#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 131 of 1
yep white arabian is good
honestly i would say perlino andalusian is the best because its still really fast with high stamina
but far better health and spooks way less than arabian
ig i can check andalusian too ty bro ur the best
you're welcome
Yo any secrets, I’m new to rdr2
Oh ok. I am in Chapter 2. Thx for helping me
Yo guys u know any hidden locations?
uhh
i feel very bad when killing bleeding wolves
nevermind i just fixed it
oh
shoulda never tried to attack my horsey 😭😭🙏
or the photographer guy
Albert Mason
yes.
but
i still feel horrible
why you lookinat me like dat
even when im doing low honor i feel horrible
Yeah
I hate wolves
thats why whenever a lawman's severely injured horse happens while im massacring a town i revive it
Yo guys what the best spot in Saint Denis for a shootout with the lawmen or any other place
Does the white Arabian despawn?
I failed to calm it and it ran away and now I can’t find it bruh
Whats the best way of killing the animal and maintaining its perfect quality? Whenever i come accross a perfect quality animal and i go kill it, woth bow or melee it always becomes good pelt or poor
Headshot
The more bullets you use on the animal the worse the quality gets
Is the last mission our best selves? With arthur I made 5 saves
The best way to get a good animal kill is headshot? So it doesnt damage pelt? (RDR1)
Yeah and also make sure you’re using the correct weapon for the animal you’re hunting
who have rdr2 mod?
Oh shit didnt know that! How do i know which weapons used for which animal
The animal compendium usually says in the description what weapon is best for them
Alright! Nice thanks! Love the game - didnt know theres a compendium (rdr 1)
Oh nevermind then😂I completely missed you saying it was RDR1
There probably is still specific weapons for the animals tho
Rdr 1?
Yeah, like in 2010 when the game released, it was still known that a shotgun would obliterate a poor bunny rabbit😂I’d still recommend using bows for smaller animals and some sort of lighter rifle for medium animals
Didnt know theres bow in rdr1
Why does Elias Green still have a bounty 
Im replaying rdr2 with headphones this time haha
How can i kill dutch with rampage trainer
Go to spawner settings - ignore relationship
Guys I went to get the white Arabian and after failing the first time he just disappeared
Alr
Is that normal?
Thx
I went to go try and get him again today bc I’ve been trying for a while first I almost crashed into him then I was about to mount it but it bucked me off then a couple of wolves showed up then it just disappeared
I think it is normal idk it’s weird
Any game recommendation? I mostly played all games need something fresh
Anyone got any tips for Algernon wasp? I’m not on that part of the game yet because I had to restart all of my progress at 100% completion (my file got corrupted) and when I did have my amazing 98% I found it really difficult for Algernon wasp and really the whole finding specific animal quests any tips?
guys how many treasures are there exactly in the normal edition?
i only done two, jack hall’s and high stakes one.
hello
I’m looking for a posse to join one that does moonshine and supply missions I need serious cash anyone to dm?
anyone whos in the gang during the blackwater heist is wanted
as for arthur hes done previous crimes that add up
and is one of the main figures for the gang
what happens if i finish the game ith middle honor? is that counted as good honor or low?
also, my honor hasn't moved, im on chapter 3 now
Just reduce it to low and play high honour in the next walkthrough
11 treasure's total idk about normal edition, i thought they all include same in all edition
depending on the choice you make in the end between the two options, one is low and one is high. mid honour doesnt have an ending as you gain and lose honour depending on what you pick
it's not high or low, it's just there. although it is my favourite of the 3 as it has some pretty cool honour cutscenes
whats good pc specs to run ultra graphics?
Yeah I just found out it’s normal just wait a couple of ingame days.
And it should respawn
How do i increase honour quick
Go to a big city like Saint Denis ask someone for a ride and then just greet everyone you see
Ok
Or just get the bad ending
Does your honor have to be at max for you to get the good ending or can you still get it even if it’s on the white area of the bar
It can just be in the white
I didn't have it at the max when I finished
Gotta start grinding bruh im cooked
After Arthur got kidnapped I saw a wolf 🙏 😭
Man u have lot of time just let Arthur be in low honor.
He is better at low honor.
Wdym “he’s better”
Why
High honor gives you morr secondary quests
Bc then the gameplay is more enyoyable.
I’m at like chapter 4 or 5
Why tho
Saint Denis chapter
You can have high honor and still kill people
Jup. Dont worry bro low honor its so nice still John is better
both choices are valid really
I’m worried about the ending
High honor as arthur
High honor gives you promotions to buy things too
You can have high honor and still kill random people
it ultimately doesnt matter which arthur you like to play as
I mean rn I’m at the middle
For the first playthrough have high honor
There are more secondary missions
I’ll try
I would do good honor then replay with bad
Can I do survivalist 10 as Arthur or there is fish I need in locked area?
Yeah in first high after the first time low.
Yes thats what most people do
its easily avoidable
Yo did anyone completed the game 100%? I have a question
how long does it take to get from level 9 to level 10 beard
Hey, guys im a bit bored of base game anyone got some brutal low honor mods for me to try out??
hey, anyone who knows if i can play rdr2 without wifi on ps4
nah you still got a lot to do don't worry
Yeah I think so
It’s a single player game
Just greet people in Saint Denis it takes some time but it's the best method without random encounters also don't kill anyone now but once you reach the epilogue honour doesn't matter and go wild
drink 40 hair tonics and sleep for 15 years
Real
Uhh can you
better start robbing trains and deposit your money into the aberdeen pig farm when you're done
Aberdeen pig farm?
yes
What’s thst
you can get it all back later
Is that a lie or
I only have 3k rn
However
I do need to rob a train for 100%
3/4 robberies
Stage coach done, home done I think, and store
ong
micah should of murdered arthur in high honor endings
Would’ve been even more meaningful
he has no reason to leave arthur laying on the ground dying
Imagine if he just fucking domed Arthur 😭
if john can get blasted regardless of being good or bad, then so should arthur
😭
Bro has no shame
I think I’m one of the only players that actually liked Micah
and if you picked the one where he dies at beaver hollow, the murfrees shouldve used his corpse for their evil things
Oh dear god…
it makes sense
I think they should’ve dragged out the revenge arch longer
Had John actually have to track them down
I think this also makes sense
in a thematical sense, murfrees using his corpse for low honor arthur at beaver hollow is okay
because his low honor death is basically the oh no anyways meme
along with a super short may i stand unshaken tune that gets it done and over with and moves on
💀
You must get a montage then it practically just cuts to John
Actually I don’t know about low honor death, I played through like 3 times and finished at high honor each time
On my 4th now, so I think this one will be low honor
Hey is anybody on PC that mods RDR2? I got problem that I can't seem to fix. I playing the first Chapter rn and I notice some of the character arms are invisible or missing but the sleeves from their jackets are moving. And their gloves don't move
Idk if it the WhyEM dlc it might that because it's the only mod that has to do with clothing as part of it but I have no Idea
they killed the majority of the murfrees, at least I think so. And the random encounter where they go to your camp in wilds, the death of those three is prolly the death of the Murfrees as a whole. If I were a survivor I’d just assimilate into society and be normal
Does this trolley go to Tahiti?
i set a macro to allow me to go afk while doing "rest till morning" outside van horn store repeatedly lol
Hi gang - im on RDR 1 hardcore, and confused, does health regenerate or am i crazy?
it does regenerate just real slow
Oh nice okay, back to full real slow?
not sure but it does regen
Who wanna do legen deru bounty
Is there a place to post video clips, I need to ask for someone's opinion to make sure I'm not going crazy, it's very petty but it'll eat at me if I don't ask someone lol
I tried the media section and it deletes my message immediately
you can put mods in cracked
Does anybody know how to quickdraw on controller?
I'm playing on steam deck and I don't know how
Lightly hold your fire trigger
not really you still encounter the murfrees in the open world and theyre back to their home prior to 1907
in theory they would use arthur's corpse for their evil fantasys if charles didnt get to arthur's corpse in time, as well as susan's body
i ned help
my rdr2 takes hours to come
like
i have to wait for like 1h to play the story mode
like the pictures and the music
so
do
do i get help?
It could possibly be because of a low memory
Or I don't know, I once had issues with loading into the game because my graphic got reset and changed it to high, so I had to lower the graphic and it loaded just fine
It also depends if you use DX or Vulkan
Which chapter?
I believe that the hunting missions and overall camp missions are random, I don't really know to be honest
If you are on the last mission of chapter 2 and the honor missions do not pop up can you go back to your last save and do honor missions and then come back to your save at the end of chapter 2
Hey is anybody on PC that mods RDR2? I got problem that I can't seem to fix. I playing the first Chapter rn and I notice some of the character arms are invisible or missing but the sleeves from their jackets are moving. And their gloves don't move
Idk if it the WhyEM dlc it might that because it's the only mod that has to do with clothing as part of it but I have no Idea
hello, i have 100%'d my save file and i want to play as Arthur instead of John, what mod should i use for that?
Facial hair simply rejects to grow
does not go beyond this, done most of the known stuff
any recs?
Is the lend in hand trophy still glitched where if u do epilogue you get trophy
I need some help, I got real fat and started a new game, I saved the other one tho. Now I went to get the white Arabian again but it isn’t there does anyone know if it is still possible for me to get one
why dont you just
not eat for a while
and you still have your horse
The fat issue could be easily solved by not eating and running around on foot to the point you empty your stamina
With the horse issue I don't know how to help
Damn ment to say got real far
how do i enter cheat codes idk how to enter them via console (pc console) and no settings shift doesrnot entthing there
s thaing there
⟟ just finished rdr2 for the first time and I'm crying my eyes out wtf 😭
sadly i dont have emotions because the emotion side of my brain is dead
Dang
low honor ending?
High honour, save John
L ending
Damn okay 😔
Low honor, help John is the canon ending
Game is called red dead redemption for a reason tho
I’m pretty sure high honor save John is the canon ending
Yes John had an ending just like arthur
Looking at the sunset
Reminding of old memories
Definitely didnt get shot 21 times
best ending imo is high honor, return for money. low honor,help John is 2nd
I agree. I got low honor which was pretty bad
You're gonna have to manually type them out unless youre on xbox.
Dont listen bro, IMO easily the best ending
nvm i have to disable achievements and autoisave
Thanks mate lmao, thought I had the " wrong " ending for a sec
I just feel like going for the money is just insanely greedy and out of character for high honor arthur
wait which console do you have? I have always tried to use kbm on ps5
no
wait im confused now
you never heward of a keyboard and mouse?
I thought when you said PC console you play with a console connected to your PC mb.
Okay anyway, anyone know any interested locations in stock game?
` usually enters console
is it possible to get on story mode without signing into social club? i forgot my email and cant sign in
somehow my steam account has different rockstar social clubs for gta 5 and rdr2 and i have no clue how or why
YES
it actually accepted that email
for some reason 2 days ago that email was invalid
i dont think micah ratted on the gang in chapter 6, but i think he ratted on them by telling the o'driscolls about them
micah is not seen when shady belle was attacked, and the meeting in chapter 3 felt suspicious
guys is there any possible way for me to complete the "Reach maximum Health, Stamina and Dead Eye" as john? ive done everything and the only thing left for me is to finish that
Because Kieran did
And yes Micah ratted the gang in chapter 6
will A.E.M break the game if i use it with W.E.R.O? i havent seen anyone talk about it so i'm guessing it doesnt
what is the fastest horse
I didnt know you could catch the kid BEFORE they get to the whole group of em in saint denis
if im not wrong there is legendary horses
What things can be done eternally in rdr1? Wanted posters? Blue circle missions??
Before which mission should I put all my money in the pig farm?
buy every reinforced equipment from the trapper,and you should get maximum health,stamina and dead eye
you can have 4 horses at a time:3 in the stable and the one you're riding
bounties are infinite,but I don't really know anything else since I don't have rdr
Thanks for answeting though
you're welcome

The heavier bodies version work with any euphoria mods
imo many more people would’ve picked that option if it said, “Go back to kill Micah.” rather than, “Go back for the money."
nobody cares about the money
yeah "return for the money" doesn't make sense, it's more like "return for Micah"
do u actually kill micah in that ending tho?
You stab his eye
And he loses his eye
And i killed dutch
before he opened the door
but then it mission failed :(
so i just killed him 2 more times to skip the mission
Dutch died a very bad way
dutch didnt die?
oh u mean rdr1?
Well lets leave it
Yes
Oh
im waiting for the ''potential'' pc release
Rdr1 is still not on PC?
No
I like to think rockstar is too busy making GTA 6
i hate sadie bro
"im seeing triple"
im seeing a goddamn bear eat my fucking stomach
what you talking about bro
its a good thing they hired double eleven to port rdr to the switch and ps4 and later on pc
Yes
Its not a bad port just deceptioning
Everyone so hyped for a remake
Also too expensive
Join all call
huh
Howdy!
Can I ask about the Talismans? Do they have to be "shown" on the outfit in order to function?
no
abigail roberts is underrated as hell, shes much more developed than any camp girl because she wants a better life for her son and her heart always stuck to john even in his extreme neglection stages. she aint always right though, shes both right and wrong in certain parts, shes morally grey but in a likable and understandable way. sadie on the other hand is a hypocrite blood thirsty lady, preaching about avenging jake but becomes a selfish outlaw herself and then for no reason becomes a bounty hunter, wtf.
Meanwhile John shoots guy who bumped into him
yea, sadie sucks
True
Some people hate her
hearing arthur saying fuck is like ceaser saying "no!" in rise of the apes lol
ive been in camp for 4 minute and miss grimshaw has come at me 3 times
Fr
im tryna catch legendary fish, so im at the bait shop in lapras or lagras or wtv but its not letting me buy stuff, only steal. i got enough cash and i used the shop a while back and it worked, so idrk, do i need to wait for the owner to come out or something? its daytime ingame
Try setting up camp and sleeping a few days
kk ill try that
Ok if that doesn't work try reloading the save file
Other than that I have no idea
She’s bad asf
But yeah she’s the most devovlped character wise
🤨🤨
wheres the snake bite guy that gives you a free gun
same
he should be around the bayou
it's random tho
no the one
that gifts you a gun
does the stream folder
and the horses you replace
get you banned in online?
i used to play the game in my ps4 and now recently it broke up, not accepting discs, can’t find anything to solve this problem, guess i’ll just give up here, thank you all for helping me in my gameplay. i only played for 4 months, (completed story once, and in my 2nd play through my console broke up)
I´m having some trouble with modding the single player version of RDR2 , the blunderbuss mod to be more specific , can anyone help ?
Guys who have platinum rdr2??
Guys I’m trying to get the vampire knife I went there like 2 night and he ain’t there
Is that normal?
do you go there between 12 and 1 am?
also do you have all the texts around saint denis?
I just replayed a bunch of missions and it didn't save any-
5 right? Yes
Yep
Hm, that's weird then
Can i stealth kill or just 1 hit kill with knife in rdr1?
Hey how long does 100% comp on rdr2 cost? I played it on release until the boat gambling area then my old pc would freeze lol
Also how much of the game is left after that scene?
I'm playing chapter 6, and I'm wondering if the gang will ever go back to how they were before? and is Dutch really that bad?
and is the online mode good? should I end it when I finish the story or play online?
if u wanna know,play the story.
Online on PC sucks because of the cheaters,but if u wanna give it a shot you can play it whenever you want
well you're on chapter 4,not that much I guess
still a lot
I finished the story, someone said there were 8 chapters, maybe I remembered wrong
uhh
there are 8 chapters
yeah
epilogue
if i knew chapter 6 was the last chapter i wouldn't have asked that and would have guessed the ending
Dutch just doubts about loyalty...
what a sad story
It's amazing
Wait, why did Dutch suspect John in the first place?
If not, what explains the abandonment and subsequent refusal to rescue him?
at the end dutch went totally crazy and believed everything that Micah said (like abandoning Abigail,a thing that,I think,he would've never done before chapter 5 I guess)And if it wasn't for Arthur and Sadie,John would've probably died,because dutch just didn't care.
techically there are 8 chapters but theres 6 chapters for the main story and 2 chapters for the epilogue
So, Dutch didn't care about John even before he suspected a traitor.
you finished the game?
no he just didn't care from chapter 6
he just believed Micah at that point
I just finished chapter 6 and can't continue playing yet
some of them might be
Hey does anyone know how I can remove Arthur’s suspenders? I’m in chapter 2 and my game is fully updated
I’m on ps so I can’t use mods
you can't remove them. most you can do is get ones in a colour that blends in or wear a vest
It’s right after you first come into Horseshoe Overlook, you go to your horse and equip the custom outfit on it. It should be after the mission called “Eastward Bound”.
Personally Schofield
Hello Guys
Hi there cowpoke
i might get Schofields
Good choice
Can i stealth kill or just 1 hit kill with knife in rdr1?
Imo the navy’s are uglé
Yes
ill get schofields now
Myesss…
What about legendary weapons like Otis revolver Micah revolver stuff like that
?
Micah’s revolver is a double action which I hate but the Otis miller revolver is beautiful
Micah sucks
And his revolvers
Yeh
Can i discard gun(s) in rdr1?
Damn... hehe
Wish Rockstar had let you deck him from time to time while antagonizing
theres almost no point in greeting because it goes no where for you
all you get is some honor but you can get more honor in better ways thats meaningful
antagonising can lead to interesting consequences that evolves if you keep it up
rockstar teaching wisdom in greet greet antagonise
Guys
Is Bollard and Walton gangs in rdr2?
sadly not, only in rdr1
Whats the gangs in rdr2 other thsn driscolls
night folks,lemoyne raiders,skinner brothers, murfree broods,Laramie and del lobo
Nice!
why do i get wanted for killing lemoyne raiders?
st denis chief hates me more than them

I guess it's a bug,you can't get wanted if it's a gang member
this bug happens a lot actually,the game thinks your killing just a normal NPC and it will get you wanted
Does anyone know how to get 10/10 on the horse stamina level? Currently it says 9/10 for stamina and for health its 8/10
it might be due to the horse's breed. some can only go so fast and have so much health. what's the breed?
Missouri fox trotter
Isn’t the Missouri fox trotter the fastest horse in story mode?
from fandom.com max stam is 7 and max health is 5
so i think your horse is maxed out
and yes i'm pretty sure fox trotter is one of the fastest
I got the panther saddle the best one
I can’t equip stirrup
Probably because of the saddle
I just got the the red Arabian :D
Is there such thing of as a horse close to dutchs?
yes, the white arabian. you can find it at lake isabella in the grizzlies
dutch's horse actually shouldn't exist because albino horses can't survive to adulthood irl
I see, thank you!
I had no idea the pinkertons were and are a real thing
yeah
they decided to use the real things instead of making one up in a world of fiction
can someone give me an acc with storymode
Do rare guns have higher stats than purchased guns?
slightly better. like the rare rolling block has just a little more range/damage i believe
Rolling block can't be upgraded in the shop, probably the same for the other guns
no get it yourself
fr im helping the city to get rid of bad folks..
you can discover the rare rolling block in the wild.
rare guns come with a few upgrades but arent upgradeable
is this ur first playtrought?
somebody knows how to play rdr 2 on vr?
I can’t trigger the Otis skinner hanging anyone have any idea to fix it
I’ve done 3 bounties without seeing the hanging but I want to see this one
Im in rdr1 hardcore mode but war horse is 5000 how come?? Its supposed to be 10000
No
yes💀💀 you can
where do you find the ufos?
Hey I’ve just started the side quest where you have to take down the bounty posters for mr black and mr white. And I got arrested before I could take the last one from the bounty hunter is it still available
Either it will have saved your progress and you just need to get that last poster, or the mission will have reset and you can go back to where the mission starts and do it again, either way the mission will never become unavailable
Yeah I found the bounty hunter again and it was like I never got arrested.
how?
What horse do you use? And what’s the health and stamina at?
The red Arabian. Max health and stamina, max bonding.
What does it say for your health and stamina?
The only horse that can have max stamina and health is the rose gray Arabian
Hey i need help im stuck on a mission at Saint Denis at the party , my game keeps crashing when i go downstairs … someone can help pls
my game is closing after i login help
Well darn, that sucks
The best saddle is the panther saddle u gotta get a 3 star panther pelt for that n craft from trapper
The rose gray arabian horse is the best horse in the game on yt everyone was saying missouri fox trotter
guys forget my good bye message.. because im back!!
I don’t even know you but welcome back

im at chapter 3 stuck for seans coach robbery
it’s not spawning..
how can i make it spawn? any tips?
i need help: im doing the serial killer mission and im at the lucky's cabin but i cant open the celler door for some reason
i've gottenn all the map peices
got it to work! i had to restart the game
Guys, who know, why all my photos disappeared from the gallery?
On the way to shady bell after guarma, only one song can play right
No matter the honor
Also i don't lose my money right? I had 5k on Arthur
You shouldnt
I usually get my money and weapons back when you find the gang and finish the mission
Where can I find it?
blackwater stables
oh...
Anyone want a free schofield revolver
Go behind the drug store in valentine and look through the window
Then rob it
Click rob back room
There will be some loot and a gun case with the revolver
Make sure to rob the cash register on ur way out as well
Wait
Ellhnas?
Yes

Schofield is the best revolver imo
Uh guys
I did the thing with the snake guy to get a free item
But i accidentally pointed my gun at the gunsmith
And had to run away
Can i still claim the free gun
Yes i think
Try going back another time it should work
Why can't I buy stirrups yet? I just started Chapter 3 and I have the Beaver Roping Saddle equipped.
What do i do to unlock the rolling block rifle i want a perfect bison pelt
For fucks sake i have to save micah again
yk the guy i the mission "fine joys of tobacco" named hamish
can you not kill that guy?
like knock him out
you can do the hosea hunting mission
go back with him
jump on his horse
blow it up
pick the gun up
Already did it tho
then idk
can i not kill hamish
i feel bad
can i just slam him on the back of the head with the handle of my gun
should i do low honor or high honor on my first ever playtthrough
i kinda wanna do high honor but at the same time being civil isnt that much fun
Low
low honor is the canon ending
High honour
Lower prices
Plus idk for u but for me this game just makes me wanna do high honour
Bcuz the game feels so real
well now i have contradictory opinions
Id say if u want lower prices and to feel like a good person go with high honour
If u just wanna annihilate everything then low honour ig
Yo I got a question
you should just play and see where it takes you
if you feel like robbing a guy in saint denis rob the guy
if not
then dont
I just started RDR2 recently. This sounds crazy but I want to get the platinum. Or hope to. But I want to know something before I battle this game
It’s about the 70 gold medal trophy

good luck
Anyway my idea is I 100% everything but the gold medal part. Go into ng+ and have a maxed out character then try to gold medal 70 missions. When I start mission 1 can I have anything in my inventory with the stats I had at endgame?
This can take me 200-500+ hours to platinum. So I want to know what to expect as I’m playing the game
I dont think there is a new game +
so like yeah
im five playthroughs in and havent seen anything about a new game +
I heard people play the game a 2nd time with max stats then get 70 gold medals but I want to confirm it since misinformation and misinterpretation is a common thing on the internet
I think you can redo missions when you finish the game (you have to be loaded into your save)
Let’s say I complete the game and get really stacked up. On the same playthrough, can I enter that mission as a leveled up character? Or is my character gonna be the same level when I started that mission the first time?
I think you enter the mission as your leveled up character
I hope that’s the case. Especially swapping weapons and using something more powerful
I love my scotfield revolvers
I hear mixed strategies on the 70 gold medal thing and just want to have an easier time with it. I prefer if my stats are higher level
So I guess I’ll progress the game then revisit the mission after I’m done with everything else
Just want to know what’s optimal
so i just started to play rdr2, does anybody know like any tips of increasing my honor? my brother is going for low honor and im going for high honor
also its diffucilt for me to even do missions without getting low honor randomly becuase i wanted to protect myself (in some encounters)
Helping NPCs and choosing the morally decisions, helping around in the camp, taking care of your horse. Should all help increasing high honor.
catch fish and then release them and greet people in towns
If you have spare money Giving minimum 20 dollars every time to camp for many times does give honor
imma start like getting food and supplies and money for the camp
go to a town and greet everyone
dont pick an ending you want, just make the decisions you think is fun and see how it ends up. I think it ruins the fun when you cant do things you really want to since its literally a game.
I just threw away all my money to customise a lancaster and a revolver
Was it worth it?
Abso-fucking-lutely yeah

I've been showing my gf red dead redemption 2. So far she hates Sadie, Lenny, and Charles the most
I hated Sadie during my first playthrough too, she’ll learn to love her
I dont think that's gonna happen. I'm in chapter 6 and she's annoyed her anytime she's been on screen
Ah
Molly, Micah, Javier, Bill and Strauss are the most dislikeable. Coincidentally, the traitors...
what did she see in them to hate lol?
How are Javier and Bill traitors? Don't they stick with the gang till the very end?
She said Sadie is annoying with how much of a try hard edgelord she is. And she hates her voice
hey guys im having trouble with fishing in the game
whenever I try to fish for the legendary lake sturgeon, nothing ever happens, i just sit there for minutes on end. Any idea what could be happening?
Have you tried changing your lure? Could be using the wrong lure for the location
yeah ive checked, im using the special river lure
im in the epilouge lol
I looked it up lol, ign say use the rive lure and when i pull my rod out it says river too
Have you tried not following ign
bro ive tried all 3 lures 😭
don't you need the special lures for the legendary fish?
and yeah i used two different spots
Idk dude, I don't do fishing
I do legendary animals
i want to do all of it
It might be time sensitive
oh maybe
Like you might be able to fish for it at night
but i did try a lot and im sure i would have done it in different times/weather
Ima use some cheese
They betray Arthur etc.
Oh, sure I guess. I got confused I thought you meant they all betrayed the gang
My fault.
I left my game in Strawberry and when I open RDR2 again for some reason the game thinks im at Guarma
if i buy clothes from trapper as Arthur, does it convert to John aswell ? or do i lose it in the epilogue
you'll get them back
thank you
I’m currently on my first ever playThough and it’s sadly coming to an end but if creating a new playThrough will it delete my original ???
No
Would you mind telling me how to crest a new playThrough for when the time comes
Pause the game, go to story and tap new game and save
Save in onother slot not in the one where your current playthough is
Okay thanks for telling me !
i just played “the joys of civilization” mission for the second time and tried to do that trick
i watched it from yt to catch the boy early
but somehow he runs faster than me when i get close to him
Yeah it gets annoying
and somehow you teleport to other places you werent in when tackling the little shit
I caught the kid early
jumped down from a ledge and grabbed him
just so you know creating another save disables autosave Im pretty sure so be careful
Do you guys know whether pure white shire horses are in the game? I've only ever found light-grey shire horses
steal Dutch’s >:)
Which are the easiest and fastest challenges to do other than bandit and explorer
All of them
Which one is the fastest to finish other than those 2 tho?
What do you mean?
I finished it just fine
Just do any missions you have left
I figured it out
Oh alright
Regarding the Epilogue, can I meet Tilly on the bench in Saint Denis... When I have Anthony Foreman on my horse's back?
Thought it'd be interesting lol
Whatd you have to do?
60 fps with ps5 pro 🥲 ?
Advice for Sharpshooter 3?
I use deadeye and it shows red even though it keeps missing
(Tomahawk 80 feet)
These Legendary Fish missions are the undisputed worst missions i've ever played in any game
The last about 5 days have been dedicated to never-ending casting
You're getting really unlucky then
It only took me a few hours
Anyone know where to find opposums?
you can find them by riggs station at night. you'll be able to hear them shriek
Ok thanks
so uh.... I just couldnt find a mission right in camp because the icon was in the wrong spot.

guys! i'mk in chapter 6 now!
GG
Totally
How do i unlock certain guns? Some of them are locked for me
I want to waste my money but the game won’t let me 😔
The gunsmith in San Denis has the m1899 and the Lemat revolver, and some weapons must be found in the world
You unlock them while you progress through chapters
random q for y'all, what are your favourite towns?
personally i think van horn and tumbleweed are underrated
van horn did what rdr1 thieves' landing did but better
I like tumbleweed and armadillo
rdr2 armadillo?
sometimes i get drunk there, esp in online, but it pales in comparison to tumbleweed
armadillo in single player doesn't even have a post office iirc
rdr2 new austin really does feel like the wild west
tumbleweed is a top 5 town for me
but armadillo is one of my least favourite
whether in singleplayer or online it just feels wrong to stay in such a sickly town
which is likely deliberate to avoid plotholes
because in rdr1 john is unfamiliar with armadillo
you got a top 5?
for me it's probably tumbleweed, valentine, blackwater, saint denis and van horn
rhodes and strawberry are also nice, but not my favourites
armadillo, tumbleweed, valentine, strawberry, rhodes
I really like rhodes for the saloon
I'm not a big fan of saint denis at all
The mission where Arthur has to escape the O'Driscolls while they are at the campsite on the mountain. Is it possible to escape without them knowing or no matter what they know?
i like armadillo the most feels the most western place imo
I like valentine because it’s the only place I’m not wanted
lol
Yeah, Valentine is legendary
all towns feel the same really
I love Valentine but I have a soft spot for Saint Denis I just like the industrial feel to it
they dont give the players reasons to go to them other than whats it like there
they dont offer anything new and are selling the same items
its the case of been to one seen them all
hard disagree
it was true in rdr1
but not at all in rdr2
no 2 towns are the same
they look different but they offer the same things
no 2 towns offer the exact same services
yes they do
every stable has different horses, the shopkeepers are unique npcs with unique dialogue
every town has a different sheriff (or police chief)
go to gunsmiths, go to barbers, go to general stores, go to doctors, they offer the same exact things
no shit that's every game
same shitty ai
all sheriffs are trigger happy
yeah i'm not gonna argue
it would be nice if all sheriffs behave and rule the town differently
they literally do
sheriff freeman shoots on sight
if you have a bounty
all the sheriffs have different dialogue if you're in jail
several sheriffs are killed and replaced in the story
such as in rhodes and strawberry
as for ai, rdr2's ai is the best of any rockstar title
I have to agree with @raw forge
For some reason it chose @hidden moss when I meant to chose @raw forge
i feel like folks sometimes are just looking for things to complain about
i have my issues with rdr2
a lot of them to do with cut content
we have stores that aren't stores (strawberry's doctor as an example)
Plus Sant Denis sells stuff like ties unlike Valentine let’s say
yeah
very small differences
Cause it fits cause Saint Denis is more fancy I feel
you're just flat out ignoring all the differences we mentioned
hell, drinks at the bastille saloon in saint denis cost twice as much
food in every saloon is different, and they have unique models
you just going to ignore that every town is offering mostly the same things
as i mentioned, the stable horses
no, i already acknowledged that and countered that it's the norm in games
Plus towns in poker have different cards
the difference here is that i'm comparing rdr2 to other open world games, not to some perfect ideal
small differences arent enough to warrant a visit to every town in the game
have you ever stopped to listen to npc dialogue?
even in online it's really immersive
there are missed opportunities, but rdr2 really builds on rdr1
It does
i ended up making a tier list for rdr2 towns
S: Saint Denis, Valentine
A: Blackwater, Tumbleweed, Van Horn Trading Post
B: Rhodes, Strawberry
C: Annesburg, Emerald Ranch
D: Armadillo, Lagras, Thieves' Landing
While yes the towns do sell almost the same stuff they still feel different
thoughts on it?
I mean I agree that Saint Denis and Valentine are good
forgot blackwater
thats all they offer, they feel different but function the same on a foundation level, it would be nice if every town's foundation is different
Blackwater is good but the only issue is that it’s missing a gun store
Other than that it’s pretty good
how about in saint denis they only sell expensive suits while in valentine they sell cheap clothing, thats the difference im talking about, thats just one example and that alone warrants a visit to town to get specific stuff only in that town
haircuts too
how about each gunsmith having their own gun styles and paintings instead of making all gunsmiths equal
I mean I must admit as good as rdr2’s customizations are good I do feel like there could be a little bit more
Like the suit you get on that poker boat mission should’ve been unlocked for the open world after doing the mission without glitches
i feel like rdo fixes this
i actually like some of the changes in rdos map
Yea rdo does fix this but I mainly play story mode
armadillo has a post office, thieves' landing has a saloon
i play both
rdo is underrated
I played it for a while but got a little bit bored imo
But if you like it then that’s fine
Funny enough the whittemore outfit for me can be glitched into the open world
oh nice
Idk if it works for Xbox but I can send you the guide on how to get it if you want
You have to do that poker boat mission in chapter four but apparently you get a second chance at it in the bank job in Saint Denis
But you can only get one variant of the suit you can’t have both had to learn that the hard way
Rdo has so much potential, they can still make updates its not late
Yea it definitely does too bad rockstar gave up on it for gta online
can i talk about rdr2 mods here (singleplayer only)?
So sad
Yea definitely
rockstar overestimated rdo's success and its the lack of things to do that ultimately made gold bars underperform
theres nothing much to spend on and theres no incentive to drop real money for gold bars because theres fuck all to do with the gold bars
if only they updated rdo like adding new mounts, like unicorns and cattles and bisons, that can only be purchased with gold bars, then rdr2 would of gotten more care and a 9th gen version gets made
its the nasty microtransactions that trumps all things
hopefully rockstar does good plannings for rdo2 when red dead 3 comes
because rdo is not a bad idea and the idea is good to get big profits, its just the execution terribly did not go to plan
Anyone else think that Karen is severely underused? I love her character and design. She's bad ass as well, we see her in action at the bank robbery in valentine. I just wish she had at least a couple more mission tag alongs. Or atleast the ability to sleep with her 😏
her mysterious closure can open up possibilities of a new game
karen is one of the only gang girls thats like arthur in attitude and outlaw compulsions
and stands up for herself against the worst of the worst like grimshaw and lawmen
you shouldnt take tilly's conclusions as fact because shes only guessing what happened to karen
What does tilly say about her again?
She thinks that Karen drank herself to death
goddangit what a game honestly
arthur morgan was a good man
he was just at the other side of the law
Yall is there any way to sell my unwanted weapons
So many cigarette cards man
Nope.
All for a pair of damn handcuffs
Rdr2 is getting a remastered version for ps5 next year hopefully that’s when the game starts getting updates again
Well better updates
Since they’ve been working on gta6 sadly that’s why they aren’t doing big updates for rdo
A billion dollar company can't keep up w everything, that's just sad dude. And they keep adding major updates to gta online dude so its not a word about "being too busy w gta6"
That’s three games that they have to focus on so I understand
I will be buying a ps5 this year, I would love to play that remaster fr
4k 120 fps I heard
Just reminding you that its a billion dollar company
Ik
It’s a remastered version so yea
Since the base game is 60
Bro the graphics and the movement on that will be soo clean if its 120fps
Fr
So sad that the new ps5 pro doesnt include blu-ray disc reader 😭😭😭
I want rdr2 on a disc fam
Base game is 30 fps, it never got a 60 fps update
For me it’s 60
It doesn’t look 30 to me
Not on PS
True, most triple A games are locked on 30 fps
Ok so the remastered is 60
I own one game that supports 60 fps 😭
Crazyyy ... Still gonna do it
This is probably just me but I hope they add more clothes in story mode
Imo while it’s good it still feels a little lacking
Yknow the price difference is 500 for next gen to 2000 for the same performance right?
Can you not pick up elk carcasses?
$2000 can get you 120fps on rdr2 pc
even more if you get stronger specs
Same with xbox also fps above 60 doesnt rlly matter
No, but you can take their pelt but it’s the size of a dear on the back of your horse
What about for xbox?
C96 or FN M1900?
give me a good black and white horse name
Chess
Zebra, Cow...
Oreo
Nah, I'd probably name it Sinner, like the darkness is taking over the innocence idk
Pepsi
coke
Can you do errand boy trophy in chapter 6
It becomes unavailable after chapter 4
I know of 1 request you can get from Uncle during the epilogue but that’s it
Nope
I’ve got sadie and jack items in chapter 5 but I can’t give it to them
Can’t I give it in chapter 6
No, that’s why it becomes unavailable after chapter 4
No but you need it if you’re going for the platinum
If you just want to 100% your save file tho then you don’t have to worry about it👍
But can I go to a old save and get the trophy from there
Should be able to
Yup and for RDR1, both a massive grind😂
Rd1 is 40 hours
Rd2 is 150 minimum
I’ve done all online trophies
Just need story trophies
RDR1 has some of the most luck based trophies I’ve ever seen😅at least RDR2 is just grinding
Still tho RD1 is no where near 150 hours plat
Both are annoying😂
Fr
Can you link an article where you read this? I looked it up and didn't find anything saying there was a remaster coming out next year
I just found out that the leak was fake
😪
We will never win
Guys, I’m desperate for help here.
I’m currently doing Herbalist 7, I’ve read the pamphlet for a Special Miracle Tonic, have collected 30 of each required item - but the SMT does not appear on my crafts menu? I’m really confused. Restarted my game but issue still occurring.
(Currently playing PS.)
does anyone know who the Del Lobos are I found a bunch of them next to a big river to the right of Armadillo (location is also called Thieve's landing)
they're a gang that hang around new austin a lot
my games lasting 30-40 minutes before crashing when i open a catalogue or go in first person. any fixes?
you might have 3 already in your inventory (thats the max what you can carry) you to your inventory and use/discard if you have them already
rdr3 could get announced by rockstar for future take 2 earnings report, maybe next year. they wont say its rdr3, its likely they'll say the next red dead game like how they called gta6 the next grand theft auto
i think (almost) 6 years is enough time to wait to annouce another game
hello guys im new to this server, is it possible to craft or buy a white or black satchel?
Hey guys, im playing this great game for the first time - im in chapter two and just unlocked the option to sell wagons
after completing that mission all the yellow missions disappeared so im a bit lost right now
do you have any tips for me?
I’m like close to chapter 5 but I feel like chapter 2 gives me joy and is just fun, not a lot of people die, no one I think
Can we talk about modding in here?
Just finished the blood feuds mission. Oh boy, what a mission

hel fucking yes
is there any action to be found north of valentine?
Weird there should be missions.
I've had that problem before it might just be a playstation thing I think what helped it for me was doing a side mission or sleeping
Lads i have a perfect bear pelt can i do anything other than sell it
trapper can make clothes out of it
sell it to him then he can make some chaps I think
Uh
So.
I just beat story for the first time.
Really hated micah.
Guy was a dick.
So next Playthrough I might triple antagonise always.
Why is John here?
I thought he escaped.
This should be the end.
So it appears john is the epilogue character
If that's so.
Jack killed Ross in the epilogue.
So that means.
I'm gonna kill micah as John.
Yipee
Is there any way to make a shit ton of money i want that race horse
Not sure.
I mean I just hunted a lot.
I didn't really focus on money

