#red-dead-singleplayer

1 messages · Page 49 of 1

terse prawn
#

could have figured actually

#

bozo died

hearty mulch
#

And to be fair Arthur is the one that made the bad choices he could've ran away with Mary

terse prawn
#

Loyalty matters to Arthur

#

he didn't want to abandon Dutch

hearty mulch
# terse prawn bozo died

Let's talk about that actually arthur couldve easily killed him when Dutch let go off the gun at the end but the dumbass decided to go see the sunset

hearty mulch
#

Yes?

terse prawn
#

The gun was far away

hearty mulch
#

Arthur had it in his hand.... Durch just stomped arthur hand

terse prawn
#

exactly

#

Plus you think

#

A sick man

#

about to die naturally

#

can see well

#

to shoot a person?

hearty mulch
#

So your telling me he has enough strength to crawl to the other side of the cliff but not enough strength to lift his wrist and shoot a man that's like 3 meter away from him ?

terse prawn
#

he didn't crawl that much

#

he just turned his back

hearty mulch
#

Arthur Morgan , the man who killed all the legendary gunslingers couldnt beat micah bell

#

Thas crazy

terse prawn
#

TB

hearty mulch
#

U cant use this as an excuse for everything

#

Dude shooting a man is so easy

terse prawn
#

It's not an excuse

#

No 💀

#

it's not easy

#

You need to have a clear vision first

#

And you don't have when you are about to die

#

and sick

hearty mulch
#

Revolver arent heavy and the ones in 1899 barely had any recoil

terse prawn
#

It's not recoil or weight

#

it's eyes

hearty mulch
terse prawn
#

punch weakened him

sour wasp
sour wasp
hearty mulch
sour wasp
#

Its not a toy gun

hearty mulch
hearty mulch
#

Explain smartass

sour wasp
#

I just did read up

hearty mulch
#

Ye show

sour wasp
#

Son life aint like movies like how you vision it

hearty mulch
#

Ok ? Your point being ? Your sources being ?

sour wasp
#

When a mans dying theres a lot of stuff on his mind, dying and knowing that you are gonna die are seperated cases

sour wasp
#

Just telling you in this chat

#

Wether you agree or not i dont care thats your own business

hidden moss
#

"revolvers dont weight much" the fuck bro 💀

sour wasp
#

Kid thinks lifes like cod

hidden moss
#

Lmao

hearty mulch
#

A revolver is average 1.5kg

#

A child can lift that

sour wasp
#

These guns are pure fiction what is wrong with you

hearty mulch
#

Red dead keep bragging about the realism of the game

hearty mulch
hidden moss
hearty mulch
#

🤡

sour wasp
hearty mulch
hidden moss
#

Lol

sour wasp
#

You aint gonna get a hit when you are dying out, goodluck aiming.. I bet you can even concentrate on making the shot

hearty mulch
hearty mulch
#

When hes that close to you

sour wasp
#

3m is a distance, especially when dying out

#

There aint no goddamn crosshair to help you out

hidden moss
hearty mulch
#

A grown man arm is like 1m so that reduce the thing to 2M , just shoot straight

sour wasp
#

You know thomas, I believe you. You are right. How can you be wrong

hearty mulch
#

Yall just dickriding the game

sour wasp
#

Dont even try to conversate with him

#

I tried

#

Didnt worked out

hidden moss
#

This is genuinely fun

sour wasp
#

Yep

#

Seen many clowns but this one tops them all

#

Grown man is 1m reduce the thing to 2m, what thing? Where is the common sense?

hearty mulch
sour wasp
#

European

hearty mulch
#

3 meter minus 1 meter equal 2 meter

hearty mulch
#

The thing is that arthur simply didnt care about killing micah because he became a pussy overtime

hidden moss
hearty mulch
sour wasp
#

I get your point but you totally forget the dying out part, loss of senses, loss of vital organs, eyes fading out, body starting to lose it.

hidden moss
hearty mulch
sour wasp
#

In all honesty

#

He knew he was gonna die

hidden moss
#

How did the argument even start btw

sour wasp
#

Id rather die seeing the blue sky than that goddamn mica face

hearty mulch
#

So distance is even shorter

hearty mulch
sour wasp
#

So did Micah shot Arthur?

hearty mulch
#

Because in this ending micah doesnt care

sour wasp
#

Thats why arthur didnt

hidden moss
hearty mulch
#

Micah ain't pure evil, he is just an outlaw like the others the true bad guy is definitely Dutch

sour wasp
#

Dutch is the reason some of them are dying

#

I never liked Micah

#

He gets himself in trouble and expect others to help

hearty mulch
#

If he wouldnt be so stubborn everything would've went well and they would've found out about Micah but he preferred to trust Micah, someone who they met 6 months ago that mess every single one of their plans over Arthur, a guy that was litteraly raised by Dutch for 20 whole years

sour wasp
#

And then backstabs you in the ending

hearty mulch
#

He knew micah wasnt good

#

But he preferred going away with the money while micah just tried to avoid problems with Pinkerton

sour wasp
#

Yeah lots of Dutch his decision I question often, if he done things differently maybe the gang could co exist

#

Was hoping rdr2 had a 2 story based game, where the ending is defined by the choices you make. Would had been great for it

hearty mulch
#

I think Micah is a really good character even tho people doesnt like him . It's just that I dont really like dutch pretty much only thing he say is "loyalty to me" "I got a plan" "one last score"

hearty mulch
hearty mulch
#

Actually that's just me being annoying but the low honor end is more realistic in my opinion

cloud pulsar
#

do side stories matter cause i wanna end off a good way instead of just skipping through

sour wasp
#

Well the ending is also kinda Rockstars fault

#

They decide to create games in secretcy without asking for suggestions from their player base

sour wasp
#

Then you get doopers like this

cloud pulsar
hearty mulch
#

Oh

#

Well that's my opinion but side missions are usually more annoying than helpful to the story

#

Like the ones with the natives people

#

They boost your honor but they are kinda pointless except for the last one

#

Like you could skip all the cutscene and it wouldnt matter

sour wasp
#

'What the f.. just wasted 300 hours just to watch character die over something I could had survived'😆

cloud pulsar
#

also once im in the epilogue does honor reeeally matter

sour wasp
#

Nah not really only for certain side missions

cloud pulsar
#

sick i can massacre towns without worrying now

sour wasp
#

Yes i do the same and can perfectly follow the story

#

Got a 500 dollar bounty currently

hearty mulch
#

I always cared about it for better dialogues and story

#

But after that I can do wgat I want and dont have to worry

#

Honor only matter if you want to bonus related to it

sour wasp
hearty mulch
#

Dollar doesnt matter much after epilogue

#

You get almost every gun for free during the storyline

#

And for horse you can get the white Arabian for free

#

But if you care about money you can do the pig farm with Arthur to keep money after

empty lark
#

Hunted down the legendary bison, glad it had a weakspot around the back cause it turned to run after 2 of the 3 shots i needed to kill it

pale merlin
#

He becomes a bad low honor outlaw in the beginning and shoots back out as a high honor, well-serving, max 10 length level bearded warm heated wholesome western shooter protector man.

thorn hull
#

There’s a trapper pretty close to it but there’s no difference in the different trappers (price etc)

#

Basically you go there after the tutorial in fact anywhere

#

I have the lichfield from the hidden robbery in the valtine gun store very good then I got the schifleid relovler the volcanic pistol and a sawed off shotgun and a double barrel from the mission with kirean and a bow and arrow and yes my spelling causes aids

edgy barn
#

I just finished the main story like an hour ago, and I'm still trying to hold back my tears from that ending

empty lark
#

Which one did you get

edgy barn
#

high honor ending, it was my first playthrough

empty lark
#

there's two

#

High honor what, help or go back?

edgy barn
#

i know, there's another one with low honor

empty lark
#

no

#

there's two each

edgy barn
empty lark
#

alright

low rune
#

how do i get the black arabian random encounter? it won’t happen for me. are there any requirements besides saint denis and chapter 2+??

ornate cradle
#

Where can i buy a better bow

astral scroll
#

I tried to shoot the kids who stole my satchel and it didn't let me

#

Anyone know why

empty lark
empty lark
ornate cradle
#

I just read something about an improved bow

empty lark
#

Well read a bit more and you may have realized that's in Rdo only

astral scroll
ornate cradle
#

Oh ok

empty lark
#

A shot to the leg is still something they can die from

astral scroll
empty lark
#

If you wanna shoot an adult pickpocket then you can

#

yeah

astral scroll
#

Or is it because of the mission

empty lark
#

You can antagonize them but you cant shoot them, probably would've given rockstar trouble if you could

astral scroll
#

I'm only kidding

empty lark
#

That's why people mod the game

astral scroll
#

can I lasso them though..?

low rune
#

the street urchins in saint denis?

empty lark
#

you cant hurt them

astral scroll
low rune
empty lark
#

if you want to, then put in a mod that allows you to

astral scroll
vale osprey
astral scroll
empty lark
#

I dont even remember the last time i've seen a kid in saint denis, cant remember where they've gone and it doesn't help i've got a huge ass bounty

empty lark
#

yeah there's a couple of those

#

Clearly the ones i used to escape the law weren't the right ones

low rune
empty lark
#

good god all the meat i've gotten from these legendary animals, probably wont need to hunt anymore for a while

#

i've beaten the game and last time i tried which i dont remember when that was, i couldn't shoot one

low rune
empty lark
#

I'll run into saint denis one last time and see if i can before the law is all over me again and if i can i've found my new favorite thing in that annoying city

low rune
empty lark
#

if im lucky maybe i'll finally find the clan on the way there and be able to shoot them up too

#

I bought the black arabian in the saint denis stables so im not sure if you mean the white one or if i've never seen that

astral scroll
empty lark
#

Grey arabian sits in the Blackwater stables, still haven't used it

low rune
empty lark
#

i dont think that's right considering i literally bought it myself

low rune
empty lark
#

A thousand dollars for the damn thing in the epilogue after i beat American Venom

#

got a picture of it in a minute when it gets to my phone

astral scroll
low rune
low rune
low rune
astral scroll
low rune
# astral scroll Alright thanks

trappers cloak, black classic vest (valentine), black stand collar shirt, black riding gloves, black deluxe relentless boots, any spurs that match, black with stripes town pants, and if no vest black fine leather suspenders

#

and if you can get the no satchel glitch it just randomly happens

hidden thorn
empty lark
#

Finally found those street urchins

#

Can't shoot them

#

The dot greyed out whenever i tried and they just ran off

low rune
empty lark
#

Found Kieran's little resting place for the first time, i wondered where they put him

low rune
astral scroll
low rune
low rune
astral scroll
#

Oh yes I think I'm up to that part

#

I just have to activate it in the camp

low rune
astral scroll
#

Wait what. How do you know so much then?

low rune
#

many play through

#

i’m in my like 4th-5th

empty lark
#

What direction from shady belle do you think that panther is?

low rune
empty lark
#

had to clear out the place all over again but i didn't get the popup behind it

#

Probably didn't go far enough, horse kicked me off cause it doesn't wanna run past alligators

low rune
empty lark
#

damn nevermind then

#

i'll save that stuff for later

low rune
#

well master hunter 10 is killing the panther @empty lark

astral scroll
#

What's a good satchel upgrade from Pearson?

low rune
low rune
deft mountain
#

up to chapter 3, what horse should i try to get

astral scroll
#

Fastest horse in the west they say

#

have you done the bear hunting with Hosea?

deft mountain
#

and yea the one at the start i have

astral scroll
#

I have the white one and the stats is pretty good

astral scroll
median swift
#

where do I find camp upgrades in the first camp

#

In new Hanover

#

Right after train robbery mission

astral scroll
#

you can find and tame it in the grizzlies west near lake Isabella. I suggest watching a video on YouTube for a detailed location and instruction

ornate cradle
#

What do i need to get 3star rabbit pelt

red helm
ornate cradle
red helm
ornate cradle
#

Oh ok

#

Thanks

red helm
#

Yeap.

ornate cradle
#

Wait, you’re saying I have to use a rifle in a deer I tried doing that, but it didn’t work

red helm
#

Head shot? Did you use a Springfield type weapon, or a Repeater?

ornate cradle
#

Carbine repeater

#

I hadnt looked at the clean kill thing didnt know it was there so i might have used the wrong one

red helm
#

Then, that's what you did wrong, Repeater's are not Rifles, when it comes to hunting.

ornate cradle
#

Oh

#

Ok

red helm
#

Repeaters are only used for a couple animals. Great for Humans, however.

deft mountain
astral scroll
red helm
#

Ouf, that sucks. Stupid deep water.

ornate cradle
#

I saw a bear cub looking thing but it ran. What yall think it could be

red helm
#

Black Bear. They tend to do that. The Browns are the big ones.

#

... and they rarely run.

grim stump
#

how can i keep the donkey forever ?

thorn hull
#

What are the advantages of buying a horse then just catching it the wild

grim stump
#

it just so funny when riding the donkey because it's short 😄 @thorn hull . i just catch one and hitch it at camp, save and reload, then the donkey will stay at camp.

raven jasper
hidden moss
#

i need help with strawberry to saint denis 9 min dry race

#

do i need to use horse stimulants for it

soft prairie
#

What do y’all think Arthur’s canon honor would be

vital marlin
edgy barn
#

but I personally did high honor for the entire game

tall mountain
#

Is it possible to beat Hortensia?

hidden moss
#

When i get TT gun

fathom prism
#

Ngl I feel sorry for how much I slander the cattleman revolver

#

This weapon is so versatile

#

Reloads fast

#

Decent range and damage

#

The quick shoot is very fast

#

This weapon has barely flaws

dull geyser
#

It has the most cowboy vibe along with schofields imo

buoyant juniper
#

So what’s better

#

Cattleman

#

Or schofields

#

Cause to be the flaws are low

#

For both

feral jewel
#

Does anyone know how to fix the horse textures on pc? Everything else is 4k but the horses are all blurry and muddy

buoyant juniper
#

So look on YouTube

maiden pawn
#

Is it a permanent thing or just started now?

feral jewel
#

It's perma

#

Apparently it's just how it is on pc

soft prairie
soft shuttle
#

I have a brindle thoroughbred but just came across the white Arabian just now, you reckon i should keep both horses? Which one is the better horse?

maiden pawn
#

Good to have a spare to stow more stuff on em

hidden moss
#

Two Volkanics >>>

hidden moss
hidden moss
hidden moss
#

rewilvers?

#

Rewolvers

old pine
#

😭 bruh

hidden moss
#

Volkanic its my favoriute rewolver

#

revolver?

soft shuttle
#

I've heard they scare really easy tho

hidden moss
#

I havent came upon that problem

#

why when i'm near jack i can't shoot

hidden moss
soft shuttle
#

I dual wield a Schofield and volcanic

hidden moss
#

ye

#

Yea

soft shuttle
#

Also I'm customising my Arabian what typa fade should i give him

#

Torn between braids and mohawk

hidden moss
#

How make FAT artur

shy tiger
#

A lot

unborn onyx
#

hey, just a quick question. in order to craft the Homing thomahawk i need the recept right? and there is that location where you can find it, i went there and nothings was there, do i need to have a certain amount of the story complete to find something there?

shy tiger
#

I think

unborn onyx
#

do you know how far by any change

#

or like which mission

shy tiger
#

🤷🏻‍♂️

soft shuttle
#

Do the saddles and saddle attachments have a big impact

unborn onyx
unborn onyx
maiden pawn
#

Go to moonstone pond

hidden moss
maiden pawn
#

Theres a cabin there

unborn onyx
maiden pawn
#

And the pamphlet is there

soft shuttle
shy tiger
maiden pawn
#

Or well chapter

unborn onyx
#

there is this box which you can loot and i dont get anything out of it

unborn onyx
#

i think

maiden pawn
#

Weird i dont think it should be mission locked

#

And you cant just buy it at a fence?

#

I mean I just bought all the pamphlets lol

unborn onyx
maiden pawn
unborn onyx
#

well silly me i bought that and though i had to find more stuff to craft it.

#

can i craft it at campfire?

maiden pawn
#

Yeah

unborn onyx
#

any stuff i need?

maiden pawn
#

Yeah

unborn onyx
#

where do i find what i ned

maiden pawn
#

Youll get the recipe when you get the pamphlet

unborn onyx
#

so open my bag and look at that thing?

maiden pawn
#

Yup

unborn onyx
#

thomahawk and owl feather

#

i can buy the thomahawk?

maiden pawn
#

Yea

unborn onyx
#

where do i get the owl feather from?

maiden pawn
#

And the owl feather can be gotten quite easily, go to emerald ranch and sleep til night an owl usually spawns there

unborn onyx
#

kk

maiden pawn
#

Or go to the train tracks by saint denis and sleep til night

#

Just look up in the sky

#

They fly alone

unborn onyx
#

shoot them with a gun or with a boy

#

bow

maiden pawn
#

Just shoot em with whatever if you arent looking for perfect

unborn onyx
#

i will not get a wanted level?

maiden pawn
#

So long as you dont disrupt or harm the npcs or their farm animals

#

You should be fine

unborn onyx
#

tomahawk is locked in the hehler

#

or however that guy is called

maiden pawn
#

Huh okay then i guess its mission locked

unborn onyx
#

f me

#

just wanna get that homing thomahawk

#

also is 3.5k much money?

dull geyser
#

I prefer the looks of that gun as well

dull geyser
#

Especially if you have legend of the east satchel and a ton of money

#

You can just spam provisions

hearty drum
#

eat loads of food to get authur fat

#

eat at camp every time it's available is a cheaper option

lament dock
#

anyone got the outfit saving bug where after you reload a save it deletes all custom outfits and reverts to the gunslinger

hidden moss
#

at this point i cant help but think rockstar are adding these bugs intentionally

#

their games got too many

lament dock
#

its so annoying istg

chrome pond
#

Just had a huge shootout for the funniest reason.

I have a puppy that hangs around with me in the basement, and he wanted attention. My dog will tap me with his paws when he wants pets.

So he pawed the controller by accident, and Arthur kicks a chicken, then he does it again, and Arthur punches another npc

After escaping Strawberry and a decent shootout, I got a 120.00 bounty in West Elizabeth and I lost a shit ton of honor

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Getting big bounties on accident is great until you decide you need to pay it off

thorn hull
empty lark
#

was chasing someone on my horse in saint denis and an npc just kept walking right in front of where i was going

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Took the entire body weight of a black arabian running as fast as i could make it and i just left the place as quickly as possible

#

I can kill bounty hunters just fine so im never paying off that bounty, sneaking around lawmen isn't too hard either

#

but if i get caught by their goddamn dogs again i just might

thorn hull
#

Oh the bounty hunter ones

empty lark
#

I was off on a hunting trip and some bounty hunters had dogs with them

#

fucking tore me apart

chrome pond
#

I have multiple Arthur saves

thorn hull
chrome pond
#

mainly because I miss the old antagonize lines

empty lark
#

One dog is managable, two is as well but three and bounty hunters is a death sentence

thorn hull
#

I just grab my Lancaster go dead eye and pop some hats off

empty lark
#

They were already on my wrists when I tried

thorn hull
#

reminds me of cougars

empty lark
#

Spoiler tags dont work here btw

#

Dont ask why i have no idea

thorn hull
#

So do caps

empty lark
chrome pond
#

One got me outside of the ranch

thorn hull
#

I can hunt legendary wolf bear and buck but can just barely survive a cougar

chrome pond
#

Already had a bad day at the time, so I turned on cheats and went on a rampage

empty lark
#

The bear is the only one i've had trouble with because we found each other at the same time

thorn hull
#

We simple Xbox players we can’t cheat

thorn hull
empty lark
#

I didn't die but i got really close, had to wrestle with it till i could pull my shotgun

chrome pond
#

Albeit for the l. Cougar, I used a poison arrow+explosive rounds

#

Did it for the hunting challenges since I cougars weren’t spawning

thorn hull
empty lark
#

I usually use a fully upgraded rolling block with express rounds, kills in three shots, two if the animal is small enough

#

And im also sitting far away enough they wont smell me while i shoot their fatal points in dead eye

thorn hull
#

I just started for the first time and I had to do the Thomas downes mission and almost cried then and there

chrome pond
#

Yeah

thorn hull
chrome pond
#

I beat the game during quarantine and that was sad

empty lark
#

You can't upgrade the rare

thorn hull
#

When do you get the rifle

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Idk, just got it at some point, probably one of the things i found for free

thorn hull
#

This game wants me to do the story because it’s fun but if I do I’m just gonna cry each chapter because I know I’m closer to death

empty lark
#

You're also getting closer to american venom

chrome pond
#

I have a replay and I can’t bring myself to free Micah

thorn hull
empty lark
#

pretty sure it's not

chrome pond
#

Albeit I want to save on Chapter 3

thorn hull
empty lark
#

that's when you're playing in the final mission of the epilogue and the entire game

thorn hull
empty lark
#

It's fine, Our Best Selves is what you're talking about

thorn hull
chrome pond
#

Also I have a mischief save

#

Where I have Arthur in a really stupid outfit

#

Reserved specifically for antagonizing

#

And other shenanigans

thorn hull
winter harbor
#

I would agree with you rebel.

thorn hull
#

Pretty sure everyone hates him

empty lark
#

I got an outfit that i like to use when im running on trips outside the ranch for bounty hunting or whatever and another i'll use when im out killing people just because

chrome pond
empty lark
#

Im very surprised i still haven't found the klan yet, i've been waiting to kill them since the start and i still haven't found them at the end

chrome pond
#

And a fast horse for getaways

thorn hull
#

I have one that looks fancy then that same outfit but with a fucking legendary bear hat

azure kestrel
#

What’s the best gun?

chrome pond
#

I like schofields

thorn hull
#

Schofield relover

azure kestrel
#

Ok

empty lark
#

There isn't a best but there's best for each types

azure kestrel
#

I have it

chrome pond
#

I dual wield those

azure kestrel
#

I do

#

What else

crimson inlet
empty lark
#

Lancaster best repeater

chrome pond
#

I have a black engraved and a white engraved one

azure kestrel
#

Ohhh

chrome pond
#

When I did American venom, the black had explosive

crimson inlet
thorn hull
#

I can’t get the dual wield because I got mine from the medicine store robbery and I’m just waiting to buy mine

empty lark
#

Can never go wrong with the lancaster, always reliable

chrome pond
#

Called them the Angel and the devil

thorn hull
empty lark
#

14 rounds, free early on in a story mission

azure kestrel
#

Yeah

empty lark
#

I still use it, never go without it unless i swap it out for the Rolling Block rifle when i hunt

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Not for legendary animals, and no not really

chrome pond
empty lark
#

As long as I hit the head with a normal bullet the pelt should be fine

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Unless it's small game then i've probably obliterated the poor thing

empty lark
#

I dont hunt small animals though, not usually

thorn hull
empty lark
#

I will for the trapper but not for anything else

thorn hull
empty lark
#

I didn't even bother hunting for Pearson, bought all the satchels from a fence in the epilogue as soon as i could

thorn hull
#

Because he didn’t single handily kill Micah

empty lark
#

Despite going low honor in the epilogue though i will never rob his store in saint denis

thorn hull
#

In the navy should be in the ditch

empty lark
#

It is, in the epilogue

#

Not during chapters 1-6

crimson inlet
thorn hull
#

I thought it was in valatine

crimson inlet
#

It’s in Rhodes-

empty lark
#

oh fuck

#

i said saint denis

thorn hull
empty lark
thorn hull
empty lark
#

Yeah rhodes

thorn hull
#

I’ve robbed Saint Denis without any remorse

#

Fuck the amount of cops they have

empty lark
#

Shot through them all with just a revolver once

chrome pond
#

Fuck Saint Denis

thorn hull
#

Fuck Saint Denis

empty lark
#

Did the hidden Saint Denis Gunsmith robbery and it went wrong, had to shoot like 15-20 of them

#

Wasn't even worth the money

thorn hull
#

So i got out scot free

chrome pond
#

Albeit I beat up the Rhodes gunsmith

#

For what he did

thorn hull
empty lark
#

I just threatened him and left him to be sad and grieve on his own

thorn hull
chrome pond
#

That and the dog abusing kid

#

Chased him and antagonized him a ton

empty lark
#

Probably not, kidnapped him cause he looked like his son

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Drowned in a river cause his dad gave him a gun that had too much recoil for the kid

chrome pond
#

And I always attack raiders

chrome pond
#

Backwards fools

thorn hull
empty lark
#

im not sure why the law got upset when i shot the raiders in the middle of a town

#

they're not good people or anything, they're a gang

thorn hull
chrome pond
#

Nah I beat them in town

empty lark
#

and they still tried to arrest me for getting rid of them

thorn hull
#

I shot the ones that told me not to camp

chrome pond
#

Yeah

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Skinner brothers and murfrey broods hardly scare me when they catch me camping, i either shoot them when after they give me my warning or we have a nice little short shootout

chrome pond
#

Yeah

#

Murfree ambushes though

#

The tiger trap one is annoying

empty lark
#

I haven't been in murfrey territory in a while, usually camp out in skinner area or somewhere where neither of them are

thorn hull
#

Murfree are so Stupid probably from the incest

chrome pond
#

I only camp in murfree land if I need to hunt

empty lark
#

Smart enough to form a dangerous gang that people are scared of

chrome pond
#

Never camp in the swamp unless I need poison or big game

empty lark
#

stupid enough to run at me with a machete while im about to unload two revolvers into their chest

thorn hull
#

Anyone else find the guy who gets hanged and shoot him down in the swamp then get ambushed by like five dudes so your panicking because it’s your first time but you still win

chrome pond
#

Nightfolk

thorn hull
#

That’s it

chrome pond
#

Favorite camping spot imo is the snow in ambarino

empty lark
#

Not necessarily

#

some of them do, others have silent weapons

#

bows

normal relic
#

Nightfolk

thorn hull
normal relic
#

No idea

thorn hull
chrome pond
#

White body paint, melee, attack at night in the swamp

empty lark
#

And besides i dont enjoy getting up close to melee murfreys, they got me good once or twice and i've just hanged back since then with my guns

normal relic
#

They're cannibals I do believe

#

Yep

thorn hull
snow wasp
#

hey does anyone know if i can play rdr2 offline (on pc)

thorn hull
#

Who else shot the old lady immediately because you knew who she was and you hate her

normal relic
#

When I first encountered nightfolk they just stood there then started coming after me

empty lark
#

There's a lot of old ladies i've shot, you mean the one with the donkey outside her house in the forest?

#

I shot her on the way out with her shotgun

thorn hull
thorn hull
#

With the basement

empty lark
#

Killed the old homeless slaver in rhodes immediately after finishing his mission

#

Worked out well since his body fell over the campfire and burned

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Positive honor for killing him was the nice part of it

#

cant go in saint denis without killing the racist eventually

chrome pond
#

I used the racist for the horseman challenge

#

The lasso one

normal relic
thorn hull
chrome pond
#

I beat him up

normal relic
#

I think so

empty lark
#

Was that legal?

normal relic
#

Idk

thorn hull
empty lark
#

If so im gonna do that when i get back on rdr2 in saint denis

chrome pond
#

Every time I go to St Denjs I beat up the book guy

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Damn, well i already got a $200 bounty in there i'll find out myself when i get the chance

thorn hull
#

Lol

#

The lawman are stupid as long as your on the other side of the street being shady as fuck because your crouching they don’t care

chrome pond
#

I got a disturbing the peace once there for greeting

thorn hull
#

And bounty hunters are easy to kill paying off your bounty isn’t worth it at all

empty lark
#

Yeah i rode my horse on the opposite sidewalk and they didn't care

chrome pond
#

I wasn’t even antagonizing

thorn hull
#

Bruh they are so annoying like officer he pushed me over with his big fucking horse and he couldn’t even see me arrest him

#

People who become witnesses for that shit are 1899 Karen’s

chrome pond
#

Also, craziest crime I did was used the wagon and ammo cheat to make an exploding stagecoach

chrome pond
#

Yeah

#

Rode it into town and freed the horses

#

Thing had like 8 volatile dynamites on it

thorn hull
#

What are the differences between a bought black Arabian and a wild black Arabian like difference in max stats ie gray or is it in stats that can be upgraded ie the white area

maiden pawn
#

However the difference is so miniscule

empty lark
#

im still sad for my hungarian halfbred i used throughout almost all the story as Arthur

#

Watching it at the end of chapter 6 was worse than Arthur for me

maiden pawn
#

Aww

#

Rip the horsey

empty lark
#

It was probably the only death i didn't see before playing the game

haughty fiber
maiden pawn
#

Aww man

wheat grotto
#

Where can i sell big fish?

#

Butcher or?

maiden pawn
thorn hull
wheat grotto
#

Just caught a 8.9kg lake sturegeon

thorn hull
#

Nice

maiden pawn
thorn hull
#

You sir are a fish

maiden pawn
#

O yeah

#

I love that quote

#

First time I got it I legit clipped it and now it's just a random file on my PC

thorn hull
#

Lol

maiden pawn
#

Small things that make the game enjoyable

thorn hull
#

Yeah like how eagles actually catch fish

maiden pawn
#

They catch bunnies and small animals too

#

You can also see cats catch rats

#

Quite fascinating small details if you pay attention

thorn hull
#

Yep

thorn hull
empty lark
#

I didn't even use a shotgun in that mission

maiden pawn
#

^

empty lark
#

Stuck with a revolver and a repeater, never got close enough for a shotgun to work

maiden pawn
#

I just run around like a monkey with melees

thorn hull
empty lark
#

i kinda wish the gunsmith would change if you killed them, robbed and killed the saint denis gunsmith without being caught but i saw him the next day after

wheat grotto
#

Nooo

#

Ong

#

My horse kicked me off next to a gator

empty lark
#

I know he was dead as well, stabbed him like twenty times after getting my knife designed to look good

wheat grotto
#

And i died

hidden moss
#

With the Rhodes mission with the grays they replaced the sherrif

hidden moss
#

So why not just randomly generate a name

empty lark
#

Yeah stay on the roads in the swamp area, your horse will appreciate it

wheat grotto
#

And i lost my fish

#

Omg

#

Ima find that gator

#

And lay 20 dynamites

empty lark
#

If you wanna go off roads then do it on foot, you can be more careful that way anyways since there's a ton of alligators there

thorn hull
empty lark
#

It's not hard to get past them, just dont get too close

thorn hull
#

Not even joking I was terrified but my horse didn’t buck me and we just swam right through

thorn hull
empty lark
#

Part of a mission is about wading through alligator filled swamps and i was constantly in and out of eagle eye

thorn hull
#

Lol

empty lark
#

My horse is great but she will run from nearly everything, and she runs far every time

empty lark
#

I liked it, didn't die at all and saving the kid from the alligator was nice

hidden moss
#

I dint die aswell but I hate gators

empty lark
#

Wasn't it the legendary bull gator that Dutch and Arthur were shooting at?

hidden moss
#

I was really angry at Dutch during that mission

empty lark
#

Pretty sure it was, hunted it down last night and killed it fairly easily

#

nearly turned to where i couldn't hit a fatal point but it took more bullets than any other animal i've hunted so far

hidden moss
#

I normally don't use eagle eye

#

Or dead eye

#

Because it's more real

empty lark
#

you dont normally use dead eye?

hidden moss
#

No not often

empty lark
#

Arthur and john have a pretty fast draw, that's kinda how the game shows it but ig i understand

hidden moss
#

I use dead eye very sparingly

#

Hunting

empty lark
#

I use it a lot to save myself the need to regen my health back

hidden moss
#

I use it to reload

#

That's pretty much it

empty lark
#

And also a bullet saver, less bullets spent looking for the headshot i need to escape the law

empty lark
#

After finishing the epilogue i dont

hidden moss
#

I don't really rob stores or anything

#

I get enough law from missions

empty lark
#

I love robbing stores, mainly the ones with the special robberies because they're unique

hidden moss
#

I know ones in strawberry

empty lark
#

I didn't think the general store in Strawberry would also be running a Moonshine operation

hidden moss
#

I've not been there yet

empty lark
#

I still need to find the thing to start the Valentine gunsmith robbery, heard you get a free litchfield from it but i've already got every gun i can buy

#

Even made sure to remember the High Roller revolver from a fence

#

shame you can only get one, i like the style even if you cant change it

hidden moss
#

Yeah

#

I wish the Schofield revolver had better carvings

empty lark
#

Schofields just seem boring to me because they're kinda just the standard perfect revolver to use

hidden moss
#

Because you have to buy it

empty lark
#

Usable at longer ranges than the others, incredible accuracy and a fine fire rate

hidden moss
#

Normally people just rob the doctor for the revolver

empty lark
#

Kinda wish i did the Legendary Gunslinger missions earlier

hidden moss
#

Yeah I did those asap

#

Because I love to draw

empty lark
#

Could've gotten some use out of Calloway's schofield or the unique cattlemans

hidden moss
#

I wish I could've played without spoilers

empty lark
#

it's a bit disappointing Black Belle didn't really have anything but she did give the only picture of one of the four gunslingers alive

empty lark
#

No

#

She's the only one that Arthur took a picture of alive

hidden moss
#

Yeah

#

I need to do a high honor playthrough eventually

empty lark
#

I did that on my first, kinda wanna restart for low honor arthur or a second high honor run where i do everything i can with the strangers but i dont wanna suffer the tutorial again

#

I couldn't find that guy with his horse Buell unfortunately

ashen condor
#

How much can you actually get done in chapter 2

empty lark
#

A lot, but you'll run out if you dont progress

#

Mostly stranger mission things and finding secret robberies probably

ashen condor
#

Bec I'm jus restarting on Xbox bec I got lost at where I was but on pc I've spent like over 10 hours just on chapter 2 going around doing random stuff

#

Where can you get a bolt action early

hidden moss
#

I think it's on chapter 2

#

Or no

#

Chapter 3

#

You get a wagon full of them

#

With sean

ashen condor
#

Ah alrr

hidden moss
#

Sean is one of my favorite characters

#

Hope he doesn't die

buoyant juniper
#

How would I get duel cattelmams

#

Mans*

#

I need help

#

I have 1

#

How could I get another for duel

stone gulch
#

Break Micah outta jail

buoyant juniper
#

I did that

#

Is there another way

#

I have duel wield unlocked

#

I just need a second cattleman

#

And I’m asking how

stone gulch
#

Buy another one at the gunsmith…?

buoyant juniper
stone gulch
#

Yea

buoyant juniper
#

Ok thank you

fallow atlas
#

I hate my life bro

#

I get killed by the legendary crocodile

#

Then im hunting the leg fox

empty lark
#

That's fine, consider using a more long ranged weapon

fallow atlas
#

And bounty hunters ruin it

empty lark
#

cant do much about that ig

fallow atlas
hidden moss
#

Use dynamite arrows

empty lark
#

I always try to make sure to have my dead eye filled when i hunt

fallow atlas
empty lark
#

it wont ruin the legendary pelts

fallow atlas
empty lark
#

and it's dynamite arrows, sounds great

hidden moss
#

They do a ton of damage and it’s a legendary animal

empty lark
fallow atlas
#

But I'd use my sniper

#

with high velo ammos

empty lark
#

Wouldn't express be stronger

fallow atlas
#

maybe

hidden moss
#

High velocity has more range express has more damage

#

Both are better than regular though I think

empty lark
#

Yeah

fallow atlas
#

at least I killed like 6 legendary animals

empty lark
#

I dont imagine needing more range on my sniper than i've already got so i use express

fallow atlas
#

so im chilling

lament dock
#

I hate the outfit saving bug

empty lark
#

that bull alligator wasn't too bad for me, got a bunch of nice shots at the side and front of it's head

hidden moss
#

The only legendary animal that’s hard to kill imo is the panther

empty lark
#

Is it out by shady belle?

hidden moss
#

But the alligator can kill you if you get too confident which has happened to me

empty lark
#

Someone said it was but i couldn't find it before i had to stop playing for that day

hidden moss
#

It’s between Shady Belle and Old Harry Fen and it requires master hunter rank 9 to spawn

empty lark
#

oh right

#

that's kinda annoying, i'll get to it eventually

hidden moss
#

Master hunter is the most fun challenge set to me but it is a bit time consuming

patent ocean
#

Master hunter challenge gives the best rewards

#

Really good gun holsters

red helm
#

I liked the look of the Bandit challenge set the most.

full relic
#

so how do i get quick money, i got a 300$ bounty first day i got the game in valentine

alpine reef
#

unpopular opinion: micah is only unlikeable during chapter 6

#

cause ngl i love micah

#

except for chapter 6

#

then i hate him

hidden moss
red helm
#

He is quite racist in Chapter 1, and other chapters, so...

hidden moss
full relic
#

do i lose anything or?

hidden moss
#

If a lawman recognizes you he will aim his gun at you and you can surrender

#

You just have to spend some time in jail

full relic
#

ah ok, thanks

hidden moss
#

I usually don’t have a bounty unless I did something on accident

fallow atlas
#

i cant even go into Saint Denis

#

but I wanna finish the game with high honor this time

#

and keep arthur alive for longer

acoustic chasm
#

Hi y'all! I kinda have a problem, my manual dead eye sometimes won't mark even if my bars are full, and I don't know what the problem is.

acoustic chasm
#

It just doesn't wanna, even with a gun that can shoot multiple rounds (bolt action)

#

I know I need to press Q, but it doesn't work

#

that's my problem

acoustic chasm
#

Scope, but scope usually works.

#

I don't use anything else than scope tbh

low rune
acoustic chasm
#

I tried non-scoped too, and also doesn't work

low rune
#

L

buoyant juniper
#

Yea there is a part where you just have to use the regular dead eye

#

Intill you unlock

#

Manual dead eye

hidden moss
#

If it’s none of those it’s probably a glitch

#

I have also never played on PC so there might be something I just don’t know

red helm
#

I'm assuming it works the same as Xbox and PS.

hidden moss
#

If you just haven’t unlocked manual marking yet then it should mark them automatically when you move the reticle over them

#

If it’s not marking at all then it’s not that

acoustic chasm
red helm
hidden moss
#

I’m assuming they meant chapter 3

#

In which case manual marking would already be unlocked

raw violet
#

Is white Arabian hard to get

hidden moss
#

why am i getting shot by an invisible creature when im in new austin??

#

how can i get white arabian horse

#

i found mine in lake isabella within the first minute there

#

i it isnt around the the lake

raw violet
#

Is it hard to get

hidden moss
#

just lasso it and get close then get up and balance yourself

#

i got it while playin arhtur

hidden moss
#

but i cant with john

hidden moss
#

Idk

#

it isnt resping

#

i restart game go to valentine hotel and try again

#

is it possible to explore new austin when im wanted

#

i keep getting shot by invisible people and it makes me think rockstar doesnt want me to succeed lmao

hidden moss
#

So i got no way of exploring it?

#

Not yet

#

No spoilers

#

thats such a shame

#

they should make it possible but hard

#

That's how most people feel

acoustic chasm
hidden moss
#

Especially since I don't even think the gang was wanted in New Austin anyway

#

Just Blackwater

#

And why the hell do the AI in new austin/blackwater have SIGNIFICANTLY way more aimbot than other AI

#

They hit every shot lmao

#

That's just how Pinkertons are programmed in free roam

#

Rockstar really did not want Arthur anywhere near that area

#

They did everything they could aside from just putting an invisible wall

hidden moss
#

Ik that seems obvious but I have no idea how it could glitch that bad

acoustic chasm
hidden moss
#

Are you using a gun that reloads after one shot

#

Like the springfield rifle

acoustic chasm
#

No

#

Bolt action and varmint

hidden moss
#

And you're sure you're pressing the right button

#

Again I don't play on PC so idk what that is

acoustic chasm
#

Definitely pressing the right button

hidden moss
#

when you go to the map and see a drawing of an animal, does it indicate this animal is popular in that area

#

Idk then

#

I guess it must be broken

#

It seems like you're doing everything right

hidden moss
#

It doesn't necessarily mean it's popular it just can spawn there

#

i never see the animals

#

im trying to get badger and raccoon pelt

#

cant find any

#

Oh those aren't super common

#

can i use a bow on them with regular arrows

#

for perfect pelt

#

I'd recommend looking up a guide to see the best time and locations to find them

#

I think they both need a varmint rifle

hidden moss
#

Damn

#

Alright thanks

acoustic chasm
acoustic chasm
hidden moss
#

I can't even imagine trying to kill a squirrel without dead eye

#

Near impossible I'm sure

acoustic chasm
#

Trying to get all the satchels

hidden moss
hidden moss
hidden moss
#

Not when you consider you have to use a bow

hidden moss
#

You must just be a better shot

#

well, atleast i dont have to worry about squirrels any more 😂

thorn hearth
#

anyone know why options in a hotel can be greyed out?

#

I just started playing

hidden moss
#

When you've already purchased them

#

Or if you're wanted I would assume

acoustic chasm
hidden moss
#

Squirrels are incredibly common they can just be hard to see sometimes

#

Because of their size

hidden moss
#

see if my auto aim locks onto it

#

I just use eagle eye

#

true

#

i should do that too

acoustic chasm
#

I try eagle eye but they blend in so well

hidden moss
#

Most squirrels I find are 3 stars

#

Same with small birds

maiden pawn
#

There's a LOT of small animals especially squirrels there

acoustic chasm
#

I'll check that out, that's not really a place I come a lot 😅 but worth a trip tomorrow!

maiden pawn
#

Works like a charm

#

Especially for the taxidermist

acoustic chasm
#

Awesome, I'll check. I used to love hunting on the great plains in online, but in solo that's out of the question

broken fable
#

What can you do with the big legendary bear carcass after i have skinned it? can you cut it up or what can i do with it

hidden moss
#

Give it to the trapper

broken fable
#

but i can only have the pelt

#

what about the bear that is on the ground?

hidden moss
#

Yeah give the pelt to the trapper

#

Oh wait I misread what you said

#

Some animals are too big for you to take the carcass

#

You can just leave it it's not important

broken fable
#

okay

#

thanks

broken fable
hidden moss
#

Give it to the trapper

#

Hey so

#

i helped some NPC on the road who crashed their wagon and asked me to look after it while he gets another wagon

#

does he ever come back

#

or am i just being played

#

He does not come back but if you take his stuff you lose honor

#

guess im dishonorable then

#

Sigma

broken fable
#

i found him

#

i just told him what a sack of shit he was

#

and then he said something back

#

i tried to donate it

#

but i can't

hidden moss
#

Uh

#

Are you talking about Pearson

#

The trapper has a lot of locations but he's most easy to find in Saint Denis

fallow atlas
hidden moss
#

I don't think you can antagonize him

fallow atlas
#

I had a Legendary white bison pelt

#

I got ambushed

#

my heart was racing

#

But I got out alive

hidden moss
#

Skinner Brothers are wild

broken fable
fallow atlas
broken fable
#

what do i do with the pelt?

fallow atlas
#

ig