#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 157 of 1

spring wraith
#

And they died

worthy hearth
#

we know he was just with hosea and dutch

#

and there wasn't a major event

zinc maple
#

and we already know about all the characters, idk how entertaining it’d be

worthy hearth
#

rdr2 was a perfect prequel because we HAD a super major event

spring wraith
#

He was homeless and an amazing thief

worthy hearth
#

and plus, do you want them to have the same protagonist, but less wise?

spring wraith
#

Who else would even be a protagonist

#

We’ve had Arthur jack John and John again

worthy hearth
#

that's the same thing people said about rdr1

#

they should make a new story in a different location

zinc maple
#

i think sadie could be cool but idk how it’d work

spring wraith
#

Red dead is a western game though

worthy hearth
#

sadie after she leaves john is a pretty open book

spring wraith
#

Doesn’t she just become a bounty hunter

hidden moss
#

There's unanswered questions about what happened before Rdr2

I think rockstar will make 2 small games around the 2030 mark.

One depicts the story before rdr as micah bell joins, maybe as some other character, taking place in the unfilled northwest of the map, and the other will give the story of jack marston in 1916 experiencing the death of the west, the finale to the rdr timeline.

Only presuming what seems logical based on what I know.

worthy hearth
spring wraith
#

2 small games for 5 years is crazy tbh

worthy hearth
#

if there was a prequel to rdr2 you literally know all of the characters and what happens to each and every one of them

zinc maple
#

it’d be cool if we saw sadie’s story after everything

spring wraith
#

Either a whole new character or Sadie

#

That’s my top 2

worthy hearth
#

yeah fair enough

spring wraith
#

If only we left Micah alive maybe one of Sadie’s bounties could of been Micah

worthy hearth
#

no

zinc maple
#

no

spring wraith
#

Why

hidden moss
worthy hearth
#

killing micah was perfect closure

zinc maple
#

^

spring wraith
#

To bad u need a cliff hanger

worthy hearth
#

well no

#

not really

spring wraith
#

Yes

#

Yes

zinc maple
#

i do not agree with that

hidden moss
#

That isn't a cliff hanger

#

I misinterpreted nvm

worthy hearth
#

it really isn't a cliffhanger, and i feel like even if the epilogue was shaved off the game would be great

#

but i still don't think forgetting about micah would be a good choice

spring wraith
worthy hearth
#

just don't worry about it

zinc maple
#

you'll find out

worthy hearth
#

he's in the first game

spring wraith
#

Ok

#

I didn’t play the first game

zinc maple
#

i recommend playing the first game after this

spring wraith
#

Ik

#

I will

worthy hearth
#

i played rdr2 4 times before i played rdr1

#

def prefer the second game, but rdr1 was great too

zinc maple
#

you'll have a lot of questions answered

#

rdr1 is very good i really enjoyed it

#

undead nightmare is really fun too

spring wraith
#

Only reason I don’t want Sadie as the protagonist is bc ever protagonist in rdr games dies

hidden moss
#

You really need to finish rdr2 man

spring wraith
#

I don’t wanna part one is so boring😭😭

worthy hearth
#

what

#

why did you join a rdr2 discord server if you don't really like the game lmao

spring wraith
#

Did I say the whole game or part one

zinc maple
#

part one of what

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

Epilogue

somber badger
#

guys i put in the tommy gun mod in rdr2 but its not working

somber badger
#

i need help

hidden moss
worthy hearth
spring wraith
#

Yes

worthy hearth
#

still, you joined like

#

a fan server before finishing the game 💀

zinc maple
#

you just need to get through it i fear

#

if u want to finish it

worthy hearth
#

the housebuilding song makes up for it

zinc maple
#

real

#

thats so good

somber badger
#

i beg someone help me with this mod

spring wraith
#

Wth even is part one Vinland Sage part two

zinc maple
#

i dont really use mods

worthy hearth
#

yeah, i tried modding rdr2 once and just gave up

spring wraith
#

Can u even mod on console

zinc maple
#

i only have seasons

hidden moss
zinc maple
hidden moss
spring wraith
#

Yea I couldn’t mod if I saw a step by step video 10 million times

worthy hearth
#

modding some games is pretty easy

#

project zomboid modding is super simple

spring wraith
#

Ok not saying Abigail doesn’t have a reason to get mad at John but what is John supposed to do let them shoot him or change his past

worthy hearth
#

give them what they want

#

unless it is them trying to kill you

#

but the main issue is that he keeps doing it

#

that's why john and abigail keep moving across the country

spring wraith
#

Well the mission I just did they prolly would of killed Jack and me if i didn’t fight back

#

And now she’s pissed

worthy hearth
#

that's about the only circumstance its kindof okay

#

but she sees him as somebody unfit to raise a child

#

which if he's killing tons of people, he is

spring wraith
#

He kinda is

hidden moss
#

I sound like a Swiss John Marston

spring wraith
#

He’s grown more fit but still not too good

#

The gedds relationship is messed up

hidden moss
#

I always wondered how so many people live in Rdr1 and Rdr2

Because in the rdr1 map there's barely any buildings, yet you kill like 1000 people in the story.

Same for the second game

There doesn't seem to be enough housing to accommodate all these people we see

spring wraith
#

Well there’s lots of gangs who prolly don’t live in houses who u kill

#

Lots of families

#

Lots of homeless

hidden moss
#

Yeah there are cults living in the wilderness and campers but that'd be a fraction of the population

worthy hearth
#

saint denis makes sense

spring wraith
#

Lots just camp and travel

#

Not many of the ppl u kill actually live in houses

zinc maple
#

what shirt?

hidden moss
hidden moss
charred galleon
# zinc maple what shirt?

Lmao my bad , just went on a quick trip to Pinterest and found out it was a mod , disappointingly 😞

zinc maple
#

aw man

worthy hearth
#

a lot of the gangs actually have hideouts, which leads it to make a bit more sense

spring wraith
#

Yea when u raid hideouts theres a good 40 ppl there

worthy hearth
#

the pinkertons, i guess, have a ton of people come in from different cities outside of the states we see in the game

charred galleon
#

I posted the pic of him in the shirt in general media if y'all wanna see

spring wraith
#

Bye now ima go play farmlands simulator Two

hidden moss
#

2??

spring wraith
#

Rdr2

#

Epilogue

hidden moss
#

Ooo

#

Enjoy

zinc maple
#

have fun

hidden moss
#

I wanna steal Dutch's fit

zinc maple
#

real

worthy hearth
#

his rings are really cool

zinc maple
#

unfortunately he has mad drip

worthy hearth
#

i honestly wouldn't mind buying some of those

spring wraith
#

Ok is it just me or does John have better fighting capabilities then Arthur

hidden moss
#

I have Arthur's hat and coat unironically. I got the hat as a gift from an old lady and I bought the coat last year in January.

zinc maple
#

that’s so cool

hidden moss
#

I didn't realize the similarity

zinc maple
hidden moss
#

Crazy how every character has different drawspeeds roo

spring wraith
#

Who has the fastest

#

Arthur?

hidden moss
#

John I believe

spring wraith
#

Oh

hidden moss
#

In the first game

spring wraith
#

Yeah makes sense

hidden moss
#

In rdr2 it might be John or Dutch I forgor

spring wraith
#

Dutch?

hidden moss
#

You know who Dutch is, right?

spring wraith
#

Feel like Arthur would be faster then ditch

#

Dutch

#

Yeah

#

I’m in the epilogue

hidden moss
#

Arthur is a big, beefy guy.
It's probably harder to draw a weapon with big arms, easier to aim though.

#

Well

spring wraith
#

And what if ur underweight

hidden moss
#

Not jacked

#

I debunked my own theory

#

Nvm

spring wraith
#

I’m pretty sure Dutch is bigger then Arthur unless u eat too much

bronze vale
#

also hi i just joined

zinc maple
#

welcome

spring wraith
#

He’s old and always drunk

worthy hearth
#

welcome

bronze vale
hidden moss
spring wraith
#

In the end doesn’t even matter if they don’t have dead eye

bronze vale
#

so

spring wraith
#

I should prolly do the Calloway mission

bronze vale
#

its fun

#

i loved the gunslinger storyline

#

i do it asap in like all my playthroughs for the guns

spring wraith
#

As long as anyone John or Arthur isn’t fighting has deadeye in a standoff the one with deadeye wins easily

bronze vale
#

well yeah obviously

spring wraith
#

John or Arthur probably beats Calloway in a draw speed anyway

zinc maple
#

good thing npcs don’t have deadeye be_bluethumbsup

spring wraith
#

Even against fast opponents with there guns out u can draw your gun and shoot them if ur decent at the game before they even get a shot on you

spring wraith
hidden moss
spring wraith
#

Well he has it when you play him

zinc maple
#

well other than npc john

spring wraith
#

And deadeye doesn’t just appear randomly

#

So obviously he has it

worthy hearth
#

deadeye isn't a like

#

a canon thing

#

it isn't like vats in fallout

zinc maple
#

i mean npcs you fight

worthy hearth
#

i believe deadeye is just a system to make the player feel like a more badass gunslinger

zinc maple
#

and it works

bronze vale
#

in my unchangeable opinion deadeye isnt canon+

crude wyvern
#

🥐

worthy hearth
spring wraith
#

What even is deadeye is it just implied like it’s given to gifted people or insane hard work or what

bronze vale
#

just a feature to show how superior arthur is

spring wraith
#

And John

hidden moss
#

Is it bad that I love 1916 Jack Marston more than the other characters?

spring wraith
#

Yes and no

zinc maple
#

i think he’s cool

worthy hearth
bronze vale
#

Is there a lore reason why at the end of the game Arthur couldn't just respawn after dying, when he did it countless time before? Is he stupid?

worthy hearth
zinc maple
#

it was his last one

hidden moss
crude wyvern
#

dead eye is just a mechanic to say that they can quick draw really fast it's not a superhero ability

worthy hearth
spring wraith
#

If that’s what deadeye is then John and Arthur would be the fastest drawers

worthy hearth
#

when i swapped to him i ended up murdering everybody i saw

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

i haven’t played as jack enough

#

i’ve been grinding undead nightmare

bronze vale
#

deadeye

zinc maple
spring wraith
#

Well Dutch tried to shoot us and so has Micah and they missed every shot

#

So not them

#

Not Calloway bc we would of never would of been able to kill him if he did

bronze vale
#

calloway was unc and probably hungover

#

probably drunk in the moment too

hidden moss
#

Honestly, rdr2 has GREAT graphics as a game from 1899, it blows my mind

worthy hearth
#

how have none of you mentioned landon ricketts

spring wraith
#

I mean u can use deadeye when ur drunk as Arthur and John can’t you

bronze vale
#

also all the other legendary gunslingers

worthy hearth
#

he says himself, he was the best

spring wraith
worthy hearth
#

he's the only one who's still alive

bronze vale
#

whats the hispanic legendary gunslinger

zinc maple
bronze vale
#

the diving one

#

he could have it

zinc maple
#

it’s landon

#

how could i forget

bronze vale
#

diving and shooting is hella hard

spring wraith
#

Where do you even find a legendary gunslinger

worthy hearth
#

in a small town over in mexico

spring wraith
#

I only know of Calloway

hidden moss
bronze vale
zinc maple
#

landon ricketts

#

like sushikov said, you meet him in mexico

spring wraith
#

Any legandary gunslingers other then Calloway in rdr2?

hidden moss
#

John Marston

zinc maple
#

black belle

bronze vale
worthy hearth
#

like that you have to track down for that quest

spring wraith
#

Who are the three main ones

worthy hearth
#

i'd have to look it up

bronze vale
#

black belle billy midnight

#

andd

worthy hearth
worthy hearth
#

granger is the other one

bronze vale
#

emmet granger

#

and

#

diving mexican

spring wraith
#

Can u find em all in epilogue

#

Or only as Arthur

worthy hearth
#

you can

spring wraith
#

K

#

If Calloway is on his 40s when u play as Arthur then he’s almost 50 in epilogue

keen valve
#

i need to adapt

#

to my new gun

hidden moss
#

Michael Townley

keen valve
#

WHAT

#

makora!?

worthy hearth
#

must've been the weather

bronze vale
#

who do you guys think is the most interesting character

worthy hearth
#

dutch i'd say

#

til the end of the games you don't understand him

hidden moss
#

He's just a silly guy

#

Jokes

bronze vale
#

sae

#

same

#

i love dutch so much

hidden moss
#

In the first game isn't he all schizo?

zinc maple
#

i’d say dutch yeah, he’s a good antagonist

hidden moss
#

If I remember

worthy hearth
bronze vale
#

theres a theory that he was a cannibal

zinc maple
#

i don’t really know how else to refer to him lol

worthy hearth
#

fair

zinc maple
spring wraith
#

How is it that when I kill horses I lose honor but when npcs kill em it’s just fine

hidden moss
worthy hearth
#

he is if you think about it, but the real antagonists of the games are the pinkertons and society

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

^

spring wraith
#

Well I’m not saying the first game

crude wyvern
worthy hearth
#

our way of life is changing, dutch

spring wraith
#

I don’t get how Dutch always needs more money

bronze vale
#

i could have got us out the mud by chapter 3

spring wraith
#

Like in 1899 is it really more then what he had stashed and all the money the gang has to go on a big boat

#

He had almost 50k

#

1.7m in todays money

bronze vale
#

why did dutch have human bones in his cave?

crude wyvern
bronze vale
#

oh makes sense

hidden moss
# crude wyvern Who could have guessed society would not approve of people robbing and killing p...

And also Cornwall rightfully hired the Pinkertons as Dutch kept attacking his business.

If you think about it, the Van der Linde gang are antagonists, they bring more and more heat on themselves which leads to their downfall. At least Dutch does.

He'd have more time if he didn't bring so much heat, he'd have money if he dug the 20k up from blackwater.
I doubt his plans were real tho I'm probably wrong

spring wraith
bronze vale
#

i think

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

Plus gang member money if we needed it

spring wraith
hidden moss
bronze vale
#

there was so much cannibilism shit in the first game

spring wraith
#

And I don’t even know how much was on the bags from chapter six train robbery

hidden moss
#

There are so many things I could answer for you if I could spoil things

spring wraith
#

Like epilogue things?

crude wyvern
#

you can literally find out how much Dutch had by going for the money at the end of chapter 6

spring wraith
#

Who goes for the money unless you wanna beat the hell outta Micah

#

I mean who doesn’t

#

But helping John feels more Arthur ish

fresh root
#

Who here has irl version of fish in the game

bronze vale
#

i always helped john

spring wraith
#

I’ll prolly give Micah a scar next time but I want a more arthur ending for the first play through

bronze vale
#

guys what if gavin was a secret traitor?

crude wyvern
#

huh

spring wraith
#

Whose Gavin

bronze vale
#

an npc walks around throughout the game looking for a guy named gavin but we never hear of gavin other than that

agile patrol
hidden moss
zinc maple
spring wraith
#

Oh the Gavin guy

crude wyvern
spring wraith
#

Is Gavin even findable

agile patrol
crude wyvern
bronze vale
#

really?

crude wyvern
#

yes

spring wraith
#

So how do we finish that stranger mission

hidden moss
bronze vale
#

nope

#

discovered in 1911

#

the term was made atleast

zinc maple
#

gavin’s hiding in a cave out in ambarino

hidden moss
#

Schizophrenia was discovered the same year my favorite pistol was finalized... everything makes sense now

agile patrol
hidden moss
bronze vale
#

do you guys think micah was the only traitor

spring wraith
#

Wait don’t tell me Nigel is still looking for Gavin in the epilogue

zinc maple
#

you’ll just have to find that out yourself

hidden moss
spring wraith
agile patrol
spring wraith
bronze vale
spring wraith
#

She was drunk and Milton prolly blackmailed her

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

So she didn’t know what she was talking about

bronze vale
#

but other than her i think its def possible

agile patrol
#

Were y’all surprised Micah was a traitor or not

bronze vale
#

because its hinted at afew times that blackwater was a trap

spring wraith
#

No

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

Everytime we were with Micah we either had to kill everyone there to escape or sacrifice someone

bronze vale
#

and also all the robberies started going wrong before they said they caught micah

#

or micah ratted

hidden moss
#

Micah is also a newer gang member

spring wraith
#

Yea he was only with us what six months

zinc maple
#

yeah something like that

spring wraith
#

Six months is what he said in valentine

bronze vale
#

i think micah also was a traitor before milton said he was

spring wraith
#

Who would he rat to

bronze vale
#

i dont know but

hidden moss
#

I believe it was Micah who set up the blackwater heist, and it's clear that was a setup

bronze vale
#

the game says micah urged dutch to do the blackwater job

#

and also the game says micah urged dutch to kill the girl on the ferry

spring wraith
#

Ferry?

#

Is this just lore mentioned or is any of it in rdr1

bronze vale
#

just lore

#

the blackwater job and escape via ferry takes offscreen

spring wraith
#

Wish that they atleast let us experience a lil of it

bronze vale
#

yeah

spring wraith
#

Start it off like gow 3

bronze vale
#

also when we break micah out of jail

#

in strwaberry

#

micah says arthurs first and last name like a wholeeee bunch

#

like he wanted people to hear it

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

No he mostly just calls us cowpoke

#

After the jail break

#

Since he sees us as a threat

agile patrol
#

I don’t know why Dutch trusted in Micah more at the end of the main story, who was with them for six months then Arthur who was with Dutch for 22 years

spring wraith
#

Then when he calls us black lung he does it openly since he knows he was easy to expose of now

bronze vale
spring wraith
#

He’s a selfish bastard after chapter 4

agile patrol
hidden moss
spring wraith
#

I feel like Javier would of sided with Arthur not Micah

bronze vale
#

i think micah purposely killed off all the people who would have sided with arthur

#

like sean

agile patrol
bronze vale
#

and maybe he convinced some people to leave

#

to weaken the groups loyalty

spring wraith
#

All the people who left wouldn’t of even helped tbh

zinc maple
#

yes they would

#

hosea def would, and lenny

bronze vale
#

even if they didnt it still affects the group

spring wraith
#

Left

#

Not died

bronze vale
#

lenny 💔

#

lenny was so nice

spring wraith
#

Fr

zinc maple
#

i loved lenny

#

if sadie was there we know she would have sided with arthur

bronze vale
#

sadie would have went off icl

spring wraith
#

Yea

zinc maple
bronze vale
#

sadie probably has dead eye

agile patrol
zinc maple
bronze vale
#

rdr3 as sadie confirmed

spring wraith
hidden moss
#

Lenny's invulnerability turns off a moment before he dies so you can kill him instead

zinc maple
#

why would you ever want to do that

spring wraith
#

Did u kill Lenny

bronze vale
hidden moss
spring wraith
#

Lenny was like a son to me and Sean was like a brother

bronze vale
#

probably would bring some cool bounty hunting

spring wraith
#

They were my favorite tbh

zinc maple
#

about kenny

#

lenny

bronze vale
#

ohh

spring wraith
#

Ok bye now I need to finish farm man similar

bronze vale
#

bye

agile patrol
#

On my fourth play through or so, when I knew what was coming. I tried to enter dead eye at the perfect moment just shoot the Pinkertons. but it was no use.

hidden moss
#

Jack Marston's story after rdr isn't explained too well. The game ends in like 1916.

There's a Jack Marston book in GTAV which is an unreliable hint to say he lived but idk

zinc maple
#

i never knew there was a jack marston book in gta

#

that’s cool

spring wraith
#

Nvm I’m back in pissed at Abigail

#

Getting mad at me for saving people’s lives😭

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

And for saving Jack

zinc maple
agile patrol
bronze vale
#

what if micah joined the gang with the sole intent of stealing the blackwater take?

hidden moss
#

I was thinking why there's no Rdr hints in GTAIV and remembered GTAIV came out before Rdr 🤦🏼‍♂️

zinc maple
#

lmao

spring wraith
#

Like what do I do let men kill me and Jack let ppl take our cows and kill the ranch owner and workers

zinc maple
#

maybe we’ll get some easter eggs in gta 6

spring wraith
#

Abigail has good reasoning sometime but not rn

#

Time to speak to Sadie

zinc maple
#

sadie my beloved

agile patrol
spring wraith
#

Abigail took Jack wtf

hidden moss
# zinc maple maybe we’ll get some easter eggs in gta 6

I also wanna know more about Niko Bellic tbh

He's my favorite character of all time behind Aiden Pearce. Absolutely zero explanation is given for his life after the game besides the $800k he makes throughout the game including the $500k at the end

I guess he has multiple houses, government protection and lots of cash with no loose ends.

This is a rdr server so I'll shut it

spring wraith
#

I wanna shoot her

zinc maple
spring wraith
#

Stg if I don’t get to see Jack or Abigail again

zinc maple
#

i’m not super far into the game but it’s good

zinc maple
zinc maple
spring wraith
#

She took Jack and abandoned me for saving lives

#

What am i supposed to do

#

Like her?

zinc maple
#

play the game

spring wraith
#

I can hate npcs and play the game

bronze vale
#

kieran my beloved

hidden moss
# zinc maple i’m not super far into the game but it’s good

My favorite game

Love the vehicle handling, crash physics and ragdoll physics, along with the filthy and depressed air of Liberty City. Niko's complex character, backstory and everything. It has such a realistic tone to it despite being 2008

It's also just fun to circuit around the city and listen to music, which I've probably soent like 500 hours of my life doing, and I'm doing it right now.

spring wraith
#

Sondang do you speak in anything but paragraphs

agile patrol
#

What did Charles do after the epilogue?

steep smelt
#

I spent 1500 hours on rdr2 story

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

i still need to get used to the driving, i’m so used to gta v car physics

#

but i have really enjoyed the game

spring wraith
zinc maple
spring wraith
#

Especially in a rdr2 discord chat

spring wraith
#

Dawg when can I give John a clean cut

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

He looks like Albert Einstein

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

😭

distant trellis
spring wraith
#

Can I not access stores until part 2

distant trellis
spring wraith
#

If u go to Canada can u find him

zinc maple
#

u can’t go to canada

bronze vale
hidden moss
bronze vale
#

international rdr2

spring wraith
#

If I do a g word u can go to Canada

zinc maple
#

do you mean guarma

spring wraith
#

No

#

There’s a g word to go to Canada

distant trellis
zinc maple
spring wraith
#

no

#

CANADA

#

there’s a gli

zinc maple
#

that’s not a thing

bronze vale
#

do you guys think micah was approached to snitch like how arthur was while fishing with jack?

spring wraith
#

I’ve done it before

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

No

bronze vale
#

after returning from guarma

zinc maple
#

but i also wouldn’t be surprised if he just did it on his own

bronze vale
#

what if micah didnt snitch at all and milton lied

agile patrol
spring wraith
#

How does a guy spend months just working for 3$ a day without thinking about his son or wife

#

Who left him

bronze vale
#

why would milton show his hand like that?

spring wraith
#

Because he thought he was gonna kill Arthur

#

And Sadie

#

And Abigail

hidden moss
#

What happens if I call Dutch at 3AM

distant trellis
spring wraith
#

If you think u can kill someone theres no reason why u wouldn’t say anything

bronze vale
#

milton is the equivalant of a cia agent

#

i just dont think he would tell arthur everything then

spring wraith
#

I wish you could get a dog in rdr2

spring wraith
agile patrol
hidden moss
spring wraith
distant trellis
bronze vale
#

like milton couldnt have thought more people would be there soon?

hidden moss
#

I find Josiah Trelawney to be very forgettable

spring wraith
#

He knew they wouldn’t go for a dying sick man

bronze vale
#

trelawny was the rat confirmed

distant trellis
spring wraith
#

With Micah as a rat he also knows the gang isn’t as big anymore

agile patrol
#

Anyone feel different when you played red dead redemption two then one. You feel more for the characters, like lost souls who have gone astray, instead of people you just need to kill.

agile patrol
bronze vale
#

ahh

spring wraith
#

UESS

#

MY GOD

bronze vale
#

yeah for sure

spring wraith
#

I got Arthur’s stuff

distant trellis
#

I recently finished the story today for the first time. It's a beautiful masterpiece.

spring wraith
#

AFTER

#

ALL

#

THIS

#

TIME

hidden moss
#

John Marston taking all of Arthur's stuff after he dies:

(Then Jack doing the same after John dies 😭)

spring wraith
#

the whole hour I spent on part 1

zinc maple
#

my favorite game ever

bronze vale
#

what was yalls favorite chapter?

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

How do I get Arthur’s hat as John

hidden moss
#

The chapter 1 OST is also great

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

It only says John’s classic hat

agile patrol
spring wraith
#

When I check my horses hats

agile patrol
bronze vale
#

I think my favorite were either saint denis, beaver hollow or clemens point

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

i like chapter 4

#

when we get to saint denis

hidden moss
spring wraith
#

4 or 3 for me

zinc maple
#

it really is

#

i really love the vibe of saint denis

bronze vale
#

intro to saint denis had me thinking hard about life for a second

zinc maple
#

it’s def my favorite place to visit and just walk around

hidden moss
#

The chapter with rhodes is also great

agile patrol
bronze vale
#

i used to get bored and go on like hour long chases through saint denis and around the swamps

#

so fun

zinc maple
#

the swamps are cool too

bronze vale
#

but one time my arabian got killed and i never saw him again

zinc maple
#

i really like that whole area

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

LMFAO

bronze vale
#

he got injured, i had no revives left for him then i got killed too

#

and respwaned with scrawny nag and i just never saw him in any stables

zinc maple
#

💔

agile patrol
#

Has anyone played red dead redemption like GTA sometimes. Saving your game, then committing mass chaos.

zinc maple
#

not scrawny nag….

bronze vale
#

yeah

regal sage
#

gotta get ur horse insurance !!!!

bronze vale
#

scrawny nag is a real one

regal sage
#

scrawny nag a real 1

bronze vale
#

always there when im at my lowest

zinc maple
#

it’s true

bronze vale
#

alwayds there when i need him most

zinc maple
#

i just end up running into something and it dies immediately

regal sage
#

scrawny nag always comes through fr

#

that too yeah

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

i hit a single tree and it’s over

regal sage
#

u hate to love scrawny nag tbh

#

love to hate

bronze vale
#

i love hating on him but hes so clutch

zinc maple
#

he really is

bronze vale
#

man i remember me and my friends used to go in rdo rhodes and start gang wars

regal sage
#

LOL saint denis fight clubs 😓😓

bronze vale
#

the rooftop

regal sage
#

literally the worlds worst at combat ever

spring wraith
#

How do I get satchels as John

bronze vale
#

i remember when i first started the game like directly after you get to horseshoe overlook i had this phase for like a month where i did 0 missions and just had fun around the map

zinc maple
#

i do that in my arthur save

bronze vale
#

i got super good at fist fighting so i cooked micah hella bad when i first fought him and was so confused on why i wasnt winning

zinc maple
#

i need to lock in and 100% the game though

bronze vale
spring wraith
#

How do I get satchels as John

regal sage
zinc maple
#

i’m at 95%

regal sage
#

i literally struggle w the 70 gold medals icl LOL

zinc maple
#

i don’t even want to think about that 😔

#

i still have so much to do…

#

i have so many challenges left and all the hunting requests

hidden moss
regal sage
#

no bc 95% sounds good but when u think about the 5% n u wanna scream

zinc maple
#

and the exotics

zinc maple
#

everything i have left is so hard 😭

#

or just grindy

#

i can’t give up i’ve made it this far

regal sage
#

i give up every time i start trying 2 do best in the west atp

zinc maple
#

real

regal sage
#

tell myself i’ll go from the start and do everything as i go along

#

i’ll never do it

zinc maple
#

i moved on to rdr1 for a while

hidden moss
#

What's the rope around Arthur's hat for?
I have a similar one on my own hat but idek what it's for

#

Cosmetics?

zinc maple
#

cosmetic i would guess but i’m not sure

regal sage
#

probs cosmetic

#

i haven’t even began to think abt 100% rdr1

zinc maple
#

i’m currently playing undead nightmare

#

i finished the storyline in the main game

regal sage
#

i struggle so much w undead

hidden moss
#

I want undead nightmare so bad but my rdr1 is on my PS3 and to get undead nightmare I gotta travel 13 miles to the nearest store and bring an adult to buy it since you gotta be 18

zinc maple
#

oh gosh

#

i really like undead nightmare

#

i find it fun

#

and the story is interesting

hidden moss
#

I had it on PS4 back in like 2017 but my adoption parent sold the PS4 for special herbs

#

And I was devastated

zinc maple
#

oh gosh i’m sorry to hear that

#

i would be too

hidden moss
#

Yeah literally the only activity I could do too

#

Her excuse was that I was too young and it'd have an influence on me whilst she was dating gangsters and criminals lmfao

#

Anyway

#

I won't speak about anything else before I get warned or something

bronze vale
#

hi am ack

zinc maple
#

welcome ack

regal sage
#

the trophy for 100%

bronze vale
#

ugh

regal sage
#

yeah me too

bronze vale
#

not even gonna think of trying that

zinc maple
#

i’ll get to 100% by the end of the year trust 🙏

bronze vale
#

i believe in u

zinc maple
#

thank u

hidden moss
#

Just discovered a ranch, and there's a doggy so I pet the doggy and the rancher pulls a gun on me. I draw and Arthur has to reload the pistol... I kill the guy and I'm forced to kill doggy when they attack me 😢

zinc maple
#

that is so messed up 💔

bronze vale
#

wolf man

hidden moss
#

He pulled a gun on me for petting a doggy

zinc maple
#

you gotta ask first

hidden moss
#

The dogy gave me permission

regal sage
#

u gotta pat every dog in rdr

hidden moss
#

You can't pet cats in rdr2 is it even worth installing?

regal sage
#

I KNOW !!!

#

atleast u can say pretty words 2 then

hidden moss
#

I got warned for using a smiley face
Gonna cry

hidden moss
#

Kitties are awesomeness

#

Cat herding in rdr2

#

へ ╱|、
૮ - ՛ ) (` - 7
/ ⁻ ៸| |、⁻〵
乀 (ˍ, ل ل じしˍ,)ノ

zinc maple
#

i wish you could pet every animal

#

let me pet a bear.

hidden moss
#

Also in the saint denis fence there's a wardrobe blocking a door. Is there an explanation for this?

#

I thought it was an illicit side business but so far idk

zinc maple
#

i’m not sure about that

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

that’s a risk i’m willing to take

#

or let me pet a cougar

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

i could tame them trust me

hidden moss
#

I'm allergic to cats but when I go to my sisters house I steal all her kitties and pet them

zinc maple
#

i love cats

hidden moss
#

And when I see a cat on the street I make sure it knows what being adored feels like

#

When I ride a horsey I pet them a lot too c:
Same in rdr2

spring wraith
#

I’m sad

#

I can’t replace grimzy

#

My original black Arabian😞

hidden moss
#

🥺

#

Does anybody else get the problem where I press to mount my horse but Arthur has better ideas and attacks a random guy instead

zinc maple
#

i have had that happen to me before yes

#

i tend to mount my horse away from people though

hidden moss
#

It's especially in saint denis

#

But yes

zinc maple
#

yeah saint denis is rough

hidden moss
#

It's probably better to lure the horse away from people so Arthur's psychotic violent delusional states don't make him a wanted man

zinc maple
#

😭

spring wraith
#

Anyone know why I can’t hunt the bull gator

#

It says I’m in its territory but I see no question mark

#

Are there requirements?

hidden moss
#

You gotta use eagle eye or whatever it's called to track the gator

spring wraith
#

But there’s usually a question mark

hidden moss
#

I didn't get one when I hunted it

spring wraith
#

I looked for a while can’t find any clues

hidden moss
#

There's a mission about it so you probably have to hunt it after the mission

spring wraith
#

I did that mission

hidden moss
#

Odd

spring wraith
#

Unless there’s a mission in the epilogue I should be able to find it

#

I heard that it might need to be rainy foggy or thundery

hidden moss
#

I believe it's west of the Lakay sign on the map just accross the stream

spring wraith
#

Btw is there just one legandary gator

hidden moss
#

Most likely

spring wraith
#

Isn’t there like a teca gator and a bull gator

hidden moss
#

I really don't know

zinc maple
spring wraith
#

Oh there’s a alligator and a bull gator

#

Gina do u know if gator and alligator are near eachother

#

DAMN

#

bull gator is big dawg

#

Took six headshots with express carcano rifle to kill it

spring wraith
#

How long do I have to wait for my hair to grow

#

Like I used 3 hair tonics and it’s been some days and it haven’t grown at all

hidden moss
#

Thank god hair doesn't have realistic growth rates

spring wraith
#

In rdr2 it don’t

strong pasture
#

Can someone tell me how can I play rdo? I have xbox series s but I bought Rdr2, in the menu when I click on rdo it tells me I have to buy gamepass, but if I buy rdo from g2a separately it still asks me for gamepass?

spring wraith
#

U need game pass

#

It’s a special online feature

strong pasture
#

Damn

#

Rip

spring wraith
#

Yea crafting satchels is a waste of time

#

Especially legend of the east

#

Well nvm crafting legend of the east is useless

feral sonnet
#

why can't I get the rock carving that's NW to Annesburg and NE to Deer Cottage (shack)? no matter where I stand I'm unable to get the prompt and i didn't discover it before because it's not on my map or anything. it's the last one I need

feral sonnet
glacial mantle
#

How can I get Arthur's hat in the epilog?

stable widget
glacial mantle
stable widget
#

I think you get it like 2 quests into the epilogue

#

It's just on your horse

glacial mantle
#

I am in epilog 2 and it isn't there

#

Maybe it's because I bought a new horse and sold the previous one?

stable widget
#

The stuff on your saddle stays

glacial mantle
#

so why can't i find it?

stable widget
#

Did you do "Jim Milton Rides, Again?" yet?

glacial mantle
#

yeah i did im in epilog 2

#

?

stable widget
#

That's weird

#

In the very last mission of epilogue 2 you are forced to wear it again as well

glacial mantle
#

okay ill check that out

#

if that doesnt work ill just install rampage trainer

spring wraith
#

Check wardrobe

stable widget
#

Make a save before the mission, maybe you need to lose the hat mid-mission and pick it back up to count as acquired

spring wraith
#

It’s called Arthur’s gambler hat

#

No it’s in John’s wardrobe

#

It doesn’t go in his horse for some reason

glacial mantle
#

in epilog

spring wraith
#

Go to a hotel or sum and change clothes and u should see sum called Arthur’s gambler hat

stable widget
spring wraith
#

Just change your clothes at a hotel

#

It happened to me too

stable widget
glacial mantle
#

thx

spring wraith
#

I have no idea why I wasted time crafting the legend of the east satchel

#

Never knew u just got to buy it in the epilogue

glacial mantle
#

how do i make it stay on my horse

#

?

spring wraith
#

There should be a stow on horse button

dreamy mirage
#

can some1 recommend me a good reshade

storm fulcrum
#

Dutch worse than micah tbh

#

All bark no bite 😂

arctic musk
#

you can hold 99 of almost every item

#

after you beat the game you can just buy the satchels at the fenc

#

e

novel hollow
#

Hi, wich is best revolver to play in story mode ?

arctic musk
#

lemat revolver is also nice

#

same with m1899 but its a pistol

sly kayak
#

hi guys i just started playing and i have a few questions, so i have been looting every body which i killed and i find much of the jewelry where can i sell this? and for example when i skin an deer and i get its hide where can i store it or sell it?

arctic musk
#

you unlock the fence after the 2nd mission with hosea

sly kayak
#

cool thanks, do i have like unlimited weight?

arctic musk
#

you can carry 5 items per item ussualy

#

but you can craft satchels at pearson but its hard

feral sonnet
#

when an item description on the RDR2 Map says required: chapter 2, 3&4, do I need to do it in chapter 5 or am I able to do it at chapter 3-4 too?

arctic musk
feral sonnet
storm fulcrum
#

Ayo im john i thought i get to keep Arthur's guns?

#

Thanks for this brother. You're a good man Arthur Morgan

arctic musk
carmine kindle
elfin lantern
#

so im on chapter 2 and ive just saved someone in my group who had a bounty and i dont think i have another main quest to do just 3 quests at my camp

carmine kindle
#

or look at the whole map and see if you have a main story mission

elfin lantern
carmine kindle
#

you can party with them or just go to the tent symbol and sleep

elfin lantern
hidden moss
#

Just completely finished rdr2

#

Couple side missions to do in a couple different chapters but I'm thinking about buying rdr1

#

Is it worth it or nah

#

Cos I wanna see how John's story goes

zinc maple
hidden moss
zinc maple
#

yes

hidden moss
#

Cos I know he kills Javier and Dutch and gets killed himself

hidden moss
zinc maple
#

i got it as soon as it came out on pc and i have no regrets

#

plus undead nightmare is rly fun

hidden moss
hidden moss
zinc maple
#

in the epilogue yes

#

oh i read that wrong

#

you play as john

hidden moss
full oasis
#

so i was hunting the legendary fox and i found it, studied it and then i spawned in my camp by mistake. ive went back 3 or 4 times even at night and its not spawning again. any ideas?

arctic musk
#

ill probably get it when theres like a 40% sale

hidden moss
#

I'm not paying more than 25£ and I think even that's to much

arctic musk
#

50 bucks is probably worth it but still too much for me

hidden moss
#

It's a 2010 game

arctic musk
#

it comes with the undead nightmare dlc

hidden moss
#

It's on sale for like 40£ rn

#

I'm hoping just rdr1 and undead go on sale for 20£

torn ocean
#

revenge is a dish best eaten

arctic musk
#

50% sale will probably come in a long time

zinc maple
#

it was just on sale recently

#

so it’ll probably be a bit before the next one

arctic musk
zinc maple
#

ye

#

i bought it for my friend

arctic musk
#

w

torn ocean
hidden moss
arctic musk
#

on steam it wasnt😭

zinc maple
#

is that real

hidden moss
silver gate
#

It was on ps but that was a long time ago

zinc maple
#

i bought it immediately the day it came out on steam and i have no regrets

hidden moss
#

Either way I'm getting it just want it to get it a bit cheaper 😭

zinc maple
#

but i don’t blame you for waiting for a sale

#

i did that with the 2nd game

silver gate
#

I bought it too for 20$

hidden moss
#

I seen it in a store the other day for like £6

#

Pains of digital console

silver gate
#

But I bought rdr for like 40 DOLLARS

#

My biggest regret was getting the digital copy but here we are

noble crater
#

Should i buy a rifle in chapter 2 for easy hunting?

abstract quest
#

Yea or just a bow with arrows improved

spring wraith
spring wraith
torn ocean
#

and xbox im pretty sure

spring wraith
#

Do certain bandoliers have different stats then others

#

Like does any bandolier allow u to carry more ammo then the upgraded one

torn ocean
#

can i rob a stable?

#

without losing honor

#

😭

spring wraith
#

Stables?

#

U can rob stables

torn ocean
#

oo la la

#

also i keep shooting ppl on wagons why cant i cut the horses free am i stupid

carmine kindle
torn ocean
#

nvm i got it lol it was an appoloosia pretty sure thats rare

torn ocean
#

oo i dont uh have my very extremely rare horse anymore

#

but oh well im in guarma

spring wraith
#

Dawg I keep going right on legandary animal signs and there’s no clues question marks and it doesn’t even say I’m in its territory

hidden moss
torn ocean
#

yippe

potent hill
#

Morning everyone, how to I get the next part of wildlife exhibition once I finish one?

#

Do I need to pick it up somehwhere?

arctic musk
#

i forgor what that was

#

i'll probably be able to help

arctic musk
potent hill
#

Ok so just go back to the post office after 24hr?

arctic musk
green flicker
#

Can i steal buell from that one leg guy or is it rewarded after completing some mission with him?

arctic musk
#

of that guy

feral sonnet
#

does the 2 meteorites actually give the buff against heat?

grave dock
feral sonnet
arctic musk
feral sonnet
# arctic musk nah

damn that sucks, saw some sites saying it gives a buff but didn't see anything pop up

coral orbit
#

arent there some things you can only do as arthur tho?

arctic musk
#

optional honor story missions and collecting debt

coral orbit
#

oh is that it

arctic musk
arctic musk
coral orbit
#

guarma doesnt count in yhe animal log anyway i dont think

arctic musk
coral orbit
#

oh right

feral sonnet
arctic musk
#

but yeah

grave dock
feral sonnet
feral sonnet
grave dock
torn ocean
#

ffs

#

all i had to do was kick the rifle im acc a dunce

feral sonnet
#

do you guys know any animal heat map that's available for free?

coral orbit
grave dock
coral orbit
#

oh dear

torn ocean
#

back in lemoyne that shit was short asf but it was peak🤑💰

#

should i do all side missions

#

ive been doing them along the way up til now i just dont want to feel like i rushed the game

coral orbit
#

may aswell tbh

torn ocean
#

is there anything to really want to do in chapter 5 i want to get to chap 6 as late as possible considering ik whats going to happen

#

unshaken is playing omg my heart is pumping the second i heard that chord bro

coral orbit
#

im in chapter 6 now and im literally avoiding main missions after realising how close i am to the epilogue

torn ocean
coral orbit
#

💔

torn ocean
#

im in lakay if you wanna know where i am in the game

coral orbit
#

ohh ik where you are, i liked the mission tbh even though its a bit annoying

torn ocean
#

alr im going to play peak dead redemption now🤑💰

#

okay agreed that mission was rlly good

#

how come i cant buy any horses in van horn

spring wraith
#

What does it say

abstract quest
#

Do I unlock Blackwater in chapter 6 or in the epilogue?

spring wraith
#

Epilogue

abstract quest
#

Thanks

spring wraith
#

But no reason to go until u get Arthur’s stuff

abstract quest
#

I'm in the middle of chapter 6.

spring wraith
#

Btw how much money in rdr u have

abstract quest
#

4300

spring wraith
#

Do u know how to transfer it to John

abstract quest
#

No,how?

spring wraith
#

So u can either do this before our last boy or after it

#

But don’t do the mission our best selves until u do this

#

So go to Aberdeen pig farm

#

Let them rob you

#

Then you take it back once your John

abstract quest
#

Aaaaa i know the Aberdeen pig farm

spring wraith
#

Wait did u already kill them

abstract quest
#

No

spring wraith
#

K good

abstract quest
#

I was going to go but it's good that you told me.

spring wraith
#

So just go do our last boy mission then let em rob u

abstract quest
#

and I'm going to have to go there like John and steal their money, right?

#

I take down the painting and take the money, I saw it on TikTok earlier

spring wraith
#

Yea

#

Anyone know why legandary animal won’t spawn for me

hidden moss
#

this game just wants to hurt me😔

zinc maple
#

i’ve never had issues

zinc maple
hidden moss
zinc maple
#

NOOOO

hidden moss
#

on the trainstation

#

yeah….

zinc maple
#

i’m so sorry…

hidden moss
#

😭😭😭

#

“I’m afraid”

#

I literally started tearing up

zinc maple
#

😭😭😭

hidden moss
#

🥲

#

I need a therapist after this game

ripe fiber
#

I wanted to share my tips to people for when your trying to catch a legendary fish but it isn’t budging much, just move ur LEFT joystick up and down once the fish takes a break for you to reel in, it’ll pull the fish closer to you each time

arctic musk
#

i just move my rod left and right on pc its op

abstract quest
#

and I made myself a hat and a jacket

wary kestrel
#

my trappers cloak is really dirty and has a hole in it, is there a way to clean it?