red-dead-singleplayer

[oak apex]

okay thanks

i love to kill everyone on my way but is it better to play with honor ?

[blissful garnet]

different ending

different dialogue lines

minor gameplay changes

25% off at any shop when maxed though

[hidden moss]

Bro got the fastest horse for free, and said bad choice.

You leave it?

You can't 100% after the epilogue unless you've done all stuff that can be missed at least.

[blissful garnet]

not the fastest

[hidden moss]

You get some different cutscenes, well, not entirely, but different animals in some, and get a big discount int shops, plus a specific grip for your revolver.

[hidden moss]

For free? It absolutely is. It's also a very easy find on top of that.

[blissful garnet]

"fastest" and "fastest for free" is not the same thing

MFT is the fastest horse

and is also free

[drowsy spoke]

One of the fastest for free yes, even the fastest Arabian? No

[blissful garnet]

so what u said is not valid

[hidden moss]

Bro is calculating exact words.

Has a take I've never heard before too.

[drowsy spoke]

Hell, not even entirely the fastest for free, you can get the black arabian in that one Rhodes story mission

[hidden moss]

There's not really bad decisions in RDR2, and choosing that horse definitely is not one of them. Especially for the "size" being the reason.

[blissful garnet]

no

it's dark bay turkoman

[hidden moss]

Yea, but for right away and a guaranteed spot, it's pretty damn solid.

[blissful garnet]

you can get black arabian if u catch lemoyne raider burning a building in saint denis

[hidden moss]

Until you can save up some decent money.

[drowsy spoke]

Won't deny that, got me through a majority of my first playthrough

I do find it a bit too cowardly though

[hidden moss]

Rather than saving up immediately for a faster horse, it allows you to buy guns and stuff that's more useful, while having a solid horse for a while.

[drowsy spoke]

What is this "stuff thats more useful"?

[hidden moss]

The smaller horses are usually a bit worse, but when they're higher level, it's a bit better.

[blissful garnet]

why not just get the MFT

[drowsy spoke]

Absolutely

[drowsy spoke]

Well I love the handling of arabians, and them getting scared can be a benefit when they don't buck you off due to the speed boost they get when spooked

[hidden moss]

Depends on the player. Could be health tonics, horse stuff, etc. I'm not saying it's hard to make money in the game, but I much prefer not worrying about saving up for a fast horse right away when going through.

[drowsy spoke]

Ah, I personally just steal off of bodies

[hidden moss]

Like isn't one Arabian like $1250 or something? That's a chunk.

[blissful garnet]

all horses have the same chance of bucking you off

it's complete RNG

[hidden moss]

Yea, I do too, but sometimes you're in a pinch and need to buy some.

[drowsy spoke]

Not true, I've had horses run over panthers and others that bucked me because of a snake

[blissful garnet]

it's

RNG

[drowsy spoke]

Larger horses have a tendency to be more brave, thats an actual hidden stat

[hidden moss]

Indeed.

[blissful garnet]

no it isn't

[hidden moss]

I believe they're also more of a tank for smaller damage.

Obviously not freaking bullets.

Just minor stuff.

[drowsy spoke]

A random stat to roll yes, but typically you'll be more likely to have a good amount of bravery on a warmblood opposed to a morgan

[hidden moss]

I've never properly tested that though as they're slower.

Much prefer smaller and more agile horses.

[blissful garnet]

no

[hidden moss]

I don't crash it enough.

[blissful garnet]

it's RNG

as a "stat"

it is the same for every horse

there are however external factors that modify that

the most important one is the bonding level

and also spamming G to calm the horse can help

[hidden moss]

Right, yea that's right.

It's not a stat.

[blissful garnet]

like

do u know when u approach a wild horse

[hidden moss]

When it's leveled up, it's more uncommon it gets spooked I think.

[blissful garnet]

u have to press G to calm him down?

the spook bar

[hidden moss]

Like it becomes better chances.

[blissful garnet]

that's what happens to "bravery"

[hidden moss]

But I don't think it's an outright stat.

[drowsy spoke]

Well supposedly its a hidden one

[blissful garnet]

yes

[drowsy spoke]

It would explain why some horses keep going where others at the same bonding stop and buck you

[hidden moss]

I also think having it's health full and energy full help some, but not entirely sure. I notice when it is, that the horse is better because you aren't worrying about it slowing down and staying too close to the animals.

[drowsy spoke]

But anyways Im not saying a horse that gets scared more often is a bad thing, the speed you get from a spook makes it worth the occasional buck

[blissful garnet]

u can't create

2 identical situations

to test that out

[hidden moss]

Especially when being chased.

[blissful garnet]

when the horse is spooked you get a speed boost

[hidden moss]

Really? Damn, I gotta bring a fake snake in my satchel.

[blissful garnet]

when u re riding on tracks or in town, max speed is lower

[hidden moss]

Yea, avoid tracks.

At least go to the side of them.

Not directly on the tracks.

[drowsy spoke]

I assume thats kind of for realism, though ideally you wouldnt even want the horse to be trotting on hard surfaces like that

[blissful garnet]

also i believe someone made a chart

for horse speed

[hidden moss]

You wouldn't want it to, but sometimes there's no choice.

[blissful garnet]

and for the max speed, they all go between 31-32

except for MFT that goes up to 32-33

km/h

what would set them appart would be handling and acceleration

and obviously the max health/stamina

[hidden moss]

I usually use train tracks for a quicker cross rather than a giant roundabout or escape lawmen.

[drowsy spoke]

Either way, the in practice speed difference is actually very minimal

A 7 speed horse is almost identical in speed to one with 9, though they will be slightly faster

[blissful garnet]

after using thoroughbreds (cause i liked how they looked) i can't say i saw a difference in speed

compared to arabians

[drowsy spoke]

Handling, acceleration, health and stamina are all unparalleled with the rose grey araabian

[blissful garnet]

u can't get that as arthur

unless modding

and MFT is the fastest horse in the game

and u can get it in ch2

[drowsy spoke]

MFT is the fastest, but you also agree that speed isn't a big factor

Acceleration would take priority, since getting to that top speed is where the most visible difference lies

MFT is also great in that regard, which is what makes it such a great horse

[blissful garnet]

that only matters for like

how much

3 seconds?

[drowsy spoke]

Speed will matter for 2

or even 1 depending on the difference

A 2 speed horse takes about 12 seconds longer to cross the map compared to a 9 speed horse

Shires aren't even that bad of horses, handling and acceleration aside because of this

[blissful garnet]

shires are the biggest horses

[hidden moss]

arthurs ex

reaal

[drowsy spoke]

Still cant say no to her, I feel like doing that hurts Arthur even more

[plain needle]

if i fast travel with a pelt on the back of my horse will the pelt disappear or will it come with me to my destination

[candid parrot]

π

[next venture]

Does anyone know if you have the ardennes and the Arabian for example and I call one out from my stable and then bond with another horse in the wild or whatever and I lose either the Arabian or the ardennes while hunting or whatever will they just show back up in the stable? Or would I have lost them? I really wanna try hunting with 3 horses but I'm too afraid of losing one of my stabled ones.

[fallen parrot]

Very complicated question.

[next venture]

Yeah probably just gonna have to trial and error it but figured I'd give it a shot.

[fallen parrot]

If you are asking if you can have 3 horses that is a yes.

But the other part I am just lost in.

[next venture]

I'm guessing if you lose the one that is not saddled it probably is just gone. But if it did just reappear in the stable that would make things a lot easier.

[fallen parrot]

That is right. If it isn't saddled it is gone.

But you can have 3 horses in the stable

[next venture]

So you have 1 horse saddled. The other one in my case the Arabian is my temp horse. I then bond with another horse in the wild. While hunting or whatever somehow I let the Arabian get to far and lose it. Because I had it stabled before I am wondering if it'll just still be back in my stable or if that horse will just be lost.

Yeah alright I was guessing that was probably the case.

[fallen parrot]

Alrighty

[blissful garnet]

didnt even know

you can get for free

2x cattleman, double action, schofield, sawn off and volcanics

before doing any mission in ch2

[hidden moss]

It stays on your horse. The only way you lose it is if it gets knocked off say via a big pelt and your horse falls or sometimes there's a glitch with loading back into your game with a giant pelt on it (giant as in bear, moose, etc).

[hidden moss]

It doesn’t disappear it stays on the back of your horse

Bolt Action and Carcano

[tall minnow]

where the hell does the opossum spawn??

I'm doing the hunting requests and got everything except the opossum

[hidden moss]

Near Riggs station

South of it

and ring neck creek

oh yeah make sure it’s night time

[tall minnow]

alr, hopefully it'll be there

[hidden moss]

The opossum was brutal for me

Couldn’t find a perfect one

Had to force spawn for 3 hours

[tall minnow]

ok so

I didn't find it there

I found it near the owanjila lake

the river part

[untold lily]

Rdr2 is the best game ever

[restive moon]

Facts

[untold lily]

I’m sorry I just had to say it

I keep seeing so many comments saying it’s boring or too long

[restive moon]

Yeah

[untold lily]

Like what??? My attention span isn’t great but damn

[restive moon]

It is slow paced but that’s the point

[untold lily]

I loved every second of it

[restive moon]

yesss

[untold lily]

It’s a nice change of pace having a game that is longer than 15-20 hours

Especially for $60

[restive moon]

yesss

bc then you don’t speed through it too fast and then it’s a waste

[shell totem]

Am I not able to change John's honor when I play as him?

[hidden moss]

Wdym

[shell totem]

When you get to the epilogue and play as John. I've been doing high honor actions but doesn't seem to go up

[hidden moss]

Oh yeah you can improve your honor

I’d recommend fishing

[shell totem]

Maybe its just slow then?

[hidden moss]

Good way to improve it quickly

[shell totem]

its still gray..

[hidden moss]

Yeah

[shell totem]

I'll try that, thank you :)

[hidden moss]

Good luck

Greeting people and fishing is the best way

Though it takes a while

[hidden moss]

Did you finish the epilogue?

Or nah

[shell totem]

Not yet, I'm on epilogue pt 2

[hidden moss]

I recommend you finish that first

Once you’re done start going after legendary fish

You’ll get a big boost in honor while actually working towards something

[shell totem]

I'll keep that in mind, thanks again!

[hidden moss]

No problem

[blissful garnet]

for the people thinking

that you get a lot of money from all the treasures than u dont have what to spend on

all the money would be roughly 11-12k $

if you purchase all clothing items, you will be left with around 1,5k

[deep turtle]

I found it (opossum) over by the abandoned oil rig. But only one spawns per night.

When do certain weapons become available and where? I've almost finished the game and no carcano, no repeater pistol M1899?

[steel spoke]

You get the carcano in chapter 6

M1899 can only be bought from Saint Denis gunsmith

[blissful garnet]

what weapons can you get

within chapter 2

dual cattleman, double action, schofield, volcanics is achievable for free

springfield can be bought from gunsmith

bolt action from Curtis

rolling block from hosea (steal after pursued by a bruised ego)

semi auto from watson

double barrel from six point cabin

rare shotgun from a hermit

am i missing anything?

[ionic bay]

Does anyone know if there is an app that would allow to me explore the games audio/dialogue files on PC?

[blissful garnet]

the audio files need to be converted

the soundtrack is purchaseable on their website

if u want it as a file

otherwise, get the audio files you need from youtube or manual recording

[blissful garnet]

.

[ionic bay]

Oh ok.. I’m more just looking to listen to all the dialogue. Not interested in the music.

[blissful garnet]

searching on youtube would be your best choice

[hidden moss]

What happened to Arthur in that house💀

[hidden moss]

He got touched

😭

[cold carbon]

I love Peggle

[blissful garnet]

.

[west ore]

I'm at Chapter 2 atm and did few story missions, I'd like to do everything possible before moving on to next Chapter. Is there any mission in particular I should avoid?

[deep turtle]

You can always exit the game w/o saving if it is going to advance to Ch3.

Looking for a Robin and a Chipmunk.

[steel spoke]

Just avoid the main missions then

[blissful garnet]

if u want to be stuck on the last mission in ch2, dont do the mission when john is at auction yard

also, i wouldnt go for the bounties (benedict albright) if u want to get the talisman from new austin

[versed tide]

Lancaster from rhodes gunsmith's basement encounter

[blissful garnet]

is that the only one?

[fallen parrot]

Most likely.

[calm night]

what should i do for my 2nd playthrough?

[valid cypress]

you can get a rolling block????

What do you mean by "steal"

[dapper schooner]

Yo someone please help I’m playing rdr1 and my joysticks are reversed

[dapper schooner]

please

[distant egret]

whatever you didn’t do in your first play through

[valid cypress]

interesting discord name

[hidden moss]

Do everything you can

[distant egret]

it’s reverends ip address

[zinc geyser]

does anyone know why the legendary coyote wont spawn, ive completed all other legendary animals on land apart from the panther, coyote and the New Austin ones. ive returned to the area of the legendary coyote and it wont show anything on the top left of the screen showing that it is a legendary animal area and whatnot. ive tried returning there mutliple times (leaving some ingame days in between) and it still refuses to show anything that im in the area of a legendary animal

[twin herald]

bruh i hate tempest rim im trying everything but i cant get to the area can someone help idk how to get up ther'

[zinc geyser]

you literally cant

i mean you can but not without glitching out of the map

[twin herald]

dang

i just wasted like 40 minutes on it ;-;

i wanted to explore it so i can get the stuff off the map

[spring plume]

What if i did everything already?

[hidden moss]

Have you tried hunting it recently? If you failed you need to wait 72??? In game hours (a few in game days)

[calm night]

so nothing

[distant egret]

well you actually can’t do EVERYTHING in one play through

there’s a lot of side activities that can’t be discovered without playing multiple games

[valid cypress]

whats micahs?

imma doxx micah

blud dserves it

[clever sinew]

enjoy with cheats?

single player*

[zinc geyser]

wdym by hunting? Ive gone to the area recently and nothing has shown up on the top left of the screen saying that im in legendary animal territory if thats what you mean

[hidden moss]

If you have tried looking for that animal before (recently) you need to wait for a bit to try again

[grand crater]

No I live with Micah

Don’t doxx me

He lives in my walls

That fucking rat

[valid cypress]

damn

get a rat trap bro

[karmic prism]

yeah i bet 90% of players dont know you can save bill from bounty hunters in chapter 2

[calm night]

He doesn't get captured, atleast o me

[distant egret]

i found him captured over near where the geddes farm wouldve been and had to save him with javier

don’t know if the location is randomized but it goes to show how impossible it is to find every interaction

gta 6 needs to be exactly like that if not better

make so much dialogue so that there will never be a point where you can’t find more

[pale wasp]

I’m in the epilogue 2 - does anything happen after you kill the saint denis’ mayors butler?

Like is there more missions

[candid parrot]

If you dont kill him

He becomes the city mayor

But is really bad at it

And if you kill him

[pale wasp]

Damn I knew I shouldn’t have killed him

[candid parrot]

Go fishing next to the mayor's mansion

[pale wasp]

Is there more missions after you kill him? Or is that it

[candid parrot]

You might find his arm

That's it

[pale wasp]

Damn

[candid parrot]

You get paid for killing him though

[pale wasp]

Yeah

I’m just at like 85% completion and there’s no more missions popping up so I’m bored ahh

[candid parrot]

Just do the challenges

And hunting request

After you complete hunting requests it gets fun

[pale wasp]

Aight bet

[candid parrot]

Because of the small small side quest

[regal cobalt]

I just started the game but if I accidentally scared of the white Arabian horse. Will it come back or do I have to restart the game?

[fallen parrot]

It will come back.

[regal cobalt]

What’s to trick to not being bucked off?

[fallen parrot]

I don't even remember the last time I was "breaking" a horse. So I don't remember.

[random zealot]

Knee closure and being in sync with the movement 😉 sorry, couldn't hold back

[plush light]

.

[deep turtle]

Which ever way the horse is turning while bucking, pull the reins the opposite direction until the "you've broken the horse" announcement. Then feed, groom and pat horse a to get your bonding up a bit, then saddle up. repeat as necessary, lol.

[tall minnow]

how tf do you do gambler challenge 8

[toxic knot]

Suffer

[candid parrot]

Patience

And you need huge skill

It all depends on skill

[tall minnow]

really?

cuz it seems like im getting 9s and 10s as the cards and cant hit

im very sure its luck

[toxic knot]

It’s all luck

Skill won’t really help at all

Jack black isn’t like that anyway

You need some strategy

Like not hitting when you have 17 or something

But that’s about it

Know when it’s safe to hit and when it’s not to

[hidden moss]

If I set Micah on tnt will Arthur survive?

[reef swallow]

where do i post story and spoiler at

i need some questions answered 😒

[cinder viper]

here

[reef swallow]

i did but it got removed

[cinder viper]

do not use caps or / spoiler

[reef swallow]

ah i see

hi I have a quesiton regarding the story of red dead 2 and 1 so After u kill micah and get back to farm what happens to john just see 2 pinkerton taking him in or whats going on , just started the red dead one but i still dont get why im not at blackwater for example

[pliant hollow]

By Killing micah jonh was found by the pinkertons at the ending of 2 by the begining of 1 hes beaing blackmaild to catch his old gang members by to pinkertons so they wouth'nt hurt hus family

[reef swallow]

Okay I see now so he just now protecting his family

[twin herald]

hi

why is the state of new austin on lockdown even though the pinkertons already knew that the gang was in ambarino

[tall minnow]

the robbery in blackwater went wrong and ppl got killed

ig it made them wanted dead or alive

[twin herald]

it would of made mote sense for the state of ambarino to be in lockdown since thats where the gsng and the pinkertons knew they were there

[reef swallow]

did sadie adler go to South America at end of rdr2 or did she die somehow?

[cinder viper]

if you watched the credits, you see her leaving

[reef swallow]

yea i didnt do that I was googling how to play rdr1 on pc

[cinder viper]

Rdr1 it's not on pc

[reef swallow]

i know its on switch

[cinder viper]

And PS/xbox

[blissful garnet]

You can take it from hosea's horse

[regal cobalt]

The white horse is not back even after I did a mission.

[regal cobalt]

I did it finally, had to play a few missions then go back and camp out a night.

[feral terrace]

Urm can someone hgelp me

nvm

[karmic prism]

short answer: gameplay
long answer: r* needed smth to do in the epilogue so they just gatekept new austin from the main story entirely even if it made no sense

they werent even wanted in new austin, blackwater is in west elizabeth but arthur can still go to strawberry

and john had never been there before rdr1

[tall minnow]

its been 2 days since ive been doing gambler challenge 8 help

how do you this shit of a challenge

[gilded scarab]

I remember I did that in 1,5 hours, take your time, have some patience and you will get it eventually

It's all about luck to be honest

[karmic prism]

thats the funny part idk how i did the gambler challenges

all of them and i still dont know how to play any of the minigames

[gilded scarab]

I learned poker and domino due to that lol

[reef swallow]

tbh I love the part in rdr1 where u dont fight and do the ranching stuff more tahn the actuall gameplay

Guess i like the story between abigail and john to much

[toxic knot]

Just say your problem

[west ore]

Is there any point in maintaining camp supplies?

[tall minnow]

not really unless you want honor

[tall minnow]

well than it means i have very shit luck

Ive been doing it all day today AND NOT EVEN 1

[outer bloom]

For those of you who did the noblest of men and a woman as John, what books did John say that Jack read in the mission "the wheel"

I noticed that they said the book name about Jim boy calloway

[twin herald]

thats what i got as well

[reef swallow]

Finished rdr1

What happens to jack after u finish the game

are there any like hints?

'or are we left to wonder for the next rdr game

[twin herald]

apparently he is an author of book there is a book somewhere in gta i think in franklins house or something

[reef swallow]

i havent playd gta 5 in like 7-8 years

or so

[twin herald]

the book is called "red dead" as well

[reef swallow]

some reddit post think he remained on the ranch and lived there and ran it

if he ever meet someone is unclear

[karmic prism]

not really you can just assume everything you do after the game is canon

at lot of people think he fought in the war but i dont think he'd let himself be drafted given he hates the government with a passion

[reef swallow]

So we just gotta wait for next rdr game which will probly be in 2050

at this point

[twin herald]

i doubt any more games will be about jack

[karmic prism]

yea but i'd love to see it

[reef swallow]

Well there will probly be hints about him in the game

Like side missions

books

[twin herald]

yeah probably

[reef swallow]

in the game etc

I'v never been this invested ina family ina game before

[twin herald]

i just want a new red dead revolver somethigns thats in the middle of the wild west

[reef swallow]

my biggest annoyance with rdr2

[karmic prism]

fanfiction territory but him meeting 50-something year old red harlow would be chef's kiss

[reef swallow]

is that no matter what weapon u buy, mission forces u to use specific weapon

Like I didnt know who john was when i first played rdr2

Since I never played rdr1

so I was just on the Arthur train

[karmic prism]

i thought dutch was gonna be the mentor figure that dies early when i first played lmao

how wrong i was

[twin herald]

its like the opposite

[twin herald]

mine is the guarma chapter i was so excited only to find out you get sniped while trying to explore

[karmic prism]

its weird that end of ch4 forces you to use cattleman

but since im a cattleman user already it doesnt bug me as much as other people

[twin herald]

i use m1899 pistols super good for hip fire as wlel

and varmint as well

[reef swallow]

First time playing rdr2 i was loving dutch

and then end of game im like

[reef swallow]

I BOUGHT that rifle to hunt animals nothing else

[twin herald]

its good for combat as well idk it just feels very nice and accurate

[reef swallow]

I will not bother with rdr online

so I already uninstalled both games so I can fit something else on my tiny ssd

[karmic prism]

yea i wish you could uninstall rdo to save some space

i know it mostly uses story assets but i've never played it in my life

[twin herald]

i only play rdo for achievements

it couldve been something good

[karmic prism]

that too why do online achievements count

i'd have the 100% if not for that

[twin herald]

i just need 2 more single player achievements skin deep and the grin and bear it achievement

i missed the guarma animals so i went out of bounds

[cinder viper]

the guarma animals do not matter

[twin herald]

wait what

i thought they did

[karmic prism]

well if you want a full compendium they do but theres no achievement for it

still good to keep it full

[cinder viper]

you don't have to study the animals in guarma for zoologist

[twin herald]

oh

well im already on guarma so yeah i might as well get them all

i just need the fer de lance snake

[west ore]

Wait, isn't that a mandatory mission?

[twin herald]

its a random encouneter

[toxic knot]

After 4 hours I got the legend of the east satchel and the snake vaquero saddle

God damn

[long agate]

@eternal hawk yo

[humble ore]

Hi there, could someone help me with Money Lending and Other Sins I + II please? That's the one with three debtors to collect from

I've got a question, I can either trigger the third part right after collecting money from a single debtor, and possibly get back to the other two later (they effectively become side missions), or I can collect all three debts first and only then donate to camp funds and trigger the last part with Downes. Is there any difference in profit? Do I get the same money from the other two debtors if I get back to them later? Thanks fellas

[toxic knot]

You get the same money

Well, should

I haven't tried it out personally, but it doesn't make sense for the other debts to not give you the same yields if you do the second mission before or after you claim the other debts.

[humble ore]

Thanks. I checked the wiki but tbh it left me confused. I also check the official paperback guide (great book btw!) and it literally says "You only need to go after one of them to complete the mission, but taking care of all three will lead to a better payment" ... So that's where I'm at, not really sure because they could mean you get more money overall, or just from that mission, which doesn't rule out the option of collecting more money later when they become side quest

[toxic knot]

When I read that, I interpreted it as meaning that it is only required that you get one of the debts, but if you claim the other debts, in total you will get a better payment.

Anyway, you should be fine. Don't worry about it.

The money you get from the missions isn't all that much tbh. I think it's like 40 or so dollars, which you can get easily.

[humble ore]

Yeah, the question is whether they mean in total within the context of that one mission, or in total in general.

[toxic knot]

Total in general, I feel like.

[humble ore]

I know, it's just my immersion and completion OCD. And I hate reloading so i better decide now! 😄

[humble ore]

Hm, that would mean I'd better check all of them before returning to Strauss for the Downes cutscene. Thanks

[toxic knot]

Relatable, yeah. I collect all of the debts, though I never had to worry about the sequence in which you do the missions.

I didn't even know there was an official guide.

[humble ore]

I see. You just went to all three of them first and then went to the camp, that's what you mean?

[toxic knot]

Yep.

[humble ore]

There is and it's really cool, recommend. The only issue is, it's one of those on release guides, lots of pages, lots of good info but with sucha huge game you never know if they got everything right. Because they had to write it so it was ready for the release. There are some neat stats like food calories, it's really detailed

[toxic knot]

I'll check it out, thanks.

[karmic prism]

strauss makes barely any money anyway lol

i could go out rob a store and make twice what his debtors usually give in less than half the time

and not contract a terminal disease

[steel spoke]

omg I really want that

[flint shard]

I just the panther clothing item I’ve done 4 missions into chapter 2 (this is my 4th play though because I messed up and couldn’t 100% my last save)

[plush light]

I have played over 500 hours of Red Dead story mode.

[left sedge]

What is perfect snake skin used for

[toxic knot]

If you get 10 of them you can get the best saddle in the game

[left sedge]

Isnt the panther saddle the best

[toxic knot]

the panther trail saddle and the snake vaquero saddle are interchangable

I say it's the best saddle because it goes with every horse unlike the panther trail saddle

they pretty much have the same stats

except the snake vaquero focuses on the health core iirc

[sterile magnet]

Wheres the on story gang atttt

[sterile magnet]

Lit

[slate laurel]

Can I go back to the casino boat after the mission?

[untold wave]

No

[slate laurel]

Damn

I heard something about there being a watch on it

Like not the Reutlinger

[analog wave]

Brev....on my 6th play....I only now realized that you can quick draw by holding R2 like whenever lmao I thought it was just for duels😭

[distant egret]

how the hell

[hidden moss]

The boat specifically comes in for that mission. Whoever said this is speaking out of their ass.

[hidden moss]

I-

[toxic knot]

lmao

[lone quest]

bro i wanna get the sheep cloak but i don’t wanna loose honor
are sheep only in places like farms? or are they in the wilderness as well

[fallen parrot]

Sheep are only at farms. You won't loose that much honor by killing them

[lone quest]

o alr

thanks brodie

[undone ore]

if i killed a legendary animal, do i have to pick up its body too after skinning it?

[untold wave]

no

[undone ore]

okay thank you

[gray plank]

DLSS is so trash in this game

you can see ghosting on birds

and overall a blurry image

[pseudo ferry]

FSR is blurry too. It's don't thinks it DLSS or FSR rather the shitty implementation of TAA. Rockstar has abandoned the game in favor of GTAO and GTA6. RDR2/RDO won't likely be patched again considering how longs it's been since either received a patch or new content, respectively.

[hidden moss]

Why does lenny die?

[sterile magnet]

He gets shot by two of miltons men.

In the middle of escaping the pinkertons.

There is no way to stop him dying sadly.

[hidden moss]

Mario gonna cry

[sterile magnet]

💀

Lol

[hidden moss]

What if you use a modern weapon to delet them from existance

I mean a modded

[sterile magnet]

I think the game would bug out.

There is a chance though.

But the story is lenny dies so its like a 15% chance

Actually

Probably not

[west ore]

I love how bounties are wanted alive... so that Sherrifs can hang them themselves lol

[sterile magnet]

😂

[steel spoke]

People should see them

[gray plank]

drunk dude asks me to look after the crashed wagon. Does he ever come back?

Screw it am looting the bastard's wagon

[toxic knot]

Lol

Whenever I see that NPC I either ignore him or just kill him

[analog wave]

I think you lose honor if you take anything so might as well lose honor blowing his brains out

[gray plank]

The blackwater general store cashier wasnt there so I looted the store and the cash register without any consequences until he spawned in not knowing a thing lmao

free 30 dollars ig

[left sedge]

Theres nop way to revive my horse right

it kinda caught a gattling gun to the head

and I miss my white arabian

[hidden moss]

You don't HAVE to, but they fetch a good price.

[hidden moss]

I remember one time, I pre aimed and I'm pretty sure I killed both of them before they shot Lenny, and then he basically just had a heart attack 😭.

[hidden moss]

It's more of justice to the people and to show that they don't tolerate criminals, even petty ones. Then worse ones, they just have them killed because the townsfolk know they aren't worth the hassle of being brought back alive, and even if they aren't killed, it's a slim chance they'll return with that kind of bounty on them.

[hidden moss]

If it's next to dead and on the ground dying, you can use a horse reviver. If it's straight up dead and there's no prompt and it's not moving, no. Also, the White Arabian respawns. I think the time is 3 days.

[left sedge]

It was like me and him both died

and i respawned with a different horse

I assume hes gone gone

[hidden moss]

If you died when it was even downed, I think it classes as a death.

You can check the map to be sure, but I'm pretty sure it's dead. Just wait 3 days and go get it again.

[left sedge]

Im aboutta tweak bro

is it worth going for another white arabian

Actually Ill do the flaco hernandez mission and get it ig

[left sedge]

So hypothetically speaking if one was in chapter 3 or whatever the Rhodes one is and tweaked out and commit genocide and got like max low honor, would it be difficult to get high honor by the end on the game if that one person wanted a good honor ending

[dark fern]

I just stole the saint denis sheriff's hat and it won't register as stolen why?

[hidden moss]

You only need to get past the middle. You can just talk to people all around Saint Denis and look for little events/encounters. Such as the blind man, hurt people, etc.

There will also be stuff during the story to get honour, but you may miss the good honour parts if you're that low.

[hidden moss]

Like to keep? It probably isn't one that can be kept then.

[dark fern]

Trying to collect every sheriff's hat

I'll try going to beechers hope to see if that's how to save it

[hidden moss]

Yea, it probably can't be kept.

[dark fern]

😔

I'll still try

[hidden moss]

Google isn't saying anything either.

Is it that tall round hat?

[dark fern]

No

It's like a police officer hat

[hidden moss]

I looked up sheriff hat and those ones are showing.

[dark fern]

The ones on costumes

Kinda looks like that

[hidden moss]

Is it the flat cap one? That the mustache guy wears?

[dark fern]

Yes

[hidden moss]

Alright, give me a second.

[dark fern]

It won't save 😔

[hidden moss]

Yea, Google isn't finding anything about the hat. I don't think you can keep it.

[outer bloom]

Boys

[hidden moss]

You can try saving your outfit with it.

[dark fern]

Alr

[hidden moss]

Store it on your horse maybe.

[outer bloom]

I may or may not have found a potential glitch

I haven't tried it out yet but in theory it should work

[hidden moss]

One of those ways may work. You'll have to swap outfits to test, so do both first. If it pops back on, it's kept. So make a proper outfit with it.

[hidden moss]

Huh?

[outer bloom]

I believe that you can get both variations of the whitmore outfit

[dark fern]

I guess I'll ss it and go onto the next sheriff

[outer bloom]

You can do the poker mission with either honor, I would personally go with the opposite of whatever you are trying to do with your playthrough

So if you are trying to do high honor go with low honor

Trying to do low honor go with high honor

Then the st Denis bank robbery is the whitmore outfit

So if you did high honor for the poker heist go with low honor, if you are doing low honor for the poker heist go with high honor

Again I have not tried this out yet so save your game before you do this

[dark fern]

Well I can get Malloys hat

So I should go for Armadillo next

[outer bloom]

Although you can take them you can't save them

Other than malloy's because it's the Nevada hat

I tried to do it with calloway's hat and save it as a custom outfit but it doesn't save it

[vital path]

How do I get a all black outfit

[outer bloom]

Everyday shirt-black, opulent vest-black, everyday pants-black, either classic roper boots or wingtip gaiters in black, dress tie-black, either clean stalker hat in black, rodeo hat, or Nevada for the hat, and for the cost go with the black rambler coat from the farrier

You can get the farrier as Arthur with social club

If you can't get social club then use the cost from either the Drover (honor 6 to unlock and be able to buy) or the Deauville (also honor 6 to unlock and be able to buy) if neither of these are possible use the duster coat that I believe you get after Eastward bound

Also the farrier is honor 6

Positive of course

[outer bloom]

If any of you actually try this please tell me if it worked

[toxic knot]

That doesn’t sound bad

#red-dead-fashion send it here

Ah got it

[left sedge]

So my white arabian died is it worth the effort getting another?

[toxic knot]

What chapter are you in?

[left sedge]

3

[toxic knot]

I’m not sure if it respawns but I’d wait until chapter 4 so I can get the black Arabian

[left sedge]

It respawns pretty sure but is the black arabian as good?

[toxic knot]

The black Arabian has better stats

[left sedge]

Fr?

No it isnt

Its slightly worse

Ill just wait for the black arabian ig

[toxic knot]

Pretty sure

Same speed and acceleration

But the black Arabian has better health and stamina

[left sedge]

How do I get it in chapter 4

Just the stable?

[toxic knot]

Saint Denis stable

[left sedge]

How helpful is the first lodging upgrade

Encourages other to pitch in

Is it like alot

or like not much

[toxic knot]

I never really noticed much of a difference

[left sedge]

Thats what i expected

[toxic knot]

Aren’t the lodging upgrades Dutch -> Arthur -> Then everyone?

[left sedge]

Yeah

[toxic knot]

I didn’t know there were more lodging upgrades

[left sedge]

Dutch encourages others to pitch in more

it says

[toxic knot]

Alright

I see

Yeah I didn’t notice much

I just bought it because I’m a perfectionist

[left sedge]

Im a perfectionist in a realistic way

I am not 100%ing this game

But the camp I can do

[toxic knot]

Fair

Hm I rarely do camp upgrades

I’ll probably start crafting stuff there

I’m not sure if it’ll do anything

[tulip pumice]

why does every one hate micah he a cool guy

[coarse coral]

[tulip pumice]

Why what he do fr

[coarse coral]

He took everything away from Dutch

[tulip pumice]

What how

What u mean

[fallen parrot]

You'll see.

Just keep playing the game.

[random zealot]

How is he cool? He's racist, full of hatred, misogynistic and a total asshole and those were only the vibes he gave me just after strawberry 😂 but I really love to hate him, it's fun, he's an interesting character

[tall minnow]

i was so close to finishing gambler 8 challenge, then the dealer won against me. I tortured the whole town of rhodes, im feeling awesome!

[gray plank]

I fear a rdr2 update?

[distant egret]

i just finished with the hamish missions

now i’m sad

[untold wave]

You finished it after ch6 right?

[hidden moss]

Hopefully...

[toxic knot]

The worst thing ever

[toxic knot]

I’m gonna look for the Perlino Andalusian

Looks nice

Decent stats

[distant egret]

during chapter 6

why

[toxic knot]

Say bye to Buell

[distant egret]

ima stash him in a cave in black water and get him back in epilogue

[hidden moss]

Well enjoy that m8

[sterile magnet]

Can u get the white arabian in like CH2 onwards

?

[oblique summit]

ehh

[sterile magnet]

?

[toxic knot]

You can get it in chapter 2

Why?

[sterile magnet]

Just asking

[twin herald]

hi

[sterile magnet]

Hi

[slate laurel]

What should I do before the mission "Our best selves"

By the way this is my third playthrough

[outer bloom]

Sell all your valuables

Go to to Aberdeen pig farm and take both drinks

[slate laurel]

I already killed them

[outer bloom]

Then do the mission after you wake up

Ber

WHY

[slate laurel]

Silver chain bracelet

Hehe

[outer bloom]

You can get it from one of the treasures maps

BRUH

Try to see if they will respawn

I already killed the hermit guy and he has respawned multiple times, and I already have the map

[stable root]

Hi, has anyone here had problems completing the western stranger achievement? In the total completion screen the strangers part is checked off but i havent gotten the achievement yet.

[untold wave]

Ch6

[stable root]

chapter 6+ only

[untold wave]

Don't complete it yet

Leave the whole mission for john

[hidden moss]

Do Panthers only unlock in Chapter 3+?

Because I'm on Chapter 2 and trying to get the Panther belt but no panther will spawn.

Tried both locations mentioned on the reddit post

[left sedge]

Ik cougars jumped my ass in chapter 2 but i am in chapter 3 and I have not ran into a panther

Think they are just rare tho

[hidden moss]

Yeah I got mauled by a cougar up in the northwest, too 🤣

[simple bronze]

I got jumped by a cougar and I'm in chapter 3

[hidden moss]

I have been sitting at around the exact location above LA and nothing yet.

I put down potent predator bait on the road and sat there overnight..... nothing

Even set up camp and waited again til night, sat there, went AFK to get and eat food... nothing still

Thought I'd come back to me being respawned somewhere from getting mauled overnight but nah

Wtf game :/

[left sedge]

I gotta get a panther pelt

For satchel

Such a grind

[hidden moss]

Ikr, such a damn pain

[left sedge]

I need a boar badger beaver racoon some more deer 1 elk panther cougar wolf

and I think thats it

Ill probably go for boar and racoon and deer soon

Panther cougar wolf and like beaver gonna have to wait a little

[hidden moss]

Still surprised how I managed to find an Iguana

Since a guide said they only spawn in New Austin

Which would mean I'd need to wait til I can play as John for that, which would omit basically 90% of the story AFAIK

[left sedge]

No they are all over the island

right next to clemens point

[hidden moss]

Clemens Point?
Edit: Ahhh right up the Western coast of Rhodes, gotcha 👍 Thank you

[left sedge]

Yeah

That island there

I just heard an NPC get jumped by a cougar

Lmao

LOL

Im balling out 2 perfect deer and a cougar

Gotta go back to camp

[hidden moss]

I finally found a panther!

Yeeeeeet

I was cruising down to Old Harry Fen, when I saw a panther spawn in the forest

Just between 'Harry' and the F of 'Fen', follow the crease down. It was right between the splits of the terrain and in the open area below it

[left sedge]

Is it perfect?

So I need 1 elk 1 buck 2 deer 1 panther 1 bison 1 racoon 1 boar 1 beaver and 1 wolf

Thats not the worst

Elk deer and buck arent gonna be too bad

Bison is gonna be kinda annoying

racoon is too

boar is easy

beaver idek

[hidden moss]

No, even though I nailed it in the head with a bolt action rifle with Nitro rounds

[left sedge]

and wolf idk

[left sedge]

RIP

[hidden moss]

Was it possible it was because I didn't study it first?

It creeped up on me, my horse bucked me off. I had miliseconds to shoot my rifle at its head before I got turned into mincemeat.

[left sedge]

I just dont think it spawned as perfect

if it was a headshot with a rifle

[hidden moss]

When the dust settled, I went up to its body and it said 'Big Cat'. I got a direct, deadeye headshot with rifle straight between its eyes, practically hitting its snout

[hidden moss]

Worn Born-Action Rifle, Nitro Express rounds

[left sedge]

Yeah thats enough for a perfect

as long as it was a rifle to the head

Thats how I just got my cougar

[hidden moss]

That actually hurts a bit

I really wanted a panther, just a perfect panther, not a poor one :\

[left sedge]

Got another perfect deer 1 more to go

Got a perfect buck

[toxic knot]

Are you going for the satchels

[left sedge]

Yeah

Now I need

1 elk 1 deer 1 panther 1 bison 1 racoon 1 boar 1 beaver and 1 wolf

Deer is easy

elk is easy

Bison is easy

Boar is kinda easy

Panther racoon and wolf and beaver

are gonna be a pain

I think

[toxic knot]

You can knock out a lot of animals around the strawberry area

Raccoon, boar, and beaver are there

Ofc the elk and deer

Wolf is also there

[left sedge]

Beavers are in strawberry?

[toxic knot]

Make sure to go around night time

[left sedge]

Damn ima have fun at strawberry

[toxic knot]

They are by lake owanjila yeah

[left sedge]

Why night time

For wolf?

[toxic knot]

Because that’s their most common spawn

[left sedge]

FOr all animals or wolf

[toxic knot]

Wolf

[left sedge]

Yeah thats what i expected

[toxic knot]

The wolf spawns at night

It’s almost guaranteed

Actually one sec

#red-dead-media

Check this in a bit

I’ll put the locations

[left sedge]

Bet

[toxic knot]

Raccoons iirc have higher spawns at night too

Not sure though

They’re pretty common around black bone forest

[left sedge]

So what im hearing

is panther is gonna be the pain in the ass

[toxic knot]

Ehhh

I’ll show you a trick

[simple bronze]

Can you rob banks?

[left sedge]

only on missions I think

[toxic knot]

No

Only in missions

[simple bronze]

Damn

Do you know the mission?

[toxic knot]

You can rob trains but not banks

[toxic knot]

Chapter 3

Sodom back to Gomorrah

[left sedge]

Chapter 3 robs valentine

[toxic knot]

Banking the old American Art

[simple bronze]

Awesome

I'm in chapter 3 right now

[simple bronze]

Who gives the mission

Nevermind

I just found it

[left sedge]

So I'll just fast travel to strawberry take some time to get all those tomorrow then get bison and boar

And panther is gonna be a little

[hidden moss]

Just discovered that there's a secret sewer exit tunnel underneath Saint Denis that the cops can't see / can't find. Perfect for escaping Lawmen in S.D. if you get wanted

Ironic that it's just like the tunnel in GTA where the cops won't know where you are if you go inside it

[toxic knot]

Me

I stay in Chapter 2, 3, and 4 the longest

then I rush through 5

and stay in 6 until I do some challenges

then I go to epilogue

[dark fern]

Won't let me visit That weird scientist dude

[left sedge]

@toxic knot Alright I tookm your advice and knocked out alot of them I just need boar bison elk and panther

then boom

[toxic knot]

Oh my bad

you can find boars in the same spot as the wolves

not sure if you looked for them but it doesn't really matter

[left sedge]

I didnt find any 3 stars

[toxic knot]

go to bolger glade

[left sedge]

But the bison aint spawning in the bison spot

[toxic knot]

there's a lot there

[toxic knot]

do you have the buck antler trinket?

[left sedge]

Yeah

[toxic knot]

damn

unlucky

[left sedge]

I got the wolf 3 star tho

So that was a good use of it

[toxic knot]

for the panther I place bait and hide behind a specific rock

I can show you tmrw

[left sedge]

Ight bet

Will like a bolt actuion or springfield do the job or do I needa use rolling block

[toxic knot]

if a animal doesn't show up make sure to save and reload the save

[left sedge]

Cause I hate that like the scope annoying

[toxic knot]

any of them are fine

use the bolt action

imo

[left sedge]

Ight bet

Then the rest just gonna take a little bit of traveling but other than that itll be easy

[sullen trellis]

No offense but I'm not really a fan of the game's story and characters despite how much I'm enjoying the game. It actually took me a whole month to finish the rest of Chapter 2 and I've mostly been causing lots of trouble from all over the place heh

[sterile magnet]

not just that the vibe is up in chapter 2 towards ch4 it gets shit.

like the end of ch3

[shy jungle]

sean dying destroyed the mood

[shell totem]

If I start a new game, will my current game be deleted??

[gilded scarab]

No

Start a new game and make a save in different window

[shell totem]

different window?

[gilded scarab]

When you are manually saving, there are few empty windows

[shell totem]

Ohh that

[gilded scarab]

Empty slots

[cinder viper]

if you disable the auto save, no

[sterile magnet]

Word

[fickle adder]

If i wanna get red dead and get mods can i do that on steam

[drowsy spoke]

yes

[sterile magnet]

Yh

Or RSTAR launcher

Any ig

[fickle adder]

Alr ty

[sterile magnet]

Np

[uncut pine]

after u take jack fishing as john what is the name of the next main antagonist (i forgot i the name)

[obsidian wharf]

Agent Milton

and agent Ross

Oh as John

the snake?

That bit Rufus

[karmic prism]

the amount of comments i've seen recently saying blessed are the meek made then stop playing/ruined the game is insane 😭

[restive moon]

What happened in that mission again? I forgot

[karmic prism]

breaking micah out of jail

[restive moon]

Ah

[left sedge]

I just wanted my 2nd holster 😭

[plush light]

.

[sullen trellis]

Is Micah really that bad?

Pretty sure we've done worse in-game lol

[untold wave]

He killed a child

[worldly turret]

w, children are stupid anyway

[sullen trellis]

Didn't we kill those kids in Saint Denis?

[untold wave]

With mods, yes

[sullen trellis]

And Shirako kept torturing that Feminist that got the whole game in hot water in the first place

Like, there's something about Rockstar games that brings the psychopath out of us it's actually scary

[untold wave]

I've killed the feminist in every playthrough

[sullen trellis]

Exactly

But I don't

Still, how is Micah worse?

[untold wave]

Maybe you've got a point

[sullen trellis]

I mean they're all outlaws at the end of the day so, idk

[untold wave]

Why do people think Arthur is honorable

Arthur killed many people just like micah

[sullen trellis]

Because Cowboy dude good or whatever

Because he's the protagonist or whatever

I don't feel much of a connection tbh. Barely going to the camp

Like, I'm just being Billy the Kid here lol. Just wanna fuck around in the Wild West

[untold wave]

Right

[tulip pumice]

yo micha just killed arther wtf im sobing

[sterile magnet]

Its alr.

The white arabian is better.

[untold wave]

Stagecoach robbery in ch2

[fading crane]

Arthur isn't good but hes good amongst bad people

[untold wave]

I mean for a guy who killed thousands of lawmen and killed thomas downes for loan money, he's not good

[fading crane]

He also helped a lot of ppl

[untold wave]

Killing is an unforgettable sin

[fading crane]

Hes like an anti hero

[fading crane]

Lawmen shoot first, arthur shoots back 🤷🏼

self defense tbh

[untold wave]

You call robbing a bank self defense?

[fading crane]

Arthur doesn't kill and hope if possible to not kill ANYONE when robbing a bank

he ends up killing people anyways bc lawmen shoots at him first

[untold wave]

What about those poor soldiers from ch6

[sullen trellis]

I kill people as Arthur all the time

How is Micah so different?

I feel like it started off as a meme that snowballed and everyone unironically believed in like how people think Verbalase is now bankrupt for spending 50k on some fan animation when his net worth is 2.8 million

All the characters are pretty bland tbh. I only like Hosea for his golden voice. What accent is that anyways?

[cinder viper]

"arthur doesn't kill" also arthur who beat a sick man for money, ruined the lives of innocent people, rob people, he killed a whole town after saving Micah

he is a good man

[sullen trellis]

There's a reason why they're called Outlaws

They deserve what they got

No one's good in Red Dead except the Native Americans and the other minority groups who are all caught in the crossfire

[cinder viper]

I'm not saying Arthur isn't an outlaw, I'm saying he isn't a good man

[sullen trellis]

I mean being an outlaw means you're not a good person to begin with

Like Jessie James and Billy the Kid

I feel like Arthur is that stereotypical "Just Following Orders" kind of guy

[cinder viper]

say this to the arthur crazy fans who think that after arthur helped a few people whose lives he ruined in he deserves the ending with high honor

[sullen trellis]

I wonder who's worse, Arthur or John?

I feel like John had the potential to be worse, then again every single gameplay I see online of John is always low honor

[fading crane]

as long as u didn't do anything wrong to him, he's a good man

as long as u don't give him a reason to, he won't harm u

[fading crane]

he deserved that ending, arthur said he were never a kid. Indicating that he has been taught to kill and rob people since a child

Childhood plays an important part of ur life, what ur father do or what u were taught to, you keep that for ur whole life

Arthur was taught to kill and rob since a young child, no one showed mercy to him despite all that he's still somewhat good and help people he believes are good

Arthur is a good man influenced by bad people

Arthur said he didn't want this life, more like this life chose him. Arthur is forced to rob people as he believes he has no other choice. His whole life influenced by bad ppl like dutch convincing him robbing is his only option

[fading crane]

^^^

[cinder viper]

I didn't make him to beat a sick man

[cinder viper]

he said he didn't want this life only after he found out he was going to die

[fading crane]

it was definitely before 💀💀

[fading crane]

idk if you've been bad honor arthur the whole game but my honor was kinda high and i remember him saying this life chose him

and he didn't want this life

he was forced to

[cinder viper]

he is still a bad man

and he probably burn in hell

if you help a few people with money just because you die, that doesn't make you a good man

[untold wave]

Tell that to Arthur fans

[celest dawn]

He is still a bad man

In a way

[golden sluice]

Hello, Pearson's all upgrades are maxed out, even resupplying multiple times but I still couldn't make the camp food full/yellow. Is there a fix to this?
Thank you.^^

[lone quest]

i just get more food honestly

like if i’m too lazy to hunt i just buy prime meat

[lone quest]

ong

[primal dawn]

he takes pleasure in killing

thats the difference

if arthur was the best man ever in chapter 2 it wouldnt be called REDEMPTION

[craggy scaffold]

DUDE

I was at Saint Denis train station a minute ago then this random women came outta nowhere and kept punching me 💀

For no absolute reason

[random zealot]

Your face looked punchable

[obsidian wharf]

Are there special clothes u can get on social club catalogue

[drifting coral]

Does anyone know where exactly i can find cougars for the hunting challenges i been going on the other side of owanjila lake but no luck

[sterile magnet]

Near blackwater.

The plains.

Or west elizabeth near there.

Strawberry etc

[untold wave]

The farrier

[drifting coral]

I been to the location it shows on the internet but idk what time they spawn

[untold wave]

Dawn or dusk

[drifting coral]

Ill try thank u

[crude needle]

Anyone know how to easily get an eagle feather or if I can buy one anywhere? I’m trying to make an upgraded tomahawk

Also

Nvm apparently I can’t say that

[karmic prism]

yeah you can get the john exclusive outfits as arthur via that

make sure you have cloud saves on, catalogue doesnt work without it

[toxic knot]

Look at the sky and find an eagle

[crude needle]

I’ve tried but i don’t see any

[toxic knot]

Hm

They’re really common

Go to west Elizabeth and go up to little creek

There should be a lot there

[crude needle]

Alr

[slate laurel]

I went to "confront Strauss" but he's not at camp

I saved and re-loaded and he's back

Well he's gone now

But for different reasons

[hidden moss]

Mountains. Go up Mount Hagen or Mount Shann, and you'll find a lot just chilling on edges.

[obsidian wharf]

is that only on pc

[karmic prism]

i think it works for consoles too, never tested it though

long as you have a social club acc

[boreal temple]

i have a plan

[vivid juniper]

one more decent take

one more big score arthur

one more train

and a whole lotta noise

and then poof

we're gone.

bro

im having a brainrot

[golden sluice]

Okay thank you; It’s really sad that the ammo or health can be yellow even not being able to be fully maxed out.

[urban panther]

vengeance is an idiots game

[tame osprey]

whats the better schofield+schofield or schofield+midnight pistol/ mauser

[gleaming basin]

Am i the only one here with Micah as their favorite RDR2 character

[distant egret]

cattleman + volcanic

[distant egret]

yes you very much are

[forest granite]

Hello, may somebody help me finding the panther for Arthur's satchel ?

I know it's at the left of Shady Belle, but I am roaming around and I never found anything

[left sedge]

I got mine south of brithwail manor

So what I did is I went here

Stood on the rock and placed some predator bait like right next to the rock

Nvm i cant send pics here

#red-dead-media

@toxic knot Im doing the tobacco mission for the braithwaits and my game keeps crashing know any fixes

[forest granite]

Tysm, I finally got it

[hidden moss]

can anyone dm me if they can help me with challenger 9 gambling, ik its a hard one but i fr cant do it cuz idk how to play dominos, dm me if u can help

[craggy scaffold]

hey yall ehh

Anybody knows where can I find a story book for Jack?

[untold wave]

Pleasance

[untold wave]

Or maybe at downes ranch

[karmic prism]

both work i believe

[toxic knot]

I know PC is really buggy

Sadly can’t help

[karmic prism]

usually rdr2 crashes have to do with social club disconnecting

[toxic knot]

Since im console i have very little problems with rdr2

[karmic prism]

because some asshat thought it would be fun to only let you play an offline game with a connection

[hidden moss]

can anyone help with challanger 9 gambling?

[toxic knot]

Go to the dominoes table in emerald station

[vivid juniper]

then shoot everyone in the head with a shotgun

[hidden moss]

bro i have been here for soon 4 hours and im standing up when i see that im about to lose, i cant win

no matter what i can not win

[toxic knot]

Also if you’re losing a match make sure to back out of the game

[hidden moss]

i am doing that????

[vivid juniper]

then shoot everyone

[toxic knot]

It’ll save your progress

[hidden moss]

i have also shot everyone

i ahve done that