general

[obtuse osprey]

john's aura was unlimited

when he killed javier, bill and dutch in rdr1

[rancid oyster]

Check media rq

[normal fable]

brodie can't even swim though 😭

[fleet ivy]

Dutch actually killed himself but yes

[obtuse osprey]

he got him to the point

where he had to give up

arthur died to micah

john killed micah

[rancid oyster]

Depends if u have low honor u die by Micah but if u got high honor u just die peacefully

[obtuse osprey]

john killed most of the left gang members in rdr1

[orchid torrent]

At least John doesn't like them young.

[fleet ivy]

That's too much now

[fleet ivy]

But I like John more yes

[fleet ivy]

But he didn't kill him

[obtuse osprey]

what was he gonna do lol

he was held at gunpoint

if he did something he would've been dead

[rancid oyster]

Arthur carried the gang while John was learning how to be a father bro

[obtuse osprey]

john took over mexico

[fleet ivy]

Could have surrendered but that's not the fact here it's the fact that he killed himself and not John

[obtuse osprey]

and gave himself up for his family

[orchid torrent]

What are you talking about?

"Arthur carried the gang"

[fleet ivy]

Hosea carried the gang

[hazy oyster]

what you talking about? Micah carried the pinkertons.

[normal fable]

nah kieran was the backbone of the gang trust

[fleet ivy]

When he died, Dutch lost his mind

[obtuse osprey]

(dutch already lost his mind since blackwater)

it just progresses

[hidden robin]

haiti

[fleet ivy]

Hosea was a trigger

[storm scaffold]

theyre all crazy

thats it

[normal fable]

i'd like to think the trolley incident is what made him go crazy, you can see the differences after and before the mission

[frosty ore]

He lost his mind before blackwater

[orchid torrent]

Arthur is so fucking dumb he let a sick man spit on him instead of using his mask or his gun

[frosty ore]

He shot a girl in cold blood

Or killed a girl

[rancid oyster]

Took over Mexico? Bro was doing errands for people who didn’t even respect him

[normal fable]

yeah but it was a bad situation

[fleet ivy]

No

[obtuse osprey]

oops

wrongr eply

[obtuse osprey]

no lol. he already lost it since blackwater

[frosty ore]

I mean Arthur says it himself in his journal

[wet pilot]

1800s had less knowledge than we did now

[frosty ore]

That Dutch was always coo coo for Coco puffs

[orchid torrent]

yeah because so many people respected Arthur wtf are you even talking about

[frank lava]

hi guys

[fleet ivy]

Hi

[rancid oyster]

I only liked Dutch when me and hosea and Dutch were vibing and singin while fishing

[orchid torrent]

so arthur doesn't even have 2 brain cells?

[frank lava]

vandermatthewssssgshegsgsahvdj

[orchid torrent]

Just like his fans

[obtuse osprey]

by the end of the day both of them die with a gun in their hand killing the lawmen lol the redemption just gets cleaned away

[rancid oyster]

Van DEr linde

[frank lava]

vandermatthews

[frosty ore]

My Arthur didn't die with a gun in his hand

[wet pilot]

Probably thought it was just a common cold

[frosty ore]

Dutch stopped him getting his gun

[obtuse osprey]

moments before that

he was shooting the lawmen

[frosty ore]

um ashKUslLy

[devout island]

“Take a gamble love exists, and do a loving act”

[frosty ore]

He was fighting Micah

🤓☝️

[obtuse osprey]

moments before that

he was shooting the lawmen

[storm scaffold]

glad that rat died

[frosty ore]

Moments before that he was giving John his hat and satchel

[rancid oyster]

Yessir

[obtuse osprey]

moments before that

[orchid torrent]

Real, im glad the rat (arthur) died

[obtuse osprey]

he was shooting the lawmen

now its correct enough

[rancid oyster]

"U shot me good"

[fleet ivy]

Arthur wasn't the only rat

[frosty ore]

Now that sounds about right

[rancid oyster]

[frank lava]

[rancid oyster]

Peak

[obtuse osprey]

moments before that

kills 50 lawmen

(he redempts himself)

[rancid oyster]

Moments before that

Gets jumped by Micah

And dies peacefully

[frank lava]

i miss lenny

[obtuse osprey]

wheres the redemption if both of them die killing

[storm scaffold]

arthur and micah wouldve been an interesting duo

[obtuse osprey]

doing exactly what they did in their past lives or whatever

their past lives is their current lives

[storm scaffold]

ask the writers damn

[rancid oyster]

Arthur and John

[hidden robin]

john marston

[frosty ore]

The redemption in number 2 is John accepting his role as a parent

[frank lava]

redemption is when u switch to john in the epilogue basically

yea

[orchid torrent]

Arthur and Micah can't be a duo, Arthur likes kids and Micah doesn't.

[hidden robin]

john poop

lol

[frank lava]

hah

[storm scaffold]

brothers

[frank lava]

🥹🥹

[thorny elbow]

i just got some budgies i need name suggestions

[rancid oyster]

Weird take plus also wrong

[obtuse osprey]

not wrong

[thorny elbow]

i was thinking coco or evie, which one sounds better

[storm scaffold]

dont fall for the bait partner

[orchid torrent]

and how is it wrong?

[thorny elbow]

i already named the other one

[obtuse osprey]

the bait is bait but it's not wrong

arthur did impregnate a 15 year old or so

named eliza

[orchid torrent]

Arthur was the one who got Eliza pregnant when she was 15 not micah

[rancid oyster]

Arthur helps Jack, saves street kids, and calls out predators. That’s in-game

[obtuse osprey]

now talk about what he did in his past

[storm scaffold]

was that confirmed

[obtuse osprey]

he did impregnate a 15 year old

yes

they had a baby

that died

[orchid torrent]

he is literally one of them

[storm scaffold]

would appreciate if a trusted source was provided for this

i keep seeing misinformation everywhere lmfao

[orchid torrent]

"a trusted source" yeah the game exists

[storm scaffold]

didnt hear a dialogue about it

[frank lava]

it’s in the one of the missions with rains fall

[obtuse osprey]

i believe he mentions eliza when he goes out with rans fall

[hidden robin]

i am glad you liked my original qoute

[quick hatch]

I'm afraid

[rancid oyster]

[frank lava]

but i don’t rmemeber when he says her age

[rancid oyster]

All talk

[storm scaffold]

same here

[rancid oyster]

We all are partner

[orchid torrent]

Arthur: "She was a just kid, 19, Eliza," which confirms her age, if Eliza died at 19 and Isaac was around Jack's age (4 years) she got pregnant when she was 15, also arthur calls eliza and his son "kids" so there was a age gap between arthur and eliza

[rancid oyster]

Overall Arthur and John would make a great duo

[amber sentinel]

Chat, if Jack is 4 and Abigail is 22, she got pregnant at 18, right? And fell for John at 18 because of Jack right?

So why did Arthur write in his journal, "many years ago before she fell for that fool MARSTON, I should've married her", you know, when she was under 18 years old and Arthur would've been like 32 at most %e

[obtuse osprey]

she got pregnant at 17
not 18
it takes a year to develop a kid

[frank lava]

hi vix

i see you

[rancid oyster]

Bro

Why do yall hate martson and Morgan

They are a perfect duo

Admit it

[obtuse osprey]

yes ill admit john marston is better than arthur morgan

[visual summit]

I was aboutta be like “yes Arthur did impregnate a lady who was way younger than him, it was during the Horse ride with rains fall in the mountains it just depends on what dialogue options you choose to talk about”

But then like everyone else hopped on it

[frank lava]

vix hi

[rancid oyster]

Arthur is a better gunslinger and muscular but martson is smart and creative

[storm scaffold]

ill be damned. how about charles? anything up with him as well?

[frank lava]

i’m pretty sure this was supposed to be taken as him being jealous of what john has considering arthur’s love life and death of his child

[visual summit]

Ivan hi

[frank lava]

hi vix i love u

[obtuse osprey]

bro how do you get this part

arthur istn abetter gunslinger

than john

[visual summit]

Don’t think so, just an chill man who wants peace

[rancid oyster]

If I could take anyone during a zombie apocalypse it would be my Boi Charles

[frank lava]

LALO

[stray nymph]

hi ivan hi vix

[obtuse osprey]

sir you have never played rdr1

[visual summit]

I love you too ivan

[frank lava]

I LOVE U

[obtuse osprey]

arthur isnt better than john at gunslinging

[rancid oyster]

For sure buddy

[visual summit]

laalllooooooo

[storm scaffold]

thats a godamn relief

[visual summit]

I always loved Charles

[orchid torrent]

and why is his son dead? because of him, because he wasn't there to protect them

[rancid oyster]

Ppl respected Arthur too

[orchid torrent]

no one respects arthur

Rest in piss arthur morgan

[obtuse osprey]

arthur isn't a better gunslinger than john

[rancid oyster]

Say what u want bro ur all talk

[stray nymph]

vixxxxxx

[rancid oyster]

atleast Arthur didn't die by Ross and a firing squad Arthur died in peace resting by the sun

[visual summit]

I think a lot of characters have bad things they’ve done that they all tried to work on eventually. Like Arthur who sadly ran out of time to do so but did his best to give john that chance of redeeming himself

[orchid torrent]

never forget the moment when rockstar released the first trailer for rdr2 and everyone hated arthur

[stray nymph]

okay i gotta be dry

i love you too ivan.

[rancid oyster]

Yea guess what everyone loves him now

[orchid torrent]

Arthur got killed by a little germ, that's embarrassing 😭

[obtuse osprey]

he died for his family that's the thing you're missing

[rancid oyster]

Yea atleast he endured less pain buddy

[frank lava]

not really,,,, i mean it wasnt curable back then

[orchid torrent]

Are you stupid?

How is that less pain?

[wary kindle]

rest in piss arthur morgan

[rancid oyster]

I'm not I'm pretty sure like 100s of bullets are way more painful

[visual summit]

lol

[frank lava]

justice for lalo,,,

[rancid oyster]

A literal FIRING SQAUD

[wary kindle]

i was the germ that killed arthur morgan

[rancid oyster]

Whatchu on bout

[wary kindle]

im a public hero

[obtuse osprey]

thanks mate

that guy had to go

[storm scaffold]

what was your reaction when humans discovered a cure

[wary kindle]

i got better

[rancid oyster]

Idk why yall hate Arthur so much

[wary kindle]

i hate arthur

because i hate him

[obtuse osprey]

i hate arthur

[visual summit]

Why we hating on Arthur bruh yes he did bad things in his life he literally lived in guilt to the point that he couldn’t accept that he was actively doing good things for others. His wrong doings haunted him until the very last breath and I mean yeah- it sucks that Arthur did what he did but he eventually realized it and did his best to be a better person

[rancid oyster]

And why is that?

[rancid oyster]

I agree

[frank lava]

they were all bad people collectively but obviously had good in them too

[obtuse osprey]

he realized it and in the end his choices turned out to be doing the same thing: killing people in cold blood

[frank lava]

[storm scaffold]

ive witnessed more brutal hatred towards micah

[frank lava]

yeah micah’s deserving of it

[young parrot]

tbf who doesnt hate micah

[wary kindle]

he can cry me a river

[storm scaffold]

all the characters had some crazy shit going on, thats for sure

[obtuse osprey]

he cant

he died

[visual summit]

I’m not dismissing what he did with Eliza in the past though. I was like man wtf dude

[rancid oyster]

Ye

[storm scaffold]

ive met a few

[orchid torrent]

and the way he never tried to change anything "oh no my life sucks" but i will continue to kill people until my last day alive

[wary kindle]

o u right

[wary kindle]

right like

using that logic you sound like an apologist for a lot of bad people

[young parrot]

i didnt know he did that until i decided i'd spectate this server im crine

[rancid oyster]

Yall gotta remember that Arthur saved John not once but twice

[obtuse osprey]

the real redemption for arthur morgan should've been shooting himself in the moment when he realized that he is a bad guy and not following the route of killing people until he dies

[visual summit]

He was in a rough situation everyone in the camp was

[rancid oyster]

Even said by Martson himself

[wary kindle]

he ran with a gang that canonically tore families apart, hurt countless ppl and disturbed many ways of lives

[storm scaffold]

in all honesty, i wanted the game solely to explore with my horse

[young parrot]

literally what about him is redeemable, or even remotely likable 💔💔

[storm scaffold]

shits fun

[dim river]

Smash

[storm scaffold]

just crashing into fellers and boulders

[frank lava]

like every gang

[wary kindle]

i need you to meet gaycah the goat

[frank lava]

[visual summit]

The what now

[orchid torrent]

yall need to remember that arthur didn't do shit, he was always helped by other people to save john

[wary kindle]

my point lol there's no point in defending him, he's not special for having a fake redemption

[young parrot]

didnt he grow up with them?? how are you supposed to get out of the gang at that point lwk

[frank lava]

so true

[wary kindle]

same way the others did

[obtuse osprey]

im a jm fan but i didn't catch the redemption of jm or arthur morgan cause both of them end their lives by being a killer lmao

[storm scaffold]

no idea partner, im assuming they like micah for how hes written rather than who he is

[frank lava]

yea he was raised by dutch and hosea

[wary kindle]

tilly was pretty much raised there too she dipped out pretty easy

[dim river]

his writing is SO ASSSS

[visual summit]

Yeah Micah’s well written but he’s morally a terrible character

[young parrot]

others didnt have the same bond that he did though, thats why it was so hard for him to leave. even when he realized everyone else should leave, he couldnt

[wary kindle]

cuz hes a fraud

[rancid oyster]

Hm true

[obtuse osprey]

there's no redemption for a gunslinger who has been killing people and still killing people when they realized that

[storm scaffold]

a lot of contrasting ideas going on here lmao

[wary kindle]

albert mason would never

[orchid torrent]

John grew up with the gang too but it wasn't that hard for him to leave

[rancid oyster]

They both still had good in em

[orchid torrent]

[dim river]

Albert mason the goat

[visual summit]

What fcking van der linde male character hasn’t sexually harassed / grapped a lady atp 😭😭 shit was terrible back then

[wary kindle]

john stays better 🥹💔

[storm scaffold]

the camera dude?

[orchid torrent]

the way people are trying to find an excuse for arthur and it doesn't even make sense

[dim river]

like... most of them.?????

[visual summit]

Frick you sheriff

[wary kindle]

you mean the land's savior? lol

[obtuse osprey]

nor john or arthur had a redemption

[wary kindle]

that's the goat you're talking abt

[storm scaffold]

i keep forgetting these peoples names

[wary kindle]

john definitely did

[visual summit]

Exactly

[obtuse osprey]

i said my comment above. read the chat

[storm scaffold]

im assuming thats a yes
hes goated

[rancid oyster]

Yall don't know the heck of times Arthur saved john

[young parrot]

liking an antag cause theyre well written is fine ig, but even then its kinda to a point where yes the writing is admirable, but its so admirable to the point your supposed to hate him. if ppl hate arthur for what he did to eliza, then ya'll kinda gotta hate micah too

[orchid torrent]

john literally left the gang for a year, what is arthur's excuse?

[storm scaffold]

dont tell me albert mason got some crazy shit in his life as well

[visual summit]

And hate dutch too

[obtuse osprey]

.

[visual summit]

Lol

[young parrot]

right like yall cant play favorites like that be so fr 😭

[visual summit]

Too late too little type stuff

[storm scaffold]

might as well hate everyone

[obtuse osprey]

im a jm fan but where's the redemption for both of them

[dim river]

i love dutch i hate micah

[obtuse osprey]

they don't have a redemption

[frank lava]

i love hosea!!1!1!1!1

[visual summit]

Omg me too yay that’s grandpa

[young parrot]

right like just admit you hate almost everyone in the gang 💔

[wary kindle]

in comparison to Arthur john was the one with a redemption. from a deadbeat father that ran away for about a year, wasn't fatherly to his son or a good husband to finding a plot of land for his family and being a pretty good partner and father for the time period?

yeah I'd say that's more of a redemption than whatever Arthur had

[obtuse osprey]

wheres their redemption

they ended up by killing people

[rancid oyster]

Arthur > absentee dad John, every time

[frank lava]

the redemption is him being a better father and husband 😭

[wary kindle]

right.. still a redemption

[obtuse osprey]

and not becoming a farmer

he failed at that

[orchid torrent]

I'm starting to think you're stupid, you say John is an absent father but Arthur let his son die

[visual summit]

In rdr I’m p sure he did

[dim river]

john actually lied about nigel's elixir so hes irredeemable :/ hes a horrible person.

[rancid oyster]

And plus Leaving doesn’t earn respect. Staying does.

[orchid torrent]

How does that make sense?

[wary kindle]

most of the epilogue is about john's redemption with becoming a stable person for his family

[obtuse osprey]

john died for his past life

of being a robber and a killer

[frank lava]

i will agree that john is better than arthur tho

[visual summit]

Yeah same here

[wary kindle]

now you're getting it

[storm scaffold]

so the redemption in the title of both games is about john

[rancid oyster]

Can we talk during the game story not before the game even started

[obtuse osprey]

yes

[young parrot]

i fear that this doesnt completely throw away his redemption, and he is actively trying to stop killing people. pretty sure by the end john is hunting down micah because that man needed to go, not just for no reason

[visual summit]

Like it’s evident

[wary kindle]

yes

[orchid torrent]

and what respect did he gain? because he died like a little bitch alone on a mountain

[storm scaffold]

call me shakespeare

[obtuse osprey]

im talking about rdr1

[frank lava]

well i’ve always liked john more😭

[dim river]

im crine

[visual summit]

But honestly? To each their own, like who you like it’s your world and no one can take that from you

[young parrot]

ahh yeah nvm i cant speak on that mb gng

[rancid oyster]

John wouldnt be proud of yall

[obtuse osprey]

yeah play rdr1 one day

that's where john marston's actual story gets shown

[orchid torrent]

bruh then don't mention john leaving his son because that's not in the game 😭

Are you stupid?

[young parrot]

i want to, i js dont got the money rn and i aint playing it on netflix

[rancid oyster]

Who took jack to fishing

[storm scaffold]

is rdr worth it

[rancid oyster]

Where was his absent father

[wary kindle]

(because he was asked btw)

[frank lava]

YES

i love it

[obtuse osprey]

rdr1 is worth it

[dim river]

no dont recommend

[wary kindle]

he wouldn't have done shit if abigail didn't ask him

[visual summit]

Hell yes

[rancid oyster]

But he had real fun and made Jack's day

Unlike john

[storm scaffold]

ill try it out

[orchid torrent]

doing better things

[rancid oyster]

Absent father

[visual summit]

Who later redeemed himself

[orchid torrent]

the smartest arthur fan

[obtuse osprey]

john did redeem himself becoming a better husband and a father. like it should be clear redemption isnt about going to hell or heaven

both of them are going to hell

[storm scaffold]

word

[orchid torrent]

"absent father" he is literally in the camp but he doesn't care. that's why the game is called "redemption" because he accepts jack as his son

[dim river]

i love this profuile

[rancid oyster]

Better things? Arthur was saving lives while John was what, running errands?

[wary kindle]

i don't think you understand that in order to have a redemption you need to be in a bad spot

[young parrot]

isnt the whole point that theyre all shit people who are js doing their best to be even a bit better despite their past, or their occupation

[livid sparrow]

ah yes, i love yours too hey

[visual summit]

Pretty much

[faint goblet]

did you play the epilogue

[wary kindle]

the whole point was that John was a poor husband and father and then his redemption was him becoming a rancher with his gorgeous wife and son

[orchid torrent]

Ragebait 100/100 a criminal is now a superhero

[visual summit]

I guess some people had it worse off than others (like Arthur)

[frosty ore]

Idk what we're aruging about about Sean goated

[orchid torrent]

Who did Arthur save?

[frank lava]

i love ur profile

[dim river]

why thank you!

[visual summit]

They got a video shitting on him btw

[dim river]

grahhhhhhhh

[obtuse osprey]

john saved himself

[young parrot]

thank you ^^ i like yours too, your graphic set is hella nice

[storm scaffold]

notice how theres zero charles hate

[obtuse osprey]

if you dont help him he still makes it

[livid sparrow]

ey you're welcome partner!!

[frank lava]

thank you!!!

[rancid oyster]

John multiple times

[dim river]

charthur charthur

[visual summit]

There is at least one person out there who hates your fav always

[young parrot]

charles is js the goat

[obtuse osprey]

he saves himself

on his own

[frosty ore]

Fym shitting??

[visual summit]

omg charthur yes hesyesyes

[frank lava]

notice how there’s zero hosea hate🥹🥹🥹

[frosty ore]

Like whos pooping on Sean :Sob:

[wary kindle]

charthur is growing on me

[visual summit]

A video calling Sean the real rat

[frank lava]

HELP

[faint goblet]

TRUE

[orchid torrent]

if you say that arthur saved john then we can say the same thing about sadie and javier because artjur was never alone in saving john

[visual summit]

You not even the fart

[dim river]

as it should (pretend this is all caps)

[young parrot]

hosea doesnt deserve hate, even with his flaws

[frosty ore]

Well idk how thats gonna work considering bro is fucking dead by chapter 3

[wary kindle]

i hate to say it but despite how much i hate arthur i lowkey shipped him with my goat Albert mason a little

[rancid oyster]

There's one mission where u gotta dead eye quickly to save John and plus in the starting where he was wounded in the snow cliff

[wary kindle]

just a little bit

[frank lava]

do u guys remember when dutch and hosea confessed their love to each other and got married and then they rode out into the sunset??

[dim river]

how do u not know about the seance scene? :/

[storm scaffold]

met a feller who claimed that hosea deserves hate for manipulating dutch

[visual summit]

I can send you the video, I was lowk shocked watching it myself

[rancid oyster]

And he saved John and his family

[silver girder]

hi guys

[frank lava]

bye they’re literally boyfriends

[young parrot]

💔💔💔💔

[faint goblet]

there was a second rat on the blackwater ferry btw

[visual summit]

No fr

[frosty ore]

No cause the creepy thing is the ship name i have between my oc and sean IS Seance

[orchid torrent]

John still gets shot on that train, so Arthur didn't do shit.

[young parrot]

sometimes i question if some people even played the same game as the rest of us

[obtuse osprey]

it was the girl 💯 that dutch shot in cold blood!

[frank lava]

i love vandermatthews so much

[visual summit]

Clearly not lol

[dim river]

omg im such a genius

[young parrot]

no literally 😭😭😭

[visual summit]

Don’t even start lad

[frank lava]

[frosty ore]

It was between Seance and Speen

[visual summit]

I love vandermatthews so much.

[frosty ore]

#vandermatthews

[young parrot]

lwk it wasnt even completely on the gang rat the gang was js kinda shit at being a gang, and thats why it failed

[frank lava]

me too ohmyoghd

[visual summit]

Speen 👑

[faint goblet]

i reckon davey was the rat in blackwater but because he died they had to get another rat and thats micah

[orchid torrent]

clearly not if arthur fans mention that arthur saved john but they don't say how javier and sadie did the same shit

[dim river]

he was gonna leave john on that damn mountain 😭

[frank lava]

vandermatthews best ship

[storm scaffold]

couldnt bother explaining shit to that person because you know how rdr/2 players are when it comes to hearing about lore

[rancid oyster]

U expect Arthur to save John everywhere

[whole kayak]

i just joined this server today, and i have been playing since june or july of last year, but i recently have heard of a group called the nite folk can someone pls tell me who or what the ite folk is?

[orchid torrent]

Don't mess with us Arthur fans, we don't play the game.

[visual summit]

Yeah 💔

[rancid oyster]

Arthur earned John's respect

[obtuse osprey]

dont mess with us arthur fans we avoid playing rdr1

[dim river]

arent they in uhhhh

[visual summit]

Run run run run run run run run

[dim river]

they in da swamps

[orchid torrent]

You're the one who said that Arthur saved John

[visual summit]

Lagras

[whole kayak]

what even are the nite folk?

[visual summit]

If you’re crossing lagras Run buddy

[wary kindle]

in a world of charthur i am the sole albert and arthur shipper

[young parrot]

i fear i am somewhat an arthur fan but yeah you got a point there

[wary kindle]

yk coining the ship name photobomb

[visual summit]

No I’m here too I scream as they drag me away

[whole kayak]

why??

[dim river]

ughwathever i jsut want harringrove

[visual summit]

The nite folk are watching you

[rancid oyster]

He saved John in chapter 1 and chapter 6

[young parrot]

more of a dutch fan honestly his writing is so good

[whole kayak]

who even are the nite folk tho-

[dim river]

boi

[orchid torrent]

Javier saved John in Chapter 1 and Sadie in Chapter 6

[visual summit]

Love how bstshit crazy he ends up turning like fucckkk he lost his shit

[orchid torrent]

why don't you mention them too?

[visual summit]

Him in rd1 ohhhh my god dude

[obtuse osprey]

him in rdr1

we cant fight gravity

[visual summit]

Lol

[wary kindle]

how i feel after being the main person to show up if you search "Albert mason" in general

[young parrot]

HE DID and im ngl i love the progression and how you can see his sanity dwindle, and then his whole speech just repeating to show that it wasnt ever genuine after a certain point 🥹🥹

[rancid oyster]

Yalls hate against Arthur is disgusting

[whole kayak]

i did see a crying woman in lagras though i didn't approach

[dim river]

youd be surprised at what more has been said

[frank lava]

dutch mentioned you’re summoning sammy

[wary kindle]

disgusting like how he got a teenage girl pregnant?

[visual summit]

Okay wait can I . does anyone fw Abe because I can’t get enough of him… that rancher dude in epilogue

[flat citrus]

hi hi

[wary kindle]

who said that

[young parrot]

i feel like arthur isnt the only one that deserves hate here. everyone in the gang deserves hate because like

[dim river]

prime exmaple

im crine

[visual summit]

They left help

[wary kindle]

oh my god abe

[orchid torrent]

why don't you mention how charles and kieran saved arthur? why is it always about john

[young parrot]

if your gonna bring this up so you gotta bring up micah and dutch too be so fr we cant js single out arthur 💔💔

[orchid torrent]

Or haven't you played the game?

[rancid oyster]

Aren't u the virus? Ur way more gross

[visual summit]

Omg thank you finally some Abe recognition I love him so much

[dim river]

i do not recall dutch or micah doing this

[storm scaffold]

lmfaoo the role

[wary kindle]

i never said i like dutch or Micah 💔💔💔

[dim river]

actually yea micah did

dutch my goat ✌️

[obtuse osprey]

strayy are you happy with your role now

[frank lava]

micah’s a r4pist

so is dutch

[young parrot]

i mentioned it earlier and someone did mention dutch did smth so

[wary kindle]

when is there Albert mason fan role i need to be the sole MF with it

[storm scaffold]

still zero charles hate

keep it up

[visual summit]

Give me the Abe fan role too

[frank lava]

still zero hosea hate

[visual summit]

Hold on let me cook

[wary kindle]

Charles my tragic beautiful king

[dim river]

is this from his poster in rdr1??? i genuinely cant rmb

[rancid oyster]

Guess what Charles is a real one and stayed with Arthur and always saw Arthur as a leader

[orchid torrent]

and arthur is a pedo

[frank lava]

my fav side characters are charles chatenay and archie downes

[whole kayak]

??????

[frank lava]

i didnt,,, deny anything?

[wary kindle]

i love charles chatenay

[visual summit]

I hate

How you can’t send gifs

[orchid torrent]

wtf wdym charles saw him as a leader what game did you play?

[visual summit]

Or talk in all caps

[dim river]

chârthur

[frosty ore]

SKILL ISSUE I GUESS

[visual summit]

Let me express my excitement dang it

[frank lava]

fordham says hi

[dim river]

how do you have rights to do this

[storm scaffold]

another debate ive been seeing often is the height differences of each character

[orchid torrent]

I didn't say you did, but you forgot to mention him.

[frank lava]

me too

[obtuse osprey]

what bro

[young parrot]

oh dude i dont even wanna try and attempt this

[dim river]

wait plz dont murder me i played rdr1 years ago 😔

[frosty ore]

I nitro boosted x

[wary kindle]

the real redemption here was Albert mason 😇

[visual summit]

Okay me next

[dim river]

ah

[frank lava]

fordham says it**😭

[visual summit]

IS IT WORKING

YEYAHEKCOFV

[dim river]

crine

[orchid torrent]

#general-media send the video where charles says he sees arthur as a leader

[visual summit]

Mwueheheehehehe

[orchid torrent]

because wtf is that

[frank lava]

IM A BOOSTER TOO WHY CANTI CAPS

oh yeah i can

HELP

[storm scaffold]

proved yourself wrong

[obtuse osprey]

u cant spam tho

[wary kindle]

i miss my nitro and my rdr2 server boost

[obtuse osprey]

[frank lava]

i don’t really want to

[wary kindle]

my prime lowkey

[storm scaffold]

nitro is lame

[dim river]

i miss byler

[frank lava]

ME TOO.

[obtuse osprey]

wait what dont you have nitro

free fire

[wary kindle]

i miss hannigram

[dim river]

cries into my pillow

[storm scaffold]

huh? youre seeing things

[frank lava]

dude i had a dream that the duffer bros got their shit together and made byler real

[young parrot]

i agree, dont check my nitro tag trust

[whole kayak]

what are the night folk??? are they like the Lemoyne raiders????

[obtuse osprey]

shit

[orchid torrent]

I love arguing with Arthur fans, they're always say the most random shit that doesn't make sense

[storm scaffold]

on dutch, i dont have nitro

[dim river]

is this hannibal shoudl i watch it

[frosty ore]

I personally liked the he was my tammy thing

[obtuse osprey]

i dont trust dutch!

[young parrot]

on sean neither of us have nitro

[storm scaffold]

theyre doomed

[wary kindle]

yes it changed my life

[fleet ivy]

Do it

[wary kindle]

every waking thought of mine is hannibal

[frank lava]

noooo dude it’s such queerbait they built up byler SO much just for him to say that i was so sad

[frosty ore]

That was NOT queerbait

Queerbait is johnlock

[wary kindle]

every username i have is hannibal related. almost every piece i make has a little bit of hannibal snuck in there.

[frank lava]

i love archie downes so much i never hear any talk about him

[young parrot]

i lwk want some toast

[wary kindle]

i do not play about that damn show

ravioli time im hungry

[frank lava]

i think i used the wrong word well not like queerbait it was just like

[dim river]

oh no ur so right

[storm scaffold]

cool off and play stardew valley

[young parrot]

share? i would like some

[frank lava]

oh okay

[wary kindle]

im big and hungry idk if i can

[young parrot]

its ok i can get some of my own + thats real

[wary kindle]

Mr not graham!!??

[frank lava]

so who here likes the quarry heh….

no…? okay…

[young parrot]

umm i like the bendy and the outlast trials
outlast in general really

[young parrot]

what is the quarry

[frank lava]

it’s a horror game abt camp counselors who have to spend a night at the camp that they don’t know is haunted basically

[young parrot]

oh wait that seems rlly fun

i like that concept

[neat cedar]

it does sound fun

thank you ivan

[frank lava]

like werewolves and stuff, and for the game you can literally kill anyone it depends on ur choices, it has 186 endings

[frank lava]

you’re welcome ren

[wary kindle]

i like outlast omg

[young parrot]

186??

[neat cedar]

smirks

[frank lava]

YEAH ITS

[young parrot]

the amount of potential, i must play this

[frank lava]

it’s kinda crazy

[frank lava]

yes plz

[young parrot]

YES outlast is so fire. i kinda hate that it hit the mainstream cause of what ppl r saying abt the outlast trials, but i love it either way

[frank lava]

i also love life is strange

[young parrot]

thank you for telling me abt this, i will add it to my list of games

[frank lava]

YAY OFC!!!

[wary kindle]

i like trials bc i am interested in the cold war but outlast 2 was always my favourite personally

[young parrot]

ive seen stuff on this game and i used to have it on the xbox 360, never played it fully though. ill have to go through and look at it again lwk

seems like its got a good story

[frank lava]

it’s really awesome i love it sm,,,

it is

but imo lis2 is way better

[wary kindle]

omg ew why is my mr. graham !! gone

i feel naked.

[young parrot]

i like how they play around with religion and with the town like being a different view of how murkoff affects towns and the general population, that was cool. i like the dlc personally

[wary kindle]

who reverted my display name i feel vulnerable and scared.

[errant atlas]

Hola

[neat cedar]

😭

[young parrot]

i will keep this in mind :D

[amber oak]

hellooo, i'm new to RedM and was wondering if anyone knows any good servers?

[rancid oyster]

This Indian unc YouTube tutorial saved me before my physics exam

[somber saddle]

Could anyone help me with a problem I’m having?

Whenever I save my game and load the save my special and ultimate edition content goes away. Is there anyway to fix this?

[hushed marsh]

I have returned

[magic belfry]

@hushed marsh yo

[storm scaffold]

someone joined your clown icon club

[magic belfry]

I just came in blackwater with a 1c bounty to 1500$ bounty beacuse someone one bumped into me how rude

[fossil brook]

Burps

[calm jungle]

how is everyone doing

[karmic zinc]

I am real

[hoary thorn]

Any PlayStation players are down to play?

[rancid oyster]

Bro who put the clown role on me

Prolly the lgbtq supporters

What can u expect

[proven aspen]

[obtuse osprey]

you got the

arthur fan role

[karmic zinc]

Son 😭😭😭

[pine otter]

🫩🥀

[frigid quartz]

Just got done cleaning the coop and I can't even take a shower now because the pipes are being replaced so now I gotta wait 😔

[coral mesa]

based name

...except now I'm hungry 😭

[rancid oyster]

Idk why this lgbtq supporter is talking

[obtuse osprey]

you're a

lgbtq supporter yourself

[rancid oyster]

Sure buddy

[obtuse osprey]

pal

check your roles

[rancid oyster]

I don't recognize myself as one

So don't count

[proven aspen]

im eating rn heh...

[obtuse osprey]

count

braindead and homophobic arthur fan

[rancid oyster]

At this point ur admin abusing

[coral mesa]

do you happen to be eating hot tamales

[obtuse osprey]

admin abusing

[rancid oyster]

Ykw kick me if u don't like me that much

[obtuse osprey]

ok im gonna kick you now

[rancid oyster]

Kick me

[hollow berry]

watching w popcorn

[rancid oyster]

Good boy

[hollow berry]

[dense verge]

are u rlly homophobic in 2026 or is this js some ragebait

[fleet ivy]

Insane

[hollow berry]

fight! fight! fight!

[obtuse osprey]

lilith pplz kick him

[rancid oyster]

I love homophobic

I hate gay ppl

[fleet ivy]

Sure bud

[rancid oyster]

See I said it

[rancid oyster]

Kick me

[hollow berry]

that one bar fight in valentine:

[fleet ivy]

Go kiss some ass

You'll like it

[hollow berry]

[rancid oyster]

Yo no way this whole server is full of gay ppl

What a joke

Yo kick me already

[obtuse osprey]

braindead and

homophobic arthur fan

what a combination

[rancid oyster]

Blah blah

[obtuse osprey]

all comes from being an arthur fan

[dense verge]

big news arthur kisses men

[hollow berry]

that one racist pamphlet guy in saint denis:

[rancid oyster]

Why don't u go and peg John already

[dense verge]

say less

[obtuse osprey]

say less

[fleet ivy]

Imagine hating on love 😂

[rancid oyster]

Good boy

[hollow berry]

say more

[coral mesa]

you can just leave

[obtuse osprey]

say less plz (seriously)

i want to less of your messages

[rancid oyster]

I'll just leave myself

[wide apex]

ew

[rancid oyster]

If yall good boys can't kick me

[dense verge]

good

[wide apex]

BYE

[fleet ivy]

Bye

[proven aspen]

[coral mesa]

👋

[obtuse osprey]

be gone son

[dense verge]

your presence won’t be missed

[obtuse osprey]

we dont miss you

[hollow berry]

this wasnt in dutchs plan

[wide apex]

Stray might be gay

[dense verge]

“might be” he IS

[fleet ivy]

He is

[obtuse osprey]

he loves arthur

[fleet ivy]

He wants Arthur's ass

[wide apex]

”d-daddy arthur”

[pine otter]

What’s going on 😭

[dense verge]

him every night

[hollow berry]

[wide apex]

im sayin

[dense verge]

i can relate

[wide apex]

[frigid quartz]

I open the server to this LMAO God I love this server

[fleet ivy]

Loll

[wide apex]

LMAO

[dense verge]

exactly

[obtuse osprey]

i love stupid arthur fans making the server more fun

[dense verge]

ive only met homophobic rdr fans on tiktok this is refreshing

[lost karma]

My horse is stuck on a mountain and won't come down and I can't get up there.

How do I get it back?

[hollow berry]

don't count tiktok,every comment on tiktok hates on something for no absolute reason

[wide apex]

im not a arthur fan after him now

[dense verge]

today an arthur roleplayer wanted me to be his mary linton and kept flirting with me

[obtuse osprey]

thats why you should choose john marston

[dense verge]

yeah ik i’m a content creator i’m experienced ✌️

[wide apex]

[lost karma]

Only got up there when I went to camp

[hollow berry]

don't

[obtuse osprey]

ill

[dense verge]

but i want to

[hollow berry]

he is dead

[winter token]

https://tenor.com/view/sukuna-jujutsu-kaisen-sukuna-looking-down-gif-7333648534605432939

[dense verge]

undead nightmare here i come

[obtuse osprey]

he has to die later

undead nightmare happens before the story

[dense verge]

dead or not he’s hot

[hollow berry]

travel back in time and tell john to not shoot the strange man

[obtuse osprey]

also i prefer to hear deadman's gun compared to cruel cruel world

[hollow berry]

[dense verge]

dmc fan spotted

❤️‍🩹

[winter token]

https://tenor.com/view/devil-may-cry-gif-13065915

[dense verge]

peak

[eager storm]

run

[dense verge]

i gave up the game for rdr2 but i’ll finish it

[white zealot]

[dense verge]

some time

in the future

[wet pilot]

oogy boogy

[dense verge]

boothill 🥹

[winter token]

You better

[white zealot]

yez

[dense verge]

yes ofc i wouldnt miss witnessing peak

[dense verge]

you know ball

[white zealot]

i'm matching with my wife, she's argenti ‼️

[fleet ivy]

[dense verge]

argenthill more peak

[coral mesa]

you didn't deny it 😆

[white zealot]

also i like your strawpage, very very peak

[dense verge]

TYSM

🫶🫶

[white zealot]

hallooo

[proven aspen]

why wouldn't i

[dense verge]

awkward silence

[wicked fable]

Ask the horse idk

[wary kindle]

is ur name after tcsov

[dense verge]

yes!!!

[wicked fable]

Just take a few steps away and whistle (is this hard)

[wary kindle]

omg yes

[wide apex]

who THE FUCK took my last soda

[wet pilot]

i think bro likes the lgbtq

[wide apex]

[dense verge]

me

sorry

[wicked fable]

Ye

[wide apex]

count your days

[dense verge]

1

[wary kindle]

i used to be a huge noé fan

[dense verge]

2

3 4

5

SIX SEVEN

ok sirry

sorry

[wide apex]

blocked

banned

[wet pilot]

its quite hard to tell, u should make it more obvious 💪

[wide apex]

and reported

[dense verge]

IM SORRY

I SORRYSGSGSH

[wide apex]

youre done

[wet pilot]

you're*

[wide apex]

[wicked fable]

What is this user

Bruh

[wide apex]

RUN IT

[wide apex]

who

[wet pilot]

you're

[dense verge]

ooh!

he’s a peak character

[wicked fable]

You bruh

[wary kindle]

should i play wolfquest or spend some money in rdo

[wide apex]

what did i even do 💀

[wary kindle]

thanks guys rdo it is

[wet pilot]

both

[wary kindle]

i made a ton of money with my friend but never spent it

[wide apex]

just catchin strays

[dense verge]

wait sorry u shoukd spend money ❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹❤️‍🩹

[wicked fable]

Game money or real money

?

[wary kindle]

game

[wicked fable]

If you ain't a noob or a starter you don't have much to spend on

[wary kindle]

i wanna buy my oc a new outfit

[wicked fable]

So

[wet pilot]

i like tortoise

[dense verge]

omg oc

can i see

can i

[wary kindle]

im like average i kinda just use it for ammo and food for my horse lol

[wicked fable]

Ah understood

[wary kindle]

sigh hold on he's kinda ugly

he's from my book

[dense verge]

YAY

[wide apex]

now i gotta see

[dense verge]

me first

get away

[wide apex]

nuh uh

WOAH

insane username

[dense verge]

shush

[wet pilot]

wait

[wide apex]

[dense verge]

it’s peak wdym

[wet pilot]

would transgender john marston be a male or female, bc would they of trans to male from female or trans to female from male

[dense verge]

dude

[toxic shuttle]

Mtf

[wide apex]

huh..

i had a stroke reading that

[toxic shuttle]

Just reflecting

[wary kindle]

oh my god i love your name

[dense verge]

that one friend thats too woke

[toxic shuttle]

My name woke transgender john Marston

[toxic shuttle]

Hi guys it's me

[wet pilot]

thats why i did it

[wary kindle]

ftm john marston..

[dense verge]

it’s woke transgender john marston, micah

[frosty ore]

Is this meant to be funny

[wary kindle]

this is my status now thank u

[toxic shuttle]

I'm like woke and play rdr on a switch 2

[dense verge]

hey credit me

[wary kindle]

not rlly i just genuinely like the idea

[wet pilot]

to cause u and specifically u @wide apex pain

:)

[karmic zinc]

Nuh uh

[wide apex]

fork yew

[frosty ore]

Me?

[dense verge]

i’m still waiting for that oc

[wary kindle]

yk what fuck yeah actually ftm john sounds so badass

[frosty ore]

He does fr

[obtuse osprey]

🤥 Arthur fan role

[wet pilot]

no

[wary kindle]

#general-media

[karmic zinc]

He’s goated

[karmic zinc]

[frosty ore]

My OC is trans ftm

[karmic zinc]

Sweet

[wet pilot]

i dislike u

[wide apex]

you missed the plot twin

[wary kindle]

i have a character in my oc's book that's ftm too

[wide apex]

[round kindle]

what did aurther do ):

[wet pilot]

nah arthurs amazing

[wary kindle]

it's more implied than anything because it isn't the main focus of his story line but he's cool

[obtuse osprey]

Arthur is a character that made a lot of stupid and homophobic people join here

[dense verge]

me when i lie

[frosty ore]

He's the guy i've got shipped with Sean. It's been really interesting researching into it, and other trans people during that time period

[wary kindle]

the mc does kill him however....

[wide apex]

Nooo someone was in here being homophobic and they were a arthur fan

[round kindle]

anyways byeee

[dense verge]

ohh

justice for him

[dense verge]

byyeyey

[wary kindle]

well he hunts werewolves

[dense verge]

ohh interesting

[wet pilot]

good for them but arthur got nthn to do with it

[keen trout]

Yo i had this bug when i got to the horse table in Valentine to sell the big black horse at the begining of the game and on the final custcene there was this weird fog like things in the stable, also shadows flickering at the edge of my screen and characters in cutscenes not sitting right or sitting while bugging

[round kindle]

ehhh

[shadow geode]

Hello

[frigid quartz]

Howdy

[wary kindle]

or just puts them down because lycanthropy you can't really escape in this world ive got them in and there's hunters that will burn them alive (like how my oc's wife got killed bc she was bitten) so he hurries to kill them mercifully before the hunters can

[dense verge]

pls tell me ur pfp isnt ai

[shadow geode]

It is but i like it

[dense verge]

this is peak writing wait

[obtuse osprey]

Banned

[dense verge]

erm

ban this guy

[obtuse osprey]

Banned ai pfp

[shadow geode]

What

[wary kindle]

just go ahead and deactivate bro

[wet pilot]

let the man have his pfp

[golden palm]

I know human beans 🫘, Arthur

[obtuse osprey]

No ai pfp or ban

[shadow geode]

Bro wtf

[dense verge]

if u want to have ur planet in some years

[wide apex]

youre banned

[shadow geode]

I didn't do anything

[wet pilot]

its legit just a pfp

[shadow geode]

Thank you

[balmy vine]

[obtuse osprey]

switch the pfp or ban

[wet pilot]

i got u bro

[dense verge]

that used ai

[wide apex]

[shadow geode]

Fine I will change it damn

[wet pilot]

nah his pfp is awesome

[obtuse osprey]

It’s ass

[wet pilot]

nah dont change it

[obtuse osprey]

It’s ai

[wet pilot]

dont let nobody boss u about

[dense verge]

ban this guy

[wet pilot]

id rather be banned than in a dictatorship server

[wary kindle]

sigh i need male rdo character ideas

[dense verge]

good

[golden palm]

Apparently the camp has already begun to split into two parts.

[wide apex]

i think they are joking chat..

[wet pilot]

u can shove this server right up yer arses

[frosty ore]

It's okay he dropped out of school real young, I don't think he understand how bad AI is

[shadow geode]

Damn is that better

[wary kindle]

yes

[dense verge]

probably

[wet pilot]

im out