red-dead-singleplayer

[tranquil talon]

thought so

[main linden]

and pick up the free gold bar in limpany

[tranquil talon]

Arthur gonna be a rich man

[main linden]

I already got 4k in chapt 3

[tranquil talon]

heading to the land mark of riches start point

[main linden]

meanwhile the thithing box only got 60 dollars

[tranquil talon]

im gonna make sure to give arthur some new clothes - hate the first outfit

[ionic juniper]

There are a ton of glitches in the game, I guess they are too lazy to fix them

[tranquil talon]

FOW is so annoying in this game

[arctic musk]

wdym

whats FOW

[tranquil talon]

fog of war

[ionic juniper]

I don't like rain in this game

[arctic musk]

why not

[shadow wraith]

how can i get role people?

[arctic musk]

send the bot @fervent apex a dm with proof you have the achievements to get roles in this server

[shadow wraith]

thank you bro

but what i will do for first role

[tranquil talon]

found a really good guide for the game

[spice cove]

Whats the best ending yall?

[mystic grove]

Damn🥀

[tranquil talon]

high

[mystic grove]

After chapter 4 i feel like i am being angel

My honour is from this

To max

Damn
Like when collecting the debt or other you will do in the better way

[lavish prairie]

Guys I just got back to RDR2 and now there is this problem activation error with the social club or something, can anyone help?

[ionic juniper]

John:thank you good horse Arthur:Good Boah

[shadow wraith]

тут есть ещё русские кроме меня, если есть напишите ниже

[pine cedar]

The rules say you have to speak in English

[shadow wraith]

I just asked question about my language, because i want to know about Russian people on this server bro

[bleak crypt]

Yo i cant get a panther to spawn, any tips?

[brave sphinx]

why did my john just change outfits for no reason when i started the game again?

odd

[midnight ocean]

save and quit in the area then reload

worked for me in the spot in southern lemoyne

but be ready for that panther lol

[long mist]

are there any must have mods for rdr 2?

[thorny peak]

should i just do the bandit challenges in chapter 2 because it loses so much honor but theres an honor cap and after just go meet people in saint denis or should i wait till the epilogue?

[midnight ocean]

it doesnt lose that much honor

the bounty gained from freeing micah can complete bandit 5 for you

[mystic grove]

[midnight ocean]

real

[lost peak]

does anyone know why im not getting the jim boy missions after i did all the gunslinger photos? do i have to wait?

[autumn lynx]

you gotta wait until the story progresses to saint denis

[lost peak]

ohhh ok tysm :)

[main linden]

use predator bait in the forest areas of lemoyne

or go to lakay at night

[main linden]

do the bandit challenges after you complete the epilogue

bcs I don't really care abt honor when playing as john

[midnight ocean]

having the gold medal system and having it be required for 100% really sucks when the way most missions are designed makes them lack replayability

[mystic grove]

“dont you oh Arthur me”

[static dragon]

oh orfur

[main linden]

there's a naked guy being chased by a wolf near annesburg

wth

[blissful crane]

he chill with the wolves

[thorny peak]

for bandit 2 does it have to be coaches specifically or any wagon?

[arctic musk]

i think a coach

i recommend going to emerald ranch and not looking at where hes supposed to spawn until he spawns

then steal the coach with bandana on escape the law and break open the lock behind the coach and that counts for the challenge

[main linden]

when you get a rare horse like the chestnut arabian as arthur, will it respawn when you play as john?

[ionic juniper]

sure

I sold the white Arabian horse many times and it always spawned

[main linden]

oh alr

[vestal crystal]

Rdr2 became... Woke...?? I am so fucking angry rn... I need to go read my bill williamson x kieran duffy fanfic to calm down... Fuck....

[ionic juniper]

Only the best saddle in the game is the panther saddle?

[arctic musk]

yeah panther saddle is best

[hidden moss]

Panther, beaver and snake saddle are all on the same level with a total reduction rate of 70%
They are just balanced a bit different with snake being the most equal balanced one
Panther has a slightly better stamina drain but less health drain
Beaver is the other way around

So if you like to run your horse, panther
You like to shoot up towns on horseback, beaver
You want both, snake

And to be fair, we are talking here of differences in the 2-4% range which sounds like a lot, but is really minor in the big picture
Just choose whatever looks good on your horse

Snake: -22% HCDR, -24% SCDR, +24% SRR --> balanced, total of 70% bonus stats

Panther: -20% HCDR, -26% SCDR, +24% SRR --> stamina-focus, total of 70% bonus stats

Beaver: -26% HCDR, -20% SCDR, +24% SRR --> health-focus, total of 70% bonus stats

[ionic juniper]

I realized that saddles completely change the appearance of horses

[hidden moss]

The panther looks really nice in the black shire that you get early in chapter 2 from hosea
Many smaller horses look stupid with it in my opinion since the saddle itself is really big
So if you move the camera around the panther saddle is kind of floating in the air

[weary harness]

survivalist challenges are just a mix of master hunter and weapons expert

also its basically the fishing challenges of rdr

[ionic juniper]

Thick bridle looks cool

[ionic juniper]

sharpshooter 8 gave me a hard time

[noble fractal]

I watched a YouTuber who did all the challenges as Arthur which was just as impossible as you think

[mild flume]

lol

[thorny peak]

i know theres clothing pieces exclusive to high honor but are there low honor ones?

[noble fractal]

There’s a gun handle

[pearl pollen]

Guys, can someone tell me should i catch even all fish for Zoologist achievement or no?

[noble fractal]

Don’t you need all fish for the 90 challenges

[pearl pollen]

I know about challenges, im too lazy for these, just wanna get zoologist in one safe cuz I think im almost got it

Can someone send names of fish from 1st page on 8th and 12th places🙏🙏

[main linden]

Bluegill, Channel Catfish, Lake Sturgeon, Chain Pickerel, Bullhead Catfish, Largemouth Bass, Longnose Gar, Muskie, Northern Pike, Perch, Redfin Pickerel, Rock Bass, Smallmouth Bass, Sockeye Salmon, n the Steelhead Trout

n every fish has a legendary version

[ionic juniper]

the best way to get arthur legend of the east outfit is to have a PC

Probably easy to get with saves or mods

[pearl pollen]

Oh, thanks you so much friend🙏

[pearl pollen]

I almost got it, 96.4% and 2 weeks of my life, as a result this writer for whos I should bring food just ruined me this quest, he didnt want to get this food and in few game days he just left house(or idk what he did)

[ionic juniper]

I think a better outfit could have been made, I started to get bored after 1 or 2 weeks of use

It didn't give me the feeling that you have finished all the challenges, but it's not a bad outfit

[shadow wraith]

Guys who play rdr 1?

[arctic musk]

i play rdr1

its very fun

[long mist]

where can i install Lenny's Mod Loader? besides rdr2mods because after i scanned Lenny's Mod Loader from there it showed a virus.

[teal kiln]

what

explain

[vestal crystal]

Its most likely a false flag

[vestal crystal]

The server icon

[teal kiln]

Gay

[weary harness]

I play it

the gameplay is better than rdr2

it lets you travel to waypoints

[vestal crystal]

I played it

[teal kiln]

Rdr2 has fast travel dood

[paper osprey]

i use rampage trainers teleport

very convenient

[arctic musk]

its great but i feel like it discourages people from exploring

[opal lava]

It does??

[vestal crystal]

Yeah

U just gotts buy a map in the camp ledger

I mean

Upgrade arthurs tent

[shadow wraith]

Ye, for me gameplay in rdr1 much better then rdr2, a lot of little details

[arctic musk]

i like some things about rdr1 and i dont like some things about rdr1 but its the same with rdr2

[shadow wraith]

I agree with you

I complete rdr2, and now start complete rdr1, and already search many funny things which were not there in rdr2

My English maybe bad, because I'm from Belarus

[arctic musk]

yes and you need to get most of your money outside of missions instead of rdr2 where you get alot of money from story missions

[arctic musk]

its good i understand

[shadow wraith]

Thank

Where a you from?

[arctic musk]

i am from the netherlands

there are some cool things in rdr1 like pardon letters you can use it and your bounty goes away without spending any money

[shadow wraith]

It's very good country

[arctic musk]

yes

[shadow wraith]

it's a pity, because rockstar don't want do rdr 1 remake

I heard they wanted to do rdr 2 remake, but for what? Game so good still our days

[arctic musk]

i think something simple like 60fps

[arctic musk]

probably not

i hear they might do gta4 remake so that gives a bit of hope

[shadow wraith]

Yes, maybe

But i complete rdr2, on ps4, and this was not cool, 30 fps, average graphics, and gamepad, but now a have pc

[arctic musk]

i have about 50-70 fps on pc but 30fps is bad

but i have to play on 30fps on gta6 when it releases

[shadow wraith]

I have 70-70 fps in rdr2 on max graphics

70-80*

[arctic musk]

i have something like that i checked a long time ago and the fps is different in alot of places in the map i think

some have more detailed things like saint denis

[frosty sedge]

What can I do in rdr online? I mean how is it different from the story mode?

How do I get the money to buy some business or something?

[arctic musk]

just get 2 factor authentication on rockstar social club, wait 1-2 days and with the gold get bounty hunter

you have to wait 30 minutes in a bounty hunting mission for the most money

[shadow wraith]

On playstation 4 when i was in settlement, royds sent denis and other settlement my fps was approximately 15-20 and this was torment

[arctic musk]

yes sometimes i had 10fps in saint denis at night but it didnt happen alot

[frosty sedge]

Wait that's just a single bounty?

[arctic musk]

there are some story missions, i still have no clue what the story is but its nothing special
what you do in rdo is just play missions and competitions and those things

[arctic musk]

no its for infinite bountys

[shadow wraith]

Ok, i need to go, gl

[arctic musk]

there is a cooldown on the best bounty

[frosty sedge]

But hunting etc. is the same right?

And stealing wagons to sell at the fence

[arctic musk]

hunting is decent, legendary animal missions with new legendary animals, hunting wagon to store alot of animals in

rdo is like really grindy rdr2

the things are still the same at its core but not fully

for me it stayed a bit fun until i did most missions got rank 100 and all achievements

[bold ocean]

Yo im having a weird glitch or idk something

I got a tomahawk while playing the mission paying a social call

I restarted it because I didnt like how I went about it

This time around I dont see a tomahawk

Anywhere

Is it just a random spawn

Do you have to get it before all the people near the campfire disperse

And if I dont get it rn is there another time I can get it?

@arctic musk

Do you know anything abt this

If its easy to obtain ill just move on but if not i wanna reload the save

[arctic musk]

you can get a tomohawk at a fence for a few bucks

[bold ocean]

Thats why im curious so I can move past it

Oh okay

[arctic musk]

im not sure how you got it

[bold ocean]

Yeah idk withier

I kept replaying the mission to do it quietely

[olive hazel]

So, i have a question. Is low honor or high honor better?

[bold ocean]

Every time I would mess up I would run near campfire

To just kill myself

To restart checkpoint

Every time I do that

Id get the tomahawk

[arctic musk]

high honor but for what purpose?

[olive hazel]

Just to play as in general

[arctic musk]

high honor

cheaper store prices

[olive hazel]

Ok

[arctic musk]

and some other small stuff

and the story changes a bit so it matches your honor better

[carmine warren]

hello i jus tgot here and want to make friends and understand this server

[bold ocean]

@arctic musk

Can you take bountys you got from bounty hunters and turn them in as your own

[arctic musk]

yes it should

i think you can also untie them and they will give you a secret way into a shop like a secret robbery

you can turn the bounty in to the sherriff but i dont think the game gives you any text so just drop the bounty in a cell

[bold ocean]

In your expirience which is more bang for buck

[arctic musk]

probably turning it into the sherriff

its easier too

[bold ocean]

Or i could untie them and get the secret way into the shop

Then tie them again

Imma try that

[arctic musk]

thats smart you could try im not sure if it works

[bold ocean]

Ill update you on how it go

[arctic musk]

alright im curious

[frosty sinew]

Can you just tie up any bounty hunter and get a bounty for them

[arctic musk]

bounty hunters have bounties that you can take

[frosty sinew]

How do i do that

[arctic musk]

just shoot the bounty hunters and take the bounty from the horse or shoot the lock from a stagecoach im not sure if it works

[opal zinc]

Where are the secret robberies? I know of the one in the strawberry general store

[visual lark]

is archaeology for beginners bugged? it seems that the 1 min and 30 seconds objective just does not work

[arctic musk]

did you respawn from checkpoint or anything?

[visual lark]

yeah

is that why

[arctic musk]

theres alot you'll need to watch a youtube video on it probably

[arctic musk]

yeah

you can respawn from checkpoint in some missions

[visual lark]

so i pretty much can't just skip with the "abandon 3 times and skip to next checkpoint" stuff right?

[arctic musk]

yeah thats why

[opal zinc]

Thanks

[bold ocean]

@arctic musk

Whenever I untie him he just runs away

So idk if I messed up or took too long too talk to him

He says something like its my brother you want not me

[arctic musk]

im not sure either

[bold ocean]

But there's no way too

Progress the convo

I think this one prob just doesnt hsve any secrets

Imma just turn him in

[ionic juniper]

Is there any way to get the John gambler hat? I can't find it anywhere.

[arctic musk]

johns hat?

[ionic juniper]

Yes

[arctic musk]

do you not have it as john?

[ionic juniper]

John wears a different hat at the beginning of Epilouge

[vale osprey]

You get later in the Epilogue.

Maybe a hour or two in I would say

[teal kiln]

Yeah but I had to search for it too so you're not the only one who didn't know at some point

[paper osprey]

make sure when you’re at pronghorn to have it knocked off and to put it back on to add it to your wardrobe

otherwise you might miss your chance

[ionic juniper]

Then I'm too late

[paper osprey]

rip hope you have a save file

[visual lark]

holy moly thank you

getting gold in that mission gave me chronic depression until you stepped in

[arctic musk]

im happy i could help

[arctic musk]

i didnt know that, cale is probably right

or the other guy im not sure

[haughty sable]

How can I create a backup of my save(s)? Where do I find the save files on my computer?

[midnight ocean]

man i cannot get lennys watch request to trigger

wonder if i missed the timing for it

[ionic juniper]

Yeah, that's right.

It's still bullshit

[vale osprey]

The epilogue for the game is bad. I have played it twice once during my very first play through and the second time was during my hundred percent play through

[ionic juniper]

Do they have a reason?

[vale osprey]

IDK, Epilogue kinda just sets up stuff for RDR 1 kinda

[sonic wraith]

Hi

Any one play with me

[ionic juniper]

I just don't like the too much calm in the epilouge

[vale osprey]

Yeah completely agree, that’s why I don’t play it anymore

[ionic juniper]

Just to make the story better, I can be sure that Arthur is dead

Neither character is alive lol

I hope we don't see the same things in gta

[vale osprey]

Yeah, hoping we don’t see that in GTA

[winter moat]

Guys, idk about this grind

Finding all animals seems crazy

Finding all 30 bones seems crazy

[unreal patrol]

Anyone knows if rampage prevents you from joining rdo?

I kinda couldnt connect to online mode and im assuming its because i have rampage installed

[weary harness]

actually thats kinda true i havent explored new austin a lot

[weary harness]

i know, but rdr1 lets you travel to an exact point

[weary harness]

it gives you mexico as well

huge win

[barren grotto]

so uh... how do I make the legendary sockeye salmon in lake isabella actually bite my special lake lure? I can get any of the other big fish to bite in about 5 seconds. this thing, nada.

[wild gorge]

Yeah wich is really annoying it doesn't exist in rdr2

[vale sinew]

love giving Arthur all-black fits

anti-hero vibes

[hidden holly]

does rdr1 have chapters like rdr2? im pretty early on

[blissful crane]

yea there's 4

or was it 3

[halcyon sky]

Theres about 4 stages of that game but it doesnt have chapters no

[weary harness]

4?

[olive hazel]

I need animal fat for explosive ammo. How do you get it?

[inland badger]

I think you just need to kill an animal

[main linden]

kill big game animals

or boars

[inland badger]

Bears boars pigs I think can work

And duck and geese

[unreal patrol]

Most animals must give. The best way imo is getting it from ducks because they are grouped

[midnight ocean]

hosea be soundin like jordan peterson at the campfire

[split quartz]

lol

[carmine warren]

YOOO ANYONE WHO PLAYS right now and want friends?

[covert barn]

Anyone on here know how to stop the ‘ERR_GFX_STATE please reboot or restart game’ av been trying to sort it since last week and really struggling can someone help me out?

[wooden lagoon]

Which is better, Otis miller revolver or Micah’s one

[thorny peak]

man i hate hunting panthers the can just jumpscare you at any moment

[unique sable]

Fr panthers and cugars and they have so less spawn u need to wait half an hr to get a new one 😔

I just use explosive ammo for leg. Panther and cugars it's much easier if they jump at u

[unique sable]

I think otis

It just looks insane but calloway's revolver is good too

[ionic juniper]

Most weapons have high damage when I use express ammo

[thorny peak]

is there lik a specific time frame when badgers spawn cuz i cannot for the life of me find one

[arctic musk]

otis and calloway revolver have same stats

[formal lion]

what happens if i add micah in rdr1

[onyx dagger]

Please answer me bro

I wanna play

[elfin kraken]

The legendary animals are not appearing on my map what do i do

[wooden lagoon]

Ok thanks 🙏

[weary harness]

spam kill ducks

it will cost you some honor but its useful in the long run

flight feathers, animal fat

all can be obtained and used for ammo crafting

[ionic juniper]

I think animal fat is also found in cows

[elfin kraken]

How do i start hunting legendary animals

[arctic musk]

find their tracks

[prisma monolith]

how do you change outfits from horse??

[elfin kraken]

They aint there and the logo aint on me map

[prisma monolith]

i always lose my hat and aurther feels naked without it

[unique sable]

when ur near the tracks or hints of legendary animal u can see small gray question mark that where u can inspect and follow the trail

[winter moat]

How come an ace in blackjack is sometimes a 10 or sometimes a 1?

[noble valley]

I got no idea what to respond to that because I neverrr play blackjack in RDR2

[elfin kraken]

I know i saw on yt but they dont pop up for me lad

[lofty ridge]

hmm

[noble fractal]

It’s the irl rules. The value changes to whatever value you need. So if you have 20, you can use it as a 1 and get 21

[noble fractal]

Also check your horse it always has your hat. Arthur’s like Indiana Jones, never loses his hat

[ripe temple]

Why can’t i break free from Tommy?

[elfin kraken]

Fym

[lofty ridge]

tommy's pretty easy

spam the break free button

very hard

[feral magnet]

hey guys, how to make John wear the bandolier in his shoulders?

[weary harness]

you mean wear it?

[feral magnet]

yeah,, rn its in his hips

[weary harness]

that must be the gun belt

[feral magnet]

unlike Arthur,, its in his shoulder

[weary harness]

you probably have to equip it

just go to any wardrobe in a general store, tailor or hotel room

change clothing > weapon equipment > bandolier

[feral magnet]

I still got wat Arthur has,, cuz when I go to the shop, its states "Owned"

[weary harness]

could you give me a photo of your john

in #general-media

[weary harness]

wait did it work

[feral magnet]

im doing it now,w8

btw, did u guys change the horse of John?

Dang! my treasured Brindle from Arthur.. Im remembered it again

[weary harness]

we didnt really have a choice

i wish i could have my old horse back

[ionic juniper]

I don't like thoroughbreds

[ionic juniper]

Old boy?

[feral magnet]

then wats good that I should get?

[barren tree]

How do I get Otis millers gun

[muted viper]

Somewhere in new austin close to the dinosaur bones

[barren tree]

I haven’t even been in new Austin yet

[delicate solstice]

Are u with arthur?

[barren tree]

Every time I go there I’m killed

[muted viper]

You can only get it in epilogue

[delicate solstice]

Oh

[barren tree]

Wait how did u get there

[delicate solstice]

U will see

For now wait

And play

[muted viper]

What do u mean

[delicate solstice]

He is in first chpaters

[muted viper]

Ow

Then you cant get it

[barren tree]

I’m in chapter 4

Can I get there in the next chapter or something

[delicate solstice]

Not next chapter

But after chapter 6

[barren tree]

Alright

I think we can all agree bill is top 10 characters

[vestal crystal]

Whu do wolves ALWAYS show up at the worst moments

[delicate solstice]

As well as random things that ruin encounters

[winter moat]

I want clarification: can I restart checkpoint for a mission gold medal if mission does not have :

a time objective

A no healing objective.

Correct?

[muted viper]

If i exit the game woth an animal stowed will it stay there?

[vestal crystal]

Yeah

[vestal crystal]

Yeag

[frosty sedge]

how do I kill that cougar in a cave mission??

bitchass cat killed me twice

[twin loom]

Wait until it tries to attack and then enter dead eye and unleash all bullets on its head. Don’t turn you back, what I did is back up to wall and get a full view of the cave.

[novel path]

damn game stole my hat after visiting hours mission.... it was on my head, comfortable and shade-granting, then after the mission arthur plays with his gamblers hat in the transition animation and my hat is just gone

never left a hat behind and this is how it ends

[red narwhal]

does john also get some type of ledger? does anyone know?

[tardy tiger]

lumbago

[fading sleet]

I’m stuck on sharpshooter eight, it’s to disarm three people in a row without reloading with the same weapon, some of the guides suggest the O’Driscoll‘s hideout, I shoot the one guy in the barn. I see him drop his rifle I leave I check I have one disarmed man, but then I come back and it recesses to zero before I can get a second.

Resets

[fading sleet]

I don’t think you ever actually lose a hat, even if you leave it behind, it should be on your horse or in the camp closet

[novel path]

it wasnt in the camp storage but I´ll check the horse to be sure

[fading sleet]

If it was part of a custom outfit that you’ve saved, just select that custom outfit again and it’ll be there

I’m still stuck on sharpshooter eight and I’m not sure what I’m doing that resets the account. I’ll try the Cornwall kerosene and tar because they all have long arm rifles, but I get one successful disarm, then the counter just goes back to zero and I’m not sure why.

[novel path]

it´s legit just gone, i´m pretty sure I looked at all hat-related submenus now I´ll just buy another one, though the principal of the matter still rubs me wrong

dont take my hat

[fading sleet]

I know it works with guns like if you swap out guns you don’t lose your gun when you find a random gun, as far as hats I usually just go with outfits that I think were cool, and if I do, we have a hat behind on a mission when I go toselect the outfit again it’s I don’t have to buy the hat again or the outfit again

I’m not sure what’s resetting the count for sharpshooter eight, like I’ll shoot one of the guys either O’Driscoll‘s or at the kerosene and oil guards, I see them drop their weapon and I know that I get a plus one and I check and there’s a plus one on the counterso I’ll leave and then come back and in the counter is back to zero

Oh dear eye causes a reload? Hmm

Apparently, the Maxim gun at the 3 dog ranch can work for this if you sneak in and there’s enough O’Driscoll’s alive to shoot because you’re not reloading the maximum gun you’re just constantly firing more bullets

Or poison arrows people just get poisoned and then drop their weapon. I’m gonna try that first.

[novel path]

or do it without deadeye

[fading sleet]

Yeah I got it finally

Next is shoot 3 hats on the same dead eye

[delicate solstice]

.Spoiler. I saw many videos that they kill micah with other weapons. But is it possible without mods? Anyone know?

Like axe and etc

Even arrows

[fading sleet]

Do you mean during American venom

[delicate solstice]

Yeah

[fading sleet]

I don’t think you can. I don’t think the story will let you, at least you’re not supposed to.

[delicate solstice]

Ok thx

[fading sleet]

I’m trying to do sharp shooter number nine, but I can’t get off three shots on the same dead eye yet, I think you have to get a certain way in the story mission before you get better at the dead eye

That’s annoying, I wanted to see how far I could get in chapter 2

[frosty sedge]

Is reposting media allowed?

I found something on Reddit I'd like to repost, I'm not the original creatir

[hidden moss]

Guys does someone has same problem or had with western stranger trophy i have in progress 10 strangers but in second playtrough i had only 8 and its stuck on it

[formal crag]

i think so yea

[weary harness]

no it works

it is a bit more difficult though

[weary harness]

It's best to try this out at Saint Denis as the lawman have large hats there. Basically what you wanna do is wait till three of them are a far distance from you, and then mark the very top of their heads in dead eye using a DB shotgun. The shotgun bullets will scatter and most likely shoot their hats off without killing them. But still, make sure hard save your game right before attempting because you can fail a lot of times.

You might gain a bounty though 😅

[fading sleet]

It does not let me tag more than 2 tags at this point

I’ll check again

[graceful tide]

whenever i get in the mission with lenny and hes about to go to shady belle and it says take cover

i do take cover but the idiot lenny just stares at the wall

so i'm soft locked

and whenever i try to restart checkpoint its infinite

and no version.dll isnt installed

what should i do

[graceful tide]

okay, turns out the "no weapon straps" mod, which has a "weapons,ymt", was the reason why it wasnt working. apologies for the rant

[weary harness]

oh sorry

not DB shotgun

a different shotgun with more ammo capacity

[jovial phoenix]

you eat babies

[timber glacier]

does somebody here plays in ps5?

[timber glacier]

its so if somebody can like pass me the game or game share it with me hmmm u probably dont trust me and i get it i can share an acc with minecraft, fc 25 etc

but i really need the game and i would appriciate if u dm me

[last prairie]

Just went and found all the Graves, went up one whole percent

[frosty sedge]

What do I do with prisoners I caught??

check red dead media for pic

I bring him to sheriff but they're just ignoring me

[mystic condor]

I accidentally started the final mission and my horse ain’t fully bonded yet and there are tons of stuff I wanted to do with Arthur 😭

[plucky shuttle]

Guys I firstly installed script hook, version dll to mod the game a little bit, now i want the red dead offline mod to het navy revolver but it says to get ocu, now how do i replace version dll with ocu cuz version dll i just put it in game file directory same as script hook and other smaller script mods

[plucky shuttle]

That sucks did u have a save becuz i had one after my last boy

[main linden]

chat how do you make naked arthur

like shirtless

[mystic condor]

Yeah but it’s really far back and I don’t even have my horse then

[paper osprey]

mods

don’t think you can in the base game

[main linden]

aw

[light gorge]

im just above the D in cumberland forest and have found the moonshiners and i cant find any tobacco plants there what do i do

[brave sphinx]

for grays secret i picked up the letter but i couldn't inspect the body

how do i fix this

[ionic juniper]

I don't want to kill the wolves in the game but they attack

[weary harness]

is it because you dont want to kill your own kind 🐺 🗣️

[weary harness]

it gets so fucking hard sometimes

[light gorge]

ive very much getting sick of the oregano

[weary harness]

the moonshiners always spawn in the places where the herbs dont exist 😭

[light gorge]

all this activity has done has made me realise how low on herbs ive been

i just had to shoot a wolf that was chasing some poor wild horse whilst searching for tobacco

and i just found tobacco!

[ionic juniper]

I show mercy when they are wounded

I guess I wouldn't be a hunter in real life so lol

[vestal crystal]

Kill them kill them all

They ALWAYS spawn when i need to be quiet and precise

[blissful crane]

since rdo randomly got a new content update, would rockstar actually be working on a current gen port rn

all i need is 60 fps dynamic resolution with vrr or 4k 40 fps

vrr makes everything better

[vestal crystal]

Tf is vrr

[blissful crane]

variable refresh rate

basically constantly changes your monitors refresh rate to match the fps

preventing screen tears and whatnot

makes lower frames feel way smoother than without

[vestal crystal]

Oh thats cool

[blissful crane]

yeah it's a standard for most modern monitors and tvs

[ionic juniper]

I used almost all the horses in the game and when I was attacked by wolves, all the horses threw me off

[blissful crane]

just spam calm button

itll buy you time before your horse inevitably bucks you

my dark bay turkoman never bucked me off unless it's an alligator, cougar or panther

he dont gaf about gun fights and wolves as long as i keep calming him

[ionic juniper]

I'm using dark bay turkoman and silver or gold looks too absurd

The Andalusian horse is said to be the bravest horse, but I don't believe it, you just need to spam the calm down button as you said

And 4 levels of bonding

John Marston:Run Heifer Moo

[main linden]

wdym they're the worst animal in the game

when I want to hunt them, they cease to exist for some reason

and when I was just strolling through cumberland, I got jumped by 4 of them

[wide pike]

What should i do with the two Aberdeens?

[brave trench]

Here y'all

I'm new to rdr2

Do you guys recommend that I play the story first before online?

[vapid mulch]

Hello new to rdr2
I'm A Shadowy Friend

[brave trench]

Hello A Shadowy Friend Nice meeting you

[vapid mulch]

Say you not new to rdr2

[brave trench]

I have played an hour or so

[vapid mulch]

That joke went over you didn't it?

[brave trench]

I don't get it I'm slow

[ionic juniper]

Gambler 8

[thorny peak]

i just walked in on abigail and susan having an argument and susan said "we all have to earn our supper" to which she answered i aint doin that no more did she just tell abigail to go back to prostitution?

[hidden moss]

[winter moat]

Guys I just wanted to say:

I completed Gambler 8

[civic zodiac]

any1 here who can give me roadmap on rdr2 all achievments?

[uncut crag]

congrats dude

[ionic juniper]

Gambler challenges are all about luck

I wonder who designed Gambler 8

[noble fractal]

It’s like they be wanting us to get a gambling addiction irl

[ionic juniper]

There is maybe a 20% chance of winning by hitting 3 cards in the game

I sat at the table to the right or left of the croupier, and when I got a high number, I got up directly from the table

otherwise a waste of time

[winter moat]

How hard is gambler 10 in comparison?

The herbalist challenges also look crazy af

[ionic juniper]

the same goes for gambler 9, he wants us to win the domino game 3 times without losing, when you realize you are going to lose, get up from the table and sit down again because it will reset

[ionic juniper]

It's crazy if you do it with Arthur

[noble fractal]

It’s possible with Arthur but barely and lowkey game breaking

[weary harness]

it seems almost impossible

[winter moat]

Why?

Yes I know what happens at the end but why

[noble fractal]

Arthur can’t go into Blackwater and the last herbs you need for herbalist 10 require you to go into Blackwater

I have watched a video of someone finding a workaround to the sniper in Blackwater for Arthur and ended up being able to complete all 90 challenges as him but it’s next to impossible

[winter moat]

Oh wow. There goes my dream of just 100% the game as Arthur

I realized I also had to stop at the dinosaur bone quest

[hidden moss]

Hey

You said you wanted all 90 challenges and 100% as Arthur?

I can help you

It's easy tbh

[hidden moss]

I have found a workaround

It's easy to do and it's the EASIEST method by far to get everything in new Austin

No buggy method

No carrying animal method

It's very easy

I have already got all of the 3 Legendary Animals in new Austin as Arthur

In Chapter 2

[ionic juniper]

ı think

Legend of the East outfit john is a special outfit

I guess that's why some of the plants in the New Austin area

[ionic juniper]

There is a glitch steal a small horse carriage with a closed back, then change the camera settings and the sniper can't shoot you

When collecting the plant, you must take it without seeing Arthur's head or body or the sniper will shoot you

[noble fractal]

You cant visit all the graves as Arthur

[weary harness]

oh yeah because he's one of them lol

and susan

therefore its not possible because susan and arthur die in the same mission

i think thats the only graves he cant visit

[winter moat]

As most as I could but it’s not that serious I don’t want to glitch it

[winter moat]

Too much work bruh

I’ll consider it if I do everything I can and it seems reasonably doable

But I just want all the achievements lowkey, just rather do most of it with Arthur that’s all

[thorny peak]

how do i get pearsons rabbit item request i want his jacket

[arctic musk]

talk to him while hes cooking i drained my stamina and deadeye easily first which is required, the stamina and dead eye cores need to be red

[thorny peak]

im so confused some ppl say cores dont matter other say they do

[arctic musk]

they do matter

i think you need atleast 2 and these are the easiest

[thorny peak]

alr well ill let you know if it worked

[arctic musk]

alright

[thorny peak]

btw any specific time?

[noble fractal]

I’ve heard in the morning but I’ve never tried it myself so I can’t confirm

[heady inlet]

Does anyone know if the gilded cage tuxedo glitch still works

[barren grotto]

so what's the deal with hats. If I pick up a random hat, can I save it to my character somehow?

[hidden moss]

Hi

[cyan pendant]

Real quick do hats the glowing ones save even if your out of space?

[hidden moss]

Not at all,dm me for more

[languid parcel]

i just use mods to get that outfit

much better not wasting time

[arctic musk]

morning-evening something like that

[arctic musk]

you cant use npc hats

[arctic musk]

im not sure what you mean with glowing but i think so

[ionic juniper]

No ridgewood harm yes ridgegold harm

[arctic musk]

i beat rdr1 today so peak

nearly as good as rdr2

[lapis sable]

So today, i decide to roam about Ambarino using a headless corpse with all limbs being shot off via explosive bullets...

On the back on my horse

Cant believe how much am I getting reported

[thorny peak]

i got it i didnt need to have any cores drained you just kinda gotta wait for the right moment

[lethal urchin]

hiya guys looking to buy a horse, what does the horsie circle symbol mean?

[arctic musk]

thats weird

but im glad it worked

[arctic musk]

what do you mean?

[lethal urchin]

when u show info on a horse, there is stamina, health and some other circle

idk what that last one is

[arctic musk]

i think the bonding

[ionic juniper]

You are probably referring to the brush icon that shows how dirty the horse is or not.

[lethal urchin]

its a symbol of a horse

[lethal urchin]

and is that how bonded we are or how easy it is to bond?

[arctic musk]

the bonding level it is

it would make sense because there is 4 bars

[thorny peak]

does bandit 5 have to be in one state or not?

[amber trellis]

Do y'all have some goddamn faith

[obsidian palm]

Hi guys, is it possible to modify a file somewhere in the game so that the dogs bark less frequently ? Thanks !

[olive hazel]

I keep seeing the wolf. What does that mean? Is my honor too low?

[arctic musk]

yeah

[crystal nova]

Wsggg people

[sage gale]

Should i get 100% in rdr1 too?

You will choose my faith

[sage gale]

Yeah only one

If you already have 250 in a state just step foot in it and the challenge should pop

[arctic musk]

yeah i think it takes like 50 hours if you start from nothing

[sage gale]

Oh okay then ill do it

Thats like

3 days of playing😭

I have NO plans until 29th so

Waiting for my bestfriend to get his license so we can do our sidequeats

[last prairie]

Its taken me quite a while to get to 87%, but i think it's possible if you're straight grinding and not messing around like I do

[ionic juniper]

What is your favorite gang horse

[sage gale]

Either bill or dutches

[grave musk]

Definitely Dutch

Bill’s looks modded lol

[keen flume]

Anyone here interested in finding the hidden ritual ?

[opal lava]

How do I find those dinosaur bones for that lady

Would there be a weird patch of dirt on the ground or something?

[weary harness]

dont worry ambarino is a very empty state

just don't show the native americans

[tough isle]

Hey guys I got myself the white Arabian with a beaver roping saddle. The Schofield revolver, Lancaster repeater and then semi auto shotgun can I proceed w the story missions in chapter 2

[main linden]

get the panther trail saddle it's the best

but it looks awkward on an arabian

[fading sleet]

Honestly, there’s a number of horses I like better than Arabian, less skittish around snakes and alligators. Thoroughbred, Mustang, also the shire horse that hosea gives you instead of selling it just keep it

[tough isle]

What horse do I get

[fading sleet]

Hosea gives you a free one in chapter 2, it’s a Shire and it’s quite good

When you hunt a bear with him, you first go to the horse shop

[tough isle]

Oh yea the more expensive one?

[fading sleet]

That shire horse will ask you until the end of the game, no, it’s completely free

Hosea gives it to you and suggest you sell it and buy a new horse

[tough isle]

Oh that one I don’t think I have that I sold it

[fading sleet]

Instead of selling it just stable it. Get it to level four bonding, a panther saddle.

There’s a number of horses I would suggest, the Arabians are good, but a bit skittish. I like Mustang and thoroughbred, also the Hungarian half breed.

Get them good equipment and literally any horse can be good

The Panther saddle is quite good for recovering endurance

[tough isle]

Alr I’ll get that saddle

[fading sleet]

You need a perfect panther skin, and you have to craft it, just sell it to the trapper and then you can buy the panther saddle

[main linden]

anybody know how to do survivalist 7?

that shi pisses me off

[idle garnet]

I dunno i'm new

Fuck micah

[lapis sable]

I did tho!

Figured they need more meat in their diets 🤡

[fading sleet]

I’m trying to catch the legendary fish and I’m stuck on the musky by Van Horn, there’s a lot of musky fish, and I only catch the regular ones which are already huge, I have no way to identify the legendary musky. How exactly am I supposed to spot the legendary musky?

I use the special lake lure because the regular fish are supposed to avoid it, but I still catch regular muskies.

[waxen sierra]

Use special river lure and if you go on hunting mode while fishing legendary fish kinda growing ✨️ different than regular fish

[quaint wren]

aaagggghhhhhhh okay just finished another playthrough and I fear it’s time to attempt best in the west, skin deep and zoologist (perhaps gold rush, though I only have 10% on that (7 golds))

wish me luck in hell everybody

also gonna go bountiful in my next game

[weary harness]

i like to push them into campfires

because they're mean to me

[lapis sable]

I wish i can shoot the indians too

[weary harness]

you're gonna get banned

[lapis sable]

From where

[weary harness]

twitter

i also wanna shoot the saint denis kids

[lapis sable]

Damn, see I ain't done nothing wrong, aside from not play the games to their rules.

[weary harness]

its okay you can shoot them in rdr1

[lapis sable]

Cochinay aye

[weary harness]

as they're dutch's men

[weary harness]

our time has passed john

i wish arthur was gay

[lapis sable]

Damn me getting bounty hunters every 5 mins or so of freeroam

[weary harness]

we could have gay arthur drunk lines

[lapis sable]

In every state

[weary harness]

same bro

[lapis sable]

I didnt bother to pay my bounty

[weary harness]

ambarino took a long time

its like 7500

too much

[lapis sable]

I just kill enough so i get 7500 and more

Then i pay all if i get bored

[weary harness]

when i became john

i never left WE or NA

[lapis sable]

Damn i wanna go to mexico canon

In rdr2

[weary harness]

honestly

but it will never happen

[lapis sable]

Imagine a 6th state for me to be the legend shooter of the west

[weary harness]

technically its a whole other country

[lapis sable]

Someone should recreate rdr1 into rdr2

[weary harness]

yes

[fading sleet]

You can add mods to RDR one to make it look like RDR2

[weary harness]

AAA

no mods

you get banned

[fading sleet]

Graphic mods

You don’t get banned

[weary harness]

its in the rules of this server

[lapis sable]

I dont see anything wrong as long as it is singleplayer

[fading sleet]

Also, it doesn’t change the fundamentals of the game. It just improves the graphics.

[weary harness]

rule 15

[fading sleet]

But it looks like you’re playing RDR 2 with the RDR one game

[weary harness]

yeah

[lapis sable]

Oh ye in rdr1 you can skin dogs and horses

[weary harness]

i had to skin my kentucky horse

[lapis sable]

Can i skin my MFT

[weary harness]

mft is in rdr1

the dark horse

[lapis sable]

Haha

Imagine horse pelts and meat in rdr1 having breed types

Arabian, the wagyu of the wild west

[fading sleet]

I finally got the legendary musky

[keen ice]

I just got the unknown error FFFFFF crash and I logged back on to be reset to the beginning of the game

can someone help me?

[weary harness]

W

i love rdr hunting because i can shoot the animals 100000 times with a shotgun and it wont affect the quality or anything

[lapis sable]

Actually, I like rdr2 hunting more

[weary harness]

but bobcats!

[lapis sable]

Quality of the pelts/meat matters

[lapis sable]

Ye i wish bobcats are in rdr2

[main linden]

chat I'm near owanjila is the chestnut arabian worth it?

[arctic musk]

i think i might be able to do most of it without a tutorial

i beat story in like 28 hours and ive earned so so much money in the open world

[junior horizon]

im having this problem where i cant gain honor i dunno if i can even loose honor

[arctic musk]

why do you think that?

[junior horizon]

because i tested it i do a high honor thing and it does the honor gain thing on the right but it dosent actually move the honor bar

[arctic musk]

the honor bar goes up every 40 honor points

[haughty sable]

The in-game pictures that I take with my camera in the game.
Where do they end up in my computer?

[urban geyser]

yes

[arctic musk]

rockstar social club is where you can find them press the home button on your keyboard

[junior horizon]

ive done a few more things to increase my honor and its still not going up

ive done the right thing for almost ever event ive come across (donate "accept" etc)

[ionic juniper]

What is the location with the highest number of snakes

[idle garnet]

I need help guys

I was going with my horse, when suddenly I passed by the house of the father who argues with his son, what do I do in that part? Do I shoot the father?

[modest raft]

so iirc you can either donate the father 100$ or get him the woods but I dont know about the wood part since I got lost there.

wait in 1899 or 1907?

[main linden]

woods and lemoyne

[modest raft]

How do I get special river lure for fishing im in chapter 2

[main linden]

go to lagras

near saint denis

and buy a bait

[modest raft]

A guy sells it?

[main linden]

a woman

yes

[modest raft]

Alright ty

[main linden]

chat what's the best way to kill mr compson

[idle garnet]

1899

[modest raft]

you can donate 100$ but if I can remember it didnt gave me any honor

[idle garnet]

There is a parent who argues with his son who is "old" enough to leave the house, and you as Arthur can enter the house

[modest raft]

Wait does the father ask you for woods?

I might be mixing up with something else

[haughty sable]

Thank you very much.

[ionic juniper]

when using a bow, it shakes a lot, is there any way to reduce this, I have a hard time hunting snakes

[winter moat]

Any tips on gambler 9

[idle garnet]

Nope

[arctic musk]

glad i could help

[quasi knot]

Somebody alive XD

[lapis sable]

Yes

[thorny peak]

does the "pony up" achievement (spend 5000 dollars across all shops) go through save files?

[arctic musk]

most achievements mean on 1 save file

or all

[ionic juniper]

At 2/3 I started to feel it getting harder and then I tried again

when you know you are going to lose, get up from the table and sit down again do not close the game otherwise the challenge will be reset

[arctic musk]

replay a fine night of debauchery, finish it, replay who is not without sin, and go all in playing poker, finish the mission

no rng way to do it

[ionic juniper]

the shark tooth trinket didn't do much for me

it helps to make your bonding level with the horse faster, this value is only 10%

It should be at least 20%

[peak hollow]

[thorny peak]

guys what should i name my dutch warmblood sooty buckskin (female) i know that boadicea is a historic figure because of her rebellion against the romans which i think fits arthur very well so something along the lines of that

rn im thinking Clementine because i like TWDG even tho it has nothing to do with history

[weak cliff]

yo

guys tell me something to do i completed the game but its so boring now

[thorny peak]

did you complete the story or 100%

[old walrus]

chat does anyone got the glock 18 mod

[arctic musk]

yeah thats nice

[weak cliff]

story

[thorny peak]

do the challenges theyre really fun (sometimes)

[weak cliff]

ok

its no fun playing as jogn

john

i just love arthur

[thorny peak]

i feel you man i feel you

[cosmic tendon]

can someone help me, I cant buy ammo from the gunsmith catalogue whenever I hold the buy button (enter key) nothing happens. I try to restock at camp and pick up the ammo but still I have no ammo in almost any of my guns. im a new player

I also have mods

[jovial phoenix]

i just finished the epilogue again

[normal snow]

At least you can do the best part of the game which is hearing the house building song.

[weak cliff]

lol

[woven kernel]

oh man, Arthur just got TB 😦

I knew something was coming, just didnt know what

I guess getting to Austin is the compensation for dealing with that?

[ionic juniper]

Arthur didn't have to die

rdr and rdr2 both have similar endings

For some reason rockstar likes to do that

[gray mesa]

it was for the drama

[ionic juniper]

of course

[woven kernel]

I tried not to read too much here but couldnt avoid knowing he dies

made me sad but as soon as he went to the doctor and heard he had TB I knew time was short

😦

I dont really want to play as anyone else

[opal lava]

Could someone tell me how to find the dinosaur bones for that woman

Please

[arctic musk]

you need to use an interactive map website

[opal lava]

Fr?

[arctic musk]

yeah because it'll be like impossible to find it yoursel

[opal lava]

🥀

[wild idol]

I just figured out the extinct bison mechanic

[arctic musk]

on rdr1?

[wild idol]

rdr2

wait wdym rdr1?

[arctic musk]

rdr1 you can extinct bison in rdr2 its parakeet

[pulsar shadow]

Hello

[ionic juniper]

rdr2map was very useful for horseman 10

[golden kraken]

Has anyone completed the entire compendium?

[wooden lagoon]

I’m doing gambler 8 rn 😢

1/3 and it’s been 30 minutes

[urban geyser]

I got all 3 in 10 minutes lol

The trick is where if you get a bad hand, leave the game/stand up to reset it. For some reason it also makes your hand of cards smaller

[tacit reef]

Finally got the platinum

What a grind

Oh my god man

[urban geyser]

You did the rdo stuff??????

Yikes

[tacit reef]

I think rdo is fun so i didn't even focus on them or anything just had em already

[wooden lagoon]

Ok 🙏

[limber talon]

wheres the best place to find bears. i googled it, all the places to find them i have found 1/3. which wa the legendary bear.

how do i find the bears...

[weary harness]

there's one good spot in the forest in west elizabeth near hanging dog ranch

i'll show you in media

[winter moat]

Question. I’m trying to 100% rdr2. I’m doing pretty good so far, and I wanted to ask if it’s necessary at chapter 3 to care about honor level? Is honor level tied to some story missions?

(Trying to do bandit challenges and my honor is sinking rapidly)

[golden kraken]

does it matter if i get the legend of the east satchel in chapter 3?

[main linden]

it doesn't

I got it in chapter 2

[weary harness]

same

[weary harness]

only if you like the discounts, yes. but for chapter 3 i'd say don't really worry about it now. just make sure to fix it up during chapter 4 and get back to that white. also, if you need any help with the challenges let me know i'll be happy to help

[limber talon]

is there a way to get the poison arrows by buying them by any chance

im having a hard time getting cougars to die w just regular arrows so igoogled it n this dude killed it easily w poison arrows.

n if not how do u get the flight feathers, killed a bird, didnt get anything from it. soooo

even tho u can get it from any bird??? so uhm im not understanding

[weary harness]

no

[weary harness]

your satchel may be full of flight feathers already, consider getting an upgrade by seeing pearson at camp

[lapis sable]

The trick to winning gambling is get off the table, use your revolver and pop all of your tablemates, loot their shit.

[weary harness]

there's this one npc named hyram who i always battle in dominoes

we've faced each other in saint denis and emerald ranch

[weary harness]

i did this with the guy who took $50 from me in poker

[lapis sable]

Yeeeee

Oh while i am at it, i shoot every witness too

[weary harness]

i was in the saint denis saloon

[lapis sable]

More loot! More money!

[weary harness]

[trim hamlet]

[lapis sable]

Because killing animals for profit in one shot is kinda slow

Killing people is faster

[bronze basalt]

Hii

[lapis sable]

It is super fun to outgun the law

[winter radish]

Anyone know where to find the splashed white American Paint

Wanted to get John something

[lapis sable]

After all, we are not citizens. We are outlaws. And outlaws are...

[weary harness]

dutch should've said that

[weary harness]

its very rare it can only be found at npc camps

[winter radish]

Oh damn

[weary harness]

there is a beach in the heartlands

sometimes there is a camp there

[winter radish]

Idk if anyone kinda cares but if you want horses that Arthur can't get until the Epilogue I know a location, but it's on a certain patch

[winter radish]

👍

[weary harness]

which horse?

[winter moat]

Guys I need help bad. I tried to replay a mission for gold and my game is stuck on the menu (not frozen because I see birds flying) but I haven’t saved in like 2 hours

[weary harness]

there is no way to fix it except for closing the game

[winter radish]

Javier's horse, Hosea's horse, Trelawney's horse and much more

[weary harness]

really?

[winter radish]

If I want I can show some pics

[weary harness]

yeah go #general-media

[winter radish]

K

Gotta load the save rq

[winter moat]

I’m screwed. Why does that happen?

That’s a crazy ass bug

[weary harness]

yeah

[winter radish]

Check general media @weary harness

[weary harness]

okay

[lapis sable]

A shotgun never fails to pop heads

Or sever limbs

[weary harness]

rare shotgun

[fading sleet]

Use your auto save?

I’m trying to do these legendary fish, I’ve caught three of them so far. But I seem to be stuck anytime a fish tries to take a nibble, the Hook fish option will flash for a split second, but then they stop nibbling and I can’t seem to catch anything.

I’m clearly doing something wrong. I’ve tried switching up the special lure . I’ve checked videos to make sure I’m standing in the exact correct location.

[limber talon]

no it isnt. i checked the crafting n it says i dont have any.

[weary harness]

what birds are you killing

[limber talon]

i don't remember since i got off because i raged 🥲

i got angry at cougars

[winter radish]

Anyone have information on where the wild bay mustang is

[weary harness]

rio bravo

south

i think its southeast of fort mercer

[winter radish]

I think it's in the Great Plains sometimes, and The Heartlands, thats what someone told me, I'll check Rio Bravo cause I haven't had any luck

[weary harness]

wait wait

my bad

i thought you meant tiger striped bay

[winter radish]

No

[weary harness]

@winter radish i last saw one at cornwall kerosene and tar

[winter radish]

I'm talking about the one that looks like a mule

[winter radish]

Kk

Damn gotta go all the way back

[winter radish]

What do you need for Herbalist 9?

[weary harness]

every single herb

including orchids

[winter radish]

Damn

I might be able to help

[weary harness]

and 4 of those are in new austin

making it almost impossible to complete as arthur

[winter radish]

Have you finished the story?

Just wondering

There might be another way

[winter radish]

Let me dm you some tips

If that's cool

[weary harness]

yeah

shoot

[orchid girder]

Hola

[fading sleet]

There are some useful videos on YouTube for herbalist number nine. Trying to get the ones in new Austin and Mexico can be difficult as Arthur, while it is possible. It’s also time-consuming. You would need either a covered wagon to block the sniper or carry a pronghorn on your back to block the sniper.

I got a couple of the herbs in Mexico and then gave up as it just got to be too time-consuming

It’s super easy as John though because there’s no more sniper

[winter radish]

I've already done Herbalist 9 for Arthur

With a certain glitch

That's now patched sadly

[weary harness]

wait mexico

do you mean rdr1 herbalist 9

[fading sleet]

No, I’m talking about RDR two, I thought there were a few in new Austin as well as one or two in Mexico.

It doesn’t let me post YouTube links here

[weary harness]

well mexico isnt in rdr2 so just new austin

[fading sleet]

I put up the link in the general media section

[weary harness]

okay

genuinely confused though because you mentioned mexico

[junior horizon]

chat can someone recap the first rdr1 story?

[blissful crane]

uhh man gets his family kidnapped by the BOI, forced to hunt down his old friends and gang members to get his family and freedom back, he gets lied to and dies

[junior horizon]

whos the "boi"

i love how in both games the character you play as ends up dying

jst chugged 3 hair tonics i expect a thick beard within 1 hour

[weary harness]

Bureau of Investigation which is now known as the FBI

but before it was called BOI

[eternal estuary]

It’s like TLOU

[weary harness]

no its not

the second game protagonist doesnt die

[mortal tusk]

Is there any way to reset the story without losing ur progress? I kinda didn't pay attention to chapters 1-2

[main linden]

everybody who lives in rdr2 fucking dies

[blissful crane]

you can replay each individual mission in the game one by one

[blissful crane]

what about pearson

he's probably chillin in rhodes or left

[main linden]

not everyone

[blissful crane]

charles and sadie etc

[mortal tusk]

How

[blissful crane]

sadie might have died because she thinks of pursuing a violent career in mexico

but we don't see her in rdr1 so either she died or left long ago

[mortal tusk]

Yall should make 2 channels one for rdr1 one for 2

[blissful crane]

story section in main menu

[mortal tusk]

Oki ty

[bronze basalt]

.

[lapis sable]

I will not kill pearson

And i wont rob him either

I'll still shoot up all of rhodes tho

[fading sleet]

It takes a lot more than three tonics. Probably several dozen total to get to 10 hair and beard.

[fading sleet]

I think most people are playing RDR two, but a separate channel for the first game would be a good idea. If red dead revolver ever gets a remake or re-release, that should get a separate channel as well.

[mortal tusk]

Yeah but the category is called rdr2 and if someone who hasn't played rdr1 like me comes here and sees rdr1 stuff they'll get spoiled

[cunning ether]

He's a rat dutch

Guys prove to me that you've played rdr2 in one sentence

[junior horizon]

"AUGH Broke the God Damn wheel"

[cunning ether]

Awesome

I have one for rdr1 YOU EAT BABIES!

[fading sleet]

“I didn’t realize I was talking to a lady”

[fading sleet]

Berries!

[weary harness]

sadie didnt think of going to mexico she thought of going to south america

so like brazil or argentina

[cunning ether]

No it's babies

[cunning ether]

Awesome

[ionic juniper]

I'm tired of shooting bottles and making money 🤠

[blissful crane]

even with lowest honor john, robbing pearson is off the list

shoot up the entire town then buy a few tonics from him and leave

[lapis sable]

We dont own the man that rob pearson or kill him

[blissful crane]

imagine doing that to a man that literally kept you alive

maybe his food was shit but it kept them going everyday

is it bad that i have 1500 in saint denis and bounties in the hundreds as highest honor arthur

[blissful crane]

guido's men tried to gang up on me and it ended with me slaughtering the entire police force of saint denis

[ionic juniper]

Saint Denis NPCs:what is your problem

[frosty sedge]

I hunted down 4 perfect beavers where the fuck are they?????

Like they're not on my horse anymore and can't find them in the inventory either

My compendium also went backwards...

Few species I already discovered are not discovered now

[midnight ocean]

did you load an old save

[frosty sedge]

no, I once died to bounty hunters and did some fast travel

[midnight ocean]

if you die you lose pelts that are on your horse

[lapis sable]

I have no remorse in drive by shooting of people in the roads! Like damn! Move! Get out of my way!

[winter moat]

Is it easy to go from bad to good honor in chapter 4?

[arctic musk]

with fishing yeah

it'll take like 40 minutes idk

ive heard 90 fish you release back into the water

[viral ingot]

Fishing gives honor?

[woven kernel]

Sadie dies?????
I gotta stop coming here

[wide pike]

Yo

After Fussar's island

do i get back my weapons and money?

last time i played that chapter it was 2 yrs ago

After Goodbye infernal paradise

[arctic musk]

yeah

[arctic musk]

no she doesnt

[arctic musk]

yeah

[wide pike]

Thanks

[urban geyser]

#1. No. and even IF it is true (it isnt), id still say no
#2. you do

[lapis sable]

Just walk around town for a few rounds greeting people

[arctic musk]

fishing worked better for me

[weary harness]

YES

yes

fishing + greeting is preferrable

[main linden]

why is it always raining when I'm doing a dry run

[weary harness]

hey silverware how'd survivalist 7 go

[main linden]

no

[weary harness]

[main linden]

soon

[weary harness]

are you doing horsman 9

i HATE

it

[main linden]

6