ye
#red-dead-singleplayer
hybrid tree
dull geyser
Atleast that's how revolver portrayed red
hybrid tree
He'd been like clint eastwood on crack
dull geyser
He didn't just slowed time but freezed it
empty lark
Mr. Nigel West Dickens was selling a cure for everything, including Lumbago, in rdr1
totally was a cure and not some random drink
dull geyser
so I can play rdr1 and
I tried finding some back then and no joy
dull geyser
Mr. Nigel West Dickens was selling a cure for everything, including Lumbago, in ...
Gotta keep him nerfed somehow
But I think prime landon ricketts is probably on par with red harlow
empty lark
I cant wait to see what my 2nd mission with Ricketts is gonna be like in rdr1
lone cairn
I have a bit of an issue, in my stable I have Buel, my white Arabian which I am very attached to so can't sell,my red Arabian same story and my rose bay but I need 2 more slots
empty lark
sell red and grey, grey probably has the ugliest coat of them all and besides, the white arabian performs nearly the same to it anyways
dull geyser
Yesss
empty lark
get to lvl4 bond with grey arabian to sell it for the most money you can with the stables
dull geyser
I have a bit of an issue, in my stable I have Buel, my white Arabian which I am ...
Use the horse you're very attached to
Just saying
lone cairn
Train has joined the battle
lone cairn
get to lvl4 bond with grey arabian to sell it for the most money you can with th...
I have no need for money
upper sinew
alright i have another, another question, how do i fill out the rdr2 story mode map, is it just exploring every inch?
empty lark
yes
lone cairn
I have nearing 40000
dull geyser
Train has joined the battle
The train remains undefeated
dull geyser
I have no need for money
But you're gonna need some slots sometime in the future
hybrid tree
to have the best rdr2 experience you should turn off all gui exept the gps
and all missions money you get you take in camp
donate
lone cairn
Yeah I would like the mft
lone cairn
Other gap for my favourite coat of Arabian
lone cairn
what's yalls?
Hungarian half-breed from Valentine
My reason is because I had one as athur
dull geyser
Hungarian half-breed from Valentine
Also a very great pick
I like war horses because I go on hunting a lot
Sheesh but he's doing well on the other side now atleast
lone cairn
I do like the warped Arabian tho
dull geyser
I do like the warped Arabian tho
Yea it has a very cool look
Dark bay andalusian one of my favs
dull geyser
Any way gtg now cya
Aight aight peace out
ember marsh
Is the map bigger than gtav? I've heard it is and isn't. Obviously it feels much larger and is much more detailed but is it actually?
long mountain
@ember marsh ive played both and the map in red dead seems way bigger to me but i have no real evidence lol
fluid brook
fleet gull
“Self-Defense”
marble fern
guys i collected all 144 cigarette cards but i could only send 4 sets and i cant send the rest of them can someone help me pls its very frustrating
fiery turtle
Is the map bigger than gtav? I've heard it is and isn't. Obviously it feels much...
Played both games for many hours rdr2 feels much bigger and a lot more detailed
iron ocean
No glitch, just run from tall Trees like the wind, take plenty of tonics and cut thru the woods, then thru the plains super fast, and you can even exit alive by the river
empty lark
oh so it's just a bit unnecessary
iron ocean
guys i collected all 144 cigarette cards but i could only send 4 sets and i cant...
DO you have a lot of duplicates maybe?
empty lark
fair enough
iron ocean
not un-necessary, I glitched Arther after epilogue and can only play with him 😄
marble fern
DO you have a lot of duplicates maybe?
i figured it out
turns out...
i didnt have enough
i finished the compendium thing but
didnt have all of it in my inventory
empty lark
i think it's a bit unnecessary when i'd say a fair amount of people didn't "glitch arthur" after the epilogue and just did it as john when they had the chance
iron ocean
I had no other option
same as with most other challenges, I only have arthur left
by incident I deleted the epilogue 2 last save with John, so it's over
now I hgave to learn how to maneuver a stupid buggy cart to get the last fish
hidden moss
I have the Tiger Striped Mustang in the stable
long mountain
Hunt
visual drum
Neither. Commit war crimes are Arthur instead.
visual drum
why
wdym
i didn’t have a single high honor ending in my 3 playthroughs
low honor >
hidden moss
high honour fits arthur more
idle granite
how high of honor do you need to have to have the high honor ending?
normal relic
High honor is better
hidden moss
how high of honor do you need to have to have the high honor ending?
if u press alt your honour should be more on the right then left
normal relic
Ye
hidden moss
this is for high honour
visual drum
have freedom
normal relic
White is high red is low
visual drum
do anything you want
normal relic
What chapter are you on
idle granite
i liked chapter 2, i am just now in chapter 3. i like the chapter 3 camp location better in terms of setting right on the water
visual drum
is a high honor play through worth it?
normal relic
You got enough time to raise your honor
Yeah
I got high honor on my first time playing story
idle granite
im doing high honor, not robbing folks and stuff. but i feel like the game might be more fun to be a ruthless outlaw
visual drum
it makes me feel good to commit war crimes such as torture, massacring, destruction, and kidnapping too
normal relic
I plan to do high honor again if I start a second playthrough
Yep
Epilogue honor doesn't do anything
So you could basically can go shoot up blackwater
normal relic
I'm not even doing low honor
More sad seeing Arthur getting shot then him dying naturally
Everyone here spoils the game
hidden moss
Everyone here spoils the game
it shouldve won goty bur god of war was also a very good game (i beat both)
normal relic
it shouldve won goty bur god of war was also a very good game (i beat both)
Ik I wish rdr2 got it
upper sinew
Are you trying to save the pelt or just kill it
Cause saving the pelt would need lowest damage and in the head i think
empty lark
rolling block/bolt action to the head of any medium to large sized animal
nimble dew
Dutch really got the nerve to lecture me for not putting money in the box when Arthur is the only one who puts anything of value in there 
vague nymph
rolling block/bolt action to the head of any medium to large sized animal
But with the lower damage bullets?
woven sail
it makes me feel good to commit war crimes such as torture, massacring, destruct...
Relatable
idle granite
ya this is what I get for starting a game like 5 years after release. thats okay, even knowing components of the end, the game is less about the story to me and more about the gameplay
i am a little bit disappointed i basically have the top tier horse of the game already in the black arabian
also a little bit disappointed that for all the effort that goes into catching horses, they are worth jack shit to sell
yet cost so much to buy
eager pasture
rachel best horse
vague nymph
i am a little bit disappointed i basically have the top tier horse of the game a...
The Rose Bay Arabian is actually the best stats, but which horse is actually best is objective
I really like MFTs and Mustangs
idle granite
ya i was thinking about going and wrangling a mustang
vague nymph
They're pretty rare spawns before epilogue, but they can pop up in story area if you hang around down by the border
idle granite
i saw one in chapter 2 somewhere, didnt nab it because my stable is full
kinda regret it
long mountain
@hidden moss high honor arthur just feels right. Wwhad. What would honorable arthur do
empty lark
Hard to believe micah would just let arthur die without doing something to him, like he does in the low honor endings
dapper forge
low honor endings are nice
Wrd love playing low honor
hidden moss
That first time when i saw the ending i didnt know what to do with myself
empty lark
no you're still wanted dead or alive
and the way the game sees it, might as well be dead 
cloud sand
BRO WTF
i was doing the mission after u get home from guarma and i was on the maxim gun and my game just closed out
why
idle granite
no you're still wanted dead or alive
i was trying to go over by armadillo, but i couldnt find anywhere to pass over the mountain range
dont like that in an open world game
visual drum
dont like that in an open world game
wait till epilogue
upper sinew
There’s probably a thousand peopl here that havent
idle granite
lol
upper sinew
Especially when you can lasso people and hogtie them and throw them in a river
And if you find del lobos or skinner brothers or something, you can do it and not lose honour but itll be more difficult
hidden moss
yes
usually in middle of forests
or just in the middle of nowhere in general
did you beat the game yet?
oh
which chapter
hunt
does honor matter to you
oh
then just kidnap people in forests and if someone sees you kidnap them as well
then murder them brutally
fun and makes you rich
but i think just doing missions is more efficient
the incest family?
oh yeah
i dont think you can rob them
they just rob you and you can take your money back and maybe get a few cents from looting them
idle granite
i came across a klan rally
i threw a stick of dynamite into it and picked off the survivors
very satisfying
manic aurora
Does anybody know a good spot to hunt perfect black bears
idle granite
Does anybody know a good spot to hunt perfect black bears
i found several west/northwest of strawberry, along the border to new austin. also found a cabin w/ a grizzly bear inside that just about ate my face off
manic aurora
i found several west/northwest of strawberry, along the border to new austin. al...
Thank you
idle granite
Thank you
over by the Trapper icon west of strawberry here
wont let me post a link
directly west of where the map label says BIG VALLEY
good luck
lone cairn
Treasure hunter?
hidden moss
Deos anyone here know about the hidden gold bar you can find as soon as you begin chapter 2 in the sheriffs office of a old burnt down town near horseshoe overlook
radiant girder
yeah
radiant girder
can you report the Rhodes gunsmith to the sheriff's office?
after yknow, kidnapping
dark lintel
Bro i just killed the undead in saint Denis
hidden moss
Have you guys every played LA Noire? I’m going to be playing it soon for the first time. I know literally nothing about it. I know nothing about the story. I’ve Seen maybe 1 minute of gameplay.
hidden moss
Bro i just killed the undead in saint Denis
“I will suck you dry”
-St. Denis vampire 1899
serene cedar
Wish there was nice looking satchels. I got The Gambler outfit, all of the reinforced Gambler equipment from the trapper, and 2 fully gold, ornamental engraved cattlemen revolvers with hero pearl grips. And then I'm forced to wear a dirty brown sack on my hip...
The valuables satchel is probably the best looking, but it's still pretty hideous
hidden moss
With knifes
Night Folk? Are you in Saint Denis or the swamps?
hidden moss
Wish there was nice looking satchels. I got The Gambler outfit, all of the reinf...
Legend of the East
Holy shit, I’m a Cowboy now
serene cedar
Legend of the East
Still looks too uncivilized. Still looks like a survivalist. I'm covered in pristine leather, hair pomade, pearl and engraved gold... having some hillbilly sack looks off.
weak swallow
can someone help me
hidden moss
I’ve never understood why people dress fancy or wear top hats in this game. Arthur wouldn’t be caught dead wearing that stuff. But that’s just how I feel lol.
weak swallow
I'm doing the iniquities of history or wtv it's called and there is no watch in the house
weak swallow
clean but not fancy is best imo
dark lintel
Night Folk? Are you in Saint Denis or the swamps?
:Swamp
dark lintel
Oohhh
serene cedar
I’ve never understood why people dress fancy or wear top hats in this game. Arth...
True, I still look pretty bad ass tho. I mean, I always carry 4 guns, even in Saint Denis. They may be gold, but 2 rifles and 2 revolvers still looks pretty intimidating
hidden moss
I mean dressing like that in Saint Denis is understandable
weak swallow
I mostly stick to the default arthur fit
but I've got one of the bands with bullets that go over and I use a different overcoat
hidden moss
But I wouldn’t want to be dressed in a suit with a top hat when I’m hunting grizzly bears or killing gang members lol
weak swallow
killing kkk members is the most fun
serene cedar
But I wouldn’t want to be dressed in a suit with a top hat when I’m hunting griz...
Lol, fair. I think the Gambler still looks pretty cool tho. It ain't like a full on suit with a tie and top hat. Just like a southern gentleman with 4 gold guns and a level 10 beard
weak swallow
when you guys hunt do you always check the quality of the animal before you go for it
serene cedar
Yes
serene cedar
Unless I just need meat or feathers
weak swallow
I usually forget and end up killing shitty animals looking for money
hidden moss
The only animal left for me to find and kill is the parakeet
weak swallow
I don't put too much focus on hunting
unless I like run into legendary territory on accident
I just accidentally robbed someone
I meant to dismount my horse but forgot I was focused on him and the dismount and rob buttons are both e for me
serene cedar
I can't believe you lose honor for beating up that asshole in the Valentine saloon that calls everyone women and says he once fought 50 "injuns".
I feel like the town should praise me as a hero for shutting him up. Hell, not even just beating him up. You should GAIN honor for full on killing him 🤷♂️
weak swallow
I hate having to worry about my honor when killing or robbing shitty people
hidden moss
“Hey Bill, ever anyone tell you you’re a moron?”
“I’m a what?!”
“Sorry, I..I’ll use shorter words. Anyone ever tell you just how dumb you are?”
Arthur has entered the chat
“Why don’t you go make us some money, or get us some food if you’re so full of energy”
“Whatever you say boss”
“Do something useful, both of ya!”
serene cedar
I hate it when arthur insults or mocks people when I hit greet
Fr.
Greet: it's Arthur, you dumbass
weak swallow
cause then I have to kill them and lose honor
my honor is just above half rn because I always end up accidentally dropping it
hidden moss
I saw one camp interaction where Micah was sucking up to Dutch and he awkwardly told Dutch he was amazing. Then Arthur was like “what the hell is up with him” then he called him a slimy boot licker
hidden moss
Fr.
Greet: it's Arthur, you dumbass
Except when it’s Bill
Idk why Dutch always acted like Evelyn Miller was a God. Dude was a weirdo when I did that mission with John
hidden moss
Fr.
Greet: it's Arthur, you dumbass
“Well well, roll out the red carpet”
vestal plover
Anyone know why comment keeps getting deleted
radiant girder
no
empty lark
if you're using spoiler tags that may be why
or too many capital letters
or if it's a link to somewhere, post it in the media channels
hidden moss
What do u guys think of the double action revolver
vestal plover
if you're using spoiler tags that may be why
Oh ya im using spoiler tags but thats the reasion im using the tags, i dont want to spoil to anyone that hasnt finished playthrough
empty lark
What do u guys think of the double action revolver
ass gun
empty lark
Oh ya im using spoiler tags but thats the reasion im using the tags, i dont want...
Rules says it doesn't matter as long as you're not ruining someone else's experience
hidden moss
True
vestal plover
Rules says it doesn't matter as long as you're not ruining someone else's experi...
Ah, it kinda ruins experience to someone who hasnt played ig but thats why i want to put the tags
empty lark
pistols have higher accuracy, faster fire rate and more bullets to shoot, and deal barely less damage
empty lark
Ah, it kinda ruins experience to someone who hasnt played ig but thats why i wan...
Well if nobody here is saying to not spoil the game then it doesn't matter, is what the rule means
hidden moss
pistols have higher accuracy, faster fire rate and more bullets to shoot, and de...
The volcanic pistol tho
Is phenomenal
empty lark
Volcanic pistol being a better revolver than the double action revolver
empty lark
Yeah
It's balanced sort of like the Schofield
Except a bit less damage and a bit more fire rate
empty lark
There is no gun worse than the double action revolvers
Not even the Litchfield repeater
which at least has higher damage
hidden moss
The Litchfield is an interesting gun
empty lark
still doesn't make up for its glaring lack of accuracy either but it has something at least
hidden moss
The only thing the double action has going for it is the fire rate
empty lark
Fire rate ain't worth shit if you cant hit anything
hidden moss
Sometimes I like to use both the DA with the semi auto pistol
Which is a decent combo
Usually tho I run the Schofield with the volcanic
Or the cattleman
empty lark
I usually run two of the same gun type
empty lark
something feels awfully wrong to me about using a pistol and a revolver which have different ammo capacities
hidden moss
I never really thought about it
empty lark
one is probably gonna run out more than a couple of shots before the other and it dont seem right
empty lark
Still doesn't hold an equal amount to any of the pistols
hidden moss
I didn’t really think the ammo capacity gap mattered that much
empty lark
Feels especially wrong when the reload is different as well
All pistols except Volcanic reload all bullets at once but all revolvers go one by one
hidden moss
Feels especially wrong when the reload is different as well
I wonder if reload speed changes drastically
hidden moss
All pistols except Volcanic reload all bullets at once but all revolvers go one ...
That’s why I like using it
hidden moss
I hate when I join a group on Facebook for fans and there are people that join just to hate on it.
Some clown with a penny wise pfp was saying RDR is trash like bruh I bet RDR 2 drew more money than IT
astral leaf
Fr
neon snow
Anyone know which songs is best not to play during livestreams that are in the story?
tulip wolf
Got an idea for rdr3
Let it be called "Red Dead Redemption 3: A chance to do things right."
Story carries on with John Marston, same story as RDR1
But once he returns to his family, you have the choice to escape
Idk, just got that idea
azure sentinel
Is there a way to auto follow an NPC when horseriding in a mission?
dull geyser
Is there a way to auto follow an NPC when horseriding in a mission?
I just focus on them
dull geyser
What do u guys think of the double action revolver
A pretty fun gun to use especially with its fire rate
hidden moss
A pretty fun gun to use especially with its fire rate
But it’s shit in accuracy and damage
tulip wolf
Is there a way to auto follow an NPC when horseriding in a mission?
Activate cinematic camera and maintain the riding button pressed
Either A, or X, in Xbox or ps, idk
tulip wolf
What do u guys think of the double action revolver
All around very mid, ngl
Only stands out because Micah used it lol
hidden moss
Only stands out because Micah used it lol
That gun is the perfect match for him
tulip wolf
Good thing he didn't get a pistol
He would've been hella duckin fast
I've just finished the game again, and I can say Micah is hella mid
The only tough enemy at American Venom is the first sniper
hidden moss
The only tough enemy at American Venom is the first sniper
I sniped him with the carcano rifle
tulip wolf
You have to reach a certain rock
Basically, until the game tells you to actually kill him
hidden moss
Yea
tulip wolf
Otherwise, he's just the twin to the invisible sniper
Actually, might be him
Got to guarma and never felt anything when I shook up the guards there lol
I don't really know what else to do with my file now
Got every mission gold medal
I'm dreamcatchers away from 100%, so I might do that
But then? I don't know...
I've already got legend of the east too, so...
valid berry
did they patch the heartland oil fields bug to get fox trotteR?
dull geyser
But it’s shit in accuracy and damage
Yea schofields or cattleman make a better choice
hidden moss
Yea schofields or cattleman make a better choice
How about both
dull geyser
With L2 on controller?
Yes and just double tap x or a
steady venture
can you kill the guy that violated arthur?
torpid mauve
oh nah, its farming simulator now
idle granite
is dual pistols good? I feel like when i am dual pistols w/ flaco and volcanic im worse off than if i just use the lancaster repeater
idle granite
maybe its situational and im trying to do too much longer range stuff w/ pistols
i also have done the last few missions at night so seeing the enemy has been tough. need to stop that
im not super sold on the lancaster repeater either as my standard
split olive
Guys I have a problem with money lending mission if someone can enlighten me..
hidden moss
Strauss is a nerd
split olive
Guys I have a problem with money lending mission if someone can enlighten me..
One of the debt mission with the dollar mark on my map in rhodes dissapeared in chapter 3. Is this even normal?
The debt mission you have to collect the diamond brooch
From the grave
idle granite
One of the debt mission with the dollar mark on my map in rhodes dissapeared in ...
are those debt missions or homestead robberies?
oh
split olive
Single player
I am stucked now, I don't want to load a previous save file and lose all that progress
There are 4 or 5 but u can do them as John Marston, they are not missable
Anybody can help me with my issue?
Also anybody can tell me if I keep the diamond brooch and not give it for the camp funds will I be able to do all the money lending missions in the next chapters?
Any help would be appreciated
serene isle
do u guys think hugh jackman could play arthur morgan in a live action project
long galleon
best crafted saddle?
and can i have the race woman encounter again i accidentally crashed into her
normal relic
do u guys think hugh jackman could play arthur morgan in a live action project
I'd think so
lost gale
Uhm a bit of panic mode....does someone know something about a 219mb update for RDR2?
long galleon
whats wrong with that
lost gale
Because of scripthook maybe?
long galleon
ok where can i find a panther
long galleon
panther trail
thanks
empty lark
a bit under Bolger Glade on the map is where i found mine
long galleon
ill go get it after this
empty lark
I lured it out into the open with bait
hidden moss
ok where can i find a panther
Old Harry Fen
You can climb on the house when it starts chasing you if you’re fast enough
long galleon
tried to dead eye micah he disappeared
puma?
theres a cougar only
cause u aint supposed to shoot him i guess
yea its a cougar
shot dutch lmao
micah killed me
last mission
0
yea
micah died
noob
got 25k
idle granite
some of these clowns in the gang, man... if i was the boss they'd be out.
but if you kill em, you fail the mission
long galleon
I lured it out into the open with bait
what gun for the perfect pelt
empty lark
bolt action rifle/rolling block
if you want a bit more distance between you and the panther you could use the rolling block but i used the bolt action since it doesn't really see you that easily when there's bait anyways
hidden moss
what gun for the perfect pelt
Bow
long galleon
I lured it out into the open with bait
some damn pig came eating at the bait'
elfin yew
Help please!
I was playing through rdr2, and I got to the one mission where you get jumped and knocked out, then carried away on a horse by some unknown guy
Well, I got stuck on the loading screen, so I restarted my game, and now it’s saying I need to buy story mode, when I have story mode? Since I bought the whole game?
serene isle
if i use cheats and then turn them all off, can i still get achievements
long galleon
well i cant seem to find one
came back lets see now
slim steeple
Where is the best place to find a skunk
idle granite
i hope they change the autosave rule and the auto load your last save behavior if they ever make rdr3
let me choose what damn save to load
sometimes i want to go on a murder hobo spree before i log off for the night. thats a parallel timeline
long galleon
a bit under Bolger Glade on the map is where i found mine
any other spots?
been running around here
finally
one came running at me
was just about to give up
radiant girder
if you want a bit more distance between you and the panther you could use the ro...
placing the bait near the intersection on the edge of the woods is a good way to hunt it
serene isle
if i use cheats and then turn them all off, can i still get achievements
radiant girder
placing the bait near the intersection on the edge of the woods is a good way to...
and hiding behind the boulder
radiant girder
if i use cheats and then turn them all off, can i still get achievements
probably not
long galleon
placing the bait near the intersection on the edge of the woods is a good way to...
just walk around and be the bait
radiant girder
u can't save ur game so it would make some sense that you can't get achievements either
hidden moss
was just about to give up
I literally said “Old Harry Fen”
hidden moss
Ur game is brokN
long galleon
so i just walked around
radiant girder
just walk around and be the bait
i tried that and got attacked instead
long galleon
i tried that and got attacked instead
dead eye
hidden moss
But yeah the pig shows up to eat your bait
long galleon
But yeah the pig shows up to eat your bait
yea thats why i wont use bait now
radiant girder
just shoot the pig
hidden moss
I just ride around the area until it attacks. It spawns out of nowhere half the time
long galleon
kinda hard when u can barely see it
mini map
radiant girder
also attracts it
long galleon
maybe
hidden moss
It’s pain in the ass to try and “study” the panther
radiant girder
it's easy if you just stay out of sight of it
hidden moss
You have to have it ambush you and then make sure you’re close enough to escape to a rock. Or it has to take your bait
Hell. One time a big cat did take my bait at old Harry’s fen, but it was a damn cougar instead, like wtf?
radiant girder
like i said, place bait and hide behind the boulder at the intersection
and use cover scent lotion
radiant girder
yeah but you might not get a perfect kill
long galleon
well i did
radiant girder
considering how fast they are
long galleon
Well i noticed it in the minimap and then dead eye and kill
But arent panthers black?
radiant girder
i think that's just the legendary panther
long galleon
In real life they are usually black
slim steeple
Where is the best place to find a skunk
nvm, found one
radiant girder
In real life they are usually black
not the florida panthers
still don't make sense because the game has both regular and florida
long galleon
Whats the regular ones then
Or where are they
Ive only seen cougars and florida panthers
hidden moss
Nobody ever asked me where to find the animals. And I know all the best spots 😖
solid sentinel
Abi, someone knows dubbing skins
slim steeple
I'm at the saint denis stables (post-epilogue) and there's a black arabian, but it won't let me buy it, and it says "You cannot afford this horse" despite the fact that I have $21,926.43
Anyone have any idea why?
Nvm, I think it's because I already have a black arabian lmao
slim steeple
Where actually is the white arabian, exactly? I'm at the spot according to rdr2map.com, but there's none here
empty lark
Left side of Lake Isabella on the map, could be on the more flat side of the ground or on the slope
It just spawns around that area, no exact spawn point
slim steeple
I'm currently left of the lake. wdym by the more flat side etc?
empty lark
flat side as in it is not a hill or a mountain it is flat ground
it is not a slope going up to somewhere, it is flat and a path could be made on it around the lake should people desire
slim steeple
How big is the area where it spawns? Like is it only on the left side of the lake? Or could it be north, south etc?
empty lark
left side
muted oak
Anyone looking to chill play on ps4
empty lark
it is not on the right, it is not above or below, it is on the left
slim steeple
Ok, thanks. So I can just go north and south along that bit until one spawns?
empty lark
Anyone looking to chill play on ps4
this is the story mode channel, #ps-lfg
muted oak
Ohh I'm sorry I'm stupid 😂
empty lark
Ok, thanks. So I can just go north and south along that bit until one spawns?
If you haven't already scared it away without noticing then it should already be there, just ride slow and look up the slope and in front of you and pay very close attention
It is as white as the snow, so you can look over it if you dont see any of the somewhat small things that make it stand out
slim steeple
Damn, ok. I'll fast travel away in a minute and ride back
Any idea how far north and south it can spawn?
empty lark
doesn't spawn past the ends of the lake
slim steeple
Ok, perfect. Ty!
empty lark
Never has for anyone i've seen capture it, didn't for me, so im pretty sure that's the limit to where it spawns
also any tips in #red-dead-fashion i'd definitely appreciate, it's such a fine hat but i cant make anything out of it
hidden moss
This dumbass game isn’t letting me sell my horses
slim steeple
God damn, this is hard. I've spent this whole time looking for one, and haven't found a single one
Let alone tamed one
grand vine
Is there a site that has all missable content in the game?
slim steeple
Is there a site that has all missable content in the game?
I believe Jim Milton#9776 can help you with that. I'm not gonna ping him, bc I don't wanna disrupt him, especially since he's not online rn
grand vine
I believe Jim Milton#9776 can help you with that. I'm not gonna ping him, bc I d...
Ok well do u know if any horses are permanently missable or?
slim steeple
The black shire is, IIRC
Also, I've been up and down this straight for ages, and I haven't found a single white arabian. WHY? 😭 😭
hidden moss
I don’t really like the coats on the MFT
Why does the LOTE hat look like Micahs? Lol
slim steeple
Also, I've been up and down this straight for ages, and I haven't found a single...
I give up. I've been doing this for an hour and a half, and I still can't find one. Forget it, I'm done
hidden moss
Are you looking for the white Arabian?
slim steeple
Mhm
hidden moss
Check behind lake Isabella
slim steeple
That's where I am
hidden moss
There’s a dot on your map behind Lake Isabella. Go@over there. It’s an open field of snow. That’s where she is
slim steeple
Wdym?
slim steeple
Where the shack is? On the north east side of the lake?
slim steeple
Yeah. I've been there, it hasn't been there once
hidden moss
If it’s not there exit the game and load back in
slim steeple
I cba rn. Its almost 2am for me so I might try again tomorrow
Idk if this might be the reason, but I do have 3 horses + one that I tamed. Is that why I can't find it? Because I have too many horses?
So I have one main horse, 2 stabled, and one more horse with me
edgy bone
How do i read my journal
slim steeple
Hold left on the d-pad
edgy bone
Thanks
slim steeple
Np
hidden moss
Idk if this might be the reason, but I do have 3 horses + one that I tamed. Is t...
That shouldn’t be an issue
hidden moss
No it’s because you didn’t reload your game
slim steeple
Wdym?
slim steeple
Hard save?
hidden moss
Manually save your game
slim steeple
Oh right, ok. Well I've already saved the game and exited it, so hopefully I'll be able to find it if I play tomorrow
worn crag
ive played rdr2 before, i got 77 hours on it, and today it says "Verifying ownership failed and your offline activation data could not be loaded. Please ensure your internet is connected and restart RDR2, if issue persists, contact support"
grand vine
Anyone know a site that has all permanently missable content?
neon snow
Activate cinematic camera and maintain the riding button pressed
It’s holding the touch pad on PlayStation
idle granite
Is there any way to check that looting a corpse will lower your honor? These guys blew themselves up opening a safe
slim steeple
Anyone know a site that has all permanently missable content?
I'll Dm you what Jim Milton#9776 sent me
grand vine
I'll Dm you what Jim Milton#9776 sent me
Ty
radiant girder
Also, I've been up and down this straight for ages, and I haven't found a single...
What chapter are u on
cuz u can steal one of the braithewaite's
serene cedar
Uh, I just killed 4 deer, 2 does, 2 bucks. I brought them to Pearson to craft satchels.
But only the 2 does counted as a deer, apparently he wouldn't accept deer buck pelts.
It's the same damn animal and material, Pearson!!!
hidden moss
The most fucked up thing I did in camp was go to the scout camp to cook all my meat and start walking around camp eating it while there was no food at camp
covert wing
So what’s everyone’s cure when the depression seeps in after chapter 6.
tulip wolf
So what’s everyone’s cure when the depression seeps in after chapter 6.
It was quite the honor for me to be Jim Milton, so depression got carried right away when I saw him... I felt like I had second chance to take care of him, after playing rdr1, knew how good of a man and gunslinger he was, and now I treat him like he was me
torpid mauve
went to valentine for sadie bumped into someone got into a fight and she started shooting at people what\
tulip wolf
went to valentine for sadie bumped into someone got into a fight and she started...
Gosh, same thing happened to me!
long galleon
I don’t really like the coats on the MFT
yes u do
mild summit
just bought rd2 lets see what all the hype about
real warren
Trust me, you're gonna love it
hidden moss
just bought rd2 lets see what all the hype about
Got it a couple months ago played 250 hours and got the first one this week
fast flicker
I got it last month
hidden moss
Rdr2 is peak fiction
Haven't finished 1 yet
It is awesome
Ans liars dice has no right to be this fun
mild summit
Got it a couple months ago played 250 hours and got the first one this week
sheesh well already i’m liking it so far
hidden moss
Wait till the open world opens up
long galleon
so it turns out that the panthers in this game are florida panthers
hidden moss
I hate how the duster coat looks in rdr2
split olive
Anybody can tell me if I keep the diamond brooch and not give it for the camp funds will I be able to do all the money lending missions in the next chapters?
dull geyser
sheesh well already i’m liking it so far
Welp it gets better the more you progress
dull geyser
I hate how the duster coat looks in rdr2
Yeaa I preferred the look of duster coats in the first game
limber sapphire
Almost done with weapons expert
stoic ocean
just bought rd2 lets see what all the hype about
i got it a week ago on chapter 2 uncle is goated
dull geyser
i got it a week ago on chapter 2 uncle is goated
Fr
slim steeple
What chapter are u on
I've literally finished the game lmao
hidden moss
I played the game 2018-2019 for months pretty much daily and i recently found out that you can do a chore where you fill some water buckets at the camp. and now i've seen it on youtube and i can't believe how i have missed this. i dont remember doing this at all when i played the game and even after that during all these years that i've been dabbling in my old game saves 
hidden moss
I just looked at my first playthrough when the game came out
How pathetic
Only 41 animals discovered
Barely any weapons
9 equipment
None of the challenges completed
What a pile of shit
I should delete that save
It’s an insult
limber sapphire
Lmao
slim steeple
I killed a wolf that tried to kill me yesterday, up in the mountains. I've fast travelled away to valentine, and ridden back, I've saved and quit the game etc etc, yet the wolf is still here. I suspect that means that the white arabian won't be here. How do I get this wolf carcass to despawn and get the whole area to kinda "reset"?
NEVERMIND! I found it!
slim steeple
I need name ideas for my arabian
normal relic
I need name ideas for my arabian
Hmm I'm thinking
slim steeple
Also, all 4 of my horses are now female. I gotta change this
slim steeple
I'll only get rid of one, I think, and try to get a male
long galleon
idk why the criminals in valentine jail are just in there
they never get hanged
like alfred benedict and the prostitute killer
empty lark
Anyone know a spawn location for Robins?
I need it for the Rhodes hunting request and I've found every other animal on it other than that one bird
long galleon
Anyone know a spawn location for Robins?
do u know
slim steeple
If they knew, they wouldn't be asking
visual drum
like alfred benedict and the prostitute killer
i saw the prostitute get hanged
long galleon
ok
limber sapphire
Weapons expert down
long galleon
i saw the prostitute get hanged
i didnt
even with john
it was there for 2 chapters and 2 epilogues too and it is prolly still theer
low ember
Does reputation really matter in singleplayer or no
empty lark
yeah
simple otter
Does reputation really matter in singleplayer or no
Mostly matters for the endings
empty lark
The lower your honor is, the better loot you get off of corpses, the higher your honor is, the higher discounts you get when buying things
having -4 or lower honor lets you buy the Ebony Gunslinger grip for the Double Action
long galleon
The lower your honor is, the better loot you get off of corpses, the higher your...
no u get better when u have higher honor
empty lark
+4 for the Pearl Hero grip for the Cattleman
empty lark
no u get better when u have higher honor
stfu you ain't helping
Also affects Arthur's voicelines
long galleon
stfu you ain't helping
yes i am
empty lark
then define better, there's a lot of ways to be better
long galleon
Also affects Arthur's voicelines
yea he sounds like batman
long galleon
then define better, there's a lot of ways to be better
u get more money atleast
or i get
empty lark
sounds nice, my low honor gives me more things to sell to the fence when i loot corpses
low ember
Ok thanks for the help
long galleon
sounds nice, my low honor gives me more things to sell to the fence when i loot ...
yea maybe
empty lark
Ok thanks for the help
And a minor detail is it affects your suit color in the ch4 mission "A Fine Night of Debauchery"
long galleon
And a minor detail is it affects your suit color in the ch4 mission "A Fine Nigh...
whats the colors
empty lark
Red for low honor, blue for high
long galleon
oh yea it was that
empty lark
red looks better tbh
low ember
Interesting
slim steeple
How do you get range gloves?
long galleon
going back for money looks more fun
empty lark
How do you get range gloves?
should already start with a pair as arthur
John has his own
slim steeple
cowboy outfit
John's outfit? From RDR1?
long galleon
should already start with a pair as arthur
my arthur dont got no gloves
long galleon
John's outfit? From RDR1?
no its the one u get after jim milton rides again mission
slim steeple
I'm trying to get some white gloves. Anyone know where I can get some?
slim steeple
no its the one u get after jim milton rides again mission
So yes then 🤦♂️
slim steeple
No but its the outfit he wears in RDR1
long galleon
I KNOw
undone reef
I KNOW
slim steeple
Sheesh, alright.
slim steeple
So is there a way to get some white gloves? I can't find any
slim steeple
Ok, thanks
empty lark
Trapper has some
trapper has some
slim steeple
Oh I didn't see that, sorry
sleek umbra
does everyone here still cry after arthur's death if you beat the game multiple times
empty lark
no im too fucking busy trying to find a single goddamn robin
long galleon
does everyone here still cry after arthur's death if you beat the game multiple ...
no
limber sapphire
no im too fucking busy trying to find a single goddamn robin
I found it near braithwaite manor
undone reef
does everyone here still cry after arthur's death if you beat the game multiple ...
no
empty lark
alright i'll go look there
limber sapphire
Near the gazebo iirc
empty lark
as long as someone dont start getting pissed with me for being near the burnt house i hope it'll be easy
long galleon
as long as someone dont start getting pissed with me for being near the burnt ho...
for me they did
empty lark
dont care
slim steeple
How do you unlock more trappers?
empty lark
what
limber sapphire
Wdym
empty lark
you just find them
long galleon
How do you unlock more trappers?
it roams around
empty lark
there's one in Saint Denis
slim steeple
Like there's a few that aren't on my map
limber sapphire
Saint Denis has a fence near it great location
slim steeple
So you just have to go to it, and then it will show up on the map??
long galleon
it roams around
what u mean with the skull
limber sapphire
The comment was stupid
limber sapphire
Wdym roam lol
long galleon
its just in different spots
limber sapphire
He has 3+ set locations
long galleon
ok
limber sapphire
@empty lark good luck 👍
slim steeple
He has 3+ set locations
5 apparently
limber sapphire
Yeah
hidden moss
5 apparently
Where are the other 2? I know of only 3
hidden moss
A certified "what now" moment
Play it again
hidden moss
Just finished RDR2 boys😢
Is it great? Or is it great?
pallid mica
It's a masterpiece
empty lark
have fun with 9
long galleon
never beat up people in van horn man
vagrant mirage
am i still able to get billy midnights pistol in chapter 5?
limber sapphire
Yeah
limber sapphire
You can do almost every stranger mission in every chapter
Except the brother dorkins missions
Let’s go
On survivalist 10
slim steeple
If I want to get garment set stuff from the trapper, for example The Ghost Bison set, the hat and coat both require 1x legendary white bison pelt each.
Does that mean I need 2 legendary white bison pelts to make both the hat and coat? or can I make both with just one?
limber sapphire
Survivalist finished
slim steeple
Nice
limber sapphire
If I want to get garment set stuff from the trapper, for example The Ghost Bison...
Who already get the required amount of pelts
slim steeple
Huh? Wdym?
slim steeple
So I'd need 2 legendary white bison pelts to get both the hat AND coat?
limber sapphire
That require that type of pelt
empty lark
thank fucking god
limber sapphire
So I'd need 2 legendary white bison pelts to get both the hat AND coat?
No lol you can get them right after hunting the animal
empty lark
i finally found the robin
limber sapphire
Nice
empty lark
Found it at an old broken fort
slim steeple
No lol you can get them right after hunting the animal
So I can make both the hat AND coat with one pelt??
limber sapphire
So I can make both the hat AND coat with one pelt??
Technically you get more than one pelt from killing the bison but yes
empty lark
I took an hour long break because Iron Deficiency John slipped down a cliff and died and somehow lost all his pelts on the horse in the process
slim steeple
Ok, sweet. Thank you
slim steeple
I took an hour long break because Iron Deficiency John slipped down a cliff and ...
NOOOO I feel for you
empty lark
I didn't save, i was just pissed
slim steeple
That is some pain
empty lark
Because I had a perfect cougar pelt and I didn't save the game before I fell and died
slim steeple
BRUH
empty lark
i also somehow dont have my perfect opossum carcass anymore but that was when i reloaded the game the day after i hunted it
i wonder how many animals i killed before finally getting this god forsaken robin
slim steeple
i wonder how many animals i killed before finally getting this god forsaken robi...
There should be a thing for that. Like how minecraft tells you how many of each block you have mined, how many times you've jumped etc
empty lark
perfect skunk, 3 perfect muskrats, 2 perfect cardinals, 2 good sparrows, a poor crow, good badger, perfect blue jay, 2 perfect iguanas, good songbird, 2 perfect sparrows, 2 good and 1 perfect oriole, perfect opossum pelt, perfect chipmunk, perfect songbird, 2 perfect woodpeckers, 2 perfect racoons, perfect squirrel, good sparrow, perfect rat(not micah, relative), 2 perfect rabbits, perfect badger
empty lark
perfect skunk, 3 perfect muskrats, 2 perfect cardinals, 2 good sparrows, a poor ...
all of this before one single perfect robin
wind breach
Its literaly broken
empty lark
i gotta hunt another opossum again but other than that im done with the rhodes request
hopefully i have animals needed for the other requests too
slim steeple
Where is the legendary moose, and what do I use to kill it? Bearing in mind that I need the pelt for the trapper
empty lark
there's also like 4 perfect pelts sitting on my horse
slim steeple
there's also like 4 perfect pelts sitting on my horse
.... HOW?
slim steeple
lol
Also, where is the legendary moose, and what do I use to kill it? Bearing in mind that I need the pelt for the trapper
empty lark
I believe the moose is near the top right of the map
slim steeple
Ah ok, thanks
empty lark
left of Charlotte's place
slim steeple
I thought it was that one, but I wasn't quite sure
empty lark
yeah it's up there
Pretty easy to see tbh
Big and doesn't blend with the surroundings too well
slim steeple
Can you get poor pelts etc from legendary animals, or will they always be a good enough quality for the trapper?
slim steeple
Big and doesn't blend with the surroundings too well
true lol
empty lark
it's always good enough for the trapper
even if you use incendiary rounds
it doesn't matter how you kill it
slim steeple
Imma use dynamite lmao
empty lark
if im lucky i'll find a cougar in Black Bone Forest, if not then maybe i'll find a opossum
slim steeple
Also, can you hold the dynamite out while it's lit to reduce the time until it explodes after you throw it? or is that not a thing in rdr2?
empty lark
yeah
slim steeple
Oh hell yeah
empty lark
it can blow up in your hand if you wait too long
slim steeple
Do you know how long the fuse takes in rdr2?
slim steeple
Ok, no worries. Imma try to kill the legendary moose with dynamite lmao
slim steeple
gonna save my game first though 💀
Might be wise
empty lark
aw
it doesn't blow up in your hand
Arthur/John just puts it out
ok i dont think it actually matters how long you hold it before throwing it
slim steeple
gonna save my game first though 💀
You: lights dynamite
Also you: tries to throw dynamite
John: Has an iron deficiency and drops the lit dynamite
You: OH FU-
slim steeple
Arthur/John just puts it out
Damn, that's unfortunate
empty lark
i just held onto one for like nearly ten seconds and threw it, blew up after like 2-4 seconds, same with the one that i only held for one second before throwing
slim steeple
Awww ok. Thanks for trying that for me
empty lark
im not sure what i killed but i've already reloaded my save
slim steeple
btw what do I do with the pelt when I go to the trapper? Sell it, to him?
empty lark
yeah
slim steeple
Ok, thanks
hidden moss
good morning
empty lark
morning
slim steeple
Good Morftereve!
(MORning-aFTERnoon-EVEning)
hidden moss
lmao hi
empty lark
opossum hunting is fun until you run it over with your horse because it's night
hidden moss
I always headshot animals with poison bow to get perfect pelt and after killing i shoot it 5 times with worn cattleman revolver 😃😃😃
slim steeple
What do you need to make the poison arrows? I swear I have the pamphlet, and probably the ingredients, but I can't for the life of me figure out how to make them
hidden moss
What do you need to make the poison arrows? I swear I have the pamphlet, and pro...
u need an arrow
empty lark
oleander sage
slim steeple
u need an arrow
Noooooo you don't say (sarcasm)
slim steeple
oleander sage
I swear I have that
empty lark
i prefer hunting animals the way god intended, with a bow and dynamite
hidden moss
i prefer hunting animals the way god intended, with a bow and dynamite
i personally prefer to use train
empty lark
respectable tbh
hidden moss
i get -rotten pelt
since it’s so bad it’s in negative
but it’s so bad that it’s rare
so it sells for triple price
😎
it’s 12 am idk what i’m saying
empty lark
i wish there was a good white fancy style coat in story
slim steeple
I GOT IT!
empty lark
Yeah I think i've seen it
slim steeple
With dynamite!
empty lark
nice
i wish the rdr1 random npc duels were kept in rdr2
and the Fast Travel to Waypoint
slim steeple
I'll send the video in a bit 🤣
empty lark
ok wherever i saw the animals for the Rhodes hunting request on was fucking wrong
Poster in game just said to get a rabbit and a squirrel 💀
slim steeple
oof
empty lark
alden wont let me mail the shit
maybe it's because even though the game says i have a rabbit carcass, i dont
got two perfect pelts but not a carcass
south flame
been wondering, what's the best saddle in Story Mode?
south flame
Panther trail, I think
Thats what people are saying but ive also heard that Rattle Snake is better...?
slim steeple
Chill, check media
empty lark
but there's hardly any difference
south flame
i see, ty
slim steeple
I just realised that when you're on the hill north of the trapper near annesburg at night, you can see the lights from saint denis and sisika lol
Also, where's the best place to find wolves?
empty lark
sometimes i'll find a pack of them at Black Bone Forest
at night, i dont remember if i've ever seen them at day
slim steeple
I found a reddit post saying you can find a guy camping with a perfect wolf hung up, so I'm gonna check it out first
Well there's no-one there so I'll try what you said
The perfect wolf pelts you need for the trapper. Can they be any kind of wolf?
Because I remember seeing some wolves up by lake isabella
empty lark
yeah
slim steeple
sweet, thanks. Imma head up there and see if I can find any more
BRUH
I just got attacked by like... 6 wolves, and I got all of them first try with my bow
empty lark
nice
empty lark
So in my god awful hunting of a singular robin, i have somehow collected most of the animals needed for the hunting requests
slim steeple
lmao
empty lark
i've sent like 3 hunting requests in a row, without actually going out to hunt anything
slim steeple
Can you do anything with wolf carcasses other than sell it to the butcher for profit?
empty lark
nah
empty lark
i need a perfect skunk, bullfrog, and toad next, i already got a perfect songbird and sparrow
after that are the carcasses of a cedar waxwing, bat, crow, beaver, and i already have a perfect blue jay
slim steeple
FUVK
I just got killed by a fucking cougar or some shit because my dumbass horse wouldn't ride away, and instead bucked me off. I was spamming A, but he still bucked me off. I bet I lost that god damn pelt now
FUCK
FML
I lost the pelt!
This dumb fuck
I'm loading an autosave from one minute ago. If I've lost that pelt, I'm gonna be so pissed off
FML
It's gone
I'm done
I really want to blow this horse up with dynamite rn
limber sapphire
after that are the carcasses of a cedar waxwing, bat, crow, beaver, and i alread...
For the bats go to Elysian pools water fall
Cedar waxwings I found near the Dakota river
Beavers near owanjila
Crow in bolger glade
rain badger
I really want to blow this horse up with dynamite rn
Horse rn: “skill issue?” 😏
slim steeple
literally
It's a white arabian too, and I want to blow it up
That's how annoyed I am
empty lark
gotta grow up first
empty lark
For the bats go to Elysian pools water fall
What about the three before those? I've seen them around but i dont really know a good spot for any of them
Toad and Bullfrog done, gonna try to find the skunk now
limber sapphire
What about the three before those? I've seen them around but i dont really know ...
Oh skunks
They’re easy to find in upper west Elizabeth
Toads you can find in the bayou
I don’t remember the bull frog
Might be there too
vagrant mirage
real
empty lark
how in the fuck does a cougar killing me have anything to do with my horse losing all of its pelts
how can i keep all of the animals i have stored in my satchel but my horse cant keep any of its pelts
empty lark
it probably ran away so hard the pelts fell off
yeah and me falling off of small ledges numerous times doesn't make the pelts fall off
my horse did a whole front flip once when we were falling, pelts stayed on
frozen aspen
front flip so the momentum made the pelt stay on idk
empty lark
and what about when we hit the ground
frozen aspen
Horse just neighs
empty lark
dont have an answer to that then
frozen aspen
yup
empty lark
thankfully i found that bitch of a cougar and killed it again
frozen aspen
I just poison arrow them and follow them while watching them die painfully on the ground
empty lark
I could not imagine this war horse actually serving in any war and surviving past the first five minutes
frozen aspen
I could not imagine this war horse actually serving in any war and surviving pas...
I think its supposed to just be able to ednure bullets in the chance it gets shot not stay around to find out what bullets can kill it
empty lark
War horse is big enough seem like it could intimidate animals but skittish enough to feel like im riding a worse arabian
limber sapphire
Ngl I don’t think there’s much a difference in skittishness
frozen aspen
my turkoman is basically just my arabian if it was bigger
it gets scared of everything
limber sapphire
Like if you compare an Arabian to Turk or MFT right
At max bonding
I guarantee you they will have similar outcomes
empty lark
i think im gonna blow its legs off with dynamite after im done
frozen aspen
make it volatile
empty lark
i got another turkoman anyways and i dont really care much for selling
empty lark
If you've already found the treasures nah i doubt it
frozen aspen
how would that work
limber sapphire
Yeah what I thought
Ima take a shower and retry
After this I just got bandit challenges to go
empty lark
Hardest part of horseman 9 for me was getting past Strawberry
I always seemed to get a random encounter there that slowed me down, Laramie Boys or whatever
limber sapphire
For me the 2nd stretch is the most stressful
Which is the train tracks from flat neck to strawberry
lone cairn
Any tips for hunting skunk?
vagrant mirage
shoot it
lone cairn
thanks
lone cairn
ok thnks
empty lark
i have no idea where to find one
im trying to figure it out though
hunting for one rn
lone cairn
i know where i just didnt know if night or not
empty lark
trying to hunt along a river near black bone to see if i can find it but i had to kill a cougar first
found it already
my horse nearly ran full speed over it though
because of a snake
that was slithering away
such a brave little war horse
empty lark
small game arrow
lone cairn
but i am a frog
empty lark
get over it
vagrant mirage
sacrafices must be made
empty lark
i kill other persons all the time and im a person
empty lark
i kill other persons all the time and im a person
sometimes they make for good snacks too but i prefer animals if i can get them
vagrant mirage
cant wait to get to john, i just wanna kill npcs
lone cairn
WAIT they will EAT ME???
vagrant mirage
i love arthur but im tired of playing the good guy