should I try playing with a controller

[midnight ocean]

some amount does or they wouldnt still be updating it

[errant turtle]

An Xbox controller

[white seal]

Bro i Just think that after 7 years i would like a "WE ARE DROPPING A REMASTER UPADTE" more than "WOW ZOMBIES IN RDO, AGAIN"

[calm oasis]

Since you can just do the story missions, buy bounty hunter and grind it out

[midnight ocean]

if you want

[calm oasis]

Or just take the money spawned in by modders

[errant turtle]

Alr

[midnight ocean]

nobodys talking about zombies

[lofty furnace]

They haven't done any major updates in years

And they probably never will

[white seal]

Its not "stop making money" its "lets build a community that will spend money on us anyway"

[midnight ocean]

well yeah i mean its not as successful as gta online but they just did a content update for it right

so it must be making some money

[midnight ocean]

they already have a community, and whats the community gonna buy if the game is free? old games? shark cards?

[white seal]

what i mean is that its been 7 years, and we get only rdo update, and its the same with gta, i am just sad that rockstar has this "game finished now it wont be updated" mentality

[white seal]

Yea?

bro gta has been free

and i dont think they lost that much

it costs 5 dollars, do you think they make billions out of 5 dollars? and same for rdr2 you can find it at like 10 $, they dont make money selling games anymore

[midnight ocean]

no?

[white seal]

epic games

now it aint anymore, but it has been released for free

even on PlayStation

and idk but i think on xbox too

[midnight ocean]

briefly being available for free a decade after release is different than releasing a game for free day one lol

[white seal]

yea you are getting what im saying wrong

[midnight ocean]

like how much money did they already make off copy sales alone before they made it free

[white seal]

what im saying is, After 7 years i dont think they NEED to make you pay for a remaster update or a dlc

[midnight ocean]

i mean my main thing was that it would be silly to expect them to release a dlc or a remaster completely for free

[white seal]

Call me silly then, i just would like if companies thought about community more

[midnight ocean]

mcdonalds doesnt need to limit me to three sauces for my 20 piece mcnuggets either

[white seal]

bro wtf does that even have to do with it

[midnight ocean]

they can afford a fourth sauce

[white seal]

dont start throwing random shit in the convo

[midnight ocean]

sigh lol

[white seal]

that big companies are assholes is an all time truth you dont have to throw random shit

now i got bored about this convo

[midnight ocean]

okay relax

@toxic pier random question but did you get the liberty hat from the night folk stranger mission by any chance?

[toxic pier]

ah no not yet

and I missed the bucket hat

[midnight ocean]

thought bucket hat wasnt missable

[toxic pier]

nah

it is

it's the apleseed timber worker

[midnight ocean]

some say it can be found on wagon riders in big valley

oh but only in part 1 of the epilogue

[midnight ocean]

i think you got the wrong chat bro

[toxic pier]

I think I'm missing 1 herb for herbalist 9

hm

shit

[nimble dew]

If I start a new game, will all previous save files be deleted?

[midnight ocean]

no

[midnight ocean]

this is gonna be me i just know it lol

[nimble dew]

Phew, that's good to know.

[frigid horizon]

I just started chapter 4 and there isn’t any yellow missions to do it say that the gang are busy because they just saved jack so how long does it take till a mission?

[toxic pier]

I found it

a goddamn raspberry

[ashen compass]

Hello i need help. So currently im with John and Dutch and we need to see Angelo Bonte in his house, but the problem is when im going thru the door there is like an invisible wall and i cant enter the house. ANy ideas about the problem? Is it from a mod or?

[midnight ocean]

just wait a day

they have a party to celebrate jack's return

[midnight ocean]

lol

yeah i need most of the berries and mushrooms still

at like 30/43 rn

[toxic pier]

you should use jimbatron's guide

I'm using it rn

it's a livesaver

[silent geyser]

I bought my sister rdr2 and note that she isnt a gamer AT All she wanted to try it.Today she finished the story and was crying the whole.Also she was hoping arthur and sadie are going to get married throughout the whole game

[toxic pier]

chat who is the scariest: night folk, murfree, or skinners?

[vital kraken]

Id say skinners tbh

[hazy python]

i was playing as john marston after the whole story and i went to saint denis gunsmith and accidentally killed the gunsmith and i can’t get out the main door, what do i do?

[winter moat]

can i safely complete epilogue 2 without missing any sidequests on the map?

[soft root]

I mean......if you look for them, then yeah, if not, there will still be sidequests

[obtuse trellis]

whatever the ones are that randomly run out at you with a machete

[toxic pier]

that's basically all three

[obtuse trellis]

what are the night folk

[toxic pier]

they lurk in the swamps at night

they're like ghosts

[obtuse trellis]

ik the murfree brood are the ones from chapter 6 and tbh they just weird bro

[obtuse trellis]

the swamp is a weird place

[toxic pier]

yeah

[obtuse trellis]

i dont like that 3 out of the 6 camps are in the swamp

from what i can remember doesnt john solo all the skinners

[stark ledge]

cliffs hurt

[stark ledge]

#torturekirean

[vital sundial]

may you burn in hell

and let that sweet guy be

[stark ledge]

no

[wanton shoal]

what

shady belle and lakay and what else

[vital sundial]

he didnt do anything wrong

[stark ledge]

horse murder

[vital sundial]

bruh

[stark ledge]

hes an odriscoll

[vital sundial]

he changed

[stark ledge]

you can burn him

arthur drowned him

[stark ledge]

i know

just preventing bills harassment'

[vital sundial]

he dont deserve torture man

[stark ledge]

im preventing bill harassing him

[vital sundial]

aight whatever you say

[stark ledge]

he has a dolla

nutered him

now to camp

[obtuse trellis]

clemins point

[wanton shoal]

that is literally not a swamp

[obtuse trellis]

its right next to one

[wanton shoal]

not realy

[obtuse trellis]

which means exploration is limited

[stark ledge]

a gun works just as well as tongs

[wanton shoal]

no?

bru

[obtuse trellis]

lemoyne is strange

its like 50% swamp 25% saint denis and 25% plains with farms

[stark ledge]

kirean got a bullet to the crotch'

[wanton shoal]

its kinda just louisiana

wrong reply

🥀

[stark ledge]

hell yeah

[wanton shoal]

my bad brother

[wanton shoal]

except its nkt

not

[obtuse trellis]

from what i can remember

unless it extends further

sisika is apart if it??

[wanton shoal]

yeah

i didnt know that either actually

but the swamp is only a small part of lemoyne

its mostly scarlett meadows

[obtuse trellis]

scarlet meadows is beautiful

[wanton shoal]

i like killing the kkk in scarlett meadows

speaking of lemoyne i forgot i had a 300 dollar bounty and i just got arrested in saint denis

[loud kernel]

Wassup y'all so Im trying to cook up a outfit in rdr2 but for the finishing touches I need the black french dress online it says I need to do the Le Desire mission in chapter 4 but idk how to trigger it could someone help?

[mortal shale]

Has anyone had problems with small game arrows not doing anything to squirrels and rats?

[arctic musk]

with squirrels yeah but with rats no

what kind of problems?

[calm oasis]

I heard you can save Johns hat from epilogue part 1, how do I drop the hat? I fought a guy, I got kicked in the face by a horse, but the hat seems to be glued to Johns head

[empty ingot]

can i access somehow the horses from arthur in the epilouge?

[calm oasis]

If im not mistaken they should be in the stable

[obtuse trellis]

black french dress?

[loud kernel]

Yes

[obtuse trellis]

try the tailor from saint denis he might have an outfit for it or it could just be there

[midnight ocean]

no

not without mods at least

[limber pewter]

guys i have a guarma question if anyone could pls help me

so i know that the animals in guarma don’t count for 100%, however while im here i thought i may as well add what i can to my compendium. my issue is - how tf do i get to the actual beach?! its all through restricted sections. i’m looking mainly for the crab and if the turtle is actually real but idk how to find them

[idle geyser]

So close to 100%, just need to complete the exotics mission 😭

[obtuse trellis]

pretty sure they aint real

[limber pewter]

well that’s a mighty shame

[obtuse trellis]

ill look it up for you

one sec

theres 11 animals exclusive to guarma

[obtuse trellis]

theres no turtles but theres green iguanas and cuban land crabs

[limber pewter]

i’m struggling with the land crabs honestly but i read somewhere you can also find them outside of guarma?

[midnight ocean]

I think so

you can find crabs and iguanas on the island in flat iron lake

just have your horse swim across from clemens point

don't sleep there tho because it'll teleport you back to the mainland

ive been carrying a perfect crab in my satchel since chapter 2 lol

[obtuse trellis]

no its different

theres 2 kinds of crabs i think

[midnight ocean]

that figures

well the green iguanas are there at least

[limber pewter]

i just can’t seem to get to any sand without having to go through heavily guarded areas and i darent start any missions because then i’ll just be trapped in them 😭

as much as i wanna get off guarma im curious about the animals

[midnight ocean]

i just checked and the ones i found were cuban land crabs

there's no empty slot near it either so i think that's the only crab

the closest thing is crayfish

[midnight ocean]

there's 7 guarma exclusive animals from what i know

you should be able to get them all

[limber pewter]

ah okay cool, i currently have 6 so that’s less daunting 😂

[midnight ocean]

actually this says 8

four snakes and four birds

[limber pewter]

thank you!

[midnight ocean]

np

im actually excited to get there lol im trying to fully complete the compendium

in chapter 4 now

[limber pewter]

managed to get them all i think finally 😭 been running around for about 3 hours

[midnight ocean]

excellent

[thick stream]

I’m free from jail nice

[winter moat]

Just got my gold on all missions

What a journey

[midnight ocean]

gz

[winter moat]

Ty ty

[midnight ocean]

what were the worst ones

[winter moat]

I have a few lol one sec to get the names

Def Anders obviously

American distillation

And Fine Joys of Tobacco

Leviticus Cornwall I got with my third try but I know that’s a tough one

[midnight ocean]

i gotta do tobacco soon

i think i got those other three already

oh no i need distillation too

[winter moat]

Dead eye tf out of tobacco to avoid being hit

[midnight ocean]

i think its distillation where you cant be hit

tobacco is the time limit for dousing the fields and then killing all the greys before sean can

[limber pewter]

how did you manage this? i got bronze on one of them so replayed and met all the gold requirements but it still stayed bronze?

[midnight ocean]

all the objectives were checked off at the end?

if you restart from checkpoint it can negate certain ones

[limber pewter]

none of them were checked off but i know i completed them during the replay of the mission

is it only story missions or do all including stranger ones count?

[midnight ocean]

stranger missions dont have objectives usually

[midnight ocean]

what mission was it? and did you use a checkpoint during the mission?

[limber pewter]

i think the one i tried to redo was a brother dorkins one. i finished it the first time and it said bronze so i looked at the objectives and then it gave me the option to replay it so i did, did both of the objectives it said but still came back bronze after id finished again

[limber pewter]

i don’t think so

[midnight ocean]

maybe try again, you might just be misremembering

i think i missed my chance to get the pipe request from dutch and im debating if i should load a save from two missions ago to try and get it or just say fuck it

[fathom mantle]

hey guys my name is kai and i love rdr2 i am on chapter 4 i just completed chapter 3 i need some tips please

[midnight ocean]

tips for what?

[fathom mantle]

just stuff like shooting and missions or just whatever

[midnight ocean]

you can save deadeye meter by aiming near the person first, then enter deadeye and just kill that one person

youll save meter compared to if you try to shoot several guys in one use of it

[fathom mantle]

oh i never thouht of that that will help alot

[sage veldt]

Does the john marston restoration project remove his ability to grow and cut hair and facial hair?

[fathom mantle]

i dont know im only in chapter 4

[sage veldt]

yea no its a mod to play as him

[fathom mantle]

oh

is there a way to get mods on xbox probaly not

[sage veldt]

nah modding is for pc

[fathom mantle]

dang

it

[sage veldt]

some games like skyrim however have options for console.

[autumn lynx]

nope

[sage veldt]

but dw i have played for 1000 hours and am only now starting to mod, it isnt really needed. It's a great game nontheless

[sage veldt]

thanks

[fathom mantle]

oh i have heard of skyrim but dont fully no what it is what is it

[sage veldt]

its a completely different game just used it as an example

[fathom mantle]

ok

i wish i had xbox game pass so i could play with other people on rdr2

if you plug an xbox into a computer if you play on it would you be able to use mouse and keybord

[midnight ocean]

you cant plug an xbox into a computer lol

[naive ibex]

Ay who is the strange man bro

Im diving into the lore so bad rn

I finish the game so many times and i walk into his cabin and i get invested again

[fathom mantle]

yes you can i have seen people do it with a laptop

and i started playing like a 3 days ago i have not played it that long

@fathom mantle

@sage veldt

[midnight ocean]

satan

[soft root]

the man who makes the honor system or death itself

[naive ibex]

I agree with this

[midnight ocean]

its satan

[naive ibex]

I feel like he is more connected to judgement and he is quite morally ambiguous or neutral giving the choice between honor and dishonor in rdr1 whereas devil is more temptation, the strange man says he is an “accountant, sort of”. I dont believe he has any resemblance towards the devil

To add to this, the strange man is more observant and shows judgement rather than corruption

If anything he is closer to death than satan

However i dont think he is death

[midnight ocean]

depends on which interpretation of satan you compare him to i think

[naive ibex]

Fair enough however the only interpretation i could think of satan being related could be his title of “satan the accuser” in hebrew bible

[midnight ocean]

there is a story by mark twain about the devil and its called "the mysterious stranger"

also he makes deals

i think he also mentions being damned and having a son (the antichrist)

[naive ibex]

I shall look into the book because it seems to be close to the time period of the game maybe that could be inspired

[naive ibex]

Is this referring to the book or the game?

[midnight ocean]

the game

[naive ibex]

At what point does he make deals?

[soft root]

it is merely suspected that he makes deals

[naive ibex]

Is it the herbert moon?

Thats the only deal i can think of i guess

[midnight ocean]

herbert moon yeah

or whoever hes talking to in that writing

[stray jackal]

Hi 😄

[naive ibex]

Well he apparently made a deal of happiness or two generations of family

He chose happiness and the quote “moon will shine on through the darkness” refers to his ability to coincidentally survive the virus in town

Also the picture of the man is of course in his shop

I think it really depends on the rendition of satan which is given

[midnight ocean]

yeah i mean hes not red with horns and a pitchfork

[naive ibex]

Of course, im saying that in this case it is definitely a very niche rendition of satan if it is the case

And at least a oddly neutral one

My personal theory is he could be inspired by samael the angel of death

[midnight ocean]

yeah thats the top result if you ask google lol

[naive ibex]

Who samael?

I have seen theory of cain ,death, satan even gavin but rarely him

[midnight ocean]

oh i guess its azrael

but theyre both called the angel of death

[naive ibex]

Ah fair ok

[midnight ocean]

also i think samael is sometimes interchangable with satan

[naive ibex]

Yeah

I think samael may be more of a jewish rendition compared to lucifer (more christian)

He was considered an agent of god

Who led people into moral challenges

Just like john herbert and maybe even arthur with jimmy brooks who is mentioned in the writing from his cabin

[midnight ocean]

maybe hes just a rockstarified version of the idea instead of a direct stand in

[naive ibex]

Definitely

Probably inspired from more than one person also

Just fun to theorise

[midnight ocean]

like how in the game you have new orleans except its not new orleans, its saint denis

[naive ibex]

I agree 100%

[midnight ocean]

i hate camp requests

[brave sphinx]

it makes the game fun

[midnight ocean]

riding into camp over and over at a specific time and then sleeping and trying again isnt fun

[brave sphinx]

bahahahah

[midnight ocean]

like everyone just put the shit you want on a billboard

and ill go get it

[soft root]

you get rewards, honor for it though

[midnight ocean]

i know

the problem is getting them to trigger

[soft root]

oof, actively looking for those? hell no, I've had this fountain pen that mary beth supposedly is supposed to want it and I've been carrying it since ch3

I'm at ch4

[midnight ocean]

its lenny and dutch for me

i did marys

even did the pearson rabbit

[midnight ocean]

what sucks is i cant progress any more if i want to get the dutch one since the last four missions of chapter 4 are all dutch missions

[warm salmon]

Can all cigrette card sets be completed from premium cigarettes? or do some need to be found in world?

[severe gyro]

i am almost positive they can all be found from the cigarette packs

[warm salmon]

Nice okay

[misty sigil]

i have played till second chapter rdr2 is fun game except when i get attacked by a couger which is my enemy in the wilderness

[midnight ocean]

if you happen to know you're in cougar territory but havent spotted one yet, try to stay on your horse and keep your rifle equipped

if you have a rifle yet which you might not

[misty sigil]

yeah i made a mistake with that where i was helping some random encounter npc with a couger but i got mauled

i did not expect it to one shot me

i do get the springfield rifle

[calm oasis]

Who the hell made those hunting requests, all birds look the same damn it

[misty sigil]

i have one shot bears though with my springfield

[warm salmon]

I just finished them and goddamn bat is the hardest

I saw so many people on reddit say elysian pool is ez spawn

But my game knows how to torture me

[calm oasis]

There is a shitload of them in the cave behind elysian pool

[warm salmon]

Not a single bat on the ground there

[calm oasis]

Ohh, yeah, thats fair

[warm salmon]

Stop it

There are none

zero

Robin also took a while

[calm oasis]

I was mere seconds away from tearing off my face when I was doing the challenges and now I remembered that hunting requests is a thing..

I will smash my head through a window I swear to god

[warm salmon]

I finished everything except gambler

And cigarette sets but doing that now

[calm oasis]

I was stuck on dominoes for almost a week

[warm salmon]

That's what I'm stuck at too

[severe gyro]

i found the one at the emerald station was the easiest for dominos

[calm oasis]

I mean if its any help, you need to get rid of your dominoes as quickly as possible

[midnight ocean]

i already got the robin for the hunting request but i need a couple more for the trapper

[calm oasis]

Yeah

Best if there is only 1 guy with you

[midnight ocean]

dominoes at camp is easier i think

always will just be one person

i got my 3 in a row with hosea

and i got the earlier one with tilly

[warm salmon]

Where do I see which treasure maps I'vefinished?

[severe gyro]

i completely forgot there was a chance of gambling at the camp

[warm salmon]

I'm in epilogue

[calm oasis]

Im sitting here and I saw every single bird fly by EXCEPT that damn cedar waxwing

[midnight ocean]

the last hunting request has to be as john right

[calm oasis]

yep

sadly

[severe gyro]

they should just be in your bag

[midnight ocean]

i started collecting the birds in advance but i think im gonna lose them all

[calm oasis]

very possible

[severe gyro]

in the documents tab

[warm salmon]

I found cedar rather easily. Near fort riggs, northwest of blackwater

[warm salmon]

Yeah I lost a perfect rat carcass when I cooked striingy meat

[calm oasis]

I lost all the food and tonics I had

[midnight ocean]

rip lol

[warm salmon]

They are all there. Even the ones I found. Which is why I am confused

[midnight ocean]

i just mean losing them when arthur dies

[calm oasis]

Imma check it out, thanks

[midnight ocean]

i know i keep some stuff but i dont think animals are included

[severe gyro]

i would have stopped playing for a while after that

[midnight ocean]

rats are so easy to get tho

[warm salmon]

Nah rats are ez pz

Prolly the easiest animals to get

[midnight ocean]

but if i lose a perfect moose pelt

[warm salmon]

Apart from the farm ones like chicken and sheep

[calm oasis]

But god damn this is the furthest I have ever gotten in the game, I completed the mission Motherhood and have 91% completion, my record so far was 92.6%

[midnight ocean]

hoo boy

[warm salmon]

I'm kinda annoyed you can 100% the game without crafting every item at the trapper

I'm at 99% and I have gambler left (And the get max stats which is tied to gambler 10 for the equipement)

But I have barely crafted anything at the trapper

Even the fence I've only crafted 2 talismans

[midnight ocean]

i did the trapper anyway just for fun

[warm salmon]

100% should mean 100%

[midnight ocean]

think i just need all the stuff thats exclusive to new austin now

[calm oasis]

NOOO

This game hates me

Finally found the cedar waxwing and its only 2 star, damn this game

[midnight ocean]

shoot it anyway

if you have buck antler trinket it could turn into a 3

[calm oasis]

Nope, still 2 star

[midnight ocean]

rip

i used to see those things all the time tho

try near a river

[calm oasis]

And I do have the trinket so the game messed me over

[midnight ocean]

well it doesnt work every time

just a chance to increase quality by 1 star

[calm oasis]

Yayy...

[mortal tusk]

Any way for me to have both a jhon save file and arthur save file

[warm salmon]

2 doesnt turn into 3

[calm oasis]

Save the game as John into one save slot and as Arthur in the other save slot

[warm salmon]

It only increases the chances of 3 remaining a 3 if you don't head shot it

[midnight ocean]

yes it does

[warm salmon]

Which is not even relevant to small game birds

[warm salmon]

Nope

Trust me I've done research

[midnight ocean]

i mean

its happened to me

[warm salmon]

If you body shot a 3 start rabbit there's a chance it remains 3 star. But normally it wll turn to 2 star since not a headshot

[midnight ocean]

you dont have to headshot for a 3 star lol

just crit which can be on the body too

[warm salmon]

If you can prove it you'd be proving a whole lotta people and websites wrong

[warm salmon]

That's what I meant

[mortal tusk]

But how do I go back to arthur in the first place

[mortal tusk]

Without straight up deleting jhon file

[calm oasis]

When you go into save game you have empty slots, you can keep your save as John and then save the game as Arthur in one of the empty slots, that way you can play as either John or Arthur, but you cant play as Arthur on the save where you are already playing as John, only in mission replays

[mortal tusk]

Okay but like

How do I go back to arthur

Like as in

[calm oasis]

In the same save?

[mortal tusk]

Nono

I wanna have 2 files

1 for jhon another for arthur

[calm oasis]

Ehhhhhh?????

So

If I understand

You are playing as John, and you want an Arthur save from that same playthrough?

[mortal tusk]

Not really no

I wanna restart the game

But I don't wanna lose my jhon save

[midnight ocean]

you wont

just make sure you save manually as john

then start a new game

[calm oasis]

And then save in a new save slot

When you try to save your game, you have the name of the last mission you did and then you have Empty Slots underneath

[mortal tusk]

Oh

It's that easy huh

I thought I would get my saves deleted

Ty boys

[calm oasis]

All good

Finally got that little bastard

[mortal tusk]

What ya doing

[calm oasis]

Was looking for a Blue Jay

Im doing the hunting requests

[mortal tusk]

Oh nice, I'm thinking about 100% the game is it worth it? After completing the story I am taking the game slow and enjoying the little things so I thought about 100% the game

[mortal tusk]

People request you?

[calm oasis]

Nah, its a collectible strand, of sorts. There is one woman in Strawberry and she is a taxidermist. She will ask of you to get her animals, so you have to kill them and send them to the post office

I think you unlock it in chapter 2, maybe 3, there will be a poster at the train station in Rhodes

[mortal tusk]

Ah I barely step foot in strawberry lol

Hey you know how to get a poncho with jhon? I've been looking everywhere. Unless it's in armadillo or tumbleweed

[calm oasis]

Same, just for that drowned rat Micah and the robbery you can do, no other reason to hang around there really

[calm oasis]

I think its mods, you cant get a poncho, at least I dont think so

[mortal tusk]

Aww man...that's sucks

I'm mexican + poncho jhon looks badass

[mortal tusk]

Yeah it's just kinda...there

Ig you can go there in the epilouge

[calm oasis]

Yeah, it is a.. Id say big part of epilogue but really you only go there to get a job at Pronghorn ranch

And Abigail gets that cleaning job

[mortal tusk]

And to pick up that thing

That Abigail ordered

[calm oasis]

Well.. doubt its cleaning because she goes there dressed like if it was a photo shoot

[mortal tusk]

Does she say what her job is? I don't remember

[calm oasis]

Cleaning the doctors surgery

[mortal tusk]

Oh yah

[calm oasis]

But why would she bring a dress

[mortal tusk]

Well back then it was kind of like

Required of women

[calm oasis]

A dress thats blue and white mind you

[mortal tusk]

What else would she wear

[mortal tusk]

Does it have any meaning?

[calm oasis]

Not really just

If you were to clean up a surgery

Would you bring something white?

Surgery, probably a lot of blood

Why on gods green earth

[mortal tusk]

Well she probably either only cleaned the tools or wore something on top

[calm oasis]

I mean maybe Im looking too much into it

[mortal tusk]

I think you sre

Cause like I said

Women didn't rlly have a choice back then

[calm oasis]

Yeah, possibly

True

[mortal tusk]

The only woman I recall wearing pants or just smth that isn't a dress is saddie

I think

That I recall

[calm oasis]

Yeah.. and I dont think we see any other women wear pants, outside of online, or?

Because no female npc with pants comes to mind at the moment

[mortal tusk]

It's cause I'm guessing it was viewed as rebellious

Or too much curves or smth

Out of curiosity, what do you think about the jack isn't jhons son theory

[calm oasis]

I mean.. he does look an awful lot like Javier..

[mortal tusk]

That's what I was thinking

[calm oasis]

But I think he's John's

I'm really split because he looks like a mix of Javier and John

[mortal tusk]

Maybe it's jhons and javiers child

It's cause when he's young he looks white asf

But then when he's 19 he looks A LOT like javier

And even arthur says he looks like Bill or javier

And Dutch ofc says the iconic "everyone had her" line

[calm oasis]

Exactly

Or the fact that he seems darker is because of the sun, but I'm just looking too much into it

[mortal tusk]

I mean it's implied he took care of the ranch right

[calm oasis]

Yeah..

[mortal tusk]

So he's probably in the sun

But also even like

Look at his facial hair

Can I send gifs here

[calm oasis]

True, and facial hair I think is determined by genetics

[mortal tusk]

Yeah...

like the little triangle beard thing

[calm oasis]

Okay yeah he has the exact same facial hair

[mortal tusk]

YEAH

He actually legit just looks like javier

[calm oasis]

He looks like a mix of John and Javier if anything else

[mortal tusk]

Like I said, jhon and javiers child. Screw (epilouge) Abigail

[calm oasis]

Lmaoo

[mortal tusk]

I wonder what other proof there is if any

[mortal tusk]

The thing is he has jhons eyes and eyebrows.

[midnight ocean]

in rdr1 javier asks if abigail misses him 😳

[calm oasis]

What??

I dont remember that line

Holy shit

[mortal tusk]

He does

But yall gotta consider

People get jack confused for jhon a ton in rdr1

[midnight ocean]

hmm

[calm oasis]

I just got jumpscared by a beaver

[midnight ocean]

lol how

[mortal tusk]

How many animals are in this game

[calm oasis]

Hundreds

Okay.. only 178

But thats almost 200

[midnight ocean]

maybe 200 if you count fish

[calm oasis]

Little bastard bit me while I was trying to shoot a crow out of the sky

[mortal tusk]

Did u get the dual wield sawed off

[calm oasis]

With fish there is 208

[mortal tusk]

Oopsies

[mortal tusk]

Holy moly

[calm oasis]

Yeah, rockstar went batshit crazy with this game, crazy people. I bet gta 6 will be even better, though I doubt the story will be better

I dont think that anything can beat red deads story

[mortal tusk]

Gta has never rlly been praised for its story

More for its gameplay

[midnight ocean]

gta iv story is goated

[calm oasis]

True

2 best stories are rdr2 and gta 4. one you have an outlaw seeking redemption, the other broken man hunted by his past trying to confront it

[mortal tusk]

That's 4?

[calm oasis]

Awesome games

[calm oasis]

yeah

[mortal tusk]

I haven't played

I only played through 22% of gta 5

[calm oasis]

Youre missing out big time

[midnight ocean]

iv is a little dated now but

[calm oasis]

Still a masterpiece

Well..

The bugs..

[midnight ocean]

you mean like the stuff from the framerate getting upped?

[calm oasis]

Nah, not only that, some missions are broken on pc

Well

[midnight ocean]

that sucks

[calm oasis]

Tend to break

[mortal tusk]

Meh idc so is rdr1

And I loved ot

[midnight ocean]

even on console tho a lot of people cant beat the game

because of the bug with the last mission

[calm oasis]

For example when you are stealing the truck with packie, where you have to hold onto it and climb on top, then yeet the guy out

[mortal tusk]

Without much spoilers what happened

[calm oasis]

That tends to bug out and not work

You can spam buttons for your life, the game wont register it

[tall pewter]

What’s the best guns and horse in the game

[mortal tusk]

Use anything in terms of guns lol

If you wanna only use the revolver you get at the beginning you pretty much can

[calm oasis]

Depends on your playstyle, if you want speed, probably the M1899 and for the horse an arabian, either black or white

[tall pewter]

I want speed what I seen on clips

I like how the white horse look

[midnight ocean]

get the white arabian then

you gotta tame it near lake isabella in the snowy area

[calm oasis]

The horse spawns up north, near Lake Isabella

[mortal tusk]

I need that ngl

[tall pewter]

Can you show me the location 😭

[mortal tusk]

Use google

[midnight ocean]

its on your map "lake isabella" near where the game started

northwest part of the map

[mortal tusk]

[tall pewter]

I’m on chapter 3 am I too early for those things

[midnight ocean]

no

well not for the horse

[tall pewter]

I noticed Arthur hair and beard grew a lot in that time skip

[calm oasis]

You can get it as early as chapter 2

[tall pewter]

What about that fast gun

[mortal tusk]

That's later...

[calm oasis]

You will need chapter 4 I think

[mortal tusk]

Yeah sometime there

[calm oasis]

But

You can get it earlier

[tall pewter]

I want to use something fast and deal a lot more damage

These animals can be a hassle

[calm oasis]

If you roam Lemoyne there is a chance for KKK encounter

[midnight ocean]

naw you only need one shot for most animals

dont spam with pistol

[calm oasis]

You kill them and there is a chance they will drop the M1899

[midnight ocean]

use the correct weapon and one shot them

[calm oasis]

Best is a bow or a rifle. Just go for the head every time

[tall pewter]

It’s the predator animals

[midnight ocean]

depends entirely on the animal

[mortal tusk]

If yoy damage them too much the pelt goes bad right

[tall pewter]

Alligators and bears or cougars or whatever

[calm oasis]

True, but most will get a clean kill with rifles

[midnight ocean]

if you have the springfield rifle you can one shot cougars and wolves and get perfect pelts

gators too

[calm oasis]

Cougars, panthers, wolves, deer you can get clean kills with bows

or rifles I think, but bow 100%

[midnight ocean]

yes rifles too lol

rifle is better for self defense as well

[tall pewter]

I was struggling to kill a cougar a couple days ago for this mission

It took me a couple tries I used a pistol 😭

[midnight ocean]

yeah just grab that trusty springfield and headshot it

if its 3 stars you can then skin it for a perfect pelt too

[tall pewter]

Yea I was collecting money for that old guy

[midnight ocean]

strauss

[tall pewter]

Ye

[midnight ocean]

yeah pistols are not good for hunting lol

[tall pewter]

I’ve just been bounty hunting

And doing side mission

Idk what to do with this money

[midnight ocean]

you can buy upgrades at camp

otherwise just spend it on clothes and guns

[tall pewter]

I got 300

[midnight ocean]

guns can be upgraded at the gunsmith and decorated

[calm oasis]

best thing to buy for camp is pearsons tools, because you can make satchels which give you more capacity to carry more stuff, valuables, tonics, food etc.

[midnight ocean]

but you will need to hunt

[calm oasis]

Yeah, but I think its worth it

[tall pewter]

I’m at Saint Denis now

Is red dead redemption 1 like this

[midnight ocean]

sorta

just less to do

[calm oasis]

And smaller map

[tall pewter]

Because I got 1 aswell

[midnight ocean]

and you're a lone wolf, no gang or camp to go to

[tall pewter]

I’m planning on getting once I beat 2

[midnight ocean]

but theres still cougars

so watch out

[tall pewter]

I don’t remember much on one I only played at once when I was little

[mortal tusk]

Does Bonney count

[midnight ocean]

no

[tall pewter]

I remember an old guy help John beings better gunslinger

[midnight ocean]

i got confused for a sec i was like william bonney?

[midnight ocean]

he gets mentioned early in rdr2

[mortal tusk]

XD no you know who

[tall pewter]

What’s the best guns yall say

[midnight ocean]

i dont really have a preference

whatever i need for the animal im about to shoot

in combat i use revolvers and a repeater

[mortal tusk]

I like the shotguns. Favorite guns

I like going around and killing random passerby

[tall pewter]

I don’t see any pump shotguns

Only pump action shotgun

[midnight ocean]

...

[mortal tusk]

You get them later. I'm specifically talking about the sawed off shotguns

[severe gyro]

do yall know where i can find crabs?

[mortal tusk]

Isn't that...a pump shotgun

[midnight ocean]

island on flatiron lake

[severe gyro]

oki thanks

[tall pewter]

Oh I’m slow

[severe gyro]

does it matter what island?

[tall pewter]

I upgraded my Arthur gear

[mortal tusk]

Nice ^_^

[calm oasis]

Should be the biggest one

[midnight ocean]

i dont think so but i went to the biggest one

[severe gyro]

ok

[midnight ocean]

youll need your horse to swim over to it i think

or boat

[mortal tusk]

Try to get the sawed offs. They go in ur pistol slot and they're SOOO satisfying

[calm oasis]

Or a boat

[mortal tusk]

Can you drivw your boat over to uh

[calm oasis]

Oh no I forgot John cant swim

NO

[mortal tusk]

The place directly east of the map

[midnight ocean]

the prison?

[mortal tusk]

Yah I didn't wanan say it

[midnight ocean]

oh lol

[calm oasis]

Yes

There is a legendary fish there

[midnight ocean]

thats funny because i literally just did that an hour ago

[tall pewter]

Springfield rifle only got 8 bullets?

[mortal tusk]

I always thought about it but never actually went

[midnight ocean]

its the 1800s man if you want an ak47 you're not gonna find one

[calm oasis]

Nope, I think you dont have more rifle ammo, you have to go buy some

[mortal tusk]

Nah trust, if you like crouch 3 times then talk to javier 5 times then say Lenny 8 times you get one

[calm oasis]

Aw shucks..

[midnight ocean]

i just failed gold on the riverboat mission lol i hate this shit so much

i didnt know you have to kill a certain number of guards first because this game doesnt tell you fucking shit

[tall pewter]

Ima go get me a good fast horse next after I do this bounty

[mortal tusk]

Guhh I wish there was like a non spoiler rdr channel and a spoiler one

[calm oasis]

Im not doing all gold or I would lose my mind

[midnight ocean]

if theyre gonna keep doing gold medal shit in these games i want objectives clearly stated on screen and a timer

[mortal tusk]

I wanna ask some questions but the guy is here

[mortal tusk]

They arent??

[tall pewter]

What guy

[midnight ocean]

you could use spoiler text

[mortal tusk]

You silly XD I just don't wanna spoil

[calm oasis]

doesnt work

[mortal tusk]

Not allowed, message auto deleted

[tall pewter]

Are u talking about the ending