red-dead-singleplayer

[red helm]

Yes, people have talked about losing the Unique ones, when they didn't pick them up.

[ashen aurora]

How many playthroughs u guys done in total

[timber jasper]

Yes

[median haven]

I’m in maybe~6 but I’ve only completely finished the epilogue once I believe

Got to John maybe twice

I tend to start a game and spend a lot of time in chapter 3 then Peter out or screw around online

[pastel jay]

Kinda of a silly question but can you put horses in the huge pen in beechers hope without them desponing? Need it for a horseman challange

[red helm]

No, the pen in Beecher's is any different than any other part in the game, unfortunately.

[spring sonnet]

??

[hidden moss]

[lyric charm]

im asking probably a dumb question, but is there a mission with sadie in the canyons?

i played the game on ps4 but now im playing it again on pc

[hidden moss]

epilogue part 2

yes there is if you mean about the bounty mission

[lyric charm]

im not sure but i think they are about ambushes

you like need to ambush some people

[hidden moss]

yes

this mission is mostly about a bounty

the bounty has a gang

that you need to ambush

[uneven horizon]

no the bounty hunter has a gang

not the bounty

[lyric charm]

when the hell do i reach mexico

[uneven horizon]

rdr1

[hidden moss]

the bounty is a bounty hunter

[lyric charm]

and what about that island garma, rdr 1 too?

[hidden moss]

rdr2

[lyric charm]

bruh i dont understand

[uneven horizon]

after Banking the Old American Art

[hidden moss]

how do you not get it

when u played it at ps4

[uneven horizon]

and before Fleeting Joy

[lyric charm]

im currently on chapter 3 in the rhodes city

[hidden moss]

1 more chapter

2*

[lyric charm]

i didnt complete the whole game on ps4

[hidden moss]

chapters

until guarma

[uneven horizon]

what mission did you complete as last

[hidden moss]

say the name

[lyric charm]

going with sean to a homestead

[hidden moss]

thats side activity

[uneven horizon]

I am in Chapter 6 in my 6th playthrough and going for platinum trophy

[lyric charm]

you asking what mission i last completed on ps4?

[uneven horizon]

last main mission

[hidden moss]

yes

[lyric charm]

helping the sherrif of rhodes on the train if im correct

i really dont remember

[uneven horizon]

The New South

[hidden moss]

a new south

in chronological mission order its the first mission of chapter 3

[lyric charm]

i played rdr2 first time 3 years ago

yea prob

i have no idea what happens next in the game

[hidden moss]

well you know about guarma

[lyric charm]

i only know about guarma and mexico (both watched on yt)

[hidden moss]

big spoil kinda

[lyric charm]

where are the geysers

i have jack gang map 2

something about geysers

or volcanos lol

[uneven horizon]

I am on 74% completion as Arthur alone so I might get 100% completion

[hidden moss]

you can search the guide on yt

cant really tell you the location

[uneven horizon]

one of the rocks at Cottora Springs

[lyric charm]

how much more citys will i find?

[uneven horizon]

where the Legendary Wolf is

[lyric charm]

i discoverd strawberry, valentine, colter and rhodes

and blackwater

[uneven horizon]

but you cant get there as Arthur

[hidden moss]

strawberry, blackwater, tumbleweed, armadillo, saint denis, colter, rhodes, annesburg, lagras

[uneven horizon]

Van Horn

[hidden moss]

van horn yeah

emerald ranch

valentine

[lyric charm]

i never knew about tumbleweed, armadillo, saint denis, annesburg or lagras

thats new for me

and van horn, whats that

[uneven horizon]

Emerald Ranch is more an establishment than a town

[lyric charm]

is that a city as well?

[uneven horizon]

a small town

[hidden moss]

its a location so

[uneven horizon]

yeah but you can only find a Fence and a Train station there

[lyric charm]

is there any boats or flying machines in the game

[hidden moss]

and post office

and cards game

so

yeah

[uneven horizon]

hot air balloon in Chapter 6 when you go to Sisika

look for John

[lyric charm]

wow

[hidden moss]

arturo

[uneven horizon]

only for that mission

[hidden moss]

my favorite side character

[uneven horizon]

I am going Lilian for this one

or Tommy

in Chapter 2

[hidden moss]

she is annoying af

cant even drink in a bar

[lyric charm]

how do you hunt the legendary bear?

in the mission with hosea

[hidden moss]

eagle eyes

[lyric charm]

the bear is so tough

did you mean dead eye?

[hidden moss]

you can kill it only after u finish the mission with hosea and stay there (if you leave its the same but the bear will spawn another time)

[hidden moss]

no eagle

[uneven horizon]

only for clues of the bear

[lyric charm]

oh

well i chose to stay and hunt for the bear

and i died brutally

[hidden moss]

i spam F

when i get attacked by the bear

[lyric charm]

i didnt know you can escape the bear grapple

[uneven horizon]

I need to do that 18 times for a trophy

and kill it

[hidden moss]

already done it lol

you can watch Nick AR if you are hunting for platinum trophies

a youtuber that reached 100 platinum trophies

[lyric charm]

how do i get money quick

i really want to upgrade the camp

[uneven horizon]

I have 71% progress of platinum trophy

[uneven horizon]

find gold bars

[hidden moss]

nice

[lyric charm]

how much is one worth about?

[uneven horizon]

$500

[hidden moss]

you can get 1 after chapter 2 for free

[hidden moss]

sometimes its more depends on the weight

[lyric charm]

from the german family?

[hidden moss]

yeah

[uneven horizon]

thats a gold ignot

[lyric charm]

yea i got it

[hidden moss]

you have one i presume

[uneven horizon]

worth $300

[lyric charm]

yea but thats only one

[hidden moss]

oh yeah mb

[hidden moss]

you can sell it at the fence

[lyric charm]

i need A LOT

[hidden moss]

in emerald ranch

[uneven horizon]

or donate to camp funds

[lyric charm]

can you rob banks by yourself

[hidden moss]

then do treasure hunt

[uneven horizon]

no

[hidden moss]

no

[lyric charm]

i know that you can rob trains

[uneven horizon]

you cant rob banks by yourself

[hidden moss]

in the ultimate edition there is a side activity (like sean robbing homestead) where u rob the rhodes bank

[hidden moss]

yes

[uneven horizon]

its with Javier

you can do it in Chapter 4

[lyric charm]

i robbed like 5-10 trains

[hidden moss]

yeah

ik

[uneven horizon]

and Sean is dead in Chapter 4

[lyric charm]

alr ima go play rdr 2

this is way too many spoilers

[hidden moss]

see my msg again

[hidden moss]

and that was a spoiler

you cant

hide

idk why mods dont enable it

[uneven horizon]

I would do an spoiler message but its deleted the second you send it

[hidden moss]

yeah

[lyric charm]

i play cracked rdr 2

[hidden moss]

oh

[foggy flint]

same here

anyway quick question what does the darker area from the gun stats mean?

[uneven horizon]

what you can get for the gun stats

[lyric charm]

i dont wanna play rdo. if im being honest i dont wanna spend my money

[hidden moss]

rdo is dead anyway

so

[lyric charm]

alr bye everyone

ima head to play rdr 2

[hidden moss]

bye

[uneven horizon]

bye

[foggy flint]

wdym about that?

[loud nacelle]

Wait you can't use spoiler tags?

Oh my god you can't

Why not

[hidden moss]

idk

ask the mods

i believe its considered to be spam or sth here

[loud nacelle]

💀

[hidden moss]

guns potential. gun familiarity increases its potential. meaning the more u use it the better u get with it. also bullet type

just finished the game

it was so good

the ending is so sad

[foggy flint]

so you mean the more i use the gun the stats of it like the dmg and range will increase?

[foggy flint]

if only herr straus sent micah instead of arthur

[foggy flint]

cause even with max condition and good ammo type it still has the darker area thing

[hidden moss]

Whats ur guy’s favorite fishing spots

[hidden moss]

new austin and west elizabeth

I like lemoyne , i seem to catch the biggest fish in the swamp

Up north to like where u catch the legendary salmon

[loud nacelle]

Just behind the mayor's house

Nice big fish

[uneven horizon]

I only fish for the challenges I dont really have a good fishing spot but Dakota River can be a good place

[crisp acorn]

The river above Rhodes right before the swamp

[quasi island]

Lake Owanjila, mostly for the surrounding wildlife, trapper and beauty

[hidden moss]

bards crossing best fishing spot

[worthy spire]

help me out here

my beloved horse just fucking died

it god mauled by a train so fast I couldnt revive it in time

is she dead forever

[loud nacelle]

Reload the save

@worthy spire

Oh nvm it's been 7 minutes unless you're smart and make new saves continually you're fucked from autosave

💀💀💀

But yeah that train just wafflestomped your horse

[worthy spire]

guess thats that

[loud nacelle]

Should've had a better saddle 🤷‍♂️

[worthy spire]

goodbye white arabian

[worthy spire]

fym

[loud nacelle]

Is this your first playthrough?

[worthy spire]

yes

im john doe

[loud nacelle]

Did you not know... You can get better saddles?

[loud nacelle]

Oh lol

I was gonna say the horse respawns in epilogue I think

[worthy spire]

what saddle is going to protect my horse from a rampaging train

[loud nacelle]

A better one

[worthy spire]

???

[loud nacelle]

Just get a better saddle and maybe you wouldn't have been hit by a train

I think a really good saddle is the one you can make at the trapper if you give him a perfect panther pelt

[worthy spire]

bro what are you talking about

I took a train ride

[loud nacelle]

And your horse's saddle was shit so it got destroyed

[worthy spire]

and I got off the train and my horse decided to stand right infront of it

[loud nacelle]

Simple

[worthy spire]

BRO

wym?? saddles?

I had a good saddle

[loud nacelle]

I don't get what you're not understanding

Just get a better saddle and this won't happen

[worthy spire]

I dont understand what makes you think a saddle couldve prevented any of this

she’d die

saddle or no saddle

my friend

[loud nacelle]

Clearly you weren't that good of a friend if you let her get hit by a train and not get a better saddle

🤷‍♂️

[worthy spire]

bro why are you so hellbent on a god damn saddle

im also reffering to you as my friend, not my god damn horse

well shit

[hidden moss]

I like that too

[hidden moss]

Ill have to check that out

[hidden moss]

yea i like just fishing in my free time

[vivid fable]

hi

[quick shadow]

where can i find the other mutilated corpses? already found the one near valentine

[quick shadow]

also is there any better horse than the white arabian?

[surreal oxide]

One near riggs station i think, and the other is south east of Braithwaite Manor

[steel sail]

hi

[quick shadow]

wooooo

i found 1$ at the bottoms of a well

omg

this game is so good

the dude that lost his house is the one from the mission where you hide in the shed and he gets visited by some dudes

[celest harbor]

there's a couple wells you can find money in i believe

[shut trench]

Guys I have a question, I can't see my fps on rdr2 (pc) softwares like Fraps or Msi doesn't work (but for other games they just work fine only not for rdr2) someone nows how I can fix that? I would realy appreciate it

[native valve]

Black Arabian is the best one in the game I believe

[quick shadow]

Where do I find that?

[sudden stirrup]

Guys i have benn doing legendary bounties and I get no xp for my bounty Hunter role why????

[native valve]

You buy it in the Saint Denis stable

For a couple thousand

[quick shadow]

Pff

Can I steal it?

[native valve]

#rdo-chat

[quick shadow]

Like a chad

[native valve]

Lol

Sadly not

[quick shadow]

How much better is it than the white?

I have it on bonding 4 already

[native valve]

It has almost full health and stamina rings, 8 on speed and 8 on acceleration

With lvl4

[daring atlas]

just finished rdr2 but got low honor ending, im too curious and i wanna see the high honor one, should i watch it on yt now or just wait to replay the game with high honor and see it myself

[red helm]

If you are curious, go and ahead and watch the other Three.

[agile trellis]

I mean its really your choice

Many people streamed high honor so you can always watch ir

it*

But imo playing for high honor is better

[hidden moss]

It is

[red helm]

Higher since of Achievement, sure. But, rather a long game, so...

[pastel jay]

Doin gambler 8 right now...

Someone kill me😫

[red helm]

Ouf.....

[loud nacelle]

I haven't even done the fourth yet LOL

[pastel jay]

I stopped on the fourth one for a while but I just started up again

[loud nacelle]

I'm a terrible gambler

[pastel jay]

I'm good at poker but God awful at blackjack

[loud nacelle]

They should've done stealth challenges instead of gambling

I'm a sneaky mf

I play stealth games 😎

[pastel jay]

Lol, I ain't, I go in guns blazin

[loud nacelle]

(Dishonoured)

[loud nacelle]

Oh me too in rdr2

I have my lancy why wouldn't I

Speaking of which is the lancaster or the evans better

[pastel jay]

U use Lancaster too

!!

[loud nacelle]

Yeah

Whenever I start a new game my first priority is always rhodes gunsmith

[pastel jay]

I have no priorities

I'm currently grinding 100 percent though

I'm at 92

[neat knoll]

Bruh why does Sadie keep nagging Pearson after the first mission with her?

[regal flicker]

what do you mean?

[neat knoll]

She keeps yelling at Pearson and it’s annoying

[empty harness]

help

help meee

[loud nacelle]

First playthrough?

[neat knoll]

6th

[hidden moss]

Same

Im at like 90%

[frozen fox]

I'm only at 13% of the way I just got to the part where Arthur gets tuberculosis

[hidden moss]

Yo bro keep going

[pastel jay]

I will man, I will

[hidden moss]

What is your honor

[pastel jay]

Max

Positive

Max positive

[hidden moss]

I'll show u my honor in #red-dead-media

[pastel jay]

Alrighty

[cold lily]

I'm letting my brother do the single player

He shot up valentine

[hidden moss]

Anyone else accidentally do something bad and load save to fix ur honor

[pastel jay]

I've been on gambler 8 for 2 hours now😭😭😭

[cold lily]

Yep

[cold lily]

I feel your pain

[pastel jay]

Riding too fast in valentine

[hidden moss]

That actually happend

I hit a man

Loaded save

Fixed my honor

[pastel jay]

I've been looking at a reddit for the gamble challenges and it says do it in van horn, be left of the dealer, and bet 12 cents. All of which I'm doing

[hidden moss]

Wrong place, reddit bad utube better

[pastel jay]

I ran over a man while riding to the mission our best selves and lost honor, but I just greeted 3 people and got that honor back

[hidden moss]

It feels so good to greet people and go up honor level

[pastel jay]

It really does

I've decided to go to Arthur's grave whilst I'm at 99 percent, cuz then I'll get the visit all fallen gang members trophy, abtain 100 percent, and the special line of dialog

[tawdry moon]

FML I can't find 3 star opposum anywhere

[twin herald]

hey guys im trying to get bountiful achievement but how do i get a high bounty in ambarino?

[solid eagle]

Question, why are Dutch and Micah together in American Venom? It's obvious that their friendship seemed to dissolve as Dutch walks away from him and Arthur after Arthur's death. He also waits to reveal himself from the cabin rather than assisting micah from the start when John and the gang began firing.

[dark matrix]

does anyone know of any mods that get rid of weapon bloom?

[daring atlas]

hi i started the epilogue but i ended arthur with low honor, is it worth to finish the epilogue or can i just restart the game and go for high honor arthur, and after that do the epilogue

i rushed thru the game and i did no side quests and now i see its a mistake

[solid eagle]

Do you just want things like arthur's grave to be decorated in the epilogue?

[daring atlas]

no i just realised i played the game too fast, literally did each chapter in 2-3 days, did no side missions and people say there are good ones + i wanna experience the high honor ending, i just wanna know if i should do it now or finish with john and then do it

[pastel jay]

When your in chapter 6 go around greeting every 3 people in Daint Denis and you'll get your honor up. There is an honor bonus in chapter 6. A lot of people say fishing is quicker but that is CAP, I spent 1 hour fishing and got my honor up to half but I greeted people for 30 minutes and maxed my honor

Make sure you have max honor before you do the mission Our Best Selves bc after that mission you get launched right in to the mission Red Dead Redemption which is where something happens...

[daring atlas]

thank you, i wish i got my honor up, but i was gonna replay it anyway cuz i missed lots of stuff, i just dont know if i should replay it now or finish with john and then do

[worthy spire]

replay it now

it does come down to you but

experience it again, not rushed and being a good person

I think it’s better than just johning it all

[quasi island]

and the epilogue feels more rewarding after a high honor run

[pastel jay]

And Arthur's "Spot" looks pretty cause the flowers🤗
I remember on my first high honor play through all I wanted to do was shoot anything that moved🤣🤣

[loud nacelle]

If you want to play high honour

Rush through the story with high honour

And then go back to the other save with John and fuck around

[tiny nymph]

Can anyone test something for me since I don’t have the game on PC, I need someone to spawn in the legendary alligator with a trainer or mod menu on a save before Chapter 6, study, kill and skin it

Then sleep and check if Arthur drew it in the diary

I’ve done all the legendary animals including the New Austin ones in Chapter 2 with Arthur so I just wanna see if it’s possible to get the alligator with a trainer

[spring sonnet]

I was never able to spawn the legendary alligator with Arthur on pc, then i read it will not spawn before chapter 6, same with the Tatanka bison aparently

[quick shadow]

yoo new deadeye ability

[crisp acorn]

Dutch was completely lost after Arthur left and also wanted to kill micah so when they meet again Dutch makes Micah think he wants to work together but in reality Dutch wants to kill him. Dutch just got the chance to kill Micah when John came up

Once Micah was dead dutch was just empty which is why he says “I ain’t got much more to say” and just walks away

[spring sonnet]

sorry actually legendary alligater needs chapter 4

[crisp acorn]

No it needs epilogue to kill

You see him once in chapter 4 in that mission but you can’t hunt him till you play as John

[spring sonnet]

the tatanka is only once in epilogue, alligater is in chapter 4, i just read it

hm

ok yes you can see it in chap 4 but only kill it in epilogue, they mention that elsewhere on the page

looks like the only 3 i can do as i did the others are wolf, coyote and fox

i'm only at beginning of chapter 3

[quick shadow]

bought the black arabian now

gave it braids lmao

[spring sonnet]

my white arabian has black braids 🙂

where do you buy the black arabian?

[crisp acorn]

St denis chapter 4

[spring sonnet]

ok thanx

[crisp acorn]

Np

[spring sonnet]

cant get it yet, neways i'm sure i dont have enough money

only have about 1k$

[crisp acorn]

With high honor discount it’s 800 but with no discount it’s 1000

[spring sonnet]

ah ok not bad

[crisp acorn]

In the epilogue there’s one more Arabian you can buy in black water

[spring sonnet]

my honor is at about 2\3 i think

what happens if you find a house stash before Strauss send you to that specific place/ I'm sure i found one last i played

ended up in a house with a black man and his son in it, the father attacked me and i killed him, i threatened his son and he told me where money was hidden in the chimney

pretty sure it was going to be one of the place Strauss will send me in chapter 3

also killed maybe 20 lawmen there hehe

[thin coral]

How do i get the lasso in rdr1??

[spring sonnet]

@thin coral see Bonnie she give u a mission at MacFarlane's Ranch, she shows u how to use lasso and guves u one.

[thin coral]

Okay

[civic vault]

You can get a black arabian for free if you rescue a couple in St. Denis thats being held up by a crook who's riding a black arabian. Beat/kill that crook and get his horse. The encounter usually happens at night.

[tiny nymph]

That’s why I’m asking to do it on a trainer

You can spawn animals and legendary animals with it

[tiny nymph]

You can get every animal in the game in chapter 2 besides the legendary alligator

Unless you spawn it in with a trainer

[quick shadow]

it was 1050 for me

bro amputed his arm

poor guy

[quick shadow]

Where can I find legendary animals and how do I hunt them?

[lyric charm]

is armadillo in new austin

and tumbleweed

[hidden moss]

ye

[spring sonnet]

sux, on 3rd mission for the photographer, he sends you to herd some horses to him, one of them is a really nice silver pinto, sadly, you can't get it. i tried running after the horses after he took his photo, they all stop under some trees and you cant interact with them. if you talk to photographer after he takes his photo, the horses just climb a hill and disapear 😦

i really wanted that horse, can't even lasso it.

[quick shadow]

NOOOO

arthur starts coughing

[celest harbor]

what chapter are you in?

[quick shadow]

currently attacking brontes house

[celest harbor]

i first heard Arthur's cough in like chapter 3 i believe, maybe chapter 4 I can't remember

[hidden moss]

i think theres only one cough in chapter 3 when you go attack that weird family with javier when he lifts the big box he starts coughing out

its a side quest

[hidden moss]

😩😩

[quick shadow]

hes coughing again

[lucid oak]

so tragic

[quick shadow]

[lucid oak]

tell him to stop

[hidden moss]

I use to make him smoke after he started coughing

Bro literally like coughs up a lung

[quick shadow]

i liked straus but now i hate him

[hidden moss]

I liked bro

He evil tho

[lucid oak]

such an upstanding citizen

[quick shadow]

bc of him he got tb

[hidden moss]

Wait what part r u on?

[quick shadow]

robbing a bank rn

[hidden moss]

Which one

[quick shadow]

NOOOOO

hosea

[hidden moss]

oh shit lmfao

Ur on that mission

[hidden moss]

sad 😢😢

not just hosea

[hidden moss]

those who know

[quick shadow]

LENNY

NOOO

fuck you

im done

[hidden moss]

[quick shadow]

can i cancel the mission? i wanna make a save game

[hidden moss]

i think so

i also think you can jhust load ur last autosave

and it will load the moment before u started the mission

[quick shadow]

i cant save

somehow

says currently unable to manually save

[hidden moss]

yeah u cant save during mission

[quick shadow]

im not in the mission anymore

[hidden moss]

oh just wait in the game for a bit

the game might be autosaving

u cant save during an autosave

[vital marlin]

yes

open the log, choose the mission and hold space

[quick shadow]

bill looks like trevor in that suit

[swift forge]

Is this game still worth a play if ive got the ending and mostly what happens in chapters 4-6 spoiled

[hidden moss]

thats how i played it

[quick shadow]

me too

yeah its worth it

[long wing]

I just got to Chapter 2 and killed 3 men in Lonnie's Shack, I guess I woke them up. Should I reload a save? I don't know how this would affect the story and I'm trying to get 100% with all missables

[swift forge]

Ok im just in chapter 2 and the story seems a lil dry so

[quick shadow]

oh fuck

oh fucking hell

naahh

micah

[long wing]

No spoilers pls

Or please use the spoiler tag thing

[hidden moss]

spoiler tag gets auto deleted by bot

idk how to work around it

[long wing]

That's lame

This is the official RDR2 discord???

[hidden moss]

its partnered but i dont think its endorsed by rockstar? could be wrong

[long wing]

I'm new to the game, they should let you use spoiler tags

[hidden moss]

the people in lonnies shack do come back

btw

so u could probably reload a save if you dont want to miss

an encounter

[long wing]

Ok, I did

[hidden moss]

but its not that interesting

you will inevitably miss encounters because of just how many there are

[long wing]

I'm trying to lasso deer, I suck at this

[hidden moss]

and camp convos and item requests as well

just shoot them in the head with an arrow for perfect pelt if thats what ur trying

[long wing]

Nah, I'm following a guide

I only have a normal bow so far

[hidden moss]

yeah

[long wing]

No special arrows

[hidden moss]

u only need a normal bow

[long wing]

For a 3 star?

[hidden moss]

no special arrows needed

for deer

or cougars or pronghorn

most medium animals like those

[long wing]

Shoot them in head and it's 3 star?

[hidden moss]

just need normal arrow

no

[long wing]

Clean kill I mean

[hidden moss]

it needs to already be spawned as a 3 star

and u need to shoot it in the head with an arrow to not ruin the pelt

[long wing]

Ohh so some deer just aren't 3 star

from the get go

[hidden moss]

yeah they are just bad genetics

or whatever

yeah but u can ruin the3 star if you use revolver or repeater

the caliber is too light or something

or the gun is not powerful enough

but if the gun has rifle in its name it is powerful enough and u can headshot them

or if its a bow

[long wing]

I'm confused about what to do with the carcasses. You can only put one the back of your horse.

[hidden moss]

yeah you take them to pearson

and u can get upgrades from him

if you collect enough

[long wing]

Just one at a time?

[hidden moss]

but you don tneed the full carcass

[vital marlin]

buck antler trincket

[hidden moss]

you can store as many skins as you want on the horse

but only 1 carcass

[long wing]

Yeah skins, but I mean carcasses

[hidden moss]

1 big carcass 2 small on the sides

[long wing]

What is the best thing to do with the carcasses?

[hidden moss]

carcasses are only required i think 3 times

carcass is usually worthless

unless u wanna sell it to the butcher

but its a hassle getting them one by one

[long wing]

If I'm carrying one and set up a camp, can I cook it?

[hidden moss]

ye

same with fish

[long wing]

Ok cool ty

[hidden moss]

goes without saying the carcass is deleted after you cook it

you should skin it before cooking it

if you plan to cook it

and if its big game meat try to find seasoning for it and you can get buffs

[long wing]

Is there a way to get a decent horse besides the special edition one and the Arabic white one in Chapter 2? I want a black horse, or a dark brown horse but with good stats

and without buying it

[hidden moss]

Really?

what do you mean by decent

Is it only big game

yeah

I season most the food

[long wing]

Similar to the white arabic, even if it's not as good

[hidden moss]

Interesting

big game is the only one that gives you golden cores

[spring sonnet]

interesting glitch, I'm in St-Denis, decided to visit the cemetery, one of the biggest mosoleum didn't have doors, so i go in the check it out, just a bunch of coffins and a large angel statue, i turn around to leave, 2 doors have appeared in the entrance and now i can't get out.

[long wing]

I just want a decent black or dark brown horse, not spotted

[hidden moss]

horse stats dont matter just get one you think looks cool

horse speed is capped in missions, your horse will never be shot at by npcs in missions, so health doesnt matter, and your horse stamina is capped too

i recommend an American Standardbred horse

that one is fully black

you can find it north of strawberry

[long wing]

Ooh I'll look it up

[hidden moss]

its to the west of horseshoe overlook

near wallace station there is a beautiful valley where you can find the horse

you cant send links here

[long wing]

Ohh

[hidden moss]

go to #red-dead-media i think

or maybe links arent allowed idk

[long wing]

Ok I posted it

[spring sonnet]

yup cant get out of mausoleum and had not saved for a long while 😦

[thin coral]

My arthur looks like a caveman

I never shaved his beard for 3 chapters

He had the same gunslinger jacket for 3 chapters

[hidden moss]

shave everything’s

make him a new man

[thin coral]

I refuse, if i shave everything my outfit looks bad

I need an actually good beard

Clean shave too basic

[hidden moss]

fax

I usually get the English man or whatever its called

The chops and mustache combo

[thin coral]

I dont wanna look like micah

[hidden moss]

Arthur looks cool with it

micahs looks stupid

[thin coral]

hair and beard in #red-dead-fashion

lumberjack arthur ftw

[quick shadow]

srsly?

a chain gang

now im fighting with some local monkeys

[hidden moss]

Mr white and mr black

[quick shadow]

ok dutch has gone insane

[sweet glade]

im working on 100% completion rn and the hunting requests are the hardest thing to complete i stg

[quick shadow]

arthur pls stop coughing

[daring atlas]

does arthur's ending affect the epilogue?

[pastel jay]

I don't think so

[daring atlas]

ty

[pastel jay]

I mean... you lose Arthur's money but if you get robbed by the Aberdeens before the mission our best selves then go back during the epilog then you can get it back

[gray oyster]

it effects how people talk about him.

[hidden moss]

That's why high honor better

[thin coral]

If you go back for the money micah will be missing an eye

I think

[hidden moss]

Which honor

[thin coral]

Both i think

I did it as high honor and it still took his eye

[hidden moss]

Noice

[civic vault]

People found some ways to get that silver pinto but it seems tedious to do so I don't bother lol. Would be nice tho

[gray oyster]

I prefered to see how much of an asshole charles would be towards arthur

[hidden moss]

Why would u do that

[gray oyster]

how much of an asshole is charles

[hidden moss]

I know but still

[gray oyster]

Idk whether jack changes though.

[hidden moss]

[hidden moss]

Nah dutch is genius

[hidden moss]

I had such a hard tkme with the rabbit pelts lmfao

[pastel jay]

Oh my fucking god

[hidden moss]

Fax

[pastel jay]

Yes!! I HATE the hunting requests with a passion

[hidden moss]

i couldn’t find a single rabbit

it took my so long

[pastel jay]

I can't find a perfect oriole for the life of me

[somber knoll]

guys, can someone help me with this mission: good, honest, snake oil?? It isnt appearing to me

[long robin]

sad

what chapter you guys on

[lucid oak]

only high honor takes his eye

[somber knoll]

is it a bug or what? I'm starting chapter 2

[long robin]

same

[hidden moss]

3

[long robin]

cool

[pastel jay]

Any tips for gambler 10

?

Nevermind😁

[drowsy mountain]

i really noticed the turning point was in chapter 5 in guarma

not gonna spoil it anymore

[quick shadow]

god damn

crawling behind sadie sure is a sight

[burnt bough]

😐

[vivid fable]

I Have a very important question\

i need a respond asap

please

@burnt bough

[burnt bough]

ummm

Do i wanna know

[vivid fable]

i hunted for a panther for like 4h i got it i drived it to trapper in saint denis and it dissapeared|

[burnt bough]

🤨

Idk what u want me to tell ya

[quick shadow]

huh, cant i give perfect pelts in the lakay camp?

[elder quail]

That sucks

[quick shadow]

bro im so good at this game

found a way to skip the skinning animation

[queen fossil]

Yeah, you just put a horse on the carcass

You can do that on rdr1 too

[quick shadow]

im currently in elk territory but i cant find any

nvm found one

and a perfect one at that too

[hidden moss]

How many pelts can you put on the back of your horse? Ive read various things online and im not sure what to believe.

[native valve]

How do you complete the gambler challenge 4?

I’ve been at it for hours

[hidden moss]

Which on is that? Ive heard those gambling challenges are hell.

RNG for days.

Wanna prepare myself. 😂

[vernal raptor]

Does anyone know how to fix this?

I keep getting an error message when I try to open RDR2 that says "Failed to connect to Rockstar Games Library Service"

[hidden moss]

Are you signed into the right profile?

Do you need to update Rockstar Social Club?

Or whatever RDR2 uses in conjunction with Steam.

Are you on console and everything I said was bullshit!?

😂🤣

[vernal raptor]

This might be right, I tried updating the Rockstar Games Launcher but maybe

[hidden moss]

Let me know if it works

Ok so try checking the integrity of games files

[vernal raptor]

Nvm apparently they're the same thing

[hidden moss]

Are you on Steam ?

[vernal raptor]

I'll verify the game files now

Yeah

[hidden moss]

After that is done. Try me a favor and restart your PC.

Let me know if it works after that.

[vernal raptor]

Will do, cheers.

[hidden moss]

I hate Van Horn

Evert time i go there they kill my horse for any reason

[ashen ibex]

Eh

Hu ha!

[hidden moss]

Yikes. Bad luck.

[ashen ibex]

My time play: 1,644.1 hour is this fine?

[hidden moss]

Some idiot npc basically told everybody to get out of the saloon just when i was passing with ny horde

[native arrow]

Where the hell are the big cats
I have no luck with them 😭

[deft knot]

Leveling the honor scale up seems to take forever

[hidden moss]

Me too

I am greeting all npcs, doing missions that give u more honor and im still on neutral-low honor

Can anybody give me tricks?

[deft knot]

Donate in camp too

[deft knot]

Fishing and throwing back

It works for me and it does go up

But so slow... 😂

[hidden moss]

Forgot about fishing

[deft knot]

You sir, are a fish! 🐟

[quick shadow]

what do i need to hunt the legendary bear?

[hidden moss]

Nothing just use any guns and enough bullets to slay the thing

No perfects

Just legendary

Any gun

[fathom brook]

Advanced Arrows work good on bears generally too, but...

[hidden moss]

[quick shadow]

but what?

[fathom brook]

But they don't shoot as fast as guns and there's a decent chance you'll get mauled if you miss the head in the two or three Arrows you'll get off compared to a gun.

[hidden moss]

Just get a fast firing gun with lots of ammo

Or duel weild revolvers

[hidden moss]

Worked for me!

[quick shadow]

i entered the bear area but it said too much stuff to track

[fathom brook]

If you are sneaky you might find a high point that the bear cannot run straight up so it'll have to circle and it'll give you more time e to shoot it. Or you might see it fairly far off and it'll also give you time to get more shots off with your rifle.

[quick shadow]

i dont need any of those tricks

i have aim

🗿

proceeds to get mauled by it

[fathom brook]

sips his coffee.

Make sure you stream that...

[hidden moss]

[quick shadow]

should i?

[fathom brook]

No...

You should go find your bear! Good luck!

[quick shadow]

i cant find it

[hidden moss]

Track the gold things in eagle eye

[quick shadow]

there are no gold things

[hidden moss]

Oh

Uh

Maybe return to camp and sleep a few days

[fathom brook]

Is the area gold covered? Like a cloud with a gold ? In it?

[hidden moss]

Send screenshot in #red-dead-media

[fathom brook]

Did it say 'there is a legendary animal near you'?

[quick shadow]

i think my horse is broken

its steaming

[quick shadow]

no

[fathom brook]

Then you are not in the right spot

[quick shadow]

im literally on the bear symbol

[fathom brook]

Have you killed any other legendary animals?

[quick shadow]

no

i only encountered this big gator in that one mission

idk if that dude is legendary tho

[hidden moss]

@quick shadow

Try this

[quick shadow]

i did

[hidden moss]

Or save and reload

[spring sonnet]

@quick shadow shotgun with slugs, in the face, bear does not like it at all 🙂

[quick shadow]

i heard a bear roar just now i thinl

[quick shadow]

can i lasso it?

[hidden moss]

No

[quick shadow]

bad game

[hidden moss]

[spring sonnet]

using a lasso on a bear, whether it worked or not would just piss it off and you'd die

anyways if it's close enough to lasso, you're pretty much already dead hehe

[quick shadow]

dam mooses are big

[spring sonnet]

same thing, use shotgun with slugs in the head on those

[quick shadow]

shit

it lost a star

[spring sonnet]

did you kill the legendary buck yet?

[quick shadow]

no

i didnt do anything legendary

[spring sonnet]

when you kill it. go see the fence at Emerald Farms, he can make you a buck trinket with the antler, it raises your chance of getting a 3 * pelt

[quick shadow]

it said i have entered legendary territory

[spring sonnet]

then use eagle eye to track it

[quick shadow]

theres nothing to track

[spring sonnet]

u just said you have entered a legendary area

once you see that message, start tracking, clues will appear as yellow trail and clues as a kind of yellow cloud of particles

[quick shadow]

found it

lol

that was so easy

[spring sonnet]

if u dont see any of then, either you are not far enough inside or you already got out of area

good

it often is in the woods not too far from the fall

if you have not shot at it yet, check wind direction with eagle eye

or use one of those scent blocker thingy

first time i tried it, it smelled me from quite a distance and then ran all over the place, including in the woods across the track

i still haven't done the hunting requests, first one reqs a perfect rabbit and perfect squirrel skin, how the hell do you kill those to get perfect skins?

[quick shadow]

do i have to sell the bear pelt to the trapper in order to buy the outfit things?

[spring sonnet]

yes

oh so it was not the moose you were after?

you're on the mission with hosey or whatever his name is

[bold pulsar]

I'm currently doing some challenges right now. Who know the best way to complete Sharpshooter challenge 8?

[spring sonnet]

so what do you use to get perfect rabbit and squirrel pelts, small game arrows?

i want a pellet gun 🙂

[hidden moss]

Varmint

Squirrel u need small game arrows

[spring sonnet]

yeah i never got a varmint gun

my main problem when hunting is, i do not use dead eye, i find it makes things too easy but i may reconsider that for the very small stuff like squirrels and small birds

[quick shadow]

currently in the legendary buck area but i cant find any clues

[red sand]

hey so how do i cheat in a duel

[quick shadow]

legendary buck killed

[median haven]

Using small game arrows on squirrels I don’t even think it matters where you hit them to get a perfect squirrel pelt.. you don’t have to aim for the tiny heads anyway

[quick shadow]

what do i do with the legendary buck pelt?

[median haven]

Take it to the trapper

[vernal raptor]

@hidden moss No dice :(

[worthy spire]

cheat in a duel?

[red sand]

yeah

[spring sonnet]

@median haven good to know thanx

think I'll try dynomite 😛

[worldly blaze]

can anyone help me install a mod

[quick shadow]

are all my trinkets active as the same time?

or do i need to equip them like rings in dark souls?

[floral yarrow]

All active at the same time

Same with satchels regardless of which one u have equipped

[quick shadow]

oh really?

i though you can only have 1 satchel

[floral yarrow]

Nope

You can only have one cosmetically equipped, but they all function at the same time

[hidden moss]

Nah u can hunt and donate perfect pelts to Pearson and he'll craft u bigger ones

[floral yarrow]

You can also buy them from a fence but only once you finish the main story

[hidden moss]

So If I have legend of the east and equip the kit satchel the effect of the east are still active?

[floral yarrow]

Yup

As long as you have it unlocked it works

[hidden moss]

Yooo

Epic

[floral yarrow]

Yea

Kit satchel is my favorite cosmetically too haha

[hidden moss]

Because the kit satchel looks best with my drip currently

[hidden moss]

Same

[hidden moss]

Is that same with holsters and gun belts and bandoliers?

[floral yarrow]

Ye

[hidden moss]

Ok

[floral yarrow]

Although its unclear on if upgraded and reinforced are the same or not, i believe they are not

[hidden moss]

Upgrades gun belt and holster are my current

[floral yarrow]

Meaning youd need to buy one reinforced and one upgraded and then wear whatever you want

To have full effect

I think

[hidden moss]

And horseman bandoleir is my favorite

[floral yarrow]

I like the gambler bandolier

Very slim and not chunky

And the pouches look sick

Just wish it was a darker color

[hidden moss]

Do robberies decrease honor

Like the stagecoach robberies

I'm very smug about my honor

[floral yarrow]

Nah none of the 'mission' type activities decrease honor

Where you go with a member of the gang

[hidden moss]

What about going up to a man in van horn and robbing him

[floral yarrow]

You will lose honor

[hidden moss]

Lame

[floral yarrow]

Selecting the rob interact on anyone makes you lose honor

[daring atlas]

hi i have a question when im looking at objects in the distance and im moving i feel like i see the objects flickering or moving idk how to explain it if someone knows what it is please tell me

[floral yarrow]

Turn on anti aliasing

[daring atlas]

can i do this in any game

[floral yarrow]

Yeah basically any pc game has some sort of anti aliasing option

Anyway time to go hunting with hamish

[daring atlas]

can u help me out

[hidden moss]

A true chad

[floral yarrow]

With what?

[daring atlas]

i dmed you

[quick shadow]

can you rob the bank in rhodes?

[red helm]

I believe with the Ultimate Edition there is a mission to bank the Rhodes bank.

[floral yarrow]

I accidentally just started choking out some lady i saved from a couple of murfree guys

Dammit

[red helm]

Was she standing to close to your horse, and you meant to mount it, but that's the same button?

[floral yarrow]

No, she was standing too close to her dead husband who i was trying to loot and thats the same button.

[red helm]

Ahh, Okay.

[floral yarrow]

Lol

Tbf i thought he was a dead murfree at first

[red helm]

Yes, it's rather hard to tell if it's just a "Stranger" or a random gang corpse. Sometimes.

[floral yarrow]

I wish the legendary moose jacket wasn't too warm for hot weather, it looks so dope I want to wear it everywhere

My favorite jacket along with the wittemore

[red helm]

Yeah, a lot of the cool Trapper cloths are to warm. I like to wear the Ghost Bison Hat around.

[floral yarrow]

Lol based

Do you get the weird clothes dialogue at camp from that?

[red helm]

Yeap. Part of the reason I wear it, to hear people say those. I have a outfit with the Viking Helm if I want to be serious. Though, it also gets those dialogs as well.

[floral yarrow]

Heh

Im gonna be sad when i have to make my outfits suit john again

And regrow my handlebar stache that took so long to grow out

[red helm]

Ugh, yeah, switching over to John was annoying, I didn't want to remake any of Arthur's sets for him.

[floral yarrow]

I feel like the lighter clothes dont look nearly as good on him as on Arthur

But i havent actually played as him in a while so idk

[red helm]

I didn't feel like many of the Trapper Outfits worked that well with John. So, I mainly kept him with his default outfits.

[floral yarrow]

Thats fair

It was hard for me to save too many stranger missions for John, so far all I think im gonna leave left to do as him is the second part of the saint denis mayor mission and the gunslinger missions

[red helm]

A couple of them are Arthur only. So, careful.

[floral yarrow]

Yeah ik

[red helm]

Figured, my last play through I was low honor, and missed the Mrs. Downs Side mission. Feh.

[floral yarrow]

Oof

Thats rough, i loved that mission

Just did it recently actually

[red helm]

Yeah, and would've had a easy Gold medal on one of them.

[quick shadow]

if i fast travel will the big pelts stay on my horse?

[hearty notch]

yes

[floral yarrow]

Some dude on a horse just fully stopped and stared at me while i stabbed a dead dude i murdered repeatedly in the head. He didnt say a word, or threaten to call the law, he just watched me. What a perv

[red helm]

Strangers be odd sometimes.

[hearty notch]

maybe hes a visual learner

[floral yarrow]

Its funny when arthur rides by some guy, i greet them, and then they pull out a gun and start shooting, and then after i yank them off their horse with a lasso, disarm them, and finally shank them after they pull a knife, i lose honor

Like really? How am I in the wrong in this situation?

Like okay, if id lost honor for repeatedly desecrating their corpse with a hunting knife, thatd be one thing, but.

[hearty notch]

[floral yarrow]

Rude

[hearty notch]

rockstar games when making the honor system

[floral yarrow]

True

[prisma lark]

some one should make a mod so you can have holster on both sides of your hips like dutch because the off hand holster looks really awkward ad doesnt look good at all

[quick shadow]

do both trappers share the pelts i already hunted?

[floral yarrow]

Ikr literally every other character who has two holsters has them on the hips

[floral yarrow]

There are a lot more than two, and yes, they are the same person after all

[red helm]

There are 5 trapper locations, and yeap, all the same dude.

He actually makes a comment about being able to move his stuff around faster then other people can travel on horse.

[floral yarrow]

He makes that comment a lot. It gets annoying after a while. What an arrogant sod amirite

[sterile nymph]

y’all got any tips for hunting legendary elk

[hidden moss]

Shoot it

Track him down

Get a gun(s) with high ammo and dead eye him to the ground

[sterile nymph]

Would a rare rolling block rifle work?

[hidden moss]

Definitely

[quick shadow]

so ez, find it, shoot it like 3 times and it drops dead

i was hoping legendary animals would bring a challenge to the game

[regal flicker]

Yeah I feel like in some situations losing honour or getting a wasted level is stupid

like if some guy pulls a gun on you in St Denis because you stood too close to him but you get arrested for disturbing the peace

[ashen aurora]

[untold lintel]

Is there a downside between dual wielding and one handing revolvers?

It seems like dual wielding just lets me shoot constantly and have more ammo, I don't see a downside beyond not feathering the hammer.

And I rarely do that anyway, it's fun but not as effective as just aiming and shooting em.

[hidden moss]

No

[regal flicker]

I kind of hate chapter 4 tbh

I can’t play in Saint Denis without murdering 300 cops and getting bored

I don’t get any missions done

[quick shadow]

i was just fishing and it said press r to increase reeling speed

but it didnt do shit

it was slow af

spent like 20 minutes to catch this fish for the mission

[spring sonnet]

I find it strange that there's no hotel in St-Denis

[regal flicker]

There is

But you can’t go inside

[spring sonnet]

well i meant a hotel you can use 🙂

[floral yarrow]

You spam r a few times and then its maxed

Legendary and big fish take a suuuuuper long time to catch

[drowsy mountain]

that has never happened to me but different players have different experiences

[drowsy mountain]

Murder 300 cops then 300 more come back

[true rose]

Hwats the matter witch you

[drowsy mountain]

Get out my damn way

[true rose]

No

🤠

[drowsy mountain]

i just imagine you saying that

[true rose]

I guess

[drowsy mountain]

Monneh

[true rose]

Don't forget the quarter

[drowsy mountain]

Im gonna search up how much arthurs there are in this server

[oblique radish]

I got my email of rockstar but i forgot the password and it is not logged in gmail

[deft knot]

How is it going with your honor level? 😁

[hidden moss]

Still on low neutral honor

[deft knot]

I'm at good honor a little more than three quarters now

[deft knot]

Do the chores at the camp and always contribute a little amount it helped me alot

[spring sonnet]

I havent been to camp in days 🙂

in real time, in game time, it's probably been a couple of weeks or more since i've been to camp, i was there once, at beginning of chapter 3 and I've been roaming about since

[karmic narwhal]

has a camp member come to search for you?

[twin garnet]

what is the name of the mission where sadie adler stabs a mans hand? im afraid that i might have missed it

[spring sonnet]

@karmic narwhal not that I've noticed, are they known to do so?

[karmic narwhal]

If you are away for a long time Dutch will send someone like bill to find you and make sure you’re not dead

[spring sonnet]

oh hehe, guess I'll wait til that happens

[zealous igloo]

i'm at lake issabella and i can't find the white arabian, any help?

[karmic narwhal]

It has a spawn chance i think

I got it first try tho

[zealous igloo]

ah thanks

[karmic narwhal]

[civic vault]

I wish there were more activities in the snowy parts of the game

To everyone here, what's your favorite outfit for Arthur?

[karmic narwhal]

Normal gunslinger outfit

[civic vault]

For me, I always go for all black. And sometimes with the legion vest.

[civic vault]

The blue definitely suits him

[karmic narwhal]

Yessir

[civic vault]

Also i sometimes have him wear the scout jacket

It's my go-to jacket for him

I tried the fancy stuff for him but i've always felt like he was out of character with them. So I always stuck with clothes that makes him look more like a wanderer

[hidden moss]

i like the death roll

The one u get frm the trapper

[swift pike]

I have spent like 3 or 4 hours going in and out of that forrst south of the Braithwaite Manor looking for a perfect panther, I have only come across 2 in that time neither being perfect , wtf am i doing wrong?

[hidden moss]

nothing lmao

the games spawns r dookie sometimes

Just other places they could be lok

[hidden moss]

All red, upgraded gun belt/holster/off hand holster and horse bandolier

Panama hat

Legion vest

I can show u later in fashion

[native valve]

Can you catch the legendary catfish that you unlock after completing a fisher of fish?

[celest harbor]

i believe you can catch all the fish as soon as you start the mission and the cutscene ends

well most of them

if there are any in like blackwater and new austin, they probably can't be caught until you can play as John

[hidden moss]

Idk i tried a couple of times and never caught it

Then i looked it up and it said it isn’t in the game

But that wouldn’t make sense

so idk

[native valve]

It’s not in the compendium

But it’s on the map

Ig not then

[hidden moss]

Im pretty sure it is in the compendium

There is a open spot on the legendary fish page

[hidden moss]

Hey can some body help me out here I have been trying to play rdr2 story mode for maybe 2 hours and every single time I start it it immediately goes to 50 percent and stays there not moving up a single bit

[vital marlin]

what goes to 50%

[vital marlin]

no

[native valve]

Nope

[vital marlin]

it is i think but u can't fish it

[hidden moss]

the loading thing

this

[vital marlin]

ahh

verify game files?

[hidden moss]

i am onps4

on ps4

[native valve]

Maby try reinstalling the game

[deft knot]

Can you update PS system?

Solved one of my problems once

[hidden moss]

i did

still doing it

[vital marlin]

o-oh

[quick shadow]

i just killed the legendary elk but it died in the lake and i cant skin it

what should i do

[normal relic]

Try using your lasso

[quick shadow]

doesnt work

[normal relic]

Hmm