general

[swift lion]

I just made it to chapter 4 for my first playthrough.. i just want to play as john how much longer is this going to take 😭 😭

[orchid torrent]

real john is better

[swift lion]

Agreed but a few minutes ago i did a mission and he uh.. he kinda retired from life. (Sry for spoiler!)

[swift lion]

Exactly

Just 2 more chapters to go..

[left herald]

[hollow wagon]

What's up with the new spider easter egg

[coral bone]

No it's good I finished the game I sadly know☹️💔

[abstract sage]

Grinding is so long I hate it

Does anyone else feel like they’re grinding for nothing atm with the way rdo is so dead😫

[frosty basalt]

You guys do know Sean didn’t die right

It just stung him a bit

He got a bandaid so he’s finer

[snow echo]

Yea, and you can meet him again in the Epilogue

[spare ledge]

e e e e e

[frosty basalt]

eeeeeeee

[buoyant kestrel]

Hello everyone new to the server, looking for chill people to chat with an grind the game

Hmu or dm for some gameplay

[subtle tide]

For the online game
..In the Free Roam lobby can missions be repeated. Even after they've been completed one time . Example,, The Right Side of The Tracks mission

[candid fossil]

good day all

[winged tangle]

Guys

Im coughing with blood

Thats not cool im slowly becoming arthur😔 ✌️

[molten dragon]

Hey! everyone

How are you all doing

[midnight oar]

Hi

[wet pilot]

hello peoples

[fleet ivy]

Morning

[fleet ivy]

Good wby

[molten dragon]

I'm fine

You like to read books?

[fleet ivy]

Depends

I RARELY do but I have like 2

One about space and another about WW2

[molten dragon]

Nice! Sounds interesting. I’d like to see them.

[shrewd abyss]

Omg are you okay

[coral mesa]

yes.

go into the catalogue at a general store, go to Dry Goods, then click Classic Oatcakes.

Horses in RDR2 have a "Horse Calorie" system that determines their weight. 0 is Malnourished, 25 is Thin, 50 is Fit, 75 is Overweight, 100 is Obese.

Oatcakes (I think) have the highest "horse calorie" value of any normal food in the game at 5, meaning 5 oatcakes would take your horse from Thin to Fit, or Malnourished to Thin, etc.

The Horse Care Package has a Calorie value of 10.

[steady grove]

Hello

[fleet ivy]

Welcomeee

[fringe jewel]

hello

does now anyone play rdr2 online?

@everyone

[frosty ore]

You tried x

[fringe jewel]

is no one play?

[frosty ore]

#rdo-newswire

wrong channel

#rdo-chat

that one. Go in there.

[cyan cypress]

Hi

[frosty basalt]

Sybau

[patent aspen]

Lizzo ahh

[night pecan]

hi

[neon cave]

?

[patent aspen]

Search up Lizzo meme

[night pecan]

jejeje lizzo music

[young oracle]

Hi!

[blazing path]

yo

[young oracle]

RDR2 peak

[blazing path]

real

[young oracle]

I have Lumbago

[patent aspen]

Knee surgery

[left herald]

[frosty basalt]

Bro my horse just ran infront of a train why can’t I revive her

[runic summit]

Got horse reviver?

[frosty basalt]

Yep

It didn’t give an option to use it

[shrewd abyss]

omg that happens to me all the time

it's so frustrating

[old temple]

can i get rdr2 clips here?

for edits

[ionic pawn]

Who do you wanna edit? I can tell you an instagram account with like mega links for clips 😭

[old temple]

doesnt rlly mater

cn u sned a link?

send*

[ionic pawn]

I can just tell you the account I don’t think ur allowed to send links 😭

[frosty marsh]

[old temple]

dm?

[frosty marsh]

[ionic pawn]

Sure

[frosty marsh]

[ionic pawn]

Imma have to add you tho it won’t let me send without adding you lol

[bright jacinth]

lake Isabella” anyone 👀??

[old temple]

im acc trying learn editing with clipchamp. Gon be hard asf to make em good

[frosty ore]

Capcut is easier

if you want an easier route

[neat plaza]

i eat dirt

[frosty ore]

You should not be doing that

[gloomy torrent]

so my friend who cant swim is going to cosplay john marston

[obtuse osprey]

how'd you get muted for 7 days

[gloomy torrent]

never seen a more accurate cosplay

[frosty ore]

Cause I said something that could've been related to a political figure because of the surname Jenny from rdr2 has.

The automod snatched me

[patent aspen]

Guys what does „this user is banned from this guild“ mean

[old temple]

alr masterd cc its b oring

[obtuse osprey]

wait so you cant mention the surname of jenny?

[ionic pawn]

Blurrr is fun if you haven’t mastered that already

[frosty ore]

No

[obtuse osprey]

but you can mention eipstein

[frosty ore]

Because of the surname it is

There was probably big arguments about it so just nipped it on the bud

I get it

[inland kraken]

hey. feed me

[ionic pawn]

Lowkey lemme dm the account names bc I dunno if I’m allowed to say them in here due to “promotion” rules and stuff

[left herald]

[subtle tide]

If this is at the town of Valentine,,,that's better than traveling all over to Blackwater. I almost fell asleep during the boring trip to Blackwater..So thank you posting this

[tall nymph]

yo can anyone help with mods?

with catalogue improvement mod dm me if u can

[forest egret]

[frigid quartz]

Played last night. Tried mounting my horse to get away from the law and accidentally punched my horse instead

[gloomy gate]

sup

[patent aspen]

Hello

[fleet ivy]

Hi

[gloomy gate]

hru man

[patent aspen]

Good u

[fleet ivy]

I'm on my lunch break and then I gotta go work again more 3 hours

[patent aspen]

😭 i got work tomorrow again too

[fleet ivy]

Me too

Are you part time or full time

[gloomy gate]

good thanks

had a job interview yesterday

I felt like I did pretty good

[patent aspen]

Part time thank god because I’m still doing school while working

[patent aspen]

Ohhh good luck

[fleet ivy]

Congrats I hope you pass

[fleet ivy]

Oh I see I am in between, i work more than 20 hours and less than 40 hours a week

[gloomy gate]

thx

hope I get the job

[fleet ivy]

You will think positively

[gloomy gate]

why do we have all the welcome messages in here lol

kinda clogs the chat

[patent aspen]

Yeah there should be a join log

[fleet ivy]

Meh no reason to create a separate channel it's fine like this

[gloomy gate]

mhm

[gloomy gate]

see what I mean

[brittle tangle]

Yo

[gloomy gate]

sup

[fleet ivy]

Hey

[deft hawk]

Hmm why was there a deer on my screen?

[gloomy gate]

and another one

[brittle tangle]

Do you know about this Easter egg with the spider?

[gloomy gate]

yea

pretty cool

[fleet ivy]

W

[brittle tangle]

there been some info and now we found the next step if anyone wants to give info would be cool

[deft hawk]

I swear I jus want to play dominos with Tilly

[wet pilot]

Dominoes is fun

[deft hawk]

I want to give her the necklaceee

[wet pilot]

What necklace and who

[deft hawk]

Tilly and a necklace, a requested item

[wet pilot]

Ohh, i forgot they request items been ages since i played the story

Usually online nowadays

Is dominoes stopping u from giving it

?*

[deft hawk]

I can give it to her while playing dominos

[wet pilot]

Then why not give her it

[deft hawk]

Because I’m never able to play dominos with her

[wet pilot]

Ohh

I prefer irl dominoes ngl

[wraith topaz]

where did you find te necklace for her?

[lost karma]

Can I sell these pocket watches to anyone in story mode?

[lost karma]

I swear I have 6 of them

[wet pilot]

Prob fence

[coral mesa]

you can get it anywhere there's a general store.

[stiff orbit]

Whenever I see a rat irl I can’t help but to make a Micah joke 😭

[crisp moon]

👋

[wet pilot]

its not a joke bro

[fleet ivy]

He IS a rat

[winged stag]

Can you play red dead rp on steam deck?

[lost karma]

I am starting to hate any mission Micah is apart of

[winged tangle]

"Micah died" i dont give a fuck

[winged tangle]

i wish strauss chose him to collect downs debt lol

[lost karma]

Nah, we are doing a stagecoach robbery and he going to yell "this is a Robbery" a whole ass mile from the coach

[winged tangle]

Omg i remember the videos where ppl said "Thats how you dont get a tb" and they would come to downes with a mask so blood doesnt get on arthurs face

[lost karma]

I just paid off this bounty. Whyyyy are we shooting people in Strawberry again!

[winged tangle]

Is it your first playthrough?

[lost karma]

Yeah

[winged tangle]

do you know the end?

[lost karma]

Yeah

[winged tangle]

oh

[lost karma]

Or at least Arthur's side of things

[winged tangle]

you can also kill micah in a mission

thats what im talking about

[lost karma]

Will I still have good honor?

[winged tangle]

it wont change bc if u kill micah u will fail the mission

Im talking about strawberry, stagecoach and the last mission

You can kill him with dynamite in strawberry and stagecoach

[winged tangle]

And in the last mission i think you can kill him with hands and block every his attack, but the mission will fail again

[zenith granite]

in chapter two are there any fence shops in the heartlands so i can sell my gold bar (i had to restart my story my save kinda got messed up)

[winged tangle]

No

[zenith granite]

Goddamn it

[winged tangle]

They are in emerald ranch, van horn trading post, rhodes and saint denis

[zenith granite]

oh shit nvm

[gentle sleet]

bro is this a spoiler🫩

[winged tangle]

bro its what mission shows if you kill micah with dynamite

[winged tangle]

its not even the end

[zenith granite]

ive been to emerald ranch

[winged tangle]

Im talking about stagecoach and strawberry jail mission

[zenith granite]

there is a fence in emerald man how the fuck did i not know that

[steel flare]

👋

[gentle sleet]

how do i get gif perms

or pic perms

[orchid torrent]

#general-media

[lost karma]

The oil tankard for John was just sitting outside somewhere random unmanned for anyone to take. Don't mind if I do

[gaunt olive]

hi

[sour swallow]

hello

[lost karma]

ican finally get the mission to fish. (no caps)

[sleek ether]

I just hunted the legendary bear I killed it but the corpse disappeared right when I killed it can I redo it to skin it or is this one time only

[lost karma]

Bot kept deleting my messages because too many caps

[fickle ledge]

i have a plan

[frosty ore]

THATS A SHAME :/

[lost karma]

Oh, do you now?

[fickle ledge]

One last time!

[fickle ledge]

have some god damn faith

[fickle ledge]

one last score

we still need money

to go to tahiti

[harsh sequoia]

rdr3 when

[fickle ledge]

when we arrive to tahiti

[harsh sequoia]

what do u mean by we

😭ii

|no ones left|

[fickle ledge]

WE are a family

[harsh sequoia]

how to spoilee mark

[fickle ledge]

at the start of the message type /spoiler

[leaden wren]

[fickle ledge]

were allive

[harsh sequoia]

/spoiler poopoo

[fickle ledge]

have some goddamn faith!

[lost karma]

I have always used ||

[harsh sequoia]

/spoilerpoopoo

[harsh sequoia]

yesss this

[lost karma]

I have always used ||. At the beginning and end of messages

[harsh sequoia]

works

[fickle ledge]

what edition of rdr2 do you guys have

i have ultimate

[harsh sequoia]

i have reboot

rdr2 reboot

that one

why do my spoiler msgs dont get uploaded

huh

||

oh finally

what

[waxen mesa]

tahiti

[harsh sequoia]

i wish i could play rdr2 again

[lost karma]

Okay, now that I can fish. Can I sell them? Like to the butcher?

[wicked fable]

I wish rdr2 was 60 frames because 30 kill my eyes

[fickle ledge]

you are an odriscoll

get the odriscoll

[harsh sequoia]

its sad u didnt get the best experience for playing peak

[lost karma]

'Ah, yes. Let's bring Micah AND Sean along. That's a wonderful idea!" 🙄

[wicked fable]

Ye really sad

[fickle ledge]

i have 60 fps

[harsh sequoia]

rip get a new pc soon

[wicked fable]

Even tho internet-cafe exist

[harsh sequoia]

i have 100 but its capped to 60 hehe haha lol

[wicked fable]

I can go and play it there

Just to experience 60 frames

[fickle ledge]

im on chapter 6 rn

[harsh sequoia]

ohhh but do they let u make save files

[fickle ledge]

dont spoil

[wicked fable]

Ye even tho I don't care much

[harsh sequoia]

ohh

[wicked fable]

I ll just

Sit 8 Hours straight to enjoy it

[harsh sequoia]

get off internet bro

[harsh sequoia]

how much eould that cost

[fickle ledge]

tfdym

[wicked fable]

Around 8 to 10€

Not much

[harsh sequoia]

spoilers are inevitable as long as u stay on the internet

[harsh sequoia]

woah

[fickle ledge]

get spoil bated

lol

[winged tangle]

Hello

[fickle ledge]

ik the spoilers

[harsh sequoia]

rip

[wicked fable]

I ain't seeing rockstar releasing a new version of the game

[fickle ledge]

i have 51 hours on rdr2

[wicked fable]

Anytime soon for ps5

[fickle ledge]

i startert playing on the 25th of december

[wicked fable]

So this is the only way

[harsh sequoia]

yes thats why computer is peak

[wicked fable]

Ye but its too expensive

[fickle ledge]

should i go get some legendary gunslingers revolvers

[harsh sequoia]

save money

[harsh sequoia]

get the rat's revolver its great

[wicked fable]

It would be too expensive to get a pc that runs rdr2 on 60 frames with a quality of graphics like a console so

[fickle ledge]

im on chapter 6

[fleet ivy]

Hey I left work

[harsh sequoia]

ask parents

[wicked fable]

Pretty much no reason now tho

[fickle ledge]

too early

invest in some stocks

[harsh sequoia]

ohh

[winged tangle]

u can get micahs revolver in chapter 1

[fickle ledge]

im gonna get grangers revolver first

[winged tangle]

but i love legendary gunslingers revolvers too

except billy midnight one, he has a gun that looks like Mauser but its golden

[ocean summit]

BOO

[fleet ivy]

Bo

[fleet ivy]

Welcome

[winged tangle]

So many playstation players

[frosty basalt]

[lost karma]

St. Denis is fancy. Thought it isn't my first time down here, I forgot how much of a sore thumb I was and why I preferred Valentine

[coral mesa]

why can't I post red dead media in #red-dead-media? Literally what it was designed for.

[coral mesa]

I got an Arabian (side note, holy shit they're small), got a fancy outfit, and shaved.

I didn't look as poor once I did that lmao

[scenic sentinel]

The ai bot in here is rlly mean tbh

[fathom herald]

https://tenor.com/view/meowdy-howdy-cat-howdy-cat-in-a-hat-cat-in-the-ten-gallon-hat-gif-27347110

[scenic sentinel]

A talking cat in discord? How can this day be any better

[faint goblet]

how small is the predator baits area of effect

a fox just walked next to it and didnt start nibbling

[somber copper]

[granite herald]

only dutch doesn’t look goofy riding an arabian

[somber copper]

I read that with an Irish accent in my head.

[faint goblet]

i was about to get a fox to nibble on my predator bait, then an ANIMAL WALKED UP BEHIND ME AND BUMPED INTO ME AND GOT SPOOKED

stfu

genuinely

scaring the fox away

[somber copper]

awwh man

[frosty basalt]

Hello Arthur meorgan

[fleet ivy]

Welcome all

[marsh robin]

unwelcome all

[fleet ivy]

Damn

[inland viper]

Navy. Pearson was a proud Navy man.

[inland viper]

Very cool! Did I sign that for you in person? Or was it an online thing?

[frosty ore]

Online!

[obtuse osprey]

it's really cool to see a voice and a motion capture actor for a character in rdr2 in a fan server

[frosty ore]

I unfortunately have not been lucky enough to meet any of the cast face to face, so I instead freak the hell out and screen record my thing being signed 😭

[upbeat mantle]

hey can someone help me learn how to edit game models and make it a mod?

chat GPT sucks asss😭 🙏

[fleet ivy]

Omg hey Jim

[inland kraken]

not using ai is a great start

you could possibly find resources on the internet

[upbeat mantle]

i cant find shit

[dim musk]

I remember I got bored and asked chatgpt about some of the gang members, it said sean was egyptian and charles was caucasian

😭

[upbeat mantle]

"he" is crazy😭 🙏

[dim musk]

meant to say it

used to describing people instead of ai

[inland kraken]

detroit ahh

[upbeat mantle]

ya

[inland kraken]

🥹

[lost karma]

Well, I'm fishing now because I want to kill dutch myself for shooting up my favorite town.

Are we going to a new town now?

[stoic aspen]

I need y'alls help. I'm in the market for my first tattoo, and I'm thinking of getting an arm piece. I'd like to get something red dead related on my arm. Anyone have any idea's for a picture that can be tattoo'd? That'd be great of y'all

[toxic shell]

u could get arthurs hat, or johns if ud like!

it would be a cool tat

[lost karma]

Uhhh, my only tat is a tree, but I want a Monster Hunter one so idk. Maybe a revolver or something

[lost karma]

Or this

[toxic shell]

so sick

[lost karma]

I want one of my favorite monster stamp from the game.

[stoic aspen]

There was this one I saw online, of Arthur's grave. I think that would also be pretty cool

I'll see if I can find a picture to use for an example

[lost karma]

"I got a plan!'

   -Dutch

Kinda want to go to blackwater and get this kid's book

[viscid basin]

I’m back

I was muted for two weeks

[stoic aspen]

2 weeks?

Might I ask what happened?

[viscid basin]

For saying the current president of the United States last name

That’s literally it

One word

[stoic aspen]

Wow

That's sad

[obtuse osprey]

also don't say jenny's surname

[viscid basin]

Super liberal mods clearly

[stoic aspen]

I can't say I'm surprised

[viscid basin]

Lmao yeah

I wasn’t even supporting him

I just said his last name

Wait lemme try it

I’ll dm you if I get muted

Jenny Kirk

[elder rain]

Charlie

?

[obtuse osprey]

wait wow

Rip

[near meadow]

tbh, i thought i fixed the jenny kirk bit but i never saved it lmao so jenny kirk is now fine

[obtuse osprey]

might want to unmute him maybe

[near meadow]

if they want to tempt fate and try to test bots then no smh

[stoic aspen]

Guess he got lucky?

[near meadow]

plus timeouts don't go past a week so it wasn't 2 weeks

[stoic aspen]

Unless a mod just timed him out again for a second week 😂 😭

[obtuse osprey]

i think he is just a big fan of jennifer and wanted to say full name

[near meadow]

it happened on the 29th and expired on the 5th at 5:27pm

[near meadow]

no he went to say charlie's too

so

[thin shell]

Is rdr2 online still active or is it mostly dead?

[zenith granite]

pretty active sometimes

most times actually

[thin shell]

Oh reallyyy

I cant seem to find players

So I always end up playing story mode HAHAH

😔

[kind forge]

Me and the crew I’m in are pretty active on Xbox, just depends on the server. Some have a ton of blueberries and others are empty

[thin shell]

Omg funnn

[near meadow]

also depends where you are

go to a town, sit in it for a bit then pause, online and free roam, it usually finds a session where there's players in that town you're in

[thin shell]

Thank you for the tip!

[lost karma]

Am I about to be close to a new town? Dutch and I just fled Valentine

Taking a break from missions to fish and hunt and I hope there is a new butchers (that also takes fish).

[kind forge]

Yeahhhhh I think Rhodes is next?

[lost karma]

It is like St Denis or more like Valentine?

[kind forge]

It’s nicer than valentine

Not quite Saint Denis

[lost karma]

Thank you. Saint Denis is fine and all but I keep running into people by accident

[zenith granite]

I know its a nice city but that sucks i do it too

[lost karma]

I lost a poker match and I ran by accident getting up a little too hard, falling into someone's arms and almost got arrested for "disturbing the peace."

[kind forge]

lol yeah Rhodes is much less crowded than Saint Denis

Less things to run into

[lost karma]

Was there even a butchers at St. Denis? My kid is awake now so I can't play RDR2- would be nice, but the only word I would be able to teach her is "horse."

[kind forge]

Yeah there is

He’s kinda hidden in a little shop

[lost karma]

I think once I get to this new town, I'll pay my fines and go off on my own again for a while.

[subtle tide]

I might uninstall then install my game from Steam due to a problem with it . Will my progress in the online and offline game still be there. Or will all my progress be lost

[fossil brook]

Burps

[leaden wren]

[marsh robin]

excuse you

[prime quail]

Bans

[whole dawn]

Would you guys choose gta6 or RDR3

[marsh robin]

rdr4. rdr2 is rdr3.

[marsh robin]

hello folks

[quaint zenith]

DUTCH

van der Linde gang is the gang im in

[coral mesa]

Same! Like, people, I ain't stopping this half-ton animal just cause you can't move outta the damn way

[lost karma]

My parents own a horse farm. You get out of the way, not the other way around.

[marsh robin]

i hate trying to ride in saint denis bro

[lost karma]

Rdr

[marsh robin]

word girl mentioned, peak

[lost karma]

I just walk but the town is so big. I just prefer not going there at all

[lost karma]

Thank you

[gloomy storm]

nah seriously man im actually devastated i just finished chapter 6 oh my gosh bro

[coral mesa]

"you" as in the people on foot?

[lost karma]

Anyone. Nobody should be in front of a horse that might or might not stop

I don't think anyone wants to take that type of Gamble

[coral mesa]

yeah
I meant like, in this case, did you mean the people walking on foot
but you answered the question

[lost karma]

In this case, I mean the city folks. I don't mean to run people over, but I rather look like Superman trying to get out of the way than Yamcha

[coral mesa]

...I don't get the reference 😔

who is yamcha

[lost karma]

Dragon Ball Z. I'll show a gif or something in #general-media

[shy merlin]

“cant go over it, cant go under it, gotta go through it!”

[lost karma]

Point is, Yamcha died

[shy merlin]

the little lad who went to the market with his granny watching some cowboy absolutely flatten her:😦😦😦

[lost karma]

Spoiler for a show that's been out for almost 40 years

[west briar]

sean?

[whole dawn]

Ye everyone starts as Arthur in the Van der linde gang

[shy merlin]

now this dont feel right? icoulda told ya tha-🧠

[coral mesa]

oh. so like, you'd rather the NPCs dive out of the way or smth?

[quaint zenith]

I was referring to a song 😭

[quaint zenith]

I’ve played the game a long time ago

[shy merlin]

i love my horsey and my horsey love me

[lost karma]

Or something, not just sit there and take a horse to a gut and get the cops on me for an accident

[quaint zenith]

Exactlyyyy

[marsh robin]

SEAN

[whole dawn]

@rockstar games can we start working on rdr3 please

[shy merlin]

john watch out, agent milton

[marsh robin]

i love sean

[quaint zenith]

Me too

[near meadow]

peacefulsean emoji

[shy merlin]

whos tryna run some CTA?

[whole dawn]

[oak dove]

Someone in this channel must've asked about finding players in a non-lfg (looking for group) channel. Please ask to find players in the proper lfg channels, being #xbox-lfg, #ps-lfg or #pc-lfg

[west briar]

micah?

[marsh robin]

[whole dawn]

Y

[lost karma]

I have had Epona for 18 hours, but if someone hurts Epona, I will burn everything down (in the game).

[whole dawn]

This is like crime against humanity

[west briar]

POOR arthu

[marsh robin]

he's a pedo btw

[coral mesa]

I mean like

if you have a total lack of survival instincts to the point where you see a thousand-pound animal walking towards you without stopping and don't get out of the way

then you should not get to call the cops for that level of mind-numbing stupidity

[lost karma]

Every time I am around him, I have to pay a bounty. I have to spend my hard earned money to be his friend.

[whole dawn]

It’s just a game

[west briar]

🤨

[whole dawn]

[marsh robin]

[west briar]

low honor

[lost karma]

I have pretty high honor

[coral mesa]

I have had Ambrosia for uhh

almost however many hours I've spent in the game (prolly 50 or so)

if that horse dies I will make your threat look like child's play. idk how yet. but I will. in game of course.

[west briar]

same here

[coral mesa]

[lost karma]

Yeah, I didn't know how the server would take threats of fictional violence. She's my horsie. I even wrote a RDR2 drabble fanfiction for her

I feel bad the few times she died, but I always got my vengeance. I don't mind paying off that bounty

[coral mesa]

fair enough. I think the "in game" disclaimer works fine for that.

wait you what? you're a writer?

[lost karma]

I am called Word Girl for a reason.

[coral mesa]

...I should have seen that coming 😭

[lost karma]

My fanfiction link is in my bio if you really want to know, and I write original stuff, but that, somehow, is more embarrassing

[coral mesa]

damn your horse is just like "alr ima just un-die rq"? /j

[west briar]

it's sad to have max level on your horse and in the end the horse die then arthur will sit by the horse

[lost karma]

Yeah, I got revives (which apparently I'm glad is a thing)

[lost karma]

Wut

[coral mesa]

yeah, I always carry a horse reviver on me

[lost karma]

What?

[coral mesa]

Like the tonic thing

Horse Reviver

[lost karma]

Yeah, I got it. I thought my horse died, story wise, permanently

[waxen mesa]

tahiti

[lost karma]

You're killing me, smalls /ref

[west briar]

what mission is your favorite?

[lost karma]

It's my first playthrough, and I can't tell the difference between missions and optional stuff, because I love it all. EXCEPT MICAH

[west briar]

same

[coral mesa]

please stop saying untrue things

[trail steeple]

Do we have a tiktoker role?

[west briar]

ok

[lost karma]

I think I am going to ignore John for a while and go back to St. Denis to pay off my Valentine bounty.

I want to go get the kid's book from Blackwater

Anybody did that yet? Is it hard?

[west briar]

yes i did

[wintry sun]

is there a mod in rdr2 that makes fire in the game better?

[west briar]

idk

[lost karma]

Was it hard?

[west briar]

yes just looking for the book

[lost karma]

I want to but I might go on foot. Problem is I know if I run into animals, I'll get distracted and want to hunt.

[near pewter]

Evening 🍺

[west briar]

get the shotgun

[lost karma]

Maybe I should talk to John first to find the town and then make my way down there.

[west briar]

the book is not in blackwater

[lost karma]

Will John need me for a while after re- locating?

[lost karma]

I thought it was. I am not looking at my missions right now as I can't be on my game while my daughter is awake.

Where is it?

[proven aspen]

[lost karma]

She's 2.

She'll get into everything

[west briar]

outside of saint denis

[lost karma]

Oh.

Idk why I thought it was in Blackwater.

I'll put it in my to-do list, but that means I have to go to Emerald Station, make a wife birth around Valentine, even maybe, stop by the post office. I hope it won't be too high

[west briar]

by an abandoned house one of them swamp

[lost karma]

Thank you

I have about 500$. I haven't had a bounty over 75

No, I lied. I think I had one 300

[shy merlin]

on my low honor arthur i achieved the limit of 1500 for each state

[lost karma]

How in Red Dead Hell did you do that?

Nevermind

Don't answer that

[shy merlin]

i dont think u want to know.

probably spent about 10K in bullets

im not proud of what these hands have done😔

[lost karma]

I replenish my bullets but that's a little extreme

Is that why I have so much money?;

Also, why should I give money to camp donations?

[west briar]

yes

[shy merlin]

only for honor

if u want to achieve high bonor

[lost karma]

Tossing back fish gives you honor too, but keeping them doesn't take honor away

[shy merlin]

plus i lake to make the camp look cool

and they have pretry funny dialogue if the camp id happy

[lost karma]

I don't even spend any time at camp, not if I can avoid it

[frosty ore]

You should.

There's loads of camp interaction

[shy merlin]

yesssssss it makes it feel worse when the gang splits up tho, i had attachments to all the characters

like uncle plays with jack

[lost karma]

I interact when I go through missions, but if I'm not at the poker table, hunting, fishing, or falling down a cliff by accident, I'm probably not doing much at all

[shy merlin]

charles teaching jack how to make a bow etc

[simple nacelle]

Hello

[west briar]

i like lenny

[shy merlin]

wow

lENNayyyy

is that enough caps for you sheriff?

[frosty ore]

LENNAYYYY

[lost karma]

Lenny alright. God, Lenny, Micah, and Sean in the same room and I am turning right back around and out the door I go

[frosty ore]

What did Lenny and Sean do

[lost karma]

Nope

[agile musk]

the lenny meme is unfunny imo

i just don’t like it

[frosty ore]

Its to overdone

[agile musk]

exactly

[shy merlin]

jeez mate who pissed in ur cheerios

[agile musk]

especially by rdr2 tiktok

[shy merlin]

nahhhh rdr2 tiktok fandom is evil

[agile musk]

i see it atleast twice a day because for some reason it’s spammed as shit

it’s like nickleback

but red dead 2

[shy merlin]

they ship john and arthur the dont got an option

[obtuse osprey]

rdr2 on insta...

[shy merlin]

opinion

[lost karma]

Lenny? Not a darn thing and that's the point

[agile musk]

charthur is just outright stupid

[frosty ore]

Let people ship who they want to ship

As long as they're both adults. There's nothing wrong with that.

[lost karma]

This.

[agile musk]

when it’s two canonically straight men that see eachother as brothers it’s kinda weird

[frosty ore]

You've obviously not been in fandom space enough.

[lost karma]

And?

[shy merlin]

exactly

literal family

[frosty ore]

As long as they're both adults. Nothing wrong with it.

[agile musk]

it’s even worse considering arthur and john both already have love interests

[fleet ivy]

I agree

[shy merlin]

100%

[fleet ivy]

It's weird

[misty slate]

[obtuse osprey]

i agree

[velvet sparrow]

. I think there should be a barrier cuz they're literally family like adopted brothers they are siblings

[lost karma]

I don't ship them, but I don't find it weird if others do

[fleet ivy]

They're family, not by blood but surely by bond

[shy merlin]

only people who disagree is the tiktok booktok girls who read wattpad whos husbands dont give them enough attention

[lost karma]

You ever been in the supernatural fandom?

[frosty ore]

So I don't read wattpad, not have a husband

So let people ship who they want. It doesn't affect you.

[lost karma]

I have a husband, but not on Whattpad or tiktok

[shy merlin]

ye but ur weird so it cancels out

[frosty ore]

You're also weird x

[velvet sparrow]

. I mean I don't ship them personally but I find it weird a Lil but overall idc

[velvet sparrow]

. Na

[fleet ivy]

Same thing as shipping Dexter and Debra for example

It was gross

[obtuse osprey]

John? Incest?
Yeah. Incest
Of course, pal whatever you think is best

[shy merlin]

at least i dont ship two canonically straight men who are like family

[shy merlin]

THIS

[lost karma]

Well, you're really gonna be weirded out if you went into that fandom

[frosty ore]

Hey it's never explicitly mentioned they're straight

[velvet sparrow]

. There's a reason I'm not in it by now probably

[frosty ore]

Nor does it really matter

[agile musk]

if you want to ship characters, i’d say there are 3 rules to not make it overly weird:

Make sure they do NOT see eachother as siblings.

i’d say atleast try to make their “ship” canon to their sexuality

Don’t force it on other people, especially those who find it disgusting / unappealing

[lost karma]

And bi people exist even back in cowboy times

[shy merlin]

both have love interests who are female. its canon they are straight

[velvet sparrow]

. This

[frosty ore]

Mans never obviously heard of bisexuals ig

[shy merlin]

yep exactly

[lost karma]

Right?

[shy merlin]

its not canon

ur feelings does not make that canon to the gamr

[frosty ore]

Is it canon they're straight?

[velvet sparrow]

. It's not Canon that they're straight either nor part of LGBT

[lost karma]

"They have been with a woman so they have to be straight!"

[coral mesa]

what did i just come back to 😭

[lost karma]

Not unless Arthur straight up said it himself, and I doubt he did

[velvet sparrow]

. So people have free will to do their own AUs and do what the fuck they want

[frosty ore]

It's not canon for them to be bi, nor straight nor anything cause it's not said x

[frosty ore]

Exactly 😩

[agile musk]

if i’m correct, most men and women in red dead 2 show interests to only the opposite gender; not saying that there’s anything wrong with being homosexual however, bill is one of my favourite characters

[obtuse osprey]

people that consider shipping jm and arthur normal vs people who consider that weird

[fleet ivy]

Let's leave out sexuality and focus on the main problem here. They're family

[hearty anchor]

We need money

[shy merlin]

google is free, they cut the charles arthur love interest canon before the game even came out

[hearty anchor]

Because I'm broke.

[shy merlin]

exactly

[velvet sparrow]

. I personally don't ship siblings or adopted siblings like adopted or not they see each other as siblings

[frosty ore]

Hey we didn't even bring up sexuality first. You guys did.

[agile musk]

and yes, roger clark does address things like charthur and says it is interesting, but he doesn’t state that’s it a canon nor that he thinks it is lore important

[velvet sparrow]

. Like you have friends you see as siblings and if someone shipped you w them you would be weirded out

[lost karma]

People married their own cousins back then

[frosty ore]

I said let people ship whatever the fuck they want aslong as they're adults.

[agile musk]

that’s my fault sorry, i brought up arthur being straight

[fleet ivy]

It's weird to ship brothers

Sorry

[shy merlin]

at the end of the day shipping two brothers is weird, even if theyre adults

[velvet sparrow]

. Me too, I just might find some weird but I wouldn't force nobody to not ship or ship them

[amber sentinel]

Never forget how Arthur wanted to marry Abigail "many years before she fell for Marston"

She fell for him when she was 18 btw. Arthur wanted to marry a minor.

[obtuse osprey]

actually that even happens in the game but i won't spoil much lol

[lost karma]

Yeah, I know it

[agile musk]

aberdeen

and murfree brood

[lost karma]

18 isn't a minor? I met my now husband at 18

[shy merlin]

literally the serial killer couple are siblings, but that doesnt make it okay to ship other siblings

[agile musk]

he was much older than her

[velvet sparrow]

. Yea

[lost karma]

My husband is 22 years older than me

I got that point

[agile musk]

that’s wild

[wary kindle]

playing w my irl friend and our mini mapd disappeared this MF goes "just go without the map it's more immersive go with the flow dawg 😎"

grown ass man

[agile musk]

but you do you i guess

[wary kindle]

MY NAME I'm Mr graham the second im ur king

[shy merlin]

again my point stands, it is weird and ruins the fandom when all they talk about is shipping brothers

[agile musk]

i’m nobody to poke at another’s marriage

[frosty ore]

Difference is. They're related. John and Arthur are not.

I don't ship them, I ship someone else. But you have to know that they're not physically related via blood

[near meadow]

before she fell for marston

she fell for him at 18

so what's before 18?

[shy merlin]

their brotherly bond is very well shown in the game, THEY grow up with eachother

blood or not theyre still brothers

[frosty ore]

UhM akSuLLy

Arthur was already grown

[agile musk]

i see my best friend as practically a brother, if i saw two people ship us as lovers, i’d be appalled. this is my personal point

[frosty ore]

Good you added personal

[shy merlin]

okay so he basically raised john, my point still stands. someone should check on ur siblings

[velvet sparrow]

. Yea but other people have their own AUs and in that little AU you can change the whole story into your OWN

[coral mesa]

do we know that she fell for him at 18 tho?

like
legit question cause i don't actually know the lore behind this

[lost karma]

Then it could have been a minor, depends on her birthday

But then, 1899 is also a different time period. Even here, where I live, you can marry at 16, if your parents sign off on it

[shy merlin]

doesnt make it not weird

[fleet ivy]

But like... Not trying to sound rude and I'm just expressing my opinion but

It's the same as shipping Dexter and Debra from the Dexter series. It was a weird ass plot

[near meadow]

abigail is 22
jack is 4-5

[wary kindle]

i love you guys but i also agree i think shipping john x arthur is weird if that's what we're talking about

[dim river]

Hi world

[obtuse osprey]

canonically no jm or arthur morgan ship was meant to happen inthe game thats it. and now it's all up to the community

[velvet sparrow]

. I'm not saying it's not weird I find it weird myself but at the end of the day it's their AU their opinion I won't fight over it

[fleet ivy]

Yeah that's we're talking about

[shy merlin]

yes

[dim river]

eugh

[agile musk]

he’s 4 at the time of read dead 2

[velvet sparrow]

. Hi Tessa

[lost karma]

I don't ship anyone, but you can't call someone else weird for their own ships

[wary kindle]

are you agreeing with me

[dim river]

boi what the hell boi

[coral mesa]

how do we know jack is 4-5
that feels like an estimate to me

[dim river]

YES

[wary kindle]

Ok good omg i thought you said eugh to ME

[fleet ivy]

I'm not calling someone weird, I'm saying it's weird shipping Arthur and John

[dim river]

NO OMG

[shy merlin]

yes, yes u can its called an opinion and everyone is entitled to one

[obtuse osprey]

ok well then whats jack age in 1911 and then just subtract

[agile musk]

but you can understand our points, it’s weird to ship two men who see eachother as brothers of different blood

[hexed mulch]

Is there a corner of this server where people talk about the new easter egg stuff?

[frosty ore]

I was to distracted talking about letting people ship who they want I ran out of time hunting a bounty 😭

[coral mesa]

what is his age in 1911? i don't know.

[velvet sparrow]

. Well u can express how you feel about it

[frosty ore]

14

[agile musk]

16

[near meadow]

so 22-4 is 18 and she fell for him when jack was born or probably when she was with him in that smelly ass tent

[coral mesa]

hooooooold on.

i'm getting conflicting answers.

[obtuse osprey]

Jack Marston was born in 1895, making him 4 years old. during the story of Red Dead 2, we see him age from 4. to 12 to 16, and then finally 19 in the year 1914. see boom

[lost karma]

People ship siblings. I personally don't, but I'm also not going to judge others who do as it is not my place.

[velvet sparrow]

. Yea

[fleet ivy]

?? It's literally incest

[agile musk]

he wasn’t 16 in red dead 2 :think:

[dim river]

okay so theres actually a law against this!

[obtuse osprey]

he was 16 in rdr1

[frosty ore]

Mans never seen a harry potter fandom

[obtuse osprey]

he was 12 in rdr2

[lost karma]

It's also not real life

[obtuse osprey]

he was 19 by the end of rdr1

[prime quail]

Fun Fact

RD1 / Red Dead 1 = Revolver

RD2 / Red Dead 2 = Redemption 1

RD3 / Red Dead 3 = Redemption 2

[lost karma]

Not in my state.

[shy merlin]

“im just gonna sit back and be okay with incest because if not me then i dont care” ah personality

[fleet ivy]

It is wrong equally

[coral mesa]

So

in 1911

is he 12, 14, or 16?

[obtuse osprey]

in 1911 hes 16

[fleet ivy]

Doesn't matter what fandom is

[obtuse osprey]

in 1914 hes 19

[agile musk]

12 in the epilogue, 16 in the start of red dead 1, then 19

[shy merlin]

amen

[dim river]

this is not the response you think it is

[fleet ivy]

Sorry Merlin but it's weird as fuck

[lost karma]

Because I don't. It's not real life. It's a video game.

[agile musk]

this is why america deserves annihilation

[lost karma]

I didn't say it was a good thing

[fleet ivy]

I didn't hear this right

[shy merlin]

okay then dont even comment ur obv not in this argument

[agile musk]

america isn’t tho

[coral mesa]

so if he's 12 in 1911
and the game takes place in 1899
that means he was born in 1899

[fleet ivy]

Right

[agile musk]

16 in 1911

[neat cedar]

whos marrying their family members 💔

[near meadow]

you mfs going on about incest, that's the most american thing i've ever heard

[obtuse osprey]

16 in 1911

[agile musk]

apparently some american states

[lost karma]

It's fictional. Y'all caring too much about this

[obtuse osprey]

he's 4

[coral mesa]

oh.

[neat cedar]

gross

[obtuse osprey]

its confirmed information he's 4 in 1899

[lost karma]

It is

[agile musk]

exactly

[obtuse osprey]

he's born in 1895

[shy merlin]

only the americans are the ones who dont care that shipping john and arthur is basically incest

[lost karma]

But it is also legal.

[coral mesa]

Meaning he was born in 1895.

[obtuse osprey]

correct

[fleet ivy]

You're okay with incest?

[agile musk]

america deserves annihilation

[lost karma]

Isn't Arthur American?

[neat cedar]

just bc its legal doesn't mean its okay 💀

[dim river]

no

[shy merlin]

based off this conversation we gotta nuke the whole world

[dim river]

lolz

[coral mesa]

and how old is Abigail?

[shy merlin]

half the population is trying to justify incest rn

[fleet ivy]

What the fuck is going on

[obtuse osprey]

dutch wasn't okay with incest. remember that one scene in chapter 6

john? incest?
yeah. incest
of course, pal whatever you think is best

[dim river]

i have no idea but i do not like it

[shy merlin]

europe is better

[agile musk]

on top bro

[fleet ivy]

I am hating this

[lost karma]

I'm justifying it. I'm justifying pro-shipping

[shy merlin]

i love being slavic

[fleet ivy]

Oh hell no

[dim river]

how.. old are you??

[shy merlin]

bro fr..

[coral mesa]

just gonna put out there that I was not shipping anyone during this conversation

[lost karma]

How old do you think I am?

[fleet ivy]

12

[coral mesa]

for the record

[shy merlin]

11

[obtuse osprey]

holy crap make sure they dont edit it to "how old are you" ⚠️ this is discord

[dim river]

too old to be acting like this !

[coral mesa]

they have a 2 yo daughter bro
they literally said this 😭

[fleet ivy]

Nah I'm 18 I can show my id to mods

[near meadow]

they aren't siblings so it wouldn't be incest anyway plus they're like 10 years apart in age so arthur would've been like 22 since john joined when he was 12 so they weren't really raised as siblings either unless you count a decade of sibling gaps in non siblings

[lost karma]

They don't pay attention

[obtuse osprey]

i'd still not take the risk, i've been banned for saying a fake age before

[fleet ivy]

I'm being sarcastic

[neat cedar]

[agile musk]

plus the chat was moving fast, no wonder it slipped past

[shy merlin]

they grew up tg, its mentioned multiple times that arthur is basically like a father figure/brother to john, they had no family besides eachother, they were family. it is incest and it is weird