red-dead-singleplayer

[empty lark]

Honestly I'm glad Charles was able to get out but it's a shame Arthur had hardly anyone to take his side

[dull geyser]

Yea the ones that could've took his side are dead

[empty lark]

Anyone that would've was already gone one way or another

[dull geyser]

It's just grimshaw and john that was on his side that moment

[empty lark]

Javier was a bit indecisive i think but he still stood around Dutch

You'll learn

Just wait till you play the game

[ivory valve]

If Uncle was there without lumbago he would destroy Micah and the gang

[empty lark]

Yeah sounds right

[dull geyser]

For sure

R* had to give him lumbago so he doesnt outshine everybody

[empty lark]

It took me like 5-6hrs to download the game but it was worth it and still runs better than i thought for me

[fathom prism]

We wouldn’t recommend staying here in this channel

It’s not spoiler free

If ur a fist timer playinf rdr2

[empty lark]

we try to be but cant always guarantee it

[dull geyser]

Yep but dutch saved him and teally blinded by loyalty

[fathom prism]

Tho we ain’t kicking you just warning you

[dull geyser]

Yep

[empty lark]

Poor Karen though, i was hoping maybe Arthur could've helped a bit with her but she was really out of it

[ivory valve]

Bro I envy you, it took me half a day to get it done

Indihomo parah sih💀

[dull geyser]

Javier probably left the gang after that then bill

[dull geyser]

She just disappeared

Maybe pinkertons got her since she's drunk

Kieran got snatched by o dricolls so I think this could be the case as well

[empty lark]

When did Kieran get snatched anyways? I tried to keep a close eye on him until I decided to sleep the night away but he stood fairly close to Pearson's wagon

[dull geyser]

After jack got back

Probably while celebrating

[empty lark]

Damn

[ivory valve]

They did him dirty

[dull geyser]

Yep

Also strauss even tho I hate him

Not dirty but the way he got taken out was respectable at least

[ivory valve]

Strauss didn’t snitch on the gang

[ivory valve]

His redemption

[dull geyser]

Tortured to death but he rather die than snitch

[ivory valve]

By decapitating him?

💀

[dull geyser]

Nahh i mean strauss

[ivory valve]

Oh

[empty lark]

Spoiler tags dont work here for some reason

[dull geyser]

Yea

[shut pond]

Oh sure, thanks

[empty lark]

no channel for spoilers but no spoiler tags is crazy

[dull geyser]

Yeaa it was working back then

[shut pond]

So, then just normally: spoliler alert: why didn't Dutch tell the gang (except Micah) he had the Blackwater money all along?

[ivory valve]

He had a plan

T

[dull geyser]

Yes

[ivory valve]

Ta-

Tahiti

[dull geyser]

Tahiti could've just gone down like guarma

[empty lark]

Probably wasn't enough for him and just had to keep them going thinking they needed more

[shut pond]

Well, sure

[dull geyser]

John couldn't tag along in chapter 5 cause he cant swim lmaooo

[shut pond]

but why did he tell it to Micah only?

Did he trust only in him?

[dull geyser]

Micah got to his head

The ferry job was his idea also

I think

[empty lark]

He trusted only him because Micah always told Dutch something he wanted to hear to get him to do what Micah wants

[dull geyser]

Yea

Micah inflated his ego

[shut pond]

Sure then...

His betrayal of Arthur still hurts

[empty lark]

Dutch did also probably have something wrong with himself im sure, seems like he went through too many awful situations for it to have just been Micah

[hidden moss]

Someone can give me a good setting for a ryzen 3350G 3.60hz 16Ram and a gtx 1650 pls

[shut pond]

Yeah, that's true... but the ending is sad after all

[pearl scarab]

hey

did rockstar delete the option to hand over a escaped prisioner?

i keep being wanted for kidnapping

and i remember this didnt happen

[ivory valve]

Just free them to get tips for robbery

It could be useful

[empty lark]

i swear dogs and wolves are more dangerous than anyone with a gun

[normal relic]

Ye

[empty lark]

I wont die to a bunch of bounty hunters but god forbid should i even try to survive against their dogs biting my ankles

[normal relic]

Exactly

Damn dogs

Hate how the wolves chase you

[ivory valve]

Use machetes

Don’t even use a gun

[hidden moss]

yo

[true obsidian]

Can I play the train robbery mission in chapter one over and over again to get money or do I just get money the first time I do itv

[hidden moss]

Just get money the first time

[true obsidian]

Oh ok

[empty lark]

You'll get more than enough the more story missions you play

[hidden moss]

Help me

Send me messages privated

I have a question

Does the donation money matter in the story like do I need to donate some money to continuie at one Point?

[vale osprey]

No, you don’t have to donate any money

But Dutch will encourage you to donate but you don’t have to

[hidden moss]

RDR2: Metal Gear lite.

[steady ether]

They should add freebird to the games music

[uneven horizon]

its the story

[trim horizon]

Is it possible to find Missouri Fox Trotter Horse afther Arther's death?

[ocean cipher]

Seems the Legendary Buck is quite elusive

Must've bagged $50 worth of pelts and carcasses in the vicinity of that area and still no sign of any clue on tracking it

[empty lark]

All of Arthur's guns are transferred at that one point in the game right?

[ocean cipher]

you cannot lose your guns: they either go to your horse or the camp

[empty lark]

So yes i will still have all the guns i bought after chapter 6, alright

[ocean cipher]

On THAT I'm not positive, but I would suppose that yes: even after Chapter 6 you keep all of them you have accumulated

Have played the game 262 hours and never got past early Chapter 3

[hidden moss]

After a certain point yes, but not immediately

[empty lark]

That's fine, as long as i get them

[ocean cipher]

gawd daym this game is gorgeous

[empty lark]

Making sure to buy two of every sidearm and another sawed off before i get too far

[hidden moss]

Where are you

[empty lark]

Chapter 6, just rescued Eagle Flies and im talking to Dutch now for another mission

[hidden moss]

Ah

Once you start Our Best Selves there's no more free roam

[empty lark]

damn, it's my next mission

Gonna go buy everything now before it's over with

[ocean cipher]

what should I do with all these perfect pelts? Does Arthur unlock the ability to craft stuff at some point or am I supposed to give them to Pearson to make stuff?

[hidden moss]

Some things can be crafted by Pearson with certain pelts, other things can be crafted by the Trapper

[ocean cipher]

I mean I know I can sell them for cash but, I can harvest them at a steady rate now so, seems sensible to get the stuff that they can build for me too

[ocean cipher]

Okay! So a mixture: I'll deliver to Trapper until he seems to be topped up

[hidden moss]

You get certain items by skinning animals that you can craft things with but the pelts have no use on your person

[ocean cipher]

Do each of them only need one perfect pelt to build from, or do they use multiple perfects?

[hidden moss]

Depends on what you want

For example the satchels that Pearson makes require 3 different perfect pelts for each one

Most of the things the Trapper sells require legendary animal pelts too

[ocean cipher]

Arthur has the metabolism of Adonis . . . Eats whole Mooses daily and still manages to get "Underweight"

So the "Murfree Brood" are supposed to be scary?

[hidden moss]

Not to a skilled gunslinger

To civilians I'm sure they are

[ocean cipher]

is there a hidden "Familiarity" variable that buffs weapon use as a function of number of kills with it?

[ashen condor]

Do you have to visit a area to be able to fast travel

[hidden moss]

Yes

[ashen condor]

Alrr

Can you unlock every area after the Valentine camp?

[hidden moss]

Technically no

Once you complete chapter 2 you can go wherever you want but you're wanted dead or alive in Great Plains and New Austin as you can see on the map

[ocean cipher]

you can get double revolver holsters in order to dual wield?

[hidden moss]

There's a fuck ton of Pinkertons with aimbot and an invisible sniper if you go too far

[ashen condor]

Yee ikk

I've jus been doing the maps and been all the way from strawberry to van horn was jus wondering

[hidden moss]

Yeah anywhere other than far south/east West Elizabeth or below it you can go to in chapter 2

[woeful fulcrum]

Can you rob a bank in story mode in free play without a mission

[hidden moss]

Unfortunately no

You can rob trains though

[terse prawn]

and wagon

or local stores

[ocean cipher]

Is it not possible to use boats until you unlock them in Chapter 3 or something?

I've found boats three times and had no interaction prompt at all

[terse prawn]

Idk

[hidden moss]

Press Y

Wait you're pc

Whatever the button is to get on your horse

It's the same

[ocean cipher]

E

[terse prawn]

use it

[ocean cipher]

hmmph

[terse prawn]

what button is that

Can't see on my keyboard

[ocean cipher]

For me, "mount horse" is "E"

[terse prawn]

Use E on boat

[ocean cipher]

I'll try it next time

I guess maybe I didn't tap E, might have expected a use prompt

[hidden moss]

What happens if you try go somewhere other than the mountains in chapter 1?

[ocean cipher]

mission fails

you go back to last auto save

[hidden moss]

Never tried it but from what I've heard the snowstorm kills you

Or at least almost does so you have to go back to camp

[hidden moss]

What about where u have those 2 missions available and you can kinda roam around

Can't u leave then?

[ocean cipher]

In Chapter 1 you only ever have one mission at a time

and never any time that you are not "in" a mission

[normal relic]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

Not true

No you don't there's a point where u have a Pearson and I think a Javier mission

And u can choose

[hidden moss]

No i think it was Charles not javier

[normal relic]

Pearson missions were fun

[hidden moss]

Idk

[normal relic]

I didn't do many gang member missions tho

[ocean cipher]

yeah that is true . . . I dunno. I suppose that if you get too far from either one of those mission prompt areas you'll fail and go back to autosave

[hidden moss]

He's talking about the required ones in chapter 1

[ocean cipher]

that is the general theme of how missions work: go outside the boundaries and you fail and it respawns at last autosave, and pretty much all of Chapter 1 is set up to prevent you from being able to free roam

But once you get to Horseshoe Overlook, you can roam almost limitless.

[normal relic]

The main ones yeah

[ocean cipher]

Still have stuff you cannot buy because it is "locked" but if you totally focus on exploring and looting and doing everything possible, you can do A LOT!

[hidden moss]

I just looked it up if you leave Colter your horse dies almost instantly and then you die after

Presumably from the snowstorm

[normal relic]

Ye

Chapter 1 takes a while til you get to horseshoe overlook

[ocean cipher]

A lot of times it'll just say "FAILED" in a black and white photo-esque screen freeze

[hidden moss]

I'm pretty sure that screen can only appear if you're in a mission

[normal relic]

Yeah

[hidden moss]

And why would it do different things sometimes

[ocean cipher]

Legendary Beaver eh . . . I thought that was only on reddit . . .

[normal relic]

I killed an legendary coyote the other day took it to the trapper after

[hidden moss]

are they supposed to be hard to kill

they seem surprisingly easy

i killed half of them already but dont know what to do with the stuff i get

the trapper in saint denis doesnt but my stuff

Idk if they're supposed to be but they're easier to hunt that normal animals imo

Set locations and pelts can't be ruined

The panther is a little tough though

[hidden moss]

Idk how that's possible

You're supposed to give the pelts/carcasses to the trapper and the other item to the fence

For example the elk and buck give you antlers

[ocean cipher]

look for the traper icon on the map. For me he is always north of Elysian Pools

[red helm]

The Bull Gator can be rather rough the first time you try him.

[hidden moss]

He has set locations

[ocean cipher]

or . . . actually northwest

really . . . more west than north!

[red helm]

Yes, there is 5 Trapper locations. All specific.

And, also, yes, they are all the same guy.

[ocean cipher]

Because I'm doing as much as possible before I finish Chapter 2, he has never moved

[hidden moss]

He doesn't move he has set locations

[ocean cipher]

wanna see if I can get 10s in all my energy bars . . .

[red helm]

He makes a joke about being able to move faster with his stuff than other people can move with just a horse.

[hidden moss]

If you go to one of them he will always be there

[ocean cipher]

ah . . .

much like Arthur's horses and gear

[hidden moss]

Also Sadie's horse just died and it did not fail the mission

She is just walking

Wtf

[red helm]

Do you mean level 10?

[ocean cipher]

yep . . . I know that DeadEye has Tiers that are locked behind story progression

[red helm]

I had this happen, sort of, Karen lost her horse once, and was just running along with us.

[hidden moss]

I don't think it is

[red helm]

Well, No, not story, in order to get level 9 and 10, you have to complete challenges, and than buy the gear from the trapper(Wearing said gear is not required, fyi.)

[ocean cipher]

I'm Level 7 and pretty sure I still do not have the manual targeting functionality though

[hidden moss]

Oh that's what you meant

[ocean cipher]

my understanding was that Deadeye has two leveling dimensions: size of the bar, which is not locked behind story; enhanced functionality, which is

[hidden moss]

Yeah the level you're at just determines how long it can stay active the different abilities are unlocked through the story

[red helm]

Deadeyes functions are however locked by story progression. Yes. But, getting health, stamina and deadeye to level 9/10, refer to my previous statement.

[ocean cipher]

When you hit Deadeye 8, does the game prompt you to let you know what challenges / gear you gotta get?

[hidden moss]

Dutch left me to die, yeah.

[hidden moss]

No but it's Explorer, Herbalist and Master Hunter

Then and only then did Arthur realize that the Dutch he knew was truly gone.

"I'd die in your place if I could."

Nothing but empty platitudes to keep everyone in line.

[ocean cipher]

sweet, you can assault, kidnap and murder random robbers without taking an honor hit

[hidden moss]

How do you get vintage civil war handcuffs

For the alligator tooth talisman

[red helm]

Pretty sure it does not.

[red helm]

It's a reward from the Cigarette cards. I think for the first set, you send him.

[hidden moss]

Oh lord

I haven't even started with those

[red helm]

They aren't to bad if you like exploring.

However, the easy way to do them. Just Discard all the premium Cig's in your inventory, then buy a bunch from the store, repeat.

[hidden moss]

The Tuberculosis is getting worse.

The German family I saved.

[empty lark]

damn, the horse i've kept since the beginning of the game just died in the mission im in

[red helm]

Horse Reviver?

[empty lark]

Wasn't the fastest thing but never found a reason to replace it

it's a certain chapter 6 mission

[red helm]

Oh, was it "That" mission?

[empty lark]

yes

[red helm]

Awww!

[empty lark]

Always liked how it was taller than the other gang members' horses

[red helm]

Saddest Cutscene in the whole game.

Oh, did you keep the Raven coat Shire?

[empty lark]

The big black horse Hosea got? No i sold that one, forgot the breed name but maybe i can find it

[red helm]

Ardennes is the other big horse breed.

[hidden moss]

Suffolk Punch

Belgian Draft

[proud crystal]

just bought the game stuck in loading screen for like 15 minutes

whats up with that

[empty lark]

Hungarian Halfbred i think it's called, grey with some white spots, i know it was at least taller than Dutch's horse or at least always seemed to be when I rode with him

Whatever it was it's dead now and i might try to find another like it when i get the chance

[red helm]

Are those in Story Mode?

[hidden moss]

I don't think either can be bought at a stable or found in the wild

But if you cut them free from wagons you can saddle them

[red helm]

Huh... okay, I don't remember them being around.

[ashen condor]

What is best saddle for white Arabiam

Arabian*

[hidden moss]

Panther saddle is the best in my opinion

[ashen condor]

How yu get that

[hidden moss]

Bring a 3* panther pelt to the trapper

Then buy it

Then it will be in "pre-purchased saddles" at the stable

[ashen condor]

Ah aler

I'll stick to gerden trail for now till I progress more

[hidden moss]

I n s i s t

M a n g o e s

[empty lark]

Seeing jack after Chapter 6 is different, kinda like it

[hidden moss]

Opinion: jumping off the cliff in Favored Sons was Dutch's last good plan

[hidden moss]

I think you're the only one

[empty lark]

Sounds about right

I wish I could've thrown "that guy" off the cliff

[hidden moss]

What ending did you get

[empty lark]

High Honor help

[hidden moss]

W

[red helm]

Jack is a little jerk in the Epilogue.

[empty lark]

I heard, still like it for now since it's different

[red helm]

The Epilogue itself is nice, though.

[hidden moss]

Part 1 is trash I can't even sugarcoat it

So boring

Part 2 is pretty good though

[red helm]

Nah, 1 is fine, it's a big change of pace from the last chapters.

And, I mean, It's not like it's long.

[hidden moss]

Literally only 1 gunfight

[hidden moss]

True but that doesn't make it better just more tolerable

[red helm]

Eh, I find it relaxing.

[hidden moss]

Suit yourself

[ashen condor]

For the satchels is it worthit to just make them all first then equip the legend one or

[hidden moss]

Yes

Legend of the East satchel is so good

You can just buy them from a fence in the epilogue though if you're willing to be patient

idk where you are in the game

[ashen condor]

In chapter 2

Done all missions apart from the love Letter

I've jus finished upgrading everything at camp except the peirson stuff

[hidden moss]

In that case yes it's worth it to craft them

Each satchel lets you carry 99 of the item it's for rather than 3

Legend of the East satchel is 99 for all items

[empty lark]

gonna do that myself when i can, couldn't be bothered to hunt for all those perfect pelts

[ashen condor]

Aah sickk

I'm just practically doing everything as early as I can

Apart from collectibles unless I find them normally

[hidden moss]

I tried doing that but I didn't have the patience

[ashen condor]

Ahaba

[empty lark]

I either found something just below perfect or something i did or something random popped up and scared the perfect ones away

[ashen condor]

I jus needa buy a rifle then I can hunt everything in like 2 goes

I've wrote down all the satchel pelts apart from the 2 that you gotta unlock

[hidden moss]

Did you get the bolt action from The First Shall Be Last

[ashen condor]

Na

Gonna buy one

[hidden moss]

F

[ashen condor]

Got every type of fun apart from rifle

Gun

[hidden moss]

It's unlocked in chapter 3

[ashen condor]

So I can't get it rn

[hidden moss]

No if you didn't get it in that mission it's unlocked in Preaching Forgiveness As He Went

You get it for free

[red helm]

All of the animals you need for those satchels should be available in chapter 2.. ?

[ashen condor]

Ah bet idm only got few missions till chapter 3

[ashen condor]

Ik Im on about the satchel that you gotta donate 5 corpses for and craft 5 things for

[hidden moss]

You don't need a rifle though unless you really want one

A bow is just as good

[ashen condor]

Ye but I need to get the perfect pelts

Ah

[hidden moss]

Yeah you don't necessarily need a rifle for that

Although it is good

[red helm]

The Springfield is acceptable, you won't need the Bolt Action for anything.

[ashen condor]

It's only a few animals

4 dear,2elk and 1 of the rest

[hidden moss]

How did you get all the others

If you don't use the bow and don't have a rifle

[ashen condor]

I haven't

[red helm]

I did the all the Satchels in chapter 2, with-out- the Bolt Action, and don't remember a problem.

[hidden moss]

The final mission.

[ashen condor]

I jus said it's only a few animals to get

Like 8

[hidden moss]

Red Dead Redemption.

Oh I thought you meant you already got most of them

[ashen condor]

And half are varmin so it's easy to get like 5 in one run

[hidden moss]

*American Venom

?

Nothing just keep playing the game

U don't need to narrate it here tho

[ashen condor]

How many pelts can go on horse

[hidden moss]

Medium sized pelts like deer are infinite I think

Big game pelts only one

Obviously

[ashen condor]

Alrr

[red helm]

Yeap, I've never had a problem with getting medium pelts on my horse.

[ocean cipher]

Try checking file fidelity or whatever it is in Steam

wth, my name is green now?

Imagine Arthur with some '80s big hair man

and a goatee

[maiden pawn]

Welcome to the cowboy gang

[ocean cipher]

I got $2100 in-game . . . should probably upgrade my wardrobe just a bit

[maiden pawn]

lol

[ocean cipher]

still wearing "Winter gunslinger"

[ashen condor]

Will donating a animal carcass also do the pelt

[maiden pawn]

Yea

Or what?

[ashen condor]

Ah nice

What does it mean by craft 3 recipes at a scout fire

[hidden moss]

The scout fire is the campfire on the outskirts of the camp

[ashen condor]

The one in menu

[hidden moss]

?

[ashen condor]

Wdym

[hidden moss]

What does the one in menu mean

[ashen condor]

Weapon wheel

[hidden moss]

Oh

Wait

I'm confused

[ashen condor]

The camp you can put up anywhere

[hidden moss]

From my understanding there's 3 campfires at camp and one of them is the scout fire

That's how I did it

I don't think the one you set up counts

[ashen condor]

Wheres the scout

[hidden moss]

For some reason it's never indicated which one it is or where it is so I had to look it up but it's on the outside

Away from all the tents and stuff

Do you think "That's the Way it Is." is Arthur wishing the Marstons good luck in their new life?

[hidden moss]

I don't think the lyrics have much meaning to be honest

my messages finally started to load 4 hours later

anyways

How do i get perfect pelt? without maxed out dead eye

[maiden pawn]

it's the one by the horses I believe should be the scout fire

[ashen condor]

Ah yep literally just saw it

[maiden pawn]

Tho apparently it's picky with how you sit

[hidden moss]

Find an animal that has 3 stars next to the name when you focus on it then get a clean kill and skin it

[ashen condor]

Got bill and Keiran around it

[maiden pawn]

Depends on animal you need different weapons and headshots / just any gun that 1hit ko if it's bigger you can also use lasso

[hidden moss]

will a simple headshot work

[ashen condor]

By 5 recipes is it 5 different things or just 5 of 1 thing

[hidden moss]

Sometimes you need a specific gun but yes it needs to be a headshot

[maiden pawn]

Nope

[hidden moss]

will bow work

[maiden pawn]

Bows with poison or small game with certain animals

Is fine without headshot

For some reason on some animals

lol

[hidden moss]

I think it just means craft 5 things doesn't have to be different

but without poison im obligated to hit a headshot?

[ashen condor]

Headshot with right weapon or if it's a big animal use ur Lasso

[maiden pawn]

Nah from my experience so long as it's a 1 hit KO

[ashen condor]

Alrr

[hidden moss]

Hmm okay

[maiden pawn]

it doesn't need to be a headshot

[hidden moss]

doesnt seem that hard

[hidden moss]

Oh yeah if you use poison cause then they die anyway

alright, thank you all

I forgot

[maiden pawn]

Yeah all it needs is a 1 hit KO

thus bow with poison is easy

[hidden moss]

I mean...they do.

Also if they're on the ground killing them with your knife doesn't damage the pelt

Or killing it with your knife when it's lassoed

[maiden pawn]

Lasso killing also works fine

[hidden moss]

But wait

[hidden moss]

No it's just meant to be a sad song to fit the sad moment

The people themselves said what that song meant.

...if only I can send a link.

ive been one shotting rabbits with a regular bow and never get a perfect pelt, do i need small game arrows

[hidden moss]

I didn't mean it's gibberish I just meant it's not super deep it's just supposed to be sad and vaguely fit the story

[maiden pawn]

Varmint

I think

[hidden moss]

It can mean whatever you want it to

Ah okay

Oh, they themselves said that it's Arthur comes to the realization of the choices he's made, and the choices he will make going forward.

I can't exactly send the link or a screenshot for some reason.

I mean that is what's happening when the song plays so I don't doubt it

[woeful fulcrum]

How and where can you check how many Hours you have

[hidden moss]

Can I just DM you the link?

[ocean cipher]

so, if I just stole someone's fishing pole where would it be?

[hidden moss]

The link to what

The meaning of "That's the Way it Is" from the songwriters I mentioned.

[maiden pawn]

What launcher are you using?

[ocean cipher]

ah fishing pole is in the Items at 5 o'Clock

[hidden moss]

I believe it

Ok.

"I didn't have a choice"
You did, Dutch. You had that choice to save John. You left him because he "doubted" you.

Micah shot Susan, a trusted ally of Dutch's...and he still sides with him?

Pride is one heck of a drug, then.

[empty lark]

I love the way Dutch doesn't realize that his plans aren't good for them until nobody's around for him and i cant wait to get finish the first part of the epilogue to get back to it, this normal life stuff is killing me

[ocean cipher]

I have heard tell that game harvests sold in areas distant from where the critter dwells fetch higher prices (e.g., sell gator stuff in Valentine, or . . . I suppose . . . elk stuff in St. Denis?). I don't suppose there is any similar effect for horse breeds? I wouldn't see an inherent reason for such a dynamic, but I wonder . . .

[ocean cipher]

Dutch is one of the most convincingly despicably incompetent CEOs ever written in fiction!

[hidden moss]

How come I've lost when Micah kills me (high honor)?

I'm supposed to die.

Rockstar logic

It has to be in the cutscene

Or am I supposed to convince Dutch to leave Micah before dying?

And thus ends my journey as Arthur Morgan.

Fixing cisual and cloth glitches? Nah.

Horse balls? Sure.

[empty lark]

yep

[ashen condor]

Is the fake blink man the one near fort Wallace with a cane and backpack on

[empty lark]

That's why i started cutting arthur's hair shorter than i usually do, it was going through my coats and i didn't like it

[hidden moss]

And thus Arthur sees his final buck vision.

[ocean cipher]

only part(s) of the game that really rub me the wrong way: (a) auto long-arm holstering; (b) locking Arthur out of exploring so much of the map; to a much less extent (c) locking weapons, abilities, and such behind story progression

[empty lark]

Did anyone else wear the suit Arthur had for some of his robberies?

[empty lark]

first one is really annoying, once went into a fight with just my pistols because arthur left his lancaster on the horse and i needed it for better shots

Another time i went in without a shotgun, which isn't nearly as bad since i can just use my pistols to put a bunch of holes in someone's chest but it's more ammo used than needed

[ocean cipher]

What is even more unbelievaable about the auto-horse holster thing is: it seems abundantly clear that almost all users agree it is annoying, and it has been ranted about incessantly from the very beginning of the games release, yet they have apparently never even pondered something so trivial as an option toggle to disable it

It makes you consider that: maybe they think they know what we are supposed to enjoy better than we do?

[maiden pawn]

b) I understand I suppose as it is lore

[hidden moss]

Abigail and John were 34 at the time of the epilogue, right?

Do you think Jack is the one teaching Abigail how to read?

[maiden pawn]

It's shown and seen at camp

Sometimes you can see people teaching Jack stuff

[empty lark]

I wore this most of the time after I got it, took off the coat of it before Arthur's last and i cant wait to get back into it, i loved the way the vest along with the pants and all that came with it looked on him without the coat

[hidden moss]

Boy Calloway.

[maiden pawn]

There's a lot of dialogues and conversations at the camps

[hidden moss]

Arthur Morgan, even in death, has spread his influence.

"King Arthur."

PTSD Intensifies.

So since John's neutral in honor, I'd like him to try to be honorable at first, then go down a downward spiral just before Abigail and Jack leave him, and then get his honor back up.

[empty lark]

i dont care about honor too much anymore, i'm gonna kill anyone that i feel like deserves it when i get the chance

[ocean cipher]

game just got a bit weird: werewolves and Vikings . . .

[hidden moss]

How do I rob a train without lawmen on me?

[proven mural]

hello im new to red dead online and looking for someone to carry me to get some cash

[empty lark]

wrong channel for that

[empty lark]

I think someone said to stop it in a tunnel, definitely stay away from towns when you're planning to rob one though

[hidden moss]

ah tunnel

smart

[empty lark]

Yeah if you start from a town (which i think should be kinda clear that you shouldn't but still) law will come by quick

Did y'all let Jack win or lose the race, im planning on letting him win

[maiden pawn]

Take train to Annesburg, stay on it jump on top and put on mask. Get inside once it starts rolling north and you'll reach a tunnel. Stop the train and rob there. Law can't get there

[ocean cipher]

Arthur, wearing a Viking helmet, and clothing modeled on the O'Driscolls, with two horses following him (both loaded down with pelts and carcases) and Arthur toting a Good Alligator Carcass on his shoulder . . . jogging into St. Denis . . . greeting everyone in sight

Dude in a carriage: "Now I done seen everything."

[serene tundra]

I died and my current horse (Zues) disappeared and my other horse (Johnny) was spawned in with me instead now I go to a stable and it says Johnny is in the stable but zues isn't which is weird cuz I was just with Johnny but now zues somehow doesn't exist can someone help me with this??

also Johnny had just died before going to the stable which makes it extra weird to why he is alive and stabled ( I didn't revive him)

[south adder]

Nice cat

[ocean cipher]

Damn this TN Walker can get $24 in St. Denis!? Even with level 4 bonding I don't think I've ever seen a TN Walker sell for more than about $12 in Valentine

That means I probably made about $35 off that one poor schmuck I murdered up in the Grizzlies

[maiden pawn]

Sell em at horse fences

[ocean cipher]

"horse fences!?"

[maiden pawn]

When you progress the story you unlock 3 diffent fences for different things

Wagon / stagecoaches fence

Horse

And just the regular fence

Where you earn more than the regular rate for selling there

[ocean cipher]

What is "Seamus?"

the dude in Emerald Ranch?

[serene tundra]

my horse disappear what do

[ocean cipher]

I was pretty sure you could sell coaches and wagons to him too

[maiden pawn]

Wagon fence

[ocean cipher]

was it your "main horse" or a temporary?

[serene tundra]

my main horse

[maiden pawn]

You can sell wagons and stagecoaches and he runs a regular fence

[ocean cipher]

might have died?

[ocean cipher]

so he is a general purpose but not horses

[maiden pawn]

Yep

[ocean cipher]

go to a stable and see if they have your saddle maybe?

[serene tundra]

no I died then when I respawned it was my other horse

[maiden pawn]

The horse fence will be in lemoyne around bolqer qlade I think

Nvm its north of rhodes lol

[serene tundra]

I checked the stable and my horse never existed apparently

I didn't even have a 2nd saddle

[ocean cipher]

"2nd saddle?" I thought one could only ever have one saddle

[serene tundra]

Yeah now that I think about it I think I just used the one saddle

But my horse just completely disappeared

[ocean cipher]

Given that you died, I'd say it is a pretty good chance your horse died

[serene tundra]

I got killed by outlaws are they able to kill my horse?

[ocean cipher]

oh yeah

[serene tundra]

And my horse doesn't respawn with me????

BRUH

That was my best mf horse goddamnit

[ocean cipher]

if your horse got killed in battle/accident/whatever he doesn't respawn

[serene tundra]

I'm very angry now wtf bruh

Now I'm stuck with this stupid half wit horse

[ocean cipher]

ah there are tons of horses though

almost all of them are okay, and some of them are real good

I've been riding mostly TN Walkers and KY Saddlers most of the time, and with a Mustang in tow

[serene tundra]

I have no idea the breed I got rn but it's fast

[ocean cipher]

get off of 'em face 'em, select 'em (on PC that is right MB) and then pull up "Info" (Q on PC)

[serene tundra]

It's a thoroughbred

[ocean cipher]

yep very fast. not so tough though and quite skittish

[serene tundra]

I hate the skittish part she jeeos slowing down cuz if small Rocks

[ocean cipher]

most of the ones that are courageous are hard to get or expensive or locked behind story progress

Turkoman seems to be, arguably, the best horse in the game, but until late in the story, damn near impossible to get unless you knock a bounty hunter off of one.

[sour wasp]

Pouring forth oil missions with John pretty funny, but so many cops at the end of the robbery😂

[ocean cipher]

Is there a police station or sheriff office in St. Denis? I caught this pickpocket . . .

[dull geyser]

Yes

[ocean cipher]

well, apparently you cannot tote him around like you can on some of the random encounters

immediately got a witness for kidnapping

[dull geyser]

Is it one of them kids?

Or the pickpocket from the tailor

[ocean cipher]

from a shop

I did a save right before so if it is screwball I can just go back

[dull geyser]

Ohhh doing that shit in st denis is troublesome

[pale merlin]

If I apply pomade to my hair is it permanent?

[dull geyser]

It wears off for like 2 in game days

[pale merlin]

only 2 in game days??

[dull geyser]

Yep

[pale merlin]

That’s like 96 minutes in real time 💀💀

[dull geyser]

Yeaa time goes faster in the game

Like a minute there is a second

[dull geyser]

I also have a special save when some kids starts talking shit in st denis

[hidden moss]

Im a fool

[ocean cipher]

kinda sucks, cause I know there is at least one very well scripted out random-ish encounter where you can apprehend a criminal (a murderer) take 'em to the sheriff and turn 'em in and no one gives you any flak about it.

[hidden moss]

I went by chapter 2 a little too fast and never got to rob the valentine bank with karen

[dull geyser]

I think that one is a chapter 3 mission

[dull geyser]

The only similar thing I know was the one on valentine

The working girl that stabbed a dude

You can report it

[ocean cipher]

Do the different stocks (Straight Grain and Wide Grain) have any effect on firearm effectiveness or is it just cosmetic?

[empty lark]

Pretty sure it would show a difference in the stats while you were looking at them if it did

oh thank god i just found Uncle in the epilogue

[ocean cipher]

yeah, but this dude in St Denis is saying "I got some better stocks that would fit that gun. Could add to stability."

[hidden moss]

I dont think so I talked to Karen in camp and they said it's a shame they never robbed that bank

[empty lark]

Probably just saying things

[empty lark]

It's not a chapter 2 mission

[hidden moss]

Are u sure?

[empty lark]

You'll do it eventually

Yes

im past chapter 6

[hidden moss]

Okay ty

[dull geyser]

It becomes available after you and lenny attack shady belle

[hidden moss]

Does that happen around the end of chapter 3 or is it beginning-midway

[empty lark]

Just take your time, it's not an optional robbery or anything you'll have to do it at some point

[hidden moss]

That is such a great mission. I love the acting Lenny does.

[empty lark]

feels so nice to have access to Arthur's guns again

[hidden moss]

Did you just get back from Guarma?

[empty lark]

beecher's hope is just pathetic though, couldn't imagine a smaller house

[hidden moss]

Get ready. Game gets crazy....er. lol.

[empty lark]

Yeah im in the epilogue, just waiting for the news on Micah

[hidden moss]

Ah, nice.

[dull geyser]

Yea

Mid way

[dull geyser]

Yepp praise be

[empty lark]

Finally got all the satchels now from a fence

[hidden moss]

Is it just me, or did the Dead Eye sound effect change?

[empty lark]

Yeah Arthur's deadeye sound is different from the "other person's"

[hidden moss]

Is it really? I never noticed that. Not that I played the other person's story much. I started over right as I got to it. 😂

[empty lark]

It's a small detail, probably wouldn't notice unless you just listen at some random point

Heard Arthur and other guy aim differently too, Arthur kept both eyes open while other guy closed one

I think it's supposed to mean Arthur's a more experienced shooter or something like that

[hidden moss]

Yea, I've heard that too.

But I mean, we all know who the better shooter is. 😉

Both legends, but one is definitely better than the other.

[dull geyser]

John has the same deadeye from the first game

[dull geyser]

I say john in rdr1 is a bit better in a gunfight but arthur can swim

But arthur is gonna win h2h

[hidden moss]

You might be onto something.

Arthur never had to fight any zombies.

The fact there is no undead nightmare for RDR2 is criminal.

[ocean cipher]

Wow, a Level 1 bonded TN Walker only commands $2.40 whereas I just sold a basically identical horse that was bonded level 4 for $24.00

[dull geyser]

Undead nightmare 2 with the gang would be nice

[hidden moss]

Yea, it would be so sweet. A missed opportunity.

[dull geyser]

Cant see it happening now

R* doesn't care much for rdr

[hidden moss]

Nah, if it hasn't happened yet it's not going to.

[dull geyser]

I think they confirmed rdr3 tho

Idk might be just fake news

[hidden moss]

Yea, I know. It's such a damn shame too. RDR is way better than GTA

[dull geyser]

Yea just because gta makes them more money

Cant blame em

[hidden moss]

GTA just makes them money, so they go with what makes money.

Yea, I know. Just sucks.

[dull geyser]

Yep

They might put the same amount of effort for gta 6 tho

[hidden moss]

We shall see.

[dull geyser]

Yess

Hope they deliver this time

Not much bangers around

[long robin]

can you stop arthur from kicking out strauss?

[hidden moss]

Don't do his missions?

I'm not entirely sure.

[dull geyser]

Nahh it's gonna happen

[hidden moss]

Where can I find Dutch's money?

[dull geyser]

U cant

The one he got in american venom is probably the blackwater money

[hidden moss]

Doesn't John get it?

I haven't finished the epilogue, so I don't know

Or at least part of it?

His start up money for the beginning of the first game.

I would love a spinoff or expansion, or hell even the next game to let us play the events leading up to Blackwater.

[astral plume]

Yes

[sour wasp]

Arthur as deputy sherif, thats cool

[hidden moss]

Mmm....Legendary Elk meat.

Holy fuck

I was just riding and a bear totally fucked me up.

I killed it. But damn, by the time I realized what was going on the damn thing almost killed me.

Now, where can I sell this Legendary Elk pelt?

Ah, Blackwater.

8 years since John has visited this place.

[dull geyser]

Yeaa there's a lot of things that we don't see before rdr2

I wanna see how the gang started

[hidden moss]

Right!? There are so many unanswered questions.

[empty lark]

Just got finished turning that awful little house at Beecher's hope into something nice, definitely a big improvement

[hidden moss]

So, I'll need to get money.

What can I trade to a Fence for the most money?

[hidden moss]

Gold bars iirc

[hidden moss]

It's a shame I'd love to see a far more updated online

Another prequel game would be kinda fun to play tbh

[dull geyser]

We can have a heist there as well

Arthur kept a piece of newspaper that is about their first score

Then they gave their take away

To the people

[hidden moss]

W

[hidden moss]

I'm there.

Arthur's place of death.

You visit the grave?

It's so surreal being there.

Not his grave.

Where he and Micah fought.

Where the Van Der Linde gang truly died, and where Arthur succumbed to his Tuberculosis.

[real tartan]

Alright i need some help, im doing the epilogue mission "An Honest Day's Labors" and to preface this, i have no mods installed, i have reinstalled and attempted failing the mission in different ways.
When Sally goes and takes cover at the rock the entire mission softlocks, and no npcs respond to anything anymore.

[hidden moss]

U just said his place of death..

[hidden moss]

Ah

And that is where he died.

His body was moved to the area of his tombstone, but this area is where he died.

[real tartan]

Nothing ive tried to fix this works and im getting tired of trying

[hidden moss]

It's awkward camping at that spot.

[hidden moss]

And we thought the ending to rdr1 stung.

[steady prairie]

How do you get horse stamina/health to increase outside of bonding

[sour wasp]

I believe thats only possible with bonding, there are only 4 levels of bonding so once you have reached lvl 4 its maxed out

[steady prairie]

Alright

[hidden moss]

Ye

[sour wasp]

But there are various horses and each horse has good, or bad stats

[sour wasp]

Thats the game ending? So what happens to John, wasnt he hunted by Dutch his gang in rdr1 and forced to the West?

[hidden moss]

John and Abigail moved north for 8 years.

I think that there should of been a cure for Arthur or something but I mean in one mission eagle flys gave us like the herbs and stuff but it does nothing or rockstar could of made the game to have two endings depending on your honour like if u have low honour Micah kills you and if u have high honour you would survive and live a happy life somwhere over seas

They tried to start over multiple times, but John's nature as a gunslinger keeps getting in the way.

Yeah he kept on killing people

[hidden moss]

Thing is, there was no cure for Tuberculosis in 1899.

Yeah true

[sour wasp]

It wasnt human proof until as early as in 1949

[steady prairie]

If New Austin wasn't so sniper filled in 1899 then Arthur could've at least lived a little longer

[sour wasp]

Goddamn pinkertons

[hidden moss]

Will I be wanted if I beat the Lemonyne Raiders in Saint Denis?

[hidden moss]

They should of let Arthur go into new Austin without there being snipers

[sour wasp]

Only if there are witnesses

[hidden moss]

I'm glad we didn't see Arthur suffer TOO much.

But it's the Lemoyne Raiders.

Surely someone would let me off the hook for that.

Depending on the ending

Also, I hear it was Arthur's torture that helped his TB progress to such a point.

[hidden moss]

They are really annoying and keep shooting my horse

I always thought it weird that we contracted it so early.

[sour wasp]

Maybe but thats not the story, they had to run East instead of West and give up all hope of living in the West again because of their sins and beef with local police- and pinkertons

[hidden moss]

Hey, it's that Veteran Shelter.

And Arthur's name is on it.

[hidden moss]

Yeah but Arthur did suffer quite a bit like he got kidnapped by in chapter 3 and shot and had to escape they he nearly died after the bank robbery in chapter 4 and then got TB and suffered then died

[sour wasp]

Same reason mexico wasnt included, aint the story

[hidden moss]

I thought he got it in Guama, but no. Like a few hours into the game.

No he got it in chapter 2

By jimmy brooks

He coughed on him

[steady prairie]

Yeah you can hear him cough a few times after that and before chapter 6

[hidden moss]

It wasn't jimmy Brookes

It was Thomas

Oh yeah jimmy brooks is the guy they said he saw Arthur in black water

[hidden moss]

Yeah Thomas downs

[steady prairie]

No I-I didn't see no Arthurs

[hidden moss]

Hmmm so you didn’t call him out in chapter 2 when he was in valentine?

[steady prairie]

Nope never seen the feller I'd remember

[hidden moss]

Hmm okay I believe you sir

So why does John look like an Arthur reskin?

They had a John Marston model right there that looked like his 1911 iteration.

[steady prairie]

John was trying not to look like John

[sour wasp]

Watching Pearson prepare stew is pure satisfaction, how he cuts the meat, carrots and potatoes.. hmm

[hidden moss]

rockstar was lazy

it's really dumb i wish john looked like john

But horse balls? That's where they put their effort towards?

[sour wasp]

Wow 😂

[sour wasp]

He looks younger in rdr2 and kinda makes sense

[hidden moss]

but in the main story as an npc he looks like how he does in rdr1

like a younger version

[sour wasp]

Its true his shoulders are terribly inconsistent

[hidden moss]

he looks bigger and built like how arthur did

when he's supposed to have a more slim body type

[sour wasp]

That and the movements are slightly different, when he jumps he jumps higher in rdr1 than 2😂

[dull geyser]

Yep I wish we used the same model of him as an npc in the epilogue

But would be probably a shit ton of work if we'll be using clothes meant for arthur in john's model

[sour wasp]

Yes and yes but besides this the story is just great

[dull geyser]

Yeaaaa I love how we see him turn into his rdr1 version

Mowing down tons of enemies in one go

[woeful fulcrum]

rockstar games launcher

[maiden pawn]

Settings > RDR2 in installed games

Somewhere there you should see time

[woeful fulcrum]

thank you

[sick adder]

I have a plan.

[sour wasp]

Running away and hiding 😆

[sick adder]

One last big take, and we are gone…

We are going to Tahiti.

[sour wasp]

Its in the Southern hemisphere so that means no Pinkertons

[wheat bolt]

hey the gear symbol thing on my bottom right keeps spinning and it's not diappearing is that a problem

[hidden moss]

Bro I saw some shit on yt and it said Arthur dies or sum😭 Im on chapter 4 already bro it aint fair the spoilers

I’m staying away from anything like that

where can i get real fast horses

best i got is the american halfbred sold in valentine

Arabian horses you can find in the wilderness there are tutorials on where to find them

Or buy them

where can i buy them, for how much

Saint Denis stable you can buy one I think

An Arabian

Also remember you can upgrade the speed with accessories on the horse

Does it cost above 300

[hidden moss]

Yh its like 1050 I think

Expensive af

i found it

a white elite arabian horse

man i want a horse irl so bad 😂

How do i get the gaucho hat

I need it for my outfit

[maiden pawn]

Randomly around the map on NPCs

[hidden moss]

Alr

[maiden pawn]

I believe there's one on a stagecoach somewhere in Strawberry

And one in Rhodes

Tho that's still jsut random

[hidden moss]

Im just waiting at rhodes

Ive seen it multiple times but law killed me

[maiden pawn]

Just bump into him and he'll start running

[hidden moss]

Alr

[maiden pawn]

Make sure you also run and when he's farther away

Deal w him and run away

[dull geyser]

The brindle white thoroughbred is pretty fast

You can also get a fox trotter or arabian

[hidden moss]

Im doing the midnight mission because ive had the most luck doing this

[dull geyser]

I recommend fox trotters

Really good all around and just as fast as arabians

[dull geyser]

Gunslinger?

[hidden moss]

Ive spent 10+ hours messing about lmao

[hidden moss]

Ye

[dull geyser]

Lmaoo just do your thing in free roam, exploring stuff in the game is fun

[hidden moss]

Fr

Im on my 46th playthrough rn

💀

[dull geyser]

Sheeesh

[dull geyser]

He's pretty legit even though with that crouching bs

[hidden moss]

Fr

[visual helm]

Heya, doing my 2nd playthrough with hella mods, was wondering if anyone have the merge files for NPC catalog and Whyems RDO edition, thanks in advance

[dull geyser]

I just did the draw correctly and it automatcally locked on his hand so its pretty easy

[hidden moss]

Ya

[dull geyser]

Only calloway and granger fought pretty fair

Flaco was the mexican max payne and midnight tries to dropshot

[hidden moss]

Omg

I finally got jt

[dull geyser]

What is it

[hidden moss]

Gaucho hat

I can finally finish my outfit

[woeful fulcrum]

If you sell a horse you can buy it again or catch it

[dull geyser]

I just do the glitch in the stables

Dem prices hurt my pocket

[thorn hull]

I just bought red dead redemption 2

I know how it ends but I’m still gonna cry and I already have the perfect gun load out that I can afford by finding gold nuggets in chapter 2 so grind out chapter one

[sour wasp]

Gold nuggets? Where to find these im in chapter 3 😂

[pale merlin]

Excuse me??? I just killed a random dude in his little tent by throwing him into his campfire and it gave me good points! Whaaat??

[hidden moss]

is the arabian horse considered the best

[woeful fulcrum]

But do you know if you sell a horse if you can catch it again or buy it

[hidden moss]

probably a criminal you killed

[woeful fulcrum]

yes

[hidden moss]

Perfect

[pale merlin]

I was doing a mission where you needed a ledger and pistol and another thing and I confronted the guy in his little tent / campfire

[hidden moss]

where can i get better saddles

i bought the best saddle in valentine and i wonder if there are any better saddles in other towns

[woeful fulcrum]

You can get the best from the trapper

[hidden moss]

i dont know that one

[hidden moss]

Oh

[pale merlin]

I just shot this guys shackle off and accidentally killed him 💀💀

[hidden moss]

i did get better points from killing KKK members hahaha

[dull geyser]

Yes

[pale merlin]

Oh I did that yesterday, I used dynamite on one, missing arm, burned a kkk memner in the campfire and the camp made me release his body cuzz you can’t bring dead bodies into the camp

[dull geyser]

Wouldn't call any horse the best but stat wise it is arguably the best

[hidden moss]

aside from speed and accel, are there other attributes to consider in a horse?

[dull geyser]

Health

[hidden moss]

stamina and health can be maxed with any horse no?

[dull geyser]

No

It's like speed and accel

[empty lark]

Where can I find my clothing and weapon locker in the epilogue?

[dull geyser]

It depends on the breed

[hidden moss]

Ah Okay

is there anything else to consider

[empty lark]

Didn't see it in the house, not sure if i missed it or what

[dull geyser]

If you like the horse's coat I suggest taking it

[hidden moss]

Makes sense

[woeful fulcrum]

On the farm at the beginning I don't think you have to continue playing

[hidden moss]

i love the arabian white

so ill stick with it

[dull geyser]

You wont really feel the difference between the stats

[dull geyser]

Yep looks like u got your horse

[hidden moss]

Very happy with it

[empty lark]

I finished part 2 so is it only there?

[woeful fulcrum]

Are you already on Beechers Hope

[empty lark]

i finished part two

yes

i've done american venom i killed the guy and got back home

[woeful fulcrum]

Dan in the house when you come in left

[hidden moss]

W

[hidden moss]

Is there a reason why my beard isnt growing? Im using hair tonics

Ive slept so much

Do i have be in a specific chapter?

[maiden pawn]

It will reach a max point, you havent reached that yet?

[hidden moss]

Im at style 7 atm in chapter 2

[pale merlin]

This is really stupid but does anyone know how to sleep in chapter 4? I can’t sleep.

I just got here in this point and I can’t find a bed

[fallow atlas]

If I remember right

its next to the stairs

like u go up

and its behind the stairs

I think

[pale merlin]

I know but all I can do is sit

[fallow atlas]

uuuuuuuuh

[maiden pawn]

It doesn't matter what ch. you are on

It just reaches max beard after a while go to any barber to see what length your beard is

[hidden moss]

where do i get the hair tonic

i want it to be really big

[native valve]

General stores

[hidden moss]

I think u go up the stairs and it's the room furthest on the right

Idk tho I haven't played chapter 4 or been to shady belle in ages

you can just place a camp no?

[frail escarp]

Does anyone know what I should do in chapter 2 before I move on? (First play through)

[hidden moss]

All the side missions

[frail escarp]

where do I check them

is it the 90 challenges?

[hidden moss]

They'll be white markers on the map you can find them through exploring

Iirc around I think flatneck stations u can find 2 stranger icons

[frail escarp]

Is there a way to keep track on how many I’ve done and how many there is?

[sour wasp]

Play missions until you unlock the 'a strange kidness' mission, reward is a gold bar worth $300

#chapter2

[frail escarp]

I’ve only got one yellow mission thing left on the map

so I don’t know how long I’ve got left

I’m really new

[hidden moss]

Put ur marker over that mission on the map rq and tell me the name

[sour wasp]

Chapter 2 has 19 story missions

[frail escarp]

Is that one in black water

Its*

Javier Escuella

[hidden moss]

Have u done any by strauss or javier/micah?

[sour wasp]

The gold bar you get saving a german fellow and return him to his family, that guy is in the gold mine business

[frail escarp]

The debt collecting?

[hidden moss]

Yes

[frail escarp]

I just finished a debt collecting mission but the dude was about to die so I just left him

anywhere where I can send images?

[hidden moss]

What was the guys name

[sour wasp]

#red-dead-media

[frail escarp]

In the missions index I’ve got; Javier Escuella, Bounty Hunting, William

that’s it

[frail escarp]

Thomas downed

[pale merlin]

I’m just gonna use a stagecoach, and finally, my Arthur finally grew to level 8 on my new save (restarted merely for the beard and my low honor)

[sour wasp]

Javier Escuella unlocks more missions

[frail escarp]

Ohhh

[hidden moss]

damn

[frail escarp]

Oh yeh I only have 8 completed

[frail escarp]

What?

[sour wasp]

11 missions to go until chapter 3 bud

[hidden moss]

I only did 18

[frail escarp]

Should I do the 90 challenges while I have free roam?

[hidden moss]

Your choice

[frail escarp]

I saw a Reddit post saying do as much as you can in C2

[sour wasp]

Theres i believe 20 missions some are optional i think

The white marks on the map

Not the debts

[hidden moss]

Make sure you don't lose honor

[frail escarp]

Don’t the white marks only appear if you close

[hidden moss]

You want to keep high honor

[frail escarp]

I wanna try get the honourable ending

So I’ve been trying

I don’t know many ways to get honour

[sour wasp]

The big white question marks

[hidden moss]

Has the game been spoiled for you?

[frail escarp]

I only know one thing

very big

[maiden pawn]

Honestly honor doesn't matter just play and have fun :)

[frail escarp]

abt Arthur

[maiden pawn]

Like rewards are nice and all but you should play how you like

[hidden moss]

Story and stranger missions can give honor based on your choices and you can greet people that wirks

[frail escarp]

I don’t know anything about the endings

[hidden moss]

Honor kind of does matter

[sour wasp]

Agreed honor is just a side thing BUT with good honor you can do more missions

[hidden moss]

Plus high honor gives you discounts at stores iirc

[maiden pawn]

Yeah but if you enjoy playing dishonorable just do it

[frail escarp]

I wanna try get 100% completion but will I have to start a new save file if I miss something?

And spend hours and hours redoing the game

[hidden moss]

No

[maiden pawn]

100% completion achievemnt isn't missable

[sour wasp]

You wont miss out i can guarantee

[hidden moss]

Save a new file at every chapter if you're worried

[frail escarp]

So just play the game normally and go back? 🤷‍♂️

[maiden pawn]

I still recommend making a lot of save files incase you miss other things

[sour wasp]

Chapter doesnt end before you finish all chapter missions

[hidden moss]

I'd say better to play honorable first then if you want to replay you could go for dishonorable

[maiden pawn]

Also recommend doing most stuff in Ch2 if you doing 100%

[frail escarp]

Like what

90 challenges?

[maiden pawn]

Just be careful with missions like taxidermist

As that easily bugs

[maiden pawn]

Go into the menu, click progress

[frail escarp]

Yeh

[maiden pawn]

You can see your progress there

[frail escarp]

ohh

[maiden pawn]

It should say XX.X% click that square and you can see what to do

[frail escarp]

Which one

Story or total

[maiden pawn]

Wait lemme check lol

Completely forgot

[sour wasp]

Think both are the same

[maiden pawn]

Or just click your way through it

One of them shows your total progress

[frail escarp]

im so new im still tryna get 15 gold bars is rdo

[sour wasp]

Mines are both on 27%

[maiden pawn]

Mines at 100% :)

[frail escarp]

Ah yeh found it ty

[maiden pawn]

Total completion

Should show you what you need for it

[sour wasp]

Only started recently on the game 😂

Long way to go

[frail escarp]

anyone got a guide which has stranger locations or gang locations? 🤷‍♂️

[maiden pawn]

I got it it only took what

460 hours (including other stuff + my online time is counted in it)

[sour wasp]

Nice 👍

Sounds like a good time spending game

[maiden pawn]

Yeah it was really enjoyable worth every penny

[sour wasp]

Yea i have more hours on online than story tho

[maiden pawn]

Just spending countless hours on just hunting

I find that really enjoyable lol

[sour wasp]

I really love the fishing aspect, it kinda makes sense the way that goes

[maiden pawn]

Fishing is so easy to cheese in this game

[frail escarp]

is fishing part of 100% apart from the bestiary thing?

[sour wasp]

Yet relaxing and satisfying at times especially if you catch the legends

[maiden pawn]

I got the legendary fish within 5 seconds

It's so easy to cheese the fishes

lol

[sour wasp]

Yea its a game in the end

Hunting is also easy

[maiden pawn]

Yeah I don't find fishing that fun

[sour wasp]

Especially the tracking part

[maiden pawn]

I never track I just go skrrt skrrt

[sour wasp]

Follow the lines and the animal will be presented to you, little effort but makes it fun and exiting

I do that i end up in armadillo from valentine lmao

[maiden pawn]

my god the reward for 100% completion in this game is

Just

why