red-dead-singleplayer

[arctic musk]

some people like easy boring stuff, grinding etta doyle in rdo and grinding cayo perico in gtao

[valid field]

Would the things I do even get me leveled up ? @arctic musk@slim dock

[arctic musk]

some, but barely i think

[valid field]

dang okay sticking to singleplayer oof

[random salmon]

yo where do i play poker

i just started basically done a few challenges and cant find where to play it

not in valentine not saint dennis

[obsidian plinth]

This is form the wiki page:
Red Dead Redemption 2

Valentine: $2.50
Tumbleweed: $2.50
Saint Denis: $5.00
Flatneck Station: $2.50
Blackwater: $5.00
Sometimes available to play with gang members at any camp with a $1.00 buy-in.
Played during the mission "A Fine Night of Debauchery"

[slim dock]

Of course, you level up by just doing stuff. There’s also a few scripted missions you can play with multiple people . They were fun to play for the first time with friends

[valid field]

I think online is the only way to pull off a train robbery ngl

[deft knot]

Cant find this skunk bruh

[rough hemlock]

I finished the story mode some time ago and decided to hop on again but the moment i loaded into story mode i saw that i was playing as arthur morgan if you know what happened shouldn't i be playing as john now?

[glacial crypt]

Look into progress and check if u played every mission

If not

Then u didn’t save

[rough hemlock]

yeah it says also 100% completed

[glacial crypt]

Then

Play some mission doesn’t matter which one

And then

Fail the mission

So u can quit it

And it should be fixed

I think

@rough hemlock did it work?

[rough hemlock]

Sorry didn't see the ping

im at the airport rn ill check when i get home

thanks

[rancid maple]

As in you are at Beachers hope as Arthur

[rough hemlock]

as in i can roam the whole map as arthur

just like im playing normally

[rancid maple]

Does he have black hair

[rancid maple]

Like
Brown hair
TB Arthur?

[rough hemlock]

grey hair

[rancid maple]

Like jet black?

Has a scar on the face?

[rough hemlock]

I don't look at the details

he has grey hair

rides on the same horse

[rancid maple]

I don't think you have a glitch then

They just heavily fucked up John in the rdr2 epilogue

And gave him Arthur's body and head

Just with black hair and John's scar

[rough hemlock]

Thats a new one

[rancid maple]

Did you have to update the game before going into story

[rough hemlock]

ill make a screenshot of how he looks lemme start up rq

[rough hemlock]

no

[rancid maple]

Alr

Send it in general media

And ping me

[rough hemlock]

alr

[drifting vapor]

Had no clue about the exploding house in new Austin. Scared the 💩 outta me

[slim dock]

Are there any reason to have good honor when you’ve finished the story? . Or can I finally just go ham now

[drifting vapor]

Not really no. Some npcs may act slightly different but nothing really story wise changes one way or another

[random salmon]

how do i achieve rdr2 gambler 8

[kindred kayak]

Complete the “Who is not without sin” mission. That unlocks poker.

[lapis sable]

“Justice will be served in this town today!”

I overheard Sheriff Malloy announcing the execution of one criminal.

That criminal had a family, and the way I see it, he was just defending himself.

He made his peace. His wife and son was wailing.

Everyone seem evil and nonchanlant about that poor dad.

So… I did what had to be done.

I took my Lancaster Repeater with EXPLOSIVE ammo, and shot all the lawmen and Sheriff Malloy in the fricking head.

And I shoot everybody else except the wife and boy. They look better without heads for doing such a flawed judgement.

And then I used a schofield revolver with regular ammo to free the man.

I told him to go be with his family.

That man will always remember me as a hero and brother. And I got the Rolling Block Rifle! 😄

And then I shoot up the entire town of Valentine until I got max bounty, and ran. The End.

Now the man won’t have annoying neighbours that will rat that man out

and the town of Valentine remains in lockdown

Some days pass, I return to Valentine when it’s off lockdown, got confronted by a widow, calling me a murderer and I should rot in hell…

Well that ain’t very nice. I help folk by killing bad people. The way I see it? Her husband is one of the bad ones.

So I shot her in the head with an explosive ammo. She can join her husband in hell.

I wouldn’t worry about the three kids she mentioned. They might as well join the church instead of being with those lousy people.

Naturally people got riled up. So I shot everyone again! Did some rooftop hide and seek to get to my horse which ran to the other side of town.

Ran away again. Met some bounty hunters that told me to come along easy. Well… bounty hunters are also outlaws. So who cares? I shoot those damned hypocrites up too.

But all these ruckus ended when in my joyride i accidentally led the law to camp :/

And I got a scolding from Miss Grimshaw and Dutch

“Hey Arthur, are you the lunatic that’s been shooting all them people?”

Noise, Dutch. NOISE!

[lapis sable]

My guess for my next target? Being the top menace in Blackwater. With the power of Rampage Mod that disables the snipers, it’s me charging into Blackwater to kill as many people and retrieve the Blackwater Money from the townspeople!

150,000 in gold and items. Let’s recollect them all!

[woeful gull]

I got the jack hall map from that traveller but I can't find it in my satchel now??? why

I wanted to go treasure hunting

[rancid maple]

Where even is that I've never seen it

[arctic musk]

if you have a high number in cards go out the blackjack table and go in again until you get low number in cards

then when you have low just hit 3 times i think

[unborn pasture]

anyone know how tp push the bartender on pc for doing the stranger quest, I've tried alot of stuff and everytime i get wanted or just punch the gyt

[hoary nacelle]

Guys whats the best weapon to hunt big animals

[haughty dirge]

Big gun

strong gun

Shoot in head

animal die

[harsh narwhal]

I'm doing the poker mission in chapter 4 what do I do when strauus says no by moving head in a no direction

[haughty dirge]

check the hints

yknow the lil popup that shows up every now and then on the top left of your screen

check em carefully

[harsh narwhal]

Should I fold when he moves his head in a no direction

And call when moves his head in a yes direction

[haughty dirge]

when his head moves in a yes direction go all in

if his head shakes then fold

[unborn pasture]

anyone know how to push the bartender on pc for doing the stranger quest, I've tried alot of stuff and everytime i get wanted or just punch the guy

[haughty dirge]

wut

I'm confuzzled

what stranger mission is this

[unborn pasture]

Uh I saw on YouTube u could get Calloway revolver early by pushing the bartender

But I don’t know how to push the guy

[haughty dirge]

get really close to him

actually nvm scratch that uhh

just follow the vid step by step or smth

..or do the Calloway missions :*

[unborn pasture]

The video just said “push him” if I get really close to the man and press left click I just punch him

[arctic musk]

rolling block rifle
if you have rare rolling block rifle use that for slightly more accuracy
or use the springfield for animals close to you and it has a scope you can toggle but it doesnt zoom in as much as others
use express ammo for any of these

if you're hunting legendary animals use explosive ammo on any weapon or a shotgun

[median haven]

Ok apparently don’t shoot down birds that land within Dutch’s first yellow mission spot on the Guarma map because they disappear when you approach? There go my red footed boobies!

🎶theeeeere go my boobies🎶 sung to the tune of that Foo Fighters song

Watch them as they fall

[median haven]

Oh shoot it’s been a while, do all these Guarma missions go one after another until I’m off the island? I didn’t get the snakes yet.. maybe I’ll glitch back as John if so (if that still works?)

When you drink until you pass out in a certain spot where you wake up outside the map and walk to Guarma

And if you can still glitch there as John can he get the sun hat?

Totally forgot once you start Dutch’s mission it goes though the entirety of Guarma

[arctic musk]

yes he can get it

[arctic musk]

that works but theres also other less efficient ways

[median haven]

Ok nice cuz I don’t wanna redo all that over again hah

Arthur keeps coughing he must have a cold or something

[arctic musk]

yeah i did the guarma trick too you can make some cool pictures there just make sure to pick the right weapons and clothing because you cant change them

[distant falcon]

What I do is I just make sure I get the hat before leaving guarma

Which I did and now have..

[median haven]

Feels good to be back on the map now tho

[median haven]

Yeah I meant to, I thought I had more free roam time after doing Dutch’s mission, I was running around picking up hats through all the missions haha, didn’t get it tho

I got all the birds but not snakes

[exotic nest]

guys i gonna play rpg (story games) on ps5 i have option like buying a gaming monitor (qhd , 144hz , 32 inch) for $320 or budget tv (4k 60hz , 55 inch) for $360
which will be give me more game quality , which should i buy

[distant falcon]

Get 144 hz

Plus cheaper may only be seen as worse but 144hz is minimum for best quality

Monitors like that are what I plan to get in the future

[median haven]

I wish we had more horse stalls so bad

[distant falcon]

Yeah need rdo amounts

[exotic nest]

but it is less brighter than tv like (400 nits) and many says tv gives more immersive experince for story games

is that true

[plush geode]

144hz will make everything much smoother imo better than 60 hz 4K

[exotic nest]

but in ps5 many story games locked in 60 fps right

[exotic nest]

what games u play rpg or battle royale?

[plush geode]

It’ll still look better, I had a 144hz monitor and my dad had a 60hz 4K when I was younger and I’d hands down pick 144 for any game

Even if it’s capped

Capped by game is different than capped by software

[plush geode]

I play a bit of everything

[exotic nest]

ok

thk

[arctic musk]

ive heard for ps5 its locked to 30fps for rdr2

[exotic nest]

1440p is ok right 4k is not essential for monitor ?

[distant falcon]

It’s locked for Xbox as well

But it’s always been like that

[median haven]

Yeah I’d love the Breton in story mode

[distant falcon]

I’d love to collect every unique wild horse

[median haven]

I’ve got a dark bay Turkoman, dapple Hungarian halfbreed and brindle thoroughbred racing n my stalls now, riding a silver dapple pinto MFT

[distant falcon]

I wish that I could find a 1 to 1 copy of old boy for my John but you can’t

There are a lot of things I wish I could have but being console stops me..

[median haven]

Yeah same I picked up that piebald tobiano Hungarian halfbreed you get when riding back to shady bell but I have no more space

Hate to sell it but ah well.. I think you can get another from bounty hunters I forget

[median haven]

You don’t keep hats when replaying missions right?

[haughty dirge]

YEAH

and more horses

i NEED more horses

albino Arabian my beloved

[median haven]

Right? We should be able to buy more horse stalls, I’d pay like $1k per slot if I needed to

[haughty dirge]

ooo

donation system to fund construction for buildings in town would be fire

it technically is in the game with that house near valentine with the dad and the two sons and the memorial hall in Saint Denis but imo it's underutilised

[median haven]

Arthur just fell over coughing, he was probably just really tired

[vague ravine]

arthur just likes being dramatic, he is fine

[median haven]

Now I just wanna get to the epilogue, only did that once so far

Might have to play rdr1 after this!

John can rob the Saint Denis gun store back room later right? What about any leftover wagon missions? I think I have one or two left in strawberry

Rhodes guy told me he was closing up shop for wagon stuff after I got back from Guarma I forget if I did them all or if they have a time limit

[obsidian plinth]

Just strep throat. He'll be fine

[median haven]

Yeah the doctor didn’t make any sense all he said was “I hurt my toe, sis” but I didn’t see his sister anywhere.. weird!

[obsidian plinth]

Damn. I hope her toe is okay :(

[median haven]

Does Arthur always fall over before the mission with Sadie or is it random in Saint Denis?

[frigid anchor]

Hey guys

[median haven]

The hot air balloon one

[frigid anchor]

I finished epilogue like 3 weeks ago

[obsidian plinth]

I'm not sure

[frigid anchor]

Nothing can compare now to rdr2

[obsidian plinth]

Agreed

It's left a deep impression on me from the first time I played it five years ago

[median haven]

Yeah nothing matches up with it. I have other favorite games but very few hold a place in my heart like rdr2

[formal crag]

Yes

Before sadie

[frigid anchor]

Im trying to play the witcher now though, BUT its still not the same

[median haven]

Ok just curious mostly thanks

[frigid anchor]

It honestly was the best time ever, it took me 3 months to finish the whole game

[obsidian plinth]

I wanna try playing the Witcher. I watched the first season on Netflix when it came out but I feel like I need to experience it in game form

[median haven]

I love the Witcher 3. Horizon Zero Dawn is another one of my favorite gaming experiences because I went in without knowing anything about it, just figured “oooh neat robot dinosaur” but slowly uncovering the story through data points when you’re exploring the world was one of my favorite things

I mostly am just into 3rd person open world RPGs. Besides Diablo 1 and 2 I played those a ton too

Ghost of Tsushima was fun but no RDR2

[frigid anchor]

id just yap about it to the people who knew nothing about the game, i couldnt really study cause i kept thinking about the plot, it was so amazing

[frigid anchor]

i do want to play it

ive heard its also long?

[median haven]

Beautiful game, I really love how there is very minimal UI, to follow things you follow which way the wind is blowing it’s a pretty good idea

Yeah maybe 40 hours or so? I forget. Good chunk of time tho

[frigid anchor]

Same i hate first person perspective

[median haven]

Me too and I wish I didn’t! There are so many games I wish I could get into like fallout stuff and cyberpunk etc

[frigid anchor]

But i do want to try to play cyberpunk tho

Yeah!

[median haven]

I dunno what it is, 3rd person or top down view for me

[obsidian plinth]

Me too!

But it's so expensive I'm waiting for a sale

[frigid anchor]

Exactly im thinking about trying cyberpunk but im scared of the first person perspective

ive heard it makes the game even better in this case

[obsidian plinth]

I've played baldur's gate 3, and it IS fun, but it's no rdr2.

[median haven]

Aww I hate when the free cam is blocked, like I can’t orbit the camera in photo mode during this hot air balloon ride… boooo

[frigid anchor]

What was your fav mission in rdr2?

[median haven]

Yeah I gotta revisit that, I liked it enough. I’ve been playing PoE2 the last couple weeks I’m enjoying it, it’s a lot like diablo 2

[median haven]

1,000,000% the one where you all roll up to the Braithwaite manor and Dutch yells “get down here NOW, you inbred TRASH!” - the music is so good too I honestly listen to that track all the time

Aww can’t post links but Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern

[frigid anchor]

Thats yeah one of the best missions but also missions in chap 3 in general they were really great

[median haven]

Sososososo good

[frigid anchor]

chapter 3 and 5 my fav id say

I liked chapter 5 cause it kinda reminds me of tomb raider, i liked the vibe

[median haven]

Yeah I usually stay in chapter 3 for as long as possible, but I usually fizzle out after that. Only did the epilogue once but have replayed it many times, just never finished it a second time so I’m doing that now

And gonna try to 100% and platinum

[frigid anchor]

oh so u replay the game :D

I feel like i need a few years to come back

[median haven]

Oh yeah for sure. Even just to boot it up some early mornings and fishing or hunting with coffee

Did online for a while

[frigid anchor]

Woah amazing

[median haven]

I enjoyed it, wish there was more to do. I pretty much have everything at this point and nothing left to spend gold on

[frigid anchor]

I wanted to do that too but its just too much effort

😂

[median haven]

I know I’m trying not to burn myself out playing too much, I’ll boot it up on weekend mornings and try to tackle some of the stuff

[arctic musk]

you can post them in the media channels #red-dead-media has 10 min cooldown and #general-media doesnt

[haughty dirge]

ngl, it's gotta be any of the train robberies or bank robberies in the game (especially the Oil Wagon train robbery in ch. 2, the army train robbery in ch. 6, Sodom? Back to Gomorrah, and the Saint Denis Bank Robbery are amazing)

but if i gotta pick? I'll say overall it's American Venom. it's gotta be one of the best endings to a video game I've ever had the pleasure of witnessing, sure it was very fanservicey but I still enjoy it a bunch because of how replayable it is. I'd have to say my second fave mission has to be Dear Uncle Tacitus, I really enjoyed the ride back to Shady Belle

[arctic musk]

most fun and immersive way to rob stuff like stores and trains?

[hollow dirge]

Where do I change clothes as John in beachers hope??

[arctic musk]

i think when you walk in from the front go left

[hollow dirge]

Thx

[haughty dirge]

in the bathroom

[haughty dirge]

Shoot and ask questions later

[arctic musk]

i like robbing the general store at a train station
i tried to rob the train after going away from valentine

but it stopped at the oil place

also ill try to play without ui in first person with iron sights and stuff i think that makes it better

[haughty dirge]

speaking of that cunt at the general store

[arctic musk]

doesnt he have a prostetic leg or is that the one in strawberry

[haughty dirge]

I'll give him another one

[haughty dirge]

I don't get why some outfits are locked to high honor only

[arctic musk]

yeah some honor unlocks are annoying

[haughty dirge]

I'm trying to be a good man now because one of the outfits he's selling has a good black coat

but it's really hard

I went to the Saint Denis police station to collect a bounty

but I accidentally pointed my gun at one of the officers

[arctic musk]

my horse doesnt have good handling or smth when they see cops

[haughty dirge]

and I had to surrender cause I'm not gonna lose all the honor I built up

and I lost five dollars

those five dollars meant something to me

I earned those five dollars

now I have to get these bum ass bounties to get my honor up and shit

[hidden moss]

im on chapter 2 but ive heard smth about arthur dying

is that true

idc it’s spoil

[arctic musk]

yeah it is unfortunately

[hidden moss]

oh 😭

[haughty dirge]

Fri is lying

[formal crag]

theres more than 1 ending

[hidden moss]

oh

[haughty dirge]

Arthur goes to Tahiti with Dutch and Hosea and they dance around as mango farmers

[formal crag]

dont look at this server too much till u finish the game

[tame dome]

Yeah, either you die like an asshole or a semi good person

[formal crag]

try an avoid spoilers if u can 🙏

[arctic musk]

dutch harvest mango's and hosea bananas

[haughty dirge]

chat stop spoiling to a beginner

this is not behaviour

[hidden moss]

😭

[formal crag]

Man shut up 🤦‍♂️

[arctic musk]

ill just fish a bit for max honor

[haughty dirge]

I'm gonna have to report you to the local authorities

[hidden moss]

im in the low end already😭

[haughty dirge]

see I tried that

[tame dome]

Fishing gives honor???

[arctic musk]

catch and releasing them

[tame dome]

I didn't know that

[arctic musk]

its like 90 fish for lowest to highest honor ive heard

[tame dome]

WOW

[formal crag]

just enjoy the game bro there's 4 endings depending on the decisions you make 🙏

[arctic musk]

it doesnt show the bar bumping up though so you have to check every once in a while

[hidden moss]

holy shit

[haughty dirge]

I better start fishing then

[hidden moss]

im stalking this chat now

[arctic musk]

i got spoiled about alot on rdr2 but it still had a lot i didnt expect

[haughty dirge]

Don't

[hidden moss]

okay💔

[haughty dirge]

there will be consequences

[hidden moss]

I’ll try

[arctic musk]

i also got spoiled about rdr1 🙂

[formal crag]

the game is WAAAY more enjoyable if you dont know what happens so def avoid this channel

[haughty dirge]

you will know too much

[haughty dirge]

and basically every channel in this server

[formal crag]

and take ur time dont rush thru the chapters 🙏 lots of side quests

[tame dome]

Honestly, my dad spoiled EVERYTHING, just lied about when it happens to I'd get jumpscared by stuff

[formal crag]

yeah except like camp stew and pet pics

[haughty dirge]

even those

[formal crag]

noooo😭

[haughty dirge]

you don't know when the spoilers come spoiling

[hidden moss]

my dogs in pet pics

[formal crag]

your dog is VERY cutesy

[hidden moss]

ty

off topic now..

[haughty dirge]

there is an alarming amount of bird pics in pet pics

guess the number

0

[arctic musk]

fun immersive way to rob trains with law?

[haughty dirge]

keep the train moving

it'll alert law

[arctic musk]

and if i stop it?

[haughty dirge]

lower chances of law being alerted

[tame dome]

You'll be fine, just gonna have to fight law

[haughty dirge]

unless you make some noise

[tame dome]

Yeah, is it possible to sneak kill the guards?

[haughty dirge]

I don't think

unless they're scattered

which they usually aren't

[arctic musk]

where do i rob the train? it stopped at the oil factory last time

there were so many enemies

[tame dome]

Anywhere a little away from town

[haughty dirge]

you can wait for a train to spawn at one of the stops or order some tickets at a post office with railroads

very important btw

[arctic musk]

i dont feel like waiting ngl

[haughty dirge]

some towns have post offices but no railroads

and you can't access trains thst way

Strawberry, Blackwater and Tumbleweed

and I think Van Horn?

the rest have railroads

[arctic musk]

what spot do you reccomend i rob a train?

[haughty dirge]

I recommend taking a train from Valentine to Annesberg

wait for the train to take off into Ambarino

and start robbing

OR

you can recreate John's train robbery by placing an oil wagon in the railroad

causing the train to stop

[bitter fossil]

Led the law to beechers hope then I got shot so I didn't find out if there was anything that happens. is there?

[tacit topaz]

I like wasting money apparently

I have spent nearly 6k in chapter 2

I did spend like 200 dollars on 99 moonshind

[slim dock]

How? Everything in the game is so cheap, especially compared to the online. Most expensive thing in the game is often your bounty

[tacit topaz]

I dont even kniw

[slim dock]

If you buy all weapons and cloths, ur still not spending 6k I think

[tacit topaz]

Okay i did die like 5 times trying to do weapon expert stuff in cornballs oil place

I lost like 600 there

[slim dock]

Only way I could spend 6k in the story is poker

[tacit topaz]

Yea the gambler challenges probably take a lot of money

[slim dock]

I’ve lost close to 10k I think by paying off bounties as John 😂 wasting our family’s blackwater money

[tacit topaz]

My first playthrough i didnt even know how easy it was to hunt heck i didnt even know you could craft satchels

[tacit topaz]

I dont remember do you get some of the money that dutch and micah have at the end of the epilogue or do all of the money go to the bank?

Dept

Debt

[slim dock]

You get 20k. The orginal money stolen from blackwater was 150k, but it’s been 7 years so.

[tacit topaz]

John gets 20k in the end?

[slim dock]

Yeah, and I’ve spenst close to 10 of them on bounties 😂

[tacit topaz]

Damn

What to do after beating the game

I guess 100% it

[slim dock]

There’s barely any way to make money after the story. So they just gave you 20k

[tacit topaz]

Robbing trains is so much fun man

[slim dock]

I know, you earn like 100-200, but the bounty is also the same amount so you win basically nothing

[tacit topaz]

You pay off bounties?

Why

[slim dock]

Sometimes, it’s annoying that every time u enter a area lawmen chase u+ you loose the fast travel ability

[tacit topaz]

I have never fast traveled

Idk why

[slim dock]

Spamming x on your horse often gets a bit repetitive imo. I like to fast travel

[tacit topaz]

Sometimes i put a waypoint cinematic camera on and just let it ride to that location play some clash of clans during the time

[slim dock]

That’s what I did when the fast travel through wilderness camp was locked cause of bounty

[tacit topaz]

Im half way to completing all of the challenges

[slim dock]

Sometimes the autopilot sucks ass and crashes in a wagon or some and your horse die. Mad annoying

[tacit topaz]

Yea

[slim dock]

I have a rule of thumb, which is always carry 3 horse revivers

[tacit topaz]

I was doing race to st denis from strawberry and crashed into a bounty hunter

I once had to run to valentine to get horse revivers for my horse

My 15$ morgan

Later i bought a 500$ beast of a horse still stupid doing that spinny thingy every once in a while makes me want to shoot it

It has Carried all my hunted carcasses and pelts

[slim dock]

I might be the only person to do this. But I was first introduced to rdr2 by my friend cause he wanted to play online. So I bought only the online version, and ended up spending 100+ hours, before I eventually played the story. In the online, if your horse die. He eventually comes back. So when I killed him off in the story. I got pissed and sad when I knew he was gone forever

[tacit topaz]

My white arabian got killed by bounty hunters those bastards shot the thing on purpose then shot me too like why

[slim dock]

And you had no horse reviver

[tacit topaz]

Anything but the horse

[tacit topaz]

The thing is i died

I couldnt revive it

White arabian max bonding

[slim dock]

Did you notice when you had the white Arabian that npc’s complimented ur horse 24/7

[tacit topaz]

Yes

Where did a fella like you get a horse like that they say

[slim dock]

You can’t return to it, when you respawn ?

[tacit topaz]

Nope

Its gone

[slim dock]

“That’s a fine horse you got there”

Also one that is often used

[tacit topaz]

I heard youre fast wanna race?

[slim dock]

Or “I’d do anything for a horse like that”

I played with the white Arabian throughout most of the story too

[tacit topaz]

Have you noticed everyone comments on the bear hat

[slim dock]

Haven’t had it

[tacit topaz]

Also if you have blood on your shoulder for carrying a deer carcass people at the camp comment to it

I think it was karen that said "i dont wanna know whose blood that is"

I dont remember what were the others but i got it a lot

[tacit topaz]

"What on earth are you wearing"

[obsidian plinth]

My favorite is when you're dirty and muddy and miss Grimshaw yells at you

[slim dock]

The range of voice lines in the game is what impressed me the most. You get different conversations depending on the order you do the mission/how far away you are. If you spend a lot of time,all that. It’s crazy how immersive it is

[tacit topaz]

I dont like grimshaw but i do like incendiary buckshot rounds

[obsidian plinth]

you don't like gang mama bear????

[tacit topaz]

If youre looking for high honor dont use incendiary buckshot

[slim dock]

Swanson is the most annoying, mf keep yapping and following after me in camp

[tacit topaz]

Hes cute

No gay

[obsidian plinth]

He's just a weird fella

[tacit topaz]

Hes so innocent

[slim dock]

And he steals from the camp

[tacit topaz]

Just hanging around

[slim dock]

What a cunt

[tacit topaz]

He does

[obsidian plinth]

God forbid a man has hobbies

[tacit topaz]

Pearson is the goat

[obsidian plinth]

The people around camp I find annoying are Abigail and bill

I'm chill with everyone else for the most part

[slim dock]

Bro is just drunk and useless, doesn’t contribute with a thing. Also Arthur almost die saving his dumbass

[obsidian plinth]

Leave him alone, he's trying :(

I get sad whenever he comes over and tells Arthur "I've been bad, Mr Morgan"

He sounds so broken. I'm glad he has a somewhat happy ending

[tacit topaz]

I feel bad for bill ofc hes fat drunk and snnyoing but people are way too rude to him hes trying to be friendly to srthur and he just yells bitch get bsck to work

[slim dock]

I would if he left me alone lmao. Every time you enter the camp he nags at u and follows u around

[obsidian plinth]

I can agree to this. He may be rude and annoying but I feel like everyone around camp is so hostile towards him all the time even when it's not necessary

[obsidian plinth]

He just wants to be your friend :(

[slim dock]

Abigail has a reason tho. John’s doing nothing for them/dont give a fuck, like bro got a child

[tacit topaz]

Javier was my favourite from the start i like his style but he just lost me towards the end

[slim dock]

Abigale in the epilogue is a different story tho. There she is a bitch without any reason

[obsidian plinth]

I mean I guess, but I still don't like her all too much. I feel like she treats John like shit when he's trying hard (like in the epilogue)
I can understand her wanting to leave the past in the past but many people sacrificed so much for her and Jack to get out so she should've tried to be a little understanding to John wanting to avenge said people

Like girl get a grip. He's going after Micah, who hit on you constantly. You should be helping smh

Preteen Jack is also kinda annoying. Like please get a grip, your mother babied you too much oh my gOD

[slim dock]

When the ranch was glad about John helping out, doing it his way. Abigale was just being stubborn without having any reason behind it

[obsidian plinth]

L i t e r a l l y ! He was doing his best to keep his job for you

She was so mad at him all the time and then she just LEAVES

I hated epilogue Abigail a lot

[slim dock]

Jack’s voice lines when John is helping the dog is arguably the funniest shit in the entire game

[tacit topaz]

What is the character you hate the most?

[slim dock]

Dutch at the end

[obsidian plinth]

Mary Linton

[slim dock]

Worse than Micah imo

[tacit topaz]

Yeah

[obsidian plinth]

I like the fact that Micah is a well written villain

[tacit topaz]

Eagle flies and charles they were absolute chads

[obsidian plinth]

Charles my beloved

They could never make me hate Charles

[tacit topaz]

No hes just the goverments good little boy

[dense rock]

“Charles, will you ride with me”

[slim dock]

Charles is just a chill guy

[dense rock]

He did what he needed to to live

And ended up dying for it

[obsidian plinth]

He was asking Charles out on a date

[dense rock]

“Charles will you ride me?”

Wait no

[tacit topaz]

He lucky i didnt shoot him in the balls if he had any

[dense rock]

It’s smooth Fr

[obsidian plinth]

Charles: you have my friend
Bounty hunter: I'll give you money
Arthur: you should've taken the money

[tacit topaz]

I bet milton and ross sucked them dry

[obsidian plinth]

LMAO

[slim dock]

Yeah, Micah knew the gang was falling apart, and even tho it was a morally wrong thing to do. He had a reason behind it. Dutch was just a paranoid greedy dumbass

[dense rock]

When was this?

[obsidian plinth]

When saving Trelawny in rhodes

[tacit topaz]

One character i feel bad about is molly

[dense rock]

It was going to get over with even if Micah wasn’t there

[dense rock]

Ooh yeah

[obsidian plinth]

Me too tbh

[tacit topaz]

Dutch just did her wrong

[dense rock]

Molly was ignored for her relationship for like a few months then got shot because she eqanted to attention

She had the right to get attention

Even if it ended badly

[slim dock]

When you actually think about it. Both Dutch and Walter white had an extremely similar character development, or just similarities as a character in general. I can’t be the only one who noticed that.

[obsidian plinth]

Sure she was spoiled and snobby but Dutch treated her like absolute shit and she took the fall for Micah while hysterical and mentally unwell

I also feel bad for Karen

Like. A lot

[tacit topaz]

Why

What happened to her

I dont remember

[obsidian plinth]

Her fate is left unknown but she probably ran away and died of alcohol poisoning. She was upset after Sean was killed and didn't handle Molly getting shot very well

She just disappears and no one knows when or where. She doesn't even get a grave at the end

[tacit topaz]

She was in love with sean?

[obsidian plinth]

Yeah

[tacit topaz]

😦

I like shaun

[obsidian plinth]

When you rescue him you can see them around the party talking to each other

[tacit topaz]

Sean

[obsidian plinth]

They even sneak into John's tent to do the hanky panky

[slim dock]

Both start with good intentions – Dutch wants freedom for his gang, Walter wants to support his family.
2. They manipulate others – They use big words and lies to keep people loyal, claiming it’s all “for the greater good.”
3. They say they’ll stop – Dutch promises “one last job”; Walter says he’ll quit after making enough. But they keep going.
4. Pride and control drive them – Over time, it’s less about the cause and more about their ego and need for power.
5. They become their own worst enemy – Their downfall comes from their refusal to change or let go of control. It’s actually crazy how similar they are.

Dutch’s character must’ve been extremely inspired by Walter white

[tacit topaz]

I just sunk 30 bottles of whiskey and sang some diddly doddley

[obsidian plinth]

Sean mentions his "little Sean" and how he learned his techno from his dad of something it's to ridiculous

[obsidian plinth]

Bro you should follow them. Karen yells at him that he only loves her when they're both drunk

[tacit topaz]

I like how sean says arthur morgan "i love you äyrthur mörgen"

[obsidian plinth]

But you notice that she gets more and more drunk after he dies. She falls off the wagon hard

[obsidian plinth]

I like it when he calls Arthur "English" it's so funny

[tacit topaz]

English man

How old is sean

[obsidian plinth]

Early twenties

[slim dock]

Bro got violated 😭

[tacit topaz]

Poor bastard

[obsidian plinth]

Lenny too. Didn't deserve his fate

[tacit topaz]

Yea

[obsidian plinth]

Just a young man doing his best

[tacit topaz]

The gang just died when Hosea died

[obsidian plinth]

I love you Lenny summers

[tacit topaz]

I loved hunting with hosea

[obsidian plinth]

It's true. Dutch lost his long time best friend who was the voice of reason and it just went from bad to worse

[tacit topaz]

Yea

Luckily im at chapter 2

So hosea is going to be with us for a long time

[obsidian plinth]

I like to stick to mid chapter 3 for most of my playthroughs

It's when things are nice and somewhat happy

[tacit topaz]

Yea

I need to unlock horse fence to proceed the bandit quests

Challenges

[obsidian plinth]

I need to get back on single player

I've been playing online mostly

[tacit topaz]

I hate online

[obsidian plinth]

I like the different roles. It's an interesting concept

[tacit topaz]

There is a rich fuck following me spitting on me and if i even try to pull a gun out the fucks body guards shoot me

[obsidian plinth]

But I've had modders teleport me to shoot me dead so much it's awful

[haughty dirge]

im jealous 😔

[tacit topaz]

I cant be bothered to play online

[obsidian plinth]

This one guy yesterday kept gathering people on Saint Denis and hogtying us all to kill us

[tacit topaz]

Melee in online is too op

[obsidian plinth]

So I just ran as fast as I could to teleport to the other side of the map it was awful

[haughty dirge]

I play singleplayer only (mainly cause I'm broke as shit and can't afford PS Plus) and finding out about all the online content that isn't in the singleplayer inconveniences me greatly

[obsidian plinth]

I just wanted to gather stuff

[haughty dirge]

I wanna do gun tricks mane 😭

[slim dock]

Back in my online rdr2 prime, I was the reason people had that opinion

[obsidian plinth]

This is so real

[tacit topaz]

I bought the full game and online from steam for 20€😀

[obsidian plinth]

I tried online on psn years ago (friend bought me one month ps+ for my birthday)

[slim dock]

Before I started playing the story. I was full time professional griefer in the online mode.

[obsidian plinth]

I just want to chill and collect my animal samples :(

[tacit topaz]

I like drowning people into puddles in story

You guys do that too right?

[haughty dirge]

Yes

[obsidian plinth]

I've yet to be a menace in story mode

[tacit topaz]

:))

[haughty dirge]

I usually drown the residents in Van Horn near the river

[obsidian plinth]

I can't do it to Arthur

[slim dock]

I sniped everyone in sight, carcano rifle and slippery bastered perk, I was unkillable

[obsidian plinth]

[haughty dirge]

yk the river right next to Van Horn

[tacit topaz]

Am i the only one that just cant get my self to kill an animal like a horse especially a dog

[haughty dirge]

that was my haven for harrasing the locals

[slim dock]

It was fun on my part ngl, got some threats on ps messages too. Wish I could transfer that account over to PC

[tacit topaz]

If a horse dies it dies i try to avoid it but a dog i just cant

[haughty dirge]

gets ragdolled by a goat

I then get a 1500 bounty in that state

[tacit topaz]

I remember hanging an o'driscoll

[obsidian plinth]

I have to praise every dog I see

[haughty dirge]

except bloodhounds

[tacit topaz]

By a cliff

[haughty dirge]

those fuckers

[slim dock]

No one escaped my duel shaved shotguns 💀

[obsidian plinth]

I've been a bit of a menace to the npcs in online so i may attempt menace to society Arthur

[obsidian plinth]

B r o

I be treating online like it's my personal single player

And then people happen

[tacit topaz]

Its just the urge to shoot a random person with your volcanic pistol

[haughty dirge]

yeah people suck

[slim dock]

I was high honor Arthur for the ending. And when I got to play as John I reached lowest honor in like 20 min. Dogs, horses, people. All got it

[haughty dirge]

Dew it

[obsidian plinth]

Honestly i might do that

I can't play low honor Arthur. I cannot do that to him

[haughty dirge]

YES

[slim dock]

Same. It’s not the Arthur I raised

[haughty dirge]

I can B]

[tacit topaz]

For me to get to max honor its going to take a lot of HEY THERE MISTERS!

[obsidian plinth]

MISTER

[tacit topaz]

Hey there mister(s)

[obsidian plinth]

and a couple of "Madame"s in Saint Denis

[tacit topaz]

Yea

[slim dock]

High honor is just boring. There’s much more creativity in being low honor, like robbing trains and stuff. I just couldn’t give Micah the satisfaction of killing Arthur

[haughty dirge]

I once shot a guy infront of the Valentine Sheriff's office

[obsidian plinth]

My favorite thing Arthur says is "my lady" when you greet Sadie

Got me giggling and kicking my feet fr

[haughty dirge]

one of the deputies ran out to see what the commotion was and just walked back into the building

I greeted him to see if he had any unique dialogue after witnessing that but he just replied with "Howdy"

[tacit topaz]

The laugh made me want to drown him in a puddle too :DDD

[obsidian plinth]

He doesn't get paid enough for this

[haughty dirge]

like bro I shot a guy in the nose do your job 😭

[slim dock]

I love Sadie as a character, but holy fuck her voice acting is horrible. She overreacts every line there is.

[tacit topaz]

She is hot

[haughty dirge]

^

[tacit topaz]

Its just a fact

[slim dock]

Based. Arthur’s ex clears tho

[tacit topaz]

Idk

She hot too but

[valid field]

What lines are you saying she over acts?

[haughty dirge]

which one

[slim dock]

Every damn line, she just sounds dumb

[valid field]

Meh I don't get that feel from her...

[tacit topaz]

Idk why but i didnt even know sadie came from chapter 1

[haughty dirge]

she's much calmer in the Epilogue when compared to the first 6 Chapters

[tacit topaz]

I was surprised on the second playthrough when i met her i was like damn she looks familiar wait is that sadie?

[slim dock]

Her screeching voice, was just insufferable, it was a bit better in the epilogue, but really annoying during most of the main story, especially the mission where you rescue John from the prison

[haughty dirge]

bro the place is called Adler Ranch 💔 💔

[valid field]

I am on CH. 3 an I am getting depression feelings more as I get closer to th ending 😭

(I have played and beaten the game 4 times)

[slim dock]

Yeah. Every line was maybe a bit over exaggerated by me

[tacit topaz]

At chapter 3 already mate youll get a stroke at chapter 6

[valid field]

That may also come from the fact her actress is using a fake accent

[slim dock]

Which sounds horrible, so yeah, actors fault of course, not the characters writing

[haughty dirge]

it's probably because she sounds like she hasn't drank a drop of water in ages

but still Sadie's actor did a great job

[valid field]

There are points and I dunno if you caught it but I hear the Irish accent in Arthur's actor start creeping in

[slim dock]

You can so easily tell it’s fake, she also over does it, which makes it sound even worse

[haughty dirge]

Perks of acting as the same character for 5 years

[valid field]

You can blame (or could past tense) Rod Edge and Dan Houser for that - THEY asked her to sound super southern

[slim dock]

Sadie sounds like some of them role players in rp servers😂

[valid field]

Actually all the girls and most the guys are putting on fake accents

[tacit topaz]

Hate it

[valid field]

You do?

[tacit topaz]

Yea

[haughty dirge]

Something I realised after I played RD1 (before the disc got scratched beyond repair 😭) was the difference in Rob's performance as John

[slim dock]

She sounds like a rp server bro. Or the people there, that’s how bad it is

[haughty dirge]

his voice is more uhh

how do I describe it

[valid field]

The only one using their natual voice is Bill

[haughty dirge]

raspier in RD2

if that makes sense

[slim dock]

And John

[valid field]

Yea, but even Rob has said he is playing up his accent a bit

Oh Dutch too

[haughty dirge]

My goat Le Dutch James

[valid field]

No Dutch's actor is the only one not using an accent besides John and Bill

[slim dock]

They all do it, but it sounds convincing, compared to Sadie who sounds like a dumbass trying to imitate

[valid field]

Go listen to Grimshaw's Actress talk then go listen to her play the character you'll find her acting to be desired too

[slim dock]

She doesn’t have a big role anyway. So I can just avoid her talking. I probably wouldn’t notice Sadie too, if she didn’t have a big role

[valid field]

Also is anyone aware of why Abigail has a different actress in RDR2 then RDR1

[slim dock]

No idea. But Abigale sounded fine imo. That’s how Sadie’s voice actor should’ve done it

[haughty dirge]

the original actor for Abigail in RD1 actually worked in RD2, credited for additional motion capture

[harsh narwhal]

Uh where the fuck is guaramo

Is it in Cuba

[compact mountain]

island near cuba i think

[haughty dirge]

an island off the coast of Cuba

[tacit topaz]

How many horses do you need to break for horseman 10

[haughty dirge]

All of them

[tacit topaz]

How many are there

[haughty dirge]

and not just the mem

men

but the women

and the children too

[tacit topaz]

How many are there

Youre not anakin skywalker

[haughty dirge]

I don't like sand

it's coarse, rough, irritating

and it gets everywhere

[tacit topaz]

I think thats boba fett mando or iron man

[haughty dirge]

no it's defo anakin

[tacit topaz]

Mando said it

Im 100% siee

Sure

[eager crater]

hey everyone

[naive gale]

Is 200 the max pistol ammo?

[distant falcon]

Yeah that’s max you can hold with all the satchel and holsters

[naive gale]

Alright, thanks

[weary harness]

i thought it was 400

[gray mesa]

400 revolvers and repeaters 200 pistols and rifles

[lapis sable]

Explosive ammo never gets old

I’ll turn all the NPCs I see into headless corpses. Or missing a limb

I’ll make them all unrecognisable

Went to replay Sheep and Goats.

Bought a sniper rifle, equip them with explosive ammo.

Look at the sheperds.

Back in my high honor playthrough, im just to scare them.

But imo, what better way to scare them than to send them to hell?

So I shot their heads. Boom! Headshot! And again, and again!

Went down back to valentine, saved john and strauss, and made their escape, and then I do a huge shootout in the town to max bounty again!

[kind mango]

I wish I couldve recorded this. I went to store a bounty on my horse, missed by dropping him right behind the horse, and at that moment my horse decided to take a dump right on his face. Perfect 👌

[weary harness]

john?

[weary harness]

so what's your total playtime in rdr2

[arctic musk]

i have 550+ hours but you didnt ask me i think

[weary harness]

nah

i asked everyone

[arctic musk]

how many hours do you have?

[weary harness]

almost same as you

538

[arctic musk]

nice what did you spend all those hours on? replaying the story a bunch?

[weary harness]

free roam

[haughty dirge]

how can you see ur playtime

[weary harness]

its in the bottom right

[haughty dirge]

whar

[weary harness]

next to arthurs bandolier

in the title screen

on ps5

🤠 👍

[haughty dirge]

I'm on PS4 😔

[weary harness]

same thing maybe

i think its in the same area?

nvm

its not

☹️

[haughty dirge]

nuts

[arctic musk]

same

idk what to do in the free roam know though

[harsh narwhal]

How to get the belt that has bones on it

[harsh narwhal]

Massacre

[weary harness]

i'd say a quarter of my time was spent in guarma

because i got there using exploits

in chapter 2

[harsh narwhal]

I just reached chapter 5

And I'm hating this jungle already

i hate jungles

[weary harness]

especially with the snipers you wont really get to go anywhere

but i dont have the sniper 😃

[harsh narwhal]

Hey did you complete the game?

[weary harness]

yes

if you mean 100% then no

but epilogue is complete

[harsh narwhal]

did you 100% the progress

[weary harness]

nah

i'm like 86%

[harsh narwhal]

Are you playing as John

[weary harness]

yeah

sometimes i play as arthur

[harsh narwhal]

Wait you can play as John in the story too?

somebody told me that

[weary harness]

yeah but later in the game

i can just play as arthur sometimes too

i like playing arthur more

[harsh narwhal]

How old would be Arthur in rdr1 if he was still alive

Well I'm feeling very sad

I got spoiled about a pretty big part

[weary harness]

yeah maybe dont go on the discord or the subreddit

we discuss major spoilers

[harsh narwhal]

How many chapters are there?

[weary harness]

8

2 you play as john

[haughty dirge]

7 actually

Epilogue pt. 1 and pt. 2 count as one

[weary harness]

oh

7

[weary harness]

what horse do you guys use

[arctic musk]

white arabian for free roam

and as arthur the turkoman from braithwates

[weary harness]

the dark bay

so you got it now

[woeful gull]

How do I conserve my dead eye

How do I use dead eye in manual mode? Currently it just autoselects targets which leads to bullet wastage on few targets

But I've seen videos on YouTube and people manually select their shooting points. How do they do this?

[weary harness]

you unlock it by progressing through the story

[woeful gull]

How far

[weary harness]

"pouring fourth oil 4"

in chapter 2

you get it pretty early

[woeful gull]

oh ok I'm I did like 2 missions of that pouring oil bought that Cornwall wagon to that spot near emerald ranch stable

Haven't had the 3rd / 4th one pop up yet

[weary harness]

the 3rd one is just going back to john and telling him that the wagon is in place

[woeful gull]

But I'm like 20-30hrs in maybe I've spent too much time just wandering around

[woeful gull]

Oh yeah then I guess the 4th one hasn't popped up yet. Ty for the info

[weary harness]

yw

[zenith raft]

Yo I just finished rdr2

[weary harness]

chapter 6

or epilogue

[zenith raft]

Epilogue

[weary harness]

W game

[zenith raft]

Yeah

[weary harness]

you been to mexico yet

[zenith raft]

Bruh you can't in rdr2

[weary harness]

but like

[zenith raft]

You only can in rdr1

[weary harness]

with glitches have you

[weary harness]

ik ik

[zenith raft]

No

[weary harness]

that was the first thing i did when i finished the game

there isnt a lot though

just el presidio but no major settlements like escarela or chuparosa

[zenith raft]

I wish I can download mods :[

[weary harness]

as a console player

this is very relatable

[zenith raft]

Yeah

[weary harness]

i always see cool outfits with ponchos but then i realise its just mods

[zenith raft]

Yeah

People with ps4 are lucky

[weary harness]

wdym

[copper wren]

there are 6 chapters and 2 parts of the epiloge

[haughty dirge]

wat

[zenith raft]

Bc thay have Internet to search for mods

[weary harness]

really?

[weary harness]

you dont need mods for mexico though

🤠

i love mexico

[zenith raft]

Yeah

But I'm bad it doing Glitchs

[weary harness]

its pretty simple

[lapis sable]

If you got pc you can develop mexico

But sadly no missions nor animals as far as i can tell

[weary harness]

true

i had a horse named friday once

she was an american paint

and during the final mission of chapter 4 i disowned her and rode with her one last time

i never saw her again until the epilogue in which she was in a forest in ambarino so my headcanon is that its the same Friday that arthur had

[haughty dirge]

bro I wish you could get that JM saddle in the vanilla game

the one John had on his chapter 1 horse

[weary harness]

let me see

ohh

NOO

why'd they have to waste it on that horse

same with mauser holster

[slim dock]

Does the train stop in armadillo? And if it does, can I safely rob it there without getting lawmen/bounty on me

[humble canyon]

Yall can anyone help me 😭 the pouring oil 4 or whatever keep crashing my computer even though km in safe mode

[harsh narwhal]

What's the finest horse I can buy in saint Denis stable

[humble canyon]

When I get to the train car with john I crash every time, I've already done it 6 times

No other missions have had any problems

[obsidian plinth]

I personally liked the Turkoman more than the Arabian

[harsh narwhal]

Well I'm looking for something who's good in stats and looks

[arctic musk]

right before that just keep pressing L press on the mission and press abandon and press retry checkpoint until the skip checkpoint button appears

[humble canyon]

Thank you!!

[haughty dirge]

the railroad is destroyed to stop people from getting cholera

I don't think trains can stop there

[frigid anchor]

Thats gonna be unpopular opinion but i hated the last missio in the game

It was perfect but i was struggling not to die 😂

The music was so good

[frigid anchor]

I couldve boight some stuff before doing that mission

[cursive wharf]

I love my wife

[frigid anchor]

ew

[frigid anchor]

not that ship

[haughty dirge]

hah embed failed

[frigid anchor]

.....

[cursive wharf]

Sade is my wife

[frigid anchor]

That once scene

she looked powerful

[cursive wharf]

For ever

[frigid anchor]

bruh

Thats my personality

caps\

@vital nebula server not friendly to caps 😭

[cursive wharf]

Hi

[vital nebula]

I know 😔

Oh wait unusual area

[vital nebula]

Hello!

[warm musk]

Excuse me?

[cursive wharf]

Hi

[spark oasis]

arthur morgan!!!!

[muted zephyr]

One more score, Arthur.

[valid field]

Why is it veteran Gunfighters like Uncle and Hosea seemed to think the Gang was doomed even before the gang started falling apart?

[hollow dirge]

If I wanna 100% the game do i need every Gold medal?

[lone turret]

if skinny and maddy had micahs guns what did he shoot them with

(yes i joined this server just to ask that question)

[lone turret]

im not gonna lie i think 100% is just getting all achievements

i dont even think you have to 100% the game to get 100%

idk it just leaves stuff out you dont actually have to have all of it to have 100%

[valid field]

this please 🙏 ^

[lone turret]

Idk they old and wise

Maybe in Blackwater they started to realise "this guys insane he gonna get us all killed"

[valid field]

I am only asking cause they been spouting it since Colter lol

[formal crag]

it was easier for them to see that dutch was losing his mind cus they knew him longer

[harsh narwhal]

What's the finest horse I can buy at saint Denis stable?

It needs to be good in looks and stats.

[valid field]

Was it just cause Dutch or was it because of the increase in civilization in the West?

[formal crag]

Both

Dutch is 100% mentally ill with something of some kind nd also the gang was gonna have struggles regardless cus they cant keep up with the civilization of the west

[formal crag]

Black arabian

[harsh narwhal]

Is it good in stats and looks

[formal crag]

Yes

[harsh narwhal]

Should I kill my previous horse

[formal crag]

Turkoman is good too but i think arabian is better

[formal crag]

Noo💔💔 set him free

[harsh narwhal]

So just click the flee button and he won't come back right

Even if I whistle

Ah fuck it he just died from crashing into another horse

[formal crag]

😭

[formal crag]

if u take saddle off Yes

[harsh narwhal]

How much is the black Arabian

[formal crag]

1050

[tawny rivet]

I've heard that keyboard/mouse works with RDR2 on Xbox One but I personally haven't had it working, does anyone know if it's true that it works or not?

[tawny rivet]

I'm on One S if that matters for some reason

[tawny rivet]

Nevermind I figured out it's not

[lapis sable]

I must have been the worst horse breaker in history

Shooting a poison arrow at the wild horse’s leg instead of lasso, feeding it a horse reviver, and then getting on it’s back to tame it

[hidden moss]

um morgan got coughed on and im on chapter 2.. im scared he is gonna get some disease😭

[tawny rivet]

dw about it ^^ he's fine

[obsidian plinth]

Naaah he's fine. Just strep throat but the fresh air helps 🙂‍↕️

[weary harness]

its chapter 2 🤠

so he's fine

[hidden moss]

ok ty everyoen

[distant falcon]

Is.. someone gonna tell them? No? Okay

[obsidian plinth]

Shhhh

[lapis sable]

Arthur is fine

[weary harness]

arther

[lapis sable]

He’s the main protagonist. He’s immortal.

[weary harness]

i used to think that every main character had plot armour until i watched train to busan

and then i said

nvm

[lapis sable]

Nah arthur only died in blackwater

When i tried to grab the blackwater money from the evil people

Didn’t even get 2k worth of items before i ran out and died

[weary harness]

my arthur keeps dying

the o driscolls shoot me to death

sometimes

[lapis sable]

I wanna get 150k blackwater booty

It’s high score called survival and booty

[weary harness]

i like trying to remake johns rdr1 outfits

i already made his elegant suit

[drifting silo]

my Arthur only has 3040.00$

[weary harness]

you should hunt the treasure

explorer challenges

[drifting silo]

O yeah

I should do that

[marsh yacht]

Hey guys, I'm planning on playing rdr for the first time because I've never played it before, but it's going to suck as i play it by myself, would anyone like to talk with me then? I could give you a screen from the game

[weary harness]

aw man i wish i could talk

[weary harness]

are you on chapter 2?

or you havent started yet

ohh right

[marsh yacht]

I need to buy it first 😭😭

I bought one

But they gave me broken one

I need to get other

Im gonna play it like on week i guess

[weary harness]

watch out for spoilers here though

we discuss them a lot

[marsh yacht]

Ik

[weary harness]

SHHH

just

play

[marsh yacht]

But u wanna talk cus im alone

Then

[weary harness]

🤠

sorry i cant talk on vc but here i can

[marsh yacht]

Not noww

In weekend when i get that game

[weary harness]

yes

maybe leave server for now and join back when you get the game

or you might as well stay because no one talks on here anymore

[marsh yacht]

Ye imma stay

[lapis sable]

You can get money by looting evil people or getting five finger discounts

I come into the stall to buy some gun oil with 50 dollars.

Got out of the stall with some gun oil, as many provisions as I can get, and 50 dollars.

Plus 100 more dollars

I have also seen the natural human decomposition in the game. It’s nice

I wish the game does not despawn them. Or send lawmen to clear up the bodies

It’s a nice feature. I wanna kill as many people and walk around seeing tons of ded rotting bodies and horses and animals

The cycle of life

[weary harness]

wait i wanna see that

the closest i've gotten was like when i slit a woman's throat and put her in my saint denis bed

and slept for a couple of days

💀

i'm sorry

[lapis sable]

I wish i can walk in saint denis where lawmen are overwhelmed by the number of dead people and their own lawmen while i walk happily paying my bounty

Maybe a mass grave or a mass fire like armadillo?

Aw yeah.

“Hey there partner! What you doing?”
“Some bastard shot up the entire town and killed too many. We’re having a hard time piling the poor fellas in a big grave not far from here . 😦 “
“Aw I’m sorry to hear that.” (Is the bastard)

[weary harness]

that would be fun

[lapis sable]

Yeah. It will be more realistic if corpses remained as they were or dumped in a mass grave when we’re on a rampage

[lone turret]

i beat the game in 12 days

[naive grove]

how can i do survivalist 6 the best?

and how long dose it take to do horseman 10?

[weary harness]

usually i just shoot up hanging dog ranch and shoot the vultures

[naive grove]

so you just wait for them to show up?

cus its taking long af

[weary harness]

yeah are you close to the corpses

[naive grove]

i have some dead animals here but there are almost no scavengers coming

[weary harness]

oh

[naive grove]

well its taking long

[weary harness]

it does take long

[naive grove]

and horseman 10?

[weary harness]

i used to think horseman 10 was break every single horse like every single variation of an appaloosa or something

but its just the breed of horse

[naive grove]

isent it that?

oww

[weary harness]

so one mustang

one tennessee walker

[naive grove]

yea

so i just need to lookup where to find them

and break them

[weary harness]

American Paint
American Standardbred
Andalusian
Appaloosa
Arabian
Ardennes
Belgian Draft Horse
Dutch Warmblood
Hungarian Half-bred
Kentucky Saddler
Missouri Fox Trotter
Morgan
Mustang
Nokota
Shire
Suffolk Punch
Tennessee Walker
Thoroughbred
Turkoman

i crossed out the ones that dont need to be broken

[naive grove]

yea there is a list in the chalange to

[weary harness]

idk i havent done horseman 10

on this save

[naive grove]

i havent started it yet

cus it will take some time

[arctic musk]

like 10 hours for me lol

maybe 5 hours

[naive grove]

it seas here that i need to break every wild american paint

[arctic musk]

gta series videos has very good guides for rdr2

[weary harness]

wait so was i wrong chat 😨

[arctic musk]

but sometimes other random channels have better guides

[naive grove]

idk

[arctic musk]

@livid sorrel ill just answer here because of the time limit
either after the cutscene sidequest i could still stay in but i dont think so
or
i went in there a while after the sidequest and the door was open for some reason?
maybe restart the save nearby so the door opens its some weird bug it works with the rock carving house

[naive grove]

ima just follow a vid i think

[arctic musk]

you can send links in media btw

i just got most my horses at little creek river

[naive grove]

Thx

Im doing survivalist 6 rn

And then I’ll do that I think

I hated doing gambler 8 btw

Worst thing I have ever done

[arctic musk]

gambler challenges are so easy with tricks

more people need to know about them

[livid sorrel]

All I need to do is actually finish the side quest now 😭

[naive grove]

i just killed a fox but not in 1 shot so it did not count

😭

[arctic musk]

im just expirimenting on how to get in there again

[weary harness]

the challenge i hate the most

[naive grove]

is there a specific channel to where we can discus the challanges?

[weary harness]

is gambler 9 and survivalist 7

[weary harness]

this one prefererably

[naive grove]

what do 1 have to do in survivalist 7?

[harsh narwhal]

How do you take saddle off a horse

[livid sorrel]

Yeah, gotcha.

[weary harness]

8 consecutive kills

of small game

with small game arrow

[livid sorrel]

L2 and up arrow

[arctic musk]

no but i know tricks for every single one that work efficient

[arctic musk]

chickens are good for that

i think only 1 type of chicken worked for me reliably

either the white or brown one

[harsh narwhal]

It's not working

[naive grove]

is that hard?

[weary harness]

nah its just because i havent done it yet

[weary harness]

hold L2 to lock on the horse

approach the horse

hold up arrow

[arctic musk]

yeah after the side quest you can just enter the house

ill make some more pictures

[naive grove]

i hate this challange man!

it taking to long!!!