#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 116 of 1

modern viper
#

Damn☠️

#

Idk

iron parrot
#

Petition for an alternative ending where if you donate 5000 dollars without cheating Dutch says “we can finally go to Tahiti!” And a cutscene plays where Dutch is farming mangoes

calm oasis
#

Just do all the treasures and take all the gold at the start of chapter 2 and you will have around 7k at the end of chapter 2

bitter heart
#

best way to make money in rdr2? for beginners

crisp cradle
#

explore, sell fat loot found while exploring, do main quests

hidden moss
#

What should I do with 3400 dollars guys :)?

spice tide
iron parrot
#

I’m having this strange bug where every time I try to put these 2 guns in a weapon locker, They don’t show up.
So basically I accidentally picked up a worn schofield and a worn cattleman and every when i open a weapon locker, They never show up so they’re stuck on my horse. It’s annoying when i get off and realize that my modded Navy is still on my horse

radiant girder
#

buy a schofield and a cattleman

iron parrot
iron parrot
wanton pier
hidden moss
#

Can somebody tell me when is the survivalist challanges unlock? İ am completed all rest of it but survivalist still locked at chapter 4

karmic prism
#

iirc survivalist shouldve unlocked at ch2's fishing mission

#

just go catch a bluegill that might solve it

quartz jewel
ancient rose
#

people still finding new things after 1500hrs = awesome.

abstract raven
#

i have 1k hours and i just found out where the cat skull mask is

#

on my 8th playthrough too

graceful wolf
#

hey what are the best settings in rdr2 for my rtx 3080 at 4k?

abstract raven
#

the highest ones

modern viper
#

Is it true that Theres a ROBOT in RDR2 map?

wise hound
#

mhm

#

but I think there is a mission for it to show up mayber? im not too sure tbh but ik there is one

lean obsidian
#

During that mission you're introduced to the robot, and after that mission after a day or two in game you can find the robot somewhere near colter!

radiant girder
#

found another wild hungarian halfbred outside of great plains

ancient rose
#

i'd leave that depressed robot alone. just saying.

glossy iris
#

yessir just caught the red arabian rcthumbsup

chilly cloak
#

W

keen birchBOT
#

||Click if Arthur sucks||

modern viper
storm bobcat
#

Even though I recognize I jumped out of nowhere pinging you, I just did the same (like a few mins ago), so yes, I understand your pain. I don't really have the motivation to actually grind everything back (I had everything as you did). I'm just trying to get over it and playing something different. The fun fact is that I was getting of another game to play Red Dead and I just did that oopsie.

#

I'll start it back when I feel like it and actually make more file copies.

karmic prism
lean obsidian
karmic prism
#

you can shoot him and shut him off yeah

hidden moss
#

I don't have the motivation to do it all over again

#

I'll maybe do it next week since I'm on break

#

this includes the snake vaquero saddle that took me like 3 hours to get

radiant girder
#

that's why you make multiple savesrcthumbsup

astral eagle
abstract musk
#

Test

#

Why the heck did my last message get auto deleted

cinder viper
#

Skill issue

abstract musk
#

I think it's because I posted a spoiler (though I put it in a spoiler tag), but I don't have access to the channel that lets you talk about spoilers...

empty lark
#

yeah because there isn't one

cinder viper
#

you can't send messages with spoiler tags here

empty lark
#

and messages with spoiler tags get deleted

#

unless it's sent by the amazing sheriff cicereius bot, or a mod i'd assume

abstract musk
#

Oh that's weird

#

Spoiler

I just finished the epilogue. I I'm frustrated that Abigail didn't leave John. He continued to hurt her even after she was begging him not to go chase after his pursuit of revenge. He's a good husband, but she deserved better in my opinion

cinder viper
empty lark
#

they would've had to get back together at some point anyways even if she did leave him after he went and killed Micah

#

unlike the other times though after he killed micah he also brought a fuck ton of cash home, more than Abigail could've probably gotten on her own

#

that is somehow entirely spent by the time rdr1 comes around

abstract musk
#

Well... This was before they were money management classes available, I suppose

#

I felt like it would have made more sense for Abigail to leave and never come back, and for John to eventually end up with Sadie or something

empty lark
#

Sadie isn't really a people person in the epilogue as she says, and seeing she never got around to settling down with someone in the 8 years that passed after Arthur had his final skill issue i doubt she'd even settle with John

#

did the opposite of settling down if anything, became a solo bounty hunter

abstract musk
#

Yeah I suppose that's true!

#

Kind of funny to think about how she HAD that family life before they rescued her lol

empty lark
abstract musk
#

I like that they made her a bounty hunter, it's like the perfect job for her

empty lark
#

yeah, serves her death wish perfectly

#

she went crazy after losing her home, not nearly as bad as with Dutch but she took it out on killing and hurting people against her so she got a job where she got paid to pick someone who will be against her and capture them

abstract musk
#

I was pissed when she shot the guy who John refused to hang (at least that's the choice that I made in my playthrough) but I also enjoy it when video games can make me pissed off like that

empty lark
#

Sadie doesn't even try to rest off the entirety of AV after getting a bad stab wound, despite the fact she's about to be up against Micah who is definitely above her skill level and not nearly as injured as her

abstract musk
#

Also I like her so much that she could piss me off a million times and I'd look the other way

empty lark
#

and the crowd supports you if you hang him in Strawberry

abstract musk
#

Maybe I'm too passive, I think I would even spare Micah if given the option XD

empty lark
#

then he'd take whatever he could to make it easiest to kill you as soon as you gave him the opportunity

abstract musk
#

Although I hate it when video games or movies don't kill characters that are obviously going to try to kill them later, so I'm a hypocrite

#

Who is your favorite character in the game?

#

John is mine, though my opinion of him fell a little bit in the epilogue lol

empty lark
#

probably Trelawney or Charles, Trelawney managed to successfully live two lives at the same time as far as the game lets on, never hear any bad news about him in the epilogue at least

abstract musk
#

I like Trelawny too, but I feel like the game didn't give us enough of his story for me to feel strongly about him

empty lark
#

yeah that's kinda his thing ig, if he's too involved with the gang then he might put his entirely unaware family in saint denis in danger so he's usually absent

abstract musk
#

He has a family? Guess I missed that or wasn't paying attention

#

Though it took me like a year to finish this game so I might have just forgotten XD

winter sequoia
#

What was the estimate take in the last train job our best selves? Anyone knows

quartz rampart
#

My horse just died in the stupidest way ever

#

I hae this game

#

hate

#

damn it

#

his name was Lenny

weak quarry
#

Hello, quick question, can i get the florida panterh during or after the epilogue?

toxic hawk
karmic prism
#

even if you knew how much the army paid there'd be a lot of assuming

karmic prism
#

he's a criminal but so are all of them she had no right to judge him

radiant girder
radiant girder
#

got wanted for unarmed assault for getting punched

#

didn't punch back

abstract musk
#

Rip

cinder viper
hidden moss
#

I’ve decided to do another playthrough

#

That I won’t accidentally overwrite

radiant girder
#

oh my lord

#

game likes to force move your horse if you're in the way of something like a wagon

#

except it kept force moving me into the back of a wagon

#

i was going with the flow of the traffic too

#

i love this game but it makes me mad so easily

radiant girder
#

ok dude kept force moving me and eventually ran over my horse

#

and i get in trouble for killing him

calm oasis
#

what is the best saddle in sp?

empty lark
#

panther trail saddle

hidden moss
#

However, the snake vaquero is somewhat grindy

calm oasis
#

Eh...

#

Damn it..

north swan
#

snake vacquero is 10 perfect snake skins and is slightly worse

calm oasis
#

yeah but...

#

if I go back to hunting panthers, Imma tear out all of my hair

#

its been such a pain in the ass

#

99% of the time nothing and then when it finally showed up, it ate me

north swan
#

my strategy tends to be constantly checking eagle eye, they usually make a big roar / growl once you're somewhat close.

#

Keep a bolt action rifle or bow w/ improved arrows in hand.

radiant girder
#

@calm oasis yo

calm oasis
#

ohhh, I remember now, thanks

fleet kernel
#

WhyEm dlc

calm oasis
#

eh?

rare cipher
#

How do I do Sharpshooter 3? Whenever I get on a train, my horse chases the train like a dumb dog chasing a car, and it usually dies when this happens because blindly runs into objects and over cliffs. It does this even if I hitch it somewhere. I thought maybe if I stable the horse it can't follow me, but when I stable the horse it won't give me access to my rifles, which I need for to shoot the birds.

empty lark
#

try choosing a train at train tracks where it wont run into anything, like at the valentine station

rare cipher
#

Do you have to shoot all 5 within the same time? I got on the train at Emerald Station after it started moving, climbed on top of a car, targeted 3 birds while in Dead Eye which I shot at (using the Carbine Repeater for its fast shoot rate), jumped off and rode off on my horse before getting any bounty at all. But when I checked the challenge progress, it's still at 0 out of 5?

radiant girder
#

pretty sure you gotta get all 5 at the same time

rare cipher
#

No, I figured out what happened. The carbine repeater didn't actually kill any of the birds. 🤣 Switched to Springfield Rifle. Got one on my first ride, but jumped off after that because I was already wanted before I shot anything. The one registered, so now I just need to do it a few more times.

karmic prism
#

i find the panther saddle only really works on the amber champagne or buell

radiant girder
#

fr

#

snake vaquero is honestly the best looking saddle

#

especially on horses that are the same color as it

astral eagle
radiant girder
#

should i get the reverse dapple roan nokota?

dull echo
#

game told me it couldnt confirm ownership and rockstars fix didnt work

karmic prism
#

has a higher speed stat than majority of arabians

#

downside is bad health stat

calm oasis
#

Could someone help me get perfect panther pelt?

radiant girder
#

use potent predator bait

#

also buck antler trinket if you don't have it

calm oasis
#

yeah, I tried that, reloaded the save file multiple times, it just wont come out

#

it did once but it was a 2 star

calm oasis
calm oasis
#

Finally

#

Sweet Jesus

radiant girder
#

i got $18krcthumbsup

#

bronte glitch just gets better and better

heavy leaf
#

I played this game again today, just started from scratch

#

It’s amazing, forgot how good it is

viscid hound
#

Is red dead redemption two getting undead nightmare?!?!? Or am I just out of the loop as to why the discord banner is like that

empty lark
robust sky
#

just overheard micha and bill talking and found out bills real name is marion

#

i had tp search it up cause i didnt believe it

#

turns out its true

empty lark
split hinge
#

Does anyone have an actual location for 3 star opossum because I've been searching for hours

alpine chasm
#

havent been here for a hot min.

rotund yew
#

What did he saiddddd

hidden moss
ripe marsh
#

I just discovered you can get legend of east before chap 3

#

Without finishing bandit challenges

#

But is there more glitches you guys know?

ripe marsh
calm oasis
#

You can drift with stagecoaches????

#

I love this game

gritty fable
calm oasis
#

How do I do bandit 10 ?

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

Has a ton of them crawling around at night

#

Another good spot is ringneck creek

tiny matrix
#

I just finished the story with Arthur , and I played sometimes with John, I leaved the game and now I'm playing as Arthur again, I thought it was saved 🤷 I guess he don't want to die 😅

calm oasis
#

What animals give fat?

prisma karma
#

Probably uhhhh bison

#

Idk

#

Or like just big animals

empty lark
#

boar definitely give fat

prisma karma
#

Ah okay

calm oasis
#

I have 17 bottles of gin so I wanted to make some fire bottles

#

I suppose bears also give fat, but I refuse chasing all over a bloody mountain just to get eaten at the end

narrow anchor
#

weird question but is there any information on who voices Trelawnys family in Saint Denis?

ornate socket
#

well, its october

karmic prism
#

elk are probably the easiest to find

narrow anchor
#

boar are everywhere around the Braithwaites place

hidden moss
split hinge
calm oasis
#

Also, what is the fastest way to improve honor

#

I want to buy a coat but I need positive honor for that

hidden moss
#

Or just spam greet

karmic prism
#

^

#

it's a long process really but says a lot

#

it's easy to ruin your reputation in 1 day, it takes weeks to earn it back

versed osprey
#

on my second playthrough, are the bounties that pop up when youre Arthur still available as John?

radiant girder
#

yeah

hidden moss
versed osprey
#

coool

#

trying to save as much for John as possible but i sometimes get conflicting information on what is or isnt available post-ch6

wise pendant
#

the legendary cat fish exist?

calm oasis
#

Only in game files

#

You can't catch it

calm oasis
#

It was originally supposed to appear in the Jeremy Gills mission, but in the end he just gets yoinked into the watery depths

#

By an unknown force

robust sky
#

tryna get the gold rush achievment

#

its a struggle

calm oasis
#

One question, how do I know what honor level I have

#

I wanna buy the Drover but I need honor rating of 6, how much is that?

#

is it like 6 tenths of the right half of the honor bar?

robust sky
#

pretty sure its in settings on the player stats

dusky crypt
#

Guys, I want to ask a question.
When I try to get the high stakes treasure map from the npc, I made a mistake, he just goes without the treasure map. How can I get this map?

potent wharf
jolly locust
#

I don’t know if anyone can help with this but I installed mods for the single player and I’ve heard that if I try to log into the multiplayer I’ll get banned instantly. Is this true?

radiant girder
#

so like 3/4 of the way between neutral and max honor

potent wharf
astral eagle
#

what's the best chapter to stop at for open-world exploration

safe spire
astral eagle
#

when are most things unlocked

radiant girder
#

2

calm oasis
#

I need help, I have the witness thingy in the top right corner but there isnt anyone near, I cant reload the save since I havent saved before and Id loose the last hour of gameplay

#

any idea how to fix it?

#

ok nevermind, its gone

calm oasis
#

Could somebody help me with the gambler challenges?

#

I dont know how to play most of the games like poker and blackjack

#

so I cant really do it on my own and since the games in game are different from youtube, I cant really look it up

#

Not different, just different cards

#

But as I said, I know nothing about this

dusky crypt
calm oasis
#

I mean I dont know how to play poker

#

the game itself

#

so thats not gonna help I think

dusky crypt
#

when you increase the game speed, you can try many times in a very short time.
there will always be a success
that's how I pass the gambler challenges. I can't play any card games

calm oasis
#

Where do I find a woodpecker

#

Im doing the hunting requests but every video online shows a location, I go there, look at the sky for the birds for about 20 minutes and yet I havent seen even one

dull echo
calm oasis
#

After Guarma, when will I get my money

#

will I get it after the pinkerton assault ?

dull echo
#

something i just realized is

#

you can get dual wield without micah

#

just buy the holster from the trapper

karmic prism
#

i mean you get it during it since arthur gets his satchel back

calm oasis
#

Any idea where to find a bullfrog

#

I keep seeing western toads but not a single bullfrog

radiant girder
#

around canebreak manor

#

and copperhead landing

calm oasis
radiant girder
#

yeah

terse coral
brazen palm
#

hey

#

finally i found the single player tab

#

everyone is talking about rdo in general

#

even tho rdo is trash

narrow anchor
#

it could've been great

brazen palm
#

yea

#

if rockstar actually cared about it

radiant girder
#

are there any white pants that don't have stripes

#

aside from the jeans

verbal cairn
#

is it possible to make an exact copy of the outfit that Dutch wears during chapter 2

radiant girder
#

no

verbal cairn
#

trash

calm oasis
#

What time can I visit the scientist feller, Marco Dragic I believe is his name

#

because it appears but by the time I get there its gone

daring wadi
#

Arthur Morgan

calm oasis
#

Could someone help me with the Algernon Wasp requests?

#

Meaning where do I find the stuff

empty lark
#

around the bayou area surrounding saint denis, all that mud and shit makes for a lovely time looking for specific flowers

calm oasis
#

Is the mission a fine night of debauchery the same every time?

#

I mean if there are the same cards

languid void
#

what's the best time in game to play the stranger missions so they don't mess up story beats

calm oasis
#

When Arthur dies, will John get the Reutlinger watch Arthur got from Blythe ?

restive prairie
#

Arthur stopped existing at the age of 5

radiant girder
#

also i think i found a use for the exotic hat

calm oasis
radiant girder
#

honestly john should get a game of his own. like a sequel to rdr2 or something

calm oasis
#

Like what he did between 1907 and 1911?

radiant girder
#

no

calm oasis
#

Well rdr1 is a sequel to rdr2

radiant girder
#

exactly

#

it was a joke

calm oasis
#

Can I cook meat on Guarma?

#

I cant find a useable campfire anywhere

radiant girder
#

no

verbal cairn
#

I'm bored idk what to do after beating the story

radiant girder
#

100% it

verbal cairn
#

I'm not good enough to 100%

radiant girder
#

then replay the story until you are

verbal cairn
#

perhaps

odd hound
#

does any1 know what Farm, Field and Falconry perk do? it isnt listed ingame

calm oasis
#

?

#

You mean the book?

odd hound
karmic prism
#

theres no known perk

calm oasis
#

Could somebody help me with the challenges? Mainly the gambler ones since I dont know how to play poker

azure grove
#

theres really detailed instructions in the game tips menu

#

also a youtube tutorial would probably be a lot more useful than a bunch of guys on discord

radiant girder
craggy hollow
#

Why does rdr1 looks so bad compared to rdr2?

#

1899 to 1911

#

should mean that rdr1 has better graphics

#

as its set later

#

is this a lore thing?

calm oasis
craggy hollow
#

But it was set 1911

#

not 1899

#

so it should have better graphics

#

because 1899 is older than 1911

#

is this hidden lore im missing?

calm oasis
#

Yeah but they couldnt make a game better looking than rdr2 back in 2010, technological limitations

#

it hasnt got anything to do with lore

craggy hollow
#

2010?

#

rdr2 is older than rdr1

#

as its set in 1899

#

so rdr1 should have better graphics

#

because of innovation

#

is the lore really that deep?

#

this game’s depth never ceases to amaze me

calm oasis
#

I jsut thought I was going insane, I heard Arthur but then I remembered that when you visit the camp location John will get flashbacks

karmic prism
#

theres your lore reason

hidden moss
#

You think the games were actually made then?

#

RDR1 came out in like 2010, when there wasn't as advanced technology, where as RDR2 came out a few years ago with advanced technology, so yes, the older one is not going to look as good.

craggy hollow
#

RDR2 is a prequel

#

it’s older

#

because its set in 1899

#

actually no

#

rdr2 is a sequel

#

rdr1 should have better technology and graphics if it is set in 1911

hidden moss
#

You're definitely trolling.

radiant girder
calm oasis
#

But thinking about rockstar a bit more, they have one last chance to impress because all the latest projects were major fuck ups

#

1st of all, the gta trilogy bullshit

#

Then the re-release of gta 5

#

Now red dead on ps4 and switch

#

Either they have gone lazy or they really have redirected majority of their staff to gta 6

#

And if gta 6 turns out badly, damn they will mess up, I guess that will be basically their funeral

#

When is it set to release, February 2024?

calm oasis
calm oasis
#

I love this game, in the mission with the sheep, John mentions that he had a run-in with the Valentine Gunsmith

#

And in the epilogue the gunsmith still has a grudge against John

calm oasis
#

How do I gain weight?

#

I keep eating everything I get my hands on and yet it keeps getting lower

narrow anchor
karmic prism
#

which is kind of weird considering that gunsmith has like 3 unique conversations with arthur but they couldnt give 1 for john

calm oasis
#

Buell really is a great horse, rarely bucks you, stamina and health both max out at 9, speed and acceleration at 5, the horse is a wonder

craggy hollow
#

Buell sucks ass.

#

I would prefer a Saddler over him.

calm oasis
#

;-;

#

Hes a good boi cmon

craggy hollow
#

I sent him flying off of Horseshoe…

autumn comet
#

does anybody know how to get the m1899 in story for me it has this red locked icon

empty lark
#

progress further in the story

opaque nimbus
#

why tf dont they just send like swanson or mary beth to get the money in blackwater???

#

kinda dumb

#

like im sure they werent the ones in the heist

calm oasis
#

Where can I find a bear?

opaque nimbus
calm oasis
#

Also how on earth am I supposed to do sharpshooter 9

#

Shoot 3 peoples hats off in the same dead eye use

cinder viper
calm oasis
#

oh yeah, didnt think of that

#

thanks

cinder viper
calm oasis
#

Also any idea what is making these shrieking noises?

#

I can hear it since the start of epilogue

#

Whenever Im near Pronghorn ranch I can hear something shrieking in the distance

calm oasis
#

You cant

#

There is an invisible sniper, you have to beat chapter 6 and then you are allowed to go to New Austin in the epilogue

iron parrot
#

huh, I managed to get a mauser in chapter 2

wide salmon
#

Hello

timber drift
#

What’s up everyone

#

I finished RDR2 today

#

The full story past the second epilogue

tidal coral
#

guys what version of john marston is better rdr1 john marston or epilogue john marston (if someone says epilogue john im going to lose it)

odd hound
#

man i was close enough from getting all 3 legendary animals in new austin as arthur but i panicked when i thought the cougar was about to disappear,is the buggy method the only way of hunting them ? did any1 try the wagon method ?

calm oasis
#

you can feel that they have rushed it and didnt really have ideas for it

slate pivot
#

damn

shy jungle
verbal cairn
calm oasis
#

It looks even worse than Arthurs body

#

Its a mix between Johns body from the main campaign and Arthurs

verbal cairn
#

we need a remaster of the first game

#

not this dumb port

calm oasis
#

But we already got the port

#

They have done their work for this year

#

They wont do shit for the rest

verbal cairn
#

the game is already out

calm oasis
#

Yeah, its an abomination

#

It looks almost the same

#

Just better framerate

#

Why on earth are they charging 3 times the price for it though

#

I really think they made Dutch like a mirror image of themselves

#

money money money money

#

nothing else

opaque nimbus
#

what about

#

dutch in disguise

#

grow his moustache and get a beard

#

cut his hair and change fits

shy jungle
#

He’s prolly paranoid who knows

hidden moss
#

it's john marston micah!

shy jungle
#

when i lasso someone, i have to keep holding rmb to keep them lasso'd

#

is there a way to make it so i dont have to hold rmb?

south shore
#

Where do I find raccoons?

lusty lantern
tidal coral
#

guys john started walking like hes drunk but he isnt help

#

it looks so goofy

bright flare
#

Anyone know where to find a skun cant seem to find one

bright flare
#

hello

granite walrus
#

does anyone have a fix for error 777777

bright flare
#

Can someone please help me I reall need to find a skun

sour wasp
patent axle
#

how come I keep getting stuck in random points of a mission?

#

while saving jack when the house is on fire I'm just stuck there and had to suicide 3 times to skip the checkpoint and while going to bronte or blonte's house it's stuck at when I'm trying to enter wth

coarse umbra
#

Do clothes you wear really matter if you do some crimes like robbing a store and the show owner can later recognize you even if you had a mask?

coarse umbra
#

Can i change the dead eye to like the online version where it doesnt make the shoots itself when i hover over something

cinder viper
#

you just have to play the story

coarse umbra
#

Cuz it marks automatically

cinder viper
tame osprey
#

which is better dual mauser or dual schofield

viscid sleet
#

I just wanna make friends in here and this server is just boring

cinder viper
spice tide
#

cool gun

#

camp fast travel

coarse umbra
#

why spoilers are removed

#

i cant even send my question here bacause of that

ripe marsh
#

Does anyone have legend of east outfit at the beginning of the game

#

Early*

dawn jackal
#

well hello there

coarse umbra
#

nah how to tame the horse i fall off after like 2 seconds

spice tide
coarse umbra
#

Can i have more than 4 horses?

#

It aint that much space in a stable :<

empty lark
coarse umbra
#

Can i deliver an odriscoll to a sheriff in valentine for cash?

#

Last time i tried sum like that it said that im kidnapping and there were witnesses

empty lark
coarse umbra
#

Can i get rid of my horse i got for free?

empty lark
#

yeah, kill them

coarse umbra
#

It says i cant sell it

#

Its not like online?

#

They’ll just be in stable

empty lark
#

no

#

they'll be dead

#

and you'd have to obtain it again if you want it back

coarse umbra
#

Cool(ish)

#

Is Buelle just a kentucky saddler buttermilk?

#

Cuz i found one on plains and tamed it

empty lark
#

Buell is a Dutch Warmblood

coarse umbra
#

Ah so different stats?

#

Probably better than this kentucky i found

empty lark
#

yes

coarse umbra
#

I saw on the video that Hungarian something something horses wont drop you off themselves if they’re scared of a predator

#

The guy on vid had a black-white one and i have a brown one and my seems pretty scared ngl. Are they different?

radiant girder
#

no

#

ur bonding is probably just low

coarse umbra
#

2/4 yes

radiant girder
#

ok my game glitched and my satchel does show up on artie

#

yippee

#

nvm it's back

radiant girder
#

andddd my horse died

#

dumbass decided to jump off a 5 foot rock

sage falcon
#

when is the new sex update gonna be added

vernal cape
#

question : if i wanna replay a mission will it destroy my entire progress

wicked socket
#

No

wicked socket
vernal cape
static lark
#

I have a question abt rdr2 gangs in general

#

Do gangs still appear even if I killed them at their hid outs

#

like after I killed the lemoyne raiders at their hideouts will they still appear randomly or do they come back to their hide out or what

radiant girder
#

they come back

dull echo
#

i got all pieces of the serial killer map but could any of you guys narrow it down for me?

#

i dont want you to outright tell me but a general location would be nice

verbal cairn
coarse umbra
#

best time to just live as Arthur before chapter 7? Maybe like before the Strauss mission III or middle of chapter 4? Question to those who have finished the game and know what im talking about

verbal cairn
#

chapter 7?

#

there is no chapter 7 that's the epilogue

safe spire
dull echo
coarse umbra
verbal cairn
#

oh

coarse umbra
verbal cairn
coarse umbra
verbal cairn
#

that gets boring after a while

coarse umbra
#

have you finished the story at least once?

verbal cairn
#

just finished my 7th playthrough

coarse umbra
#

why did you need so many

verbal cairn
#

because good game

#

I spent all my money

coarse umbra
#

theres so many like rare horses that you can get from some encounters its such a shame you can have only 4

dusky crypt
#

does any1 know if you didn't get the high stakes treasure map from the npc in the first time, where can you find this npc again?

coarse umbra
dusky crypt
coarse umbra
#

im trying to get the mft horse from that glitch where you shoot that woman and hope the horse spawn alives

#

Ive killed her over 300 times now

#

Different locations, reloading game/saves

#

It just wont spawn alive

tidal coral
# dusky crypt authur will get tb and die

sorry if i sound like a nerd but actually the most important thing after you meet rain falls is the boat heist the trolley station mission the attack on angelo bronte and then the heist on the bank

#

then u go to the worst fucking chapter

#

guarma

#

i fucking hate that chapter

#

i think everybody does

#

sorry if i spoiled the game

#

i hate when i go on yt to see rdr2 content and there is spoilers

#

like arthur dead

#

in the tumbnail

coarse umbra
#

How does hair tonic work? Do i have to take it regularly or what

#

No but you can save one of those horses

#

Are we talking about the one in chapter 3?

coarse umbra
#

Ive just robbed a doctor and the general store with a mask but they showed up as a red witness instead of dark red, how in the world they know who i was?

#

I had different clotches than ever and yeah i dunno

rare cape
#

anybody got any mod recommendations that makes the game still fun but look good at the same time

karmic prism
#

it'll put off the bank mission

coarse umbra
mild path
#

Hey

static lark
#

i love massacring van horn!!

hidden moss
#

When there's no law in van horn B)

#

I shaved Arthur bald and gave him a goatee

hidden moss
#

I obtained Benedict allbright's Hungarian half bred

glossy flare
#

It’s way too short to justify its addition

#

And you can’t even explore its map properly without being chased down by the law

#

And since all your stuff is gone on Gaurma and your weapons are limited it’s hard to kill them all

#

Gaurma kinda just felt like one set piece after another

hidden moss
#

@glossy flare I heard there were supposed to be sharks in guarma?

#

And much more

#

You have no choice but to rush the guarma chapter

#

Handful amount of cut content

tidal coral
#

like u cant go into aguadulcse

#

all u can do is do missions

#

kill law

#

and explore

#

its so boring

edgy kraken
#

Nah, what horse do you have rn?

#

That's not too bad of a horse. I wouldn't personally spend $1050, if you really want an Arabian, then get the white one which is free. There's also a place in Saint Denis where you can get free horses.

#

Are you calming it while you go? Also you can Lasso it.

#

Yeah

#

That's what I do when taming wild horses been playing Red Dead since it came it and it always works.

#

Just try your best to tame it while it's in that spot. It's really hard to chase because it's fast af and it blends in with the snow

ancient rose
#

i heard a rumor way back that if your reputation was low the white would not spawn. i found it very easily on my console playthrough. never was able to find it when i switched to the pc.

glossy flare
#

Idk I forgot

radiant girder
#

it's not really worth it

#

just keep the horse u have

glossy flare
#

Shoot it to drain it’s stamina

#

Maybe

#

Dunno haven’t tried

#

Just throwing the idea out there

#

I’m fine with the horse I have rn

radiant girder
#

just keep the horse u have

#

the black american standardbred is pretty good

astral eagle
thorn terrace
#

What horses are the 3 arabians you steal from the braithwaits

#

Well i know two of them are black and white but one seems like a strange combination of chessnut and black im mostly curious of that one

#

And it looks more beefy than the other 2

#

I tried multiple times

#

Didnt work

#

I can do a play through and do the glitch

#

I’ll do a play through and check if a glitch works

#

Nah i do xbox and i havent set it up yet

#

Ok

verbal cairn
#

why are you asking people just do whatever you want

thorn terrace
#

Ah you were chatting in here

empty citrus
#

just reply to him

#

don't ping him

bright flare
#

anyone know how to fix train not departinig from annesburg station
im trying to rob it without a bounty but it won't move

heady mica
#

anyone want deadeyedevine real info hit me up

calm oasis
#

Chapter 5 would've been the best one

#

It seems they started slacking off midway through the development, after Chapter 4

#

Guarma started out promisingly

#

But it was too fast

#

Chapter 6 was great

#

But epilogue 1 and 2

#

Garbage

#

I don't know why they just let John let Dutch go instead of something they did in the mission Favored Sons

#

Like Dutch and Arthur jump down a waterfall and come out bruised but alive

#

Dutch could have jumped down Mount Hagen, sure, seems unbelievable but still better than John hunting Dutch down and in the end letting him go just to kill him 4 years later

odd hound
#

does weapon affinity increase dmg or not ?

empty citrus
#

And they didn't know which tracks were dutches

#

It was a 50 50 dice roll and John paid for it

calm oasis
#

I mean

empty citrus
#

That's the whole point of the story

#

You can't live a bad life and expect good things to happen to you

calm oasis
#

But like, when Dutch shot Micah, John could have easily shot Dutch

#

I mean he did hate him

#

But on the other hand

#

I suppose he didn't want to shoot him because he just picked him over Micah

#

After a long time

#

Since Micah was getting into his ear

#

And Dutch thought John was the rat

empty citrus
#

Which he wouldn't of thought if it wasn't for micah

calm oasis
#

Exactly

#

So it does make sense

empty citrus
#

If John killed Dutch and carried his body to wherever the pinkertons are

#

John maybe could've gotten off scotch free

#

Jim if he didn't get shot would've let John live

#

Edgar is actually evil

#

Jim is a real hero

calm oasis
#

Yeah, he was kinda fair towards both Arthur and John

empty citrus
#

Arthur could've easily cut a deal

calm oasis
#

Arthur in the mission Fisher of men

empty citrus
#

To let John and the other harmless people live

calm oasis
#

Oh wait yeah

empty citrus
#

If Jim approached Arthur in chapter 6 by the end

#

Where Jim just told Arthur

calm oasis
#

Yeah, he would have sold him out

#

Arthur hated Dutch because he wanted to let John hang

#

So I suppose he would have easier time making a choice

empty citrus
#

And honestly hosea shouldn't have died

#

We never got to see him in action

calm oasis
#

That was Abigail though

empty citrus
#

We never saw how fast he was with a gun

#

Idk

#

Why would they kill the female who jim doesn't even know is his wife

calm oasis
#

Or at least Dutch thought it was Abigail who gave Hosea to Milton

empty citrus
#

(john)

calm oasis
#

They did kidnap her

#

But like Micah said, it was a trap

empty citrus
#

Eh

#

I would've preferred if hosea lived with john

#

He maybe could've made it to 8 years

#

And who died should've been Lenny first

#

John getting kidnappes

#

Wait no

#

That don't make senae

#

Goddammit I hate typing on phone

#

I think the plan should've been to have everyone including Sadie who was left out for some reason in the bank

#

Abigail and tilly

#

Distract the police

#

Who they gonna grab

#

Abigail?

#

John would've shot them as soon as Jim says "I've given you enough chances"

calm oasis
#

Sorry WiFi died for a sec

calm oasis
#

Tilly

#

She is wanted for killing one of the Foreman dudes

empty citrus
#

They can recover from tilly

empty citrus
#

The foremen are a gang

errant meteor
#

Still murder

empty citrus
#

Is it murder if you kill the guys that abducted you and have made you stay since you were what 12?

calm oasis
#

The

errant meteor
#

No but that's how they saw it 'back in the day'

calm oasis
#

Cousin of Antony Foreman

empty lark
#

also could just arrest her anyways since she's dangerous regardless

empty citrus
#

I guess but back to what I was talking abou5

#

If they killed tilly they could easily recover from that

#

Lenny would still die eitherway

#

Hosea could've lived to 1907

#

Micah would've been killed after chapter 5

calm oasis
#

Actually you've got a point..

empty citrus
#

Hosea would shoot Micah

#

Dutch could've been mad enough to where he pulls a gun

#

John and Arthur obviously stand with hosea

calm oasis
#

Yup

empty citrus
#

The real question is would javier and Bill side with hosea or dutch

calm oasis
#

Actually

#

I think Dutch would side with Hosea instead of Micah

empty citrus
#

Remember that this is chapter 6

calm oasis
#

But his oldest and most trusted friend..

#

Actually yeah, he pretty much raised John and Arthur as sons

empty citrus
#

But still

#

If hosea hadn't died

#

Nothing

#

Not even Edgar finding them

#

It would never of happened

empty lark
#

would've delayed the inevitable for maybe a few more months

empty citrus
#

Yeah the shootout at BH

empty lark
#

Hosea wasn't the all-perfect man some people make him out to be, he still made mistakes in his planning too and sometimes he was just outright ignored anyways

calm oasis
#

Bh?

empty citrus
#

Beaver hollow

calm oasis
#

Ohhh

empty citrus
calm oasis
empty lark
calm oasis
#

Tahiti?

empty lark
#

instead of lying low as initially planned, he changed things up and went robbing barely after escaping a failed robbery
Hosea complained about that but Dutch found a way to make him shut up by bringing up the Blackwater massacre

#

which was very hard for them, since it costed lives and injured others, Hosea just doesn't have a strong voice in matters if any at all whenever Dutch has his mind made up

empty citrus
#

Yeah

#

But still

#

If hosea hadn't died

#

John could've lived to see Jack be a adult

calm oasis
empty citrus
#

Hosea caused a spiral chain of events

calm oasis
#

Jenny, Davey and Mac

empty citrus
empty lark
calm oasis
#

I don't think they knew about Mac

empty lark
#

they did

#

Jack's fishing trip in ch2

calm oasis
#

Milton told Arthur about Mac near the end

empty lark
#

Milton says they found Mac, and "mercy killed" him

calm oasis
#

Oh wait yeah

#

Ye ye ye

empty citrus
#

But anyway

calm oasis
#

Oh wait you enjoy being a rich man's toy

empty citrus
#

Hosea was the key to John's life

calm oasis
#

Yeah that was in chapter 2

empty citrus
#

Once hosea died

#

John's was sealed

#

This sounds like a stretch I know

empty lark
#

It took John several traumatic events and a betrayal to realize he had to leave and his family actually mattered to him and had to go with him

#

Hosea's death was part of it but Hosea himself alive hardly did anything

empty citrus
#

Hosea would've either died on the cliff with Arthur or secured John through the trail

empty lark
#

he talked with him but John kept being a fool and acting like the criminal he was

empty citrus
#

Hosea definitely would've kicked John out for John's own good but let's just say he doesnt

empty citrus
#

(hoseas death)

calm oasis
empty citrus
#

Without anyone to keep Dutch in check he was unleashed

calm oasis
#

If not of his own free will, Arthur would have persuaded him

#

To leave him behind and go

empty citrus
calm oasis
#

Since Arthur was a dead man walking

empty citrus
#

It's a 2v1 against a pussy

calm oasis
#

But the money ending is brutal, how Arthur is yelling the entire way while slaughtering Pinkertons

empty citrus
#

Thr money ending is the best ending

#

You cut Micahs eye off

#

Give him a few permanent scars

calm oasis
#

Because John made it by himself

empty citrus
#

Let's wrap this up

calm oasis
#

Yeah I did the money ending and started epilogue but then I had to go to school trip for a week

#

Last day today

#

Actually

#

It's kinda ironic Micah calls John scarface if you pick money when he himself has a scar across his eye

empty citrus
#

Hosea if he didn't die would've lived and helped John through securing him to beechers and then dying to old age and his sickness when Jack would be 16 through 18

#

Hosea would've persuaded John to not go after him

#

Sadie and Charles would die to their wounds on the mountain

#

Edgar never finds them

#

The end

empty lark
empty citrus
empty lark
#

he's old

#

and sick

#

he's gonna be slower than Micah

#

He was over 10 years older than Micah

empty citrus
#

True

empty lark
#

maybe close to 20 years more, or more likely 15

empty citrus
#

But regardless

#

If Micah shot hosea

#

Dutch would've probably killed him there

#

The gang would still die out

#

Alright well that was fun

empty lark
#

Dutch is fairly quick but Micah is still probably quicker, it took multiple factors for Micah to lose in the Hagen standoff

empty citrus
#

bye now

calm oasis
#

Have a good one

#

But like I said a while back, I hate that the money ending is a scripted loss

#

I cut Micah up like a sausage and yet I died

empty lark
#

it was a pretty shit fight anyways tbh

#

should've just been QTEs or button mashes, bit of both maybe

#

Although that'd be asking rockstar to do more animating and shit

#

and rockstar doesn't seem to like doing things in rdr games

unborn echo
#

Since thats how the story is suppose to end

empty lark
#

problem isn't the ending, it's the way that rockstar made the ending happen

#

they just put you into a 1v1 knife fight with Micah where he has impossibly higher health than any other npc in the game

#

throw in some dialogue and a cutscene at the end, and there you have it

#

it could've been fine if the melee combat in rdr2 wasn't shit boring

unborn echo
#

How should it have gone

empty lark
#

the fight should not have been standard player battle

#

it should've been special

#

unique

unborn echo
#

Ah well

calm oasis
#

They could make it that if you let Micah eat shit, you will actually kill him

#

Since Arthur would die nevertheless from TB

#

Since it wasn't treatable back in 1899

unborn echo
#

That wouldn't really make sense for the story

calm oasis
#

Yeah no..

#

But it would be sick

unborn echo
#

I really wanted to kill Micah

#

But I mean

#

Spoiler alert:

empty lark
#

Arthur failed to stop Micah before, makes sense he fails to stop Micah then too

calm oasis
#

Yeah, he cut me twice, I cut him up like 20 times

unborn echo
#

God damn it

empty lark
#

just say it, spoiler tags dont work here

unborn echo
#

Yea

#

SPOILER ALERT: I got to kill micah anyways

#

As John so

calm oasis
#

It says that this may contain spoilers

unborn echo
#

Everything I'm about to yap about is going to have spoilers

#

so if anyone is in this chat, and has not finished the game

#

i am sorry

empty lark
unborn echo
#

I really couldn't believe the plot twist at the end

empty lark
#

especially with knives, where Arthur cant really just throw himself onto Micah

calm oasis
unborn echo
#

I really wanted to kill him

#

Before the ending

calm oasis
#

I did

unborn echo
#

And I don't know why Arthur didn't

calm oasis
#

The spines of america

unborn echo
#

Tell John and his family to go

calm oasis
#

Dynamite :)

unborn echo
#

Kill Micah, threaten dutch

#

Take money and leave

calm oasis
#

To tahiti

unborn echo
#

No but die before he takes the money

#

And then john comes back, takes money, gang gets back together

#

kill dutch

#

10/10 ending

unborn echo
calm oasis
#

I don't think Bill and Javier would kill Dutch even in the end

unborn echo
#

Honestly, I was scared when Arthur came back and called the gang a bunch of rats

#

And how everyone went to dutchs side and pointed guns at arthur and john

#

I really thought it was over

calm oasis
#

Also, Trelawny would definitely take Arthur's side

empty lark
#

He would, but he also wouldn't fight

unborn echo
#

Pinkertons came in time to save the day

empty lark
#

that wasn't his job, he has a family that unlike John pre-ch6, he actually cared for

unborn echo
#

And you know whats a crazy thought

#

how the pinkertons are the actual good guys

empty lark
#

not that crazy

unborn echo
#

crazy to me

#

The game is played in a perspective that we are doing whats right for what we need

empty lark
#

it's clear when you're playing as a character who is part of a gang

#

you are not the good guy

unborn echo
#

And therefore the pinkertons are #1 enemies

calm oasis
#

The game just portrays them as bad guys

unborn echo
#

They are corrupt

#

Cornwall was the most corrupt

calm oasis
#

They are just guns for hire basically

unborn echo
#

I don't think we really got anything out of killing him either

#

It wasn't really a "oh my! great googly moogly!" moment

calm oasis
#

Dutch got satisfaction since Cornwall thought he was nothing, a bug on a shoe

unborn echo
#

The pinkertons still existed, including his massive corruption complex

unborn echo
calm oasis
#

Just like

#

Uhm

#

Ahh...

#

Gimme a second

#

Bronte

#

There we go

unborn echo
#

He deserved itr

calm oasis
#

Yeah he did

#

He thought he was untouchable

unborn echo
#

Maybe it was a bit much, but I mean he stole jack

calm oasis
#

Actually

unborn echo
#

and played the whole gang

#

And nearly got everyone killed

calm oasis
#

His ego is even worse than Dutch's

unborn echo
#

Hes a mega italian crime boss

#

lmao

calm oasis
#

And that's saying something

unborn echo
#

And the pinkertons would eventually get jack

#

and lets just say they blow him off the face of the earth 21 times

#

I don't even remember why

#

Arthur knew that he was going to die so he had nothing to lose, and helped Jack

calm oasis
#

But the Braithwaite showdown is nuts

unborn echo
#

That was fun

#

In my opinon

calm oasis
#

Perfect way to close a chapter

unborn echo
#

One of the coolest missions in the game

calm oasis
#

Yeah

unborn echo
#

Probably one of the best

calm oasis
#

You just massacre everyone you see

unborn echo
#

From the soundtrack to the graphics and photography

calm oasis
#

And burn down a mansion

unborn echo
#

#1,

calm oasis
#

But sadly, Sean never got to burn the manor

#

:(

unborn echo
#

When we pulled up the mansion

#

That shit was cool as fuck

#

All of standing in a line with guns out

unborn echo
#

He had it coming

#

I never got to rob a homestead with him

calm oasis
#

And you could see how John was ready to charge at them and go full rambo

#

But Hosea stopped him

unborn echo
#

Yup

calm oasis
#

Well at least I think it was hosea

unborn echo
#

I think it was dutch

#

Who told him to calm down

calm oasis
#

Lemme look it up real quick

unborn echo
#

Seriously though, its a great game

#

When I'm ready i'm going to play it again

calm oasis
#

Yeah Hosea

#

He grabbed his chest and said "Easy John"

bright flare
#

how do I get a train to move from annesburg station. Im trying to make money and do bandit cchallenges but I can't cause the train won't move

calm oasis
#

Is the train engineer feller in the front of the train?

#

If not, you have to drive it yourself

#

If he is there and he is bugged out...

#

Well

#

A bullet to the head is the only solution

unborn echo
#

You have to go around the train

bright flare
unborn echo
bright flare
calm oasis
#

Nope

bright flare
#

If I drive it to that tunnel can I get caught?

calm oasis
#

I did it the way I jacked the train, stopped ok a bridge and robbed it

bright flare
#

no bounty?

calm oasis
#

Then drove it off the bridge, not off the bridge but off of it

#

Called my horse and up and left

calm oasis
#

But you shouldn't get none

#

And robbing a train as in going to the back and taking a van of beans counts towards the challenge as well

#

Just got to steak something

#

Doesn't matter what

#

Or rob people

verbal cairn
#

eat beans non-stop for 5 days

#

(in game)

calm oasis
#

Oh I wrote van

#

Sorry I'm on phone, I'm used to pc

#

Steak

#

Mehhh.....

exotic sonnet
#

im gonna be arthur morgan for haloween thoughts?

empty lark
#

dont forget to bring an image at least of the grave, so nobody thinks you're just a random skeleton

amber gull
#

hii

main locust
#

Is it possible to trigger jack's thimble request in the near end of chapter 2? The only mission I have left is rescuing micah from strawberry.

radiant girder
#

yeah

lucid apex
#

What's the mod called where in American Venom, it's not Dutch who's kicking the door wide open, but instead it's Arthur? Saw it in a video and would like to play that myself

ivory cliff
#

It resets to the middle of the bar like it was at the beginning of the game

karmic prism
#
  • theres no honor based story changes in epilogue
vagrant linden
#

Hey, could anyone help me with adding WhyEms dlc into my game?

vagrant linden
#

Could someone that is experienced with modding please dm me?

prisma karma
#

Is it good to get John to perfect weight or nah

empty lark
#

it really doesn't matter that much at all

#

highly unnecessary effort imo, not even sure what the benefits for being at a normal weight is if there is any at all

prisma karma
#

I think you don’t tsk much damage

empty lark
#

so damage reduction

#

pretty useless tbh

#

tonics are nearly instant in effect and easy to get, just takes maybe a second and a half to drink it and they can restore your health to full or better

would suggest not giving a shit about weight unless it also gives some physical appearance change that you want that badly

terse coral
#

shit what do i do

#

look in vc for a se

#

c

#

nvm

karmic prism
empty lark
#

significantly more damage ain't significant enough then

karmic prism
#

true, the game gives you too much health for it to be an issue

opaque nimbus
#

we need more hosea, the only good mission ive seen him in is raiding the braithwaite manor

radiant girder
opaque nimbus
radiant girder
#

that's why it's a good mission

empty lark
#

the moonshine advertising mission was cool too

opaque nimbus
opaque nimbus
empty lark
#

got his old back slammed down onto a wagon

opaque nimbus
#

i love seeing him fly over the balcony

radiant girder
#

gonna try n copy sherrif malloy's fit

#

should be easy

#

only thing that i can't copy is the watch and chain on his vest

radiant girder
#

apparently fish land on the ledge where the nevada hat is

#

ig they just spawn in the river and go off the waterfall

#

gotten about 12 fish in maybe a minute

#

oh my lord there's like 8 more

wanton pier
#

Fish glore

tidal coral
#

guys does the 10 gold bars for the 2 step verification still work?

verbal cairn
hardy lotus
hidden moss
#

im looking for my friend gavin

tidal coral
tidal coral
#

you will find him there

coarse umbra
#

hey so there are those outfits to buy that you need high honor for, do they unlock like new cosmetic items that are not available to purchase otherwise? I wanted to make my own cool outfits for Arthur but they absolutely suck and theres almost nothing to buy at the Tailor's

#

Can i please get some tips on how to make some stunning outfits? Like how to get all cosmetics unlocked to buy or some other stuff idk

karmic prism
#

most outfits are high honor exclusive but you can also order them through the rdr2 website

hidden moss
#

i somehow mandela effected myself for a good while into misremembering that john was raped by colm odriscoll

#

i was flabbergasted when i found out this wasnt in the game

hidden moss
empty lark
dull geyser
#

I like to keep it simple

coarse umbra
#

Whats the limit for the lenght of the Arthur's beard at 2nd chapter? 7/10 or smth?

old onyx
dark remnant
#

whats the best arabian horse ingame except the rose grey one

radiant girder
dark remnant
radiant girder
#

there's better horses

dark remnant
#

which

radiant girder
#

ardennes, turkomans, MFTs, hungarian halfbreds, dutch warmbloods, andalusians