red-dead-singleplayer

[normal relic]

Mask will be on your horse

[cloud grove]

hey how much of single player do i have to play to unlock story missions in multiplayer?

[meager forge]

which one is better otis miller revolver vs schofield revolver?

[cloud grove]

i just finished chapter 1 btw

[trail lance]

head is best i think

one shot to the head

also use the weapon it says in the info section of the animal

alr

[west river]

Pump shutgun with slug bulets maybe

You need srtent wepon an aim for the head or the neck

And bulets for squrels you need smal game arrows

[fallow ingot]

Is there a better way to deal with bounty hunter dogs? when I kill them they lower my honor, and im trying to keep it high

[warped rampart]

Pay your bounty 💀

[fallow ingot]

I don't have $300 on me right now, and I'm trying to hunt cougars

[surreal oxide]

I had a 1020$ bounty in new hanover but got arrested and they took 820$ from me

Made it all back by robbing stagecoaches and getting 40$ from Seamus for each one

[dusty glade]

run the frigk away

[dusty glade]

finally, managed to bust a player in valentine in poker

now for flatneck station

[undone ginkgo]

You have to be in chapter 6 to start hamish missions right?

[hidden moss]

do y all try to play the game like real life aswell?

[undone ginkgo]

Cause I'm in chapter 4 and I can't find him at all

[hidden moss]

like i removed my hud made my crosshair small

and im just trying to play it more realisticlly

but also to complete it 100% and have fun

i have on my newest save 140 hours im still in chapter 2

@undone ginkgo

yes i belivie so

chapter 6

every time so far i only encountered him in chapter 6

or as john

[dusky meteor]

No

[molten current]

Is anyone else having an issue where you are unable to move or do anything except view the map at a stable?

I have to keep going to task manager to end then restart the game

[noble spire]

yes either chap 6 or epilogue

[fallow ingot]

wheres the best place for moose hunting

[drowsy pilot]

Look up colter moose location RDR2 I found mine after like 10 tries after the spawn spot kept spawning wolves finally spawned a moose for me.

Usually best to get to that spot just at sunrise and once noon hits it won’t spawn until the next day

[dawn gate]

what's the best location to get burdock root

[hidden moss]

Yeah.

[native valve]

Can you do the hunting requests as John marston?

[vital marlin]

Yes

I need help with the perfect northern cardinal carcass, any suggestions?

[vital marlin]

near rivers

[frail bobcat]

yo where tf is gavin bro

[shut silo]

He is imaginary

[celest wedge]

yeah

its impossible to finish them as arthur anyway because that lady goes on a vacation

[native valve]

I can’t find the poster tho

I’ve been to all stations twice

[celest wedge]

isnt it the one in rhodes post office?

[native valve]

I’ve been there

And valentine

Basically all post offices

[celest wedge]

weird

[native valve]

Does it have anything to do with story completion

[celest wedge]

yes you need it for 100% completion

[native valve]

I mean the story missions

[celest wedge]

nah

they are collectables

[native valve]

I’m on my way in to check again

Is there any specific post office it spawns in?

Cause it ain’t in Rhodes

[lusty sun]

I finished the game and just realized that theres an entire area down to the left

Is there anything worth it down there?

[hexed wedge]

how do I get higher honor quick? I'm at chapter 6 and I want a good ending

[vale blade]

greet greet and greet

[hexed wedge]

alr, I know that every 3 greets is a honor point, so thanks

[vale blade]

sure sure

[native valve]

I’ve checked everywhere

Except armadillo

Can’t find it

[hidden moss]

bro

i suck at duels

and can’t retry 😫

[celest wedge]

duels are easy

[normal relic]

Can be easy

but I suck at them

[celest wedge]

it depends on the duel

if its the jim boy calloway then yeah

he draws his gun faster than any npc in the game

[rustic bridge]

for me Nah.

I ended his whole career

[normal relic]

Jim Calloway is a tough one to dual

[hexed wedge]

wait how do you unlock calloway, I have emmer, midnight, belle, and the other one

[prisma karma]

U have to go back to the saloon where u met him in pretty sure or he’s in tumbleweed or so

[normal relic]

Yea

[normal relic]

He's by the saloon in tumbleweed i think maybe he's in armadillo

[hexed wedge]

alr

[normal relic]

I've tried dualing him he's tough i die every time

[celest wedge]

tumbleweed?

its the one in valentine lol

you unlock it after the mission "a night of debauchery" in chapter 4

[normal relic]

Yea lol

I thought he was in tumbleweed im dumb lol

i hate jim calloway

[trail lance]

legendary animals, and you can explore

theres some more towns down there

im still exploring that area

[harsh cliff]

i just lost my 3rd playthrough (chapter 2, just completed mary mission) because i was playing my og 1st playthrough and i saved on the wrong spot, aka replaced my 3rd playthrough. how do i restore my save file. Its not big deal, but it is very annoying i dont have it anymore.

[lusty sun]

all those clothing items in online, are they also in story mode or no? I can’t seem to find certain things people have in online

[nocturne spindle]

Can you get a killcam with a bow?

[dusty plank]

Any idea why game keeps crashing when I get to the Trian station on the mission "the fine art of conversation"

[robust ridge]

Does it still?

[dusty plank]

yes it has happened 3 times in a row

[fallow ingot]

are the legendary animals available after chapter 6

[hexed wedge]

how do I get higher honor quick? I'm at chapter 6 and I want a good ending

[dusty glade]

yes

there are 3 locked to the epilogue

[dusty glade]

Go to saint denis

And spam greet people

greeting 3 individual people will give you an honor up

but greeting the same person more than once won't give you honor

just run around greeting and it'll give you high honor fast

[noble spire]

nah bro after u completed all 4 gunslingers you'l meet the fat guy in saint denis and tells u to capture calloway's old enemy which is a sheriff in annesburg after u get the sheriff , u go the roanake ridge then so forth...

[noble spire]

either greeting people or fishing then throwing every fish back

[noble spire]

i believe its now lost im afraid

[stiff ferry]

So I shot Lillian in the Saint Denis Bar and then I massacred the whole bar

Then when i ran out

The lawmen killed the Bartender

😔

I regret my actions

[celest wedge]

obviously no

but if you are a pc user

you can download a mod called red dead offline in story mode

[stiff ferry]

How do I cope

[lusty sun]

lmao wdym “obviously”.

[dusty glade]

because you can just check the catalogue

it's obvious they're not in singleplayer

because their catalogs are completely different

[lusty sun]

well I haven’t completed story yet so I had no clue if they were unlocked after completion

I only started the game this week, I don’t know a whole lot lmao. No need to assume I should know all this stuff

[dusky meteor]

Dam black bear charged right at me put six rounds into it with deadeye

I stabled it to death

Almost died

Then 4 wolves came and ate me

Rip

[untold lintel]

I've heard some gold bars respawn between chapters, is that true?

[bitter heath]

how do i kill someone in rdr2

[untold lintel]

Shoot em with the heckin shooty

Foolproof plan

[loud rampart]

i wonder

[regal juniper]

You don’t

[thin plume]

for some reason i cant see smoking and other hobbies mission did i miss the mission because i completed the story

[rustic bridge]

How do you what...

[thin plume]

wrong game pal

[balmy palm]

Hogtie them, alive, put them on your horse, go to saint denis, go upwards on the map, find you a gator, take them off the horse, then you feed them to the gator! :D

Easy peasy!

[sour terrace]

Ok but the fact that me and some mates do this on a daily 😂 it’s so cool😂 I’ve never realised the gator will attack or if you put a dead body in the water a gator will do the same thing

[robust sedge]

Can you hang people in rdr2? Like just lasso them and hang them off a cliff

Never tried

I killed a cat... I feel like a monster

[thin plume]

does side missions disappear

?

[robust sedge]

Anyways I need help. Can someone teach me how to catch legendary fishes? I sat around for 30 minutes trying to find the legendary one next to the water fall in the upper right corner of the map and all I got was muskies

[robust sedge]

No

I think. I the the 3rd one with the photographer one does

[thin plume]

for some reason i cant see some of them on the map

why?

[robust sedge]

Which one?

[thin plume]

smoking and hobbies

i completed the story

[robust sedge]

What's it about?

[thin plume]

well its the guy that loves cards

cigarette cards

[robust sedge]

Ohh that guy

Idk never did it. Sorry I couldn't help

[thin plume]

oh ok

[robust sedge]

But some missions require it to be a certain time of the day to activate

Such as the Nikola Tesla guy

[robust sedge]

If anyone could help I would be very very grateful

[thin plume]

u probably need special lure

special baits

[robust sedge]

Hmm

[thin plume]

never caught one but

i know that

[robust sedge]

I used the river lure

[thin plume]

it only attracts specific legendary fish

there is multiple special lures

[robust sedge]

And crickets. Also wheres Flat iron lake? It keeps saying theres a guy there that's interested about the fishy

[thin plume]

probably idk

flat iron lake is bottom of the map

[thin plume]

there is a gap between black water and rhodes

thats the flat iron lake

[robust sedge]

Ah alright

I'm guessing I dont need to play as John?

[thin plume]

no u are forced to play john

except if u want to mod the game

u cant swap between characters

[meager skiff]

Should i do all content on the map with arthur ? And can i miss sidemissions? Or just the main missions and all side content with other main cheracter? No spoiler pls

[jaunty quiver]

You can indeed miss sidemissions eventually after you progress, best to explore now and do all sidemissions possible with arthur

[thin plume]

u can do them as john

actually

but not all of them

example mary for obvious reasons

[balmy palm]

There's a good one where you lasso them and go AS FAST as possible on the horse and you just look back and they are flying 😂

Man I love that damn lasso...

[hexed star]

salut

[bitter heath]

i caught my 2nd legendary fish, damn its big as well

about to get the 3rd legendary fish

gon be tough for the night

[keen birch]

Arthur sucks.

[bitter heath]

I GOT IT

I GOT IT

NOOO

PLEASE

[balmy palm]

Unbased

[bitter heath]

NO

MY FISH

I GOT IT

BUT

[celest wedge]

how dare you

i shall kill you with repeating shotgun (explosive slugs)

[thick pewter]

How do I get the rare rifle in magicians for sport just so I dont miss it.

[robust sedge]

How do I do the third brother Dorkins quest or whatever?

I finally got the vampire dagger holy shit man

[slate laurel]

The opposite of based is cringe

[celest wedge]

theres no third quest

[robust sedge]

No like

Thered the one with the slaves the one with the mid and the one where Arthur says "I'm afraid"

I figured out anyways

Man.... my fucking horse got run over by a train....now I got to spend another 1000 dollars for it...

Nvm its 500. At least that

[celest wedge]

oh

[celest wedge]

the one with the slaves is the second

and "im afraid" is a completely different mission

its called The Fine Art of Conversation

[robust sedge]

Yeah I looked more into it

My bad

[celest wedge]

👍

[agile trellis]

why does Dutch need so much money

Is there like an actual explanation?

If so. Don't spoil TOO much

Since I haven't completed the game

[balmy palm]

Thats very unbased for you to correct me like that

[balmy palm]

For the plan, duh

[agile trellis]

What plan?

i don't pay attention to the story sometimes

[slate laurel]

THE plan

[agile trellis]

Ahh thank you

[hidden moss]

You should finish the story first

[agile trellis]

A shit-ton of deer carcasses for THE plan

which somehow grants them money

too many deer carcasses

[cloud hazel]

can someone help me find the sound effects that play when you loot or sell stuff im using openiv to look through the sound effects but i cant find the money sounds anywhere
nevermind i found them

[balmy palm]

I did that and I dont even know what he needs it for, I'm guessing Tahiti but yk... :/

[primal dawn]

theyre gonna farm mangoes

[hidden moss]

I was replying to Grenadd it’s all good

[silk temple]

Guys

I have a very interesting theory

What if... uncle had lumbago

[agile trellis]

Maybe

uncle is the best character

aka roamer of valentine

also aka pervert of valentine (probably)

[hidden moss]

I just finished the game the 14th time 2 weeks ago

i think the part i like the most would be

you know like the one with the Arthur guy

that was fun

[red helm]

I enjoy that one part with Arthur as well.

[winged ermine]

Hello, I have a problem when I play RDR 2 the savegame doesn't work, I can't complete the story because of that, can someone help me?

[hidden moss]

Like manual save

[winged ermine]

yes and autosave, the save doesn't work and I can't find my previous save game, I can find it in the folder but in the game it's empty

[hidden moss]

Try steam cloud if you can,I don’t have rdr2 for pc but try that.

[winged ermine]

this didn't work, but thanks

[hidden moss]

did you try to verify files?

or ik it doesn t seem relevant but maybe update your drivers aswell

and another thing

go to windows setting

virus and threat protection

and try to find controlled folder

press allow an app through controlled folders

and allow rdr2 related stuff

just click the blocked recently when you get there

that workwd for me

i can t send pic here

but look on general media

@winged ermine

[winged ermine]

so what app should I choose (Launcher or PlayRDR2 or RDR2)?

[hidden moss]

both actually

[winged ermine]

so when I open savegame slots it's empty even when there is already save game files, could this work for this problem

[hidden moss]

i think so,for me i kept saving my game but the old files appeared and after it work

also check your drivers not related to this but to have better performance

i really hope this will solve your problem

[winged ermine]

It only happened after I reset the PC

[thin plume]

is it normal that my horse died instantly without letting me use revive potion

i fell from a distance and it died instantly

[winged ermine]

I'll try, I was the have 4 Arabian horses, in the game

[hidden moss]

rarely can happen but yes

or if it drowns

or burns

[thin plume]

bruh then that happened

drowning

[celest wedge]

i think it happens when the game fails to execute the horse injured animation

[thin plume]

:/

[celest wedge]

oh

nvm

[celest wedge]

well

lol

[thin plume]

its pain in the ass to get the arabian back

travel across the map

[celest wedge]

use fast travel to colter

[hidden moss]

the fully customized arabian

is the fastest

also

besides the point

did you go to the horse shop(idk how its called)

oh yeah the stable

and get the stirupps?

[thin plume]

no

i didnt customize it

[hidden moss]

they make it faster and the core drains slower

its 30

the most expensive one

it rlly helps

[thin plume]

didnt know that ty

[hidden moss]

trust me i have almst 2000 hours

no problen

always happy to help

💯👍

just got off a 12 hour session

boutta go to sleep and start again in the morning

[thin plume]

2000 hours in a single player game??

thats interesting lol

[hidden moss]

well on pc just 500 since i only got it in june

[thin plume]

it takes 100 hours to like get all achievements and stuff

[hidden moss]

but ps4 almst 1400

[thin plume]

how do u even have fun

there is probably nothing to do

after 2000 hours

[hidden moss]

true but to hunt all the animals complete all the challanges also have fun it takes more

well actually rn im trying to get it completed 100 procent

everything that can be done

before i experimented with stuff tried to get rare encounters

rn i want to fully upgrade the camp get all the clothes from the trapper

in chapter 2 rn

with 420 hours

[thin plume]

i have no words for that

lol

[ionic night]

Just started undead nightmare lmao

And so far this is like the best thing ever

[lusty sun]

Guys give me suggestions of things to buy, I have everythin I can think of. Every gun in the game, the best horse, all materials and tonics and everything, idk what to buy, I have 15k left. Gimme suggestions.

[desert ether]

What's 15k in rdr2 equivalent to in GTA V money?

[lusty sun]

Idk probably a billion

nothing is more than 1k

[desert ether]

Dee-eee-ecent

[untold lintel]

Get as high a bounty as physically possible, go absolutely nuts.

[lusty sun]

I’m doing that as we speak

bounty is currently 1000

[spring geyser]

js 1000+?

dayum

the highest i got was 500

[lusty sun]

yeah it goes to 1500

[spring geyser]

damnnn

[lusty sun]

It goes beyond 1500 witht the levels though I believe

I’ll be here a while

[vast condor]

Not me bawling after finishing rdr2

[lusty sun]

thats everyone

[vast condor]

Legit

[lusty sun]

bro I cried for a solid half hour after chapter 6

[vast condor]

I'm gonna make it my mission to get the van der linde gang to sign a map of where they died and went to

[lusty sun]

just finished it yesterday

[lusty sun]

that’d be awesome

[vast condor]

It'd be much harder then getting all 6 infinity stones fr fr

I know the actors of dutch arthur and john are very active when it comes to conventions

[lusty sun]

its at max

1500

are there more hidden wanted levels

[stray yacht]

I love getting to max honor just to shoot up valentine and be negative honor again

[dim heart]

Menace

[void vale]

Guy if accidentaly fail stranger help will the quest appear again after sometime?

[hidden moss]

yes

actually

wdym by failing?

killing the guy or smth?

[void vale]

Accidentaly aim the gun to the guy and ram with horse and the the guy killed and run away

[hidden moss]

nah i dont think so

[void vale]

I accidentaly aim to a guy who need a lead to strawberry

[hidden moss]

i did that encounter like 3 times even after leading the guy to strawberry

you can leave the area/reload a save to see if he shows up again

[exotic gust]

hey guys

whats the best horse?

[grave jackal]

Free: White Arabian
RNG: Fox Trotter with max stats
Paid: Idk, Black Arabian?

[wheat flame]

Anybody wanna play rdr2 online

[robust sedge]

From what I've heard in here theres one in the Blackwater stable. That's the best one but I dont know the name of it

[dusty glade]

black arabian is free

in saint denis you can find it

during chapter 4 i think

[grave jackal]

Yeah i think there is a quest for it but it's hard to trigger i think

so the stable one is what I got

[dusty glade]

where is the stable one?

also there's a ton of other arabians but i think the white one is the best

[hidden moss]

i like my leopard appaloosa

[exotic gust]

yo guys

i really need help

i cant find the treasure map 2

[minor sequoia]

anyone that now how to fix 0xc0000005 error

[exotic gust]

i cant pick it up near the rock

[robust sedge]

What do u even do with legendary fishes?

Cant make clothes out of them which makes sense and I dont think u can make trinkets

What's their purpose

[boreal nest]

Hello, i have question, i want to kill vampire i find all texts but i dont understand where i can find him and when?

[silk temple]

Rose arabian I think

[silk temple]

U can get a white arabian in lake in grizzlies west in lake Isabella

[minor sequoia]

anyone that now how to fix 0xc0000005 error ?

[fresh grove]

Dutch "Don't doubt me Arthur"

Also Dutch: leaves him to die cause he feels "betrayed"

U can see Arthur in that moment lost all of his hopes Torwards Dutch

[celest wedge]

its not a strangers mission its a random encounter

its so random anyway i doubt you will ever find him again after that

[lusty sun]

I see him all the time

theres not so many random events that you will never hear the same one again

[celest wedge]

its not even worth leading him to strawberry

arthur doesnt let him get on his horse

[lusty sun]

I left him after halfway cause it was taking too long lmao

[exotic gust]

hey guys

please help me

now i cant get the treasure map

[hidden moss]

does anyone know where the poisonous trails map is located?

[agile trellis]

I'm always going to skip the Micah missions all he asks me for is robbing and afterwards I get an 80+ dollar bounty💀

[dull geyser]

Just get a turkoman or fox trotter

If you want all rounded ones stat wise

[robust sedge]

So what do I do with them?

Someone tell me please

[exotic gust]

yo

[thin plume]

can i keep a hat that i picked it on the ground

?

permanently

[spice fable]

Hello all, if i do the Gunslinger Quest with Artur, will i kepp the weapons with John?

[tawdry topaz]

Yea should do

[spice fable]

thanks

[fresh grove]

The fact that Jack had a panic attack whne John killed those guys who were following him.

And a few years later he will kill Ross with 0 hesitation

[surreal oxide]

I wonder what the RDR3 story will be

[minor sequoia]

i think they said it was gonna be smthing after the last mission in the rdr2

[spice fable]

Very nice.

[thin plume]

but isnt red dead 2 past

?

[surreal oxide]

I hope they go back to the past again, and we play as a young Dutch or Hosea or Arthur

Maybe play multiple characters

[mental wind]

So I go and steal the Stagecoach with Hosea right? It's night, in the back room there's a woman sleeping

Now there's 3 options:

a: I go in from the back door and ignore her (idk if it's safe to do this
b: I go in from the back door and kill her
c: I go in from the main door

[thin plume]

do u mean the house robbery mission?

[mental wind]

Yea

When you steal the Stagecoach

[thin plume]

just ignore them

steal everything from the house

[mental wind]

And you can do it daytime or nighttime

[thin plume]

and go

[opaque geode]

Kill them all

[mental wind]

Wait so I don't kill them?

[opaque geode]

Murder

[thin plume]

well its a option

[opaque geode]

Every

Last

[mental wind]

like cut their throats open?

[opaque geode]

One of tuem

[thin plume]

i left there without killing them lol

u can do that

its completely optional

[mental wind]

So I just get in from the back and nothing will happen?

[opaque geode]

Pull out your shotgun and blast their heads into oblivion

[mental wind]

Ehhh nah I'm a good fella

[thin plume]

then dont

loot and get out of the house

[mental wind]

I'll put my shotgun in your ass and blast you into oblivion

[thin plume]

i mean i chose the night option

[mental wind]

alright thanks

[opaque geode]

Shut the fuck up

[thin plume]

negative honor is worst thing in existance

[opaque geode]

🤓

[thin plume]

positive honor is very great

discounts

are op

[mental wind]

I just asked cuz the 1st time I completed story I did it on daytime I believe idk was about 1 year ago I forgot

[opaque geode]

Arthur dies tho so it doesnt matter

[thin plume]

go play doom lmao

[opaque geode]

Shit game

[bitter garden]

suss

[thin plume]

then i dont give a shit

[mental wind]

ok so do I close every closet I open?

[opaque geode]

What?

[mental wind]

or do they wake up from the Stagecoach either way

[opaque geode]

No just play the game ffs

[thin plume]

if u chose the night

[mental wind]

Stfu

[opaque geode]

Stop askin questions

[thin plume]

dude imma dm you

if you want to

[opaque geode]

How dumb r u

[thin plume]

this guy is like 4 years old

[opaque geode]

Sure i am

[mental wind]

Have you heard of

"Undetected in and out"

[opaque geode]

How they gonna know it was u lol

Plus one of them wakes up

And im pretty sure u havw to kill them

Or knock them out

[thin plume]

im sure this guy's age isnt enough for discord

[opaque geode]

Mate

[thin plume]

lol

[opaque geode]

Im not the one

With the lumbago pfp

[thin plume]

im not the one

with the anime

pfp

sad

[thin plume]

owned

muted lol

[celest wedge]

aand he got muted

[thin plume]

im satisfied

[lavish thunder]

wasap peeps

[thin plume]

i can die in peace now

[mental wind]

I love being Arthur

Imagine hiding something in your Chimney and I know it's there

Easiest 150 dollars in my life

[celest wedge]

always check the chimney

[coral pike]

yo wwanna play

[celest wedge]

i dont play rdo sory

:c

[thin plume]

is there a way to get rid of bounty without paying anything

i dont want to pay 1000 dollars

[celest wedge]

get arrested maybe

🤔

nvm

[surreal oxide]

Get arrested but the law still take money from you

[celest wedge]

the gang get you out of jail sometimes

i dont know if it will effect the bounty or not

[loud rampart]

what chapter for the limit on honor to be lifted?

[celest wedge]

chapter 6

you unlock the last 2 levels

of honor

[loud rampart]

oki

[celest wedge]

weither positive or negative

[untold lintel]

On PC can you aim when hipfiring like on console?

[celest wedge]

yeah

just press left button

without holding the right one

[thin plume]

What if they kill me do i lose the bounty or it stays

[celest wedge]

likely stays the same

[thin plume]

And if i keep my honor high does it decrease?

[celest wedge]

i dont think killing policemen or bounty hunters decrease honor

[thin plume]

i mean does my bounty decrease

if my honor is high

[celest wedge]

no

[thin plume]

ok ty

[frosty swan]

Hello

[hidden moss]

when rdr3?

[primal dawn]

the 10th

[hidden moss]

Your mother is very fat.

[primal dawn]

the 10th of deez nuts

[hidden moss]

man

[primal dawn]

got you

[hidden moss]

humanity really sucks

why cant there be

a rdr3

[forest sorrel]

real

[hidden moss]

my whole life ive been waiting

waiting for myself to grow up and move out of my house and get out of god damn school

[primal dawn]

rdr3 is in development and it follows jack marstons story but 100+ years later and it has the title grand theft auto 6 (not related)

[hidden moss]

my whole life

ive tried to fight

change

but its a waste

i see that now

its a waste

you cant fight nature

but you can fight gravity

gravity dosent bloody exist

and i can prove it

[dusty glade]

excited for the new game!

[unique hull]

How do you keep the Homburg hat? I've seen people keep the hat in their inventory, but every time I steal it, it just dissapears.

[inland spindle]

After I did Bill's mission in Rhodes, Sean was killed but when I was on the edge of Clemen's Point I saw him guarding the place with a rifle. What happened?

[hidden moss]

you're supposed to mail them to jeremy gill if you've met him yet

[signal gale]

What’s the best horse?

to buy

[spiral shell]

is there a fix for the sudden weather change?

[hidden moss]

Not really, it just happens

[spiral shell]

ah bummer

[undone ginkgo]

Wait

[celest wedge]

its not really sudden to be honest

its because when a weather is transitioning to another one

you will notice the clouds changing drastically

[undone ginkgo]

If Charles Chatenay kissed Arthur in that one mission
Then did arthur give Charles TB?

[celest wedge]

likely not

if we are talking about

healthy arthur

then no

playing stranger missions in chapter 6 doesnt feel right to be honest

especially if its sick arthur with normal arthur dialogue

[undone ginkgo]

I just played the mission about midway in chapter 4

So he has it

He just hasn't found out yet

[celest wedge]

he doesnt get sick in chapter 4

he barely coughed

only twice in chapter 4

[undone ginkgo]

Fair but he has TB in a small degree in chapter 4

Probably not enough to be contagious

[celest wedge]

even his face look the exact same from the start of the game

arthur having more blemishes (red face) in chapter 4 is a myth

[celest wedge]

the art that charles gave it to arthur becomes very expensive in the epilogue

[undone ginkgo]

Does John get Arthur's valuables in the epilogue

I can't remember

[celest wedge]

yea

i also had alot of xp boost tonics

from arthurs

[undone ginkgo]

You can also save Arthur's money by doing the first part of the Aberdeen pig farm encounter

Just go back to the house as John and the money should he there

[celest wedge]

its an

oversight i guess

R* didnt think about this

[signal gale]

What’s the best horse?

don’t really like the Arabian anymore

[north swan]

When you rob the house with Javier, the one in the woods with the residents that speak a strange dialect, Arthur has a pretty bad cough for the first time, after collecting the money. If I recall correctly, that's chapter 2, maybe chapter 3.

[celest wedge]

you can do that mission before money lending and other sins III

[north swan]

Alright, beyond that, Arthur has some TB coughs when you arrive at Bronte's house to capture him, and another time when you visit strauss in chapter 4.

[north swan]

Missouri Fox Trotter has the best speed.

[celest wedge]

yes thats why i said he coughed twice in chapter 4

he coughed a few in guarma too

[north swan]

Yeah, I just skimmed through the chat, you're probably right.

[compact wave]

So uh i encountered jon on the valentine saloon and such, i defeated him and picked up his hat, then i went to check if it was on stolen or encountered hats but it wasn't there, anyone knows what might have happened?

[lusty sun]

wtf does “you cannot set up camp while there is activity nearby” mean? I’m no where near a road, I’m in the middle of the woods

it doesn’t expand upon it or anything, it just tells me I can’t set up camp, I’ve tried several different places and none have worked

what am I doing wrong

[candid pasture]

just save and reload

[lusty sun]

didn’t fix anything

same issue

[steel folio]

cannot load the game

anyone have the issue with launching the game?

[spiral shell]

it is for me, one second it was raining like crazy ,and the next it’s sunny af not a cloud in the sky

[thin plume]

some of the side quests reset for some reason

is that normal

?

i finished some side quests as arthur but when i switched to john some of them reset

[mental wind]

Guys

Do I use Long scope or Medium Scope for the Rolling Block rifle

In story

[signal gale]

But is it the best horse

[thin plume]

rose grey horse is best

[hidden moss]

No

Rachel is the best horse

[robust sedge]

No

Morgan is the best horse

[split verge]

Wheres the best spawn point for the ring-necked pheasant ?

[sleek rose]

Idk google it

[hidden moss]

Dutch warmblood best

[north swan]

Yes, asides from the Arabian.

[lusty sun]

black arabian is the best overall right?

[late apex]

hey i need help with hunting 3 star rabbits i need one more but i cant find any like at all any help?

[spiral zinc]

I’m pretty sure they’re literally everywhere u just gotta find em

[late apex]

well thats hard dude

thanks though

[spiral zinc]

To do the challenge i just rode my house around with a varmint rifle or small arrows and they were easy enough to find perfect ones

[rich sable]

Siiiiiiuuuuuu

[minor widget]

thats chapter two

[north swan]

Thought so.

[minor widget]

yea its in the beginning of horseshoe overlook

[inland spindle]

How do you spin your gun for a long time? I've seen someone do it on a youtube video, you can spin it until you want to stop and holster it. Can someone please tell me?

[north swan]

Mods, or RDO.

[inland spindle]

What mod can I get?

[north swan]

Otherwise, double tap TAB or LB when holding your right sidearm, and you'll do a short spinning animation.

[north swan]

I believe it's "Gun Spinning Tricks." I can send you a video on how to install it, that I found very useful when I first started modding.

[inland spindle]

Sure, send me a video

[north swan]

Links are blocked on the discord server, I'll do you it.

[stiff ferry]

Isnt there gonna be bounties in Tumblweed?

I went over there in my 6th playthrough

Is it because I shot the Sheriff when he shot the Del Lobo?

[lusty sun]

Well I didn’t shoot him and I have bounties so that may be it

[stiff ferry]

Damn

[stray wind]

uhh I've read from multiple sources that I can get the dappled black thoroughbred horse again for free from valentine if it was killed but it's still not showing up after passing a few days via sleeping, any hints?

[robust sedge]

Does anyone know the song that plays when John rides from the ranch to Blackwater?

[fervent sun]

I heard that there's a good and bad ending for the game

Before I start playing can someone tell me which ending is better to get and how to get it

[thin plume]

If u want good ending keep your honor high as possible

[fervent sun]

Which is better

[thin plume]

In what way

If u want good ending

keep your honor high

[fervent sun]

Idk not to be sad at the ending

[thin plume]

thats impossible

to not be sad sadly

But u can reduce the sadness a lil bit

[fervent sun]

Like is the bad ending so bad that I'm gonna wanna replay the game to get the good one?

[thin plume]

depends on the person

But it leaves you with a bad feeling

Thats for sure

[fervent sun]

Dang

Ok I'll try to keep honor high but it would've been funny to have it low

[thin plume]

Well keeping it high

Is so useful

U get discounts

up to 50

[fervent sun]

Oh ok

But on a second playthrough I'll have low honor

[thin plume]

k then

[fervent sun]

This game gonna be so good

It's like I won the video game lottery

[short temple]

Hello guys

[strong plover]

yo

[short temple]

What's up?

[robust sedge]

Soo

I'm guessing not?

[short temple]

Should I try rdr2?

[strong plover]

you have never played it?

[short temple]

I have heard about it but didn't play it

[strong plover]

It is one of my fav games ever, i really recomend it

[daring siren]

Where Is author and the others grave??

[short temple]

Alright thanks mate

[strong plover]

BRUH

Spoioler!

@short temple has never played the game!

[daring siren]

Do I look like I give af because I don't

[robust sedge]

Average ps player mind set

[graceful breach]

This is evilness at its best

[red helm]

The Channel does say be cautious of spoilers.

Also, anyone joining a Discord about a Game should really already be aware that the people in it may be discussing spoilers already.

[graceful breach]

We aren’t talking about a game,we are talking about the game of the decade

[red helm]

There is no "Good" or "Bad" Ending, like Menzo was saying, it's more that there is High Honor and Low Honor endings.

[graceful breach]

Don't you think that the honor makes the difference for doing the “Good” or “Bad” ending in the game?

[red helm]

I guess, but still, none of the 4 endings are "Bad" in my opinion.

[graceful breach]

But…going for the money is a bad ending and going with John with low honor is also a bad ending in my opinion

[red helm]

No, going for the money is not bad. Arthur is actually causing a distraction, so that John can get away easier.

Plus, if he had got the money, and gotten away, he would've brought the money to John and Abigail.

[graceful breach]

Or is he just being greedy and decides that money is more important than John's life

[red helm]

Arthur knows he is dying from the TB, obviously that isn't the case.

[graceful breach]

So if he is dying why would he go for the money instead of protecting John?,he ain’t making a distraction because when he took the money in the caves there wasn't any Pinkerton,only Micah

[red helm]

But he was yelling and shouting on the way to the Cave, and killed several on the way there.

Which made Micah and Dutch follow him there.

[graceful breach]

The real and good ending is going with John having high honor,because they both have a really fine last words and Arthur shows that he values more John that the money,and the ending seeing the sunrise with the music show's us that is the real ending of the game

[red helm]

I mean, there is no confirmed "Canon" ending. But, sure, High/Help would be the "Best".

[graceful breach]

But if you understand Arthur's character,you would know that he will go and sacrifice himself protecting John in the mountains,instead of going for the money

[red helm]

And in my opinion Low/Help would be the "Worst" ending.

But, really, going for the Money isn't bad in the least, if you really think about it.

[north swan]

Yeah, take the money from the crazies, Arthur probably would give it away to the good members of the gang.

[hidden moss]

i think arthur is morally ambiguous enough of a character (and by design) that either option is equally plausible, if you'd gone through the game as a neg. honor character (and possibly antagonistic towards everyone around you, including john) then i can just as easily see arthur prioritizing the money over john

[noble spire]

theres many advantages to high honor but being low honor is way too fun since you don't have to care about your honor dropping every 5 minutes

[hidden moss]

even as a high honor character i don't have to worry about that

because i don't shoot every single moving object i see

[noble spire]

yea but high honor is still canon tho

since its his redemption

[noble spire]

this would happen if he hadn't gone to thomas downes or saving micah

[hidden moss]

sure, i agree. just sayjng i think that arthur can be understood in the context of either his good side or bad

in a narrative sense, either one is just as likely to win out. but of course, as the player, who actually wants to see arthur go down the bad way

well, even if it's spoiled for me now, i'd still like to do a -honor playthrough next

[fervent sun]

I was playing and I couldn't increase my honor once, but I lost a bunch it's so hard

[hidden moss]

just greet people and do camp chores 😩

and donate to the box

[noble spire]

especially donating 20 dollars every donat

[hidden moss]

aye, more helps

[stable laurel]

Guys can I ask questions on like the end of rdr2

which contains spoilers

Is it ok if i ask it here

?

[near latch]

yes

add a spoiler tag

[stable laurel]

it gets remove

tho

should i just say it with no spoiler tag

[hidden moss]

everyone else does

spoilers all up in this bitch

[stable laurel]

ok so

Should I keep collecting money, legendary horses, saddles etc but I know arthur dies at the end and we lose everything idk if i should keep collecting them knowing they will just disappear after i complete the game

[hidden moss]

let's just say you get to play and finish out the game as a certain someone after arthur's demise

[stable laurel]

wdym

[hidden moss]

you'll get to keep most of those things

except the money

[stable laurel]

horses

do i keep my horse

please tell me i do

cuz it took me 3 hours to find this horse

[hidden moss]

😬

[stable laurel]

waz that emoji for

oh ok

thanks

[hidden moss]

nah nvm you can't keep any horses

you'll have to tame/buy new ones

[stable laurel]

damn

[hidden moss]

the white arabian respawns by then, so, that's an option

[stable laurel]

whats that

white arabian

[hidden moss]

a rare horse, fastest in the game

[stable laurel]

Whats the stats of it

Oh

Wait is it better than the uhh

[hidden moss]

north shore of lake isabella

it doesn't have a lot of health and gets spooked easily but it is insanely fast

[stable laurel]

wait

I have that horse

the white horse right

[hidden moss]

yea

[stable laurel]

Its my main horse

I got it in chapter 2

so im gonna have to get it again huh

[hidden moss]

well, when you lose it, you can get it back where it spawned

yep

[stable laurel]

I guess its another 3 hours grind

[hidden moss]

it took me 5 min to find it lol

[stable laurel]

@hidden moss wait so should I keep grinding money, horses or mainly focus on the storyline so if i finish it thats where i will grind money, legendary horses etc

[hidden moss]

i just ride a circle around the shore til it spawns

[hidden moss]

that's up to you, just enjoy the game. every story mission is a step closer to the end, so, depends on how much stuff you wanna collect first

[lusty sun]

once you get to chapter four the Black Arabian is the best

You can buy it in Saint Denis

[stable laurel]

I dont really wanna get it

since i know

after chapter 6

[lusty sun]

ah

[stable laurel]

They will all just be gone

[lusty sun]

thats a fair point

[hidden moss]

might as well since you lose the money anyway

[lusty sun]

do whatever you think is best mate, all up to you

[stable laurel]

I might aswell just grind story line and when I get to play john that when i will get the black arabian

[hidden moss]

go out on a nice ass horse

[lusty sun]

you don’t have to

theres a trick to not lose your momey

I did it like last week and it worked

[stable laurel]

is it the robbery house

[lusty sun]

yeah

[stable laurel]

where u get robbed and they store it somewhere

[hidden moss]

yea you can do the pig farm thing but that feels cheap to me

[stable laurel]

yeah

[hidden moss]

i never did that

[stable laurel]

u get 20k anyways

thats like 15x more of the money i have rn

[lusty sun]

Well I’d rather feel cheep and be rich than be broke and feel rich so

Whatever you want to do is fine

[undone ginkgo]

Okay so

[stable laurel]

I also want that but knowing that you will lose all of it makes me wanna complete the game first before i get them

[undone ginkgo]

When chapter 6 starts arthur has a pretty big beard
Should I shave it or let it grow until the end of the game

[lusty sun]

idk, I’d rather have 25k than 20k but thats me

[lusty sun]

Get a massive beard and don’t cut any hair

look like an absolute hairy chad

[undone ginkgo]

Yeah

Gonna eat a lot so arthur gets big

Then he'll be an absolute monster

[lusty sun]

lmao

thats a great idea

just before the last mission just eat everything you have lol

[undone ginkgo]

Yeah

[undone ginkgo]

The 20k goes by surprisingly quick once you start buying everything in the game lmao

[lusty sun]

yeah

I have everything and still have 12 k

so not that quickly

I guess I could buy 3 more Black Arabians…

[stable laurel]

whats the best way to earn money

that includes doing a glitch or something

[lusty sun]

story, other than that? Hunting legendary animals is pretty good. the good bounties could pay like 100 I think.

[undone ginkgo]

Yeah

[stable laurel]

Im doing a glitch where u get to a cabin and 2 guys sleep with a 50$ on the table after u kill them both save the game load the game and repeat

[lusty sun]

we aint allowed to talk about glitches here but on youtube the gold glitches are patched

[stable laurel]

oh ok

mb

[lusty sun]

thats the best non patched one I’m guessing

But tbh just by doing story you’ll get more than plenty. what chapter you in?

[undone ginkgo]

Yeah there's really not that much to buy in story

Especially in the earlier chapters

Cause everything is locked

[stiff ferry]

Any outfits John should have on?

Like nice ones

That fit with him

Like the Donegal or Josiah

[lusty sun]

like premade or character made?

[stiff ferry]

What do you mean?

You mean like Story or Online?

[lusty sun]

nah I mean like ones that players have made or the premade outfits that you csn buy at the store

[stiff ferry]

premade

[stable laurel]

3

Im just gonna speedrun story mode later

[lusty sun]

ah, Farrier is cool, Gambler is cool

[lusty sun]

yeah then I’d say just do missions if this is your first time, otherwise I think that glitch is the best method

[undone ginkgo]

First time you should definitely play the game normally, take your time to explore and take everything in, cause its a wild ride and a great game

[lusty sun]

fr

[stable laurel]

yessir

[lusty sun]

man I cried when that one guy whos name starts with “A” died

[stable laurel]

arthur

[hidden moss]

Arturo the hot air balloon operator

[lusty sun]

that guy

top 10 anime deaths

[silk temple]

My horse, Bob died because of an attack of bounty hunters

[hidden moss]

My condolences

[frosty swan]

Hello

[austere plank]

Hello, do you know where I could get a help with mods for a single player? Im specifically looking for a slow mo mod

[candid pasture]

not here

[spice fable]

Hello all

[stoic birch]

hello there

[fresh grove]

Hi there mister

Nightfolk encounters still creepy af

I like the O'Drisscols signature sound

This "Dam dam daaam daaaam"

Especially in the Headless Kirean Cutscene u get paranoia of that

Since that i realized how fucking ruthless and brutal the O'Driscols are and they aren't without reason a widely feared gang

[magic dirge]

does anyone have an issue when starting rdr2 it comes up saying you have been logged out of social club?

it wont let me log in cause the log in button has a loading thingy on it if yk what i mean

[sullen gyro]

Can someone help me out, I am trying to get Mr Pearson’s request for the rabbit to get the denim jacket. Is this possible to do in chapter 3? Or do you need to be in chapter 2?

[red helm]

Needs to be Chapter 2.

[drowsy pilot]

I wouldn’t say missing the scout jacket deters you from “100%” the game.

Depends on how you view 100%

[celest wedge]

100% all clothes ig lol

[left hinge]

Man this game looks so fun

Such a huge map

And details everywhere

I just noticed that more and more snow gets on the clothew and it melts when you go to a warm place

Also

I wanna know what to do next

Im in the wooden house

After the first chapter where you save john

And idk where to go or what to do

I dont even have a gun

[south holly]

anybody got any tips on how to get the bleed out animation

[exotic gust]

Yo guys

I did the angelo conte mission and i got the mauser

And it disappeared

How do i get it back

[celest wedge]

it should be in your inventory

[celest wedge]

you mean bleeding out npcs?

try shooting them in the neck

[signal gale]

just finished the game

one of the best single player games I have ever played

[hidden moss]

I'm replaying the story for my 3rd time man and I'm going to be doing a tribute video on Arthur

[hidden moss]

I agree!

[signal gale]

I got rid of my comment incase of spoilers

but wow man

[stoic birch]

oh nice!

[signal gale]

man the ending is crazy I can’t believe it

[hidden moss]

Yeah it is man

[stoic birch]

I have like 180 hours of gameplay but I'm still on chapter 2 because most of it was spent on online mode

[hidden moss]

I don't think anything can top the story in RDR2

Originally GTA 4 was my favourite but then that changed when I played the RDR2 story

[stoic birch]

I love everything about rdr2 tbh

[signal gale]

Rdr2 story is something else

[stoic birch]

the characters, the scenery, the mechanics, all of it

[signal gale]

everything about it is just so perfect

[stoic birch]

exactly

[signal gale]

and I love how I can still do those side missions even as John

like I didn’t get all the gunslingers

had one more left

[hidden moss]

I'm currently working on a video on Arthur

[signal gale]

how great. went from killing people to shovelling shit 😄

[hidden moss]

Don't worry, John will go back to killing 😂

[crisp acorn]

It might just be me but I really wish we could get two high roller revolvers since I dress my Arthur and John as fancy gamblers and I always use the high roller but I wanna have two

[hidden moss]

Hi well I just finished red dead and I want to do the assault on braithwaite manor what percentage is that

[crisp acorn]

Wdym

[hidden moss]

Like I want to replay the braithwaite mission again

Can I do thta

That

Like when Jack dutch

John

When the house burns down

[crisp acorn]

Yes

You can replay any mission

[hidden moss]

WHAT

I CAN

[crisp acorn]

Yes

Go to progress and then story then choose the chapter then the mission

[hidden moss]

So all the time i grinded to play one mission I could've REPLAYED IT

[crisp acorn]

Yes

[hidden moss]

Tell me I am dumb

[pliant shoal]

whats the best place to find cougars i need it for my master hunter challenge

4

do chapters matter

alright so do you know a good place for cougars?

ive gone near it past it in it and i havent even seen a cougar yet

i know

still havent got anything

[lusty sun]

so can I do like a bank rob mission and redo it for a few thousand each time?

[surreal oxide]

You not got mods on PC?

[rapid wolf]

i did not understand u

[surreal oxide]

Mods are cheats, but better

You can do a lot of things with mods

[rapid wolf]

i have Arabic language mod and most of mods doesn't work with that

[crisp acorn]

Yes

But you won’t get paid

You don’t get payed doing replays

[lusty sun]

ah

ok

[celest wedge]

you clearly dont understand how to mod rdr2

[thin plume]

how do i make more than 1 custom outfits when i make another one they all become same

they overwrite each other

[celest wedge]

(و بحبش مود تعريب rdr2 : 🤮) @rapid wolf

[celest wedge]

save your custom outfit

[thin plume]

i saved it

[celest wedge]

go to "outfits on horse" or something

then save it

it should look like custom outfit save 1

[thin plume]

figured it out ty

[fresh grove]

Kirean is a tragic character

He was only a O'Driscol because they forced him to.

They said "Either u join or u die"

They knew where they were

[strong plover]

Ya, I loved Kirean

[twin mason]

so i just died with legendary animal on my horses back now i cant sell it cuz i lost it when will i be able to kill another one?

[umbral flare]

I got a new tv, when I load rdr2 it says no signal? It works on other games, what do I do?

[celest wedge]

no

you still techincally can craft clothes & trinkets without pelts

[twin mason]

so that still does count i sold it in shop cuz im trying to finish the game 100%

[shell hound]

Has anyone here tested FSR 2.1 on RDR2?

[celest wedge]

yes

[twin mason]

thanks

[kindred cloud]

Is there a new game+?

[thin plume]

no u can just look it up on google

[vital marlin]

asked this before but got no answer, does time spent while the game is paused counts in social club

in the status page