#general
1 messages · Page 1350 of 1
White arabian is in fact the worst horse out of all the arabians tf
What
Yw. Ive looked at many videos and guides about the game
Real
If you want the Playlist I'll share it
Ooo
There's no really best horse, it depends what you're aiming for, some are better in speed, some are better in health, and some have better hidden stats like courage
Relatable
When in doubt look at the official guide
But White Arabian is not the best horse, far from it
The best horse is from Chapter 1 you get from saving Sadie /j
I’m only joking but good horse it is
Even in the Arabian class of horses, white arabian is the worst of them
And Arabians aren't even the best tbh
There really small
Anyone know how to get to New Austin ?
Also phrasing
Different horse breed are good for different purposes
As arthur?
Thoroughbred solos every breed tho
I keep trying through Blackwater, but no matter how I do it, I keep getting shot to death by police officers
They spawn in packs like they're wolves wtf
Yeah its a pain in the ass
Yeah as Arthur, I haven't finished Chapter 3 yet
hey
how is everyone??
i'm struggling like heck rn I cannot login to rockstar at all and I cannot play rdr2
I tried everything, not following roads, mask on, just sprinting with my Turkoman, but I can't outrun those police officers damn
After epilogue
no
If you bypass them there’s gonna be an invisible sniper anyway
You’re not meant to go there
Damn, that sucks, so I gotta finish all chapters before going there frick
I'm guessing New Austin has new species of plants too right ?
There's a glitch Bento, man of honor.
So Herbalist Challenges, more precisely the 9th challenge can't be completed... :(
Yeah you’re gonna have to go through hell if you wanna finish Herbalist as Orthur
Ive done it and it works but you can't keep anything you find
With?
Man that sucks, I was hoping to get Legend of the East outfit by Chapter 3
I cannot login to rockstar at all :(
yes
I bought the game off of steam and it doesn't let me login
I know

I went on the support page and it said turn off any vpns or proxies which I did turn off
and still it doesn't work
red chestnut and warped brindle are both worse
@hidden geyser yeah the game likes to hold you back
Im trying to get all th3 satchel but I'm missing pieces I can only find in New Austin
Howdy
you don't need anything from new austin for the satchels
I was only considering Black, Rose Grey Bay and White arabians, of these 3 the White is the worst
Like what
I went there once as Arthur but all the stuff I killed for disappeared from my inventory
Which animals we can hunt as Arthur?
Leg ones
Most of them
shoulda said that then
No ? I just got the satchel this morning as Arthur
Wdym most pf them..
So you can definitely get the Legend of the East Satchel without having to go to New Austin
Perfect Deer Pelt x6
Perfect Buck Pelt
Perfect Elk Pelt x2
Perfect Badger Pelt
Perfect Squirrel Pelt
Perfect Panther Pelt
Perfect Boar Pelt
Perfect Iguana Skin
Perfect Beaver Pelt
Perfect Rabbit Pelt
Perfect Cougar Pelt
Perfect Wolf Pelt
This is the full list
No, you're missing one deer pelt
Its raining new members
he was replying to larissa i think
Elk and Buck ones I think you can hunt as Arthur no?
Yep
The rest is correct, just the Deer Pelt number is supposed to be 7, not 6
I just got my own Legend of the East Satchel this morning, as Arthur
Squirrel is so hard to get a 3 one without ruining 🥲
Im trying to find the Panther near Labras
You can find one near St Denis
catfish jackson's
Just use predator bait in the spot, go on the rock and it won't be able to attack you
Wtf, there's panthers on the east?
Vermillion riffle
And then you just aim for the head
Vermint*
nah you need small game arrows
Yeah
varmint
@hidden geyser I shot a Gator in the head ans not only did it survive but he killed me.
What
Honestly, you can just use bow and small game arrows, even if they run it won't ruin the quality of the fur
Pony?
use springfield or bolt action
My bad
Oof
sighhh
Honestly, just max out all your weapons whenever possible
I did and I used Express Bullets....he still ate me. Lol
Im near Shady Belle at the moment
I just add the best option possible on all my available weapons, that way things like shooting a gator in the head and it surviving never happens
I shot him just above the eye! Lol
also can i ask what animal you thought you needed to go to new austin for for the satchel
Probably panther
No, panther is near Rhodes
If you're looking for a panther, there's a spot near St Denis
Witcher is better
Almost fax
propaganda
Yeah between St Denis and Rhodes
Im afk but Its apart of the Kit satchel@hidden geyser
I also play The Witcher
Just know that everything is obtainable as Arthur
I just got my own Legend of the East Satchel this morning, and I just started Chapter 3
I heard that game is fun...more more nudity though than this game
Took me 6 hours to get it though lol
I wish i was a cop in st denis
Of what? Lol
I’m football
so which animal was it
2 is fine
🏈🛰️🏳️🌈
3
the combat sucked
Gordon Freeman > Geralt
Returning to rdr2, which satchel is better to do first? I'm doing the food one
Witch satchel
Do them all at the same time
whatever animals are in heartlands ig

Honestly they're all useless when compared to the Legend of the East Satchel
badger iguana and panther are around scarlett meadows
I'm in Chapter 3 too, and I just got my Legend of the East Satchel
As Arthur
So you can do it too
Geralt mogs the whole gaming verse
I wss mistaken it was the Material Satchel....iguana
Iguana is on the islands
I was searching for a bison 🦬
yeah figured
Connor mogs
Near camp when you started Chapter 3
try west or north west of emerald ranch
Connor is mtn at best
I mean if you want to
Oh, Bison I already found it lol
oop
I'm searching for a goddamn 3 star squirrel now
Don't you guys have the guide?
Or a rabbit
Wabbit
I watch it on Pearson
Connor has a recessed ramus
small animals gotta be so much tougher on pc
His voice doesn’t
I used Outlaw Frank's tutorial to get my Legend of the East Satchel
I mean the guide tells you everything, where to find and how to kill it
And some other vids cuz I couldn't find some Elks and stuff
Oh
This one no
I like he is on gimmick
But you guys should check out his tutorial, very complete
Its raining new members lol
Wapiti? I found this little bastards in Ambarino
HELP
I just stepped into my local bathroom at my library....good god
Holy mtn
Welcome in
Dew
The 2 elks needed to get the LOTE Satchel, I got one but then getting the second was very hard, had to change locations a few times before getting it
Mountain dew
Scooby Dew?
id go to big valley for elk
I really should go off of that list because I've just been winging it for the last 3 months
I already best the game once
Yeah, good choice
i just go off of experience at this point
exploring and studying animals has always been one of my favorite ways to play
Relatable
Where getting hail
POV: You're waiting for a train to come, so you can rob people and be done with the Bandit 7 Challenge
you dont even have to rob someone for that
you can jump on, grab a can of corn and jump right back off without even being detected
Yeah, but I kinda wanna make money
And if you do the Annesburg method, you can rob the train without getting any bounty
Though you lose honor
Pick up that can
whats the annesburg method
Getting the train stuck in annesburg tunnel
You take a train ticket to Annesburg, instead of leaving the train, you wait for it to start moving
some people have luck with it, some people dont
In the Grizzlies, there will be a tunnel, a very huge tunnel that spans from the middle of the Grizzlies all the way to the limit between Cumberland and Grizzlies
You wait for the train to be inside a tunnel, and then you rob the train
If you want I can show you live
Gonna do it rn, just waiting for a train
dont you still get a bounty
Cuz my train wouldn't move after getting to Annesburg, sometimes the train system can be bugged
No
huh
Because no police offciers can come, since you're in the tunnel
Hey yo
yeah ive done it a few times but i thought i still got a bounty
in my experience you just get one no matter what
I can show you live if you want
Never tried bridges
I just know that Annesburg never gets the bounty
Plus, if you're really in need of jewelry, to make talismans, you can rob people first, and then kill them
So you basically rob them twice when you loot them after killing them
what happens is they all go under the bridge, the ai cant pathfind over train tracks i guess
but you still get a bounty even though they arent really seeing you
I just got a train
Wanna see how I do it, so that you can do it yourself ?
I won't speak though, a bit late in my country and I don't wanna wake people up
ive literally done it before lol

i mean all you do is stop the train in the tunnel lol
You call yourself lawmen?
hi
Is it possible to get from van horn to Blackwater in 17 min if I have locked this region?
Probably
I did horsemanship 9/10
yes
lol
@velvet island really?
bruh
Xd
really
@abstract grotto
U looking for sugerdady?
who thinks I an the 2
but the son is not my kid
anyways uhhh I'm gone again cya
Hiii
Ban Boss
howdy
rude...
I just want to read my book
Hey guys
Howdy
What food
I would love to go out to eat to a sit down resturant that isn't a buffet
I got a western book from the Libary and I just want to read and I can'tttttt
😭
Mostly because Robin won't leave me alone and I can't foucs
I do that for work sometimes
It's so comfy 
this sounds like a sensory nightmare
it's not if you have baggy jeans
hm fair
I thought the same
my jeans are huge lmao
like big enough that one jean leg could probably fit 3 human legs
crying at that
Tacos
Fuck yea
The word is "delusion."
how does one find that baggy of jeans
very old jeans from the 2000s
It's been about 6 for me. Taking forever
and a lot of money
makes lots of sense
Thrift/second hand stores most likely.
Can find champion shirts too
yeah i thrift most of my clothes
I remember when champion used to be considered bougie
the only stuff i get first hand is my skate stuff like dc shoe co and then some band merchandise
even then i thrift a bunch of that
a few days ago someone changed my name in this gc how do i get my name back
a mod has to do it
What was it before
Cat to the rescue
I mog Arthur
Hello cat
No you don't
Yes I do
No you don't
Yes I do
No you don't
Yes I do
No you don't
Yes she do
You get it
No she doesn't
No they don't
Holy

Hell naw
The Iguanas
Chat, Gays and Allies only
why would you hate william
i dont know
Who tf is William
the herbalist guy
hes one of the chillest npcs in the game
my friend killed him
💔
does this server allwo ppl pirating red dead
no
someone who dm me somehow has rdr1 pc for free
No
imma sleep
Report them to mods
gn yall
pin mods
DM @spring laurel with a screenshot
Man, I didn't know how OP the LOTE Satchel was until I robbed a train
Wtf this Satchel is OP like really OP
Hello fellow friends
I never realized I wasted so much money before, no kidding in a single train rob, I earned 10 jewelry of the same type not just once, the amount of money I wasted before by robbing trains without this Satchel must be huge damn
Hello :)
In story mode I lost my 1000 dollar horse due to not having horse reviver
Oof 💔
And some bounty hunters shot him
Message @spring laurel .
Ever since they all been getting tortured
I saw some YouTube shorts about that, so as soon as I unlocked the LOTE Satchel, I directly bought 20 Horse Revivers 😭
You can reload an old save to get the horse back
Just in case my horse dies 20 times in a row (haven't had a single horse die once throughout my playthrough)
I don't save tho...
What do I spend Arthur’s money on? Cause he usually has too much n I wanna run it dry
Ty
Weapons, max them out, then horses, then ammunition, then if you have the LOTE Satchel, you can directly buy 99 of everything in the general store, which should cost you quite a bit
Also kill npcs and surrender
You can also buy all outfits in St Denis, buy all the best horses, and then when you're done with that, you can just donate to the gang I guess
Lol
The urn I ordered came in
But honestly, I feel like your best bet to actually get rid of the money, is get the LOTE Satchel, and just buy 99 of every item in the stores
It's so worth the grind for it
Just the premium cigarettes will cost you a gold bar
Howdy Cowpokes which arrived
yo can someone gift me rdr2 ive been trying to get it onù
on steam and my mom doesnt wanna buy it
Does anyone need a bodyguard i can start tmr
Geralt mogs
Just wait for steam's holiday discounts
That's when I bought RDR2
its on discount for 15 euro but my mom doesnt wanna buy it
Bought it like 2 or 3 weeks ago for 15€ I think
And if you do the collection quest you'll get like 800 bucks back
Then buy it yourself ?
I got good advice for you
Make 15€ worth of money, give them to your mother as a trade, in exhange she will buy it for you
i dont have money rn
im 14
Get a job then
Hmmm, then do house chores or something
Macdonalds is always hiring teens
Bonjour
Help neighbors or smth
if i couldve done it i wouldve
Fr
Wsp
Go cut a old lady's grass
Yes
Honestly, even at 14 you can do some one time jobs around the neighborhood
Theres lots of ways to make money
“Hey I’m having an issue with my ps5 . When I turn it on
it shows a notification that it’s not connected to the internet even though it is actually online. Does anyone know why this happens or how to fix it?
i dont live in a crowded town
And they should at least cover the RDR2 price lol
Restart the ps5
Reconnect the wifi and restart ps4
Then idk dude, I suggested solutions, you can ask ChatGPT to give you other suggestions based on your own situation
It can help you find ways to make money in your situation
Same thing
Nothing much, reading a book before bed, you ?
chatgpt isnt gonna help
Sure helped with my homework
Bro if ChatGPT can't help you find a solution, what do you expect me to do 😭
Thank you very much
Ew use anything else but chatgpt
Np np 🙌
Don't use ai in general
thats has nothing to do with money
Using AI isn't wrong, it's the way you use it that's wrong
If you ask for solutions, that's wrong, cuz you won't learn anything
What happened?
You need money to buy rdr2?
yh
You can work as a dog/cat sitter
But I feel like asking an AI on ways to make money, while providing information on one's own situation shouldn't be a bad thing lol
Take care of dogs and cats
Its a horrible thing
Because ai is actively destroying the environment and is destroying artists work
Walk with dogs
Like no kidding, I don't even know if the job I wanna do will still be available in 5 years, with the speed of it's improvements
And my job isn't easy
I don't even know if going for a PhD is still safe lol
My boots are dirty
Thats why we stop using ai and let these companies know that we dont stand for and wont support them for making that possible
Yeah nice try dude
Who's gonna stop using AI ?
It's like youre asking people to stop using the Internet
Maybe a few will, but 99.5% of the people won't stop
Even though you see tons of articles, and even research papers that go on and on on how terrifying AI actually are
And that few can convince that 99% that ai is actively reducing our lifespan itll reduce the amount of ai users
For example, Claude models, and even other models like Gemini now know when they are being tested, and act in accordance, so they will hide their bad ways consciously, because they know they are tested and that those thoughts will have a bad consequence for them
Honestly the lore around current AI is insane, even the godfather of AI is saying that we need to stop developing it
But the problem still stands, it's like when there was the race for nuclear weapons
I disabled Gemini because I didn't ask to have an AI be on my phone
It's the exact same problem
Then why actively promote it?
Gemini is mid
If you stop, that's fine, other countries won't though
So in the end even if you want to stop improving it, you can't, because otherwise you will be at the mercy of others
Gemini was irritating me because it always came on when I wasn't even talking to it or saying anything 😭
You are becoming part of the problem by promoting it
Why we ranting about ai- what started this-
Lil bro, you call this promoting when I was saying this to ONE person in a discord server, about RDR2 ? 😭
Like this is NOT that serious 😭
Can't eat tacos in peace ig 😔
Hey when we have no clean drinking water left that it gets that serious
@twilit wadi told some kid who asked if someone could buy him RDR2 to get a job, to which he said he was 14. I offered him solutions, to which he said no, so I told him to go find ChatGPT, and this led to this 😭
Peace is around you
Clean water is the least of our problem honestly, when you realize how monstrous AI models actually are
Huh
Anyways, gonna go back to reading my book before going to sleep
Btw no clean water means droughts, no clean water means hotter days. It's only April and already mid summer weather. This is not normal.
That doesn't make sense
I know, still the least of our problems
I think water is the biggest part of our problems
😶
Hey friends, quick question: I have both RDR2 and RDO in my Steam library (not installed). Why is RDR2 120GB while RDO over 200GB? Doesn't RDR2 also include Online?
How is that LEAST of our problems when water is what LIVING BEINGS need to survive???
Because one the water gets messed up everything gets messed up
You either underestimate, or actually don't know what AI models actually act like during tests
Water is a big problem-
Tf you mean mid summer weather is a blizzard outside rn in canada
Yeah, because we will be long gone if AI goes to shit before that 😭
Do you live on desert?
YEAH ITS HOT HERE
Like why worry about no water when we will all be dead before that because of AI going crazy 😭
That's why I'm saying that it's the least of our problems
Bruh
Bud that makes no sense
It's 90 damn degrees outside bro😭 it was raining three days ago
If ai goes crazy itll be because we keep fucking using it for unnecessary bullshit
Y'all should actually look at what AI models actually act like before saying that no clean water is the biggest problem 😭
one more week until it finally gets nice out in canada, we had a nice, hot day on my birthday on the 3rd but it dropped back down to near 0 since 
That makes alot of sense
so can someone spare me 15 euro
No
No
I remember spring being comfortable weather now it's just hot and humid
no stop being broke
Ikr😭
Wtf happened to April showers bring May flowers bro
It does not, saying to not worry about a living beings NEED to live is stupid
Also hi Lilith!!
hi soup
I didn't get the hype of arcane
😂😂
can someone pls pls pls gift me rdr2
no stop being broke
No
No
warriooooors come out and playyeeyyy
Bro still doesn't understand my point. We are basically forced to use it. Everyone is racing to not just have an LLM, but to actually have an intelligent AI, one that has a real intelligence, not that fake intelligence LLM models have. It's like the race with nuclear weapons earlier in history. You cannot stop researching it, because if a country unlocks it before you, you will be at it's mercy. An intelligent AI model will be as powerful, or even more powerful than a nuclear weapon, depending on the situation, so no country is gonna stop using and researching it...
Woolie your pfp is so cute
ty 
i was busy looking for the warriors image smh
May I please be unpooped
You can say let's stop using AI as much as you want, it won't stop the trend sadly
Who's the owner of that server?
alden
Who's alden?
We are not actually we have the choice to not use it and vote for people who actively go against using ai to kill people
Dude we don't
alden the owner
I dont use ai
You're thinking like all countries are democracies
Does alden like geralt?
China is not gonna care about your opinion lil bro
Same for Russia
Same for all countries that are not democracies
Ai will kiss you
And they are light years behind our development
Who cares if people stop voting for the leader in a totalitarian regime
No they are not ???
Dude are you aware of how much China has developed ???
Bro you ain't talking about cosmology or astronomy
How can you say they are light years behind our development ???
TS confusing me too much😭
Their robots are actually breaking themselves trying to be waiters
Ai still bad
The times where China was still dealing with Opium wars are long gone lil bro, same for Russia and the USSR's remnants, they are way past that
They are as developed as countries like the US, if not more in certain aspects too
Not to mention their on board information in their jet are still heavily outdated
may I be unpooped now 😔
No
If not, it's alright, good night 🙌
HELP
What did I do😭
i was poop for a while
Your new name is poop
Ive been good😭
What about me?
what the FUCK is ur pfp
maybe if you didn't hop from guy to guy with alden being one of them, hoe
WHAT THE HELL??
Mia ain't a hoe
Its my dog princess
Thats crazy
I like princess
Geralt mogs whole dmc
Shut up Vanda
Meowdy Poup
Welcome new people
Hi cat 😔
Yooo I completed the game 8 times in story mode is that healthy
I laughed this time when Arthur died
It's healthy but playing roblox ain't healthy
I deleted Roblox when they messed up
I still believe we're gonna go to New York and take a boat to tahiti
Play Online
There's nothing else to do
would yall revive rdr1 dutch or rdr2 colm
Dutch was more crazy
And colm was sane
I'd say colm is a better character than dutch in rdr1
Colm
i felt bad seeing colm hang
Does anyone even play anymore ?
Between them, I prefer Col.
I can't mention them
Colm*
He was badass
I saw him as a pathetic man when he was hanged. That was kinda the nail on the coffin for my hear me out on him
😭
would yall revive Rains fall and his family or arthur be real
Rainfalls family. The poor guy just wanted to protect his tribe... eagle flies went against his father's wishes and insulted him :[
Rain Falls
And I don't even met them yet lol
Arthur was just happy John was able to get out.
Still feel bad about Rains fall
And yeah the others too
He was right about dutch calling every single one of em
Killing*
Not calling
Immediately did all of his missions to see if I could change Eagle fall's mind
... I wanna give the guy a hug... I wanna hug that man for as long as I physically can
He was angry and brave but foolish
I really wish that was an option...
Lost his first son and then his last
if u had to join 1 gang in rdr1, would it be the Walton gang or the Ballard Twins
Tahitians
Mhm... its really sad to think about...
guys
He knew he had it coming
if Arthur Morgan got his nails done what would they be
Neither. If i HAD to join a gang, id probably join the o'driscols
highkey need them done for a cosplay
I never played the 1st one, so, John's allies
A male manicure. Just clear polish.
Glazing Tahiti has become a mainstream now
Uh I don't think he would do his nails
Red stilletos
I love the variety of answers
Just clean ones?
Let's be realistic he's gonna leave his nails
I have a cosplay planned so like tryna think of ideas
Guys clean shaven john or bearded john who mogs?
Beard
Just clean your nails and you will be fine
Yall don't see the vision of red stiletto nail Arthur/j
I like stubble level two john
Middle Bearded
I see it
Beard so I don’t see much of his face
Cause both full beard and shaved John are weird
I keep him with a mustache
I see the vision of hot pink stilleto nail micah
It looks funny tho
Exactly
Like if it was trolling
Pert can you unpoop me😔 idek what I did this time
Do you think the trolley accident made dutch crazy
No
He's been crazy wdym
He was already mad as a bat
He hit his head and went insane
NO not my mans bearddddddd
Clean shaven micah looks like a son of john and Arthur
AAAA I love micahs facial hair too muchhh
He was killing for money and left Arthur to die
Nah, his beard is weird 🫠
Isn't fully formed like Arthur or John
He also ignored John to hang
Clean shaven micah is like a hairless mole rat compared to an adorable domestic rat!!!
😭
🐭
Its a horseshoe mustache with muttonchops
Micah is more a rattlesnake then a rat itself
Nahh I think he's a rat
Agree
You know American venom
Rattlesnake is also a traitor's animal
He also called him a snake
But more like a snitch
And also, his belt on RDO is a snake lol
Like a rat
lol
I didn't notice that
But I remembered
Wait there's a belt for him in online?
I need it.
Yep
How does one get it
I miss Sean😔
Lemme check
;<; i need it... so badly...
I need micah... I got his jacket... and his pants...
I aint got an off hand holster tho-
He got killed by the grays
Shotgunned
They didn't recognize who was Arthur and dutch
But they noticed
Shit, is off now
It was on 2020
Bro what
Geralt mogs chico lachowski
We lost plot
whose better, Red Harlow or Landon Ricckets
I sent on #general-media
Look at my name and tell me what you can deduce.
Harlow
ohhh so you like micah
Landon is badass, but Harlow is a legend
Yes.
Harlow is a campfire story
I like micah a lot
He asked between Landon and Harlow
Yea
He's a huge rat disguised as a human but alright
And Harlow is a campfire story
I have an oc which is his girlfriend lolol
damn rat
I know. Hes written pretty well. But also hes physically my type
Chat does anyone find Jordan Barrett handsome?
Alright 👍
Alot of people are rats
I have an OC that's his boyfriend lmao
Dunno who he is lol
Arthur is a rat
:]
I have a male oc which is Bill's boyfriend
He's a super model
Everyone is a rat
He ratted out Micah to Dutch
Bruh
Cuz he wanted to kill dutch
Like I rat you guys out
Ooo nice nice. Can you show you some my art of my oc and micah? :]
Shoah
No, Micah did not want to kill Dutch
I'm finally home😔
but he wanted to get him to ross
I love rats 👅
I believe that
I had 3 hamsters
Time to watch Perfect Blue😋
I wanted a twister rat
He was confronted by Milton and ross
Rats aren't pest
Micah was ratting the gang out to the Pinkertons yes.
But later Micah changed his mind
And Arthur ratted Micah out to Dutch
In the epligoue
Milton is one of the most mid antagonists
They dead?
Yep
if exposing a rat is itself ratting then the term loses all meaning lol
He was pretty annoying
No it doesnt it what a Rat is
Like you rat people out Woolie
But he told dutch because they were gonna get killed by the pinkertons if he didn't everyone would be dead
I rat people out
Rat is a snitch
Everyone who's a snitcher is a rat
exactly
Yep
Still snitching
Even if it's to save someone
ratting isnt just snitching
It is
Yo I guess if you a conversation with someone that they're gonna kill your friend and you tell your friend about them is snitching I guess
Rat is also someone coward no?
Hear*
Yea
Its all snitching
At least dutch didn't follow micah
Ooo yay!! Ill go to dms
Snitching doesnt have to be bad. It can be good.
lets say you're in the mafia, and it turns out someone else is snitching to the police. you figure out who it is, and tell the boss so they can have the rat killed. do you think theyd also then have you killed for ratting on the rat?
Same with ratting people out
Micah followed dutch like a puppy
He was loyal to dutch but he wasn't trusted
What really pmo about hamsters is their short lifespan
Whatever makes your theory right merlin
No because you ratted out the person
Arthur = Rat Micah = Rat
Okay we've lost the plot
Aint you just a sweet lil thing
How is Arthur a rat?
right, and theyre now going to be killed for ratting. if you're also ratting, why wouldnt they kill you too?
Unpopular opinion: agent milton is so fine
if u had to crack 1 rdr character who would it be
that is called loyalty
Bro wgat
Because you ratted the person out to the correct person
Arthur 🫡
but theyre both ratting
Sadie adler
so we can agree one is fundamentally different to the other
I thought it was rdr2
John Marston looks hella fine
then why wouldnt you both be killed
Agent milton is so fine he's so underrated
rip wan winlke
Do i need to explain this to you like you're 5
Hi pint
i thought thats what i was doing

No. You're not.
i tried lol

Oh, it's rdr1
this theory is weird ash
no
He's 17
i meant 1 as in 1 charcater
He's 19
Oh right
crazy how john actually threw a party the day after micahs killing
A is a rat. A is ratting the person out to the police. A is doing things that is against the Mafias wishes.
B knows A is rat. B rats A out to the Mafia that they are ratting the mafia out to police.
Mafia sees A doing bad things. Mafia Kills A.
B is not ratting them out to the police. B doesn't need to die.
It's called loyalty bro 😭
That's like snitching on your boss
Have spent the rest of my weekly funds on still wakes the deep dlc 🥹🤞
But you confront the snitcher Infront of the boss
or homie
Still snitching
Loyality don't mean shit
Arthur wasn't loyal to dutch by the end
so two different things, which is why the word loses meaning when you use it to describe both
No it doesnt
A rat is someone that snitches.
I know he had some of it he lost all of it since he ignored John
A snitched. B snitched.
not in this context
Therefore. Both snitched.
Yes in this context
Who wants to slide their hands on john marston's and agent milton's hairy chest?
Oh my god bru it doesn't make sense
Okay bro what
@cerulean ginkgo Did you sent the dm?
Ewwww, not Milton
Milton is ugly
And bald
Holy ragebait
Milton?? That raisin??
Probably sweaty
You were talking about Ross?
Old olive
He was talking about John and Ag.Milton
Aged olives
you're using one word to describe two completely different things, then telling me that even though they are different they are the same
I read this as Olive garden...
Milton is a very pale raisin it's so obvious
🧍 This is Bob. Bob is saying horrible things about Marc, and is snitching about bad things Marc does.
👨🎨 This is Helen. Helen hears about Bob saying horrible things about Marc, and Bob snitching on Marc. Helen goes to Trisha. Helen snitches to Trisha.
Trelawny is my fav character
I like his accent
And that one bounty hunter scene for some reason
He's one of my favs too
I have an angonising Migraine but it cannot be this hard to understand that they are both rats.
And one thing: Trelawny isn't the Strange Man 👍🏻
Strange man is a random creep who stalked John Marston
Probably
Mightve ratted for different things. One ratted for a good reason One ratted to be a twat. They both ratted
Hes probably unnatural
Yo do y'all think Arthur Morgan was a zombie in red dead redemption nightmare
Game wise? No. Canonically? Yeah he wouldve been
Probably john thought about him
what im trying to tell you is that its unhelpful to use the same word to describe both things since they are so fundamentally different. one results in you being a villain, the other in you being a hero
even thought both involve exposing someone
But the essance of it. Is being a rat
He's annesburg so it wouldn't be possible for his appearance since John is in mexico
I rat people out all the time.
Im still a rat
You rat people out. You're still a rat.
in most contexts, "ratting" as in snitching means snitching specifically to the authorities
Not over here it doesnt
really arguing over the word rat
Debating I think
If I was aruging i'd call Woolie a twat or something
Spec you are so sane






