#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 105 of 1

umbral wadi
#

Not many escape points

#

The one time they did push was when the caravan was at its most defensible

empty lark
#

maybe to not have as many losses, which didn't really work out well anyways but the the gang was still very much united in ch3 and that probably wouldn't go well for the pinkertons

#

Arthur, Micah, and Dutch himself who was really the only target were all in the same place and they'd have to try and fight them at the same time along with the other gang members, who aren't as good but could still be some problems

#

if enough pinkertons were brought they'd win eventually but i think Milton didn't want to throw away a good amount of his men's lives to capture Dutch when there could be better opportunities if they kept tracking him

umbral wadi
#

I’m sure they had plenty more reserves, I mean they throw tons of men at Dutch and Arthur when they massacre Valentine, though a lot of those could’ve been normal citizens and local law

#

Did they know where the gang was in Chapter 4?

mortal horizon
#

I’m pretty sure they knew where the gang was the entire time

#

They knew where they were in Valentine, then in Rhodes the Grays had them figured out from the start so they probably alerted the Pinkertons. Then obviously after Guarma, the next camp gets raided almost immediately. So I think they knew where they were the entire time really and just chose when to strike. Or at the very least, they knew where they were from Shady Belle onwards. They knew about Horseshoe, but it’s possible they didn’t know about Clemens Point

glad wraith
#

Wait don't tell me I have to start a new game and finish it and do that

#

I mean I literally finished the game a week ago I don't want to start it again already

cinder trail
#

Finally finished the hunting requests

#

Holy

dull geyser
#

Their intention initialy was to hide in shady belle for only a few days so they were probably easy to find

karmic prism
#

he's a fair guy

#

i'd argue he never used ENOUGH force

urban heart
#

agent milton was just doing his job

karmic prism
#

compared to the real pinkertons he's a saint lol

umbral wadi
#

I’m 100% sure he would’ve kept his word to Arthur if he turned informant

karmic prism
#

if they just took the deal in chapter 3 it'd be problem solved

mortal horizon
#

He didnt want to kill everyone or really anyone at all, he made multiple attempts to get Dutch to come quietly or someone to give him Dutch but eventually they’d gone too far and he had to start playing hard

open plank
#

Arthur was secret gay

crimson sky
#

Does anyone know the best place to find the Californian Horned Owl? I’ve tried suggestions on Reddit, the compendium and YouTube but I have only found the Horned owl😢

sinful trench
#

california

karmic prism
#

im starting to prefer the evans over lancaster tbh

#

nearly never runs outta ammo

hidden moss
#

I believe because most of the gang wasn't as wanted. Sure, they were teamed up with some of the most wanted men, but that wouldn't give the Pinketons power to kill them at that time. At least, it would have looked bad. As they started doing more heists though, those less wanted members gave the Pinkertons the power to do full blown sieges. I think Milton originally also wanted to do it peacefully, or manipulate the gang into betraying one another.

hidden moss
karmic prism
#

i also just prefer the sound evans makes lol

#

more punchy

solid ridge
#

guys

#

how do if ind cain

#

is tehre a mission?

empty lark
#

the dog? no

#

it's camp interactions

#

he first appears in ch3 by dutch's tent where they name him, you may see it or you may not, it's not a cutscene or a mission

solid ridge
#

sad

hidden moss
#

He could have been just the same though. He could have been trying to divide the group, hence why he kept pushing the "turn Dutch over" thing. He was decent enough for giving chances though, I will admit that.

radiant girder
#

he did take abigail tho

hidden moss
#

Yea, after everything. He also seemed to be luring them out. He probably figured Dutch would go after her, he just didn't know Dutch became a monster.

#

I think Milton had to start playing dirty. Especially after Dutch killed their biggest source for money, Leviticus.

#

You think Milton was gonna just grab Abigail? Then stick in that tiny building with her, while they await a "boat"? Probably not.

karmic prism
#

if only his apprentice was so fair lmao

mortal horizon
red swallow
#

hey guys i won rdr2 on epic games and was wanting to buy it on steam cause i prefer steam would my progress save

dapper bone
#

anyone know the best place to look for wild american paint horses

hidden moss
hidden moss
#

Epic games doesn't have controller support but Steam has...

cinder trail
#

If I lose a legendary fish can I get it back?

#

I was trying to catch the legendary lake sturgeon

#

Had the longnose gar on my horse

#

Got run over by a train and lost it

dapper bone
#

you are one unlucky mf

#

damn

#

but no you cant

#

do you have a saved game from before you caught it?

cinder trail
#

Yeah

#

Could reload ig

#

Gonna have to catch all the other fish again tho lol

dapper bone
#

@cinder trail wait

#

dont

#

I found some reddit posts that say if you lost it you can fish it again

#

idk if it’ll work but I’d try it

cinder trail
#

ty

twilit yarrow
#

i got a question

cinder trail
#

@dapper bone worked

#

Managed to fish it back

twilit yarrow
#

who's the fella john killed in the start of the epilogue

#

damn I love my role

dapper bone
hidden moss
#

I mean killing in front of a kid requires next to no morals.

haughty plume
#

M

#

Anyone know how to install mods

fallow canopy
# haughty plume Anyone know how to install mods

Sometimes they're manual installs other times they need something like Nexus Mods Manager or Mod Organizer 2, but I'm pretty sure you can manually install just about anything you need. Most mod pages have installation instructions

pine lily
#

help me I’m stuck in the Rhodes post office like behind the bars

karmic prism
#

i just no damaged micah

#

life is good.

mortal horizon
#

I always found it weird how Micah was different than every other enemy in the game. Every “boss” encounter (there aren’t really any other “bosses” but like important characters) is just like a regular human and if you shoot them in the head they die. I literally had to dead eye a full clip directly into his face to kill him

umbral wadi
#

I wish there was a way to unlock Buell earlier

#

Like have the mission be available in chapter 3 or something

#

I’d like to finish the sets of missions as Arthur and use buell the rest of the game but you get to attached to your actual horse

karmic prism
#

i've always used the white arabian as arthur

#

attached to it bc i legitimately just found it wandering in the snow, no guides or anything

empty lark
#

arthur looks too weird on it tbh

#

looks way better to ride in online

#

another reason online > story

karmic prism
#

plays into their character designs being polar opposites

pseudo jacinth
#

@everyone Anybody know how to unlock Pearson's scout jacket? I've tried just about everything

umbral wadi
#

Great stats though

mortal horizon
#

Getting perfect pelts is such a pain

molten quartz
#

So hyped to try this game

mortal horizon
empty lark
umbral wadi
radiant girder
#

idk about the red cores tho

#

some people say they don't matter but for me it seems like they do

green delta
#

One message removed from a suspended account.

dapper bone
#

No

radiant girder
#

lol booby

violet sphinx
#

Who uses Whyem's DLC?

thick pewter
#

If you didn't focus on it during your playthrough and are now past the epilogue can you 100% as John?

cinder trail
#

Where’s a good mustang spawn location?

#

Been trying in the heartlands for an hour

#

Got none

radiant girder
#

around emerald ranch

mortal horizon
#

Guys

#

How tf do i find robbable coaches

#

I need a coach with a back I can rob but ive rode around the whole map and the only one i could find was a random encounter

slate jetty
#

do those side quests

#

if not just rob everyone

mortal horizon
#

Well im trying to do it in chapter 2 thats why its difficult

#

Also

#

Why the heck does the game force you to get rid of a perfectly good horse

#

I always buy a Dutch anyway but i wouldve liked to keep a max bonded Tennessee Walker

potent cypress
#

Does anyone know if there will ever be another club rewards thing or did they stop doing those

rich slate
#

i mean

radiant girder
#

well that's not nice

gilded verge
#

Question

#

I have a feeling Micah is going to turn bad in ch6

#

is this true? (I'm fine with spoilers)

dapper burrow
#

Yes

radiant girder
#

he helps arthur escape the gang and lives the rest of his life with mary

mortal horizon
#

I just lost a full stack of perfect pelts off my horse bc i got mauled by a cougar, thats so unfair lol

mortal horizon
#

Anyone know why I can’t peek in the window at Strawberry general store? The option wont pop up at the window

cinder trail
#

how do I get the it’s art role?

#

just got the trophy

dapper bone
#

theres 6 places you need to find it in

cinder trail
#

already got the trophy

#

Idk how to get the role in the server

dapper bone
#

oh

#

just DM the alden bot with a screenshot of the achievement and your username

cinder trail
#

alr

#

ty

hidden moss
mortal horizon
hidden moss
#

restart your game

mortal horizon
#

Ill try later

#

Anyone know any other spots for panthers aside from Catfish Jackson’s? Ive been running around there for hours. Leaving, coming back, sleeping, placing predator bait, waiting, crouching and sneaking all around the area. Been doing this for hours and no panther so if anyone has a better idea pls lmk

warm musk
#

I have a question. Do I need to have all the satchels for 100%? And do I need to have the camp fully customized with the animal parts?

dapper bone
#

No

warm musk
haughty plume
karmic prism
#

hello guys welcome to another episode of RDR2 PC port being barely functional™️

#

for some reason i keep getting a black screen after like half an hour of playing

calm oasis
#

Does anyone know how to do the poker mission in chapter 2?

karmic prism
#

god i have NEVER had so many technical problems with a game, it's like one after the other

calm oasis
#

Yeah, welcome to rdr2

#

The game is a masterpiece, but the optimalization sucks ass

karmic prism
#

the fact its so good makes it worse lmao 💀

#

im gonna try uninstalling mods see if that makes a difference

warm musk
#

I can't find anyone to play Five Finger Fillet with for the Gambler Cahllenge 3

calm oasis
#

Just keep loading up the save, the activity should pop up eventually

calm oasis
#

Should I be donating the pelts and such to Pearson or should I just go sell it to the town and get money

vagrant saffron
#

I’d sell all perfect pelts to the trapper, or Pearson if it’s a material in a camp decoration

#

Donate the meat to Pearson for the camp stew or keep it and cook it for yourself

#

But any pelt below perfect feel free to sell in town or just throw away cause there’s not much other use for them

calm oasis
#

Ok thanks

warm musk
vagrant saffron
#

Yeah but sometimes I slip up and ruin the pelt 😭

#

I have the worst aim known the man

dapper bone
karmic prism
vagrant saffron
warm musk
#

I fucking hate five finger fillet

#

I can't fucking do it

dapper bone
#

how

#

its the easiest out of all the games

radiant girder
#

those are cougars

warm musk
radiant girder
#

you press two buttons bro

#

remap your shit if you can

warm musk
vagrant saffron
radiant girder
#

that's why i said to remap your shit

vagrant saffron
#

It’s never that deep

warm musk
#

I've lost $15

#

I can't fucking beat it!

vagrant saffron
#

Is there any other location where it’d be easier or does it need to be in camp?

warm musk
dapper bone
warm musk
dapper bone
#

damn

warm musk
#

I did the one where it's whoever gets the most laps in 20s

dapper bone
#

did you try van horn

warm musk
#

How do you bust someone out in poker

dapper bone
#

you need to have the better hand

#

its pretty much complete luck

#

but it shouldnt be too hard

warm musk
#

Ok

dapper bone
#

look up guides on youtube

#

they help

warm musk
#

Ok

karmic prism
radiant girder
#

kid named creeping thyme

mortal horizon
minor widget
#

im on my like 6th playthrough and im dreading doing any missions in chapter 2, how can i get the bolt action rifle without doing any

haughty plume
minor widget
#

ight

#

thanks

radiant girder
#

there's two bounty hunters halfway up the road right after you stealth kill the ones that trelawny distracts

#

the one on the left has one

#

you have to kill him first

#

only drops it if they aren't shooting at you and are just standing there

minor widget
#

ok thanks

karmic prism
#

just crashed again during american venom, i'm going to find whoever ported this game and micah them

keen birchBOT
#

Micah > Arthur

minor widget
#

as a character or...

thick pewter
#

Is it possible to get the legendary fish at sisika during the mission?

dapper bone
#

you might but you dont have to do it during that mission

#

you can do it anytime

thick pewter
#

I spent 25 minutes looking for a canoe

#

I did not find one so...

dapper bone
#

theres plenty of boats at the docks of saint denis

thick pewter
#

Can u use general boats?

radiant girder
#

yeah

dapper bone
#

rowboats yeah

mortal horizon
#

Do I have to unlock small game arrows or are those already craftable off the bat

thick pewter
#

I couldn't find row boats

mortal horizon
#

So annoying the last skin i need is a squirrel and i figured i could just shoot it with a varmint rifle but now i have to do this just to kill a squirrel

minor widget
#

can i get off hand holster without freeing micah

thick pewter
#

I imagine not since he gives it to you

minor widget
#

dam

mortal horizon
#

You can

#

Through challenges

minor widget
#

which one is fastest

mortal horizon
#

Bandit was easiest for me but probably horse or herbalist

thick pewter
#

Gambler SipArthur

minor widget
#

ok

mortal horizon
#

Is there a pamphlet or smth

minor widget
#

nah there craftable already

#

you need shotgun ammo, arrow, and flight feathers no pamphlet

mortal horizon
#

So do i just have to have the materials for it to pop up in my crafting menu?

minor widget
#

yea

mortal horizon
#

Thanks

minor widget
#

np

mortal horizon
#

Wish i could just buy feathers lmao thats gonna be a pain in the ass

minor widget
#

are you trying to keep high honor

mortal horizon
#

Not really right now

#

Im only in chapter 2

#

I just dont feel like chasing down a bunch of birds cowboykekw

dapper bone
#

cause I think it would be pretty hard to catch a legendary fish with a bunch of lawmen chasing you

minor widget
#

you can kill a bunch of people and put them in somewhat the same spot and wait a bit and lots of ravens and crows will come and start eating the bodies, get a repeater or varmint rifle and go into deadeye and kill all of them

mortal horizon
#

Lol i had that happen to me while i was hunting a perfect beaver

#

Had to fight off a bunch of law in Blackwater

radiant girder
#

gives you the off hand holster

minor widget
mortal horizon
dapper bone
#

why not just go to van horn for a beaver

#

plenty of them there

minor widget
#

go to owanjila or elysian pool for beavers

mortal horizon
#

Idk the guide i saw took me to Blackwater

#

Now I need locations for:
Perfect squirrel
Perfect panther
Perfect cougar

dapper bone
#

for squirrel go to apple timber company near strawberry

minor widget
#

perfect cougar can be found at black bone forest, along with perfect grizzly bear

dapper bone
#

or maybe clemens cove near rhodes

radiant girder
#

theres a cougar spawn between the owanjila trapper and the road

#

panther spawns south of braithwaite manor

mortal horizon
#

The panther has been the hardest so far. I spent 4 in game days south of braithwaite and dumped tons of pred bait and didnt find one

radiant girder
#

use baits on the edge of the forest and hide behind the rock at the intersection

#

and cover scent lotion

#

if ur using the bolt action make sure its loaded beforehand because the noise of the bolt will alert the panther

mortal horizon
#

Do you have a pic of the map showing that spot or can you get one because i need a better tactic lol

radiant girder
#

it's at the intersection where the panther spawns

#

there's only one intersection

mortal horizon
#

There’s more than one for sure

radiant girder
#

there isn't

mortal horizon
#

But are you talking about off to the right where it breaks off into 3 paths

mortal horizon
radiant girder
#

it's right south

minor widget
#

by catfish jacksons i think

radiant girder
#

it's by the lake

mortal horizon
#

So down near Catfish Jacksons

twilit yarrow
#

searching panthers ?

mortal horizon
#

Yeah

#

Not having much luck either

radiant girder
twilit yarrow
#

I've been attacked by one near the widow house, but it was in Rdo I dont know if it change something

mortal horizon
#

Yeah ive been attacked by a few but for some reason when i want one i cant find it lol

twilit yarrow
mortal horizon
#

Sheesh i just found like 50 deer in one spot, if only i saw this when i needed 7 perfect pelts

radiant girder
#

holy shit why are crows so hard to find

mortal horizon
#

Now i cant find a wolf when i need one even though theyre always on my ass lol

radiant girder
#

just ride around roanoke ridge

mortal horizon
#

Oh cool i found a little hunting shack

radiant girder
#

you'll get ambushed sooner or later

mortal horizon
#

Rn im in the mountains about the “West” in West Elizabeth

radiant girder
#

mount shann

mortal horizon
#

Oop here they come, pray for a 3 star

radiant girder
#

where do cedar waxwings spawn

minor widget
#

hill haven ranch for cedar waxwings i think

mortal horizon
#

Ah crap forgot i needed my buck skin again since i lost it earlier

#

Dammit i get immediately attacked by a cougar but its not 3 stars Sadge

thick pewter
minor widget
thick pewter
#

Ye

minor widget
#

you can find rowboats and canoes all around st denis, but you can also get a steamboat a little farther off in the lanahachee river

mortal horizon
#

Hunting these big cats is a pain fr

minor widget
#

ong

#

ofc you can never find an animal when your looking for it

mortal horizon
#

Finally found one and it wasnt 3 star and they take forever to spawn so now i gotta wait god knows how long

#

Thankfully the trapper is close so i can keep up on my materials

thick pewter
minor widget
#

idk then theyre usually there for me

thick pewter
#

Where abouts all I found was medium to large boats

minor widget
#

you might have to take your horse to swim out into the river

thick pewter
#

Ok

minor widget
#

anybody know how to get the machete in the mission where you save sean

mortal horizon
thick pewter
#

Ye but can horses get to siska

#

Clemens is quite far

minor widget
#

prolly not, they might lose stamina

thick pewter
#

If it fully loses stam in water will it die?

minor widget
#

it will buck you off

mortal horizon
#

Yay cougar skin

#

Almost killed me though the mf

minor widget
#

nice

mortal horizon
#

Buck, squirrel, and panther and then I get the max satchel

#

Wait does a pronghorn buck count as a buck

minor widget
#

i dont think so

mortal horizon
#

Lame

minor widget
#

what did you need the buck skin for

mortal horizon
#

Satchel

#

Ive seen hundreds of whitetails and only one buck in the mix. Im gonna check Cattail Pond thats where i found one the first time. But the area near Strawberry where John starts in the epilogue is also a good place

minor widget
#

does it have to be perfect

mortal horizon
#

Yes

#

All perfect pelts for satchels unfortunately

#

Which makes it even more annoying

minor widget
#

oh nvm then

mortal horizon
#

Last time i just sat an herbivore bait at cattail pond and sat across the river and one came pretty quick but that was pure luck because after i died and lost it i havent seen a buck at all since, let alone a perfect one

minor widget
#

you dont eed satchels for 100% do you

mortal horizon
#

Nah i just decided this playthrough im gonna do all the hunting stuff since ive always ignored it before

#

Gonna do this first, then legendaries, then camp upgrades, dinosaur bones, and then fish

minor widget
#

oh good im trying to get 100% this playthrough

mortal horizon
#

I would but, dont wanna do the online trophies

minor widget
#

i hate online

mortal horizon
#

Yeah its lame thats why im like screw it for 100%, im just gonna do all the challenges and extras and call that my “full” playthrough lol

#

Omg 1 star buck like why

minor widget
#

dang man

dapper bone
#

yeah 100% is soul crushing fr

minor widget
#

fr

dapper bone
#

not even gonna lie the CIA could make you 100% rdr2 as an efficient torture method

minor widget
#

lmao

mortal horizon
#

Oh my god i just found 4 bucks in one spot and they were all 1 star

minor widget
#

do you have the buck antler trinket

mortal horizon
#

Yep

dapper bone
#

getting this many 1 star bucks would be harder than getting a single 3 star buck

#

you sure your shooting them with the right gun

minor widget
#

if you find a 2 star then lasso it and kill it with your knife, youll have better chances of a 3 star

mortal horizon
#

Ya its the right gun. But im saying like they’re starting off at 1 star when i observe them, im not messing up the hunt

#

Plenty of perfect deer, but the bucks are hard

#

Bruh wtf another 1 star buck

#

This is killing me

#

If only pronghorn bucks counted because basically all of those are 3 star lol

minor widget
#

is there a way to continue the bear hunting mission with hosea without selling or stabling the shire, i hate morgans

mortal horizon
#

You can keep the shire

minor widget
#

yea but i want to keep the shire during the mission, i dont want to buy the morgan at all

mortal horizon
#

Holy shit these 1 star bucks this is ridiculous

mortal horizon
minor widget
#

hosea just sits there and tells me to go sell the horse, the mission wont progress

mortal horizon
#

Try stabling him then get him from the stable

#

Ive kept him before, you may have to buy the morgan and then just sell it back real quick but you can keep him for sure

minor widget
#

in the mission?

mortal horizon
#

Ya

minor widget
#

ok

#

it didnt work

mortal horizon
#

Finally fucking got one

minor widget
#

3 star buck?

mortal horizon
mortal horizon
minor widget
#

nice man

mortal horizon
#

After 20 1 star bucks lmao

#

Squirrel and panther all that’s left

minor widget
#

yea it didnt work the stable closes

mortal horizon
#

Damn might have to go after then

lofty cave
#

Could someone please help me? I've been at the He's British, of Course III quest for an hour, but whenever I try to kill the lion, the auto dead-eye keeps turning off for whatever reason

dapper bone
#

have you tried manually marking it

lofty cave
#

It doesn't let me

mortal horizon
#

I always thought auto dead eye turns off once you get the marking feature

lofty cave
#

it turns off right before I can do anything

lofty cave
#

sorry, when I say auto-dead eye, I mean that the game automatically puts me in dead-eye mode

mortal horizon
#

Oh

#

Well yeah

#

Thats supposed to happen

dapper bone
#

hes saying it doesnt work

#

which it should

lofty cave
#

I get that, but what I don't get is why it turns off the second I enter it

dapper bone
#

do you have a full dead eye core

lofty cave
#

Yeah

#

I had a gold core for one instance as well

mortal horizon
#

What about the actual bar

#

Do you have some of that as well

lofty cave
#

that too

#

It looks like it gets cut off by Arthur reloading his gun which is weird because I came into the fight fully loaded

dapper bone
#

is the lion the only time it doesnt work

lofty cave
#

yeah

mortal horizon
#

If you have a controller, try pulling the stick up until it pops, ive had my stick stuck before and had a similar issue

#

If that doesnt work, probably just a glitch tbh try reloading

lofty cave
#

my gun??

dapper bone
#

the game

lofty cave
#

I've done that already-

dapper bone
#

you reloaded the game?

lofty cave
#

yes

#

and I shut off my pc as well

#

I think I've found the issue

#

Arthur does, in fact, stop because he's reloading

#

I'll try switching off of express rounds-

karmic prism
#

if its really softlocked you always have the skip checkpoint option

#

or wait, do you have that in side missions?

lofty cave
#

what do you mean?

mortal horizon
#

Some

mortal horizon
karmic prism
#

3 times i believe

lofty cave
#

I always just reload the save because I hate seeing arthur die lmfao

#

Alright, I fixed it

mortal horizon
#

Man wtf i just tracked a “squirrel” and when i found it, it was glowing and everything like i was following the right animal, and it ends up being a chipmunk

minor widget
#

lmfao

empty lark
#

get fucked

mortal horizon
#

So close to this satchel

#

Finally got this mf

#

Panther time

radiant girder
#

holy shit bats are so annoying to hunt

mortal horizon
#

That sounds awful, what do you need to hunt bats for

dapper bone
#

those are actually the worst animals to hunt for hunting requests

radiant girder
minor widget
#

maybe i wont do 100%

dapper bone
#

you can find some in the elysian pool cave

minor widget
#

or limpany

dapper bone
#

they will literally fly into the walls so its easy pickings

minor widget
#

the st denis has some bats on him if you loot him i think

#

*st denis vampire

mortal horizon
#

Panther coming for me fucker better be 3 stars

radiant girder
minor widget
#

oh ok

mortal horizon
#

And he was. Yay legend of the east satchel finally secured

minor widget
#

good job

mortal horizon
#

Thank you good sir it was a grind fr

dapper bone
#

very useful satchel

minor widget
#

i can tell

mortal horizon
#

This is the first time in 400 hours and multiple playthroughs that i ever crafted a single satchel lol

dapper bone
#

i just be looting everything without a care in the world about room

mortal horizon
#

Yeah thats what im excited for, especially hair tonics

dapper bone
#

only thing I ever actually got 99 items of was cigarettes

minor widget
#

i just let my hair grow to like mid chapter 3 and then i do 3 hair tonics a day

mortal horizon
#

I usually force max beard in chapter 2

#

Although, i may forego the beard this time and rock clean Arthur

radiant girder
#

finally got that damn bat

#

beaver time

mortal horizon
#

Has anyone ever actually drifted a horse lmao

mortal horizon
minor widget
#

like the stage 4 bonding ability

mortal horizon
#

Yea

hidden moss
#

hello

radiant girder
dapper bone
#

when I did hunting requests I hunted the beaver first

#

huge mistake

minor widget
#

its really useful in st denis streets

dapper bone
#

ended up rotting when I hunted the other animals and I had to hunt it again

mortal horizon
mortal horizon
dapper bone
#

rearing is good for pictures

#

thats about it

mortal horizon
#

Im done

minor widget
#

i only use rearing for pictures, drifting in st denis and skid stops are useful for everything

mortal horizon
#

Rode past some Lemoyne mfs and they just blew me down, lost my pelt

karmic prism
mortal horizon
#

Like why tf do u lose the pelt if the horse is fine

mortal horizon
karmic prism
#

oh is was that the ambush with the gatling gun

minor widget
#

ive never gotten that ambush

mortal horizon
#

Thats so fucked up i literally spent all day searching for that panther, didnt find it, finally came back and got it first try and then that happens like wtf

mortal horizon
karmic prism
#

it happens near the panther spot so i imagine

#

lemoyne raiders are such cucks lmao

mortal horizon
#

I tried to just slide past

#

To save my pelt

#

But nope

karmic prism
#

they need a literal gatling gun to pose a threat

mortal horizon
#

Fr cuck lords

minor widget
#

ong

mortal horizon
#

Man im about to break my controller now the panther wont spawn

karmic prism
#

and they just work for rich people so fuck em SipArthur

karmic prism
#

just sleep and do other stuff

mortal horizon
#

This is so bogus

hidden moss
karmic prism
#

i kept getting bounty hunters sicced on me while hunting lol

hidden moss
karmic prism
mortal horizon
mortal horizon
hidden moss
karmic prism
#

though my bounty in lemoyne was like 300$ at the time so it was warranted

mortal horizon
#

Oh if i had that option i wouldve been done that lol

karmic prism
mortal horizon
#

Thank god the panther is here

#

Better be perfect i stg

karmic prism
#

everybody gangsta till 2star good panther pelt

mortal horizon
#

And naturally its a 2 star pelt

#

Screw you for saying that tbh

karmic prism
#

hehehe

#

man i wish all of the legendary animals were availible as arthur

#

only way to have him wear the badass panther cloak is through mods

mortal horizon
#

Thats weak

radiant girder
#

you can get that as arthur

mortal horizon
#

Damn this time i reloaded and the panther jumped on my back the second i spawned in lmao

#

Im taking a miracle tonic and riding for my life them raiders arent doing me again

#

At least the squirrel in my bag was secured. I wonder why you lose the stuff on your horse cargo but not in your bag when it comes to animals

karmic prism
#

is it just doing the master hunter challenges then?

dapper bone
#

yes

karmic prism
#

i love misinformation.

mortal horizon
#

Same

#

Cooking is so tedius

karmic prism
#

yeah it is, usually why i just stow 5 big game and save them for when i need it

mortal horizon
#

Has anyone else ever experienced bounty hunters chasing them when they have no bounty in chapter 2? It’s always 2 bounty hunters and they come when im camping

mortal horizon
dapper bone
#

if you plan on doing challenges herbalist 10 requires you to cook and season all types of meat

mortal horizon
#

You can…season meat?

radiant girder
#

yeah

#

how long does it take for the squirrel statue to appear in the chest

#

in johns room

mortal horizon
#

Gonna do all the camp craft upgrades next, wish me luck

#

So wait, Arthur cant hunt all the legendaries?

karmic prism
#

gave a nice health boost for the last mission though

karmic prism
#

and the bull gator is ch6 only

mortal horizon
mortal horizon
karmic prism
#

i think you just need cooked meat and herbs

#

the one i made was with oregano i think?

mortal horizon
#

Crazy that i never knew this in all my time playing

#

2 perfect goats was the fastest hunt of my life

minor widget
#

yea you can get them at larned sod or butchers creek

#

butchers creek also has chickens and pigs

mortal horizon
#

Larned Sod was perfect

#

Upgrading the entire camp is gonna be an endeavor, probably a lot harder than the satchels lol

radiant girder
#

i suggest getting the moose first

#

so you don't have to deal with the hassle later

mortal horizon
#

Why do u lose honor for killing cows

mortal horizon
karmic prism
#

its weird how some items require cow hide though

dapper bone
#

at 99% completion

mortal horizon
#

Definitely not having much luck with a moose

minor widget
#

the legendary moose is easier to get than the regular moose

queen heath
thick pewter
#

How do you max hp stam and deadeye for 100%

#

All of them are lvl 8 for me...

queen heath
#

Do challenges

#

Get reinforcement equipment

#

Done

thick pewter
#

So you need to equip all the equipment from the challenges?

dapper bone
#

No

#

just buy them

thick pewter
#

Ok cool

#

I'm close to 100% 🙂

#

Originally I gave up hope thinking you had to skin legendary animals since one got stuck in a lake but now I'm feeling good

#

Anyway cya

radiant girder
opaque aurora
#

arthurs shi gotta be at least 6.5 inches

cunning briar
#

dawg what

karmic prism
#

let em cook

mortal horizon
#

Got the moose, dang he’s a big boy

karmic prism
#

dont question how arthur somehow makes the antlers 5x smaller in order to carry

pseudo berry
mighty vector
#

I tried going into Wallace station general store but it's locked

#

Tried different times of day but it's still locked

#

I'm in chapter 6

solid ridge
#

did dutch kill colms brotehr first or did colm kill dutches lover first

arctic dragon
#

whats the best pistol

#

in story mode

hidden moss
#

volcanic

arctic dragon
hidden moss
#

for damage

#

if you're for fire rate then semi automatic or mauser

arctic dragon
#

i'm trying to decide if i should get lemat revolver or m1899 pistol

#

cuz both look good if u design them well

hidden moss
#

dual wield mausers are deadly

arctic dragon
#

what abt m1899

hidden moss
#

i can consider that but its not as fast as those 2

solid ridge
minor widget
#

mauser has the best fire rate and holds the most rounds

solid ridge
#

not fully

minor widget
#

and the reload is super fast

arctic dragon
#

both guys are assholes

solid ridge
#

yeah

arctic dragon
#

i hate dutch as equal as micah

solid ridge
#

f#ck dutch

arctic dragon
#

hosea was the real one

solid ridge
#

and he DIED

arctic dragon
#

cuz of dutch

hidden moss
arctic dragon
#

u notice that whenever bad stuff happens, right before it hosea is telling dutch not to do it

#

like remember when they had the parley thing in chap 3

#

hosea said its a trap

#

etc etc

solid ridge
#

and everything bad happened when hosea died

arctic dragon
#

he didnt want to rob the bank in saint denis either

solid ridge
#

after

minor widget
#

hosea also didnt want to go after bronte for revenge

hidden moss
#

bro just fed and housed jack

arctic dragon
#

i want more of a western style char

hidden moss
#

schofield or cattleman

#

cattleman was the most famous revolver

#

i think

#

but if you want extra damage then schofield

arctic dragon
#

no lemat

minor widget
#

damage is schofield fs

arctic dragon
#

im fighting for lemat

minor widget
#

lemat has the shotgun part too

hidden moss
#

sure its fine but the reloading is shit

empty lark
#

lemat goes crazy

#

if reloading is an issue in story

#

skill issue

hidden moss
#

ok

minor widget
#

i carry double cattleman or one cattleman and one sawed off shotgun,
lancaster and bolt action for rifle or rare shotgun

arctic dragon
#

idk im tryna make the hottest pistols i possibly can but i want to have good pistols

minor widget
#

cattleman, you can get long barrels and nice combos for colors

radiant girder
radiant girder
#

highest damage and has 9 rounds

#

slow ass reloading but that can be by passed with deadeye

solid ridge
#

i use the m1899

karmic prism
#

more like a rifle than a revolver

#

its technically the best, highest capacity and accuracy on top of the shotgun attachment but

#

idk just feels weird to use for me

#

same with double action, feels out of place in its category

hidden moss
#

Yi

mortal horizon
mortal horizon
#

I like the Cattleman the best looks wise but it’s just shit

karmic prism
#

i hate the fact the game forces you to use the cattleman during the bank robbery

#

just to not let you bring your own gun to guarma

mortal horizon
#

I saw somebody dual wielding some pistol combo that was literally like using an automatic weapon

#

Probably Mausers

mortal horizon
#

I always do the Rhodes back room immediately for the Lancaster

karmic prism
#

yeah, valentine doctor and rhodes gunsmith are go tos

mortal horizon
#

Speaking of back rooms, I literally cannot rob the Strawberry one. It wont let me peek through the window, ive tried everything and cant find anything online about this

#

I saw someone say you have to get a tip about it before you can do it, but ive never had that happen before

mortal horizon
karmic prism
#

pump action but yeah

#

i like how robbing them doesnt cancel the mission with javier either

#

i think that one rude old lady with the donkey has a semi auto shotgun in her basement, couldnt point out the location though

mortal horizon
#

I always found it funny how you can clear places like that and still have missions there later. For example, Shady Belle I stumbled upon very early. I thought it would be hilarious if when you got there with Lenny it was just like “oh, i already killed these guys, move the fam in!” but no you have to do it again

karmic prism
#

tbf murfree country would be pretty anticlimactic if it was empty

mortal horizon
mortal horizon
#

Aside from the few and far between Murfree encounters. Although, I really liked the camping encounters with them. Nice twist

karmic prism
#

yeah sadly theres no reward for clearing beaver hollow early

#

though blasting those sickos heads off can be seen as its own reward

mortal horizon
#

I also find it insane that you can miss the widow, that’s one of Arthur’s best good guy arc missions

karmic prism
#

i accidentally killed her bc she was in the way when i deadeyed the wolves 💀

#

had to reload my save and redo the whole mission

mortal horizon
karmic prism
#

least bad are probably the laramies

#

theyre just standard thugs

mortal horizon
#

I didn’t realize that if you don’t go soon after it appears she just croaks. I also didnt ever meet the creepy photo guy until this playthrough. Once I realized who he was talking about I blew his brains

#

I dont know if that guy ends up killing her or what

#

She’s in the worst place ever to be a single woman lmao. Murfrees, that guy, bears, wolves, like just go home at this point lady

proven ingot
#

how do i replay rdr2 story

#

i finished it a long time ago but i wanna play again

cobalt oracle
#

how are you trying to connect it?

#

i'm pretty sure you can connect it wirelessly

#

huh

#

i know in some games you have to turn the settings to controller before you can use it

#

oh alright cool

tawny lava
#

how do I catch the legendary fish

radiant girder
#

fishing rod

#

and bait

mental lynx
#

bro has dark souls 4

pseudo berry
pseudo dragon
#

Fuck micah

#

He's an asshole

minor widget
#

ong but hes a good shot tho

pseudo dragon
#

True

minor widget
#

i envy micah bc he can aim two guns in different directions

mighty vector
#

Do the trapper saddles get the stirrups boost as well

pseudo dragon
#

What do that the meen

mighty vector
#

Like the speed and acceleration bonus from the stirrups with stable saddles

#

Do the trapper saddles get that as well

pseudo dragon
#

Not sure

minor widget
#

hooded stirrups are best

#

with gator saddle

pseudo dragon
#

Sounds awsome

mighty vector
minor widget
#

panther or gator are my go to

mighty vector
#

Where are panthers found

pseudo dragon
#

Oh you mean like the legendary animals

minor widget
#

south of braithwate manor

pseudo dragon
#

Like the clothes and shit

mighty vector
mighty vector
pseudo dragon
minor widget
#

bolt action rifle

mighty vector
minor widget
#

cock the gun first the panther will hear it

mighty vector
pseudo dragon
minor widget
pseudo dragon
#

Good tip

radiant girder
#

can't change stirrups on crafted saddles

#

god i hate how you can only have four saved outfits

pseudo dragon
#

Where are some legendary animals at?

dapper bone
#

all over the map

#

which one are you specifically looking for

pseudo dragon
#

Nevermind I googled it going
After a bulgater

radiant girder
#

it's only in chapter 6

pseudo dragon
#

Oh

#

I've been lookin for it in chapter 4

#

Are legendary animals only there for 9ne chapter?

radiant girder
#

no

#

only the bull gator

hidden moss
radiant girder
#

and the legendary panther is only available once you do all master hunter challenges

hidden moss
#

Yea, but that's not locked by a chapter at least.

mighty vector
pseudo dragon
#

Help im starting to like furries

#

HELP

twilit yarrow
#

let's play hangman

twilit yarrow
pseudo dragon
#

Help

radiant girder
#

they're better in pretty much everyway

#

just get the beaver one

mighty vector
radiant girder
#

beaver is just easier to get

hidden moss
#

Fuck that. Danger FTW

#

tbh beaver or panther is more of your choice

#

if you care about the horse's health then beaver, if stamina then panther

hidden moss
violet sedge
#

Guys i really need help, maybe my rdr2 its bugged bc my bull gator doesnt show up not even his area pop up, i alr camped searched for hours and yes i alr finished the chapter 4 mission and im actually on chapter 6 rn but this mf dont show up

radiant girder
#

what mission are you on

violet sedge
#

Save john marston from prison

#

Mission with sadie adler

radiant girder
#

it should be there by then

#

but maybe not

violet sedge
#

Ikr

radiant girder
#

huh

violet sedge
#

But this mf dont appear not even in any map

#

Idk why

radiant girder
#

play a few more missions and try again

violet sedge
#

Ill finish the game and try to hunt this boy

#

Bc i he doenst appear im going to have to reset my run

cinder trail
#

Finally got 100%

#

Holy shit

idle crescent
mortal horizon
mental lynx
#

i wanna get all achievements but the gold rush one seems stressful

idle crescent
#

it isn't that hard tbh if u have a list of them

#

like preparing before hand

mental lynx
#

ah okay

mighty vector
#

Bro why haven't I seen a single panther

#

I went south of braithwaite manor at the intersection, used predator bait, waited till nighttime, and used cover scent

#

All I'm seeing is coyotes

pallid bay
hidden moss
#

I wonder if it would make sense for Arthur to use the navy revolver

mighty vector
#

I saw videos of dudes just waltzing in and getting attacked by one

#

It's like I made them go extinct except I haven't even studied one yet

cobalt oracle
#

wtf is the "elysian pool" by butchers creek

#

I found a cave behind its waterfall with a bunch of yellow/orange liquid and a bottomless pit

#

along with a gold bar and multiple large jewelry bags

normal relic
#

There's a mission to go in there

cobalt oracle
#

oh ok

empty lark
#

have you tried fishing in the elysian pool yet?

hidden moss
#

for the legendary fish

radiant girder
lethal warren
#

ok

lethal warren
radiant girder
#

fr

lethal warren
#

big brain time

pseudo dragon
#

Morning

calm oasis
#

Should I kill the legendary bear as Arthur or go back to kill him in the epilogue as John

calm oasis
#

I just realized something, Dutch is an asshole, at the end of the game we find out he had over 20 thousand dollars stashed away from the blackwater heist, and yet, throughout the story he keeps yapping about how „We need money“. 20k in 1899 is a shit ton of money, surely enough to move 20 people to a new country, this is just one more proof of how evil Dutch is and always has been.

waxen wind
#

I don't think he actually had evil plans, seeing how in earlier parts of the game he clearly cares about his gang members

calm oasis
#

Isnt 20 thousand like around 700 thousand dollars though?

waxen wind
#

Idk

hidden moss
#

Hi guys, today. I just completed Arthur's storyline with high honor for first time. For now, i'm in Epilogue.

main crypt
hidden moss
#

If i was Arthur in my final stand with Micah, i would have pushed him off the cliff.

dapper bone
#

he probably would’ve pulled you down with him

hidden moss
karmic prism
#

he just wanted to keep fighting

#

literally every time they go and shoot a bunch of people he just says "we did it to survive"

deft umbra
#

can i reach 100% completion without doing some of strauss's missions?

deft umbra
#

oh well

warm musk
mighty vector
mighty vector
deft umbra
#

can i get 100% completion without missable missions like hunting with uncle?

patent axle
#

is there a way I can skip missions? I got all the way set back like 5 missions back. I was at chapter 3 and got setback to towards the end of chapter 2. : c

radiant girder
#

no

patent axle
#

dang it

radiant girder
mighty vector
mortal horizon
#

Anyone know where i can get an Ardennes?

radiant girder
#

scarlett meadows

mortal horizon
#

Thanks

mortal horizon
mortal horizon
# patent axle why?

Because the vibes are immaculate. No real benefit from it from a real gameplay perspective but story wise and vibe wise I stick around in chapter 2 as long as I can. Everyone is alive and happy, things are a lot more positive

patent axle
#

wdym everyone's alive and happy...

#

what happens in later chapters?

mortal horizon
#

I always do everything available to me in chapter 2 in chapter 2 and only move forward when everything is done

patent axle
#

not like anyone gonna just die randomly lol

mortal horizon
patent axle
#

I'll be fine

#

I'll just try to spend time in chapter 3

mortal horizon
#

Do whatever you want im just suggesting

patent axle
#

yeah been doing that

#

killing people here and there and running people over in valentine yk

mortal horizon
#

At a certain point the story kind of picks up pace so chapters 2-4 are just the best times to really take everything in

patent axle
#

o

#

alright

#

do anything bad happen in later chapters?

#

like after 3

mortal horizon
#

I won’t spoil anything but lets just say you want to take your time lol

patent axle
#

ok

#

is the stuff that happens later on very important?

#

like

#

or I mean is it a really good story later on?

mortal horizon
#

There are countless secrets and encounters and etc so explore during chapters 2-4 if you really want to soak everything in

mortal horizon
patent axle
#

interesting

mortal horizon
#

It’s one of the best stories in gaming or media in general lol

patent axle
#

is the story better tahn gta5

mortal horizon
#

By a mile

patent axle
#

oh wow ok

#

I heard gta5 have a good story didn't finish it though

#

might go back to it sometime

mortal horizon
#

Personally i didnt care too much for it. Especially not in comparison

#

Arthur is an amazing character really

#

Which is the main thing

patent axle
#

yeah I like his personality

#

he's cool

mortal horizon
#

Well, he has a great arc. There’s a reason it’s called Red Dead Redemption lol. You’ll see, but just take your time

patent axle
#

okay moving on to other stuff, I have lancaster repeater, semiauto shotgun and bolt acton rifle

#

which 2 should I use

mortal horizon
#

All are good depends on situation

#

Bolt action I would mostly use for hunting though

patent axle
#

which ones would generally be good, cuz my horse can't be with me all the time yk

mortal horizon
#

The other two should be your main rotation

patent axle
#

oh ok

#

what about revolvers and pistols n stuff

mortal horizon
#

I like the Schofield early on

patent axle
#

oh yeah I use schofield and double action

#

hey where would I hunt?

#

also like what's the point of hunting, after I get the skin of animals idk where to put them or what to do with them.

mortal horizon
#

There’s a lot of point in hunting

#

For one, hunting is how you upgrade your satchel

patent axle
#

satchel? that's on the horse right?

mortal horizon
#

It’s also how you get “trinkets” which are basically like talismans that give you active perks

mortal horizon
#

You can upgrade it to be an unlimited bag if you get all upgrades

patent axle
#

oh that's interesting

#

I'll go try hunting n stuff now then

#

good time to try out bolt action rifle

mortal horizon
#

Satchel upgrades, trinkets, outfits, camp aesthetic upgrades

#

Food

#

Which is important

patent axle
#

oh, author barely gets hungry

#

after I few days he just eats canned corns LMAO

mortal horizon
#

Well no but you should aim for average weight

#

He’s a bit more spongy at average

patent axle
#

oh yeah he's average weight rn

radiant girder
patent axle
radiant girder
mortal horizon
#

I used double action my entire first playthrough

patent axle
radiant girder
patent axle
#

oh

mortal horizon
#

Schofield is nice

patent axle
#

what should I use with the schofield then?

patent axle
#

I think I saw it somewhere once but idk where

mortal horizon
mortal horizon
patent axle
#

ok

#

oh

#

this guy's underweight

#

hehee....

#

apparently I'm underfeeding him

mortal horizon
#

I would start eating more if i were you

#

At least twice a day

patent axle
#

where do I go eat?

mortal horizon
#

Your satchel probably has food in it

#

Or a saloon

patent axle
#

oh canned corns?

#

lel

#

where would I buy some?

mortal horizon
#

Or you can set up camp and cook if you have meat

patent axle
#

can I buy some at the grocery store in rhodes

mortal horizon
#

General store, but you loot plenty out in the world as it is

#

But if you have the money stock up

patent axle
#

okk

#

imma keep watching that hunting guide and figure out how to upgrade satchel n stuff

mortal horizon
#

Its a lot of work im not gonna lie to you

#

But if you enjoy the game its fun

patent axle
#

I'm enjoying the game

#

been playing it a lot

#

more than other games lol

#

played like 10 hours within 3 days

radiant girder
#

eat three things of food and fast travel to some place far away

#

like saint denis to strawberry

radiant girder
#

repeat until ur over weight

patent axle
#

oh

#

ok

radiant girder
#

over weight arthur can tank more bullets

mortal horizon
#

You dont need to be over weight

#

You’ll lose some stamina

radiant girder
#

barely

mortal horizon
#

Average is best of both worlds

#

Plus overweight is kinda hard to maintain

#

Arthur has an iron gut fr

patent axle
radiant girder
#

weight is easy to maintain if your constantly fast traveling far away

#

the things you gotta do to hunt moose

mortal horizon
#

I got lucky on my moose

#

Pulled up to cattail pond, boom first try

radiant girder
#

i got a few three stars in one day

mortal horizon
#

Which tanked my rng for the panther because that took me almost an entire afternoon to trigger

radiant girder
#

hunting is easy tbh

#

especially moose

patent axle
#

I still don't understand after watching a youtube video

radiant girder
#

you just gotta know where they spawn

patent axle
#

wihch means either I'm stupid or it's too hard

patent axle
radiant girder
#

if they don't spawn then look somewhere else

mortal horizon