red-dead-singleplayer

[uncut nimbus]

Yeah

The count is an albino arabian but the closest you can get is the white arabian

[gilded light]

I need a perfect bison and beaver pelts for satchels, any idea where I can find them??

[ionic juniper]

When we take a gang horse to the stable, a warning appears in the upper right, I think they guessed that such glitches could happen

[ionic juniper]

for beaver owanjila

If it's not 3 stars, don't hunt him, leave the place, then check again.

[hidden moss]

There is a river crossing just a little south of butcher creek
There is always a couple of Beavers there

[uncut nimbus]

Great plains and somewhere in the middle of emerald ranch and valentine

And owenjila for beavers

I have no idea how you spell it btw

[uncut nimbus]

And the river going down to great plains

[ionic juniper]

for bison, they spawn near the letter A of New Hanover on the map

My honor level for completing Garments sets has dropped by almost half

[winter moat]

Can someone for the love of god on pc tell me how my line keeps breaking when fishing

And no I’m not pressing anything but holding right click when it’s splashing

[uneven pollen]

You have to stop reeling when it splashes

[eternal estuary]

Caring about graphics in the big 25 💔

Rdr1s graphics are only slightly worse than gta 5s

It’s just the lighting that makes it look bad

And the character models look better even though it’s an older game

[lapis sable]

I hope one day we can reimagine rdr1 in rdr2, and bring in mexico too

Jack deserve to visit rhodes and meet Uncle Pearson again

Maybe meet Aunt Tilly in Saint Denis

[twilit dagger]

Can you dual wield sawedoff shotguns?

[cyan pendant]

Yeah

[fading sleet]

Quick question, it’s been a while since I’ve replayed. I wanted to save the treasure maps for John in the epilogue to get him some quick gold to buy fancy horses and what not . will I be able to keep all the maps as John? Or I have to go and collect them all from scratch.

[fading sleet]

If you have the PC version of RDR one, you can use mods to make it look better, close to RDR two

[simple hare]

can someone help me fix my game the graphics look absolutely horrible

[eternal estuary]

If you collect them as Arthur they’ll appear in John’s satchel when the epilogue starts

Also you don’t have to save all the treasure maps for John, there’s this glitch where if you visit the Aberdeen pig farm right before the “our best selves” mission you can get the couple to rob you of ALL your money, and you’ll wake up outside the property

Then when you return as John in the epilogue you can go reclaim Arthur’s money at the same house by going up to the painting and removing it

I mentioned you in #red-dead-media with the video

[slate furnace]

Has anyone tried

Once you get the guy in the suit to spawn in the bayou

Placing dynamite where he stands ans lighting it up

Then running to the mirror to see what happens

[uneven pollen]

have you

[slate furnace]

no

I dont have the game anymore

[slate furnace]

Can you try it

[uneven pollen]

i dont know who youre talking about

[slate furnace]

the strange man

Black suit

Looks like trelawney

[uneven pollen]

whats his name

[blazing dawn]

the strange man

lol

[simple hare]

can someone help me fix my game?

[uneven pollen]

oh duh

[fading sleet]

If it’s death, then you can’t kill him

The strange man

[junior horizon]

why the hell is my honour going up so slowly

ive done like so much high honor things and its only gone up a little bit in the span of like 3 days

3 real days

[pale scaffold]

Same here, I was greeting people in Saint Denis for half an hour and it went up just a bit

You can try donating in small pieces of 21$ to the camp

I would do that too but I have no money since I customised all my weapons

[blazing dawn]

tbh greetings baaaarely raise honor

[uneven pollen]

you can catch and release fishing for honor, its a good break from hey mistering around saint denis

[junior horizon]

ive done that but i dont wanna be a "your a good man arthur" for releasing fish also ive done the good option for every event and it still dosent go up unless i do like 5 of them

[uneven pollen]

ive been trying to collect hats for days now

theres 4 yo can get in butchers creek and i was tired of lassoing and running away to protect my honor, so i massacred the entire town and lost so much honor

and i only got 2 of the hats out of it

[toxic pier]

why did I get wanted for killing the racist in st denis

this is nonsense

[arctic musk]

rdr1 has great graphics imo i took some insane pictures

i cant complain about the graphics honestly

[ionic juniper]

In the general store in the town of Armadillo there is a photo of a strange man, interestingly the shopkeeper did not get sick

[distant python]

I mean yeah thafs the second thing i care about the most just behind gameplay thats why I asked is it Worth jt

[ionic juniper]

They say that mac callander could be the main character in rdr3. I wouldn't want that. We know he'll die at the end of the story.

[pale scaffold]

I think Dutch before Blackwater should be the main character

[rugged meteor]

I just did the murfee cave mission and I was wondering who is mrs downes if I’ll find out later just lmk

[sacred niche]

It’s the wife of the guy Arthur killed in chapter 2 for the debt

[rugged meteor]

The sick guy?

[sacred niche]

Yh

[rugged meteor]

Ok thx

[little heron]

should i give rdr2 a 3rd chance?
1st on day on(ps4) delusional
2nd 1 year ago: boring
didnt play rdr1 btw

[sacred niche]

You can help them

[sacred niche]

Did you play past chapter 1

[little heron]

yea

honestly was so boring

[sacred niche]

Maybe don’t rush the story and explore and interact more with gang members

Bc that makes the game feel more alive

[gritty zinc]

Hey, im confused about how hunting and donating meat works. What exactly does donating things to the butcher at my campsite do? Does it increase the level of food rations? Does donating perfect pelts mean i can craft something with them later, or do i need to keep them on my horse to do that?

Also i keep hunting rabbits using the rifle the info says to, but they are always good and never perfect

[ornate sand]

e

[gritty zinc]

im confused if i should keep donating stuff to him or not. ive only noticed my reputation goes up sometimes, or i get money for the camp

[sacred niche]

Use .22 ammo + varmit rifle

[arctic musk]

it starts a bit slow paced but its an important part of the story

[late knot]

It just like makes Pearson to make better stews

[arctic musk]

1. it makes the camp happier with better stews
2. yes donating perfect pelts works like that
3. no and animals will rot if they're on your horse for too long if you dont have a specific trinket so sell them to pearson when you can
   also something else using a rifle is easier than bow hunting

[arctic musk]

try to hunt them without deadeye, that worked for me

[arctic musk]

just do it on occasions i think you need to do it when the food icon on the top right of your screen in camp is red

[gritty zinc]

okay, i was wondering if it would impact that, or if i could only buy stuff from the ledger to increase that. Thanks for all your answers! i was worrying that i would donate a pelt i needed and wouldnt be able to use to upgrade stuff with him

does it matter where you hit the animal for its score? or just the weapon

[late knot]

Matters

Weapon and spot

[arctic musk]

yes you need to hit headshots with the correct weapon

[late knot]

Like repeater and stomach can gibe you Bad pelt

[arctic musk]

you can try lung shots or heart shots but its not worth it

[late knot]

I use pistol and jeadshir

[gritty zinc]

okay so headshots the way to go

[late knot]

Headshot**

[late knot]

Ye

[arctic musk]

pistol?

[late knot]

With a revovler or pistol

[late knot]

Ye

[arctic musk]

for what animal

[late knot]

Rabbits

[gritty zinc]

Can I sell the cigarettes somewhere? Nobody will buy them

[late knot]

Shops

[arctic musk]

if you cant sell them at the fence i dont think you can

[arctic musk]

i think that ruins the quality

[late knot]

No?

[gritty zinc]

Yeah I’ve only met fence and general store people and nobody wants them

[late knot]

I ussualy don't keep the pelt cus I've finished the game

[arctic musk]

if you want to get rid of them you can discard them in your satchel

[gritty zinc]

Did u find all the collectibles too? Just met the dinosaur lady lol

[late knot]

Nah im too lazy

I just shoot people

[arctic musk]

you might be right i just cant find anything about being able to use a pistol on rabbits for a perfect pelt and i cant find anything about having to use a pistol or revolver for a perfect pelt

[arctic musk]

i have its pretty much impossible to find it without a tutorial though

you need to go to all dinosaur bone locations

[late knot]

Idk I use lemat and Otis revolvers nowadays

[serene trail]

Hello,

I’am I the only one who thinks Red dead 2 is boring ?

[arctic musk]

what chapter are you on?

and you're not the only one

[gritty zinc]

How do you know the chapter?

[arctic musk]

i like rdr2 but on my 2nd playthrough its not as fun

[arctic musk]

when you move camp it shows your chapter

[late knot]

Yes

[arctic musk]

or check your achievements if you dont know anymore

[late knot]

Idk I liked it more

[arctic musk]

i knew what was going to happen in the story and the combat was less fun for me

[gritty zinc]

Oh I didn’t know we were packing up lmfao. I’m at horseshoe overlook. So do the camp upgrades transfer over or no?

[arctic musk]

yeah

[late knot]

Oh welp I didn't play rdr frin that point like 5months

[late knot]

2nd chapter

And yes they di

Do

[arctic musk]

except the boat camp upgrade you unlock it soon in the story but goes away after a few chapters

boat upgrade isnt worth it anyway

[late knot]

Frfr

[serene trail]

I finished the game.

[arctic musk]

fair but i'd still remember most

[arctic musk]

what did you find boring?

[late knot]

Welp now I gonna return ti playin it cus other games are boring

[serene trail]

The sidequest.
They are superslow and long.

[arctic musk]

have you played rdr1?

[late knot]

I wanna😭

But it costs like 35dollars

[arctic musk]

yeah i think some are like that but they're side quests so you dont have to do them

[late knot]

Fr

[arctic musk]

i got it for 30bucks recently and i nearly have 70hours and all achievements

[late knot]

Wow

[arctic musk]

30bucks for 70 hours of fun is worth it imo and the game is beautiful i have some pictures in media

[late knot]

Ye I saw mine sadly didn't send😭

[arctic musk]

limit is 4 for images

[cyan pendant]

I don’t even have all the achievements and I have 200+ hours

[late knot]

Ohh

[arctic musk]

rdr1 has some worse things than rdr2 and rdr1 doesnt have things like photomode but rdr1 has a bunch of good things like horse bonds (infinite horses) pardon letters(pay off your bounty with 0 bucks) cool weapons and so much more

[arctic musk]

what did you spend all that time doing?

[cyan pendant]

Replaying the story for the 10th time

[arctic musk]

whats your fav chapter?

[late knot]

Yee saw that from vids

[cyan pendant]

3

[arctic musk]

thats west elizabeth right?

[cyan pendant]

Rhodes

[arctic musk]

right

[cyan pendant]

Idk something about old dead towns in a western game

[arctic musk]

my fav chapters
1: chapter 6
2: chapter 3
3: epilogue 2
4: chapter 4
5: chapter 2
6: chapter 5
7: epilogue 1
7: chapter 1

[late knot]

What are tour fav horses??

[arctic musk]

white arabian

but not in story missions

it just looks good in open world with legend of the east outfit

[late knot]

Mine is
Nokota reverse silver dapple or smth idr (race)

[cyan pendant]

The white and black Missouri Fox Trotter tiger stripes mustang and the red ariban

[late knot]

Based

[cyan pendant]

I love that fox trotter man I use it during story mode all the time

[pale scaffold]

It's too small

[arctic musk]

next to other horses yeah

[pale scaffold]

All black American Standardbred

[cyan pendant]

All Arabians are

[pale scaffold]

Or that white Andalusian

[late knot]

I had one till train ran over it

Paid frickahh 960 dollars i think from blackwater stables

[cyan pendant]

Yeah

That happens

[arctic musk]

anyone else really sad chapter 5 has so much cut content?

[cyan pendant]

That’s what happens to my Turkoman

[late knot]

Yea?!

[arctic musk]

i love the vibe of tropical stuff and i think guarma had so much potential

[late knot]

Ohh yhh guarma

[late knot]

I just got one

[arctic musk]

it would be nice if rockstar updated guarma but i dont think they could

it would be weird for the story

[late knot]

Frfr

[cyan pendant]

Did you get the one from horse meat for dinner?

That one’s my favorite

It’s a mission in chapter 3

[late knot]

What

Ohh

No

I finished game long time ago

[cyan pendant]

There’s a misson were you John and Javier steal horses

[late knot]

Ohh yhh that glitch

[cyan pendant]

You should do that your next playthrough

It’s not hard either just feed it til it bonds with you

[late knot]

Idk If I wanna do another playtrought

Myb high honour run

[arctic musk]

what horse should i get in chapter 2? theres no good ones like white arabian right?
i want a good size one that looks good in story missions

[late knot]

Ardenees

Or shire

[arctic musk]

where?

[cyan pendant]

Missouri Fox trot

[late knot]

From bounty hunters

Get like 600+ bounty and steal one from them

[arctic musk]

from albert mason?

[late knot]

I have like 4k+ in bounties

[arctic musk]

i might

how good is it

[cyan pendant]

So you know where the oil fields are?

[late knot]

Not bad pretry fine stats

[arctic musk]

yeah

[cyan pendant]

In the heartlands

Yeah so go through the tunnel your gonna need a scoped rifle

[late knot]

Ohh that glitch

[cyan pendant]

And keep killing that lady till the horse spawns in alive

[late knot]

Poor woman

[cyan pendant]

Eh it’s worth it

You can always get your honor back

[arctic musk]

best character you barely see in the game? i say bertram lol

[late knot]

Strange man

[cyan pendant]

I like the miget more

[arctic musk]

valid

[late knot]

Fr

[cyan pendant]

Do we even see the strange man?

[arctic musk]

ngl i think strange man is just john seeing things it doesnt make sense but i only thought that because of the last time he saw strange man

[late knot]

Yes

[arctic musk]

in rdr1

[cyan pendant]

I know in rdr1 but 2?

[late knot]

And rdr2 too

[arctic musk]

or tiny bit in rdr2 im not sure

[late knot]

Ye in that house

[arctic musk]

as a picture?

or is he a real person

[late knot]

Nop

[late knot]

Ye he spawns behind you

[desert sand]

Chat

[late knot]

Ye?

[desert sand]

Hi

[late knot]

Hey

[desert sand]

Brp I can't send pics😭

[late knot]

Same

[arctic musk]

you only can in media

[desert sand]

I have a John Marston roblox avatar

[late knot]

Wow

I fukin wanna undead nightmare 2

Like gang comes togehter and participates in ww2

[arctic musk]

i think hes just in a painting and in a picture

[desert sand]

Lmao

[late knot]

There is a vid about ut search on tt or yt strange man in rdr2

[desert sand]

Aight it's in red dead media

Nvm

[arctic musk]

you can only send 4 images or less'

[desert sand]

My images keep getting deleted

Oh ok

[cyan pendant]

We all do

We could play as a undead Arthur

[desert sand]

Imagine skeleton arthur

[late knot]

Frfr

[cyan pendant]

If we ever do I hope it goes off the ending you get like if you had low honor you can see there is a bullet in his head

[arctic musk]

oh hes in a mirror reflection in rdr2 thats pretty cool

[late knot]

Ye I said about it

[late knot]

What about when he went for money??

[desert sand]

It's in general media

[late knot]

Like a knife in his back

[cyan pendant]

He would have a knife wound

[arctic musk]

right i misunderstood you

[cyan pendant]

Maybe like a slit throat

[late knot]

Ye happens its fine

[late knot]

Frfr

[cyan pendant]

I don’t really remember that ending even if I do low honor I usually help John

[late knot]

I tried the first tike help john

Oh shit..

[pale scaffold]

Scared easily

That's why I like that pearl Andalusian

[cyan pendant]

It’s really not

[late knot]

Nah

[arctic musk]

my white arabian barely bucks me off its very rare for me

[pale scaffold]

It always bucks me off

[late knot]

I think my horse beats white arabian

[arctic musk]

only happened a few times every few hundred hours

[cyan pendant]

Maybe yours just hates you

[late knot]

Myb not lvl4

[pale scaffold]

Lmao

Idk but that Andalusian is the best for me

[cyan pendant]

Because it’s a war horse?

[late knot]

bruh

Donkey from Bob Crawford is the best

[cyan pendant]

Ima be real I don’t remember what the Andalusian is

[late knot]

That lik ninja is like a arabian

[late knot]

Fr

[pale scaffold]

Yes and it's also very pretty

[cyan pendant]

I like war horses I used use like Ardennes tho

[late knot]

Ye ardennes is good

If I had more place in stables I would have ardennes

[cyan pendant]

I need a new one any ideas?

[pale scaffold]

All black American Standardbred looks very nice but it isn't really the fastest nor the bravest

Maybe Nokota

Or Andalusian

[late knot]

I have a Nokota

Best horse i've had

[pale scaffold]

Yeah it's good

[late knot]

I can't remember full breed

[cyan pendant]

I was talking about a new Ardennes

[desert sand]

The paint is bad tho right?

[late knot]

Only Nokota dapple or smth like that

[late knot]

Yhh pretty bad

[pale scaffold]

There's only two? I think

[ornate wind]

im tryna get a perfect moose pelt
one of my friends told me to get the potent herbivore bait and then save just before using it
and keep loading the same save until i find a moose
i’ve doing that for quite some time and its not working
any other suggestions?

[pale scaffold]

The one you take from that guy that abused him?

[late knot]

Just go into mountaine search for it and headshot it wid a rifle

[late knot]

Nop bought

[pale scaffold]

You can lasso him also

Just like most herbivores

[late knot]

Not interesting

Like a gamble when shooting

[ornate wind]

the mountain north of grizzlies west?

[pale scaffold]

I hate that word since gambler 8

[late knot]

I reccomend the road from ehh idk how to mountains and somwhere there

[pale scaffold]

I have found it multiple times near lake Isabella

[cyan pendant]

So I figured how to get another Ardennes as John

[late knot]

Like on top of ehh emerald ranch

[late knot]

Bounty hunters

[cyan pendant]

No you know bills horse?

[late knot]

Mybbb??

[cyan pendant]

Yeah you can get brown jack in the epilogue

If you replay a misson he should spawn at John’s ranch

[late knot]

Ohh

[cyan pendant]

Apparently

Off a video I saw

[late knot]

If I would need I would just take from bounty hubters

[cyan pendant]

Eh

[late knot]

Like when your bounty is more than 600

[pale scaffold]

Can I get Baylock somehow, he looks fire

Micah's horse

[cyan pendant]

There is a glitch

During chap 2 has to be

You bring a person to the camp so you alert the gang and then kill yourself with dynamite

The gang members will follow you around just get off your horse and steal baylock

This is why I replay story mode these glitch’s

[pale scaffold]

I tried it but I couldn't bond with it

Nor take it to the stable

If I remember correctly

[cyan pendant]

Yeah

You can’t

Just don’t turn off the ps that’s how I kept it

It’s a glitch your not ment to do it

[distant python]

does anyone of you got a nice steam guide that helps with completing rdr2 100%? if yes than it would really help me

[urban geyser]

just look at reddit for the specific things youre trying to do

[distant python]

yeah but the problem is i have no idea where to start cause its my second playthrough and i have no idea where to start

[arctic musk]

i found a guide

[urban geyser]

look in challenges

and total completion

then chose something easy

[arctic musk]

just go from top to bottom in total completion

[urban geyser]

or any order tbh

and do challenges

i did the early ones first

like horseman is easy

and stuff

most of them are REALLY easy

[arctic musk]

theres some tricks on the gambler challenges

[distant python]

you have to get gold on every mission for 100% right?

[arctic musk]

no you need gold on like 60 missions for a achievement

not needed for 100%

[distant python]

ok thats good

[late knot]

😭

I have like 10golds

[arctic musk]

its pretty easy

[late knot]

Im just too lazy

[arctic musk]

i sent you a guide in general media

[plucky heath]

What is the best weapon in your opinion?

Why do you think its the best?

[urban geyser]

14 bullets, VERY high accuracy, high fire rate, GREAT range and damage

[ionic juniper]

I think the reason we can't have gang members' horses is because they're special

Actually, there is nothing wrong with this, Rockstar should have at least offered this possibility in the stables or in the wild

[urban geyser]

you can

rdr2 epilogue

in a certain stable

in new austin

blackwater or something

cant remember

gang members horses are in there

like dutch, javier, and bills i think

[ionic juniper]

Even at 2000 dollars, I would buy one of these

I feel like the gray overo texture sold in the stable at tumbleweed is of poor quality

[cyan pendant]

There is also a glitch were you can get them just not keep em

[ionic juniper]

Do we have to play the Horsemen mission again?

[cyan pendant]

For a set few yes

Also that mission in the bar fight against Tommy

[pale scaffold]

Evans repeater

It would be bolt action of it wasn't so slow

[heavy sparrow]

cattleman revolver (or carbine repeater), they get the job done

[pale scaffold]

Or Schofield revolver

[gritty zinc]

The whole reputation thing annoys me. Everything I do puts me in the red. Like obviously I’m going to loot people if they try to kill me

[ionic juniper]

I think all sorts of things have been tried to bond with a gang horse

It is not possible in any way

[cyan pendant]

It’s because they are special horses like if you study them it doesn’t say their breed instead it just has their name like with John’s old boy who is just a Hungarian halfbreed

[ionic juniper]

in the tumbleweed stable they only put the horses that are accessible in the game

Turkoman or american paint

[arctic musk]

yeah it sucks

[ornate wind]

this perfect moose pelt is driving me crazy

[late knot]

Why do you need it

??

[ornate wind]

aura farming outfit

[late knot]

Ahh frfr

[cyan pendant]

I know Sean’s and hoseas is in there

[coarse pond]

I only see 2 moose in all the game

[ornate wind]

i’ve only seen one and it was a 2 star

at lake Isabella

[coarse pond]

I lied, I saw three with the legendary

Can you hunt legendaries with dynamite?

[cyan pendant]

You can hunt anything with anything

[coarse pond]

Yes, but what about the skin?

[arctic musk]

it will still work

[uneven pollen]

how much of a bounty would i get if i throw one volatile dynamite in the saint denis market

[storm bramble]

what kind of question

[arctic musk]

atleast 1 dollar

maybe more

[ionic juniper]

The hardest things to find

gavin

moose

The best location for me was grizzlies mountain

If there is a 2 star spawn, I save the game without hunting and load the game, this time it spawns 3 stars

[arctic musk]

does the moose just change star?

ive found nearly 20 2 star moose

[ionic juniper]

yes

If it spawns as 2 stars, I save the game without doing anything, it spawned as 3 stars after 2 or 3 minutes in the same place, this method worked very well for me.

[arctic musk]

rip my dozens of hours spent looking for a 3 star moose

[ionic juniper]

same

I decided to investigate and saw this method in videos

[arctic musk]

ive looked through tons of videos and didnt find that method

[ionic juniper]

Remember that after hunting a moose, it will not spawn for 72 hours

[arctic musk]

i think i reloaded my save and it worked

the spawn thing

it was a while ago though so im not sure i remember properly

[ionic juniper]

Did the 3 stars spawn?

[arctic musk]

no not that

just the moose spawning without skipping 72 hours and just reloading my save

[cyan pendant]

I say just skip the 72 hours it’s not worth turning off your whole system just to maybe get a 3 star

[calm oasis]

Such a shame it was rockstar who made red dead, considering their servers are absolute garbage to the extent where you cant even play the damn game because the social club bullshit which is entirely unnecessary doesn't work 90% of the time

[simple hare]

can somebody pls help me fix my game

[limber talon]

for some reason. the legendary fish near the braithewaite manor, isnt loading up?

[cyan pendant]

It’s spawns at the trapper

Just not for much money as it would normally be

[limber talon]

nvm still caught it just wouldnt load up on my map?

[ionic juniper]

It's not safe to go to New Austin in a small horse carriage

because it's safer there are glitches

[scenic tundra]

my power just went out after 2 hours of grinding quest, now im so behind. anyway to revert?
nothing saved. im gonna kms

[soft root]

guys, is the m1899 better than the schofield?

[celest harbor]

lost all of my save data i have to attempt to 100% again

literally every save file i had is gone

[opal lava]

One time while I was riding back to camp, a lady at a random part of the train-tracks wanted me to race her. Then suddenly a train came by and somehow hit her fucking horse whole she was still on it 💀 the horse died but she survived and still wanted to race somehow

I wish I said yes to the race

[alpine chasm]

yo do you guys know the MY NAME IS JHON MASTON meme

[formal crag]

yea

[autumn lynx]

pretty sure everyone here knows that but yeah

[alpine chasm]

nice

have any of you discovered the ghost train yet

[autumn lynx]

me in game no but on other gameplay yeah

[alpine chasm]

kk

[soft root]

guys?

[cyan pendant]

Yeah its better

[midnight jacinth]

Is that a thing

[alpine chasm]

yes

[midnight jacinth]

I lowkey forgot about it, it’s near Rhodes right

[alpine chasm]

i think it porb between lemony and some ware

no near lemnoy

[cedar pollen]

what time does it show up?

[alpine chasm]

night

[cedar pollen]

like around 3

[vestal crystal]

Lemony

[celest harbor]

ive seen the ghost train on only one playthrough

for some reason i have a hard time getting it to spawn

[weary harness]

it has to be a certain time because

[cyan pendant]

Can someone let me know how to get the grey Ardennes without that pre order code it’s such a cool horse but I can’t get it

[golden kraken]

simple
build a time machine and
go back and pre order it!
hope this helps

[weary harness]

there's only one other way which is to enable cheats

and do the cheat that summons a war horse

you're gonna have to keep spawning until you get that one

its temporary though, unless you've done the cheatsave thing with the angelo bronte mission

[gritty zinc]

Is it really bad to have your reputation be in the red?

[weary harness]

[soft root]

I mean....not really? never tried low honor but...perhaps I'll do a low honour playthrough soon

[alpine chasm]

yo

guys what if aruthur was the leader instead of dutch and arthurs fav is jhon maston

instead of micah bell

[sacred niche]

Would ruin the story tbh

[honest portal]

For someone only in chap 2, what hore should i go for? The arabian? or focus on the story

[toxic pier]

js focus on the story first in chap 2

[honest portal]

ok

[toxic pier]

and don't get the arabian, get the turkoman from the horse stealing mission in chap 3

[honest portal]

alr, thanks for the help

[toxic pier]

np

[gritty zinc]

Best way to increase reputation easily?

[frosty sedge]

crafting-wise do I need more aligator pelts or black bear pelts??

[weary harness]

i sold that shit for an appaloosa

[weary harness]

alligator

[toxic pier]

no bear

[weary harness]

neverseen black bear parts be used before

[frosty sedge]

alligators are trivial to find though

[toxic pier]

there's a lot of bear hats and stuff

[frosty sedge]

i just found one black bear in the fking swamp where alligators are wtft

and thats the first bear i found in the game

[weary harness]

alligators be everywhere

[frosty sedge]

yea exactly

[weary harness]

bear

bears then

[toxic pier]

my horse is scared shitless when I'm riding in the bayou

even though it's a turkoman

[weary harness]

L horse

[toxic pier]

it still treats me good though

[frosty sedge]

its funny when I ride with bill

his horse is huge, bigger than my arabian + me combined

[toxic pier]

where is this damn skunk I need

[plucky heath]

Did you find it? I have been looking for skunks for the past 5 hours

[toxic pier]

only 2 star ones

the perfect skunk js went extinct I guess

[plucky heath]

Are u doing it for compendium or clothes?

[toxic pier]

hunting request

[plucky heath]

Did u get that one trinket?

[toxic pier]

what trinket

ah great a pack of wolves came and mauled everyone in riggs station

[weary harness]

riggs station for skunks all the time

[plucky heath]

Buck Antler Trinket. It increases the quality of skinned animal parts, making it easier to get perfect pelts from animals

[toxic pier]

oh I got it

but the hunting request lady is a bitch and don't want the animals to be skinned

[plucky heath]

Make sure u get the bison trinket as well for higher rate 👍🏽

[weary harness]

which bison

the white one or the new austin one

[plucky heath]

Tatanka or zombie works just fine

[weary harness]

zombie? 😭

[supple gust]

how did micah grey so quick

[arctic musk]

fishing small fish and putting them back in the water worked best for me

[gritty zinc]

How u get that

[arctic musk]

not worth it

its like 1 in 30 chance

[plucky heath]

To obtain the Buck Antler Trinket in Red Dead Redemption 2, you need to hunt and skin the Legendary Buck, then sell its antler to a fence. The trinket will then be available for crafting at the fence for $22

[arctic musk]

doesnt it only work if you messed up a 3 star pelt

[plucky heath]

Yes thats what its for

[arctic musk]

the chance is just so low

[plucky heath]

If u find oerfect pelt and accidently not shoot in the head its still perfect pelt

The chance is 100%

[arctic musk]

i didnt know that thats really nice

lots of people say different things on it

thank you for letting me know how it works

[wide oak]

I am currently trying to spend as much time on chapter two while doing as little as possible story wise. so i need some clarification.

the only three story missions i need to do to unlock hunting and the ledger is Americans at Rest, Money Lending and Exit Pursued.
This is correct right?

and i dont even need to do much on Money lending, just collect one debt to open the ledger

[stiff prawn]

howdy friends

[weary harness]

i'm not sure if its true

wait

holy shit it is

thats why the poor animals i kill are always good

[arctic musk]

a 1 star pelt turned into a 2 star pelt when i skinned it though

[weary harness]

hang on... this changes everything

[weary harness]

yeah same

yo i didnt know that

[arctic musk]

yeah

same

[weary harness]

i just thought it was a bug or something

the wiki said this:
If they kill an animal in a wrong way (i.e. with a wrong weapon or not in one shot), the trinket raises its quality by one star after skinning it, but not higher than the quality was originally when that animal spawned so the player can't increase the animal's spawned quality with the trinket.

and i'm having a stroke reading

wait nvm it makes sense now

so basically you can kill a 3 star pelt with an explosive bullet and it will still be 3 star lol

i think?

[toxic pier]

chat I need underrated horses

I don't mean like mft or turkoman

like actual unknown underrated horse

[arctic musk]

it would be one star then i think

[weary harness]

aw man 😔

[urban geyser]

i tried doing the master challenge where you kill 3 or 5 cougars with bows, then skin them and on the last one, i used a dynamite arrow but it RUINED it. it said "Ruined Cougar" so i couldnt even skin it or anything

then i found another but thats beside the point

its just GONE if you explode it

[weary harness]

few spotted appaloosa

[weary harness]

fucking hate that challenge

[urban geyser]

REAL

[weary harness]

it took me forever to complete

but now i finished master hunter :)

[urban geyser]

it did 😭

so have i

[weary harness]

imagine 5 cougars

[urban geyser]

im 98.8% through 100% now

[toxic pier]

it's easy though

[urban geyser]

id just jump.

[weary harness]

easy but long

[urban geyser]

they do NOT spawn in

[weary harness]

they always spawn in when i dont expect it

or when i dont have a bow on me

[urban geyser]

real

[toxic pier]

except for the time I accidentally shot one with a dynamite arrow

[urban geyser]

REAL

[weary harness]

ig we've all done that

except me it was fire arrow for me

i forgot to switch

[toxic pier]

forgot to switch the ammo

[weary harness]

yeah

and i havent fucking studied a panther yet

[urban geyser]

about 3 times, i was in cinematic mode to go there automatically and they spawned aand my horse bucked me and it mauled me so i fought it off but then i didnt have my bow / would need to draw it and itd kill me 😭

[toxic pier]

one spawned near hanging dog ranch for some reason

[urban geyser]

i ALWAYS did that

aside from one time i accidently used small game arrows

and STILL killed it

😎

[toxic pier]

yes that too

took me 14 arrows

[urban geyser]

it took so many 😭

[toxic pier]

wait wtf

[weary harness]

also survivalist 7

[toxic pier]

why did this skunk spawned in a roof

[weary harness]

i hated it

[toxic pier]

the miracle tonic one?

[weary harness]

no 8 consecutive small game kills with small game arrow

[toxic pier]

oh

[urban geyser]

that was SO annoying cause i was using the normal satchel and couldnt hold all of ingredients for all of the tonics 😭

[weary harness]

i had no idea where to find stuff

[toxic pier]

yeah I just massacred chickens

[urban geyser]

exactly what i did

in emerald ranch lol

[weary harness]

miracle tonic one was herbalist 6 wasnt it

6 or 7

[toxic pier]

and the ingredients always spawn in small groups

[weary harness]

hang on...

[urban geyser]

finding that stupid crab for one of the challenges just to cook it with a plant was SOOO BAD 😭

they wouldnt spawn in on the ONLY tiny place on the map theyd spawn

[toxic pier]

I have a hot take

[urban geyser]

it took like half an hour 😭

[weary harness]

i'm doing challenges as arthur, so no herbalist 9 ☹️

[toxic pier]

I liked algernon's missions

[urban geyser]

who?

[weary harness]

i just have survivalist 10, gambler 10 left

[weary harness]

[urban geyser]

OH

i only JUST did that recently

[weary harness]

never finishing that

[urban geyser]

i wanted to blow my brains out

[toxic pier]

it's quite fun tbh

[urban geyser]

NO???

[toxic pier]

yeah so I can explore the map

[urban geyser]

the birds are SCRIPTED to not spawn on the current task of killing them

[urban geyser]

you mean the shit filled swamps?

[weary harness]

does anyone else just

[toxic pier]

I accidentally sold all but 1 of the cormorant feathers

[weary harness]

hate bluewater marsh

[weary harness]

wow

[urban geyser]

i did it as john too so the birds would fill the swamp and id use my horse to kick them to land

[weary harness]

cooked

[urban geyser]

and the crocs would scare my horse

so it would SPRINT even further into the fucking river

😭

then the bird would sink down to NEVER be seen again 😭

[toxic pier]

js shoot near the crocs

[urban geyser]

thats the same with those hunting missions

[toxic pier]

they're scared from the gunshots

[urban geyser]

ik

but still

[weary harness]

havent done the hunting request yet

[urban geyser]

dont

😭

[toxic pier]

that mrs hobbs makes me want to blow my brains

[weary harness]

but will as soon as i can finished challenges

[urban geyser]

it wasnt as bad for me

the 3rd one was HELL

and 2nd

or was it the 4th?

one of them

[toxic pier]

3 star animals just go extinct when you do it

[urban geyser]

I KNOW

the 2 last ones were easy as though

[toxic pier]

pro tip: I farm small birds near limpany so I can get ahead

[weary harness]

limpany just have rat

[toxic pier]

the 3rd one is a grind

[urban geyser]

it WAS

[toxic pier]

can't find no single woodpecker

[urban geyser]

i found that one first

around rhodes

😒

[weary harness]

i heard robins are hard to come across

[urban geyser]

the songbird and other ones were MISSING

[urban geyser]

they were 😭

[toxic pier]

they actually spawn often near the trapper up in annesburg

in the bridge

[urban geyser]

theres a tiny island next to the Braithwaite mansion where theyd spawn and every time youd do a lap, theyd respawn

BUT

they never DID spawn 😭

[weary harness]

its like people saying gambler 8 was hard

it wasnt hard for me

[urban geyser]

aside from ONE time where it flew into the ocean after i shot it to never be seen again

😭

[toxic pier]

It WAS hard

[weary harness]

nope

was lucky

and it took me half an hour

[toxic pier]

took me 2.5 hours

I would hit 3 and get 21 but the dealer would pull up some shit and I got pushed

[weary harness]

holy damn

[urban geyser]

ive done EVERYTHING for 100% but arthurs grave, last 2 gambler challenges, and last horseman challenge

so i gotta tame 4 more horses

and gamble 😭

hot take
gambler 7 was light work

i did it in under 15 minutes of actual blackjack

[toxic pier]

I fear gambler 9

can't play dominoes

[urban geyser]

i can

i love dominoes

[weary harness]

gambler 9 easy

just took long

[toxic pier]

I love it too

[urban geyser]

its like scrabble but numbers

[toxic pier]

the pizza

[toxic pier]

what the hell is scrabble

[weary harness]

gambler 7?

[toxic pier]

there ain't no scrabble in my country

[weary harness]

was exremely easy

[urban geyser]

3 blackjack was 3 plus hits and win

easy as

[weary harness]

that was 8

[urban geyser]

2 of the times i landed on EXACTLY 21

[urban geyser]

same shit different smell 😭

[toxic pier]

I must've landed on 21 like five times then I got pushed by the dealer

[urban geyser]

😭

im sorry you had to deal with that

i was in vc with one of my mates and it would be quiet as and then id do one and id SCREAM

lol

hes only in chapter 2

and hasnt played before

hes lowkey clueless not just to the story, but GAMEPLAY too

we've played online for like 350 hours

but he is STILL clueless

[weary harness]

v

[urban geyser]

wont eat or feed horse, doesnt know how to shoot, aims like helen keller, etc

he was killed by 3 odriscles at a camp

WHILE using deadeye

😭

[weary harness]

L human

"aims like helen keller"

[weary harness]

my friend finished the game not knowing about dead eye

[urban geyser]

what

[weary harness]

they only had it in those events yk

[urban geyser]

😭

[weary harness]

because sometimes it does that

[urban geyser]

both our mates are ROCKS

[weary harness]

needless to say they became the most accurate person in the west

[urban geyser]

so me

😎

[weary harness]

they could shoot a pin drop

wait

[urban geyser]

so can i

[weary harness]

i'm def not accurately

[urban geyser]

also in case you havent, turn your sens to MAX and SLIGHTLY lower your aim assist by 1 or 2

[weary harness]

but i disabled aim assist

[urban geyser]

it makes it SOO much better

[urban geyser]

im working my way down to that

[weary harness]

i disabled aim assist

because in rdr1 i used expert targeting mode

[urban geyser]

i didnt

😭

the aim"assist" is aimbot 😭

it LOCKS on them

will not move at ALL

like rdr2 tbh

the max aim assist paired with default sensitivity is actually hell

and i used that for 4 playthroughs 😭

AND online

[pale scaffold]

How to fix brightness

[urban geyser]

iouno

settings

[toxic pier]

let's go I found the skunk

[ionic juniper]

John:ladyyy Arthur:your brave girl

[ionic juniper]

I can't remember how many times I've fallen off my horse looking for dinosaur bones 😄

[plucky heath]

Im still looking

[plucky heath]

What horse do you have

[uneven pollen]

it definitely is sometimes... i spent 3 hours and didnt even get one. came back another day and got 3 within 20 minutes

[toxic pier]

try near riggs station at night

[plucky heath]

Ok i’ll try, near the station? Or which direction?

[toxic pier]

the woods near it

be careful not to get jumped by wolves

[plucky heath]

Ok near like the fence?

[toxic pier]

there's no fence

[plucky heath]

Sorry i meant near the lake

[lament briar]

Howdy

I’m just looking for friends here

[plucky heath]

Im currently looking for Skunk

[ionic juniper]

dark bay turkoman

[plucky heath]

Is it alot bigger than arabian? Im looking for mediums size horse

[ionic juniper]

Two or three times bigger than an Arabian horse

[plucky heath]

Thank you

[ionic juniper]

I like the white Arabian horse, but they are small and easily frightened by everything

[cyan pendant]

Also Arthur looks funny on it

[tiny inlet]

sharpshooter 8 is so stupid

[arctic musk]

why?

[tiny inlet]

its so hard to hit peoples small little hands without deadeye

and it feels random what it deems a disarm

[arctic musk]

where are you doing the challenge?

[tiny inlet]

where should i be doing it?

[arctic musk]

van horn saloon i think

[tiny inlet]

ill try that ty

[arctic musk]

van horn saloon works good for alot of challenges

[valid idol]

Should I play Rdr2?

[storm bramble]

yeah

[plucky heath]

Id save the money for the upcoming hxh game

[plucky heath]

Whats the name of the dominoes style they play in rdr2? I tried looking up how to play dominoes on youtube but they play completely different game

[ionic juniper]

What is the reason why pistol weapons are expensive in the game?

[arctic musk]

they're late game and op

[prisma breach]

I waited until the Epi to do the 3rd lone woman whose man got killed by a bear mission and when I got there she was de@d inside the house, will this stop me from completing everything as 100%?

[modest raft]

I just got red chestnut Arabian where's the owner

so i dont get caught

also im using swamp lure to go fishing at Lagras and when im reeling it wont get closer

any tips pls?

it broke my hands fr

[frosty sedge]

can anybody tell at what graphics setting was the photo I posted in media taken??

im genuinely interested if its easy to tell apart

[supple gust]

anyone got any idea on how to kill 4 people with one stick of dynamite, enemies

not citizens

[frosty sedge]

find lemoyne raiders, lasso each one of them and stack them up idk

[supple gust]

can they get out of the hogtie

[frosty sedge]

theres an old church close to rhodes, thats one of their bases I think

[frosty sedge]

I don't think so

only happened once that a person did that and it was a bounty mission so it was probably intended scenario

[molten crest]

Tamed my first white arabian

[uneven pollen]

Missouri Fox Trotter is better

[balmy dirge]

tamed it a few days ago too its small

my main is an American paint

[molten crest]

Ok then

[balmy dirge]

anyways don't let me disturb you

[molten crest]

And also got all legendary fishies

[balmy dirge]

i rarely get any legendary

always them small ones

[molten crest]

Lol

[pale scaffold]

Where can i find cougars?

[arctic musk]

where the trees are with no leaves north of owinjila

just keep riding around looking at your minimap

[weary harness]

yeah true

and for my whole first playthrough i just thought that was my amazing skills at shooting

how did i think that

[mental jetty]

just finished the story i cried my eyes out

[lunar moat]

i jst bought rdr2 is it that sad.

[mental jetty]

you will sit in your bed and cry all night looking at author on ticktok

good luck brother

and don't go back for the money

[lunar moat]

damn.

[mental jetty]

ya

[lunar moat]

do u have like any tips i should when i start

cus i never played rdr before tbh

[mental jetty]

go with high honor it will better at the end and just the game play

will be better

[lunar moat]

alr

[mental jetty]

and brag to your friend that you have it

[twin loom]

Play slowly and don’t rush the game, take your time to complete everything and explore everything. You should finish your playthroughs with 300+ hours.

[mental jetty]

i have 800 beacuse of hunting all the time

[twin loom]

I have 6k hours just on story

[mental jetty]

and do the side quest they give you honor

dam

[lunar moat]

i would prob jst take a rope and jst catch ppl tbf

[mental jetty]

then welcone to low honor

[lunar moat]

damn it

[mental jetty]

welcome

[twin loom]

Things to do after finishing:
buy everything off the trapper
Murder valentine
Start another playthrough
Massacre valentine

[lunar moat]

bet

20 mins and its installed

yes i have a timer on phone for that shi

have to prepare

[mental jetty]

you will cry at the end no mater what you do just play the game and then you will know when it is time

[twin loom]

I love searching around and finding the cheat codes. There’s one in the bear cabin in the drawer, numerous in the snow, such as Sadie’s house or the random broken cabin. Also one in the broken house near Clemons point. Cool thing to do instead of just searching it up on yt

[lunar moat]

wait fym cheat codes

eh il find out anyway

[twin loom]

Another under the owanjilla dam too

[mental jetty]

ya there so fun

to use

[twin loom]

Cheats, such as add $500 or unlock all outfits

[lunar moat]

oo

[twin loom]

The only downside is you cannot close your game

Because you cannot save it

[lunar moat]

damn

[mental jetty]

and go all black outfit aurthor

[twin loom]

Legend of the east imo

[lunar moat]

this game is gonne either where i spend my summer in or where i play for 1 hour and forget

[mental jetty]

ya that sucks

[lunar moat]

prob the summer option

[twin loom]

I always figure it must be so weird for people like rob whietoff, Roger Clark or Peter, as the either have to play as themselves or shoot themselves. Must be funny

[unreal patrol]

Is there any way to get back the money i got robbed in a random event at Saint Denis? The one who guides you to a hallway then you get knocked out. I came back here but nobodys there

[bold ocean]

Hey so im in chapter 2 and I killed everyone at Cornwall kerosene and tar idk y

And I have no bounty

Is there anything worth it to loot here

Or like can I sell the oil

Before the mission

Im trying it

🤷‍♂️

[ionic juniper]

The collection of exotics is very long and I didn't finish today 😃

[pale scaffold]

Valentine is my favourite town and also my no.1 place for massacres and striking fear into folk

Strawberry is much nicer but it doesn't have a barber nor a gunsmith

[onyx dawn]

Barber makes a town good

[pale scaffold]

Yeah bc i can maintain my level 10 pencil mustaches

And i like hunting in west Elizabeth but then i have to go to valentine

[pulsar ruin]

What theories do you guys have about the game, if any?

[empty delta]

How do i take the legendary fox pelt out of my horse's cargo?? It doesnt say anything when i click on the pelt doesnt say to remove or take or anything

[pulsar ruin]

You can sell it to a Trapper, and he can make you some special clothing items.

[empty delta]

oh ok

[uneven pollen]

arthur morgan is a deeply closeted gay man and wants to go spend his days frolicing on tahitian beaches nude with micah

[pulsar ruin]

lol

I think Arthur is afraid of heights.

[uneven pollen]

boring

[pulsar ruin]

Oh, but I also have a theory that there was no rat.

[hardy granite]

What?

[pulsar ruin]

Milton lied about Micah betraying the gang, and the reason things went down like they did is because Dutch is stupid.

Yeah, rob a bank in the same town you just tried to rob the trolly station of, real smart.

[hardy granite]

Have Some FAITH

[pulsar ruin]

Think about it. Just about every job Dutch planned went poorly.

[celest harbor]

you can sell the oil wagons to a fence you meet during one of hoseas chapter 2 mission

[toxic pier]

bill is gay

[pulsar ruin]

Well, that's pretty much proven.

[celest harbor]

that's not a theory it's true

[hardy granite]

Hey leave Marion alone

[celest harbor]

hosea makes a comment about Bill and Phil

who do we think that's about huh?

[pulsar ruin]

Plus the way he talks to Kieran makes me think they kind of had a thing.

[celest harbor]

he picks on him because he's a gay and i think Kieran is straight and liked Mary Beth

[celest harbor]

ok this sounded hateful

i didn't intend for it too bad wording sorry

[pulsar ruin]

I also have a theory that Molly was pregnant.

[celest harbor]

i meant he picked on him because he had a crush and is in denial

[hardy granite]

You all good bro

[pulsar ruin]

At one point, she says she has something to tell Dutch, but is of course brushed off.

[celest harbor]

she's brushed off many times

unfortunately

[hardy granite]

Micah killed Karen I think

[pulsar ruin]

But why not just say it in front of Arthur and everyone?

[celest harbor]

hmm

Mary Beth said she drunk herself to death

[pulsar ruin]

When

[celest harbor]

when you meet her as John in the epilogue

[toxic pier]

She tried to, but uncle interrupted her to give arthur "a great gift of information" (cornwall stage)

[celest harbor]

at the valentine post office

[hardy granite]

Think about it. The last time we see Karen is before the mission where the Indians attack the oil station. And Micah stayed behind

[celest harbor]

hmm

[pulsar ruin]

I'm also certain Tilly loved Arthur.

Like, love loved him

[celest harbor]

tilly was like Arthur's younger sister i thought

[toxic pier]

tilly is black

how

[celest harbor]

ok and? you can think of someone like family regardless of race

[hardy granite]

Question

[celest harbor]

i don't mean like biological sister

[pulsar ruin]

Arthur's half black anyway

[toxic pier]

ooh

[hardy granite]

Has anyone found Gavin?

[celest harbor]

no

gavin is a figment of dudes imagination or he is gavin

Nigel i mean

there's a note on him that explains the lore behind him

[hardy granite]

I have a theory that the cave hermit is Gavin

[celest harbor]

the one who thinks he is the devil or the wolf man?

[hardy granite]

The devil

[celest harbor]

perhaps

[pulsar ruin]

I like the theory that Nigel has MPD and Gavin is a personality of his that just sort of left.

[celest harbor]

i think that guy is just some weird dude who wanted to be the devil

[celest harbor]

it's called DID now but yes

me too

back then he was probably undiagnosed

or he was schizophrenic

[celest harbor]

i don't think the personalities can just leave

they can be suppressed by others but not outright destroyed

[hardy granite]

Do you think the feral man with the wolves was schizophrenic?

[pulsar ruin]

What do you think about my Molly pregnancy theory, though?

[celest harbor]

i think he just went crazy

[celest harbor]

it could be true

[hardy granite]

Oh 100%

[celest harbor]

not sure how tho

[toxic pier]

gavin is in the legendary channel catfish that ate jeremy gill

[celest harbor]

it could have been like BPD or something similar

or maybe some kind of PTSD

i think he has a journal that mentions some of his backstory

[hardy granite]

I think I saw that as well

[celest harbor]

i like Jeremy's hat

[hardy granite]

Do you guys think Uncle is Red Harlow?

[onyx dawn]

No

[dense snow]

any1 knows how to use controller on pc?

[blazing dawn]

nurp

i love red harlow tho

[cyan pendant]

That’s still the dumbest theory even the actors think it’s dumb

[blazing turret]

how do i get Missouri fox trotter before epilogue?

[hardy granite]

I have no idea which horse that is homie

[cyan pendant]

Ok this is kinda hard to explain you know those oil fields?