I like otis revolver
#red-dead-singleplayer
real yacht
gleaming basin
like i asked earlier
why cant i use the "wait till morning" at the van horn fence
i shot the guy and ran outside but it didnt show it
im trying to do the level 10 beard thing
and please someone respond to this
real yacht
Maybe thats why the option didnt show up cuz theres noone to man the shop
Are u tryna get level 10 beard?
gleaming basin
yeah
real yacht
Just drink some hair tonics
gleaming basin
ik
real yacht
Whats the fence have to do with beard
gleaming basin
i have 84 of them
gleaming basin
Whats the fence have to do with beard
its a g
real yacht
A what
gleaming basin
oh wait
its a strategic
to get lvl 10 beard
you shoot the fence owner go outside and drink 3 hair tonics
real yacht
Idk anything about that strat im afraid 
gleaming basin
then use wait till morning and go and keep on doing it
gleaming basin
Idk anything about that strat im afraid <:Anon:795145103291318323>
its alright
faint zodiac
Go to van horn, shoot the fence owner and just ‘wait until morning’ and then use hair tonic
Its pretty poggers
trim sail
how do you open the menu on ps4?
wheat grotto
how do you open the menu on ps4?
What menu?
trim sail
like where you can change settings and save your game and stuff like that'
wheat grotto
like where you can change settings and save your game and stuff like that'
Like spawn in stuff?
That isnt possible on ps4
desert coral
like where you can change settings and save your game and stuff like that'
press options button
trim sail
oh okay thanks
wheat grotto
I thought he talkin bout mod menu
desert coral
i have no idea what they talking about either
trim sail
like where you can leave your game, it comes up in the left side of the screen and is red
trim sail
yes okay
wheat grotto
Ye
wheat grotto
If on pc esc
wheat grotto
i am so bad at explaining ;-;
Is it all red and text like entities etc?
trim sail
can i send a pick of it in media?
wheat grotto
can i send a pick of it in media?
Ye
heavy adder
How tf do you catch the fish near braithwate manor
I've got like 10 shitty bass with special lake bait
Tried special river bait too, no luck
hidden moss
guys theres no missions on my map???
heavy adder
guys theres no missions on my map???
What chapter?
heavy adder
Try passing time by doing side quests
hidden moss
Try passing time by doing side quests
wym
oh yeah btw i havnt discovered te whole blackwater
should i do that
heavy adder
As soon as you approach the place...
Let's just say some not-so-friendly people will kindly ask you to leave
hidden moss
lmao
heavy adder
Rather, aimbot pinkertons that spawn in very big groups
That get half of your health with one bullet
hidden moss
Rather, aimbot pinkertons that spawn in very big groups
oooh i know why i cant do any missions
it says
the camp is celebrating that sean returned and any missions wilkl be unavailable
hidden moss
okay
heavy adder
okay
Oh and btw
Try to keep a good karma
I don't wanna say too much, but let's just say, it affects the ending
You also get a nice discount for having good karma
heavy adder
You won't enjoy the bad karma ending
hidden moss
but how do i get it too good fasdt
heavy adder
You're not close
Don't worry
You're only like 1/5 through the story
You will have time
hidden moss
ok good
heavy adder
Just try to keep it positive
hidden moss
i also got 6thousand money
bc i did the jack hall gang treasure ma
idk what to buy or what to do with it
since i can barely buy any guns
real yacht
buy all the clothings
heavy adder
Ehh
real yacht
cuz idk what else to spend on
hidden moss
im gonna do that in the end if i have alot of money
heavy adder
im gonna do that in the end if i have alot of money
In the very end of the game you get more money than you'll need
heavy adder
Best horse is the arabian
heavy adder
You can either buy it with 1k dollars when you unlock it
Or get a white one for free if you find it
One in stables is always black
hidden moss
any specfic place to find them
real yacht
arabians are really skittish tho so expect them to throw you
hidden moss
skittish?
real yacht
theyre big scary cats compare to the other breeds
hidden moss
theyre big scary cats compare to the other breeds
isnt that good
heavy adder
Uh no
real yacht
nah
hidden moss
oh u mean scaredy cats?
real yacht
they would yeet u off them if they got too scared
hidden moss
oooh
heavy adder
they would yeet u off them if they got too scared
Any horse will
hidden moss
u guys know a good saddle tho
heavy adder
But if you get it to level 4, it won't
hidden moss
I think crafting them give you perks ?
real yacht
oh u mean scaredy cats?
oh yea that lol i typed it wrong my bad
hidden moss
I'm not sure.
real yacht
But if you get it to level 4, it won't
my level 4 arabians still throw me ):
heavy adder
Are there any boats near saint denis?
hidden moss
Then you're torturing them lol
hidden moss
Are there any boats near saint denis?
Yeah, a whole dock but I don't think you can use any of them.
guys best saddle?
heavy adder
Yeah, a whole dock but I don't think you can use any of them.
I need to get to the fucking peninsula
twin mason
guys best saddle?
Look it up yourself
real yacht
guys best saddle?
the panther saddle imo but u gotta craft that one
heavy adder
Swimming with my horse didn't quite work
hidden moss
I need to get to the fucking peninsula
For Jimboy Calloway side quest?
heavy adder
Fish
hidden moss
the panther saddle imo but u gotta craft that one
the best that u can buy?
heavy adder
Da fish
heavy adder
Get the camp boat
Epilogue
hidden moss
Oh
real yacht
the best that u can buy?
idk then i always use crafted ones
real yacht
go along the east beach of lemoyne, sometimes u can find a canoe there
heavy adder
The fact that you can't drug your horse when swimming pisses me off
heavy adder
go along the east beach of lemoyne, sometimes u can find a canoe there
Looked up online, should be one at bluewater marsh
twin mason
guys it will only let me buy ardennes
Which town
hidden moss
its not ina town its like
hidden moss
2 in stall and one out
twin mason
ye but how many hours on a game u have?
hidden moss
idk
twin mason
and only in chapter 2? u gotta unlock them ig
hidden moss
i went straigt into online
twin mason
and sell the ones in stall im not sure u will need them
twin mason
guys it will only let me buy ardennes
so u are saying it for online?
hidden moss
no
twin mason
okay i think u gotta unlock them
hidden moss
man bruh
twin mason
and sell those in stall i think u wont need them
twin mason
can i find a arabian somehow?
ye u can
hidden moss
any specific location?
twin mason
DM
real yacht
theres a white arabian northwest of lake isabella
a warped brindle west of the wapiti
twin mason
theres a white arabian northwest of lake isabella
ye i sent him the location
real yacht
oh nice
fallow ingot
do squirrel pelts fit in the satchel
fallow ingot
how the hell am I supposed to hunt a squirrel and retain the quality
twin mason
bow
or try stepping on them with the horse
and they are slow so u can just kick them
cunning flume
I just saw such a beautiful video that brought tears to my eyes again. It's called "Arthur." I don't know if yall know that, but it's really great.** But contains spoilers!**
nova oyster
Hello guys
jovial anvil
why can't I donate money to camp? I'm on chapter 6 next to this cave and there is no place on the map where I can deposit as it was in previous chapters
grand sedge
No point in donating
at that point
and I’m pretty sure it’s like that because the gang is falling apart
So
bummer
nova oyster
1911 John Marston > 1899 Arthur Morgan
sorry about that
bbut its true
i played rdr1 rdr2 rdr undead nightmare and red dead revolver
hidden moss
guys im tryna get the black arabian horse but it didint spawn once the whole night
nova oyster
guys im tryna get the black arabian horse but it didint spawn once the whole nig...
arabian horses spawn only in lake isabella and only 1 white arabian spawns you can find other arabian horse colors in stable
hidden moss
arabian horses spawn only in lake isabella and only 1 white arabian spawns you c...
no black can also spawn
nova oyster
No my buddy only white spawn
Buy black from stable
Also 1 horse spawn at lake isabella
sorry for my bad english im turkish
Good night boah
real yacht
theres a random encounter in saint denis that spawns a black arabian
quaint temple
Guys
Know what I never understood
The mission My Last Son
Why did John go with Dutch?
Sadie and Charles were all “Fuck Dutch, we’re riding with Arthur”, BUT JOHN RODE WITH DUTCH
real yacht
to keep an eye on dutch maybe idk
hidden moss
No my buddy only white spawn
no at midnight in saint denis a black arabian spawn
quaint temple
Heres a thought
So Sean, Kieran, Hosea, Lenny, Molly
You think any wouldve sided with Micah?
hidden moss
how do i fix a drifting controller
quaint temple
how do i fix a drifting controller
Buy a new one or replace the small bearing the sticks ride on
hidden moss
and btw i got the panther but it got removed fropm my horse and i cant find it and now it wont even show up
real yacht
what panther
real yacht
like the pelt?
quaint temple
Go back and kill another
hidden moss
yes
real yacht
did u get the pelt and then die
hidden moss
Go back and kill another
i have been waitying for 14mins
hidden moss
did u get the pelt and then die
no it just disapeared from my horse
quaint temple
Is the Panther pelt considered a large pelt?
quaint temple
You can carry a panther carcass right?
real yacht
go to the trapper anyway, see if u can sell it cuz sometimes stuffs disappear from my horse too its buggy
quaint temple
Yeah, animals in RDR2 are either small, medium, large
Small animal pelts can be stored in the satchel
Some small carcasses too
Medium animals can be stored on the horse, as can their pelts
real yacht
i have been waitying for 14mins
u need to wait for 3 in game days before it can respawn, so just sleep until 3 days have passed
quaint temple
Large animals can only be skinned
hidden moss
u need to wait for 3 in game days before it can respawn, so just sleep until 3 d...
man fuck sake
real yacht
Yeah, animals in RDR2 are either small, medium, large
i thought its small medium large and massive
quaint temple
All I know is theres 4 ways to deifne it
real yacht
small animals are ones u can put in ur satchel, medium can be stowed on the sides of ur horse, large ones on the back and massive can only be skinned
quaint temple
- Can have the carcass and pelt stored in satchel
- Can have the pelt stored in satchel, carcass on horse
- Can have carcass and pelt stored on horse
- Can have pelt stored on horse
real yacht
ye
hidden moss
small animals are ones u can put in ur satchel, medium can be stowed on the side...
that sounds abouty right
quaint temple
Guys
I ship Arthur and Tilly
Like we know Arthur was gonna have a cut love interest
I think they meant they cut a love story with Arthur and Tilly
I mean look at both Anthony Foreman missions
In Valentine, Arthur runs up to him, draws his gun, and shouts “Get your damn hands off her!”
Chapter 4 has a whole mission of Arthur saving Tilly and helping her get revenge
hidden moss
do i need predator bait for the panther to come?
red helm
do i need predator bait for the panther to come?
'Need' No, but can be helpful.
quaint temple
do i need predator bait for the panther to come?
I almost never bait an animal, I find it, and shoot it
real yacht
do i need predator bait for the panther to come?
no, unless u wanna hunt it from afar
red helm
I ship Arthur and Tilly
I think they completely cut Arthur's romance interest from the game. From what I have heard.
real yacht
usually i just let them hunt me lmao
quaint temple
RDR2 shouldve had spear fishing
Imagine Arthur Morgan walking around with a fucking spear
“It’s a tool and a weapon you see”
red helm
do i need predator bait for the panther to come?
Also, also, you definitely don't need to wait 3 game days for the Panther's to respawn. I've seen 2 within 10 minutes.
quaint temple
Fun Fact: bow fishing is possible in RDR2
The bow + deadeye can be a substitute for the fishing rod
real yacht
fun fact: u can fish with dynamites
red helm
Gun fishing is a thing. and technically a challenge.
quaint temple
But I wish we had spear fishing
red helm
Or to be exact, there is a challenge to get some fish without using a rod.
quaint temple
I know
wanton sorrel
Anyway to make quick money?
quaint temple
I wonder if tomahawk fishing is possible
red helm
A spear would be interesting, but they couldn't add everything.
red helm
Anyway to make quick money?
What chapter are you in?
quaint temple
Anyway to make quick money?
Go to Shady Belle and Beaver Hollow, keep looting the bodies, they respawn every few in game hours
wanton sorrel
2
quaint temple
Rain hell on Shady Belle and Beaver Hollow
You wont lose honor as theyre enemy gang camps
They have useful loot
Youll get TONS of revolver and repeater ammo
wanton sorrel
Ok
real yacht
shady belle over beaver hollow
hidden moss
Or to be exact, there is a challenge to get some fish without using a rod.
theres many rotten carcasses will that affect?
red helm
2
There is a burned down town just a tad west of Horseshoe(Your home camp), Check the sheriffs building for a desk to loot.
real yacht
murfrees are broke as hell
red helm
theres many rotten carcasses will that affect?
Assuming they need to have meat on them.
real yacht
yea but they want money
quaint temple
Beaver Hollow is THE way to get a weapon early as John
I run in there, beat the first guy I see, grab his cattleman
red helm
Beaver Hollow is THE way to get a weapon early as John
They are in Chapter 2, so not relevant...
quaint temple
Yes but Beaver Hollow is packed with weapon loot
Tons of revolver, repeater, and shotgun ammo
real yacht
can also try hanging dog ranch too
quaint temple
The first few guys spawn with Cattlemans
Deeper in the cave you’ll see them with Schofield Revolvers, Repeating Carbines, Double Barrel Shotguns, and Machetes
real yacht
cattlemans arent hard to find, also john spawns with one
quaint temple
Not until Motherhood
wanton sorrel
I already got the basic weapons
quaint temple
Im talking between The Wheel and Motherhood for getting John a gun
real yacht
thats very specific
red helm
One, Beaver Hollow is rather far away from where they are. and Two, you kind of need to have a good amount of skill to take on Gang Hideouts, and assuming they are just starting the game, so...
pastel egret
why cant i go into the mutant house as john
quaint temple
Mutant house?
hidden moss
bro theres not a single panther comming
pastel egret
yes
quaint temple
What is the mutant house
red helm
bro theres not a single panther comming
THey are random, Patience.
real yacht
bro theres not a single panther comming
where are u finding them
pastel egret
the scientest who made the beast
quaint temple
Oh idk
hidden moss
where are u finding them
by saint denis
pastel egret
oh wait nvm
quaint temple
Fun Fact: once you encounter ANY animal, an image of them will appear on the map where you first found rhem
pastel egret
i just climbed in the window
quaint temple
For starters, go to Lakay
wanton sorrel
The only way i was able to make a little money was by selling carages
red helm
by saint denis
Best spot I found for Panther's is a little cabin called Harryfen Downs. It's just southeast of the Braithwaithe Planitation. North of Catfish Jack's.
quaint temple
No enemies spawn at Lakay and really good loot such as Jewelry and Potent Tonics spawn there
wanton sorrel
And by robbing trains
red helm
The only way i was able to make a little money was by selling carages
Did you see the message I sent, about Limpany?
hidden moss
Best spot I found for Panther's is a little cabin called Harryfen Downs. It's ju...
im kinda there
quaint temple
Lakay is also home to a legendary fish
wanton sorrel
No sorry
quaint temple
Go to Lakay for loot
red helm
im kinda there
Okay, Cool. I found several in that forest, the florida one as well.
wanton sorrel
Did you see the message I sent, about Limpany?
No sorry
hidden moss
Okay, Cool. I found several in that forest, the florida one as well.
i found one but it randomly disapeared somehow
red helm
No sorry
There is a burned down town just a tad west of Horseshoe(Your home camp), Check the sheriffs building for a desk to loot.
wanton sorrel
Ok thanks
cunning flume
is there a way to see my playtime in rdr2?
red helm
is there a way to see my playtime in rdr2?
You can check either the Steam Library, or the Social Club.
wanton sorrel
Which is better robbing trains or selling carages
quaint temple
Which is better robbing trains or selling carages
It depends on how shit the loot is or how shit the coach is
Missions will pay y’know
real yacht
i say train, but that costs more honor
pastel egret
Which is better robbing trains or selling carages
train
red helm
Which is better robbing trains or selling carages
Trains is rather dangerous, and you'll easily get a high $ bounty, and low Honor.
Wagon selling is much better.
quaint temple
You make like 600 when Arthur, John, Charles, and Sean rob a train, and a few hundred more the very next mission when Arthur and Micah rob a coach
real yacht
wagon is safe but boring as hell
pastel egret
maybe this is why im a low honor lol
red helm
Wagon's aren't nearly as fun... True, but.... Far safer
wanton sorrel
Ok i will do both
red helm
Give trains a try. Make a manual save first, though.
grand sedge
If you don’t care about honor
the largest carriages give you 40$ from Seamus
plus another 10-50$ From challenges
wanton sorrel
What is better double cattleman revolvers,double sawed of shotguns or double volcanic pistols?
grand sedge
double cattleman for results double shotguns for fun
wanton sorrel
What are the best rifles?
wanton sorrel
Best rifles for starters?
real yacht
springfield
real yacht
u can get that real early
grand sedge
you usually make around 1200 near the start of the game
hidden moss
how do i know its midnight in saint denis
real yacht
when its 12 am??
grand sedge
Down on the D pad
real yacht
u can also equip a watch and use that if u wanna be immersive
real yacht
same
grand sedge
A beautiful piece 
real yacht
i might be a low down criminal but that dont mean i cant be fancy 
grand sedge
Near the start of my high honor play through
I tried dressing like Dutch
made the cutscenes pretty savvy
hidden moss
GUYS
FUCK
look
i found the couple and all
got the horse i went on it
it threw me off
now
its runnjing away
real yacht
how did u got thrown off 
grand sedge
The couple?
hidden moss
it did that 2leg thing
real yacht
they tryna get the black arabian
real yacht
run after the horse and try to calm it down
grand sedge
in Saint denis
hidden moss
i have 6k cash but i havt unlcoked it
neon copper
arabians are pricey
missouri fox trotter for free is better
grand sedge
ah
real yacht
missouri fox trotter for free is better
yea i would take that over an arabian but this aint about me
neon copper
yea i would take that over an arabian but this aint about me
I would also take an arabian
my level 4 bonding white arabian
If u dont like white color u can get a chestnut and warped arabian
hidden moss
or black
neon copper
Rose arabian is the best but u cant get that as arthur
real yacht
@hidden moss did u want a black arabian specifically?
hidden moss
yes
red helm
I'd use a Trotter or Turko, as well. Arabians and their scaredy catness is just a ugh...
hidden moss
and i got it now
real yacht
oh u got it back?
neon copper
I'd use a Trotter or Turko, as well. Arabians and their scaredy catness is just ...
Turkomans are good but i dont like the color
red helm
Bond 4 only does so much, They just bolt if a leaf falls near them.
hidden moss
yes
neon copper
I prefer silver trotter and arabian
red helm
Turkomans are good but i dont like the color
The dark gray coat one from Blackwater is great.
neon copper
ye
Honestly rn im not even looking for horses
Tryna get new austin herbs as arthur
Extremely difficult
grand sedge
I'd use a Trotter or Turko, as well. Arabians and their scaredy catness is just ...
Yeah on my John marathon save my Arabian got ran over so I ended purchasing the Golden turkoma
hidden moss
is there any way to get maks for my horse
red helm
That darn challenge, it should've just been all the ones 'getable' as Arthur.
neon copper
That darn challenge, it should've just been all the ones 'getable' as Arthur.
Also the name doesnt suit john, legend of the east is arthur
legend of the west is john
red helm
Also the name doesnt suit john, legend of the east is arthur
Indeed, Rockstar logic right there.
real yacht
is there any way to get maks for my horse
maks?
red helm
Masks?
real yacht
whats that
hidden moss
horse masks search it up
real yacht
no u cant
red helm
Not that I am aware of.
hidden moss
u can
real yacht
at least not in story
neon copper
I dont know if i should use my missouri fox trotter as arthur
neon copper
I have it but idk if i should use it
One thing im annoyed is that u get a free ultimate edition horse in story mode, but u cannot remove it for stable space
its some useless throughbred
real yacht
hey that thoroughbred served me well ):
red helm
That sucks. Only 4 horse slots in the stables is way to limiting.
real yacht
and it doesnt take up a stable place wdym
neon copper
and it doesnt take up a stable place wdym
It does
neon copper
I will check
real yacht
u can sell it if u dont want it
it doesnt take up anythingin the first place if u havent bought it
neon copper
Alright
Ill see
Also since u have ultimate edition u got those 3 free guns?
cuz i couldnt
real yacht
ye
neon copper
I only got nuevo paraiso outfit
real yacht
did u check the gunsmith
real yacht
ye
neon copper
Ill have to check
Oh
nv,
I thought the pump and varmint and the volcanic were already free 😂
odd sandal
update on this puppys are way much better
hollow mantle
hey that thoroughbred served me well ):
Same, I got a Black Arabian close to the end, and let the throughbread in the stable. Good thing I did, as the Arabian dies in a tragic way at the end, I would have gotten much more emotional if it was the horse that served me through newrly the whole game that died.
topaz blade
High honor or low honor Arthur
real yacht
High
gilded pollen
High honor or low honor Arthur
high
opaque barn
High honor or low honor Arthur
high
quaint temple
Same, I got a Black Arabian close to the end, and let the throughbread in the st...
I always use the Shire that Hosea gives you
I even name him Matthew, after Hosea Matthews
From Chapter 2 to Chapter 6, he’s my boah
midnight dawn
Is rdr1 base online game and dlc's still well populated?
fluid wolf
Should I drink ginseng elixir
Does it increase my health point
Like, if I drink one, I'd get more levels for my health?
real yacht
U get exp to level up if u haven’t reached max level already
fluid wolf
U get exp to level up if u haven’t reached max level already
So I should drink it then?
Im not yet max so...
real yacht
Yea go ahead
wanton sorrel
What are these animal things on my screen?
raven jasper
What animal things?
keen birchBOT
Read if Arthur sucks.
raven jasper
You can get discounts and special outfits with high honor but I feel like Arthur in itself is a bad man already, given how many he kills during the story
wanton sorrel
The animal symbols
raven jasper
Yea what animal symbols, in the hud or on the map or what? i've no idea what ur talking about man
twin mason
Is low honor bad or just not as good?
people will be rude to you and u wont have any discounts like good honor but you get something for low honor too im not sure what
fiery nebula
am I the only who thinks micah was the best dressed dude in the gang lol
if only we could wear his leather coat
harsh cliff
just witnessed arthurs death the 2nd time. Hits just as hard as the 1st time
hidden moss
Anyone know much about the letter from Micah’s brother in Shady Belle?
ionic night
Anyone know much about the letter from Micah’s brother in Shady Belle?
I just found that myself
I have no idea really though what it’s about but seems Micah’s own family doesn’t even like him
hidden moss
guys yk the legendarty animal map is the cougar panther or like?? how do i get the legendary panther eye or?
wheat grotto
Does anyone else just like shooting ragdolls?
harsh cliff
Does anyone else just like shooting ragdolls?
this
wheat grotto
Or am I the only psychopath?
old ridge
Or am I the only psychopath?
i mean you had a plan........
wheat grotto
i mean you had a plan........
I had many plans, most of them didn't work, we robbed a post office, and got 15 dollars and a quarter each..
keen vapor
my dad is mad bc i called him black lung
hidden moss
im trying to do the challenge find 3perfect rabbits but bro its so hard to find 3stars
i have been searchjing for like 30mins
old ridge
I had many plans, most of them didn't work, we robbed a post office, and got 15 ...
but we never went to Tahiti
old ridge
im trying to do the challenge find 3perfect rabbits but bro its so hard to find ...
call charles
man knows every inch of the map
civic sandal
finally started the game back up after almost 2 years of not touching it 
getting 100% really took all my efforts out of the game but ive been craving to play again so here i go on my 8th playthrough 💀
midnight dawn
Rdr2 for me doesn't have a replay value
I played it once and that's it it's a very good game one of my favorites but it's should be a one time experience
civic sandal
I personally gotta disagree on that. Every time I play again I find new little things I missed previously.
Yes the game only truly is impactful the first time playing, but I love going back and going through everything over again. But im also autistic, so maybe thats causing some bias 😅
hidden moss
Hello
midnight dawn
I personally gotta disagree on that. Every time I play again I find new little t...
Eeh well yeah depends on what type of gamer you are, for me i spent nearly 600 hours in one playthrough, so i think i saw everything i need to lmao, whenever a new discovery comes to light i'll just log back in and replay a certain mission not the whole game
civic sandal
Thats valid! My first run was right when the game came out and I finished it in like 70 hours? I don't think I slept at all 💀 I wanted to beat it before i saw spoilers lmao
My 100% run definitely was in the 300 hour range though
loud rampart
this sounds stupid but while i was trying to get the wood for the father in the timber company i accidentally ran over one of the workers with my horse, now i cant even greet the foreman, is it possible to get the wood now?
jovial anvil
how much money you get after finishing the game?
quaint temple
Guys
Redoing my chapter ranking
Heres my ranking of the chapters
- Chapter 4: Shady Belle
- Chapter 6: Beaver Hollow
- Chapter 8: Beecher’s Hope
- Chapter 2: Horseshoe Overlook
- Chapter 5: Guarma
- Chapter 7: Proghorn Ranch
- Chapter 1: Colter
- Chapter 3: Clemens Point
quaint temple
how much money you get after finishing the game?
20K
Yeah
Finishing the game rewards you 20K and a unique revolver
jovial anvil
and after finishing the game I can continue to do missions from strangers etc?
quaint temple
Yes and no
There is one mission strand, the one for the Professor, it MUST be done BEFORE Chapter 7
It unlocks in Chapter 4
jovial anvil
with a professor with an electric chair I finished
jovial anvil
i in epilog
jovial anvil
honestly I don't know
quaint temple
Whats the last thing you remember
Does John have access to Arthur’s weapons for you?
jovial anvil
yes
quaint temple
Did John, Charles, and Uncle do the thing yet?
celest bolt
I believe
quaint temple
Main menu -> progression -> story
@jovial anvil you’re watching the cutscenes, right?
Them cutscenes are powerful
jovial anvil
is the option to skip i skip
quaint temple
For RDR2 and GTA V, i always watch the cutscenes the first time doing a mission on that save
quaint temple
is the option to skip i skip
Dude…
You missed a lot
So many jokes you wont get
“Don’t forget the quarter”
For the mission American Venom, DO NOT SKIP
The cutscenes are vital to that mission
normal relic
Yep
jovial anvil
but it takes centuries before it ends cutscene
quaint temple
So?
quaint temple
Not like you have better things to do with your time if you’re talking to me
Some cutscenes, man
Besin
What choice did you make for Arthur?
jovial anvil
what
quaint temple
Did you save John or go for the money?
jovial anvil
save john
quaint temple
High or low honor?
jovial anvil
I almost had the whole
quaint temple
Did Arthur watch a sunset, or did Micah shoot his face off?
normal relic
I hate micah
quaint temple
Theres 3 ways Arthur can die
candid pasture
quaint temple
- Die of TB watching his final sunrise after knowing John is safe
- Micah shoots Arthur in the face
- Micah stabs Arthur to death with Arthur’s own knife
real yacht
jovial anvil
arthur died when he fought with the micah on his fist and almost reached for the gun but the dutch stood on his hand
quaint temple
So you got the best ending
The general consensus is that help John high honor is the good ending, help john low honor and go for the money high honor are neutral, and go for the money low honor is bad
normal relic
You got high honor
quaint temple
Also, last night
normal relic
Save John and Arthur dies during sunset
quaint temple
I encountered the worst bug
I went fishing with Javier, but Javier just kept fishing
Same damn line from him every time I caught something
normal relic
Weird
quaint temple
“It’s small, but might make a nice meal”
I had to fail the mission to fix a bugged Javier
normal relic
I never got bugs like that
quaint temple
Javier is buggy for me
lime ridge
Dear lord... Skipping cutscenes in games that are more focused on the story.
normal relic
I never skipped the cutscenes
quaint temple
The game tends to softlock for me on the Javier house robbery, so I need to mission fail to un-bug Javier
I only skip cutscenes in mission replays
normal relic
I knew they were important
real yacht
Imagine playing a story heavy game and skip all the story
quaint temple
Im on playthrough 5, I still watch the cutscenes because its my first time doing these missions on this save file
normal relic
I rushed my first play through
quaint temple
I rushed my first play through
I rushed Chapter 5
normal relic
I rushed every chapter
quaint temple
My first time doing 5, I did it all in 1 sitting, no piss break
normal relic
I didn't know there were things i could've done throughout story
quaint temple
There is only 1 way to do American Venom
Wearing Arthur’s hat and using Arthur’s revolvers
normal relic
That's chapter 6
quaint temple
American Venom
John’s final story mission
The game makes you wear Arthur’s hat during the mission
But I choose to use the gold double action revolvers I used as Arthur on American Venom
normal relic
I keep Arthur's hat on John
quaint temple
I like having John wear his RDR1 hat
John is not Arthur
I wear a modified version of John’s RDR1 outfit mostly, but I try to keep John and Arthur separate
That being said, I do not doubt John would wear Arthur’s hat for certain occasions
Wouldve been cool if Arthur’s hat was the one John wore with the wedding suit
quaint temple
Y’know, for Banking The Old American Art, the game wont remove Arthur’s hat from your horse so long as you dont mission fail
normal relic
Really
quaint temple
Yeah
And for Goodbye Dear Friend, on PC at least, it wont remove the off-hand sidearm so long as you dont mission fail
normal relic
Interesting
jovial anvil
and I have one more question I can finish the game at 100% when arthur died?
real yacht
u cant 100% legitimately as arthur
quaint temple
John’s story missions are required for 100%
You could try to get some things that only spawn in the RDR1 map as Arthur
normal relic
Yea
quaint temple
But you cannot do the 1907 storyline as him
Some stranger missions required for 100% also will NOT spawn for Arthur
The 100% rewards are for John
After 100% you get 7 exclusive cutscenes with John
normal relic
Stranger missions for 100% never knew that
quaint temple
Iirc there’s 31 stranger mission strands
1 has to be done as Arthur
Some of them can only be finished as John
I know Charlotte and Hamish’s missions have to be started as Arthur and finished as John
normal relic
I finished Hamish with John
Charlotte i don't remember if i finished with arthur or john
quaint temple
For her, you do the first 3 encounters as Arthur and the final one as John
The game wont let you do the 4th encounter as Arthur
Just do 3 encounters with her, then return to Willard’s rest as John, and iirc, it unlocks Willard’s rest as basically a secondary safehouse for John
normal relic
I dont know any other stranger missions besides those 2
That's up by that Marco guy
candid pasture
Idk how many i have done
you can check in the pause menu > progress > 100% checklist
quaint temple
Fun Fact: only 4 characters did NOT get recast in RDR2
John, Dutch, Bill, and Agent Ross
Uncle’s the one with the most actors; 3
He was played by Robert Madison in RDR1, then John O’Creigh got cast for RDR2, he died during filming so James McBride was cast to play Uncle
But John’s performance remains in the game, as it’s his voice when Uncle sings
normal relic
Cool
quaint temple
And theres only 2 characters to appear in 1899, 1907, 1911, and 1914
Jack and Ross
normal relic
Yea ross is in rdr1
quaint temple
Imagine everyone in 1899 finding out Uncle and his Lumbago outlive almost everyone
normal relic
I think he outlived most of the gang
quaint temple
Its easier to count who he did NOT outlive
John, Abigail, Jack, Trelawny, Swanson, Pearson, Charles, Sadie, Tilly, Mary-Beth
Uncle manages to outlive Davey, Mac, Jenny, Sean, Kieran, Lenny, Hosea, Susan, Strauss, Karen, Micah, Javier, Bill, and Dutch
And Arthur
normal relic
Yea
quaint temple
Lumbago is a real thing
Uncle actually has it
Its where the lower spine stiffens up, limiting mobility
I wonder, how did he get the name Uncle?
Is Uncle somebody’s Uncle?
normal relic
Idk
quaint temple
Uncle is only 50 in 1899
normal relic
Could just be a nickname the gang gave him
normal relic
I think so
quaint temple
The Van Der Linde gang has a whole love dodecahedron
John and Abigail are married
Abigail has dated Bill and Javier, its implied shes had relations with Arthur and Dutch as well
Dutch has dated Molly, Anabelle, and Susan
grand sedge
Is Uncle somebody’s Uncle?
it’s a nickname
quaint temple
Tilly can confess to Arthur that she loves Javier
Arthur and Tilly as well as Arthur and Mary-Beth are common ships
Micah seems to simp for Abigail
normal relic
I guess idk
normal relic
Kieran wasn't with anyone
quaint temple
Yes
grand sedge
Molly was so bad 😝😝😝
quaint temple
At Sean’s party its outright said Karen and Sean are dating
grand sedge
💀
normal relic
Karen was always drunk
quaint temple
Arthur even tells Karen “Look after your boy tonight”
And you see Sean and Karen being affectionate
normal relic
I didn't like Karen
quaint temple
Same
normal relic
She's was always drunk
grand sedge
that’s because Sean is a proper Scouser can’t deny it
quaint temple
Susan going after innocent Tilly and Mary-Beth when she should be whipping Karen and Molly into shape
quaint temple
That being said, Susan is a lion
She is the mother lion
Arthur and Susan rescuing Tilly
normal relic
She was annoying
quaint temple
Susan siding with Arthur
Susan may be annoying
And a bitch
But she is the mother lion
normal relic
She drove me nuts every time i got back to camp
quaint temple
That being said, the Tilly rescue mission and Arthur’s final mission are Susan’s best appearances
“She’s mine!” “She told me in confidence”
Susan seems to care
Never knew an emotionless bitch could have a heart
normal relic
Yea
quaint temple
The way Susan just shoots Molly
grand sedge
i think you’re overlooking the characters
quaint temple
She didnt whip Molly into shape
normal relic
I hated that
normal relic
Molly didn't do anything
normal relic
Molly was better then karen
normal relic
Molly was with Dutch I thought
quaint temple
Yes
And she uses that as an excuse to be useless
I wish we got A Quiet Time 2, where Arthur, Lenny, Pearson, Swanson, Sean, and Karen just drink together
normal relic
I thought karen was gonna die before the gang moved camps
quaint temple
I think once Arthur even says that Pearson, Sean, and Swanson are drinking buddies
In Chapter 1 i loved Dutch and thought Sadie would be dead weight we kill in Chapter 2
By Chapter 6, I wanted to empty my Varmint Rifle into Dutch and Sadie was in my top 5
quaint temple
Dutch says Plan more than Jesse says Bitch
loud rampart
this sounds stupid but while i was trying to get the wood for the father in the timber company i accidentally ran over one of the workers with my horse, now i cant even greet the foreman, is it possible to get the wood now?
should i just rob the wood
real yacht
maybe leave the area then come back later and see if it reset
i never had that problem so idk
loud rampart
nah he hates me now
real yacht
loud rampart
in my defence the guy didnt move
if i get the wood ill get honor right? but if i rob ill just lose honor so is there any point?
hidden moss
guys im tryna do the caught a fish without fishing rod when i shot them it dosent count and i ant pick the fish up???
loud rampart
maybe its too deep in the water?
real yacht
are u doing the challenge?
normal relic
The fish challenge
rustic bridge
Hello fellow cowboys
real yacht
go to hani's bethel north of emerald ranch, the water there is real shallow, just ride ur horse around and u got urself some dead fishes
rustic bridge
I'm glad I got to okay rdr again💀
ps plus extra saved my ass
my shitty disc broke on me while I was on a misson
rustic bridge
fr
normal relic
My rdr1 is on disc
normal relic
Weird
rustic bridge
And sends me an error
normal relic
That's odd
normal relic
Never had that happen
normal relic
No never got it
normal relic
Ik i still enjoy rdr2
I'm trying to figure out the challenges and other stuff for 100%
grand sedge
Sharpshooter challenge 7 is a bitch to complete
real yacht
Whats sharpshooter 7 i forgor
grand sedge
Disarm three enemies without reloading or switching weapons
rustic bridge
it's easy.
formal hare
hey
austere citrus
Hi
real yacht
Disarm three enemies without reloading or switching weapons
use a bow with poison arrow, go to a gang hideout (or kerosene and tar in ur not in the epilogue), shoot at their legs
quaint temple
use a bow with poison arrow, go to a gang hideout (or kerosene and tar in ur not...
I used a poisoned knife and threw it at their feet
real yacht
i never tried it but that could work too, i just find arrows to be more accurate with longer range
formal hare
is there any way to fix the saint denis gunsmith and doctor to stop always being shut
this has never happened before
quaint temple
know which death was the saddest? Kieran
he never got the redemption he deserved
Dutch didnt even let him ride with them to attack the Braithwate's
wouldve been 100X better if Kieran and Sadie went too
formal hare
this has never happened before
nvm fixed i just had to basically beat the guy into opening up
formal hare
he never got the redemption he deserved
ikr its sad i just went through that mission again
also what happened to him too
quaint temple
the Odriscolls found out he betrayed them, so they kidnapped him, gauged his eyes out, tortured him, beheaded him, tied him to his horse, and had his horse bring his headless body to Shady Belle
quaint temple
my personal theory is that Colm himself did it to Kieran
real yacht
i wouldnt put that past him, yea
quaint temple
i hate how we dont get to kill Milton or Colm ourselves
we get the chance to avenge our fallen friends but Abigail just kills Milton
real yacht
watching colm shit his pants when he was about to swing was a treat tho
quaint temple
yeah
wouldve preferred if at the last minute Arthur shot Colm in the nuts
Colm did that to Kieran
real yacht
ngl colms death was one of my favorite moments in the game, the motion capture and the acting was soooo well done
real yacht
yea 
quaint temple
they both twitch and moan for about a minute after being shot
at least Lenny did get to die with Arthur by his side
real yacht
at least theyre resting together
quaint temple
someone on YT said that everyone has a different recation to Lenny's death
real yacht
lenny and hosea were very close, like mentor and pupil
quaint temple
that Arthur is pissed that Lenny was killed
Charles tried to give Lenny the best he could in the time he had
real yacht
i mean yea u can see it on the screen
quaint temple
Bill was still traumatized by Hosea's death so he couldn't process Lenny's death
Javier and Dutch cared about Lenny but their goal was ensuring the remaining 6 escaped alive
quaint temple
we have to share that kill with Dutch
thats the worst part
John cant even avenge Davey, Jenny, Mac, Susan, and Arthur
he gets sloppy seconds
real yacht
idk why but the whole game being so serious and realistic and then micah's death is like?? so goofy
quaint temple
wouldve been better if Dutch just said "kill him" and walked away as John shoots Micah to death
keen birchBOT
Read if Arthur < Micah.
quaint temple
idk why but the whole game being so serious and realistic and then micah's death...
YES
Dutch shoots him
Micah seems fine
John empties 6-12 rounds into Micah
and he just... walks and then falls
I get he's the final boss
real yacht
he ate all my bullets and just waddle for 2 steps and plop on the ground lmao
quaint temple
like Gus' death\
real yacht
idk who that is
quaint temple
half his face blown off, walks out of the explosion, fixes his tie, and drops dead
Gus from the Breaking Bad Universe
real yacht
oh i think ive seen that scene from memes tho
yea its goofy as hell
at least gus looks cool doing it
quaint temple
Fun Fact: Micah and John's American Venom outfits are the same outfits they wore in Colter
and John's American Venom outfit is just a buttoned up version of his back coat over his RDR1 outfit
real yacht
I still need to play rdr1 but i dont have a console 
hidden moss
do i loose all my money if i go into the ebeerden pig house
quaint temple
do i loose all my money if i go into the ebeerden pig house
yes and no
quaint temple
if you have over 20 mil, itll only take 20 mil
real yacht
U’llget it back
quaint temple
its the only way to give Arthur's money to John
hidden moss
U’llget it back
how?
quaint temple
go back to the house as John, Arthur's money will be behind the painting
real yacht
how?
They gonna rob u, so just rob them back, they stash ur money somewhere in the house
real yacht
Let them play how they want
quaint temple
once you get a gun as John in Chapter 7 or manage to get Arthur's guns back, then you go back for the money
or else John will be dirt poor until you finish Chapter 8
hidden moss
so i go there and i get killed lose all my money go back kill them and get money behind a painting?
real yacht
John being dirt poor is more immersive
real yacht
so i go there and i get killed lose all my money go back kill them and get money...
Basically yea, u dont get killed just passed out
real yacht
When u pass out, the people in the house will say something to each other and thats ur hint
Idk how much u wanna find it out for urself vs having someone saying it out right
real yacht
Yes
hidden moss
100%
real yacht
Yes
hidden moss
ok but what town is it near
real yacht
the pig farm?
hidden moss
theres many pig farms
real yacht
its in lemoyne near bluewater marsh
like the edge of lemoyne if u look at the state lines on the map
gleaming dagger
guys i need some help , i think i bricked my red dead 2 (pc)
hidden moss
is lemonye by annesbrug
real yacht
i'll send a picture
hidden moss
ok
real yacht
sent in #red-dead-media
real yacht
have a hog-killing time 
hidden moss
have a hog-killing time <:cowboy_cool:888462778329862214>
they gave ma another drink should i drink it or leae?
real yacht
drink it for funsie
hidden moss
okay
real yacht
u aint gonna die if u worry about that
hidden moss
got my mnoney back an set the place on fire
hidden moss
u aint gonna die if u worry about that
yk where the ghost ppl is?
real yacht
ghost people?
theres a ghost in the bayou but idk if thats what ur looking for
havent encountered it myself tho
hidden moss
the night ppl in some swamp
real yacht
oh night folks?
hidden moss
yeah
real yacht
theyre random encounters
hidden moss
oh
real yacht
ride around in the swamp at night and u'll get one eventually
u can encounter them daytime too, just look for hanging bodies
hidden moss
can i do it at any swamp?
real yacht
theyre in the bayou nwa area
hidden moss
okay
Hey I need a very quick way to up my money and honor. I want get some outfit pieces and guns, etc. but some of them are honor locked so I came to ask a quick way to get it up.
real yacht
go greet the entire population of saint denis
u get an honor boost for every 3 people u greeted
including dogs and cats
hidden moss
go greet the entire population of saint denis
It takes too long, I mean sure it’s a good way too but I can’t sit there for 1 day just greeting to get an outfit.
real yacht
its the fastest way to up ur honor as far as i know
hidden moss
its the fastest way to up ur honor as far as i know <:Anon:795145103291318323>
Are you sure?
real yacht
as far as i know, and it seems fast to me
u go up an honor rank for every 40 honor points
hidden moss
as far as i know, and it seems fast to me
i cant find anything like that
real yacht
wdym
opaque pecan
Oh no
real yacht
theres no alligators in the swamp?
opaque pecan
I broke uncle
opaque pecan
I threw a stick of dynamite at uncle and now he cant get back in his horse
real yacht
night folks are random so maybe come back there next time
opaque pecan
So hes walking to beechers
real yacht
ur making his lumbago worse!! ):
hidden moss
will it work if i put up a camp andf sleep?
real yacht
yea
hidden moss
there was a woman talking
but when i wnet to her she disapeared
i couldnt sere her
real yacht
that might be the swamp ghost
naive shard