red-dead-singleplayer

[lapis sable]

That even mexico has more functionals

If you use the rampage mod, and hunting wagon mod, hunting becomes really fun to play

[arctic musk]

how does the hunting wagon work

[lapis sable]

Stows carcasses/pelts

But they arent subject to pronghorn

[arctic musk]

using the horse works fine for me

[lapis sable]

Meaning for eg, if you hunt in new austin and want to feed the camp at beaver hollow (which IMO you shouldnt), you had to race the clock

[arctic musk]

hunting wagon is pretty nice in rdo though

[lapis sable]

Horse is fine

Ye

2 horses is the norm

[arctic musk]

ive just used 1 horse but i might use 2 horses for big trips, how should i get a 2nd horse?

[haughty dirge]

wagons suck imo

[arctic musk]

also im pretty sure a shotgun works on some animals if you headshot so thats cool

you can also lung shot deer and other animals and they also insta die if you have a good weapon but in my opinion the lungs arent in an accurate position to real life

[haughty dirge]

they're annoying to maneuver around with and you can't attach a horse to em

[arctic musk]

i like lung shotting animals more then headshotting in rdr2 ngl

[arctic musk]

yeah the handling

[lapis sable]

Kill someone or steal a horse from a town

[haughty dirge]

Shotguns ruin the pelt

all the time

[lapis sable]

Headshot guarantees pelt

[arctic musk]

is it true ball shots are critical ive seen it be red in dead eye on videos

[arctic musk]

yeah less risky

[lapis sable]

If you lung shot you might as well use poison arrow on the body

[haughty dirge]

On men, yes. On Animals, yes.

[arctic musk]

i find it more fun doing lung shots without deadeye though

[haughty dirge]

Getting shot in the balls is a horrible thing to endure especially in the Wild West

I wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy

[arctic musk]

thats probably true i feel like ive gotten 3 star without trinket and with shotgun once but i dont remember well

[lapis sable]

I dont need the buck trinket. I just need to land headshots with the right weapon

[haughty dirge]

except Micah I unloaded 6 bullets into his groin

[lapis sable]

I used 6 explosive bullets

In the head

[haughty dirge]

DAMN

[lapis sable]

Im obsessed with headshots

[haughty dirge]

oh

[arctic musk]

buck trinket is kinda bad it works like once every 5-30 times its such a small chance

[haughty dirge]

bro imagine if you could kick someone in the balls in RD2

would've made combat more fun

[arctic musk]

yes

[lapis sable]

Its only here to clean up your mistake

[haughty dirge]

what does buck trinket even do

[lapis sable]

If you use a wrong ass weapon, you’ll still get a better grade pelt but you’ll still have a shit carcass

Carcasses are MONEY

[arctic musk]

like 1 in 30 chance of skinning an animal and it goes 1 star higher

or if you pick up small animals like birds

[lapis sable]

So I say those that overrely on buck trinket for hunting have skill issue

[haughty dirge]

Hunting isn't even that hard

[lapis sable]

Just use the right weapons and ammo and hit the head. Not that hard

If it’s a rabbit, use a varmit. If it’s a bear, use a rifle

[haughty dirge]

something that really bugged me was how blood doesn't touch the hat

only bullets and stuff

[arctic musk]

its crazy how a bolt action rifle can take down a grizzly bear with a headshot

[haughty dirge]

but no blood

[arctic musk]

and kinda sad black bears dont attack

but i found out in 1 red dead online bounty hunting mission they do attack

[haughty dirge]

like when it's on the ground next to the corpse it's bloodied but when u pick it up its fully clean??

I don't get it

[arctic musk]

what is a good looking horse next to gang members but with really good stats?
i have an american standardbred buckskin right now the stats are terrible but it looks good

[haughty dirge]

I mean there's a ton

idk if Buell can be accessed until ch. 6

there's the white Arabian near Lake Isabella

in the West Grizzlies region

[arctic musk]

its so small compared to gang members horses

i had it my first playthrough but i'd rather have a bigger horse early game

[haughty dirge]

in my current playthru I got the Gold Turkoman from the Saint Denis stables

[arctic musk]

there is a good mustang or something in new austin but thats new austin

[arctic musk]

does it have any brown fur variatons?

[haughty dirge]

for the hair?

I think so

[arctic musk]

for the skin

[haughty dirge]

I don't think so

[arctic musk]

i guess i can check in the stables every chapter

[haughty dirge]

there is a Missouri Fox-Trotter in that one stranger misison

with the guy taking photos

[arctic musk]

race horse though

[haughty dirge]

I think his name was Mason

[arctic musk]

doesnt that have bad handling

[haughty dirge]

I don't think it does

[arctic musk]

it has insane speed stats but i am using a race horse and i dont really like its controls

[haughty dirge]

I got it from the Blackwater stables and its a great horse

[arctic musk]

hm alright thanks

[haughty dirge]

you can always test horses beforehand with cheats and/or mods

[arctic musk]

thats true

[haughty dirge]

Missouri Fox-Trotter is a great horse if u get it to max bonding

even if its not max it's still a great horse

[haughty dirge]

np

[tawdry fractal]

Can I attach a horse to my horse via lasso so I don't have to hold the lasso continuously? I think the feature was hinted at in the game but vague.

[lapis sable]

the easiest way to tame the horse is to use a poison arrow, get it to near death, use a horse reviver, and tame it

or a lasso, that works too

who gives a shit about calming it

[haughty dirge]

or just

put your main saddle on a random horse

[delicate solstice]

What?

Why don't u use the following option

[tardy tiger]

I finished rdr2 yesterday and now i finished the epilogue and now i got the money but there is no point

i wanted to go to tahiti

but idk with who

[haughty dirge]

you unfortunately can't farm mangoes and go to tahiti 😔

[tardy tiger]

thats sad

Now i got the money but i cant go

[haughty dirge]

we... need.. money

🤑

[tardy tiger]

I dont need to break anymore wheels

but like what do i do if i finish all the main missions?

[rose willow]

100% the game

do all the legendary beasts, all the side quests

discover tresures

the dinasour bones

[tawdry fractal]

So lasso in hand, leading horse while on other horse, but I can't use other tools/weapons simultaneously

[lapis sable]

i wish we could. tahiti animals and all

if a mod allows us...

[tardy tiger]

What if bonnie from rdr1 is a pinkerton?

[tawdry fractal]

what are the Pinkertons anyway?

[obsidian plinth]

A detective agency

[formal crag]

detective agency hired to hunt down outlaws and protect railroads mostly

they existed irl i think they were founded in the 1850s

still exists today but lots different obviously

[hollow dirge]

Why cant i do challenges?

Like bandit

[tardy tiger]

And and

What do you think about that theory?

[hollow dirge]

Its locked

[obtuse pollen]

It will get unlocked

[hollow dirge]

How

Im tryna stay in story for arthur open world

I aint doing the storyline

[formal crag]

I havent played rdr1 yet im gonna buy it for my birthday

[hollow dirge]

What

I wanna stay in chapter 2

[rancid maple]

Which one

[hollow dirge]

Dude wym which one

Bandit chellanges

Locked

[rancid maple]

Which bandit challenge

[hollow dirge]

Dude

The category

The whole thing

[rancid maple]

As in
You haven't done the first step of the first one?

[hollow dirge]

Yes

So how do I start it

[winter sage]

rob someone in town

[hollow dirge]

Ight

[slim dock]

Is there a hidden difficulty system I can’t find, or do I need a mod for it?

[drifting geode]

is it possible to find the person that robs u in the alley way in saint denis ?

[warm salmon]

You're supposed to chase him right after

[drifting geode]

i got knocked out and woke up on a bench

[warm salmon]

That is unfortunate

[atomic parrot]

Don't think so

[bitter fossil]

Ye technically they did kill somone in 2020 tho

[slim dock]

How ch2 is kinda boring

And everyone in the gang is lowkey depressed and struggling at that time

[atomic parrot]

I also got knocked down outside Saint Denis, from a weird guy, tbh I was expecting exactly that, then I woke up on swamp coast and returned... and he just shout "fuck its you again" and start shooting xD

[slim dock]

How do you get knocked out ? Never experienced that

[atomic parrot]

There is a Guy in a Cabin, north of Saint Denis... That guy say he can give you food or supplies? iirc, and when you enter the cabin, boom knocked out. Like I said, I had expected it, and just wanted to see what happen xD

[drifting geode]

i got it from talking to a stranger in saint denis he asked if i needed some money then took me in the alley then i was pistol whipped and robbed

[formal crag]

sounds like sonny 😒 worst guy

[atomic parrot]

Possible, don't know if that guy had a name 😄

He now just have some lead...

[verbal quartz]

I have an issue with the materials satchel

[atomic parrot]

Materials satchel? don't heard of it, but im not that deep into Singleplayer yet.

[verbal quartz]

I've already gotten almost 100 hours into the game and am on my second playthrough

The requirement for it is you need to craft 3 items at your scout campfire, which is the one just outside of your camp next to your horses

[atomic parrot]

Ah ok, I see

[fresh root]

Who is it

[lapis sable]

I love poison arrows to poison horses and animals

So i can study them

And when they fall, i will walk in style to them. Study them. And then I shoot an improved arrow or a fire arrow at their head.

[haughty dirge]

they're craftable satchels you can get from Pearson or any fence if you get the materials necessary

but in the Epilogue u can buy them from any fence without the need to craft em

[weary harness]

i like hunting for them 👍

i have all of them

in chapter 2

[haughty dirge]

fair

[weary harness]

do you

[haughty dirge]

not rly

I like fishing more

[weary harness]

fishing i havent really given a try

but it seems really cool

[haughty dirge]

there's a dock south of valentine

it's a stranger mission that unlocks all the lures and special lures u can use in fishing

[weary harness]

is that a fisher of fish

[haughty dirge]

ye

[weary harness]

oh yeah but isnt that chapter 3

i started it last playtrhough

but i forgot about it

[haughty dirge]

no I don't think

they're really helpful when u want to catch legendary fishes

and muskies

and sturgeons

and other big fish

[weary harness]

nah is

oh wait

no it isnt

only legendary fish i've caught is the one in hamish's second mission

[haughty dirge]

the great tyrant?

[weary harness]

yeah

[lapis sable]

I loved chapter 2 and 3. I liked chapter 4

But I dont quite like chapter 6 😦

Cant donate, can only donate carcasses… etc

Cant do activities…

No campfire singing, no happy vibes

[haughty dirge]

chapter 3 was peak fiction

[lapis sable]

It’s sad. I really liked the camp functions

Ye

Chapter 3 is peak

Until sean died

[haughty dirge]

I mean

the shootout at the Braithwaite mansion was peak tho

[lapis sable]

I meant the camp amenities like donating and upgrading etc

[haughty dirge]

oh right

[lapis sable]

You’ll never get that past chapter 4

[haughty dirge]

I liked rowing out on the boat near camp and fishing

[lapis sable]

What i do not like about chapter 3 is I cant kill people in rhodes

[haughty dirge]

You can sort of do that

[lapis sable]

How

[haughty dirge]

in the Rhodes gunstore

yk the kid he trapped under it

if you free the kid and shoot the gunstore cashier u can (to an extent) harass the locals

[lapis sable]

That’s bs 😦

I wanna shoot up everyone

This world is flawed, I am the harbinger to send them to another world 🙂

[haughty dirge]

fair

[haughty dirge]

I'll be honest I never rly liked chapter 4 to such an extent as chapter 3 or 2

it didn't have the same vibe in the camp

[lapis sable]

No sean, no kieran, im sad

Sean is a lovable bastard

Kieran is a goofy ahh boy

[haughty dirge]

the missions were great but Saint Denis is just mid

[lapis sable]

You can be a literal terrorist in saint denis

There will always be innocent people to kill even at max bounty and fighting lawmen

[haughty dirge]

also something that really bugged me was how every chapter was named after the gangs current camp but Chapter 4 is named Saint Denis

I don't get it

[lapis sable]

You can destroy trams, kill everything you see

Trains also show up often so you can sic a dynamite arrow on them and rob passengers and loot

[haughty dirge]

ik but I mean the city in general

it doesn't have the same vibe as Valentine or Rhodes

[lapis sable]

True

Valentine is the best though

[haughty dirge]

yeah

[haughty dirge]

I mean, Guarma did the same thing too but they didn't really have a hideout or camp in Guarma

[obsidian plinth]

Shady belle is a better name too

[haughty dirge]

yeah

[obsidian plinth]

My favorite camp is the second one in chapter 3 where everyone is there and it's spacious and not many bad things happened yet

But horseshoe overlook is my favorite camp name

Beaver hollow is also a really good name

[rancid maple]

I rlly like the start of that chapter's cutscene
Dutch goes "Look at that, the future." And then it shows a very dark image with no life of smoke coming out of pipes covering up a rainbow, probably symbolising the gangs downfall

[lapis sable]

Ranches everywhere, can start a mass shootout over sheep and pigs

[obsidian plinth]

I plucked up the courage and shot Rhodes down in rdo, it was very funny (I needed the low honor for a story mission)

Maybe I'll do low honor Arthur because it's funny

[lapis sable]

Please do

You can be a jackass to everyone equally

[obsidian plinth]

I have to finish my high honor playthrough first

And then I'll attend to do low honor

[lapis sable]

Low honor hunting is very fun. Run from the law while ensuring your carcass remains 3 stars

Getting hunted every 10 mins means more loot too

[obsidian plinth]

So I'll be rich... got it

[lapis sable]

You can walk into stores with $100, and leave the store with tons of items and $100

Five finger discounts across the state

You can go into restricted areas

You can destroy entire towns, trains, trams, boats…

[obsidian plinth]

I see I see

[weary harness]

yeah because chapter 6 was about the story now

[obsidian plinth]

It'll be fun

[weary harness]

no more fun

thats why

its showing that the gang fell off hard

[obsidian plinth]

It's such a good tragic chapter

[lapis sable]

Yeah. Sad. I wish the camp function is in beecher’s hope where we could have bought ranches and more

Maybe even herd bison instead of hunting them

[weary harness]

yeah

[weary harness]

i was not expecting it though

[obsidian plinth]

Me too tbh

[weary harness]

i didnt know it wouldnt let you do shit anymore

[obsidian plinth]

Everything happened so fast

[weary harness]

fr

[obsidian plinth]

One second you're robbing a bank thinking yeah we're gonna make a mess and leave again

[weary harness]

i read about this thing that dutch kinda saved john from dying in a way?

[obsidian plinth]

The next you're in the end times

[lapis sable]

If we can turn beecher’s hope into a hunting ground where we can hunt any sort of animals we could instead of running to areas to hunt I think i will be so happy

If only there are more crafting tables too

[weary harness]

THIS

is a crafting table

[weary harness]

fr

[lapis sable]

I want more items that require crafting

If only rdr2 has more

[weary harness]

because think about it... even though it was bad of Dutch to let John get arrested at the heist he would've had a much worse fate in Guarma because their ship crashed and he left Arthur on the ship because he spoke bad about his plans so he would've left John too and he would drown because he can't swim so

[obsidian plinth]

Oh my god

Now that I think about it yeah

John would've drowned

[weary harness]

he's got a plan

it was all part of his plan

[obsidian plinth]

Dutch knows he can swim he probably would do it on purpose, or worse. Micah throws him overboard and goes oh noooooo he's gooooonnneee

[weary harness]

yeah they tried to kill off john and arthur so it makes sense

like in cornwall kerosene and tar

and the train

[lapis sable]

Dutch has always been like that even before colter

The story shows his facade crumbling and his true persona showing it’s ugly head

[weary harness]

yes

[lapis sable]

John describes it perfectly

[weary harness]

someone who got found out for who they really were

[lapis sable]

Yep

[obsidian plinth]

And really, it's Abigail that begs us to find him on the mountains, not Dutch

[lapis sable]

If dutch really was not holding a facade, he wouldnt have taken micah in

[obsidian plinth]

I don't think Dutch mentions John in chapter 1

I could be mistaken though

[weary harness]

he does i think

when you ride with micah

and him

[obsidian plinth]

Oh yeah

Just briefly

[weary harness]

yeah it was only her because everyone thought he'd come back

[lapis sable]

Dutch wouldnt have shot the girl from blackwater

If he is not running a facade

And he would have continued his robin hood operations and actually adapted

I’m 100% sure dutch’s boys would have been a transitory farmer group instead of outlaws if dutch wasn’t holding a facade

[weary harness]

yes

[lapis sable]

That their dreams of sailing to tahiti to grow mangoes would have been a reality (and a side business)

But it’s obvious dutch isnt that

Because if he is, why would he want to make N O I S E?

There is no need for that. Even Hosea knew

And travel is actually quite cheap. All they had to do is hunt a few animals and sell pelts, and they can get to tahiti already

Including seed capital

There was absolutely no need to rob trains and banks

[haughty dirge]

it's a great story chapter, not a great vibe chapter like 2 or 3

though I will admit 6 had some of my favorite missions in the entire game

Icarus and Friends is a heavily slept on mission

[haughty dirge]

Dutch was already too far gone when he suggested going to Tahiti instead of moving with Hosea's idea of moving further north so obviously he'd make some rash decisions

[lapis sable]

He was gone long before

[haughty dirge]

They didn't even need the money from the train robbery, they could've just used the money from the Valentine Bank Robbery to go to Tahiti

[lapis sable]

They dont even need to do robberies. Just sell pelts and game

[haughty dirge]

Yeah but Dutch didn't see that as a viable option at the moment

[lapis sable]

If everyone hunted, getting to tahiti is a reality

No law will be attracted to them

[haughty dirge]

also the fact that Tahiti would've most likely been in the same situation as Guarma

[lapis sable]

Yeah

And tbh they dont need to go to tahiti

They could have made Horseshoe overlook their permanent home

Or even the blackwater camp

[haughty dirge]

And regardless law will still be on their asses as shown by Fussar's efforts to kill them and also the Naval ship that showed up to Guarma for the sole purpose of capturing or killing Dutch's men

[haughty dirge]

in Hell Hath no Fury

[lapis sable]

Hell, if dutch was truly caring for the gang, no law would even touch them

No micah too

[haughty dirge]

The problem with that is that since the gang was too comfortable in Overlook they started causing noise that was enough to track down their hideout

the bar fight at the start of Ch. 2

the shootout at the end of ch. 2

[lapis sable]

Pinkertons wouldnt know the gang turned a new leaf if they hadnt robbed that train

[haughty dirge]

the train robbery

they tracked Arthur down much easier due to the shootout in Strawberry

[lapis sable]

As i said, the gang had that one last chance to turn over into good people back in Colter. They wasted it.

[haughty dirge]

That still wouldn't really help them

[lapis sable]

It would. Pinkertons wouldnt know any more of dutch’s boys if they truly kept quiet until probably decades later

[haughty dirge]

since the Blackwater Massacre caused Pinkertons and State Marshalls to be stationed in South West Elizabeth for most of the games story

[haughty dirge]

knowing Dutch he wouldn't stay quiet for too long

[lapis sable]

Yeah, and that is the problem

If dutch lay low for good starting from colter, his gang wouldnt have broken down

Also, if dutch has a brain for business, he would have realized that selling meat and pelts to the right areas would have been the way forward for the gang

Think. Have anyone in the civilized world ate herptile meats?

How does a gila lizard taste? How does moose taste? Or bison?

They are so forturnate to be able to eat all types of meat compared to the “usual” of 1899

[weary harness]

yeah very dark vibe

i also read somewhere that the move from blackwater doesnt make sense

[lapis sable]

I think jack was weaned on roadkill chipmunk meat

[weary harness]

i'll post in media

[lapis sable]

Tbh i never ever insult pearson

Whether im high honor or low, i will never insult the cook

[weary harness]

yes

no one hurts him

[lapis sable]

Man feeds the camp, man is a jolly person, that I’m not surprised he’s married in 1907

[weary harness]

oh yeah he has a wife

do we ever see her?

[lapis sable]

Pearson will never get charged as a criminal

You know why? That man is an asset everywhere

[weary harness]

because whenever his wife starts talking to him i look behind me and theres just this one guy that appears every time

the same worker

[lapis sable]

He can cook, he can skin, he can craft good stuff and satchels, he can tan leather

And he is the true honest guy

Also the fact he has never contributed illegal things to camp

[weary harness]

yeah the whole time bro was just a chill guy

highest honor

[lapis sable]

Sadie and Charles will probably get charged

Pearson won’t

Also his backstory was that dutch found him while he’s drunk

Because he served in the navy, which wasnt what he want, as he want to be hunting whales like his father

He did nothing wrong

Same with Swanson, but swanson is more of a freeloader

[lapis sable]

Bro broke the high honor cap

[haughty dirge]

Sadie and Charles wouldn't get charged

[weary harness]

yes they will

[lapis sable]

Yes they will

They did some gang activities

Sadie murdered people in cold blood without remorse, same as charles

[haughty dirge]

lemny!?

[weary harness]

they will find them and #########

just like what they did to #####

[haughty dirge]

lenny!?¿

[haughty dirge]

bro got tagged

[lapis sable]

Lenny did join gang activities

[haughty dirge]

Life.. is roblox

[weary harness]

all of them are bad people

[lapis sable]

Nobody is innocent except Pearson

[weary harness]

except for pearson and jack

[lapis sable]

Yeah

[weary harness]

they did nothing 🙏

[lapis sable]

Only Pearson and Jack

[haughty dirge]

nah Jack is pure evil

no one saw it

he committed the most atrocious crimes known to man

[weary harness]

some people say mary beth and tilly but no

they're also bad people

[lapis sable]

If pearson is an outlaw, why can he settle down in Rhodes and have a general store and have a wife that can enjoy his stew of many animals he can cook with?

[weary harness]

mary beth helped with the train robbery and tilly used to run in a gang

[haughty dirge]

I don't think Swanson would get charged

[haughty dirge]

he's mostly just chilling around and getting drunk

[lapis sable]

Pearson is just roped in with the wrong people

[lapis sable]

He wont.

He did absolutely nothing.

[weary harness]

yeah

he was just a morphine addict

[haughty dirge]

Arthur gets charged with death because he broke the goddamn wheel 🔥

[lapis sable]

Yeah.

[weary harness]

or was it heroin

[haughty dirge]

Morphine

[lapis sable]

Arthur Morgan killed the most people

[haughty dirge]

it's specifically Morphine

[lapis sable]

It’s pretty obvious the law wants him

[weary harness]

5000 dollars on his head alone

[lapis sable]

But they are willing to let it slide because dutch is worth more

[haughty dirge]

5000 dollars

can he turn himself in

[lapis sable]

Though they are sure to get him later

[weary harness]

how much is dutch's bounty again?

[haughty dirge]

it's never really stated

but it's definetly higher than Arthur's

[weary harness]

yeah

he's leader

[lapis sable]

Definitely add a 0 after arthur’s 5000 bounty

And you’ll probably see why they just want dutch

Initially

[weary harness]

you cant fight... money

[haughty dirge]

haha embed fail

[weary harness]

☹️

you know what it was though

[haughty dirge]

get Lumbago'd

[lapis sable]

Tbh with the way arthur earns money, if high honor he can easily pay 5000 dollars

[weary harness]

i have over 5000

[lapis sable]

Paying our own bounty makes us a free man

Ye

[weary harness]

by the way

[lapis sable]

But the game pretty much cement that we cant pay other bounties

[weary harness]

is there a specific reason why we were wanted in new austin

we didnt even do anything

[lapis sable]

So arthur’s always going to be wanted

[weary harness]

as arthur

[lapis sable]

News spread fast to new austin

Blackwater is really close to new austin

[haughty dirge]

Probably because Pinkertons spread posters all over Armadillo and Tumbleweed

[weary harness]

also is close to valentine which doesnt make sense

hmm

[haughty dirge]

Blackwater is much closer to New Austin than Valentine

[lapis sable]

Strawberry, not valentine

[weary harness]

yeah but like the towns

valentine is closer to blackwater than blackwater is to armadillo

eh

its for the plot

[haughty dirge]

they probably spread the news via the train station

and the post offices

[weary harness]

makes sense

[lapis sable]

Jack marston is not jack marston

He is John Marston Jr

[weary harness]

☹️

you made me remeber

[lapis sable]

Jack’s just a pet name

[weary harness]

i wish to not remember

[lapis sable]

As i said, jack definitely tried all sorts of meat

I envy him

From skunk meat to iguanas

[weary harness]

yes

[lapis sable]

Here we are

Restricted to only a few types of meats

I guess getting weaned on roadkill is why he wanna be a gunslinger when he grows up HAH

[weary harness]

low honor jack is a creep

[lapis sable]

Jack is high honor canonically

John, probably middle-high

[weary harness]

yeah

BRUH

[lapis sable]

Canonically, jack made it to gta series

Died of old age i suppose

Made a book called Red Dead

[weary harness]

oh

really?

[lapis sable]

Yeah. Really.

[weary harness]

when he was 78 he could watch star wars

[lapis sable]

He probably could have served in the world wars

[weary harness]

1895

he was born in 1895 so 74 he would watch star wars

wait no

82

and when he was 115 he could play as himself in red dead redemption 1

[lapis sable]

He’s dead by now

[winter sage]

that's not canon at all

it's just a easter egg

rdr & gta exist in separate universes

hell gta iv & onwards are in a separate universe from past gtas too

hd universe & 3d universe

[lapis sable]

different universes but we all have our headcanon

unless stated otherwise by rockstar

like, nobody will know ending C is canon unless rockstar canonized it

[haughty dirge]

technically it is

Both Franklin and Trevor show up in GTA Online which takes place about 10+ years after the singleplayer story

And during one of the missions with Franklin, he mentioned that he knew one of the producers at Solomon Richards' studio when you drive past it

which was Michael

so Ending C is canon

[lapis sable]

trevor's was before 2013

[haughty dirge]

it was?

[lapis sable]

yes

[haughty dirge]

oh mb

[lapis sable]

i love that goofy psychotic bro

the perfect gta protagonist

[arctic musk]

what horse do yall use in the story mode?

[weary harness]

uhhh

i think the mft from the albert mason mission

[arctic musk]

its a race horse right?

[weary harness]

yeah

[arctic musk]

does the horse work good

i have a race horse and hes not super good at turning and going where i want him to go

[weary harness]

well i think its very nice 🤠 👍

[weary harness]

oh

[lapis sable]

White arabian for me

[arctic musk]

does the mft look good next to other peoples horses

white arabian looks so small compared to others

[weary harness]

mft is not small

[lapis sable]

I love it better when the white is soaked in BLOOD

[arctic musk]

nice

[weary harness]

but its hard to get

as arthur

[lapis sable]

Me trailing across new hanover, murdering people and animals

[weary harness]

real

[lapis sable]

Coating my white arabian with pelts and blood

[arctic musk]

true

[weary harness]

well actually everyone says its hard but not really

took me like 8 tries

[arctic musk]

any good bounty hunter horses?

[weary harness]

wdym

[arctic musk]

bounty hunters can have decent horses

[lapis sable]

Depends on how far in the story

You wont get anything much of value when at chapter 2 for eg for bounty hunter horses

[arctic musk]

i need a good stat horse in chapter 3 ngl

and not too small

[lapis sable]

Arabian

[weary harness]

the turkoman

using glitches

[lapis sable]

But its up to you

[arctic musk]

bounty hunters just killed my horse

bruh

now i really need a new horse

rip bert

im never using a shotgun on horse again😭

[weary harness]

noooooo

[arctic musk]

shotguns in pve suck sometimes

[weary harness]

err

yeah

[arctic musk]

ill try and get the turkoman in chapter 3 with the story mission bug

is that late in chapter 3?

[weary harness]

horse flesh for dinner

where you steal the braithwaite's horses

🤠 👍

[arctic musk]

nice, is that early or late in chapter 3?

or in the middle or so

[weary harness]

its like 2 or 3 missions before A Short Walk In A Pretty Town.....

so late ig

[arctic musk]

you dont wanna know how many times ive replayed that mission

stupid gold medals😭

i thought i had to get all of them so i skipped no missions

[weary harness]

nooo

there was this glitch

and sean blinked

[arctic musk]

scary

what is it with everyone talking about arthur breaking the wheel i dont get it

[weary harness]

fr

[weary harness]

in "eastward bound" arthur says a line

"I broke the goddamn wheel!" and now its a meme

[arctic musk]

yeah i know he says that but i dont get why its a meme lol

[lapis sable]

Use a repeater next time

[weary harness]

its just funny yk

[arctic musk]

yeah i had one in my loadout but decided to use my shotgun for fun

and i play without deadeye so it was a stupid decision lol

[wise drum]

is there anything required to catch white arabian horse or do i just catch with lasso

[arctic musk]

lasso doesnt work i think

just go slowly and keep calming it

it takes like 1 or 2 minutes

[wise drum]

alright ill try to do that rn

[arctic musk]

gl

[wise drum]

thanks

why is my feed button on the horse greyed out?

[obsidian plinth]

You might be out of food

[wise drum]

i have carrots tho

[wise drum]

yooo i just got ittt

[obsidian plinth]

Are you close enough to the horse ?

[wise drum]

yep

[lapis sable]

Shoot your horse

Then steal a horse and saddle it in

[obsidian plinth]

You could try feeding the horse while mounted

Open the wheel and feed it fork there

[lapis sable]

Or shoot up people. You’ll get horse food too

[weary harness]

i think bros low honor irl

all i've heard from you is low honor things

lol

[lapis sable]

Lol

Because low honor is the way to play rdr2

[weary harness]

yes until chapter 6

[lapis sable]

Haha

[weary harness]

thats why its called red dead redemption

you have to redeem yourself

[lapis sable]

You still redeemed yourself by saving john or jack

The question is how you want your death to be like

I personally like it quick

[weary harness]

oh i guess

[lapis sable]

A gunshot to the head is better than suffering a final and agonising 20 mins of your life

That is why my first playthrough is low honor fr

High honor rn is just me going out to hunt

Greet everyone

Avoid campers

Sounds dumb

Oh wait i also cant kill domestic animals so much 💀

Also in the epilogue

No one cares if john is high or low honor

Same with rdr1.

No one cares about john’s honor

[weary harness]

i'm high honor john because

i get the benefits of high honor

i still kill people though with my bandana

🤠 👍

[lapis sable]

See, high honor players are actually hypocrites

They want to wantonly kill like low honor players but had to spend time meeting and greeting people to get back to high honor

[weary harness]

in rdr1

in rdr2 my john is.... 😈

[lapis sable]

And with the ending of rdr2 for arthur, people want high honor because they think coming to terms is the way to go

The truth is, there really wasn’t any coming to terms

[slim dock]

Honor system feels a bit rigged, cause it gets dragged down by just playing the game

[lapis sable]

It’s how you want to play as

[weary harness]

it gets dragg down?

[lapis sable]

I simply embrace that this is an outlaw game

[weary harness]

live as an outlaw

die as an outlaw

[slim dock]

Yeah, by doing robbery and shooting lawmen all that stuff, it takes down ur honor. And there’s nothing you can do about, cause that’s how the missions work

[lapis sable]

And as outlaws, I get to shoot, murder, rob and kill as many people as i want

[weary harness]

oh well i'm careful so i never lose huge amounts

[lapis sable]

My first huge case of honor loss is robbing the doctor in Valentine

Bastard has a side business of odrisscols, i kill em, the law think I am evil for eliminating this plague in their town, so… i shoot up the entire town

[weary harness]

the doctor doesnt make you lose honor

just dont shoot the doctor

[lapis sable]

300 dollar bounty with my first Schofield revolver HELL YEAH!!!

[lapis sable]

I killed the doctor too

[slim dock]

At that point you can just run away, no one forced u to shoot up the town.

[weary harness]

as a high honor arthur, i dont kill the doctor

[lapis sable]

Arthur Morgan aint no coward

[slim dock]

Its when the missions are telling you to do something that takes away honor, it gets a bit annoying

[weary harness]

they always give you an option to spare

[lapis sable]

I kill all the pursuers and then I run away

[weary harness]

you can get honor though by completing the inquisities of history

kill the guy

[lapis sable]

Yes

[slim dock]

Not what I’m talking about, when you’re getting chased down by lawmen or do a heist, you loose honor

[weary harness]

its what you do best

[lapis sable]

You know what’s better, shooting them with incendiary bullets

[weary harness]

i've never experienced that

there's always a better way

[lapis sable]

Screams of agony is good

[slim dock]

There’s nothing honor full in robbing civilians on a train lmao. Just how the game works

[lapis sable]

In my first playthrough, my deadeye sounds mostly have screams

[weary harness]

did you rob the passengers in pouring forth oil?

[lapis sable]

When I rob trains, I rob a compartment, shoot everyone in the head, go to another compartment, repeat

[weary harness]

bro i'm telling you the easiest way to get low honor is robbing the passengers on that train

is so easy

you lose one level every time you rob one of the passengers

[slim dock]

The mission is telling u to do it, its indicating it

[lapis sable]

Wrong. Rob and KILL

[slim dock]

Having low honor is not worth it, cause of ending imo. In online tho. I’ve went ham

[lapis sable]

It’s worth it.

Five finger discounts with an explosive bullet in the shopkeeper’s head, works everytime

[weary harness]

Yes but you can actually get past that mission without robbing them yk

you dont have to

[lapis sable]

I did

Money is money

[weary harness]

of course

i'm gonna start another playthrough

low honor

[lapis sable]

Please do

[weary harness]

loww honor

[lapis sable]

You’ll love it fr

[weary harness]

what ending did you get

did you go back for money

[slim dock]

Is it possible to start new playthrough but start at a specific point ?

[weary harness]

err

no

[lapis sable]

Help john

[slim dock]

Damn, I would maybe play it again, but chapter 1- early ch3 is so boring and repetitive

[lapis sable]

What’s the use of money lol

[weary harness]

a true low honor would get the go back for money ending

[slim dock]

That ending option is so ass, because there’s no logic behind it

[weary harness]

yeah

i did all endings

i made a save before our best selves

[lapis sable]

Yes but i wanted the gunshot

[weary harness]

ah okay that makes sense

[jovial swallow]

can buy holsters in story mode?

[weary harness]

"tennis boat!" pew may iii stand unshaken? amidst amidst a crashing world

[weary harness]

no

not buy

well actually yes

[lapis sable]

I did all endings too but my favorite is low honor

[weary harness]

you have to finish challenges to get differnet ones

[weary harness]

yerm?

low honor makes sense i guess

[lapis sable]

I mean personally, when I know I am gonna die, at least let me die quick. Not an agonising can’t breathe moment

[slim dock]

But do you wanna give Micah the satisfaction of doing so ?

[lapis sable]

Yes

[weary harness]

yeah tbh arthurs high honor death makes no sense

[slim dock]

I wouldn’t mind if it was anyone else than Micah

[weary harness]

a real TB patient would die from very very very bad coughing

he died peacefully???

[lapis sable]

Of course not

LOL

[slim dock]

I mean Arthur would’ve technically died in every mission, or nearly every lol

[weary harness]

plot armour 😎

[slim dock]

His plot armor is nearly as strong as Nathan drake

[lapis sable]

How about you go to the poisonous trail finale and fall off a cave

[weary harness]

nathan drake has toughest plot armour

[lapis sable]

There. Quick and painless

[weary harness]

the bullets dont even hit him

[lapis sable]

While jumping off, scream CHELONIA

[slim dock]

At some point it got a bit too ridiculous for my liking, like when you’re escaping that prison with John, ur a sitting duck on little boat with 20 guards shooting directly at u. Like cmon. A line has to be drawn

[weary harness]

real and can we also talk about guarma where five men blow up an entire fucking ship by themselves

[lapis sable]

Actually i wish it didnt skip to the cutscene

I wanna destroy prison boats

[slim dock]

Cause they knew it made no sense at all you made it back 😂

[weary harness]

i wanna get into the prison

[lapis sable]

Actually it does make sense because it will show arthur is a badass

[rancid maple]

Saa geniune question wdym you saw my post on reddit, I'm just asking because I'm literally not on reddit

[slim dock]

No man no matter skill should survive that

[weary harness]

i saw that video on reddit today

let me see if i can find it

[rancid maple]

Yea it makes sense but it would've made more sense if he atleast was shot in the shoulder

[lapis sable]

I wish the cutscenes dont skip fights

[rancid maple]

Huh

I didn't post that to reddit it's just my rdr2 gameplay

[weary harness]

maybe i'm just confused bro

[lapis sable]

Also, i wish we can craft more type of items

[weary harness]

deja vu maybe?

[lapis sable]

Not just trapper/fence/pearson

[rancid maple]

Campfires:

[weary harness]

eh

yeah nvm

i did see this one though

[rancid maple]

Idk I was only asking because I've never had reddit nor posted anything to it

[weary harness]

its like deja vu or something

eh

its okay

i saw this funny one with john

[arctic musk]

efficient but fun way to rob trains?

[weary harness]

hmmm

[weary harness]

take the train from emerald ranch was it?

and then you have to wait till the train is suspended over bacchus bridge

sorry no @arctic musk take the train from annesburg

then stop it when you get to bacchus bridge

[arctic musk]

i can try it out thanks

[weary harness]

the lawman wont be able to get to you

[hidden moss]

should i restart the story

[weary harness]

err

idk

[hidden moss]

i finished the game

[next glacier]

Your name doesn't correlate with your role man

[hidden moss]

but im unhappy

[hidden moss]

yeah blame the mods 😔

[next glacier]

Embrace the clown role..

[hidden moss]

but i like arthur

😔😔😔

[weary harness]

i love arthur

[hidden moss]

hes my zaddy

[next glacier]

Lets all be real, we'd ALL do exactly as Micah did if we were in their position

[hidden moss]

hell no

fuck micah

[weary harness]

yeam

[next glacier]

Wdym? I'd totally rat out the gang for assured freedom

[weary harness]

anyway goodnight chat

[hidden moss]

they should make a dlc where u can throw dynamite at micah and he actually dies 😔

[hidden moss]

goodnight

[woven salmon]

how do i not receive any damage with only fists against a knife?

[lapis sable]

They should make a dlc where we can craft more items

For eg, crafting our own RDO wagon in rdr2

The rdo Hunting wagon would be a godsend

But i think we can all agree we deserve mexico dlc

[hidden moss]

YES

[lapis sable]

Give us the ability to skin cats and dogs

And horses

Just like rdr1

I love me a kentucky saddler steak please

Or dog meat

And do not cry peta to me because it does exist in rdr1

Dog meat, horse meat, mule meat.

Dog fur, Horse hide, Mule hide

So TECHNICALLY, Arthur Morgan can shoot up horses and skin them!

Dogs too, and dare I say cats

yummy 🤡

Also, you can eat bat meat from bat carcasses. Don’t ask how

[valid field]

How did Catherine Braithwaite know the Moonshine Hosea and Arthur brought to her homestead was her's? Hosea never made mention of that.

[tawdry fractal]

When Arthur says to John Marston "go be with your family" I wonder if there's a touch of sadness to it. Besides the gang, Arthur doesn't really have a family.

[obsidian plinth]

Because where we get the moonshine was the Braithwaite's place and they heard it exploded, I'm sure they got a description of Arthur and Dutch form in town and saw him coming along. Big family = many eyes

[valid field]

Wasn't it Leymone raiders you fought at the distillery ?

[obsidian plinth]

I'm pretty sure it was a braithwaite distillery regardless. They probably work together

[haughty dirge]

Raiders were the buyers I believe

[hard flame]

been playing the game for some years now, anyone knows any secrets and places someone like me may not know? Like the devil-guy in the cave or the killer, I know those...

[obsidian plinth]

Uhhh

The giant in the cave
The strange man's cabin

[hard flame]

like things you guys didn't know you could find even after exploring like 70% of the map

[obsidian plinth]

I can't think of anything too big of a secret

I'd say check out the Strange Man YouTube account for ideas. They do a lot of secrets and stuff. It's super interesting

[hard flame]

aight, thanks mate

[median bone]

hii, where can i sell valuables?

[obsidian plinth]

The fence! The symbol for it is like the general store but it has an x in the middle

[median bone]

thank u!!

[obsidian plinth]

You're welcome ^^

[nimble jewel]

Is the Bharati grizzly bear the same one as the legendary bear? Cuz i hunted it when i went with hosea but its not marked on my map like the other legendary animals i hunted

Nvm figured it out

[blissful grotto]

how do i increase honor quickly

i seem to get the most from stranger side quests

[fringe hedge]

Go to Saint Denis and click greet to everybody

[blissful grotto]

but when i greet everyone in st denis i don’t get any

bro the doesn’t work

i get the icon but no progress

[fringe hedge]

Why not

Works for everybody else

[blissful grotto]

idk

im trying to get deauville outfit

[fringe hedge]

Have you tried google

[true roost]

Can some one give me rdr2 for free on steam I only have gta v

[blissful grotto]

just buy it bro

[vague ravine]

did bro just join to ask that?

[blissful grotto]

probably

is volcanic or m1899 better

for duel wield

[true roost]

lol I played the first one

[blissful grotto]

rn i use schofields but might switch

[true roost]

John marston was goated rip

[blissful grotto]

he’s in rdr2 b

dw

[fringe hedge]

He wasn’t

[true roost]

Really?

[tawdry fractal]

I was trying to work out where Sandy Knee is supposed to be, I think they mean Saint Denis

[haughty dirge]

Fish

when you catch one throw it back to the water

Donate to camp

kill the slave owner

Donate to the donation box in Saint Denis

do camp activities like chopping wood

[tawdry fractal]

Can I adjust the camera's position relative to Arthur? So not quite so far away

[haughty dirge]

you can zoom in the lense

or use Orbit

[tawdry fractal]

do you mean photo mode?

[haughty dirge]

oh

u mean ingame?

[tawdry fractal]

yes

[haughty dirge]

uhhh

I think so

[lapis sable]

I play a simple game with the law most of the time.

I go to their most populated domestic animals pen with my good ol hunting wagon mod.

Then I kill all the animals with the preferred rifle in the head.

I let witnesses go as I take animal carcasses into stowing the wagon.

I fight the law and if they manage to shoot the carcass to make it drop quality, I lose a point.

Then when i captured all animals inside, I run and abandon the wagon, and then I go back to harvest

[haughty dirge]

bro you can genuinely write a screenplay for a Saw movie

[lapis sable]

Cows are harder to skin because the skinning process takes time

There is another fun way i can play rampages. It’s called Area defense

Get to an amenity like a shop, or something

Then i kill and loot everything

Get the law to fight me there

Harder in Ambarino though

Also poker tables are very dumb, i dont like playing poker, so i will destroy every establishment and turn it into a war zone

[woven kernel]

im snakebit and missed what it said - which herb do I need to find?

[tawdry fractal]

do you have any health potions on you? That'll work.

[woven kernel]

Ginseng helped I think

[remote lodge]

what do the stars next to animal name mean

[tawdry fractal]

I was thinking ginseng (hence including it originally) but wasn't sure so.

[slim dock]

What fov slider do people here use? First person or 1,2,3?

[winter sage]

it means the quality

1 star is poor 2 star is good 3 star is perfect

affects the price u get for them

and to craft any items you need a perfect one always

although if you have the buck antler trinket, then most times a 2 star can turn out perfect too

[remote lodge]

alr

[remote lodge]

how can i get the buck antler trinket

[winter sage]

hunt down the legendary buck then go to a fence

[harsh narwhal]

Where do I get a hair tonic from

[weary talon]

i think you can get it from the general store in valentine

[harsh narwhal]

Do you know how you can dye your hair and beard

[weary talon]

i dont think youre able to

i think it’s just you can do different hairstyles and beard styles at a barbers

and you can just shave in camp

[harsh narwhal]

Well that's unfortunate

I was trying to make Arthur look like an Irish viking

[weary talon]

damn

maybe you can find a hairstyle that channels his inner vikingness

[harsh narwhal]

Well I do have a idea

Grow my beard the longest

My hair

and wear fur

and go half naked

[weary talon]

lmao 😭 nice

[harsh narwhal]

Apparently you can have custom hair color but you have to install mods

[weary talon]

ah i didn’t know that

[harsh narwhal]

How much time in-game I have to wait for the hair tonic to work

[slim dock]

I wish they made longer hair more compatible with different clothing, it often bugs through it

[harsh narwhal]

Why the fuck the hair tonic isn't working

[slim dock]

They often happen through a cutscene or time skip

[harsh narwhal]

I gobbled up 3

[slim dock]

That’s not much tbh

[harsh narwhal]

How much do you want me to drink

To get a goddamn viking beard

[harsh narwhal]

How do I do a time skip

[slim dock]

Set up a camp and sleep

[harsh narwhal]

How many hair tonics

[slim dock]

Or just get a cutscene

[slim dock]

Take like 10 maybe

[slim dock]

If you’re using coats and neckwear I don’t recommend long hair. It bugs through and looks like shit

[harsh narwhal]

I'm wearing a fur

[slim dock]

As long as the fur is not in contact with ur neck area ur good

[harsh narwhal]

Do you know where I can get the viking helmet

[ionic juniper]

There are a lot of theories about strange man, what do you think?

In rdr 1, we saw him in a mission called I know you, and in rdr 2 there were a lot of related things

[slim dock]

I have a feeling I saw something like that at a fence up in Rhodes

Or it was from the butcher in Saint Denis, can’t remember which one of em. I’m putting my money on the fence tho

[harsh narwhal]

I did a time skip and the tonic is working slowly

[harsh narwhal]

Since I can't dye my hair and beard I'm gonna be a Scotland highlander viking

[harsh narwhal]

Do you know how to fatten up Arthur

Like buff hum

Him

My Arthur is skinny

[slim dock]

Eat, especially the meat called plain big game, which comes from larger animals like bears and crocodiles

[harsh narwhal]

Will it get him to look bigger

And look strong

Also where do I get this meat

I don't wanna hunt

Is there some other way?

[slim dock]

Fat

lol

[harsh narwhal]

Yeah but will he look big

[slim dock]

You can’t have a massive size while keeping him trained

[harsh narwhal]

How do I get a massive size then

And have muscles

[slim dock]

Yes. The beard will cover up his fucked up jawline when fat

[slim dock]

Don’t know if you can have both muscles and big

[harsh narwhal]

Fuck what do I do

This is so stressing

[slim dock]

It’s hard to keep him at that condition tho. You have to eat consistently and there’s a limit of how much meat u can hold

[harsh narwhal]

How do I get muscles

[ionic juniper]

I love bounty hunting, I don't remember exactly, but a sheriff told me he doesn't want to do it in his district anymore lol

I think he made a deal

[slim dock]

Have perfect weight, but then he’s not particularly big

[harsh narwhal]

So I should drink 10 tonics

For the level 10 beard

And then do what

[rancid maple]

I don't think Dutch "thought" about Arthur in a sad way in American Venom, mainly because of how narcissistic he is, I feel what went through his brain was more a mini-identity crisis when John said "ARTHUR SAVED MY LIFE, MORE THAN ONCE" remembering the gang's old morals, and when Micah mocks it, Dutch realises Micah didn't save anyone but himself, and decided in that moment that Micah was just a liability and decided to kill him off

[harsh narwhal]

Are spoilers allowed?

Dude fuck

You ruined the whole game for me

[granite peak]

Rule #11 | Spoilers - There are no rules against spoilers in this community. However, if you are posting spoilers with the sole purpose of ruining the experience for someone else, it will not be tolerated.

[harsh narwhal]

He could at least use ||

To mark the spoilers

He ruined the whole story for me

And possibly more people

Plenty of people

[supple trout]

The spoiler tags are disabled here, people use them to bypass bot restrictions

Also, the reason we aren’t’ spoiler free is the game is 7 years old at this point

[slim dock]

U need more than that

For Max

[harsh narwhal]

I'm at chapter 2

How do I get a level 10 beard in chapter 2

[hidden moss]

This game wants me to hunt 5 cougars with a bow

I’m so ass with a bow, man

All I want is the panther coat

[slim dock]

If you’re using a controller, it’s impossible to be bad.

[hidden moss]

It’s just that once you aim after a while your camera gets shaky and it’s really annoying

[slim dock]

Don’t hold it for too long then

Fire when you see a red mark, like

[autumn kettle]

Yea i used to play on ps4 its kinda hard to aim w bow sometimes

[slim dock]

How? The lock on aim does the work for u, just let go when marker shows red

[hidden moss]

My horse gets me killed by launching me off, then there’s a guy shooting at the cougar when I respawn

[rancid maple]

Hair tonics

[ionic juniper]

I want to do the whole challenges but it probably takes a long time and sometimes I complete something by chance

I only want to do it for one outfit

[valid field]

Why do I always get a odd sense of dread heading into chapter 4?

[autumn kettle]

Thats so true

[valid field]

I have trouble playing past CH. 3 because I know its all down hill from there

[autumn kettle]

Same

[naive gale]

am i allowed to post a stupid clip in #red-dead-media where my horse is modded to be tiny as a joke

single player

oh it says they don't condone or punish

[valid field]

When specifically, do you think, the grays and braithwaites realized they were being used against the other?

Like I know I asked before, but like what moment do you think it clicked?

Like they came to the conclusion to attack the gang?