red-dead-singleplayer

[eager crater]

i hate that bot

but which outfit are we talking about

and how do i get it

[grand musk]

wouldn’t you like to know

[vagrant copper]

😔

[cosmic fox]

Bro wanted to see his dihberculosis

[vivid sparrow]

They didn’t want to motion capture those

[valid field]

I still don't understand how the Auctioneer in town figured out Arthur and John had stolen the sheep in Valentine 😭 It seems like a writing over sight

[formal crag]

cus they dont look like herders

[toxic gate]

i got rdr1!

its peak lowkey

[valid field]

Didn't they those guys John and Arthur ran off didn't look much different then they

[cyan pendant]

Can you not get lowest honor before chap 6 cause I’ve been constantly stuck at -6

[tacit pasture]

Super newbie here. Just made it to chapter 2.

I've got my horse I'm bonded with, but just found a horse I like better. Literally just because she has a massive saddle covered in storage.

Any way to move that saddle to my horse? Or move the stuff from my current horse to the new one?

[cyan pendant]

You have to buy saddles you can only loot their saddle bag

[tacit pasture]

If I start bonding with this new horse, what happens to the old one and all my stuff in it?

[cyan pendant]

Can’t move someone else’s saddle to yours

[cyan pendant]

Like a new horse? Just stable your old one or sell it if your not gonna use it

[tacit pasture]

Do I lose all the stuff I have stored in the horse?

[cyan pendant]

Nope that’s your saddle and your saddle bag

It just transfers over to that horse

When you saddle up

[tacit pasture]

Ah cool good to know thanks

[cyan pendant]

Just curious what horse did you find that you like better?

[tacit pasture]

Belonged to a guy trying to sell me a treasure map.

All black, but the saddle has a boatload of storage. Like boxes hanging off the side.

Also minor spoiler for early game, I found $600 after killing a bunch of O'Donnells, but it didn't go to my inventory and don't seem to have a way to give it to Dutch. Any ideas where it went?

[cyan pendant]

Sadly you can’t steal someone else’s saddles

[tacit pasture]

But if I bond with that horse, it'll keep the saddle right?

Like I'm sure it's just cosmetic, but I want it lol

[cyan pendant]

So each misson you do for money that you do with the gang you get your share then the rest of the gang gets some so you probably didn’t get all 600$

[tacit pasture]

Uhhhhh the horse is just gone now?

[cyan pendant]

Did you get off it

[tacit pasture]

Yes but hitched it at camp

[cyan pendant]

Did you stable it first

Like make it completely yours

[tacit pasture]

Not sure, no idea how

It said I could keep it temporarily at camp

[cyan pendant]

You go to that horse shoe icon that place you went with hosea to sell that shire

That’s where you can buy horses and saddle up new ones

[tacit pasture]

That doesn't sound familiar

Don't think I've done that yet

Went back to take a screenshot of the cool saddle, horse was gone 10 seconds after leaving it hitched 😦

[cyan pendant]

Hosea will ask you to go hunt a bear

[hollow fulcrum]

The SADDEST thing is when your horse dies… like there was this time in a certain part of chapter 4 where my horse got hit by a car and i was contemplating shooting the INGAME town up

[cyan pendant]

That’s what happened to me with my turkoman

I has in the gun shop for 5 minutes and he died let’s just say saint denis doesn’t like me much rn

[hollow fulcrum]

dang are spoiler tags not permitted?

[tacit pasture]

Can you permanently own multiple horses?

[novel compass]

Yep, 3 slots in the stables and 1 that you have equipped

[tacit pasture]

Awesome thank you

[novel compass]

If you haven't unlocked the stables yet you unlock them in a mission with Hosea pretty early on

[indigo remnant]

Guys any tips for the mission "our best selves"

[novel compass]

Like completing it? Shoot ur gun ig idk

[indigo remnant]

this doesn't help

[novel compass]

Well what's the issue more specifically

[indigo remnant]

Im about to start anything I should watch out for

[blazing dawn]

can you explain the mission

[indigo remnant]

I swear to god if you say enemies that shoot at you

[blazing dawn]

or like what is said to happen

[novel compass]

Smth with a train bro idk

Just play the mission and you'll see how it gors

[indigo remnant]

How far are you into the game

[novel compass]

Maybe do any side quests ur missing before this one tho

[indigo remnant]

"gors"

[blazing dawn]

ive completed both

[indigo remnant]

Who's your favorite character

[blazing dawn]

marston

lol

[indigo remnant]

Which one

[blazing dawn]

john

wbu

[indigo remnant]

Arthur

What happened to cain

[blazing dawn]

i think he ran away..

[novel compass]

I'm not acc sure, I think he just ran off. I remember seeing some theory about dutch that involved cain but I don't think there's anything in game

[indigo remnant]

Some people say Micah killed him

I think he used the donation money from camp to go to Tahiti but he could only buy a ticket for himself so he's in Tahiti waiting for the gang

Where did everyone go

[blazing dawn]

i hate micah

stupid facial hair..

[novel compass]

Pretty funny theory ngl

[gusty meadow]

wow. on the final main story wirh arthur and i was fighting micah and was almost done and the game crashed. now i gotta do the whole train and sadie abigail and everything all over again

[cyan pendant]

Kinda need help with this I’m just confused

[obsidian plinth]

Apparently not. Honor is capped to a certain point until chapter 6

[cyan pendant]

Well I have bombed a whole state for no reason then

[eternal estuary]

The m1899 is one of the few reasons I wanna get to chapter 4 asap

Closest thing to an smg in this game

[arctic musk]

definitely

[full bloom]

Hey I have a question when Arthur dies John gets his weapons but not his loot like fish or lucky charms that give a boost or cigarette pictures can someone tell me if I can get that again

[blazing dawn]

i think he does get this stuff actually

he gets his satchell and i still had all the cigarette cards

[polar basalt]

how long is the main story

[full bloom]

about 100 hours

[polar basalt]

damn

how much chapters until u can freely explore

[peak arch]

after the first chapter u can play and explore freely

[polar basalt]

oh thx

[arctic musk]

its 100 hours if you really take your time and do alot of other stuff but i did all side quests i could do and all main missions in like 75 hours

[blazing dawn]

nahh

[blazing dawn]

yeah main missions took me 65-70 hours

[arctic musk]

its possible to do it in 100 hours but thats if you do alot of other stuff like challenges hunting and more

[blazing dawn]

yeah, im super impatient so i grinded out the main story in one week

[arctic musk]

i also did it pretty quick

[blazing dawn]

but if u wanna do the side quests and everything it'll prob take waaaayy longer

[arctic musk]

also the course of true love missions add like 1-2 hours

and i dont even like them

[obsidian plinth]

Any tips for fishing up the legendary fish at sisika? I'm not sure which lure to use. I've tried the river and the swamp ones but no luck

[arctic musk]

the legendary lures?

[naive grove]

it seas that when you like look at the time

[obsidian plinth]

I'm having trouble getting it, I'm at the spot, I have the lures but no luck

[queen dew]

A funny glitch just happened to me I started a new play through and got the first Mary letter but it wouldn’t let me read it then when it ended the cutscene that happens after wouldnt trigger so leapold was just standing there I ended up jumping of the nearby clif and exploding myself to fix it

The reason leapond was nearby is because I haven’t done downs yet

[polar basalt]

i jist want to tie people up dawg

[indigo remnant]

What game are you in

[obtuse cliff]

60 hours if you actually play the game 100 if you play like a REAL MAN/WOMAN

[polar basalt]

ill buy rdr2 thursday

[obtuse cliff]

You get everything back except for the horse

Cuz he gives Arthur the satchel and all that

[indigo remnant]

Please don't get too attached to anyone in the gang

[polar basalt]

ok

why tho

[indigo remnant]

Is it okay if I dm you

[polar basalt]

u can

it is okay

ill just reply in an hour i gtg to my class

[queen dew]

It took me around that long for my first play through

[obtuse cliff]

60?

[queen dew]

No like 100

100 something

[obtuse cliff]

Yh cuz you propably messed around with stuff

[queen dew]

Yeah

[obtuse cliff]

wich makes the experience even better

I did 50 of messing and 100 of actually playing the game😭

[queen dew]

In my first play though I have 90 present

[obtuse cliff]

I did 97

Crazy

Or 98

I forgor

[queen dew]

This is one of my favorite games

[obtuse cliff]

Real

[queen dew]

I mean i put in 216 hours into the game I pretty much stand this game

[obtuse cliff]

I recently bought it again but on pc and I’m currently 250 hours in and still in the beginning of chapter 3😭

hunting and fishing are more important this time trust

[terse sleet]

i got mauled by 3 grizzly bears.

they played soccer with my dead body

[queen dew]

Real

[warm musk]

Dude what?

[polar basalt]

im back

[cedar pasture]

Good Evening, I just Joined today and possibly start the game this week after my finals in Thursday

I can't wait to play it, I'm late about 6 years but better late than never. Also because I just got my very first gaming laptop last year.

So, RDR2... Anything I should be aware of before starting the game ? This is my first time playing this level of detailed Open world, so far I been playing MGSV, WD 1 and 2 for open world

[obsidian plinth]

Take your time with it! Enjoy it at your own pace

[cedar pasture]

Okay, hopefully this gonna hook me up more than the previous 3 open world I used to play.

Tired of modern day stuff, wanna step back a little to the old times.

I have few question from what I been stumble on so far in YT.

First of, which horse should we buy? I think there is three option? Cheapest, medium and most expensive

[hidden moss]

Depends on how much money you have when you do that mission
you can also get a free one if you have the special or ultimate edition

[cedar pasture]

I'm buying the standard game, didn't have much money and economy at my country is sucks rn so yeah, Standard is my go

[hidden moss]

That's real
Also
You can just not sell the horse you're given
But I'm not gonna say more
You'll find out yourself soon

[cedar pasture]

Copy, we have map in game right? Since I've read someone literally make digital map of it online since the in game doesn't felt accurate enough

Didn't wanna end up getting lost and killed and lost my stuffs early on

[hidden moss]

Yeah the game does have an in-game map

[cedar pasture]

I see. Alrighty, so far I have heard PLAN and Tahiti, that got me interested to play and Dutch seems to be a very badass

I mean look at his drip

[hidden moss]

Ong

Also
Know that the server isn't spoiler free so be careful round here aight

[cedar pasture]

Copy that. Just three days left, till things are set and done.

The only thing further I know about RDR2 because of certain YouTuber who made a video recently is

Drunk Driving in RDR2

[hidden moss]

True
Running people over with a wagon is fun!!!!

[obsidian plinth]

Oh I do not want to start this mission

[hidden moss]

Btw I hope you enjoy the game bro

[cedar pasture]

Thanks. I'll hang around when I joined and actually started my journey. Rn, just watching Arthur chugging these foods and showcase all of these guns

[hidden moss]

Real

[cedar pasture]

Shame we don't have sniper rifles here, I guess scoped guns really arrive only in WW1

[hidden moss]

There are sniper rifles In the game

[ivory lark]

how long till vendors respawn after killing em

[polar basalt]

what about me🥀

im about to get the game

[cyan pendant]

We literately have rolling block ride and Springfield

[polar basalt]

can u do kung fu in rdr2

[cedar pasture]

Ouwh, thought we don't have them till ww1, I mean sure Mosin exists before ww1 but maybe not until ww1 the scope version are there

[hidden moss]

I hope you enjoy the game too bro

[cyan pendant]

It’s still technically a sniper

[toxic pagoda]

How can I get high honor fast

[low monolith]

help strangers and turn in bounties alive

[obsidian plinth]

Say hi to everybody you see

I think you gain honor for every 3 people

[polar basalt]

yayy

[ivory lark]

donate 21 dollars to the camp 1000 times

this is probably the fastest way

just sit at the box, and make as many sperate 20 dollar donations as you want

each one will give a good amount of honor

this is probably the fastest way

[balmy terrace]

donate 1k

[gusty meadow]

when you are playing as john when are you able to craft items at fences?

[maiden gorge]

Anytime you please

[maiden gorge]

Well, excluding the time you are in the middle of doing missions

[exotic cove]

I think

Purple

[maiden gorge]

Good answer!

[gusty meadow]

says i cant when im working for the ranch

[maiden gorge]

Damn fr?

Never paid attention to that, guess I got that wrong

[visual echo]

How to make money fast?

[maiden gorge]

Best thing I could think of is bounties and the story missions

[fluid hound]

ive done 6 camp requests uet the trophy its linked to hasnt popped any tips?

[hidden moss]

Gosh dayuum Sadie in chapter 3

Id hit it 100%

[fluid hound]

oh my

[sturdy barn]

any speedrunners on this server?

[drifting hemlock]

hey, not sure where to ask this, but my horse randomly changed to the chestnut tennessee walker from buell?? I just got buell and came over here to uncle to do a quest, I was on buell before the quest (he was saddled up since I put him in the stable first and then took him out) and after the quest he just disappeared and I got this chestnut horse instead. any way to fix this? i have autosave on so I can't go back

also he isn't in the stables

[zealous oyster]

can anybody help me find the legendary chain pickerel i have already caught the legendary bluegill while is was fishing with kieran.

[lyric python]

Green

[exotic cove]

Thats scary

[lyric python]

Why??

[fallen rose]

Does anyone know if the trophy for skinning all species of animals is specifically for all animals or just one animal of each species?

[ionic juniper]

The big horses in the game look more beautiful, they just get tired very quickly

[sage gale]

is it possible to get 2 lemat revolvers?

[fallen rose]

somebody??

[fluid hound]

google it

i wish you luck

[indigo talon]

when i encounter a stranger ingame, instead of just shooting them without thought, i help them THEN shoot them to give them a false sense of hope

[fluid hound]

[indigo talon]

"Your a good man, arthur morgan"

[maiden gorge]

One of my favorite rdr2 quotes

What is everyone’s favorite rdr2 quote?

Yes, it can be comedic

[indigo talon]

the entirety of arthur insulting sean after freeing him

[maiden gorge]

What was said there? I don’t remember quite fondly

[sage gale]

Uncles roast to john in the epilogue

[indigo talon]

i would kill for this gang, i would die for it, but i wouldve let you rot if charles hadnt stopped me

[maiden gorge]

I knew he said something about caring for the gang, but damn that was colder than the mountains of grizzlies west!

[maiden gorge]

Like the “better nightmares than this dream” and “two dollar whore”?

[sage gale]

john the rock farmer

[maiden gorge]

They’re MINERALS Marie… MINERALS

[indigo talon]

i also like when arthur said to uncle "your my favorite parasite, wait no ringworms mah favorite so your second, oh and the rats with the plauge so your mah third favorite parasite"

[sage gale]

for the last time theyre MINERALS

[maiden gorge]

Marie needs to quit robbing from house tours and get into understanding minerals with Hank

[sage gale]

105 hours in 35 days damn

[maiden gorge]

What you talking about?

[sage gale]

My hours in red dead lol

[maiden gorge]

Oh I see

You tryna go for 100?

[sage gale]

Hell yes

[maiden gorge]

I wish you luck, fellow outlaw

[indigo talon]

i already have 77 hours after only about a week

[maiden gorge]

The hardest part in the reaching of 100% has gotta be the challenges

[sage gale]

not really

they are just fun and mostly easy

Imo the only hard part has been the Van horn to blackwater and the 3 Hits in blackjack

[maiden gorge]

Have you done herbalist 9?!

Not only do you gotta get all 43 herbs, but you gotta track each individual herb yourself

The game doesn’t do it for you

To be fair though, it is more tedious than it is hard

[sage gale]

easy

just takes long

Havent done it but i know what it is

[maiden gorge]

Yeah you are kind of right on that part

[indigo talon]

the series of missions with the journalist at the saloon is pretty fun and has some good missions to offer so i recommend you try it

[maiden gorge]

Is that Albert mason you are talking about?

[sage gale]

Im doing everything so yeah

[fluid hound]

do yall know how to check hours played on ps4

[maiden gorge]

Woah woah

[indigo talon]

idk his name lol, the guy that was writing about the gunslinger guy

[maiden gorge]

They removed my poop role….

[maiden gorge]

I forgot his name, but his set of missions are fun

[sage gale]

the dude where you take a pic of black belle and them?

[maiden gorge]

He kinda looks like Theodore Roosevelt right?

[indigo talon]

yea

[sage gale]

they lit

[maiden gorge]

My favorite has to be emmet granger

[indigo talon]

most of the guys with mustaches look like a younger theodore roosevelt

[maiden gorge]

Because you lather that dude in genuine fecal matter

Very funny

“I think you had yourself a proper shit show, Mr Granger.”

[sage gale]

I love Trofees on youtube. Hes awesome, though im very convinced hes cheated multiple times

[maiden gorge]

That’s a familiar name…

[sage gale]

hes done all the challenges like 5 times lol

including once as arthur

[maiden gorge]

Oh yeah I watched the dudes video of him doing challenges

[indigo talon]

i wanna kill sonny in the early game, but for some reason he only appears in his cabin after a specific mission ingame

[maiden gorge]

Well if he’s doing them as Arthur, there’s gotta be a mod involved

[maiden gorge]

Who is Sonny again?

[sage gale]

well he only did the challenges

it was the herbalist thing who makes that tricky

[indigo talon]

the guy who does "things" to arthur

[sage gale]

he just made sure to use dead deer and wagons lmao

[maiden gorge]

OHHH that dude in the shack of lakay?

Yknow what’s crazy

I only encountered him as John

You can just tell by looking at the guy he is up to something mischievous

[indigo talon]

just shoot him and ransack the cabin everytime you see him, youll have to take a honor hit tho

[maiden gorge]

Doubt it lowers it by much

I always hated the swamps

Especially at night

The Night folk scare me man..

[indigo talon]

im playing low honor rn so it probably wont matter

[maiden gorge]

lol true that

[indigo talon]

yeah but it is home to one of the major towns ingame, (saint denis) so atleast it has something going for it

[maiden gorge]

That’s it’s only plus. But if we’re being real here, despite the Saint Denis title screen saying “Bayou Nwa, LE” it is sort of outside the swampy terrain

Especially on the northern end of the city

[indigo talon]

another bad thing about it is that the damn crocodiles wont die, i used deadeye to shoot it 6 times but it just ran away like it was nothing

[maiden gorge]

Never had that issue. If you just headshot it with a repeater or rifle, it goes down immediately

Obviously lower caliber firearms won’t work the same

[cyan pendant]

It’s not like you can get minimum honor unless your in chap 6

[hidden moss]

should i delete the mods i have installed so i can play rdo?

[pearl pollen]

Hello guys, I have some problem, I almost got 100% in game, but quest "The American Inferno, Burnt Out" got an error, I just couldn't give to this poet some food after 3 days, after 1 week, and as a result he just "left" his house, not any buttons to interaction with door or with him, just nothing, is it popular problem? Did I just lost my "almost 100%" game?

[obsidian plinth]

I ran into that guy for the first time the other day, absolutely hated it

[obsidian plinth]

Alright gang, what should I do before I start the end of chapter 4. I'm at the bank mission and I've yet to start it. I could find all the legendary animals I haven't just yet but what else should I do before guarma

[pearl pollen]

You probably should to play all side quests if u want, all things with saving your money is important only after chapter 6

[obsidian plinth]

I think I've gotten them all? Or most of them at least

[indigo remnant]

Anyone else know bills real name
(Bill is his surname)

[obsidian plinth]

No it's William Williamson. It was Marion Williamson

[cedar pasture]

Best girl in rdr2?

[obsidian plinth]

Karen <3
And Sadie

[cedar pasture]

For Sadie, understandable, Badass. Tomboyish, let's just say I peeked a little bit too much into RDR2 while I'm not even playing it yet.

American Venom Mission

Love her outfit for that mission

[obsidian plinth]

I love her arc from grieving widow to total badass

[hidden moss]

Charles châtenay

[obsidian plinth]

So true

[untold sapphire]

Whats the best gun in red dead storymode?

[weary harness]

schofiel

i think

[untold sapphire]

aight

[arctic musk]

its down to preference but if you had to only use 1 i'd say lancaster repeater

lemat revolver might be better then schofield

[weary harness]

nooo!

[weary harness]

how to get infinite cocaine in red dead redemption II

you have to go to the mr white and mr black mission and kill them, loot them

then they respawn and you do it again

[arctic musk]

is that real

[pearl pollen]

Hamish

[cedar pasture]

Which one do you guys pick when play RDR2 ?? Django Unchained or Clint Eastwood style ??

[haughty sable]

I have a mission in Blackwater, but I can't go there since its a red area, and I'll get a bounty on my head if seen (and I already have a bounty in Strawberry).

Is there a way to get into Blackwater safely?

[haughty sable]

What does that mean?

[cedar pasture]

Like either the dress up or gunfighting

Or basically way to play

[haughty sable]

I don't completely understand you.
But I try to avoid unnecessary trouble, like getting into fights and stuff. Just minding my own business.

[cedar pasture]

I see, sorry for the messy words

[haughty sable]

Any way you can help me out a little?

[haughty sable]

^^

[cedar pasture]

Sorry, cant do. i havent start the game yet, approx tommorow since thats my final day of my finals

[haughty sable]

Oh, I see. Thank you for your time. See you around then.

[arctic musk]

i understand i love going to the most west gang hideout and putting on spaghetti western music while fighting without deadeye
i also enjoy hunting and bounty hunting

[arctic musk]

i can try to help you

[haughty sable]

Oh thank you.
Do you have a way?

[arctic musk]

yes you need to go from the water ill show you a picture in general media

[indigo belfry]

Anybody have Some tips for the duchesee and other animal quest i only Find stupid gathors

[indigo belfry]

How do i respawn them or is that just luck ??

[obsidian plinth]

They respawn every in game 3 days i believe

[indigo belfry]

Oow wow gues i have to stay at camp Longer Thanks for the tip

[cedar pasture]

I've seen MK IceandFire finish the game in 27 hours

That's actually the length to complete the story and not whole game right?

Don't worry, I haven't watch it at all, just stumble by it on my feed

Just one more day.. One more finals

[indigo remnant]

Is it limited to sidearms

[arctic musk]

you can just keep sleeping and if you cant anymore save your game then go back into it and you can continue doing the cycle

[indigo belfry]

I can also get killer nu a geator right because other wise there wont be spawing new birds

[empty sparrow]

finished red dead 2

john got his red dead redemption

[indigo belfry]

Is the first red red good never played it ?

[cyan pendant]

Yeah

[empty sparrow]

you mean redemption or revolver?

[indigo belfry]

Redemption

[obsidian plinth]

Man. So i was turning in the killer prostitute right. And as soon as i pick up my $12 reward, i become a suspect of a kidnapping 🗿

[slender rain]

can anyone help me with mods in here?

[granite peak]

Rule #15 | Exploits/Glitches/Hacks/Mods -
For singleplayer, we neither condone nor punish the use of mods.
For multiplayer, any and all modding, or content including it, is prohibited.
Discussions on how to do or find exploits/glitches/hacks/mods, or distributing any of these, is prohibited for both singleplayer and multiplayer.

[cedar pasture]

Ouwh, I guess I can't ask if it's fine to install certain weapon mod in the game.

[sage gale]

Bout to meet the norwegian fella in the epilogue

my people

[wild gorge]

Hey
In valentine near the show
I keep hearing someone shout i need help
Help
And stuff like that but i can't find it
Can someone explain?

[naive gale]

What's more fun is high speed horse collisions

[hidden moss]

Real

[indigo talon]

i just got wanted when i was extremely far away from the corpse, wtf is this witness system

[naive gale]

Did anyone else find a hat, decide that's your favorite and never change it

Loving the pirate hat

[supple gust]

ommgggg, i just closed the damm game without savin

rip my moose and beaver trinket

[simple wyvern]

I never realized this until now.
Arthur literally looks like Saul Goodman if you shave his facial hair, and maybe adjust a few clothing items

[twin loom]

It autosaves when you purchase something does it not?

[cyan pendant]

Your fine it saves when you buy something

[zealous oyster]

hey any really good tips for singleplayer just asking

I have one im willing to give out

[versed bloom]

Jack pmo……

[ionic juniper]

Where's Gavin?

😃

[odd moss]

hello guys.

Its been a long time.

Since i was active...

Damn im never active, are there any good singleplayer things to do in this server?

[naive gale]

Does anyone else like doing a few punches into a pistol whip and execution

It just looks so slick

[coral osprey]

I like........the idea that modders had to take it into their own hands to make John look like John in the epilogue

because Rockstar was too busy ensuring you get to have your cake and fuck it too in rdo

[uneven pollen]

what's faster for honor, throwing fish back or spamming greetings to everyone

[wild coral]

is it still possible to get the black abrabian in St Dennis?

[fluid salmon]

Yeah I got it today actually

[spring fog]

Probably greeting, especially in chapter six there's an honor multiplier,plus if you suck at fishing (like me) or just can't get a bite,then greeting is faster, especially in Saint Denis

[wild coral]

Where at in town? I'm over north of the N

but been trying for like an hour

I saw somewhere that if you had the event happen and didn't get the horse, your'e SOL as it's a one time event?

[fluid salmon]

I got mine in a stable after i finished the epilogue

[wild coral]

yeah, that's not what I meant then

there is a random encounter that starts in chapter 2 where you can steal it

[toxic pagoda]

Fuck Molly

[obsidian plinth]

Alright. Anyone have tips on finding a silver chain bracelet

[weary harness]

yes

[weary harness]

yes

[uneven pollen]

i found one on the chick after the awkward pig farm encounter

[sweet jungle]

What is that one "companion" thing at the chapter 3 camp

Its shown to be on Arthurs wagon but i haven't found anything there or i just dont understand what it id

[obsidian plinth]

It might be a letter or item on the table

[sweet jungle]

There aint any letters on the table

[obsidian plinth]

You can use eagle eye to see if there is anything to interact with

[sweet jungle]

On the table there is following items: A flower, horse stimulant, First bank robbery newspaper scrap, cigarettes and 2 photographs

[obsidian plinth]

Have you recently helped a gang member with a request?

[obsidian plinth]

It's the horse stimulant I believe

[sweet jungle]

I have done 5 camp request items or whatever they are

[sweet jungle]

Aint got no room in my bag for it

[golden elbow]

Oh man he is new to the game?

Wish I could play rdr2 for the first time again

God

Such peak

[sweet jungle]

Got like 40 hours

mainly have hunted animals

Much more fun

[golden elbow]

Respect

I played for the story

[obsidian plinth]

When you pick it up, the little companion dot will go away

[sweet jungle]

Okay thanks for helping

[obsidian plinth]

No prob! If there's a dot, it means a gang member gave you a gift for the request you helped with

[golden elbow]

My boy had max of that item already😭

That was me the whole game too

[obsidian plinth]

It's easy to max out in early game and you loot

[golden elbow]

I always had money and items stocked up

[obsidian plinth]

I think I had a health cure I could not pick up until I moved camps because I forgot to pick that one up from my table 💀

[golden elbow]

XD

[obsidian plinth]

It mocked me. I was in chapter 4 and it was in the bed, and I couldn't pick it up for a long time 🗿 worst ever. Eventually I threw one out and picked it up

[golden elbow]

My ass woulda let it stay there until I needed it lol

[sweet jungle]

Btw where to find badgers for satchel and what weapon to use for it?

[untold sapphire]

Guys I'm halfway through chapter 2 and got a volcanic pistol and a Lancaster repeater. Is that good?

Also got a Springfield rifle with a scipe

[arctic musk]

maybe robbing people on trains

[arctic musk]

yes lancaster repeater is all you need ngl

get express ammo if you can

[sweet nexus]

Kieran and marybeth live in a cabin where he takes care of their horses while she writes novels and they have a kid named Arthur (named for obvious reasons) and they all live happily together, and kieran fully supports Mary-Beths career and learned to read just so he could read her books in order to make her happy

[real prism]

kieran died..

[sweet nexus]

no he didn’t

arthur found him

and saved him

[real prism]

r u serious bro

stop the cap

[sweet nexus]

(I say as they drag me away to the mental asylum)

[sweet nexus]

stop the cap in the big 25

[real prism]

shi

[real prism]

yes gotta keep ts alive

[sweet nexus]

unlike kieran 😭

[real prism]

lmfao

[sweet nexus]

but thats a headcanon

for if he had survived

[real prism]

real

[arctic musk]

big 25 in the big 25

[sweet nexus]

Kieran probably would’ve left the gang when marybeth did

big 25 in the big 25 in the big 25

[obsidian plinth]

M a n
Alright I'll try robbing one, thank you

[untold sapphire]

Is volcano Pistol good though cuz it was very expensive

[arctic musk]

its alright

[weary harness]

i love volcano pistol

[arctic musk]

they might be on a poorer part of the train

idk how to explain it really

[untold sapphire]

I believe I bought some express ammo with the rifle i think. Or it was a different type

[frank mango]

just spent about well over 2 hours of hunting racoons for a satchel just to realize i cant make any without pearson 💔

[sweet jungle]

How to get ram carcass? I have tried shooting perfect bighorn rams but i dont get the ram carcass

I have do i need to bring the whole animal to camp or skin it?

Or how to obtain the carcass

[frank mango]

I think you just need to bring the whole carcass, without skinning it

[sweet jungle]

oh okay i will try that next time i will play since i just stopped

[ionic juniper]

I think I'll start a new game to play with Arthur

[arctic musk]

you can get the satchels soon

without carcasses

[weary harness]

i love legend of the east satchel

[arctic musk]

yes same

[weary harness]

but my favourite is the iguana one

[frank mango]

its not that, spoilers but im in ch6 before the last mission and pearson kinda leaves before that

so theres kinda no way of getting new satchels as arthur

[arctic musk]

yeah i get that

[weary harness]

;-;

yeah nah i'm sorry

[cedar pasture]

Wonder why many people hates Abigail

Anyone wanna share a fraction of info?

Just a quick word on why she is hated

[weary harness]

because she is so ungrateful

john worked so hard for her

but she doesnt understand him

[cedar pasture]

That's a good info, hopefully I still gonna get the impact of experience this in the game later

[weary harness]

"oh but you will. you will be responsible for your actions" - the strange man

those who know 💀

[autumn lynx]

don't remind me

[cedar pasture]

Responsible for my action

Karma, isn't it?

Guess I have to just get this urge to go gun frenzy onto hunting

Instead of shooting random people

[weary harness]

"this is a fine spot." - strange man

[autumn lynx]

[weary harness]

"now go, git!" - john marston

[burnt orchid]

Chapter 5 was faster than i thought

[ivory lark]

Dutch

I'm tired dutch

[obsidian plinth]

Idk. It always felt like nothing was ever good enough for her, no matter what John did she always seemed so hateful towards him, even before the gang broke up. She's so grumpy.
I don't hate her, I just don't like her very much

[weary harness]

this

[cedar pasture]

I see

[weary harness]

she wouldnt listen to john

[obsidian plinth]

She was especially ungrateful during the first epilogue. She knew they didn't have much and John was trying his best to give her a better life the only way he could, by putting in his 20+ years of skill to win people over (his farm job)

[weary harness]

and then she left him

smh my head

poor john

[cedar pasture]

Can we uhh... Send her to another realm ? if we could, does it gonna affect our reputation meter ?

[weary harness]

we all had her

but john married her

that makes him the better man

[obsidian plinth]

And then he does get her the farm, when he could've just let her leave him forever.

But he still worked hard for her

[weary harness]

john is

[obsidian plinth]

You're a good man, John Marston

[weary harness]

epilogue john:

[autumn lynx]

the game is called red dead redemption for a reason

[weary harness]

rdr1 john:

[obsidian plinth]

When is Abigail's redemption

[weary harness]

we dont talk about my epilogue john

[weary harness]

😅 you see thats the thing

[cedar pasture]

Finals done, time to start

A little nervous ngl

[obsidian plinth]

I feel like in rdr1 she was under utilized as the wife of a gunslinger

But also I only played rdr1 once

[cedar pasture]

Uh, one more before i get on the game, Can Arthur swim?

[obsidian plinth]

Yeah

[autumn lynx]

yes

[fervent iris]

Is it possible to 100% the game as Arthur and then do the last mission?

[obsidian plinth]

But you do have a stamina bar and can still drown if it runs out

[cedar pasture]

I see, welp, time to step in

[obsidian plinth]

I don't think so, some stuff is region locked in new Austen (animal entries, bones, legendary animals and weapons and treasure)

[fervent iris]

hmm

[weary harness]

i find it stupid that arthur cant get legend of the east outfit

like

he is the legend of the east

[obsidian plinth]

You're gonna give me the satchel but not the oUTFIT??

[weary harness]

not john

him

[cedar pasture]

It says install rockstar launcher, does it gonna affect the game if i install it not in the same drive as where the game is?

[weary harness]

sorry i'm not pc

even though my... role says i am...

[obsidian plinth]

I think you need it, because it's linked to your rockstar acc and rdo stuff (I could be wrong)

[cedar pasture]

So, install it on the same drive then ?

[obsidian plinth]

I think that would be for the best

[cedar pasture]

Alright, ill install it in my Cell-D, steamapps common area

[obsidian plinth]

As long as the game files and stuff are all on the same drive it should be okay

I had moved a game away from the files once and I could not launch it

[faint jasper]

how many deer can you carry on a horse?

[analog estuary]

My saint denis tailor is missing since chapter 4 in my first singleplayer run. I am in chapter 6 now. Is this on purpose or is that a bug. Can anyone help me fix it

[formal lion]

how to beat the game in just one steap

[hoary nacelle]

Lenny

[obsidian plinth]

Me when I get socially anxious

[obsidian plinth]

Yeah I have no idea, maybe try shooting up the tailor to have police show up and run away. Idk if it'll help but I feel like it'll reset the location peds

[arctic musk]

1 deer carcass, infinite deer pelts

[cedar pasture]

Im back, finally got off that mountain

FInally in the woods, camp with the others

Now...uhh..what should i do ? three mission is up rn

Also, do you guys shave Arthur after got to that camp ??

[sage gale]

yes but your gonna need a wagon

[cedar pasture]

Drunk driving and make sure to not broke down the god damn wheel

[sage gale]

do whatever man, just get the mission down in the left first because its awesome (stick to the coast)

[cedar pasture]

The one in the camp? Alright

[fervent iris]

Wat

[sage gale]

no the bottom left of the whole map

[cedar pasture]

Oh, okay

[fervent iris]

So Arthur can go to new Austin?

Without cheats?

[sage gale]

if you use a wagon and make sure to hide your head the sniper cant hit you, it sees what you see so if you hide arthurs head which is what he shoots hes just gonna hit the wagon

a split second of it exposed and your dead unfortunately

[cedar pasture]

Hey uhh, so during this hunt with... Forgot the guy name, didn't get know him much yet. One with busted wing and uses bow. Did I make a mistake by not shooting that bear that we stumble by during way back to the safe house?

Back up that mountain

[fervent iris]

Alright thanks

[sage gale]

No that doesnt matter your gonna meet a bigger in a bit

or smaller

[cedar pasture]

I see, alrighty.

So go to bottom left first. Can't wait to get myself some gun oil, need to clean that revolver.

Also, am I do a bad thing by kill those three gentleman from the train and then get it run?

Cuz well, don't wanna end up have some feds up our rear

[sage gale]

i did the same

[cedar pasture]

I see. Ya know, I love dutch

And he stabilize after we reach that overlook for our camp

I mean look at his outfit and the way he treat us all

[sage gale]

Can i add you? i would love to hear from you as you progress the game you seem cool

[cedar pasture]

Sure thing, send it and I'll accept the request.

Ngl, I never feel this annoyed to snow

It feels so damn nice to be back on the good old grassy forest

Instead of these cold white powder mountain area

[obsidian plinth]

Howdy cowpokes, I have time off from work. Should I finally advance through the end of chapter 4, cry, and maybe just maybe finish the game so I can start all over again

[proven parrot]

ive seen some people get perfect pelts even thought the animal is 2 stars not 3 is it because of the buck antler trinket

[arctic musk]

buck antler trinket is a bad trinket

like 1 in 30 chance

doesnt even work with carcasses

[indigo belfry]

Hi a question i am doing the animal and plants quest but now I have to Find plants in a erea that is not open wat should i do ?

[burnt orchid]

Why u crying

[sweet jungle]

Do you mean new Austin?

You can only enter there with John

[indigo belfry]

The blackwater erea

For the rat plant

[sweet jungle]

Yea you cannot go there as Arthur

You can get there after you done all missions in arthurt

[indigo belfry]

Wait wat that is stupid

But thanks for the info @sweet jungle

[obsidian plinth]

Because this game makes me sad

[mighty heath]

anyone wanted to experience that they are on a ride with arthur morgan gang?

[sweet jungle]

np

[slate wadi]

What are all the optional honour missions? I’m gunning for completions with acheivements and I cannot figure out what all of them are when I swear I’ve finished them all

[arctic musk]

i replayed my last boy and i got the achievement for it

very odd

[slate wadi]

It might be the exotics I haven’t finished but I thought that was its own achievement 😭

[arctic musk]

thats not optional honour i believe

its not a main mission so

[slate wadi]

I didn’t think so either

[eternal sand]

i litrally have no option to save outfits?

just happened now

any idea why?

[obsidian plinth]

Is it not on the side? I don't know what button it is on keyboard, but on my ps5 controller it's R3 to save an outfit

[cunning elm]

I just had to fight off a wave of O’ Driscolls when another wave of bounty hunters conveniently came in at the same time…

[vale osprey]

Do you have the max amount of outfits you can store?

[eternal sand]

I have zero outfits

[uncut nimbus]

Is the outfit glitched?

Cause you cant save glitched outfits

[cold pebble]

Yo

[indigo remnant]

I just finished the mission "red dead redemption"

I miss arthur

[cedar pasture]

Should i sell the horse were given or stable it ??

The big boy

I got the mission to buy new horse

[past heart]

If you mean the black horse in Valentine, stable it.

[formal crag]

its the only horse of its kind in the game so i'd keep it

[broken dawn]

the big black horse?

keep it

I had him for awhile

A decent horse

Until I acidentally knocked a dude over with him in saint denis then he hit another horse barley half of his side and died

I killed all of saint denis

As arthur

But it was worth it

Once you get the stranger missions for old like outlaws or something do them

Free guns

[steep elm]

whatre the best places to find dogs?

any set spawns

[cedar pasture]

Yeah

[broken dawn]

Keep him

[cedar pasture]

So, which one to buy if we didnt go sell the big black?

[broken dawn]

Find any town

dmsll town

[broken dawn]

Cheapest

Sell it after the mission

[cedar pasture]

Alright then.

[broken dawn]

Keep the bbh

Until you get a white Arabian don’t use any other horse

Even then you should be able to get a good price for white arabians

[cedar pasture]

Alrighty, keep the BBH and buy the cheapest, sell the cheap afer the mission.

[cedar pasture]

How about the one we can tame at near lake izabella?

[broken dawn]

The one in the mountain?

[cedar pasture]

Yeah

[broken dawn]

You know it’s not just one right

They respawn last I checked

Correct me if I’m wrong PLEASR

[cedar pasture]

Nope, idk that

[broken dawn]

Should respawn after about 3 ingame days

For me it spawned literally in my horse

[zealous oyster]

giggty

which is better cattlerman or volanic

[naive gale]

What are the best places to catch fish I can sell

[zealous oyster]

ringneck creek for bass and the swamps are good places

for gar and sturgeon

don't try the river near annesburg since there is polluted fish there

[simple wyvern]

Rdr logic. Catching a fish, and throwing it back grants honor.
How does traumatizing a fish give you honor

[zealous oyster]

u made it live

so yuh

[naive gale]

It would be really fucking funny if your honor went down for keeping it

LMAO I idled on the keep/throw screen too long

The fish dies and Arthur comments on it

[zealous oyster]

me to happen with a poor bluegill i was going to toss back

[zealous oyster]

this would only work with really small fish instead of very fish u keep

[naive gale]

Nah it wouldn't work period for gameplay tbh

It would just be funny

[simple wyvern]

And now it's traumatized

It makes sense for little fish, not for big fish

[naive gale]

Dumbass question about real fishing, does the fish getting pierced through the side of its mouth not affect it that much or something?

[signal acorn]

guys is there any goldbar glitches that still work now in story mode? im in chapter 2

[vale osprey]

I dont believe so but IDK to be honest

[ionic juniper]

Is raven black shire a good horse?

[formal crag]

if it's a clean hook, they can usually recover just fine. they're only in real danger if you hook them through the head or stomach (this is called a foul hook) or if the hook barbs end up too deep in the fish's mouth

i foul hooked like 4 ladyfish in a row once i felt awful

[formal crag]

yes they're brave and don't get spooked easy

[autumn lynx]

i have one currently in my run, i named him onyx

he my good boah

[naive gale]

The legend of the east satchel is pretty based for letting Arthur carry like 200lbs of fish without slowing down somehow

[naive gale]

interesting, thanks for the info

[cedar pasture]

Finished the hunting mission, do we have to get that legendary bear like in that mission or we can finish him another time?

Cuz I didn't end up kill it, only scare it away

Lost my hat too since I got pinned down by it

Also, is it fine if everytime I stumble upon a small group of Driscoll boys, I dead eye them?

Cuz I've killed the ones that is hanging around by the treeline not far from our camp

Also I killed the guy who settle a camp in the forest, one that white wolf captured

He stares at me funny and point his gun at me

[novel compass]

Yep, you can go back for him along with hunting all the legendary animals on the map Hosea gave you

[novel compass]

I prefer tossing them in front of a train but same effect

[cedar pasture]

I see

So, my current set is the cattle man, sawn off and repeater.

What should be my next loadout after the first big score? I'm open to any suggestion

Pistol, Shotgun, Repeater combo

Rn for pistol, I'm thinking Schofield for replacement

[mortal trout]

I almost completed all 88% now

[sweet jungle]

Semi auto shotgun is pretty good but its up to you what you wanna use

[ivory lark]

The scout jacket looks so amazing

It's so much better than the gunslinger coat

Just a better version

[obsidian plinth]

Agreed. It's the best looking jacket in the game in my opinion

[gusty meadow]

anyone know a good spot to find greater prairie chicken? ive been looking online and going to all the places but just can’t find any

[obsidian plinth]

Google says near black water (great planes) or north of emerald ranch

[weary harness]

i thought there was just chicken

i got a chicken kill cam once

sick as hell

[obsidian plinth]

That sounds hella epic

[gusty meadow]

ive been going everywhere ive found online and can’t find one. been saving and reloading and traveling back and forth and everything and nothing

[obsidian plinth]

Found a YouTube video that says south of Valentine, between the N and E in the New Hanover, near caliban's seat. You could try there? I can send the link if you'd like

[gusty meadow]

sure thanks. ive been looking alla round black water emerald ranch rhodes and a few other places but just can’t find any

[obsidian plinth]

Had to send it in media chat but I tagged you! I hope it helps

[cedar pasture]

Does it exist in the Valentine gun store?

Need help to return this borrowed horse from uncle mission

Valentine horse

I can't find the owner anywhere

Even after uses clue from internet

Also I leave that boy alive, Jimmy Brooks

@obsidian plinth a little hand?

[obsidian plinth]

He should be near the butcher or gallows, that's where I've found him at least

[gusty meadow]

that spot finally spawned one thanks

[obsidian plinth]

I'm so glad ! You're welcome

[cedar pasture]

Can't find him near the butcher, I'll try gallow next

Or just... Leave the town for a day or two then came back

[obsidian plinth]

You can try riding around the town until he pops up ?

[sweet jungle]

You cannot buy it but you can get it from a old lady that lives in a cottage

@cedar pasture Sent you a tutorial how to get the semi auto shotgun

[cedar pasture]

I guess I'll try

[cedar pasture]

Okay

Hopefully I can get it this early

Instead of have to wait till later on

[sweet jungle]

You can go there whenever you want

there shouldnt be any restrictions

[obsidian plinth]

Any luck?

[cedar pasture]

Just closed the shop, not yet playing now

[crisp summit]

can anyone help me on getting white arabian tutorials dont work

[arctic musk]

what doesnt work?

[crisp summit]

when i do everything that the tutorial says to do

like where the horse is

i go there

i even start to go in stealth from far

but white arabians never there

[indigo sentinel]

yo

i just beat the epilouge what shold i do now

[empty sparrow]

whatever you want

if you want to continue the story you can play the first game

but there's still probably a lot more side quests you can do

[rapid locust]

huh? the story continues in the first game?

[empty sparrow]

red dead 2 is a prequel

[daring imp]

Ist there a rdr1 remaster planed

[empty sparrow]

I mean the game is already on steam and plays fine enough

[rapid locust]

Ohh

I'm playing the epilogue rn, started it about 4 hours ago

[empty sparrow]

yeah the epilogue is mainly just to connect stuff to the first game

[rapid locust]

Don't know how I never heard of this game earlier 😭

[daring imp]

Just started my second playthrough the first one was with out watching anything for guidance and now i want to tresure Hunt and complete as mich as possible

[empty sparrow]

also rockstar likely has most resources on GTA6 so we won't get that in a while

[daring imp]

thats a good point

[molten crest]

i'm on my third playthrough delaying the missions because i have to go to the downes family and rescue the rat

[daring imp]

i would love to be able to Pick fight with Camp members

[molten crest]

Especially micah

[daring imp]

The Rat would be dead a long time ago if that were possible

[molten crest]

and also to pick a fight with lil jack

[daring imp]

damn Abigail would knock you out cold

[molten crest]

or javier

[rapid locust]

🙏💀

lil jack is the best character fr

[daring imp]

you realy think Jack is mexican

[molten crest]

I was joking

[rapid locust]

no

[daring imp]

i mein in rdr1 he looks a bit like it but still he is Johns boy

[molten crest]

Aside If i punched jack, John might kill me

[daring imp]

german Auto correct is annoying

[molten crest]

The austrian loanshark also deserves a beating frfr

[daring imp]

agreed

[molten crest]

givin my boah tb

[rapid locust]

same

wait so

at the end of the epilogue, I heard we get to kill micah?

that true?

[daring imp]

jep

[molten crest]

Yah

[daring imp]

best Part in the epilog

[molten crest]

Aside from housebuilding lol

[daring imp]

i Plan to let him burg down with a fire arrow or tut arrow

[rapid locust]

my god the housebuilding was so beautiful

[molten crest]

especially the music

[daring imp]

yea the ripped native working together with John

[cedar pasture]

Nope still no luck sadly

[rapid locust]

i was mad on uncle tho 💀

[molten crest]

and lumbago just telling instructions

[indigo belfry]

Can i finish the legendary fish quest with Arthur ???

[obsidian plinth]

Nope. There's three fish in new Austen

[arctic musk]

what chapter are you in?

[crisp summit]

im on 3 but no need i somehow found it

[arctic musk]

nice

[vagrant fractal]

hello

[naive grove]

Hi

[cedar pasture]

Got the shotgun from the six point cabin

Is it good?

[past heart]

The double barrel over the fireplace?

[cedar pasture]

Yep

[arctic musk]

its good

[ionic juniper]

Have most people here finished the game?

[daring imp]

Is there any way to get gillamonster hide as Arthur?

[obsidian plinth]

rampage mod, spawn yourself one

[daring imp]

Thx

[sage gale]

Im doing herbalist 7 rn and the herbs just wont respawn, i have reloaded save twice, restarted the game twice and slept like 10 ingame days

what could i be doing wrong

[frank apex]

Do I have to skip cutscenes to get gold in "Old Friends" mission in Chapter 1?

[arctic musk]

no i dont think so why?

[frank apex]

I am just watching one tutorial and he is saying you have to

I am not sure if the cutscene time counts in the mission timer or no

[arctic musk]

i think only in 1 mission

stagecouch with micah mission

[frank apex]

Aight

I will try

[arctic musk]

what guide are u using

[frank apex]

All The Shinies, Jimbatron and the RDR2 book

[ionic juniper]

There are a lot of gameplay differences between Arthur and Marston, as if there are more random events in free roaming with Arthur

[shell barn]

Yes

[toxic pagoda]

Can some one who has played the entire game multiple times call me

I have a question

[ionic juniper]

I miss playing with Arthur

[toxic pagoda]

Before Arthur dies, can you sell your horse to a stable and buy him as John?

[ionic juniper]

I don't think most horses you find with Arthur are not found when you play with John

I will stop doing mission after I get some gold and money I don't want to play with marston at the end of the game

[cyan pendant]

No you can still find all the Arabians

[shell anvil]

Hello

[burnt orchid]

Most of you played rdr2 then 1 or the opposite?

[uncut nimbus]

Bro i fucking hate saint denis im trying to get every hat in the game and everytime i gotta check what hat someone is wearing i either get "disturbing the peace" or "unarmed assault" and then i get arrested and then i loose the hat and then i gotta search for another 45 min

#removesaintdenis #removedisturbingthepeace #makesdwomenstopsnitching

[ionic juniper]

Can we have the horses from the horse stealing mission?

There must be chapter 3

[hidden moss]

Someone give me motivation to finish rdr1 I haven't beat it yet and don't know the ending I need motivation bonnys missions are crushing my spirt

[odd fog]

looking for any tips on getting cougars to spawn north of trapper in West Elizabeth trying to get legend of the east satchel

[cedar pasture]

Any tips on how to win 1v5 bounty hunters?

[exotic cove]

Idk

[cedar pasture]

Not to mention fighting those Driscoll's on horse when we travel to the east from our camp?

[exotic cove]

Deadeye

[cedar pasture]

Still sometime lose in a fistfight and gunfight

[cedar pasture]

Still training it out, not yet got easy with it

Btw guys, I stumble upon this.. Abandoned house while chasing a debt guy

And jesus Christ it's spooky

The guy on the main table is a skeleton

Everyone there is bones

[odd fog]

i got the perfect cougar pelt now just the pather wish me luck

[delicate solstice]

For new gamers maybe like u it is better to always have tonics.
And by using dead eye and good guns it is pretty easy to take out many guys. And u can have a strategy to not face them all at the same time. Like running and they come after u so take them one by one. If u r on full hp even 10 guys can't knock u out don't worry.

[serene dagger]

Kinda late, but I've found the best game ever. Sorry it took so long, but I'm here. 😆

Being so late here, I feel like every question i ask, is the 1,000,000,000 time it has been asked.

I'm sure there is links to most of my questions. I've completed the story and basically thought I would never finish the game so I stuck to the story. (Not explore, "stopped to smell the roses") it was mostly one mission after the other.

Now I want to play it and choose from the various play styles people have come up with. I do want my new play through to be much harder, life like. So no tonics, no radar - stuff like that.

Where should I start? Who has links to the holy grail of information overload?

[hidden moss]

Is this game buggy or something

In Epilogue 1, I was fighting but mouse buttons are not working in the fight .

10 sec ago I was doing gun fight , the mouse button was working fine

[obsidian plinth]

It's always freaky finding spooky stuff in this game.

[cedar pasture]

I see, well rn my guns are...

Schofield (single wield)
Two barrel shotty from the fireplace
And the standard repeater.

I'm mostly stationary and not a good on the move shooter. Just.. Hide behind cover, then stand up and shoot.

Still not used to with item wheel using in middle of combat to refill health and dead eye. But I will try train more.

I'm currently trying my best to not get bounty every time I kill a Driscols

[cedar pasture]

Yeah, I was worried that I will get some sort of jump scare since when I enter the house it's already night time rising.

[cedar pasture]

Because my spendings now been always paying my bounty

[molten crest]

My horse got shot up by o'driscolls, I ran all the way to valentine and bought horse revivers and ran back to my horse and revived it

[lapis sable]

I love disturbing the peace!!!

[uncut nimbus]

#removedisturbingthepeace😔

[lapis sable]

Bullets in the heads of everyone!

[uncut nimbus]

Its fun to do when your not spending hours searching for a thing

[lapis sable]

Maybe we should search for the thing with law chasing us

I guide law to the jack hall treasure zone, i shoot out thetr, i get the treasure

[uncut nimbus]

Im searching for "the thing" in saint denis i aint having yhe law on me in there

[lapis sable]

What thing in saint denis

[uncut nimbus]

Hats

Stealable hats

Im tryna get every single one

[molten crest]

bro became the hat thief

[uncut nimbus]

Its actually fun to steal hats because i can make like 10 new outfits with each hat

[molten crest]

I might try it

[uncut nimbus]

I got a list that can give you i think every hat

Well every hat obtainable after completing epilogue because i aint starting a new playthrough for some fucking hats

Some hats are missable

[molten crest]

ok

[uncut nimbus]

Wait what chapter are you on

[molten crest]

chapter 2

[uncut nimbus]

Epilogue or nah

[summer cosmos]

Does the white Arabian respawn after the final mission with Arthur

[uncut nimbus]

Yeah

All arabians will respawn after 3 ingame days doesnt matter which mission you do

[summer cosmos]

Thx

Ts

Wait if I have rdr2 as a disc is till have time get ps plus for online right

Ion wanna do the update just to not play it

[obsidian plinth]

Yup

[summer cosmos]

Shi

This server empty asf

[uncut nimbus]

Its pretty empty but you can find some decent people

[summer cosmos]

Ig

[final wigeon]

exotics r the worst 100% requirement in the entire game

some sadist developer was CACKLING when he made this 😭

4 hours.. for the first of four parts....

[arctic musk]

i kinda liked the other collectibles but these were worse

also for most side quests i recommend getting the things before the side quests because theyre harder to get when you have the side quest like hunting requests or exotics

[final wigeon]

that's so evil

[arctic musk]

yeah

[final wigeon]

I hate how so much of it is luck 😭

[arctic musk]

ive heard its so rockstar gets more money because people invest in them if people have alot of hours or something

online also makes you afk in missions for more money

[arctic musk]

yeah but how else could you make it

[final wigeon]

uuuuh

guaranteed set animal spawns...

to not make me run around for 90 minutes looking for the last singular egress feather I needed 😭

[arctic musk]

wont you be able to get infinite of that animal super easy then?

[final wigeon]

I mean

they do already have like a 3 day respawn period

[arctic musk]

and in the open world animals might look weird always being in a few spots

[arctic musk]

i just reloaded my save file a bunch and it'd spawn them

[final wigeon]

didn't the same kinda go for herbalist 9

red sage only being near tumbleweed and nowhere else on the map

[arctic musk]

i didnt know that actually i thought all herbs had a ton of locations

[final wigeon]

some do

like mint and oregano and stuff

[arctic musk]

if you know the spawn mechanics of some animals you can get them pretty efficiently but its not that fun

[final wigeon]

red sage is only in I think it's called cholla springs?

[arctic musk]

if it had guaranteed set animal spawns what if you want to each one already

the bayou isnt that big and birds are still supposed to be rare

[final wigeon]

I guess

but

running around aimlessly and just

hoping that you're lucky is so much worse than silly animal spawns 😭

I'm never recovering from the egress hunt

[arctic musk]

i just reload my save near a spawn location it works good

iirc they spawned everytime

or most times

[molten crest]

no

[uncut nimbus]

Bet

[uncut nimbus]

Dms

[frozen peak]

can saving and reloading change an animal to 3 stars

[arctic musk]

no

[cedar pasture]

For taking out big animals

Shotgun or repeater?

And which shell that fits the job?

[hybrid patrol]

my map is completely empty like ive never stepped foot anywhere suddenly?

idk where to post a picture but like i had the entire thing discovered before

also my horse is completely gone, nowhere to be seen in the map anywhere

[hoary nacelle]

@hybrid patrol Close the game and restart🗿

[hybrid patrol]

lol still the same

something strange that happened just before is i fast travelled from one end of the map to the other via my camp, and both my main horse and temp horse were with me, but once i fast travelled i was just walking without my horse and thats when the horse disappeared

then restarted the game, crash, restart again, crash, then restarted again and no crash but my map is undiscovered and the horse is still gone xd

the horse still exists on the horse stats view, but with completely empty health and stamina cores so idk if the horse magically died or?

[molten crest]

for me it's repeater with high velocity or express

[arctic musk]

shotgun with slugs but rifle is better

[ionic juniper]

the white Arabian horse is too small, it didn't look so bad on Marston, but it's a bit strange on Arthur

In fact, even if it is the fastest horse, for me it is also important whether it is brave or not

[molten crest]

arthur looks goofy on a small arabian lol

[hybrid patrol]

Lol I whistled and my horse literally spawned out of thin air right in front of me, like dropped from the sky

[quartz trellis]

Man, i swear, modding rdr2 sp is the most tedious thing, i install em mods, then after a while, decide i want to play online, so i delete all the mods, then another time i gotta reinstall the whole thing of mods 😭 also, conviniently, it allways passes just enough time for me to forget how to do it, so i have to watch a guy explaining it on youtube

[molten crest]

heavenly horse

[burnt orchid]

Dont you think that the ending is kinda dissapointing?

[arctic musk]

why would it be

its one of the best endings in video games

[burnt orchid]

Like the character you spent hours and probably days shaping it, building it, dies like that and just some moments later im carrying groceries with john, like hey arthur just died !

[arctic musk]

what else should there have been after he died

[burnt orchid]

Revenge ? Or just end the game ?

[arctic musk]

how would you be able to play the open world

[fluid compass]

What is the best horse to get?

[arctic musk]

but i understand you my english isnt good enough to explain why i liked the ending alot

[arctic musk]

does price matter?

[fluid compass]

No

[arctic musk]

missiouri fox trotter

aka rose gray arabian

[fluid compass]

Where cab I get it

[arctic musk]

blackwater stable i think

[fluid compass]

How much is it

[arctic musk]

maybe like 2k

[fluid compass]

Okay thanks

[arctic musk]

np

[steady edge]

I DID IT I finished it

now what 💀

[cedar pasture]

Guys quick

Should I kill the old lady or not? Own where we get the semi-auto shotgun

[stuck garnet]

hello guys

can somene tell me how they know that I'm arthur when I had full mask on and robbed a bank?

after it I shaved cutted my hair and switched clotes

never had this problem

[pine oar]

the game just automatically knows

[cedar pasture]

Hey guys, where can I buy a dynamite?

[burnt orchid]

U gonna play the epilogue
Im wondering if its worth playing?

[steady edge]

alr played, it's worth

[lapis sable]

Worth playing

You get to shoot micah

[fair oak]

Guys which horse sell for the most at Clive?

[tame nebula]

the reason why its my fav game ever

[tame nebula]

uhh?

oh i know