red-dead-singleplayer

[crude shadow]

*9

Read all dat

[sage gale]

breaking bad sot player no way

[crude shadow]

Hating

[sage gale]

what hating

i have 800 hour sot and seen better call and breaking bad twice

and el camin

[ionic juniper]

Do most people play the game in epilouge?

[sage gale]

the epilogue is really good

always do it

[ionic juniper]

I saved the game in Chapter 4 or 5, I think I accidentally deleted it

I like Arthur better, but John is not bad either

[languid hemlock]

hey

rdr2 is trash

play robloxxx

arthur diesss

[pine cedar]

This is of no surprise to anyone in this discord

And if RDR2 is trash why are you here

[languid hemlock]

rdr1 better my opinion

story wised

[pine cedar]

Valid opinion but why the rest of it

[languid hemlock]

and baased on the time rdr1 as released

hey real echo whats ur feetfindr?

[pine cedar]

Don’t have one

Don’t even know what it is but I can guess

[languid hemlock]

u sure?

[pine cedar]

Positive

[naive gale]

Can I blow cougars up with arrows for the hunting challenge

[languid hemlock]

no the carcass will be poor

real echo'

[naive gale]

the challenge just says to kill them with a bow and skin them

[languid hemlock]

add me on ps

[pine cedar]

So I’d assume you could do that yeah

[languid hemlock]

play_bott998

[pine cedar]

I mean try it why not

[naive gale]

cool those cats are gonna eat shit

[languid hemlock]

but why will the cats eat ur shit

the are non veg

[pine cedar]

I’ll give you this you are a top tier waffler

[languid hemlock]

yayyyyy

[languid hemlock]

add mee

on ps

[frosty sedge]

how do i distinguish side quests from main story??

im on chapter 2 so new to the open world

are letters with yellow background main story? does the order of completing them matter?

[sly zodiac]

If it has yellow on the icon it is main story I believe

If it's white its a side mission

[twin loom]

Everybody always talks about animals decomposing, but did you know fish can too?

[naive gale]

I smell it in the break room at work I'm very aware unfortunately

[dark anchor]

where can i see the monthly or weekly bonuses like 2x exp or smth?

[hidden moss]

How old are you bro

[tawny valley]

LMAO

[hidden moss]

Why molly defender

[tawny valley]

because i like her a lot and also she did not do a thing wrong. not once in her life

[hidden moss]

Thats what i mean, what are u defending 😭

[tawny valley]

you would be surprised at the level of people who hate on molly 😭

[hidden moss]

Why would they hate

[languid parcel]

why does everyone hate her???

I just felt bad for her getting used by dutch

[paper osprey]

she doesn’t contribute anything to camp

uh oh

oh no

i take it back

[tawny valley]

:)

[languid parcel]

she used to be rich with her family but she left it all to live with dutch

[naive gale]

molly was done dirty

[languid parcel]

ikk

[tawny valley]

she doesnt contribute because its implied dutch actively encourages her NOT to

its an extremely common manipulation and abuse tactic to isolate and love bomb

[languid parcel]

why would she even contribute??? her lover was a leader

[tawny valley]

why would she have to do anything if shes “”dutchs girl”” after all?

that type shit

anyway i dont know but a lot of people DO hate her and it sucks

[languid parcel]

i dont

hate her

[tawny valley]

she was just a girl who got used. her story is SAD

[languid parcel]

ik

[tawny valley]

theres also a lot of people that did not have their listening ears on and claim she ratted the gang out

(she didnt)

(milton outright SAYS she didnt)

[languid parcel]

Ik

[autumn lynx]

those people who say that are insane like bro were you not paying attention?😭🙏

[tawny valley]

I KNOW IT MAKES ME SO MAD

[solid badge]

@languid parcel we Are Arthur

@willow axle you too

Every Arthur here is Arthur

[pine cedar]

You aren’t Arthur you’re Micah

It legit says so on your name

“Arthur Morgan’s #1 hater”

[solid badge]

thay gave me this SHITTY name

If i would be Micah, why i would have a profile pic of Arthur???

[pine cedar]

Idk irony maybe

[solid badge]

NO

I FUCKING love Arthur

[pine cedar]

If you really love Arthur answer this

What were his parents names

No google

[solid badge]

Ok

Ok now i will say their names

Lyle morgan

And Beatrice morgan

[pine cedar]

Correct

[smoky halo]

she didnt rat

she was drunk

[tawny valley]

i know, thats what my message was saying lol

[frosty sedge]

how big of an impact do taa and fxaa have? should I leave them on at all times??

[solid badge]

Micah was rafting bc he spread the gangs base at the police, that goddamn bastard

[smoky halo]

fuck micah

[solid badge]

Forever my friend

[smoky halo]

anti aliasing in red dead looks shit

and off it looks even shittier

[frosty sedge]

I know but I heard taa was meant to be on by default so turning it off might cause glitches?

[smoky halo]

im not sure i just kept taa high all game

but i also used nvidia dlaa

made it look a bit better

[solid badge]

I have a goddamn question

[frosty sedge]

should I complete all side missions before moving on with story missions or theyre available later as well?

[solid badge]

1. how to activate spoiler

[smoky halo]

many side missions r missable

[frosty sedge]

okay thx

[solid badge]

I have a spoiler question

[frosty sedge]

ya cant

spoiler seems to be blocked my mods

[solid badge]

Shit ok

[frosty sedge]

idk why

but its || text + another set of those

[smoky halo]

whats spoiler

[solid badge]

Censure some words

[frosty sedge]

2x'|' spoiler 2x'|'

[smoky halo]

ah

[frosty sedge]

why they blocking some random shit

this is so stupid from the mods side

[solid badge]

Fr

[frosty sedge]

add picture perms to almost all chats (either earned by levels or linking steam) and dont block random shit like this

but then curse words arent blocked

crazy

can anybody tell me where do I sell stolen items?

and whats the best way to profit in story mode?

[obtuse pollen]

[frosty sedge]

currently on chapter 2 btw so maybe not everything is explored yet

[obtuse pollen]

If it works like that, it’s needed

[frosty sedge]

why though? preventing spoilers?

preventing spoilers by blocking spoilers which are meant to prevent that

[obtuse pollen]

Preventing slurs hiding under

[pine cedar]

You can’t spoiler block in this server for some reason

[frosty sedge]

ohh I see

that wouldnt work right?

it cant be

blacklist would be triggered

[pine cedar]

Tbf tho I don’t think you should be in this server if you don’t know the whole story bc you’re basically asking to be spoiled

I’d recommend completing the game first

[frosty sedge]

but there are dum dums like me who passed chapter 1 and now have entire open world and dont know what to do with it

because theres so many random stuff you can do which is no longer related to the linear story of chapter 1

[pine cedar]

What I recommend with that is legit just explore and see

That’s what I did in my first playthrough

I’ve completed the game countless times and only joined this server recently

[frosty sedge]

I have a funny screenshot I'd post here but I cant because of perms. I'll post to red-dead-media.

[reef nimbus]

i dont see my mask when i go to put it on in storymode when they rob the first train

[rugged meteor]

Prolly just a visual glitch

[reef nimbus]

so how do i fix it then

[pine cedar]

I have seen it

I take it you have no supplies at all

[pine cedar]

Usually to fix visual bugs requires a game restart

[reef nimbus]

i did but it still didnt work

btw if you want to talk go in small camp\

[pine cedar]

Can’t rn I’m watching a movie w family I’m just multitasking

But I can communicate here

[obtuse venture]

Hey can I join

[reef nimbus]

cool

yes

[obtuse venture]

Do I add you on ps

[reef nimbus]

cant im banned

but i can still play online

and im on pc rn

[obtuse venture]

Dang 8m on play station

[reef nimbus]

but we cant talk join small camp vc

[obtuse venture]

Ok

[frosty sedge]

got some from robbing

and also a $200 bounty

so not worth it lol

[pine cedar]

Use your bow to hunt game

[frosty sedge]

i do use my bow for hunting

but dunno what to do with animals except bringing them to camp

[pine cedar]

If you progress a little further you can do 2 things

• Sell pelt at Butchers in towns

• Cook the meat at a mobile camp anywhere in the wilderness

[frosty sedge]

where can I sell the extra horse I got?

got it from going to town with uncle

[pine cedar]

At a stables but only after a specific mission where you have to buy a horse

It’s called “Exit, Pursued by a bruised ego” and is given by Hosea

You may even have it available already

If you hover over missions on the world map you’ll be able to see the mission names

If you have a “HM” symbol that’s yellow on your map in camp that may be it

@frosty sedge

[frosty sedge]

not yet

but thanks

[pine cedar]

What main missions do u have available

Main missions will be yellow

[hidden moss]

Can someone help me with a question regarding the cigarette cards? 🚬

[frosty sedge]

uhh currently doing one in saloon

[pine cedar]

Ah that’s “Americans at rest” I believe

If you wanna get the stables soon after that mission do the mission given by Uncle in camp

It’ll be called “Polite society, Valentine style”

[frosty sedge]

does the order matter?

will it give me an obvious clue to advance chapter?

I wanna do some side quests too before advancing

[pine cedar]

No not particularly

[proper pier]

Man, Algernon's quest is so damn annoying 😭

[pine cedar]

You can do the missions in whatever order you want all I was saying is the way to get the stables

[lament jasper]

#red-dead-media here

[hidden moss]

Fr omg

[proper pier]

Idk why, but those damn herons and egrets are so difficult to find after starting it

[hidden moss]

Which items are you struggling with?

[proper pier]

I know where to find all the stuff

[frosty sedge]

got it

[hidden moss]

Egrets I see them everywhere,herons on the other hand..

[proper pier]

I never see egrets when I need them but the moment I no longer need them, they're everywhere 😭

[hidden moss]

You can go in the swamps, they're always there

[pine cedar]

@frosty sedge believe me it’ll be obvious when the chapters gonna end

[proper pier]

That's where I've been looking

[pine cedar]

You’ll notice a build up

[hidden moss]

Which swamp tho?

[proper pier]

I've looked all through bayou nwa, lakay, and lagras

[frosty sedge]

okay thx

[proper pier]

I've even searched around the area behind shady belle and around the train tracks north of Saint Denis

[pine cedar]

If you have any more questions feel free to ask I’m always happy to answer if I can

[rich solstice]

Hey Dutch

[proper pier]

Lenny...my boy

[pine cedar]

I’ve sent a friend request to so you can dm if necessary @frosty sedge

[rich solstice]

You left me to die 😞

[proper pier]

I'm sorry my son...I had no choice

[hidden moss]

Check dms because I can't send pictures here

[rich solstice]

Why couldn’t Micah go instead of me

[pine cedar]

Dutch has fallen for Micah’s lies Lenny

[frosty sedge]

do you know wheres the guy that gets bitten by the snake?

[proper pier]

Mr Bell is a fine man...but in that time...I wish he would've died instead of you

[pine cedar]

That’s a random event you can encounter in many different areas

[rich solstice]

Not in saint dennis 😞

[pine cedar]

You’ll just have to ride around

Also @frosty sedge just so you know spoilers are posted a lot in the server so just watch out

[frosty sedge]

now im on that mission with hosea

got me a new big black horse

bro this thing is huge

wtf

[barren grotto]

is there a way to search a horse's satchel without getting kicked in the head? I've tried everything I can think of. if I give too many pats, I end up taming the horse and its satchel disappears

[pine cedar]

Yeah now after that mission is complete you can sell horses to stables

[pine cedar]

Wdym exactly

[barren grotto]

Ok, I get attacked by Bounty Hunters. Kill them. I want to loot the saddlebag of their mount. But the horse will kick me. So I try to calm it down, and give it a pat or two, but I still get kicked. and if I pat the horse too much, it gets tamed, and you can't loot the saddlebag on a tamed horse

[pine cedar]

I don’t believe you even can loot their saddlebags

You can just loot the bounty hunters themselves

[noble valley]

I mean if you want the satchel the aggressive route is to just kill the horses but that brings down honor or only loot the bounty hunters and let the horses run off

[barren grotto]

You're mistaken

[tawny valley]

what? you can absolutely search saddle bags 😭

[pine cedar]

Oh I can’t say I ever have

[tawny valley]

in fact its where a lot of players get LOTS of gold nuggets

[noble valley]

Mhmmm

[tawny valley]

i wish i had advice for you friend but a lot of the time its up to luck 😭 i saw a few people saying that peppermint helps

[noble valley]

Yeah basically, that’s the easy route to not lose honor 😭

I can only wish you luck aswell

[pine cedar]

Tbf while I do always try to play high honor, losing honor early in the story isn’t the end of the world

[noble valley]

Mhmhmhm

[pine cedar]

Bc you have plenty of time to earn it back, sure store prices will be a bit worse depending but if it’s for endings C6 gives loads of opportunities for high honor

[noble valley]

So it’s really up to you @barren grotto whatever you do choose I wish you luck

[pine cedar]

So in C2 and 3 I’d say don’t worry too much abt honor, it’s only in C4 and beyond I’d say to start being more careful if u want high honor

[hasty sedge]

Bout to do my 20th playthrough of rdr2 🫦 (i never get tired of it)

[noble valley]

That’s so valid, I’ve played it about 23 times

[proper pier]

My friend told me Rdr isn't that fun yet he has 1600 hours on it 😭

[pine cedar]

I’ve just completed another playthrough myself

[hasty sedge]

Nice

[noble valley]

Never get tired of it for real

[hasty sedge]

Real wish guarma was playable 😔

[noble valley]

I agree on that, that’d be interesting 😭

[hasty sedge]

anywho

im gonna go back to playing rdr2

bye bye

[noble valley]

Have funnn

[pine cedar]

Funny thing is I’ve done like 20 Playthroughs of RDR2 myself yet I never knew you could loot saddle bags

Tbf never tried and the game never tells you so that’d be why

[noble valley]

Yeahhh, you learn new things every day when it comes to RDR2

[pine cedar]

I just thought of a gold nugget farm

As Arthur attempt to enter south West Elizabeth to the point it spawns lawmen and bounty hunters

Lure them to the edge of Big Valley and kill them, then loot safely in big valley

This will need to be tested

[noble valley]

Yesss

That does need to be tested

[hidden moss]

What does this have to do with gold nuggets?

You mean the Pinkertons?

I don't understand 🥲

[hidden moss]

Prolly all online

[tawny valley]

horses often have gold nuggets in their saddle bags

[proper pier]

Most likely

[hearty stirrup]

Hey handsome 👅

[proper pier]

Ahem, what?

[hearty stirrup]

Howdy

[gusty meadow]

gambler 9 is broken. it keeps losing progress even when i dont lose. i just 1 won and then won another and it says i only got 1 when i should be at 2. earlier i was at 2 and won my third and then it reset to 0

[barren grotto]

I did Gambler 9 two days ago-worked fine for me. Are you getting up from the table?

[sleek widget]

hi

i am new

[tawny valley]

i always get so irrationally angry when people capitalize/space dutchs name wrong

its Dutch van der Linde.

not Dutch Van Der Linde. not Vanderlinde. its Dutch van der Linde

[rich solstice]

Bro it’s not that serious 😭🙏

[tawny valley]

so irrationally angry

im aware brother

i’m not even actually mad lmao it’s just a pet peeve ig

[rich solstice]

dutch VanDerLinde

Lmaoo

Oh nothing 😭

[mild fog]

#red-dead-media does anyone know what mission this screenshot is from

It’s driving me NUTS

[golden kraken]

Has anyone seen the lemoyne raiders interaction where they are vandalizing Saint Denis city hall?

[proper pier]

I have a few times, I usually just shoot em and keep riding

[rich solstice]

I put 3k into the box how do we need more money 😕

[proper pier]

We just need more money son

[golden kraken]

Did anyone else just get lit up with a Gatlin gun outside Saint Denis?

[rich solstice]

Who’s we I’m dead 😑

[proper pier]

That Gatling gun got lit up by my deadeye

[rich solstice]

You and Arthur could’ve saved me 😞

[proper pier]

I'm sorry my boy

[rich solstice]

Picked me up too 😞

Keep me in the abandoned house until yall got back

[proper pier]

At least you and Hosea got buried together

[rich solstice]

Yea 😪

[rich solstice]

I think you meant to kill me 👿

Micah’s plan to 👿

[proper pier]

I didn't want anyone to die

Sean, Davey, Mac, Jenny, Kieran, Hosea, you, Molly, Miss Grimshaw, Arthur...I didn't want any of y'all to die

[rich solstice]

Kieran’s death was the worse 😭💔

[mild fog]

Fr tho Dutch gets too much hate tbh

Not saying he isn’t a bad person, he 100% is

But ppl who say he didn’t give a shit about anyone close to him is just wrong

[proper pier]

Dutch is honestly a perfectly written villain

He has a spiral into madness, you can tell he's insane, and you can see he has remorse in his eyes, it's just he can't stop himself

He knows he's too far gone

And in the first RDR, I like how his voice cracks a lot during his cutscenes

[rich solstice]

Micah when he found the body in the wagon vs blood lust dutch who’s winning

[hearty stirrup]

Dutch x Micah doomed yaoi💔

[proper pier]

I feel like they'll kill each other

Micah is definitely skilled but dutch is smarter

[mild fog]

Yeah, but he did care
A lot
And I think that the fact Dutch cared so freaking much about everything, contributed to his decline

[rich solstice]

Bro you could tell Micah was bouta go ape shi and start killling anyone especially dutch and Arthur 😭

[proper pier]

He cared so much for his gang, he did nothing to help himself

[mild fog]

Like he was overextending himself emotionally and mentally and physically
Something had to give

[proper pier]

Yeah

[proper pier]

And the only one truly helping was Hosea, after his death, it went from a slow decline to a fast decline

[mild fog]

Like I feel like his lack of emotion at the deaths was a masking response
We already know he feels like doubt is bad so it’s a reasonable inference that he might try to hide his emotions to appear strong
He can’t break down and ask for help! That would make him seem unfit! (In only his eyes)

[proper pier]

Yeah

I like to imagine after Arthur dies on that mountain, a few moments later, dutch walks over to him, sits next to him, and holds his body while crying

[mild fog]

Also this is shown in a camp interaction with Miss Grimshaw in chapter 3, she asks if he’s okay and he deflects by asking her for a dance

[proper pier]

Yeah

[mild fog]

Like it’s subtle but if you’re really paying attention you can tell Dutch cares a whole lot

[proper pier]

Yeah

[mild fog]

Like even Micah is like
“He cares way too much about you people, he should cut you loose”

[proper pier]

Everyone in that gang loved Dutch

And he loved them too

[mild fog]

And what’s more, he earned that

[rich solstice]

“Let the weak go, us leave and get a new life”

[mild fog]

And then he says “that ain’t happening” in response

[proper pier]

Dutch loves everyone in his gang

[mild fog]

I will NEVER let that scene go

Because that’s in chapter six

[proper pier]

When they were taken under Dutch's wing, Dutch never wanted to let them go

They were like his children

[rich solstice]

Yo I just watched the hardest edit of rdr2 oat 😭

[mild fog]

Yeah??

[rich solstice]

Look up “i shoot the lights out rdr2 edit”

It’s actually gas

[proper pier]

Alright

[mild fog]

Is there a place to put edits in this server?

I made one a while back

[proper pier]

Also, a funny thing I noticed

[rich solstice]

I think we should add an edit channel lowkey

[mild fog]

Could I link it in red dead media or no

[proper pier]

During the story, Dutch says "they won't catch me and I promise whosoever stands by my side they won't catch you either." In the end, Micah, Cleet, Joe, Bill, and Javier are standing by Dutch, and all of them were killed by John

[rich solstice]

@proper pier I haven’t beat the full game yet and haven’t played as John

[proper pier]

Whoops

[rich solstice]

But I don’t really care if you spoil or not

[proper pier]

Meh, not really that big of a spoiler, it could've been worse 😭

[rich solstice]

So when you play John, you get to kill Micah cleet and Javier

[proper pier]

And Bill

[rich solstice]

Idrc about bill he makes me so mad bro 😭

[proper pier]

It's just Javier and Bill don't die until the first game

[mild fog]

Ok but fr what percent of the community just 100% hates Dutch no exceptions

[rich solstice]

So in rdr2 who does John kill

[mild fog]

It feels like a lot but maybe they’re a vocal minority

[proper pier]

Micah Joe and Cleet

[rich solstice]

I don’t 100% hate him

👍🏻

[proper pier]

Joe and Cleet are 2 people Micah used to run with

[rich solstice]

I only hate dutch from chapter 4-6

1-3 he was absolutely goated

[proper pier]

I love Dutch

In fact, he's probably honestly my favorite character

He was so well written

[mild fog]

I love him but god what happened

[rich solstice]

Let’s be real

If Lenny stayed alive

[proper pier]

Lenny, Hosea, Sean and Kieran would've all sided with Arthur

[rich solstice]

He would’ve gone with Arthur and Micah and Lenny would’ve killed Micah before he got to Arthur

[mild fog]

Like at one point there was just a turning point that happened offscreen and I wanna know what it is so bad

[tawny valley]

unironically theres like 30 edits that use that song lol i have like, three saved on tiktok

[proper pier]

Which one?

[mild fog]

Idk that’s the problem

[rich solstice]

It’s the very first one

[mild fog]

At some point Dutch took a turn for the very worst

And I think it had to do with an offscreen conversation between him and Micah tbh

[proper pier]

I feel like it started soon after he took Micah into the gang

[proper pier]

Now that you mention it

[mild fog]

Well yes that’s when it started but at some point in chapter 6 Dutch has a sharp decline

Like it’s bad but then it gets REALLY bad

[proper pier]

I did once overhear Micah and Dutch talking

[tawny valley]

well you didnt really say which platform or like…anything. plus, even if it shows up first for you doesnt mean everyones search results will look the same. itd be better to save it and send it in media

[rich solstice]

Micah,bill,cleet,joe,and dutch vs Arthur, Lenny, Javier, Hosea, and Sean, who’s winning this

[tawny valley]

i have so many thoughts on dutchs character and downfall

if my nickname has anything to say about it

[proper pier]

Arthur could've took it alone

[mild fog]

Lmao I have a whole TikTok account dedicated to it lol

[proper pier]

Deadeye is busted

[mild fog]

Unironically

[rich solstice]

Idk about that if there was no deadeye Micah and dutch would be his biggest problem

[proper pier]

Micah and Dutch would be his biggest problems regardless of deadeye or no deadeye

But with deadeye, I feel like Arthur could gun everyone down before they could even react

[tawny valley]

the other gang members most likely have their own form of “deadeye”

[mild fog]

Have yall seen those deadeye videos on TikTok 😭

[proper pier]

Well if they do, they clearly don't use it often

[mild fog]

They SEND me

[tawny valley]

i mean…ok lets think about this logically

do you think arthur, john, and adult jack literally have the ability to slow down time?

because outside of that, deadeye is just quickdrawing

[mild fog]

I always thought of it as just showing how experienced gunslingers see the world

[proper pier]

Ok, I can admit, I feel like the gang does have their own versions of deadeye

But Arthur, John, and Jack are just faster and better

[tawny valley]

actually, semi off topic but partly on

have you noticed that you can tell who taught who how to shoot based on their stances when aiming?

[proper pier]

Yeah

Arthur definitely learned from Dutch

[tawny valley]

arthur stands almost exactly like dutch, whereas john stands like hosea

[proper pier]

They got practically the same stance

[tawny valley]

sadie ALSO stands like arthur!

wait

no. someone does

i don’t remember who

[proper pier]

Also, completely off topic

I recently noticed something in Rdr 2

[mild fog]

But back to Dutch
Yeah Dutch in chapters 2 and 3 are my favorite 😭

He’s such a dad I can’t

[rich solstice]

Yall look in media

[mild fog]

“Don’t you be callin’ him ‘boy’ now Bill, he don’t like that no more”

[proper pier]

During the mission, "The Battle of Shady Belle" when Agent Milton comes to the camp, damn near everyone has a gun in their hand. Hell, even Strauss had a gun out 😭

[tawny valley]

dude

[mild fog]

I have a Dutch edit but it’s too long, I don’t have nitro so I can’t post it

[tawny valley]

that clip unironically goes so hard

[rich solstice]

Just cut it down to 30 sec or less

[tawny valley]

even kieran pulled his gun out bruh

[rich solstice]

Surprised jack didn’t whip one out 😭🙏

[proper pier]

Everyone was ready to throw down for Dutch

It shows how much they cared about their leader and how they were willing to fight alongside him

[tawny valley]

and the fact they were literally SURROUNDING milton and ross

the whole fuckin gang in a perfect circle around them. crazy

[proper pier]

Let's be fair, if they wanted to, they could've killed both Milton and Ross and threw their bodies into flat iron lake

[tawny valley]

oh easily

[rich solstice]

Greatest gang member in rdr2
5:sean
4:micah
3:john
2:dutch
1:arthur
based off skill

[tawny valley]

but that would have gotten them hunted and killed so much faster

[proper pier]

I can debate Sean

I'd say that Javier has more skill than Sean

[rich solstice]

Sean is tied with Lenny lowkey

[tawny valley]

i love sean but his ass does NOT deserve to be in the top 5

[mild fog]

Can I link it?? It’s not really good to cut in half

[rich solstice]

Most underrated one is eagle flies like bro hit EVERY shot with a fucking arrow 😭🙏

[proper pier]

Actually no

I'd replace Micah with Charles and put Micah in 5th

[rich solstice]

Make a spot where it looks good then edit a fade

[tawny valley]

ugh i don’t even want to talk about eagle flies he makes me so sad

[proper pier]

Top 5 gang members (based on skill)

1. Arthur
2. John
3. Dutch
4. Charles
5. Micah

Charles deserves it

[tawny valley]

he do.

[proper pier]

That man once quickdrawed with a sawed off and won

He's a great hunter, he's physically strong, and he's humble

[rich solstice]

Switch dutch and john and that’s actually a perfect list
Dutch did more to help the group
John was always getting caught and Arthur and Sadie had to go help get him in prison

[proper pier]

Yeah

But if we're going off of their versions from Rdr 1, I could argue John is the most skilled

[mild fog]

Put it in red dead media

[rich solstice]

Shits actually good

[mild fog]

Fr??

[rich solstice]

Yea

How do you do that thing with the words

[mild fog]

Very very very slowly lmao

With LOTS of time

Oh wait you mean like doing it behind?

[rich solstice]

No like matching it with the song

[proper pier]

Dude, that shit could be a movie trailer for Rdr

That was beautiful 😭

[rich solstice]

Rdr3 trailer

[mild fog]

I’ll wait til the timeout is over to post the second half lol

[tawny valley]

oh my fucking god you guys just made me realize i can send my wifes edit too

once the timer finishes that is lmao

[rich solstice]

Pick me a song to edit about rdr2 pls ik bored

[mild fog]

Is it actually good 😭

[proper pier]

May iiiii stand unshaken

Amid, amidst a crash of worlds

[proper pier]

If you're referring to the edit, yes, yes it is

[rich solstice]

I already tried I couldn’t do it 😭

[proper pier]

Damn

Erm

Damn idk

[tawny valley]

theres my wifes edit . flutters my eyelashes

[mild fog]

The second half of the edit is my favorite I can’t wait four minutes 😭

[rich solstice]

Pick a song that fits the one I sent

[proper pier]

Man bro, your wife can cook too

[tawny valley]

I KNOW i was so proud of them when they posted it

[proper pier]

Jesus Christ, I was I had editing skills like you fellas

[mild fog]

Mad dog by the Crane Wives
It’s super niche but a Dutch edit to it would SLAP

I’m so lame I don’t do the editing everybody else does with the fancy transitions and effects I just have clips, words and a dream

2 minutes and I can show yall my favorite bit I am so HYPED

[proper pier]

Shit looks like it could be a movie trailer for Rdr, the fuck you talking about 😭

[mild fog]

You’re so nice 😭

I just like doing like
Story-centric edits a lot

[proper pier]

Well, it's really good

[tawny valley]

smfh yall showing love to everyone else but only ONE person paid attention to the loml’s….yall fake as hell (teasing)

[rich solstice]

If it’s good at .50-.75 speed I’ll do it

[mild fog]

Almost tiiiiime I am SO HYPED to show yall the second half

[proper pier]

Bet

I want it NOWWWA

[mild fog]

ITS UP

[rich solstice]

God damnnnnnn 😭

[proper pier]

It was beautiful

Ngl, who chopping onions? That shit is so sad yet so good

[mild fog]

My favorite bit is the middle part with the music stop and the “I am so sorry” because I thought of that

And it makes the second part go so much harder imo

[proper pier]

I had to heart that shit, like Jesus

[mild fog]

I also have another one I’m working on

[proper pier]

Honestly, people will say I'm glazing but idgaf

Best rdr edit I've ever seen

[mild fog]

It flopped on TikTok 😭

[proper pier]

Well those people clearly flopped on their heads when they were babies

[mild fog]

Not like SUPER flop it has like 4K views but still

[proper pier]

It deserves more

That is immaculate

[mild fog]

Oh oh I can show some other ones I made if you guys want

[proper pier]

Yes.

Yes.

[mild fog]

Warning they’re literally all of Dutch

XD

[rich solstice]

@mild fog I’m starting the edit

Pick a character anyone

[mild fog]

YAAS

[proper pier]

Dutch is my favorite character so I ain't complaining

[proper pier]

Sean Maguire

[rich solstice]

Yessssss 😭🙏

[proper pier]

Somebody should do a classy edit of Trelawny

[mild fog]

I have one other “good” edit the rest are questionable lol

[proper pier]

I would LOVE to see them all

[mild fog]

Actually wait I only have one other posted one and then a concept I’m working on

[proper pier]

Interesting

Ngl, I don't know how my friend could say Rdr isn't that fun

He said that about story mode

[mild fog]

I love using voiceovers in my edits lol
It’s my favorite thing to do

Also WHAT

[proper pier]

Idk

And he has 1600 hours on that game

[mild fog]

What???

[proper pier]

And says it's not as fun as I said it was

[rich solstice]

How do I find clips to edit bro there’s none on TikTok 😭

[mild fog]

Then why?? Is he playing it??

[proper pier]

Idk

It's because I said it's possibly the most fun game I've ever played

[mild fog]

Ok like 2 minutes til my cooldown is over

[proper pier]

And I played games like fortnite, all the cod's, ultra kill, all metal gear games, Minecraft, Roblox, sea of thieves, etc.

[mild fog]

I deleted my other one bc I realized my watermark isn’t on it and I don’t want anybody stealing

I’ve never actually played red dead bc I don’t have access to a console to play it on
Or money lol

I’m just very passionate about the story

[proper pier]

It's honestly the best game I've ever had the pleasure of playing

Has the best story and best characters and development I've seen

[mild fog]

My other edit is up :D

[proper pier]

Dude...

STOP

WITH

THE

[mild fog]

The what!!

[proper pier]

Cooking

I can't make it all caps

L

[mild fog]

Lmao

I’m very pleased with this one too

It flopped hard I only have 125 likes on it

[proper pier]

Bruh

[mild fog]

My edits never do well 😭

[proper pier]

That's honestly sad

[mild fog]

My Dutch analysis content does relatively well tho

[proper pier]

You deserve recognition, you can make good edits

[mild fog]

That’s what most of my page is on TikTok lol, analyzing Dutch and framing him from a more human perspective, not defending him but explaining possible thought processes behind his actions based on the context of the situation

[mild fog]

Aww 🥺

[proper pier]

Makes sense

Dutch, a man who went from the revolutionary outlaw to the fallen leader

[mild fog]

Ok and then I have one more edit snippet concept thing I can show yall that’s not even close to done

[proper pier]

You should make a classy edit of Trelawny

I would love to see that

[mild fog]

I’m super hyped for it tho but it’s gonna take a lot of work

[proper pier]

Bet

[mild fog]

See I always see the character centric edits to make them appear attractive but I prefer the trailer-style ones

[royal violet]

I got a question, is there a specific chat I ask in or can I ask in here?

Well I got two questions

[proper pier]

Ask away

[proper pier]

That makes sense

[royal violet]

If I got an animal pelt, is there a place I can store it so I can keep it?

[proper pier]

Usually no

It takes about 2-3 in game days to rot tho

Unless the animal can be stored in your satchel, it's gonna rot away

[proper pier]

But I don't think there is a place

[royal violet]

Ok thank you

[mild fog]

Okay got like a minute and a half left on my timeout

[proper pier]

Yay

[mild fog]

You actually get a 2 for one

Because I realized I have more drafts than I thought

[proper pier]

Oh bet

[mild fog]

Ok they up

[proper pier]

Yes

Just yes

[rich solstice]

@mild fog this is gonna be ass bro 😭 there’s like no Sean clips that line up with the song

[mild fog]

Nooo 😭

I always saw that as a Dutch centric song tbh

[mild fog]

Really :D

[rich solstice]

I’m trying tho 😛

[proper pier]

Of course

[mild fog]

The “storm” one goes hard but I ran out of dark scenes to use

😭

I just realized I have one more full finished Dutch edit and then a Molly one also

These are so cheesy aaa

[proper pier]

I bet they'll still turn out good

[mild fog]

It won’t let me send anymore 😭

You could check out my TikTok tho if you wanted

[proper pier]

I don't have tiktok 😭

[mild fog]

Nooo 😭

[proper pier]

I might get it just to support you

You make some fire edits

[mild fog]

Awww 🥹

Also I did manage to send one more but if you did get TikTok to support me that’d be really sweet

[proper pier]

Bet

I'll download it later tho

I'm too tired to download it now

Also, good edit

No, not good edit

[mild fog]

Thanks!! :D

[proper pier]

Great edit

It's better than good, it's great

[mild fog]

This one did somewhat well

9K views and 1.1K likes

[proper pier]

Not bad

[mild fog]

The unfinished one with a bunch of overlapping voices is gonna be focusing on the pressure Dutch was under and the isolation he felt

God I love storytelling through editing sm

[formal crag]

whats ur tiktok

[mild fog]

it’s wildcherrybloom!

[formal crag]

omg i saw one of ur vids earlier on my fyp😭

[mild fog]

My display name is so cheesy it’s Cherry (the Dutch van-alyst)

[formal crag]

i did NOT realize that was u omg.

[mild fog]

OMG

Fr??? Which one!!

[formal crag]

i have like half of these liked HJLEP😭

the one with dutch petting the dog 💔 i saw it literally a few hrs ago

[mild fog]

The one that’s like “Dutch doesn’t care! Dutch:”

[formal crag]

YA

i love dutch analysis vids..

[mild fog]

Literally if you put Dutch in context peoples arguments fall apart so fast

This man was under so much pressure

[formal crag]

dutch hate is unreal tbh cus if u take 5 seconds to think about his situation i think its easy to sympathize with him

[mild fog]

Literally

His crashout like “I gave you all I had” is SO valid

And everybody screams “MANIPULATION” when the guy is just trying to be straight with Arthur

“When you’re not behind me, it hurts”

[rich solstice]

@mild fog @proper pier I’m done

[proper pier]

Bet

[rich solstice]

It’s ass tho

Go to media

I cut it way to late I just realized 😭

@proper pier @mild fog

Alr I fixed t

[tawny valley]

what about his behavior towards molly though 😭

like im a fan of dutch but also he did the gang as a whole and molly SO fucking dirty

[royal violet]

Ok I got another question that I may know the answer to but I'm not sure so I wanted to ask and make sure

If I bring a horse to my camp that isn't my main but I still wanna keep it will it stay at the camp?

My stables are full already

Nvm

[tawny valley]

idc how much pressure ur under, molly went up to him and said “dutch can i talk to you?” and when he snapped “NOT NOW”, she just sadly walked away
and when arthur and him walked away, he said “can you BELIEVE that woman?”

like…ur gf wants to talk to you, its not a crime 😭

[rich solstice]

“You’re a worm, Arthur. A parasite. A rat.”
Saying that to Arthur is actually insane

[tawny valley]

im ngl i dont remember that line at all

[rich solstice]

Chapter 6

[lament jasper]

Odysseus mentioned, then Penelope.. What’s next, telemarketer??

[unique sable]

Lol guys idk if it's a working method or I got the micah's revolver by luck i was doing a mission and some guys were shooting at Micah but one of them disarmed his revolver and it fell and when I step on it I got it in my inv and can use it after the mission

[river lotus]

do you guys think that RDR3 could be possible

[rich solstice]

Yes ask @mild fog he made a trailer for it

[unique sable]

I think so but after a decade ;-;

[gusty coral]

Maybe

But it would be cool

[proper pier]

I could see it happening

The only thing is who would it take place in the eyes of

[river lotus]

id love to see more cause rdr is PEAK

[rich solstice]

@proper pier what’s the “my last boy” mission?

[proper pier]

I got 3 ideas

1. It takes place in the eyes of Hosea and Dutch during the foundation of the Van Der Linde gang
2. It takes place in the eyes of Lyle Morgan, Arthur Morgan's dad, and the epilogue is the eyes of a young Arthur
3. An adult Jack Marston running a Mafia in the 1920's

[river lotus]

ngl i hope i wont lose interest by the time it releases (if that will ever happen)

[proper pier]

I think it's where the natives invade Cornwall Kerosene and tar, but I could be mistaken

[rich solstice]

I like the jack idea that would actually be tuff

[rich solstice]

But like is that the last mission?

[proper pier]

One of the last

[rich solstice]

Damn bro 😭

[proper pier]

At least in chapter 6

[river lotus]

i think this is cause of me recently finishing the whole game but the 2nd idea sounds too good

[proper pier]

I would like to see the first one

[river lotus]

what if they managed to squeeze all 3 of your ideas in one game

[proper pier]

And the last mission be the blackwater massacre

[proper pier]

That would be very difficult

[river lotus]

another decade to wait

[proper pier]

I could see the first two, but then to have a giant time skip to when Jack is an adult in the Mafia would be difficult

Maybe a saga

[river lotus]

yup

[proper pier]

Where it starts with the formation of the Van Der Linde gang, then there's a dlc showing the life of Lyle Morgan, then it transitions into the ending of the gang, then it goes to John trying to escape the outlaw life before finally ending with Jack in the Mafia

I was also thinking if Rdr 3 was to be in the eyes of Jack as an adult, there should be a collectible called "remnants of the past" which is where you go to a location where a big event in the story happened and it basically shows a flashback to that event

[calm seal]

Hello i need some help im in Chapter 4 and i was wondering when the bank heist is about to start i done the river boat mission im very close to the bank heist mission?

[proper pier]

Do you mean the mission in the swamp?

[calm seal]

Im not there yet

[proper pier]

Hmm

Well, you still got a little way to go

You're about halfway there

[calm seal]

Alright thank you sir i cant wait to do this mission again its been a while

[rich solstice]

Why can’t we kill dutch 💔

He left Arthur to die 😭

[calm seal]

because red dead redemption 1 will not exist

Since its after the story of 2

[rich solstice]

😒

[calm seal]

I know i know

[rich solstice]

Dutch is out of my top 5 best gang members now bro 😭

He left Arthur to die and got eagle flies shot

[calm seal]

one thing i learned in life from Arhur is that always time to redeem yourself

[rich solstice]

Yea

[calm seal]

like saving john from the pinkertons and the Snake and Dutch

I got High Honor for the first time i played the game i was so proud of myself

for me i say this without a doubt this game is the best ever made by mankind

[rich solstice]

My honor is all the way to the left 😞

First time playing through

[proper pier]

Honestly, unless GTA 6 does some crazy shit in its storyline, I don't think it's story is gonna beat Rdr 2 story

[rich solstice]

To beat rdr2 gta 6 has to have the best physics the best graphics and the best story oat to beat it

[calm seal]

I dont care if GTA 6 will be 10 times better than Red Dead 2 nothing will ever change my heart for red dead 2

The Story was Perfect

and sad

maybe im just too stubborn to accept new games are going to better but i cant help myself

I'm the only one feeling this way?

[rich solstice]

Which ending is better
A way out
Or red dead redemption

[calm seal]

Red Dead Redemption for me

[rich solstice]

A way out was honestly shocking for me bro

Me and my brother were playing it and when we got to it we were both shocked 😭

[ionic juniper]

Rockstar loves stories with death or betrayal

[rich solstice]

Did John actually die after he got shot by the guy on top of the train

[calm seal]

No

he survived but was left behind by dutch and the snake

John made it all way back to the camp at Beaven Hollow where you know the final times of the gang was

[rich solstice]

So Micah kills Arthur but does John get the money after he kills Micah?

[calm seal]

yes at the end end very of the game

you see Dutch walking away past John with regrets

and never be seen again until rdr 1 story starts

[rich solstice]

But you get to free roam with John right

[calm seal]

of course you are free to go where you want with John

even in New Austin

the desert the wild west

[rich solstice]

I just want to kill Micah tho he pisses me off

[calm seal]

Just a reminder that you get a lot of money after the entire story of the game s

you can buy anything

Fastest Horse

[gusty coral]

I didn’t know that

[rich solstice]

Don’t you get like 20k

[calm seal]

Yes

[rich solstice]

Can you rate my edit of Sean pls

[calm seal]

Sure

[rich solstice]

It’s in media

[calm seal]

i dont see it

[pine cedar]

Canonically Micah doesn’t actually kill Arthur

[rich solstice]

Red dead media

[ionic juniper]

strange things happen at night in Saint Denis, a woman is talking and our photo appears on the left side.

what the hell

[calm seal]

Beautiful edit

[rich solstice]

Nun of Sean’s scenes barely fit together

I’m gonna do an edit for John after he says “stfu Micah” going to rig the train

[hidden moss]

Not bad edit and all but rdr2 fandom should really start to consider other editing styles 😭

Its always either that type of edit or woodl

And its been like that since 2018 and its really getting boring looking at them

[rich solstice]

Wdym? Sorry I’m slow

[hidden moss]

Theres too much of these edits now, the woodl if u know what that is and the editing style ur doing

[rich solstice]

So what should I do?

@hidden moss

[hidden moss]

I mean that isnt to like tell you to switch, i mean most edits come out good if you only do what you like

What do u edit on

[rich solstice]

CapCut 😭 what else would I edit on

God damn what do you edit on

That’s amazing

[hidden moss]

After effects

[rich solstice]

Is it good?

How do you do that

What’s the app called it doesn’t pop up

[hidden moss]

I use ae 2020 and its on pc, but it takes some time to get used to

[hidden moss]

Its pc 😭

[rich solstice]

Dammit 😭

What’s the best mobile edit app

[hidden moss]

Hmm wait lemme see

[hidden moss]

Do u have an android?

[rich solstice]

Apple

[hidden moss]

Download vsp bro

[rich solstice]

What’s that?

[hidden moss]

Video star

[rich solstice]

Video star?

Ok

Is that good?

[hidden moss]

Yes man most good rdr2 edits come from either video star or after effects

Just watch some tutorials tho to get comfortable with it

[rich solstice]

Ok

Thanks

[ionic juniper]

Ardennes horses don't have high stats, but based on my own experience, they spook less than other horses.

I wish I could have a gray Ardennes horse

[frosty sedge]

You know that mission for collecting debt? Well at the woman one where she tells me to loot her friend some other mf reported that as a robbery and now I got a $10 bounty bruhhh how is this fair 😭🙏

I should've killed that woman right on the spot somehow

[pine cedar]

You should’ve chased the witness, caught up to him and threatened him so he’d say nothing

[frosty sedge]

can you tell me where do I buy the leather working tools required to upgrade the satchel etc?

also, where do I sell those watches and other valuables that I steal?

[pine cedar]

So the leather working tools can be gotten from the camps ledger

You can donate money to it so you can buy them

[frosty sedge]

ohh got it

[pine cedar]

Then once they’re bought you talk to Pearson to get the satchels

[frosty sedge]

I already donated like $100 or so

[pine cedar]

And for these you need to sell them to a fence

No regular shop will take them only fences will

[frosty sedge]

is the best way to lose bounty to get arrested?

I had almost $200 bounty and I think I started a bar fight so I shot someone and got surrounded

after arrest bounty dissapeared

[pine cedar]

Well that is one way to do it

But if you don’t wanna be arrested you can pay off your bounty at train stations

Just FYI: The bounty in Great Plains, West Elizabeth (where Blackwater is) that says Wanted: Dead or Alive cannot be removed

[frosty sedge]

thats only acceptable if I currently have more money than the bounty costs?

[pine cedar]

Ye

[frosty sedge]

but even then I could donate all my money to the camp and get arrested

still net positive

[pine cedar]

Yeah you could

[frosty sedge]

okay but getting arrested

theres no some time strains or something?

[pine cedar]

Wait what

[frosty sedge]

how much time passes while I'm in jail

will the gang be worried or something

[pine cedar]

No but something you should note abt getting arrested is it will still cost some money

You’ll have to pay 80% of your original bounty cost which is still technically better than paying it off

For example say your bounty is $100

Getting arrested will take $80 saving you $20

[hidden moss]

Yeah id rather just pay the full bounty 😭

[quaint bronze]

Hello

[fervent mauve]

finally chapter 2 complete

[tranquil talon]

should I continue after doing the epilogue

[quaint bronze]

Yeah

[quaint bronze]

I did a whole thing where I became a wild man in the woods and lived there for weeks

[tranquil talon]

sounds good im sold

might move up to colter

[languid parcel]

I did that too it was a quite experience

[rich solstice]

Got 100 from the CapCut edit some how 😭🙏

[frosty sedge]

I found a prisoner stranger by the side of the road, what should I do with him?

He asked me to uncuff him but I tied him up and put him on my horse lol

[hidden moss]

Well its mostly luck i got 10k off a capcut edit

[bold moat]

I can't find the Ridgewood farm treasure, but I don't have a map. The locations on YouTube lead me to places but I can't find anything, should I get a map first?

[hidden moss]

Cant do a treasure hunt without starting the quest

Finding the map starts the quest for the trasure

[formal crag]

sorry i got timed out for some reason but yess I agree

[hidden moss]

Why are u arrhur hater

[brave sphinx]

odd you can't fast travel to colter from bechers hope

21/22 locations

[formal crag]

im not it's fake .. Im being framed

[hidden moss]

What movie is ur pfp from

[formal crag]

the 2017 Punisher TV show featuring Jon bernthal

[valid charm]

goated pfp

[hidden moss]

Oh okay

[formal crag]

🥰

[brave sphinx]

wtf why do you lose honor for shooting the dream catchers

[vale cedar]

How can anyone hate Arthur

[hidden moss]

Idk probably cus ur not appreciating peoples creation and culture

[brave sphinx]

right

[vestal crystal]

Ye i can

[hidden moss]

Dm thanks

[hidden moss]

I lose honor for killing the bounty dogs that want to kill me

This game's honor system is dumb

[brave sphinx]

xD

yeah but not for killing the bounty men

[hidden moss]

I also lost honor for killing the racer,why?,bc he was about to kill his horse,and I saved the horse,and I lost honor bc I killed the guy

[hidden moss]

Ok brian moser

[ionic juniper]

In Red Dead Redemption 2, do you enjoy free roam more during Arthur's story or in the epilogue with John?

[hidden moss]

Definitely Arthur

[brave sphinx]

i have 257h on rdr2🔥

and even 100% completion lol

[hidden moss]

Can Somebody give me advice on chapter 2 missions?

[hidden moss]

Wdym advice

[pine cedar]

What advice are you after?

[hidden moss]

When does the mission sheep and the goats spawn

I already have done pouring fourth Oil IV

And Abigail's jack fishing

[pine cedar]

You have to complete:

• “The Spines of America”
• “Pouring forth Oil IV”
• “A Fisher of Men”
• “Money Lending and other sins III”

[hidden moss]

But..

Does it not spawn if I don't complete money lending and other sins?

Yk why..

[pine cedar]

Yeah unfortunately no it won’t

All 4 of the missions above must be completed

It’s bc unlike the other money lending mission “Money lending and other sins III” is considered a story mission for obvious reasons

[hidden moss]

But

That's sad

But I don't have to free Micah right?

[pine cedar]

You can leave that pretty late but eventually you’ll have to

Bc you can’t progress past C2 until that happens

[hidden moss]

No I wanna stay in chapter 2 as much as possible

But the gigantic problem is sharpshooter 6

I can't get rolling block rifle

[pine cedar]

You cannot outside of glitches before the mission “The sheep and the goats”

[normal walrus]

man the saving mechanics are so annoying

[untold kayak]

it's ok

[tranquil talon]

epilogue done - i will now expel myself to colter

[rich solstice]

I just finished the epilogue what do I do

[tranquil talon]

restart

or finish anything you missed as arthur

[rugged meteor]

do what the other guy said and if you havnt you could move inti the online

[rich solstice]

I’ve been playing it forever but my gamepass ran out and don’t get paid till next Friday

[ionic juniper]

I want to start a new game for Arthur so I can play with both of them

[empty ingot]

didnt the VA for john marston say that there would be a rdr2 update, a big one, coming? He said it will definetly come before friday last week. But where is it now

[mystic grove]

Damn

Hosea die🥀

One of my favourite characters

[ionic juniper]

The next gen update or whatever was supposed to come towards the end of the year but I hope it comes soon

I need NG+ and 60 FPS update

[languid narwhal]

the epilogue could be a game on its own

[radiant berry]

Yo If rdr3 releases what will the protagonist/s be?

[rich solstice]

Yooooo what if dutch had a baby and that becomes the protagonist and it’s jack vs Dutch’s son

[ionic juniper]

like what

[languid narwhal]

or its dutch's son trying to escape his father's psychopathic path

while living his own life

[tawdry isle]

y’all

this is my 2nd playthrough and i rly need tips or tricks to find side quests

those white “?”

cuz i feel like i’ve looked everywhere so i’m doing sth wrong idk

so far i only did “of course hes british” and the one with the exceptionally tall fellow

[zinc fulcrum]

honestly they do just appear but you could try to do the white logos aswell which might help! (the ones that have the same thing as main missions except white)

[tawdry isle]

damn they just appear ? :( i guess i’m doing sth wrong

i’m just in chapter 3 now so i didn’t get white logo missions except strauss debts

[zinc fulcrum]

honestly don’t ask me i’m in my 3rd playthrough LOL

[zinc fulcrum]

ohh ysah i’m also in chapter 3 i believe they appear more in higher chapters

[raw tiger]

i dont know if anyone has thought of this, but the time we first meet Milton and Ross at horseshoe overlook, I thought when Ross says to Jack "Enjoy your fishing kid, while you still can" i think its a callback to RDR1s final mission where Jack goes to the beach where Ross is fishing and confronts him

[proper pier]

If it's with the founding of the Van Der Linde gang, I feel like it'll switch between Hosea and Dutch
If it takes place in the eyes of a young Arthur, then it'll be his dad Lyle Morgan and the epilogue we play as Young Arthur
If it takes place in the time after RDR 1, it'll be an adult Jack

[raw tiger]

people have said that, and or having an older jack marston continue on

[blissful crane]

yeah it's a foreshadow to edgars death

[naive gale]

if rdr3 happens and involves any characters we know rn it would feel forced

if jack's story moves forward it's not red dead anymore

[vale osprey]

We dont need an RDR 3

but I wouldnt complain about it

also yeah Jacks story is done

the story is done

[naive gale]

It's probably going to happen but I wouldn't be surprised if it happened when I was like, 40

15 years

[vale osprey]

Lets be real

we all are going to be on are death beds before we get an RDR3

[naive gale]

real

[unkempt igloo]

Jack’s story was finished in red dead 1

[raw tiger]

right, im doing my first playthrough on the game and I caught that detail

[unkempt igloo]

oh rdr2 does A LOT of foreshadowing and I love it

[raw tiger]

thats the first ive caught so far

[unkempt igloo]

Abigail saying that Jack wouldn’t become an outlaw over her dead body and the first thing we see in his epilogue was standing over her grave as an outlaw ready to take revenge😭

[raw tiger]

I'm loving the game, always have, im at horseshoe overlook right now,

my pc isn't able to run the game so i play on my friends xbox,

with the money im getting im gonna hopefully save up enough to buy a new pc

[naive gale]

lemat + volcanic pistol dual wield is fun

similar guns and ammo lasts longer or at least it feels like it

[worldly turret]

jack wasn't even in red dead 1

[keen birch]

Fun Fact

RD1 / Red Dead 1 = Revolver

RD2 / Red Dead 2 = Redemption 1

RD3 / Red Dead 3 = Redemption 2

[unkempt igloo]

you got me there💔

should’ve just said red dead redemption 1

[dim pasture]

Just finished the last mission of RDR2.

What a masterpiece

[cyan pendant]

? He’s literately the character you play as at the end of the game

[proper pier]

Their most likely calling red dead revolver red dead one

[calm seal]

so Red Dead 4 is going to be Red Dead Redemption 3 lol

😕

[vale furnace]

I just saw this and i know I'm late but they definitely cut a ton of crap out of the epilogue

it was definitely gonna be at least 4-5 hours because if you look closer at a lot of things they had set up a big villain when you rescued Charles From the Soldiers of Guido martelli, The new Mob boss in St. Denis and they have a model of him in the game older that was never seen so safe to say tha john would have been having tons of more problems with that mob in the future after but they cut it for some reason

[molten jacinth]

Hellooo

Ik this is the single player chat but it seems kinda dead in general and I had some questions

[languid narwhal]

it was at least 4-5 hours

i finished it in 5

[heavy crown]

I just finished the main story tonight

I’d say by far RDR2 is the greatest story/open world game of all time

[uneven pollen]

bro obv never played roblox

[dim pasture]

same dawg. Just started the epilogue.

[quick loom]

Has anyone taken the time to read the descriptions for the weapons in the catalogue?

I think some are pretty interesting

Especially the testaments from people writing in about their experiences

[eternal estuary]

Idk

I don’t really like dual wielding 2 different guns

[ionic juniper]

I feel lonely at Epilouge

[devout nexus]

should i try rdro

[weary harness]

i miss exelforce

he was cool

[frosty sedge]

how do I charge deadeye???

I know how to fill the core but the outter ring doesn't fill at all

[proper pier]

Specific tonics and provisions and i think you can shoot animals and people and shit to get it charged

[frosty sedge]

ye but they only charge the core

[proper pier]

Oh