red-dead-singleplayer

[ivory mortar]

Holy hell

Don’t bump into Mr

Me

[lime orchid]

I almost shot Dutch

I pressed the wrong thing

And now it’s a free for all

[ivory mortar]

W

He tried to leave me

You should hit next time

OH

the Germans saving me is crazy

Thank you Germans

[hidden moss]

Dude I’m actually going to fucking kill myself I OVERWROTE MY NEW PLAYTRHOUGH

[ivory mortar]

Damn

[hidden moss]

dude I had everything set up

I’m actually so stupid

[ivory mortar]

?

[hidden moss]

I’m going to jump off a cliff

[hidden moss]

I got a good horse

Tons of money

I got clothes from the trapper

legend of the east satchel

and all of that to be overwritten by my other save

[ivory mortar]

Ain’t no way Chelonians are leaking through the chat

Rip

[hidden moss]

They were right all along

[ivory mortar]

Last mission time

Chat should I get the rd1 remake?

I have not ever played it

[sage falcon]

someone know why my john suddenly has the voice lines of jack in rdr1

[deft cliff]

rockstar coding

sometimes my horse rides like its drunk

is it because its a 'wild' one? or do all horses sometimes behave a bit weird

its the white arabian from the north-west area

[deft cliff]

ok i googled and it looks like there is no 'bravery' stat in the game. horse behavior is only affected by its status, how well you calm it and keep its health/stamina stats up

[deft cliff]

oh

is my Honor stuck at like 90% because of story progression?

the game just prevents me from raising it further until i proceed the story?

[spice tide]

what chapter are you in

you can max it out after chapter 5

[deft cliff]

chapter 3

some reddit posts say you can max it as soon as chapter 2

others say its locked behind story progression

🤷

[shrewd edge]

Tbh I cried a little at the end of Chapter 6-

Yesterday

[hidden moss]

Completely valid.

If you didn't cry, you don't have a heart.

I even shed some tears when replaying it for 100%.

[shrewd edge]

I've finished like a couple side quests, I feel bad for not doing all of them.

[hidden moss]

They make it better.

Honestly, 100% made me feel more because I spent more time doing honorable things.

[shrewd edge]

I did have High Honor

So I got the better ending.

[hidden moss]

I mean like you do so much good stuff with the side quests.

Makes you feel more.

You spend so much time going around helping people.

[shrewd edge]

Yeah, It felt good helping out.

[deft cliff]

i just robbed a bank and have 3.5k dollars

and nothing to buy with it?

i could just buy all the clothing outfits i guess

even though i made 2 outfits at the start of the game (warm and cold) and havent changed anything since lol

[hidden moss]

HELP

HELP

anybody there

if I go to tumbleweed casually buying a gun in gunsmith

a stupid corrupt cop arrests me for no reason

[shrewd edge]

Favorite pistol?

[ivory mortar]

Volcanic

[hidden moss]

Bro

how to attack sherrif freeman

[shrewd edge]

M1899

[hidden moss]

What?

plz i cannot visit tumbleweed

a cop called sheriff freeman is arrestingme for now reason

Have you finished the game?

yes

I am epilogue

why does the cop freeman attack me plzzz

I wanna visit tumbleweed

[ivory mortar]

What do I do to back for money or help John

[karmic prism]

whatever you want, both are great endings

the former has better gameplay and music than the latter tho imo

[deft cliff]

where the hell did my money disappear

20k dollars stolen from bank, divided between everyone, left me with 3.5k

now im looking at my money and im back to 1k, like the whole bust is deleted

looks like other people reporting issue with this mission too

on reddit anyway

'sodom? back to gomorrah' mission

ah i see what happened. its the save/load buggy system again

somehow it rolled me back as if i havent completed that mission yet

[ivory mortar]

How many missions are in the epilogue

Both parts

And when do I get weapons and such

[karmic prism]

you dont get your weapons back until epilogue 2

but its ok epilogue 1 is very short compared to 2

[ivory mortar]

What about clothing

[radiant girder]

make sure to get johns gambler hat and flat cap

you can only get those in epilogue 1

all of arthurs clothing is transferred to john

[ivory mortar]

Where do I find it

Sorry I’m asking all these questions I’m just new to the epilogue

Nvm

[radiant girder]

only way to get the hats is by being kicked by a horse

and picking the hat back up

[ivory mortar]

Least obscure way to get a missable item in rd2:

[radiant girder]

real

[bright flare]

Hey can anyone help me with getting a perfect badger pelt I've bem looking for like 6 hours

Where should I look

[karmic prism]

damn the appleseed timber ending actually made me kinda sad

the area was once so beautiful now its just dead trees and dirt

[radiant girder]

riggs station at night

[bright flare]

appreciate it

[ivory mortar]

How do I stop Jim Milton rides again from softlocking

[bright flare]

Anyway to locate the badgers easier im at riggs station at night still having trouble

nvm i got it

[spice tide]

I got them automatically added to my horse in epilogue 2

[hidden moss]

In the future just look at Yt guides instead of coming here

unless you’re looking for more intricate concepts

or tips for challenges

something like that

[bright flare]

can sleeping reset animal spawn

im trying to get a pnather rn

i found one but it wasn't perfetct

okay thanks

[hidden moss]

You have to sleep for 2 days

save and reload

to have another sleep ready

repeat that until the corpse is gone

[bright flare]

this is gonna suck

[hidden moss]

It’ll take like 10 minutes at most

not even 10

More like 5

[bright flare]

to get a perfect panther?

[hidden moss]

Any animal really

[hidden moss]

I did this for the grin and bear it trophy

where you have to survive and kill 18 bears

[bright flare]

i appreciate your help

oh damn

[hidden moss]

It took an hour and a half

one panther isn’t going to be bad

do you want to learn a trick for a easy panther kill?

[odd sandal]

I finished the story mode something Ive never done in the history of me playing rockstar games

[bright flare]

yes please

[hidden moss]

Alr lemme load up rdr2

[bright flare]

i got it

[hidden moss]

oh ok

👍

[bright flare]

thanks for all the help

you the bet

[hidden moss]

I’ll give the trick anyway

if you need it in the future

I’ll post it in #red-dead-media

[bright flare]

okay

thanks

[thorn terrace]

How many punches would it take to kill an elk because im outside of the map and i found that elk dont run

Nvm ill count it up

16

-85

[shrewd edge]

I'm gonna miss Arthur Morgan.

[deft cliff]

how come my guns never run out of ammo and i never need to reload

i think dead eye doesnt expend the ammo in your gun or something, must be a bug

[empty lark]

in story, activating deadeye automatically reloads your guns

and if you have your gun holstered long enough, it'll reload automatically then too, i think there's a setting to turn that off though if you'd like

[lime orchid]

I quit the game because I accidentally killed my horse

I’m not living with that

[deft cliff]

i have 15 backups of my save

🧠

[empty lark]

skill issue

[lime orchid]

It definitely is

[cobalt blaze]

It is the only logical thing to to.

[deft cliff]

when finishing a mission with bronze/silver, it has the option to 'replay'

does that allow to improve the score?

[empty lark]

yes

[karmic prism]

van horn's kinda a vibe tbh

[deft cliff]

i love it

its so different than the rest that it gave me horror-game vibes 😄

[karmic prism]

i'd take it over the swamp any day

aaand i got into a firefight

[deft cliff]

oh boy

its time

time for pain

Gambler 8 😐

this is literally trolling the completionists

someone did the math

the probability of busting on Gambler 8 is 90% lol

and on the 10% where you dont bust youre still not guaranteed a win obviously, you might have a score as low as 11

i went to Van Horn to do it

entered the saloon and immediately get pickpocketed -500

lasso'd the guy, someone else started shooting me

then i killed the entire town 20+ people lol

huh they keep respawning ive killed like 40 of them now

Van Horn must have endless respawning drunks instead of police :/

[lime orchid]

I couldn’t figure out how to use the lasso so I accidentally kept flinging Kieran

[deft cliff]

this must be the biggest flaw of the game

weird unintituitive controls

sometimes you have to use right mouse + left mouse to shoot, sometimes its just left mouse

sometimes you loot with E, soemtimes its R

im sure its because its how awkward it was on controller, they kept the awkwardness on keyboard too

do i need to stop to eat or can i keep playing blackjack

24 ingame hours passed already lol

[ivory mortar]

Just beat the epilogue

Kinda feels like dlc

[ivory mortar]

I’m dead now

[deft cliff]

2 hours later and Gambler 8 is at 1/3 lol

i went in bald and coming out with long hair and grampa beard

i think im extremely unlucky. shouldve been done in 1-1.5 hours lol

im doing maximum speed strat too

sitting in 1st chair, leaving table as soon as i have 15 or higher with 2 cards and also leave as soon as i bust

game's trolling

when i get an ace+2 opener, dealer gets blackjack lol

[ivory mortar]

What is it?

[deft cliff]

win a game of blackjack where you hit 3 times minimum

so you need to have 5 or more cards and be below 21

[ivory mortar]

How?

That’s crazy

[deft cliff]

yeah its torture lol

its pure luck

[ivory mortar]

And here I am thinking beating the game is an achievement

I got 71 hours on it

[deft cliff]

pure luck with absolutely terrible odds

im exactly 100 hours now

at the end of Chapter 3

[ivory mortar]

Sucks because I love that set but i don’t wanna do that

[deft cliff]

im doing all the side and challenge content so i expect to hit 100% at 200-250 hours ;x

for the first hour i was watching a tv show

but now im playing more actively to speed it up with the desk-leaving method lol

its faster to leave and sit again than it is to wait for the dealer and the other 3 players

but takes more active play

not sure if devs were trolling, plain evil, or its a strat to pump up their internal player counts

[ivory mortar]

Damn

[deft cliff]

at least the Poker game lets you skip animations.. not in Blackjack though lol

they programmed animation skip for one game, they couldve done for the others but didnt

oops instead of sitting at the table, i choked a lady and now everyone's mad

omg finally 2/3... only a little left to go lmao

2.5 hours for 2/3

nice 3/3 just 10 minutes later

2h35m for Gambler 8. now im committed to 100% the game lol, the worst is behind me

[craggy hollow]

only 2 hours and you already got one? lucky mf

bit more than a week for 1 and a half hours a day spent on gambler 8

no progress

[deft cliff]

week? thats 168 hours

youre must doing something wrong :p

ah 1.5h per day only

still thats way too much

ive seen youtube videos of people getting all 3/3 in 1 hour

so my 2.5h must be unlucky

the speed strats are super useful

always make sure you got 1st seat from the dealer (clockwise) and if your starting cards are worth more than like 12 or so dont bother, just stand up and immediately sit back

this way you never have to watch the other players playing

ok chapter 3 done, all Gold. 51% progress too

the ending of chapter 3 was unexpected and insane, very stronge

[ivory mortar]

The only thing that I’ve really spent a lot of time on in a rockstar game is the stupid prison break heist in gta online

Everyone would keep on failing it in one way or another and it took a few weeks probably to complete it

[lime orchid]

I’m such a crybaby I got teary eyed when I made Arthur pet a dog

[radiant girder]

wait is this your first time playing?

[deft cliff]

yeah

alright and here i start my Chapter 4 adventure 😄

[deft cliff]

is Vanilla needed for some challenge or is it just a troll when youre looking for Orchids

[ionic walrus]

guys

fast

lemat revolver

or vulcanic revolver

cmon tell me

i need fast

[ivory mortar]

Hi Abigail

I finished the game

[ivory mortar]

Volcanic

But it’s not a revolver

And it’s up to preference

Volcanic is slow and does a lot of damage and lemat is fast

[lime orchid]

Nice

[deft cliff]

for Gambler 9 (win 3 dominos games in a row)

is the challenge to just win 3 rounds, or 3 full games?

like sometimes a 'game' goes up to score 100 or whatever, and that may take like 10 rounds

looks like its full games

damn

hnmmmm

Gambler 9 is actually going to be worse than Gambler 8 😐

bcause in Gambler 8 you can at least shut your brain off and just let it play

in 9 you actually have to use brain and win games

[deft cliff]

done how long was that

1.5h, better than gambler 8 🙂

[lime orchid]

I lost 2 in a row

[deft cliff]

you dont actually have to lose

if you see you are about to lose, just stand up before you actually lose

this way your streak doesnt reset

[radiant girder]

@deft cliff since ur doing the exotics quest make sure to hunt the birds before you get the request

once you get the request the spawn rates lower

[deft cliff]

i already completed the 1st part with herons and egrets

really? wow thats insane

i got half of the 2nd mission too

20 herons and 10 moccasin orchids. need the 7 lady slippers and its done

[radiant girder]

use rdr2map

[deft cliff]

i use another map

the popular rdr2map is subscription gated

pretty lame they charge separately for every game lol

the one i found shows a really nice heatmap when you choose specific animals or plants

so you can know where youre more likely to find stuff in a smaller clump

id link it but the bot dont like that

[radiant girder]

dm it

[deft cliff]

dm'd

[shrewd edge]

"Arthur, Just one more score!"

🤣

[keen birch]

||By clicking this message, you have joined the "Arthur Morgan Sucks" group and have officially signed and admitted that Arthur Morgan sucks. Thank you for your time.||

[thorn terrace]

Was it ever confirmed that pearson died before or after the events of rdr1

[cyan yoke]

Bro I need help

[thorn terrace]

Lay it on me

[radiant girder]

pearson never died

i mean he eventually died but whatever

[empty citrus]

pearson was

probably really healthy compared to everyone else

and he owns a general store

if he needs food he can just pull some carrots n shit out of his own stock

he has a whole BARREL

[deft cliff]

what does the Legendary Panther Giaguarno trinket do exactly

Permanently decreases the speed at which the Dead Eye bar drains by 10% for 3 seconds

does it make the first 3 seconds of going into Dead Eye cost 10% less juice? is that it?

[radiant girder]

i think

pretty shitty for the amount of work you do to get it

[deft cliff]

i mean thats pretty good because if often use dead eye for less than a second at a time

just lock onto the head and click for guaranteed headshot

this way you also dont waste dead ye juice while your gun's rate-of-fire is just waiting

[deft cliff]

some hillbilly in the swamps knocked me out and did something to me... took -$1 and then let me go

wtf did he do to me

[radiant girder]

seriously

he actually does

[deft cliff]

xd

[hidden moss]

Uh

[hidden moss]

This

[wintry mantle]

Hello, if I buy rdr2 standard edition, in single player will gang hide outs will spawn or not

Is it in only ultimate edition?

[deft cliff]

Plus get free access to Additional Weapons in online.```

its -70% on steam now might as well get it

i dont think you can buy Special Edition anymore? i dont see it on Steam anyway

[charred abyss]

gang hideouts spawn in normal rdr2, there’s missions where you attack them so they do exist

[spice tide]

i’ve just got max honor as john, and i’d like to do the bandit challenges so what honor related stuff should I do or buy before starting those

[deft cliff]

i did all the bandit challenge without losing honor lol

except the earliest ones, hold up townsfold and rob 4 shops in one day

the others are cheesable.. steal 5 horses - you can take horses without a saddle from your own hideout lol

steal and sell wagons - just take a stagecoach from anywhere to Emerald, sit back on it and drive it into the fence without any bounty

hogtie 3 and leave on tracks - you can do it against any random enemy or bounty target

if you can untie then you can re-tie and drop them again lol

5 train robberies - take a train anywhere and instead of leaving, run to the back of it and loot 1 can of veggies, rinse and repeat

[barren fractal]

that reminds me i havent done my bandits yet

[deft cliff]

i just completed bandit 10 and gambler 10 a few minutes ago ;d

[barren fractal]

all i have left is bandit, gambler, sharpshooter, and im on the last survivalist

[deft cliff]

gambler is the worst, especially if you didnt pre-cheese it

[spice tide]

i’ve done herbalist, sharpshooter, hunter and survivalist

[barren fractal]

im saving gamber til last

[spice tide]

(i’m doing all the cool sounding ones)

[deft cliff]

gambler 8 (win blackjack with 3 hits) is the worst, takes 2-4 hours of complete luck

gambler 9 (win 3 dominos in a row) takes some actual playing but is semi-cheesable

[barren fractal]

pretty sure gambler is the only one iv only finished once

[deft cliff]

and gambler 10 is totally cheesable (win 3 poker hands in a row) using a main quest where you get 2 scripted poker wins in a row, but if you dont do that then i think its borderline impossible lol

[spice tide]

yo wtf I just found rains fall in annesberg

[barren fractal]

im prob gonna start my bandit in a bit, currently tobacco feilding with the sean

[deft cliff]

i dont normally 100% games but somehow >90% of the stuff in this game is enjoyable to do

apart from a handful of things

[spice tide]

what’s the worst story mission in rdr2

[barren fractal]

for me, that one in epilouge 1 where u take jack to strawberry

[karmic prism]

anything in epilogue 1 that isnt jim rides again

[wintry mantle]

I read that in ultimate edition you get gang hide outs thats why I asked, so Normal rdr2 have gang hideouts nice

[deft cliff]

wow Algernon's Revolver is fancy

[misty lily]

how scary is undead nightmare? i wanna play it but i cant do horror games

[deft cliff]

what mission is that

[barren fractal]

its not that bad

[misty lily]

its a dlc for rdr1

[misty lily]

thats good to hear but im scared of even the least scary horror games so idk if that applies to me LOL

[barren fractal]

it only scares me every now and then when im not paying attention whatsoever

[misty lily]

ok thank you !!

[sterile locust]

Undead nightmare is unplayable for me

the headless glitch ruined it

I still finished it tho

[barren fractal]

Mines chillin

[sterile locust]

I have the xbox disc version

it’s unplayable

[barren fractal]

Unlucky

[sterile locust]

yeah

[sterile locust]

The worst thing that can happen is when a zombie hits you while you’re not paying attention

especially when they don’t scream until they’re right behind you

[simple vector]

wait is it playable on pc

[wooden quarry]

My sister is on the epilogue and is wondering if there is any way to get Buell back, she stabled him before Arthur died but now he's gone

[empty lark]

no

either reload to a save back before getting Buell or just deal with it ig

[deft cliff]

when is the earliest time you can fully fill the honor bar to full?

mines always at like 90% i cant get it any higher

[spice tide]

chapter 5

[orchid harbor]

Is there a way to get the Leviticus Cornwall cigarette card from Fort Wallace in Epilogue? When I go there it's heavily fortified and I'm thinking only Arthur could get it under the main story.

[coral otter]

u cant enter fort wallace or theres just a lot of people

bc if theres a lot of people

dynamite

[simple vector]

I don’t know if this happened to anyone else but I was riding around the camp in chapter 6 and in the forest I saw a hanging man so I ran towards him to get a photo with him lol and then the Murphees attacked me, I knew it was there intentionally but god it was creepy

[hidden moss]

Tell her that it sucks to suck

She isn’t getting Buell back

[jolly hearth]

I thought it was only nite folk who did this, creepy that murfrees do it too

[sly shore]

American venom

[hidden moss]

Dear Uncle Tacitus

[radiant girder]

just buy premium cigarettes until you get it

[radiant girder]

nah

[timid helm]

Hello9i

[radiant girder]

country pursuits

[karmic prism]

at least that has story implications and introduces the bull gator

[shrewd edge]

Welp I did it.

I killed Micah and completed the story missions.

[radiant girder]

now you have to kill his eviler brother, Hacim

[ivory mortar]

😔

[ivory mortar]

Fr I forgot to get a horse so I had to run the entire thing

[verbal cairn]

this game was probably the first in a long time that I played without knowing anything about it

it was worth it and ever since it's been my favorite game of all time

[faint gate]

Yeah, but it's a shame they had to kill off most of the "Best" Characters (Really they're all good, Except Micah)

[verbal cairn]

killing characters makes the story good just like the last of us part 2

[radiant girder]

only challenges left are gambler

yippee

[verbal cairn]

after I beat the story I always spend all of my money at poker and blackjack tables

I don't even know how to play

[faint gate]

Lol, I'm sure we've all been there

[ivory mortar]

Yes

[radiant girder]

only table game i know is dominoes lol

[ivory mortar]

5 fingered filet moment

[verbal cairn]

and uno

[ivory mortar]

I only know 5FF and blackjack

[verbal cairn]

It's fun playing blackjack because if you lose too much money you can feel better by shooting the dealer in the face

[ivory mortar]

I never thought of that

I always just bet double but to each their own

[verbal cairn]

or sometimes I like to kidnap the dealer

[faint gate]

Yeah, and riding off to do it again in a different town will make it even more fun

[verbal cairn]

I'm a psychopath in the game lol

[faint gate]

That's what's good about Rockstar, there's no in between you either play like a psychopath or like a good person

[verbal cairn]

my first playthrough I was nice but now i leave no survivors

my favorite thing to do is to antagonize the sheriff and when he threatens me I kidnap him and execute him at the Adler ranch

[faint gate]

I'm alright with killing random NPCs, but for some reason I just can't willingly harm Mickey specifically (And yes, I know about him already)

[ivory mortar]

I play as a good person

Bc it makes more sense story wise

[faint gate]

That's what I thought on my first playthrough too, but now on my second I'm doing everything I can to be bad lol

[verbal cairn]

I'm on my like 7th playthrough lol

[faint gate]

Maybe on your 8th you can find a way to cure TB (Or, avoid Downes altogether)

[verbal cairn]

I tried shooting him

[faint gate]

That's actually the most humane thing to do, Downes was gonna die anyway

[verbal cairn]

can't you kill him when he's asking for money at valentine

[faint gate]

No, You can't even knock him over lol

[verbal cairn]

can't you throw dynamite next to him

[faint gate]

I haven't tried that yet, I don't know where to find dynamite (I'm already past that part I'm pretty sure too)

[verbal cairn]

haven't played the game in a while

[pine lily]

I just got burlap as John, and I set up a camp right after mountain him and now I can’t find him. How do I get him back

[verbal cairn]

what is burlap

[faint gate]

Assuming you already have it set as your primary horse, have you tried whistling for it?

[pine lily]

no my old horse came back

[verbal cairn]

Oh it's a horse

[pine lily]

I mean buell lol sorry

[ebon summit]

Did you get level 1 bonding with him?

[verbal cairn]

the first time I got Buell I killed it on accident

[empty lark]

it's generally a good idea to put your main horse's saddle on your new horse after taming it

[faint gate]

Accidentally? How?

[verbal cairn]

the sheriff shot it in the head and I didn't have horse reviver

[faint gate]

Oh, I was imagining it somehow forgot to stop at a ledge lol

[verbal cairn]

no that's how my horse from the first mission of the game died

I am horrible at horse riding

[faint gate]

Can't blame you, I was only good at riding because I played RDR

[verbal cairn]

Oh that reminds me

[ivory mortar]

Wouldn’t you still die from Micah

[verbal cairn]

wanna hear how I killed Micah in chapter 2

[ivory mortar]

You show him

[verbal cairn]

huh

[ivory mortar]

I was only good at shooting bc I played gta V

[ivory mortar]

*shoot

[verbal cairn]

no I actually killed him it wasn't a mission or anything

[ivory mortar]

How

[faint gate]

No, Arthur without TB would've killed him as quick as he found out

[ivory mortar]

Oh

[verbal cairn]

so I got the game when it first came out so there was a lot of glitches and I'm chapter 2 after you free micah from strawberry i went straight back to camp and saw Micah running down the road so i ran him over with my horse a dozen times and blew him up with dynamite and he was dead and i got his revolver early i used it the rest of the game

[faint gate]

Considering he probably would've came back later (Since he wouldn't really die), could've you gotten both if you're lucky?

[verbal cairn]

got both what

[faint gate]

Oh, both of Micah's Revolvers

[verbal cairn]

oh no I went to fort hagen and there wasn't a second gun

[ivory mortar]

Huh

[verbal cairn]

huh

[spice tide]

the game only allows you to have 1, if you get his revolver in chapter 2 it don’t spawn on top of mount hagen

[simple vector]

someone please tell me some of the best weapons in rdr2, I have no idea

[empty lark]

schofield revolver, cattleman revolver, lemat revolver, semi auto pistol, mauser pistol, volcanic pistol, m1899 pistol, midnight's mauser pistol, granger's cattleman revolver, flaco's cattleman revolver, lancaster repeater, carbine repeater, evans repeater, double barrel shotgun, semi auto shotgun, pump action shotgun, repeating shotgun, sawed off shotgun, springfield rifle, bolt action rifle, varmint rifle, bow, otis miller's schofield revolver, carcano rifle, rolling block rifle, rare rolling block rifle, rare double barrel shotgun, dynamite, throwing knives, tomahawks, calloway's revolver, antler knife, hunting knife, fists, hatchet, cleaver, double bit hatchet, broken pirate sword, civil war knife, rusted hunter hatchet, hunter hatchet, viking hatchet, machete, wide-blade knife, ornate dagger, hewing hatchet, rusted double bit hatchet, jawbone knife, john's knife, stone hatchet, ancient tomahawk, john's cattleman revolver, fire bottles, lasso

[empty lark]

answered your question for you

go find any of those totally hard to get and totally rare weapons and you'll be set for the entire game, even just one of them would be good enough considering this game is not at all difficult and almost every weapon in the game can kill quickly and easily

[simple vector]

Thank you so much man

[karmic prism]

thoroughbred died doing the new austin bridge jump, never trusting a yt guide again

[karmic prism]

also really any of them are good

objectively probably the lemat revolver, repeating shotgun and evans repeater as they have the highest ammo count but its entirely up to preference

[slow geode]

Just curious going for plat trophy on rdr and do I need to collect all the exotics

?

[radiant girder]

yes

[radiant girder]

every single weapon except double action

[orchid harbor]

Ah ok. Cheers

[next night]

I was playing rdr2 on my way to camp to farm some honor, when someone knocked on the door so I went to open it and put the game on cinematic mode and when I was back my level 4 bond arabian was dead, arthur had all of his cores low and as soon as I grabbed the controller I got stabbed by one of those murfree mfers 😭

[empty lark]

would suggest pausing the game next time tbh

[next night]

I didn't want to waste time

never again

[empty lark]

never used cinematic mode while away from the console because it doesn't stop random shit from happening

[next night]

yeah

[verbal cairn]

what's the biggest shootout you have ever had

[ivory mortar]

Blackwater

[hidden moss]

Good on them for killing your Arabian

You’ll learn it was for the best

[shrewd edge]

I accidentally hit PC role but I have the game on Xbox XD

It'll be nice if I have it on PC though. :v

[karmic prism]

true...

foxtrotters for life

[radiant girder]

are there any white coats that isn't the legendary bison coat

[empty lark]

there's a white hunting jacket from the trapper

i think from legendary moose but i cant really remember

i never used it

[regal kestrel]

Who was wanted more in terms of money, Arthur or Dutch?

[ivory mortar]

Dutch

Milton wanted only dutch in horseshoe overlook

He killed an innocent during blackwater

[regal kestrel]

No i mean like in terms of price

Is there anything on that

[radiant girder]

dutch

wanted in 5 states and it's probably a ton in each

add them all up it's probably over 5k

[untold lintel]

In normal gameplay you can get a max total bounty of $7,500 but I assume Dutch was wanted for even more than that even.

5000 for Authur, yet saying they only want Dutch, they gotta be worth that maximum or more. They were in other states at some point or another, they may be wanted in even more places than the five states.

[radiant girder]

apparently sheriff gray and hosea have the same outfit

except gray has the shirt from the Dewberry Creek outfit

[hidden moss]

Legendary moose hunting jacket

but it looks

bad

imo

[radiant girder]

might recreate sheriff malloys outfit

[simple vector]

If I lose the legendary bear hat, it won’t be lost forever… Right? Can I get it from the trapper

[hidden moss]

You can’t lose hats

[simple vector]

Oh! That explains it then

[hidden moss]

They’re stored on your outfits/hats section on your horse

or in any place that allows you to change clothes

[simple vector]

I forgot thank you man

[hidden moss]

Np 👍

[next night]

huh

[karmic prism]

likely dutch, micah has his bounty poster which says 1000$ but its probably an old poster

[next night]

yeah probably dutch since he's the leader of the van der linde gang

[karmic prism]

so do yall think john canonically lost arthur's hat in american venom? i honestly think it would make sense narritively because american venom is basically john shitting on arthur's sacrifice

[simple vector]

Someone fucking help me please I’m catching the legendary fish with Hamish and whenever I reel it in it literally doesn’t get closer to me at all it’s still in the same spot??? I’m fishing like normal I don’t know what’s happening

I GOT IT

[karmic prism]

btw you can pull back the rod with the left stick to pull in fish faster if you didnt know already

[lilac fog]

that mission took me like 10 mins to do! even with the tip of pulling back

[simple vector]

I did it by putting the rod pretty close to the boat and then reeling it closer which attracted the fish and I was able to catch it really quickly

[karmic prism]

aww man, i didnt know william's quest had an ending

now i'm sad i liked seeing him

ignore the part where i stole his horse and he shanked me

[verbal cairn]

what's the best strategy for getting the chilupa thing for rains fall without being seen because I always mess it up

[faint gate]

Chilupa? Are you talking about the One where you have to steal something back for him?

[verbal cairn]

yes and yes

[faint gate]

Oh, from what I remember you don't really have to sneak around them, you can shoot them if you want (I'd try to sneak anyway, I could be wrong)

[verbal cairn]

did you read when I said about "without being seen"

[faint gate]

Yes, but like I said I could be wrong

[karmic prism]

just sneak up on the guys patrolling and leave the dudes sitting down alone while you grab the stuff

[verbal cairn]

I do that but they always have Superman level hearing

[karmic prism]

might just need to take it slow

[karmic prism]

do you think it would be more interesting if your horse could only hold a certain amount of your weapons instead of an entire arsenal

[ivory mortar]

GTA moment

[karmic prism]

hey at least arthur doesnt pull a cannon from his ass like gta protags

instead he pulls one from his horse's infinite pocket dimension inside its saddle

[ivory mortar]

Ok true

[simple vector]

no I like the fact that I can have infinite weapons

[karmic prism]

me realizing i did all the treasure hunts and got 10000$ as arthur only to lose it when i switch to john

[verbal cairn]

I know how to save your money as Arthur to give to John

[simple vector]

I’m sorry bro ☠️

[cosmic yoke]

playing the final mission and i am very sad

[simple vector]

Did you finish it already

[cosmic yoke]

not yet

just at the part where dutch steps on arthurs hand

I am very sad

He's dead

arthur is dead

[empty lark]

skill issue tbh

[simple vector]

bro I finished it almost a week ago, haven’t cried like that for years

[empty lark]

in both endings he loses his gun and also fails to have what i would imagine be a pretty obvious idea in both endings

the mountain scene ig i understand him losing his gun, but in Going Back i don't understand as well how he never even attempted to get it back

[cosmic yoke]

(This is the 9th playthrough I've done)

[simple vector]

it will always hit hard

[cosmic yoke]

fr

[empty lark]

he should've just used his hunting knife like a throwing knife in the money ending tbh

his aim is basically perfect anyways, he always hits with the blade on thrown weapons

[calm oasis]

Could someone help me with the gambler challenges

I have no idea how to play poker, but I really want to unlock the legend of the east outfit

[karmic prism]

yea but i already killed the couple at the pig farm

[karmic prism]

also i'd argue the mountain is more absurd because micah CHOOSES to run up tackle arthur who is in a gunfight instead of just shooting him

whereas in the money ending it's a surprise attack so it makes a bit more sense

and maybe theres a bit of begrudging respect in the knife duel

[empty lark]

well micah could've shot him while arthur was leaving the cave too

i think it's more of a satisfaction thing for Micah, he had been wanting to be better in arthur but only really matched up with him in gun skills

beating arthur to death when he has a chance of actually winning was probably more fun for Micah, just didn't expect it to still be kinda difficult

which is kinda fair ig, arthur at his lowest was only barely being overpowered by milton and didn't really look like the type to be in any fist-fighting condition

[simple vector]

Arthur was already dying and still almost beat Micah, he wa so fucking strong.

[empty lark]

i think even Milton was physically stronger than Micah

[simple vector]

Micah is a piece of shit

[empty lark]

Arthur could've definitely won the knife fight at Beaver Hollow though if he had just used his hunting knife as a throwing knife

he always hits his targets with the blade ends of throwable weapons and deadeye(i know it just represents speed and shit) does work with throwable weapons

[radiant girder]

arthur woulda been shot by milton if it weren't for abigail

[faint gate]

He might have just been too weak to actually throw them, his TB almost overtook him during the fight

[lime orchid]

That’s why she’s my favourite

[empty lark]

how is he too weak to throw a knife

but strong enough to resist milton's gun slowly being aimed down on him for like 3-5sec

he's not that pathetic

[faint gate]

Considering he was too weak to crawl towards Micah's gun, it's not too far from likely

[empty lark]

remember that's after micah was beating him

before that arthur was standing fine

shooting down at pinkertons

he got up fine after micah tackled him too

[faint gate]

I guess plot armor, didn't save him from dying but made him live longer

[empty lark]

it's a shame how free micah gets off of killing arthur, not really any injuries except for the eye scar in the high honor money ending

[faint gate]

What really hurt me the most about that scene is the fact that Dutch only gave up on Micah AFTER Arthur died

[empty lark]

does arthur even attempt to look where his gun went after micah gets off of him in the money ending? micah is quick enough to take advantage of that with a gun but they were using knives

[karmic prism]

he pretty much actually beats micah in the high honor money ending too

[empty lark]

in the mountain ending im sure it just falls off the edge but in the money ending it kinda just stops existing

[karmic prism]

and thats after micah snuck up and got a cheap stab

[karmic prism]

his guns just disappear from his belt i checked

[faint gate]

Maybe he thought it was too risky, chances are he would've been shot if Micah saw him trying to turn around

[empty lark]

wild

[radiant girder]

isn't it arthurs gun that he tries crawling to

[faint gate]

And Arthur without a gun is still strong, but not unstoppable anymore

[radiant girder]

or is that micahs

[karmic prism]

they really didnt know how to set up a believable hand to hand fight

[empty lark]

talking about the money ending

[radiant girder]

ah

[karmic prism]

and it is

[empty lark]

i think all they had to do was pick a mountain or other fighting zone with not an obvious edge to throw micah off of that you are unable to throw him off of
and for the money ending make micah kick the gun far away or have it fall into a burning pile of rubble from the camp

[faint gate]

What I remember it was Micah's, I doubt he would've tried to find his

[karmic prism]

he couldve taken off arthur's belt during the sneak attack yeah

anyway it's more satisfying beating/slicing micah up than shooting him

[empty lark]

i kinda wish Dutch walked in on Micah and Arthur after Arthur had died in the low honor money ending

and maybe put the screaming/moaning of names from Arthur to Dutch about people who didn't damn them somewhere in the high honor ending

[karmic prism]

the dialogue in the low ending is def better

[faint gate]

Maybe, but I don't imagine it was pleasant for Arthur to die knowing he will never be considered to have been "Good"

[karmic prism]

i dont imagine anything in the low honor ending is pleasant

[faint gate]

On the plus side, Low Honor is more fun than High Honor

[lime orchid]

I love Mickey

[shrewd edge]

Ive finished the Epulogue and I got 20k, What should I do with it?

[faint gate]

Do whatever you want, buy all the guns get all the horses

[shrewd edge]

I think I got most of em.

But why not

[karmic prism]

blowing it on horses is fun

i wish the rose gray arabian didnt look so silly though

[shrewd edge]

Bro what- I've seen two dead bodies on a wagon.

[analog wave]

Hungerian halfbred or appaloosa?

[faint gate]

Never ridden either, but seeing as every "Best" horse from RDR1 is bad in RDR2 I guess Appaloosa

[karmic prism]

probably hungarian

i like appaloosas aesthetic but theyre not much good at anything

at least halfbreds are tanks

[radiant girder]

hungarian

very good war horse

[ivory mortar]

What happened to John

[lime orchid]

Not in that way

[ivory mortar]

Mmmmm okay

[ivory mortar]

Just me or is Sadie’s outfit in the prologue 2 the best outfit an npc has ever had?

[karmic prism]

you mean epilogue?

idk i liked her outfits in the main story

yellow suits her better than black and red

[calm oasis]

Could someone help me with the poker mission for Swanson, I know it can be skipped, but I want the money

[karmic prism]

i think i know a straight up guide for that one if you want that

[fluid nexus]

So if I'm in epilogue part 2, is the killer treasure map unavailable now?
I have parts 1/2 of killer treasure map but the third one seems to be gone?

[calm oasis]

How on earth am I supposed to do Sharpshooter 4

[faint gate]

Haven't gotten to that yet, what do you need to do?

[calm oasis]

Kill an enemy at least 80 feet away with a thrown tomahawk

But I have somehow managed to do it, even though it did take me 20 minutes

[faint gate]

That sounds impossible, but good job

[summer anchor]

how to get more moneym

[calm oasis]

Uhm, do birds count towards sharpshooter 5?

[calm oasis]

you can do the treasure hunts

There are plenty of them

[fluid nexus]

Depending on what part of the story you are in you can do a few things

There's robbery tips, which you can see by left clicking the d pad.

There's being a bandit and robbing stores pretty much from the first chapter.

You can sell stolen horses, but that's also later in the game. Along with stagecoach robberies

[fluid nexus]

I believe birds do count. They are considered animals in every other sense in game

[fluid nexus]

The real question is, if you can find a ranch and massacre cattle and sheep

[round hawk]

i look at my inventory and theres a golden revolver, i just started 2nd chapter lol

how

[empty lark]

did you do a certain treasure hunt in gtao

the email was vanderlinde something something iirc

finishing it gives you a golden double action revolver in gtao and in rdr2 story mode

unfortunately it is way better in gtao than rdr2 but it's still nice ig

[round hawk]

yea iirc

bro the rampage trainer is wil

d

[karmic prism]

why they have to make double action the drippiest while also making it damn near useless

maybe if arthur had max payne's bullet spread it wouldnt be an issue

[faint gate]

I'm fine with them being bad, but why is it more expensive than the Cattleman? Don't make no sense

[radiant girder]

the game likes to think that the gun is good

when all it's stats is worse than the cattleman

like ALL of the stats

even speed

[faint gate]

I mean, I'll admit they look pretty badass but stats.. yeah they're just ass

[karmic prism]

yeah cattleman hipfire is way faster than double action

[ivory mortar]

What else is there in gta that you can get from rd2?

I have both

[empty lark]

in story just the golden double action and stone hatchet or tomahawk or whatever

in rdo just Lowry's revolver

it's a shame the gang doesn't call out Arthur on having an entirely gold and pearl gun on his hip

[faint gate]

Maybe it's because they don't really care, they are more worried about staying alive, not staring at someone else's holster

[empty lark]

yes in their severe lack of money

not even dutch has a full gold gun and he's the fanciest of them all, it's definitely not like arthur to have one

[faint gate]

Well, Arthur also isn't known to be a very careful spender so it's not too out of character for him to blow like $50 for a full gold gun with a pearl grip

[empty lark]

yes he doesn't usually have that kind of money, until the player gets control at least

they never really question a lot of the things arthur gets anyways ig, like a massive supply of clothes from both tailors/general stores and a trapper's animal clothing or the huge weapon locker he can build up in the little chest of his

"You know Mr. Morgan, with all that money you're spending on those clothes of yours, I'd expect at least some of it to have gone into the box"

[faint gate]

"I've been working hard, Ms. Grimshaw."

[karmic prism]

i always use mods to pick up otis miller's revolver as arthur

his + calloway's are the ultimate flex

[radiant girder]

i used calloways revolver since the start of chapter 2 on my last playthrough

[verbal cairn]

i used the cattleman's revolver for the entire game on my first playthrough

[shrewd edge]

I cracked up when arthur yells out lenny 🤣

[verbal cairn]

i was crying

[shrewd edge]

It was the bar mission

[verbal cairn]

I know

I was crying because everyone looked like Lenny

[verbal cairn]

what do you all name your horse

[lime orchid]

I have 3

Calypso, Pretty boy and Makka Pakka

[verbal cairn]

oh

[faint gate]

When I got my first White Arabian, I named it "Alaskan Mystery" since no one ever knows exactly where it spawned

Also, I just thought it sounded cool lol

[verbal cairn]

am I the only person who keeps the chapter 1 horse and John's horse for the entire game

[faint gate]

I don't ride it, but yeah I kept that starting horse

[verbal cairn]

that isn't nice

how do you think the horse feels? to stay shoved into a stable for their entire life

[faint gate]

I could care less, besides It probably gets taken care pretty well there

[verbal cairn]

That hurts my feelings

[hidden moss]

Dickhead F. Poopshit

[verbal cairn]

what does the F stand for

[faint gate]

Might be best you don't worry about it

[verbal cairn]

fair enough

I always name my horse "Kibutsuji"

[faint gate]

I normally just give mine common names like "Nelly" (Less common but still popular)

[hidden moss]

I name my first girl horse after Friede from Dark Souls

(Its almost always the Missouri Fox Trotter, specifically the pinto)

Both of them have a similar color scheme, so it’s fitting

[radiant girder]

named my horse Boot-E-Hol

[verbal cairn]

my horse has the best name

[radiant girder]

i also have Hot Diggity and Farticus

[simple vector]

I have a question
I have like 17k should I save it up or spend it

[lilac fog]

i was too for other reasons

[verbal cairn]

relatable

[lilac fog]

depends, do you NEED anything important? as in weapons, clothes?

[simple vector]

I don’t think I need it but it’s hard to not spend it 😔

[lilac fog]

yep..... when i do my second run, oh man, itll hurt

[verbal cairn]

I've beat this game 6 times

about to become 7

[lilac fog]

lol i feel ya, but you dont need that much. max ive had was like 4K after the valentine bank robbery

[lilac fog]

damm

[simple vector]

I’ve had 5k the whole game and then I got 20k in the epilogue and I don’t know what to do with it

[ionic thorn]

Lennnnayyyyy

[gilded kelp]

arter moangun in #red-dead-media

[spare trout]

Hey guys, idk if it’s only me, but when I do x mission the others is gone after I finish it, why is that?

Is it bc there is more than one ending?

It’s my first time playing the game

[feral terrace]

Guys

I need some help

How do i do the first shall be last quest, if blackwater is on lockdown

[median haven]

Just avoid the bounty hunters it’ll let you in there for the mission

[feral terrace]

ok ty

[median haven]

Also one thing to note, if you want the bolt action rifle early, after you and Javier knife the 2 bounty hunters in the river, there is a big path filled with bounty hunters, and there are 2 bounty hunters on the left - kill the one on the left first, with a headshot, without alerting them, and he will drop a bolt action rifle

I always get that on every play through its a good rifle

Argh wtf i just ran through and disarmed an entire O’Driscoll camp and it didn’t register a single one for the Sharpshooter 8 challenge

Oh maybe you have to disarm with a weapon not your fists.. hm

I’ve been running gung ho into enemy camps with nothing but my fists trying to disarm them haha

[spare trout]

?

[median haven]

Not entirely sure what you’re asking @spare trout

[lilac fog]

Yeah, gonna guess you asked about the one where you have to steal an oil wagon

if you take too long, wether by sidequests, or in general, John will do it for you

very usefull if you struggle with the mission

i know i did

i think its the only mission where something like this happens if you take too long

"This mission is technically optional. If the player fails to complete the mission in the same day as "Pouring Forth Oil I", John will steal the oil wagon instead and therefore this particular mission will no longer be available."

@spare trout is that the mission you asked about?

dead chat

[spare trout]

I meant in general

When I do a mission and complete it, the other missions I had just vanished from the map

Or I’m high

[grim wadi]

I do wonder what sadie was writing in the credits

Cause i forgot if it was ever mentioned

[radiant girder]

sadie?

that was mary beth

she's a book writer in the epilogue

[charred abyss]

what’s the best way to get the thimble item request?

[radiant girder]

loot bodies

[empty lark]

i got it off a dead bounty hunter

[green delta]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[karmic prism]

i wouldnt say so

generally you need a bigger horse like a dutch warmblood to make the jump

[radiant girder]

just go through owanjila dam

17 minutes is more than enough time

[karmic prism]

yeah but in vanilla the bridge is the only way arthur can do it without dying

[radiant girder]

just put a bounty on the ass of ur horse 👍

[green delta]

One message removed from a suspended account.

One message removed from a suspended account.

[radiant girder]

catch a bluegill

[green delta]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[lament osprey]

If you were drowning in a lake and there was a dog on the shore, he would get into the water and swim towards you, but he wouldn't be able to help you.

[verbal cairn]

I swear that I'm a psychopath in this game because once I beat the story I immediately start to kill every NPC I see

[blissful sandal]

odd flex

[verbal cairn]

the NPCs in this game are immortal

I've blown up the sheriff of Valentine and I come back and he's perfectly fine

Does this dude have a healing factor

[blissful sandal]

i love sitting on top of the sherrifs office in valentine

and just throwing dynamite

[verbal cairn]

the part of the game that frustrating is the clothing I can never decide what to wear

my favorite outfit is probably where I tried to get a Jason Voorhees looking outfit to go along with my mask

[exotic pier]

Don’t remind me of Dutch

Nobody shall speak of plan Der linde

[verbal cairn]

I had a goddamn plan!

[simple vector]

But he had a plan 😔

[obtuse apex]

Poor dutch

He just wanted to farm mangoes in tahiti

But nobody had any faith

[simple vector]

Real

They all were wrong and Dutch was right

he literally did nothing wrong

he's innocent how do people hate him

[summer anchor]

whats this weapon blip in my map

[exotic pier]

Because he has a plan

Al he says is “I have a plan”

[simple vector]

that makes him even more likable, what do you mean?? 🤨

[exotic pier]

No it don’t it makes him anoying

[simple vector]

How dare you insult him like that 🤬 he’s perfect and he did nothing wrong

[exotic pier]

It just my oppinion

[verbal cairn]

did you know that Dutch has a gun

pretty good hidden detail

[simple vector]

I wasn't serious bro, it's good

[exotic pier]

Yes I did now and he has saved me with it

[obtuse apex]

I thought he was shooting people with a bow. 0/10 game.

[verbal cairn]

he was

[clever thicket]

Tf happened here?

[verbal cairn]

i wish I could experience this game for the first time again

[hollow veldt]

still downloading rdr2 looking for people to play with later on! still new btw

[blissful sandal]

Hey if you use #pc-lfg you'll be able to find people easier!! This channel is for the single player story !

[iron parrot]

What’s the best revolver
I use Lemat and it’s very good

[empty lark]

anything but the double action

[misty bronze]

I Personally like the double action occasionally because it gives more of a challenge

[radiant girder]

it's lemat

stat wise i mean

[iron parrot]

I once bought double action because I didn’t know how horrible of a gun it was and I instantly regretted the purchase

[empty lark]

yes it has the lowest damage and accuracy of the revolvers

lowest accuracy of all sidearms except sawed off shotgun but there's at least a good reason for that

maybe lowest damage too but semi-auto pistols might be a bit lower i don't remember

either way semi-auto still way better than double actions with low damage made up for by actually good accuracy and high fire rate, also a very quick reload if you're not using deadeye to do that anyways

[karmic prism]

lemat is probably best objectively, only downside is the bad reload

its up to preference

[verbal cairn]

what was the first ending you got? my first playthrough I got the low honor help John up

[ivory abyss]

Howdy

[ivory mortar]

Same but high honor

[verbal cairn]

I did that in my second playthrough

[ivory mortar]

[serene cedar]

old woman pulls out knife and threatens Dutch and Arthur, so Dutch kills her in self defense

Dutch: "she was gonna betray us, Arthur. Couldn't you tell"?

Arthur: "no"

[verbal cairn]

funny how betrayal is foreshadowed

[obtuse fog]

hello I'm new to this, I'm Noah as you can tell

how far are you guys in story mode ?

[verbal cairn]

7th playthrough, chapter 6

[obtuse fog]

i played the story 6 times and I'm in chapter 2, because some how before chapter 2 I was playing in chapter 6 but It randomly restarted, I was so pissed

i gotta go bye, it was nice to meet you

[hidden moss]

12th playthorugh chapter 2...

[hardy willow]

2nd playthrough chapter 3

[radiant girder]

6 or 7th playthrough

going for a second 100% playthrough

[slow geode]

Doing gambler 8 and I wanna jump off a bridge

[obtuse fog]

oh you suicidal sometimes ?

[dull geyser]

Yep but that downside is gone once you use deadeye for instant reloads

Probably on par with schofields for best sidearms

[karmic prism]

schofield is best balanced

accurate, good reload

it should be miles quicker than the cattleman realistically bc break action is faster but i digress

[verbal cairn]

when I beat the game I'm going to spend all of the money you get I haven't done that yet

chapter 6 feels like the longest chapter in the game

[cunning shale]

Bruh I like the double action 💀 just like the fast fire rate for close quarters

Good for when there's loads of targets close by

My favorite is the Schofield tho

[ivory mortar]

Chapter 2 goes on for forever though

[verbal cairn]

is there a lore reason to why every NPC is immortal

[hidden moss]

Can anyone help me with "All's Fair" trophy? I'm on pc

[hidden moss]

The happiest chapter of the storyline, yep.

[versed basin]

i completed the epilougue and i want to change johns clothes im in his house where do i do that?

[empty lark]

bathroom

[solar briar]

guys how do i download a save file that skips chapter 1

[lime orchid]

You can’t I don’t think

[verbal cairn]

the ending to the 2nd game is both a good and a bad ending

[karmic prism]

i'm at 98% completion

almost there

[novel cliff]

Keep going

[severe river]

yo i got a question
will losing honour once change anything story wise?

i killed the guy at the cliff that said he knew me from black water

please ping reply if you answer

[novel cliff]

Probably but I let him live

[severe river]

ah shit

[cinder viper]

honor affects arthur's personality

[novel cliff]

But next time if you want to do a different slot for a new game let him live

[cinder viper]

and the end of the story

[novel cliff]

Yeah

[severe river]

yeah i know that but will 1 honor loss change anything

feel like ill lose alot from that 1 situation

eh never mind i read about it and honour is meaningless ig

until a few chapters later

thanks for everyone answering

[karmic prism]

generally chapter 5 is when major honor differences start happening

[sick star]

hola

[radiant girder]

theres a avalanche just northeast of Watsons cabin that leads up the edge of mount hagen

overlooks east side of big valley

new photo spot

will try n post it in #red-dead-media

[iron parrot]

Is the Lichfield good

[radiant girder]

yes

[north swan]

lancaster over every other repeater imo

[karmic prism]

yeah but has a lot of recoil and a slower reload

but its the most powerful

[verbal cairn]

who needs guns? sharp objects and the bow is the way to go

[hidden moss]

Fists are the best .

[verbal cairn]

yeah both is good

[graceful tapir]

I cant save

[cinder viper]

?

[verbal cairn]

what's the best horse in the game

[radiant girder]

mfts and turkomans

[verbal cairn]

where are those

[radiant girder]

no where

they ain't in the wild

[verbal cairn]

where

[radiant girder]

glitches

[verbal cairn]

no glitches or mods what's the best horse

[radiant girder]

mfts and turkomans

you don't need the best horse anyways

just use the horse that you like

majority of the "best" horses are obtained through glitches

[wise ice]

can you rob gunsmiths?

im in the gun shop but the gunsmith isnt there, i just took a bunch of ammo but can u take the weapons or nah

[verbal cairn]

no

[mossy apex]

can’t take guns but you can rob the register

[verbal cairn]

I don't like his how the police send an infinite amount of cops to kill you

Valentine sheriff sends infinity police to kill you for shoving a woman off the balcony

[noble spire]

arabians horses in the wild but they too small and very timid

they are fast horses tho

[spice tide]

buell

[karmic prism]

subjective

[karmic prism]

unless its buell, then its objective

[iron parrot]

I think there should be an alternative ending where if you knock out/kill Micah in the final mission a cutscene plays that shows Arthur dying from TB (maybe in a bed or sum)

[verbal cairn]

I like the towns that have no law where you can do anything you want

and I found a really funny detail in van horn

[iron parrot]

Which towns have no law

[untold lintel]

Does anyone have a deffinitive way to fix the annesburg train not leaving the station? I've heard several methods that claim to fix it and not a single one has solved the issue.

Some work sometimes, then stop working entirely, that's the best I've gotten.

[verbal cairn]

Armadillo and van horn

[iron parrot]

Oh so you can just rob someone with no punishment

[verbal cairn]

yeah you get away with everything in armadillo but in van horn if you do something then everyone in the town tries to kill you it's like 8 times out of 10 there if they'll attack or not

[verbal cairn]

also I heard that the character model of John in the epilogue is just his head on Arthur's body? Is that true

[empty lark]

yeah pretty much

john has all of arthur's hair and facial hair style options, it's basically just his face put over Arthur's and the hair changed to black

[verbal cairn]

that is not ok

[untold lintel]

Trains have stopped functioning entirely, I'm livid

[green delta]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[iron parrot]

I think so

[karmic prism]

just visited ms grimshaw's grave, damn charles did her dirty compared to high honor arthur

[karmic prism]

you only need to complete 10 stranger missions for the game to consider it "complete"

and whether you burn the posters or turn them in doesnt matter

[iron parrot]

Why isn’t the Navy revolver in story

I had to mod it in

[empty lark]

because rockstar was too lazy to move anything from rdo into story

it's only more annoying knowing that rdo happens about a year before story at 1898

[lilac fog]

i tried rdo, but ut felt overwhelming when you join for the first time, much prefer story mode

[karmic prism]

so i think i'm softlocked from 100%

i've done all the sharpshooter challenges but it won't let me purchase the bandolier for no reason

gonna have to use a save editor i think

[verbal cairn]

I'm crying after seeing the ending to this game for the 50th time it's still good

[karmic prism]

ok done, hopefully it works

idk why it never gave me the bandolier i might have just messed with mods too much

[verbal cairn]

I found a big chungus easter egg in the game

[karmic prism]

finally, i had to undo every sharpshooter challenge and use a mod to do it again

that was a lot of effort

[hollow wasp]

I'm in chapter 4 and I don't think my honor is going up

[thorny fiber]

Pics or it didn't happen...

[verbal cairn]

It's just my horse, I named it big chungus

[hidden moss]

I get thus server is for rdr2 but I don't know where else to ask

in rdr1 does dialogue change based on you outfit and suff

they keep referring to John as a city dweller. is that because I'm wearing the suit

[modern viper]

I shot a heart Broken man and he fell on fire....

[verbal cairn]

you get good honor for doing that

[modern viper]

Oohh

But threw his stuff what he needed

Into fire

[verbal cairn]

if you go back to his house during 3am you can see a ghost in the window

[radiant girder]

jeremiah compson?

you should kill him

cuz y'know he's a slave owner

[verbal cairn]

was

[iron parrot]

Will RDR1 get a pc port

Also will rockstar add any new features/collectibles/side missions or move some RDO guns to Single player?

[empty lark]

for now no, if rockstar wanted to move shit from rdo to singleplayer then they could've done it way before now

i wouldn't expect an rdr1 pc port either tbh, they might've just done it with the ps and ns ports if they were going to and they're still mainly focused on gta6 and not rdr

[empty lark]

at least people have made mods on pc to do what rockstar should've done themselves though

[hidden moss]

i think i made the record for the longest fall in rdr2

[wise ice]

If i continue with the main story, will i be able to revisit side missions afterwards (mary linton, brother dorkins etc)

[radiant girder]

no