red-dead-singleplayer

[long galleon]

playthrough is 11 hours on yt

i wont play 11 hours for that

i have done that too

[astral juniper]

then you aren't a dedicated hunter bro

bro why ask if you're gonna say you've done it 😭

give us a list of what you haven't done

[visual drum]

what ammo do i use with the varmint rifle for torture?

[astral juniper]

and we shall decide as a council

[long galleon]

well let me see

[long galleon]

varmint ammo

[astral juniper]

doesn't it only work with .22 ammo

[visual drum]

wait that exists

[visual drum]

uhhh

UHhhHh

[iron ocean]

only 1 type of varmint ammo afaik

[astral juniper]

it is the only ammo used with varmint rifles iirc

[long galleon]

ive done all predators except wolf

[iron ocean]

the varmint ammo is the wet fart

[visual drum]

oh ok

[astral juniper]

then hunt a wolf using only thine knife

acquire three pelts

[long galleon]

ive done boar

[visual drum]

after homework i’ll continue torturing innocent people, thanks y’all

[long galleon]

the legendary i mean

[astral juniper]

yeah

[long galleon]

cant get 3

[astral juniper]

cheat

idc

[long galleon]

no

[visual drum]

how many shots does it take to kill somebody with a varmint rifle?

[astral juniper]

how many outfits include the pelt

[long galleon]

but i killed it with tomahawk last time

[visual drum]

huh?

[long galleon]

idk but the one pelt goes for all

[long galleon]

5 maybe

[visual drum]

oh nice

definitely good for torture

thanks for the tip ❤️

[long galleon]

then ive done legendary wolf and coyote

[astral juniper]

the ui shows multiple pelts when with the trapper iirc

therefore if there's 3 or more then kill it and sell the pelt

[long galleon]

it wont

[iron ocean]

took me a lot of shots to down an NPC with the varmint, however I was surprised to one shot kill one to the head

[astral juniper]

ight brb bois we huntin in rdr and finding this out

[visual drum]

i’ll have fun shooting npcs in the upper parts of their body with a varmint rifle 🤪

[long galleon]

i dont want u back

[astral juniper]

dang that's cold man

[long galleon]

:DDD

[astral juniper]

If my point is proven I want 2 cents and lollipop

[iron ocean]

once I shot a dude in the face, and he took forever to die, with the cattleman I think, and he started to bleed a tiny long streak of blood, like non stop

im on the series X I have no mods, so this is the vanilla slow death

that was really disgusting

[long galleon]

yea thats bleeding out

with the varmint thats what neck shots do

[iron ocean]

really? 😄

that sounds horrible, but if you can confirm I'll try that next time 😄

[long galleon]

yea confirmed

can i get crafted saddles as john anymore?

[normal relic]

Yeah you should be able too

[long galleon]

where

[normal relic]

Trapper I think it's been a while since I was in story

[iron ocean]

trapper or fence

[normal relic]

Yeah

[long galleon]

yup

arthur can get them from pearson only?

[normal relic]

Yeah I think so

You gotta craft them for John

[long galleon]

yup

[normal relic]

Ye

[long galleon]

cant u buy em with john?

from fence or trapper

[normal relic]

Probably

I never thought to look

[iron ocean]

yes you can, that's how I did it

Pearson is nowhere to be found

[normal relic]

Yeah

He's in rhodes

[iron ocean]

pearson is in Rhodes ?

wth is he doing in there

[long galleon]

he owns the shop

[iron ocean]

oh I did't know 😄

can you rob his fat ass too ?

[long galleon]

yea but john says im only kidding

[iron ocean]

but I guess he doesn't craft anymore

[long galleon]

or something

[iron ocean]

oh that's fun

[long galleon]

i dont have the heart to rob pearson

[iron ocean]

I wouldn't care to rob the walrus

[long galleon]

hes nice

u dont even get anything from robbing shops

[iron ocean]

I calculated after testing it few times, always under 20$

30$*

27 / 29$ never lmore

[long galleon]

yea thats not worth

[iron ocean]

ok dude, I'm headin out, bye now

[long galleon]

bye then

[astral juniper]

alright my theory has been proven

the icon at the trapper shows the number 3

[long galleon]

u cant get 3 legendaries

[normal relic]

He works at the general store in rhodes

[astral juniper]

I did not get the legendaries

[visual drum]

have y’all ever robbed pearson?

[astral juniper]

I sold 1 pelt, and the trapper gets 3 for crafting purposes

[normal relic]

Nope I won't rob pearson

[astral juniper]

because there are 3 different recipes that use 1 legendary pelt

[long galleon]

ok

[normal relic]

I wanna go back to Saint Denis and rob the tailor at night

[visual drum]

robbing pearson can be quite funny

[long galleon]

its not

[visual drum]

he says “Abigail must be real proud, huh?”

[astral juniper]

the dialogue you get is somethin else

[normal relic]

I'm not gonna be mean to him

[long galleon]

yea

as john it dont look right

[visual drum]

i robbed him

[normal relic]

This time I'm going to knock the tailor out before robbing him

[astral juniper]

most sane red dead player

[long galleon]

fr

[normal relic]

Knock him out and hogtie him

[visual drum]

you can’t kill how tho

[visual drum]

bros making a robbery plan for 20 dollars

[astral juniper]

the fact that you tried

[long galleon]

yea thats ur damn friend

[astral juniper]

we needa get to tahiti somehow

[visual drum]

you can burn him but he runs away

[normal relic]

I've robbed the tailor in Saint Denis before

[long galleon]

u must wear a beating hat

[visual drum]

how many hours y’all have on rdr2?

[long galleon]

cause ur that evil

[normal relic]

But I got caught so I'm going to try at night

[long galleon]

192

[astral juniper]

I currently have a little over 300

[normal relic]

Have no idea

[visual drum]

y’all mid

[astral juniper]

I got the game roughly 3 months ago

[normal relic]

Not alot

[visual drum]

i had rdr2 since last christmas and i have over 350 hours

[astral juniper]

but I only play on weekends so I am mid 😔

[normal relic]

Because I don't sit in story all the time

[long galleon]

i do

its very nice

[visual drum]

same

[long galleon]

cause u can talk

[astral juniper]

finna beat you man I got 2 weeks to go over this

[normal relic]

Story gets so boring

[visual drum]

i’m homeschooled - i can play whenever i want basically

[long galleon]

online was kinda annoying

[normal relic]

I spend more time in rdo the story

[visual drum]

i dislike the grinding

[astral juniper]

My 1st playthrough took so long man I just soaked in the game

[visual drum]

i got like 3 hours on rdo and over 350 on story

[normal relic]

I rushed my first play through

[long galleon]

im still in the tutorial

[visual drum]

rdr2 feels so alive

[long galleon]

its too long

[normal relic]

I'm sure I have more hours in rdo then story

[visual drum]

how many combined?

[normal relic]

Idk

I don't check it

[astral juniper]

Lemme get the exact thing

20 mins or less in rdo because I will leave my character with only pants for eternity

and roughly 307 hours in story mode

[long galleon]

go get the legendary bear hat then u have a beating hat

[visual drum]

nice

[normal relic]

There's nothing to do in story

[long galleon]

and get a long beard then ur ultimate low honor beater

[visual drum]

i dislike those hats, i only wear arthur’s hat

[normal relic]

Rav same

[visual drum]

i don’t even play as john

[long galleon]

not a beater then

[normal relic]

I keep Arthur's hat on John

[astral juniper]

I just pomade my hair and play hatless sometimes

[visual drum]

i almost always play as arthur

[visual drum]

ew

[astral juniper]

I'm disgusting ikr

[long galleon]

fr

[normal relic]

omg no

[long galleon]

no pomade never

[visual drum]

you joining the saint denis high society or something?

[normal relic]

Poor Arthur

[astral juniper]

I do it as john man

[visual drum]

arthur deserve better than no hat and pomade hair

[normal relic]

I hate using promade

[long galleon]

messy ass hair and all hair max lenght

[astral juniper]

Arthur's hat stays on at all times unless I need to viciously beat someone to death

[normal relic]

Nooo

[long galleon]

thats the best

[visual drum]

99% i use the gunslinger outfit with beard 4 or no beard

[long galleon]

cant dodge

[normal relic]

Not even max length hair on Arthur

[long galleon]

it looks good

[visual drum]

max beard and hair… nah

[astral juniper]

coward

[long galleon]

i keep it as a joke on my low honor save

[normal relic]

I kept 3 or 4 beard on Arthur all the time

[long galleon]

bro lets people beat you

[visual drum]

this is correct:
Medium hair
Beard 4

[long galleon]

sometimes they get a hit or 2 but yeah i win

[normal relic]

Ikr rav Arthur looks horrible

[long galleon]

7 hair and 10 beard is the best

[astral juniper]

vicious beatings require effort from both ends

[normal relic]

My Arthur always had medium hair and beard 4

[astral juniper]

no fun if you come out unscathed

[long galleon]

i dont see the hair from under my bear hat

[visual drum]

i don’t want my arthur to be a caveman

[long galleon]

but it looks funny

[visual drum]

omggg same 🤪 ❤️ 🔥

[astral juniper]

I like 7 hair and like 6-8 beard

[visual drum]

anyways gtg

[long galleon]

good

W bread fr

[astral juniper]

bye rav tell us your tales of torture when you get back

[normal relic]

Arthur looks pretty damn good

[long galleon]

santa enjoyer

like me

[astral juniper]

clean shaven arthur haunts me ngl

[long galleon]

i got 7 beard it wont GROW

[long galleon]

fr

beating beard and hat is the best thing

[normal relic]

I can't

[long galleon]

no one else uses the legendary bear hat?

[normal relic]

Clean shave Arthur is a no

[astral juniper]

clean shaven bald arthur 💀

[long galleon]

extra clean shaven tho

[normal relic]

Even bald Arthur is horrible

[long galleon]

bald and santa beard 👍

[normal relic]

Omg no

[astral juniper]

wait

extra-clean shaven bald arthur

you gotta leave no stubble

[normal relic]

I can't even imagine Arthur

[astral juniper]

not a spec of hair on arthur's face

[long galleon]

6 hair with the middle parted looks kinda good imo

but for me 7 hair cause i wont go to barber ever

[astral juniper]

I down so many hair tonics in this game man

[long galleon]

with john i will

[astral juniper]

it aint even funny

[normal relic]

I always went to the barber as Arthur

[long galleon]

i do 3 when it wears off

[astral juniper]

like at this point arthur is forming an addiction to the substance in those with my save man

[long galleon]

👎

[astral juniper]

I only go to the barber to change styles

[long galleon]

use the legendary bear hat

[normal relic]

Arthur is horrible with long beards

[long galleon]

me too

[astral juniper]

I have the whyem dlc thing so there's a ton of hairstyles to choose from

[long galleon]

my low honor save too lol

[normal relic]

If I restart I ain't doing low honor

[astral juniper]

when it's way too long I agree

but when it's just long enough to be a mall santa but not long enough to be an experienced mall santa it looks kinda good

[long galleon]

i always beat everyone up

i want the level 10 beard

[astral juniper]

I can't bring myself to do a low honour playthrough yet man

[long galleon]

then i have ultimate beating beard

[long galleon]

its actually fun

[astral juniper]

while I agree that viciously beating up others is fun

[normal relic]

Right I always trimmed it when it got long

[astral juniper]

I prefer to leave the crimes against humanity to john

[long galleon]

i didnt drop the dude in chapter 2 from the cliff

but other than i do pretty bad things

[normal relic]

I looked it up on youtube

[long galleon]

arthur its more fun

[astral juniper]

I can't let TB(Tellietubby) Arthur do that after getting diagnosed as having a tv in his lower abdominal region man

[normal relic]

After seeing what happens in low honor ending

[astral juniper]

I will not go for the money man

[normal relic]

I'm like nope not doing it

[astral juniper]

seeing it on yt is enough

[normal relic]

I didn't

Same

[astral juniper]

it is like an unwritten rule to always save john man 😭

[normal relic]

I'll just keep doing high honor save John

Ikr

[long galleon]

its much better

trust me

[normal relic]

I did save John high honor first playthrough

It's not

[long galleon]

with high honro

honor

[long galleon]

me too

but idk if i will complete my low honor save

[astral juniper]

as much as I want to blind micah, no

[normal relic]

I'll always do save John high honor

[long galleon]

i might leave it in chapter 4

[long galleon]

yes u do want to do it

[long galleon]

maybe ill do it but yeah i might do another save for that

like yk same save but 2 different parts

[long galleon]

most overrated one

[astral juniper]

ngl doing a modded run after completing a vanilla one feels nice

gives it a bit of freshness for the slightly repetitive parts of the game

[normal relic]

Everytime I'm in story I head up to Arthur's grave

[astral juniper]

charles is a real one for burying arthur ngl

[normal relic]

Yeah

[astral juniper]

and following his final wishes with how he wanted to be buried

[normal relic]

He picked the perfect place too

I feel like crying everytime I head up there

[astral juniper]

and his spirit animal sitting there man

[normal relic]

I got a marker on where Arthur's grave is

Yep

The deer

[astral juniper]

doesn't he get an eagle with high honour or something?

and a coyote with low honour arthur iirc

[normal relic]

Yeah

Wolf is low honor

Eagle or deer is high honor

I love what it says on Arthur's grave high honor

[astral juniper]

yeah

[normal relic]

Full of flowers

[astral juniper]

it really sends a message of how charles felt about arthur in the end

[normal relic]

It does

[astral juniper]

Also the charles dialogue in saint denis if you had a low honour arthur is devastating to me man

charles remembering arthur as a bad person is something I will not let slide 😭

[normal relic]

I never looked that up

Did you go see Mary Beth as John

The things those 2 say about Arthur made me cry

I went to see Tilly and Mary Beth I never found rains fall

or Eagle Flies

[astral juniper]

I've only seen it on yt

all the interactions

[long galleon]

coyote with low deer high

[long galleon]

👍

u can be high honor with going back for money

[astral juniper]

I meant the animal that hangs out by the grave

normally it's an eagle for high honour

[long galleon]

dumbass trelawny mission or cerberus mission

[long galleon]

oh ok

coyote seems much cooler

[astral juniper]

I will still not let charles think of arthur badly after his death

[normal relic]

It's an eagle

[astral juniper]

I will not be able to come to terms with that

[normal relic]

Me either

[astral juniper]

yeah that's what I was talkin about

[long galleon]

its just a game man

[normal relic]

I rode up to Sadies burned ranch

[long galleon]

so which

[astral juniper]

you are the reason that so many videos that play the song in this shirt exist

[long galleon]

low honor= better gameplay high honor= better story

[normal relic]

The eagle sitting on Arthur's grave

[long galleon]

whats wrong with that

[astral juniper]

nothing wrong with it

[normal relic]

I've always wanted to capture it

[astral juniper]

It sucks that you can't interact with those animals man

[normal relic]

Ik

[long galleon]

what a bad song

[astral juniper]

what

[normal relic]

I can't even kill a deer and an eagle because it makes me remember Arthur

[long galleon]

the in this shirt song

[astral juniper]

It's a bad song on it's own ngl

[long galleon]

yea

it is

[astral juniper]

but in the format of the videos it's used in, it's nice

[normal relic]

The deer reminds me of Arthur

I think it's buck in Arthur's visions

I liked high honor

High honor is better

[hidden moss]

sure it is, behaving like a gentleman, not a tough boy

huh?

[astral juniper]

Choices: High Honour save John

High Honour go for money

[long galleon]

High honor go for money is the best one

U still get ur eagle

[normal relic]

Yeah

[long galleon]

This is true

[idle granite]

i would have preferred to ditch the gang and run away w/ the woman after the theatre

the gang depends too much on me

[astral juniper]

bro without arthur the gang is just bat wings and one last score

[long galleon]

Going back

[astral juniper]

saving john truly suits his arc

[long galleon]

Low suits arthur but high and going back is best ending imo

[astral juniper]

as he bonds with John while he realises that Dutch isn't what he remembers

bro why ask about endings in chapter 2

that's a death sentence man

[long galleon]

He seems like wanting revenge so yea

Low honor suits arthur high honor suits john

[astral juniper]

it's a very long game for most people

speedrunning it definitely leaves a bad taste in your mouth

[long galleon]

Epilogue boring but yeah the chapters were good

What do yall think is the best chapter

[astral juniper]

once you finish all epilogue missions you will slowly crumple into nothingness as you lose your 73rd hand of poker

[long galleon]

Imo 3 or 4

[astral juniper]

chapter 2 or chapter 4 maybe

[long galleon]

Low honor file time

[long galleon]

Do going back for 2nd playthrough

[astral juniper]

I can't unfortunately

I'm playing and streaming to someone else and they specifically want me to play a high honour playthrough

third playthrough maybe

[long galleon]

Yes u can

Its still high honor

Lol i barely got high honor for the deer

Cause i rushed chapter 5 and 6

And had honor in middle

The whole game

Idk who it was that told me i would cry in the ending but i didnt like i said

[long galleon]

Idk if it was u

Someone with arthur pfp

And #1 arthur fan too

[hidden moss]

It wasn’t me but I know who you’re talking about

Can’t remember their name

[long galleon]

Yea yea

He was singing the song cruel world i must go on

[lost gale]

Is it just me or does anyone else expecting something go horribly wrong im the Saint Denis Theater shows?

[long galleon]

Never watched one

[idle granite]

i was expecting the lady to catch the curtains on fire

arthur had some very crass cheers

i was disappointed in him

then i remember he's killed roughly 2000 people

[empty lark]

john never says what his daughter's name was does he

[idle granite]

i kinda wish in RDR2 i had a choice about living somewhere else, like moving into a homestead i clear out, instead of it having the main quest storyline

[potent flare]

How messed up is the chapter 2 save Micah mission, in doing a good Arthur play though and heard that mission is a killing spree

[empty lark]

it wont affect your honor

[long mountain]

@empty lark rachel i thonk

Think

[empty lark]

that is a horse

in part 1 of the epilogue

[potent flare]

How messed up is it though

[empty lark]

it's just a shootout

[potent flare]

Ohhhh

[long mountain]

Yea i thought it was named after his daughtwr

[potent flare]

People said it’s the one thing they wish they didn’t do in the game

[empty lark]

because micah is a fucked up human being

anything that rockstar could give to him to make him a bad person, they did 💀

only thing good about him is how amazing of a shot he is with the shittiest guns in the game

[daring wadi]

Unpopular opinion: I think the low honour ending and saving John is the cannon ending. (Even though I played the game with high honour)

[empty lark]

fair

[limber sapphire]

Yeah same

[empty lark]

i think it's more of what would happen rather than what did personally

I find it hard to believe nobody whatsoever would go put flowers up at Arthur's grave

[limber sapphire]

I mean

Mary would imo

[empty lark]

I wonder how Linton found out about his grave, i didn't pay too much attention to the credits

someone probably told her and maybe it was Charles or John but I'm not sure

[limber sapphire]

Yeah definitely Charles did

[lost gale]

Lol, the most recent dumb thing I like to do is pissing off strangers or bandits while on my horse, catching them with my lasso and drag them around. Sometimes into a pond, sometimes until they expire or sometimes icjust let them loose again.
Or climbing up a building that's low enough for a lasso to still reach people, catch them by lasso, pull them up and drop them🤣
I know, I'm a silly goose

What's your recent silly thing?

[idle granite]

i discovered that in chapter 3, in rhodes, you can kill an infinite number of townfolk by running them over with your horse and never get a wanted level

so thats fun

im only in chapter 4 now. chapter 3 camp location is my favorite so far

i hate having to go inside the house in 4

i hate not being able to run

[glad flint]

GUYS

my girlfriend wants to name our child micah

[idle granite]

Is there anywhere that gangs respawn where i can go on a murder spree?

[idle granite]

I've cleared it out already. Does it respawn?

[hidden moss]

Some idiot on YouTube is trying to argue and say that Undead Nightmare is canon.

[onyx pebble]

Dutch plan der linde

[astral leaf]

Dump her she's not worth it man the kids gonna kill a whole town to get 2 guns

[limber sapphire]

test

Yes

got the role

[hidden moss]

Goggity

[woven sail]

robbed a man and then kidnapped his wife

[edgy bone]

Verification failed, is their a way to fix it?

[long galleon]

Am i the only one who likes micahs gun

[limber sapphire]

No

I like it too

but the stats are eh

[visual drum]

quick drawing without dead eye is so much fun

2nd best rockstar feature after torture

[hidden moss]

Double action revolvers are trash

[astral leaf]

They look cool though

[visual drum]

who cares about benefits of guns

[astral leaf]

But then again so does every revolver

[visual drum]

cosmetics >

[astral leaf]

Fr

[visual drum]

“umm that gun looks cool but does bad damage so it sucks” - 🤡

[hidden moss]

Who hurt you?

[long galleon]

I know that but it looks good

[hidden moss]

His gun looks cool but I’m not going to use it

[long galleon]

Im gonna steal it

[hidden moss]

I like Lemats, Volcanics, and Schofields

[long galleon]

Schofields suck

Or i dont like em

[hidden moss]

Dual weild lemats are overkill

[long galleon]

Dual wield semi auto pistols 🥰

[hidden moss]

I think the volcanic is overall the best. Accurate and good damage

[long galleon]

U got aim assist so dont talk about accuracy

[hidden moss]

No. I hate those guns, I hate the Mauser, and the high powered pistol (what it was called in RDR 1)

[long galleon]

M1899?

Smg

[hidden moss]

Headshots.

[long galleon]

Maybe that

[astral leaf]

Minigun speed

[hidden moss]

Yeah. Keep that shit out of my cowboy game

[astral leaf]

Fr

[long galleon]

Fr

[astral leaf]

Like a modern looking pistol don't have no place in a wild west gamr

[long galleon]

Otis miller revolver u must like that then

[astral leaf]

It ain't even a real pistol I googled it

[long galleon]

And the calloway

[hidden moss]

I haven’t used them

I like my guns to match

[long galleon]

They are schofields

[astral leaf]

I like schofelds

[hidden moss]

I wish Micah dropped both revolvers instead of one. I actually would be using his guns but because he dropped one I’m not.

[long galleon]

I dual wield 2 cattlemans the flacos and the normal one

[hidden moss]

I want both guns to be the same gun with the same design

[long galleon]

Boring

I do it myself too

[long galleon]

Can u get it twice like get him disarmed in 2 different missions

[hidden moss]

I think so, but I’ve never tried it

[long galleon]

I might try 2 lemats

[astral leaf]

I never duel wield I think it looks cooler with 1 gun

[long galleon]

Maybe

I like 2 tho

Cattlemans too fast

[hidden moss]

That guy called me a clown because I said double action revolvers are trash

Probably a 12 year old. No grown ass man gets that butthurt over an opinion

[astral leaf]

Chill bro I'm sure he was joking

[hidden moss]

Oh I’m good.

[astral juniper]

I personally like double actions when I want to take pictures in the game

[hidden moss]

I’m not the one that’s angry

[astral juniper]

Especially Micah's

[hidden moss]

Micahs revolver is cool but the problem is he only drops one

[bitter leaf]

I wish we could dual wield

[empty lark]

fucking hell i just collected each goddamn treasure of the landmarks of riches maps and the game has me stuck on the goddamn stagecoach menu, cant select where to go or anything else

[bitter leaf]

I also wish we got one of Dutch’s revolvers

[hidden moss]

RDR 1 is backwards. In that game double actions are good. And the best horses are ass in RDR 2

[astral juniper]

dear god

did you save?

[empty lark]

no, i didn't think i'd have to but this game shows me a new problem every day

[hidden moss]

When I first played RDR 2 I figured the Kentucky saddlers, Hungarian half Breds, and the American standards would be the best horses only to find out their mid af

[astral juniper]

I started saving after my game crashed a couple times because mods

[bitter leaf]

I just wanted a brave horse that was fast and wasnt a pussy-

[hidden moss]

Sometimes when I press pause it takes 10 seconds to pull up the menu

[astral juniper]

I mean, you mainly pick horses on the spectrum of health and stamina

[hidden moss]

@empty lark How did you get your roles?

[empty lark]

yeah but unfortunately this isn't modding this is just the shit that rockstar didn't fix before abandoning the game

[hidden moss]

Like best in the west and it’s art

[empty lark]

read #roles

[astral juniper]

the thing about how they get scared doesn't make sense to me because the less scared they get the closer wild animals will be able to get thus when you actually do get bucked off you get mauled or bitten

[empty lark]

the user is modmail if you just see a bunch of numbers in place of what should be a name

fuck i cant even open the damn menu to load up my john marston save

[bitter leaf]

I just want a good war horse thats tanky as fuck and somewhat fast and is nowhere near a bitch about combat, idk which horse though

[astral juniper]

I just use the raven black shire because I just like how it looks man

[hidden moss]

The user I’m supposed to DM is just a bunch of numbers

[empty lark]

read

[astral juniper]

Try a shire they're quite tanky normally but not insanely fast, still fast enough

[empty lark]

please

[hidden moss]

I clicked on their name and nothing happened

[empty lark]

i said something about that

[astral juniper]

bro

[empty lark]

read

[hidden moss]

I did fucking read

[astral juniper]

.

read the message I replied to my guy

[empty lark]

no you fucking didn't read, not everything

[bitter leaf]

Do they buck you in combat?

[hidden moss]

Oh I thought you meant in there

[empty lark]

god fuck this im gonna play rdr1

[astral juniper]

Not too sure, I prefer combat without horses tbh

[hidden moss]

Don’t play online

You will get iso modders

[astral juniper]

Wait I remember there being a channel which gave a great overview of rdr2 horses

let me just

[empty lark]

made so much damn progress without saving because i was actually confident that the game wasn't gonna be a bitch with an unfixed bug right as soon as i got my $3000

[empty lark]

didn't even have the camp fast travel for that either so i had to keep riding back and forth between some spots, on top of random encounters

[idle granite]

i quite often regret not saving often

im almost in the habit of saving every time something notable happens

find a perfect pelt? save

[empty lark]

i thought i had seen every bug in the story mode but i guess i was wrong

[astral juniper]

@bitter leaf try going to a channel named danielecasts, they give quite good but short overviews of most horse breeds

[hidden moss]

Dude I’m not relogging in on browser for a dumbass role. Idgaf

[empty lark]

least now i know i cant open the map while looking at the stagecoach ride selection, bullshit stuff but whatever ig, i'll just continue after another month passes

[bitter leaf]

Ok cool thank you

[astral juniper]

I didn't really encounter any bugs playing the game tho, but recently I've been getting one where lens switching in the camera causes my mouse to appear and thus breaks the game because I can't do any of the normal controls :/

[empty lark]

fucking jack isn't at his mission location in rdr1 so i gotta wait for his ass to get here

[astral juniper]

😭

[empty lark]

now he's here and he's reading a book under a tree but i gotta "come back later"

"how do you do sir" i wanna put a bullet through his head

[astral juniper]

please do

[empty lark]

i hope he can at least ride faster than he did the first time i rode with him

mf is 16 and still rides like he did at 12

[hidden moss]

How long does it take to get the roles? I sent the screenshots

[empty lark]

like one to three days

[hidden moss]

Okay

[empty lark]

took me maybe 2 or 3 for notorious, little less than one for my other two

[hidden moss]

It would be a lot easier if a mod did it.

I’m just trying to get best in the west, it’s art, and zoologist

[empty lark]

im pretty sure they do

[astral juniper]

The purpose of modmail is to mail the mods man

[empty lark]

but they're just not the most active

[astral juniper]

it's in the name

[empty lark]

still, could've been worse, at least i got this nice red before a whole day had passed

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

Once I 100% I’m going for gold rush and the 2 study and skin animals trophy

[empty lark]

oh thank god rufus is with us, i thought it was just gonna be john and jack's annoying ass

[hidden moss]

I’m just glad Abigail finally left the squirrel statue alone

[limber sapphire]

Then I’ll do a second playthrough where I do the misc trophies

[hidden moss]

No shit Sherlock

[limber sapphire]

And finish the rest of the rdo shit

[bitter leaf]

Which saddle offers the most benefit to speed stat? And also how do you get 3 yellow speed stats instead of 2

[astral juniper]

speed really doesn't matter

[limber sapphire]

In rdr2 story there isn’t a way to get 3 bars through saddles I’m pretty sure

[astral juniper]

it's like a 0.6 difference in each bar

[bitter leaf]

Damn

[hidden moss]

I’m not really noticing a speed difference between Buell and a MFT

[bitter leaf]

Is there a way through racing?

[astral juniper]

yeah

[limber sapphire]

Fr?

[hidden moss]

Nope.

[astral juniper]

2 or so races with the same person should increase your speed stat

[limber sapphire]

I feel that the MFT is way faster

[hidden moss]

5-7 speed doesn’t feel any different to me

[astral juniper]

I don't really notice the difference as well

[bitter leaf]

I mean the only difference I barely see is acceleration

[astral juniper]

I use to go straight for the white arabian because I wanted speed but now I just go for what I like

that channel that I mentioned also did a horse speed comparison

a relatively long route only saw a 20 second difference from 2 to 10 speed

[hidden moss]

I have the MFT in stabled. I’m using the Nokota from the ST Denis stables. It’s just as fast as the MFT

[bitter leaf]

There was only a 2 second difference

[astral juniper]

yeah the short route had only a 2 second difference

really surprising tbh

although the MFT has quite a nice coat so I might just get it for that ngl

[bitter leaf]

I don’t really care about speed, acceleration, or stamina, I just want an extremely chunky war horse and colossal health

[hidden moss]

I bet it’s too late to try and be a voice actor in RDR 3

It’s probably in development as we speak

[bitter leaf]

For some reason I never liked the MFTs, maybe I didn’t get the right image or I suck at listening

[hidden moss]

I don’t like the MFT coats

[astral juniper]

shire is the biggest horse in the game that's very tanky (like horse run in with no health loss tanky) unfortunately it's handling is heavy so it's a bit unresponsive to controls

[hidden moss]

That’s why I’m using the Nokota

Grey coat with black head

[bitter leaf]

If this was responsive I would be using it rn

[astral juniper]

I will probably always use the Raven Black Shire man

[bitter leaf]

I really wanna use the Ardennes but the hair on it’s legs are ugly..

[bitter leaf]

I sold mine sadly and I really wanna get it back on my main save

[astral juniper]

unfortunately it doesn't spawn anywhere else

[hidden moss]

If you guys get the Ardennes, specifically the one from the valentine stable. I think it comes with the special edition of the game. You have to name it Phill

[astral juniper]

the one that hosea gives you is the only one

[bitter leaf]

Is there a way to transfer it from a save without mods?

[astral juniper]

it has slightly increased health and stamina iirc

[bitter leaf]

I really want it

[astral juniper]

I don't think so

only way to get it would be to spawn it in via a trainer

or if you're crazy do some wacky stuff somehow with the horse spawn code

[bitter leaf]

Can you spawn it using cheats

[astral juniper]

I don't think so, lemme look at the cheat list

but keep in mind you can't save when a cheat is activated

[bitter leaf]

Ik

[astral juniper]

try the code "You want something new" for a while and maybe it'll spawn, the code will spawn a random horse every time

[bitter leaf]

I did it one time where I had a rose grey bay arabian and 15k in chapter 4

I saved with cheats somehow

[astral juniper]

cremello gold dutch warmblood might also be an option for you

or chocolate roan but it looks kinda bad imo

[bitter leaf]

I did do Buell, but whenever I was in the swamps he kept bucking me and he was super skittish

[astral juniper]

ah

[bitter leaf]

I am going to just use my gold turkoman, it’s not a pansy and wont buck you

Should I switch to the dark bay or silver though?

[empty lark]

i loved rufus at first in rdr1 but the whole "follow rufus" thing is getting boring goddamn

way slower than my horse but apparently nobody else knows where to go other than this dog

[astral juniper]

silver seems nice, you could also just go for an andalusian

[bitter leaf]

I suppose so, I mean I’d still like some acceleration and speed to win races, but other than that I mean

[astral juniper]

tbh

most races have the other person getting caught in some sort of way that gives you the advantage

that or you can always go off path and win

[bitter leaf]

Yeah

I am going to just stay with Butterscotch (my turkoman) and use it for my main horse

[shrewd meteor]

i got a question if u dont mind answering

do u need squirrel statue to 100% the game?

since u got 100% aswell as squirrel statue achieved

[limber sapphire]

Yes

[empty lark]

you need to do all the hunting requests and go see the woman

so yes

and it's a little fun thing to do anyways

[shrewd meteor]

oh

[empty lark]

one of the less than 5 reasons to actually keep going back to Beecher's Hope in rdr2

[shrewd meteor]

cuz im thinking to myself should i do squirrel statue or not

cuz i want to do squirrel but that would mean i have to redo it once again for 100%

[limber sapphire]

Wdym

[shrewd meteor]

i want to achieve 100%

aswell as squirrel

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

[shrewd meteor]

but i dont got 100% rn so i would have to do squirrel

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

[shrewd meteor]

but that would mean next time i do try to get 100% i would have to do squirrel once again

[empty lark]

so go get the squirrel then

[limber sapphire]

So do the squirrel stuff

[limber sapphire]

Yep

[shrewd meteor]

i got 83.3% and its the epilogue

[empty lark]

worst part is hunting the birds, but maybe you'll get through them, tiny shits

[shrewd meteor]

only if i did more side quests 😔

[limber sapphire]

I recommend going to the fort near van horn

[shrewd meteor]

it was my first run aswell

[empty lark]

every side quest that is required for 100% can be done in the epilogue

[limber sapphire]

Don’t start the hunting requests until you have the animals

[shrewd meteor]

oh

so misses downes?

[limber sapphire]

Go to new Austin and get the legendary pronghorn trinket

[empty lark]

no

[shrewd meteor]

cuz she's only for arthur

[empty lark]

she isn't required

[limber sapphire]

So you can put small animals on your horse

[shrewd meteor]

well maybe i can achieve 100% then

[empty lark]

yes

you can

[shrewd meteor]

should i try tho

[empty lark]

great question

[shrewd meteor]

cuz the challanges seem random aswell as difficult

[empty lark]

search up guides then

[shrewd meteor]

i need dedication but it would feel great since im close

[empty lark]

they're not that hard anyways

just annoying

really annoying

[shrewd meteor]

83.3% is quite close

do u need like

all trinkets

and shit

[empty lark]

no

there's a checklist of things you need

in game

[shrewd meteor]

do u need all equipment and animals

[limber sapphire]

I can help you out with challenges

[empty lark]

no

[shrewd meteor]

alright

[limber sapphire]

They’re easy but tedious

[empty lark]

look at the in game checklist and you can see everything you need if you have discovered it

[shrewd meteor]

cuz i got bandit challanges level 1🔥

[empty lark]

bandit is easy as hell

[shrewd meteor]

i just never bothered

cuz i went fully max honor

[limber sapphire]

Bandit is probably the easiest set of challenges behind explorer

[empty lark]

gambler isn't hard either, until gambler 8 and 9, which isn't as hard as it is annoying and long

[limber sapphire]

Yep

[shrewd meteor]

well i guess since i beat all the stories

[shrewd meteor]

what even are gambler 8 9

[limber sapphire]

Herbalist 9 also takes a while

[shrewd meteor]

some are just very specific

[empty lark]

if i said what they were you probably wouldn't understand until you did it

[limber sapphire]

Everything else you can probably do under 2 days

[shrewd meteor]

like shooting 3 birds while on a moving train

[empty lark]

that's easy

[shrewd meteor]

tell me either way

[empty lark]

alright give me a second to actually type it

[shrewd meteor]

aight

also so both of yall are on console?

[empty lark]

gambler 8 - hit 3 times in a row in blackjack and beat the dealer (3 times)
gambler 9 - win 3 consecutive games of dominoes

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

[shrewd meteor]

dominoes sound easy

[limber sapphire]

PTSD

[empty lark]

it's not

[limber sapphire]

It’s annoying

[shrewd meteor]

i shitted on tilly 3 times in a row once

on dominoes

[limber sapphire]

Really annoying

[empty lark]

the game itself isn't hard, the length of the game is

[shrewd meteor]

yeah

i heard some people say

[empty lark]

you also can't quit the game until you beat the challenge or else your progress resets

[shrewd meteor]

they dont even know how to play dominoes

[shrewd meteor]

dang

brb

[limber sapphire]

I did that once

And I cried

[idle granite]

if i cancel a mission can i restart it later?

[empty lark]

yes

[idle granite]

dutch started talking to me but i dont want to do this mission

so i killed his horse w/ a molotov

[shrewd meteor]

honestly

what i regret is overwriting my save

[empty lark]

im still fucking pissed about that glitch after i got my $3000 from the maps

[shrewd meteor]

that had arthur alive

last mission

[limber sapphire]

I forgot I have rdr on my Xbox

I haven’t played it yet

[empty lark]

i cant stand doing more missions with Jack's annoying ass but I'm too pissed off to play rdr2 again

[limber sapphire]

I’ll do it over summer

[limber sapphire]

What happened

[shrewd meteor]

I want to redo rdr2

But i fell to lazy for that

[empty lark]

I got my $3000 from the treasure map, tried to use a stagecoach to go to valentine since it was the closest place to camp, i opened my map to make sure it was the closest, and when i closed the map i couldn't exit the stagecoach's location selection screen nor could i actually purchase a ride to valentine or any other place

[limber sapphire]

dammmmnnn

[empty lark]

I almost never use stagecoaches, never had that happen till today and I didn't save after doing the entire map set

[limber sapphire]

Fuckk

That sucks

[empty lark]

i dont even think i saved after that stupid ass hunting mission with hosea

[limber sapphire]

I save every 3 minutes

[empty lark]

so i gotta go on another slow ride with him, i love hosea but that mission is fucking long

[limber sapphire]

Damn

[empty lark]

gotta do it if i wanna be able to use stables or saddle another horse though

[limber sapphire]

As soon as I get a horse I’m glitching the MFT

It’s way easier than I thought

[shrewd meteor]

Hosea is amazing simply

i loved his moonshine mission

i dont see many people liking that mission but its one of my favorites

[violet turtle]

help

why isn't there a post office in valentine?

there's one before

[astral juniper]

is the icon missing?

or is it just locked

keep in mind that the post office isn't inside the town it's along the tracks

[violet turtle]

icon is missing

[astral juniper]

try restarting the game

[torpid mauve]

it started fogging everywhere and rdo crashed

[violet turtle]

okay

[astral juniper]

if that doesn't work, you may need to uninstall and reinstall

or try starting a new save

[supple hare]

I haven't gone to Valentine as John at all

[astral juniper]

I go there sometimes to shoot up the place

[supple hare]

I avoid getting bounties as John

except in Saint Denis

I hate Saint Denis

[violet turtle]

doesn't work

[astral juniper]

you uninstalled and reinstalled that fast?

but okay if the install doesn't work verify the integrity of your game files

go to properties, game files (I think) and select the verify integrity option

sorry local files*

[supple hare]

he has a Playstation I think

[astral juniper]

ah

My brain did not see the icon 😭

if uninstalling doesn't work I'm not really sure what else you can do man

if a new save also doesn't work maybe contact rockstar support or somethin

[supple hare]

I'm gonna go to Red Dead Redemption Tombstone

[violet turtle]

yeah

[violet turtle]

alright

[supple hare]

I miss Hosea

[shrewd meteor]

yeah same

he was a nice gang member

[tight notch]

could somebody assist and help me delete whyems dlc mod

[astral juniper]

removing the lml folder that you put in in should do the trick

[tight notch]

the thing is i dont if i should get it

i have a 1650 but im pretty sure it wont be able to hold the game more then 20 fps

[astral juniper]

change your graphic settings a bit and it should work

sacrifice a bit of quality for a smooth gaming experience

the game still looks very nice on high or a little bit low

[tight notch]

yeah true but every time i get in the game even tho i dont have any tabs opened or apps i still get the warning message that this game is running low

while i still play with the lowest settings in the nvidia geforce

[astral juniper]

do you edit settings in the game or a separate app like the geforce experience?

if you want, download a settings/system.xml from a trusted source and use that

[tight notch]

no no look like this

let me send you a vid rq

ah shit

cant send it here

fuck it it wont work

it is what it is i wont get it screw it

[astral juniper]

try #red-dead-media man

the channel specifically for rdr videos and images

[tight notch]

there send it

[muted yew]

Note to self: Don't go to the swamp at night 💀

[long galleon]

go

its actually fun

[muted yew]

I got fucking stabbed to death by a bunch of swamp hillbillies (?)

[long galleon]

nightfolk

[astral juniper]

nightfolk are basically the bois lookin for beans at 2am

it just so happens you have beans on you

[sick elm]

Hello everyone, how and where can I get a forlev bay Arab horse in ddr 2?

[sick elm]

Hello everyone, how and where can I get a forlev bay Arab horse in ddr 2?

[muted yew]

Had 2 Murfrees showing up when I set my camp on their territory lol. Fuckers gave me a warning. I gave them 2 bullets in the head

[opaque panther]

good job 🙂

[violet turtle]

damn brother

you motherboard still has a ddr2 slot?

[idle granite]

I found a cave hideout of theirs and murdered the lot

[astral juniper]

where's the hideout you massacred?

is it like beaver's hollow or?

[idle granite]

I don't remember, but there were like 30 of them. Actually i don't remember if it was them. I think it was. It was this big cave you could access from the ground level or from top of a big hill

[astral juniper]

was there a wagon and stuff inside?

[empty lark]

pretty sure they only have that one hideout and it's the beaver hollow cave

[astral juniper]

or somethin like that?

yeah it sounds like that

bro is sequence breaking rdr2 💀

[hidden moss]

GUYS

[slim steeple]

Finally got minimum honour

[hidden moss]

How to explore a good portion of the map in 2 easy steps:
Get on a train
Profit

[slim steeple]

Yes

[opaque panther]

Hello friends, can I ask you a question, I have completed all the challenges, but the legend of the east outfit has not been added to my wardrobe. Damn I tried so hard for this.

[slim steeple]

Just so you know, you sent the same message twice

[opaque panther]

I know but I don t saw the answer

Now please can anybody answer me

[iron ocean]

do you need to handout some pelts for it or not ?

this outfit looks like the Canadian horse police, I didn't go for it

[opaque panther]

Anybody knows this problem?

[normal relic]

[normal relic]

Cool I can't even get John's honor back up

[slim steeple]

Oof

[normal relic]

I did alot of killing lol

I was bored and decided to start fighting strangers

and robbing

[idle granite]

you should be able to loot corpses you find w/o losing honor

im just checking their pockets for identification to notify loved ones

and if i should happen to find a gold watch, why i consider that payment for services rendered

[empty lark]

some corpses that even if you find you lose honor for them but it usually makes sense as to which ones they'll be

[iron ocean]

no you lose honor for looting civilians, even those you didn't kill: e.g. when you find the 2 murphy robbing the couple the killed, if you loot the dead bodies, you lose honor

[empty lark]

like when you see two Murfrees that just killed a couple of people camping out in the wild

[idle granite]

also, if im walking around, and someone starts shooting me because i got too close to their camp, and then i loot them, i shouldnt get dishonor

[iron ocean]

but you do

although you don't for killing them, when they shot first

[idle granite]

ya thats the part thats weird to me

[empty lark]

maybe dont invade their space

[iron ocean]

It kinda makes sense, either legitimate defense, or legitimate defense with a twist 😄

[empty lark]

they give you one warning and you can defuse to make them wait a bit longer before getting more aggressive

[idle granite]

does lassoing someone and dumping them in water lose you honor?

[empty lark]

yeah if they drown im sure it does

[iron ocean]

if you shoot some guy on your lawn, you probably can tell the judge: hey your honor, the crackhead was coming at me, I had no choice. But if they find his gold watch and belt buckle in your pockets, Judge may not hear it the same way

[idle granite]

ya but its not their lawn, its open space. i cant go to the park, and if someone sets up a blanket close to me, start shooting em

[empty lark]

their camp is their "lawn"

[idle granite]

this fictional game makes no sense

[iron ocean]

this is why if this happens, you shoot the guy BACK, and don't lose honor

[idle granite]

ok thats fair

but if i then go take his wallet

[empty lark]

then that's not just self defense

[iron ocean]

but if you shoot him back, then empty his pockets, it means you defended yourself, but you're also kind of a douche, you gotta accept that

I'm fine with this, I never leave a pocket full

but I agree to lose my honor cuz I'm a rotten snake

remember Arthur saying you can't live a bad life and expect good things

well, there you go

being a douche in this game don't bother me none

[idle granite]

i think its funny i can shoot a bunch of cops in the face and not lose honor during a mission

[iron ocean]

yeah missions overwrite tons of stuff

[idle granite]

i wish there weree more camps of bad guys i can go wipe out

its my favorite thing lately

[iron ocean]

there's kind of a lot

and even moar if you include the Van Horn freebie

[idle granite]

ive cleared out every one i can find so far up to chapter 4

not in van horn yet tho

[iron ocean]

in Van horn there is no law, boi

you can kill everyone

same in Butcher Creek

[idle granite]

that sounds fun

[iron ocean]

wish I didn't brun the whole village though, I lost the ugly banjo playing elephant man

[empty lark]

i was kinda surprised to see that Butcher Creek had guns, not sure why but i just didn't expect them to have any

[iron ocean]

can't find him anymore

[empty lark]

or they at least had a lot more guns than i was expecting out of them

[iron ocean]

those inbred animals are really loaded

[idle granite]

art imitates life

[iron ocean]

and the other way around is also true

at least, sometimes, in the eyes of the beholder

and now that you know this, that either or imitates the other one, you swill enter a vortex that will suck you in with the universe

[empty lark]

although i think it might've been more terrifying if Butcher Creek just had a ton of bows or melees

[visual drum]

fr

[opaque panther]

Please Can anybody answer my question

[limber sapphire]

You sure?

Hm

That’s a weird bug

[opaque panther]

Yes bro I m sure

[limber sapphire]

Ask support I guess

[opaque panther]

Indeed

[opaque panther]

Where is ?

[limber sapphire]

#rdr2-online-support

or go to rockstar

[opaque panther]

ok thanks

[normal relic]

[opaque panther]

or should I also complete the story?

[iron ocean]

no peeps have been able to unlock the LOTE outfit before

but you sure you got the herbalist 10 too ?

kinda hard, if not impossible almost, before epilogue

[opaque panther]

bro I m sure

[iron ocean]

how did you go to NA to pick up them feverfew and other plants?

[opaque panther]

In epilogue

[normal relic]

I think herbalist 10 is impossible to do before entering epilogue

[iron ocean]

if you're in epilogue then you finished the story

some peeps do it with the damn buggy trick but it's really not easy

[opaque panther]

no I first finished challanges but not finished the story

[iron ocean]

cuz afaik I went there during the angelo bronte mission, but no flower spawned

[normal relic]

You didn't complete story yet

[iron ocean]

hey you can equip Arther with the LOTE, so this is not something you MUST be in the epilogue to unlock, that is if youc an do the herbalist 10

[normal relic]

I never tried

[opaque panther]

Should I finish story too?

[iron ocean]

Horseman 9 and 10 doable as arthur, 9 is okish, 10 can be a challenge to get the hungarian accross the river

[normal relic]

Yeah

[opaque panther]

You sure?

[iron ocean]

the only way I could do horseman 10 was to bring the strawberry law with me into blackwater

[normal relic]

Horseman 10 you gotta find alternate routes

[iron ocean]

the pinkertons on your ass trying to tame a horse, I could never get it done

I brught the law with me, so pinkertons didn't spawn, and wiped them all but 1 lame idiot, then I could do it

[normal relic]

I'm on horseman 2 or 3 I gotta ride from Valentine to Rhodes

[iron ocean]

I kept the horse, still have it 😄

after 7days looking for a hungarian in the main map, no luck, I had to find a way

[normal relic]

Might complete Horseman challenge

[opaque panther]

Bro should i finish the story too?

[iron ocean]

it was a ton of fun

[normal relic]

Yeah

You should

[iron ocean]

check YT, on how to get LOTE with arthur

[normal relic]

Is horseman pretty easy to complete

[iron ocean]

there have to be half a million vids

horseman is super easy except for part 10, when you want to do it as arthur

as john it's a cakewalk

[normal relic]

I wonder if riding on the railroad tracks woukd help with riding from Valentine to Rhodes

[summer sundial]

it does

[iron ocean]

Valentine to Rhodes ?

[normal relic]

I think it's like 15 minutes or something

Yeah

[iron ocean]

I remembered it as strawberry to rhodes

[normal relic]

That's the one I'm on

Strawberry

Not Valentine

[opaque panther]

Thanks I finally found this info I owe you 🙂

[normal relic]

So i could easy take the tracks once I reach fort riggs

[iron ocean]

I did so I could cross the river

big parts on the tracks, but then on land

[normal relic]

you're welcome

[iron ocean]

horseman were my fav challenges

[normal relic]

I'll probably just complete that challenge

[summer sundial]

have u done gambler challenges yet

[opaque panther]

My favorite were Sharpshooter

[normal relic]

I don't even want to touch gambler

[summer sundial]

why not its so much fun

[normal relic]

I haven't done any of them

It's annoying

I can't play dominoes

I'm still on gambler 1

[iron ocean]

I haven't tried gambler at all, to me it seems the hardest of them all

[normal relic]

It is

[iron ocean]

ohhhh bandit is something, yes 😄