#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 127 of 1
Lemme load the game back up then
Gotta close it to use Discord
It's that slow to type
And make sure you are in vulkan
What do you mean?
Whenever I have RDR2 open, typing is super slow.
Like even now, it takes forever for what I type to load.
But the game run smoothly right?
Yep, never had any issues with the game.
Do you guys agree with john that dutch was secretly always like how he was at the end or do you think he changed
My original thought was that he changed because he saved sadie at the beginning
but then again he murdered an innocent woman right before the game started in blackwater
can so0meone help me to download mods
My theory is that he just lost the ability to hide his real personality in that one mission in saint denis where the trolly flipped over and dutched hit his head hard and said it hurt
But remember that dutch killed an innocent girl in the blackwater heist the trolley was the final hit for his madness
i feel like dutch changed his game plan, how so? I would say that Dutch tried to hide the real himself until the end of the gang.
Eh. Dutch is a human being, same as the rest of us. Humans are complex, and beyond two-sided. I think Dutch always had that madness in him, but the numerous events of RDR2 (especially the trolley) simply amplified that part of Dutch.
I feel like Dutch has always been on the manipulative/not quite as truthful as he seems to be side. I've noticed that Dutch often seemed to find people suffering and in desperate need of support to pull into his criminal lifestyle. Obviously this is nit the case for all of the gang, but quite a few have been pulled off the street. He knows people's weaknesses and uses them to his advantage
often times people, like Javier, feel that they owe Dutch for saving them out of the goodness of his heart and he feeds into that idea
the second somebody goes against his ideas, he's quick to shut them down by playing the loyalty card
I also noticed that Dutch also says something along the lines of "I expect you'll betray me in the end, you're the type", I'm not sure if that's just Dutch being Dutch but it seems that he doesn't appreciate Arthur's free spiritedness and his ability to speak out when something doesn't seem right
I rambled a lot more than I intended to, sorry gang 
likely dutch being dutch, and arthur just being the only one in the gang who at least somewhat regularly goes out of camp for an extended period of time
arthur every once in a while spoke out but never did anything else to make sure he expresses himself whenever dutch just ignores what he said
I think thats manipulative, trying to maintain arthurs loyalty by questioning it
you could really tell that he was crazy on that one opening to a mission where hes playing chess in his mind
Dm
why
I Want to Ask you about a horse mark i don't know the name
Plz man help me
Just dm i will not eat you xd
ok but no guarantee i will know
Ok just dm
I believe he was reciting a move known as the 'Dutch Defence'
real
I have a question ,
Just killed the two bounty hunters
And I have taken the bounty they had on their horse
I'm in the strawberry jail rn and it won't let me put the bounty in jail
What do I do
how do I spin my gun, the one that angers npcs
You are putting him in the cell downstairs, right?
I think maybe you hold L1
you mean double tap? Or is this a separate one
wait no holding it opens the wheel
maybe the spin that doesn't holster your gun is a mod
idk
Yes
That's where I'm trying to get him
Beats me
That’s weird. How did the law react (if at all) when you first entered the jail with the bounty?
They said thanks for helping the law
So whag do I do
Is it possible to get the chocolate roan Dutch warmblood from bounty hunters? Or do I have to buy it from a stable?
Not sure there is anything you can do. If you have a save from just before the encounter with the two bounty hunters you could reload and try again, but if not then that’s just a case of bad luck.
I think you can only get it from the Valentine stables
Actually, I might be wrong about that - give me one moment
On a website I’m looking at, it lists prices that the player can sell the horse off for, and has a category for stolen horses, which does seem to imply that somehow you can get the horse without buying it.
Okay cool
Any idea where I might be able to get it?
I've found one reddit post suggesting you can get it from bounty hunters but I've tried a bit and never found that specific coat
Unfortunately not. I’ve skimmed through a few different things now, but nothing I’ve read actually seems to say where it might spawn.
Wish I could help more
I'll keep looking for a bit but if I don't find it I'll just buy it
No worries!
where the hell are the trappers i can’t find them in chapter 2..?
You don’t know where on the map they are or they aren’t spawning in?
has anyone else gotten wanted for intimidation?
cuz I just did
tried to threaten a witness but I got wanted for intimidation
I swear I'm not lying
I think it’s happened to me like one time
Anybody else feel like there should be more legendary animals
Maybe like a Black Bear in Tall Trees
Bison in The Heartlands or something
We were definitely robbed of more collectibles
Yo I got RDR2 spoiled for me how to I get myself a new brain
What did you get spoiled on
the entire fuckin game
at first it was one video
then spoilers showed up in my recommended
So I don't know what's happened but the thing to donate to the wuincy hall just isn't popping up she's just not there
How do I get it back
When I first came I didn't have enough cash but now I do and I wanna donate
Hello
Rip
You should never have clicked on that video because youtube will recommend you loads more rdr2 videos
I tried my best to avoid spoilers but i got a few things spoiled for me during my playthrough, i guess it was inevitable with how big of a game this is
same thing happened with me

At the risk of sounding like a complete noob do I need to fully study, track and kill an animal to contribute towards 100% the game or will just studying suffice? All help appreciated thanx 🙂 👍
For just the 100% I think you can do any of the ones you mentioned, it just needs to be in your compendium one way or another, but for the trophies like Skin Deep and Zoologist, they will need to be fully studied and skinned
Thanks that's really helpful 👍
Did you find a resolution? I have the same problem...
Nope :(
My brother suspected it was my CPU
My specs arent the greatest however ive never had a problem before
Also, I have the game open rn, so my typing is super slow.
Yeah, Ik it's not a hardware issue for me.
Its been like this now for a week, 2 days ago my pc was fine and typing normally. Now it is back to being slow again
Didnt change a thing
And like you said, seems like nobody has this problem because i cant find anything about it
What is the percentage of your CPU rn?
Bout 30% rn.
Mine goes up to 80. Maybe it is my CPU that is the problem. However like i stated, its never been an issue before

How do you quickdraw on pc?
On pc, you have to be locked on to an entity, then hold the fire button down until it draws into deadeye
You can't gauge your draw with precision like you could with a controller and you also cannot draw without locking on to some entity.
Tihuana arthur
they are not spawning..
what do i do
Is there a mod that helps with the law/witness system?
do you mean like disabling it or
No I just mean that the law instantly recognizes me, finds me, teleports, and it’s just not fun
Especially st denis
either your wanted or the system is just bugged
Like if you wear the mask and you kill or stealing well the law will not recognizing you because the mask
It always says wanted: Arthur Morgan
The law will always identify you as Arthur Morgan if you are spotted by them
Masks are there to prevent witnesses to give the law your description and identify you without them being there and seeing you
But if the law see me they will identify me?
Yes that's right
No problem
Now if you want to keep your identity hidden regardless, there is a mod for that
Do it before you get wanted
"No Bounty When Masked" is a mod that basically makes it so you never get a bounty on your head as long as you keep a mask on
Most you will get is a 5$ bounty
@oblique shadow why are uou an arthur hater
No im not a hater it's just a bastard change my nickname and you know that snake
You know a solution to change it
what mod causes me to lose tens of thousands when i die?
Do you have any mod installed that increases the difficulty in any way?
Also, it's possible that a banking mod causes a certain percentage of money to be lost.
Perhaps that's what is happening
i don't think so
Can you share what mods you have installed? Here or in dms
it's fine it doesn't bother me it was just weird
Alright then
I know a Solution.
What is it
From this chat press ur pfp
You’ll see “Edit Server Profile”
Click that and u can type in a new name
Red dead anime when
I dont get why people think arthur is a good person
Even if just at the end
he kills loads of innocent soldiers right before the final mission
i see him as a bad guy that did some good near the end of his life
most of the things people include that supposedly makes arthur a way better person than he is are side content, stuff that he could've likely not done and even then they're all pretty small acts for a small number of individuals and never make up for even the effect robbing the valentine bank had on people, and definitely not for everything else
he didn't have enough time to redeem himself and imo he never put in enough effort to even get a start on it
I think canonically every side quest happened but still thats a single grain of sand compared to the desert of sins hes commited through his lifetime
I completed 1st part of the epilogue, and i don wanna go any further in the history😭🙏
Those soldiers weren’t innocent. They followed orders from a corrupt government Agent .
I would go till Arthur’s death then play rdr1 then do the epilogue
Why 💀
Goddamit
no spoiler tags are allowed fr some reason
you just have to say it 💀
alright
So I was saying, Milton says Micah ratted them out "since Carribbean" assuming it means Guarma(?), how the Pinkertons know about the Hosea's bank robbery? (Hosea is dead)
Bronte.
Oh so Bronte's death notified the Pinkertons
I always thought Micah ratted since blackwater
Most likely
I thought so too, but apparently not
So Micah isn't that bad as ppl say he is, after guarma they're all weak, I would rat too if I were in his position but Strauss died for the gang...
Yes dont forget it was mentioned he had them in his pocket
No doubt Milton realised this had to be the work of Dutch
And Milton coulda lied
Ab Micah?
I mean, he's pretty bad
I can't send messages with spoiler marks?
Whatever
Yeah lol
He shoots arthur and kills him in both low honor endings, so. He's still a horrible person
And beats the shit out of arthur in high honor. So he's definitely not good
I understand that, but there was no need for Micah to both shoot or beat arthur up
Even if arthur was to die anyway/was a monster
what do i do with the legend fox
Online or story?
story
Take the pelt to the trapper (either in san denis or there's a traveling one)
Use whatever part it gave you to make a trinket in the fence
With the pelt, you can make clothing items and saddles and stuff at the trapper
do i skin it
aight
so i sell the pelt what do i do with the rest
just fence the charm
Yes, go to the fence
Sell the charm to the fence, then you can craft it if you have all the ingredients
where do you get the clothing? i looked the trappers wears but i couldnt find it
What ab him now
He was good friends with Bronte
And he was funding the Pinkertons
He sent them to Saint Denis
I tried they said that i need a nitro
Well it's ok with this name
do you ever get accsess to blackwater
cus theres an entire town that for 4 chapters ive never seen
no spolies pls
i know arthur dies and that is all
4
oh in that case
u can go there after arthur dies
jhons not wanted there?
Hey, how can I play with a ps5 controller? Epic games purchased
Nope! You can go into blackwater and new austin during the epilogue
He's not wanted there
With a ps5
Yes but if u try to go to new auistin and black water as arthur normaly u will be a chese with 200 holes
But u can go there as arthur
yes
i play every game with pc and ps5 controlleronly rdr
İf u care a bounty with u on ur horse law wont attack u but font go to the towns for dont get to close to law
U can get the best pistol for exapmle
The otis miller's revolver
poor kieran took holding your head in you hand literally
Whats everything i need to do before starting the epilogue I'm trying to 100% the game
To get 100% it requires a few online trophies
Im talking about 100% not platinum
you can do everything even at the end of the epilogue 2 there aren't missable things for 100%
No stranger missions challenges legendary fish cigarette cards nothing is time sensitive?
Oh yea don't you also need to do tasks from the gang while your arthur
most stranger missions aren't time sensitive, enough to fulfill the requirement for ingame 100%, legendary fish aren't time sensitive and neither are cigarette cards
well someone already told you that there aren't permanently missable things for 100%, do you just want someone to copy and paste that message again?
you can do everything even at the end of the epilogue 2 there aren't missable things for 100%
Bet
They were protecting a train that was getting stolen, i dont think the pinkertons and US army are related anyway
The gang got on an army train and started robbing and killing them
The soldiers arent wrong for protecting their train
the train had the army's payroll on it, also even if they are corrupt soldiers the gang is still plenty worse in that chapter alonr for blowing up the fucking rails at minimum
@empty lark are your server roles ‘Best In The West’ and ‘It’s Art’ just for being active in the discord? Or for getting the achievements/trophies?
i just got a train and escaped the cops (so i have no wanted level) what should i do?
You actually have to get them in game
Could you give a link to where I go to get the roles plz? I’ve got both trophies
#roles read them
It tells you how
Thanks👍
Np
the games called redemption for a reason
just because he helped 5 people it doesn't mean that he is a good man
20 years of being a criminal ≠ redemption
He wasn't a good man, even if he did redeem himself towards the end a bit, but also, that's how he survived. He would not have survived had be not been stealing and become outlawed. Falling in with dutch probably had some to do with it, though
No mom, no dad, no other family other than Dutch and Hosea when they found him
I can agree, he isn't a kind character, but his character arc, and the way he was written, is
I agree. I think the conclusion to his story was done beautifully. The gang truly did matter to him all the way up to the finale.
He always accepted the consequences of what he did straight ahead.
Sadie’s a bada$$, just did Mrs Sadie Adler widow
I got a main mission with John, oh god, is this the last mission?
I won’t give away any spoilers - all I will say is that the last mission is not marked as a John mission on the map
Spoil away, this is my 2nd playthrough
Ah, gotcha
I spoilered the message so that people who haven’t played the entire game yet wouldn’t have it spoiled, but it deleted for some reason
It doesn't allow spoiler messages
Makes sense ig
I can't remember the last mission character, but the name is american venom
So if you look on it, and it's called american venom, that's the last story mission
It may be either sadie or Abigail
Well, that’s the last last mission - I think Adores is talking about last Arthur mission (in which case it is a Dutch mission in the chapter six gang hideout - not gonna say the place name just because I feel like it kinda spoils the start of chapter six if you haven’t played the game before).
American Venom is Abigail
OH
The last mission for arthur is 'our best selves'
I believe it's a dutch mission
What is every golden gun in the game like the midnight pistol
so how do you get a beard back after the ferry mission bc it hasnt grown back
You have to wait ingame days
You also dont have to trim any hair you can just style it
I suggest buying and using hair pomade
Maybe i didnt spend enough time at camp but i didnt know that Molly and Dutch were a couple until after she died
Welp my horse died and I don’t have horse reviver
LMAO
Yeah
Yup, that’s the mission that just popped up
Here we go I guess
Good luck soldier
No because I’m actually gonna cry when I start the mission
Hold on
Have you visited the porky family?
(The incest ones at the farm or whatever)
I did
If you let them take your money, you can go back as John to get it
I plan on doing that before that mission
They’re both dead already
He’s got that 20k coming when I go rat hunting
Slayyy

Fr
Me questioning how Arthur didn’t give John his money
Idk, probably because it was likely on his person
Or John spent it in the years between arthurs death and the epilogue
so i have collected nearly 2k but i dont really know what to spend my mola on
i got a perfect loadout and all the accsessories from the gun shop
Climbing a lighthouse for Sadie, the things I do for her
Back at camp for the very last time, I’m actually gonna cry again
I'm doing the san denis bank robbery. I'm gonna cry
Hosea and lenny, my babies 💔
I’m playing as John now 😭
😭
He’s gone, it’s over 😭
Exactly how I felt the first time I played that mission
Literally sat and cried on the phone with my friend
is there any downsides to using split point ammo
Are there any upsides?
should i switch out the brass on my lancaster or gold?
the 0$ in arthurs pockets:
LMAO
he gave it to tilly
not really any big upsides or downsides to using regular, split point, or express ammo, deadeye drain is easily solved with tonics and not wasting time
and headshots i guess for what little they restore
Increases xp gain and damage
i am so mad that the donation at saint denis is locked because of a bug
uh what happens when im on the random island
TAHITI
no guarma
is it just me or does micah look like discount buster scruggs in the bank job in saint danis
if charles or javier dies im revolting
Im convinced i could hold out forever if i had infinite ammo and canned food
Against the police
Hi
Howdy
So er how long do you spend at guarma like I want my guns and my horsy back
About 5 missions take place on Guarma
Few I had like 2k and 200 things to do
Had a list of sidequests as long as my hate for Strauss
Wait Lenny wasn't even twenty
Yes
Jaysus
He is 18
Dude couldn't even drink but was gunned down by the Pinkertons
In America I should say
U get ur staf after u get back to new camp and get attacked by pinketons
@fleet swift
Dont worry
every time i right click to aim with a gun near a horse,the game focuses on the horse and doesnt let me aim to shoot. any solution for that?
How to make John look like Arthur 😔
How many missions are in epilogue part 1? I don’t remember
Oh? The last mission I did was with the horse and draining it’s stamina
11 missions in Epilogue part 1, 12 missions in Epilogue part 2
yo i wanna buy a outfit but i don’t know which should i buy. is there one that’s the best or they’re all the same?
it's cosmetics, the best is your opinion
Which horses get 10/10 in either stamina or health? I know buell has 9/10 in both
Whatever looks good. Only legend of the east outfit has benefits I think
Story mode only
whats the best cosmetics mod to download?
Guys, I got spoilered the entire ending of rd2. How much have I lost cuz of that?
Ok so I tried a few times already to try to rob the back room of the doctor in Valentine.
Every time I draw my weapon in automatically shoots
How do I get the option yo rob?
*to
I mean it just says draw then automatically shoots. Idk how to.keep it from shooting after I draw.
you didn't lose anything, you actually just gained knowledge earlier
I am a professional artist. Anyone who needs logos, emotes, overlays, or any kind of work, message me. And this month, I have a 30% discount on all my work.
Just tap the draw button
Dont hold
About to go rat hunting 🐀

Guys
Is it worth doing all the side missions
Tbh some of them are annoying
Idk if I wanna do them
Oh ok. Because it seems to be like one of those load things. It advances slowly in the square. The white line I mean.
Yeah it does that for me too I just tap it tho
I beat the epilogue and this guys still looking for Gavin 😭
If u want platinum
Ok thanks. I tried using tab but it didn't work.
I guess I have to be fast at looting the pistol too so I don't get caught by the lawmen.
Heyy, i'm starting the game(a bit late...i know) but is it really useful to eat? What happens if i don't ? and how often do i need to eat/drink?
so kieran wasnt part of the van der lins during the blackwater masacre so couldnt he collect the money in blackwater if the gang trusted him
how far in are you
guarma
and that would mean lenyy and hosea would survive
hell sean mightve survived
well hes dead so....
i know that i mean earlier in the story he couldve gone to blackwater and took the money before anyone died
true
then they couldve ran away to tahiti
I feel like he would have not been able to do it on his own
well its not like the pinkys wouldve been looking for him
like as long as he kept his cool he couldve walked in grabed the money and walked out
Yeah, kind of, the game is more immersive and encourages you to hunt more and stuff, plus your statistics can change depending on your physical condition, but nothing happens in the story.
In the story, little, in emotion, a lot.
so im back on the mainland how do i get my money and shit back because i had ALOT
and my horse is lost?
You'll get them soon don't worry
few, spent alot of time and money on my guns
Same, I was desperate to think that all the work I had put into getting them went to waste.
is there any jobs in red dead that i can do to get money
uhhhh bounty hunter?
Collector is also really chill
is there a way to turn down how much guns sway
Eat hella pineapples and baked beans, smoke cigars for dead eye core and you ever only neeed to eat when health stamina or dead eye core is low
someone please tell me low honour arthur kablomos molly
i fucking hate the tratorous bitch
LENNY is dead
Arthur doesn't
And she wasn't ever the rat
then why would she strut into camp bragging about how she killed dutchs best friend and a child
agent milton couldve just made it up about micah
But he said Molly never snitched, and Micah had. Micah was always the snitch, and dutch even knew in the last chapter. He realized
Anyone using rampage trainer
Yes?
When does Arthur throw out Strauss?
there’s a “drunk mode” with a value. How tf do you turn it off?
micah: how a little groveling can overturn 20 years of loyalty
guys , at the beggining of chapter 2 you gotta make some missions before starting to explore and collect?
not necessarily
Than why is not the white arbaian horse near the lake? I even verified the files
u have to do the hunting mission with hosea first
you will get it after you do the mission with reverend and the mission with uncle
and the bar fight mission
Ah got it , thanks mate
Is it better to hunt for food pr to buy it?

Should I use John’s horse (Rachel) to go get the white Arabian?
I bought the black Arabian from the Saint Denis stables last night so it’s my active horse
who broke the wheel
Chapter 6, after his 2 missions
alr
What should I do first with money?
Honestly, I usually just upgrade all the camp stuff first thing
Anything you want tbh, the camp upgrades do not matter at all
I mainly just buy tonics, clothes, and upgrade my guns all the way
I just like the fast travel map
Guys
What
is there any mods that give me double side holsters?
Exactly, I love this game but I am not going back and forth on my horse 😂
Especially as John when you unlock black water and new Austin, takes forever to get to Saint Denis or annesburg
you guys dont have the "fast travel" option when camping?
In like chapter 6, you get it
But you have to upgrade your camp yo get it earlier
I don't understand why ppl buy clothes and customize weapons when u can spend your money on helpful things
May I
Because I like to customize my Arthur/John
I want my character to look different than everyone else’s, I also always shave and get haircuts for them
because the extent of "useful" things to purchase for any amount of money more than $5 i guess is two camp upgrades
hunted food is better than all store bought, tonics are unnecessary in every situation and you can loot bodies and some spots for them anyways
I didnt know this existed
Half my gameplay was riding horses to places
probably like 60%
Maybe im over estimating
Yeah! With the second camp tent upgrade, arthur gets a fast travel map in his tent, and you can then fast travel from a campsite
I always use stagecoaches tbh
I like the stagecoaches, but when I have a bounty, I never wanna pay it just to use the stagecoach
😭
Fr, depends how much money you have tho I guess
My arthur currently has... 12k?
It also depends how far it is away, the further away the higher the price
Maybe 13k. Idk, I like the stagecoaches but usually just fast travel
Might as well, it’s free 😂
WHY DO DYING ANIMALS HAVE TO SOUND SO SAD i just had a pack of wolves try to eat me one was bleesing out but i felt so bad and it looked so sad and scared it just tryed to eat me
i get really confused about who gives quests for some reason the quest where you free horses with eagle flies is given by swanson?
It’s just a matter of whoever you talk to first, even if that person is barely in the mission at all (like with Swanson, who has nothing to do with what happens during the main sort of that mission - it just so happens that canonically he’s who Arthur is speaking to when Eagle Flies arrives at Beaver Hollow).
Helloo
express or high velicoity
Does anyone know about the high stakes treasure? I have the first map, and I watched a video about where it is and how to get the treasure. My question is, do I have to get the other two maps? Or can I just go to the treasure without all the maps
Unfortunately, you need the maps
Fortunately, it's worth it
Game got stuck in fast travel, I just gathered everything for the legend of the east satchel and it's frozen.....
Is there somewhere I can buy another Bandana? This one is boring.
In story?
No
only in online you can buy another bandana
Breton Seal Brown: I have the correct file in the stream folder. When will this horse spawn and where ?
My sister just said she "prefers playing as John" even thought she's played at least 2 and a half hours on each character
anone wanna buy beta version of rdr3
I think pretty much all of the O’Driscoll free roam encounters only occur once, so
i got killed bc my health was too low
Y’all finished the game?
No
What chapter u in
Best chapters imo definitely 2 & 3. Worst is 5. 6 is 🥲. Rest & epilogue is okay
Youre going to get the game spoiled for yourself here

yeah guarma is too out of place
ch 6 is not bad, it is just complivated to understand
idc, I stopped playing in chapter 1
Thats basically the tutorial
It has its purpose
and it's cool, well, i wish it was a little longer, and that you could do more things in colter
I thought this game was above stuff like that when i first got to that part
Felt very stereotypical video gamey
I stopped playing when I saw Arthur's face
you stopped playing when you bought the game
Real and true
you stopped playin when the game was announced
yo, is there any (possible and not-cheater) way to get the golden revolver with arthur? (forgor the dudes name)
Playing guarma feels like they put uncharted in the middle of this game
i killed some parrots in guarma, just for the feathers, when i arrived at the mainland, they were gone- but they could have used guarma for a lot of other things, like you could go back there with john. and see that it was a completly different place, with stores, saloons, hotels
Otis Miller’s revolver? No I don’t think you can without cheats
what is the best ending. just completed my second run with low honor retrieve the money and felt very disappointed
Good honor and staying to help John
Idk if im a bad person or not but i find it so hard to keep the honor
Like i lost honor because i beat the Mexican sharpshooter in a bird shooting contest. Didn't know that losing was a honorable thing.
Real bro
You’re not, it’s so difficult to keep at max
I just beat the last mission and holy shit that game is peak
Please check #red-dead-media and help me
imo its not that hard just dont be a jerk
Hi, fellas. I am kinda new to the game. I noticed Arthur just keeps coughing more and more lately, is it because i dont wear a coat at cold weather? I have been hunting near ambarino lately.
.. 👀
if I redo American venom can I get Micah’s guns
what chapter are you on?
you don’t have to redo
how?
just go where he’s
yeah
you’ll find it there
I’ll look it up, but Ty guys
Recently got chapter 4
it’s where u killed
I don't wanna get my arthur sick thats all, i will feel pretty bad
just play more it will make sense after ch 5
trust
bro mark it as a spoiler 😭
That sounds ominous 
😔
.
I hope i didn't catch tuberculosis from going down on uncles ass during that cutscene
trust
yo i didn’t helped that one woman..
who’s borrowed horse died
i tried to help her but
i took her on my horses back with me and i was going opposite direction for 30 sec only but then she got off of my horse and ran away ..
will she respawn now? i wanted to help her
do y'all know if the Elemental Trail 1 treasure guy despawns if shot down from his rope
for context I managed to shoot him down as Arthur but I got off the buggy and the New Austin sniper slipped a good shot in
also lmk if there's a better channel for this discussion
shiiit i missed the mission of men and angels fuckkkkk
I think I might be in love with Sadie.
Marry her
She’s in #general
Scroll up
Anyways
Is there some good bugs you miss if you update the game ? Like going back to guarma etc
And what they added between the first version and the actual one
I heard something about being able to make custom weapon lockers, so you carry only the weapon you actually use
Also how many weapons do you normally carry ? Of each type, don’t dare tell me “59”, like 14 guns 8 close range etc
Excuse me
I'm not sure
That would be a question for google
I assume you can have as many as you want on your horse/in your weapon locker
Uhh all of them but I use 4
“All of them” man I asked for a number 😭
I meant like
14 revolvers and pistols
16 heavy weapons (the ones that get carried on your horsey)
Etc
U can Carry all of them
I KNOW
i just want the number
I already played the game yknow
And 100% everything except the map and side quests
But it was 6 months ago so I forgor
And that save is gone
I use 2 pistols, a shtogun and a rifle
I've alr spent way to much money to making them look cool so I don't rlly care abt guns lol
Skib
I had 2 semi autos
A semi auto shotgun
And a lancaster
But I think I’ll update my game
well there's 64 items in the weapons compendium
I'm sure you can hold more if you pick up worn versions of each weapon somehow
or buy a second one of each, like two cattlemans
that sounds miserable to sort through if you had them all on your horse idk why you'd want to do that to yourself LMAO
even though I basically did it by going around collecting all of the knives and axes
unfortunately the game hecked me over and I didn't get to get the blade in saint denis
You cant
Since if you have all the weapons, the worned up ones discard when you mount your horse
Tho, the game hecked me over too and threw away my fully customized repetition carbine when I accidentally picked up a worned up one early
Low
High
High, it’s better
innnnit


What do u need to do to unlock the “lending a hand” achievement?
Do all the optional honour missions
ALL?
Yeah
can’t i miss few?
There's like 10, it's not hard tbh
ok but i failed to help that woman who’s horse dies in the middle of the road
Oh, it's not that.
i accepted to help her tho
There like proper missions.
Search up a guide and you'll see all the names of em.
And when they appear
oh ok bro ty
Np
she ran away bc i didn’t went to her location fast
could i find her again tho?
she wanted me to go to emerald ranch
Do whatever you feel like doing, I think what you choose to do might change
is there a way to remove the gun belt in epilogue yet
maybe using the grizzlies outlaw outfit gun belt

yeah u can but u have to play a bit more to unlock character customization
All, there’s 16 of them

Hey
I plan on 100% the game, like a true 100% with everything
But idk if I have things left
Since I’m pretty sure there is flagged spoiler words
I’m just gonna do a reddit post
Pluh
Links are not allowed
If anyone wants to help tell me I’ll dm you my list
Since you also cant use spoiler marks
I sure hope the gambler challenge 8 wont brutalise me.
It will
Trust me
This challenge is horrible
Also was I the only one who doesn’t know how to play cards but still managed to pass missions about it
Like I just did random stuff
And got it first try
Great I guess
Well looks like Im in a real big dandy then partner
is the platinum worth it?
Yes
Im not going to attempt it
just did rdr2 100% damn..
where do i find them, is there a video on yt or somewhere ?

is it normal that when i completed it i jus tstarted killing everyone?
Probably
Anyone had any experience with rampage trainer ?
guys i’m on the second to last mission should i wait and do everything i can as arthur?
Hey guys my uh white arabian got killed if I go back to lake Isabella will it spawn again
I think if you go back to one of them stables or whatever they’re called (where you buy, sell and upgrade horses) it’s there alive and kicking
Not sure tho
I tried it's not there
If I go back to the lake won't spawn anymore right?
Ya’ welcome
yea it spawns back just gotta give it time
because u can get it again as john when u finish the game
So I can get it the second time as Arthur righ
yh well i got to at least
You got it the second time?
u haven’t saved since it died?
yea I havnt
But I
Didn't save it before aswell
The last time I saved it is chapter one💀
aight man thanks
np
Anyone know how many missions in chapter 2 before the Hosea hunting one? I’m trying to get the white Arabian asap
Should become available after like 3-4 chapter 2 missions, it’s a very early mission
do u have the link? if yes dm me it
yep, i think most players do it, even those who helped john escape during the rdr mission
Will the item requests by gang members trigger again if i miss it, Don't progress and wait? (For example Abigail asking for 5$ to buy jack some clothes)
yeah your honor doesn't matter in the epilogue so its fine lmao
lol alr should i do a new game or play it again
Isn’t the hosea hunting mission for the bear?
Do uncle than javier
U will unlock to remove sadle
I prefer you to wait till the blacwater mision than get the tiger strpied bay mustang in new austin
U can have arabian as john
What's the best time to explore as John in the epilogue that'll make the most sense story wise?
I have a plan
i have a plan
Hey man uh I tried checking there was only wolf's there
After the main story missions are done
idk then bro
Nvm found it
We're going to Tahiti
Im doing my second play throught rn, im in chapter two some mission after the downes one. And he start sweating, this is so saaad
I’m doing a second playthrough, I’m in another country with my family, playing it a bit so I re-familiarize with the game (I played it 6 months ago, unc deleted the save) and then since he gave it to me (yessir) and that now I have a ps4 I’ll gladly re-do a 100%
Btw, I have a list of everything for the true 100%, and a list of all combined effects, price and mats required for the things that give effects ifykyk
Ping me if you need them
Since they contain flagged words and would time me out 5 minutes
First time I didn’t get it
Like I beh he just coughed
And after I got it
I can still hear it
“Mayyy III,
Stand unshaken?
Amidst, amidst the crash of the worlds…”
guys i’m about to finish my 3rd playthrough i’ve already helped john twice should i do the money ending
yh ik it is but im low honour anyway
even if i help john it won’t boost my honour enough to get the best ending
i regret everything
at least i made a separate save copy so i can go get high honour and help john again
👍
Fr
Always do that
I put the right before last mission save at the bottom
So it wouldn’t be touched
i’ve got 2 save files from after i finished my last boy
Also btw
Dont forget two things
First the elixir for your cores
Always keep it for johnny
Second
Dont forget to transfer your money
Go at the home with the inceste bros
And get drunk and eat bla bla
Theyll steal yo money
Then with johnny go back
And get da money
well i’ve already started the epilogue so
Not a single penny less
Ah
It will be behind a painting
i’ll js make another save
imma js go get the white arabian back first that’s all i care abt rn
Skib
The black horsey exists too
Yes I am responding an hour after
The black horsey is better than the white horsey
But the grey horsey is better than the black horsey
Also don’t forget you can get a free extra speed bar from winning two horse races with the random man
Also dont forget to get a perfect panther pelt
You can use the bait you get early in the game with hosea
The big predator one instead of crafting one, dont waste it on the legendary fazbear
Get a springfield shoot that panther right between the eyes dead eye
Give it to the trapper
Best saddle and comes with the best stirrups
personally i had boar saddle whole game
pretty similar stats
Had the panther one whole game
i eat ur family :3
dont bring dutch into this..
13/90 challenges atm, working on gambler
I lost my white arabian today
I kicked a wagon and caught the lamp which set me and the horse on fire
Devastated
you can get it back from lake isabella! just wait a few days
Does anyone know why I'm suddenly able to run inside buildings? (Hotel, saloon etc)
you can run inside buildings only if you're chased by the law/enemies
Yeah but I can run up the stairs in the hotel now, and to the room lol
How do i see which fish ive already caught for survivalist 10, im at 14/15 but im unsure which fish i still need to catch and i dont wanna have to go all the way back and catch each one again
You'll catch them bro.
Hell yeah.
i bought game yesterday and i have story 20% completed...
Good, you mention that for some reason?
nah idk why i mentioned lmao
Oh, well, in that case enjoy, i guess. X)
yea
should i play as low honor or high honor?
im trying to get high honor but idk its kinda hard
The ending rewards you for that work bro believe me.
Hell yeah.
I played low honour not knowing what it would bring me 😭
Sad
Also tip for new players
When you have something expensive to sell like jewelry
Sell it only when you need money
Because taxes will follow you even in the game
And if you die you get taxed a maximum of 200$
Ikf
oh that’s useful thanks
Np
Learned it the hard way
And also
When saving manually
Never save in the first slot
This slot is for autosaves
In case you want to go back because you killed the horsey for example
Autosaves will overwrite your manual save if in the first slot
i didn’t know manual saves existed lol
can i post spoilers here?
I have finished but idk bout other ppl
i think spoilers are allowed
of the pinkertons
i have a question, if i didn't get "Friend with benefits" trophy, can i still get 100%
pikertons its like the police?
or just another band
another band for a saw or remembr
also the last part of the island where arthur dutch main boss and another dude were all pointed to guns
who was the other dude a traitor?
I dont think so
bruhh, i don't wanna start all game again
i think you might be able to though? missables arent really included im pretty sure?
private investigators/army, not really that lawful
i think in the current times its illeagal for pinkertons to work for the us like law or something?
yeah, i also think so
i see
if it's so, i just can get 100%, create a new game and get that trophy
and that guy was a traitor?
in the part where all were pointed with guns and you kick the shotgun to the guy on the floor
the dude who dies there
(in the part where the last one had a bombard i killed it from a lowground for sure a bug, its just a pixel)
that's the guy who got captain
fussar's dude
aight so no traitor
the only traitor for now its the woman
who you kill
i mean the old lady kill
molly?
yes
the game its fucking great
i just little lost with all characters and names
but i got it i think
i just started last chapter
i cant remember that part or its spoiler
but i see the girl not being
traitor but its dead
ok sorry
its fine
i have 15 years playing competitive games and only that
first time following a lore its very hard for me lol
so the indian dude its the traitor
i mean no the other
also las one how many finals the game have?
*ends
@tender stream how can we get accurate answer to my question, it really bothers me a lot
with that trophy
okay i went on a bit of a deep dive, found out it's not needed
so you're good
not needed either
bro u saved my ass
i'm at 90%
i'll get "Legend of the West", create new save game and get those 2
just finished the game, i knew arthur was gonna die but man that shit still made me tear up
fuck dutch
In rdr1 we really smash him

can’t wait to kill him in rdr1

i lost my horse that hosea wanted me to buy at level 4 bonding..
in a bear attack i tried to throw a fire bottle at the bear but instead i accidentally threw at my poor horse

whats the best weapon in story? (not revolvers, for real fights with many enemies)
im on chapter 3 on my second play trouygh
and?
I’m on chapter 2 and 2nd play through!
nice
i’m thinking to go for 100% this time wby
same
im in chapter 10, just completed the 6 playthrough
Guys can someone help me with minimal spoilers
play with high honor
Only need to know something regarding endings and honor
arthurs death scene is better then
Yeah so i need that bar full by the ending
That's all that matters for the best possible ending?
Arite i got it thanks bro
the best way in my opinion is to play low honor 1-5
and then in chapter six you get high honour
its a grind to get it, but it just shows the redemption arthur gets
So i can fuk around all i want the first 5 chapters
yes
And get honour up when i start 6
Doesn’t need to be completely full, just needs to be on the high honour end
I don't play games more than 1 playthrough so just want the best experience first time
Thanks yall
completely full unlocks a gun
also, when youre in the chapter 6 before the mission "my last boy" please do the money save trick
What is that and is it important?
in the mission youll get put in jail and the cops steal all youre money
which gun i can’t find it for free and must buy it from gunsmith?
on the map theres a house and when you go in there the couple living there will poison ya
then they steal youre money and put in behind a painting
so after the mission you can just come back to collect youre money
are you having some hallucination
Okay
I'll keep that in mind
if you only plan on doing the story, not in the slightest
if you dont, still no unless you looted every piece of money in the game for some abominable reason
you get $20k for finishing the story

