red-dead-singleplayer

[limpid schooner]

just wait until arthur dies

[cobalt oracle]

bro

[hidden moss]

Yes. You get all your stuff back.

If it shows a cowboy, and it's to the right, you're good. If it's to the left, and that skull, you gotta level it up.

we need money

That's the point.

🤑

🤑

[hidden moss]

Old joke.

[hidden moss]

🤓

[hollow bronze]

omg how have u not been spoiled yet being on this server??!?

but fully agree. this game is brutal, I love it

[calm oasis]

Almost 750 hours and I just now learned the gang have been in Chicago

[haughty plume]

Anyone know how to install more pretty gun mod?

[calm oasis]

Why cant I get the 2nd mission with Charlotte Balfour or whatever to spawn?

It doesnt pop up on the map

[calm oasis]

When do I have to go to aberdeens pig farm as Arthur?

[mortal horizon]

Before the end

[calm oasis]

Yeah but which mission is it

[mortal horizon]

If you’re in chapter 6 just do it by the time you get to the Eagle Flies final mission

You will know when its his final mission

After that, go pig farm

[calm oasis]

SO I got a bunch of time, since I havent even completed the money lending and other sins 6

[mortal horizon]

Once Micah’s homies show up to camp and Eagle Flies mission series ends, the game is about to wrap up

[calm oasis]

And will the Reutlinger pocket watch transfer over to John or should I sell it

[hidden moss]

it tranfers to john

[calm oasis]

Because the watch looks good

Even though its 155 dollars, it do be lookin good

[hidden moss]

only thing i know that dont transfer to john is sellable items, female fertility statue and the viking comb

valuables that are unique or are used to craft stuff are kept

[hidden moss]

Female Fertility Statue
Diamond Brooch
Gold Bar
Gold Ingot
Gold Nugget
Gold Ring
Gold Pendent Necklace
Gold Belt Buckle
Necklace
Pearl Necklace
Pen
Platinum Band
Platinum Necklace
Platinum Earrings
Platinum Engraved Buckle
Platinum Spring Bracelet
Pearl Earring (unknown if it carries over or not)
Silver Buckle
Silver Locket (J. John Weathers Debt)
Silver Emblem Ring
Silver Necklace
Silver Tooth (only spawns once, I’d recommend getting it as John so it doesn’t get lost)
Wedding Ring
Ancient Viking Comb
i think

[calm oasis]

those are the things that dont transfer over or those that do?

[hidden moss]

yes

the ones that are valuables and are used to craft stuff will not be transfered

[calm oasis]

:/

so the watch wont carry over to John?

[hidden moss]

it will

i had a run, john had it

[calm oasis]

because I know that the emerald from the dude, Margaret or whatever does transfer

[calm oasis]

What weapon loadout should I use for Visiting Hours

[hidden moss]

lancaster or bolt action

the gaurds will be coming for you and you have time to take them down from a long distance

[weary crest]

i beat the game

i cried

should i do low honor for the epilogue and fuck everyone up

[calm oasis]

How do I reel in the legendary northern pike

Its stuck in one place, it aint moving

Could somebody help me?

Ok nevermind got him

[marble mantle]

i have a question: i have some sort of visual thing going on in my game where whenever (for example) my character aims with a weapon, the spot where the gun was being holstered before still renders the image of the gun for a split second, kind of like the mouse pointer option to have a trail, idk how to explain it

its in no way annoying me but its very weird and i thought it might be some sort of bug

[weary crest]

honestly i might not play the epilogues

the first one is boring so far and im depreessed now

[calm oasis]

What the hell

They shot my health cure out of my hands

Is that a thing?

[twilit yarrow]

probably

never happened to me but I wouldn't be suprised if it was the case

[haughty plume]

What should i do when i have .rar file while tryina install mods

[violet sphinx]

I know the entire summary of the story, but when I play I force my brain to forget and play like it's my first time.

[radiant girder]

god i remember riding through the heartlands for the first time to help hosea rob carmody dell

[cobalt oracle]

I just learned that after you do the mission with the Saint Denis mayor, if you decided to kill the guy at the end and you go fishing in the pond where you dump the body, you can pull up the dead guys arm

[empty lark]

yes

it almost never happens but it can

it's made of glass so if it gets shot it'll break, the hard part is an npc actually shooting where that can happen

[midnight obsidian]

alright so, for those of you who complain about money being hard to grind without mods, i have a pro method to do in singeplayer

here:
take a train ticket to riggs station, as the riggs station train is the most valuable, with 3 safes, a money clip and jewelry in the back, and coin purse in a case, and all passengers are wealthy
start the robbery, rob all passengers, then head to the back, plant dynamite on the rear safe, go to the rear carriage, loot the money clip and jewelry in the drawer and cupboard, then go back to the safe, loot it, then go to the secondmost front carriage, plant dynamite on the safe there, go to the front most carriage, plant dynamite on that safe, and then the dynamite you just planted on the secondmost carriage will have detonated, so go back, loot the safe, then move to a chest around the back of the carriage, take the coin purse, go to the front carriage, loot the safe, then get outtta there

you can make about 200-300 dollars per robbery this way

then, go up to wallace station and repeat

this is just street knowledge i learned during my years of playing on PS4

[karmic prism]

just kill people lol

[cinder viper]

[trim plover]

are Stilt Shack and The Loft really not possible to "inspect"??

i read those are points of interest, but i cant inspect them

[hidden moss]

This method actually breaks quite a bit. I had to wait a whole day irl before the train would work again. Basically, when you travel with it, it never moves.

[radiant girder]

yeah you can't

don't make sense why you can't but games are just like that sometimes

[trim plover]

ahhh ok. good to know

[calm oasis]

When does the veteran mission spawn?

I mean what time in-game

[karmic prism]

just after fleeting joy

or it might be after murfree country idk

you can do it before the diagnosis at least

[mortal horizon]

I never got it until chapt 6

[calm oasis]

Does Hamish have only 4 missions?

[mortal horizon]

Yep

[calm oasis]

So I should leave the 4th one to John if I want Buell in epilogue?

[calm oasis]

Wait so the last mission is My Last Boy?

[tawny lava]

Damn epilogue ending was great

So much better than base game

[cobalt oracle]

why can no shoot chiken in farm

[midnight obsidian]

John without long hair is heresy

Change my mind

[calm oasis]

If I do the ending where I go for the money from Beaver Hollow, can I get the money as John?

[cobalt oracle]

nope

you get a ton of money after the epilogue anyways so it doesnt really matter

[calm oasis]

Yeah, and I have over 20 thousand at Aberdeens pig farm so screw it

[wooden quarry]

Can anyone help me? On my first playthrough I had to press Q to do X's on ppl in dead eye. But now it's automatic. How do I change it back to pressing Q?

Same thing goes for online

[cobalt oracle]

you're only able to manually select after a certain point in the story

just progress more and it'll fix

[wooden quarry]

But in my first playthrough it was like that in the beggining

[cobalt oracle]

that's weird

[wooden quarry]

Yeah

And it's automatic in online too, always has been

[cobalt oracle]

I know it's not supposed to be manual until a certain point in the story

[fast flicker]

I got a question about how the gang tents work in chapter 2

Why does John have a huge tent to himself after leaving the gang for 1 year
But Hosea is on a sleeping bag next to bill and Lenny

[worthy stag]

i caught that pos street urchin before he reached the market

[mortal horizon]

I wish rdr2 had unlimited bounties like the first one

[hidden moss]

You can only do his missions in chapter 6 if I'm correct.

[hidden moss]

John has a wife, and a child. They take care of the women, and children better. It's a respect thing.

Women, and children always come above men. He's only under that tent because they're his family.

[fast flicker]

They sleep on the floor elsewhere

[hidden moss]

They also get a room at Shady Belle.

Again, it's the whole women, and children thing.

[fast flicker]

But jack and Abigail sleep on a sleeping bag nowhere near johns tent

At least in chapter 2

[hidden moss]

I think it was there for them. However, they fought a lot, so she probably slept away from him. Dutch can't exactly kick him out of the tent either.

[silent osprey]

im trying to kill the vampire and he wont show up even though i found all of the writing what should i do?

oh

nevermind

[karmic prism]

you can unlock manual deadeye by just levelling it up yourself too i think

it just auto unlocks at fleeting joy to make the setpiece work

[cobalt oracle]

oh ok

[summer pine]

Ong I had the whole story spoiled for me I knew what happened but the first time I played it still hit hard as shit

[karmic prism]

i didnt know dutch was a villain in rdr1 and thought he'd die in chapter 1 lmao

[dapper scroll]

guys?

how do i make version.dll not crash my game??

tryna get gun tricks mod

why this so dead

[twilit yarrow]

no mods

[hollow bronze]

SAME WTF I was an idiot and browsed the subreddit lmao. but despite knowing almost everything that was coming, it still hit me like a goddamn train

[glad wraith]

Guys can somebody help me with gambler 8? I ain't gonna learn how to play dominoes for it, does anyone know how to?

[warm musk]

Isn't Gambler 8 where you have to win blackjack with 3 hits

[glad wraith]

no that's 7 I already did that

except if it is 9 idk I need help

[warm musk]

Idk then I'm on 7 I guess

[glad wraith]

it's the one where you have to win 3 dominoes round in a row

[sturdy sail]

during the chapter 4 mission Country Pursuits Dutch goes on this ramble about this and that and how Hosea lost his spine and such and he goes on about this thing that he's not forcing anyone to stay in camp, but way later in chapter 6 when Arthur mentions about letting the women and jack go he seems pretty objected to the idea to say the least, and i don't really know if this is something the writters overlooked or its to show how quick Dutch can change his opinion on something

But then again the mission is just after he got that bash in the head from the trolley station job so maybe he just said it without meaning it

[weary crest]

i finish the epilogues

[karmic prism]

dutch was incredibly paranoid and unreasonable by the end

actively calls everyone who left "traitors and cowards"

[calm oasis]

Why cant I get the white arabian to spawn in?

Nevermind, found it

[hidden moss]

Go to Emerald Ranch station. That's your best bet. You just have to plan ahead with your dominoes, there's no real method. Emeral Ranch station seems to be easier though.

[glad wraith]

that's what I tried I don't know how to play so I just played random things and kept loosing

[hidden moss]

It's because it's showing him turn into the man he always spoke ill about. He always said women, and kids were to be protected, but then he killed women, and didn't care what happened to Jack. The trolley incident messed his head up, that much was obvious, but Hosea dying, and Micah getting in his head really finished the job.

[hidden moss]

My best bet, look at your dominoes, plan it out. For example, do a 4 and 4, 4 and 5, 5 and 6, 6 and 2, 2 and 2.

Basically look what move you can make after your previous domino, and play it in that order.

They will block it, but surprisingly not that much.

[glad wraith]

4 dots you mean right?

I just play a random one that is available

[hidden moss]

Yes. You aren't gonna get that exact order, the point is look at what can go with what. You're gonna wanna plan all your dominoes before you even lay one out. You wanna get as many down as possible as fast as possible. You will draw a lot, but if you're down low, you will still win.

[glad wraith]

wait so do you know how to play dominoes?

[hidden moss]

That's probably your biggest issue. For me, I played randomly, lost every game. Once I started planning every domino out ahead of time, I won. You will draw, and will have to switch up, but you're so low on dominoes that you'll get lucky.

[hidden moss]

It's mostly luck. I beat it immediately because I planned it out.

[glad wraith]

exactly how do i "plan it out"?

[hidden moss]

You can also get up after each win, and save the game.

If you lose, you then reload.

[glad wraith]

Oh yeah great tip

I don't know how dominoes work in the slightest so i cant really plan it out

[hidden moss]

Like I said before, look at your dominoes. Here's another example, say you have a 2 and 2, 5 and 2, 2 and 3, etc, play the one that will allow you the move after that move. You need to make sure you can keep going.

You have to look at each domino, think ok, if I put this down, I can play that domino, then that domino can be played off of that one, etc.

[glad wraith]

How do I know if a domino can be played after a different one

[hidden moss]

Ok let me explain it a bit better.

Before you lay a single domino down, look at each one.

[glad wraith]

do you want to just go on a call? I can share my screen and you can just type what I need to do

[hidden moss]

Sure.

Go to vc in here.

Go to LFG 1.

[calm oasis]

Should I be using Buell or White Arabian?

[hidden moss]

I think White Arabian is better for speed.

[summer pine]

Ikr? That’s how you know it a good story

[radiant girder]

Save buell for epilogue

use something other than white arabian tho

like a turkoman

or a MFT

[hidden moss]

Am i the only one that uses the random horse i tamed in like chapter 2 and i’ve been using it but its a good horse it was a brindle thoroughbred but i didnt know at the time

[pseudo dragon]

Is it fast?

[mortal horizon]

Fame mechanic shouldve came to the second game

It’s so funny to walk around and everyone is talking about John Marston. “Did you hear what John Marston said?” “Hey look it’s John Marston!” “Is it true that you can shoot a man between the eyes at 100 paces?” Just makes John feel like such a hero lol. That wouldve been cool

[gaunt bobcat]

Does the 250$ bounty in all 5 states count with Arthur?

Just murdered all the kkk as Arthur

[radiant girder]

no

can't have a bounty in 5 states if you can't go in 5 states

[bright dawn]

Which town has the nicest rooms i can buy

Like the ones in the saloons

[ornate gorge]

.

[midnight obsidian]

real question, how have johns scars not healed

i'm not sure they'd remain for 12 years

for instance, i lost my left middle finger a year ago, and the wound has fully healed

no scarring

[radiant girder]

saint denis or strawberry

[radiant girder]

we weren't so advanced in medicine back then

[karmic prism]

true, especially because honor is so different in 2

fame kind of plays into high honor though, as in you get recognised more for your good deeds and get discounts but its not the same

i still miss the bandanna from rdr1 that just let you do whatever you want its so silly

[hidden moss]

who else hate the fact that you as Arthur can't harm Micah at the camp like by punching him?

I mean Charles and Javier could do it so why not Arthur?

[tiny jolt]

Is there a way to reach armadillo as Arthur? I'm trying to complete the cigarette card side mission.

Is there a glitch I can do? Or do I just keep spamming tonics?

[hidden moss]

i think there should be tons of tutorials on youtube for it

[mortal horizon]

He got attacked by wolves bro if it’s a deep cut that definitely wouldnt heal. I mean, it’s healed, but you would be heavily scarred forever by that for sure

[radiant girder]

there's the angelo bronte glitch

just search it on youtube and you be good

[radiant girder]

u should be able to aim ur gun at people

only when they do those lil camp interactions

like micah kicking cain

not shoot them just aim it at them

[hidden moss]

spamming tonics is useless cuz one step in new austin the sniper will get you with one hit

[tiny jolt]

Damnnn bruh. Guess I gotta wait to play as John

[hidden moss]

theres a glitch to enter in new austin in a chapter 4 mission but i never did it

so go search

[pseudo dragon]

What's in new Austin?

[calm oasis]

Sand and dirt and one treasure

Elemental trail I think

[empty lark]

legendary cougar, otis miller's revolver, tiger striped bay mustang, armadillo, tumbleweed, macfarlane's ranch, part of that fisherman's mission has a legendary fish there that kills him and cant actually be caught

elemental trail treasure map yes

[gray cedar]

im hunting all the legendary animals

low key easy as fuck

but for the love of god i can NOT get ANY legendary fidh

there's no clues so you just gotta hope for the best

[gray cedar]

also why am i losing honor when i throw dynamite in lake isabella to catch the legendary fish

[hearty drum]

ikr why is legendary fishing so hard, but you could kill all the legendary animals in 1 day.

[spark pasture]

Why are some challenges locked ?

Im playing the story again and cant remember how to unlock the challenges

[hidden moss]

What chapter are you on?

I think they either are automatically unlocked, or you do something along the lines of the challenge, and it unlocks.

[hidden moss]

It's not really that hard, just time consuming.

You just need patience with them, which is why they're legendary. They aren't supposed to be caught in 5 seconds.

[spark pasture]

2

[spark pasture]

Thx

[dapper scroll]

im trying to install whyems dlc but my game keeps on crashing before launch, i think its the version.dll

any tips?

[radiant girder]

god i wish xbox could use mods

clothing and gun customization is kinda doo doo

[mortal horizon]

I just got attacked by 3 full grown bears at once

Red Dead 1 >>> 2

I didnt know dogs will attack other animals if they come near them

[pure stirrup]

What happens if i lose a legendary fish from my horse? Can i no longer ever send it in?

[mortal horizon]

FIVE bears attacked me at once now jesus Tall Trees is messed up

SEVEN

[pure stirrup]

wtf are u even doing there

[south shore]

For some reason the rockstar launcher cant find my rdr2 files, anyone know how to help?

[mortal horizon]

Bruh 11 fucking bears

[mortal horizon]

Came here for a bounty and killed 7 bears on the way. Then on the way to jail encountered 4 more. He got ripped off my horse and I had to duel it out with 4 bears and his homies at the same time lol

I saw more bears just now on this one trip than ive seen the entire game

[bitter quartz]

How did you encounter 11 bears bro

[silk walrus]

You unlock them by doing certain things for that specific challenge. Like for the herbalist challenge you need to collect I think yarrow in the wild to unlock the herbalist challenge

[spark pasture]

Thanks

[mortal horizon]

Idk i guess there was some kind of spawn issue because as soon as i got to Tall Trees i fought 7 bears in a row then as i was leaving they were just spawning everywhere but i fought 4 more lol

[mortal horizon]

Damn i almost just got the manifest destiny trophy in one go but one buffalo escaped. Im never gonna find that mf

[radiant girder]

tall trees fr best place in the game

[mortal horizon]

Fr i completed like basically every hunting challenge there lol

[peak sluice]

Anyone on?

[wintry violet]

Yes

[peak sluice]

What’s ur favourite character?

In story I mean

[wintry violet]

I like charles

[peak sluice]

Solid choice

Guess mine lol

[wintry violet]

I'm assuming dutch

[peak sluice]

🤯

I was gna assume urs was Sean

But yeah

[wintry violet]

I just think he's funny

[peak sluice]

Same

Especially when he says that thing abt the braithwaite guy

“I’ll shove that silver spoon down his throat and pull it, clean out of his arse. The smug fucker”

Best line in the game 💀

[wintry violet]

Who's your least favorite?

[peak sluice]

Ooh

Most ppl say Micah

But

[wintry violet]

Yeah

[peak sluice]

I think it’s probably got to be Strauss

Or agent Ross

[wintry violet]

Same

[peak sluice]

Ong

[wintry violet]

Ross is just kind of a jerk

[peak sluice]

yeah he backstabs John

I hate him sm

Especially after playing rdr1

[wintry violet]

Yeah I've played both games

[peak sluice]

Agent Fordham is ok tho

He’s just doing his job

[peak sluice]

Undead nightmare?

[wintry violet]

YES.

[peak sluice]

Wheyyy nice

[wintry violet]

I got the game of the year addition

[peak sluice]

Oh cool

I bought the special edition when it was on sale bc it left game pass

I have 75 days on rdr2 ☠️

[wintry violet]

Jeez

189 💀

[sturdy reef]

Yooo what happened bruh

Just got to chapter 5

Went from a Western vigilante to a character in stranded deep

[wintry violet]

That happens

Prepare for chapter 6

It gets sad

[sturdy reef]

I get to go back right

[wintry violet]

Yes

[sturdy reef]

Cause if I had of known I’d be shipped off I woulda settled my affairs

[wintry violet]

Trust me I've played the game 3 times

[sturdy reef]

Sheesh

[wintry violet]

I know right?

[keen birch]

[sturdy reef]

And his beer belly

Man that’s ugly to look at when his shirt is undone

[keen birch]

Arthur with a mask or bandana be like

[hidden moss]

LMAO

[karmic prism]

idk how he hides it

like it just looks like hes got a bit of a gut when its buttoned up but damn

[sturdy reef]

I know dude. The shirt makes him lose a good 15lbs

[karmic prism]

i like his hair better when its behind his ears though

[hidden moss]

Is it weird I never noticed it until the island? I genuinely thought he was fit.

[sturdy reef]

Same bro

I wonder if that was intentional

Like they remodelled him

[hidden moss]

I don't think so. I think he just didn't wear a tight shirt. It was a bit loose, even tucked in.

[radiant girder]

i think it was to accommodate his face

hateable looking face, and a body that fits it well

[sturdy reef]

I also feel like Dutchs face got fater

I mean… Maybe I just didn’t notice but his face looked fater since the island

Like his cheeks and stuff

[warm summit]

[radiant girder]

[tender sigil]

yo

[sturdy reef]

Oh

I got tuberculosis

[empty lark]

[cobalt oracle]

tuberculosis is a potato 🥔 🥔 🥔

[mortal horizon]

U should be able to change the ending of the first game depending who you hit with dead eye frfr

[cobalt oracle]

is there any reason why after killing some people in valentine a fuckin lynch mob with torches attacked

it was like a clump of people and they had knives and torches

i've never seen torches outside of guarma

[mortal horizon]

Idk but thats cool. Single player or rdo

[cobalt oracle]

single player

[hidden moss]

You've done crested a riot in the 1800s.

[cobalt oracle]

they didnt even attack me

they went around me and it looked like they were trying to kill me but they didn't do any damage

[wintry violet]

[umbral wadi]

Because that’s just how it is

You can’t save after activating any cheat

It’s kinda stupid

It’s only single player

[hidden moss]

so I am only in chap 2 story mode and I want to rob the medical place in valentine but for some reason I can't rob it I have checked all entrances did all things but I can't rob it, can someone help me?

[pseudo dragon]

I'm sad

[trim plover]

i just got through the stranger mission Idealism and Pragmatism for Beginners (with Henri Lemieux). OMG if you replay that mission, watch Arthur's face during the cutscenes. He makes some goofy ass and hilarious faces LMAO

I also just found out Pearson's first name is Simon. hmm something else I never knew after 600+ hrs of play

[hidden moss]

can I only do it 1 time or something?

I discovered it and got killed by police ofr wearing a mask

so is it one time per play through?

[hidden moss]

i dont think so

[gaunt bobcat]

Just got the grin and bear it trophy it finally

[compact patio]

I think I will play rdr1 for the 15th time In the past month

It only takes 2 days to complete for me with all side missions

[sturdy sail]

That little ?

I would've thought it would take more with all side missions too

[compact patio]

Well on my last save I didn't fast travel did most challenges and all side missions and it took 18 hours

Tbf that took like 3 days instead of 2 but still

[analog trench]

[vital epoch]

[analog wave]

You have to go in and pull the weapon on the doctor and threaten him. He will lead you to the back and unlock the door. Kill everyone in the room and take the money and run

[analog wave]

I hear they're gonna remake rdr1

[compact patio]

Ah I hope so

[analog wave]

I haven't played it unfortunately, that would be awesome if they remake it

I just visited that shack in the big valley to get cigarette cards and there was a grizzley inside bruh my heart sank💀

[compact patio]

The game is so good

Is it on the ps store still

Ik it use to be available to stream

[analog wave]

Nope

Also it's only compatible with ps3

[compact patio]

Ah that's a shame

I wanna see a rdr1 remaster or remake tho

[mortal horizon]

I just played it again for the first time in 10 years and its better than the second one frfr

[cobalt oracle]

if you have the 360 disk it's backwards compatible with the xbox 1 and series x

[silver flame]

does anyone know where a good cougar spot is? ive been in black bone forest and yet i only got 1 cougar in 3 hours

[radiant girder]

willards rest

just go far away from black bone forest and sleep for the max amount of time

go back to black bone and there's a spawn between the road and the trapper there

near the stream

[silver flame]

ty

[hidden moss]

I believe you need a tip.

[left ore]

You're losing your time, pining after John

[vernal fiber]

This morning I was hunting the legendary bison and while I was there was a question mark near the lake. Didn’t want to lose him so kept going but went back a min later and it was gone. Anyone know what I missed?

[radiant girder]

just go back there after a few in game days

it'll respawn

[magic kite]

dang it sure the horse sometime are stupid

[analog wave]

The question mark sometimes appears where the first track is. I don't think you missed anything. Just go make a camp somewhere near. Sleep a day or two and come back.

[pseudo berry]

i’d like a remaster

[compact patio]

If they dont screw it up it would be good

[vast oak]

If you sell a legendary pelt to a trapper, can you get all the items from that though? It’s been a while since I played last time

[vernal fiber]

Thanks a bunch!

[analog wave]

Npp

[pastel jay]

Not quite sure wym

[mortal horizon]

Yes, you have to sell it to get access to corresponding items

[vast oak]

I meant if you can craft all of the items from it. Let’s say you craft the bear helmet or whatever it’s called, can you make the shirt as well?

[mortal horizon]

If its legendary, you can only catch one anyway so you only get one use from it. Outside of legendaries, one pelt counts towards one item only

[vast oak]

I know that. But from the pelt you can craft special clothing. Can you only craft one piece or can you do all with the same pelt?

[mortal horizon]

One piece per pelt if it isn’t legendary

[karmic prism]

is there a way to change the quickdraw controls on controller to how it works on the mouse? my new controller doesnt have trigger sensitivity lol

[hidden moss]

already tried it doesn't work

[hidden moss]

wdym?

[analog wave]

Did you activate the mission by peaking trough the window in the back?

Also this guy could be right. There's an encounter where you free an escaped prisoner and he tells you about the operation behind drug store

[hidden moss]

I have knocked on front door, rear, peered through the window but it doesn't say I found the secret operation

I did find it earlier but before I could even start the robbery the cop caught me for wearing a mask

[analog wave]

I encountered him somewhere in the heartlands

[analog wave]

Jeez, yeah you shouldn't wear the mask lol

[hidden moss]

oh, did I ruin my only chance?

[analog wave]

If u started the robbery and then the law was on you yes.
Happened to me when that prostitute asked me to help her hide the body. I antagonized some guy and the mission stopped

Dw tho there's plenty other places to rob

[hidden moss]

I didn't even start yet tho

just walked it with a mask and he got pissed

[analog wave]

Idk then lol

[hidden moss]

all I want to do the robbery for is the schoefiled

do I gotta wait a couple days?

[analog wave]

Maybe

Try sleeping couple days

[marble mantle]

Is the navy revolver in the game or is it only for rdo

[mortal horizon]

Only rdo

[analog wave]

Rdo

[marble mantle]

Rip

That gun slaps

[mortal horizon]

You can mod it in on pc

[hidden moss]

I did try sleeping for a couple days and it let me open the door but I didn't get the notification for finding it

[analog wave]

Fr

[marble mantle]

Idk

Depends

I havent used mods yet in rdr2

[mortal horizon]

If I had PC I’d absolutely be using mods

[marble mantle]

Ill check them ojt

[mortal horizon]

At the very least gang hideout mod, gun tricks mod, etc

[marble mantle]

Out*

[hidden moss]

also I picked up the quest in the bar where you gotta find the outlaws but then forgot abt it, any way I can still do it?

[marble mantle]

Gang hideout?

[mortal horizon]

There are mods that add some good content. Dialogue and whatnot

[mortal horizon]

Yeah there’s a mod that adds gang hideouts like there were in the first game. It basically just places groups of rival gang members over the map for you to fight

[marble mantle]

Ohhhh

So it basically keeps all the original gangs that go against you back or smth?

[mortal horizon]

Same gangs, it just adds in more encounters

[marble mantle]

I didnt play rdr

[mortal horizon]

Well in the first game, there were “gang hideouts” which were basically missions where you had to fight a bunch of guys to clear an area

So they added something similar in a mod

[marble mantle]

Oh so its like the rdo bandit safehouse things around the map right?

[mortal horizon]

So now, you may walk past a store and see a couple gang members standing outside. They might start shit with you. Adds a little more depth to the gang rivalries

[marble mantle]

Hmmm

I see

[mortal horizon]

Something like that

[marble mantle]

Well, ill check it out tomorrow

[mortal horizon]

Gun tricks mod is also sick

I think there are a few good mods for added dialogue, encounters, etc

Makes the world more alive

[acoustic totem]

One of my favorite mods tbh. I just walk around twirling my gun

[mortal horizon]

Wish i had pc in order to do that lol

Thinking about getting one tbh

[acoustic totem]

It’s 100% worth it man.

Tenfold compared to console

Wyhelms DLC is top notch

[mortal horizon]

I always liked the idea of mods but ive just always had a playstation so instead of pc i went for ps5

But now im getting back into a lot of old games and playing a lot of games with dope mods so im thinking i might get one

[acoustic totem]

I get that. PC gaming is just so much better in my opinion, better games, mods, graphics, list goes on and on.

[mortal horizon]

The mods and indie games along with the ability to use emulators are definitely the top selling points

Its just soooo expensive in comparison to console

[acoustic totem]

I love realistic FPS games. So many good games for that on PC.
I lucked out and got a solid PC for $800. I run RDR2 at 80-90 FPS.

[mortal horizon]

What is this btw

[mortal horizon]

If i could find something decent for that price id probably buy

[acoustic totem]

It’s a outfit and hairstyle mod. You get access to basically every single hairstyle and piece of clothing in the game

[mortal horizon]

Maybe i could get one using that afterpay shit or whatever

[mortal horizon]

Oh that’s cool. Ive been seeing some mods recently that seem to add a lot of content and encounters so im mostly interested in those since ive played the game so much now i want something new

[acoustic totem]

It’s so cool having access to all that stuff. You can make Arthur or John look so much better, the trainers are also really cool. The rampage trainer adds a undead nightmare mode

I spawned a hot air balloon and just flew around

The only thing I need to upgrade on my computer is the storage

[cobalt oracle]

wait yo

what's the undead nightmare mode in rampage trainer?

i've had rampage for months and haven't heard about this at all

[mortal horizon]

Definitely sounds nice to have more options. Might breathe new life into a game ive already pretty much seen every inch of lol

[acoustic totem]

It’s in miscellaneous I believe

[cobalt oracle]

what's it do?

[acoustic totem]

Spawns a storm and everyone turns into zombies

[cobalt oracle]

are the zombies hostile or is it just the normal npc's but they look like zombies

[acoustic totem]

Nah they will chase you down in hordes lol
They have legit zombie models

[cobalt oracle]

thats sick

im gonnna try that later

[acoustic totem]

It’s pretty fun honestly

I turn on rapid gun and just mow them down

[cobalt oracle]

rapid gun lags my game so i have to use rapid fire instead

there's no big different it just looks slightly different

[hidden moss]

I believe somebody needs to mention it to you.

[acoustic totem]

I just turn both of em on. Or I’ll spawn a Gatlin gun

[cobalt oracle]

i really like the cannons but it's annoying that you have to place them correctly cus you cant turn them around

[acoustic totem]

Yeah, I wish there was a way to have those as your regular gun if that makes sense.

Arthur shoulders it like a rifle

[cobalt oracle]

lmfao that'd be great

you can do some crazy stuff with trainers

if you change your damage multiplier to .01 every time you shoot someone in the stomach with a shotgun they start to bleed out from like 6 different spots all at the same time

[hidden moss]

still confused...

[mortal horizon]

In the game, npcs will give you “tips” on backroom dealings and home robberies. They’re saying you may need a tip from an npc to do the robbery, but you dont. You just have to complete a certain mission in chapter 2 that explains robberies and it should unlock. Have you “peeked” through the back window yet?

[hidden moss]

Ok, you can run into drunk people sitting down, who if you give them money, or talk to them, they'll give you a "tip".

They'll say "I was in a poker game in the gunsmith" or other stuff, then you get it as a robbery tip. You then go in there, point your gun at whoever runs it, and ask to see the back room.

[mortal horizon]

You can “discover” all of the back rooms though, you don’t need tips to do them. You just have to find them by looking around. That being said though, I have experienced a glitch on more than one playthrough that doesnt allow me to rob certain back rooms. You may be having that problem

[radiant girder]

go behind the doctors office

there's a window you can peek in

that'll give you the tip

or knock on an iron door that's behind the sherrifs office

[hidden moss]

mhm took all approaches

I also got another question how od I get the midnight pistol? I found a guy in the bar talking abt his book or whatever and he wanted me to find some people but that was a while ago, can I still do the mission?

[hidden moss]

I got the notification that I found tje business but as I was about to go do it I put my mask on too early and the authorities arrested me, ever since I can't do the robbery even though I have done all steps

[radiant girder]

probably

pretty sure you can do it at any time

but i might be wrong

[hidden moss]

alright and final question, can arthur wear a poncho, it would be sick and it would make no sense if not

[cobalt oracle]

he cant

[gray cedar]

oh my god i just finished red dead 2

(main story not the epilogue)

i'm shaking

best ending ever

but for the record

i don't feel like doing a delivery mission after the ending scene

[radiant girder]

micah the goat

[gray cedar]

i hate him but i will say he was a very well written character

[small trench]

trying to launch rdr2 story mode and once i select story it sits on the loading screen with the chamber loading thing in the bottom right, when i alt f4 it gives me the confirmation message that if i rly want to close this game and any unsaved progress will be lost. Tried restarting pc and turning anti virus off. Any help?

[analog wave]

He's a snake. But Dutch is the real problem. Riding with a snake he met 6 months ago while doubting his right hand man for 20 something years

[hidden moss]

just be patient oml

[snow field]

What side missions should I save for John

[cobalt oracle]

the last part of Hamish Sinclairs mission

[hidden moss]

I cant give myself onlinr weapons on story mode even with a mod menu

[cobalt oracle]

you have to download Red Dead Offline mod to do it

[mortal horizon]

Its a long load

[hidden moss]

just installed this, thx

[cobalt oracle]

no problem

[snow field]

What are some play through options that aren’t high or low honor

[hidden moss]

I don't think there is any.

[spark pasture]

Bro made a lot of enemys with those words

[carmine osprey]

I accidentally punched an Oriole

[pseudo dragon]

I accidentally kicked a tied up woman when I tried to save her

[gray cedar]

basically his son

[analog wave]

So when I go to legendary animal territory I can't find any tracks whatsoever. Anyone know what's up with that?

[carmine osprey]

jack marston would have been able to see stealth aircraft

[gray cedar]

did you try eagle eye? there should be yellow flying particles visible if in eagle eye

also are you sure it's legendary animal territory

does it have the crown

[analog wave]

Yeah that's what I mean, when I use eagle eye it never shows the particles

[analog wave]

Yup

[gray cedar]

hmm

what legendary animal u huntin

[analog wave]

I go right where the symbol with the crown is and it says I entered legendary animal territory

Big horn ram

Next to that pond west of Valentine

[gray cedar]

then just look around if you're sure and then the clue should show up on the map as a grey question mark

[gray cedar]

yeah for me the clue was on the side of the road it was uh some scratchings on a tree

[analog wave]

Yeah I tried going everywhere in that area checking with eagle eye, showsn nothing, no question mark either, it sucks

[gray cedar]

you can fix it by initiating a bounty hunt or mission

it's a glitch

[analog wave]

Oh, I'll try that

[gray cedar]

can i get the white arabian again if i got him in the main story and now i switched

[twilit yarrow]

if you got a bond with normally yes

[hidden moss]

White Arabian can only be found once per playthrough.

[gray cedar]

fuck

so i can't get it again

i shoulda gotten him after the end

[sturdy sail]

Is it just me or Evelyn Miller dying of starvation or whatever when he was writing his book is one big slap to what Dutch's philosophy was based on ?

I mean symbolism aside could you imagine Dutch finding out his idol, the man who he quotes over and over, to end up dead like a moron while trying to write a book

[radiant girder]

yeah it can

[pseudo dragon]

Cool

[karmic prism]

just found something weird, if you do the train robbery in ch2 before going fishing with jack arthur will still talk about the pinkertons finding him near camp

despite that, you know, not happening

[granite cargo]

can someone help me with a mod

[shut silo]

hey

guys i killed dutch in read dead 1 and a music started i almost cry

[cobalt oracle]

what mod?

[sturdy sail]

Ive been thinking, did Sadie indirectly sent Agent Ross after John ?

Because the events of RDR1 are sparked by John getting revenge on Micah

[wild loom]

what mod

[sturdy sail]

And John had no clue if Micah was alive or not until Sadie told him

[cobalt oracle]

he got it working

[wild loom]

was it upscaled poop

[cobalt oracle]

lmfao

[small trench]

ive waited for like 30 minutes and it hasnt loaded, i have a bad cpu but last time i played it it didnt take that long

[umbral wadi]

Kinda yeah

She definitely didn’t mean to but yeah, her, Charles and John killing Micah ended up killing John

[twilit yarrow]

did you called me ?

[mortal horizon]

They were onto John well before that

The Micah thing is the last scene in the after credit cut scenes. They had already found him at Beechers Hope before that

[sick spindle]

anyone knows what type of file i have to use for mods

i tried a mod

that had a rar type

and it didnt work

[trim plover]

WHAAAAT?! after returning to the mainland, I cant replay the Guarma missions to get gold on each mission????

[pseudo dragon]

Just realised the reason the pinkertins might of found John because he used his real name in the bank when getting a loan for beachers hope

[karmic prism]

hosea when he learns i brutally murdered all of the guards at hagen orchards to get him a stupid crime novel

[trim plover]

nevermind. i had to complete Fleeting Joy in order to save again and have the option to replay missions again

so annoyed though. i made a goal for myself to get EVERYTHING in the game. just came back from Guarma, but I had to go onto the bank robbery without getting ONE THING!! Bill's pomade request. i spent sooooooo much time trying to get his request to activate when he was sitting at his chair at his tent through Chapter 2-4. he never even approached me. ughh i finally gave up and said "screw it" LOL

F*** your hair Bill! there's not much of it left anyway

[karmic prism]

how do we tell em

[rapid hollow]

u want to unpack that using 7zip

or some other unzipper program

[sick spindle]

i didnt get a zip

[rapid hollow]

Does anyone got experience with dynamic seasons, vestigia and longer days?

[rapid hollow]

u still can unpack it using 7zip

the rar file

[sick spindle]

7zip?

[rapid hollow]

it will work just like a zip file

[rapid hollow]

yeah or any other unzip program u use

[sick spindle]

where can i get this 7zip

[rapid hollow]

look it up on google, cant send links here for some reason

but it can do more than the standard build in zip program from windows

[sick spindle]

ok

[karmic prism]

got the scout jacket request

finally

woooooo yeahhhhh babyyyyyyy

[sturdy sail]

No not really

Well maybe but him getting revenge on Micah gave them a lead

[mortal horizon]

In the credit scenes they had found him way before the Micah shit

[sturdy sail]

No ?

[mortal horizon]

That was the last one as far as I remember

[sturdy sail]

Its after

After they visited mount hagen they went on an investigation

And then they found him

It wasn't before

Micah getting killed was what led them to John

[mortal horizon]

Yeah but they had to have already been on the trail to even come there

[vagrant saffron]

They were on Micah’s trail for killing that woman

That’s why they went there

[mortal horizon]

Why would they need to be on Micah’s trail if he was already connected to the Pinkertons

[empty lark]

consider that micah is as he said

a survivor

[vagrant saffron]

Because he had tens of thousands of dollars in gold and killed a girl

[mortal horizon]

They were more likely hoping to find Dutch or John by finding Micah

[empty lark]

he can stop talking to them if he thinks it's more beneficial for his own survival than to keep going back to them

[mortal horizon]

As we know from future events, that clearly isnt how it works

[vagrant saffron]

What

[empty lark]

sure, unfortunately micah isn't john and micah would run away whenever given the best possible opportunity

[mortal horizon]

You dont just get to turn off your connection to the feds, John thought he could do that and we saw how that went

[vagrant saffron]

Yeah, he died. So… what would the Pinkerton’s do if Micah tried to cut off his connections??

[empty lark]

dont forget john didn't run away because he actually had people he cared about, micah didn't, all he cared about was his guns and money

[vagrant saffron]

They’d probably track him right?

Possibly to mount Hagen???

[mortal horizon]

Point being they wouldnt need to find him

Once you’re in that position they’re not going to lose that tab

[empty lark]

another option is they kept using micah to get to dutch and dutch had caught on to the possibility, pinkertons knew he'd be up there and the only way down iirc is the way they came

maybe promised micah some money to keep him interested

[mortal horizon]

Maybe Micah was even in on the plot to get Dutch out there

[empty lark]

or micah had his eyes on the money in the chest

money that dutch wasn't giving away to just anyone

[mortal horizon]

And then they so happened to find John through that, or they were looking for another member of the gang to exploit

[empty lark]

money that had to be taken from him

micah risked killing dutch's best man for two double action revolvers, i cant imagine him having dutch's health before his own if even at all in his mind

[mortal horizon]

I just think given the way the feds are portrayed in the game and the political situation of the time they wouldnt make dodgy deals with outlaws without some kind of security of a long term deal

Once they had John they had him in their clutches completely so I imagine if Micah was really the rat he would’ve been in a similar position

[empty lark]

john is fighting for his family, not just to be free for himself

[sturdy sail]

Yeah

[empty lark]

he couldn't just run away from the pinkertons out of fear for what would happen to his family that didn't deserve to be hurt for the shit john did

micah doesn't have anyone who loves him

he doesn't love anyone

[mortal horizon]

Everyone has something or another to lose

[empty lark]

he loves things, not people

he loves his guns, he loves money

[vagrant saffron]

All Micah has to lose is money and his life

So really, he hasn’t got much to lose

[mortal horizon]

And thats exactly the kind of person that’s easy to manipulate into an informant

[sturdy reef]

He could lose some weight

[vagrant saffron]

Real

[empty lark]

micah is greedy and selfish, he lives for himself

if he dies he cant live for himself, he knows that

[sturdy reef]

He eats for 5

[mortal horizon]

He’s selfish, making him the perfect person to manipulate into doing something like this

[sturdy reef]

I’m constantly going to make fat jokes about Micah

[mortal horizon]

They could offer him money or whatever. Or perhaps he fears for his own life. Either way, he would be an easy egg to crack. If anything i think he was in some kind of deal w them, not just giving information freely

[sturdy sail]

Micah's fat ? Since when, he certainly has a belly but he's far from fat

[mortal horizon]

He’s all gut

[empty lark]

people are capable of accepting deals with untold backup plans of their own, micah didn't have a pinkerton attached to his ankle and neither did john, however john was worried for his family's safety which would be in danger if he were to run away

whatever micah would be endangering by breaking a deal with pinkertons is something that might not even exist for him to earn

and his own life but that could be taken too if he just kept going along with it, he's always on about money and himself

[mortal horizon]

John’s shot at redemption didn’t really exist either, it’s all about dangling the carrot

[hidden moss]

You can tell Micah planned on betraying Dutch. He was gonna let the Pinkertons in, and they'd take Dutch. Dutch was aware of this I believe, seeing when John asked what he was doing, Dutch then replied "same as you, I suppose". We know why John was there, and that hinted at Dutch was there to kill Micah, which he did.

[sturdy sail]

I mean

Thats a stretch given how long Dutch stayed with Micah

[empty lark]

Dutch had trust issues

[sturdy sail]

Why wouldn't Micah have betrayed dutch before

[empty lark]

money

[hidden moss]

The Pinkertons arrived shortly after the fight. I doubt they'd be up in the Mountains searching.

[sturdy sail]

Its 8 whole years

[mortal horizon]

Dutch obviously wasnt there for the money or he wouldve taken it. There was a reason he came there. Micah either lured him there or Dutch knew something

[sturdy sail]

Between 1899 and 1907

[empty lark]

dont forget the chest full of money john finds in the tower after you kill micah

[hidden moss]

He wanted money, and he needed to control Dutch for money. Dutch then left, so Micah got the money from Blackwater.

[mortal horizon]

Because, they werent running together that whole time. Maybe they had just regained contact

[hidden moss]

It's both. Micah lured him, but Dutch knew.

[sturdy sail]

The money could've been there long before John learned about Micah being alive

[hidden moss]

Many people have pointed it out. You put it together, and it makes sense.

[sturdy sail]

So it still doesnt really make sense as to Micah not betraying Dutch earlier

If it was the case

[empty lark]

how much earlier

[hidden moss]

20 grand just sat in a chest? No, it was the Blackwater money.

[hidden moss]

Again, he needed Dutch.

[sturdy sail]

They couldve gotten it earlier

Before the epilogue

Again

It doesnt make much sense

[hidden moss]

Eventually he was probably given the choice of dying, or getting Dutch.

[mortal horizon]

Everyone was where they were supposed to be during the final mission and every person there was playing into someone else’s hand one way or another

[empty lark]

blackwater was on lockdown during ch1-6, they couldn't just go back that same year, they'd have to wait a while

[hidden moss]

It's not really hard to piece together. We know Micah was working with the Pinkertons, they then show up at the exact spot Micah had Dutch at.

[empty lark]

and it was gonna be a very big heist, they didn't want the gang to potentially show up to try again

[sturdy sail]

They could've during the gap between VI and the epilogue

[empty lark]

they probably did

[hidden moss]

Micah did. John had other stuff to worry about.

[sturdy sail]

Yeah so Micah could've betrayed Dutch earlier

[empty lark]

you dont hear about them being in blackwater

[sturdy sail]

If it was about betrayal

[mortal horizon]

Micah wanted Dutch there, Dutch wanted Micah there, Micah wanted John there too, John wanted Dutch there. Everybody was in the right place because of Micah more than likely

[hidden moss]

He did. Dude, he literally was working with the Pinkertons. He had to stay "loyal" so he wasn't outted.

[mortal horizon]

If I remember though idk if it was Cleet that said it or if it was Micah but Dutch and Micah hadn’t seen each other in years at that point

[hidden moss]

Micah wanted John there? He didn't bring John. They got a tip, and killed Micahs friend for the info.

[empty lark]

considering the amount of men that tried to kill john

[hidden moss]

Yes because Dutch left. We saw that at the final scene with Arthur.

[empty lark]

i dont think they wanted them there

[sturdy sail]

John didnt even knew whether Micah was alive or not lol

Before sadie told him

[hidden moss]

He was trespassing, so they shot. I wouldn't want somebody coming up either with that much money there.

[mortal horizon]

He didn’t bring him there but it’s all in service to the plot

[hidden moss]

I think we're missing out on multiple key details here.

[empty lark]

micah is more than capable of handling some random ass people himself

especially if he just has his huge gang sitting up there guarding the place as usual, just not shooting on sight, it could be john or it could not be, most of them there wouldn't know

[sturdy sail]

Yeah well the whole epilogue is kind of a busted mess

[hidden moss]

He had Dutch, and Pinkertons. He would want back up incase they tried anything. Micah may have been a dick, but he wasn't dumb.

[empty lark]

im trying to say micah didn't want john up there if so many men were trying to kill him from the start, and if he ever did actually want him there, he could've set it up to where he's still protected and someone can confirm whether it's john or not

Joe knew who John was, he remembered him

[hidden moss]

John went through the same thing, and didn't have back up. Hence why what happened to him.

[hidden moss]

He recognized him in that moment, but nothing states they knew before that.

[empty lark]

im not saying they knew before they started shooting them, im saying if micah wanted john up there, they could let joe be at a halfway point or somewhere he can easily see him and john could be making his way up till joe recognizes him and would try to let him through, im not saying what happened im saying what could've happened if Micah really wanted John to be up there like that other guy said

and if John shot Joe at that point on the journey to the hideout, it's a gun, they're gonna hear it, and they could just have people set up around the rest of the path behind joe

people that clearly aren't as good at john but the gunfire is a fine alert for micah to be ready as he was the way the game actually plays it out

[mortal horizon]

No snap aim in hardcore mode

[analog wave]

Jesus I'm doing the hunter mission where you need to kill 5 cougars with a bow, I'm getting progressively depressed

[vagrant saffron]

That’s where I gave up and just started a new play through

[analog wave]

I got 2😭 no giving up now

The method so far is using my mount as bait in that area west of big valley with the cougar icon

It's easy to kill them I just can't find them

[mortal horizon]

I would just save on the road near the trapper to the far West and run past over and over

There should be a double cougar spawn there

[white carbon]

is yalls rdo being a absolute butthole rn

[mortal horizon]

I assume thats where you already are

[white carbon]

like my rdo is not working

😭

[analog wave]

Yeaah

I'll try that

Not much to lose at this point lol

I wouldn't even do these missions normally but I never got that panther coat, it looks so dope I want it

[radiant girder]

leave the area n go far away

then sleep for max amount of time

and go back

[analog wave]

I run around all morning and then I sleep till next morning, i hear they mostly spawn in the morning

[radiant girder]

one should spawn between the road and the owanjila trapper

[analog wave]

But I'll try leaving

[radiant girder]

it usually worked for me

[analog wave]

I got the first two with this method

Don't seem to work now lol

[radiant girder]

try willards rest

or the road that goes between there and annesburg

sometimes the best way to find one is just riding around

[analog wave]

Big valley is my top 3 places in the game and this challenge made me hate it ngl😭

[karmic prism]

anyone know how to trigger the rescue bill mission in chapter 2?

[radiant girder]

just ride around valentine

not in valentine but near it

like the east side of cumberland forest

or by the dakota river

[karmic prism]

thanks i'll give it a shot when i can

[cobalt oracle]

lmfao I just saw something about a new mod called "comprehensive shit upscale" which upgrades all the feces textures in the game

[high flint]

im so goddamn pissed

my game didnt save the part WHERE I HAD SAVED UP 15 GOLD BARS

FUCK!

[radiant girder]

lol

[high flint]

it reset my rabbit pelts

now i gotta do the challenge again

SHIT

[shut trench]

guys where and when can i start that heisst robbery mission which you get from the ultimate ediition ?

[hidden moss]

its in chapter 3

at the camp

check charles

[shut trench]

which camp was chapter 3 again ?

[hidden moss]

south

[shut trench]

i just google it and someone said it is in early chapter 4

[hidden moss]

oh wait

caps

i thought it was in 3 cuz it was in the south

my bad

[shut trench]

Ok good, because I'm currently at chapter 4, Im mean I guess it is chapter 4. I'm there where the house is with the alligators

[shut trench]

Ok nvm got it. Is that the only extra mission?

[radiant girder]

yeah

[olive path]

I fucked arthur

[mental lynx]

excuse me?

[hollow bronze]

same

[hollow bronze]

omg. a mod we never knew we needed

[midnight obsidian]

chapter 3

[midnight obsidian]

clemens point

[stiff rampart]

anybody know how to unlock the weapons from the red dead offline mod?

[analog wave]

Finally got to Master Hunter 9😭

[cinder pivot]

Now kill giaguro

[cobalt oracle]

go to the fence

for almost everything

and the saint denis gunsmith for the elephant rifle

[stiff rampart]

ok ty

[drifting juniper]

when you change your player model to someone using Lenny's Outfit Changer mod it removes you ability to speak can you somehow get a mod for you to speak again?

rampage trainer or other ones?

[analog wave]

Is it worth playing rdr online?

[radiant girder]

if you have the time yeah

shit can take a while sometimes

[vast oak]

High or low honour. Is there any that is overall better?

[mortal horizon]

High is always “better” in terms of not only story, but perks as well. There are very few perks to low honor

[vast oak]

What is the good thing with low honour? People won’t get mad at you?

[mortal horizon]

Low honor yields no benefit really, at least not in RDR2. In the first game, low honor gives you discounts at a few shops and a horse as well as eventually free drinks and lower property prices (if you do a certain quest the right way in the endgame). In the second game, you don’t really get anything aside from the satisfaction of doing bad things, whereas with good honor you get shop discounts, better loot, and what most people consider a more canon story. Low honor can give you some different interactions and stuff though.

[vast oak]

Better loot? From quests or looting people?

I have 5000 bucks and it’s totally worth it for killing some innocents

[mortal horizon]

You can get 5000 bucks way easier without killing anybody really lol

[mortal horizon]

From bodies

I like to play low honor until like Chapter 4 and then start my “Redemption” lol

[vast oak]

No I just meant that it doesn’t matter if stuff is pricy because I can afford the most stuff. So then I can have fun shooting ;)

[mortal horizon]

Oh well yeah I dont really care much about the perks, Im just saying that good honor is better in terms of perks. But I also think the story is better with good honor, which is what I really care about

[vast oak]

Another question. I was looking at a video of the best guns and they mentioned the Schotfield revolver and that you get it at a side quest in valentine but that’s long gone. Can you get them in weapon stores?

[vast oak]

Hmm.. is it a big difference in story?

Sorry for asking so much questions

[mortal horizon]

Kind of yeah, it changes the whole ending and a lot of dialogue and etc

[mortal horizon]

Schofield you can either get by robbing the back room at Valentine Doctor or just buying it at any store by the point you’re probably at

[vast oak]

Nice

Chapter 6

[vast oak]

Sadly I got the ending spoiled (only that he dies and that Dutch betrayed him sorta)

Chapter 8 is the last before the epilogues, right?

[mortal horizon]

Chapter 6

Then the 2 epilogue chapters for a total of 8

[vast oak]

Ohh

Well in that case I better be starting working then up

[mortal horizon]

I prefer good honor ending

[shut trench]

Guys is it possible to lost a unique weapon after you get it?

[deft umbra]

do you need every journal entry for an achievement or 100% completion?

[radiant girder]

no

[radiant girder]

no

[hearty drum]

me too low honor doesnt make sense

[mortal horizon]

It feels like based on the story, Arthur was more on the low honor side until toward the end of Chapter 3, then he changes a lot. Hence Red Dead “Redemption” lol

[hearty drum]

there is so much honor to get in chptr 6 for a reason

[radiant girder]

imo arthur is low-mid honor chapter 2-3 and then starts his whole redemption thing in chapter 4

[shut trench]

guys what is the best saddle in the story game ? I have the deluxe edition saddle, but idk if it is the best one

nuevo paraiso saddle

[analog wave]

Jesus Chris

Where do I find a possum 😭

I tried northwest of owanjila nothing

Tried the woods around citadel rock, nothing

[radiant girder]

panther trail saddle

[radiant girder]

i usually find one in the heartlands

[analog wave]

Heartlands? Next to that ruin?

[radiant girder]

the oil derrick? no

between valentine and emerald ranch

[analog wave]

I'll try there

Been looking for the little bastard for hours

@radiant girder any general area in the heartlands or? Should I just run around?

😭😭

[radiant girder]

uhhh

look between that big ass cliff and the main road between valentine and emerald ranch

[shut trench]

is it much better than the crocodile one ?

because i need the panther pelt alreardy for my bag

[karmic prism]

think i just had the most disastrous bounty hunter encounter in history

i was skinning a snake when they suddenly ran up to and surrounded me, then when i went to confront them a buck ran me over

A BUCK

WHAT

theyre supposed to be the honorable animal yet he nearly killed me

[shut trench]

Guys are raccoons only there on nights?

[radiant girder]

the alligator one is a good substitute

[hidden moss]

Does anyone else feel as if the only good people in this game are Arthur, John, and Sadie?

[radiant girder]

no

what about micah

[trim plover]

many parts of the story have Arthur feeling bad about doing many bad things. the game basically wants you to go the high honor route

it's just better

[fair onyx]

I hate trying to get up go or on story bcz every time I did a mission it would remove honor for shooting dead bodies so anytime I shop someone in the head twice I lost tons of honor

[hidden moss]

Have you finished the game?

[radiant girder]

yeah

that's why he's good

[hidden moss]

He's a traitor

[radiant girder]

nuh uh

[hidden moss]

Micah a big meanie

[mortal horizon]

No

[mortal horizon]

It always feels right to rock low honor until chapter 4 and then start your “redemption” imo

[radiant girder]

already got low honor

not even in chapter 2 yet

[hidden moss]

I keep my honor just below neutral until im near the end the i get high honor

[mortal horizon]

Arthur is a savage but he shows many times that he has a heart and morals so high honor is really the most realistic way to play. You can still do low honor activities and keep high honor but high honor is the way

[karmic prism]

arthur: literally carrying an entire animal to eat
dutch: WE ARE GONNA NEED SOME FOOD OR SOME MONEY ARTHUR

[karmic prism]

the more time i spend with dutch the more i understand why molly went crazy

[drifting sparrow]

me after I slaughter valentine but I ran around saint denis greeting people so i’m a good man

[mortal horizon]

Me after I massacre a hundred lawmen and innocent people but I’m very concerned about the local fish population so I’m a good dude

[hidden moss]

i once hogtied a strawberry resident and took him to flat iron lake on my horse, put him in a canoe, waited for him to run off the boat and then i shot him so his body would never be found in the water

but i greeted like 6 people so it was ok

[drifting sparrow]

most sane rdr 2 player

[shut trench]

Guys how much time did you needed to unlock all bags?

[olive path]

Oh yes arthur stick it in there mmmm

[karmic prism]

"you're not better than me morgan!"
"yes i am micah, you never greeted anyone in saint denis"

[pseudo berry]

i did the same thing but with the valentine sheriff

[mortal horizon]

I took Chick Matthews to the creepy house near the tree holding his money at night and dropped him in there, firing shots around him while the UFO flew overhead and he screamed for help, then I left him there, found two guys on the road, killed them both, came back and shot Chick in the head, then killed his horse. But I threw back a bunch of fish after that so I’m good

[karmic prism]

the only sheriff who is morally fine to kill

[mortal horizon]

I like to kill the anti semitic shopkeeper and the eugenics guy, they’re also always morally fine to kill

[hidden moss]

i always make sure to blow the head off of the most troublesome npc in a gunfight with a sawed off shotgun

[mortal horizon]

I prefer the leg

[hidden moss]

i killed the eugenics and the pyramid scheme guy

havent been to new austin yet

[mortal horizon]

The shopkeeper in Armadillo says some pretty wild shit

He said to me while i was playing as John that “John Marston is a paid killer for the Jews”

So I killed him

I guess he was right

[high flint]

I HAVE 430 THOUSAND DOLLARS (gonna donate 10 thousand for 420K y'know what i mean by 420) AND DUTCH STILL NEEDS ONE MORE BIG TAKE

[karmic prism]

you know dutch would probably get banned from this server because he speaks in caps lock by default

[high flint]

true that

[hidden moss]

I just finished the game a second time for the high honor end and im in tears

I think you should've been able to kill Micah for high honor

[high flint]

May I... stand unshaken

[karmic prism]

taking his eye out going for the money is reward enough

[wintry violet]

[gaunt bobcat]

Love playing father&farmer simulator for the gold rush trophy

[drifting juniper]

i like Micah

said no one ever

[hidden moss]

Why do you care about honor? If you do so much bad stuff.

[hidden moss]

You can’t get gold rush just from that though

[uneven knoll]

What did you guys do to the slave trader guy?

[snow field]

If the murfrees are a inbred family how is there no mention of and murfree women

[mortal horizon]

Put a hole in him

[drifting sparrow]

rockstar things

[karmic prism]

knife

better not to panic the people outside

[drifting sparrow]

I threw a throwing knife at his head

[quiet vortex]

I’ve come for you Ross

[hidden moss]

How rare is a splashed white coat for the American paint breed??

[shut trench]

Guys why can I not upgrade the trapper saddles fully?

[radiant girder]

not rare

[radiant girder]

wdym upgrade

[calm garnet]

Has anyone else had this glitch in rdr2 1.00 version where john just swaps bodies with Arthur midway through the epilogue

Like

At the start of the epilogue he's a skeleton, he has his own torso, it's not Arthur's body. But midway through the epilogue it just becomes Arthur's torso for some reason

[radiant girder]

that's probably because rockstar just put johns face on arthurs body

[calm garnet]

I'm talking about 1.00 version

like at the start of the epilogue john has his own model but for some reason it changes to Arthur's midway through the epilogue

[shut trench]

Like specific Accessoires which gives you extra boosts. I can't do that with the patnha saddle

[radiant girder]

because the panther saddle is the best saddle in the game

plus it already has hooded stirrups i think

and if you could change those things it would just make it way overpowered

[warm sparrow]

im currently in chapter 3 at the point of robbing either the grays or braithwhites, and im wonderin which one's better to rob

if theres a change

[hybrid dagger]

There isn't no change

maybe just some dialogue changes but that's all

[warm sparrow]

so no money difference?

[hybrid dagger]

No not rlly

[warm sparrow]

k ty

[shut trench]

alright

btw how can i equip my unique knives ? I cant see them on the weapon wheel or weapon stash

[radiant girder]

select hunting knife and there should be an option to switch which knife you use

[warm sparrow]

i got a cattleman revolver with a poker symbol next to it, what does it mean

[radiant girder]

wdym poker symbol

[shut trench]

Dude that's so lame, you can't even skinning the animals with those unqie knives

[radiant girder]

wait you can't?

damn that sucks

[topaz vigil]

hey is it hard to 100% this game

[radiant girder]

no

[tepid orchid]

depends

[mortal horizon]

The online trophies are lame

[vernal marsh]

Red dead online fucking sucks

Anyone who plays online is a fucking nerd

Ugly ass mother fuckin griefers

[hidden moss]

hi I'm new to the game, is it better to play low honor or high ? because I dont really understand how it works

[warm sparrow]

if you play high honor you get a better ending, better drops and overall people like you more

[topaz vigil]

just don't have low honor on the last missions

[hidden moss]

and there's no advantage playing low honor ? i've seen videos on youtube of people playing low honor and it seemed to be fun and cool playing like this but idk

[hidden moss]

okay thanks

[warm sparrow]

if you got low honor its cool that you can rob, kill and do whatever you want

without losing honor

[topaz vigil]

you get the sad bad ending 😔

[warm sparrow]

or anything really

[hidden moss]

ok thanks to you guys I think I know how I want to play now

[warm sparrow]

#rdo-chat

[warm sparrow]

sorry, didnt see the message

can i dm u a pic

[quiet vortex]

Hey everyone in rdo community are lovely people who do no harm

[vernal marsh]

:/

Why are you lyin so badddd

Everyone is fuckin griefers

[radiant girder]

sure

[karmic prism]

so true bestie

[quiet vortex]

Wdym only 99% of the time do I get shot riding through valentine by 5 people

[fair onyx]

Personally ide say get high honour and then if u ever play red dead online do whatever the hell you like