general

[mighty parrot]

It’s always dead

Atleast in EST

[mortal moth]

Mhmmmm……

[mighty parrot]

Never see ppl talking when im not up at 3 am

[random cliff]

Found my people

[mortal moth]

They all went to Tahiti that’s why it’s dead

[random cliff]

No rdr slander over here

[mighty parrot]

I NEED MONEY I can get us to Tahiti

[mortal moth]

Yeah no joke

Get the train

[mighty parrot]

“The mangoes Arthur the mangoes”

[mortal moth]

And don’t forget jelly beans!!!

[random cliff]

Good lord is everyone here in EST

I’m bout to be boreddd

[mighty parrot]

You eat baby’s

[mortal moth]

Nah I don’t think sooo

[mighty parrot]

My name is John marston

Raaaah

[random cliff]

Punt the baby

[mortal moth]

RIP wan winkle

[mighty parrot]

Alright goodnight my scrumdididly chat

[mortal moth]

Oh shit I did a Marston edit and forgot to check how it’s doing

[mighty parrot]

For indubitably I shall sleep

[mortal moth]

Ight gn boah

[random cliff]

We brought life to this chat today partners

Welcome to the revolution

[mortal moth]

XD

Not for so long

[random cliff]

A win is a win

[mortal moth]

Yeah congratulations!!!🙌

[jaunty scarab]

I can’t sleep

[mortal moth]

Bruh

You on phone

How tf you are supposed to sleep

[jaunty scarab]

No I actually did try to go to sleep

[mortal moth]

Well then try again partner

[wary rover]

Talib mean seeker

[steel fern]

@slate brook @grave scroll 13ks in, 5 to go

[candid silo]

yo wassup

[wheat terrace]

Sup

[daring lava]

yo

rdr2 is w

[candid silo]

yah

[random cliff]

I will be back to bring life to this chat tmmr night yall

[jaunty scarab]

Ok so I found out why he broke up with me. I know everyone is asleep and shi. But before I forget this it’s because he wanted to date a guy

[random cliff]

I have risen

I feel I’m missing context I joined way late

[jaunty scarab]

Nahhh

I literally just sent that

Well actually u might’ve with everything else

[daring lava]

nah

[random cliff]

Leaving you for a guy is blasphemous but you will prevail

[jaunty scarab]

And then he asked me if we could get back together today

[random cliff]

Hard pass

No sir

[jaunty scarab]

Right

[grave scroll]

Damn bro actually went for a run

[steel fern]

Yeah

#general-media

[formal python]

[grave scroll]

Why am I spending time doodling gaycah x Gay der linde instead of completing my crash animation meme

[formal python]

How do I get the lgbtq supporter thing

[grave scroll]

No

[gusty silo]

why

[formal python]

Square up Micah

[grave scroll]

I'm the best here, clearly

[grave scroll]

Ask a mod

[gusty silo]

[formal python]

I love your confidence!

[rustic canopy]

Hey

[grave scroll]

Micah, very great

[grave scroll]

Honorable Arthur fan role 🤑

[rustic canopy]

Does anyone know where you could find like clips of Arthur in like cutscenes

[grave scroll]

At least you didn't get the SMALL pp role like someone had

[rustic canopy]

Doesn’t help my point rn I know

[gusty silo]

search up what you just said lol

[rustic canopy]

Making Arthur edit for 1k sub special

[gusty silo]

“arthur morgan cut scenes”

[grave scroll]

Damn, congrats

[gusty silo]

youtube

[rustic canopy]

Thanks

[gusty silo]

download the video

[rustic canopy]

Yea you have to pay tho

[grave scroll]

YouTube.. And those risky ass websites

[formal python]

Ayyyyyy

[woven lynx]

slow pp

[formal python]

What song are u using

[gusty silo]

imo i would just screen record it

[grave scroll]

YT to mp4 converter or something

[rustic canopy]

Daylight

[gusty silo]

yeah

[grave scroll]

I messed up real bad 💔

[rustic canopy]

Yk what your right ima do some shady shit rn to get these💀

[formal python]

u should use the new chief keef song pls

[rustic canopy]

What’s it called

[woven lynx]

lol no i laughed

[formal python]

Lms

[grave scroll]

I did too once you pointed it out lmao 💔

[rustic canopy]

Young black and rich for Arthur Morgan would be tuff

[woven lynx]

what does that mean

[rustic canopy]

Is song

[grave scroll]

The song

[formal python]

It’s called Jam

[grave scroll]

The one they use for those aura farming boat kids or something

[rustic canopy]

Lemme see

[woven lynx]

arthur would hate this generation

[rustic canopy]

Doesn’t not fit the tuberculosis redemption arc cuh😭

[rustic canopy]

Real

[proud helm]

is this chat alive or nah

i guess nah

[rustic canopy]

Bill would love it tho iykyk

[grave scroll]

I'm getting tested for tb

[proud helm]

🏳️‍🌈

[woven lynx]

no. noone is talking rn

[formal python]

Okay maybe for another edit?

[grave scroll]

I don't wanna end up like black lung

[proud helm]

ok black lung

[rustic canopy]

Yes if I make a non sad redemption edit yes

[grave scroll]

Be quiet cowpoke

[rustic canopy]

Wild type shi

[glacial vector]

oh how the tables have turned

[woven lynx]

na you should mosey along to another discord prolly

[rustic canopy]

“Oh I love it and I hate it at the same time”

[proud helm]

sycpau

[grave scroll]

What the hell does that mean

[proud helm]

shut your cowpoke ass up

[woven lynx]

your mom

[glacial vector]

ohh

[rustic canopy]

Lmao ima use that

[grave scroll]

New slang

[rustic canopy]

Better than the original one

[glacial vector]

that was tuff in the 1800s

[grave scroll]

Rdr rotted

[rustic canopy]

Guys Arthur vs Micah in pie eating contest

[proud helm]

tennis boat

[rustic canopy]

Who wins

[grave scroll]

Me

[glacial vector]

never

[woven lynx]

[glacial vector]

hm pie eating contest maybe you

[rustic canopy]

With that chapter 5 build fuck yea

[proud helm]

the lack of fuck john is saddening

[grave scroll]

Thank you Vandalism 😋

[wide bramble]

are any of you guys in 1st marine battalion server

[grave scroll]

[proud helm]

tf is that

[glacial vector]

What is a 1st marine battalion server

[woven lynx]

noone actually plays the epilogue.. chapter 2 lingerers here

[proud helm]

oh someone dm’ed me on playstation about some (number)st infantry cavalry whatever of the us

[glacial vector]

chap 3 best chap

[proud helm]

while i was playing rdo

[formal python]

FLOCK I thought you could have more than one tag

[proud helm]

[formal python]

it got rid of my silent hill tag thingy

[glacial vector]

I’m lowk unbothered to play epilogue

[viscid oriole]

epilogue is the best part

[proud helm]

if you want to scoop shit then yeah

its fun

[glacial vector]

Really?

[proud helm]

i found it fun

[viscid oriole]

epilogue ties the events of rdr2 into the beginning of rdr1

[proud helm]

scooping shit and milking cows

[glacial vector]

Maybe I will

[proud helm]

especially the credits

[runic fiber]

So quick but weird question Is it weird that my G F is taller than me?(im like 5’7 and she’s like 6’0 or 6’1)

[glacial vector]

I’d honestly just play it for Sadie Adler 🤗

[proud helm]

you can also revisit characters

[viscid oriole]

tdlr john needs to learn how to hide a body better now the government is after his ass

[glacial vector]

REALLY

[proud helm]

like mary beth, tilly, rains fall

[glacial vector]

oooh ong

And Sadie.

[proud helm]

and pearson and the rhodes general store

[formal python]

ya everyone thinks it’s weird and that u should just disappear

[proud helm]

and charles

[glacial vector]

And Sadie!

[proud helm]

yes i get it

[grave scroll]

I love visiting Pearson sm

[woven lynx]

i like the rhodes salloon

[grave scroll]

Best cook

[proud helm]

same

[glacial vector]

Charles omg

[proud helm]

”this meat is rotten”

[grave scroll]

He's actually so so silly

[wide bramble]

Don’t join them because they freaking leak fake IP’s addresses because of a goddamn game

[glacial vector]

I’m still not over Arthur I’ll

Icl

[glacial vector]

Pardon?!

[proud helm]

y’all remember that one thing

uhhh

[viscid oriole]

John was one of my first character tragedies

[steel fern]

Hello guys, I finished my run

[proud helm]

”Reaper Lords”

[glacial vector]

Hello!!

[wide bramble]

So I will high Jacking there server real soon

[proud helm]

hijinxs

[steel fern]

Their*

☝️🤓

[formal python]

Omg, tool!

[steel fern]

Yes

[proud helm]

Don’t you love getting shot constantly by griefers the second you enter Valentine?

[wide bramble]

Is 4am for me right now so my brain is not braining

[steel fern]

I'm eating lunch at 6pm

[viscid oriole]

I love how people got flashbacks, me including when they open the barn doors at beechers hope in the epilogue

[glacial vector]

it’s like 9am normal time

[formal python]

I’m not

[steel fern]

There is no "normal time"

[glacial vector]

Awe

[formal python]

the normal time is night time

[glacial vector]

9am is like standard morning time yk

[steel fern]

The normal time is 23:73

[wide bramble]

I just do all nighters that my friends do because who ever have the most hours get a huge cash prize at end of the summer

[earnest laurel]

first it was rabbits now its cougars

[glacial vector]

Ooh!

[earnest laurel]

i cant find even 1

[formal python]

Normal time is anything but this

[glacial vector]

Wait that’s not a real time

[rustic canopy]

It’s done

After 2 hours of editing

[wide bramble]

That is 24 hour clock

[rustic canopy]

It’s finished

[steel fern]

Its 00:13

[glacial vector]

ohhh so it is

[rustic canopy]

Can’t even send it here smh cause discord hates things that are vids

[wide bramble]

I always use a 24 hour clock or military time they just way better

[glacial vector]

Idk what military time really is but 24 hour clock is hoated

[grave hornet]

when can i edit johns clothes

[formal python]

ima look out for the young black rich Arthur Morgan edit

[glacial vector]

I wanna know when I can shave his BEArd

[rustic canopy]

Nah bro I used day light

[wide bramble]

Is like if it 4:30 am it would be 0430 in military time

[rustic canopy]

I’m finna post it rn

[viscid oriole]

https://tenor.com/view/john-marston-sigh-rdr1-rdr-rdr-john-marston-john-marston-death-gif-11028313591288783167

[grave hornet]

you can do that by the time u get to the cabin but i cant STAND his fuckass outfit like i really cannot i need to change it

and it locked the wardrobe

[glacial vector]

You can?! Where?!

[wide bramble]

PSTD

[formal python]

have u guys ever accidentally killed ur horse and felt rlly guilty after

[viscid oriole]

you can just go to any town while still at pronghorn ranch, granted a cutscene will play when you return and abigail will be mad you left

[grave hornet]

its right next to the big bed in the cabin i just wander around until it pops up

[steel fern]

Why, when an animal is alive their meat lasts for as ling as they live.
But as soon as it dies it starts to go bad even when preserved?

[grave hornet]

ohh

[glacial vector]

Ohhhh thankyou!

[viscid oriole]

If you leave pronghorn ranch for more than a day a secret cutscene shows up when you return to Pronghorn ranch

[rustic canopy]

Uh in story yes in online fuck no I’ll run that shit into a volcano

[grave hornet]

i havent even done the first mission in the epilogue yet lol i just really cannot stand his outfit

its outrageous

[steel fern]

I had a horse and killed it after 5 minutes

[formal python]

why

[steel fern]

Because I fell off a cliff

[grave hornet]

i sold my horse on accident once (the raven black shire) and i cried for an hour

[viscid oriole]

My RDR1 horses have died so many times it's probably a record

[formal python]

I wanted to cry

[steel fern]

🤔

[formal python]

They done shot my horse💔💔💔

[grave scroll]

I hate this fact

[viscid oriole]

whoever decided to put undead cougar pairs in undead nightmare count your days

[steel fern]

Hello Micah.

[formal python]

Always carry horse reviver

[rustic canopy]

But let’s be honest

[steel fern]

Fake micah? More like real micah

[viscid oriole]

cant even escape cougars in rdr1 when the world. is infected with zombies

[rustic canopy]

If our horses could respawn they wouldn’t be the same

[woven lynx]

fucking trains

[viscid oriole]

its easier to kill your horses in rdr1 aside the fact you can quite literally just shoot your horse

[rustic canopy]

This one life thing they have makes them feel like real animals

[rustic canopy]

Friendly fire ahhh

[steel fern]

[formal python]

yes def

i felt bad even like replacing my horse

[rustic canopy]

Yea

[formal python]

but honestly my new horse an upgrade

[rustic canopy]

Idk man

Rdr2
Is goated

[woven lynx]

i locked onto an eagle and my horse ran off a cliff and died earlier 😭

[rustic canopy]

I hope rdr3 is better

[rustic canopy]

Ooof

[formal python]

😭😭

[viscid oriole]

fuckass cougars man

[formal python]

this makes me feel better

[steel fern]

Nah, rdr7 is next bro

[formal python]

genuinely

[steel fern]

They forgot numbers

[rustic canopy]

I remember when I was in mb last fun as John I Bassickay spent all 20k on horses

[grave scroll]

Stupid

[steel fern]

Hi real micah

[rustic canopy]

Playing as young Dutch and then epilogue as Arthur or smth idk

Bruh

[formal python]

i feel like maxing ur horses out is a good idea

[rustic canopy]

I NEED a prequel to the prequel

NEEEED

If I don’t get Arthur in rdr3 I’m not buying the game

[viscid oriole]

We already know everything that happens in the prequel-prequel, if anything we will either get a remaster or a new red dead game since red dead is a series, its not just the redemption games

[steel fern]

Arthur morgan as an infant child

[grave scroll]

Oh fuck it didn't reply

[rustic canopy]

At least give me dutchie poo

[viscid oriole]

New revolver game when

[grave scroll]

Internettt...💔

[wide bramble]

I need RDR3 about Jack Marston after RDR1

[rustic canopy]

Nah like blackwater massacre prior we really don’t know much lore to the gangs formations

[viscid oriole]

We do though

[rustic canopy]

A story about that as Hosea or Dutch would be cool

[steel fern]

Rdr3 stars Arthur morgan as an infant

[viscid oriole]

the game tells us

[woven lynx]

luckily i saved right before

[rustic canopy]

It’s not the same as playing through it though

[viscid oriole]

I'd hate on mac callander just as much as I do bill

fuck mac

[rustic canopy]

Yea but my point is it’s different to play through the era rather than read abt it in a games newspaper

Like we know John goes to ww1 doesn’t mean we shouldn’t get a game abt it

[woven lynx]

rdr3 would definitely be a pre prequel of dutch

[grave scroll]

Yes, it is I, real Micah

[rustic canopy]

Although it wouldn’t fit RDR vibes

[rustic canopy]

I agree

[steel fern]

Dutch as an infant child

[rustic canopy]

They can’t give us all this

[grave scroll]

Oh my goodness this internet pisses me off

[steel fern]

I know, that's what I said

[rustic canopy]

Without explaining the formation of the gang

[viscid oriole]

Jack likely gets gunned down later anyways cause he basically exposed himself just for revenge (If you havent noticed, revenge leads to the death of every character when they do it, its a pattern)

[woven lynx]

not as an infant that would be stupid

[steel fern]

OH mb

[grave scroll]

I was trying to reply 💔

[formal python]

there’s like a moment of silence every time u do smt stupid in the game

[rustic canopy]

Jack lives till like the 80s dude

[steel fern]

Yeah I get that

[rustic canopy]

He didn’t die

Well he did

But old age

[grave scroll]

I'm gonna bawl my eyes out

[steel fern]

Y

[viscid oriole]

and what evidence do you have

[rustic canopy]

Here lemme find it

[woven lynx]

right.. like wtf did i just do

[grave scroll]

Yet again, Internet

[viscid oriole]

Rockstar never confirmed Jack's life after the events of RDR1, everything you see is fan created by theories

[rustic canopy]

The j Marston book

[viscid oriole]

Just a fact, I know people think so because of the easter egg from GTA V, but many new players don't know what an easter egg is anymore

[rustic canopy]

That had to have been written sometime after ww2 I’d guess

[viscid oriole]

Easter eggs arent canon

[thick bronze]

Hi p

[rustic canopy]

Yea I guess

But it’s good widened

[formal python]

omg also the npcs will see u approaching on ur horse and stay the f in the way

[rustic canopy]

Wvidence*

[steel fern]

Holá

[rustic canopy]

Evident

Evidence holy shit I can’t spell mb guys

[thick bronze]

Are you afraid of spelling tests?

[viscid oriole]

It was proven easter eggs, rockstar has easter eggs all throughout the series, like campfire stories talking about Red Harlow, when Rockstar said they were different universes

[thick bronze]

[rustic canopy]

Like I get it’s an Easter egg but the implication and I feel like all the sacrifices made for him should’ve led to smth

[viscid oriole]

Just easter eggs cause they are games made by the same company

[rustic canopy]

But yea I think a Dutch prequel would fit the Wild West much better than getting gassed by the Germans

[viscid oriole]

In reality its rdr players cant grasp the concept of game endings

[thick bronze]

…

Germans?

[rustic canopy]

Had the French

[unique parrot]

Senior porfavor

[steel fern]

I love how in this server half of the convos are about the games and the other half is like food n whatever else

[rustic canopy]

Bassickay everyone in ww1

[thick bronze]

You said you knew Spanish

[thick bronze]

Dutch prequel much better than WWI

I’ve though of that

[rustic canopy]

I agree

[unique parrot]

[thick bronze]

We have battlefield 1 if we want to experience it

[rustic canopy]

Ww1 would need a new title and like a whole new branding

[steel fern]

Señor por favor

[formal python]

[steel fern]

☝️🤓

[rustic canopy]

Just imagine our character is Jack lmao

[viscid oriole]

English only

[thick bronze]

MEDIC!

[steel fern]

I was correcting him mb

[formal python]

i thoufht u weren’t allowed to speak a dif language in here

[rustic canopy]

But uh Dutch could be red dead redemption 3 or red dead smth

[steel fern]

I was correcting him mb

[rustic canopy]

But yea Dutch makes so much more sense

[formal python]

there’s no room for mistakes ur getting reported.

[rustic canopy]

It’s either that

[unique parrot]

Yes yes, I just wanted to say it like that, I do not really speak English hehe

[rustic canopy]

Or brand new characters

[formal python]

jk!!!all sunshine and rainbows over here

[thick bronze]

W PFP

[steel fern]

Senior is an old person or someone older than you.
It doesn't necessarily mean sir

[formal python]

excited for season 27😌😌

[rustic canopy]

Of RDR hell yeaaaaa

[steel fern]

Grrr

[formal python]

of south park ……………..:..

[woven lynx]

it would be an obvious pick but has anyone even said rdr3 would happen?

[rustic canopy]

May daddy Arthur arise from the dead next game

[thick bronze]

Could someone rate my John fit?

[rustic canopy]

They have too like

[steel fern]

Mortyyyyyy
Can we get rid of dyno pleaseeeee

[viscid oriole]

rdr2 is pretty

[rustic canopy]

If they don’t it’s a wasted oppurtunity for a whole fan base

[thick bronze]

Nah real life just got a graphics upgrade

[rustic canopy]

They’d ruin a whole population of people

Wouldn’t make sense

[thick bronze]

I’ll be honest about a Dutch prequel

[formal python]

i haven’t finished rdr2

[woven lynx]

rockstar is kind of doing GTA6 right now and its going to make them like 1 billion dollars

[thick bronze]

It’ll be fun to recreate the blackwater massacre

[steel fern]

Guys who votes to get rid of dyno

[rustic canopy]

Rdr3 would make so much money

[unique parrot]

Oh, I really do not know if we talk about the same thing, I made the joke that Dutch spoke Spanish

[rustic canopy]

Yea but after I reckon RDR3 will be there next big project post gta6

[viscid oriole]

pretty right

too bad its not rdr2

[woven lynx]

ok rdr3 ETA 2031

[thick bronze]

All in favor of getting rid of Dyno, say I, all opposed say Nay

[steel fern]

Morty

[thick bronze]

I

[viscid oriole]

no

[steel fern]

Pleaseeeee

[rustic canopy]

Prolly 2035 😭🙏

[steel fern]

😭

[viscid oriole]

britknee got muted point and laugh everyone

[thick bronze]

Another day another dollar I guess

[woven lynx]

send 3 stickers in a row to bypass automod caps and too fast messaging

[steel fern]

@formal python 🫵🪑

[rustic canopy]

Hosea my grandpappy

[thick bronze]

Your PFP fits perfectly with that message

[steel fern]

Thx

[thick bronze]

Yelcome

[unique parrot]

What is your favorite mission guys?

[thick bronze]

Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern

[steel fern]

Last one

I forget what it's called

[thick bronze]

Which last one

American Venom?

[steel fern]

Ye

[viscid oriole]

the mission called red dead redemption, near the end

right before epilogue starts

[thick bronze]

Y’all know the best train robbery mission?

Pouring Fourth Oil IV

[unique parrot]

That is good.

[thick bronze]

And then it’ll be Our Best Selves, follow by Who the Hell is Levicitus Cornwall

[steel fern]

House building EP has gotten me through some hard times

[thick bronze]

A New Jerusalem if anyone is wondering

[steel fern]

Hmm

[unique parrot]

Guys you think that Dutch became like that over time I mean the decay of the band and the rat of micah or was it always like that?

[steel fern]

Interesting

[steel fern]

What?

[viscid oriole]

https://tenor.com/view/john-marston-red-dead-redemption-surrounded-john-marston-death-open-door-gif-10004198226810567881

[steel fern]

That made no sense

[thick bronze]

My theory is that Dutch went crazy after he bonked his head in the trolley station robbery

[viscid oriole]

fan created fact, not true

[thick bronze]

How so?

[viscid oriole]

wdym

[thick bronze]

How is it not true?

[steel fern]

Oh you don't build a barn, dumbass. What is this 1785?

[viscid oriole]

the fandom theorized it around 2019

it was from a clickbait fact rdr youtube channel

[thick bronze]

I agree with many others that Dutch went crazy because he hit his head

[viscid oriole]

spread like fire

and now people believe it

for whatever reason

[thick bronze]

Still

[viscid oriole]

also you dont just hit your head and magically become sadistic, dutch had always had those traits

[thick bronze]

It’s likely because of the trolley station robbery

[viscid oriole]

but its not

[thick bronze]

He hit his head and went crazy

Not sadistic

[viscid oriole]

thats not even how that works

[steel fern]

Or is it?

[thick bronze]

He always had a silver tongue, as Milton said

[thick bronze]

Could happen

[viscid oriole]

but it didnt

[thick bronze]

It did

[thick bronze]

How do you think Dutch went crazy p?

[steel fern]

He went crazy because of how much it hurt

[viscid oriole]

you're believing a clickbait youtuber

[thick bronze]

I’m believing a popular opinion that I believe is a strong point

Not because other people believe it

[unique parrot]

I find it hard to understand what they say, do not know English but I guess they talk about the blow that Dutch took on the train?

[steel fern]

Probably

[thick bronze]

Sure

[thick bronze]

Guys thunderstorm outside

Am I cooked, yay or nay?

[steel fern]

Yay

Probably

[unique parrot]

Sure

[thick bronze]

[viscid oriole]

rdr1 was about realizing you cant excuse your past with morals (ie what dutch always yapped about) which was what john was trying to do but eventually realizes you cant change your past and it will catch up to you

rdr2 is the gangs perspective, everything you are told is under dutchs manipulation and as the game unfolds and the gang collapses under dutchs poor leadership and influence (ie you cant tell someone everything is gonna be fine when it isnt)

[thick bronze]

Sum it up

Why did you put that there?

[steel fern]

Yeah, I aint reading allat

[polar ravine]

guys someone said in media that morgan dies. and ik he does not because im playing as him rn

[viscid oriole]

is this why you rely on clickbait lying youtube videos

[thick bronze]

No, I just ain’t reading all of that because I’m lazy

[viscid oriole]

its literally summed up

[thick bronze]

And it’s 3 AM

Fine I’ll read it

I mean yeah

That’s basically the red dead redemption series in a nutshell

[viscid oriole]

John tries to use excuses but gets shut down by everyone and the more you play as him and what he experiences via Bills gang he comes to terms he cant excuse what Dutch's gang did, and by the time he reaches Mexico he believes it because it's what he tells Javier when Javier tries to use the same excuse John did pre-Mexico

[steel fern]

[viscid oriole]

Dutch was never crazy from a concussion, he was losing control

Because of his own actions

[viscid oriole]

For example, The Chapter 1 train robbery was the reason Cornwall hired Milton and Ross, which led to the later events of the games

Dutch didn't HAVE to rob it, he was greedy

[thick bronze]

Not enough punctuation, can’t read

Basically you’re saying he went crazy because he lost control

Got it

[viscid oriole]

ban kids who rely on clickbait youtubers

[thick bronze]

Still believing the opinion by the way

You believe whatever you please, I believe whatever I please

[steel fern]

My feet hurttttt

[polar ravine]

i heard that rdr2 is gonna get deleted

[thick bronze]

Buy new ones off the black market

I saw some selling for 17,000

[steel fern]

Erm

[thick bronze]

That’s a bargain in my opinion

[steel fern]

I have 3 dollars

[thick bronze]

[polar ravine]

same

[thick bronze]

Also of course he was greedy

[viscid oriole]

It's interesting but it's really up to you though. The whole "Dutch was always crazy vs. he became crazy" was present in the first game. Sure you can say the trolley was on par with "He became crazy" vs. people who say he was always crazy

[thick bronze]

He always yapped about money

[thick bronze]

Bruh

[viral sable]

🤓☝️

[viscid oriole]

But that thought didn't appear until a year later

[steel fern]

☝️🤓*
☝️🤓

[viral sable]

Ur right

[viscid oriole]

Or whenever it blew the fuck up, far as i'm concerned RDR2 2018 was all about online bullying actors and people with the same name as Colm O'driscoll

[viral sable]

☝️🤓

[viscid oriole]

If anyone forgot about that lmao

2018 RDR2 fans needed to touch grass

But back to the original debate, many characters get their shit rocked and Dutch isn't the first so it's really just fan created theories, nothing was ever proven by Rockstar

[thick bronze]

You put out a strong argument and I respect that, but I’m still sticking by my opinion

[thick bronze]

Also agreeed

[viscid oriole]

You can believe it, i'm just going by facts

[thick bronze]

I didn’t start playing until 2020

[viscid oriole]

Like the easter egg of Jack's books were actually just confirmed easter eggs, not him actually becoming a writer

[viscid oriole]

Basically what I was referring to was fans sending death threats to Micah's actor and harrassing people with the same name as RDR2 characters, a guy named Colm O'driscoll was recieving hate and death threats just because his name was the same as Colm from RDR2

It was pretty big back then

[thick bronze]

He most definitely became crazy. He cared for Arthur and the gang in chapter 2 and 3

[thick bronze]

That’s stupid

[viscid oriole]

Nothing wrong with theories, but a lot of them were just created by clickbait youtubers who were running out of things to say and kids went along with it, like the whole marston books or really anything.

[thick bronze]

Do you know the YouTuber who made the trolley theory?

[viscid oriole]

Like that one channel I forgot the name

fuckass clickbait youtube videos

it was big back in 2018-2019

oh yeah mrbossftw

dude could create 10 minute videos talking about nothing

[viscid oriole]

It was a lot, not sure who originated it or if someone on reddit somewhere theorized it

[thick bronze]

Dude I watched him all the time

Then he became trash

[viscid oriole]

always was

[thick bronze]

Though I didn’t get the theory directly from him though

[viscid oriole]

Most fact rdr2 youtubers started losing things to talk about and started just making stuff up

[thick bronze]

Somewhere on Reddit I think with a lot of replies

[idle grotto]

yooo guys

[viscid oriole]

Although Strange man or fish whatever his name is werent too bad at talking about rdr2 facts

[thick bronze]

Now most of em are using this stupid “my names John Marston!” Sound effect and the house building song sung by a complete bone head

[viscid oriole]

idk about tagback, I don't remember any others

[idle grotto]

yeah

[thick bronze]

My FYP is full of them

[idle grotto]

really

[idle grotto]

full of whAT

[viscid oriole]

2018 jokes were just all lumbago, tahiti mango jokes over and over

[idle grotto]

i think it was cuba

[viscid oriole]

"I got a plan" as if Dutch never said that in the first game

[thick bronze]

Now all the content is is just cheat locations when we can look them up, secret treasures which we all already know of, bunch of other crap that they didn’t put effort in

[idle grotto]

revenge is luxury we can't afford

[feral pulsar]

could anyone help im doing algerons wasps mission and im getting the ghost orchids rn i went to all the locations but i got some of them and then after i slept they werent there? i used mods to give myself them since i had JUST got them and its not fair that they arent there anymore but its not showing up that i can go back to him yet idk what to do

[vale frigate]

pert sleep

[viscid oriole]

youtube videos show where different spots are

as for birds, good luck lmao

[trim acorn]

[vale frigate]

Why u rude? :(

[feral pulsar]

yeah no im doing a youtube video to help like i literally went to the location, got the flowers and they arent in my inventory anymore

[viscid oriole]

oh yeah did you ever see those images i sent of kcd2

@vale frigate

[viscid oriole]

dont mod i guess

[feral pulsar]

and one of the flowers literally just isnt there

[vale frigate]

how to make?

[feral pulsar]

what do i do

[vale frigate]

not yet... in general media?

[viscid oriole]

i can repost them

[vale frigate]

its ok will search

[feral pulsar]

@viscid oriole

[supple sinew]

Morts mortys mortyz

[thick bronze]

Are the panthers somewhere near catfish Jackson’s?

[viscid oriole]

banned

[viscid oriole]

idk start over

they respawn after a few days

[feral pulsar]

really?

do i just fast travel to emerald ranch and sleep 18 times

[viscid oriole]

I guess

[thick bronze]

Morty

[viscid oriole]

what

[feral pulsar]

what if my name is morty

[thick bronze]

Are panthers located somewhere near catfish Jackson’s?

[viscid oriole]

yeah

[thick bronze]

I swear I saw one but I can’t find them again

[supple sinew]

Morty will always be the og morty

[thick bronze]

Cool

[viscid oriole]

and outside van horn

and up north by charlottes cabin

specifically near the bridge

oh wait those are cougars

[feral pulsar]

they are northwest at the intersection northeast of catfish jacksons and theres one near the owanjila lake trapper

[viscid oriole]

yeah panthers suck but theyre usually at night around the swamp

[thick bronze]

Aight thanks

Both ikea and Morty

[viscid oriole]

I got spawn killed by a panther when I spawned into Rhodes area in RDO

[thick bronze]

Oof

[feral pulsar]

i disagree, ive never found a panther at night

[thick bronze]

I don’t understand the white Arabian glaze

[feral pulsar]

and especially the one at the bridge near charlotte

[viscid oriole]

standardbreds are superior

[thick bronze]

Yeah good stats but I have a horse that looks better and has better stats

[viscid oriole]

cougars or panthers

[thick bronze]

I just stopped going for the white Arabian, waste of my time

[viscid oriole]

cougars are by charlottes

panthers are only in the swamp forest area

cougars are everywhere

[feral pulsar]

people love it because its one of the if not the best horse in the game thats easy to get at the start of the game and people think it looks nice

[viscid oriole]

Black standardbred >

[thick bronze]

Dude it’s not that deep

Plenty of horses much better looking and better stats than the white Arabian

[feral pulsar]

?

you ask a question i answer

[feral pulsar]

uh huh

[thick bronze]

Uh huh

I’m correct

[feral pulsar]

???

how are you correct and im wrong

highkey no freaking idea what i did

[candid silo]

Black Arabian the best

[thick bronze]

Apologies, worded that wrong

I’m just saying that there are many horses in the game that are better than it

[feral pulsar]

i agree, im just saying thats why people glaze the arabian

[candid silo]

yes like black arabian

[feral pulsar]

i cant lie idk why people hate on arabians

they have an inbuilt danger detector

whenever they are near danger they politely push you off so you can fight the danger

[candid silo]

me too but i like arabian

[thick bronze]

I have a reverse dapple black thoroughbred that looks better and has phenomal speed and acceleration

Much better than white Arabian

[feral pulsar]

wherd you get that

[wary rover]

Bruh

[candid silo]

yes

i stole one

[thick bronze]

I believe it was somewhere in new handover, around emerald ranch

I was lucky enough to get one as John as well

[feral pulsar]

i have a mod that makes appalosians or whatever they are called into donkeys

[candid silo]

I have Black Thoroughbred

[feral pulsar]

funny part is that its my best horse stats wise

[thick bronze]

Missouri Fox Trotter is also better then white Arabian

[thick bronze]

Speed wise, white Arabian has better acceleration

[humble sundial]

Anyone here in Australia/Oceania

[thick bronze]

But me personally I prefer my speed

[candid silo]

idk why horses names are so complex in te game

[thick bronze]

They’re real life horse breeds buddy

[candid silo]

oh idk

[thick bronze]

Yeah, they didn’t make em up

[feral pulsar]

are you the type of person to name their horse "Moonlight" or something like "Oceanwarth"

[candid silo]

tru

[thick bronze]

Lol

[candid silo]

no man

[feral pulsar]

i give my horses some pretty good names lowkey

[thick bronze]

What’s your horse name IKEA

[feral pulsar]

u want me to tell you all of them

[thick bronze]

No

Your best one

[feral pulsar]

i have 2 really good names

Gordo Butterballs

gave to the turkoman you get in horse flesh for dinner

and jim gigglenuts

my big ass shire i stole

[candid silo]

My horse name is knight rider

i dont have that good names

[candid silo]

wtf

[feral pulsar]

arthur had to have a laugh in his last 3 chapters

cmon

[thick bronze]

My horse is named Mansuetus

Also I lied about the location of my horse

I guess it’s for ultimate edition only, Valentine

[feral pulsar]

and my best horses name is fenton

[lofty willow]

My name horse Is solitaire

[feral pulsar]

throwback to the name hosea gives you in that one mission where you give people alcohol

[thick bronze]

My name is Latin for quick by the way

[candid silo]

i have an ultimate useless

[feral pulsar]

and because im 99% sure hes on fent all of the time

[thick bronze]

L Fent user

Dude the ultimate edition is on sale for 20

I payed 100 for mine

😭

[feral pulsar]

goodness

i think i have have the ultimate edition

idk lowkey

cuz i got a free pump action varmint rifle and volcanic

saw what you said

[thick bronze]

Yeah you have it

[candid silo]

what is in ultimate edition tho

[feral pulsar]

usd and cad

oh steam

idk what you mean

[candid silo]

it feels like i wasted 20 SAR

more

[lost sable]

black outfit, some kind of gold bar or pampleth i think and a uhhh horse that is free from the start

[astral apex]

[lost sable]

oh and a mission

i think

[thick bronze]

Reverse dapple black thoroughbred, free weapons including varmit rifle, pump action shotgun, and volcanic pistol, a free Arthur outfit, and a Rhodes bank robbery side mission

[steel fern]

Tired and Australian sorryyyy

[candid silo]

how to get that horse

[thick bronze]

Plus a few talismans

[lost sable]

valentine horse fella

[lost sable]

go there

[thick bronze]

I believe Valentine stable

Yeah

[candid silo]

ohk

[thick bronze]

I think it’s free

[lost sable]

it is

[steel fern]

@vale frigate it's just how I'm used to being treated at school

[lost sable]

Oh and you get a saddle as well for free

[candid silo]

I think there is one hideout mission also

[feral pulsar]

ion remember these

[thick bronze]

Remember what?

[feral pulsar]

ok well gang

i gotta sell one of my horses

which should i sell

[thick bronze]

Do it

Your most useless one

[feral pulsar]

but i love all of themmm

[thick bronze]

If you want the horse too bad

[steel fern]

Hi pixel

I'm back

[thick bronze]

I was gonna name mine blackie, but I figured that’s racist

[thick bronze]

Hello p

[feral pulsar]

why the flip flop didnt i get this at the start gng

its there

[steel fern]

Hi ikea

[feral pulsar]

hii

what about the tlaismans tho

[thick bronze]

Trapper or hotel room I think

[feral pulsar]

eeeuuuhhh

[steel fern]

Eating dinner rn even tho I had lunch 30 minutes ago

[thick bronze]

The Rhodes bank robbery side mission was fun too

[steel fern]

I'm so fulllll

[candid silo]

whats in special edition then ??

[feral pulsar]

should i actually keep this horse or reload my save

[thick bronze]

Black horse, a few talismans, bank robbery mission

[steel fern]

I game atuff

[feral pulsar]

ok guys what should i name him

[thick bronze]

Hold on

[candid silo]

ok

[thick bronze]

Don’t name em yet

[steel fern]

If you get the ultimate edition (disc) you get a map

[thick bronze]

Fortis

[steel fern]

To hang on your wall (irl)

[thick bronze]

Name him Fortis

[feral pulsar]

why the freak fortis

[thick bronze]

Latin for strong

[steel fern]

Bc he's an absolute fortress of power

[thick bronze]

Or don’t, I don’t care what you do

[feral pulsar]

ok should i really get rid of my old horse tho

[steel fern]

Name one of them todd

[feral pulsar]

his name was jim gigglenuts

[thick bronze]

Did you name the horse yet?

[feral pulsar]

no

[thick bronze]

“Move it Todd”

[feral pulsar]

in my stables rn i have
fenton
rachel
buell
jim gigglenuts - sold rn

[thick bronze]

That works

[steel fern]

Jim gigglenuts is such a cool name

[feral pulsar]

he was a big ass horse too

the big black shire

[steel fern]

Name one fentanyl

[thick bronze]

Racist

[candid silo]

jus name it nuts

[steel fern]

That's what I did

[feral pulsar]

nooo thats why i have FENTON

[steel fern]

Ah

Ok

What about todd

[feral pulsar]

todd.?

[thick bronze]

Name one Bert

[steel fern]

(My Sydney funnel-web's name)

[thick bronze]

Fortis

Fortis

[feral pulsar]

u really want fortis

[candid silo]

name it horse

[thick bronze]

Or Bert

[steel fern]

I have the most dangerous spider in the world in my room and his name is todd

[thick bronze]

You missed the perfect opportunity to name him Dave

[steel fern]

I cant

That's my dad's name

[thick bronze]

Spider Dave, you better behave!

[feral pulsar]

name him john

[thick bronze]

Man

[candid silo]

noo need to name him

[steel fern]

Who

[feral pulsar]

your dad

so you can name the spider dave

[steel fern]

No

[feral pulsar]

ok mayor of grumpville

[steel fern]

Dad says ok

[candid silo]

the spider would havve named you an assasin or killer orr a threat

[steel fern]

He is now John and Todd is Todd or Dave

It's interchangeable

Let's normalise eating pert

[thick bronze]

Did you name him Bert?

[feral pulsar]

is todd john and dave or is dave tohn jodd and pinapple

[feral pulsar]

no not yet

havent named him yet

[thick bronze]

Bert is an amazing name tbh

[steel fern]

Huh?

[steel fern]

Sart bimpson

[thick bronze]

[feral pulsar]

he just fucking shat on the floor while hes waiting for me to name him.

[thick bronze]

Narl Cash

[thick bronze]

Lol

[feral pulsar]

what do i actually name him tho

[steel fern]

So cuteeeeee

[steel fern]

Todd

Pleaseeeeee

[thick bronze]

Fortis, Bert, or Todd

[steel fern]

😭

[thick bronze]

Those are your options

[thick bronze]

P I’m cooked

Thunderstorm outside

[steel fern]

For why

Oh yeah

[feral pulsar]

hear me out guys

[thick bronze]

Big ass one

[feral pulsar]

astolfo-chan

[candid silo]

horse be like

[steel fern]

Adolphus

[feral pulsar]

i didnt laugh.

[thick bronze]

Hdolf Aitler

[candid silo]

Adolf hiler

[feral pulsar]

i expected better from you

[steel fern]

😱

[steel fern]

?

Wdym

[thick bronze]

Chat my power went out

😭

[steel fern]

Chat should I finish my dinner?

[lofty willow]

Wolfenstein antagonize

[feral pulsar]

Astolfo Goonster?

[steel fern]

YES

[thick bronze]

Yes

Golden Gooner?

[feral pulsar]

great minds think alike

[thick bronze]

[steel fern]

×5

[feral pulsar]

what free wsaddle do i get tho guys

[thick bronze]

Is it wrong that I know all the lyrics to the house building song?

[steel fern]

First one

[thick bronze]

Just get the golden vaquero or whatever it’s called

Buffs your horses stats

[grave scroll]

Good

[feral pulsar]

g-guh?

[steel fern]

I've only had 3 horses so idrk the names

[feral pulsar]

why??

why cant i get a trapper saddle

[thick bronze]

It may be 65 dollars but it’s worth it

[steel fern]

Hi real micah

[thick bronze]

That’s Gaycah

Boah

[feral pulsar]

trappers are better

[steel fern]

Bwoah

[thick bronze]

Whatever you please, I’m not playing

I’m just giving a thoughtful recommendation that improves your horses stats

[feral pulsar]

i chgecked and the panther trail saddle is WAY better

[steel fern]

🫵😁👍

[thick bronze]

No

Get the High Plains one

[steel fern]

I'll be back guys

I gotta cling wrap dinner

[thick bronze]

High Plains saddle

[feral pulsar]

which

eeuuh?

its not there guys

[thick bronze]

I think it’s a free one

Drain rate -25 percent

[feral pulsar]

the kneller mother hubbard?

[thick bronze]

What?

No

The High Plains Cutting Saddle?

[feral pulsar]

its not here twin

[thick bronze]

Idk what to tell you twin

It’s a goated saddle

[feral pulsar]

oh god

[thick bronze]

You know what I hate?

[feral pulsar]

panther trail saddle is
health core drain rate -20%
stamina core drain rate 26%
stamina drain rate -50%
stamina regen rate +24%

[thick bronze]

Dude just get it

[feral pulsar]

ok i swear i did NOT say the n word

[thick bronze]

I don’t care what you do, I’m just making recommendations

[feral pulsar]

what do i name my horse tho

[lofty willow]

N word

😹

[steel fern]

Jeffery jigglynuts

[feral pulsar]

no thats too similar to jim gigglenuts, the horse i just deleted

[thick bronze]

WILD

[steel fern]

Fuggly fred

[feral pulsar]

9what do i name him

[lofty willow]

😆

[steel fern]

Fuggly fred

[thick bronze]

Can we all agree that the Rhodes general store owner is a cranky bastard?

[steel fern]

Yes

I hate that guy

[thick bronze]

Especially when you rob him

He’s relentless

[steel fern]

Ong

[lost sable]

Yea i burn him then take his limbs off. I hate him the most

[thick bronze]

Nice

[steel fern]

Hello silent

I blow him up

[thick bronze]

He looks like an emmet granger knockoff

[feral pulsar]

p-pearson?

[lost sable]

Oh noooooo i uhhh bring him animals

[thick bronze]

No the one in the main story

Not epilogue

[lost sable]

that ye

[thick bronze]

One of his lines that I fucking hate:

“Typical, first I stub my toe then you walk in the door.”

Like bud, shut the fuck up

[lost sable]

the only way i keep that fella alive is for that rifle hes got then next encounter i do my signature

[thick bronze]

I robbed Pearson in my play through

I still feel bad about it

Out of all the things I do, robbing the camp cook was not on my “forget about it” list

[steel fern]

Mmmmuh

[rose kindle]

Ye reference

[steel fern]

[thick bronze]

[steel fern]

[thick bronze]

Listening to RDR2 playlist rn

[feral pulsar]

send me it twin

[thick bronze]

I can’t twin

[steel fern]

Not listening to anything rn 😔

[thick bronze]

YouTube music

[grave scroll]

I'm out my jail cell mb 😋

[rose kindle]

My headphones broke unfortunately

No music for me

[steel fern]

Damn

[thick bronze]

House building song on rn

[steel fern]

Waltuh

[thick bronze]

🔥

[steel fern]

What music do you listen waltuh

[rose kindle]

Everything

Besides country

And modern pop