#red-dead-singleplayer
1 messages · Page 83 of 1
So is it worth the 36 dollars ?
I mean
I am gonna probably have to wait for it to go on sale…
I got it when it was on sale
It’s worth it if you really want to know how the story continues
The ultimate edition is on sale for like 36 but the normal version has its original price with no discount which is 79.99
I am talking about red dead 2
Ends in 2 days and I legit can’t spend money on anything☠️
I got it full price when the game came out
I don’t have the money for it right now 💔

Looks like I am gonna have to wait for it to go on sale
It’s the ultimate edition too… like I really fumbled
It will probably go on sale for cheap
What does the ultimate edition have btw?
Nothing lmao
☠️
What are your favorite games btw?
And I just didn’t realize I have it
Idk
Doesn’t seem like the discussion to talk about in this channel 
Wait so you bought a hundred+ for the ultimate edition
Ahh true true, my bad

I think I am gonna leave this server and come back to it when I buy the game, otherwise I am just gonna get spoiled over and over again
Or is there a channel for people like me
Just beginners
Idk
General
Don’t leave tho lmao

Just don’t look at #red-dead-media
If you don’t want to be spoiled
I have seen people talk about deaths in gen chat ☠️ I don’t think it’s a good idea
These are spoilers 💀
Man💔
what happens if you go the micah's hideout before American Venom?
I go into van horn with max honor, start greeting everyone and they're still all assholes 😭
Everyone in east New Hanover are assholes
They think they are tough in Van Horn until I massacre the entire town
You shouldn’t lose honor for killing them. They are all criminals
Fr
Tbh if you a join a server where the rules literally say "Spoilers are allowed" you're asking to get spoiled haha
I wouldn't join a place like this until I was done playing story
How tf am I supposed to study a Florida panther when they attack me before I see them 💀
They ignore my predator bait
I even have cover scent on
binoculars
Just got the diagnosis. Ignore me being heartbroken over here as I pet and love my horse as much as humanly possible
can someone share their save file with me after the toy box mission in epilogue 2 please
my game isnt advancing
I seen it in a video a long time ago, and forgot this even was in the game... I was just hunting in Bluewater Marsh when I found a body hanging from a tree and got the encounter where you get surrounded by Night Folk.
That was terrifying honestly.
I found a body but it was before sundown so they didn’t attack. I got a note from his body, his buddies has dared him to go out to the swamps, not believing in the nite folk, and he was swinging from a rope…
It just happened to me at 1 pm in game... which tbf, I did think was odd.
Maybe it was because it was cloudy and raining for me
I found the guy that "violates" (not sure if the accurate term is banned or not, but it starts with "rap") Arthur... do I lose honor if I just blast him in the head before going inside and actually getting violated? Or do I need to be violated before killing him?
Screw it, he's getting a fire bottle to the face, I don't even care
This game is so fucking stupid sometimes
It’s impossible for me to study this stupid Panther
It won’t let you study it if it’s after you, so I climbed on the house when it was chasing me and it vanished, like wtf?
I got it
I climbed on a rock and scared it off and was able to study it then
Going back for the money with high honor is not a bad ending
Nah, you do. I tested it. Probably because you're not supposed to know he's a "violater" until after he violates Arthur. Then you can go back and kill him, I'd assume. I care too much about Arthur to purposefully violate him for the sake of testing tho.
Based
I did that to the incest couple
I wish you could hogtie animals
torture that bitch
in my experience you can't tie the fat one
Is running into him mission related or just random chance?
alguien español?
How do i prove that i have 100% completion?
where tf we kill some owls ??
Charles is so stupid! Im trying to do the "throw dynamite into the cave" but every time i do he rushes forward and gets blown up
just throw one in at the start, the rest you can shoot just fine
Just stand back a bit when you start shooting, hard to tell the melee murfrees apart from the ranged ones sometimes
if you're doing it for that one weapons expert challenge then ig good luck, Charles usually stood fairly back for me, or he got knocked over by the explosions
Finally managed to get it done, my issue was the second I got close enough to throw it where they wanted it, he charged forward after id already let it go, so he exploded, so I threw it so it barely touched the area, didnt kill anyone but let me progress
do stuctures burn in RDR2? Ive never tried
Thanks friend, makes sense! Wish I could somehow know what the trapper needs without actually running all the way to him. Is there a way to check without doing so?
This dumbass Rio Grande Turkey doesn’t exist in my game
I’ve went to every location it supposedly spawns and it wasn’t there
Just those stupid pigs instead
is javier's horse boaz a male or female? curious because i want to copy him🙃
Is there a way I can fast travel back to the camp?
How do i install mods
yeah i know
What food in the general store will make you gain the most weight the fastest?
Chocolate
i went to the snow and tamed the elite albino horse and now all other horses (that ive found so far) are ruined
i came across a thoroughbred racing horse and the albino horse is faster top speed
albino is probably not the right word to use but the white one you find near lake isabella
i wish i had more than 3 stable slots, i'd catch one of each
if i go out and tame a few of them, will multiple follow me back to the stable? not that it is super lucrative but i enjoy the activity
The Carolina parakeet is proving to be just as annoying as the Rio grande Turkey
Best way to do it is, bring your own horse, tame one, bond it to level one, tame another, ride it (the bonded and and normal horse will follow you when you whistle) tame one more horse and lasso it and lead it along. Then you have 3 horses to sell
No prob, I also love mass horse taming. I think the lasso lead works on any broken horse, not sure if it requires you do have done the "Horse meat for dinner" mission first though
I'm looking at a google sheet of RDR2 Horse Stats that lists em all. Is every horse type (not necessarily color) generally speaking available to catch wild? or is it only a subset?
e.g. the rose grey bay arabian
or black arabian
I have absolutely 0 clue. I havent even finished my first play through, lol
guessing not then. paying $1000 for a horse from a stable is too much
Every horse breed can be caught in the wild although they are not as good as horses bought from the stable, and not every coat can be found in the wild
actually
no
War horses I believe aren't in the wild
Never seen a wild Turkoman, Ardennes, or Andalusion
I'm not sure if i've ever seen a wild shire or suffolk punch either
well a good amount of horse breeds can be found in the wild
but not all, and not all coats
found an american paint
in the wild
Im like pretty sure that theres a wild andalusion up by brandywine
am I supposed to just not do the last debt collector missions to be able to get Buel?
As John I mean
It's the last side mission with the Veteran, for Buell.
yeah poor Hamish :(
I just thought of another setting for RDR 3
Micah before he joined the gang
I want to see an origin story of Micah and why he is the way he is.
I mean Mustangs are War/Work so that's only partially true haha
abusive father
criminal father as well iirc
Is there a way to save Hamish? It does give you that like, split second to shoot the boar as it charges him
no
Damn
I would never play it my hatred for Micah is too strong
Yeah maybe you can play as Micahs father?
as much as i would love to beat a younger micah i dont think he would be too interesting
Micah? i thought he was at the GAY ZONE
Young Dutch would be cool too
ARTURD
yo anyone online
Arthur high honor had the most peaceful death ngl
me after killing micah
But Charles had the best character ending
I said this before but I actually like the going back for the money ending. Dutch has more dialogue and you can see the cracks in micahs armor
I captured the white Arabian horse and got my bonding to lvl 4. I am brushing, feeding and petting quite often but lately she constantly tossing her head and acting skittish. How can I fix?
what chapter are you guys in
Has anyone found the Rio Grande Turkey and/or the Carolina parakeet
I’m convinced they got patched out
im in chapter 6
I finished the game 100%. Just achievement hunting now
nice
Also you stab Micah’s eye out
And you bite his hand
I’m in chapter 6 currently
same
If you have high honor and go back for the money you bite his hand before he stabs you
Arthur gets beats up but not has bad as helping John escape
Which leads to Arthur being able to say a lot more than any other ending. Also has more Dutch dialogue than any other ending.
Yeah exactly
what do you guys think red dead 3 is going to be about
Red Dead 3 is probably being made right now. RDR 2 started like a year or 2 after RDR
You know RDR is a cash cow now. It’s a mainstay.
One team works on GTA, the other works on RDR
Smaller teams work on games like Bully, and Max Payne. I want Bully 2
i heard that there working on gta 6
that is coming out next year
Idc about GTA.
i have a question
Some dude on YouTube tried to argue that Trevor beats Micah in a fight because of a non canon game mechanic. Dead eye is canon because it’s used to transition from a cutscene to the game several times. Lol
do you guys think that uncle is red harlow
Rage mode is some horse shit ability to give to Trevor because Michael and Franklin have abilities
If he is. It’s not the campfire folk tale version you play as. It’s a normal gunslinger.
hey guys me after killing micah
Can I promo my server👉👈
I wish Micah wasn’t such an asshole
same
Still not as bad as Ross Atleast
agent ross

you are not worthy

DarkViperAU
Big fan of RDR2
He played it like once
There aren't cougars in missions
Runs dead
Hello and welcome to what is hopefully my final attempt at finishing Red Dead Redemption 2 without gaining depression, i have a max hp of 1 so any sadness from any source will immediately kill me.
guys i have to go to sleep good night
Ok
this game is spectacular.. anyone who disagrees will meet mjölnir with his face
word
The amount of detail in a headshot is insane
There’s a bit of brain and everything in the bullet hole
i got the black arabian
hmm apparently not anymore. if you save it and reload while its still your temporary horse it appears to disappear
Every in-game day, I do every single chore, donate meat to Pearson, restock everything in camp and put $20-40 in the box. EVERY. DAY.
So anyways, I just wanted to go get some pelts to craft camp decorations. It took over a day, so for once, I didn't do those things. The second I come back with a bunch of pelts and meat for Pearson, that bitch Grimshaw comes up and whines that I stopped putting money in the box...
I did that too already, but I still put in daily to boost morale and keep them off my back.
But the very moment it's been 24 hours without them sticking their hands in my pockets, Grimshaw comes nagging.
Eh i never donated to much in the donations box
The Carolina parakeet doesn’t exist in my game
I found the Turkey though
I killed em good
Does somebody know a trick on how to get to blackwater with a horse in 17 minutes, without touching water?
Thats hard af
I never touch water and i get there under 17 minutes but i still don’t get the achievement 😤
Unless they count rain as touching water, that would be hella unfair
ride across the butcher creek bridge, ride across the train tracks covering the gap at Flat Iron Station, ride across the Owanjila Dam, as soon as the land lets you just start riding straight to blackwater
Only thing that messed me up when I did it was random encounters in between Strawberry and the Dam
Cant fall off your horse, that resets the challenge so ride carefully when you go off roads
Oh i didn’t know that! Thanks 🙏
He killed Arthur so I don’t like him
He in a way killed almost everyone in the gang
Micah beat up Arthur and Arthur died by Micah and tuberculosis
It’s crazy how Arthur dies the Same way as Mr.downes died
Ah i love getting spoiled
you shouldnt be on rdr community servers or googling up anything related if you dont want spoilers
Your not getting spoiled for a game thats 5 years old and your in the discord server
well yeah the fact he genuinely makes you frustrated just means the character was immensely well made
there was great acting done
Didn’t the actor get death threats after the game launched
peter blomquist! he’s such a lovely guy, rly sad that he got so much hate as an actor simply for Micah
he only killed him in bad endings
Anyone know where the best place to find a perfect elk is?
anywhere that has elks
i dont really know
Anywhere up north really
alr, thanks
oooh my spoiled eyes
im guessing when the sick dude coughs on him early on. i noticed in the cut scene shortly after that arthur looked kinda sick in his face
I finished story mode, when can I get arthur's items? like weapons.
send me in private
Anyways tldr it's after a couple missions in epilogue
You'll get everything back except horses
it's in epilogue 1 or 2
I don't know that part for sure, Google is free, but I do know you get it back after the "Motherhood" mission.
Oh right you also don't get your money back, unless you did the silly pig farm workaround.
There’s no point in saving Arthur’s money
You can’t buy half the items while working at the ranch
uwu
thanks
My favorite chapter was chapter 4
you need it to remove the secondary holster glitch
What does the glitch do
chapter 3 >
removes the secondary holster from John
Guys i got the legendary pronghorn something near the fort Mercer but tumbleweed butcher doesn't buy it. Where is the closest trapper?
Epilogue 1 was boring
mhm
look in the map sherlock
There’s no point in getting it back, but I want my money back. My Arthur is rich
I also have 5K, closer to 6 now
Currently my Arthur is broke as hell because I decided to get into a bunch of stupid fights and died 
I casually walked into some kind of O'Driscoll thing and got slammed. I didn't realize it was them. I still gotta Google that and see what that was even about. It was in that burned up town and they were hanging people.
A pretty significant portion, yeah. When I had like 10k, I died once and they took like 3k.
When I died I stopped getting charged after chapter 2
Is it only sometimes? Feels like just about every time to me. Is it related to bounties?
I remember getting killed a couple times and I didn't lose anything, or maybe the amount I lost was hardly any
I lost about 150 to people when I died to them
How do you get rid of it??
I just sold all of the cigarette cards, i thought if i can sell it to the fence, they're all dupes
reposting my message here since its kinda sinking away in #general by to much traffic
I didn't find any appropriate channel for my question, so I hope here's fine.
I just installed my new NVMe stick into my system, and then moved my rdr2 installation over with the Rockstar Launcher, when I now press Play it says Loading and after around 20-30 seconds it says Quitting.
~~The Game never launches, it posts no errors or anything else. ~~
~~I already verified my files and no missing/broken files were found. Now I'm stuck. Googling helped me no single bit, just came up with weird websites, Youtube also was to no avail with being full of non-helpful videos. Any ideas/advice would be appreciated. ~~
Before anyone asks the NVMe is fine, other games run just fine on it.
Also, please don't point me towards Rockstar Support, we all know that 9 out of 10 times it's just a waiting game for weeks, and then the answer is not helpful.
I found the tiger striped mustang
But I left it alone.
Will it still be there if I come back for it?
I want to put it in the stable with my MFT and RGBA
yeah it should be
You're looking for #pc-technical-stuff
Am I allowed to send messages that might contain spoilers for others?
thanks!
Yes
Did you read #welcome-rules ?
Yeah but I don't remember every single rule
Well okay
Just witnessed the death of Molly 🥳
Probably the only gang member death i didn't care about
fr
I didn't care about molly
The death that actually hit me personally was lenny's
I didn't really care but that didn't mean it didn't catch me off guard haha
would have sent the whole plot in here
but it was 2000 letters too much so i couldnt
Lenny was so good, I loved him tbh. Caught me just as off guard.
Molly sticks to Dutch like glue
Which is annoying
so is flacos revolver a cattleman
it shoots like one ill keep it cause its pretty fast and better than a normal one
grangers is a good cattleman too
yes
so... i didnt grab the bolt action during the quest to free Sean from bounty hunters. Is my opportunity gone? Or would it still be there on the ground somewhere if i go back?
no it wont probaply
its a very nice rifle but a lancaster will do for you for a long time
are the m1899 good?
Quick question to you guys, do any of you struggle to take samples from animals as naturlist? I can’t get it to register at all
you can take “samples”?
loses ammo too fast
Anyone else kinda feel like there should be a Buster Scruggs outfit in the next red dead game? I'd love that
Np for me
i really like michas knife and i found a mod for it but i have no clue how to use it
Very good they are like smg if u dual wield
Yes?
Just that only 150 ammo so it goes away pretty fast
How u do that
imagine explosive ammo with those
any good m1899 design?
I always use the same on every gun
All black and gold carvings
And skull on the knife
It looks nice
imo gold looks bad on guns
I only have gold on my high-honor revolver, but only as highlights/to accentuate the colors
“high-honor” 🤡
Hey, I kept high honor the whole way through the story, and only started going for low honor after the epilogue
U sedate the animal with the varmint rifle. Then u just walk up to the animal after it drops and take a sample. But the task doesnt register in my field guide for some reason
can someone help me with this mod rq
its to change the antler knife to look like michas
im using rdr2 lml but its not working
how do i unlock the first fence? i've nicked a stage coach for him but the icon just has a little padlock next to it had a bounty
I nabbed the semi auto shotgun and have been debating btwn running w/ that + slugs vs buying a new rifle but im only in chapter 2 still, and not much available from gunsmith rifle wise
Just killed everyone at thieves' landing while shooting from the hip. Now my fingers hurt
hey guys im back from school
You'll get a rifle for free during a mission early game so just wait and use the shotgun imo
You get another rifle free during a later game mission too
i just spent a bit of money to upgrade the semi auto shotgun, buy some slugs, and also buy a varmint rifle just to try out on small game
are scopes on the varmint rifle useful at all?
I dont see the point personally unless you just love scopes and want it
I dont put scopes on anything other than a better scope on my rolling block
I put scopes on the Varmint Rifle only because small game can be a pain to sneak closer to and I like accurate shots.
I've never actually used the scope, but it increases the stats slightly so why not
Does honor change anything in the epilogue
no way. dishonorable arthur >
there’s nothing like hearing dishonorable arthur’s quiet chuckle after killing a civilian
Store prices. That is all
Hey everyone, I just finished gambler challenges
and honestly, I've never wanted to throw my console so bad
The domino one is awful
they should’ve added way more gambler challenges
they were the best part of the game
not entirely lucky-based challenges
completely skill
gambler 8: nightmare; gambler 9: non-stop headache & gambler 10? if you know how to play poker, it isn't that bad
but I was frustrated by that point, I just wanted to complete the damn challenge
I spent a week on gambler 8
exactly
they should’ve added an extra 15 gambler challenges

Dutch in 1911 be like: You can’t hang me if I jump off a mountain 
Probably a far more painful way to go though
It depends. You could die on impact and feel nothing. Or you could feel the impact and then die because you don't hit the brain right away / severely enough... Or you could just shatter your bones and survive.
Hanging too you usually didn't actually asphyxiate, because when they would drop the gallows it would snap the prisoners neck
But if your neck didn't break, I can't imagine slowly running out of air
Our time has passed……John
I wish I got to punch gang members.
Honestly I feel bad for Dutch sometimes
I do too.
There's clearly like, something mentally not okay
To be fair, he didn't really seem to care about losing people
Even if he went to Tahiti they would have found him

Personally I think it's a cover
His narcissistic attitudes won't allow him to let it show that things bother him
He starts to crack a good bit after Hosea dies, IE, and I think he feels like Hosea's death is his fault (and it kinda is, because iirc Hosea was against the robbery) but he never admits it
Finished herbalist
Congrats 🎉
thanks
Im saving bandit for last which challenges should I do next
Horseman
Sharpshooter
Weapons Expert
Survivalist
Are the challenges I haven't done yet
Horseman honestly isn't that hard, might as well knock it out
There's guides for the tricky challenges like the no wet rides
what weapon equipment holds the most ammo?
I beat horseman 9 first try. I thought for sure I would hit a rock and ruin the run or get spawn trapped.
there's no difference between them, just buy the upgraded equipment from the stores and that's it
The only difference between all weapon equipment is looks
I've read countless guides and watched countless videos and explored in-game for hours...
I CAN'T FIND A FUCKING MOOSE!!!
I've been searching non stop for atleast 5 hours
I'm fucking enraged, this is bullshit. It's 10x easier to find legendary animals than it is to find normal ones.
I can't craft the camp decoration until I get a fucking moose antler
Give me a minute
I’m the moose expert
I’ll find you a moose
Cool thnx
How tf do I finish the challenges when they require me to go into new Austin
Ok. I killed a legendary bear. I took the hide to the roaming trapper and had him craft me a hat. But i still have a hide. The guy at horseshoe won't accept it for crafting
I guess i just sell it
holy shit
i just shot a guy through a moving train
the got him through the gap in carriages
try around lake isabella
When Arthur dies, does John inherit everything he has?
not money
but everything else
But horses and clothes
clothes and guns
And guns
horses dont transfer
Do you at least get money from completed American venom
one as arthur
I did. No moose. Just wolves
you get rich
No rush, but are you still searching?
go south there should be a small lake near train tracks there are usually some there
Why?
there is a better epilogue horse
I see
I’m currently trying to do high honour play through
Then ima do low honour
alrigt
How much money does John start off with in the epilogue?
No, I’m driving. I’ll be able to tell you where I found the moose. There’s actually several good spots
0-10 $$$
u get more money as soon as u progress
You get 20k from The American Venom misson
thats at the end tho
I see.
How much honour will I lose if I shoot the kid who steals Arthur’s stuff in Saint Denis
not much
mission fail tho
Oh
hit the cart with a fire arrow allows you to catch him
u welcome
Alr thnx. I've checked Lake Isabella, Cattail, Owanjilla, and O'Creags, all with countless saves and reloads, cover scents and herbivore baits.
Can't find shit
Join a call so I can easily explain it better
Sure. You ready rn?
Yep
Hello fellers i need someone who is addicted to rdr2 and will complete the game 100% i have a save file where you can play as healthy arthur after the epilogue the game is completed almost 91 % i need someone to complete it to 100% @ me if you are down to do this or dm me
I have Buell as my main horse and I have the Tiger striped Mustang, Rose bay Arabian, and the MFT Stabled. Buell has worse stats than the Arabian and the MFT but I keep him out because he is sentimental
Ah, yes, MFT, the mother f trotter
Really good horse
I loved the fact that you get level 10 stamina and health with the rose gray bay arabian
Really fits in with John's full health, stamina and dead eye
And it ain't as skittish as the fancy bi*ch white arabian
What kind of horse should I get in chapter 2
whatever you want, just learn how to shoot well on horseback and it wont matter
you could get the white arabian from Lake Isabella until better options get unlocked ig
but i prefer looks > performance
I’m looking for something decently fast, good health, stamina and doesn’t get skiddish when riding past a rattlesnake
I was thinking about breaking a mustang in the heartlands
I mean, not all horses are terrible
Yes
The thing is i dont care if they are or not
I care about how good they make my character look
Arabians make Arthur look silly because of how small they are
Thats why I myself am not particularly a fan of it
And the only thing good about it is speed
Overrated asf if u ask me
i find myself a bit apprehensive to advance from chapter 2 to chapter 3
it would be nice for some more weapons to be available though
Hi, when I go to get the gta online weapon, can I get it more than once in red dead or just once? Like if I get the weapon I can only have it in a story mode save?
u can have it in every story mode save
im assuming ur talking about the double action revolver
Hi, I'm on my first playthrough at chapter 6 and I was wondering if I can get 100% on the first playthrough or 100% completion can only be done on a second playthrough
The only thing I know for sure is that you can't get 100 percent completion as Arthur without cheating
I'd guess it's probably possible to get everything in one playthrough
yeah I know that but is there something that can only be gained in a second playthrough
no
there's no new game + or anything, you just start over with the knowledge from your 1st playthrough
so I should be able to get everything I can as Arthur finish the game get to the epilogue as john and get the rest
Doesn't 100% completion also count to doing all optional quests too
I feel like getting the 100% completion achievement 😄
I'm not sure what counts as part of that and what doesn't
There's a checklist in game
o
Everything that isn't available for a certain amount of time is required
I know about the checklist but there is one thing I haven't found yet ingame which is the graves
is that something that can only be completed as john?
So unfortunately you are forced to do Algernon Wasp's stranger missions to get 100% completion
yes those are a pain
halfway done with those but still
Horseman 9, ride from Van Horn to Blackwater in 17min or under without touching water
Herbalist 9 iirc too
Collecting all herbs in the game
can I do exotics as john even tho I started it as Arthur?
yes
Do those start in epilogue? I don't think I've met that person yet
No
thonk
is reaching max deadeye, health and stamina also limited to john?
I can't remember who that is then
yes
That means doing all the challenges
and as i said
some challenges cant be done as arthur
oh ok I know that the gangs one can't be done as arthur and the gang hideouts aswell as the dinosaurs
what about the legendary fish?
nah
and the hunting requests
can I get hunting requests done as arthur?
Never seen them tbh
Yeah I don't think that's part of it
It is
Unless you mean legendary animals
no no
No
hunting requests the one you get in the mail at the station
that's something different and Arthur also can't hunt all legendary animals
oh
yeah all legendary animals I know
I don't think I've ever gotten a hunting request then weird
Me neither
Last time I got something in the mail was when I sent cigarette card sets to Phineas
Are cigarette cards completely randomized or are the ones you find laying around at least set
I doubt there's a set to be collected just off the ground tbh and even if there is that's slow as hell
you could just go to a shop buy and discard the cigarrate cards until you get a set
I didn't even think of that
premium cigarettes are like $10 a pack so have some money stacked up
Normal packs dont have the cards iirc
I find them all the time even still
I just haven't figured out if you like, have to smoke the pack to get the card or of it's automatic
so is 100% in a first playthrough possible?
yes
nothing changes in your second playthrough
it's the same game, you just know more
just different endings which I will have to get
oh one more thing, do you know when the mission mrs. sadie adler, widow I & II unlock?
It's an optional mission, it'll just pop a waytag for her on the map
Hang on I'll see when exactly
It's after "Goodbye Dear Friend"
Anyone know how to remove the satchel?
Pretty sure you go to the stable
The option should be there
You can get all of them but the last one as Arthur
She goes on vacation after the 4th one I believe
that's a saddle, which does have a satchel
satchel is the little bag arthur/john wears on themselves
On Arthur
but you cant take that off unfortunately
Oh
Yeah I guess you can’t in that case
Why would you want to take the satchel off? You can’t carry anything if you somehow did
Which guns suit Arthur
some outfits would look better with it off
whatever you think
or whatever looks better with your outfit
For Arthur's Gunslinger outfit I'd use a revolver, because it fits better
I like the schoefield
Everyone likes the schofields
Schoefield and volcanic
the one pistol that shoots and hits more like a revolver than a pistol, it's nice
is there any downside to dying aside from losing a little bit of money?
ive been save scumming but that is getting a bit tedious
Volcanic pistol is my favorite
if you go to rhodes then look next to the gunsmith and talk to the dude in the basment then rob the basment you can get a lancaster repeater from the gun box downthere
Yep i just nabbed that one last night
Does anyone have any horse recommendations cause my current one is absolute shit
Hey look up white arabian location it's the best horse in the game and relatively easy to get
it's not the best horse in the game
Oh I thought it was my bad
What is then?
I mean the satchel is already like, magical anyways. You can't tell me Arthur/John is fitting 30 different pieces of meat, multiple bottles of alcohol, cans of peas and peaches, and more in that tiny bag
Either of the two Missouri Fox Trotters, slightly faster speed, less acceleration but that doesn't matter much, since you can still get pretty fast pretty quickly, and they're not as skittish, but horse bravery is still randomly determined after purchasing the horse
they also look better
Arabians short as hell, solid color coats are nice but the height makes Arthur look ridiculous
Yeah lol
It's the best "starter" horse since it's free and pretty easy to grab with some effort, but which horse is actually "best" is entirely objective to user preference. I really like MFTs, but a lot of people would say Turkoman or Andalusian is better
I forgot what kind of horse Buell is
Damn I just got the white arabian and never looked back
I like Buell
Dutch Warmblood
I have to keep changing the name of my MFT because everytime I bring it out of the stable it changes genders for some reason
I'm in love with my SDP MFT
Turkomans are great if you want a breed that can go fast but still take some hits, since they're War/Race
Genderfluid honse 
Andalusions are purely war horses iirc
It’s probably because I didn’t actually ride it. I took it for a short run around black water and then stabled it again
I just want a horse that won’t throw me off everytime I go to the swamps
What are the war horses?
Turkoman, Andalusion, Ardennes are the three off the top of my head
All available in stables
Mustang is a War/Work
Yeah but the Ardennes throws you off
They're also pretty decent
They all throw you off
It did it to TagbackTV on one of his playthroughs
You still have to calm them
Yeah they'll all throw you if you're not self aware
You would think Buell would be able to handle this better since he’s a “big mean bastard” but then again he throws Hamish every day
The difference is how quickly they throw you off
Imo just pick a horse you think looks pretty and get good at shooting from horseback
And Horse Bravery at this point im convinced either just does not exist or is random and i have shit luck
I’ve never been bucked from wolves. But cougars and alligators I have every single time
Agree, everyone says this or that horse is super brave but all my horses kick me at a tiny snake nearby
For some reason with bears my horse just goes crazy and books it. I don’t get thrown off
I usually have the awareness to hear a pack of wolves getting ready to chase me and my horse down
The wolves are so annoying
Whenever I hear wolves I just jump off and shoo my horse
It's easier to wait for them and shotgun them down
I just start riding the opposite direction and get my bolt action ready
Taking every chance I can to get perfect pelts without much struggle
True, shotgun does almost always result in "good" at best, usually poor.
But it's effective.
Bleedout shots on bears are honestly annoying
You can't stab them to end their suffering so you gotta sit through their death
I wouldn't mind if i could kill them without damaging their pelt since i like getting bleedouts on animals every once in a while
Is it true that if you stand still and stare a bear down it won't attack you
Right right
Is there a "best" place to shoot certain animals? I've noticed if I headshot an Elk it usually shrugs it off. But if I shoot it in the ribs, I usually end up with a bleedout at best.
April should be the Try not to shoot the entirety of valentine month
who ever can complete it gets hugs from me
i currently have the white and black arabian horses and then a white (or is she grey) and black shire. i dont really have any reason to keep these particular horses, i ride the black arabian because it has the best stats and doesnt get dirty, but so far i cant bring myself to sell the big chunguses
hello i have a question relating to dropping weapons, if i drop john's cattleman revolver and it despawns do i get it back?
yeah it should be back on your horse after dropping it for another gun
alr thnx
im trynna get all the famous gunslinger's guns and i was worried id lose it
uncle can solo every single thing or person in any universe easily
no question about it
hands down
yeah
He WOULD be able to if he had not been nerfed by lUmBaGo
i have a new issue...
i cant save
ive done the entirety of part 2 of the epilogue since my last save
@fluid brook thats because back in the day uncle was known as the one shot kid.
Different people have different opinions but the Missouri Fox Trotters can go faster than the arabians
Barely but still faster, slightly slower acceleration but that hardly matters considering you're still riding one of the fastest horses in the game and still get to speed fairly quickly
oh my god, can you not save once activating cheats
cant save the game while using cheats yes
how do i turn them off
look it up, i've never used them because i want my achievements
omg you have got to be kidding me right now
i used the fill out map cheat and now i will lose like 10% of the story and many gunslinger guns
No I can restart ur game to disable cheats
thats not-
thats not helping with the save thing though
it will revert to my last save if i do that
i legitimately did not get a single popup
im hoping the autosave thats there is after the epilogue but i have no clue
its been 8 hours since my auto save
great
welp there goes a day of my life
thanks rockstar 👍
Would having the rose grey arabian and whatever you said on a wagon be faster than a rose grey arabian
what
What
i am blowing this damn horse up after im done with it jesus christ
🤯 that’s sad
Exactly 😂
I think u gotta restart the game like close the application and turn it back on again
I’m almost in chapter 6
How do i change clothes
go to your wagon if you're playing as arthur
- but that cowardly killer……that shot…. Mr. Miller… has laid ol Otis in his grave, YEAH
Those are cougars. If you’re looking for panthers try old Harry Fen. It’s behind braithewaite manor
Asked an AI to rewrite rdr2:
The story of Red Dead Redemption took a dramatic turn when Arthur Morgan was diagnosed with cancer. Despite his illness, Arthur continued to be a loyal member of the Van der Linde gang, led by Dutch van der Linde.
One day, Dutch announced that he was getting married to a man named Micah Bell, a member of the gang. After the marriage, Dutch became a Native American and an artist. Dutch stayed in the gang, but his loyalty to the gang began to waver.
He eventually murdered Hosea and betrayed the other members of the gang. Arthur, despite his illness, was determined to bring Dutch to justice. He tracked Dutch down and confronted him, but Dutch refused to surrender. In the end, Arthur was forced to shoot Dutch in self-defense.
With Dutch gone, the gang disbanded and Arthur was left to face his illness alone. He eventually succumbed to his cancer, but his legacy as a loyal and brave member of the Van der Linde gang will live on.
Brilliant
How does it feel being a gay murderous native american artist
Not good because Arthur Morgan was forced to murder me in self defence
Do you get multiple Chewing Tobbaco when buying them from General Store?
Depression
Wild mustang will never buck you off and will get you all NPCs complimenting it, all the time
it's also pretty damn fast and looks like a small miniature tank 😄
one thing that puts me off though is the hairy bottom of the paws, not super good looking
I found the one hors I find the best looking and it's a blood bay thoroughbred, a bit below the mustang in speed and courage, but this thing looks so gorgeous
I just did the horseman 9 with Arhur
wonderful, what glitch was that one again
They gave him lumbago for a reason
What gun were you using?
What's the most accurate sidearm + with customizations in story
Like arthur's revolver?
what's arthur's revolver?
Like the one we buy and use as our sidearm with him
Or pickup
I don't think arthur had his own unique and styled revolver like the rest of the gang, just the cattleman he starts with at ch1
Which would be unique compared to the rest of the gang ig, since it doesn't look like anyone else's
I just wanna know what the most accurate sidearm is
Yea probably just with the upgraded look atleast
Yeah if they didn’t nerf Uncle then he would literally save the whole gang without any effort
Schofield, Cattleman, Volcanic, Semi Auto, they're all very accurate what kinda answer do you want
Schofields if im not wrong
most accurate
which
how fast are you shooting
is there any like stats website
stats only do so much for you
to check gun stats
90% of your accuracy comes from you
yes
95% i'd say actually
Some are just pretty good on paper
Is there a website for gun stats tho?
I think wiki has one
or smth google docs
You want 100% accuracy? Deadeye has that for you
dude
Any gun can land a bullet in between someone's eye if you use deadeye
I wanna test something with the crosshair
That way, you get to enjoy whatever you want
Just try the guns yourself sometime, if it hits accurately enough to satisfy your desires for high accuracy then use it
Probably destroyed ross' army in rdr too
What'd you see
yeah if you shoot at a slow-medium fast pace the m1899 can be very accurate
Yea have at it if you like
M1899s really get deadly if you spam deadeye
Frr
hardly any gun in this game is NOT accurate
Everything is accurate as long as it lands between the eyes lmaoo
i just like accuracy
The only inaccurate guns are any Double Action Revolver and the Litchfield Repeater
Just arthur is enough if we talk accuracy
no sir i believe you're mixing up accuracy with fire rate
Yeaaa
no
you can KILL faster with higher accuracy
You can SHOOT faster with higher fire rate
Yes
an unnaccurate gun that shoots fast like the double action
If you just spam
your not gonna hit your shots
but with a gun with high accuracy u can shoot fast and hit all your shots
mf the volcanics have high accuracy
and do they shoot fast?
fuck no, they shoot slow
dont use volcanic xd
Like schofields
actually its pretty good ngl
They are accurate and pretty fast
yes schofield is so good
accuracy =/= fire rate, this is my point
You should stick with that gun it's a solid choice
ch4
It's too op
Its the only gunsmith that has all the items if im not mistaken
actually next time I play rdr2 story again
I'm just gonna stick with my cattleman revolver
its not fun to be op
It's a really good choice
saint denis got every shop in the game
I rock the cattleman everytime
exept fishing shop lol
It just has the best aesthetic imo
It's so good
too good of a starter gun in my opinion
Yes
D-A if you like firerate and like to miss your shots
You get a lot of op starter weapons
and feel like a badass
Like the lancaster repeater
U get it ch2
Just with the cost of bailing micah out
Its main mission
exept the saint denis beggars😡
Where you rob a coach with micah
I help em everytime
u also get the
They give robbery tips
off holst
And i dont feel the sting of losing a couple cents
nearly free tonic
Yea
exactly
Still not that big
I have a feeling rdr2 is trying to get us to donate to charity
could just loot tonics off of corpses though tbh
imagine going irl and donating to a homeless person
Something I'd do on a low honor run
i've never bought or made tonics as John, i just loot them off of Van Horn people
We got arthur's name on like the home for the vets iirc
yeah
bro
if you donate then come back as john then you can see his name on it with a bunch of others
I feel so guilty doing treasure hunts
Yesss
I feel rich after doing it
you have 4000 in your pocket
I just wonder who the hell left six gold bars up for the taking
Could've just spent it then dipped and saved the trouble
I have a question about rdr2 mods for singleplayer
No complaints from me since it's mine for the taking lmaoo
weird that you dont get a honor loss for stealing someone's stash after taking 2 gold bars from a trasure hunt....
ur literally stealing someone's stash
is it just me that whenever im in valentine i antagonize people and fight a bunch of people
Tbf I think they want ppl finding it since they got maps and sht
so in the video it said dont save the game with the mods so does thjat mean I have to unistall them all before saving it?
say that to the judge
lol
"You'll never take me aliveee"
"LENNY!"
"There you are lENNY!!"
damn i miss lenny
he didnt deserve to die actually
He was such a good friend to arthur
like they came along better than anyone at the camp
Yea and it also happened so fast
He let his guard down
I mean he died as a warrior
I was kinda happy hosea died
after he went me along a bear trip
for like 40 mins
and then he left and wasted my time
and i had the hunt the bear myself


But still too young
Dayummmmn he didn't want any smoke with the bear
i cried so hard my keyboard broke
hosea was arthur's dad and dutch's husband(i was there for their marriage) i was upset to see him go
what
Yea they were basically the first 3 members
Or the founders of the gang
it's totally not like hosea calls himself, dutch, and arthur "a couple and their unruly son"
Welcoming their 2nd child named john
he's not but im sure uncle was better than harlow anyways
It's not true
Uncle is too old
yea
I think it's a pretty good theory but still not believable
if uncle we're red harlow
He'd be a beast
