red-dead-singleplayer

[weary harness]

i love my horsey and my horsey love me

[formal crag]

prob after they burned the fields of tobacco or whatever it was i reckon idk

[valid field]

You don't know lol I always assumed it was pretty much right away like after the Saloon and Lemoyne Raiders Moonshine shit

[formal crag]

Yeah i dont know i sped thru that chapter

The moonshien maybe makes sense

[valid field]

Why'd you speed run it?

[formal crag]

Not sure

Im replaying game slower now

[blissful crane]

grays was after we burned the tobacco fields ig

[valid field]

What about the Braithwaites?

[blissful crane]

either after we stole their horses or the moonshine

imo best time to free roam is chapter 4 until american fathers 1

you got every weapon unlocked except for the mauser and repeating shotgun

a bummer that sean and kieran aren't present though

[obsidian plinth]

Yeah

After Sean is gone i knew shit was about to get real

And it did

[hidden moss]

i just got ambushed outside of saint denis

they killed my damn horse

they killed.

my damn horse.

[valid field]

Something very hypocritical about those two families - They kill, rob and lambast each other but make peace to kidnap Jack and try and kill the Gang. Is it just me or is that kinda fucked up?

Oh and Tavish unlives himself after so 🤷‍♂️

[lapis sable]

Who cares about those inbred hicks

[valid field]

Just asking if anyone noted how as soon as their money actually threatened they put it aside lol

[lapis sable]

I believe it’s a seperate attack and it’s purely coincdental that it happened at the same time

[valid field]

Could be either way, Honestly Dutch could have pulled it off if he'd done it differently - Divide the camp, no one person goes to both places

[soft parrot]

@rancid maple Are you a czech

[obsidian plinth]

Yeah i do think the most major undoing was sending Arthur to both families. And while i understand it's so we the player see things, it made no sense

[valid field]

How I always see it and how Arthur's and Dutch's actor see it is - Dutch under estimated them, thinking their hate for each other would make them to dumb to see they were being used against the other.

[obsidian plinth]

That's also a good point. I feel like Dutch underestimates everyone around him too

[valid field]

He turns being wrong about Colm looking for them in the Grizzlies as Arthur doubting him - not that he might just be wrong

[obsidian plinth]

His pride was his undoing fr

[valid field]

Also I guess from what his actor thinks is Dutch thought his Robbin Hood antics would mold society into a perma-wild west

And when he realized or was fed crap by Micha to make him realize it was not working and won't work - he gave up on everything

[lapis sable]

Eh who cares. Explosive bullets in their heads hell yea

[valid field]

😐 ummm....

[rancid maple]

Why was this what I saw first thing from opening the app

[winter sage]

no he didn't

he still believed the same BS in RDR

only now he was more ruthless & depraved & desperate

[tall elm]

anyone else get stuck when making an outfit

i just try making a new outfit and then my arthur stays in there for multiple days because i cant decide whats best for him 😭

[winter sage]

yeah happened all the time actually

[tall elm]

its so annoying

my arthur grew a level 4 beard by the time i was done and i started at clean shaven

[weary harness]

thats a long time

looong

i was trying to make elegant suit for john and the same thing happened

[winter sage]

never seen that happen

[arctic musk]

canon arthur beard length?

[cosmic flower]

yes

[winter sage]

if there's any, it's the one he has at the start of chapter 1

[arctic musk]

thats probably like 2-4

[weary harness]

level 3

[winter sage]

level 3 natural beard
level 3 hair right parted

[arctic musk]

ill check it out, what clothing do you think is canon for arthur?

[haughty dirge]

through NPC dialogue we know that bounty hunters went into Rhodes and asked about Arthur and Dutch in town

[haughty dirge]

Summer Gunslinger for ch. 2 & 3, The Gunslinger for 4, Winter Gunslinger for ch. 6

that's what I did 🤠

also use majestic accessory for the hat because it's

majestic

[lapis sable]

Damn, i lost another poker match in saint denis

Guess I will shoot up the entire saloon…

[haughty dirge]

I hate Blackjack

[arctic musk]

winter gunslinger for chapter 6?

[haughty dirge]

yeah

most of the missions are further north meaning it'll get cold

[ionic juniper]

I don't know how to play poker games, I just play to complete the challenge lol

[haughty dirge]

also winter gunslinger looks badass

also GRHAHESSdjaucjazj

why are specific outfits

only for HIGH HONOR

[arctic musk]

yeah but in the cave isnt it like 15 degrees celcius

also some cool foreshadowing i found in chapter 2 looking for a new camp arthur said no way dutch would live in a cave it would go against everything he stands for or something like that
and in chapter 6 its pretty much in a cave

[haughty dirge]

I think it's to reference Dutch's cave in RD1

[arctic musk]

it could be

maybe both

i havent played rdr1 but i got spoiled about dutch in rdr1 in a music video

[weary harness]

winter gunslinger for chapter 6?

oh wait nvm its already been answered

[weary harness]

my take: chapter 1: winter gunslinger
chapter 2-6: custom outfit 1

[haughty dirge]

it looks badass

[weary harness]

i love my custom outfit 1

[haughty dirge]

aw hell naw

stick with Custom Outfit

[weary harness]

my custom outfit for arthur is just him with a bolero hat and no shoes

[haughty dirge]

WAIT

[obsidian plinth]

Neked

[haughty dirge]

I have the perfect fit for chapter 6 arthur

so you know the fatass at Aberdeen Pig Farm right

[weary harness]

wait where are you going with this...

[haughty dirge]

steal his clothes

[obsidian plinth]

Overalls and no shirt?

[weary harness]

jokes aside i make arthurs chapter 4 outfit the gambler

[obsidian plinth]

Boobs out no bra?????

[weary harness]

or the saint denis

and then chapter 6 is the gunslinger

[obsidian plinth]

Mine is usually the opulent vest with a shirt under

This time I'm doing purple

Last time I did the maroon colored one

[weary harness]

ooh nice

[obsidian plinth]

I make him look fancy for the big city

[haughty dirge]

tbh I just use Summer Gunslinger with the majestic accessory hat

[weary harness]

yeah you gotta

[weary harness]

from trapper?

[haughty dirge]

ye

[lapis sable]

Killing everyone in annesburg is super fun though

[haughty dirge]

I hate hunting burds

birds

[lapis sable]

Invading the mines

[obsidian plinth]

I dress him up every chance I get. Love playing dress up with my cowboy

[haughty dirge]

Woodpeckers especially

Fuck you woodpecker

[weary harness]

its sad how they didnt give outfits certain abilities like in rdr1

[haughty dirge]

always scurrying away

[weary harness]

like elegant suit used to let you cheat

[haughty dirge]

They don't even peck the wood they just fuck off to the mountains

[weary harness]

real bro

[weary harness]

and there were gang outfits that would make gang members not attack you

but now

now they do nothing

[obsidian plinth]

Man I never even noticed

I didn't dress John up at all

[weary harness]

what?

really

[obsidian plinth]

I need rdr1 to go one sale

I've only played it once !

It was hard to get delivered to my location

[weary harness]

although cheating in poker is something i find difficult

[haughty dirge]

imagine if you could be the camp guard

[winter sage]

i mean it makes sense with the game's mechanics

arthur is famous

[obsidian plinth]

Arturd

[weary harness]

*not famous

[winter sage]

he is to the other gangs

[haughty dirge]

famous*

[weary harness]

oh yeah i guess so

[haughty dirge]

in the eyes of the law and other rival gangs atleast

[winter sage]

just cos he shows up as an o'driscoll doesn't mean they won't recognize him

guy is considered dutch's right hand man

[obsidian plinth]

I find it so funny when he tells people his real name like he isn't wanted by the law

[haughty dirge]

yea but to an extent John is too in RD1

[weary harness]

john was famous too but he could wear a bollard twins gang outfit and they dont give a fuck

[haughty dirge]

with the fame system

[obsidian plinth]

And other times he uses a fake name

[winter sage]

he's not

[weary harness]

more famous than arthur

[winter sage]

yeah the fame system is in game

[weary harness]

after john dies everyone remembers him but no one remembers arthur

😔

the true hero

[winter sage]

story wise he was some gang member from decades ago

[haughty dirge]

consequences of making a prequel sequel

[winter sage]

milton didn't even know him when he first saw him

[weary harness]

yeah

[weary harness]

he died thinking his name was rip van winkle

[winter sage]

nah he'd have figured it was an alias

[obsidian plinth]

Rip van winkle

[weary harness]

but then john made himself known in rdr1

[obsidian plinth]

He's so funny

[weary harness]

he killled a famous outlaw

[winter sage]

only if he used his name for it

[weary harness]

and one of the leaders of mexico

[winter sage]

the bureau took the credit for his work mostly

[weary harness]

yeah but in the game you hear people talking about him

[obsidian plinth]

They can't be saying an outlaw followed the law

[weary harness]

if your fame is high

[winter sage]

i know

the fame mechanic

but once again that's a game mechanic

he can also be not famous

if the player wants

[weary harness]

oh yeah just wear bandana

but canonically he dies famous

[haughty dirge]

speaking of bandana

bandanas suck in RD2

[weary harness]

yes bro

[haughty dirge]

they don't even hide your identity

[weary harness]

but honor was about the inside rather than the outside

in rdr2

[winter sage]

it makes sense

arthur announces himself to the town

[weary harness]

as in rdr1 its about how people see you as a person but in rdr2 its about your self honor

[winter sage]

then everyone's seen how he looks & his outfit

guy puts on a mask & he's not recognizable?

[winter sage]

rdr2 is more accurate for the word

[weary harness]

yeah

rdr1 is more fun though

[winter sage]

rdr1 is more spaghetti western

[weary harness]

true

[winter sage]

rdr2's revisionist

[haughty dirge]

RD2 doesn't have Wilhelm scream 0/10

[weary harness]

real i miss wilhelm

you would dynamite them and then they fly into the sky

screaming

[haughty dirge]

speaking of dynamite

buh

[weary harness]

dynamite in rdr1

[haughty dirge]

you smell Dyno

[weary harness]

you could mark

[haughty dirge]

Homing Dynamite was fun

[weary harness]

it was like a missile

@cosmic flower

go to the ledger at dutchs tent

[cosmic flower]

thanks

[weary harness]

it wont be there at first but after you purchase upgrades for dutch's lodging

then it will show up i think

[arctic musk]

if i have max deadeye fortified and yellow cores and everything do i have more accuracy?

[weary harness]

no

it just lasts longer

accuracy depends on the weapon but if you dont like it you can turn off the reticle and then your shots are accurate 🤠 👍

100%

[lapis sable]

You can do explosive bullets on their horse if they ride it

Shoot a full round, it will skyrocket their rider into the sky

[weary harness]

real low honor move

[lapis sable]

And while in the sky, i shoot their hand or their limb with explosive bullet

Screams all the way flying down

Hell yeah!

[weary harness]

crazy shit

guys whats your favourite town to cause a shootout in

[arctic musk]

st denis or van horn
honorable mention valentine

[lapis sable]

Saint denis
Blackwater
Valentine

[weary harness]

i see

[lapis sable]

Annesburg as honorary mention

[weary harness]

i agree with you guys

van horn is cool but like they short tempered as fuck

i beat a guy in a duel fair and square

[lapis sable]

The only functional town in new austin is tumbleweed and there really isnt much aside from Sheriff freeman

[weary harness]

and then the whole town shot at me

[weary harness]

i hate new austin

jk

[lapis sable]

And when they die, it’s a ghost town. No law reappearing

[arctic musk]

best non scoped rifle?\

[weary harness]

there was never any law

[weary harness]

bolt action

no doubt

[lapis sable]

If van horn had law it will be quite fun

[arctic musk]

i was thinking of using it i just got it

[weary harness]

new hanover is probably my most favourite state

[haughty dirge]

Van Horn is peak

[weary harness]

second is ambarino

[haughty dirge]

everyone is aggro

[weary harness]

yes

[haughty dirge]

Ambarino is the best state in the game

[weary harness]

i also like climbing up the blackwater ladders

[lapis sable]

Ambarino is so tough to earn bounty and pick fights

[weary harness]

and uppercutting people

[haughty dirge]

it has that vibe yk

[weary harness]

i have a 1.5k bounty there

[lapis sable]

The only viable place to fight a warzone against the law is Chez Porter

[weary harness]

haha but i kill people on their horse

and then i blow off all their limbs with a shotgun

[lapis sable]

I mean, you had to kill people on their horses to attract witnesses

[weary harness]

and then i stow them on my horse and ride around waiting for someone to notice me

[arctic musk]

lancaster repeater or bolt action rifle?

[weary harness]

i'm so conflicted

i love them both

[lapis sable]

And then afterwards its a matter of leading them to cholla springs or the snowy mountains or somewhere else

[arctic musk]

bolt for far range cover maybe and lancaster for run n gun medium range

and for cover aswell

[lapis sable]

But by the time you do, you already got 1.5k bounty lol

[haughty dirge]

Lancaster for accuracy

[lapis sable]

Also do you know explosive bullets can destroy safes?

[haughty dirge]

Bolt for vibes

[lapis sable]

No need for dynamite

[arctic musk]

doesnt bolt have max accuracy?

[weary harness]

actually no my whole bounty i was fighting in ambarino 😔

[lapis sable]

One explosive bullet on the safe

[weary harness]

i didnt lead them anywhere

[lapis sable]

Well yes that’s the point. But i wanna choose my battlezone, not just the passage im in lol

[haughty dirge]

The Loft seems like a great hideout if you're on the run from bounty hunters

[weary harness]

thats a good idea i should try that bc i never thought about it

[lapis sable]

Like, if i wanna fight in a gun store, Damn it, I’ll fight there

[weary harness]

the loft is my favourite place in the game

its got a camp and a house which is really cool

[lapis sable]

Saloons are prime places to “hold the fort”

Saint denis saloon is really fun

[haughty dirge]

it has a bed, chest, and if u go upstairs u can use it as lookout to see where the bounty hunters are

[haughty dirge]

Tumbleweed Saloon is my fave saloon

next to Armadillo but

[lapis sable]

Because of sheriff freeman, right? LOL

[weary harness]

my friend killed over 200 lawmen in the valentine saloon

[haughty dirge]

Armadillo doesn't have any law enforcement and everyone is sick

[weary harness]

and a map 😃

[haughty dirge]

yeah

[weary harness]

i once led lawmen to armadillo bc there was a train that i robbed before

[lapis sable]

Have you fought in Castor Ridge?

[haughty dirge]

it's crazy how he's the only NPC in the game that can one-shot you

[weary harness]

theres more than that

night folk

[lapis sable]

Hermit can too

[weary harness]

and i've had police chief dunbar one shot me

with a fucking knife

its so scary bro

[lapis sable]

Go antagonize and shoot the father and his sons

And then we fight in the unfinished house!

[weary harness]

i accidentally ran over the father

[lapis sable]

Let’s paint the house red!

[weary harness]

during my high honor playthrough

😔

[haughty dirge]

which one

[lapis sable]

Guy in roanoke ridge

[weary harness]

at manzanita post

wait no

not manzanita

the guy with the rare shotgun? where is he

[haughty dirge]

the Otis Miller map guy?

[weary harness]

yeah

[haughty dirge]

yea he's in roanoke methinks

[weary harness]

theres two people

one in tall trees and one in roanoke

[haughty dirge]

there's the strange lady too

with the wolves

or smth

oh right the uhh

all the gunslingers can one-shot u

[weary harness]

wait what!! he's not in tall trees!!

i was gaslighted

[haughty dirge]

I think you just got shat on by a skinner brother

[weary harness]

aw man ☹️

[haughty dirge]

brb gonna eat

[weary harness]

okay

?afk

[lapis sable]

Rampage mod lets you fight in caves

I fought the law in caves!

[weary harness]

what happens normally

do they not fight you in caves

[lapis sable]

There is this sick button called get wanted

So you can pick out any location to start your rampage

[weary harness]

oh but cant you do that with cheats

"You want punishment" instantly gives you a wanted level

[lapis sable]

You cant save tho

[weary harness]

oh

[lapis sable]

Try fighting law in areas where you think is fun

[weary harness]

hmm

[lapis sable]

Gaptootg ridge tor eg

[weary harness]

why gaptooth ridge

[lapis sable]

Fight del lobos and Law

[weary harness]

oh yeah

😃

[lapis sable]

Most gang hideouts are best places to fight law

[weary harness]

wont they just kill each other?

[lapis sable]

I doubt

Public enemy number 1 is more important

[weary harness]

ig

[haughty dirge]

I need to find moar ways to get Honor

help plez!!

[obsidian plinth]

Camp chores And donations

[weary harness]

my honor after completing money lending and other sins VI: 🤯

[willow knoll]

is there any way to go the saint denis tailor without getting hunted in chapter 6

[weary harness]

wdym

like you get robbed?

yes

[winter sage]

yeah pickpocketed

[weary harness]

yeah pretty sure

[winter sage]

nah he said chapter 6

[weary harness]

oh

idr

[winter sage]

you mean you got a bounty

[weary harness]

bounty hunters dont approach you in citiies

[winter sage]

cops won't arrest you with a bounty unless you become wanted

[weary harness]

or unless you commited a crime recently and you got away

then they see you and take you in

[winter sage]

yeah if you see the red lockdown circle just wait for it to go away

[willow knoll]

no your wanted dead or alive in saint denis in chapter 6

[weary harness]

ohh that

[winter sage]

yeah that

[weary harness]

it doesnt matter bro

[winter sage]

just avoid the cops

[willow knoll]

oh k

[winter sage]

they won't arrest you unless you do something

[weary harness]

he means after you breakout john from sisika

[winter sage]

i never go there after chapter 4 unless i have a mission for immersion

but it shouldn't matter

[weary harness]

and the dead or alive thing doesnt mean anything

[winter sage]

it does

[willow knoll]

oh k

[weary harness]

🤠 👍

[winter sage]

you can get random pinkerton ambushes

[willow knoll]

i just wanted to go to the tailor

[weary harness]

wait really?

[winter sage]

yeah

[weary harness]

shit i should watch out

[winter sage]

they have ambushes set up to kill you across bayou nwa, blackwater marsh & roanoke ridge

[weary harness]

oh

[winter sage]

the fun experience is turning off the minimap & riding

sometimes you'll spot a pinkerton convoy a mile out

[weary harness]

must be scary

[winter sage]

think there's always one around elysian pool

[weary harness]

minimap off is always scary

go to the forests near annesburg at night with minimap off

[willow knoll]

i despise saint denis cuz i always get wanted for disturbing the peac

[winter sage]

if you're coming downhill you'll see the pinkertons

[weary harness]

ohh

[winter sage]

just be patient & walk the horse

honestly i never like to gallop

[willow knoll]

ig

[winter sage]

you can trot

[weary harness]

i HATE horse riding in saint denis

its second place

behind dominoes

[winter sage]

i don't

i love the sound of the hooves on paved roads

y'all like to gallop everywhere at full speed I don't like doing that on the trails either

you can miss stuff or collide with something to save 2 minutes of travel time

[weary harness]

i set waypoint using map and then ride in cinematic

it stops when it sees a stranger

[winter sage]

doesn't stop when it sees an animal whose hide u can use

[weary harness]

oh

[sonic girder]

guys

i need serious help with gambler 8

i have been stuck on it for like 8 hours

i am actively losing my mind over dominos

[remote lodge]

so what do i do if i kill the legendary buck and then dont sell him to the fence

nvm

[arctic musk]

is gambler 8 win 3 domino rounds in a row?

[haughty dirge]

look up a guide on YT

[harsh narwhal]

How do I remove the bandana from my neck

[hard flame]

just go in the wardrobe and select ''no bandana'' or put on a neckerchief

[valid field]

Hey has anyone else had glitches with the outfit save in single player?

[warped spindle]

Ngl Colm o Driscoll has some fire drip

[hard flame]

that's what I'm saying!!

he has THAT drip.

[warped spindle]

I wonder if you can recreate the outfit on arthur

[valid field]

I dress Arthur in Black a lot oof

[hard flame]

technically yeah

[warped spindle]

I'm running a Duster coat rn

With rest being black aswell

[hard flame]

peak

that's just peak

[warped spindle]

But what clothes is Driscoll wearing

[warped spindle]

I also have a Golden Schofield with black engravings and a black Schofield w golden engravings

But might do dual black w gold engravings

[hard flame]

I think an everyday white shirt, some kind of vest and town pants

rifle gloves

[warped spindle]

Gotta get me those

[hard flame]

and the hat i've got no idea and neither the shoes

[warped spindle]

Would be tailor in Saint Denis be good for outfit picking

[hard flame]

yes

probably the best

[hollow escarp]

well Saint Denis has the most options out od every vendor i believe

but arent the prices different in every town?

[hard flame]

yup

[hollow escarp]

because i swear the cattleman is cheaper in valentine

[hard flame]

except for the accessorie

[hard flame]

it's 45$ in Valentine, yes?

[hollow escarp]

ah

[hollow escarp]

uhh i dont know

oh also, honor doesnt affect price yea?

[hard flame]

in RDO it does

in the story I don't think so

[hollow escarp]

is RDO any good

[hard flame]

nowdays it's not really worth it if you need to buy it

but if you have it already then I guess it's good to check it out

the ''prologue'' is good enough ig, I had fun while playing it

and I recreated Arthur as my RDO character so it was even funnier

[hollow escarp]

epilogue part 1 was arguabally one of the most boring parts

[valid field]

I can't show a picture here but I love the duster with a red shirt and dark pants

[hard flame]

100%

[hollow escarp]

and john hit the pose on that random ahh guy

[hard flame]

though you get the housebuilding song

[hollow escarp]

i hope he hited that pose on micah

[hard flame]

and Jim Milton rides again

[hard flame]

real

[hollow escarp]

isnt that part 2?

[hard flame]

yeah mb

I was about to edit the mesagge

message*

[hollow escarp]

see part 1 has nothing

rip van winkle or jim milton

didnt agent milton die thinking that john was actually rip van winkle

[hard flame]

yeah

[hollow escarp]

so jack, rip van winkle or jim milton

or the GOAT Fenton

[hard flame]

he died thinking he was Rip Van Winkle, apparently, from the RDR wiki

[hollow escarp]

cool

what even went through johns head when he came with this name

[hard flame]

isn't that like an old book?

Rip Van Winkle

[hollow escarp]

oh yeah

Washington Irving

anyway drop ur best rdr2 ship for no reason

[valid field]

Hey question - I play RDR2 on PS4 cause ngl I'm poor and can't afford a PS5, there is a glitch in the single player outfit save function.

[hard flame]

what kind of glitch I'm on ps4 too

[valid field]

I save 1 or 2 outfits and if I got to delete them and save new ones I can't the save is greyed out

@hard flame

[hard flame]

oof

is it in camp?

or you can't delete any outfits anywhere

because if that's the problem then maybe you should try saving an outfit at a tailor

or at the Valentine general store, cuz there they've got the wardrobe

and I think in the Rhodes store too

[valid field]

All camps

[hard flame]

search on the web I've got no idea mate

[visual cypress]

Hi! I have a opinion question for yall, im playing rdr2 story mode for the first time atm and i am at the 4th chapter but i kinda wanna restart and play each chapter longer and do things because i kinda just rushed the story, do you guys think i should just finish the story and then start a new one or start a new one instantly now??

[haughty dirge]

definetly start a new one

but tbh the decision is up to you

[hidden moss]

I made a cast acrylic key chain today with a cowboy and two revolvers on it that said "Goin' to Tahiti" across the bottom.

[haughty dirge]

I need this

[hidden moss]

Ngl id start over, bc since u start for the first time u can do it again take it longer to enjoy and get better reactions on certain aspects :)

If u rush it, it wont feel like a story y'know.

[haughty dirge]

though I do advise you start over and take time with the missions

maybe do some camp activities or side missions in-between the story ones

[visual cypress]

i will think about it a lil bit

[hidden moss]

^^ this

[haughty dirge]

cause your actions will have changes in the story if you choose to do side activities or not

[visual cypress]

can you have two playthrougs at once?

[haughty dirge]

yep

[visual cypress]

i didnt know that

[haughty dirge]

just start a new save file

[visual cypress]

aight

[haughty dirge]

yk how you can help someone or decline to help them

like the first Mary Linton mission

in ch. 2

[visual cypress]

the only fear i have is that the story is going to be boring because i already know it

[haughty dirge]

if you decline it that completely removes a string of story mission throughout the chapters

[hidden moss]

It wont, im on my 4th playtrough rn and im enjoying it like my first.

[haughty dirge]

ngl I thought that too but I got invested into the game heavily

[visual cypress]

alr imma just try and start a new one

also did you guys help every stranger?

[haughty dirge]

it depends

do you want to be a rotten scumbag or a kind gentleman

that decision is up to you

[visual cypress]

aight

[hidden moss]

I try to be a good guy all the time, ofc i had a low honor run for funsies but high honor is peak

[haughty dirge]

I had low honor for the majority of the game except the last portion

I won't say anything to spoil it but iykyk

[hidden moss]

I try to keep it middled till like chapter 4-6

[visual cypress]

i also wanna be a good guy but sadly my honor goes down real fast because i like to rob

[haughty dirge]

dw it's real easy to get money + get honor fast

[hidden moss]

Ofc robbing is fun but i always look at it like, "would arthur really rob randos on a broad daylight?"

[haughty dirge]

Yes. yes he would

[hidden moss]

And u can just greet everyone in valentine and get honour fast

[hidden moss]

Chapter 6 arthur wouldnt..

[haughty dirge]

that's dependent on his honor level

[visual cypress]

also do you guys think my playthrough is already kinda ruined because i know what happens to arthur and all

[haughty dirge]

not at all

but tread lightly cause you might get spoiled further

the experience is much better if you don't know what's gonna happen

[visual cypress]

aight

[haughty dirge]

cya mate and gl

[visual cypress]

cya

[lapis sable]

Low honor challenges are fun

[warped spindle]

What challenges r those

[weary harness]

gambler 8 is blackjack. gambler 9 is dominoes

but he left so it doesnt really matter

[hidden moss]

Gambler 9 is the stupidest mission in gaming history. It's literally like a 0.1% percent chance and each attempt takes 3-10 minutes and there's no way to set yourself up for a win or anything.

[warped spindle]

Any way to. Mass craft ammo‽

[distant falcon]

Nope wish you could

Only way to get a lot is buying it unfortunately

[warped spindle]

Rip

[distant falcon]

Yeah rip indeed

[warped spindle]

Wanted to make 300 split shot fast

But gonna take too long

[distant falcon]

Oof yeah I can feel all that button clicking to make all that ammo

[valid field]

Can you rob homes in free play single player mode?

@sand sinew

[distant falcon]

Yeah you can just has to be houses you haven’t robbed yet obviously.. like the Chez Porter house with Javier you can do without him, places like that yes

[valid field]

What about the big house in Emereld Ranch?

@distant falcon

[distant falcon]

The one with the big a hole owner?

[valid field]

si

[distant falcon]

Nope

[valid field]

😭

[distant falcon]

Can’t rob it since you can’t even go in the big house

[valid field]

I wanna rob that ass blind

[distant falcon]

Yeah a real asshole

There is a story behind him keeping his daughter inside and trapped

[hidden moss]

i just made it to the epilouge

i dont know how to feel about arthur dying

[dusk lodge]

Fuck marry kill: Arthur, John Hosea.

[obsidian plinth]

Oooo that's a tough one

Okay. Fuck Arthur, marry Hosea, and kill John

[weary harness]

John nooooo!

[obsidian plinth]

IF I had to choose, I choose John because he already has a wife 😔

I'd love for Hosea to talk about me the way he talks about Bessie

And well.... I love Mr Morgan

[hidden moss]

Why do I see Arthur giving out notes and after it says -60c or sth

Don’t notes start at a dollar

[weary harness]

idk just rdr2 i guess

[hidden moss]

For me, fuck Karen, marry Mary Beth, kill micah

[weary harness]

bro inserted karen, mary beth and micah

[haughty dirge]

"Excuse me mister, are you Edgar Ross?"

[obsidian plinth]

[haughty dirge]

oh shit my name is orange nkw

now

[weary harness]

cowboy

[obsidian plinth]

Orange

[lofty moon]

Certain animal can only be collected after Chapter 6.
?? For zoologist
If i use story replay, will it update Compendium??

[haughty dirge]

which animals r u referring to?

[lofty moon]

Nice no links allowed

[lofty moon]

I dont know particularly

[haughty dirge]

is it the new Austin ones?

[lofty moon]

Main question is do Compendium update when you replay a story mission?

[haughty dirge]

I don't think so?

[lofty moon]

Damn

[weary harness]

legendary bull gator

only available after chapter 6

[distant falcon]

Correction.. it CAN be hunted during chapter 6, doesn’t have to be the epilogue but yes it’s hunted post chapter 4 when you first “fight” it

[lofty moon]

I am already ended main game

Hope i dont have to replay again

[tawdry fractal]

Are the trams in St Denis realistic in terms of how fast they travel? Because they're basically walking speed

[weary harness]

if you blow them up with dynamite it looks really cool

[tawdry fractal]

But I like trams 🥺

[weary harness]

oh

[tawdry fractal]

With the electric chair invention, do I follow him or is there a marker for the next part?

[weary harness]

huh

[tawdry fractal]

ah there's a marker PR

[proven aspen]

a question for you all

why do people glaze this game

the story is okay

but the gameplay

is just boring as hell

and the cutscenes

too much of them

[tawdry fractal]

it is?

[weary harness]

💀

[tawdry fractal]

It's better than Witcher 3

[proven aspen]

how can you even find rdr2 gameplay fun?

[tawdry fractal]

at least, that which I've played

[proven aspen]

💀

[weary harness]

i dont think you like slow games

[proven aspen]

sure-

[weary harness]

thats why

[tawdry fractal]

Hunting wildlife (badly), shootouts, quirky characters

Maybe Witcher 3 gets better but I found it unengaging

[proven aspen]

yes i dont like too many cutscenes, but the gameplay is the worst part, its just so boring, and the first 2 chapters of the game are pure boredom

and also the combat in rdr2 is boring aswell

i still can't see why people say it's 10/10 game

rdr2 is more like a movie than an actual game

you stick to your horse for more than half of the game

[tawdry fractal]

what would be non-boring?

[proven aspen]

the rates are just unrealistic for this game

[proven aspen]

better combat, gameplay

and not spending over half of the game on your horse

[weary harness]

is the gameplay too slow or something

[proven aspen]

and less cutscenes

[weary harness]

you might be after a different game

and not rdr2

rdr2 is if you have a lot of time

because the story and gameplay is long

[proven aspen]

no i like 30h+ games, but not when 20h of them are just cutscenes

i loved witcher 3

[weary harness]

it is not 30h

[proven aspen]

cyberpunk

[weary harness]

its like 70 hours

[proven aspen]

that depends on who is playing and if you are doing sidequests

main story is around 40 hours

[weary harness]

yeah the pace is slow af

but i dont really mind

maybe its because of opinions that we like this game more than other games

[proven aspen]

i just came here to ask why people are glazing this game so much

and calling it 10/10

in order for game to be 10/10 it has to have good story, gameplay, world, graphics, combat, but having bad combat and gameplay would actually put this game around 6-7/10 at best, it has good story and ik i will get raided by glazers, but this is realistic rating

[weary harness]

the gameplay is realistic

it has a lot of animals

like 300 idr

200

[proven aspen]

being realistic doesnt mean it's good, im talking about actual good gameplay.
people confuse realistic gameplay to good and fun gameplay

[weary harness]

a lot of people find the gameplay fun

[proven aspen]

if it was other game with bad story they would also call out the gamplay for that game and nittpick

[weary harness]

i think thats just you tbh

and a few other people

[proven aspen]

not really, many people if they dont like a game, they nittpick and point out every single bad thing in it, but if its something they like, they try to hide every bad thing in the game and pretend like it doesn't exist

and that makes them hypocrites

especially asmongold fans

[weary harness]

in the end man its just opinions people think the game is 10/10

[proven aspen]

i can't stand grifters like asmongold and his fanbase

the fact they started hating the witcher 4 because ciri is the protagonist, and because she looked older because of the effects 💀

[weary harness]

isnt the same happening with the new ghost of yotei game because the protagonist is a girl

[proven aspen]

have no idea about yotei

but asmon grifters should just be banned at this point

they make every game look ugly

[weary harness]

oh

[haughty dirge]

game ratings are subjective

people like games for different reasons than others

I personally enjoy the gameplay and combat system because they're simply great

they elevate the game to another level and mostly everything is given extreme detail by Rockstar

[harsh narwhal]

Yeah because Witcher 3 sucked Witcher 4 will too

[obtuse pollen]

If you find yourself in a lengthy off-topic discussion please move to #general.

[proven aspen]

💀

we found asmon fan

[weary harness]

i dont have enough knowledge on the witcher to have an opinion about the game

[empty ingot]

these moonshiners in lemoyne asked me for 2 berries from the local area, but i can fcking find any berries? Only some carrots and other BS

[weary harness]

ohh

milkweed?

[haughty dirge]

use Eagle Eye and pray

[weary harness]

whats the arthur epilogue glitch

how do i perform this task

[arctic musk]

replay some mission in a specific spot iirc
theres tutorials on it on youtube

you cant revert it i believe

[weary harness]

wait so does that let arthur go to the other half of WE and NA?

[rain hornet]

Guys, i started playin red dead 2

Dutch seems like a nice character tbh

[weary harness]

really?

thats great

he is a wonderful man

🤠 👍

[rain hornet]

Ye

[arctic musk]

yeah everything stays normal you just have a different voice and model im assuming

[weary harness]

lol thats funny

[empty ingot]

why it seems that during a specific time of day, there just aint any shadows? it looks pretty weird

[tawdry fractal]

Did Charles Châtenay exist in real life or made up for the game? In games set in the past like Assassin's Creed it's common to feature actual historical figures.

[empty ingot]

most of rdr2 is made up. Rockstar never focused on making their games historically accurate

[arctic musk]

rdr2 takes inspiration from alot

[visual cypress]

hey can i play rdr1 and rdr2 at the same time or will i get spoilers from rdr1

[harsh narwhal]

rdr1 is the after story of rdr2

[visual cypress]

yeah i know

[arctic musk]

to answer your question you will get spoiled about some of the events in rdr2 if you play rdr1

[visual cypress]

is it just that john yk does the thing with the gang and what happens with arthur

already got spoiled

i just dont know why all that happens

[haughty dirge]

RDR2 is a prequel to RDR1 so obviously there will be some spoilers

I'd steer clear from RD1 content until you actually finished RD2

[visual cypress]

aight

[slim dock]

Agree, the gameplay is a bit sluggish similar to gta 5, its improved, but still,

[arctic musk]

hi can i get the sodom back to gomorah clothes outside of the mission and how?

[glass rock]

Those were some nice threads in that mission, huh?! 🙂

[arctic musk]

it's a really nice all black outfit honestly

i have 3.6k what do i spend it on

[valid field]

Okay after playing through Horse Flesh for Dinner I realized Tavish was setting them up - I think personally he sent them on a rip off job just to get the gang members killed

Also Tavish hesitated before saying how much the horses were worth so I think he had to figure out a high enough number.

[distant falcon]

You can tell that Sheriff Gray and the braithwaites set the gang up pretty much from the beginning as confirmed from Both Gray during A short walk in a pretty town, and Mrs. Braithwaite during Blood Fueds Ancient and Modern where she confirms she knew about the horse stealing despite them having never told her.

[valid field]

I often wonder if after the Horses and tobacco indicent if the Greys and Brithwaites called a truce and the whole kiddnapping and Jack abduction was a co-op thing

Like Tavish smartened up Mrs. Braithwaite or vice versa

[distant falcon]

Eh probably not as they were still at each other’s throats for Beau and Penelope during Course of True Love 5 where they both seemed to still have that feud AFTER they dissolution of they died after Gray and the braithwaites.. but a good theory that does have a little evidence

[valid field]

Never know, I also honestly think Micha was ratting as of Chapter 3 for a few reasons

[distant falcon]

Eh a lot of evidence points to Micah always being a rat or Milton being truthful

[valid field]

Not even to Milton at first I was think more he set the Arthur up with the whole "Parley" thing with Colm

@distant falcon

[distant falcon]

Some of it was suspicious yeah.. and Micah most likely talked in Dutch’s ear saying that Arthur would be fine and not to go after him

[valid field]

Highly likely, I guess there is a big theory online that the stagecoach robberies he does with Arthur is his way of telling Milton where the gang is

[distant falcon]

That’s a little far fetched but I can see that being a possibility

Brings up the actual argument of Abagail being a rat as well.. I am gonna say it rn.. there is actually some evidence but I still don’t believe she’s the rat

[valid field]

From the way she interacts out of missions with gang members minus Uncle and Hosea (both of whom helped get her into the gang) - She is pretty hostile or rude to gang members but do you think being disillusioned with what Uncle and Hosea told her would make her set the gang up to die?

[distant falcon]

Some say she was manipulating John and poisoning him against Dutch, Dutch himself said it when you fight that gator in chapter 4, there is also this really crazy theory that A fisher of men was a big setup by Abigail and Milton but Abigail willingly endangered Jack so idk

[haughty dirge]

just finished the Obediah Hinton missions

it's safe to say I'll never go near Butcher Creek anymore

[distant falcon]

And? What’d you think of the curse?

[valid field]

Like I said you think her being disiliiusoned with the gang would make her go that far?

[distant falcon]

And the manipulation to sign off land by thinking the people of butcher creek can’t read

[haughty dirge]

🤷‍♂️

the cave section was nice

[distant falcon]

There is some evidence of that.. but at the same time that whole theory is way too far fetched

[haughty dirge]

The parley was a setup

Colm always intended to capture Arthur as a hostage

no one ratted no one

[valid field]

I agree, I think he was ratting to Colm not Milton

[distant falcon]

Then it’s a setup within another setup

I def feel that Micah KNEW what would happen to Arthur and it being a setup entirely by Colm himself to capture just Arthur

[valid field]

I think after they got back from Cuba sure but no before the Gwarma issue he was collaborating with Colm I think

He was in prison with an O'Driscle in Strawberry

[haughty dirge]

First of all that was in Chapter 2

[valid field]

So i wounder if he had been passing info to them before getting stranded in Cuba

[haughty dirge]

months before the initial mission where Arthur gets captured by Colm

second there's barely any valid evidence to support that Micah ratted out to Colm

[valid field]

I think while no Micha wasn't actually a agent I think after Strawberry (as you see a Dutch Wanted Poster in his hermitage) He made the choice that he was gonna collect Dutches Bounty obsteively to take the heat off himself

[haughty dirge]

that's

no

[valid field]

Why not?

[haughty dirge]

Micah isn't a bounty hunter first and foremost

and regardless he was hiding out with Dutch during American Venom

[valid field]

No BUT its pretty clear you don't have to be a bounty hunter to collect

And? That don't mean he didn't have plans @haughty dirge

[haughty dirge]

if he was going to 'collect' Dutch's bounty that'd mean he'd have to capture Dutch and send him to the authorities

which is what a Bounty Hunter does

and I don't think Micah would even be able to enter any town in the game since he's wanted in most states

[distant falcon]

And he had the means to do that by keeping Dutch in secret, it’s obvious that Micah and Dutch wanted the money so Micah would first get the money, then capture Dutch and give him off for even more money..

[lunar coyote]

Do stranger missions go away if you don’t do them?

[arctic musk]

what do i even do with multiple thousand dollars in rdr2

[haughty dirge]

except he had the money

it's in the chest

[haughty dirge]

Get more money

[arctic musk]

genius

[valid field]

Then John showed up, he didn't get the chance

[arctic musk]

because with money is money that you money when money

[distant falcon]

Ik I JUST said that he had the money and was going to take Dutch in.. my guess is he was specifically waiting for John to get rid of him as he knew he would find him and eventually come for him

[haughty dirge]

there isn't any way he would've known about John coming for him

aside from on the mountain

[distant falcon]

I would take into account that Micah had a small gang of his own.. sure far fetched but he very well could of had people spying on John to see his whereabouts especially since Micah definitely heard of John being back in the state as that murder John did led him back

[distant falcon]

Also he still could have theoretically escaped.. he could have had surviving men from just John, Sadie and Charles and they very well could have warned him.. but again far fetched somewhat

[haughty dirge]

if you go back on the mountain there isn't any other path except the path down towards Micah's hideout which was where John was heading

if Micah was to escape on foot (since he doesn't have any specific mount shown in the epilogue) he would come across John anyway

[distant falcon]

Simple answer, Rockstar logic.. how did DUTCH get up to the mountain Arthur was at if you save John? You can go into photo mode and it’s PHYSICALLY impossible for Dutch to have gotten up there yet he did

[haughty dirge]

That's not a valid in-lore response

[distant falcon]

Haha yeah ik but still

[haughty dirge]

still I don't think Micah would've ratted out to Colm in Blessed are the Peacemakers

[distant falcon]

I can’t really say that what we are talking about is valid in lore since it isn’t even confirmed and probably never will be

[haughty dirge]

he doesn't really do any major actions with Dutch until Arthur gets diagnosed with Tuberculosis

[distant falcon]

That can be debated for a select few things..

Depends on what you would describe as “Major”

[haughty dirge]

it's true though

Micah didn't participate in planning any heists until then, he was doing 'reconnaissance' with Dutch offscreen

before then he didn't do much

he had some drinks with lenny and got arrested

that's basically his only chapter 2 mission

in Chapter 3 he doesn't do much of anything until A Short Walk in a Pretty Town

where he assists in the shootout in Rhodes

in Chapter 4 he doesn't appear often until the Saint Denis Bank Robbery

Guarma is Guarma

[distant falcon]

A lot of this not being in the game for more than half of it is suspicious of his character.. almost like he’s the villain 🤔

[misty solstice]

I disapprove of the "Micah Bell" character.

[distant falcon]

Micah is so hated yet so well written

That’s how you know you have a good villain

[haughty dirge]

youre missing the point 😔

[haughty dirge]

damn even Mussolini dislikes Micah

[distant falcon]

That was a joke but yes

[haughty dirge]

that's crazy

[misty solstice]

He reminds me quite a bit of a rat, in his actions.

I couldn't like him if he was the singular character of this game.

[haughty dirge]

rat is his spirit animal

[distant falcon]

No wonder that rat showed up at his hideout before.. you know

They always show up shortly before the bad stuff

[misty solstice]

I'm not very suprised.

[harsh narwhal]

After you finish the story do you play as Arthur or John

[arctic musk]

you play as john

[harsh narwhal]

Fucking hell

Is there any way I can play as Arthur

[arctic musk]

theres a trick to play as arthur but it doesnt work super proper

theres videos on how to play as arthur instead of john after the epilogue but you cant revert the change im pretty sure

[harsh narwhal]

I hate that scar on John's face

Ruins his beard

[arctic musk]

thats fair but i think the scar is less bad in the epilogue

[distant falcon]

Just grow a Gandalf beard and the scar becomes obsolete and very hard to see

[harsh narwhal]

How do you grow a gandalf beard

Also how much money do you get after you finish the story

[distant falcon]

Use hair tonic

Your beard grows to a certain length naturally but you can grow it to be massive when using hair tonic

You can also excel the process more with a glitch to keep skipping days to not have to manually have the beard grow out through sleeping since it only grows through black loading screens

[arctic musk]

like 20k i think

[harsh narwhal]

What's the finest revolver I can get

Expensive and amazing

[arctic musk]

in looks or stats?

[distant falcon]

Schofield as it like the best

[harsh narwhal]

Both

[distant falcon]

And stats it’s also the best you can get legitimately

[hidden moss]

i hate my life

[arctic musk]

dual wield or single?

[harsh narwhal]

Single

[hidden moss]

i antagonized micah so much the game is forcing me to stop

[distant falcon]

If it wasn’t legit and I could.. I would get Navy that is only in online

It’s just sooooo nice and amazing

[arctic musk]

theres algernons revolver but its super hard to get some people like it

[distant falcon]

Oh yeaaah

[arctic musk]

schofield is good too

[distant falcon]

Don’t do Algenor’s missions like I had to do for 100%

I was at it for.. probably a few weeks as my luck was just that bad

[harsh narwhal]

I don't quite understand the fashion in rdr2 there's so many things

And I don't know what will match what

[distant falcon]

It won’t match at you can only get a single one of his revolver

But sometimes mismatched guns is sweet

I’ve seen some duos that aren’t that bad.. but it’s all about wether you like that perfection or not

[harsh narwhal]

Also is there any way you can save Arthur

in the story

[distant falcon]

No

Only way to save him is load a save before and don’t progress

I see you’re already in the grieving phase of wanting him back

[harsh narwhal]

Very much

[distant falcon]

That’s the first of the endless stage of grief

[harsh narwhal]

Well if only rockstar could change his fate but it's too late

Spending my last moments with Arthur at saint Denis

[distant falcon]

Wouldn’t of happened regardless as it was always gonna be a prequel and rockstar lore is obviously there was No Arthur in red dead one so why would he of been alive if he was in the gang

[glacial crypt]

i told my friend to play rdr 2

he has never played it beofre

hes so lucky

to experience it for the first time

[warm musk]

Yeah my friend got it like a month ago and he's already in shady belle

He loves it

[slim dock]

I hope you’re talking about online, cause without mods the single player store has absolutely nothing 😂

[proven aspen]

well i do, the movement and combat feels clunky, but the rpg mechanics, magic, story, sidequests and the open world are great

[proven aspen]

Thanks for agreeing bro, it's rare to find non glazers about rdr2 that are realistic while loving the game

[slim dock]

For the most part I don’t really pay much attention to it, but if you’re for example doing combat in tight spaces, like a train, you notice how unresponsive and weird it can feel.

Rockstar is using a brand new engine for gta 6 compared to the one that was used for both gta5 and rdr2. So I assume this new engine will also be used for rdr3 if we ever see that in the future. Which probably offers a more responsive and improved gameplay

[wet wigeon]

I have a ryzen 5 5600 and a rx 7700xt. I'm not getting pass the loading screen when I'm now entering the game. I've tried to "verify" the steam data but nothing worked. I would say the only change i did make was going into the files for this game in the steamapps folder, entered properties for RDR2.exe and change the disabled full windows optimisation? And also to run as administrator. I also tried to run the gams from that exe application

I've since then changed back all the settings for that but nothing happened. Also restarted my computer. And powered off for a while

And it still didn't go past the loading screen Is reinstalling the only option?

[hidden moss]

think of it like this

he took a nap time and went behind the scenes helping out john

and also beat the fuck out of micah

and his lungs were magically fixed

[slim dock]

I think so, if I were to guess, something has probably corrupted during the installation

[cinder viper]

it's not a new engine, rockstar uses RAGE (rockstar advanced game engine) for all their games, it's just a new version of the same engine

[hidden moss]

they also cause rage by not releasing their damn games

[wet wigeon]

That's the thing. I have 20 hours on this game. It only happened for today

[night flower]

ur pc just sucks man

[wet wigeon]

I placed it in God's hands so that cannot be the case

[night flower]

mb

[slim dock]

Yeah, but it’s a huge improvement compared to the one they ran for both gta 5 and rdr2. But same engine name

[hidden moss]

is that dutch is a cannibal theory real

[slim dock]

Interesting, tried looking for any posts on Reddit ?

[slim dock]

He’s definitely not. But he is a dumbass

[wet wigeon]

I think something happened when tired changing things for the original file

Guys it came on

God is a good God

[hidden moss]

i hate almost all the old gang members except hosea arthur and john

[slim dock]

Why did you do that in the first place

[wet wigeon]

I deleted rockstart launcher and reinstalled it

[slim dock]

What did Charles do to you

[hidden moss]

charles is chill to

[wet wigeon]

I just wanted to disable the fullscreen optimization.

It was rockstar

[hidden moss]

john my favorite character

[slim dock]

Swanson is the one who was the most annoying to me, bro kept following me and yapping when I entered camp. Wanted to blow his head off 😂

[hidden moss]

i always hated micah even before he became a rat

[slim dock]

John’s the goat. Abigale is so annoying, especially during the beginning of the epilogue,

[wet wigeon]

How do I upgrade the camp? Currently at chapter 2

Do I have to wait?

[hidden moss]

wasn’t she also a stripper

[hidden moss]

you gotta keep doing the missions

it’s a grind ik

[slim dock]

Yeah. But her reasoning about John not helping out in his way sometimes makes zero sense

[hidden moss]

[slim dock]

Where you give money to the camp, you also have the ability to upgrade it

[slim dock]

I hated Dutch more than Micah

[hidden moss]

i hate dutch and his “beard”

it looks like a piece of fuzz taped to his chin

[slim dock]

Micah had his reasoning to do what he did. Even tho it was at the cost of the gang. Selfish yes, but he knew the gang was falling apart. Dutch was just a moron who let him get into his head

[hidden moss]

i feel bad for the people who played red dead 1 before red dead 2

[slim dock]

I think the story looks interesting and fun. But I just can’t adjust to playing with such a downgraded world and graphics.

[empty parcel]

Do you know how to do drag npc?

[slim dock]

Wdym?

Like hogtie them

[empty parcel]

Where do we download it from?

[slim dock]

Download what ? Huh

Modding ?

[empty parcel]

Dude you are dragging NPCs bro if you know NPCs tell me

[hidden moss]

do you guys watch gunsmoke

[sudden gazelle]

Currently just started chapter 3 what do I do

[distant falcon]

Do side missions as much as possible

Fuck Dutch and his missions.. just do everything but help till you physically can’t anymore

[valid field]

I get depressed when I get to CH. 4 and beyond

is that normal?

[distant falcon]

Because of you know.. the massive changes that happen afterwards?

[valid field]

I have no idea but I get to about after Kerian's death - then I get an urge to restart

[distant falcon]

I think especially after major deaths yeah.. same sometimes

[weary harness]

i like how they did kierans death which was like saint denis death

[tribal wigeon]

Sean died to soon

And Lenny

[deft knot]

Sir!

[haughty dirge]

yea when Uncle first found her she was a prostitute

[haughty dirge]

I think he means the way John dragged Cleet to the gallows in American Venom

[stuck carbon]

Im too good for this game, theres this guy with plot armor on the mountain when i go to kill micah, i shoot him 10 times with a revolver and 2 time with a rifle and he insta kills me afterwords and my game crashes

now i gotta do the entire god damn mission again

[stuck carbon]

now i died in the final standoff

the game crashes

now i gotta start all the way from hanging cleet

Fuck this game

[haughty dirge]

sounds like a skill issue

[ornate fox]

i love when that gappens

[stuck carbon]

now im at the sniper part and i died

looks like i need to restart the game again

[stuck carbon]

really luv this game

when im about to shoot micah in the balls he shoots me

now i gotta staret the entire mission over

[haughty dirge]

mate

you're just bad at the game

[glacial crypt]

Bro get a new pc if it cannot handle rdr2

[uncut wraith]

hi i have an issue again

im in the mission “escape from valentine” but every time i did it it didnt complete it and this is my 4th time trying to fix the glitch, can someone help me?

please?

wait im in the wrong chat

[stuck carbon]

I built my pc, 3090, its when i die the game refuses to load

[arctic musk]

hi how do i make gunfights in rdr2 more fun

[glacial crypt]

Mods

[tawdry fractal]

I like the quirky side characters like Andrew Bell III, to whom Arthur acts as a foil

My usual horse vanished from the available, replaced with another I own already. Did they die?

[obsidian plinth]

Very likely yeah

[haughty dirge]

Mods

[neon willow]

can someone help me
i cant skin the legendary elk

[arctic musk]

why not

[neon willow]

idk

i was wondering if someone knew

[arctic musk]

if you go too far away it automatically sells to the trapper and probably to the fence aswell

[neon willow]

really ?

[arctic musk]

yeah because otherwise 100% is missable you can look it up if you want

[neon willow]

ok

[valid field]

So I think it's pretty established that despite Arthur's playing it down and not taking much pride in it, He is that universes version of "The Gunfighter with no Name"

My question is why do you think Arthur stopped gun-slinging?

[arctic musk]

i honestly dont think he cared much

[slim dock]

You’re not supposed to kill him before you get close enough lol. I also shoot him like 5 times with dead eye and was confused af 😂

[slim dock]

It’s the easiest game ever 😂. I know it’s not a souls game, so it’s not supposed to be hard. But I genuinely think I didn’t die from enemies throughout my entire playthrough when I think about it

[haughty dirge]

I did sometimes because i was just messing around with explosives lel

[slim dock]

I don’t know if it counts as dying but I technically failed by doing dumb shit, like shooting Dutch in the end

I had 100+hrs in the online before I played the story , with a lot of time put into pvp. So that probably explains why it felt so easy to me, cause i was used to playing against real people

[valid field]

Oh that's obvious - I was meaning since it's something he could do and earn money without getting wanted; why wouldn't he just to keep the gang in doh

[valid field]

Is online even worth it ?

[slim dock]

It’s fun for some time, but there’s genuinely not much to do when you’ve finished all the content. It’s fun to play with friends tho. I spent most of my hours being a dick, violating other plays cause I was a sweat 😂 just spawn killing em. If I remember correctly I’ve killed over 500 real players 😂

[valid field]

Nice, quickdraw or just shoot outs?

[slim dock]

Just shooting in general on the big map. I played mostly in black water, cause you can abuse snipers there, which one shots. I had fun, by ruining others people’s fun😂. Let’s say I got some mean messages sent to me

[valid field]

Lol Yea I don't really wanna do Online I mean I have an OC but still

[slim dock]

Its tough if you’re a new player, cause it’s basically impossible to beat maxed out players when they come after u. I haven’t played online in like 2+ years. I was a griefing pice of shit 😭. Not happy about myself now lol

[valid field]

I mostly just gamble in Valentine or Rhodes

[slim dock]

The way you made money also makes zero sense. You get paid more the longer you spend on the missions, and the missions usually take you just over 5 min. So you see players, including myself, just waiting right in front of the finishing line for like 20 min 😂

[valid field]

Like I said, I'll gamble, Hunt and fight other players who attack me in free roam

[arctic musk]

it sucks so much but ive heard its so more people invest into red dead online or something because people will spend longer playing

[slim dock]

But having players sit in front of the finishing line doesn’t make people invest more time. It’s makes them wanna quit, cause you are not rewarded for playing the mission well

[arctic musk]

that makes sense