red-dead-singleplayer

[proven ingot]

yea that was my test.

[visual drum]

i thought turkomans were brave

i feel like they’re worse than missouri fox trotters

[proven ingot]

and uh those moves you get when you build the trust up with your horse

the 3rd move idk how to use

[limber sapphire]

19 points

[empty lark]

random bravery goes hard

[proven ingot]

it says left crtl and left shit

but nothing happens

[tight halo]

Are you running when you push those?

[proven ingot]

am i not supose to?

i know one for standing still

the left ctrl and space

[proven ingot]

what does this one actually do

[tight halo]

No you’re supposed to to skid stop, you gotta be on the horse running

[proven ingot]

it doesnt work

im on my horse trying to use stamina tonic and it dont let me use

[empty lark]

open weapon wheel

go to horse section

[proven ingot]

oh that way?

i use tonics by pressing b

lol

[empty lark]

it would sure be a damn shame to waste your time opening your satchel to consume a tonic when you need speed the most

[proven ingot]

wait what horse sections

[proven ingot]

time slows down

i never played online

ig i will once i finished story

OHHH

HORSE SECTION

WHAT

[empty lark]

i cant help you at this point im in spanish class rn

mf

[proven ingot]

I NEVER KNEW THAT EXISTED

I CAN PRESS THE WORDS ON MY WEAPON WHEEL

[empty lark]

fucking hell

[proven ingot]

the R

ohhh

i see i see

thats cool

also like how do i get better revolvers, the best i can get rn is the schofield revolver

are there like ppl i can kill for better guns

ppl said those legendary gunslingers or something

[oak wind]

Yes kill the legendary gunslingers

[proven ingot]

do you know a location of one

[limber sapphire]

Let’s gooo

Finished gambler 9

[proven ingot]

also i forgot how do i change my gun from sidearm to my main firearm

[halcyon ore]

can sombody please help me bro?

[hollow garnet]

Sure i guess

[halcyon ore]

everytime i log in i get this cloud sync conflict, theres 2 choices to select all on cloud save or local data, i select on cloud data and suddenly everything ive done for the last 5 hours is gone, and this is my 5th time redoing it

[hollow garnet]

Okay nevermind

I dunno anything about that issue

Sorry

[halcyon ore]

:/

[limber sapphire]

@empty lark let’s go

[empty lark]

nice

[limber sapphire]

Finished gambler set

[hidden moss]

Did you just start playing this game?

[hidden moss]

Go to the little saloon in valentine. Not the big one. That’s where you will get your info

[proven ingot]

yes.

[thick stump]

hi - I tamed the White Arabian couple days ago, bonded with it. It vanished on me from the camp and I thought I'd just need to go tame it again. Just now I finished the ||Horse Flesh for Dinner quest, right at the end you escort the horses back to those guys sitting on the wall to sell them|| and to my surprise my White Arabian was stood there. I know its mine because it still had a bunch of wolf pelts on its back. But then the quest cut scene kicked and I load back in my camp and the horse is no where to be seen again! Is there any way I can track it down?

[long galleon]

no theyre not

[long galleon]

stable

u can retrieve it prolly

[thick stump]

Thanks @long galleon unfortunately its not there I checked already.

[long galleon]

damn

did u reload save again

that could have fixed the whole thing

[thick stump]

Its weird because it randomly appeared at the end of that quest out of no where. I tried to load the save but all I had was the autosave which saved as I loaded back into the camp after the quest

[long galleon]

u dont have ur saddle?

[thick stump]

I didn't put a saddle on the arabian

[long galleon]

well go get a black arabian then thats a new better horse

[thick stump]

I was going to but it was hitched at camp

[long galleon]

well then for sure it can vanish then

[thick stump]

I'd love to find it, not sure if I went back to the completed quest area it would still be there

is the black arabian a horse you buy?

[long galleon]

u can get a black arabian

for FREE

or get a missouri fox trotter its alot better

[thick stump]

I'll look it up, thanks for the tip

[long galleon]

i can tell

[hidden moss]

My black Arabian died with me

His name was Achilles

[long galleon]

go to saint denis at 3 am or sometimes 12 am then in the map u know the text says saint denis and go to the street that is in the letter N place and then save the mans wife (kill the robber) and he will leave his horse in the parking spot looking and steal it and its a black arabian @thick stump

usually between 3am and 4am

[thick stump]

Thanks a lot, I'll check it out

[long galleon]

sent the video in media

anyone know if that one spot near saint denis still works when u reload the game?

guess i gotta try myself

well damn

[proven ingot]

nothing here

[hidden moss]

What chapter are you on?

[hidden moss]

Have you not met boy Calloway?

[vague nymph]

Whoa I didn't know this thanks!!!

Now if only I could get the Spotted Pinto MFT before Blackwater smh

[long galleon]

u can

[empty lark]

there's a glitch or whatever for that too yes

[long galleon]

albert mason mission

[vague nymph]

I know technically you can get it from the one quest if you do it a certain way but I already did that quest smh

[long galleon]

which?

[empty lark]

Yeah, still the other mft from Scarlett at least

[vague nymph]

I didn't have the foresight to think to track it

[long galleon]

damnnn u need a stagecoach

to slow them down

[vague nymph]

What you put it in their way?

[long galleon]

yes

[vague nymph]

Oooh

When I start a new game I'll think to do that I'll be ready

[empty lark]

Any horse suggestions? Still got 19k and nothing to spend it on and i got room for one more horse

[long galleon]

turkoman

[empty lark]

already got two

[long galleon]

any

what coat

[empty lark]

silver dollar from tumbleweed, dark bay from blackwater

the best ones

[long galleon]

rose grey bay arabian its the fastest horse

[empty lark]

gold coat is meh

[long galleon]

agreed

[vague nymph]

Arabian is very cool, though not particularly accurate to real Arabians

[empty lark]

fuck those arabians

[long galleon]

yea i gotta use it i didnt steal cerberus

maybe on some playthrough i will

[empty lark]

i need a horse that looks good, and short does not look that good

[vague nymph]

I like the gold turk, I had him for a while but I sold him to keep a Murphy horse

[long galleon]

bro its still bery fast

[empty lark]

I dont care about speed

[long galleon]

well yeah

[empty lark]

i got nowhere to run to, i've beaten the game

[long galleon]

turkomans are fast tho

[empty lark]

Yeah i got two

Also an mft

[vague nymph]

Arthur does look silly on the smaller horses. I imagine John looks just as silly

[empty lark]

all lvl 4 bonded already so i dont need to work on that

[empty lark]

he does

[long galleon]

Which coat

[vague nymph]

I plan to mod that soon (obviously single player only, i don't really mess with online at all) so that the horses are more accurate to real size, Arabians should be way bigger

[empty lark]

Silver dapple pinto or whatever the fuck, from Blackwater

[long galleon]

I like the gold dapple mft

[empty lark]

I ain't interested in it personally

[long galleon]

U cant get it sadly

[empty lark]

Great

[long galleon]

Cause u cant steal sadies horse

Or baylock 😓

[vague nymph]

That MFT from the stable in the middle-ish of the map in the woods looks funny to me, I'm not sure if it's just the default mane that makes it unappealing to me or what

[empty lark]

If the grey ardennes wasn't a preorder horse then i'd love it

but unfortunately it was

[long galleon]

Wait bob is a turkoman

Baylock is the mft i want

[long galleon]

Amber champagne?

Its good looking imo

[empty lark]

i need a new dark coat and not short horse

[long galleon]

But when did old boy die

[empty lark]

Especially now since im trying to use legend of the east pieces which are dark red/black

[vague nymph]

Maybe I'll buy it and try other manes. Right now I've been pretty happy riding Buell.

[empty lark]

except for the hat and pants which just look not that good

[long galleon]

Steal any horse from stable

Dont buy em

[vague nymph]

How do you enter the stable without entering the buy menu???

[limber sapphire]

For some reason I can’t rob stables

I really tried

But eh

[long galleon]

Go with a wagon

And shoot the roof

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

[vague nymph]

Oooh

[lost gale]

Since we're on the matter of horses, what are in your opinion the most visually striking horses in game?
I mean, sure everyone loves a pure black or pure white horse.
But what other horse breeds/coats are in-game that look amazing?

[limber sapphire]

I think they patched it

[long galleon]

Left click and aim weapon thing

[long galleon]

No

[empty lark]

dark bay turkoman

[limber sapphire]

I’m on ps5

[long galleon]

I used it to get all my horses lol

[empty lark]

silver turkoman

[limber sapphire]

So it might be patched for me

[long galleon]

Wont matter

[limber sapphire]

Lemme try

Again

Lol

[long galleon]

Until u get witneds or wanted

[empty lark]

Still not sure what horse to fill my 4th stable slot with

[long galleon]

Then get out and go feed ur horse and yeah go outsidd whistle

Its urs

[limber sapphire]

Missouri Fox Trotter

[empty lark]

already got one

[long galleon]

2nd silver dollar

[empty lark]

blackwater

max bond

[vague nymph]

Oh wow 🤯 i didn't even think of that smh

[limber sapphire]

Turkoman too?

[empty lark]

two turkomans

[long galleon]

Satire or ? Cause it sounds a bit

[empty lark]

tumbleweed and blackwater

[limber sapphire]

Ok

Get a brindle thoroughbred

[empty lark]

From the stables near Strawberry?

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

[lament plaza]

Does anyone know how to fix the activation error on steam

[long galleon]

3rd one u must get

[empty lark]

wouldn't fit my outfits/unappealing to me

style >>>> performance

[limber sapphire]

Whenever I’m in chapter 4 I’ll try the stable trick again

[long galleon]

Silver dollar fits anything

[long galleon]

Ok tell me if worked

[vague nymph]

No it's genuine, I had no idea there was a way to rob the stable

[empty lark]

surprisingly enough it doesn't, i can't remember what it was but i had an outfit that just didn't look good with it

[limber sapphire]

Imo every turkoman besides the dark bay

Looks very ass

[long galleon]

Yea u sound like u already knew lol

[empty lark]

you didn't just insult hosea's horse

[long galleon]

Silver dollar no

[long galleon]

Yea everyone likes silver dollar

[limber sapphire]

Imo it does

[vague nymph]

Nah haha. Now I regret spending like almost a grand on the black Arabian just to catch the white one by Lake Isabella and sell it

[limber sapphire]

It looks like the average Kentucky saddler

[lost gale]

True, that's why one of my horses is one.
Also still have that huge black shire I don't know what to do with and the horse I grabbed on chapter 2 at the first O Driscoll encounter

[long galleon]

Black one is better

[empty lark]

it is

[vague nymph]

I think the white one is prettier though

[empty lark]

stable bought horses are better than wild ones

fair

[vague nymph]

I named her Snowbelle

[empty lark]

and good way to make a decision

[long galleon]

Rose grey bay is the fastest horse in game but prolly the most dipshit of em all

[empty lark]

looks >>> anything else that matters

[long galleon]

I sold my red chestnut and white arabian

[limber sapphire]

The white Arabian is prolly my favorite starting horse

[empty lark]

yeah looks like ass tbh

[limber sapphire]

It looks so bad bro

[tight halo]

I stole a Turkoman from the Saint Denis stables today. Still prefer my No No and Thrice No Appaloosa to him tho

[limber sapphire]

I used it for the horseman challenges

That’s all I used it for

Then I sold it

[long galleon]

Black that i stole in saint denis from the encounter i sold to clay

[long galleon]

Yea but if ur only after stats

[vague nymph]

Where in the menu do you find the challenges? I keep forgetting which one I'm on.

[limber sapphire]

Why tf would you sell it to clay

He rips you off

So hard

[long galleon]

Got more money

[limber sapphire]

Sell at the stables

[long galleon]

I didnt buy it from a stabke

Stable

[limber sapphire]

I get for 700 dollars

[lost gale]

Even the "17 minutes from Van Horn to Blackwater"?

[limber sapphire]

Lol

[long galleon]

20 dollars for me

[limber sapphire]

How much money do you have

Rn

[long galleon]

2.3k

[limber sapphire]

That makes sense now

[vague nymph]

How much is the difference for stolen horses sold to Clay vs sold to a stable?

[long galleon]

Clay gave 80 dollars

[limber sapphire]

💀

[long galleon]

And stable gave 20

[limber sapphire]

That sucks

[vague nymph]

Oh so that's a pretty significant difference then shoot

[long galleon]

So what u think is better

[limber sapphire]

Well I never said that stables wasn’t a worse option

You should’ve just bought it like ur supposed to

[vague nymph]

One time I robbed Clay just for fun

[limber sapphire]

So you get good returns

[long galleon]

And i dont give a shit about them arabians

[limber sapphire]

Cool

[empty lark]

if you owned the horse by purchasing then you'll get a higher sell price when you sell it in the stables

[long galleon]

Bro i just happened to see then encounter so i took it

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

[long galleon]

I can steal one from stable if i want

[limber sapphire]

• the honor discount you can get a great price too

So yeah

You can make profit if you sell

[vague nymph]

I noticed that as you max out trust you get more money too? So like if you buy a horse and then max out the trust, can you get a profit?

[empty lark]

yes

[vague nymph]

Oh that's what you just said smh

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

[tight halo]

I got an Ardennes for 150, only get payed 125 afte level 4 bonding as high honor as I can be

[long galleon]

What honor discount

[limber sapphire]

My Turk I stole which is at level 4 bonding went from 40 bucks to 100

[vague nymph]

You can get better prices at shops if you have high honor

[long galleon]

Man im at the middle and we dont talk about my other save

[limber sapphire]

You get 25 percent off if you have higher honor

[long galleon]

Well i dont

[limber sapphire]

If not more

[long galleon]

Well im trying to get higher honor but its slow as shit

[vague nymph]

It only gave me the pop up like once

[limber sapphire]

• if you do the Saint Denis Mayors mission you get a extra 10 percent off

[empty lark]

so other than brindle thoroughbred, what horse should i consider for my 4th stable slot that is not an Arabian, MFT, or Turkoman

[long galleon]

And stealing the wagons dont help help my honor at all

[limber sapphire]

You have Buell no

[empty lark]

he died in ch6

with arthur

[long galleon]

Tenessee walker

[limber sapphire]

Damn it

Lol

Ehh

Get a

Nokota or Dutch warmblood

[long galleon]

Or tiger stripe mustang

[empty lark]

caught that one once

eh

[long galleon]

Nokota is cool

[empty lark]

i'll probably look into nokotas

[limber sapphire]

Put horses in one of your pens

[empty lark]

race horses right

[long galleon]

But worse than silver dollar

[empty lark]

dont care at this point

[long galleon]

Hes the best fr

Im prolly gon use him as john

Arthur has to use the gold coat one

[tight halo]

The reverse dapple Nokota is pretty good

[long galleon]

Or silver dapple

[long galleon]

Stable one?

[hidden moss]

Do you guys know what happened to the horses is the other gang members?

Is there like a Easter egg where you can find a horse of the deceased gang member?

[long galleon]

No

Idk but no

[limber sapphire]

I wish you could buy gang member horses

[long galleon]

Fr

[limber sapphire]

Like Dutch’s horse

Or bay lock

[hidden moss]

I think it would be cool if you found Hoseas horse at like Ridgewood farm or something

[long galleon]

Baylock would be mine

[long galleon]

Ugly

And arabian too

[hidden moss]

I’m pretty sure his is a white Arabian

[vague nymph]

As a horse nerd The Count makes me angry lmao

[long galleon]

Its albino coat

Only one in game

[limber sapphire]

It’s an albino coat

[hidden moss]

I think it’s just a Kentucky Sadler?

[limber sapphire]

It’s pinkish

Which I like

[long galleon]

Its missouri fox trotter

[limber sapphire]

It’s a MFT

[vague nymph]

Naw, The Count is an "Albino" Arabian, and he's genetically impossible

[empty lark]

it is an albino

[hidden moss]

Ah okay

[empty lark]

the best gang members seemed to have the best horse breeds so i wonder what breed Arthur's Boadicea was

[hidden moss]

Did you guys notice that Tilly and Mary Beth share a horse?

[empty lark]

They do?

[hidden moss]

I did those stage coach robberies with them and they both used the same horse

[empty lark]

I almost never saw them riding a horse and when I did i didn't care

[limber sapphire]

If we get a prequel to rdr2

Hopefully we get to ride her

I’m guessing it’s a turkoman

[hidden moss]

Plus I couldn’t find a horse that belonged to Tilly

[tight halo]

I wish we could get Bill’s horse

[harsh ermine]

Neither could I, I think she rides a wild one

[empty lark]

Turkoman would make some sense for Arthur

Strong and fast

[harsh ermine]

ME TOO like bro it’s so pretty

How come we get Javier’s and Sean’s horse which are pretty but not the super pretty horses like the count and bills horse

[tight halo]

It’s the nicest horse like come on let me have it!!!

[vague nymph]

I think Boadicea was either Turkoman or MFT

[hidden moss]

But when I did the companion requests I seen that Tilly and Marybeth ride the same exact one. I was able to tell because both missions were back to back.

[stuck sequoia]

Fr his horse is so pretty

[tight halo]

I just want it!! It looks like a Breton (whether it is or not) and it’s so unique!

[harsh ermine]

If I ever get a PC I’m modding the hell out of my rdr2

[hidden moss]

For some reason in shady belle, The horses got spooked and ran into camp and it was endless loop of Johns horse riding back and forth from outside the camp to in it.

[empty lark]

It's a shame both of Arthur's most loved horses ended up getting killed while Arthur was alive

[harsh ermine]

Alligators

[stuck sequoia]

A few days ago I did it but I can't play online anymore

[hidden moss]

Also one of the wild horses fell from the sky. Kinda like how a dead animal will fall from the sky when you return to the area

[harsh ermine]

That’s not fair, so like cheating but instead you loose online?

[stuck sequoia]

Yeah

[long galleon]

Idk he dirty asf

But i like it too

[hidden moss]

That’s because Bill is a slob

[long galleon]

Old boy is nice too

[long galleon]

Yea ik

[harsh ermine]

You can brush camp horses

[stuck sequoia]

Really?

[long galleon]

Not going to

[hidden moss]

I can’t stand Bill. I always antagonize him.

[harsh ermine]

Yeah, I did it

[hidden moss]

He’s a stupid fuck that can’t fight

[long galleon]

Why

I like him

[vague nymph]

I could still play online if I disabled my mods which isn't too hard, but I only have a couple for graphical / realism things anyways

[harsh ermine]

I love him

[stuck sequoia]

Poor bill, i like him

[stuck sequoia]

How nice

[vague nymph]

Bill is funny sometimes and a jerk sometimes

[harsh ermine]

You can feed them, give them tonics and brush them

[long galleon]

Why yall even antagonkze camp members

[long galleon]

Ohh yeah

[hidden moss]

Because some of them are useless

[harsh ermine]

Only fair if it’s Micah

[long galleon]

Stand near and go to the menu

[long galleon]

Fr

[empty lark]

antagonize jack

[stuck sequoia]

I played it like 15th times and I didn't now that

[long galleon]

Whats really the problem arthur

[harsh ermine]

Took me 3 times to realize

[long galleon]

Why hes so sweet

[hidden moss]

The only person in the camp that actually contributes is Arthur. Everyone else donates bat wings and toe nail clippings

[stuck sequoia]

I'll try it tomorrow

[long galleon]

Lil kid

[vague nymph]

"Only villains do that"

[harsh ermine]

Also some horses like Micah’s will be hungry so I suggest checking lol

[hidden moss]

I don’t antagonize Jack

[stuck sequoia]

Nice, wait I'll try it now

[hidden moss]

But Karen got it a lot this playthrough

[long galleon]

Fr ive donated like 500

[harsh ermine]

I do for fun sometimes

[vague nymph]

How can you tell if a horse is hungry?

[stuck sequoia]

I feel you

[harsh ermine]

Same way you check if Arthur/John is hungry

[long galleon]

I wanted horse station and leather tools

Stable dude still says u needa feed her

[vague nymph]

I know you can look in the menu but that would only work for my own horse :v

[hidden moss]

Bill, Susan, Strauss, Micah, Dutch, Javier, Karen, Rev, and Tilly got antagonized some through the game. Tilly I only antagonized when she tried to blame me for the problems in the camp

[harsh ermine]

Only if they’re underweight. You can check in Pause menu > player > horse

[long galleon]

Yea but always defuse

[long galleon]

Ik but i only feed when cores get lower a bit

Whos actually had a fat horse and arthur or john

[vague nymph]

I feed my horse a lot just because I like giving treats lol

[long galleon]

I some times when i feel like it

[harsh ermine]

If health icon isn’t full, they’re hungry

[long galleon]

Why

[harsh ermine]

The health ring > health status
Heart icon > hunger

[hidden moss]

I antagonized uncle too

[harsh ermine]

Well that’s fair too

[long galleon]

My arthur is underweight always

[vague nymph]

Oh so it does just rely on the cores?

[harsh ermine]

Yes

[tight halo]

I constantly give treats, the horse puts up with so many gun fights they deserve it

[vague nymph]

I try to keep at least average, but it can be a pain to remember

[long galleon]

I only eat when corse are at the middle or when i need

[hidden moss]

Because she kept coming up to me drunk while I was trying to do something just like Reverend

[harsh ermine]

Lol, just be careful bc they can get overweight

[vague nymph]

Chonky horse

[tight halo]

I always judge the treat by the core level, nothing more than a sugar cube over 3/4 of a core

[vague nymph]

Do they visually get fat like Arthur / John will

[long galleon]

A bit

[harsh ermine]

That’s good! I only feed my horses when their health core goes down too lol

[long galleon]

I feed when it goes down any bit

Sometimes not

[long galleon]

And to myself i do that too

[vague nymph]

I try to always keep all my cores full on me and my horses

[long galleon]

Or any core

[harsh ermine]

Also it’s good to feed them when their core goes down bc they’re slower with empty cores

[long galleon]

Same but not arthur always

[tight halo]

I had the issue where a full core mustangs was malnourished so I am a bit more free with treats and such, lol

[long galleon]

Hes so nice

[harsh ermine]

Honestly I miss having a mustang, might go mustang hunting

[vague nymph]

I love the mustangs but I only ran into a wild one once, and an NPC with one once

I might just not know where to look

[harsh ermine]

Yeah they’re sadly rare as Arthur

Even so as John

[long galleon]

Nah ive seen a few

[vague nymph]

Are they more common near Blackwater?

[long galleon]

Ive seen near horseshoe overlook lmao when i first played the game

And now im at only chapter 4

[hidden moss]

Bill, Micah, and Strauss got antagonized the most

[vague nymph]

I think around that area is where I found the one I had, and Bounty Hunters killed her for a five dollar bounty, I was pissed

[long galleon]

Why strauss

Well he kinda annoying

But i never antagonize other than micah

[hidden moss]

Also I said Karen got antagonized but not a lot. I never antagonized Karen in my other playthroughs. She was my favorite

[hidden moss]

He’s the reason Arthur dies

[long galleon]

And when they being assholes to me about my bear hat in my chapter 2 save

[vague nymph]

They like aimed for her on purpose I swear, I didn't even have time to get off her.

[long galleon]

He wouldnt know

[hidden moss]

ive seen themmquite often around the dakota river and the nokotas too

[hidden moss]

but he was when you think abt it

[vague nymph]

Love Nokotas

[hidden moss]

the white onenis so pretty

[long galleon]

And my bison pants and jacket

[hidden moss]

ive lost it too many times tho

[long galleon]

How

[hidden moss]

i think my fave is the few spot appaloosa

[long galleon]

Yea there i seen em

[vague nymph]

I don't believe there's no way that Strauss didn't know that Downes was sick

[hidden moss]

strauss knew the guy was ill and still sent arthur to get him

[long galleon]

Yea

[hidden moss]

I’ve never seen a 4 year old act like Jack. Jack acts like a 7-8 year old

[tight halo]

I’ve tried both wild ones (non tiger striped) didn’t like either mustang, they just weren’t great for me

[hidden moss]

he had to grow up fast though didnt he

[long galleon]

Yea

He aint no baby

He a gangsta

[vague nymph]

Actually, I'm a charter school teacher and I work with ages 3-6; I don't find anything wrong with Jack. 4 year olds are smarter and more independent than you'd think.

[hidden moss]

oh the mustangs can be found around heartlands too i saw the grey and like redish one there

Yeah he was probably the smartest gang member when he became an adult. Seemed like he had Hoseas mind and Johns skill

like the open land with some cliffs

[long galleon]

Yea

[hidden moss]

Hell he reached Johns level with a gun in 3 years

[hidden moss]

he was team effort he got pieces of all the gang

jack and hosea interactions are my absolute fav

the ones i see on tiktok are so so cute and in game yoo

too

[long galleon]

Its so nice when jack tells hosea about the kidnapping and he ate worms

[hidden moss]

What did you guys think was more sad.

Arthur saying “I’m afraid” while holding back tears or when he tells his dying horse thank you?

[long galleon]

Or food that looked like worms and are delicous

[hidden moss]

dont make us choose💔

[long galleon]

And to abigail he told too

[hidden moss]

i havent had the im afraid scene yet because on ym last playthroughs i didnt meet the nun

hopefully i get it this one though

[hidden moss]

naww the tilly jack and arthur one also get the most tears out of me

[long galleon]

But that bitch micah interrupting jack and john playing with sticks

[hidden moss]

the high honour endings mean so much to me that when i realised i had gotten the low honour thing when arthur finds out abt tb i closed the game and started a whole new game

Arthur’s death wasn’t as sad for me because he was at peace. He accepted his death, he fulfilled his last request and he died the way he wanted to (watching the sun rise)

he did say he wanted to watch the setting sun though

[long galleon]

Yes

[hidden moss]

the ending to rdr2 could make a grown man cry

[long galleon]

Im gonna go see it

[hidden moss]

its just before his last ride back to camp

Johns was sad to me because I didn’t expect it at all.

when abigail says 'i always was a good theif' makes me cry too ngl

I tried to go back and save him but there was nothing I could do

[long galleon]

Didnt make me cry other than first time i saw it i had a few tears drop

[hidden moss]

cause im on ps4 i cant get rdr💔

[hidden moss]

ur a little boy then

To me one of the most satisfying things I did was making sure Penelope and Beau escaped

[hidden moss]

jokes

Because you didn’t have to do that.

i had the mission in white on my map

i just never did it

was too lazy to ride all the way back down there

[hidden moss]

You’re a chump, partner

[long galleon]

Why

[hidden moss]

Can’t believe you did that to Beau and Penelope

[long galleon]

Kinda sad

But not really a moment to cry

[hidden moss]

so sorry

[hidden moss]

okay butnngl

i was crying for like the whole end of the game

hoseas death had me creating an ocean fr

[long galleon]

Ill promise i wont

[hidden moss]

u didnt cry😢

[long galleon]

No

[hidden moss]

I always imagined when Jack confronted Edgar Ross that the rest of the former gang members were watching Jack. Kinda like how Goku was watching Gohan kill Cell if you get my reference

i do not

butnokay

[long galleon]

I have the bank robbery soon

Like dutch was already announcing it

[hidden moss]

i had whenni try to avoid the bank robbery but everytime i walk past shady bell dutch shouts at me

[long galleon]

Is that where he dies

[hidden moss]

like fek off

i dont want to donit yet😓

[long galleon]

I want to hunt with him again

[hidden moss]

Hey guys. Should I go to black water for the loan or Valentine for Sadie first? What would John do?

[long galleon]

That was fun

[hidden moss]

yea

im always too scared to go back after the bear

[long galleon]

Btw what honor u have when u start as john

[long galleon]

Dipshit

[hidden moss]

but on this play through now im gonna try stay in camp more so thatni can get more side missions

[long galleon]

Its easiest legendary like actually

[hidden moss]

Past neutral

[hidden moss]

[long galleon]

Thx

[long galleon]

Im just joking

[hidden moss]

the legendary moose is my fav

[long galleon]

I hunted it with my cattleman

[hidden moss]

bro i wish we had an option to deny uncles offer to go to beechers hope with john

[long galleon]

(Havent hunted it)

[hidden moss]

i ahhe that fat sack of shit with me

[hidden moss]

wow go you bossman

[long galleon]

No

Where is it even

Im gonna go get the gator

And where does lenny die i dont want him to die

[hidden moss]

Good honor

[long galleon]

I liked lenny

[hidden moss]

I think the gator is the easiest

[long galleon]

Wolf was for me

[hidden moss]

Uncle is Hilarious in epilogue part 2

[long galleon]

Stumbled across the area and it was coming for me so threw an ancient tomahawk at it

[hidden moss]

He carries the cutscenes

[hidden moss]

i hate uncle

[long galleon]

It died one shot

[hidden moss]

he gives me mad cripps vibes

i feel like cripps is uncle reincarnated

[long galleon]

Hes lovely

[hidden moss]

is he though

“Oh darling Abigail, I’ve changed. Come live with me in an outhouse I wouldn’t ask my worst enemy to take a shit in”

Best line ever

[long galleon]

I liked the mission where u steal the cows with uncle

[hidden moss]

the things i would do to uncle if i could, i HATE him.

[long galleon]

Psycho

[hidden moss]

shush

[long galleon]

Why u hate him hes so happy always

[summer sundial]

L u m b a g o

[hidden moss]

he really annoyed me when he interrupted molly mid mission

Molly? Another one that didn’t contribute shit to the gang.

[hidden moss]

i always try to antagonize him if hes sleeping

[long galleon]

I saw it on tiktok and the sound was something like " i thought i was gonna get to see her boobs"

[hidden moss]

she died for the gang bro what more do you want off the poor woman

[long galleon]

The uncle interrupting molly thing

[hidden moss]

i think rockstar need to give us a christmas present next year of red dead 3 with arthurs younger years

[long galleon]

Funny accent

[hidden moss]

yea

[hidden moss]

irish people are lovely

like sean

sean is the best

like

It will be Atleast 2027 before we see RDR 3

[long galleon]

Did u thought that too

[hidden moss]

non important character

[long galleon]

Walking through rhodes

[hidden moss]

rockstar neglect us toooooooo much

[long galleon]

Remember that

[hidden moss]

made me cry

also

as everything else did

[long galleon]

U cry from every death huh

[hidden moss]

did u guys know that arthur can get ræpd

[hidden moss]

i do and what😡

u got a problem

[long galleon]

My dad was sitting right next to me and he said why his head got shot off

[long galleon]

I do

[hidden moss]

aw bro if only he knew

i feel like

They are too worried about GTA 6. Look, if GTA 6 doesn’t have San Andreas, Liberty City, and Vice City, then it’s a downgrade from V. I’m hearing it’s just going to be Vice City. That sounds like a downgrade

bill shouldve been the one walkingninfront

i hate gta

[long galleon]

Nice game it is

[hidden moss]

can kiss my ass bro its the worst game ever so boring

[hidden moss]

no

[long galleon]

Not boring

You would prolly cry on that games story too

[long galleon]

Lol yea

[hidden moss]

i think bill is gay

[long galleon]

Nothing wrong with crying but why with sean

[hidden moss]

he knew aboutnit when i got back to camp

[long galleon]

Wasnt really that sad

[hidden moss]

cause sean is so underrated😢

[hidden moss]

it wasnt sad but im a baby

so

[long galleon]

Ok

[long galleon]

Who

[hidden moss]

what

[long galleon]

I just said to my dad that it was an ambush so the dude died

[hidden moss]

he said?

[long galleon]

Who u mean by only if ĥe knew

[empty lark]

grays got really unlucky picking who to kill first

shot the one guy who couldn't even shoot a bottle that ain't moving anywhere

[long galleon]

No i said

[long galleon]

Fr

[hidden moss]

no like what did he say afterwards

[long galleon]

Dumbass grays

[hidden moss]

If you guys listen to cruel world. Not the willie Nelson version but the Josh Homme version. The 0:15-0:25 part always gets me. It’s the best part of the song

[proven ingot]

whos that

[long galleon]

He said ok

[empty lark]

Jim Boy Calloway

legendary left handed gunslinger

[hidden moss]

the stranger missionnu can do first in chapter 2 valentine

[proven ingot]

idk if i did

uh

[empty lark]

i think he was left handed

[hidden moss]

calloways scene on the boat wlways makes me lauhh

[proven ingot]

so like

how do i meet him again

[empty lark]

wasn't he? there was something about him that made him different iirc

[hidden moss]

What game are you even playing?

forrel

[proven ingot]

rdr2..

[hidden moss]

I don’t think you are

[long galleon]

Then he watched me shoot up rhodes

[proven ingot]

idk what kind of question that is

[long galleon]

Interesting story right?

[proven ingot]

wtf dym

[hidden moss]

yes

[empty lark]

after seeing them as early as in ch2 you have to complete A Fine Night of Debauchery in ch4 before you can see them again

[hidden moss]

Because you don’t even have the mission unlocked and it unlocks in chapter 2

im so intrigued

[long galleon]

Thank you

[proven ingot]

im fucking playing it rn so what r you on saying im not playing rdr2

[hidden moss]

Dude you’re playing GTA 6 or some shit 💀

a fine night of debauchery is a 10/10 mission

[proven ingot]

im in chapter 5

[empty lark]

it's good for making Gambler 10 very easy, the poker games there count towards the 3 consecutive poker hand wins

[hidden moss]

maybe you already have it unlocked but you didnt inspect the cards levin gave you

[long galleon]

What was that again u did it recently

[hidden moss]

If you have met Calloway. Go to your photos and find the gunslinger ones and flip them over. Then their locations will spawn on the map

[hidden moss]

wthe boat robbery with trelawny javier and strauss

[empty lark]

Trelawney sets up a robbery on a boat, arthur gets dressed all fancy

[proven ingot]

whats the name

[long galleon]

I did

[proven ingot]

oh

k

ill check

[limber sapphire]

Gonna do most of the herbalist challenges rq

[long galleon]

Oh that when i get ripped on by the whole gang

[empty lark]

nice

[hidden moss]

theyre just legendary gunslinger cards u find in the satchel

[hidden moss]

goodluck bro

[limber sapphire]

Not exactly

[empty lark]

they'll be the cards of Emmet Granger, Flaco Hernandez, Billy Midnight, and Black Belle

[limber sapphire]

Hard

[long galleon]

For my haircut that was the exact same before i left

[limber sapphire]

Just tedious

[proven ingot]

but what do i select

collection of photos?

[empty lark]

all of them

oh

[hidden moss]

Just out of curiosity. How man of the plants can Arthur get in challenge 9? I had 36. I’m hoping I didn’t miss one and that I get the rest as John.

[hidden moss]

i wish i could get modded arthur on ps4

[proven ingot]

is black belle a legendary gunslinger

[hidden moss]

theres this one haircut i want for him

[empty lark]

just open your satchel and look through the documents section

[long galleon]

What modded arthur

[hidden moss]

but i cant get it

[hidden moss]

Yea

[hidden moss]

yes

[hidden moss]

Yea

[empty lark]

every single one i just named is

[long galleon]

Which one

[hidden moss]

shes the best one in my opinionn

[long galleon]

Haircut

[proven ingot]

emmet granger?

[empty lark]

yes

[proven ingot]

k i got all 4 then

[hidden moss]

idk what its cALLED

it just looks cool

[proven ingot]

i got 4 pictures i think thats all right

theres 4 legendary gunslingers

[hidden moss]

my spelling is not on today

The pfps in this server is like 75% RDR related and 25% cats

[empty lark]

did you go find them

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

Read the backs of all the pictures

[long galleon]

Dude who u bump into in the valenine saloon is he a legendary gunslinger

[proven ingot]

not sure

[limber sapphire]

and you can find them

[hidden moss]

cats are cute

[proven ingot]

i just robbed random odriscolls homes idk if i found 1 there

[long galleon]

Im a cat

[hidden moss]

not the writer the drunk is

[hidden moss]

What do you mean you’re not sure? Did you get black out drunk before you played it?

[proven ingot]

idk how i got them

[empty lark]

you got some real bad memory or something

[proven ingot]

do the legendary gunslingsers drop their gun

[hidden moss]

u make me question all thing red dead honestly

yes they do

[proven ingot]

which one is the best

[empty lark]

3 of them do

[hidden moss]

Yes

[hidden moss]

dont diss hosea like this

[empty lark]

Opinions opinions

[proven ingot]

ik 1 with the knife

@empty lark k whats your opinion

which one should i go battle first

[long galleon]

The dude who falls just before the duel

[proven ingot]

for their gun

[hidden moss]

OMG i was so pissed off when i got to the last mission of this side mission i found the perlino andalusian i think

[empty lark]

Granger and Hernandez both drop unique Cattlemans

Midnight drops a unique Mauser

[hidden moss]

as soon as the cutscene played i realised it was ghere butni lost it

[proven ingot]

a mauser?

never heard of that

[empty lark]

it's a pistol

[long galleon]

Ooh i want that

[proven ingot]

ig ill see it when i kill him

[hidden moss]

i accidentally forgot to take hernandez's revolver

[long galleon]

Ill make him kill himself :DD

[hidden moss]

was so sad when i tried to get it again

[long galleon]

"Dont miss"

[hidden moss]

what

[long galleon]

Thats what midnight says

[hidden moss]

oh is it

[long galleon]

Before he kills himself

[hidden moss]

Granger. He killed rocks, and he killed em good.

[empty lark]

if you disarm midnight he decides to kill himself

[hidden moss]

i cant rmeber doing his misson

[empty lark]

with another gun

[hidden moss]

well i do

[long galleon]

Yes lol

[hidden moss]

just cant remember whay he says

[empty lark]

you cant disarm him twice unfortunately

[hidden moss]

my fav side mission is marko dragic

[long galleon]

Oh

[proven ingot]

how do i make something fullscreen

it has to do something with f11 right

[hidden moss]

wdym

alt f4😎

[proven ingot]

everytime i do fullscreen in the settings it just makes it a box

[hidden moss]

My favorite side mission is probably the old Cajun

[empty lark]

start pressing buttons and find out

[proven ingot]

and i cant move it around

[hidden moss]

thats what schol friends tiaght me

[hidden moss]

whats that

[long galleon]

Ill still make him get that fantastic idea

[hidden moss]

He help this hermit get his house back from the night folk

naww the night folk

[long galleon]

Oh that one

[hidden moss]

theyre a differnt breed

i hate lemoyne

or the bayou nwa mainly

[long galleon]

Where u can get any hat in game

[proven ingot]

man my fucking shit is glitched

[hidden moss]

Night folk aren’t even scary. The skinners and Murfree are far more intimidating than them

[proven ingot]

alt+enter is suposed to make it fullscreen

[hidden moss]

whats the side mission when you help the woman how to hunt

[proven ingot]

mine just flickers

[hidden moss]

or u find her mourning his husband first

[long galleon]

By dying and respawning at a certain spot

[proven ingot]

now it fucking closed

[hidden moss]

Charlotte. It’s in chapter 6

[long galleon]

Skinners?

[hidden moss]

where is she tho

[long galleon]

Who were they

[empty lark]

gang in tall trees

[hidden moss]

find them in epilogie

ue*

[long galleon]

Ok

[empty lark]

They're like the Murfrees but worse i'd say

[hidden moss]

they the people who stole uncle

[hidden moss]

They are in the epilogue

the skinners are some scary mf

They take uncle and burn him lmao

[empty lark]

They tortured Uncle, kill people in the most painful ways they can

[hidden moss]

when u see them charging at you with machetes

Dude looks like a lobster when you save him

[long galleon]

Ill make them pay for that

[hidden moss]

my heart always skips a beat

[hidden moss]

we know you will, your in love with uncle

If you kill a lot of skinners they get very scared of John

features in this game are so detailed

[long galleon]

I actually almost junped on the woman crying in swamp when she almost one shot me

[hidden moss]

the laramie gang are the biggest jokes in the game

[long galleon]

Sliced me with a knife

[hidden moss]

nahh that happened to me the woman was crying

i died inside when she attacked arthur

it took me so by surprise

[long galleon]

But had a semi auto shotgun with me 😄

[empty lark]

Yeah she tricked me once because it had been a month since i last encountered her, i lived and fucked her up

[hidden moss]

Bacisacally. Skinners is the reboot wrong turn. And Murfree brood is the original wrong turn

i hate tall trees already, skinners made that worse

[long galleon]

Their heads are now idk where

[hidden moss]

Lemoyne Raiders are just bunch of annoying pricks.

i can never enjoy a pretty forest walk😫😫

[hidden moss]

theyre funny

bro said they had to pay a toll to pass through before sadie blasted them😭🤣

O’Driscolls suck they just have numbers

[long galleon]

I always feed one of them to an alligator and fist fight the others

[hidden moss]

probably on one of your shirts somewhere

[long galleon]

What u mean

[hidden moss]

nvm

[empty lark]

their hideout is fun to shoot up though

[hidden moss]

fr

Del lobos are the only real gang. The rest are either retired vets, immigrants, inbred family, or randoms

i love the mission where u go to get cattle back

[long galleon]

Well ill go sleep now bye yall

[hidden moss]

is bonnie macfarlane a stranger mission in the epilogue?

What time zone are you in?

[hidden moss]

goodnight

[hidden moss]

No

[empty lark]

I wish the Del Lobos tried leaving New Austin, they're a huge gang aren't they?

[long galleon]

Finland

[hidden moss]

aww thats so dissapointing

[long galleon]

Yes finland timezone

[hidden moss]

onenhour ahead of me i think

[hidden moss]

Yeah they are in the snow region but I’ve only seen them with Flaco

[hidden moss]

mahoosive

[long galleon]

Yup

[hidden moss]

finlandnddndn

[long galleon]

What

[empty lark]

Shame, they could probably maintain a lot of land if they tried stepping out of the still untamed west

[long galleon]

Sweden?

[hidden moss]

uk

[long galleon]

Oh

[hidden moss]

maybe two hours then

idk

[long galleon]

U from the tea country

[hidden moss]

yes i am

[long galleon]

Its 23.39 for me

[hidden moss]

tea is bangin for your info

yes two hours then

[long galleon]

Fr maybe if im sick

It bangs

[hidden moss]

tea is what i wake up for in the mornings honestly

[empty lark]

i need inspiration for what to make out of the lote outfit pieces

[hidden moss]

its so good

[hidden moss]

whats that

[long galleon]

Kahvi better

[empty lark]

Legend of the East outfit

[hidden moss]

whats that

[long galleon]

Coffee in finnish

[hidden moss]

i dont think ive seen it yet

[hidden moss]

coffee makes me want to be sick anyways go to sleep like u was going to

[long galleon]

Tee means tea

No i wont

[empty lark]

search it up, the hat and pants are mid imo but the coat, vest, and weapon equipment are pretty damn fine

[long galleon]

Go sleep

[hidden moss]

alr

[hidden moss]

go sleep

[long galleon]

My school starts at 10 so no worries

[hidden moss]

nahh that outfit is not it

[hidden moss]

imaginngo school

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

i get thursdaya nd friday off💪💪

[long galleon]

:[

[limber sapphire]

I have this whole week off

Lmao

[hidden moss]

i havent been since monday

[long galleon]

Damn

[hidden moss]

my mum needs looking after🙈🙈

[long galleon]

Well bye now i dont wanna get told that yall dont go to school

[long galleon]

Oke

Is she sick

[hidden moss]

byebye

[hidden moss]

not sick just operation

[long galleon]

Ok

[empty lark]

any suggestions for what pants to use with them? I can't find a pair that seems to go well with it

[hidden moss]

It’s crazy to think that The Van Der Linde gang is responsible for every big name dying. Killed Grays, Braithewaites, Bronte, Fussar, Cornwall, Favours, and Milton. You can also cause Henri the mayor of Saint Denis to leave.

I killed Fussar by shooting him in the head instead of using the cannon lol

Someone on Reddit tried to say that Bronte was more powerful than Cornwall.

Bronte was a big fish in a small pond. He ran a city. Cornwall ran the nation basically

It’s just crazy how Dutch casually kills him

At the end of it all Dutch was probably the most famous gunslinger in the Wild West for the redemption universe. Even more famous than Landon Ricketts

[proven ingot]

killed emmet

bro was covered im shit

[limber sapphire]

Go to Rhodes and get the gambler outfit. You get black fancy pants which look great

[empty lark]

i tried that, something still feels off to me somehow but it's the best i seem to have

[limber sapphire]

Hm

Herbalist one done

[hidden moss]

Hey did you guys know that if you go to the art gallery in Saint Denis you can see a portrait of Arthur?

When you’re doing the artists way mission and he goes to the art gallery if you look around you will see your portrait, I’m assuming it’s from Albert Mason.

[keen harness]

can u get the white arabian horse in the wild in rdo?

[empty lark]

no

[keen harness]

so u have to buy every horse?

[empty lark]

yeah

[keen harness]

alr

ty

[empty lark]

this is the story mode(single player) channel btw

[keen harness]

oh

mb

[empty lark]

it's fine

[keen harness]

didnt see the rdo chats before now

[vague nymph]

I'm so excited to go home after work and try things I've learned here haha

[lost gale]

What the heck is wrong with Butcher Creek? Got ambushed by a bunch of Murfrees, even fell into their dumb trap, killed two Murfrees and a third one fled. Tried getting after him on my horse, saw a dude that looked like he was the third Murfree and ran him over on my Shire...only to be attacked by the whole fucking village. FYI, don´t accidentally run over one of their livestock either (which are more than often just wandering around, so very unfortunate if you dash through there on a horse) or the whole village of inbred chucklef*cks is after you 😄

[hidden moss]

welcome to butcher creek my friend🤷‍♀️

[sudden blade]

@hidden moss

[hidden moss]

hello

[sudden blade]

how do i turn money into gold

i need naturalist kit

[hidden moss]

i dont thinkyou can do that

[sudden blade]

ok

[hidden moss]

you just gotta grind bounties and stranger missions

or u can buy it buts its not aw rewarding

[sudden blade]

ok

[woven sail]

something similar happened and I got slaughtered so.. I came back and got my revenge by killing the entire town and burning all their houses

oooh I exploded their pigs and chickens

[empty lark]

maybe by slowing down

[woven sail]

one time I punched a black dude in the face and then like thirty other black guys beat my ass

I just blow everyone up with dynamite or fire bottles

I like to see them fly

only as John

John Wayne

I meant John Wayne the actor

I'm dressed as him so I became him

my dream is to pay for internet to play online again

mobile data

[hidden moss]

made me laugh sorry😭

[woven sail]

11

[hidden moss]

ngl

i have no clue

all i know is when i play the game

my ps4 turns into a helicopter

[woven sail]

red dead redemption 2 with the magnificent seven soundtrack makes me wet

[hidden moss]

i meed a ps5 asap

[hidden moss]

that is so not pg💔💔

[woven sail]

wet as in tears

throwing men off cliffs is a great past time

excuse me?

I don't really use dual revolvers I just use one

too long to reload gets me killed

[empty lark]

deadeye instant reload

or switch guns

or just not use up so many shots

[woven sail]

I don't always have dead eye or tonics

[empty lark]

or just get behind cover

[empty lark]

damn you overusing deadeye or something? I always got some to spare after every fight since im pretty good at killing without it

[woven sail]

when you're up against the entire town you use a lot

[empty lark]

must be you then cause when i go up against an entire town i take cover so that i dont have to use my deadeye a lot

[woven sail]

I like to choke the sheriff 😈

[empty lark]

Honestly it's just preference, I like using any two of the same type of gun personally but dual wielding two different guns can work out just fine

That's fine

Been using that myself lately

But instead of store bought schofields I use Calloway's and Otis Miller's

[woven sail]

you're talking to someone who did everything

7 times

about to be 8

my favorite game of all time

[empty lark]

completed the game 7 times and you still manage to run out of deadeye?

[woven sail]

hush

cover is for try hards

[empty lark]

I dont even use mine

99 cocaine gums and i ain't using any

[woven sail]

love my cocaine bruh

I like to suck like 24 shots of whiskey in Valentine then shoot all the girls I see while drunk then end up killing the whole town and waddling off to my camp LMAO

[empty lark]

Favorite horses and specific coats? Trying to find a horse that'll match an outfit more on the fancy side

[woven sail]

one time I kidnapped the Valentine sheriff 😈

I keep the horse from the first mission