red-dead-singleplayer

[analog wave]

😭

[calm shore]

Yeah...

[analog wave]

Treasure hunting I presume 😂

[calm shore]

Any good ones that'll get me a few thousands?

I've done explorer 10 as well

Heading for 100%

[analog wave]

You don't need more money bro lol, you literally can't spend it on nothing too big

Couple of horses, and that's not more than 4k if u buy all of em

[ember marsh]

If I reload my game after trying to find a horse does that give me another chance? I'm trying to find a blue roan nokota at bards crossing

[jade rampart]

guys should i play with arthur chapter 2 or john?

[ripe crown]

Can u get MFT in story

[calm shore]

I've done it previously and I was broke , got all guns and outfits.Trust me

[ripe crown]

?

?

[long galleon]

yes

from stables on chapter 4

and glitches earlier

[shut hull]

yea exactly

the lancaster repeater

[empty lark]

only been a couple days since they asked

[ember marsh]

How good and rare is the American standerbred in black? I came across when trying to find a nokota? I really wanted a nokota but this horse is fully black

[empty lark]

I wouldn't say it's rare, but it's a fine horse

Horse choice in story don't matter much

As long as you can make it work for what you do and you like it then it'll be good enough

[slow pagoda]

still waiting for @chrome leaf to become cat boy

🐱

[shut breach]

whats the best sorta horse for going fast for a long time

im using the free black horse from the stables in valentine, and i have been since i started the game

[empty lark]

missouri fox trotter

arabians

turkomans are good too, but they're not as fast

[shut breach]

do you know what kind of horse the free race horse from the stables is

[empty lark]

Honestly I think any horse you got a lvl 4 bond with can run for an incredibly long time before it gets exhausted

[ember marsh]

Alright I'm keeping it. I tried getting the nokota I did as you said but no luck. I kinda like it as I had the white arabian in chapter 6. Found the white arabian easier then the nokota from my memory. I did have a nokota in the stables but I'm in epilogue now

[empty lark]

just depends how fast it is

[empty lark]

Since pressing whatever button it is for you to calm the horse while riding it restores a bunch of stamina in the meter at lvl4

[long galleon]

fr

[long galleon]

u can get one for free

from stable

[serene isle]

U guys saw the tombstone redemption thing

Thags gonna be so awesome

[long galleon]

what?

[serene isle]

Its on my birthday aswell

The cast of rdr2 is going to tombstone arizona

[long galleon]

pl

ok

put it in medai

media

[serene isle]

have u seen the movie tombstone

[long galleon]

no

[serene isle]

its a fantastic western

[long galleon]

ok

[serene isle]

i want them to give rdr2 the same treatment tlou got

and make a tv show

[ember marsh]

I've heard you can save Mark Johnson by freeing him at his execution. Where does his execution take place? Also is it possible to miss?

[long galleon]

u want a nokota from a stable for free ?

its an easy glitch

[long galleon]

ill explain even if u dont want it

get a wagon or horse cart go to the stable u want mask if u want

then shoot roof inside it until red witness or wanted then go feed ur nokota until bonding lvl 1 and then go out and whistle

[tight halo]

Yeah the Saint Denis stable has a reverse dapple Nokota

At least in chapter 4

[long galleon]

yea

instantly when i got to chapter 4 i went to get a mft

[tight halo]

I got a Nokota and black Arabian

[long galleon]

i could get a black one too and sell it

its kinda a money glitch too

[solemn turtle]

guys what do the grey rectangles in horse stats mean?

there are white, then gold, then grey

[long galleon]

grey is like that its empty

[solemn turtle]

how do i fill them?

[long galleon]

u cant

thats the horses stats

u a new player?

[solemn turtle]

Played the online a long time ago. Now im playing the SP

[long galleon]

umm ok

idk what the gold represents but white are the real stats

or yk

[solemn turtle]

then what is the differnce between light gray and dark gray? lol

[long galleon]

idk man

i dont get what u mean

[solemn turtle]

"Speed and acceleration are represented by up to 10 bars; some are filled in white, a few more are grayed out, and the rest are blank. The filled-in bars show its base stats, while the gray ones show how far your horse can improve with different and better equipment"

found it

[long galleon]

oh yeah yeah

[tight halo]

The gold bars are stuff your tack adds, i believe. With my current Beaver pelt saddle I have 2-3 greyed out speed and 2 acceleration

[solemn turtle]

yeah its added stats from equipment

[long galleon]

what breed is johns old boy

and micah is starving his horse only half cores man wtf

im sitting in a tunnel hiding from cops in saint denis and 3 cats just came sitting here

now its following me when i said "hey cat😀 "

[long galleon]

WHAT

there are zombies

wow

[umbral grove]

wdym

[tight halo]

How do y’all stay focused on the story, I spend so much time doing other things I forget to do the missions, lol

[jade rampart]

guys is it better to play with prime arthur or john?

[umbral grove]

no idea

i mainly just freeroamed lmao

[tight halo]

I can legit be gone from camp for real life days, and never get bored

[umbral grove]

same

[tight halo]

I go hunting, treasure hunting, searching for collectables, antagonizing gangs, etc

[long galleon]

in a forest

[umbral grove]

in lemoyne?

[long galleon]

i got back from a robbing stage coach thing with micah saw a hanged dude and shot it down and zombies came at me with knives

one killed me

[umbral grove]

night folk

[long galleon]

so reloaded save gotta do mission again

[umbral grove]

encountered that twice

it’s night folk

[long galleon]

night folk? what are those

they look like zombies

[umbral grove]

some weird ass people you can encounter in the night of bluewater marsh lemoyne

theres also a crying girl if you get too close to her she’ll attack and if you follow her you’ll encounter multiple of em

basically the closest thing to zombies in rdr2

[long galleon]

they came from a swamp

[long galleon]

ive seen that

not encountered tho

[umbral grove]

i just shot her in the head with a shotgun while on my horse

[oak wind]

I've yet to encounter the night folk because i'm too scared to travel through the swamp at night

[long galleon]

why its just a game

[umbral grove]

i’ve been thru that before

[long galleon]

i was just going home

[oak wind]

I will happily travel through tall tree's but at night in the swamp is a big no

[jade rampart]

bru can someone answer my question?

[long galleon]

just saw headless kieran cool

[umbral grove]

in what rdr2?

[long galleon]

bro why

[jade rampart]

yea

[umbral grove]

arthur

[long galleon]

is it that scary

[jade rampart]

alr ty imma delete my saves

[umbral grove]

it’s terrifying irl tbh

[oak wind]

I found the dead blackwater athletics team at night and it scared tf outta me

[long galleon]

its not irl

rip kieran

[tight halo]

Night folk surprise attacked me (didn’t know they existed) and I haven’t been in the swamp since

[oak wind]

I hate going through tall tree's and seeing the dead npc icon on the map

[crystal oyster]

ayo anybody remember the man in black John attempted to shoot in RDR 1?

[oak wind]

The strange man

[umbral grove]

yeah

the strange man

[oak wind]

The strange man is the reason the cholera spread around Armadillo

[umbral grove]

he is also theoretically death

[long galleon]

YEA I SAW IT and got there sorry for caps had dead eye

[oak wind]

He has an abandoned shack outside of Saint Denis too

[long galleon]

and shot it down and they attacked me

[umbral grove]

yes

[long galleon]

what

why yall so scared

they dont look that scary

i shot them with a shotgun

[oak wind]

The strange man is a weird story

[long galleon]

but one killed me from behind

so reloaded save 😄
'

[umbral grove]

im not

i never died to them before

and i encountered them twice lol

[tight halo]

Ok but I’m carrying almost 5k, I was on foot, without my guns. If I die a lose a decent chunk of money. I don’t want to lose my hard earned money

[crystal oyster]

well yes but actually no, I believe he's Cain from the bible

[oak wind]

Anyone ever read up about what blindman cassidy means when you give him a dollar everytime you see him

[long galleon]

I LOST 90 bucks too

[tight halo]

Last time I died I lost 150, I hate losing money

[umbral grove]

i never read the bible who’s that

[oak wind]

On my save rn i have 84,000$

[long galleon]

yea but i kinda let one come to me so it killed me i thought i could break free

[long galleon]

yea i reloaded save too

[long galleon]

u can get alot of gold bars in new austin and blackwater

and respawning ones too

[oak wind]

I've found all gold bars i think

[crystal oyster]

God said in genesis that if anyone tries to kill Cain, Cain won't die and the one who attempted the kill will deserve 7x the sentence he was about to do.
John shot at the man in black 3 times and he died because of 21 bullets (7x3)

[oak wind]

He is also buried where Johm tried shooting him

[crystal oyster]

yup

[oak wind]

Him, Abigail, uncle

Gun jammed which is him sparing Jack

[crystal oyster]

so, is my theory good enough

?

[long galleon]

one can respawn or 2 it was in the video

watch player 7 named dude on youtube

and top 5 money glitch

[crystal oyster]

well, you should xD
I'm not that religious but that dude named Jesus is a good teacher lol

[long galleon]

i wont

read

[umbral grove]

I personally think he’s death since he claims he’s an accountant and had made deals with people in the past (herbert moon being the only survivor during the cholera plague outbreak) and john shot him 3 times yes but tried shooting him a 4th time but his gun jammed which i believe to be uncle, john, and abigail and the 4th bullet was jack but he was the only survivor which is why the gun jammed

but i saw that theory before and thought it was pretty interesting

[umbral grove]

maybe lol

[long galleon]

cain is a good dog

[oak wind]

The Rhodes gun smith had a son who died after the recoil of a gun sent him into a river, but why does the town all feel guilty about it though?

[long galleon]

they dont

[crystal oyster]

because @oak wind has a great cohesion despite what the old man said

[long galleon]

i just got the free lancaster from him

[long galleon]

idk why micah hates it

thats why to always antagonize him

cain on top

[oak wind]

The NPC's in Rhodes have dialogues where they talk about the gun smiths son and how he's been seeing the ghost of his son around town

[long galleon]

wow

but that dont mean they guilty

[oak wind]

Some of the townsfolk do feel guilty though

[long galleon]

cain is cain

[oak wind]

But i can't seem to find why they do

[long galleon]

i believe that cain is cain

[oak wind]

What did everyone do to that racist guy in Saint Denis?

[crystal oyster]

Cain's name (the good doggo) which was put my Dutch came from the bible as Dutch said it

[long galleon]

still cain is cain

[crystal oyster]

made him regret all he said since nobody gave a damn about him

[long galleon]

bible cain maybe

[long galleon]

what

whos that

[crystal oyster]

the dude who says racist things next to a police

[long galleon]

ok

idk him

[oak wind]

I took him up to colter and then executed him

[crystal oyster]

Hello gays

today we will have a list of top 1 Capybara

numero 1

@oak wind

[umbral grove]

fed him to an alligator

[oak wind]

I was up in Colter once and some random NPC was there

No idea who he was

[long galleon]

bros praising him

[long galleon]

ill prolly kill him

[oak wind]

[long galleon]

ill feed someone to an alligator i wanna see what happens

[long galleon]

why not me

[oak wind]

I think NPC's kick alligators to death

[umbral grove]

the alligator just bites once then hes dead

and the alligator runs off

[long galleon]

damn

well still

[long galleon]

ive tried it once

got eaten

i sneaked up behind and it bit me first then started shaking me

and i died

[oak wind]

Doesn't the legendary alligator die of a heart attack after it's chased you for a while

[long galleon]

ill feed these 2 lemoyne raiders who i knocked out

other one tied up

but kicked himm

[oak wind]

I love going to a lemoyne raider camp and throwing a stick of dynamite in there

[long galleon]

he got mad at me when i greeted him so i yanked him with my lasso

and disarmed and then tied up

then other came and i knocked him out and soon its his time

[oak wind]

Don't know why but i love shooting travellers out in the heartlands with the varmint rifle

[long galleon]

LMAO

there was a dude with a snake bite

i rode to him and he said no god and started running and died

wish i could have saved him so i could have gotten something for free

[oak wind]

I saved that dude because he can get me a free item in the gun store

[long galleon]

but lost honor automatically

[long galleon]

well i couldnt he just ran away

i just lost honor when he died

maybe cus he saw that tied up lemoyne

wait it was that dude who ate an oleander he had that yellow thing on his shirt

lost a bunch of honor there wow

but it dont matter to me

[oak wind]

I was at Rhodes station earlier and i threw a knife over the station and all of a sudden it said there was a witness to murder

[long galleon]

the alligator is just waiting

heart attack

wow

it attacked me from a few meters away

[limber sapphire]

💀

[oak wind]

I love when those street urchins talk shit in the alley ways in Saint Denis and all it takes to shut them up is to pull out a gun and point it at them

[long galleon]

whats this tree

it has blood on it

or it looks like

[long galleon]

the kids?

[oak wind]

Yes

[long galleon]

yea im gonna kill em on my low ass honor save

[oak wind]

They can't be killed

[long galleon]

on this one i dont care that much but wanna keep it in middle

[long galleon]

dynamite

[oak wind]

I think they just get up

I kept hitting one with my horse and he kept getting up and running

[long galleon]

hell nah

i seen a video when someone killed em

with dynamite

[long galleon]

hhow can i feed someone to an alligator

it bit me instead

but didnt die

[umbral grove]

you have to hogtie someone then drop them right in front of the gator

[long galleon]

i did

but MY HORSE

NO
o

[umbral grove]

your horse died?

[long galleon]

well i saved recently

[long galleon]

yea train

[umbral grove]

jesus

[long galleon]

and cant revive rn got the law on me

[umbral grove]

hate when that happens

[long galleon]

fr

my mft

[umbral grove]

maybe just shoot him instead lol

[long galleon]

who

nah i wanna do that

its gonna look funny

now im helping some dude who getting robbed

and his wife

[long galleon]

no

they need food too

the kids wont blow up

😦

[long galleon]

yea they dont react to it just running to momma

[flat rapids]

how to open basement? i made 3 pieces of map about killer

[native stone]

Best method do get the new austin plants as arthur?

[flat rapids]

or is it bug?

[native stone]

Open the map

And ? Icon shop pop up

When you are near the basement

[flat rapids]

I just open map and im in basement

probably its bug

[flat rapids]

i sent you dm

screenshot

[long galleon]

fishing is kinda fun

got a 18 lbs fish

is that big?

[radiant girder]

yeah

[long galleon]

cool i cooked it

shot this gray 18 times he killed my horse

[oak wind]

I just ran at a guy sat on a bench and he died

[long galleon]

yea thats gta v logic too

[long galleon]

2 dudes just fought at me for nothing and then they go away when they wake up

[slender grove]

hi if i want unlock the locked rifles and guns in gunsmith i need continue in story?

[long galleon]

im gonna carry the other to a boat

[long galleon]

yes

[steady venture]

a sad ending better than a "good" one

[long galleon]

@empty lark

hey was it u searching for american paint

[empty lark]

not anymore

i finished that

[outer yoke]

why is my white arabian just not spawning?

[long galleon]

from some dudes camp i found one

[steady venture]

did you finsh the bear mission with hosea?

[long galleon]

i got to some random dudes camp in swamp area and he has and american paint

[outer yoke]

you have to finish that?

[empty lark]

i needed a wild one

[outer yoke]

i thought it was just chapter 2

[empty lark]

not one someone else had

[steady venture]

yes

[long galleon]

it got away

[steady venture]

also make sure you go to the right part of the lake

[long galleon]

is it rare

if someone had it

[outer yoke]

ohhhh lmao thank you!

[steady venture]

near the burnt down house

[empty lark]

idk

[steady venture]

and if you cant find it even after that you prob spooked it so go down to the valentine hotel and sleep and it will respawn

[long galleon]

should i go get it

[steady venture]

what you talking about?

[long galleon]

american paint

i found

[steady venture]

maybe im stupid

[long galleon]

some dude had a camp and it was there

[steady venture]

take it

[long galleon]

so its rare?

in wild it is ig

[steady venture]

yea

if you dont want it you can sell it

[long galleon]

how much it sell for

cause i will

i dont need it

[steady venture]

afew 100 from what i remember

[long galleon]

i wanna get a wild one thats a flex

[long galleon]

thats good

and if i bring to that one dude near caliga hall i get more i guess

[steady venture]

yea

[long galleon]

cause they pay even more for stolen horses

[steady venture]

also i said i THINK so mb if im wrong

[long galleon]

yea yea

no need to be sure

should i use a turkoman or mft

[long galleon]

it doesnt have a saddle so idk

but it counts as stolen

i didnt need to tame it

[steady venture]

ill be honest

i havent played rdr2 in along time

just got back into it

so im just going off of memory

[long galleon]

oh ok

[lost gale]

Why do the stables also have a symbol showing a pelt next to it?
Dies one of my horses still have a pelt stored?

[long galleon]

bro its 11 dollars lmao

[steady venture]

31 dollars to my name 😭

[long galleon]

lol

few hundred lol

[steady venture]

my horse bruh

[long galleon]

i think u had the wrong horse there

[steady venture]

i got jumped by bounty hunters

[long galleon]

:DDD

[long galleon]

kill em

[steady venture]

my horse at full hp i kill all of em one of em comes out the damn trees and double barrels my horse

[long galleon]

damnn

what breed was it

[steady venture]

insta killed him cant even revive bro

arabian

[long galleon]

well it aint that bad

bad horse

[outer yoke]

has anyone tried placing dynamite infront of the bar right before the americans at rest mission in chapter two?

[steady venture]

one good thing came outta it tho

[long galleon]

no we havent lol

[steady venture]

i made a check point about 30 mins ago right before i got to thomas downes

[long galleon]

?

[steady venture]

so now i get to beat the shit outta him again

[outer yoke]

i saw a video about it, does it really work though?

[steady venture]

:DDD

[long galleon]

what would it do

[long galleon]

bro hates him

[outer yoke]

when you walk out of the bar, you have to fight the guy, the dynamite would explode and kill the dude

[steady venture]

i despise the fucker

[long galleon]

oh yea

[steady venture]

all he had to do

[long galleon]

why

[steady venture]

was sell his wife

simple

[long galleon]

but why u hating on him for that

[steady venture]

then give me the money = no tb

he gave bro tb

made it impossible to eat shit for 2 chapters

[long galleon]

yea cause u beat him and he spit blood

or coughede

he couldnt have really done nothing

[long galleon]

u can eat bro

what u mean

[steady venture]

ik

sometimes it doesnt work

[long galleon]

what

yes i can eat all the time if i want to

[steady venture]

it would only restore haif the core from

if i eat too much i get overweight arthur

then i spend about 2 hours cuz the weight system is hellish

[long galleon]

why u letting him starve

like that no cores

man the food from saloon it restores fully what

[steady venture]

i just remembered that the saloon food does that

thanks g

like i said im going off of very rough memory

[long galleon]

yea but it dont do that

just eat sum from ur inventory

man fuck these bounty hunters RUINED MY CHANCES OF TRACKING THAT LEGENDARY FOX

[red helm]

Cooking up Big Game Meat with a Herb is the best food.

[steady venture]

oh my fucking god

[long galleon]

any meat restores alot too

[red helm]

Pay off your bounty and quit doing crimes.

[long galleon]

no

[steady venture]

i hate bounty hunters more than thomas

[red helm]

Quit whining then.

[long galleon]

i like to do crimes

but they have to be in every spot

[red helm]

[steady venture]

bro i was trying to do challenges for legend of the east sat

[long galleon]

and just come when im tracking

[long galleon]

thats 700

in valentine bounty

atleast

other like 300

1k

even more

[steady venture]

and my panther pelt got ruined when i was trying to 1 hit it they missed haif the shots and layed into my godamn panther

[long galleon]

:((

[red helm]

Smh... During my low honor play through, I rarely had over $20's, anywhere.

[steady venture]

also fuck susan "i noticed you stopped donating to the box mr morgan" even tho i put 342 dollars into the box

[long galleon]

500 it was in valentine

[long galleon]

what man im at like half honor

[red helm]

I kept my Honor at Minimum.

[long galleon]

bro why u even donate that much

[steady venture]

cuz

[red helm]

You just have to know how to not get caught when you are lowering your honor.

[long galleon]

why

[long galleon]

i dont lower it i kill people

it aint fun if u just try to lower it

[steady venture]

i wanted to upgrade everything i could with money

[red helm]

I'd kill people do. I just wouldn't get any bounties while I was doing that.

[long galleon]

idk how

at saint denis if u get some conflict with cops

then shoot a few

its 200 bounty

easily

[red helm]

I'd sit on a road, Kill a random traveler, loot the corpse, wait for a Witness, kill that dude, Loot them. Wait for a Witness... Lather Rinse, Repeat. If a Witness ever got to far away, I'd turn and flee before the Law got there.
No Bounty $.

[steady venture]

is there diff voicelines from mary beth if you go high honor?

[red helm]

No...?

[steady venture]

aw

well i got no reason to go high honor ig

[long galleon]

💀 '

[steady venture]

other than micahs scar

[red helm]

Don't kill people in Saint Denis, obviously. You get a bounty for just looking in the direction of a cop, there.

[long galleon]

yea but i like it

[long galleon]

u get that in the knife fight

[red helm]

Well, again, don't whine when you have bounty hunters messing up your hunting.

[long galleon]

idk its boring

[red helm]

There are 2 High Honor endings, that are different scenes and such. So, whatever.

[long galleon]

if u so trying to get low honor and all

high honor is nice too

[red helm]

Play the game as you will. One time to lower my honor, I went and slaughtered a whole ranch of Cows... I also needed a bull Pelt.

[long galleon]

well im just near a ranch

ill go get one

[red helm]

It was pretty funny, seeing like a dozen cows there... a tad sad too. and the dumb ranchers that tried to stop me.

[steady venture]

isnt johns revolver the fastest revolver you can get

or am i wrong about that

[red helm]

Most revolvers are basically the same speed.

[long galleon]

why do i lose honor for protecting myself from these stupid bloodhounds that the bounty hunters send after me

i dont get ti

[steady venture]

i hate bloodhounds

the most bullshit annoying pieces of useless filth in the game

[red helm]

I guess because Rockstar set them as normal dogs, and never cared to set them as otherwise?

[long galleon]

yea

cockstar

[red helm]

Yeap.

[steady venture]

why do i lose honor when i throw a poisoned throwing knife into a bloodhounds leg??

i dont understand

[red helm]

😆

[long galleon]

stupid dogs coming at ur hands biting

i usually kick them after they get to attack

and wolves too are some pieces of shit

attack different times

and when u shoot one other comes from behind

[steady venture]

i have the most easy shots to kill every single one of the bounty hunters they all grouped up as soon as im about to shot the dynamte arrow one of those lil shits

bite my arm then i get layed into and im faced towards the hound

so im getting backshots no homo

and bit from the front

[long galleon]

wth is wrong man rhodes this dude got a band aid on his head i never shoot clerks

and all clerks are mad at me

[steady venture]

rhodes is the most unhinged town

other than val

every time i go to val

this godamn shop owner

starts talking all that shit

[tulip arch]

sorry to butt in. But does anyone know how i can share my ENB settings that i manually configured?

[long galleon]

yea

and now this dude "how do i put this hurry the hell up"

ill shoot him next time he says that shit

[steady venture]

than i just do the normal go back to my horse get my bow rob him so i can pull out my bow as i walk out the back door hit him in the leg with a dynamte arrow and watch him start screaming cuz he just lost his leg and hand

it would be fun if i could pull out my shotgun or both revolvers instead of what the game just picks for me

[long galleon]

now i beat this dumbass clerk up the gun store cler

started shooting

[steady venture]

hear me out

varmint rifle is the best way to make the npcs suffer

[long galleon]

now he shot at the law

and they after him

[long galleon]

should i buy?

[steady venture]

ye its free

[long galleon]

it aint free for me

85 dollars

[steady venture]

wait are you playing online?

[long galleon]

no

story

[steady venture]

i think its not free at some shops

[long galleon]

he dead on the ground and with a bandaid already lmao

[steady venture]

try valentine

[long galleon]

where is it free

[steady venture]

lol

valentine i think

[long galleon]

ok i will

[long galleon]

what u mean

[steady venture]

ok so

the bullets are for small game

like rabbits and shit

so they hurt the most

and the least amount of dmg

[tulip wolf]

The actual best way to make NPCs suffer is with mortal shots to the neck

They'll slowly bleed out to death

[steady venture]

for me only haif works with neck shots

[tulip wolf]

I've been able to pull those out with M1899, Cattleman, Lancaster, and carbine repeater

[steady venture]

when you hit the very end side of the neck the npc will go to grab it and fall on the floor and go into shock

[tulip wolf]

You'll know you did it when you get a dark red cross after the short, instead of the bright red one you get when you kill them

[steady venture]

its better if you turn off kill effects

[tulip wolf]

I love to do that to the npcs that just ride Infront of my horse and make me crash onto them

So that they learn some manners lol

[steady venture]

the dynamite arrow in my satchel:

[tulip wolf]

Ah, yes, it makes the fights go faster too

[tulip wolf]

Or the explosive round you randomly keep:

[steady venture]

fr

thoughts on volcanic pistol?

[tulip wolf]

Real powerful and a little faster to shoot than the cattleman, but over all it's really mid in my opinion

[long galleon]

got the legendary coyote

[long galleon]

imo its very good i dual wield them

2 shots everyone dead

[tulip wolf]

I rather go with M1899 (which is easily the fastest gun in game with the Mauser pistol) and run it with express ammo to compensate the lesser damage

Never had any problems with it accuracy related or range related

[steady venture]

what about the john marston revolver you can get from a glitch

[tulip wolf]

Of course, except when I don't clean them lol

[steady venture]

how do you happen to feel about dat

[long galleon]

what m1899

[tulip wolf]

Real bad, ngl lol

Standard cattleman is better than it

[steady venture]

highkey

[tulip wolf]

You unlock it in chapter 4

[long galleon]

i am in chapter 4

[tulip wolf]

Right when you enter chapter 4, go check the gunsmith at Saint Denis

It's a pistol

Be careful, though, you may fall in love with it's overall speed haha

[long galleon]

mauser i cant have yet

[long galleon]

idk if i will

[tulip wolf]

You can get one from Bronte in the mission "revenge is a dish best eaten"

[steady venture]

honestly i cant remember if the schofield is good or not

[long galleon]

cant i go to any else

[long galleon]

ik ik

[long galleon]

its alr

[steady venture]

or you can get one from midnight

[tulip wolf]

Mmmmm, not sure, I only saw it there, but maybe the Annesburg one works

[tulip wolf]

Yeah, but you can't modify it

So it won't be as good as the one you get from Bronte, which is just a regular one you can modify

Select the correct ammo and that gun is a dream

[steady venture]

whats the best point in chapter 4 to stop with arthur

[tulip wolf]

Leave the eagle fly's mission, don't do it

And complete every other one

The last one you should do, must be "revenge is a dish best eaten", and at that point you can only do the eagle fly's mission

Right there, that's the best point

[long galleon]

varmint was 75 dollars

[steady venture]

well shit im a godamn liar ig

[tulip wolf]

You yourself if you will hahahaha

[steady venture]

for me it was free

or im remembering wrong

[tulip wolf]

For real?

Like I got two Lancaster repeaters for free, but that?

[long galleon]

yeah micah mission and rhodes gun smith

[steady venture]

lancaster repeater the goat

[tulip wolf]

And really, I do, if Arthur knew how to dual wield rifles, I'd be dual wielding Lancaster's

[tulip wolf]

Exactly

[tulip wolf]

The absolute goat, totally

[long galleon]

semi automatic pistol i only have there

[steady venture]

for me it would be dual wielding pump actions

[long galleon]

no m1899

[tulip wolf]

I heard the Litchfield was better, but I don't feel the same

[long galleon]

sawed offs?

[tulip wolf]

In saint Denis gunsmith?

Check your game is updated

That gun was added in an update

[tulip wolf]

How so? Hahaha

[steady venture]

i love the pump

[tulip wolf]

An absolute beast, yes sir

Real gore you can get when you shoot npc's limbs off

[steady venture]

i wann it

[tulip wolf]

They'll even scream on the ground before dying

[steady venture]

peak

so

did anybody else play with free aim?

[tulip wolf]

Like total manually aim?

[long galleon]

it was in valentine

[steady venture]

yes

[long galleon]

but no

[steady venture]

no aim assist at all

[long galleon]

i havent checked from saint denis

[tulip wolf]

Oh, no, valentine will not have it, that I know for sure

[long galleon]

i cant have aim assist

[steady venture]

yeah but you got the better way of aimming

a mouse

mods

etc

[tulip wolf]

I tried it for a bit, but for quick headshots I found a little strategy where you slightly let go of the aim trigger, press it again, then aim a little higher and shoot, 90% of the times you'll get a headshot if there's nothing between the target's head and you, and if Arthur didn't decide to tremble lol

[long galleon]

oh the varmint is so damn gory

i got the dark red thing too

[long galleon]

not using

[steady venture]

not even clothing mods?

[tulip wolf]

Mmm, well that's right, though I have no mouse haha

[steady venture]

one second annoying ass bounty hunters found me

[tulip wolf]

Oh Lord, if I was him I would mod the Saint Denis police outfit Arthur got to free roam with it

Or the one from the mayor's party

[long galleon]

no my 1050 ti prolly cant run mods

[tulip wolf]

Try not to shoot their dogs 😦

[steady venture]

their dogs bro

[tulip wolf]

They will run off once you kill all the bounty hunters

[steady venture]

get me killed almost every time if i dont shoot them first

oh thanks

[tulip wolf]

Try to get them on horse

[long galleon]

they came at me alone recently

[steady venture]

bros life is just rdr2

same

[tulip wolf]

So like riding and shooting at them

[tulip wolf]

Oh, damn, I thought that didn't happen

[steady venture]

funfact

[long galleon]

killed mickey with varmint its funny

[steady venture]

dogs can also die slowly

[tulip wolf]

Ah, yes, same as wolfs

[steady venture]

what did cuh even do

istg

[tulip wolf]

They'll run off a bit after the shot and then fall to the ground and slowly die

[steady venture]

ive been trying to do the horsemen 9 challenge for days

harder then the gambler challenges

for me

[tulip wolf]

Wait, what's that one?

[long galleon]

Who

[steady venture]

van horn to black water

in 17m dry run

[tulip wolf]

Ok, wait, I'll get you the map

[steady venture]

its rained

about 23 times

[long galleon]

oh god the screams from the neck shots

[steady venture]

im trying to do the lote arthur glitch

[steady venture]

ikr

[long galleon]

worst thing ive seen in a while

[steady venture]

i wish there was more voice actors for the suffering sfxs

[long galleon]

other than gore videos

[steady venture]

i mean

ive got a video if you wanna see worse

[tulip wolf]

Here

Oh

Can't send photos

[long galleon]

sure

media

media put it there

[long galleon]

media

[steady venture]

i cant send a gore vid in media

[long galleon]

saved the game and im doing some varmint rampages rn

im tryna kill malloy the gory way

[tight halo]

Oh yeah, on the night folk topic, they can one shot you. When you’re wealthy, a one shot is concerning

[frigid sundial]

Where can l sell the jewelry people ‘’gave’’ me?

[tulip wolf]

Fence

[dreamy trench]

Yes I get plenty of “willing” patrons who give me “donations”

[midnight river]

almost completed gambler 9

then a train came and killed my horse

so i reloaded a save

so now I have to restart

[median swift]

How do I mod rdr 2 campaign?

[lime stratus]

Is it better to donate carcasses to Pearson, or to sell them at the butcher?

On that note, how long 'til the butcher comes back? I accidentally frightened the poor fellow away by having my lasso out

[shut breach]

lice, opinion on the lemat

[empty lark]

Donating to the camp food pot doesn't really matter at all

[lime stratus]

Apologies, I'm yet to acquire it - I'm only in Chapter 2 lol
Love the Panzerkampfwagen VI Tiger pfp, by the way

[shut breach]

thank you, its a small metal replica

[shut breach]

i just got ripped fomr my horse and eaten by a mountain lion

wth

[thorn terrace]

I just spent 4 HOURS finding a perfect badger just for me to shoot it in the wrong spot

Any tips

[red helm]

Eris Field(North of Rhodes, South of Emerald Ranch), or around Riggs Station(East of Strawberry. and I think night time is better for them.

[umbral grove]

you can do both from chp 2 but you need to be in chp 4 to continue the gunslinger quest

[lime stratus]

Why the bloomin' heck does this Seamus fellow decide not to open that wagon fence of his half the time?

[fleet gull]

Just used mods to spawn in micah. Gave him a rolling block and he used it like a shotgun 💀

[fleet gull]

Time of day or recent actions

[fleet gull]

What clothing item is that for

[tight halo]

Ok, I raced a lady with a fancy horse, and she didnt give me anything when I won? is this normal?

[empty lark]

yeah those races are for perks or upgrades or whatever with horses, i think something like your bond increases faster with them after the races

[tight halo]

I did one with a dude that upped my bond, but that race with the girl did nothing

[shut breach]

does rdr2 have a new game plus?

[empty lark]

no

just new game

[shut breach]

damn

i want ot replay hte game with op endgame equipment, like maxed out lemat revolvers, a carcano rifle, my good repeater, and dynamite for days

[hidden moss]

How can i get eyepatches

[empty lark]

eyepatches are only in online, getting them in story is only through modding

[hidden moss]

[slow pagoda]

that widow after I shot those wolves really said "man your crazy" and proceeds to starve in a day

Im not going back to guarm just to save her been there war ship that

[long galleon]

Yea thats what that did to me

Im trying to get them again soon that was fun killing em with a shotgun

Is malloy a bad dude or a good dude

[slow pagoda]

hes good

[long galleon]

Who was that bad sheriff

Someone said he was or something

[slow pagoda]

the one in new austin

[long galleon]

Ohh

Whos that

[slow pagoda]

idk hes the one based off the historic black sheriff except this time He went mad and power hungry

thats the reason why its a ghost town in rd1

[long galleon]

But what name

[slow pagoda]

:Shrug_2b:

[long galleon]

And someone in this server hates u

Chib hates u

[slow pagoda]

one day its my goal to make that everyone

[long galleon]

Well i dont like but i dont hate u either

[long galleon]

Why

[slow pagoda]

Low honor run

[long galleon]

U die either way

[slow pagoda]

we all die you either kill yourself or get killed

[long galleon]

👍

[slow pagoda]

🕺

[long galleon]

🦧

[jade rampart]

Why cant i bounty hunt?

[long galleon]

should i steal this mans stuff

someone who crashed

with a wagon and said i need to watch his stuff

i did i lost a bit of honor

i took a bit

he passed out

wasting my damn time

[wispy lily]

why is master hunter 3 so annoying

[tulip arch]

why cant there be new melee weapons in the game with mods. like fighting with pitchforks

[ember marsh]

I believe new bounties unlock each chapter. You can do them all in the epilogue

[jade rampart]

i am at epilogue 2 🫤

[oak wind]

I just entered Valentine and the sheriff is on the floor dead

[tulip arch]

died suddenly

[slow pagoda]

he comes back noooooo

[slim steeple]

Anyone know where I can find a full version of "May I, stand unshaken"/"Crash your world" (whatever it's called) but the low honor version? I found one, but it's way shorter than the high honor one

[dull geyser]

Go in heartlands or the area around owanjila

The most tedious challenge in master hunter is the 6th one

[ivory crescent]

Hey, installed mods and law is being alerted or I'm being shot without doing anything bad on the first mission after intro.

[bold pagoda]

usually the best fix when I have issues like that is to just remove the mods, put them in a folder outside of game directory, and play the mission w/o mods

[ivory crescent]

Does that fix anything tho?

It happens everywhere too, NPCs are hostile on sight

[bold pagoda]

what mods?

[lethal whale]

why does the Valentine saloon get shut down permanently

[hidden moss]

heart attack

[slim steeple]

What do you mean?

[normal relic]

The saloon never permanently closes

[slim steeple]

That's what I thought

[fair gulch]

rains fall: good. there was no need to harm them *runs over a rabbit*

[normal relic]

I've gone there several times and it's always open

[slim steeple]

Literally

[normal relic]

I haven't played for 2 weeks

I know what I was gonna do last time

[slim steeple]

Pretty much same lmao

[normal relic]

Lmao I said screw it with the challenges in story tried for like the 6th time lol

[slim steeple]

Lol

[normal relic]

I fully gave up lol

My brain couldn't handle trying to win the last 2 or 3 poker games

[hidden moss]

Bro had a heart attack

[oak wind]

My fiancee is playing RDR2 while i eat something and she just shot Sheriff Malloy

[fleet gull]

I just

Spawned

Like

Ten dutches

I killed all but three before I died

When I respawn

They all have HORSES

And are chasing me 💀

[small briar]

Haven’t been playing for long, but was wondering, why do so fra players use their mics while online?

*few

[empty lark]

This is the story channel but probably because anyone somewhat closeby can hear you with your mic, or they just prefer using some other way to talk

[hidden moss]

Three horsemen of the apocalypse

[fair gulch]

ive noticed theres a lot of missions that start like this:

mission says character needs to speak with you, arthur starts talking to them, completely different character comes in and asks arthur to do something and the mission has nothing to do with the character arthur was talking to

[hidden moss]

what did you spawn them in with?

with rampage trainer the only dutch you can spawn is unkillable and part of gnag

[slim steeple]

That's actually pretty true. Somehow I never noticed that 😂

[slim steeple]

Nvm, found one

[fair gulch]

the real van der linde gang

[fleet gull]

Incorrect. I did use rampage, but I adjusted settings so I didn’t have a relation with anyone I spawned. This meant I could kill anyone I spawned, including dutch

[fleet gull]

Yes

[fleet gull]

Thats what I thought lol

[ember marsh]

Yeah it kinda annoyed me. In chapter 2 there's cool missions with smaller characters but they later on they all become what you described. I wish we got more with trelawny. That casino boat mission with him is one of my favourite missions by far

[shut breach]

i want to rob a bank with sadie

[limber sapphire]

Im done with rdo

Super buggy

And grindy

Atleast I got to rank 50

Time to start story

[fair gulch]

ive never touched online and likely never will

[hidden moss]

If I take out the Aberdeen’s before I interact with them, will I still be able to loot the house?

[empty lark]

sure, but there's not really much of anything to take

Just let them live until ch6, then let them drug you after you get there so that their house will still have Arthur's money for you to reclaim in the epilogue

not really any other point to seeing them anyways ig

[limber sapphire]

Doing master hunter challenges rn

I could probably finish them in a few hours

[split olive]

Is it worth to keep some keepsakes and transfer them over to John than give them to the camp members? Like the pocket mirror and harmonica

[limber sapphire]

They server little purpose

In return for giving items to the gang you get special ammo and stuff

Special provisions

Upgrades to the stew

Etc.

[split olive]

Which they are also worthless for me expect the scout jacket and spurs kind of stuff

[limber sapphire]

Do what you want but you’re far better off giving the items

[split olive]

Never heard that before, what kind of upgrade?

[limber sapphire]

Gives you golden cores

If you get Ms Grimshaws interaction

[split olive]

Also can you do home and shop robberies side quests as john after epilogue? Or do you have to do those as Arthur?

[bright dawn]

You can rob stores and rob coaches as john

Also guys

Ive tried the train robbery trick by taking a train from ER to annesburg

But the train isnt moving in Annesburg

No matter how far away i go or how long i wait

Anyone know what i can do to get it moving, without getting immediately shot at + a 50 dollar bounty?

[split olive]

What about the gang hideouts, can you do them as John?

And also I read that the ancient viking comb and Jimmy's pen is not transferring to John. Is this true?

[bright dawn]

Yeah you can find gang hideouts

[bright dawn]

Im not sure i initially sold the pen lol

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

But not odriscal camps

[split olive]

I cannot make that dutch's pipe request Spawn, I'm in chapter 3. Any tips?

[limber sapphire]

Yeah idk how to spawn that

[split olive]

So i must do all odriscoll camps with Arthur?

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

6 point cabin

And some other places

What’s even the point

Are u trying to 100%

If so most of the enemy camps are done for you through missions

[split olive]

I'm trying to get everything in game

Not only 100%

[limber sapphire]

You should be good

Just do del lobo gang hideouts

And you’ll be finished with that

[split olive]

Currently I'm having difficulties spawning the carolina paraket and taking the murfree prisoners and Ransom notes

And ofc spawning the dutch pipe request

Any tips on these?

[limber sapphire]

Yt

[bright dawn]

^ how can i get a train to move while its in town at the station

[empty lark]

wait or move the train yourself by kicking the driver out and getting a bounty

annesburg trains sometimes wont move at all though

it's just something that happens there, can either accept the bounty and rob a train from somewhere else or keep trying

[drifting glade]

so I completed American venom but forgot to save afterwards, but the good thing is I saved right before American venom so it’s all good

[bright dawn]

The only time i was able to rob a train w/o a bounty is through the annesburg tunnel thing

[empty lark]

can either accept the bounty and rob a train from somewhere else
or keep trying(in annesburg)

[cosmic lotus]

[radiant girder]

wow man

that sure is a kneeslapper

[broken arch]

hmmmm

chapter 6 sad to play

[tepid jewel]

what to do after completing rdr2?

[empty lark]

complete all the challenge sets, 100% the game, start a new playthrough and play differently, mass murder, make your best outfits and post them here, whatever works for you

[tepid jewel]

alright

[broken arch]

im gonna finish chapter 6 today

[red helm]

Fun, fun.

[limber sapphire]

Do all treasure hunts, hunt all legendary animals, do all the challenges, collect cigarette cards

[hidden moss]

I’m in Guarma

[thin plank]

am I the only one who has played the story more than 1 time?🤭🧐

[lost gale]

How the heck did Jack get kidnapped?
Did he wander off and outside camp?

[thin plank]

idk maybe

[lost gale]

So the game doesn't even explain in the end how he disappeared or fell into the hands of that old plantation hag and their brood?

[tepid jewel]

idk probably so the game can introduce saint denis

[wise hound]

Just finished completely upgrading the camp

and I still havent got micah out of jail

[wicked lintel]

I’d leave him in there if I could

[lost gale]

I despise Micah even more when he starts sucking up to Dutch and the gang at the last quarter of chapter 3.
Like the whole O Driscoll shit for example

[autumn spade]

The Braithwaites found the camp. Keiran saw them

[lost gale]

Ah okay

[ebon sable]

What happens to all your money and gear after you start playing as John?

[hidden moss]

Can anyone help me? I just need 1 more knife called jawbone knife to complete my weapon compendium. I've got the knife and my weapon compendium in game shows 74/74 but in social club It only shows 73/74. The social club doesn't count or update the jawbone knife on its weapon compendium, I have tried killing people with it so many times, but it didn't work. (Edit: I have found a fix, I had to kill an animal with the knife to trigger it in social club. Basically shoot an animal with a poison arrow to stop it from getting away and then just kill it with the knife)

[empty lark]

Money disappears, only way to keep it is if you let the aberdeen pig farm couple drug you as arthur and take your money, go back to the house in the epilogue, and reclaim it

all clothing and weapons are kept and transferred to john, tonics and some other items are lost as well, i can't remember them all but you get to keep every piece of clothing you own and every weapon you've found or bought

[ebon sable]

Okay thank you

[lost gale]

Question about those cigarette cards. Can I sell them or do I need to keep them in my bag ?
They kinda start clogging my satchel

[empty lark]

there's a guy at Flatneck Station who will buy entire sets of cigarette cards

Collect a whole set, mail them to him, he'll send back a reward which is a required item to make one of the trinkets or talismans or whatever they're called, something you can make at a fence that is visible on your outfit + stat buff

[lost gale]

Good to know.
Man....there are so many cards

[limber sapphire]

Damn bruh

Giaguaro is so fast

That caught me off guard

[empty lark]

there's a small window that when it's on you, you can throw it off

it's very small, i only got it because i started mashing the button as soon as i heard it running at me

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

Not much of a problem

He had a lucky spawn

Where he was right infront of me

[empty lark]

just sneak around the edge of the zone is how i did it

[limber sapphire]

So I got a easy kill

Few shots with a shotgun and you’re good

[empty lark]

i got into a nice and open spot before attracting it, had a really clear shot when it charged at me

[limber sapphire]

Yeah

1st time I tried

He was to the left of me

And I didn’t expect it

[normal relic]

[surreal aurora]

I just beat the main story for the first time and I'm about done with the epilog, is there anything that John can't do that's crucial for the 100% completion?

[proven ingot]

anyone know where i can sell all my valuables/jewelry i got a ton

[surreal aurora]

The fence

[crimson herald]

Wow I’ve been collecting them all this time without knowing that I can sell them.

[proven ingot]

can you like maybe show it, idk where that is

can you like circle it on the map

[empty lark]

there's multiple

one at emerald ranch

one in saint denis

[proven ingot]

o

[empty lark]

one outside of rhodes

[proven ingot]

where in saint denis

[empty lark]

one in van horn

[proven ingot]

thats where i am the closest rn

[empty lark]

near the trapper

[proven ingot]

found it

ty

[surreal aurora]

You can find more if you go into your map and use your index

[tight halo]

Dang rip Kieran

[dense nest]

he was a real one

[dreamy trench]

He was an O’driscoll!

[tight halo]

He cared for the horses!

[fossil brook]

Guys I'm stupid i sold the thing needed for the alligator trinket (old war something) I finished the story after that, is there a way to find it again?

[oak wind]

I just killed the deputy in Rhodes, now time to wait for the sheriff to get back and see what i have done

[dense nest]

he saved arthur's life

[fossil brook]

It will run

[ember marsh]

with the right settings you can get a stable 60 fps. Also might depend on your cpu. If your buying a new gpu you can probaly get a 30 series or 6000 series used but depends where you live

[autumn spade]

Nope 😀

[fossil brook]

Bruh I'm stupid

I knew i had it but i just forgor when i got to the fence

[hidden moss]

Hello, I have some mod installed with lenny mod loader and i want to know how load order work. Did somebody can help me?

[lost gale]

"Don't forget to go hunting Mr. Morgan!"

Dude, I just dropped two turkeys, the meat of two boars, a handful of small fish, some rodents and a frickin deer on your table!

[glass stump]

My second playthrough and I just realized that I can make a move on Mary Linton on the date you have with her in Saint Denis

[stiff kiln]

In the mission where you follow mary's father, the controller actually vibrates when you get close to mary in the cuts cene, indicating Arthur's heartbeat rising

cool detail

[drifting glade]

I hope I’m not the only one that actually enjoys doing stuff around Beechers hope after the main story

[lost gale]

Just had the biggest laugh🤣

In Saint Denis when the professor shows off his (failing) electric chair, you can see a few bystanders in a cutscene.
A guy is remarking "well, that's not very humane at all" while what seems to be his wife says:well, I think it's mighty fine.

And her husband just sideeyes here like "the fuck is wrong with you woman?"

[tepid jewel]

not the only one 🙏

[tight halo]

Friggen HATE it. I brought 2 turkeys, a whole 3 star buck, the meat of two other deer and another turkey, and as I leave he goes "dont forget to go hunting!"

[full inlet]

Dude I’m so fucking pissed I just found a moose and was gonna fast travel with the pelt to a trapper by using the campfire and 2 fucking murfree broods interrupted it and killed my horse cause I didn’t have a reviver on me

I tried loading an old save but it didn’t work, I lost the horse and the pelt

Ruined my goddamn day 😭

[empty lark]

damn

hell im finally 2/3 on gambler 8

just gotta beat this dealer one more time before i finally go on a massacre in rhodes

[drifting glade]

I just robbed a train in Saint Denis and didn’t die. That’s the first time that’s happened.

[limber sapphire]

Damn still?

[empty lark]

i took a small break to eat

[tacit gulch]

Help - found Arabian horse near Lake - he killed me - trying since 2 hours - tried save game/quit game/fast travel and travel again - not spawning again...why?

[hidden moss]

i lured the klan into rhodes thinking the lawmen would shoot them but they kinda just watched as the klan started killing the whole town

[ivory crescent]

A human pig with wings just attacked me wtf

[crystal oyster]

you could still encounter it, just wait

[tacit gulch]

Yeah finally tamed it...thanks

[tight halo]

We just need more money Arthur!!!!

[crystal oyster]

Idk why people around here don't help each other. Like, your message was just about to be ghosted. I have few others like that too

[tacit gulch]

Yeah, I searched on Google and literally first video helped me...I wonder if these people actually play the game or just chat here acting like they know everything, because clearly they don't

[crystal oyster]

it's not that they don't, they're just lazy or hate newbies

[tacit gulch]

No wonder new players didn't come in RDO when it was alive