general

[hidden robin]

Get in bed

[pine otter]

Its 8am 😴

[hidden robin]

What the fuck.

You fucking lied to me.

[abstract bramble]

oop

[orchid torrent]

W dyno

[abstract bramble]

I Sent like two msgs ...

[hidden robin]

[pine otter]

I just want to sleep 😖😖🥀

[hidden robin]

Ok ok babe I'm sorry I'll let you sleep

[pine otter]

Okay now i guess im not going to sleep 🫢

[near mountain]

then fucking go to sleep

[hidden robin]

NO

[pine otter]

Sybau..

[pine otter]

🤢

[near mountain]

nuh uh

[pine otter]

[hidden robin]

what did I do..

[near mountain]

😝

[pine otter]

Nothing

[hidden robin]

Then what was that for 🥺

[pine otter]

No

[near mountain]

he’s a sleep deprived insomniac

[pine otter]

WHO?

[near mountain]

you

[pine otter]

Im sad now

Misgendering is crazy 😖

[hidden robin]

Don't worry I'm right here

[near mountain]

did i hurt yo feelings😢

[pine otter]

Yes..

[near mountain]

oh come here lil baby

[pine otter]

Ew

[hidden robin]

Ahem

You want to take a step back now budzo

[hidden robin]

check #general-media which pfp

[near mountain]

✋😭✋

[near mountain]

how come u can send gifs

[uncut lotus]

This is a sticker

[near mountain]

oh

[near mountain]

me sped

[pine otter]

Ew

[near mountain]

like bertram

[near mountain]

oh yeah ur a female

my bad

😭

[pine otter]

Finally

[near mountain]

lol

[hidden robin]

#general-media which pfp

[orchid torrent]

Shut up hex

[near mountain]

the dutch smoking one

[hidden robin]

There’s 2

[near mountain]

the one with the cigar closer to his mouth

[formal elk]

I just farted

[uncut lotus]

Ban vanda

[pine otter]

Funky

[vale ingot]

guys where do i ask if i have issue with rdr2 not starting?

[near mountain]

[uncut lotus]

Google

[pine otter]

Lmao

[formal elk]

if ur on pc

[hidden robin]

okay I’ll put on and see if u like it

[formal elk]

prob not enough ram left or space

[near mountain]

okie

[vale ingot]

Shut up Hex 😢

[near mountain]

wrong emoji

[pine otter]

Poor Hex

[hidden robin]

there

[formal elk]

modding rdr2 is so fun gng

[near mountain]

peak

[pine otter]

Whaf

[formal elk]

i love the dodge charger mod

[hidden robin]

I’ll put on my fav hold on

[pine otter]

Arent you on playstation?

[near mountain]

Indubitably so

[uncut lotus]

Ouuh

[formal elk]

i main playstation

[hidden robin]

Ok

[hidden robin]

this is my favourite one

[pine otter]

This

[formal elk]

tho me and my friends mess with rdr2 on pc

[hidden robin]

Hi babe

[near mountain]

also fire

[near mountain]

wut….

[pine otter]

😐

[hidden robin]

I call everyone babe dw babe

[hidden robin]

babe

[orchid torrent]

[near mountain]

ok babe

[hidden robin]

Babe

[hidden robin]

babe

[hidden robin]

Alr babe

[uncut lotus]

Vanda log off

[hidden robin]

Why babe

[hidden robin]

Babe I’ll kill ur ass

[pine otter]

Lmao

[orchid torrent]

[hidden robin]

(dutch)

[hidden robin]

Really?!? 🥹

[near mountain]

no more ass

[hidden robin]

yes bc of dutch

[pine otter]

Oh

[hidden robin]

Ok you can stab me or shoot me or wtv

[near mountain]

[formal elk]

arthur betary dutch me sad i cry

[orchid torrent]

I waited 10 minutes to get an iced coffee and it's not even good💔

[near mountain]

fr

[pine otter]

Did you make it or get it somewhere

[orchid torrent]

Can we ban hex?

[pine otter]

???

[uncut lotus]

skill issue

[orchid torrent]

[near mountain]

[hidden robin]

Can't believe John would rat to agent milton like that..

[formal elk]

fr

i sad that happens i cry beacause not cool they betray dutch i now so i crys

[prime quail]

homohexual has been banned.
Reason: No reason needed.

_vanda. has been banned.
Reason: No reason needed.

[orchid torrent]

finally

[formal elk]

My grammar is amazing

[orchid torrent]

[near mountain]

i was sad when arthur didnt let homeboy be a celonian

[formal elk]

Im gay to bro thats the thing 😭

[uncut lotus]

W

[pine otter]

LMAO

[hidden robin]

Cover up the face and she's a 10/10

[formal elk]

thank god he got banned

[uncut lotus]

Still a 10

[pine otter]

Shes cute anyway

🙄

[orchid torrent]

Our honeymoon🎶

LILITH

[hidden robin]

We have our own preferences dickhead

[near mountain]

do they let me say my fav slur here

[uncut lotus]

W album and song

[pine otter]

WHAT

[pine otter]

Tsk

[formal elk]

😮

[orchid torrent]

never trust people who use dark mode on discord

[pine otter]

Oh

[formal elk]

i use dark mode

[hidden robin]

check #general-media someone made a rdr2 trailer

[near mountain]

dont trust me then

[uncut lotus]

My mode is basically shit

[formal elk]

even phone i do

[orchid torrent]

light mode >>

[pine otter]

My eyes hurt from that

[formal elk]

light mode is ass gng

[orchid torrent]

Skill issue

[hidden robin]

Lemme guess liking people based on their features makes me a bad person hm

[pine otter]

I know, thats why i dont use light mode

[hidden robin]

sounds like u have brown eyes

[formal elk]

No bro it just hurts my eyes

[pine otter]

Im not going to say yes but yeah

[pine otter]

This

[formal elk]

i have blue eyes

[hidden robin]

check #general-media someone made a rdr2 trailer

[pine otter]

I have green eyes🤤🤤🤤

[uncut lotus]

Why would we need a trailer of a 7 years old game

[worn yacht]

[hidden robin]

I have light blue/ocean blue

[hidden robin]

Oh fuck you

[pine otter]

Ooo

[hidden robin]

redhead?

[hidden robin]

someone just did I don’t know the answer to everything

[pine otter]

No..? I have dark brown hair (it just reflects as very dark red)

[pine otter]

I will 😝

[formal elk]

wanna be gay with me?

jk

[pine otter]

If you beg?

[formal elk]

idk why i said that

[pine otter]

Lmao

[hidden robin]

Oh my

[formal elk]

Please!!!

[pine otter]

Im a girl and im gay

[hidden robin]

Fuck.

Fuck you

[pine otter]

OK

[formal elk]

well im a guy and im gay

[hidden robin]

why did i get banned in the other rdo server for my profile pic?

Fucking fuck shit

[pine otter]

YAY?!

[hidden robin]

seems chill here

[formal elk]

:3

[hidden robin]

Who is it

[formal elk]

🤤

[pine otter]

Twins?

[formal elk]

wut

[pine otter]

😖😖😖 this is embarrassing

[hidden robin]

Gays

[hidden robin]

its joseph goebbels

[hidden robin]

Uhh then idk

[prime quail]

Never forget how with high honor, Javier still points at Arthur

[formal elk]

o///o

[hidden robin]

"I gooned to Micah today John"

[pine otter]

-/////-

[orchid torrent]

Real and true

[formal elk]

i gooned to astolfo

[orchid torrent]

mods ban that word

[hidden robin]

Haven't we all

[pine otter]

Whos astolfo

🥀

[hidden robin]

FUCK

[formal elk]

a hot dude

[hidden robin]

YOU

[pine otter]

Well thats rude

[hidden robin]

I'm joking babe

[pine otter]

Ill have to take your word on that

[pine otter]

Im not

[hidden robin]

Oh sorrrry.

[pine otter]

😐

[hidden robin]

No I mean it 😖

[grand brook]

Hí

[pine otter]

Okay😭😭

[pine otter]

Hi

I can't do special letters🥀

[grand brook]

Wat

[pine otter]

What does that even have to do with anything 😞

[prime quail]

#general message
#general message

[grand brook]

I think its the Astofo guy

I dont know who he is

[pine otter]

Oh okay

[pine otter]

Oh okayy

[edgy mason]

Dining in?🤔

[little field]

buying a new xbox just so i can hop on rdo 🙏

i got like no progress on my pc so

yeah

[lament skiff]

Hi y'all

[hidden skiff]

Nice

[lament skiff]

I just bought a ps4 from a garage sale for 20$

fire games wallahi

[lament skiff]

best thing I've ever did

buy that ps4

[edgy mason]

Thong

[lament skiff]

thong

but y'all think this is good for 20$?

2 controllers

one has stick drift

a hard drive with 1TB in it

half of it is used

and..

good games

[neon lynx]

howdy

[glad fiber]

howdy partner

[trim acorn]

if you mean why it wasnt used in story its because in RDR1 john says hes never been down there before

[forest apex]

If rdr3 happens, rockstar needs to get rid of the p2p servers and use dedicated. Bootingnoffline is such a cowards tool

[raven silo]

[echo cloud]

Kuki

[plush abyss]

Hello chat

[fleet island]

Good thing that will never happen

[echo cloud]

[trim acorn]

i ate cheese but it was actually butter ☹️

[forest apex]

Yall a bunch of miserable pessimists in here 😂 I swear none of you can be positive

[fleet island]

I just said one thing and you wanna talk about no one being positive?

Real smooth

[echo cloud]

I don’t like cheesecake

I’m scared of it

[trim acorn]

RDR3 is NOT happening 😔 ✌️

[forest apex]

Yeah cause the only thing you said was good thing it’s not going to happen. That’s the definition of pessimism. As if you 100% know rdr3 isn’t going to happen

[fleet island]

If you want positivity maybe calling someone you just met with “Miserable pessimist” isn’t a good start

[forest apex]

Saw a duck I called it a duck. Maybe the response of good thing rdr3 isn’t happening isn’t a good start

[fleet island]

Then you ain’t getting the positivity you want if you’re gonna rub yourself that way against someone

Sorry, that’s how the true world works, miserable pessimist

[fleet island]

Also, why would there BE a rdr3. Dan houser and lazlow jones LEFT rdr2 and they were prominent writers.

[echo cloud]

Why can cheese be cheeseburger but burgers can’t be burgercheese

That’s not right

[forest apex]

Oh no, two prominent writes left. Better scrap the whole franchise instead of hiring two different writers who can write a different story apart from the vanderlinde gang. As if companies haven’t gone through multiple prominent employees and kept a franchise going

[trim acorn]

holy shit

a server im in jsut got raided

[fleet island]

Going farther back in the past wouldn’t conclude any reasoning for a redemption.. going further forward in the future isn’t gonna have anything with Jack if the wild western era is over. What would there be a point of a new cast of characters when rdo is already a thing and no need for a story about it if the main factors of rdr2 or rdr1 were already said and done to the point the new cast of characters not have any reason to make rdr3.

[forest apex]

Raided, as in couple crews filling the lobby?

[trim acorn]

yeah they changed the server name and channels are filling up pinging everyone

[forest apex]

That makes no sense, the new story could literally be anything. Son of a war hero that got killed by an outlaw gang, son that’s a pos redeems himself by killing the father’s murderers, or something with a love interest. The redemption arc can involve infinite possibilities

[fleet island]

Then make your own story off of that

[forest apex]

Don’t need the same cast, area or ere. Prime of outlaw time or something

[fleet island]

Why would rockstar wanna make a new game that they already have 2 games to fulfill the entire point of rdr in general.

[trim acorn]

okay so the owners are actually fighting

and one of them raided because they're mad

[trim acorn]

i just want revolver 2

[fleet island]

What’s the whole point of revolver 2

[trim acorn]

have you played Revolver 1

[fleet island]

Red harlow already got what he wanted to accomplish

[trim acorn]

ooh

what about a remake i just really want more revolver content

[fleet island]

sure there can be a remake

[trim acorn]

the changing of characters thing was pretty cool

[forest apex]

Because they can do more stories? With different characters? Why bother making gta 6, when all the other gta games are about crime?

[trim acorn]

But more redemption? stupid

[fleet island]

Don’t understand why you’d want red dead revolver 2 when red harlow’s story is finished

[trim acorn]

Nah you're right it does seem to make no sense

[fleet island]

Then make your own if you’re so inclined to wanting more stories or different characters

R better yet

Play rdo

[trim acorn]

okay so the owners really are fighting

[fleet island]

Different characters, no?

[forest apex]

As I said, pessimistic. You can’t even begin to fathom why or how rockstar could make a rdr3

[trim acorn]

and they tried to ban each other

[fleet island]

Different storyline, no?

[fleet island]

You can’t even begin to fathom why they shouldn’t or how they couldn’t make rdr3

Also just because someone disagrees doesn’t make someone pessimistic

Thought that would put a smile on your face to know that

[onyx fiber]

Sneezes

[forest apex]

It’s not a matter of disagreeing, it’s a matter of you just shutting the whole idea of rdr3 happening because you haven’t got a clue how things work and I genuinely pray your not an adult cause otherwise it’s too late lol. You’re acting as if companies don’t do the same thing with different stories even with loss of writes. Ghost recon, assassins creed, far cry, cod, elder scrolls etc. all basically the same just new cast and stories

[trim acorn]

did you even read that

[forest apex]

Buster Scruggs! Still keeping your singing voice in fettle?

[sleek stirrup]

Nope, just trying to be apart of the situation lol

A 🫷🫸PART

I'd like me a splash of whiskey to wash the trail dust off my gullet and keep my singing voice in fettle.

[forest apex]

Don't let my white duds and pleasant demeanor fool ya. I too have been known to violate the statutes of man and not a few of the laws of the Almighty

[fleet island]

“You haven’t got a clue how things work” as if you do and that’s calling out hypocrisy.. “pray you’re not an adult” because someone doesn’t think rdr3 doesn’t have much of a important reasoning to be a thing in the first place besides “It should be different characters and a story!” That wouldn’t be taken in the same route as John and the gang as both rdr games HAVE.

GTA is a different story. None of the characters were in the same game at least in these recent years, however, they’re taken in the same environment where they have full limits to making their own story without having to involve older characters.. rdr involved old characters that wrapped around the same story. Involving new characters WOULDNT be involved in the same story if it’s taken in a different era with different characters.

Also literally all the other games are literally owned by different companies that doesn’t make your argument stronger, lmao.

[fleet island]

Also pessimistic is when someone sees the worst aspects of things which Incase you haven’t figured it out yet, rdr3 doesn’t exist so I can’t see the worst aspect of it if there’s no factual proof of its existence.

Xoxo.

[echo cloud]

That’s all this about

[fleet island]

He got butthurt over one message so

[forest apex]

That’s my whole point chief….new characters new story and location, nothing to do with the existing games. Whole new redemption arc….

No duh the other games are owned by different companies, you missed the whole point that each franchise is basically the same game but with the aforementioned aspects

And why would it have to go the same route as john? These companies have massive budgets and thousands of employees, if they can’t think of anything new, they won’t last much longer

[fleet island]

[forest apex]

It’s as if, here me out, rdr1&2 have nothing to do with red dead revolver

[raven silo]

[fleet island]

‘Whole new redemption arc..’ and at that point be an entire SEPARATE western game if there’s no reason to be apart of the gang’s story.

[fleet island]

Hey you know what’s crazy

If you use your eyes and reading comprehension, its name is different.

Meaning it’s not wrapped around the gang’s story

[raven silo]

I wanna play red dead revolver

[fleet island]

Good game, but get use to the old controls

[sleek stirrup]

You can’t win the argument bro, she’s a woman lmao.

[fleet island]

LMAO?

[raven silo]

I used to play on the hospitals old ps3s when I was up there for my monthly visit, I'm sure I can wrap my head around them

[forest apex]

And far cry 1,2,3,4,5 aren’t linked at all and yet are the same game just different. Not linked in the slightest. Just because it’s called redemption, doesn’t mean it has to be linked with the gang

[covert reef]

H

[humble sundial]

Anyone in Australia wanna play some RDO?

[raven silo]

H

[fleet island]

Again different company

That shit is not rockstar

Try again

[forest apex]

Ok, each gta is the same stuff and not linked 😂🤌

All called gta

[fleet island]

“GTA is a different story. None of the characters were in the same game at least in these recent years, however, they’re taken in the same environment where they have full limits to making their own story without having to involve older characters.. rdr involved old characters that wrapped around the same story. Involving new characters WOULDNT be involved in the same story if it’s taken in a different era with different characters.“

[raven silo]

I'm so hungry

[fleet island]

They’re linked in the same universe.. but they’re not intention to be the same story with the same characters like rdr did.

[forest apex]

Oh and let’s not forget midnight club. They aren’t linked either but share the name

[fleet island]

You mean midnight club in fucking 2000

[forest apex]

It’s like arguing with a brick wall

[raven silo]

I wouldn't mind if they made a next game not at all linked to the gang because we already have two games revolving around them

[forest apex]

I’ve lost IQ

[fleet island]

You are the brick wall

[forest apex]

I’m dummer now because of this

[fleet island]

That wouldn’t surprise me

[raven silo]

I think you were already dumb to begin with /hj

[fleet island]

I’m fine if it’s in the same universe, but there’s no need to dwell with the red dead redemption franchise.

That’s why red Harlow has a different name for his game.

[forest apex]

The fact that you can’t fathom another new story of a redemption arc that doesn’t involve the same story, under the same name is astounding. Absolutely astounding

[fleet island]

Buddy did you even read the shit I say or you saying shit to say it

[raven silo]

Same, I personally wouldn't mind if it's the same universe but a new game would be cool

Doesn't need the same name

[fleet island]

exactly

[raven silo]

Unless it's still based around the gang

[fleet island]

EXACTLY

[raven silo]

Which I doubt

[fleet island]

THANK YOU

[forest apex]

And even if it was the same story….go back even further, to when the gang was in its infancy. Show ditched early years and how that influenced how he got into crime in the first place. How Hosea and Arthur got dragged in. They can literally keep going with the same story if they wanted to

[fleet island]

Where’s the redemption if it goes back in the past.

[raven silo]

Red dead past lmao

[fleet island]

at most that’s a dlc.

[fleet island]

All we get is snippets and theories about their past

[forest apex]

New main character that wasn’t in 2. Arthur wasn’t named in the first game yet he’s the main character of 2

[echo cloud]

Are we fighting

[fleet island]

Because he fits the narrative and still carries the message of the game. Doing it AGAIN for the past game would just make it feel like a copied idea.

[forest apex]

The snippets of the past are by design most likely to keep the story going back in time

[raven silo]

I am curious about what happened in blackwater, but next play through I'll pay more attention in chapter 1

I'm going to fight with my hunger (I haven't eaten yet)

[forest apex]

That’s been done plenty of times. If they do it right then it works. Hell could even have Mac be the main character. He died in backwater, Mac’s character was literally set up perfectly to be the main of 3. Died in backwater, yet we know almost nothing about him and who he was as a person

[raven silo]

Having a debate with a brick wall

[forest apex]

That’s sexist. Shame

[echo cloud]

Oooo sounds like a good time

[forest apex]

Bad buster scruggs

[fleet island]

WHY DO YOU NEED TO BE MAC

YOU ALREADY GET SNIPPETS OF DIALOG ABOUT HIM AND THE PAST OF THE GANG

[raven silo]

I think Arthur was a fine main character..?

[fleet island]

holy fuck

[raven silo]

For chapter 1-6 and then John was a fine main character in the epilogue and rdr1 (at least his part of it)

[forest apex]

It works. We hardly know anything about him, and he died in backwater. We don’t know exactly what happened there, but he could’ve died redeeming himself by redeeming himself by saving the gang or something killing pinkertons. He’s setup perfectly

[fleet island]

“We need a rdr3!” And this mf cannot compute that the gang’s story is done. No point for a past story if there’s literally jackshit to redeem for besides the fact that you have so many snippets and lore behind the past to the point the writers purposefully leaves you to theorize about it.

[fleet island]

What.

[echo cloud]

Guys chill

[raven silo]

Everyone's already been redeemed that we know of (or died)

[forest apex]

By that logic we didn’t need rdr2 because we already got snippets in rdr1 about what happened in 2 and we know John died and why

[fleet island]

Dumbass people saying dumbass shit to try to make their point stand out

[fleet island]

Do you know Mac’s character at all

[sleek stirrup]

What did i do

[fleet island]

Like anything

[sleek stirrup]

[fleet island]

not you

[raven silo]

This whole argument/debate is stupid

The gang story is done, we don't need to know any more about them, if rockstar wants to make another game and doesn't make it about the gang cool, it's their game

[fleet island]

He brought up rdr3 of what shouldn’t be a thing if it were to be a thing and I just stated “Good thing that’s never gonna happen” because the gang’s story is done, no need for extra or past content and he just went on about me being negative and a miserable pessimist

[forest apex]

You really have 0 imagination on ideas for rdr3…. Sure the gangs story is done, but we already knew parts of it in rdr1. Now we know parts of the gang from even earlier. There’s multiple ways they can tell the story of what happened in black water and before. Have you never known a story to be told in reverse? It builds anticipation

[fleet island]

You know what’s funny

[raven silo]

If you play the game you can find out .?

[fleet island]

“You have 0 imagination on ideas for rdr3” your ass isn’t even rockstar so stop tryna act like they know you and you can make ideas for them

they ain’t wasting their money on another game about a finished story.

Sure they might spin off something related in the universe but there’s no need to have ‘redemption’ in the title

[sleek stirrup]

[raven silo]

Also if rockstar wants to make it about the gang and their past good for them, and if they don't? We have new characters to learn about

[fleet island]

Red dead redemption was the gang’s name to their story.

[covert reef]

Hh

[fleet island]

Frfr

[raven silo]

Hh

[forest apex]

I don’t need to make ideas for them cause they probably already have one 😂 they set up rdr1 in a way to tell the story of rdr2 as the second game, and did the literal same thing in rdr2. So far they’ve told the story backwards. That’s a thing. The story isn’t anywhere near done if you go backwards

[fleet island]

Then go make your own story

[covert reef]

Hh

[raven silo]

Go make a fan fic if you're that pressed

[covert reef]

[raven silo]

Hhh

[covert reef]

Hhhh

[fleet island]

Stop crying about people with their own opinions and right to disagree about something they don’t see a point to

[sleek stirrup]

Men this fucking big ass alligators keeps killing me

[fleet island]

Burn it

[covert reef]

Just kill it

[fleet island]

Explosive arrows maybe

[raven silo]

I am so hungry

[raven silo]

Dynamite

[forest apex]

This is exactly my point. Your pessimistic by saying you know for a fact rdr3 isn’t happening, when so far they’ve told the story backwards. The entire story isn’t anywhere near done if you don’t know the events that happened before the current ones

[fleet island]

Oh my god and you’re still crying like a bitch and I’m the woman here

What am I being pessimistic about

Something that doesn’t exist?

deadass?

[sleek stirrup]

I have 1 dollar left

[forest apex]

And that’s why my point isn’t being grasped. Wisdom has always been chasing you, but you’ve always been faster. Slow down a bit and breathe in the scent of the flowers

[fleet island]

Guys disagreeing with someone about a fairytale is pessimistic

His words not mine

[forest apex]

About how you know rdr3 isn’t happening when you don’t

[fleet island]

Yeah buddy?

On a discord?

[fleet island]

I’ve said my points and you just kept rambling and putting more shit on the plate

[fleet island]

And you do?

Make it make sense, otherwise, shut up

[forest apex]

No, hence why I said IF it happens. Idk if it is or not but I’m not the one sitting saying it’s for sure not happening

[fleet island]

Huh, I wonder if it’s because you’re arguing on another side than I am

That’s kind fucking crazy how that happens

[forest apex]

I’m just saying there’s literally plenty of possibilities on what a third game could be about

[fleet island]

And none of them wouldve make sense to keep the redemption franchise

[forest apex]

It’s a good thing your not a rockstar dev

[fleet island]

It’s a good thing you’re not either

LMAO

[forest apex]

Cause then we for sure wouldn’t get another game

[trim acorn]

are you guys still arguing 😭

[fleet island]

I’m sure they wouldn’t want another game if you made it personally

Go make your own story

[forest apex]

Yes cause this lady here can’t grasp the fact that the story has been, and can continue being told in reverse

[trim acorn]

what, redemption story?

[fleet island]

LMAO

[trim acorn]

i swear bro

[forest apex]

Mac as a guy we know, or god forbid, another new gang member we didn’t know of like rdr1 to the events of 2

[trim acorn]

NO

GOD NO

[fleet island]

No.

[trim acorn]

NOT MAC

[fleet island]

You literally do not know shit about Mac dude

[trim acorn]

mac didnt do shit for the gang he has no major role

pretty sure that word isnt allowed

[sleek stirrup]

Woops I slipped sorry gng

[trim acorn]

Banned.

[covert reef]

Mods can see what you deleted btw

[sleek stirrup]

[covert reef]

[trim acorn]

you will be gone in like 6 minutes

[sleek stirrup]

Shot me in the head bro…

[fleet island]

With a shotgun

[trim acorn]

ronnie mcnutt?

[fleet island]

I’m gonna make it hurt

[sleek stirrup]

Wait i am black bro, i can say that

[trim acorn]

[forest apex]

Why no? Rdr1 is the aftermath of the Wild West, rdr2 is at the tail end of it, when the gang is almost done. Why not go back further to the gangs infancy, when the west was truly wild and tell the players the story of what happened earlier. The gang getting together, what happened in their journey etc. plenty of valid options rockstar has for a third game

[trim acorn]

I just dont see the point

Rdr1 doesnt thrive on knowing how the gang formed

Its about how it ended that matters

Thats what set up the story for rdr1

[trim acorn]

hello homohexual

[fleet island]

okay tell me this, how would Dutch affect the gang in anyway as it did for rdr2 to make a reasoning for rdr1. What member in the gang would have a certain fallout if things start to escalate and make a remark on rdr2 which there is literally no plot for the main cast for it to truly spark.

[uncut lotus]

Hello fake red dead revolver 💩

[fleet island]

In rdr1 THERE WAS SO MUCH rdr2 could’ve filled between the lines and they did so.

[trim acorn]

howd you type so many caps

oh a booster

[fleet island]

Besides the deaths in rdr2 for rdr3 to go off of, what redemption aspect would that have?

the same plot again?

[fleet island]

Booster

Unfortunately

[trim acorn]

No more redemption gng

[uncut lotus]

I don't think rdr3 should happen

[fleet island]

EXACTLT

[fleet island]

EXACTLYYY

[uncut lotus]

They should remake revolver

[vale frigate]

its kind of funny... how life can change 🎶
can flip 180, in a matter of days 🎶

[uncut lotus]

Or redemption 1

[fleet island]

I agree honestly

[trim acorn]

What about Red Dead Rasputin

[forest apex]

Yes, but we got lots of snippets about what happened in earlier years about the gang and how things went wrong, setting up rdr2 story well without the players having expectations. 2 is set up the same, we know a bit about Mac, and we know somewhat what happened in backwater, but we don’t know how the events unfolded, possible character that we don’t know that could’ve been involved, and how past events unfolded to bring them to backwater in the first place. Endless possibilities

[trim acorn]

😛

[fleet island]

What

[trim acorn]

This all seems very useless

It isn't something we need to know

[fleet island]

That’s why rdr2 left snippets to theorize 💔

[trim acorn]

Like I said before, the fall of the gang is what was important

[flat citrus]

Hi

[trim acorn]

Not the start or the middle of it

[fleet island]

Arthur doesn’t know what happened at black water, because he wasn’t there when shit hit the fan. That’s the entire purpose for the player to theorize and go off of what other characters tell Arthur.

[sleek stirrup]

Anyone wanna brutally kill some npc or players in rdo?

[forest apex]

We didn’t need the snippets of rdr2 in 1 either for 1 to work, but they set it up for a number two by giving us hints, and they did the exact same with 2

[fleet island]

Giving the player answers makes your audience incapable of being able to theorize and going off the lines like that

[forest apex]

It’s set up in a way where we’re kept guessing what happened before, opening up a whole array of ideas

[fleet island]

It makes the story less interesting

[trim acorn]

Red Dead Rapunzel

Red Dead Revolution

ah! french revolution!

[fleet island]

Revolution sounds like a sick name ngl

[forest apex]

We don’t have answers though, we’re theorizing what happened before just like we were in the first game

[fleet island]

THAGS WHAT MAKES IT INTERESTING

[trim acorn]

rdr fans never get enough

[fleet island]

God damn

[trim acorn]

after one game is released they want another

One more game!

[fleet island]

I love both games just as it is

I say there shouldn’t be another game about the story it already did an amazing job telling.

[trim acorn]

Rdr2 story makes rdr1 deeper

[fleet island]

Exactly

[trim acorn]

Giving us info on what killed the gang to give us more emotional feeling

[forest apex]

I agree, and they can satiate player interest after years by telling us what happened, and even leave a final cliffhanger if they want. They don’t have to go right to the gangs origins, they could leave the very beginning a mystery

[daring ocean]

i miss art hur

[fleet island]

And because it left such a huge opportunity to give rdr1 that factor of making a backstory game that was able to fill up the gaps

[trim acorn]

Rdr3 story making rdr2 deeper? not really

[fleet island]

and dig deeper into the characters

Rdr3, you’re already expecting just as much as the 2nd game

[trim acorn]

With both games you can play whichever first and still feel the same

[fleet island]

Frfr

I would love another game off of the universe.. but off of the story? No.

[trim acorn]

Yeah definitely no more of that

after chapter 3 of rdr2, the story became about jack

Everything Arthur and john did after that was for jack

So he could live a better life

[fleet island]

Exactly

[sleek stirrup]

2 hours of arguing btw

[trim acorn]

I just don't see what even more backstory to the gang would do

[fleet island]

And he said I was the brick wall..

I got more people about my argument

Shit should be settled by now

[sleek stirrup]

His argument is useless to be honest

[trim acorn]

what about Grand theft redemption

[sleek stirrup]

[trim acorn]

[fleet island]

GRAND THEFT REDEMPTION?

😭

[forest apex]

And they can do that even keeping the redemption arc if they want, by having it set in a different state, prime outlaw era, new character. Doesn’t even have to be a gang or anything. Could be a guy who used to be a real POS in the early days of the Wild West, and redeems himself somehow. Or a lawman, or a war veteran who committed unspeakable war atrocities

[trim acorn]

erm maybe we can have red dead redemption 3 to be about rains fall and how his tribe was formed 🤓

[fleet island]

What.

That shit is not rdr then

[trim acorn]

Uh

Wouldn't that make it non rdr

[fleet island]

Not red dead redemption

[trim acorn]

I just want the old games to be revived actually 😭

like bully

[fleet island]

Bully needs a huge rework

[trim acorn]

Red Dead Bully!

I knew it!

[fleet island]

in graphics I mean

[trim acorn]

Grand Dead Bully Payne

[forest apex]

Red dead redemption doesn’t have to involve the existing games at all. It can be a whole new arc with the same name. Red dead redemption doesn’t specifically mean the gang. It’s a broad term of someone redeeming themselves before death. Does not have to involve the gang or characters

[fleet island]

I personally don’t know much about the story so

[fleet island]

What?

[sleek stirrup]

What should i buy with my 1 dollar in rrd2

[fleet island]

Dude that while sentence just made me think you don’t know red dead redemption

Period.

“Red dead redemption doesn’t specifically mean the gang.”

Red dead redemption was the whole story ABOUT THE GANG

Bless your heart

[forest apex]

Cause it doesn’t. For now yes, the only two rdr games involve the gang, but the same title can be used for a whole new arc that follows the REDEMPTION philosophy. Can be literally anyone. The rockstar ceo can literally make it a story of him redeeming himself for all he cares

[fleet island]

????

ykw you go have your fantasies

I don’t need to be arguing with someone and their ideas about a fan fic

[trim acorn]

Its like dutch's plans to paradise 😭

[fleet island]

Fr

That shit never happened

The most it did was guarma

[trim acorn]

please

[forest apex]

My god the sheer ignorance is simply astounding. I don’t think you know what the phrase red dead redemption means. It literally means that someone redeemed themself before death . That doesn’t inherently mean the gang is the only story possible under that arc.

[trim acorn]

i dont want more people reedeming themselves

[fleet island]

Yeah keep saying whatever shit your mind can come up with bud

[trim acorn]

The Red Dead part just came from revolver

[fleet island]

I have the majority

[trim acorn]

capcom titled the thing btw

[forest apex]

Just cause the majority follows doesn’t mean you are right. Ever hear of lemmings?

[fleet island]

just sounds like a broken record atp

[trim acorn]

Lemmy?

Lenny?

[sleek stirrup]

Hey guys, relax. It’s not even a serious thing to argue about.

[fleet island]

Probably because they can actually comprehend that the story is over

[trim acorn]

Story is over gng

[fleet island]

be a thing you’d wish for, no?

[fleet island]

It’s really not KMAO

[trim acorn]

Who wants to see more people redeeming themselves

[fleet island]

this guy is just being a broken record

[forest apex]

And you cannot comprehend that’s it’s not if you go back even further, or have a whole new arc with the same redemption theme

[trim acorn]

going back even further is stupid

[fleet island]

Yeah keep acting big mad

[trim acorn]

Dude

Can we just have revolver remake 🙏

[fleet island]

I don’t need to rumble about fanfics

[sleek stirrup]

The lion and the monkey reference 😭😭

[fleet island]

I wanna see red harlow in modern graphics

[trim acorn]

red harlow is more badass than the likes of arthur and john

[fleet island]

LMAO

[trim acorn]

also idk why he is a legend in redemption? his story only happened in the 1880s

[fleet island]

I need to rewatch red dead revolver

I haven’t played that shit since ps3

[trim acorn]

Red has a one shot revolver

nah but jack swift though

His deadeye was op

[fleet island]

I have a vague memory of red dead revolver

I just know the ending and the beginning of it 😭

It’s been a while

[trim acorn]

Beginning is when his parents die and then ending is when he killed the guy who killed his parents

[fleet island]

Exactly

[trim acorn]

and then he turned down 5k and gave it to the girl who needed her ranch back

[sleek stirrup]

Okay the guy stopped talking, the war is overrrr

[trim acorn]

But rip jack swift 😔

[fleet island]

[grim sequoia]

Still pissed how Rockstar closed out social club… how am I gonna access the pics I took in game now???

[fleet island]

Wdym?

[trim acorn]

Jack swift apparently died

it didnt show his death on screen though

Red just asked where jack was and the people looked down implying that he didnt make it

[forest apex]

They closed the social club? When did that happen?

[fleet island]

Pretty sure you can still access your pictures

[trim acorn]

He may still be alive though

[fleet island]

Perchance

[trim acorn]

A guy i was having a conversation with in Redemption said that

by the campfire

[fleet island]

Theories are great

[grim sequoia]

Approx a month or so ago 😵‍💫

[grim sequoia]

Idk how to do that… especially since I can no longer log in

[fleet island]

Ah..

[forest apex]

Just googled and it said you can still access your profile, friends list and progress from the games website but says that photo gallery was removed. Might not be able to

Didn’t know they closed it, that’s a bummer

[trim acorn]

wait what

noooo my badass photos

[forest apex]

Wonder if gta 6 online will feature a crew system like 5 did then, since that was through the social club

Probably a rdr2o posse type system then

Or something similar

[sleek stirrup]

Bro why did they abandon this game for gta 5 like this is so much better than gta 5 lol

[fleet island]

Cause of gta 6

[trim acorn]

Because people like city shit more than cowboy shit

[fleet island]

It’s their main priority rn especially since it got delayed more

[forest apex]

Gtav was already set up with a huge playerbase, more content and shark cards and they continued pumping content for money. They could’ve done the same here with continued support, but iirc not many were buying gold bars, making for an ineffective cash cow

[trim acorn]

gta6 delay is like class pizza party

always being put on hold

[narrow comet]

hello everyone

[fleet island]

Howdy

[forest apex]

Yeah apparently there’s rumors of another delay to November

[sleek stirrup]

Yoo wassup man

[fleet island]

I wouldn’t believe it until it happens

[trim acorn]

my tab key has been sticky for 4 months and today it randomly fixed itself

[fleet island]

Same happened with my down on d pad

That shit wouldn’t work until recently

I don’t know what I did

[forest apex]

I heard that Trevor ls actor wanted his character killed off in gta 6 since they confirmed that saving Michael and Trevor is canon. Wonder if we’ll get Trevor in 6 as part of the story or something

[trim acorn]

no more honor check 😔

[fleet island]

I fixed it

I think

[trim acorn]

trevor michael and franklin in gta6?

[fleet island]

Doubt it honestly

[trim acorn]

No please no dont do this

[fleet island]

I’m not gonna say anything more

Just doubt it

[trim acorn]

Is he gonna talk about how the trio should be in gta6 now 😭

[forest apex]

Not sure if they all would be involved, I just heard that Trevor’s actor wanted Trevor to die in 6. Might involve Franklin and Michael, or they went their seperate ways and he died somehow

[trim acorn]

from the trailers its obv gonna be about this girl and guy and then they rob places and shi and have sex

[sleek stirrup]

I’m adding y’all

[fleet island]

My ankle is hurting and I’m tempted to break it off

[forest apex]

Maybe does in a heist with Jason and Lucia, or a mission involving the fib or new faction

[sleek stirrup]

[fleet island]

ITS CYBERPUNK ALL OVER AGAIN WOOOO/j

[trim acorn]

that would be fanservice to the gtav fans

i bet theyd like tht

[fleet island]

nostalgia bait technically

[trim acorn]

i personally

[lofty bison]

I was in the wrong server I was in rdo so they were talking about tech support.

[trim acorn]

have never played gta

[fleet island]

Would be a cool feature but

[fleet island]

LMAO?

[forest apex]

I know I would enjoy it. Trevor was an awesome character, cool, crazy and hilarious. They could make him die in many different ways and all would be equally awesome

[trim acorn]

mohn jarston w name

[lofty bison]

Trevor is Micah but not a snarky person he’s a…addict that’s how prolly

Fake red dead revolver… UR FAKE HORRIBLE NAME

[fleet island]

Trevor ‘respects’ women

Micah on the other hand?

[sleek stirrup]

The only grand theft auto that i liked was san andreas lol

[trim acorn]

Damn you!

[lofty bison]

The first time you see Trevor with the bike woman-

[fleet island]

I know, I know

[forest apex]

Facts. Micah was straight up diabolical

[lofty bison]

My car horn in the San Andreas theme

And!

[trim acorn]

micah killed grimshaw

[lofty bison]

He was blonde

[fleet island]

Trevor I think is lovesick honestly

[fleet island]

Micah just becomes a douche

[lofty bison]

Bro needs his ‘loverman’

[trim acorn]

i didnt find micah annoying or bad at all

[fleet island]

WHAT

[trim acorn]

i thought he was gonna be one of those people that are asshole at the start but then become better

[lofty bison]

We’re u in chap 2 before the prison mission

[trim acorn]

never mind he actually just stays the same

and its fecking annoying

[lofty bison]

The mission where you blow up the mines with Micah I’m sad that’s deleted

[trim acorn]

[trim acorn]

real

[forest apex]

he killed jacks dog and killed Mrs grimshaw

[trim acorn]

looked kinda cool

[lofty bison]

I love how him and Arthur are so chill

[lofty bison]

Micah kinda killed Arthur in a few endings

He got him weak so then he died

He shot him

[fleet island]

“Micah treats everyone he meets with sadistic and psychopathic contempt.”

[trim acorn]

it looks like they were in the tumbleweed mines when that happened.

[lofty bison]

He stabbed him

[errant ice]

Nooooooooo

[trim acorn]

so thats why it didnt become a thing

[fleet island]

Why is someone here with a roblox roleplay discord tag.

And pfp.

[trim acorn]

never mind it didnt

[errant ice]

Noooooo

[lofty bison]

Shut your fucking mouth you cunt

[fleet island]

God damn

[errant ice]

Noooo

[lofty bison]

I know

[fleet island]

[lofty bison]

[forest apex]

Read that in Trevor’s voice 💀

[sleek stirrup]

[lofty bison]

I read it in the British dudes

Y’know?

[lofty bison]

The clip

[forest apex]

“Now why would you wanna go and do a thing like that”

[fleet island]

NO

[lofty bison]

I lost honour from that

[raven silo]

Im learning how to bake

[fleet island]

I’m a loser

[fleet island]

Lucky

[lofty bison]

I can’t

[fleet island]

Well I know how to somewhat bake but

Yk

[lofty bison]

I made cakes soggy…yes the cake and the icing was pure liquid

[fleet island]

I make brownies just fine, funny enough

Then again I used to watch my mother make them when I was young cause I wanted to lick the whisk/spatula

[trim acorn]

there was originially gonna be a red bandana we could wear ☹️

[sleek stirrup]

He left him so many times to die bro

[forest apex]

I wonder if they would ever remake rdr1. Keep the same gunplay and mechanics imo, literally just improve some animations, sounds and graphics. Maybe add new outfits and guns to mess around with

[fringe current]

yeah no lol

[lofty bison]

Dutch x Hosea is like saying Gojo and Geto are good as a ship… (I don’t ship them)

[fleet island]

As much as I wish they could, they might not

They still haven’t remastered their past games

So I doubt it for now

[forest apex]

When John came limping into camp holding his shoulder, I knew shit was boutta go down. If it wasn’t for the events of rdr1 I would’ve been surprised he didn’t shoot ditch right there

[muted jolt]

can someone give me a good spot to hunt in rdr2?

[lofty bison]

“Ditch”

[fringe current]

rdr2 hasnt even gotten a current gen update

yet...

[forest apex]

Isn’t there word about Bully being remastered?

[lofty bison]

Grizzles and New Elizabeth

[fringe current]

new elizabeth

[fleet island]

and upper annesburg too

[lofty bison]

Moose

[fleet island]

Where the legendary moose is

Especially near the lake

[forest apex]

Rdr1 remaster, with new outfits guns and graphics would be peak. Even more peak…..second undead nightmare expansion for the remaster!

[lofty bison]

I was 8 in 2020 now I’m so mature

Hehehhehehe

[fringe current]

born in 2012

[lofty bison]

Just joking!

[forest apex]

I despise that rdr2 never got a undead nightmare, but it kinda makes sense since it was Seth that cause it 💀

[lofty bison]

Having a laug wit ye

Irish is a W

[fleet island]

I was 12..

[lofty bison]

I didn’t know the horses were fresher

Thanks buddy

[fleet island]

If I know my math right

[fringe current]

these horses look fresher

woo and healthy

before you degrade these poor fools any further tell me where im headed

[forest apex]

Oh wait nvm it was Reyes that caused it. But rdr2 could’ve had undead nightmare since the mask was never destroyed, and John can go to new Austin

[lofty bison]

🫳⚽️⚽️🐴

[fringe current]

they probably never bat an eye at a singleplayer dlc

they wanted online to be like gta online

[forest apex]

Peak writing 🤌

[fringe current]

and miserably failed

[forest apex]

Yeah which is wierd because rdr2 originally hit very high numbers. They dropped because of a lack of support and more for gta. A lot of initial players were gta fanboys

Rdr2 could have had some wicked sp dlc with the proper support and player numbers buying gold. I would’ve loved to see wagons in online that were flat with a maxim gun for posse carnage. Imagine the wars to be waged with maxim wagons being pulled by two Turkoman

[fringe current]

yea the post launch support for rdr2 has been awful

crazy to me that the online is exactly the same as it was when i started playing it 4 years ago

[forest apex]

Seeing how gta v lasted with continued support though, I can’t fathom how long gta 6 will last, or what the possibilities will bring

[forest apex]

Yup besides buffed ability cards, a couple new guns and the addition of roles, it’s identical. Never even got properties like a customizable ranch or nothing

Could’ve had purchasable ranches with cattle driving. The mechanics for that are there

Raise cattle to sell at valentine auction. Would’ve been a great slow paced, peaceful PVE thing

[agile musk]

Just add all cut content to single player as a 5 buck dlc
Boom call me a GENIUS

or just download mods

Up to u

[forest apex]

I wish the buffalo rifle never got cut from rdr2. That was goated in 1. Wish the explosive rifle came back as well

That thing was busted but sooo fun

Instead we got dynamite arrows

[fleet island]

I mean

[bold tulip]

Hi

[fleet island]

Dynamite arrows are fun to use

[agile musk]

Dynamite arrows are cool

How dare you slander them

[fleet island]

[forest apex]

Not slandering, just would’ve been cool if they were an addition, and not a replacement

[fringe current]

homing tomohawk

[agile musk]

Dynamite arrows at the same level as indecinary buckshot slugs

[errant ice]

gift me rdr1

[agile musk]

No

[forest apex]

Incendiary buckshot is cracked. Wouldn’t be nearly as bad if they didn’t make you fall over. Once you fall, game over

[fringe current]

they make you fall over?

[forest apex]

This look like a charity discord partnr

[errant ice]

yes

[forest apex]

Yup, if you get shot with them your lit on fire a few seconds and you fall

[fringe current]

oh

[forest apex]

They needed a nerf

[fringe current]

you're talking about being shjot with them

[forest apex]

Oh yeah, not shooting them. Way better to be on the shooting side of them

Not the barrel end. They make you roasty toasty

[raven silo]

[dusk shadow]

Sometimes some people try to rob or kill me so I kill them in self defense

but then there are witnesses if its only 1 I just scare him

but for 2 or more I end up killing them

Is this the right way like how do you guys take care of the witness problem

[lofty bison]

Why tf everyone joining?

[fleet island]

No idea

[lofty bison]

In red dead r-right?

[dusk shadow]

yeah singl player

[lofty bison]

I grapple them and threaten

[dusk shadow]

lol why would I do this in real life

[lofty bison]

If I’m annoyed and I know I’m wanted I shoot em

[lofty bison]

Dunno

[lofty bison]

Tf we getting so many gang members…

We gained 10 in 20 minutes…

[trim acorn]

Sex

[grave scroll]

Falalalalaaaa..

[lofty bison]

Fuggin party invites

[grave scroll]

Are you still high

[dusk shadow]

give

[lofty bison]

Yes

I’m high still

[trim acorn]

[covert reef]

H

[grave scroll]

H

[covert reef]

Forse.

[trim acorn]

boyfriends

[lofty bison]

I’m gay with a girlfriend

[grave scroll]

Watch as mods strike this down

[covert reef]

No

[dusk shadow]

If I was a girl id be lesbian

[covert reef]

I'm too good for all that smh.

[trim acorn]

if i was a bprof id be ashjfmnvkdlklks.edc

[grave scroll]

You're high.

Mods, ban frdr

[trim acorn]

im high

[trim acorn]

same

[lofty bison]

If I was a a 12 year old girl again I’d love K-pop Demon Hunters. (I’m a male)

[covert reef]

I finally got a new bottle bc my last one is too far to be cleaned

[trim acorn]

oh shit that me lol

[grave scroll]

What am I even supposed to call you

[lofty bison]

I’m low asf

[grave scroll]

Faredere... Uh.. Frder

[trim acorn]

megbahytge75

[grave scroll]

Something..

[trim acorn]

B

[grave scroll]

Yeah, fuck me, I keep forgetting

What was my nickname for you again?

[trim acorn]

v

its notr pasting

[grave scroll]

Wow

[trim acorn]

v

[lofty bison]

Ts dnd language?

[covert reef]

Whts even going on

[raven silo]

[grave scroll]

I give up knowing, I'm calling you mbit.

[covert reef]

I bought chips and they taste like one of my moms veggie soups I'm shaking

[trim acorn]

v

[raven silo]

You can never run away from the soup...

[covert reef]

NOOO

[trim acorn]

its not pasteing

[grave scroll]

Oh...

[covert reef]

[lofty bison]

[raven silo]

I'm tired

[covert reef]

I haven't had soup for 3 days...

[lofty bison]

It’s 11:44

[raven silo]

Wow, I never noticed

[lofty bison]

I’ve only had Pierson’s soup once

[trim acorn]

why did i cover up th colurs stuck inside my head

[covert reef]

What

[trim acorn]

i shouldave let the jagged edges meet the light instfead

[lofty bison]

Poor chessrum

[slender umbra]

One message removed from a suspended account.

One message removed from a suspended account.

[lofty bison]

Scikkkkkk

W

[trim acorn]

v

[slender umbra]

One message removed from a suspended account.

One message removed from a suspended account.

[hexed inlet]

hi

[trim acorn]

it doesnt paste

it

[covert reef]

Doesn't paste what

[trim acorn]

v

[slender umbra]

One message removed from a suspended account.

[trim acorn]

ithink my cotnrl key is broken

v

[covert reef]

V

[lofty bison]

Show me whats underneath, I’ll find your harmony

[trim acorn]

v

it doenst

[slender umbra]

One message removed from a suspended account.